kinsellacast - January 19, 2025


KINSELLACAST 345: We ain't for sale - with Lilley, Kheiriddin, Belanger, Wieder, Mraz, Mulroney, Pierson! Plus Bowie, Velveteers, Bad Dreems, Oh Daisy, Clay J Gladstone, Dead Pony, Old Mervs, Wonder Years


Episode Stats

Length

1 hour and 50 minutes

Words per Minute

155.11586

Word Count

17,166

Sentence Count

970

Misogynist Sentences

18

Hate Speech Sentences

18


Summary


Transcript

00:00:00.000 It's the KinsellaCast, starring Warren Kinsella.
00:00:30.000 It's my daughter, who is beautiful and sweet and perfect, and I've been telling her that forever.
00:00:34.940 She came to visit me with her guy.
00:00:37.360 We've had a great time, kind of a late Christmas thing.
00:00:40.040 So let me talk her into talking to you, and you too will feel that she is beautiful and sweet and perfect.
00:00:46.740 I've got to Lily and Mraz, of course, Carradine, Belanger, Mulroney, Pearson, Marcel Weider.
00:00:54.240 Got all kinds of folks on the show.
00:00:56.440 And I've also got just a shit ton of music.
00:01:01.300 So I've got Bowie, a song that you don't normally hear.
00:01:05.960 Got The Veil of the Tears, Bad Dreams, O Daisy, Clay J Gladstone.
00:01:11.320 A song about teenage angst.
00:01:14.220 I had a lot of teenage angst when I was a teenager.
00:01:17.140 Actually, some would argue I still do.
00:01:18.760 Dead Pony, Omer, Smolar.
00:01:20.860 So lots of good stuff.
00:01:22.560 Lots of good stuff, and you're going to like it, and you're going to be happy.
00:01:25.420 And I'm going to be happy, you're happy, and everybody's going to be happy.
00:01:29.200 So crazy amount of things going on.
00:01:33.320 It's just hard to keep track in Canada, in the United States, United States against Canada, Europe, Middle East, you name it.
00:01:41.220 But I just wanted to focus on one thing, something that's simple.
00:01:45.560 And it says something about our politics, and certainly says something about us as a people, when the simple wearing of a trekkers cap can cause a sensation.
00:01:56.460 Canada is not for sale, the words on the cap declared.
00:02:00.300 And beneath it, a steely-eyed Ontario Premier Doug Fort looked out at the assembled cameras at Wednesday's first ministers gathering in Ottawa.
00:02:08.780 And he wasn't smiling, and really, who can blame him?
00:02:12.240 There's not a lot to smile about these days.
00:02:14.720 The President-elect of the United States of America had said he's going to use force against us.
00:02:19.560 That he wants to take us over.
00:02:21.320 That we have nothing to offer the world.
00:02:23.400 He doesn't care what our leaders have to say, whether on the right or the left.
00:02:26.500 He's going to tank our economy with a 25% tariff.
00:02:29.260 He's even published maps, like Hamas does, with Israel, showing Canada completely gone.
00:02:35.500 So as my colleague Brian Passifiume at Post Media reported on Wednesday, Ford's hat, blue, it's got a Canadian flag on one side, 1867 on the other, caused a sensation.
00:02:46.400 Everyone, and like, no exaggeration, everyone expressed admiration, verging on adoration for Ford.
00:02:53.400 And everybody immediately wanted to know where to get one of those hats.
00:02:55.940 And so many tried, the Ottawa company that makes them, their website crashed.
00:03:01.260 How does that happen?
00:03:02.940 When five simple words on a hat can capture the mood of a country?
00:03:07.220 It happens, I think, like Simon and Garfunkel kind of said, when a worried nation turns its eyes to Ottawa and sees nothing.
00:03:16.180 No leadership, no vision, nothing.
00:03:17.760 And as the news of Doug Ford's hat-wearing broke, I was on the TV set, a TV set, a Zoomer TV, with another colleague, Brian Lilly, and historian Conrad Black was there, remotely.
00:03:32.020 And the subject matter was what Canada should do about Trump's threats.
00:03:36.100 Should we pick up a musket?
00:03:37.380 Should we write a certain letter?
00:03:38.680 Sell it all off for a few greenbacks?
00:03:41.140 Anyway, Brian made an important point, as he always does.
00:03:43.720 Trump's ravings all felt like a joke, he said at the start, but they don't feel very jokey anymore.
00:03:50.300 And Black, who told us he considers Trump a friend, conceded that his friend's rhetoric was over the top, but he insisted that Trump isn't serious.
00:03:59.560 And I was, of course, the Trump hater on the panel, and I had a different view.
00:04:04.840 And I pointed out that everybody from Stephen Harper to Jean Chrétien had been utterly appalled by Trump's attacks on us.
00:04:11.420 And everybody had been relieved to see Doug Ford assume the mantle of Canada, Captain Canada, and fight back.
00:04:18.060 Like, those things matter.
00:04:20.240 Anyway, shrugging about Trump's threats and hoping that he's joking isn't a very good fucking strategy.
00:04:27.220 It's capitulation.
00:04:28.460 And some supportive noises were made on the panel about Alberta Premier Daniel Smith, who is the Neville Chamberlain of Confederation, and I was the dissident again.
00:04:40.280 Right out of the gate, Smith basically parroted everything, every bit of crap that came from Trump's fincter mouth.
00:04:47.440 And in so doing, she put Canada last.
00:04:49.660 So what should we do?
00:04:51.420 Plenty.
00:04:51.980 Short-term, long-term.
00:04:52.980 Short-term.
00:04:53.700 We need to set aside partisan differences and really, truly fashion the sort of team Canada approach my former boss Chrétien devised in the 90s.
00:05:01.860 Everybody needs to be singing from the same hymn book all over the American networks.
00:05:06.560 And our retaliatory tariffs need to be immediate and just as punishing as the ones we're responding to.
00:05:12.380 Long-term, we need to accept that America, for the next four years at least, is no longer our closest ally.
00:05:20.620 We need to expand trade relations with the European Union.
00:05:23.640 We need to accept that NATO is probably dead or dying, like Trump's military threats against fellow NATO members.
00:05:30.000 Makes that clear.
00:05:31.240 And we need to work on fashioning a new Western military alliance, and I think it should include Israel.
00:05:36.620 And most of all, we need to accept that everything has changed.
00:05:39.600 We need to accept that Trump says what he means, and means what he says, and get ready.
00:05:45.020 And we should all get one of those hats, and let's have a rally down in front of the American Embassy in Ottawa,
00:05:50.580 and we'll wear our hats, and we'll say, we're not for sale.
00:06:00.020 Heaven loves you.
00:06:03.520 The clouds are for you.
00:06:06.960 Nothing stands in the way.
00:06:09.600 When you're a boy.
00:06:15.940 Clothes always fit you.
00:06:18.880 Life is a pop of the cherry.
00:06:22.060 When you're a boy.
00:06:25.620 When you're a boy.
00:06:27.920 You can wear a uniform.
00:06:29.920 When you're a boy.
00:06:31.820 Other boys check you out.
00:06:33.800 You get a girl.
00:06:35.860 These are your favorite things.
00:06:37.740 When you're a boy.
00:06:38.900 When you're a boy.
00:06:39.480 When you're a boy.
00:06:39.900 Boys.
00:06:40.900 Boys.
00:06:41.900 Boys.
00:06:42.900 Boys.
00:06:43.900 Boys.
00:06:44.900 Boys.
00:06:45.900 Boys.
00:06:46.900 Boys.
00:06:47.900 Boys.
00:06:48.900 Keep swinging.
00:06:49.900 Boys always work it out.
00:06:50.900 Boys.
00:06:51.900 Boys.
00:06:52.900 Boys.
00:06:53.900 Boys.
00:06:54.900 Keep swinging.
00:06:55.900 Boys.
00:06:56.900 Always work it out.
00:06:57.900 Boys.
00:06:58.900 Uncage the colors.
00:06:59.900 Boys.
00:07:00.900 Boys.
00:07:01.900 Boys.
00:07:02.900 Boys.
00:07:03.900 Boys.
00:07:04.900 Boys.
00:07:05.900 Boys.
00:07:06.900 Boys.
00:07:07.900 Boys.
00:07:09.140 Bye.
00:07:12.900 Bye.
00:07:14.900 Bye.
00:07:17.900 Bye.
00:07:18.900 Bye.
00:07:30.900 And everything you'll get to share
00:07:35.900 When you're a boy
00:07:44.900 Boys
00:07:48.900 Boys
00:07:52.900 Boys keep swinging
00:07:54.900 Boys always work it out
00:08:00.900 Girls
00:08:03.900 Jn
00:08:17.900 Jn
00:08:19.900 Jn
00:08:22.900 Jn
00:08:25.900 Jn
00:08:29.900 scripture
00:08:30.900 We'll be right back.
00:09:00.900 And we're back.
00:09:05.080 We're back with Brian Lilly.
00:09:06.040 And Brian, I really don't know what we're going to talk about this week because nothing's
00:09:10.380 been happening in Canada or the United States or Europe or the Middle East.
00:09:14.680 It's really kind of boring, but let's take a stab at it, right?
00:09:18.880 People are listening to us and they want to know what our views are, what your view is.
00:09:24.320 You actually issued a tweet yesterday that made my blood run cold.
00:09:30.900 About the incoming administration of Donald J.
00:09:34.180 Trump, who's going to be inaugurated as president of the United States again tomorrow.
00:09:39.420 And you said, we're not ready.
00:09:41.160 What did you mean by that?
00:09:42.320 We're not ready in the sense that we don't have a proper response.
00:09:48.180 Obviously, we have questions about whether we have the functioning federal government, to
00:09:53.780 be honest, with proper leadership.
00:09:57.380 Prime Minister on his way out and the rest of the Liberal caucus concerned about leadership
00:10:05.800 ambitions.
00:10:06.800 So that's a problem.
00:10:08.380 But even if we decide to respond, will our response be enough?
00:10:15.220 I'll lay some things out for you.
00:10:16.740 First off, I've been told that these terrorists will be signed into law by about 1 p.m. tomorrow.
00:10:23.960 He's got hundreds of executive orders.
00:10:25.540 He's going to sign them and we'll be hit with the terrorists.
00:10:28.580 At that point, we find out if it's 25% on everything or if there's a carve-out for, say, oil.
00:10:35.660 The U.S. was 76% of our exports in 2022.
00:10:42.000 That is a staggering figure.
00:10:44.260 You know, as I wrote my column, all these numbers that used to seem amazing that we would boast
00:10:52.360 about, biggest trading partner, we would say we would point to 470-odd billion exports that
00:10:58.740 we sent them in 2022.
00:11:00.420 That's now menacing because of that 76% figure.
00:11:04.540 The Americans in 2022, these are all U.S. dollars, by the way.
00:11:08.820 The Americans exported to us $427 billion.
00:11:14.520 That's only 17% of their exports.
00:11:17.480 So if we respond dollar for dollar, which is what Ontario Premier Doug Ford is suggesting,
00:11:23.120 what Chrystia Freeland suggested in launching their liberal leadership,
00:11:26.900 even if we did that, the impact of our tariffs, our countermeasures, would not nearly be enough.
00:11:33.720 Even something that the Ford government is looking at, which is banning the sale of all-American
00:11:39.680 booze in the LCBO, it won't be enough.
00:11:44.220 That'll be significant.
00:11:45.620 I mean, you think about it, the LCBO is the biggest purchaser of beverage alcohol in the world.
00:11:53.400 If suddenly you've got the maker of Tito's Vodka in Texas and, you know, the big bourbon distilleries
00:12:01.180 in Kentucky, both Republican areas, calling up the White House and saying,
00:12:05.480 hey, I just lost my biggest customer, maybe it gets their attention.
00:12:09.440 But the scale of our reliance on their economy compared to their reliance on ours just doesn't make sense.
00:12:19.100 And at the end of the day, Trump fundamentally believes that tariffs are a good thing,
00:12:25.000 that they benefit the American economy, and that they will protect the American worker.
00:12:29.200 Well, that's what I wanted to ask you, is why is Trump doing this?
00:12:32.340 So that's why he's doing this?
00:12:35.160 Is he right?
00:12:40.360 I don't know.
00:12:41.760 You know, I've read the various economists, and most economists, the orthodoxy now is that
00:12:48.100 tariffs weaken your economy, that they impede trade.
00:12:55.260 But then, you know, I think it's the third week in a row, I'm going to mention Robert Lighthizer
00:13:00.100 in his book, No Trade is Free.
00:13:01.440 He's well-trained in this and fundamentally disagrees with it, and even explains how, you know,
00:13:09.180 that everyone points to the Smoot-Hawley Act, our tariffs in 1936, that they extended the Great Depression.
00:13:17.800 And he points out that the tariffs then were 40% and only went to 46%, that the impact was actually negligible.
00:13:27.440 And, you know, so, look, these guys love the tariffs, and they think it's going to bring back manufacturing.
00:13:34.980 I'll tell you this, if you're a CEO, looking at where to build a plant, and there's 25% tariff,
00:13:43.980 even just the threat of it, are you going to build it on our side of the border or the American side of the border?
00:13:49.660 Yep.
00:13:50.560 Yep.
00:13:50.800 So, you know, this is what's going on.
00:13:54.480 And, you know, when Trump started, he said it was to get us to act on the border issues, increasing illegal migration, drugs, things like that.
00:14:08.020 That was an easy act for us to give, if, you know, that's what it was.
00:14:11.820 Then he started joking, or we thought it was a joke, about making us the 51st state.
00:14:16.540 And now we don't know if that's a joke.
00:14:20.880 If that's what he's after, well, then we're screwed, because how do we give that to him?
00:14:25.500 80% of Canadians would say no to that.
00:14:28.120 And they've been saying no for well over a century.
00:14:31.980 I'm going to read to you from Richard Cartwright, who was in the Ontario legislature debating the issue of whether to go ahead with Confederation.
00:14:45.820 And a big part of it was the difference between they were debating the different views of liberty, between how they saw it and how the Americans saw it.
00:14:56.440 And Cartwright said, for myself, sir, I own frankly, and I prefer British liberty to American equality.
00:15:03.000 I had rather uphold the majesty of the law than the majesty of Judge Lynch.
00:15:07.220 And you can find all kinds of quotes from George Brown and others in this book that I'm going through about Canada's founding debates on that this is, it wasn't just that they were anti-American.
00:15:20.520 They viewed how the country should be structured different.
00:15:23.920 And we've been doing that since those days.
00:15:27.680 We've kind of lost our way, but now we're under threat.
00:15:31.440 Well, here, I can add a quote.
00:15:33.320 I'll have my 12-gauge, and I'll take a couple Americans with me if they cross the border.
00:15:37.940 There are people who can quote me on that.
00:15:40.880 But, okay, so that's Trump.
00:15:44.200 That's what's coming.
00:15:46.040 You have been one of the few who have been saying from the start, we need to take this seriously.
00:15:51.440 It doesn't feel like a joke.
00:15:53.140 It feels real.
00:15:54.560 So I think you're about to be proven right tomorrow.
00:15:58.720 In terms of the Canadian political universe, such as it is, from Doug Ford, Daniel Smith, Legault, the premiers, Justin Trudeau departing the stage, Pierre Polyev, can you give us kind of quick assessments?
00:16:15.600 I apologize, it's a long list.
00:16:17.960 But all of them have been doing different things.
00:16:20.400 What do you think about the response each has had?
00:16:23.000 Well, you know, Trudeau is the prime minister still, and he should have been leading, Canada's leading voice on this.
00:16:31.740 Instead, he went into hiding after Freeland resigned.
00:16:36.520 Truly did, until he stepped out and announced that he eventually would resign.
00:16:42.000 He had said, like, two sentences to the Canadian media and public since Freeland's resignation.
00:16:47.020 And there was a vacuum of leadership.
00:16:50.880 And even now that he's come out, you know, he convened the meeting with the premiers.
00:16:55.300 That's good.
00:16:56.780 He apparently does have a plan on the border.
00:17:00.220 I'm not sure that that helps now.
00:17:02.580 I mean, I hope it does.
00:17:04.700 But Trump has changed his mind about a few things, and it's not about the border anymore.
00:17:08.680 So we'll have to wait and see on that.
00:17:11.020 What about Freeland, who you just mentioned?
00:17:13.120 You liked her launch video.
00:17:20.700 I didn't say I liked it.
00:17:22.020 I said it was effective.
00:17:24.620 Because, you know, she does open with Donald Trump doesn't like me very much.
00:17:29.500 That's really good in a liberal leadership race.
00:17:31.640 That's really bad if you're trying to negotiate a trade deal with them.
00:17:35.080 True enough.
00:17:35.420 And he has said in the past that he does not like her, that he found her to be a pain in the butt.
00:17:41.160 Like, you know, she says it's because she's a skilled negotiator.
00:17:45.060 I think she irritates him, which can be a good negotiating tactic, I suppose.
00:17:51.220 But, you know, I'm not sure it's the best one for the country going forward.
00:17:55.800 But it was a very effective opening.
00:17:57.940 Pierre Polyev has been kind of absent on this.
00:18:00.520 He's been trying to turn everything back to the carbon tax.
00:18:03.680 But my understanding is that once they know, they will pivot on Monday afternoon or Tuesday,
00:18:15.420 depending on when they find out details.
00:18:17.720 You were asking me about this.
00:18:18.920 Like, why isn't Pierre Polyev doing or saying anything?
00:18:21.720 And speaking to his people, they said, look, we just don't know what to do, what the play is.
00:18:27.500 There's no play for us in this.
00:18:29.360 If we go too far, we're accused of interfering because we're not the government.
00:18:33.680 And we don't want to be punching at shadows.
00:18:38.580 So they decided to wait and hold.
00:18:40.960 And, you know, everyone said, oh, they should get off the carbon tax message.
00:18:45.180 That's a dead issue now.
00:18:46.900 Doesn't seem to be a dead issue for Mark Carney and Christian Freeland, who have, you know,
00:18:53.800 both run away from the signature liberal policy or kind of.
00:18:57.420 They say they're going to do that.
00:19:02.340 Carney.
00:19:02.920 Let's talk about Carney.
00:19:04.200 Let me just talk about Smith and Ford quickly.
00:19:07.980 Sure.
00:19:08.760 Ford owned the week with the hat.
00:19:10.660 Yep.
00:19:10.920 And his, his message is resonating with most Canadians.
00:19:17.340 Hey, we want a deal.
00:19:18.760 But if you come at us, we'll hit you back hard.
00:19:21.640 I think that's a very populous message that Justin Trudeau even fully embraced in getting
00:19:26.580 forward to answer some questions.
00:19:28.740 Freeland's message is popular in Alberta and not popular anywhere else.
00:19:33.180 Um, although, you know, she says we can't do this.
00:19:37.340 That was the position of Anthony Fury.
00:19:39.260 He eventually came around to saying, you don't take your queen off the table when, when you're
00:19:43.360 in the middle of a chess game.
00:19:44.820 And he's an oil producing province as well.
00:19:47.540 So, you know, Freeland's playing, or sorry, Smith is playing very well for her home base.
00:19:52.800 Doug Ford is playing well for across the country.
00:19:54.760 And, uh, some guy in Ottawa and his wife who make hats, uh, sold more than a million bucks
00:20:01.160 worth of merch this week after that is my understanding.
00:20:04.320 Kearney launch.
00:20:05.640 Kearney launch.
00:20:06.420 Yeah.
00:20:07.240 Um, Jeb Bush energy.
00:20:10.340 Uh, it was low energy.
00:20:12.400 Now I'm told he had a teleprompter issue, but, uh, I was out when, when he launched and
00:20:19.120 I had to, uh, come home and, and, and, and watch it on video after, but I'd already seen
00:20:23.480 all the, uh, the social media commentary of how low energy was.
00:20:28.440 I start watching and I thought, oh, he's starting off a little slow, but not, not too
00:20:32.420 bad.
00:20:32.700 What's all the fuss about?
00:20:33.920 And then he just slowed way down and it was like, you know, are you speaking at a funeral
00:20:39.980 buddy?
00:20:40.680 He's a political rally.
00:20:42.660 And so he, uh, you know, teleprompter problem or not, he sounded awful in both English and
00:20:48.340 French.
00:20:49.200 Uh, and then he did the Q and A and he sounded like a normal person.
00:20:52.440 And so he, he, he started great on the daily show on the Monday and, uh, Thursday when
00:20:58.840 he launched, it sounded bad.
00:21:00.200 Then he had two logos he had to change because there were copyright violations.
00:21:04.160 That's bad.
00:21:05.600 Um, and he picked up journalists accredited with, uh, the Western standard for, uh, who
00:21:10.680 are accredited at the Alberta legislature.
00:21:13.260 Um, so, you know, mixed bag for Mark Carney this week.
00:21:17.240 So final question, uh, all of this stuff stitched together looks to me like we're going to be
00:21:23.380 having an Ontario election pretty soon.
00:21:25.340 Looks to me like we have to have a federal election pretty soon, or am I right?
00:21:30.220 Is the federal one going to happen this spring or next fall?
00:21:33.160 Is the Ontario one going to happen because of all of this stuff happening?
00:21:36.500 What's your take?
00:21:39.320 Uh, well, I saw someone put out that expect the, uh, the rips to drop on in Ontario, February
00:21:47.020 5th or around then.
00:21:48.700 Uh, I wouldn't expect Ford to go until he's been to Washington, but maybe he does.
00:21:52.620 Um, uh, you know, his team's waiting to see what the response is and do they have to spend
00:22:00.260 tens of billions of dollars?
00:22:01.600 And if they do, then he's already said that he believes he has to ask the public for that.
00:22:06.640 He's got bond is how bad it is for the opposition.
00:22:10.000 Bonnie Crombie and marriage styles are begging him not to ask the public for permission to
00:22:14.440 spend tens of billions of dollars that they'll just support him on it.
00:22:17.720 Yeah.
00:22:18.120 Uh, and then the, the, the federal one is still so up in the air, you know, look, this court
00:22:23.260 case that was announced, uh, that they're going to hear on February 13th or 14th on prorogation.
00:22:27.760 Um, it's a long shot.
00:22:29.160 Um, but you never know what's going to happen once something's before the courts.
00:22:34.040 Uh, does that come back and say, yes, you've got to, uh, go back to, uh, to the house.
00:22:41.080 Um, that happened in the UK to Boris Johnson and our judges love to look at international
00:22:46.960 examples and then adopt them even when they don't make sense.
00:22:49.700 So it could happen.
00:22:51.480 Um, if that doesn't happen, does Carney or Freeland strike a deal with the NDP to keep this
00:22:57.320 going until October?
00:23:00.340 Federally, I think, uh, provincially, I'm pretty sure we're headed to one federally.
00:23:05.040 I'm pretty sure we're still at the, uh, the old Quebec saying if my granny had wheels, she
00:23:08.920 did.
00:23:09.500 So, so many ifs, so many possibilities, twists and turns.
00:23:13.980 It is like a soap opera.
00:23:15.740 It is indeed.
00:23:16.300 And you and I love this soap opera.
00:23:18.340 It's fun to talk about.
00:23:19.720 It's fun to write about.
00:23:20.820 It's fun to prognosticate about.
00:23:22.620 So thank you again this week for stitching together a crazy week.
00:23:28.000 This week we get to find out, uh, by January 23rd, which of the many pretenders are going
00:23:34.060 to go up against Carney and Freeland.
00:23:35.640 You know, we forgot to mention Frank Bayless and Jamie Pateese and Chandra Aria, who speaks
00:23:42.800 no French and has trouble with English.
00:23:45.480 And we forgot to mention Ruby Dalla.
00:23:47.460 I mean, that's going to be the next chapter of the soap opera this week.
00:23:50.260 Former MP, Ruby Dalla, looking to make a comeback.
00:23:53.520 That's a very, very, very small chapter.
00:23:56.640 Although I've heard Bayless is an impressive guy.
00:23:59.140 Anyway, uh, we will see, uh, there are as many chapters in this book.
00:24:02.840 It's getting bigger all the time, but thank you for helping us make sense of it.
00:24:06.560 Brian Lillie.
00:24:07.060 Thank you.
00:24:07.700 Thank you.
00:24:08.080 Thank you.
00:24:09.080 Thank you.
00:24:11.080 Thank you.
00:24:13.080 Thank you.
00:24:15.080 Thank you.
00:24:17.080 Thank you.
00:24:19.080 Thank you.
00:24:20.080 You've got your free riding.
00:24:41.260 You don't need any money, so you go out and stay out.
00:24:50.760 But then the sun comes up and I leave you alone.
00:24:56.140 And when you come back up, then there's nothing left of you.
00:24:59.340 So I got bored.
00:25:02.360 Yeah, I got bored.
00:25:06.360 Thought that you were something, but you're just another dumb idea.
00:25:12.760 Thought that you were something, but you're just another dumb idea.
00:25:16.520 Oh, you wear your big ideas.
00:25:17.900 Oh, you wear your big ideas.
00:25:21.900 You talk a lot about nothing.
00:25:25.100 Have you got something to say?
00:25:28.640 Or not?
00:25:29.720 You walk through Surrey Hills, I do the Surrey Hills.
00:25:35.420 And you're a great big nest with a shadow of success.
00:25:38.760 It's your nature.
00:25:39.800 And you're empty like the ocean.
00:25:54.500 You're an idiot wind.
00:25:56.840 Keep it flowing in my face.
00:26:01.120 Piss off.
00:26:01.740 Piss off.
00:26:04.880 There's a thousand more like you.
00:26:08.260 There's a hundred I've been through.
00:26:11.960 To think you're someone special.
00:26:15.420 You're not.
00:26:16.060 Thought that you were something, but you're just another dumb idea.
00:26:25.400 Thought that you were something, but you're just another dumb idea.
00:26:31.560 Thought that you were something, but you're just another dumb idea.
00:26:38.380 Thought that you were something, but you're just another dumb idea.
00:26:42.160 We're back with John Mraz.
00:26:43.820 John, welcome back.
00:26:44.960 Hopefully you're a little more positive than you were last week.
00:26:48.120 You depressed many people last week.
00:26:51.480 But there is, you know, in fairness to you, there's a lot to be depressed about.
00:26:58.120 Donald Trump is going to be, again, the President of the United States by tomorrow afternoon.
00:27:05.640 And we are told, credibly, that that has all kinds of implications for Canada, for the United States, for Europe, for the Middle East.
00:27:14.500 Let's talk, let's go further afar and come closer.
00:27:18.140 So let's talk about the Middle East.
00:27:20.520 There's three hostages being returned home today, which is good news.
00:27:25.420 Some young Israeli women.
00:27:29.320 And Trump is, of course, claiming credit for all of that.
00:27:33.200 What's your view on Trump's impact, if any, on the Middle Eastern conflict?
00:27:37.280 I think the threat of Trump 2.0 must have had some impact or certainly offered some consideration and pause for thought to whomever is really in charge of Hamas right now.
00:27:49.120 I'm not at all sure it's the leader they put in front of the microphone.
00:27:52.620 I suspect it remains with money in Qatar and elsewhere.
00:27:56.440 I think that it's a terrible deal.
00:27:59.440 As much as I don't approve of Bibi Netanyahu's leadership, and I know you agree with me on this.
00:28:07.120 And certainly there have been some interesting reportage over the last week on those that left his ship from the far right in Israel because they thought he gave far too many concessions to Hamas.
00:28:19.680 Hamas and to the other, I guess the other negotiators were Egypt and Qatar.
00:28:25.520 And I do want to talk about those concessions.
00:28:28.460 I mean, we're talking about letting out several hundred Alistinian, but let's not call them that, Hamas and Hezbollah activists who slaughtered hundreds of innocent civilians
00:28:42.280 and are being released in exchange for a paucity of hostages' lives.
00:28:47.460 I, of course, want every hostage to come home, whether they're dead or alive, they deserve to be buried or loved once more, and I'm delighted they're coming home.
00:28:55.960 Don't get me wrong, but at what cost?
00:28:58.540 And a lot of the other aspects of that deal, safe corridor, no flyover zone, a return to no Israeli presence at the Egyptian border where all those weapons were coming in in the first place, is very troubling to me.
00:29:13.500 Plus the fact that the leadership of Hamas said, sir, it's a ceasefire, and in 45 days from now, the war is on again, and we still want to wipe Israel off the map and kill every Jew in the world.
00:29:24.080 Okay, I agree with every word you said, but I want to talk about Trump.
00:29:27.640 Okay.
00:29:27.860 So what is the impact Trump is going to have?
00:29:31.020 He said, we can talk about Ukraine in a moment, he said the moment he becomes re-elected, the war in Ukraine will stop.
00:29:39.460 Well, it hasn't.
00:29:40.840 It's gotten worse.
00:29:42.380 Yeah.
00:29:42.520 And he has said that he is going to fix the conflict in the Middle East in a matter of mere hours as well.
00:29:49.240 Well, things are happening.
00:29:52.100 There's a ceasefire, apparently.
00:29:54.600 What is Trump a stabilizing or a destabilizing force in Israel and Gaza and Lebanon and Iran?
00:30:02.400 As I said, he might have been influential in pushing those parties in the Middle East to the table, but I don't believe that ceasefire will hold, because I don't believe Hamas or one of the other 10 groups that think Hamas are not tough enough are going to be able to restrain themselves from firing rockets at Israel within the next week.
00:30:20.400 I agree.
00:30:20.940 So what does Trump do about that?
00:30:23.040 Well, I mean, you know, if I'm to believe his rhetoric, you know, he might carpet bomb, you know, Gaza into a parking lot.
00:30:33.600 What can he really do about it?
00:30:35.760 Well, we're already offering Israel every kind of material and financial support that we can.
00:30:41.300 I don't think he can do much.
00:30:44.240 You know, Israel is fighting not an army, but an idea and an idea that most of the Gazan population embrace.
00:30:51.860 And I don't think they care what Donald Trump thinks.
00:30:54.800 I think he's quite powerless, quite frankly.
00:30:56.800 And I noticed that Bibi Netanyahu is not at his inauguration.
00:31:00.940 And I don't know whether that matters or not, but it seems to.
00:31:04.100 Interesting.
00:31:05.540 Ukraine.
00:31:06.440 So the war continues.
00:31:08.260 It gets worse.
00:31:08.960 There's been children who have been slaughtered in Ukraine this week.
00:31:12.840 What is the impact Trump is going to have there?
00:31:15.040 Is he really going to cut off the supply of military support to Ukraine?
00:31:19.280 Or is that just rhetoric?
00:31:20.580 Well, he may.
00:31:23.460 He may very well do.
00:31:24.520 He may also reconsider that because that is what is keeping a false military industrial economy.
00:31:31.460 I hate that term.
00:31:32.320 It's very Chomsky-ish.
00:31:33.160 But really, remember that Biden was depending on an economy in North America that was being bolstered by immense arms manufacturing and security manufacturing processes.
00:31:47.780 Simply selling arms or even giving them away makes money in America and supports an economy that Trump needs to blossom and at least survive because of all the promises he made.
00:32:02.660 Will he cut him off?
00:32:03.580 What influence does he really have?
00:32:05.360 I want to start by saying it's being reported that it's a stalemate over there.
00:32:10.400 Russia has taken back over 100,000 square kilometers in the last five months of land that they had lost during the counteroffensive by the Ukrainians.
00:32:19.240 And while the Ukrainians are up in Russia, they never expected to hold that land, and they couldn't if Russia really mustered a force there.
00:32:26.400 So I think that Trump does have the ability to force Zelensky to sit down with Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin.
00:32:36.060 But I'm not sure that he can force Zelensky and the Ukrainian population to stop fighting, even by cutting off their arms.
00:32:45.020 And I am lucky enough to be working with some European political consultants this work, and they assure me that Britain and the rest of Europe remain wholeheartedly committed to supporting Ukraine because they've got Russian.
00:32:59.180 What was her name, Sarah Palin?
00:33:00.540 I can see Russia from my front door.
00:33:03.080 All right.
00:33:03.360 Well, thank God for that.
00:33:04.540 All right.
00:33:04.760 Let's turn our attention to we're doing a hopscotching very rapidly here because this has been just an extraordinary week with all kinds of activity on it.
00:33:15.020 A hostage is being released on the same 24-hour period as an inauguration, as a bunch of other events.
00:33:20.980 In Canada, obviously, I think you and Brian Lilly and I and many others have been saying for a long time he means it about the tariffs, or I think that's what you would say.
00:33:33.100 And so it looks like it's very much going to happen.
00:33:35.160 You've got the Premier of Ontario saying half a million jobs could be lost in this province alone.
00:33:40.220 Go through the range, like federally, provincially.
00:33:42.840 So Trudeau, Polyev, and provincially, Smith, and Legault, and Ford, and so on.
00:33:50.020 How does all of this affect them?
00:33:52.420 Does it help them?
00:33:53.460 Does it hurt them?
00:33:54.760 What should they be doing?
00:33:56.460 By the way, I think of all the politicians in Canada, and Doug Ford will shoot coffee out of his nose because God knows I was not that kind to him in my columns historically.
00:34:05.440 But I've started to say good things about him.
00:34:07.300 I think he's a pretty good Premier here in Ontario.
00:34:09.380 That's right.
00:34:09.760 You heard me say that.
00:34:11.900 I think Doug Ford's positioning has been the smartest, which is to say, well, be tough but respectful.
00:34:16.780 We want to meet you at the table, and we want to make sure Americans and Canadians, neither Americans nor Canadians, are harmed economically,
00:34:25.860 and that we continue to be the most loyal and best friends and allies the world has ever known.
00:34:33.960 Daniel Smith.
00:34:35.560 Daniel Smith has to represent an Alberta constituency that probably doesn't want to be part of Confederation and certainly doesn't want to take direction from a Prime Minister that's never given her province any consideration except by sticking a big straw by which we suck oil and taxes out of the West.
00:34:53.580 All right.
00:34:55.720 So that's Ford electorally.
00:34:59.040 How do you think this is going to affect him?
00:35:00.500 Because we're both hearing rumors that there could be an election call as soon as the month of February for a vote sometime in March.
00:35:08.260 How does – does this mean – I think Ford could be looking at getting a bigger majority, his third majority, bigger than anyone he's had before if he's running against Trump.
00:35:18.260 I agree with you.
00:35:19.820 I agree with you, and I just confessed to someone, and I'm going to get in a world of trouble for this.
00:35:24.120 If I had the options that are available on the table right now in the next provincial election, Doug Ford, you have my vote.
00:35:30.500 That will be the first time I vote conservative in my life for anything.
00:35:34.320 I think he's done a very good job, and I resent having to say it, but merit is – should be praised where merit, you know, exists.
00:35:43.560 So what I – but let's get back to, you know, the larger table.
00:35:49.320 I can't decide whether Trump is talking about tariffs with Canada, buying Greenland, taking back the Panama Canal, because he realized that daddy made a lot of crazy promises,
00:36:00.880 and talking about building American empire and global influence is a lot easier than actually delivering a $2 gallon of gas to consumers, you know, at home,
00:36:10.180 or whether he's deadly serious and sees an opportunity to take Canada, even if it's just economically, in our weakened states as the second largest geographic country in the world
00:36:25.720 with a population smaller than California and an economy that's wholly dependent on primary resource extraction because we haven't built our manufacturing or our tertiary or our tech sectors.
00:36:36.320 I think, as a predator, and he is a capitalist predator, there's no doubt about that, that he is saying out loud what I suspect other presidents and other American statesmen have thought.
00:36:48.180 How hard would it be?
00:36:49.520 I don't think a shot would have to be fine.
00:36:51.020 I know I said it last week, and I think you should take –
00:36:53.220 All right.
00:36:53.240 I got to get you focused.
00:36:54.640 I need you to get you focused here because we're finishing up.
00:36:57.620 All right.
00:36:57.860 Because now I'm going to ask you straight out.
00:36:59.660 Are you working for Ruby Dollar?
00:37:01.780 Yes.
00:37:02.160 Yes, I am.
00:37:02.700 All right.
00:37:03.220 Well, then, so everybody needs to know that vis-a-vis what I'm going to ask you next, which is how does the Donald Trump threat, which we're facing on multiple fronts,
00:37:15.100 how does the Donald Trump threat affect Mark Carney and Christopher Freeland, all of these other also-ran candidates?
00:37:22.800 Very quickly, how – what's the Trump impact on the liberal leadership race?
00:37:27.380 I think it's immense.
00:37:29.900 I think both Mr. Carney and Christopher Freeland have already come to the table.
00:37:34.580 Christopher came out like a pugilist, almost with a boxer stance and said, I'm a tough negotiator, and I've been there before and I succeeded.
00:37:42.780 What I remember is Donald Trump saying, I'd rather she never come back to America, and we don't like negotiating with her, and I won't negotiate with her again.
00:37:51.160 Mark Carney, of course, much more statesman-like, diplomat, governor of the Bank of England, governor of the Bank of Canada.
00:37:56.900 And I do have respect for both of these candidates intellectually.
00:37:59.980 I want to put that out there right now.
00:38:01.780 Mark is approaching it as a banker would and saying there's a solution.
00:38:05.760 I am not going to speak for Ruby Dalla or the other candidates because they've yet to comment on it.
00:38:10.540 But it seems to me that the right way to approach Donald Trump is, as an equal, with respect, understanding, to quote our old prime minister, that we are a mouse living next to an elephant, and that we would be fairly cautious if we want to keep our sovereignty and our economic security intact.
00:38:28.340 John Mraz, thank you for your analysis.
00:38:32.080 Good luck on the Ruby Dalla campaign.
00:38:34.700 And we look forward to talking about all of this stuff in the coming weeks because things are about to get really bouncy.
00:38:41.660 Thank you.
00:38:42.520 Thank you.
00:38:43.160 Bye-bye.
00:38:43.420 Bye-bye.
00:39:13.420 Bye-bye.
00:39:43.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:13.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:43.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:45.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:47.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:49.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:51.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:52.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:53.420 Bye-bye.
00:40:55.420 Bye-bye.
00:41:23.420 Bye-bye.
00:41:26.420 Bye-bye.
00:41:30.420 Bye-bye.
00:41:31.420 Bye-bye.
00:41:31.520 Bye-bye.
00:41:33.420 Bye-bye.
00:41:33.440 Bye-bye.
00:41:34.500 You got to stop being a bystander.
00:41:37.460 And you need to be an upstander. And there has been such a lack of leadership on this file that has allowed anti-Semitism to percolate and fester like an infection on the street of Toronto.
00:41:48.900 You're listening to The Alex Pearson Show.
00:41:51.700 That is the voice of Toronto Council Brad Bradford talking to Mr. Ben Mulroney on The Ben Mulroney Show this morning.
00:41:57.900 And, you know, yeah, we need leadership. And he's remarking to the latest anti-Semitic attack, this one happening at a Jewish business, a kosher business that was broken into on Friday of last week.
00:42:12.300 York Regional Police say this one happened overnight where two suspects broke into this commercial business in the Yonge and Doncaster Avenue north area of Toronto and vandalized the area pretty badly
00:42:24.040 and left some very, very noticeable messages that were very clear, but I can't say them on on the radio.
00:42:31.280 But this is not new. It's that it just keeps happening over and over and over again.
00:42:36.120 And why does it happen over again? Well, because no one stands up to it.
00:42:41.080 You know, in moments like this, you have to be absolutely clear in your condemnation.
00:42:46.560 We have to stand shoulder to shoulder with our law enforcement.
00:42:49.340 And, you know, the mayor likes to often sort of fall back on the idea that we don't direct the police.
00:42:55.740 But the the context of that is we don't direct the police who to charge and what to charge them with.
00:43:02.460 But we certainly can provide direction.
00:43:05.120 And we need to ensure that our law enforcement understands that they are fully supported.
00:43:10.000 And and while it might be uncomfortable to watch protests cleared out of the center or to shut down this sort of the hateful mobs that have taken over our streets, that's what needs to happen.
00:43:22.580 But it has not. And so begs the question, why has it been so difficult to deal with,
00:43:27.740 you know, a suspected terror entity, which in other countries is designated at that.
00:43:35.020 But here in Canada, everyone has been too scared to say anything about it's a group called the Hizbub Tahrir.
00:43:41.520 And this is a group that has been trying to get a venue in either Mississauga, Hamilton or anywhere so that it can give a conference on how to,
00:43:50.960 I guess, start a caliphate here, you know, where we can all live under Islamic Sharia law.
00:43:56.040 Sounds fun, right? But women rights were fun. Never mind.
00:44:00.160 We're going to go back to Sharia law. But nonetheless, you know, mayor of Mississauga said, well, it's not really welcome.
00:44:05.820 Didn't stop it. And then mayor Horvath in Hamilton said, well, you're not really welcome, but didn't stop it.
00:44:11.920 And then the federal government was. Don't worry about that. That's just my drink for the 20th time.
00:44:18.460 But then, of course, the federal government was under a lot of pressure to step in and either designate this as a terror entity
00:44:26.020 because it is a conference of hate against Jews.
00:44:31.180 And for whatever reason, they were kicking and dragging and, well, we are telling people not to go and we don't want it.
00:44:37.400 But they didn't go as far as canceling it, right?
00:44:39.880 They said they would wait for CSIS to decide if it fits the criteria of terror.
00:44:44.360 Well, the group has, I guess, now decided to cancel its gathering.
00:44:49.480 But why is it so hard for people in this country, especially in leadership, to actually take leadership on these issues?
00:44:55.560 Let's bring in Warren Kinsella, president of Daisy Group, former political strategist for Jean Chrétien,
00:45:00.340 and one who has not been afraid at all to confront.
00:45:03.280 And I would put you on the forefront of this fight, fighting against Jew hate.
00:45:07.560 So thanks for joining.
00:45:09.340 Thanks, my friend.
00:45:10.440 This thing, can you tell me what the, because this thing has, this conference, this like how to build a caliphate,
00:45:15.660 that's how I can kind of characterize it so it's in its simplest forms.
00:45:18.720 You know, it's been looking for a venue, it hasn't been really welcomed.
00:45:21.100 But why is it so hard for everyone to say you're not welcome here?
00:45:23.760 And is it actually canceled or are they just going to find a quiet place to go?
00:45:27.100 Well, the reason why is the reason that you gave just a minute ago, leadership, you know, in the city of Toronto.
00:45:35.780 Toronto now has the distinction of being one of the major cities in the world.
00:45:40.600 We're having one of the worst problems with anti-Semitism.
00:45:44.780 Montreal is just as bad.
00:45:47.380 And, you know, that's not the kind of distinction we should be achieving internationally.
00:45:51.240 Why has that happened?
00:45:52.500 Because in both cities, we've got mayors who, you know, tend to be a new Democrat in their affiliation,
00:45:58.800 who are just seem to be completely indifferent, Alex, to what is taking place.
00:46:04.040 And so the police are using that as an excuse or maybe an impetus to do precisely nothing.
00:46:11.200 But, you know, people are, like you also said, really upset and really concerned.
00:46:15.980 The New York Post has got a poll this morning.
00:46:17.980 In New York City, 75% of the city want to ban the wearing of masks during public protests because it's been used as a disguise for hatred.
00:46:32.980 So, you know, we should have something likewise here.
00:46:35.580 And that's why, you know, Brad Bradford and precious few others are saying the right thing.
00:46:40.700 But it's not happening.
00:46:41.940 It's not being done.
00:46:43.300 Well, you know, hate has no place here, right?
00:46:44.720 It just has no place here.
00:46:45.720 And I guess, I mean, it's such a tired line every time I hear about it.
00:46:48.720 I'm like, well, it clearly does have a place here because politicians worried about, you know, pandering to specific votes are allowing it to happen.
00:46:55.520 I would put, you know, Pierre Polyev in your category.
00:46:58.040 He has been very morally clear on where he stands on this.
00:47:01.440 And he will bring in, I think, change if elected.
00:47:05.080 But we've seen just far too many times with the light left, they pander to it.
00:47:09.000 I want to play you, you know, Greg Brady had Olivia Chow on this morning.
00:47:12.800 And she's been criticized a lot by the Jewish community for just not showing up.
00:47:17.340 But just, I mean, she has cowered way too many times.
00:47:20.460 And sure, she's been showing up.
00:47:22.000 But even today, Warren, when he asked her, like, what are you going to do?
00:47:26.100 Where have you been?
00:47:26.920 Like, how do you get rid of this hate?
00:47:30.140 Even her answer, let's play it, is, I'll be generous.
00:47:34.900 It's a bit weird.
00:47:36.080 Yes, I know hate crime is on the rise.
00:47:38.960 And the chief of police and I are meeting with the top Jewish communities, whether it's UJA or CJAP, to explore ways to, and I'm working with the Koto sector.
00:47:55.320 Because the best way for us to see each other and hear each other and be empathetic is through arts and culture to build bridges.
00:48:02.760 What the hell is she talking about?
00:48:04.300 Like, what is she talking about?
00:48:05.740 I'm like, what is she talking about?
00:48:07.660 Are we drawing pictures of each other?
00:48:09.300 Like, I don't know what she's talking about.
00:48:10.920 Arts and culture.
00:48:12.620 No, Madam Mayor, actually, there are things that you personally can do.
00:48:17.160 So, for example, on the occasion when Israel's flag is raised, just once a year in a little corner of City Hall, you can show up, which she didn't.
00:48:28.480 You can, for example, when a vote comes before council to provide a protective zone around places of worship, not just synagogues, but all places of worship, you can do something other than voting against it, which is what you did.
00:48:42.880 And in particular, you do have the power to determine the policing that takes place in this city.
00:48:50.980 You determine the budget of the Toronto Police Service.
00:48:54.000 You determine who the chief of police is going to be.
00:48:56.540 And as Brad Bradford said in the clip that you played, you determine the policy that the police implement.
00:49:03.360 Olivia Chow is pretending to have no power when, in fact, she's the mayor of one of the biggest cities in the world.
00:49:09.960 She has lots of power.
00:49:11.140 She has more power than some provincial premiers do, but she's not doing anything because she refuses to show leadership about how a minority group, a minority are being persecuted and attacked criminally because of their religion.
00:49:26.660 Well, Chief Jim Q is not much better.
00:49:28.160 I mean, he's missing in action.
00:49:29.620 I don't I don't know why he's having such a difficult time taking any leadership on it.
00:49:34.320 That doesn't matter.
00:49:35.060 I mean, it's too late now, but it sure will be interesting.
00:49:37.700 You know, this this ceasefire, which is supposed to be signed this afternoon.
00:49:42.120 We'll talk about it in a few minutes overseas.
00:49:44.240 But we are supposed to get this ceasefire and the hostages return.
00:49:48.560 And you just wonder, is it the tide going to turn now?
00:49:51.300 Will people will people talk out about it?
00:49:53.000 Because Trump has made it clear, you know, those those hostages better be out by the time election inauguration day is here.
00:49:57.960 But also, I think the whole tone will change with those protesters in the streets of the United States when he gets in because he's also said he won't put up with it.
00:50:06.140 And so he'll pull funding from universities and such.
00:50:08.600 But maybe it takes an inauguration day to change the tone.
00:50:12.040 But I don't know why it's been so difficult.
00:50:14.460 I don't either.
00:50:15.420 And, you know, as you pointed out earlier, Paliyev has been excellent on the issue.
00:50:20.160 He has been very clear.
00:50:22.200 And, you know, you know, people say, well, he's doing it for votes.
00:50:25.100 Well, there's only 400,000 Jews in all of Canada, as you know.
00:50:28.960 There's five times as many Muslims.
00:50:31.360 So if he was really, you know, attempting to doing all of this because of politics, he might be taking a different approach.
00:50:38.220 So he deserves a lot of credit for for taking that position.
00:50:42.520 And, you know, there are some other politicians in the country have done likewise, but they are in the minority.
00:50:48.140 And it's got to change because in those jurisdictions where, you know, people run DeSantis in Florida, for example, DeSantis has said to universities and he said to police forces, that's not going to happen in Florida.
00:51:03.500 Sorry, we're not going to let you do that.
00:51:05.440 We're not going to allow you to intimidate and terrorize a minority.
00:51:10.300 And it basically it's stopped in Florida.
00:51:13.960 There is a way forward.
00:51:15.880 There is a way to do it.
00:51:17.060 But the key thing is we need leadership.
00:51:19.320 And in places like the city of Toronto, we're not getting it.
00:51:22.680 No, in many places in Canada, we haven't gone it, which is why we have this dubious distinction and infamous reputation that it will not go away anytime soon.
00:51:31.540 It's disgusting.
00:51:32.680 Nonetheless, you are not part of the problem, Warren, and we can say that unequivocally.
00:51:36.280 Talk to you again.
00:51:37.180 Thank you.
00:51:38.260 Thanks, my friend.
00:51:38.960 There you go.
00:51:39.900 Warren Kinsella, I should have asked him, got a book coming out.
00:51:42.860 He's been writing a book and certainly he spent his career, like decades writing against things like anti-Semitism in this with white nationalism.
00:51:51.780 But he's got a new book coming out and we'll definitely talk about it.
00:51:55.040 But that he's been right on the front lines.
00:51:57.680 Absolutely morally clear.
00:51:58.980 I kiss the future, hello.
00:52:10.600 I taste it on my tongue, I want more.
00:52:16.300 You're running circles in the scene.
00:52:19.620 You want all the pretty truth but don't want to be called a thief in it.
00:52:25.280 Cause on and on and on and on and on and on.
00:52:29.220 On and on and on, and on and on
00:52:33.340 It goes on and on and on, and on and on
00:52:37.800 I am myself again, I'm whole
00:52:42.080 And I know my strength's for you to hold
00:52:46.100 And I wanna be your friend
00:52:50.560 Like a hungry dog, you crawl back
00:52:54.520 And it goes on and on and on, and on and on
00:52:59.020 On and on and on, and on and on
00:53:03.180 On and on and on, and on and on
00:53:07.500 On and on and on, and on and on
00:53:11.640 So get in for your little head now
00:53:15.400 Get in for your little brain
00:53:19.480 Two times a tip-a-dealer
00:53:23.480 Is always gonna do the same
00:53:27.760 So get in for your little head now
00:53:49.240 Get in for your little brain
00:53:53.240 And it goes on and on, and on and on
00:53:56.860 And on and on, on and on
00:53:59.400 On and on and on
00:54:01.400 On and on and on
00:54:05.720 And on and on
00:54:06.900 On and on and on
00:54:09.560 And on and on and it goes on
00:54:12.280 On and on and on
00:54:13.820 And on and on
00:54:15.400 On and on and on
00:54:18.100 and we're back and i'm super excited because i am here with my beautiful and sweet and perfect
00:54:26.360 daughter but that's what i've been telling her she is since she was a baby and she's visiting me
00:54:31.820 in prince edward county and we've had a wickedly cool time and it's been like a late christmas
00:54:39.100 so we've gone to wineries and restaurants and done all kinds of fun stuff well hopefully fun
00:54:44.200 have you had fun yeah yeah i've had a great time i mean it's always nice to come um in to uh prince
00:54:50.160 edward county after christmas because it's a little bit quieter but you can still go to wineries
00:54:54.360 you can still kind of bop around and go to good restaurants and stuff but you don't have like the
00:54:59.120 craze of all um the uh people traveling and like just coming here um for the christmas break yeah
00:55:07.220 bridal parties and stuff you don't have all of that so it's a nice little time to come to prince
00:55:12.260 edward county you can really get to know the people at the wineries um they really have time
00:55:15.980 to sit down talk to you um explain what they do and everything um and i mean it was a little snowy
00:55:22.260 a little bit cold but overall i think we had really good weather for this week and stuff so
00:55:27.640 yeah i mean coming from halifax where it's probably rainy and windy uh it's been a pretty nice week
00:55:32.720 so all of that sounds super positive however when donald j trump is about to become president
00:55:40.740 united states again tomorrow so you'll be going back to work and so is he how do you as like are
00:55:48.600 you millennial or gen z what are you i'm like on the cusp i think i was born in 95 so i think it's
00:55:54.420 like maybe the last year of millennial but it might also be the first year gen z i'm not really sure
00:56:00.540 as zillennial is what okay well as a zillennial speaking as the voice of your generation
00:56:06.820 how does like as your dad i for the first time in my life all of this shit happening everywhere
00:56:14.540 has made me anxious about um the future for you and your brothers um do is that misplaced do you
00:56:23.240 do you feel anxious about what's coming with trump and everything else well i think as a millennial
00:56:29.080 or a zillennial whatever i am um i think my whole like adult or conscious life i've been nervous about
00:56:36.720 the future i mean um i think uh i think things are getting really dark and i i am worried about
00:56:45.740 especially the future for my brothers and stuff i think um you know being 30 years old i've lived
00:56:50.560 through quite a few major events both positive and negative throughout my life and especially since i was
00:56:56.900 you know um a teen and stuff so uh and obviously as an adult i've already watched trump become
00:57:03.300 president once so uh yeah you know i am really nervous i'm really nervous of what this is going to
00:57:09.060 do um to you know my younger cousins and stuff as well especially because they're just becoming kind of
00:57:15.840 like conscious human beings who can form their own opinions and stuff like that so of course it's
00:57:20.480 really nerve-wracking for me to um kind of have to watch uh watch them um have to watch him be a
00:57:27.920 leader and stuff especially the leader of you know the most powerful country in the world is scary it is
00:57:33.100 scary and uh um so that is interesting well then um you know in terms of our politics like i don't
00:57:40.400 you know i don't know how you vote i don't know if you're a new democrat or a liberal conservator
00:57:44.920 what you how you feel how do you feel about the leadership we've got in the country at the federal
00:57:51.940 level like do you think they're ready for trump do you think they're ready for the challenges that
00:57:56.280 are ahead i don't think so to be honest um i think we have a lot of work to do um i think uh even as
00:58:04.580 canadians just um kind of voting in the right people to lead our parties and stuff like that just
00:58:10.260 because right now i just don't know that they're they're prepared for trump like i think they they
00:58:15.320 they think they are because they can think back you know um to 2016 and stuff and what happened then
00:58:21.420 but i think trump has just his ideologies have just come so much further and are just so much more um
00:58:29.460 kind of embedded in people's minds in the united states and stuff as we saw with this election i think
00:58:34.880 a lot of people were really shocked including our leaders at how this election turned out i mean i could
00:58:39.760 be completely wrong obviously but uh i think it really took people by shock and that showed how
00:58:44.780 unprepared people were because i think there were a lot of people who um were kind of like no like
00:58:50.280 like he's going to be voted back in you know kamala's just not doing enough she's not talking to the right
00:58:55.800 people she's not hitting the right crowds uh and he just seemed to know that he had support no matter
00:59:02.220 where he was going um even if his rallies didn't you know um they didn't uh show that uh i think
00:59:10.080 yeah i think just the shock alone at um that canadians had showed how unprepared we are for
00:59:16.360 his leadership yeah it looks like uh we're still you still have some people in state of denial
00:59:22.360 so um what do you think we need to be doing as a country whether it's for trump or terrorism or
00:59:31.380 the future that's coming it looks like it's bumpy like what do you think what do you as you know
00:59:38.600 somebody on the cusp of gen z and millennial what do you and your friends want to see you know coming
00:59:45.060 out of politicians mounds and coming out of government like what what do you want to see
00:59:51.660 that isn't happening right now um well i definitely want to see like more of like more people sticking
00:59:58.800 up for canada first of all like even though you know we all really hope and kind of know that
01:00:06.500 canada will never become the next state it's just nice to see when politicians just are like speak
01:00:12.580 their voice and really stand up for canada because it shows like yes we do have something to be proud
01:00:17.100 of as canadians we do live in the greatest country of all time uh and we're not going to let americans
01:00:22.420 bully us and make fun of us basically to our faces um and you know we do you know uh you know we do
01:00:31.900 have kind of i don't know the balls i guess to stand up for ourselves and say hey like we know that
01:00:37.700 you're a bigger country and everything like that but you can't be bullying us you know we stand with
01:00:43.320 you for so much and you know we've always been by your side no matter what you are you're asking of us
01:00:49.820 so you know show us a little bit of respect and you know we are a strong um country and we we can
01:00:57.780 help you if you want our help um but we have to work together and i think that goes for the same as
01:01:02.380 um canadian politicians uh you know i felt like when i was growing up you could always look at
01:01:08.580 canadian politicians and they all kind of seemed like they may be you know on the outside at least
01:01:13.540 got along or could agree with each other and work with each other when now it just seems like everyone
01:01:18.100 just biting each other's heads off and i think you know in order for us as a country to do um you
01:01:24.320 know to stand up to you know trump and his administration and everything i think canadian politicians
01:01:30.260 really have to come together and say like you know what maybe we don't agree on everything but we do
01:01:34.560 agree that canada is the best country in the world and we're going to show him and his you know his posse
01:01:40.400 that we stand together yeah well said well said uh i think most people are going to completely agree
01:01:48.000 with you final thing probably the most important question of all um which is like how awesome was it
01:01:55.420 to be warren cancella's dog like it had to have been like just incredibly amazing there were definitely
01:02:06.560 lots of highs
01:02:07.700 i mean i think i think i i can i definitely for sure have a lot of um even the other day i was with some
01:02:19.480 friends down in toronto and we were out and stuff and they just you know i think it's a big conversation
01:02:24.280 topic like how i grew up and like the the things i got to experience growing up especially when i was
01:02:29.640 a kid and stuff maybe not so more so much uh living in halifax but when i was around my dad more and
01:02:35.540 stuff all the cool events i got to go to and everything so i think that's like a really um you
01:02:40.640 know i don't know a lot of people who can go around bragging that they went to like fun you know or
01:02:45.540 maybe not fun necessarily but cool political events and like um you know book launches and rallies and
01:02:52.780 stuff you know like i there's a lot of things that i got to um for example the uh rallies in 2016 after
01:03:00.420 trump was inaugurated like i got to go to those rallies in washington which i think you know so
01:03:06.020 many people wouldn't say they never got the chance to do things like that and i only got the chance to
01:03:10.200 do things like that because of who my father is so um although like it's you know um a little
01:03:16.560 nerve-wracking and stuff when people come up to me on the street and ask me if my dad is warren
01:03:20.420 kinsella i think overall you start looking for the exits overall um it brought a lot to my childhood
01:03:26.680 and a lot to my life and i have a lot of experiences that a lot of people um don't have and i think
01:03:32.600 that's really cool so well there you go well you've brought a lot to my life too so back at you
01:03:37.540 so um i'll miss you and i wish you weren't so far away but i guess i can fly there like driving there
01:03:47.120 is driving there is hard it's a bit of a trip yeah it's a bit of a trip we will be back to see
01:03:53.640 you but anyway have a great flight back thank you and a great week and hopefully uh things get better
01:03:59.340 and uh the world improves because god knows we need it yeah hopefully i totally agree and uh
01:04:06.720 yeah hopefully we have a good trip back to halifax today and hopefully i'm back in ontario
01:04:11.340 sooner rather than later hear her emma kinsella thank you thank you thank you dad this is post-modern
01:04:18.820 teenage angst
01:04:20.820 let's go
01:04:23.840 i've been looking around all my friends and enemies believe me never come around but i know that you can't stand me
01:04:41.440 there's a lot of tears that turn to fear into something we can work with
01:04:54.120 this is post-modern teenage angst post-modern teenage angst
01:05:00.780 Post-modern teenagers, post-modern teenagers, post-modern teenagers
01:05:09.860 Don't try to stop me now
01:05:12.460 I've been saying it's right, all my families think I just wanna die
01:05:19.920 But I can't stand, and it needs some peace and quiet
01:05:24.620 I've been living a lie, when you watch my Insta stories you think I'm living the last
01:05:34.060 But I'm barely getting by
01:05:37.340 Post-modern teenagers, post-modern teenagers, post-modern teenagers
01:05:46.640 Don't try to stop me now
01:05:49.640 Don't try to stop me now
01:05:54.620 Post-modern teenagers, post-modern teenagers
01:06:21.060 Don't try to stop me now
01:06:23.640 Post-modern teenagers, post-modern teenagers
01:06:30.440 Post-modern teenagers
01:06:33.120 Don't try to stop me now
01:06:35.920 Don't try to stop me now
01:06:39.080 The liberal leadership race is nothing if not entertaining
01:06:46.060 And it's given me a lot of content for the Ben Mulroney show
01:06:50.260 But there's only so much that I know
01:06:52.720 I don't have the institutional knowledge about how these races are run
01:06:56.980 The dynamics at play
01:06:58.560 And so I've called upon two great friends of the show
01:07:02.200 We've got, let's say hello to Marcel Weider
01:07:05.160 Liberal strategist and president and chief advocate of Aurora Strategy Global
01:07:08.440 Marcel, welcome to the show
01:07:09.540 Thank you, Ben
01:07:10.360 And also, in an effort of full disclosure
01:07:12.300 I have a professional relationship with Aurora
01:07:15.120 And let's also say hi to Warren Kinsella
01:07:17.340 Former special advisor to Jean Chrétien
01:07:19.040 And CEO of the Daisy Group
01:07:21.240 Welcome, Warren
01:07:21.800 Hey, guys
01:07:23.100 Okay, so
01:07:24.060 If I look at
01:07:26.840 The polling data that I saw on Twitter
01:07:29.820 It looks like it's a two-way race
01:07:31.080 Between Mark Carney and Chrystia Freeland
01:07:32.900 At least at this point
01:07:34.160 With Carney being polled among liberal voters
01:07:37.020 For who their preferred liberal leader is
01:07:39.360 Carney's polling at about 27%
01:07:41.240 And Freeland not too far behind at 21%
01:07:45.140 So, Warren, would you agree with that assessment?
01:07:48.920 And given the fact that Mark Carney is godfather to Chrystia Freeland's child
01:07:52.860 Does that mean we shouldn't expect any mudslinging?
01:07:57.140 No, I think that's why they invented Karina Gould
01:08:00.440 Karina Gould
01:08:01.280 The word is she is getting into the race with no hope of winning it
01:08:05.320 But she is going to be able to say critical things of Chrystia Freeland
01:08:09.120 That Mark Carney cannot or does not want to say himself
01:08:13.080 You know, if we all remember back to the start of December
01:08:16.280 When Justin Trudeau fatally fired Chrystia Freeland from finance
01:08:23.080 He was doing that to bring in Mark Carney
01:08:25.420 And Monday morning she fired off her letter quitting his cabinet
01:08:29.820 And at that point Mark Carney said
01:08:32.480 I can't come into government
01:08:33.960 Because it would be stepping on the political remains of Chrystia Freeland
01:08:39.100 So he's very cagey
01:08:42.020 He's very hesitant to get into a kind of a mano-a-mano fight
01:08:46.020 With a female candidate like Chrystia Freeland
01:08:48.360 So that's why Karina Gould's in the mix
01:08:50.400 But anyway, right now guys, bottom line
01:08:53.180 The Trudeau candidate is Carney
01:08:55.040 The anti-Trudeau candidate is Freeland
01:08:57.320 What say you, Marcel Wieter?
01:09:00.700 Well, I tend to agree with what Warren just said
01:09:03.200 I think, however, on the Karina Gould thing
01:09:06.280 Is that she wanted to introduce somebody from the progressive side of the party
01:09:11.860 And that's what she's going to try and represent
01:09:13.860 She's also going to be the youngest candidate of the three
01:09:18.240 And so it's designed to inject a little bit of youth into the party
01:09:23.380 What about, I mean, I think a lot of us are surprised
01:09:26.480 That it's a very thin, a very few number of candidates
01:09:30.540 Trudeau said he wanted a robust national debate
01:09:33.620 I think a lot of us thought more than what we have would be in the race
01:09:37.860 How much of it is attributable to the high barrier of entry
01:09:41.220 With the $350,000 entry fee
01:09:44.920 It's $350,000 plus the time limits
01:09:49.000 To sign up members, you have to be a member by, I believe, January 27th or 29th
01:09:55.160 So that's only a couple of weeks to sign up people
01:09:58.040 And then the actual vote takes place on March the 9th
01:10:01.380 So a real compressed timeline for any potential candidate to get in
01:10:06.260 And they just announced that the spending limit is about $5 million
01:10:10.200 So, you know, on top of the $350,000 for the entry
01:10:14.100 You have to raise, you know, several million dollars
01:10:17.580 To mount a credible national campaign
01:10:19.800 Okay, so here's what I'm going to do
01:10:21.420 I've got two experts here
01:10:22.820 And we really have, for all intents and purposes, two candidates
01:10:26.460 So, Warren, if you were backing and advising Mark Carney
01:10:32.140 What would your advice be to him at this point in the campaign?
01:10:36.440 He needs to create a distinction between himself and truth
01:10:40.200 You know, Trudeau's inner circle is running his campaign
01:10:43.440 He's been providing advice to Trudeau's government on the QT, on the financial front
01:10:49.700 For almost two years
01:10:51.380 Like, he is the Trudeau candidate, as I say
01:10:54.000 So what he needs to be doing, as Khalil Gibran says
01:10:57.300 He needs to have some spaces in his togetherness
01:11:00.200 You know, he needs to hold himself out as a liberal
01:11:03.160 But not just an extension of the Trudeau policy and the Trudeau approach
01:11:07.720 Because if that becomes the impression
01:11:09.860 He is going to lose, big time
01:11:12.140 Right now, as things stand
01:11:13.620 They have to come back
01:11:14.960 Pro-aggression ends at the end of March
01:11:16.940 So they can come back for that supply vote
01:11:19.120 At that point, there will be, we are told
01:11:21.500 A new liberal leader
01:11:22.640 And they may be heading into an election immediately
01:11:25.500 If he is just seen as an extension of what we had with Justin Trudeau
01:11:29.820 You know, he may lose even more seats than Justin Trudeau
01:11:33.700 So he's got to create some differences
01:11:35.560 And he's got to do that pretty fast
01:11:37.360 I think just calling yourself an outsider doesn't make it so
01:11:40.680 Marcel, if you were backing and advising Christia Freeland
01:11:44.960 What would your advice to her be today?
01:11:47.060 Well, she needs to be having some bold ideas
01:11:49.480 She needs to be out of the box
01:11:51.560 And show that she's breaking away from the Trudeau cabal
01:11:56.120 That's been, you know, running things for the last nine years
01:11:59.620 So if I was her, I'd be doing things a lot differently
01:12:05.080 I'd be out there with some bold progressive policies
01:12:09.500 That will set her apart
01:12:10.860 And set the Liberal Party apart from a potential Pierre Polyev government
01:12:16.240 Meanwhile, last week, Anthony Housefather and Yvonne Baker, too
01:12:19.320 Liberal MPs, wrote an op-ed in the National Post
01:12:22.940 Essentially saying that for this party to become palatable again to most Canadians
01:12:27.600 They have to revert back to the party of Jean Chrétien
01:12:30.900 This party of Paul Martin
01:12:32.060 And Jean Chrétien himself
01:12:35.220 The Radical Centre
01:12:36.500 Referred to the Radical Centre
01:12:37.800 Warren, he's your old boss
01:12:39.080 First of all, it was nice to see him on TV again
01:12:40.780 Glad to see he's doing so well
01:12:42.400 Even if that happened today, Warren
01:12:46.200 How long until, and what would the party have to do
01:12:48.960 To make themselves a valid alternative to the Tories?
01:12:54.580 Because I don't think people want that right now
01:12:56.900 Well, you know, it would all be symbolic
01:13:00.040 There isn't enough time
01:13:01.480 You know, you're talking about major surgery here
01:13:04.580 And they've given themselves only a few weeks
01:13:06.880 So there's not enough time
01:13:08.500 It's like Kamala Harris, who I work for, field disclosure
01:13:11.440 You know, 100 days was not enough time for her to define herself as a credible alternative
01:13:17.980 And somebody who was different from Joe Biden
01:13:20.420 They've got, the Liberals have got an even bigger problem
01:13:22.860 So, to me though, there is one sliver of hope
01:13:26.960 There is one, you know, silver lining in the clouds overhead
01:13:30.720 And that is Donald Trump
01:13:32.600 It is evident now, Doug Ford confirmed it yesterday
01:13:35.880 The tariffs are going to happen
01:13:37.780 You know, and the Ford said yesterday
01:13:40.140 We're looking at half a million people in the province of Ontario
01:13:43.340 About to lose their jobs as a result
01:13:46.040 Nationally, it's going to be millions
01:13:48.180 That is the only issue in the country
01:13:51.060 And the advantage or the opportunity that the Liberals have got
01:13:54.860 Whoever their leader is
01:13:56.140 Is they need to be talking about that
01:13:58.260 In the way that Stephen Harper did on the weekend
01:14:01.000 In the way that Jean Chrétien did
01:14:02.680 In the way, you know, Ben, that your dad would
01:14:04.940 Like all three of those men
01:14:06.720 Would be talking about resisting the terrible mistake
01:14:11.420 That Donald Trump's about to visit on us
01:14:14.300 Pierre Polyev has disappeared
01:14:16.000 You can tell he is freaked out
01:14:18.180 By all of this stuff that's happening
01:14:20.220 Because about a third of his base are Trump fans, right?
01:14:23.960 And he doesn't want to alienate them
01:14:25.380 That creates opportunity for whoever the Liberal leader is
01:14:28.560 That, to me, is the only strategy they've got left
01:14:31.140 Anything else that Trudeau tried didn't work
01:14:33.440 To me, the ballot question needs to be Donald Trump
01:14:36.100 Marcel, the last word to you
01:14:37.760 No, I agree with Warren on this
01:14:40.020 It really will come down to a Trump-type election
01:14:43.800 Whoever the Liberal leader is
01:14:46.320 Is going to have to focus on
01:14:48.180 How they're going to protect Canadians
01:14:50.640 How they're going to respond to Trump
01:14:53.040 And both Freeland and Carney are well-positioned
01:14:57.220 You know, Carney, a former Bank of Canada and England governor
01:15:00.480 And really knows the economics of how to respond
01:15:04.800 Freeland, who negotiated the last Canada-US-Mexico agreement
01:15:10.180 Is well-poised
01:15:12.040 In fact, Trump detests her
01:15:13.880 And was happy to see her go
01:15:15.940 So either of those two are the right people to respond
01:15:20.320 Unlike Polyev, who has no background in economics
01:15:24.180 Has never held a professional job
01:15:26.620 Other than being a professional politician
01:15:29.280 So the contrast is there
01:15:31.700 And will make a huge difference in the election
01:15:35.240 The contrast is there
01:15:36.320 But so too are the challenges for the Liberal brand
01:15:38.880 In this election
01:15:40.260 But I'm glad to have the two of you here
01:15:42.080 To help us navigate the red waters
01:15:44.580 As it were
01:15:45.980 The Red Sea
01:15:47.580 Part of the Red Sea
01:15:49.320 Warren Kinsella, Marcel Wieter
01:15:50.760 Thank you both for being here
01:15:52.060 I appreciate it
01:15:52.620 I hope to see you again soon
01:15:53.360 Thank you
01:15:54.020 Did you take a move?
01:15:58.140 I see you've gone back home
01:16:00.300 It's a Monday now
01:16:02.760 I bet you're coming down
01:16:05.540 Did you think that I would cry in the morning?
01:16:11.400 Will you be right?
01:16:15.980 How were your pills last night, darling?
01:16:20.420 What did you forget?
01:16:25.700 Say you're wrong, baby
01:16:27.320 But you didn't try
01:16:28.480 Did you count?
01:16:29.620 Well, I didn't lie
01:16:31.160 Well, I don't feel right
01:16:34.420 Were you chasing every other guy?
01:16:39.180 Well, I want another lie
01:16:41.880 Well, I don't feel right
01:16:45.520 Oh, you call me up in the morning
01:16:56.220 You call myself home
01:16:59.320 Well, I don't find
01:17:01.400 Well, now I'm older
01:17:04.440 I ain't been sober
01:17:06.680 You call me daily
01:17:09.300 Well, I'll be alright
01:17:11.680 How were your pills last night, darling?
01:17:19.740 What did you forget?
01:17:23.920 Say you won't be
01:17:25.320 But you didn't try
01:17:26.620 Did you count?
01:17:27.740 Well, I didn't lie
01:17:29.360 Well, I don't feel right
01:17:33.060 Are you chasing every other guy?
01:17:37.360 Well, I want another lie
01:17:40.080 I don't feel right
01:17:44.360 You call me up in the morning
01:17:48.900 You call myself home
01:17:52.100 Well, I'm doing fine
01:17:54.480 But now I'm older
01:17:57.200 I ain't been sober
01:17:59.360 You call me daily
01:18:02.020 Well, I'll be alright
01:18:04.520 How were your pills last night, darling?
01:18:11.340 What did you forget?
01:18:15.340 You laugh, you laugh, you laugh
01:18:19.740 You say you won't be
01:18:22.780 Oh, you won't be
01:18:38.900 Americans said, look here, we'll give you one American dollar for every Canadian dollar.
01:18:53.740 Why don't you pack it in?
01:18:54.680 I agree with the, I mean, I think Moses' statement of 13% is an underestimation.
01:19:02.300 I think more than 13% would vote for that, but I think the majority would not.
01:19:06.120 We can do better.
01:19:06.740 But we haven't done, I don't want to make a partisan statement here, but we haven't done well in the last 10 years, as Diane knows very well.
01:19:14.040 We've had terrible capital outflows, including Canadians themselves, because they're better places to invest in Canada because of poor public policy.
01:19:24.000 On this business of Trump, he's not serious, he's playing poker.
01:19:27.700 And the idea of responding to complaints about people crossing our border into the U.S. by raising tariffs is a non sequitur.
01:19:35.880 I mean, we're not East Germany, we're not building walls to keep people in, and it is the responsibility of all countries to set up whatever processes they think appropriate at their borders with incoming people.
01:19:48.840 And Trump's real complaint, as he showed in the election in November, was his predecessor's conduct on the southern border.
01:19:55.260 He has no complaint of us, really, about how we handle our border.
01:19:59.020 If we should do a little more, fine, let's do it.
01:20:01.120 But in any case, that's not a terror list.
01:20:03.260 All right, I take your point, Conrad, and I do agree that Trump's rhetoric is a bit of a red herring.
01:20:07.860 But imagine trading resources in U.S. dollars.
01:20:10.500 Imagine maybe Canadians have a seat or two of the Federal Reserve.
01:20:14.240 What would that look like?
01:20:15.200 It's not a red herring.
01:20:17.580 He means it.
01:20:19.320 I worked, full disclosure, for Kamala Harris as a volunteer.
01:20:24.280 He campaigned on an every single day, tariffs.
01:20:27.860 He has a mandate to do it.
01:20:30.220 And he needs the revenue to pay for his tax cut.
01:20:33.180 He means it.
01:20:34.140 It's going to happen.
01:20:35.120 A week from now, we're going to be talking about an economy that is going to be in a tremendous state of distress.
01:20:41.740 But, you know, here's Doug Ford.
01:20:44.200 This has become the most popular hat in the country at the moment.
01:20:47.180 Can we pull up that visual?
01:20:50.120 See that?
01:20:50.900 Canada's not for sale.
01:20:52.080 So there's a Conservative leader of Ontario.
01:20:55.300 And I can tell you that is the most popular hat in the country in the past hour.
01:20:59.940 And that's across the political spectrum.
01:21:03.240 Left, right, east, west, young, old.
01:21:06.540 If you, getting back to what Mr. Black said, if you measure public opinion, which is the most important thing, not the dollar value, exchange rate.
01:21:16.060 If you measure public opinion in this country, going back decades, we regularly ask this question.
01:21:22.760 Do you want to join the United States?
01:21:24.800 And whether people are Conservative or Liberal or whatever, or however distressed they are about the way in which the country is being governed,
01:21:31.720 the answer is always no.
01:21:33.840 It's a non-starter.
01:21:35.060 Here it is.
01:21:51.080 It's on the record now.
01:21:52.720 Second guess, second best.
01:21:54.280 Feeling better, but oh my god.
01:21:56.600 It's making me sick.
01:21:58.520 Every glance, every invitation, unmet, unread, seen and delivered, asking for much.
01:22:08.540 Just someone who cares just a little bit.
01:22:13.240 Nobody will care if it's your birthday.
01:22:16.520 They don't just want to go home.
01:22:19.980 You'll drink till you pass out and learn how to run your mouth with.
01:22:43.420 So much conviction, they'll all stop and missin' still.
01:22:49.760 I'll hold your head back and chase you down and call a cab.
01:22:55.560 Cause I hold your head back.
01:22:58.040 I always hold your head back.
01:23:02.700 Nobody will care if it's your birthday.
01:23:05.420 But if they don't just want to go home.
01:23:13.420 And if it came down to me, you wouldn't have heard.
01:23:18.340 Then I don't let me know.
01:23:21.360 It would be nice for him to say that he wants me before 1am.
01:23:33.360 I thought it came, might taste nice at the party.
01:23:42.040 But now I'm falling again.
01:24:03.360 It's just the amazing.
01:24:17.500 You're never watching me.
01:24:24.380 It's just the amazing.
01:24:31.060 You're never watching me.
01:24:43.380 This is CFRA Live, Sunday political panel.
01:24:48.440 And what better way to warm up in the frigid cold than to talk about federal politics, of course.
01:24:56.020 Joining us this morning, our lovely panelist, Carl Belanger, is the president at Traction Strategies.
01:25:00.040 Good morning, Carl.
01:25:00.920 Morning, Andrew.
01:25:01.800 Warren Kuntilla is a strategist and post-media columnist.
01:25:04.540 His latest is in the Toronto Sun this morning.
01:25:06.560 Good morning, Warren.
01:25:07.480 Morning, guys.
01:25:08.420 And Tasha Karanit is here.
01:25:09.380 Political columnist for the National Post, a writer for GZero Media and an author.
01:25:12.680 Good morning, Tasha.
01:25:14.000 Good morning.
01:25:14.680 So just as kind of Donald Trump likes it, we're all watching him south of the border, right?
01:25:18.920 We're waiting on this inauguration tomorrow for a number of reasons, I think.
01:25:22.420 But we're all still waiting to hear whether or not Canada will be hit with these 25% tariffs.
01:25:27.220 We had a big meeting this week.
01:25:28.460 We had all the premiers here in Ottawa meeting with the prime minister.
01:25:32.360 It was kumbaya for the most part, I guess.
01:25:34.700 Tasha, I'll start with you in terms of this was a united front that almost was there.
01:25:38.700 It was kumbaya minus one, I suppose.
01:25:40.560 But what did you make of that holdout there from Alberta Premier Danielle Smith?
01:25:45.240 Well, it's something that's not surprising considering both her politics internally in Alberta
01:25:52.560 and the way that Alberta feels it's been treated by the federal government for the last decade.
01:25:57.860 She doesn't want to do Trudeau any favors.
01:25:59.720 And the idea of putting Alberta oil and gas up for negotiation or slapping an export tariff on it,
01:26:06.560 making it more difficult for the industry, is not something that she wants to have to defend to her base.
01:26:12.100 It's not something that she wants to give him.
01:26:14.580 Now, of course, the problem is this isn't really about him.
01:26:17.160 It shouldn't be about him.
01:26:18.200 It should be about the country.
01:26:19.140 But now it's a bit different because there's a willing partner down south.
01:26:25.180 And I think Alberta knows that, that there's actually, you know, the opening that Donald Trump has made to our country.
01:26:31.880 But it's 51st state.
01:26:33.980 What piece of it is?
01:26:34.780 I say what he wants.
01:26:36.300 Alberta would be prime pickings.
01:26:38.160 And I think there's a sentiment there that for the first time there's other options among some people.
01:26:44.740 Not everybody, of course.
01:26:46.680 But it makes for a very, it's a powder keg.
01:26:49.380 It's a national unity powder keg that is not the usual one we're used to.
01:26:53.480 We usually think about Quebec, but it's not.
01:26:55.100 So I think she is, she is not putting Canada first.
01:26:58.620 That's clear.
01:27:00.260 But like I said, considering all these other factors, I think she feels she doesn't have to.
01:27:04.320 And Warren, you know, it feels like, you know, Smith feels like there's a deal to be made for Alberta here.
01:27:09.020 But no doubt, just this obviously waters down the United Front in many ways.
01:27:13.240 Were you surprised by this, by the move by Daniel Smith not to sign the communique or come to the meeting at all?
01:27:19.300 She's a regional manager.
01:27:21.660 You know, she's not a premier.
01:27:23.580 She's the Neville Chamberlain of Confederation to me.
01:27:27.540 And I say that as an Albertan.
01:27:29.380 Somebody's worked in the oil patch.
01:27:30.900 And, you know, I grew up in the oil patch.
01:27:35.560 Like, she has undercut Canada's position.
01:27:38.780 She has hurt Canada.
01:27:40.820 She doesn't attend the first minister's meeting.
01:27:44.180 She issues a communique at the end.
01:27:46.860 She was in Panama issuing a communique about her position.
01:27:52.100 But at the end of the day, you know, I just remember great Alberta leaders like Peter Lougheed.
01:28:00.060 You know, he didn't like a lot of the elements of the repatriation of the Constitution or the Charity of Rights and Freedoms.
01:28:06.220 But he participated.
01:28:07.820 He was there.
01:28:08.760 And he fought for Alberta's point of view.
01:28:11.240 And he won, you know, because he showed up.
01:28:14.460 She didn't show up.
01:28:15.560 And she looks like a coward as a result.
01:28:18.560 So she has hurt Alberta's position.
01:28:20.920 Why?
01:28:21.720 Because at the end of the day, the movement of goods across Canadian international borders is still ultimately controlled under the Constitution by the government of Canada.
01:28:32.220 So they absolutely had the power to stop the flow of Alberta oil into the United States of America.
01:28:38.780 So it will happen whether she wants it or not.
01:28:43.020 I just don't understand what the strategy of her and her team is, why she wouldn't participate in the discussion to try and ensure we have a united Canadian position, but also to defend Alberta's interests.
01:28:55.660 Like, what's she going to do?
01:28:56.520 Going to run a referendum on separation or something?
01:28:59.680 Like, she's just not a serious person.
01:29:02.060 And I don't think she has been from the start.
01:29:04.160 That's what I was kind of confused by, I suppose, as well, is what are you gaining from this?
01:29:08.340 Because, Carl, you know, just to that point, you know, we had Francois Legault and Scott Moe out.
01:29:12.260 You know, they weren't singing the praises of Justin Trudeau, but they were playing the part, right?
01:29:15.440 And we know they have similar concerns that Daniel Smith does, but they were at least willing to go along for a little bit here.
01:29:20.820 So were you surprised that Daniel Smith, I guess, was so blatantly opposed to being involved in this?
01:29:26.740 Well, I was surprised that Francois Legault and Scott Moe came up around.
01:29:30.040 Yeah, maybe that's the biggest surprise.
01:29:31.540 I don't know.
01:29:32.000 That was the surprise, especially when it comes to export.
01:29:36.380 Like, Legault on energy was less than keen to follow the strategy that was outlined first by Doug Ford to cut the tap.
01:29:43.540 And Scott Moe and Potash, we know how important this was to catch one.
01:29:46.920 But the truth is, I was not surprised that Daniel Smith did what she did.
01:29:50.920 And she's, I mean, she's quite influenced by the Make America Great Again movement and America First, right?
01:29:59.920 So for her, it's Alberta First.
01:30:01.980 Whatever that means, in terms like a Warren outline, will it succeed?
01:30:06.400 It doesn't matter, because for her politics, it's working.
01:30:09.720 Like, you look at how people are reacting in Alberta, and they're all behind her.
01:30:14.140 And so in that way, she's kind of transforming Alberta into the new Quebec,
01:30:18.760 where, you know, we're ready to dump the rest of the federation in the face of a bigger threat,
01:30:25.020 because it's better for us somehow.
01:30:27.280 I think it's counterproductive.
01:30:28.860 I don't think it's going to lead to anything for Alberta.
01:30:31.800 If anything, it's giving Trump and the United States a stronger hand.
01:30:37.260 And instead of folding like they did, I think it would have been better if Daniel Smith had been to the table
01:30:44.740 and talked with the other premiers that come out as part of Team Canada right now.
01:30:50.020 There's disunity, and that's not good for us, the rest of the country.
01:30:55.000 But it's also not good for Alberta, because they will also pay the price.
01:30:59.560 If Trump brings in tariffs, she may try to carve out an energy exemption, but it doesn't matter,
01:31:06.460 because other sectors will be affected, and jobs will be lost in Alberta as well as the rest of the country.
01:31:12.240 Well, to your note, I was watching as well this week.
01:31:13.780 If I can jump in on those points just very quickly.
01:31:16.220 She's also not good for Pierre Pogliet.
01:31:18.200 Again, she is undercutting his position, because in the event that he becomes prime minister
01:31:23.340 and he has to deal with a firm hand with Donald Trump, he swears to us he's going to do that.
01:31:30.080 He's not assisted by the fact that his Alberta vase is undercutting his position
01:31:34.680 and contradicting the positions he takes.
01:31:37.500 She doesn't hurt the federal liberals at all.
01:31:39.800 She helps them out, because they don't stand much chance of holding on to the one, two seats that they've got in the province.
01:31:46.780 But for Pierre Pogliet, she's a nightmare.
01:31:49.840 Well, just a quick follow on that, Warren, too, just as someone from Alberta, too.
01:31:52.580 I noticed that this week what Carl was saying is that I didn't notice anybody coming out strong against what Danielle Smith is doing.
01:31:58.100 Quite the opposite, in fact, right, getting behind her.
01:32:00.820 It seems like she's not really going to face a political hit at home, really, for any of this.
01:32:05.360 She may not, but we'll see.
01:32:07.720 You know, if people in Alberta, the people I grew up with, start to see that Alberta is being isolated politically within Confederation,
01:32:16.400 and their product is not getting to the American market, you know, some are going to react with anger and be angry at the liberals.
01:32:22.940 But those are people who never vote liberal anyway.
01:32:25.520 But some of them are going to say, well, this was your job.
01:32:28.620 Your job was to protect us, and you didn't do it.
01:32:31.140 You went down to Mar-a-Lago like a water boy and came back with absolutely nothing.
01:32:36.920 And we expect more of you, of our representative, and you haven't delivered.
01:32:41.000 So I think she's at some risk, too.
01:32:43.340 But the guy who's got the most risk here is the guy who's been noticeably silenced, which is Pierre Paulyon.
01:32:50.380 Yeah, I'll jump in on that one.
01:32:52.260 Go ahead, Tasha.
01:32:53.320 Because, yeah, I think that this is actually, he's being put in the box, and he either has to step up or he could be quite affected by this.
01:33:03.080 I think as things go on, you know, they always said only Nixon could go to China, right?
01:33:08.700 If you have a political credibility that you can afford to spend some of your capital, you can go and do things other people can't.
01:33:15.580 So if you're a staunch anti-communist, you can go meet with the communists, and you can make that bridge happen, and you won't get criticized for being a sellout.
01:33:24.280 The same thing will happen here.
01:33:25.800 Paul Yev is the only person who honestly in the country can go to Smith and say, you know what, it's time to get in line.
01:33:33.720 We've got to all pull in one direction.
01:33:36.860 We can't start freelancing.
01:33:38.280 This is dangerous.
01:33:39.740 Let's do this together.
01:33:41.100 Because he is from Alberta.
01:33:42.840 He is a defender of the oil patch.
01:33:44.260 He is also in the same mold.
01:33:46.920 If he doesn't do that, then that speaks volumes about where his priorities are.
01:33:51.980 And I think Canadians will punish him for it.
01:33:53.740 I mean, everyone's assuming it's a given.
01:33:55.600 The conservatives are going to win the next election.
01:33:58.020 With things developing the way they are, I think they will still win, but I think that they're starting to lose traction already because people are seeing who's causing the problem here.
01:34:09.120 It's not, you know, liberals are trying to get everyone in line to fight Trump, and that's going to be the priority.
01:34:15.380 Because things after tomorrow are going to go so fast in terms of unfolding between tariffs and also possibly immigration issues, and people start coming here if they don't want to be deported.
01:34:27.960 Plus, there are also millions, by the way, of Canadians who have dual citizenship, right, who are in the United States right now.
01:34:33.460 They can come back if they don't like the way things are going there, and we can't stop them because they are our citizens.
01:34:40.060 What would we do if we suddenly had an influx of so many people?
01:34:44.740 We've already had issues with that in the past couple of years.
01:34:46.940 So I think that Polyev has to meet the moment.
01:34:49.580 And if he doesn't, then people can start asking questions.
01:34:53.120 And I wanted to eventually turn domestically here to kind of more on Pierre Polyev and where he needs to turn now that we've seen some more liberals throw their hats into the ring here.
01:35:02.580 But just to kind of round out the Trump talk, I suppose, we're prepared as I guess we can be.
01:35:08.500 We saw, as I mentioned, you know, the United Front this week as well.
01:35:11.040 But are we in a difficult position right now?
01:35:13.660 Jim Balsillie coming up on Vasco Capello's later this morning saying we are in a very vulnerable position right now.
01:35:18.420 So economically over the course of the past 10, 20 years, but also just with the political situation we find ourselves in right now.
01:35:25.900 So, Warren, all of that being said, do you think we're as ready as we can be for what's going to happen in the U.S.?
01:35:32.340 No, we can't be.
01:35:33.720 But, you know, and Jim Balsillie is a friend of mine, and, you know, I think he's got one of the biggest brains in Canada.
01:35:40.680 But I disagreed with what he said.
01:35:43.040 Like, honestly, guys, did anybody two months ago think that the next president of the United States would declare economic war on Canada as his first official act?
01:35:55.280 Did anybody think that he would promise to use military force against Denmark, a member of NATO, in order to get Greenland or declare, you know, he was going to use the military against Panama?
01:36:07.920 Like, who saw that coming?
01:36:09.620 Nobody saw that coming.
01:36:10.780 And they also particularly didn't see the fact that the Republican Party would roll over and say, boom, say nothing about it.
01:36:18.860 This is very different than last time when this SOB was president from 2016 to 2020.
01:36:26.840 It is very different.
01:36:28.380 This time he's ready.
01:36:30.000 This time he doesn't have a bunch of people around him saying, no, don't do that, or you can't do that, or it's illegal.
01:36:36.380 So he's got a bunch of hardcore ideologues around him who are dedicated to giving full effect to his crazy agenda.
01:36:44.400 So, you know, to everybody listening right now, I'd love to tell you that it's just a negotiating tactic like conservatives were saying, you know, a month ago.
01:36:54.800 And he doesn't really mean it about tariffs.
01:36:56.920 He's not going to do it.
01:36:58.620 He's going to do it.
01:36:59.840 And when the Premier of Ontario comes out, as he did this week, and actually says half a million Ontarians are going to lose their job, potentially, potentially more, that's something politicians don't like to do, right?
01:37:16.000 That's not something, that's not the kind of news a politician likes to deliver.
01:37:19.580 However, it's real.
01:37:21.960 And what everything, guys, tomorrow, the world is changing, and it is changing in a bad way.
01:37:28.280 We need to be ready for that change that is coming.
01:37:31.140 And, Carl, we've been talking a lot about, you know, the last few weeks, what's going to happen.
01:37:34.740 You know, are we ready as we can be, as I was asking?
01:37:37.820 No, we can't be ready because we don't have a prime minister leading the country.
01:37:43.020 We have, you know, somebody that is a lame duck and doesn't have the authority to show up and stand up to Donald Trump.
01:37:52.560 And so it's an unfortunate turn of events.
01:37:54.880 I think Warren is right.
01:37:56.040 Nobody could predict what Trump would announce, but everybody knew that Trump would come after Canada in one way or another.
01:38:03.620 The liberal government knew that, too.
01:38:07.580 And the way they tried to push Trudeau out didn't work out.
01:38:11.520 It took too long.
01:38:13.020 And the timing of the decision is going to hurt Canada, for sure.
01:38:17.220 Now, there's nothing we can do about that, but it's going to be quite interesting to see in the coming weeks how Canada reacts and how quickly and how nimble and how strongly,
01:38:26.860 because you have a government that is basically in a caretaker mode.
01:38:31.440 And you have a leadership race that's going to unfold, and we're going to talk about that in a minute.
01:38:35.840 But, you know, these candidates will say things that will be going against, perhaps, what the official line of the government will be.
01:38:45.680 And so that will bring in further division and further confusion, and Donald Trump's going to seize on that.
01:38:51.620 You can be sure of it.
01:38:52.800 I can imagine he'll be watching what they'll be saying about the government, no doubt.
01:38:57.560 Tasha, are we ready as we possibly can be, given the circumstances?
01:39:01.460 Well, no, I mean, we couldn't have been ready, because I agree with Warren.
01:39:06.640 No one saw these things coming.
01:39:09.100 I think tariffs, yeah, there were rumblings of that.
01:39:12.600 He's always loved tariffs.
01:39:13.560 But the rest of it, the aggression towards allies, that's the piece that, you know, the idea that the U.S. should once again be a territorially expansive nation,
01:39:24.080 that it's ignoring the idea of sovereignty of other countries and just looking at them as prizes, that's something that we could not have anticipated.
01:39:32.680 So what we're facing now, and again, this goes back to Daniel Smith, is the fact that when you ask Canadians,
01:39:39.720 if you ask Canadians, one-third of us say that we would join the U.S. if we met lower taxes and our dollar would be on par and we would have more opportunities.
01:39:50.660 This rises to 40% of young people say they'd consider doing it.
01:39:54.120 That's the latest poll.
01:39:55.880 While other polls have shown only 13% would want to join the U.S., when you throw in all these sweeteners, things change.
01:40:02.980 That is scary because things are going to get economically worse in this country.
01:40:06.420 And that goes exactly back to what I was saying about Smith earlier, is that for the first time, Alberta has a dance partner.
01:40:12.980 And I think in her mind, she's thinking, you know what, that's the way to get concessions, is what Quebec did to the rest of Canada, was threatening to leave.
01:40:20.480 We're basically, it's the unspoken words here, is that, well, you know, you don't treat us well, we can go.
01:40:27.760 And she's not wrong.
01:40:28.980 This is the problem.
01:40:29.780 So our country is at a very perilous moment.
01:40:33.020 We are not ready.
01:40:34.580 We have to get ready as fast as we can, which means liberals have to get their leadership rights done.
01:40:39.580 They have to get a prime minister in.
01:40:40.840 But then we're going to have an election.
01:40:42.080 So, again, it's like we're just, we're paddling, you know, it's like paddling the canoe upstream.
01:40:48.040 And you keep going further and further back because you just, the headwinds and the currents get stronger and stronger.
01:40:52.820 And all of these issues kind of coming together at the kind of what seems like the worst possible time here.
01:40:58.240 You mentioned that liberal leadership race.
01:40:59.960 I wanted to talk about that because we did see some, I guess, the usual suspects this week in terms of what we were expecting.
01:41:05.120 You know, Mark Carney announced on Thursday, Christopher on Friday, Karina Gould yesterday.
01:41:09.540 I guess, Warren, from your perspective, any surprises that stuck out for you?
01:41:13.440 Well, I know the big issue here is, you know, Mark Carney, the outsider.
01:41:16.340 But did he stick out to you this week?
01:41:20.200 He had kind of a failure to launch.
01:41:23.580 You know, he kind of flubbed his statement.
01:41:25.720 I don't know why you need a teleprompter to talk about your life.
01:41:28.780 That's the one thing you should be able to talk about without a teleprompter.
01:41:32.080 And then from the journalists I know who were there, they said he was evasive on the questions that they asked him about Brookfield and his past and his support of Trudeau.
01:41:41.340 So he's not going to be allowed to get away with that, even in a very short leadership race.
01:41:46.820 And I was told that also his French is not that hot.
01:41:49.800 It's kind of Ottawa bureaucrat level French, but not the kind of French that will attract support in Quebec.
01:41:56.140 With her, she had a good, strong video launch.
01:41:59.180 That's the way she decided to do it.
01:42:01.300 So she's the one to take on Trump.
01:42:02.920 So she's leaned into, you know, Trump hates her guts and he said he hates her guts.
01:42:07.780 And so she's embraced that and that gives her a bit of a point of difference from Kearney.
01:42:13.660 And then Karina Gold, the word on her, like she's not going to win her seat.
01:42:17.380 She's never had any achievements.
01:42:19.160 And the reason why she's running is she's a stalking horse for Kearney.
01:42:23.080 So, you know, Freeland can be attacked, but Kearney can stay above the fray.
01:42:27.600 I hope that's not true, but that's what I've been told by about 100 people.
01:42:31.500 So that's kind of the state of the race right now.
01:42:33.980 You got Frank Bayless in there and some other people and, you know, they're just running for a profile.
01:42:39.700 But at this stage, you know, it's it's not helpful to Pierre Pagliot because he has, because of his inability to speak on Trump, he's disappeared.
01:42:49.220 But also the liberal leadership race is sitting on top of all federal coverage.
01:42:53.280 And it's become noticeable that he has become less noticeable, noticeable, noticeable, he's kind of disappeared because the liberals are eating up all the real estate.
01:43:02.180 And, yeah, definitely more attention being paid to the to the liberal leadership race than than to the opposition right now as well.
01:43:08.740 Tasha, just when it comes to is there any kind of obvious favorite here?
01:43:13.460 I know some people think Mark Carney could be the savior of the liberal party.
01:43:17.540 Other people hoping that Christopher Freeland will get a shot here after being deputy prime minister.
01:43:21.360 They all have challenges ahead of them. But do you see a favorite after the first week here?
01:43:26.300 I don't see a favorite. I mean, I think it's going to be a race between Carney and Freeland.
01:43:31.040 And I think that, you know, Carney Carney's launch. Yeah, it could have definitely gone better.
01:43:36.240 I think always if you want to launch, you want to have a lot of people around you and doing anything in a smaller venue, even if it's your hometown.
01:43:46.160 I wouldn't have necessarily made that choice.
01:43:47.820 I think he's got to embrace the fact that he's not he's not a small town guy.
01:43:52.460 He left small town behind a long time ago.
01:43:54.660 And maybe in this world today, dealing with someone like Donald Trump, that's actually a good thing, because you need to be able to stand up and say, hey, you know, I understand how business works.
01:44:04.160 I've been around these people. Let's talk.
01:44:05.980 I think anyone else. I think Trump doesn't really respect people who don't have, you know, some fight in them.
01:44:13.400 And in that sense, Christopher Freeland's playing that card.
01:44:15.860 You know, I'm the anti-Trump.
01:44:17.900 I think that it is going to be it's a difficult time for for the conservatives, like I said, for the reason simply that right now it's national interest versus Trump.
01:44:26.340 Everyone's sort of like pulling together on that point.
01:44:29.060 And if you're not on side with that, then you can be attacked for not helping the country.
01:44:35.500 Right. And so they've got to decide how to respond to the liberals.
01:44:39.640 Liberal race is going to dominate, but it's going to dominate mostly off the mainstream media, the media, the conservatives operate in, you know, the smaller podcast universe and online and stuff.
01:44:49.740 They don't need to pay as much attention to it.
01:44:51.520 They can still pay attention to the conservatives in those forums.
01:44:54.060 And Carl, I suppose, just from the from the perspective of we've just seen it basically, you know, all of the candidates we're probably going to see announced so far.
01:45:03.060 Is this essentially a Carney versus Freeland race for you?
01:45:06.980 And do you have a favorite at this point?
01:45:09.600 I don't have a favorite, but yes, I think it's a favorite in a betting sense.
01:45:13.280 I mean, the people who thought that Mark Carney was a savior of the Liberal Party were in for that surprise when he launched the way he launched.
01:45:25.040 And, you know, this is the problem with Mark Carney.
01:45:27.560 He is not a politician.
01:45:28.640 He's never given these kind of speeches.
01:45:30.800 And it showed, you know, at those lines, we're falling flat.
01:45:34.760 I mean, it's not the prompter that was the issue.
01:45:36.820 It's his delivery capacity.
01:45:38.160 And so we'll see if he turns it around.
01:45:41.040 But, like, a leadership race is not the training ground.
01:45:43.400 And that's the problem for Carney.
01:45:45.300 He's learning his craft right now.
01:45:47.360 And he doesn't have a lot of time.
01:45:49.560 But, you know, in front of him, he doesn't have exactly formidable opponents.
01:45:53.260 Like, Christian Freeland is not exactly, you know, raising the crowds around her and creating a Christian mania across the country.
01:46:01.660 So we'll see.
01:46:04.560 It's also notable that, you know, there's no big names for Quebec.
01:46:08.100 Frank Billis is there, but he's not a well-known entity in Quebec.
01:46:11.300 He was an MP for one term and better known for getting, you know, federal money during the COVID crisis.
01:46:16.820 So this race is not super exciting so far.
01:46:21.020 Yet there is a bit of a rebound in some polls showing that, you know, former Liberal voters are happy that Trudeau is gone or leaving.
01:46:29.360 And so that rebound, you know, is something that conservatives should pay attention to.
01:46:35.060 Because, yeah, as my colleagues outlined, Folieva has been kind of invisible.
01:46:40.620 And so has Jagmeet Singh, by the way.
01:46:42.020 We haven't really seen it.
01:46:42.900 Yeah, good point.
01:46:43.580 And so the Liberals are the only show in town right now.
01:46:47.980 And if it stays like that, that rebound will keep going because people will project whatever they want on the new leader.
01:46:55.340 And until a new leader is chosen, it could be anything.
01:46:57.860 And that new leader could be anything.
01:47:00.140 So that's why you'll see that, I think, that rebound continue, especially if the other opposition parties are nowhere to be seen.
01:47:08.620 And we'll see if they do try to change the channel here, the opposition parties.
01:47:13.000 But we'll have to leave it there.
01:47:13.920 Carl Belanger, Warren Kinsella, Tasha Carradine, thank you so much for your time this morning.
01:47:17.180 Have a great Sunday.
01:47:18.360 Thank you.
01:47:18.820 Thanks, guys.
01:47:19.920 And Carl, the president of Attraction Strategies.
01:47:21.760 Warren Kinsella, strategist and post-media columnist.
01:47:23.720 Read his latest in the Toronto Sun.
01:47:25.520 Tasha Carradine is a political columnist for the National Postal.
01:47:27.520 He drifts in with the wind and uses a library computer to check in.
01:47:35.160 You can't sleep at the table now and you're scaring the kids.
01:47:42.700 And the fall's getting cold.
01:47:45.040 You try to catch your hair in an envelope so you can stand at home.
01:47:50.740 Sit by the back alone.
01:47:52.620 Sun on your skin.
01:47:54.040 Yeah.
01:47:57.520 Another day up in flames
01:48:00.040 Another cop that knows your name
01:48:03.700 These assholes always sound the same
01:48:08.000 Madeline, I don't think that I'll see you again
01:48:14.780 Madeline, I love you but we both know how this ends
01:48:23.840 Madeline, this time is coming in
01:48:27.280 You pull out a sink, imagine the air in your lungs is gasoline light
01:48:38.120 What the fuck you're up, some people get overlocked, some gotta live
01:48:42.980 I can't find a dress, nobody sees and no way you're living out
01:48:52.580 I got you a birthday gift, no one has sent you with
01:48:56.320 Pictures of my kids
01:48:58.320 Another day up in flames
01:49:03.820 Another year that looks the same
01:49:07.160 Madeline, I don't think that I'll see you again
01:49:15.120 Madeline, I love you but we both know how this ends
01:49:22.940 Madeline, I heard that the time is coming in
01:49:30.440 You're lost in the grave with two broken legs
01:49:33.780 Trying to swim
01:50:03.780 Try to scream
01:50:06.200 Madeline, I don't think that I'll see you again
01:50:19.280 Madeline, I love you but we both know how this ends
01:50:28.160 Madeline, I heard that the tide is coming
01:50:33.280 It walks to the grave with two broken legs
01:50:38.100 Trying to swim