Juno News - January 09, 2026


Youth increasingly supportive of SOCIALISM?

Topics
Mentioned
Canada Is Running Out of Time Pierre Poilievre Blasts Mark Carney

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

179.92

Word count

4,019

Sentence count

209

Harmful content

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

For all the gains being made in Canada when it comes to young conservatism, a record voter turnout, and even a win for the federal Conservative Party in the student vote portion of April s election, there remains the allure of socialism, that tired political philosophy that seeks to prey on the naivete of youth, and where those who gain the power to redistribute have never ever practiced what they preach. Socialism, it's the gateway to communism. And, in an exclusive policy brief being debuted here today, think tank and advocacy group Second Street have found that a significant number of students and youth continue to support socialism.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, Juno News. Alexander Brown here back for another episode, host of Not Sorry. I'm a writer,
00:00:07 communicator, campaigner, and director of the National Citizens Coalition. And we got a good
00:00:12 one for you today, an exclusive report. For all the gains being made in Canada when it comes to
00:00:17 young conservatism, a record voter turnout, and even a win for the federal conservatives in the
00:00:22 student vote portion of April's election, there remains the allure of socialism, that tired
00:00:27 political philosophy that seeks to prey on the naivete of youth, and where those who gain the
00:00:33 power to redistribute, you know, have never ever practiced what they preach, and they've never
00:00:38 shared in the misery they dish out to others. Socialism, it's the gateway to communism. And
00:00:44 in an exclusive policy brief being debuted here today, think tank and advocacy group Second Street,
00:00:50 also known for their terrific work on the healthcare file, have found that a significant number of
00:00:54 students and youth continue to support socialism. Throughout the survey, attitudes were more
00:00:59 negative than positive towards socialism. However, there was still a sizable minority in favor of it,
00:01:05 and among university students, a slim majority in favor of it. Those in favor of socialism often cite
00:01:13 myths about the ideology, such as the claim that Scandinavian countries are socialist when in fact the
00:01:19 Nordic countries feature market-based economies. Other respondents voiced outrageous support for
00:01:27 brutal regimes like Cuba, China, and the USSR. These are trend lines to watch, and they're perhaps
00:01:32 unsurprising in an era of radicalizing forces on social media and the undeniable lack of upward social
00:01:39 mobility being presented to our young people. In some ways, it's no surprise they've leaned either
00:01:44 towards conservative reform or an adjacency to communism because Canada's status quo isn't
00:01:50 working. Let's dive into this important report from Second Street with Communications Director,
00:01:55 Dom Lucek. And first, a word from our sponsor. This is a campaign called Unsmoke. Look, folks,
00:02:01 it's time to modernize Canada's rules on nicotine. Alternatives to cigarettes like heated tobacco,
00:02:06 vaping products, and oral smokeless products don't burn tobacco or produce smoke. They aren't risk-free,
00:02:11 but the growing body of scientific evidence shows that they have the potential to be substantially
00:02:15 less harmful than smoking. Despite this, Canadians are banned access to critical information and even
00:02:20 some products. Nicotine pouches remain banned in convenience stores, and current laws ban
00:02:25 communication about the risks of these products compared to cigarettes. It's unbelievable. The evidence
00:02:30 is here. The tools exist. Canadians should have the freedom to know. You can learn more by visiting
00:02:35 unsmoke.ca.
00:02:37 Dom Lucek joins us. He's the Communications Director for Second Street. Dom, thanks for being here.
00:02:41 Yeah, thanks so much for having me, Alex. It's a pleasure.
00:02:44 Yeah, Dom, this is a robust report. I just spent an hour with it. I wish I had longer because it's
00:02:49 pretty fascinating. Second Street has found that a significant number of student and youth continue
00:02:54 to support socialism. How significant a number is that? And tell us a little bit about the methodology
00:03:00 to uncover it.
00:03:01 Yeah, yeah, for sure. So what we did is, you know, you hear all these stories of people who either have
00:03:08 friends on campus or they are students themselves, and they say, oh, you know, there's socialism
00:03:12 everywhere. And, you know, we hadn't really found any research that had really, you know,
00:03:18 sought to put a number to this, right? So basically what I did is I just, I put a survey,
00:03:22 I put a survey together with a few questions, and I just advertised it to young folks on social
00:03:30 media, Instagram, Facebook. And you can advertise based on people's interests and like their status
00:03:37 as a university student and that sort of thing. So kind of the goal was to get university students,
00:03:42 and we also got a fair number of young folks in the survey as well. The sample size is a little
00:03:47 small, about 350 participants, but still it's an interesting cross section. And so what we're
00:03:54 seeing is, you know, I'm not sure whether I was surprised that the numbers weren't higher. Maybe it's
00:04:01 just my perspective on what universities seem to be like. But as far as young university students,
00:04:08 we had about half of young university students give a positive answer to the question, what does
00:04:14 socialism mean to you? That's ages 18 to 24. As far as just university students in general,
00:04:24 it was about 53% who gave kind of a positive response about socialism. So, you know, again,
00:04:30 that is a little over half, which probably should be concerning considering, you know, just how dangerous
00:04:36 of an ideology that socialism is. But to me, just kind of as the numbers came in, I expected it to
00:04:42 be a lot higher personally. Maybe I'm just a pessimist. Yeah, well, I just a realist, because
00:04:47 this obviously points to campus indoctrination of some kind. I was speaking at UBC recently, and
00:04:54 this was a robust, it's also robust, the size of this campus conservative club. And it was a packed
00:05:02 room. And when I went to university a million years ago, they were not packed rooms. There was
00:05:06 six of us in a, in a lousy sports bar in Halifax. And so, but they'd come up to you and tell you that
00:05:12 it's, you know, they're still, they still kind of keep to themselves in lecture halls, and they're
00:05:16 still walking on eggshells, and they still have to, to pass the Palestinian protests to go to the
00:05:22 mess hall. And so there's obviously an element there, like what, what factors should we attribute
00:05:27 to this, this kind of, from looking at the data, you see the, the 53% positive with socialism,
00:05:33 but then, you know, non-students, it's lower. So how might common sense Canadians potentially
00:05:40 collaborate with these conservative groups? Or how do you get these kids in the tent to counter
00:05:45 academic biases?
00:05:48 Yeah, it's a good question. I think one of the things that you can really do is just sort of
00:05:52 spread the kind of reality of what socialism is, and what socialism looks like. I think,
00:05:59 thankfully, a lot of people are sort of becoming aware of that, thanks to recent events in Venezuela.
00:06:05 You know, there's a lot of scrutiny on what that regime has been like. And, you know, this report
00:06:09 was written before those, those events happened with Maduro being deposed. And we do examine, you
00:06:17 know, in the introduction section, just a number of regimes and what socialism means, you know,
00:06:23 in Venezuela, there have been reports of people eating raw rats, because they can't get food.
00:06:31 Think about that, eating raw rats, right? And so this is, this is not an uncommon thing to see
00:06:38 in socialist countries. I mean, that's a very, you know, visceral example, but hunger is very common.
00:06:44 You know, authoritarian regimes where people are thrown in prison for speaking their mind,
00:06:49 or even just for, not even for doing anything that one would think would be contradictory to the
00:06:54 regime. You know, in Solzhenitsyn's The Gulag Archipelago, which is a recount of the Russian 0.91
00:07:01 prison camps, there are so many stories in there. But one that always jumped out at me
00:07:05 is there was a fellow who, he was working in his shop, and he needed some paper. He found a newspaper
00:07:10 with, you know, to just scribble a note down on. And it so happened, there was a photo of,
00:07:15 I forget if it was Lenin or Stalin on the newspaper, he did 10 years in a prison camp for that.
00:07:21 So yeah, I think really just just kind of showing the reality of what these regimes are like,
00:07:26 can go towards changing minds. And of course, there are going to be people who are just so
00:07:31 in the weeds with this, that no matter what you tell them, they won't change their minds. You know,
00:07:37 we shared a lot of, a lot of examples of responses to this survey, where, you know, we asked,
00:07:43 what does socialism mean? And people said, you know, a utopia, future hope, the inevitable future,
00:07:49 the hopeful triumph at the end of centuries of class struggle, and kind of this very airy language
00:07:55 that, again, it doesn't reflect any kind of reality of what socialism actually is philosophically, or
00:08:00 what it has worked out like in practice.
00:08:02 Speaker 2 No, that just sounds to me a lot like that kind of white liberal progressive gobbledygook,
00:08:08 and then the reflexive, well, we've never tried real socialism, or we've never tried real communism.
00:08:13 It's like, no, it's, and it's well highlighted in this report. It's like, there's like 100 million
00:08:19 deaths on the record here. Like, what are we, you know, what are we doing? You know, we see these
00:08:24 results and this useful data set. And, and yet the federal conservatives just won the student vote
00:08:29 in last April's election for the first time in the modern era. Polls continue to track well for 18 to
00:08:35 55 being seemingly soundly conservative. What can we make of this, this split here between those
00:08:42 numbers and and your numbers? Is that incongruous with Second Street's findings? Or is there a case of
00:08:48 useful data inside of data? Like by drilling down, can we see that the youth tend to split to the polls
00:08:54 because the status quo isn't working for them? Yeah, it's a good question. I mean,
00:08:59 there's so many variables here. And again, it is also worth keeping in mind that this is a decently
00:09:03 small sample size of data that we have. You know, the first thing that jumps to my mind is maybe
00:09:08 it's a sign of just more polarization that there are, you know, the people are just kind of splitting
00:09:15 it and getting further and further into their own camps. That could be an explanation for it.
00:09:19 Yeah. I think also, you know, it is just important to note that I think you would also have to look
00:09:27 at kind of voter turnout based on age would be a variable that would count. So I don't think that
00:09:33 it's contradictory. And I think that you can still look and see that, you know, also it's worth noting
00:09:40 not every young person goes to university, right? There are people who right out of high school,
00:09:45 they open up a business or they go to a trade school, whatever it may be, right?
00:09:51 Sounds more valuable at this point, as far as I'm concerned. I don't think my BA in poli
00:09:55 sci ended up being worth the paper it's printed on. Yeah, I dropped out in my second year and went
00:10:00 to a trade school. You know, and you're a success because of it. I'm in spite of my degree. So, Dom,
00:10:10 tell us more about what you think social media, like the role social media plays in this. The legacy
00:10:14 media loves to harp on sort of far right influences online. Our algorithms can, you know, have some
00:10:20 pretty funny stuff on there, but also some pretty gnarly stuff. What makes you maybe worry about the
00:10:26 teens or 20 somethings who are seeing, you know, far left tick tock or Instagrams? And I think of
00:10:33 somebody like a Hassan Piker who just seemingly stands for, for the world's great dictators and it's
00:10:40 become like completely normalized. Like what's the sort of tick tock or Instagram factor that could
00:10:45 be a play here? Yeah, it's, it's a good question, Alex. And I do think it is, it is worrisome because
00:10:50 you see, and to be fair, it is not just young people. I think everyone to a degree gets kind of
00:10:55 siloed within their, their interests on social media. But you know, there are kind of spaces for
00:11:01 these really extreme conversations to kind of exist without scrutiny, right? Because of the way the
00:11:08 algorithms work, you and I, if we go on our X or our Instagram pages, we're not getting videos
00:11:17 directly from people. Like, as you mentioned, Hassan Piker, you know, folks who are just very,
00:11:21 very in favor of socialism. And in that guy's case, you know, violently enforcing it. You know,
00:11:28 I think, yeah, it really just allows this kind of extremism to kind of compound and grow upon itself.
00:11:36 I mean, if you look at, you know, another recent example, when Charlie Kirk was murdered,
00:11:41 if you look at the conversation around that, right, there were, you know, pretty well defined,
00:11:46 there were, there were a couple of camps, there were people who, whether or not they agree with him,
00:11:49 were, you know, very shocked at this, this tragedy, and were, you know, sending condolences to his
00:11:55 family and friends and all that. And then you had, you know, very, very extreme folks who,
00:12:00 who were, you know, congratulating the murderer and saying, great, good job, go get more of them.
00:12:07 And so you see stuff like this. And again, I do think it is just the nature of kind of being siloed
00:12:14 and not receiving any pushback when you have 1000s of people who will kind of back up everything that
00:12:20 you say. And no matter how extreme it is, and it just kind of grows and grows.
00:12:25 Yeah, no, on in the aftermath of the, you know, the horrible murder of Charlie Kirk,
00:12:32 it was like an ice cream social on blue sky, like these echo chambers, they didn't handle it. Well,
00:12:38 the left, the left certainly didn't handle it. Well, your report rightly emphasizes historical
00:12:43 atrocities and in socialist regimes through survivor anecdotes. I think there's a real role that these,
00:12:51 I've been thinking about this recently, and talked to some folks in politics where
00:12:55 I think that there's a role that historical societies and new communicators could play here,
00:12:59 where you perhaps, maybe you risk being cringe by trying to make like history cool. But you have
00:13:04 these, we have these low information influencers who provide lazy, you know, analyses of history's
00:13:10 greatest monsters. Could we not be sort of countering, like, I'm not a pro censorship type,
00:13:16 but like, could we not be maybe countering these efforts with, like, historical TikToks, Instagrams?
00:13:23 Should we not be going to these sort of new right communicators or, or, or influencers and maybe
00:13:30 trying to get them to tell Canadian stories, like pro social pro civilizational Canadian stories? We have
00:13:37 all these great historical organizations right now. And, and it strikes me that that would be like a good
00:13:42 use of their funding to like, go out and get influencers to, to tell positive stories about our
00:13:48 democracy and our values, instead of just more of the sort of deconstruction that that these young
00:13:54 people might be seeing online. Yeah, I think a group that does really great work on that is the
00:13:59 Aristotle Foundation. Yeah, run by my friend Mark Mielke, and my friend David Hunt works there as well.
00:14:05 Great folks who I think they do a lot of great work on that. Yeah. Yeah, I think you're right that showing kind of the,
00:14:11 the positive side of it, you know, kind of Western civilization, how did it begin, not even necessarily
00:14:16 just Canadian society, there are a lot of great stories there. But even, you know, going going
00:14:20 deeper to, you know, just just the West in general, Greek and Roman roots and all that sort of thing.
00:14:26 Those are really interesting stories to tell. And they do, you know, counter these kind of Marxist
00:14:32 narratives, which, you know, again, they're, they're in the, the, the scheme of world history,
00:14:38 they're relatively recent, right? You know, Marx was was alive in the 19th century. And, but but
00:14:45 yeah, as you know, I think you're right, that's an interesting way to counter it. I also do really
00:14:50 think, just kind of showing the visceral, kind of negative aspects of what these socialist regimes,
00:14:57 which did exist right there, and to this day, continue to exist, there are nowhere near as many
00:15:02 as there used to be. And we'll see how it shapes up with Venezuela moving forward. But Cuba, Vietnam,
00:15:09 Laos, some would say China, China is technically still a communist country, though, they have more
00:15:14 of a market focused economy these days, still very authoritarian, and, and a dictatorship for sure.
00:15:22 But yeah, like, you know, we've, we've done this series in the past called survivors of socialism,
00:15:26 where we've talked to people who have come to Canada, from socialist countries, you know, I,
00:15:32 one that always really stuck out in my mind was, I interviewed a woman in Vancouver, who had moved
00:15:38 from China, and she was from China, like, back when it was, you know, a much stricter communist,
00:15:45 socialist regime. And some of the stories she told me, you know, they would have maybe 500 grams of pork
00:15:54 in a year would be their their meat allowance. And it would be like this exciting special occasion to
00:15:59 get this tiny bit of pork, you know, stories of, of because of China's one child policy of police 0.89
00:16:06 officers, you know, seeing women who were pregnant on the street, just just abducting them and forcing
00:16:12 them to have abortions. And just, you know, some of the most horrific stuff you can hear that you can
00:16:17 possibly think of happening in, you know, in human society. So it's, I think, Alex, that you're right,
00:16:25 you know, showing the positive side of things is one part of the solution. And also just showing the
00:16:30 realities of what socialism looks like, or they kind of play together.
00:16:33 Yeah, one thing I've been, I've been somewhat heartened by, and maybe it's just from seeing my own
00:16:38 echo chamber, is that in following the Venezuela Maduro raid capture, like, I see a lot of young
00:16:47 people online who think it was awesome. And like, maybe, you know, maybe there's some you never
00:16:51 know when, like, you know, trends or fervors are good or bad. But it's like, I know, like a lot of
00:16:56 based young men, quote unquote, who are like, wow, you can just do things like this. Like, that's, that,
00:17:01 that's so cool. And so it's, you want to have these kind of pro social positive balance moments with
00:17:08 young people to show them that it's like, no, like, you can depose, you know, scumbags, you can, you can, 0.98
00:17:14 this is a country whose refugee crisis extended all the way across the world. I mean, a native 0.99
00:17:20 poly of, you know, part of that, part of that crisis. What I like about this report is that
00:17:25 it does highlight the black book of communism's estimate, as we said before, nearly 100 million
00:17:30 deaths. It also correctly debunks the myth of Scandinavian countries as socialist, you know, 0.52
00:17:38 this is their pro market. And so how would you advise, you know, the folks in this audience to
00:17:44 respond to, to criticisms that downplay, you know, a figure like $100 million, or who, who go,
00:17:52 well, actually, look at European socialism, when they're really not, I mean, ensuring that young 0.71
00:17:56 Canadians can better understand that socialism has that deadly track record.
00:18:02 Yeah, it's, it's a good question. I think just starting with the question of,
00:18:05 you know, Nordic Scandinavian, quote unquote, socialism, that is a myth. I think really,
00:18:11 to debunk that first, you have to really nail down what socialism actually is. Now, a lot of the time
00:18:18 when you get into these conversations, people will just say, well, Canada is a socialist country,
00:18:23 because we have government programs. Yeah, you know, and that's, that's, that's not what socialism is.
00:18:28 If every time the government doing something was classified as socialism,
00:18:32 then every single society on earth for all of human history would have been socialist, right,
00:18:37 you wouldn't have needed Marx to come around and, and put a definition to it. So really,
00:18:42 if you look at what Marx and what Lenin said, socialism was a step on the road to communism,
00:18:49 one of the components of which was state control of enterprise. So no private business. So if you go by
00:18:56 that, as your, you know, as your indicator, you look at these Scandinavian countries, that's not
00:19:01 how it works. Yes, they have high taxes. Yes, they have very generous social safety nets that are
00:19:06 propped up because they have, you know, great resources there. But they are not socialist countries.
00:19:12 And actually, you know, there was a president of I believe it was Denmark, and I've got this quote in
00:19:18 the in the report, who just got fed up with this, I believe he was responding to Bernie Sanders talking
00:19:25 about the Scandinavian socialism. And he said, Denmark is not a socialist economy, we are a market economy.
00:19:33 So that that one's pretty easy to debunk if you just know those right quotes. And if you really
00:19:37 nail down the definition of what socialism is, as far as the deaths go, yeah, I mean, the Black Book of
00:19:43 Communism is a great source. It's also worth keeping in mind that that 100 million figure, that was in
00:19:49 the late 90s. So it's been, you know, a couple decades since then. And Venezuelist continued to exist,
00:19:56 China, Vietnam, Laos, so that that number has no doubt risen in that time. And yeah, I mean, it's it's just
00:20:03 so well documented in for each of these individual regimes, right? The Black Book, I think is great,
00:20:08 in that it, you know, combines all these different sources together. But, you know, you can find any
00:20:14 any number of historical, you know, historical records on the Soviet Union, on China, those are
00:20:21 really the two big ones, where there have just been 10s of millions of, of deaths at the hands of
00:20:26 socialism. But, you know, you can look throughout the rest of the former USSR, and some of those African 0.99
00:20:33 countries that had socialist periods, and so on and so forth. And yeah, I think you really do have
00:20:38 to point to the numbers, and then the anecdotes as well, the stories to really just make, put a
00:20:43 face to the numbers, because oftentimes, when you hear a big number, it just kind of goes over your
00:20:47 head. It's like saying there's a bajillion. Sometimes when you talk to someone, right?
00:20:54 What's that quote, where it's like, one death is a tragedy, 1000 is a statistic, that might be like
00:20:58 Stalin or Lenin. But it's like, yeah, the way you communicate things to people, if it's too big,
00:21:02 it's not relatable, necessarily. Yeah, I'm always, I'm always skeptical when I hear
00:21:08 quotes like that, whether I don't know for a fact, whether or not that was Stalin. 0.98
00:21:12 It's kind of like, you know, it's like every quote online, all an ass. Yeah. 0.98
00:21:17 Very Stalin. Yeah, I'm not sure. I check into that. But yeah, yeah,
00:21:20 I totally look it up. It's always just someone else's aphorism. Yeah. And that's great perspective
00:21:25 on the definition of socialism as well for the audience. Dom, to wrap, survey revealed both
00:21:31 hopeful and I think concerning statistics regarding young people's views on socialism,
00:21:36 because while some respondents may support the idea of, you know, modern political parties that
00:21:41 claim to be social democrats, they're clearly confused. They're often misinformed. I don't want,
00:21:47 and I think our audience wouldn't want either to just sort of sit around and wait for them to be
00:21:52 mugged by reality because it's often what it takes to draw you out of supporting socialism.
00:21:58 The report has tons of resources to better, you know, reform, to inform. Where can our audience read
00:22:04 it? Yeah, absolutely. You can just head to our website, secondstreet.org, go to the policy briefs
00:22:09 section and you'll see it there. Dom, terrific work and thanks for joining us.
00:22:14 Yeah, thanks so much for having me. It's a pleasure, Alex.