kinsellacast - December 15, 2024


KINSELLACAST 340: Under the bus with Mraz, Lilley, Zivo, Kheiriddin, Belanger plus Interpol, Illuminati Hotties, Haters, Otoboke Beavers and more


Episode Stats

Length

1 hour and 28 minutes

Words per Minute

155.81229

Word Count

13,779

Sentence Count

421

Misogynist Sentences

24

Hate Speech Sentences

39


Summary


Transcript

00:00:00.000 It's the KinsellaCast starring Warren Kinsella.
00:00:20.520 Hey, it's Warren. Welcome to the KinsellaCast. I'm up at the cabin. I'm working away at a writing
00:00:27.880 project and I'm with Joey and Tommy and I'm pleased to report that Tommy has not destroyed
00:00:35.800 everything, just some things. Irreplaceable, precious, expensive things. But other things
00:00:45.820 have survived the Tommy weekend. Anyway, it's cold up here. Hopefully it's warm where you are.
00:00:51.780 Got a hot, awkward segue, show for you. Brian Lilly, John Mraz, Tasha Carradine, Carl Belanger,
00:01:00.560 Adam Zivo, and some great music. Interpol, old, old tune, PDA. But I just love the drums at the start.
00:01:08.740 It reminds me of my brother's drumming. He's a great drummer. And Interpol's a great band.
00:01:15.740 Um, I don't think cocaine has killed them yet, but apparently it was on its way to doing so.
00:01:21.880 Um, got, um, Making Noise for, um, what's the name of the song? Making Noise for the one you love or
00:01:32.620 something like that. Um, let me check this out because I'd promised you guys that I would like
00:01:37.960 provide you with song titles. It is, is it Prime? No, it's Rat Boys. Yeah. Making Noise for the ones
00:01:46.180 you love. Um, really noisy, kind of Jesus and Mary chain, pavement, pixies. I don't know. It's pretty
00:01:56.680 good. Anyway, Rat Boys. Crummy name. Change your name, guys, gals. Uh, Angel Olson. I love her voice.
00:02:04.140 Um, speaking of my brother, Angel Olson looks like my sister-in-law, uh, Barb. And she's just got the
00:02:12.500 most amazing voice. Angel Olson does, not my sister-in-law. Well, maybe my sister-in-law does.
00:02:17.160 I don't know. I haven't heard her sing. But you're going to hear Angel Olson sing Sweet Dreams.
00:02:22.880 Got Last Night by The Haters. Despite their angry name, it's kind of blink, you know, MXPX,
00:02:31.140 that kind of sound, but good tune. And then my favorite band of all time of this week,
00:02:35.760 which is this Japanese all-female band. And they're not my favorite band of all time this week
00:02:43.780 because they're Japanese or female. They're just my favorite band of all time this week because
00:02:50.300 they're so fucking hard. Like Otoboke, I think that's how you pronounce it, Beaver. That's definitely
00:02:57.280 how you pronounce that. They're four-piece. Um, I don't know where they're from. Kyoto, maybe?
00:03:05.820 Oh my God. Like, and the drummer for this band, like they're just, you know, they make any of you
00:03:14.480 who know punk and hardcore know what I mean when I say bad brains, okay? Bad brains are the, like,
00:03:22.640 the speed limit. Otoboke, Beaver, go like 10 times the speed limit and pull it off. So anyway,
00:03:30.460 great, great band and, um, great show. And I've been going on too long. Picture a schoolyard.
00:03:36.720 Donald Trump's there. He's a schoolyard bully. He calls the other kids' names, threatens them,
00:03:42.600 pushes them around, sometimes even hits them for no apparent reason. Other kids are in the
00:03:47.360 playground and they're from all over. There's Justin Trudeau from Ottawa, Francois Legault
00:03:51.020 from Quebec, Daniel Smith from Alberta, and this newer kid, Doug Ford. He's from Ontario.
00:03:57.560 One day, Donald again threatens the other kids. He says he's going to take away the stuff that
00:04:01.740 belongs to them. He's going to hurt them and their families. He's going to do all these things
00:04:05.620 because the other kids are bad. Not him. Danielle and Francois immediately close up to Donald.
00:04:12.820 You're right, Donald, they say in little tiny voices. We're bad. We'll do whatever you want.
00:04:18.980 Just don't hurt us. Justin, who also has a rich dad and also thinks he's always right,
00:04:25.580 like Donald, tries a slightly different approach. I'm going to come to your place and bring pizza
00:04:31.040 and your favorite drink, Donald, and you can make fun of me as much as you want. The newer kid,
00:04:36.680 Doug Ford, watches all of this. Doug shakes his head. He then walks over to Donald, eye to eye,
00:04:44.900 and says, stop bullying us. And then he slugs Donald Trump in the nose. Now, I know all the
00:04:53.020 woke manuals about bullying say the bullied should never hit the bully. Reassure your kid.
00:04:58.600 Emphasize it's the bully behaving badly. Monitor the situation. Seek help. All that.
00:05:04.360 But really, every parent knows sometimes when your kid or, say, your family or your friends or your
00:05:10.520 neighbors or your country are being bullied for no good reason, talking a lot about it is not going
00:05:17.940 to change a damn thing. Sometimes, like in the movies, Karate Kid, Back to the Future, you name it,
00:05:24.180 you just have to give the bully a taste of his own medicine. And this week, finally, someone did that.
00:05:29.460 After Donald Trump threatened to slap 25% tariffs on everything we sell to the Americans,
00:05:35.860 which will destroy our economy, make no mistake, and put as many as 5 million Canadians out of work,
00:05:43.180 Doug Ford popped Donald Trump in his mango-colored nose. Hard. Quote,
00:05:48.380 We will go to the full extent, depending on how far this goes. We will go to the extent of cutting
00:05:53.080 off their energy, going down to Michigan, going down to New York State, and over to Wisconsin.
00:05:57.100 I don't want this to happen, but my number one job is to protect Ontarians and Canadians as a whole.
00:06:04.480 End quote. That was Doug Ford. To justify his thuggery, Trump falsely said Canada is sending
00:06:12.800 lots of fentanyl into his country. He falsely said we're sending huge numbers of illegal aliens into
00:06:19.400 his country. Well, fentanyl? Well, in the last fiscal year, the Americans seized a few dozen
00:06:25.660 pounds of the finished product coming in from Canada. Nearly 30,000 pounds of it came from other
00:06:33.040 countries. Meanwhile, several thousands of people have been stopped crossing from Canada to the U.S.
00:06:40.880 Canada into the U.S. last year, yes. But over a million came from Mexico alone. Does that sound fair?
00:06:48.740 Does that sound reasonable? Of course not. It's bullshit. But it certainly provides a study in
00:06:54.840 leadership contrast, doesn't it? Daniel Smith, for example, said she wouldn't hit back.
00:06:59.020 She said Donald Trump was right. We're taking a diplomatic approach, she said.
00:07:03.720 Sounding a lot like a Neville Chamberlain in a skirt.
00:07:06.780 Francois Legault was similarly cowardly. I won't threaten Donald, he joked at a press conference.
00:07:11.980 Yep. Yeah, that'll work, Francois. Sucking up to bullies always works, doesn't it?
00:07:17.120 And Justin Trudeau sure thinks so. He had his tail between his legs and he flew down to Mar-a-Lago
00:07:23.120 where Trump mocked him in front of a table full of witnesses saying Canada should join the United
00:07:29.200 States. Trudeau's response? He sounded more like a busboy than a prime minister. And he posted on X,
00:07:35.140 Thanks for dinner last night, President Trump. I look forward to the work we can do together
00:07:40.300 again. Trump immediately renewed his terror threat. Donald Trump is like all bullies. He only
00:07:48.440 understands strength. So when Doug Ford showed guts and said what he said, here's what Donald Trump
00:07:54.780 responded with. Quote, That's okay if he does that. That's fine. We have a great relationship. I have so
00:07:59.900 many friends in Canada. End quote. Spoken like a schoolyard bully who just got popped in the nose.
00:08:29.900 You are past. You're the last winner. I'm breaking all around me. Until the last drop is behind you.
00:08:40.500 Oh. You're so cute when you're frustrated. Dear.
00:08:48.700 Oh. You're so cute when you're so dated. Dear. Oh, you're still. Sleep tight. Grim right. We had 200 couches where you can't sleep tight. Grim right.
00:09:18.680 We had 200 couches where you can't sleep tight. Grim right. We had 200 couches where you can't sleep tonight. Sleep tonight. Sleep tonight. Sleep tonight. Sleep tonight.
00:09:48.680 You are the only person who's completely certain. There's nothing here to be into. And that is all that you can do.
00:09:58.680 You are past. You are the last winner. And everything we've come to. It makes you you. You. You. You cannot safely say. Well, I will be away. But you are my sinner, sadly.
00:10:22.680 I will be away. But I won't take you. You will be away. But you are remembered. I can't get around me. But I can't be. I can't consider you too. And now there is this distance.
00:10:40.760 Sleep tight, Gram-Bride
00:10:44.480 We have 200 couches where you can
00:10:48.340 Sleep tight, Gram-Bride
00:10:51.340 We have 200 couches where you can
00:10:55.260 Sleep tight, Gram-Bride
00:10:58.240 We have 200 couches where you can
00:11:02.160 Sleep tight, Gram-Bride
00:11:03.300 Sleep you tonight
00:11:04.120 Sleep tonight
00:11:07.300 Sleep tonight
00:11:09.300 Sleep tonight, sleep tonight
00:11:39.300 Sleep tonight, sleep tonight
00:12:09.300 Sleep tonight, sleep tonight
00:12:39.300 Sleep tonight, sleep tonight
00:13:09.280 Sleep tonight, sleep tonight
00:13:11.280 Now, Brian, I've got to be honest
00:13:12.700 I couldn't tell this week if you were happy with Doug Ford's threat to Trump over tariffs or unhappy
00:13:21.880 Tell us, were you happy or not?
00:13:24.520 Was it the right strategy or not?
00:13:26.220 Well, I don't know why you'd think I was unhappy
00:13:31.680 I've said he's been striking the right tone because from the outset, I was at Ford's first news conference
00:13:38.600 And I asked him questions about the increase in illegal crossings over the Canada-US border
00:13:45.600 How it's up 82% over the last two years
00:13:48.860 And he, from the very beginning, has said
00:13:51.800 Trump administration has raised these issues
00:13:55.300 These are serious concerns
00:13:57.520 We have to deal with them
00:13:58.880 But if we get hit, we will hit back
00:14:01.840 And that has, from his first day, has been what he said
00:14:05.160 And then he made the comments about energy
00:14:07.700 Which some people, I think, mistakenly read in
00:14:11.220 That he wanted to stop oil exports
00:14:13.440 Now, he's talking about electricity exports
00:14:15.360 From Ontario to neighboring American states
00:14:19.360 And I think that's a good strategy
00:14:24.080 He's saying, we will hit you back hard
00:14:26.540 If you hit us
00:14:28.020 But his first thing
00:14:29.920 From day one
00:14:31.580 And continuing until now
00:14:33.760 Has been to say
00:14:34.600 Let's deal with the concerns
00:14:36.780 Let's deal with the border
00:14:37.960 And, quite frankly, we've seen more from the premiers
00:14:43.280 Whether it's Francois Legault sending the SQ to the border
00:14:46.780 To look for people going both ways
00:14:48.500 Danielle Smith announcing a very detailed plan
00:14:51.640 51 U.S. sheriffs
00:14:52.800 Drones that can operate in cold and high wind velocity
00:14:56.420 A two-kilometer zone of interest
00:15:00.260 Where they're really going to be watching
00:15:02.060 For human smugglers and drug smugglers going across
00:15:05.080 Wob Canoe
00:15:06.140 The new Democrat Premier of Manitoba
00:15:10.380 Detailing his plan
00:15:12.340 All the premiers are coming up with plans
00:15:14.840 What's Trudeau doing on this?
00:15:18.040 He's nowhere to be found on this
00:15:19.700 When he has spoken about the issue
00:15:21.760 He's stuck his foot in his mouth
00:15:23.120 First in Halifax on Monday
00:15:25.360 Talking about how Canadians should be careful
00:15:28.840 Not to make the same mistake that Americans made
00:15:30.960 And vote for change just for the sake of it
00:15:32.800 And then on Tuesday
00:15:34.840 Lamenting that Kamala Harris lost
00:15:37.240 Oh, really?
00:15:39.100 Says the guy that beat four women to become liberal leader
00:15:41.500 Men should never beat women in politics
00:15:44.920 When he has spoken up on this issue
00:15:50.340 He has stuck his foot in it
00:15:53.040 But he's offered nothing concrete
00:15:56.160 The premiers have
00:15:57.520 Meanwhile, you've got Doug Ford going on Fox News again this week
00:16:03.280 Or this past week with Neil Cavuto
00:16:05.800 He knows that Trump watches Fox News
00:16:11.100 That's why he's also running the Ontario ads there
00:16:13.260 And during NFL football games
00:16:15.480 He was on CNBC, another channel that he watches
00:16:19.980 Just this morning is on WABC
00:16:22.500 The top radio station in New York
00:16:24.920 On a show hosted by Trump's friend
00:16:28.260 It's called the Cats Roundtable
00:16:29.560 John Katsomedes
00:16:30.800 And talking about how we need to find a way to make a deal
00:16:34.580 Let's make a deal
00:16:35.420 Let's sit down and figure this out
00:16:37.180 Those are the things the Prime Minister should be doing
00:16:40.400 But Justin Trudeau has spent the last bunch of years
00:16:43.060 Trying to run the provinces
00:16:44.460 Run their healthcare systems
00:16:46.160 Establish childcare
00:16:47.420 Establish dental care
00:16:48.500 Establish pharmacare
00:16:48.980 School food programs
00:16:51.200 He wants to be a Premier
00:16:52.360 And now he needs to do the real job of being a PM
00:16:55.800 And he's doing Stagats
00:16:57.760 So let me
00:16:59.200 Hamilton coming out
00:17:00.300 That's good
00:17:00.800 I love Hamilton
00:17:01.500 I love the Hammer
00:17:02.300 Okay, let me ask you a question, buddy
00:17:04.360 Like straight out
00:17:05.440 Do you actually believe
00:17:08.440 That any of these efforts
00:17:10.100 And I applaud
00:17:10.900 You know, what Doug Ford has done
00:17:12.820 And wrote a column about it
00:17:14.240 I condemn the inactivity of Trudeau
00:17:17.340 Looks like he's got no strategy
00:17:18.760 Do you honestly believe that the tariffs are going to be stopped
00:17:22.920 When Donald Trump campaigned on it
00:17:25.720 Day after day after day
00:17:28.000 And he has a mandate to do it
00:17:30.440 Do you actually think that any of this stuff
00:17:33.240 Is going to stop the tariffs?
00:17:34.940 Yes
00:17:36.440 And I can explain why
00:17:38.660 And you can read my column online
00:17:40.840 TorontoSun.com
00:17:42.320 You can read it in today's print edition
00:17:43.960 But the online one has the receipts
00:17:46.500 It has the links to the historic documents
00:17:48.720 Think back to the
00:17:51.040 The tariffs that the Trump administration put on Canadian steel and aluminum
00:17:55.680 Back in 2018
00:17:57.040 The reporting on that from most media outlets was horrendous
00:18:00.840 All they would tell you is
00:18:02.560 Trump put tariffs on because of national security concerns
00:18:05.920 Oh, what a joke
00:18:06.840 Canada is not a national security threat to America
00:18:10.140 Our steel and aluminum is not a national security threat to America
00:18:13.860 But if you actually listen to what the Trump administration said
00:18:17.120 And I did at the time
00:18:18.120 And I'm bringing all of this up again
00:18:21.120 And showing the documents
00:18:22.560 The Trump administration came to the Trudeau government
00:18:26.100 In April 2017
00:18:27.680 And said
00:18:28.980 You're allowing Chinese made steel
00:18:31.180 To be dumped into Canada
00:18:33.100 At unfair prices
00:18:34.820 And then shipped down to the United States
00:18:37.500 As a Canadian product
00:18:39.260 We need you to deal with that
00:18:41.240 And they ignored it
00:18:42.620 Thirteen months later
00:18:44.040 May 2018
00:18:44.880 Trump announces the tariffs are coming in
00:18:48.440 That's the first time the Trudeau government reacted
00:18:50.820 And I've got the link to Bill Morneau's statement
00:18:53.040 And I quote from it
00:18:53.920 He was then finance minister
00:18:55.200 And he says
00:18:55.560 Oh, we take this issue very seriously
00:18:57.420 And we're going to deal with it
00:18:59.160 We're working it
00:18:59.960 What if he had done that thirteen months earlier?
00:19:02.640 Now, we all know that Canada brought in their own tariffs
00:19:05.680 We put tariffs on Heinz Ketchup
00:19:07.860 And bourbon and playing cards
00:19:09.700 And if you listen to the popular narrative
00:19:11.960 That's what got the steel and aluminum tariffs removed
00:19:15.760 But here's the problem
00:19:17.380 There is a joint statement from both governments
00:19:20.240 That explains what happened and why
00:19:23.060 And why did those tariffs get removed in 2019
00:19:26.140 After almost a full year?
00:19:27.980 Because we agreed to stop the transshipment
00:19:31.120 Of Chinese steel and aluminum
00:19:32.360 We agreed to do what they asked us to do
00:19:35.580 Two years earlier
00:19:36.920 And that is why I asked the question
00:19:40.260 Because I want everybody to read Brian's column today
00:19:43.040 So
00:19:43.820 Like again now
00:19:45.060 He's coming with a very specific ask
00:19:48.040 I'm not saying he won't come up with more
00:19:50.580 He won't say
00:19:52.040 Well, you know
00:19:52.860 Unless you increase NATO spending to two percent
00:19:55.380 We're going to hit you
00:19:56.560 He may come up with more
00:19:58.240 But on this one
00:19:59.400 He said a very specific thing
00:20:01.420 Deal with this growing problem
00:20:03.380 On the Canada-U.S. border
00:20:04.680 Or you get hit with tariffs
00:20:07.340 So based on past experience
00:20:09.800 I'll tell you two things
00:20:10.700 He means it
00:20:11.880 And we'll get hit with those tariffs
00:20:13.300 Unless we do something
00:20:14.300 And the other thing that we learned
00:20:16.140 From past experience
00:20:16.960 Is Justin Trudeau's going to fuck it up
00:20:18.660 And he's going to try and campaign against Trump
00:20:21.780 Even if it costs Canadians
00:20:23.880 Their jobs, their wages, their buying power
00:20:26.220 So let's talk about jobs
00:20:27.900 A specific Canadian
00:20:29.780 With a job
00:20:31.120 And one who doesn't have it yet
00:20:32.840 Christopher Freeland
00:20:34.180 So Christopher Freeland
00:20:35.740 Has endured serial humiliation
00:20:38.420 By Justin Trudeau
00:20:40.220 And Katie Telford
00:20:41.300 And the Prime Minister's office
00:20:42.840 Leaks against the Minister of Finance
00:20:45.860 Leaks about her policy
00:20:48.020 Or approach
00:20:48.680 Or communication skills
00:20:50.120 And then this week
00:20:51.680 We learned from the Globe and Mail
00:20:53.260 That they are again
00:20:54.480 Actively trying to figure out a way
00:20:56.100 To get Mark Carney in
00:20:57.340 To take over
00:20:58.920 We presume
00:20:59.680 The finance portfolio
00:21:01.040 And nudge Christopher Freeland
00:21:02.980 Out into pasture
00:21:04.040 Much in the way they did
00:21:05.460 With Jody Wilson-Raybould
00:21:06.760 Or Jane Philpott
00:21:07.880 Or so many other women
00:21:09.040 Who had power
00:21:10.000 And said no to Justin Trudeau
00:21:11.380 I just think
00:21:12.180 Oh but he's a feminist
00:21:13.000 Yeah
00:21:13.540 He's an ally
00:21:14.980 And you know
00:21:15.840 You and I have been critical
00:21:17.220 Of Freeland's policies
00:21:18.720 In post media
00:21:20.380 Over the years
00:21:21.100 But this is shameful
00:21:22.660 Like this is an appalling
00:21:24.240 Treatment
00:21:24.900 Of this woman
00:21:25.940 Who's been nothing
00:21:26.860 But loyal to Justin Trudeau
00:21:28.460 Yeah I mean
00:21:30.420 You can take the gender
00:21:31.280 Aspect out of it
00:21:32.160 We won't
00:21:32.780 Because Justin Trudeau
00:21:33.760 Constantly reminds us
00:21:34.820 That he's a feminist
00:21:35.580 And if you don't think so
00:21:37.220 It's just because
00:21:37.720 You experience the groping
00:21:38.880 Differently
00:21:39.360 But he wants you
00:21:41.100 To know he's a feminist
00:21:41.940 While he treats women
00:21:42.860 Like utter crap
00:21:43.880 Which is always
00:21:45.720 The way it is
00:21:46.260 Like all the guys
00:21:47.220 Go back to your
00:21:48.260 College and university days
00:21:49.480 All the guys going around
00:21:50.460 Bragging about how
00:21:51.360 They're feminists
00:21:51.980 Were just creepy dudes
00:21:53.880 Trying to convince women
00:21:56.220 To sleep with them
00:21:57.620 So
00:21:58.960 She has been loyal
00:22:01.680 And in politics
00:22:02.740 That's what you want
00:22:03.980 And normally
00:22:04.800 In a normal government
00:22:06.300 That gets rewarded
00:22:07.380 Not with Justin Trudeau
00:22:09.500 So
00:22:09.800 He's got this idea
00:22:11.220 In his head
00:22:11.700 That Mark Carney
00:22:12.520 Is going to help
00:22:13.340 Save his government
00:22:14.500 Give me a break
00:22:15.560 First off
00:22:16.460 If Mark Carney
00:22:17.020 Comes in
00:22:17.440 He wants Trudeau's job
00:22:18.480 Not the finance ministers
00:22:19.640 Secondly
00:22:20.500 Carney's not going
00:22:21.920 To save the Liberal Party
00:22:23.200 At this point
00:22:23.860 The Liberal Party
00:22:24.940 Needs to go sit
00:22:25.700 In the penalty box
00:22:26.500 For a long time
00:22:27.480 And then
00:22:28.740 Rehabilitate themselves
00:22:30.160 And re
00:22:31.140 Reimagine themselves
00:22:32.300 That's what Trudeau did
00:22:33.200 When they were in third place
00:22:34.300 And he took over
00:22:34.960 The leadership in 2013
00:22:36.100 They're going to have
00:22:39.420 To go through
00:22:39.840 Some time in the wilderness
00:22:40.860 Again
00:22:41.440 But
00:22:42.560 The leaks against
00:22:45.260 Freeland
00:22:46.240 Are horrible
00:22:46.820 I do want to point out
00:22:48.220 That
00:22:49.080 In terms of the
00:22:51.040 Budget deficit
00:22:51.960 I did stoop
00:22:54.240 The parliamentary
00:22:55.360 Press gallery
00:22:56.160 With the 62 billion
00:22:57.440 Deficit number
00:22:58.920 And I did it
00:23:00.260 While sitting
00:23:01.000 At a bar
00:23:01.660 Day drinking
00:23:02.360 On a cruise ship
00:23:03.980 In the middle
00:23:04.600 Of the Caribbean city
00:23:05.740 He did folks
00:23:07.800 I can vote for him
00:23:08.700 That's where he was
00:23:09.540 He was tormenting me
00:23:10.680 With pictures every morning
00:23:11.700 Okay you're on fire
00:23:13.080 I want you to direct
00:23:14.340 Your fire
00:23:14.940 Final question
00:23:15.860 Final round
00:23:16.640 Final subject
00:23:17.580 Canada Post
00:23:19.240 Like
00:23:20.440 You're from the Hammer
00:23:22.240 I've represented
00:23:23.280 Cup W
00:23:24.060 I think the union
00:23:25.320 Leadership
00:23:25.760 Completely screwed this up
00:23:27.540 Asking for too much
00:23:28.980 In a very difficult time
00:23:30.020 For Canadians
00:23:30.540 I think management
00:23:31.300 Canada Post
00:23:32.060 Is like
00:23:33.000 Completely incompetent
00:23:34.220 As usual
00:23:34.700 But nobody
00:23:35.780 Is as incompetent
00:23:37.440 Or clued out
00:23:38.420 As Steve McKinnon
00:23:39.860 And the Trudeau
00:23:40.460 Government
00:23:40.840 Who have basically
00:23:41.960 Cancelled Christmas
00:23:43.200 Brian and Lee
00:23:44.240 Fire away
00:23:45.000 The idea
00:23:48.940 That small businesses
00:23:50.180 People waiting
00:23:52.120 For their passports
00:23:53.140 People trying to mail
00:23:54.000 Christmas cards
00:23:54.860 People trying to
00:23:56.160 Send donations
00:23:57.060 Charities rely
00:23:58.800 An awful lot
00:23:59.480 On direct mail
00:24:00.180 Still
00:24:00.500 For donations
00:24:01.280 Especially this time
00:24:02.300 Of year
00:24:02.620 All of that
00:24:03.740 Is pooched
00:24:04.700 As far as management
00:24:06.000 Canada Post
00:24:06.880 And the union
00:24:07.700 I know it's not
00:24:09.120 The exact quote
00:24:09.820 But what did
00:24:10.340 Shakespeare say
00:24:11.160 In Romeo and Juliet
00:24:12.680 Pox on both your houses
00:24:13.920 Something to that effect
00:24:15.000 That would be my take
00:24:17.020 On this
00:24:17.500 Steve McKinnon
00:24:18.920 There is a reason
00:24:20.940 Steve McKinnon
00:24:21.680 Was not
00:24:23.160 Made a cabinet minister
00:24:24.700 Over the first
00:24:25.540 15 different
00:24:26.600 Shuffles
00:24:27.180 That Justin Trudeau
00:24:28.300 Had
00:24:28.660 And it's showing up now
00:24:30.120 He hasn't handled
00:24:31.780 This well
00:24:32.220 You know
00:24:33.540 What's interesting
00:24:34.200 Is the conservatives
00:24:34.940 Are trying to
00:24:35.960 Really make inroads
00:24:37.580 With unionized workers
00:24:38.720 Although I don't think
00:24:39.460 They're going after
00:24:40.120 Public servant
00:24:40.960 Unionized workers
00:24:42.060 But they
00:24:43.100 They have not
00:24:43.820 Come out strong
00:24:44.480 On this issue
00:24:45.200 They haven't come out
00:24:46.400 Strong on
00:24:47.000 Demanding back to work
00:24:48.640 Legislation on anything
00:24:49.760 As always
00:24:52.140 The Trudeau guys
00:24:52.840 Like to play
00:24:53.600 A little political game
00:24:55.740 With any issue
00:24:56.840 And I think
00:24:57.800 They were hoping
00:24:58.560 For
00:24:59.080 Polly F to say
00:25:00.000 Bring in back to work
00:25:01.000 Legislation
00:25:01.680 Which as I've said
00:25:03.000 Over and over again
00:25:03.880 Is now unconstitutional
00:25:05.640 Thanks to Rosalie Abella
00:25:07.160 And
00:25:09.060 They wanted that
00:25:11.860 Political fight
00:25:13.160 So that they could say
00:25:14.300 We're more worth
00:25:15.080 The workers
00:25:15.520 Than these other guys
00:25:17.000 That doesn't help
00:25:18.700 Anybody trying to
00:25:19.440 Deal with Christmas
00:25:20.080 I think the
00:25:21.800 You know
00:25:22.440 Basically forcing them
00:25:24.380 Back to work
00:25:24.940 Without legislation
00:25:25.800 Is going to come back
00:25:27.400 And bite them in the butt
00:25:28.400 Because this is what
00:25:29.140 The third labor stoppage
00:25:30.620 They've done that
00:25:31.380 Yep
00:25:31.780 They're using
00:25:32.820 Backdoor tactics
00:25:33.880 They're doing indirectly
00:25:35.500 What they're not allowed
00:25:36.300 To do directly
00:25:37.000 And you know
00:25:38.200 How courts
00:25:38.680 Look upon
00:25:39.300 Actions like that
00:25:40.680 So I think
00:25:41.120 It's going to
00:25:41.600 Bite McKinnon
00:25:42.280 In the butt
00:25:42.660 Down the road
00:25:43.500 But as you say
00:25:45.040 Christmas is pooch
00:25:45.980 For an awful lot
00:25:46.760 Of people
00:25:47.180 And you know
00:25:48.660 I've got
00:25:48.960 Family members
00:25:49.960 Who had applied
00:25:50.720 For passports
00:25:51.560 Before the
00:25:53.260 Strike was
00:25:54.320 A going concern
00:25:55.960 And by the time
00:25:56.980 The passports
00:25:58.180 Were put in the mail
00:25:59.060 The strike was on
00:26:00.420 And you're sitting
00:26:01.740 There wondering
00:26:02.300 Am I going to be able
00:26:03.400 To go on this trip
00:26:04.320 Brian Lilly
00:26:06.120 On fire
00:26:07.420 On fire
00:26:08.500 He's back from his cruise
00:26:10.000 He's recharged
00:26:11.120 He's fired up
00:26:12.440 And we're grateful
00:26:13.460 That you are here
00:26:14.340 And grateful for your insight
00:26:15.600 My man
00:26:16.560 Have a great day
00:26:17.520 And a great week
00:26:18.440 Talk soon
00:26:19.660 We'll be right back
00:26:49.660 I can't start
00:27:12.460 Driving home
00:27:15.140 Looking out the window
00:27:20.640 I turn up
00:27:30.300 My favorite song
00:27:33.260 Wishing I could call you up
00:27:39.700 But I'm not gonna think
00:27:43.500 About that now
00:27:45.700 I don't wanna talk
00:27:52.360 About that
00:27:53.700 I'm not gonna pick
00:27:58.340 My brain apart
00:27:59.920 I don't wanna talk
00:28:04.460 About that
00:28:05.700 I'm not gonna do that
00:28:10.820 To myself
00:28:12.200 I get sad
00:28:24.780 When I look back
00:28:27.740 At all the time
00:28:30.620 We saw
00:28:31.860 We saw
00:28:31.880 We had
00:28:34.500 I lay down
00:28:39.860 And cry out loud
00:28:43.080 Give it up
00:28:45.780 And let it out
00:28:49.780 No, it's nothing
00:28:51.620 No, it's nothing
00:28:51.660 Big, it's nothing
00:28:52.940 I can't
00:28:53.900 Get up out of bed
00:28:55.780 I'll try
00:28:56.780 No, I don't wanna talk
00:29:01.880 About that
00:29:03.780 I'm not gonna pick
00:29:07.780 I'm not gonna pick
00:29:07.800 My brain apart
00:29:09.400 I don't wanna talk
00:29:13.920 About that
00:29:15.840 I just gotta keep it
00:29:20.280 To myself
00:29:21.660 No, I don't wanna talk
00:29:25.840 About that
00:29:27.040 No, I don't wanna talk
00:29:27.080 No, I don't wanna talk
00:29:27.540 No
00:29:29.540 I get up and write some stuff
00:29:58.100 Feel you here no matter what
00:30:03.800 We're back, we're back with my friend John Mraz
00:30:10.680 and John has got a lot of experience working in and around battle zones
00:30:17.060 and for NGOs and others
00:30:20.260 and John, this week a UK-based group called the Henry Jackson Society published a report
00:30:26.540 which is very detailed and very credible in my opinion
00:30:29.880 about civilian death counts in the Israel-Hamas war
00:30:34.080 and basically what it concludes with proof, with detail
00:30:38.900 and I encourage everybody to read it
00:30:40.660 is that Gaza Health Authority, which is completely run by Hamas
00:30:46.900 has claimed nearly 45,000 people have been killed
00:30:50.700 following Israel's incursion into Gaza back in October of 2023
00:31:00.200 but what the report says is that it gets it wrong
00:31:03.700 and that as many, close to 20,000 of that number
00:31:08.000 nearly half are Hamas combatants
00:31:10.900 What do you think about this?
00:31:13.540 I don't know if you've taken a look at the report
00:31:15.260 but is it something that we can trust?
00:31:19.280 I think the report is closer to the truth
00:31:21.720 than anything that we've heard so far
00:31:23.400 I still don't think that the report goes far enough
00:31:25.620 I have not believed since the beginning of this war
00:31:29.540 any of the numbers that have been promoted
00:31:32.120 not only by the health organizers or Hamasics
00:31:38.260 whatever you want to call them
00:31:39.520 They call it the health ministry?
00:31:41.740 Yeah, the health ministry
00:31:42.620 I mean, I just don't want to give them ministry
00:31:44.240 that's why I hesitated there
00:31:45.420 I haven't believed any of the numbers
00:31:47.820 that have emanated out of Gaza
00:31:49.800 since the beginning of this war
00:31:51.180 for a couple reasons
00:31:52.180 One is, independent journalists have not been allowed into Gaza
00:31:56.780 by the IDF or by the Hamas people
00:31:59.420 for probably pretty good reasons
00:32:01.560 It's a pretty tough place to report from
00:32:03.440 and guarantee anybody's security
00:32:04.960 Most of the journalism, quote-unquote, coming out of there
00:32:07.620 has been by locals, for locals
00:32:10.060 at the behest of Hamas
00:32:11.660 And what people have come in with the IDF
00:32:15.220 have had very limited exposure to what's going on there
00:32:17.900 So that's number one
00:32:18.840 In other words, we weren't getting any real third-party journalism
00:32:22.800 real journalism out of that area
00:32:24.560 The second is, these guys, Hamas guys
00:32:28.200 have historically lied about everything
00:32:30.800 So why wouldn't they lie about the numbers of casualties?
00:32:34.580 Even if the number is half
00:32:36.360 in terms of civilian deaths
00:32:38.160 of what it was or what it is
00:32:39.800 It's still, of course, an atrocious number of deaths
00:32:42.740 and I don't want to take away from that
00:32:45.560 This is a terrible war
00:32:47.180 It was an unnecessary war
00:32:48.720 It started by Hamas
00:32:50.400 And it had to be fought
00:32:53.340 to protect Israel's security
00:32:55.340 I know I get in a lot of trouble for saying that
00:32:57.240 but I understand why Israel went in there
00:32:59.140 Terrible number of innocent people have died
00:33:02.520 The number that Gaza
00:33:05.260 the Gaza Health Ministry has put out there
00:33:07.320 has never been a credible number
00:33:09.760 There's been a couple of things
00:33:10.960 a couple of pieces of evidence
00:33:13.020 that even sort of proved that
00:33:15.240 immediately there were any number of videos
00:33:17.220 shown of alleged casualties
00:33:19.540 being photographed by the Hamas Ministry of Health
00:33:22.680 people who then get up
00:33:23.880 and walk away after they've been photographed
00:33:26.280 And then, two weeks ago
00:33:28.060 and you remember this, Warren
00:33:29.000 the Gaza Health Ministry said
00:33:31.320 that Israel was using some sort of munitions
00:33:34.260 that vaporized people
00:33:35.640 So they were killed
00:33:36.760 and then there was no evidence
00:33:38.360 of their ever having existed
00:33:39.960 Complete atomization of their corpus
00:33:42.820 Right?
00:33:43.540 So, the problem
00:33:45.680 and this is where I want to close is
00:33:47.560 we've heard Holocaust deniers say
00:33:50.120 it wasn't 6 million Jews
00:33:51.700 it was maybe 500,000
00:33:53.560 or 100,000 or 2 million
00:33:54.920 but not 6 million
00:33:55.980 When you start fudging the numbers like this
00:33:58.740 nothing becomes believable
00:34:01.240 and so people will neither believe
00:34:03.200 that it's only 40,000
00:34:04.920 some might think it's 80,000
00:34:06.600 some might think it's 20,000
00:34:08.240 but numbers and facts mean nothing anymore
00:34:11.420 and then I'll finish by going to Ukraine
00:34:13.300 People say that a million Ukrainians have died
00:34:16.540 That was announced this week
00:34:17.800 by a major Western power
00:34:19.920 They estimate
00:34:20.980 a million
00:34:22.400 I'm not even going to name them
00:34:23.400 but a million Ukrainian soldiers have died
00:34:25.620 Ukraine said
00:34:26.200 no, no, no
00:34:26.760 it's 400,000
00:34:27.740 Russia
00:34:28.680 says only 2,000 or 300,000 people have died
00:34:32.560 from its forces
00:34:33.560 Other people say it's closer to 6,000 to 800,000
00:34:36.560 I have no idea who's telling the truth
00:34:39.000 All right
00:34:39.440 But the people who are claiming to tell us the truth
00:34:43.200 in the case of this report
00:34:45.160 that's been done about casualties
00:34:46.860 Gaza
00:34:47.620 CNN
00:34:48.300 BBC
00:34:49.520 New York Times
00:34:50.620 Watch into both Guardian
00:34:51.900 Associated Press
00:34:52.920 Reuters
00:34:53.240 and Australian ABC
00:34:54.860 Like the biggies
00:34:56.020 Like these are big players
00:34:57.160 They're not podcasters in their basement
00:34:59.940 Why, John
00:35:01.380 have they relied upon
00:35:03.000 the statistics
00:35:04.720 that have been given to them
00:35:07.220 by the Hamas-run health ministry
00:35:09.900 Doesn't that
00:35:10.800 I mean
00:35:11.260 that seems like bad journalistic practice
00:35:13.480 You've been a journalist
00:35:14.420 Like
00:35:15.140 is that something that should be
00:35:16.520 happening in the fog of war?
00:35:19.040 Well
00:35:19.180 you know
00:35:19.800 and that's a good
00:35:20.400 that's a good question
00:35:21.180 So you can only come to one of two conclusions
00:35:22.940 One is
00:35:23.540 it's the
00:35:24.380 those are the only numbers available to them
00:35:26.840 It's the only data available to them
00:35:28.180 because they couldn't get
00:35:29.080 BBC remember
00:35:30.260 was in Gaza at the beginning
00:35:31.780 and then got kicked out
00:35:32.800 Right
00:35:33.760 So
00:35:34.360 the only data you can get
00:35:36.440 is the data that's being reported
00:35:38.020 by local journalists
00:35:39.120 whether they were at one point
00:35:40.580 Al Jazeera
00:35:41.260 or BBC stringers
00:35:42.760 who were feeding BBC
00:35:44.240 or CNN
00:35:44.900 from there
00:35:45.740 but
00:35:46.580 no
00:35:47.360 third party
00:35:48.600 out of country
00:35:50.040 or region journalists
00:35:51.120 were there
00:35:51.520 so you have to accept the numbers
00:35:53.000 and you report them in good faith
00:35:54.320 the second reason is
00:35:56.040 that you have a bias
00:35:57.920 your editorial board
00:35:59.400 or your publishers
00:36:00.540 or your broadcasting board
00:36:02.420 say
00:36:03.300 we think this is a terrible war
00:36:05.980 and Israel
00:36:06.880 is out of line
00:36:08.500 this is a disproportionate response
00:36:10.280 to what happened
00:36:11.060 you know
00:36:12.420 when
00:36:13.400 the Hamas
00:36:14.660 invaded Israel
00:36:15.740 and so
00:36:17.500 we don't mind
00:36:18.340 reporting numbers
00:36:19.400 that are exaggerated
00:36:20.200 because it will get
00:36:21.380 the world's attention
00:36:22.420 and bring this thing
00:36:24.320 to a halt
00:36:25.060 because we don't like
00:36:26.240 the way Israel's behaving
00:36:27.500 it's one or the other
00:36:28.900 and I'm not going to tell you
00:36:30.440 which one it is
00:36:31.020 because I don't sit on those boards
00:36:32.360 but it's one or the other
00:36:33.800 and they knew what they were doing
00:36:35.640 certainly in the case of BBC
00:36:38.880 it's been shown
00:36:40.020 that they've been
00:36:40.700 just unbelievably
00:36:42.900 unfair
00:36:44.600 and not factual
00:36:46.460 with respect to the world
00:36:47.560 and anti-Semitic
00:36:48.840 but
00:36:50.100 okay
00:36:50.620 so Israel
00:36:51.580 this week
00:36:53.580 you know
00:36:53.820 it's been fighting
00:36:54.420 a seven front war
00:36:56.020 you and I've been talking
00:36:57.180 about that for weeks
00:36:58.080 they opened up
00:36:59.160 in the past few days
00:37:00.200 an eighth front
00:37:00.940 where they bombed
00:37:02.740 locations
00:37:03.880 in Syria
00:37:05.380 which is now run
00:37:06.460 by this
00:37:07.020 Al-Qaeda adjacent group
00:37:08.680 why did they do that?
00:37:11.560 Well
00:37:11.820 first of all
00:37:14.000 thank God
00:37:14.500 they did it
00:37:14.980 thank God
00:37:15.420 they did it
00:37:15.960 Israel sees
00:37:17.540 stockpiles of munitions
00:37:20.020 including chemical weapons
00:37:21.620 high tech Russian stuff
00:37:24.020 American stuff
00:37:25.840 in there as well
00:37:26.660 big stockpiles of weapons
00:37:29.600 that were controlled
00:37:30.360 and used by Assad
00:37:31.960 and then they look at
00:37:33.760 what's going on
00:37:34.460 inside Syria
00:37:35.140 and you have seven groups
00:37:36.520 contesting for power
00:37:38.840 and territory
00:37:39.520 seven groups that matter
00:37:40.840 I spent a long
00:37:43.000 one hour
00:37:43.640 with a friend of mine
00:37:44.620 from Syria
00:37:45.120 an architect
00:37:45.660 who just
00:37:46.260 emigrated from there
00:37:47.440 three years ago
00:37:49.340 this week
00:37:50.040 trying to get an understanding
00:37:51.260 of what's going on
00:37:52.160 over there
00:37:52.620 the group that are
00:37:54.380 ostensibly in charge
00:37:56.360 and that are being reported
00:37:57.460 to be communicated with
00:37:59.040 by the United States
00:37:59.860 and others
00:38:00.320 are not
00:38:01.260 according to my friend
00:38:02.740 or other Syrian sources
00:38:03.760 really in charge
00:38:04.520 and so Israel looks
00:38:05.400 at all of this
00:38:06.120 and says
00:38:06.920 they're really in the middle
00:38:07.860 not of a civil war
00:38:08.960 but certainly of a contest
00:38:10.100 between seven parties
00:38:11.320 to establish
00:38:12.620 a parliament
00:38:13.620 or a shura
00:38:14.280 or a governing council
00:38:15.340 that represents
00:38:15.880 all the different
00:38:16.640 and sometimes
00:38:17.460 very oppositional interests
00:38:19.360 who is going
00:38:20.680 to get
00:38:21.440 who takes possession
00:38:23.860 of these weapons
00:38:24.680 and can we trust
00:38:25.840 some of these groups
00:38:26.520 and some of these groups
00:38:27.380 are quite radical
00:38:28.200 there are offshoots
00:38:29.240 of Daesh
00:38:30.300 you guys would know
00:38:31.100 that as ISIS
00:38:31.820 or old Al-Qaeda
00:38:33.420 organizations
00:38:34.800 and so Israel
00:38:36.620 has just been
00:38:37.620 effectively
00:38:38.460 bombing the shit
00:38:40.520 not out of people
00:38:41.560 not killing anybody
00:38:42.520 but out of these
00:38:43.900 treasure troves
00:38:44.820 for lack of a better term
00:38:45.940 of weapons
00:38:46.500 in Syria
00:38:47.340 couple hundred sorties
00:38:49.300 and just taking them
00:38:50.640 out of play
00:38:51.280 chemical weapons
00:38:53.120 air capacity
00:38:54.480 anti-aircraft systems
00:38:56.180 and also ground
00:38:57.900 ground sort of tech
00:38:58.960 you know
00:38:59.260 very simple things
00:39:00.060 like tanks
00:39:00.560 and armored carriers
00:39:01.300 etc
00:39:01.660 here's the question
00:39:02.940 why aren't Turkey
00:39:04.420 doing the same thing
00:39:05.560 well that gives us
00:39:08.300 a segue
00:39:08.660 to the final thing
00:39:09.520 I want to talk to you
00:39:10.260 about is NATO
00:39:10.900 Turkey is a member
00:39:12.120 of NATO
00:39:12.580 Turkey is now
00:39:13.920 hosting the leadership
00:39:15.140 of Hamas
00:39:15.940 Turkey has become
00:39:17.820 a very dangerous
00:39:19.640 player regionally
00:39:21.000 so like
00:39:23.480 is NATO
00:39:24.360 I mean Canada
00:39:25.720 doesn't really
00:39:26.260 contribute in the way
00:39:27.260 that it had promised
00:39:28.040 to to NATO
00:39:28.960 Donald Trump's
00:39:30.560 talking again
00:39:31.420 publicly about
00:39:32.460 getting rid of NATO
00:39:33.440 what is the future
00:39:34.820 of NATO
00:39:35.240 what should we have
00:39:36.700 somebody like Turkey
00:39:37.680 in our ranks
00:39:38.420 well Turkey is a very
00:39:40.640 Turkey is the oddest
00:39:41.860 member of NATO
00:39:42.600 for sure
00:39:43.500 but remember that
00:39:45.100 this this
00:39:45.760 displacement of Assad
00:39:47.680 in Syria
00:39:48.160 was facilitated
00:39:49.280 the launch point
00:39:51.160 of that principal
00:39:52.160 rebel group
00:39:52.960 came out of Turkey
00:39:55.040 and it was facilitated
00:39:56.080 by Turkey
00:39:56.660 using American weapons
00:39:58.540 so to many of us
00:40:00.220 it looks like
00:40:00.880 the US knew
00:40:01.580 that Assad
00:40:03.520 could be displaced
00:40:04.600 that that would be
00:40:06.360 a positive things
00:40:07.920 in terms of
00:40:08.540 diminishing Russia's
00:40:09.840 footprint and power
00:40:11.080 in that region
00:40:11.880 that it would be
00:40:13.120 a humiliation
00:40:14.700 for Russia
00:40:15.480 if nothing else
00:40:16.400 but it would wipe
00:40:17.520 out its capacity
00:40:18.340 to launch its power
00:40:19.980 through not only
00:40:20.760 that region
00:40:21.320 but into Africa
00:40:22.360 so it would be
00:40:22.980 useful to NATO
00:40:23.840 and so maybe
00:40:25.080 Turkey served
00:40:26.020 its purpose
00:40:26.700 as a NATO member
00:40:27.540 right there and then
00:40:28.580 Turkey also controls
00:40:30.680 the Bosporus Straits
00:40:32.320 which is that river
00:40:34.420 that allows all of
00:40:35.500 Russia's grain
00:40:36.600 coming out of Ukraine
00:40:37.600 and the ports
00:40:38.840 and the southern end
00:40:40.720 of Ukraine
00:40:41.220 to get out
00:40:42.260 into the world
00:40:42.980 and so Turkey
00:40:44.220 is a fairly valuable
00:40:45.440 member of NATO
00:40:46.180 what is the future
00:40:47.140 of NATO
00:40:47.580 well
00:40:48.840 the United States
00:40:49.960 pays for about
00:40:50.620 15% of NATO's
00:40:52.260 budget
00:40:52.700 Justin Trudeau
00:40:54.240 somehow proudly
00:40:55.160 I don't know
00:40:55.680 how he managed
00:40:56.560 to make it look
00:40:57.140 like he was a great
00:40:57.840 accomplishment
00:40:58.220 said that we
00:40:58.880 would now
00:40:59.420 be able to meet
00:41:00.840 our 2% a year
00:41:02.340 commitment
00:41:03.620 that we're supposed
00:41:04.340 to meet
00:41:04.800 to NATO
00:41:05.240 by 2032
00:41:06.760 he announced that
00:41:07.600 about 4 weeks
00:41:08.360 ago
00:41:08.580 I don't know
00:41:08.900 I don't remember
00:41:09.300 in other words
00:41:10.940 we're not really
00:41:11.600 doing our part
00:41:12.320 in NATO
00:41:12.620 and many other
00:41:13.240 countries aren't
00:41:14.020 really
00:41:14.700 America
00:41:15.400 and Germany
00:41:16.300 together
00:41:17.340 pay for about
00:41:18.360 30%
00:41:19.220 of what NATO
00:41:20.920 does
00:41:21.460 is NATO
00:41:22.520 still a viable
00:41:23.540 useful
00:41:24.080 entity
00:41:25.320 is your question
00:41:26.140 in Donald
00:41:27.180 Trump's eyes
00:41:27.840 I think
00:41:28.340 there's some
00:41:28.780 questions
00:41:29.340 having said
00:41:30.740 that
00:41:31.060 if you
00:41:31.820 if you
00:41:33.260 wipe
00:41:33.520 NATO
00:41:34.020 off the
00:41:34.340 map
00:41:34.540 or you
00:41:34.760 just
00:41:34.960 sort of
00:41:35.240 let it
00:41:35.720 dissolve
00:41:37.080 into
00:41:37.580 nothingness
00:41:38.200 there are
00:41:39.320 treaties
00:41:39.660 between
00:41:40.040 pretty much
00:41:40.540 all of the
00:41:41.180 countries
00:41:41.580 in NATO
00:41:42.180 and the
00:41:42.580 big article
00:41:43.380 that matters
00:41:43.960 in NATO
00:41:44.280 is that
00:41:44.620 article 5
00:41:45.580 that famous
00:41:46.440 article 5
00:41:47.060 says
00:41:47.380 if Canada
00:41:48.360 is attacked
00:41:48.900 by let's
00:41:49.400 say Russia
00:41:49.920 all NATO
00:41:51.160 countries
00:41:52.060 all members
00:41:52.780 of NATO
00:41:53.180 have to
00:41:53.980 come and
00:41:54.420 help us
00:41:55.060 protect us
00:41:56.060 it's what
00:41:56.440 Ukraine wanted
00:41:57.400 in NATO
00:41:58.000 membership
00:41:58.520 and never
00:41:58.980 got
00:41:59.400 would there
00:42:01.080 be another
00:42:01.840 treaty
00:42:02.300 like that
00:42:03.040 and you
00:42:04.460 have to
00:42:04.840 know the
00:42:05.160 mind of
00:42:05.520 Donald Trump
00:42:06.060 and whether
00:42:06.420 he is
00:42:06.900 truly an
00:42:07.440 isolationist
00:42:08.120 or believes
00:42:08.800 in alliances
00:42:09.380 and strategic
00:42:10.080 partnerships
00:42:10.620 to secure
00:42:12.080 the world
00:42:12.500 so what's
00:42:12.940 the future
00:42:13.200 in NATO
00:42:13.660 very much
00:42:14.940 depends
00:42:15.440 on what
00:42:16.260 Donald Trump
00:42:17.180 and his
00:42:17.960 Senate
00:42:18.260 and his
00:42:18.700 Congress's
00:42:19.220 view
00:42:19.500 of the
00:42:20.260 role
00:42:20.620 of the
00:42:20.920 United
00:42:21.100 States
00:42:21.440 going forward
00:42:22.040 in the
00:42:22.260 world
00:42:22.520 as
00:42:22.820 either
00:42:23.280 a
00:42:23.500 policeman
00:42:23.920 or an
00:42:24.840 independent
00:42:25.220 actor
00:42:25.720 defending
00:42:26.560 only
00:42:26.880 its
00:42:27.060 own
00:42:27.240 interests
00:42:27.680 is
00:42:28.360 and
00:42:28.620 are
00:42:28.860 John
00:42:30.000 Mraz
00:42:30.420 well said
00:42:31.620 I think
00:42:32.040 we could
00:42:32.640 probably
00:42:32.940 have many
00:42:33.440 discussions
00:42:33.940 over many
00:42:34.600 days
00:42:34.940 about the
00:42:35.380 future
00:42:35.660 of NATO
00:42:36.020 we probably
00:42:36.600 will be
00:42:37.500 talking about
00:42:37.960 it quite a
00:42:38.280 bit in
00:42:38.760 the coming
00:42:39.340 weeks and
00:42:39.880 months
00:42:40.120 but thank
00:42:40.900 you sir
00:42:41.280 for your
00:42:41.680 insight
00:42:42.080 have a
00:42:42.460 great day
00:42:42.940 and a
00:42:43.240 great week
00:42:43.720 I go
00:42:44.500 I go
00:42:44.800 every time I close
00:43:08.420 my eyes
00:43:09.720 something small
00:43:11.560 within me dies
00:43:14.040 can't say
00:43:15.380 if it's
00:43:16.280 dark or
00:43:17.360 bright
00:43:18.100 but it's
00:43:19.320 all I've
00:43:20.760 ever known
00:43:21.880 and when
00:43:22.900 I sleep
00:43:23.980 I sleep
00:43:25.040 alone
00:43:26.340 I'm
00:43:30.040 alone
00:43:31.540 I'm
00:43:38.320 alone
00:43:39.320 every time
00:43:48.000 I take a breath
00:43:50.360 something
00:43:51.340 once living
00:43:52.320 inside me
00:43:53.400 has left
00:43:54.420 yes it's alive
00:43:56.180 but it's just
00:43:57.220 passed through
00:43:58.300 it's just
00:43:59.300 left me
00:44:00.200 and it's
00:44:00.940 just left you
00:44:01.980 on
00:44:03.000 on
00:44:05.740 your
00:44:06.160 own
00:44:07.600 own
00:44:16.040 own
00:44:17.460 own
00:44:18.280 own
00:44:21.080 own
00:44:21.620 own
00:44:27.020 own
00:44:31.820 own
00:44:33.140 own
00:44:33.460 own
00:44:33.780 own
00:44:34.340 own
00:44:35.600 own
00:44:36.340 own
00:44:36.640 own
00:44:36.740 own
00:44:37.180 own
00:44:37.560 And I love you most, I love you most
00:44:45.560 When I first found love in myself
00:44:49.100 And I'll give to you, give it all to you
00:44:53.880 When I first find it in myself
00:44:57.420 And the time will come for everyone
00:45:02.020 For everyone to know
00:45:05.660 Yes, the time will come for everyone
00:45:10.660 For everyone to know
00:45:14.660 And say goodbye
00:45:21.660 And say goodbye
00:45:26.660 And say goodbye
00:45:32.660 Sweet dreams
00:45:36.660 Sweet time
00:45:40.660 Sweet time
00:45:44.660 This is CFRA Live Sunday Political Panel
00:45:57.660 And welcome back to our CFRA Live Sunday Political Panel
00:46:06.660 Joining us on the phone this morning, Warren Kinsella
00:46:08.660 He is a strategist and post-media columnist
00:46:10.660 You can read his latest in the Toronto Sun
00:46:12.660 Warren, good morning, thanks for joining us
00:46:14.660 Morning, sir
00:46:15.660 Tasha Carradine, political columnist for the National Post
00:46:17.660 Writer for GZERO Media
00:46:19.660 And an author is also here as well
00:46:21.660 Good morning, Tasha
00:46:22.660 Good morning
00:46:23.660 And Carl Bellagio going to join us in progress here as we get set up on the phones here
00:46:27.660 But just wanted to ask you guys just to start here
00:46:29.660 We are expecting an announcement tomorrow
00:46:31.660 The fall economic statement
00:46:33.660 So we could see the kind of first inklings of how the federal government is going to respond to these tariff threats
00:46:38.660 It's been a big conversation this week
00:46:41.660 I guess first we'll start
00:46:42.660 Warren, what do you expect from the Liberals tomorrow?
00:46:44.660 Do you expect them to take a very hard stance on this issue?
00:46:48.660 Well, I wish they would, but they haven't
00:46:50.660 You know, their response was to hustle down to Mar-a-Lago
00:46:53.660 And the Prime Minister kind of looked like, you know, a busboy
00:46:58.660 And Trump mocked him in Mar-a-Lago
00:47:02.660 And mocked him afterwards
00:47:04.660 And Trudeau got precisely nothing out of it
00:47:07.660 And, you know, Smith and Legault have similarly attempted to suck up to Trump
00:47:15.660 And it's gotten nothing
00:47:17.660 The only leader, quite frankly, at the national level
00:47:20.660 Who I think has done what Canadians would like to see is Ford
00:47:24.660 Who said, well, I'm going to turn off the power to the northern states if he goes ahead
00:47:28.660 And that got Trump's attention
00:47:31.660 Trump responded to that and not in an aggressive way
00:47:34.660 So, you know, Canadians, I think, long for the ways of, you know,
00:47:39.660 Chrétien to Bush on Iraq
00:47:42.660 Or, you know, Moroni to Reagan on South Africa
00:47:45.660 Or Pearson to, you know, LBJ
00:47:49.660 Like, we want to see some strength
00:47:51.660 And we're not getting it
00:47:53.660 And the only one who's shown any this week is Doug Ford
00:47:56.660 And I mentioned that yesterday as well, Warren
00:47:59.660 I'm going to circle back on the premiers as well
00:48:01.660 But, Tasha, just on the federal government's perspective here
00:48:04.660 They have been fairly quiet
00:48:05.660 I don't know if that's part of the strategy
00:48:07.660 But do you expect a big announcement tomorrow
00:48:09.660 Or a big kind of retaliatory strike?
00:48:11.660 Or are we going to try to play this out as true Canadians
00:48:14.660 And kind of not say anything?
00:48:16.660 I'm not sure what to expect, to be honest
00:48:18.660 Because everyone is singing a different song
00:48:21.660 And I'm a bit of a different opinion than Warren
00:48:23.660 I think the Prime Minister had an opportunity
00:48:25.660 When he went down to see Trump
00:48:27.660 And he blew it later by basically insulting him
00:48:31.660 And, yeah, Trump needled him about being the governor of the 51st state
00:48:35.660 That, you know, classic Trump
00:48:36.660 He should have just ignored it
00:48:37.660 But instead he doubled down
00:48:39.660 And basically said Trump shouldn't have been elected twice
00:48:42.660 Which, you know, a lot of people probably feel that way
00:48:45.660 And, you know, but you don't
00:48:47.660 As the Prime Minister of a country
00:48:48.660 Negotiating with somebody about trade agreements
00:48:51.660 And facing a tariff wall
00:48:53.660 You don't say that in the way he did
00:48:55.660 I mean, it was insane
00:48:56.660 And the premiers took him to task
00:48:57.660 Apparently on the call after that
00:48:59.660 Asking him, you know
00:49:00.660 Why are you making life more difficult?
00:49:02.660 And now they're all running around like headless chickens
00:49:04.660 All saying different things
00:49:06.660 And as for Ford, I mean
00:49:08.660 He could say all he wants to
00:49:09.660 And we can turn off the power
00:49:11.660 I mean, I get where he's coming from
00:49:14.660 It's not going to happen, right?
00:49:16.660 And all it does is make everyone, like I said
00:49:18.660 Look like they're saying something different
00:49:20.660 I think that what it is
00:49:24.660 It shows the failure of Trudeau's leadership
00:49:25.660 That this happened
00:49:26.660 That we have all these different approaches
00:49:28.660 To the same problem
00:49:30.660 Which is a tariff wall
00:49:31.660 That would devastate our economy
00:49:33.660 So I hope that tomorrow they come up with something
00:49:36.660 That makes sense
00:49:37.660 I'm not sure what that is
00:49:38.660 Because, I mean
00:49:39.660 If we oppose retaliatory tariffs
00:49:41.660 If we threaten to do that
00:49:42.660 And we end up in that situation
00:49:43.660 That will be a disaster
00:49:45.660 So it's kind of a lose-lose
00:49:46.660 I think that the smart thing to do
00:49:49.660 And would have always been to do
00:49:50.660 Would be to go to people in the U.S.
00:49:53.660 And get them to talk to Trump
00:49:56.660 Governors of states
00:49:57.660 Border states in particular
00:49:58.660 But others as well
00:49:59.660 That depend on our energy
00:50:00.660 And other things
00:50:01.660 Because that's where the pressure
00:50:03.660 That's who he'll listen to
00:50:04.660 That's who he'll listen to
00:50:05.660 He's not going to listen to Justin Trudeau
00:50:06.660 I don't even think he's going to listen to Doug Ford
00:50:08.660 And just a quick follow on that Tasha
00:50:10.660 Because we didn't get to it last week
00:50:11.660 But, you know, we sent Jamil Giovanni down
00:50:13.660 To talk to J.D. Vance
00:50:14.660 Because there's apparently some
00:50:15.660 Some bromance there
00:50:16.660 Do you think we should be kind of
00:50:17.660 You know, laying on those relationships
00:50:19.660 Is kind of what you're alluding to
00:50:20.660 A little bit
00:50:21.660 Is to, yeah, rely on those
00:50:22.660 Previously connected relationships
00:50:24.660 Well, it's sort of like what Warren was talking about
00:50:27.660 The relationship that Brian Mulrini had
00:50:29.660 With Ronald Reagan
00:50:30.660 You know, he had a very close relationship with him
00:50:33.660 But it wasn't
00:50:34.660 It was built on that friendship
00:50:37.660 And that cultivation of connection
00:50:39.660 And, you know, he could pick up the phone
00:50:41.660 Or his people could pick up the phone
00:50:42.660 And talk to Reagan about acid rain, for example
00:50:45.660 The acid rain treaty
00:50:46.660 Was apparently famously
00:50:48.660 Dealt with in a phone call
00:50:50.660 And this is the kind of thing
00:50:52.660 That is absent here
00:50:54.660 I don't see Trudeau picking up the phone
00:50:55.660 Any time soon
00:50:57.660 But those relationships are cultivated
00:50:59.660 You know, yes
00:51:00.660 With more rational actors, obviously
00:51:02.660 But cultivated also behind the scenes
00:51:04.660 They're not all played out in public
00:51:06.660 And Karl Blasier
00:51:07.660 The president at Traction Strategies
00:51:08.660 Is here this morning as well
00:51:10.660 Karl, I kind of split this up
00:51:11.660 In terms of the feds
00:51:12.660 And the premiers here
00:51:13.660 This conversation
00:51:14.660 But, you know, the feds
00:51:15.660 Expecting their economic statement tomorrow
00:51:16.660 We could see, you know
00:51:17.660 The first kind of inklings
00:51:19.660 Of how they will respond
00:51:20.660 To Donald Trump's threats here
00:51:21.660 Do you expect them to come in with a hammer?
00:51:23.660 Do you expect them to be
00:51:24.660 Kind of as they have been
00:51:25.660 A little bit, you know
00:51:26.660 Silent on this issue?
00:51:27.660 How do you expect
00:51:29.660 Or what do you expect
00:51:30.660 To see tomorrow from the feds?
00:51:31.660 Well, if I were them
00:51:32.660 I wouldn't talk about that
00:51:33.660 Because they're still hypothetical
00:51:35.660 You know, we still have some time
00:51:37.660 So why would you lead with that?
00:51:39.660 Don't put oil on the fire
00:51:40.660 You know, as Dasha said
00:51:42.660 When he made those comments
00:51:43.660 About Kamala Harris
00:51:44.660 Putting oil on the fire
00:51:45.660 It's not helpful
00:51:46.660 There's no need to do that
00:51:47.660 At this point
00:51:48.660 So, you know
00:51:50.660 The default economic statement
00:51:51.660 Should focus on domestic issues
00:51:53.660 And what can be done
00:51:55.660 To help people
00:51:56.660 Feel like they are getting ahead
00:51:59.660 Because right now
00:52:00.660 The voters here in Canada
00:52:02.660 Still feel
00:52:03.660 That they are not getting ahead
00:52:05.660 And that they're struggling
00:52:06.660 To make ends meet
00:52:07.660 And the measures
00:52:08.660 That were announced
00:52:09.660 By Trudeau before
00:52:10.660 A couple of weeks ago
00:52:12.660 About the GST rebate
00:52:13.660 And, you know
00:52:14.660 Happy GST all day
00:52:15.660 Everybody feel better today?
00:52:17.660 In two days
00:52:18.660 I don't think
00:52:19.660 It's going to change the needle
00:52:20.660 Right?
00:52:21.660 And we'll see what happens
00:52:22.660 With the check
00:52:23.660 If they ever happen
00:52:24.660 We need to focus on domestic issues
00:52:26.660 Now, when it comes to Trump
00:52:28.660 And dealing with Trump
00:52:29.660 I mean, the truth is that
00:52:31.660 You know, he is the one
00:52:32.660 Creating this situation
00:52:33.660 Right?
00:52:34.660 So we can blame Trudeau
00:52:35.660 For he's responding for sure
00:52:36.660 And I think the premiers
00:52:37.660 Are running around
00:52:38.660 Singing a different song
00:52:39.660 And there's no Team Canada
00:52:40.660 Whatsoever
00:52:41.660 Not sure they can be
00:52:42.660 With the current Prime Minister
00:52:43.660 And his current
00:52:45.660 Publicity levels
00:52:46.660 That said
00:52:47.660 It's going to be
00:52:48.660 Playing cards
00:52:49.660 With a guy like Trump
00:52:51.660 I'd rather have Doug Ford
00:52:52.660 As a partner
00:52:53.660 Francois Legault
00:52:54.660 Or Daniel Smith
00:52:55.660 Who are basically saying
00:52:56.660 The guy in front of us is right
00:52:57.660 We need to do something
00:52:58.660 To appease him
00:52:59.660 No, you have to fight fire
00:53:01.660 With fire
00:53:02.660 Which is where
00:53:03.660 You know, it's exactly
00:53:04.660 What Pierre Poirier said
00:53:05.660 He would do
00:53:06.660 I'm curious to see
00:53:07.660 What he would do
00:53:08.660 In this situation
00:53:09.660 Because so far
00:53:10.660 Instead of after
00:53:11.660 He said that
00:53:12.660 He has not laid out
00:53:14.660 Any kind of plan
00:53:15.660 How he would handle
00:53:16.660 The current threat
00:53:17.660 And I'm curious to see that
00:53:19.660 And just on that point
00:53:20.660 Of the premiers, Carl
00:53:21.660 Just, you know
00:53:22.660 You know, we have seen
00:53:23.660 Different messages coming
00:53:24.660 From different people
00:53:25.660 But as Warren kind of alluded
00:53:26.660 To as well
00:53:27.660 It seems like Doug Ford
00:53:28.660 Has been the most
00:53:29.660 I don't know about the most
00:53:30.660 But the most popular position
00:53:31.660 It seems to get a lot of
00:53:32.660 Support from people
00:53:33.660 On both sides of the aisle
00:53:34.660 In terms of his kind of
00:53:35.660 Tough nature
00:53:36.660 Is there a possibility here
00:53:37.660 That as you mentioned
00:53:38.660 We could lose that Team Canada
00:53:39.660 Approach in all of this
00:53:40.660 Kind of noise?
00:53:42.660 Yeah, I mean
00:53:43.660 Doug Ford's threats
00:53:45.660 Are, you know
00:53:46.660 Caught some people's attention
00:53:48.660 But let's face it
00:53:49.660 Ontario is not the main
00:53:50.660 Exporter of energy to the U.S.
00:53:52.660 We're talking about
00:53:53.660 1.5 million ohms
00:53:54.660 It's not nothing
00:53:55.660 But there's 300 million people
00:53:57.660 In the states
00:53:58.660 So 1.5 million ohms
00:53:59.660 Mostly in Michigan, Minnesota
00:54:01.660 And New York
00:54:02.660 Is not enough
00:54:03.660 To perhaps
00:54:04.660 Make Trump to back down
00:54:06.660 But if Daniel Smith
00:54:07.660 And Francois Legault
00:54:08.660 Were to say
00:54:09.660 Yeah, we're going to
00:54:10.660 Side with Doug Ford
00:54:11.660 We're going to side with Canada
00:54:12.660 And we're going to do
00:54:13.660 What's needed for our people
00:54:16.660 I think the governors
00:54:17.660 Will start paying attention to that
00:54:19.660 I think the governors
00:54:20.660 And state legislators
00:54:21.660 Will start calling in Washington
00:54:23.660 Calling in Mary Legault
00:54:24.660 And say, hey
00:54:25.660 If you do this to us
00:54:26.660 We will be in a world of trouble
00:54:28.660 And a world of trouble
00:54:29.660 And winter is coming
00:54:30.660 And that's not going to be good
00:54:32.660 For anyone, of course
00:54:33.660 Now, you have to be willing
00:54:35.660 To pay the price
00:54:36.660 And that's where Daniel Smith
00:54:37.660 Is not
00:54:38.660 And Francois Legault is not
00:54:39.660 They're not willing to pay the price
00:54:40.660 Because, you know
00:54:41.660 Cutting off the taps to the U.S.
00:54:43.660 Means a lot of lost revenues
00:54:45.660 And they believe they can't afford that
00:54:48.660 And it feels like
00:54:49.660 We're talking about like
00:54:50.660 World War I
00:54:51.660 Cutting off hydro to the enemy
00:54:52.660 Or what have you
00:54:53.660 Sorry, go ahead, Tasha
00:54:54.660 I was going to say
00:54:55.660 If they cut off supplies
00:54:56.660 You'd have the U.S. Army here
00:54:57.660 Because America can't function
00:54:59.660 Without our oil
00:55:00.660 And that
00:55:01.660 Alberta doesn't have a choice
00:55:03.660 But to send it
00:55:04.660 Honestly, like
00:55:05.660 Under this president
00:55:06.660 I don't think
00:55:07.660 You say World War I
00:55:08.660 Well, you know
00:55:09.660 I just don't think
00:55:10.660 That the Americans
00:55:11.660 Would literally stand for it
00:55:12.660 If we were to do that
00:55:14.660 Winter is coming
00:55:15.660 It's all I
00:55:16.660 Kind of imagining
00:55:17.660 It seems like
00:55:18.660 Kind of a history lesson
00:55:19.660 But just on that point
00:55:20.660 I guess
00:55:21.660 Warren, too, to follow up
00:55:22.660 Because the premiers here
00:55:23.660 We heard as
00:55:24.660 Carl kind of alluded to there
00:55:25.660 We've heard from
00:55:26.660 Legault and Smith on this
00:55:28.660 Premiers
00:55:29.660 Francois Legault and Daniel Smith
00:55:30.660 We're actually hearing
00:55:31.660 From Saskatchewan Premier
00:55:32.660 Scott Moe
00:55:33.660 Coming up this morning on CTV
00:55:34.660 He's going to speak with
00:55:35.660 Vashley Capellos
00:55:36.660 From that, he is saying
00:55:37.660 That retaliatory tariffs
00:55:38.660 Are not the way to go
00:55:39.660 It's going to sink the economy
00:55:40.660 Who's winning the messaging war here
00:55:43.660 Do you think, Warren
00:55:44.660 In terms of the best way
00:55:46.660 To kind of help Canadians
00:55:47.660 Moving forward?
00:55:48.660 Donald Trump is
00:55:49.660 Like, you know
00:55:50.660 Listening to my friends
00:55:52.660 Tasha and Carl
00:55:53.660 You know
00:55:54.660 It's like it was
00:55:55.660 Four years ago
00:55:56.660 Four years ago
00:55:57.660 It's listening to sane people
00:55:59.660 Talk about how to
00:56:01.660 Change the mind
00:56:02.660 Of an insane person
00:56:04.660 Okay?
00:56:05.660 It doesn't work
00:56:06.660 Yeah, that's right
00:56:07.660 Sucking up to this guy
00:56:09.660 Doesn't work
00:56:10.660 It's never worked
00:56:12.660 Ask any of the people
00:56:13.660 In American politics
00:56:14.660 Who he's humiliated
00:56:16.660 It doesn't work
00:56:17.660 What works with bullies
00:56:19.660 Is showing strength
00:56:20.660 We have to show strength
00:56:22.660 Now, ideally
00:56:23.660 It would be better
00:56:24.660 If Danielle Smith
00:56:25.660 And Francois Legault
00:56:27.660 Had this head right out of the gate
00:56:28.660 Oh, Donald Trump's right
00:56:30.660 That it would have been helpful
00:56:31.660 If they hadn't done that
00:56:32.660 But they did
00:56:33.660 It would have been helpful
00:56:34.660 If the prime minister
00:56:35.660 Had shown some strength
00:56:36.660 But like
00:56:37.660 We're just
00:56:38.660 We're getting back
00:56:39.660 Into the same old pathology
00:56:40.660 We've always had
00:56:41.660 Where we wake up
00:56:42.660 You know
00:56:43.660 Every morning
00:56:44.660 After figuring out
00:56:45.660 What Trump's going to say
00:56:46.660 Overnight
00:56:47.660 He's going ahead
00:56:48.660 With these tariffs guys
00:56:50.660 It's not a tactic
00:56:51.660 He needs the revenue
00:56:53.660 To create room
00:56:54.660 For the tax cut
00:56:55.660 That he's promised
00:56:56.660 To give people
00:56:57.660 That's what he's doing
00:56:58.660 The tariffs are going to happen
00:57:01.660 And Mexico and Canada
00:57:03.660 Are not going to stop them
00:57:04.660 What we need to figure out
00:57:06.660 Is how we deal with them
00:57:08.660 In the short term
00:57:09.660 In the long term
00:57:10.660 And sitting around
00:57:11.660 Trying to figure out
00:57:12.660 How an insane person thinks
00:57:13.660 Is a waste of time
00:57:14.660 You know
00:57:15.660 And then following
00:57:16.660 Into that fallacy
00:57:17.660 I've mentioned this
00:57:18.660 As well
00:57:19.660 We're trying to put
00:57:20.660 Rational thought
00:57:21.660 Into an irrational situation
00:57:22.660 And it is just what we do
00:57:23.660 But it is also
00:57:24.660 You know
00:57:25.660 Not the greatest
00:57:26.660 What we've seen
00:57:27.660 You can't predict the guy
00:57:28.660 You can't predict Donald Trump
00:57:29.660 Obviously south of the border
00:57:30.660 But Tasha that being said
00:57:31.660 There has to be
00:57:32.660 Some kind of message
00:57:33.660 I guess
00:57:34.660 Which message do you think
00:57:35.660 Is winning out right now
00:57:36.660 Is it you know
00:57:37.660 The Doug Ford strength
00:57:38.660 Is it the Legault
00:57:39.660 And Smith kind of
00:57:40.660 Trump is right
00:57:41.660 Is it Donald Trump
00:57:42.660 I guess
00:57:43.660 Who's winning out of all of this
00:57:44.660 Well the
00:57:45.660 I agree with Warren
00:57:46.660 But what's done
00:57:47.660 What has been done
00:57:48.660 What Trudeau did
00:57:49.660 Wasn't show strength
00:57:50.660 Trudeau insulted him
00:57:51.660 Like this is what you don't do
00:57:52.660 With a bully
00:57:53.660 Is like
00:57:54.660 Is you know
00:57:55.660 Stand there going
00:57:56.660 Yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah
00:57:57.660 Which is basically what he did
00:57:58.660 I mean this is
00:57:59.660 Showing strength would have been
00:58:00.660 To ignore
00:58:01.660 And come out with
00:58:02.660 A clear statement
00:58:03.660 And a plan
00:58:04.660 If it was
00:58:05.660 It was along the lines
00:58:06.660 Of Doug Ford saying
00:58:07.660 Okay you know what
00:58:08.660 You're going to hit us
00:58:09.660 We're going to retaliate too
00:58:10.660 We're not going to necessarily
00:58:11.660 Tell you what that is right now
00:58:12.660 But you know
00:58:13.660 Just watch me
00:58:14.660 That's strength
00:58:15.660 Insulted Trump personally
00:58:16.660 Which of course
00:58:17.660 Will just make him more angry
00:58:18.660 And cause a whole stupid
00:58:20.660 You know Elon Musk
00:58:21.660 Tit for tat
00:58:22.660 Stuff on Twitter
00:58:23.660 I mean it's just stupid
00:58:24.660 I think that what Doug Ford did
00:58:26.660 Was get ahead of things
00:58:28.660 And say we're going to do this
00:58:29.660 And like well you don't know
00:58:30.660 You could do that
00:58:31.660 I think he tried to approach it
00:58:32.660 From a business perspective
00:58:33.660 I get that
00:58:34.660 It's like I will do this
00:58:35.660 If you do that
00:58:36.660 But the problem is
00:58:37.660 No one else is singing that song
00:58:38.660 So he's the only one out there
00:58:40.660 And yeah I mean appeasing
00:58:42.660 Is also wrong
00:58:43.660 I agree
00:58:44.660 What everyone should have done
00:58:45.660 Is just shut up
00:58:46.660 They should have all
00:58:47.660 Not said anything
00:58:48.660 And made a plan
00:58:49.660 And then stuck to it
00:58:50.660 And that's not what they did
00:58:51.660 That would have been the strength
00:58:52.660 That would have made sense
00:58:53.660 Because Trump isn't in office
00:58:54.660 Until the 20th of January anyway
00:58:57.660 So we do have time
00:58:58.660 And I just want to be fair
00:59:01.660 For what the government's line has been
00:59:02.660 Dominic LeBlanc asked about this on Friday
00:59:04.660 He says that you know
00:59:05.660 We shouldn't take these disagreements
00:59:07.660 As you know
00:59:08.660 Not being a Team Canada approach
00:59:09.660 Take that as you will
00:59:11.660 Wanted to get to a couple of other topics
00:59:13.660 In here as well
00:59:14.660 We've seen the feds
00:59:15.660 Kind of intervening
00:59:16.660 They have forced an end
00:59:17.660 To this Canada post strike
00:59:18.660 In theory here
00:59:19.660 As they've sent it
00:59:20.660 To the Canadian Industrial Relations Board
00:59:22.660 Carl I'll start with you on this one
00:59:23.660 Did they have no choice
00:59:24.660 Less than two weeks before Christmas
00:59:26.660 With all of the headaches
00:59:28.660 They've been hearing about this
00:59:29.660 Over the past few weeks
00:59:31.660 Well I mean it's too late for Christmas
00:59:33.660 It seems that way
00:59:35.660 I don't know
00:59:36.660 The Labour Minister seems to think
00:59:37.660 Next week the mail is going to be up
00:59:38.660 And running again
00:59:39.660 But I digress
00:59:40.660 But even if it's running again
00:59:41.660 Like the backlog alone
00:59:43.660 Yeah
00:59:44.660 You will not be able to mail
00:59:46.660 A Christmas card to Grandma
00:59:47.660 And for her to get it before Christmas
00:59:49.660 It's not happening guys
00:59:50.660 So why did they wait so long
00:59:52.660 If they were going to end up doing that
00:59:54.660 That's why
00:59:56.660 That's what I don't understand
00:59:57.660 If you're going to pay a political price
00:59:58.660 For forcing them back to work
01:00:00.660 Why are you waiting?
01:00:02.660 Because at this point
01:00:04.660 You've paid the political price
01:00:05.660 People will get their order laid
01:00:07.660 Their Christmas cards late
01:00:10.660 Everything's going to be late
01:00:11.660 It's already late
01:00:13.660 And so to what end?
01:00:15.660 I'm not sure where the win is
01:00:18.660 For the government at this point
01:00:20.660 I guess they had no choice at this time
01:00:23.660 But why not last week
01:00:24.660 When like the week before
01:00:25.660 This is what I don't get
01:00:27.660 And Carl just a quick follow on that
01:00:28.660 Because obviously I know
01:00:29.660 The NDP are kind of raising in the polls right now
01:00:31.660 So the Liberals are looking over their shoulders
01:00:33.660 At the NDP here
01:00:34.660 Is that why you think perhaps
01:00:35.660 Even that they were waiting
01:00:37.660 And even when they have moved here
01:00:38.660 That they haven't come down as hard
01:00:39.660 As they possibly could have
01:00:40.660 Do you think they're looking over their shoulder
01:00:41.660 At the NDP
01:00:42.660 And worried about
01:00:43.660 You know unionized labor support
01:00:44.660 And what that could mean
01:00:45.660 In the next election?
01:00:46.660 Maybe
01:00:47.660 But like they didn't care so much
01:00:49.660 When it was rail or the ports
01:00:51.660 Right?
01:00:52.660 Yeah
01:00:53.660 So what in effect
01:00:54.660 What the government was doing
01:00:55.660 Was picking winners and losers
01:00:57.660 And in the case of postal workers
01:00:59.660 They were deemed as not as important
01:01:02.660 As the other workers
01:01:03.660 When it comes to the national interest
01:01:05.660 And therefore did it play out
01:01:07.660 But frankly
01:01:08.660 I don't see the NDP
01:01:10.660 Bring down the government
01:01:11.660 Before Christmas
01:01:12.660 Because the postal workers
01:01:13.660 Are going back to work
01:01:15.660 I don't see it happening
01:01:16.660 So are they really worried?
01:01:18.660 I'm not sure
01:01:19.660 And yeah Tasha
01:01:20.660 What do you make of this situation?
01:01:21.660 As Carl is kind of alluding to
01:01:22.660 You know why now
01:01:23.660 Of all of the times
01:01:24.660 To kind of get this done
01:01:25.660 We could have had this
01:01:26.660 You know a week ago
01:01:27.660 And maybe we get a little bit closer
01:01:28.660 To having some mail for Christmas here
01:01:30.660 I'm still not very optimistic
01:01:32.660 That we're going to see that
01:01:33.660 But what do you make of the Liberals
01:01:34.660 I guess half kind of stepping in here
01:01:36.660 And kind of I guess
01:01:37.660 Punting the political football
01:01:38.660 To the Canadian Industrial Relations Board?
01:01:40.660 Well it's being half pregnant
01:01:43.660 Exactly
01:01:44.660 It doesn't work
01:01:45.660 It doesn't make sense
01:01:46.660 I agree they should have acted earlier
01:01:47.660 If they were going to act
01:01:49.660 I think Canada Post
01:01:50.660 Has also shot itself in the foot
01:01:51.660 By striking it this time of year
01:01:52.660 Because a lot of people
01:01:53.660 Are going to remember it
01:01:54.660 And they're not going to look favorably
01:01:55.660 And a lot of people
01:01:56.660 Will change habits
01:01:57.660 You know maybe
01:01:58.660 Grandma's going to get
01:01:59.660 An e-card next year
01:02:00.660 And people are changing also
01:02:03.660 People who are getting checks still
01:02:04.660 From some of their suppliers
01:02:05.660 They're now going to electronic transfer
01:02:08.660 They've already made the change
01:02:09.660 Because well okay
01:02:10.660 You can't rely on the postal service
01:02:12.660 So I think actually
01:02:13.660 Canada Post is going to lose out of this
01:02:14.660 No matter what they get in their negotiations
01:02:16.660 But I think the government
01:02:18.660 Yeah the government didn't want to upset union workers
01:02:20.660 And they're terrified
01:02:21.660 They're going to leave
01:02:22.660 Not necessarily just for the NDP
01:02:25.660 Or they're going to go to the Conservatives
01:02:27.660 Quite frankly that's the market
01:02:28.660 That's really looking for that vote
01:02:30.660 So yeah they didn't pull the plug
01:02:32.660 They were waiting
01:02:33.660 Maybe they were distracted by Mar-a-Lago too
01:02:35.660 This happened in Trudeau's first term
01:02:37.660 When Trump came in
01:02:38.660 It upset the apple cart
01:02:40.660 All the everything
01:02:41.660 You know all the priorities
01:02:42.660 Got moved around
01:02:44.660 Because there was no time and space for them
01:02:46.660 When Trump took up so much oxygen
01:02:48.660 So that's going to happen again
01:02:49.660 And you know this again
01:02:51.660 They were asleep at the switch
01:02:52.660 Dealing with other things
01:02:53.660 Economic statement
01:02:54.660 Etc
01:02:55.660 Oh yeah postal to post
01:02:56.660 We've got to deal with that
01:02:57.660 And here we are
01:02:58.660 And Warren what do you make of
01:03:00.660 Kind of the move on this
01:03:01.660 It seems you know politically
01:03:02.660 Like they could have
01:03:03.660 They could have let this keep going
01:03:05.660 And perhaps not not paid a price
01:03:07.660 But they've seemed to
01:03:08.660 Kind of half-heartedly
01:03:09.660 Push this over to the Canadian
01:03:10.660 Industrial Relations Board
01:03:11.660 Just what do you make of this?
01:03:13.660 Well believe me they're going to pay a price
01:03:14.660 You know it's the typical Trudeau
01:03:16.660 Government approach
01:03:17.660 Let's figure out the perfect way
01:03:19.660 To get everybody mad at us
01:03:22.660 And so they've done that
01:03:24.660 You know and I am pro-union
01:03:27.660 I've worked for unions
01:03:29.660 Like I think the union leadership
01:03:32.660 Not the membership
01:03:33.660 Because I know some of the membership
01:03:35.660 Of the Cub W made a big mistake
01:03:37.660 Seeking 22% at a time like this
01:03:41.660 Was dreaming in Technicolor
01:03:43.660 A lot of membership are mad at them
01:03:45.660 Management of course you know
01:03:47.660 Messed it up as they always do
01:03:49.660 At Canada Post
01:03:50.660 They have terrible management there
01:03:51.660 But Steve McKinnon is a joke
01:03:53.660 Like I'm sorry
01:03:55.660 But basically he's cancelled Christmas
01:03:57.660 Like this is the biggest Grinch move
01:03:59.660 I've ever seen a government do
01:04:01.660 And I know people like real people
01:04:03.660 Small businesses and so on
01:04:05.660 Who are in big trouble
01:04:07.660 Because they were counting on the Christmas season
01:04:09.660 To sell stuff
01:04:10.660 They were counting
01:04:11.660 They've been waiting for checks
01:04:12.660 And they're waiting for visas
01:04:13.660 Waiting for passports
01:04:15.660 Like this has had a real impact
01:04:17.660 On people's lives
01:04:18.660 And it's not going to be forgotten
01:04:19.660 And I know there's Conservatives out there
01:04:21.660 And all saying well
01:04:22.660 We're going to privatize the system
01:04:23.660 That's stupid too
01:04:25.660 Because you know
01:04:26.660 You go to UPS or Perlator
01:04:28.660 And the others now
01:04:29.660 They're all saying
01:04:30.660 We've got so much volume
01:04:31.660 We can't keep up
01:04:32.660 And we can't guarantee
01:04:33.660 We're going to deliver your package
01:04:34.660 By Christmas
01:04:35.660 It is a total mess
01:04:37.660 And you know
01:04:38.660 To me it just really feels like
01:04:40.660 One of the final nails
01:04:41.660 In the Trudeau government's coffin
01:04:42.660 Where they've actually killed
01:04:45.660 Canada Post
01:04:46.660 They've actually killed
01:04:47.660 One of the few things
01:04:48.660 We pay them to do
01:04:49.660 And they screwed that up too
01:04:51.660 And just a note
01:04:52.660 Lost 500 million dollars
01:04:54.660 In the last quarter
01:04:55.660 In terms of Canada Post
01:04:56.660 So we're talking about
01:04:57.660 This current strike
01:04:58.660 But obviously it's business model
01:04:59.660 Would need to come under
01:05:00.660 A microscope here as well
01:05:01.660 We've run out of time
01:05:02.660 Unfortunately for today
01:05:03.660 But I want to thank you guys
01:05:04.660 Once again for joining us
01:05:05.660 Tasha Carradine, Warren Kinsella
01:05:06.660 And Carl Belanger
01:05:07.660 I hope you guys have a great Sunday
01:05:08.660 Thank you
01:05:09.660 Thank you
01:05:10.660 Thanks guys
01:05:11.660 Thank you guys
01:05:12.660 Carl Belanger is the president
01:05:13.660 At Traction Strategies
01:05:14.660 Warren Kinsella is a strategist
01:05:15.660 In Post Media column
01:05:16.660 As you read his latest
01:05:17.660 In the Trudeau
01:05:18.660 And I'm hearing it
01:05:19.660 And I'm going to call it
01:05:20.660 The next day
01:05:21.660 I'm sick of fucked up
01:05:22.660 Didn't know that shit
01:05:23.660 That I shouldn't have done
01:05:24.660 Alcohol and vaccine drugs
01:05:26.660 Spending all my time
01:05:27.660 With people in the scum
01:05:29.660 I've had a souvenir
01:05:30.660 Are you wasting some of my best years?
01:05:33.660 I want love that I won't regret
01:05:34.660 I want memories that I won't forget
01:05:35.660 I want memories that I won't forget
01:05:37.660 We're all dying
01:05:39.660 Nine million digits yet
01:05:41.660 I want love that I won't regret
01:05:43.660 I want memories that I won't forget
01:05:46.660 We're all dying
01:05:48.660 Nine million digits yet
01:05:51.660 Last night I fell in love
01:05:54.660 With all the people that made me feel whole
01:05:57.660 Talk and talk and never sleep
01:05:59.660 I go to wax to get coffee
01:06:01.660 Give me a dark home tattoo
01:06:03.660 With a hug back rat and a kangaroo
01:06:06.660 I want love that I won't regret
01:06:08.660 I want memories that I won't forget
01:06:10.660 We're all dying
01:06:12.660 Nine million digits yet
01:06:14.660 I want love that I won't regret
01:06:17.660 I want memories that I won't forget
01:06:19.660 We're all dying
01:06:21.660 Nine million digits yet
01:06:24.660 I love you
01:06:27.660 I used to hate me
01:06:30.660 Now I love me
01:06:32.660 And I hate you
01:06:35.660 I love you
01:06:37.660 I used to hate me
01:06:39.660 Now I love me
01:06:41.660 And I hate you
01:06:44.660 Do da
01:06:46.660 La di da do da
01:06:48.660 My life is so fun
01:06:50.660 La di da do da
01:06:52.660 Do da
01:06:54.660 La di da do da
01:06:57.660 My life is so fun
01:06:59.660 La di da do da
01:07:01.660 I love me
01:07:03.660 I love me
01:07:04.660 I love me
01:07:06.660 I love me
01:07:08.660 I love me
01:07:09.660 I love me
01:07:10.660 I love me
01:07:12.660 I love me
01:07:14.660 I love me
01:07:16.660 I love me
01:07:18.660 I love me
01:07:19.660 I love me
01:07:22.660 Welcome back to the Ben Mulrooney Show on the Chorus Radio Network. It's Friday, so it's time for our political panel this week in politics. We're looking back at all the stories that we talked about.
01:07:32.660 The stories that we talked about this week that are still resonating and are still impactful. And it's time to welcome to the show both friends of the Ben Mulrooney Show and friends of Ben Mulrooney. Yes, I reference myself in the third person. Please say hi to Warren Kinsella, former special advisor to Jean Chrétien and CEO of the Daisy Group.
01:07:49.720 Hey there, Ben Mulrooney. I am a friend of Ben Mulrooney.
01:07:53.220 And Adam Zivo, National Post columnist and executive director for the Center for Responsible Drug Policy.
01:07:58.660 It's a pleasure to be here. I'm also a friend of Ben Mulrooney.
01:08:01.160 Well, there we go. I'm glad we could level set.
01:08:04.880 Listen, news breaking today, gentlemen, is that the federal labor minister, Stephen McKinnon, is telling Canada Post as well as the striking workers to figure it out by the end of the year or we'll figure it out for you.
01:08:16.060 So just in time for Orthodox Christmas on January 7th.
01:08:20.020 It's been saved. Thank goodness, guys.
01:08:23.280 Warren, I'm going to start with you.
01:08:24.660 If they were going to do this, shouldn't they have done this weeks ago?
01:08:28.100 I mean, on the first day of the strike, I was livid saying all the problems that the workers had were still going to be there for them on January 1st.
01:08:36.440 But to do this is to is to just create another problem for already struggling businesses across this country.
01:08:42.760 Oh, come on, Ben. Don't be so critical.
01:08:45.640 I mean, you know, when Notre Dame, when the church in Paris was burning to the ground, isn't it better to wait till it completely incinerates before you send in the fire department?
01:08:55.400 That that that is the Trudeau government's like approach to this insane situation where, you know, like even if they had settled this thing yesterday, even if they'd been somehow ordered back to work yesterday, we have been told that all of the packages and all of the letters and Christmas cards and passports, everything that's hung up in the system wouldn't have been delivered in time for Christmas anyway.
01:09:25.400 And like, you know, all of us, the three of us, we're all hearing from people who run small businesses who were already in trouble because of a whole bunch of reasons and mismanagement of the national economy are in huge trouble and are not going to make it to the end of January.
01:09:41.480 Like this is a fiasco to me, even bigger than the tariff threat from Trump, which I suspect we're going to talk about.
01:09:49.760 Like this is a total disaster for so many people and shame on the Trudeau guys for not for messing it up.
01:09:56.220 Adam, how much of influence do you think Jagmeet Singh and his NDP had on the decision to be hands off in these negotiations?
01:10:05.860 Because, you know, that they have they have telegraphed in the past that they do not want the government ever getting involved in labor disputes.
01:10:12.420 It's up to the unions themselves to have agency over themselves and the decisions they make.
01:10:17.300 And if the government is going to step in, well, then, you know, he's going to have to tape up that agreement so he can rip it up again.
01:10:23.300 Well, I think he's obviously had a lot of influence here because he's propping up the Trudeau government.
01:10:28.880 And had he shown more leadership and stood up for small business owners and everyday working Canadians, perhaps this would have been resolved earlier.
01:10:37.660 And I think that, of course, you know, the NDP, they're very pro union.
01:10:41.020 They reflexively support unions no matter what.
01:10:43.220 But this is the case where you clearly have a union that is making unreasonable demands and essentially extorting taxpayers.
01:10:50.340 So I just want to put a few things in perspective here.
01:10:52.220 Right. So Canada Post has lost between five hundred to seven hundred million dollars each year from 2020 onwards.
01:10:59.240 That's two billion dollars in the past four years.
01:11:02.040 And people might say, well, you know what, it's a public service.
01:11:04.840 Public services aren't supposed to run a profit.
01:11:07.600 But the question here is, are they running this service efficiently?
01:11:11.460 And when you look at it, full time employees get up to seven weeks of vacation and 13 personal days, which is insane,
01:11:18.180 considering the fact that they're not that they're losing so much money.
01:11:20.480 And on top of that, when you look at some of the things that the unions are claiming, so they say, for example, that delivering the mail is hazardous because you need to look out for for dogs and tripping hazards such as branches,
01:11:31.940 as well as obstacles like scooters left in the middle of the driveway.
01:11:35.240 And look, when I was 12 years old, my best friend delivered newspapers all summer and he seemed to find walking much less hazardous.
01:11:42.600 So I don't think this is reasonable.
01:11:46.060 And I think that, you know, things should have called out this union for for essentially making unions writ large look really bad.
01:11:55.060 And Warren, you know, I am not I don't have a reflexive problem with unions.
01:11:59.340 I think they are they are valuable.
01:12:00.640 They play a very important role in our society and they make they make the lives of so many people better.
01:12:05.640 They've made the workplace better and on and on and on.
01:12:08.960 Had they waited till after Christmas, they would have they would probably have some version of an ally in a person like myself because they have decided to to to take advantage and make life worse for the engine of the economy,
01:12:25.460 for entrepreneurs who have bet on themselves, who do not have job security.
01:12:28.760 They're trying to get job security on the backs of people who do not have it.
01:12:31.900 They do not have one iota of support in a person like myself.
01:12:36.120 Did they misplay this?
01:12:37.380 Could they have gotten more public support?
01:12:39.120 Had they waited till after Christmas?
01:12:41.060 Yeah, I think they did misplay it.
01:12:42.580 And I say that as somebody is I was when I was a labor lawyer.
01:12:45.280 I represented Cup W.
01:12:47.100 I represented the union.
01:12:48.700 But I think this is an instance where the leadership is out of sync with the membership.
01:12:53.180 And I am pro union like you.
01:12:55.260 Unions do good things for people.
01:12:57.620 But, you know, seeking a 22 percent increase at a time when everybody's hurting, like we'd all like to get that.
01:13:06.160 But it just doesn't make a whole lot of sense.
01:13:08.640 So I understood management's resistance to it.
01:13:11.780 And, you know, and I understood why they were doing it at Christmas time, you know, because they wanted to apply pressure.
01:13:18.040 But I've talked to some of the striking workers on the picket line and they they're unhappy with their leadership.
01:13:24.860 They're obviously happening unhappy with management.
01:13:27.920 But I think they all acknowledge now that they miscalculated.
01:13:31.200 They thought this would be settled by now.
01:13:33.580 I think a lot of people thought it would be settled by now.
01:13:35.780 And it's not.
01:13:36.360 So on the other side of this, when we, you know, whether they're legislated back to work or what have you, we're going to have a situation where as a country, you're going to have a lot of people like not anti-union people, serious, reasonable people saying, do we really need a national postal service?
01:13:53.840 And that's a bad position for the union to have.
01:13:55.940 Adam, we've got to take a look at the growing marshalling of resources and and and to to to protect Canada against this looming threat of tariffs from Donald Trump.
01:14:09.400 And one of the people who's assuming a position of leadership nationally is Ontario Premier Doug Ford, who's now mulling a ban on U.S.
01:14:18.160 booze across the the LCBO system in Canada, in Ontario.
01:14:24.380 Do you think that that is what do you think of that?
01:14:27.840 Is again, are the Americans going to feel that or is this or is it going to be like true to Trump swatting a fly?
01:14:36.560 Well, I think it's going to have an actual effect because, I mean, when it comes to booze, there are other people who can other other international suppliers who can just easily replace, you know, our demand.
01:14:46.760 I'm sorry, other other international purchasers.
01:14:49.260 I think that the more effective strategy would be to cut off U.S.
01:14:54.140 markets from Ontario's electricity exports.
01:14:56.900 So we essentially export enough power to to to supply one point five million homes, you know, in New York, Michigan and Wisconsin.
01:15:04.540 And that's something that doesn't really cost us a lot of money because we have excess capacity.
01:15:08.880 We actually sell this electricity at a discount because we don't really know what to do with it.
01:15:13.080 So this would be an opportunity for us to inflict a real cost on the U.S.
01:15:19.540 in retaliation for their tariffs without actually losing too much on our end.
01:15:23.720 And I think that we should be focusing on that and not on these symbolic gestures like booze sales.
01:15:28.480 A warrant between Ontario's Doug Ford, Alberta's Daniel Smith and the and our federal leader in Justin Trudeau, who has who has stepped up and is is leading the charge in the most efficient, effective and optimal way right now?
01:15:45.200 Doug Ford.
01:15:45.880 Yeah.
01:15:46.160 Doug Ford, Doug Ford.
01:15:47.140 And, you know, what's interesting, what happened yesterday is the statement that Ford made saying, you know, his job is to defend the economic interests of Ontarians.
01:15:59.620 But he also said, I'm defending the economic interests of Canadians.
01:16:03.480 And like we've been starving for that.
01:16:06.320 We've been waiting for somebody at the national level to say to Trump, who, as you guys know, I regard as a bully and a thug, to say no and pop him on the nose.
01:16:16.420 And because it's already worked, you know, Trump, I think Trump was surprised.
01:16:20.820 He said, well, I have lots of friends in Canada.
01:16:22.940 Sounds like the kind of thing that a bully always says.
01:16:25.640 You pop them on the nose.
01:16:27.000 Yeah.
01:16:27.260 And, you know, meanwhile, Trudeau going down there to Mar-a-Lago with a tail between his legs.
01:16:31.940 Smith saying Trump is right.
01:16:33.460 It's like, well, that's a hell of a bargaining position.
01:16:36.820 Warren, we're going to we're going to stick a pin in that.
01:16:38.960 We're going to come back after the break with more from our political panel.
01:16:41.340 This Week in Politics continues on the Ben Mulroney Show.
01:16:44.420 And we're joined by Warren Kinsella and Adam Zeebo.
01:16:47.620 Thank you guys for sticking around.
01:16:49.640 All right.
01:16:49.960 The Kamala Harris's presidential defeat was an attack on women's progress, according to Justin Trudeau.
01:16:56.100 And Adam, the question is, was he trying and failing to talk tough to Donald Trump?
01:17:01.460 Or is this the beginning of his election campaign and his strategy to campaign against Donald Trump?
01:17:11.920 It's hard to say, because the thing is that Trudeau seems to genuinely believe that his critics are all racist or sexist.
01:17:19.280 This has been a common theme throughout his political career.
01:17:24.100 And, you know, either he believes this or he doesn't.
01:17:28.360 And if he doesn't believe this, then he's cynically trying to shore up his party's support at the cost of the nation's interest, because it's absurd that he's using this kind of language during a particularly sensitive time for U.S.-Canadian relations.
01:17:38.600 But if he does genuinely believe this, then it epitomizes everything that's wrong with this form of progressivism, which has been so popular over the past 10 years in North America.
01:17:49.360 I mean, when we look at the underlying polling data, you know, 51 percent of women voted for Harris, 45 percent voted for Trump.
01:17:56.400 That's not a huge divide.
01:17:57.780 Right. So 45 percent of women are sexist because they didn't support Harris.
01:18:03.220 That's a bold claim to make.
01:18:05.040 And I think it makes Trump Trudeau look very foolish.
01:18:07.580 Warren, nobody knows election campaigns more than you.
01:18:10.380 So let's just let's just remind people what Justin Trudeau said on the subject of being an ally to women.
01:18:17.180 No, it shouldn't be that way.
01:18:18.960 It wasn't supposed to be that way.
01:18:20.920 We were supposed to be on a steady, if difficult sometimes, march towards progress.
01:18:26.520 And yet, just a few weeks ago, the United States voted for a second time to not elect its first woman president.
01:18:36.820 Everywhere, women's rights and women's progress is under attack, overtly and subtly.
01:18:44.240 I want you to know that I am and always will be a proud feminist.
01:18:49.160 You will always have an ally in me and in my government.
01:18:52.300 Now, Warren, your guy, who was an old white guy, defeated the only woman to ever run for to run as prime minister, defeated her party quite handily.
01:19:02.020 Nobody accused Jean Chrétien of being anti-woman.
01:19:05.600 No, and I ran his war room in that election.
01:19:08.860 And, you know, I mean, as a general proposition, we should have a female prime minister by now.
01:19:15.900 We should have more women in public life.
01:19:19.700 So what Trudeau said, you know, he's right and he's wrong.
01:19:24.380 He's right.
01:19:25.440 You know, we should have more women.
01:19:27.720 We should be working to advance, you know, gender parity.
01:19:31.500 Those are good things.
01:19:33.340 The problem with it is he shouldn't be the guy saying it, right?
01:19:37.680 Because he is in the middle of this massive potential trade war with Donald Trump.
01:19:45.380 And, you know, effectively what he's saying there is Donald Trump didn't deserve to win.
01:19:49.940 That's probably not a good negotiating strategy when it comes to fighting over the 25 percent tariff.
01:19:56.960 So, you know, yeah, for sure.
01:19:59.240 More women at senior levels in public life.
01:20:02.200 It's a good thing.
01:20:03.080 And, you know, and I worked, full disclosure, as you guys know, for Hillary and I worked for Kamala and I was proud to do so.
01:20:10.900 Is there a problem in Canada and the United States about electing women for the most senior job?
01:20:16.640 Yes, I believe he's right about that.
01:20:18.920 But he's not the guy who should be saying it.
01:20:20.720 And it seems as we move into our next story, it seemed a little tone deaf to be that definitive about his feminist bona fides.
01:20:27.000 All while there is a trouble brewing on the home front with regard to his female finance minister in Chrystia Freeland.
01:20:35.620 We've got a little bit of audio from Melissa Lansman and Pierre Polyev who lay the scene.
01:20:40.440 The prime minister bullies females and he bullies finance ministers.
01:20:43.880 And now he's bullying a female finance minister.
01:20:46.540 How much longer is she going to put up with that?
01:20:49.000 He went and got his banker friend, Carbon Tax Carney, to become his top economic advisor, stripping the power away from his finance minister.
01:20:59.900 And suddenly the guardrail was broken.
01:21:03.000 Is he really going to subject his finance minister to the humiliation of reading Carney's fiscal update, which busts through the guardrail?
01:21:10.120 I'm going to get each of you to read the tea leaves and predict what's going to happen next week.
01:21:14.640 Adam, you go first.
01:21:15.660 Well, I think obviously the Trudeau government is looking for some kind of dramatic change, given that their polling numbers haven't improved in over a year.
01:21:26.220 And the fact that he's continuing to court Mark Carney suggests that there will be some shivving of Freeland's career.
01:21:35.660 But and it's quite obvious that, you know, there's tension between the two of them.
01:21:39.900 She promised that the deficit will come under $40 billion.
01:21:41.980 The parliamentary budget officer expects the deficit to reach $46.8 billion.
01:21:47.020 He's he's undermining her.
01:21:48.820 And it appears that the piece setting up, you know, her political downfall.
01:21:53.080 So I wouldn't be surprised if ultimately, you know, she's she's she's loses her position.
01:22:01.060 Warren, what say you?
01:22:02.860 She's leaving.
01:22:03.900 And what I'm told by my sources, she's leaving.
01:22:06.440 She's got a book coming out in February, kind of, you know, a biography, autobiography thing.
01:22:12.760 And then I think she's going to pack it in.
01:22:14.500 But if I were her like this is like, you know, Trudeau, like we've seen this movie before.
01:22:20.160 Jane Philpott and Jody Wilson-Raybould can testify to it.
01:22:23.420 If you're a woman, if you have power, if you have authority and if you dared to say no to Justin Trudeau, you are going to get thrown under the proverbial bus.
01:22:33.460 That's how this guy operates.
01:22:35.280 And this stuff about being a feminist is, well, I can't say the word on air.
01:22:39.320 Yeah.
01:22:39.520 But you know what I mean?
01:22:40.820 Like he is lying about being a feminist.
01:22:43.640 He is not.
01:22:44.380 And the appalling way that he is, I'm no fan of Christopher Freeland, but the way in which he has humiliated her is an absolute disgrace.
01:22:54.120 And by the way, I don't understand why Mark Carney is thinking about jumping on the deck of the Titanic, but apparently he is.
01:22:59.600 So it's just shameful.
01:23:01.120 The whole thing is shameful.
01:23:02.020 Lastly, there's a story that came out that said that the prime minister's four-day trip to Europe racked up a bill of $71,000 in food.
01:23:11.960 And that works out to an average meal cost about $145.
01:23:15.820 And when you add it to the total food bill, it averaged more than $1,700 per member of the Canadian delegation.
01:23:21.980 Now, to put that into context, the average Canadian family of four spends less than that on food per month.
01:23:27.520 That's according to StatsCan.
01:23:28.580 So the question for you, we'll start with you, Adam, is like, are we are we numb to this?
01:23:34.780 Because we hear so many stories of overspending and billions of dollars lost going down rat holes and just a government addicted to spending.
01:23:43.440 We heard a story last week at $34.8 million was spent on sleeping bags for the military that are unsuitable for Canadian winters.
01:23:50.360 I mean, are we are we numb to this now?
01:23:53.780 Well, so what I would say is that obviously this is an example of overspending.
01:23:57.240 But I think the issue is being blown out of proportion.
01:23:59.500 Yeah.
01:23:59.880 Right.
01:24:00.240 So we have a few $10,000 that have been wasted.
01:24:03.280 And that's unfortunate.
01:24:04.620 I mean, you're looking at about $145 per meal.
01:24:07.480 But we have to keep in mind that business travel, much like weddings, often involves people being overcharged.
01:24:14.240 So I wonder how much of this could be avoided.
01:24:16.160 And let's look into it, like, let's put things into context.
01:24:19.780 Much more money is wasted on inflated consulting fees and other contracts.
01:24:25.540 Think, for example, the $54 million wasted on a Rivecam.
01:24:28.380 And that kind of waste is hard to visualize.
01:24:31.800 Yeah.
01:24:32.180 Because this work is a black box.
01:24:33.820 But that's what we should be focusing on.
01:24:35.460 We should be focusing on the millions of dollars wasted on inefficient programs and consultants, not a few $10,000 on meals and accommodations.
01:24:43.160 And, Warren, I'm not a cheapskate.
01:24:45.860 I think our government should spend the money that we need to spend because we're a G7 country.
01:24:50.860 And stuff costs money.
01:24:52.060 So I'm not averse to spending money.
01:24:55.360 But I also grew up believing that if you take care of the pennies, the dollars will take care of themselves.
01:25:01.520 So I'm a little conflicted.
01:25:05.740 Well, I'm not.
01:25:06.680 I totally disagree with my colleague Adam.
01:25:09.100 Completely, totally disagree.
01:25:10.720 Our colleague, Brian Passifium, has written for Postmedia about this in the past hour or so.
01:25:16.860 So the trip cost close to a million dollars for the trip to Italy and Switzerland.
01:25:22.720 Okay.
01:25:23.100 And like he says, maybe that's part of the job.
01:25:27.120 But you break it down.
01:25:28.360 So they spent $71,000 on food.
01:25:31.500 And included in that, there were receipts for $812 in junk food at No Frills and $102 for DVDs, guys.
01:25:42.600 Sam the Record, man.
01:25:44.620 What the hell has that got to do with a trip like that?
01:25:48.980 I had no idea about that stuff, Warren.
01:25:51.160 Hey, I want to thank both of you for joining me.
01:25:53.440 What a great panel.
01:25:54.480 I hope you join me again.
01:25:55.680 And I hope you both have a wonderful weekend.
01:25:58.680 Thanks, man.
01:25:59.160 Thank you.
01:25:59.400 Thank you.
01:26:29.840 Don't make a touch.
01:26:31.660 Don't make a touch from me.
01:26:31.900 わたして that phone,ててにゼルすんkk�
01:26:33.840 Don't fake a dash of money
01:26:36.940 Don't fake a dash of money
01:26:39.780 Don't fake a dash of money
01:26:41.740 Don't fake a dash of money
01:26:44.360 now
01:26:46.120 I want under you
01:26:47.600 ああ
01:26:49.240 I want under you
01:26:50.920 Ah
01:26:53.100 isn Die
01:26:57.660 自己
01:26:58.200 didn't
01:27:01.720 miniature on from Tu- torn box
01:27:06.660 Yeah yeah yeah yeah
01:27:07.820 use the
01:27:12.000 Yor nukashi
01:27:16.340 Yor nukashi
01:27:18.400 flower
01:27:23.160 colocar
01:27:28.120 Ciri
01:27:30.040 kuhau
01:27:30.480 Yuma Shouza, sa gdzieś go Yahaku wo
01:27:34.000 I'm going to go
01:27:41.000 I'm going to go
01:27:45.000 I'm going to go
01:27:48.000 I'm going to go
01:27:53.000 Yeah, yeah, you're good men
01:28:04.000 What do I go
01:28:13.400 I'm going to go
01:28:18.000 I'm going to go
01:28:24.000 You