kinsellacast - January 11, 2026


KINSELLACAST 396: Daniel Rachel on Nazis and Rockers! Plus Lilley, Sa'd, Pierson, Smith and Thee Tabs, Co-Defendants, Wisp, Gladie, Sea Lemon, Daniel Romano


Episode Stats

Length

1 hour and 29 minutes

Words per Minute

133.54156

Word Count

11,985

Sentence Count

493

Misogynist Sentences

12

Hate Speech Sentences

33


Summary

This Ain't Rock n' Roll, Pop Music, The Swastika and the Third Reich by Daniel R. Rachman, author of a new book about rock and roll and Nazi memorabilia, This Ain t Rock N' Roll: The Story of Rock and Roll's Nazi Symbols, is out now.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 It's the KinsellaCast starring Warren Kinsella.
00:00:17.120 Hey, it's Warren from the KinsellaCast.
00:00:19.240 I'm going to get right into it because we've got a big, big show for you today.
00:00:22.020 We've got Brian Milley, Kareem Asad, Alex Pearson,
00:00:25.880 some other stuff that is happening, some other talk stuff.
00:00:29.220 But most particularly, most importantly, Daniel Rachel,
00:00:33.000 who is the author of a new book I picked up when I was in Britain
00:00:36.120 called This Ain't Rock and Roll, Pop Music, The Swastika and the Third Reich.
00:00:41.160 It's coming out in North America shortly, and it's really, really important.
00:00:45.680 And I think you've got to pick it up.
00:00:48.500 Talking about rock and roll, I've got a number of bands that I'm going to be playing for you.
00:00:53.420 Echo Disc by the band The Tabs, and it's from their 2023 album, Temporal Space Machine.
00:01:02.900 They're from Edinburgh, and just a great sound, great band.
00:01:07.760 I've got co-defendants who are on Epitaph.
00:01:10.700 They've got Fat Mike is in this band, and it's pretty tough.
00:01:14.820 It's actually timely, given the fact that we're going to be talking about Minneapolis.
00:01:18.120 Here's a sample lyric.
00:01:19.860 I've considered suicide by police.
00:01:22.300 I'd do it myself, but I'm far too angry.
00:01:24.740 That's the way these things got to be for now.
00:01:27.340 So that's the co-defendants with Fat Mike.
00:01:29.720 Then I've got kind of a fusion.
00:01:32.280 It's like Echo and the Bunnymen and Interpol and Ian Curtis's voice.
00:01:37.260 It's a song called As Long As I Breathe.
00:01:40.480 It's a debut single by a solo project called Wisp, with a period, not Wisp, the female artist.
00:01:47.800 Kind of melodic, Britpop, hybrid stuff, led by a musician named Per Lindquist.
00:01:54.600 Really, really good.
00:01:56.460 Then I've got Gladie, who I've seen, actually I saw last year, saw her opening for Jeff Rosenstock.
00:02:02.440 And she does kind of indie stuff.
00:02:07.160 She's from Philly, and got a great tune from her called Car Alarm.
00:02:12.360 Then I've got Sea Lemon, who I played before, with the song Crystals.
00:02:16.860 And Sea Lemon is kind of a solo project, really, by Natalie Liu, who is based in Seattle.
00:02:25.060 Then I've got Daniel Romano, and he is a Canadian boy, so we've got to support him.
00:02:32.860 Poet, visual artist in Welland, and got a song, and I don't know how he pronounces this.
00:02:40.920 It's Poet, Autopoet.
00:02:44.520 Anyway, you have to look up the spelling.
00:02:46.720 It's not like it sounds, but it's a great, great tune.
00:02:49.880 And got some other stuff on there, too.
00:02:55.080 Lantern.
00:02:56.560 Who else do I have?
00:02:57.680 I think that's it.
00:02:58.460 So, some good music, and a show that's a lot about music, because I'm talking to Daniel Rachel in a minute.
00:03:04.000 And as you'll hear from him, and in his book, 400 pages, it is depressing as hell.
00:03:11.560 John Lennon making Nazi salutes on stage, sort of Mick Jagger.
00:03:16.360 Both of them in Berlin, by the way, which is illegal.
00:03:18.680 They had a cutout of Hitler on the cover of Sgt. Pepper.
00:03:22.320 You couldn't really see it, because it was in behind the bend.
00:03:26.480 Blue Oyster Cult with Nazi imagery.
00:03:28.920 Debbie Harry of Blondie saying, why can't she see Kyle?
00:03:31.980 Eric Clapton, who's always been a fucking douchebag, talking about, here's a quote, get the wogs out, get the coons out, end quote.
00:03:39.560 He said that on stage, and he would wear a Nazi iron cross around his neck because he liked the design.
00:03:44.620 Joe Walsh, similarly, from the Eagles, saying he likes to collect Nazi things, and he doesn't care about the ethics of it.
00:03:51.700 Kiss, of course, who had the Schutzstaffel SS in their logo, and Ace Frehley was the source of that.
00:03:57.900 Big fan of Nazism.
00:04:00.400 Ice Cube calling Jews the devil.
00:04:02.280 Michael Jackson talking about kikes, quote-unquote.
00:04:07.100 Zeppelin's Jimmy Page, who is a piece of shit and would wear Nazi uniforms, and recently talked about it, wearing his Stormtrooper outfit on his Instagram page.
00:04:17.840 Madonna saying Jews of the Synagogue of Satan.
00:04:21.020 Keith Moon of The Who, formerly of The Who, doing Nazi uniforms and salutes.
00:04:27.980 Of course, Motorhead's Lemmy, doing the same sort of thing.
00:04:31.500 He was actually quite open about it, collecting a vast amount of Nazi memorabilia.
00:04:38.160 The dolls, New York dolls, with the SS Death's Head design on stage.
00:04:43.920 Roger Waters, of course, is an anti-Semite.
00:04:47.080 Didi Ramon broke my heart, saying he's fascinated by Nazi symbols.
00:04:50.980 And then, of course, the many, many artists, Sid Vicious, Marilyn Manson, Johnny Rotten, Susie Sue, wearing swastika arm bands.
00:04:58.800 And then Joy Division.
00:04:59.700 When I was talking to Daniel Rachel, he pointed out the Joy Division poster behind me.
00:05:04.920 He could see it over Zoom.
00:05:06.960 And I'll let him describe it.
00:05:09.760 And so that was depressing for me.
00:05:12.140 But the biggest heartbreaker was Bowie.
00:05:13.820 And Daniel's going to talk about that in the interview.
00:05:18.420 And it's just, and he talks about it in the book, too.
00:05:21.360 And it's just depressing as hell.
00:05:24.280 Anyway, I think it's really important because popular culture has a huge impact on people, particularly young people.
00:05:32.220 And some of them have behaved really badly.
00:05:36.860 So we need to hear from Daniel about that.
00:05:39.420 But in the meantime, thank you and welcome to the Kinsella Cast.
00:06:09.420 Thank you and welcome to the Kinsella Cast.
00:06:39.420 Kinsella Cast.
00:07:09.420 Kinsella Cast.
00:07:12.420 Kinsella Cast.
00:07:13.400 Kinsella Cast.
00:07:14.140 Kinsella Cast.
00:07:14.660 Kinsella Cast.
00:07:15.300 Kinsella Cast.
00:07:18.200 Break the Habits
00:07:48.200 Cast away
00:07:51.080 Cast away
00:07:54.520 The light
00:07:57.960 Light upon the planets
00:08:02.120 They collide
00:08:04.220 We arrive
00:08:08.000 But no
00:08:11.120 We're once in and away
00:08:14.780 Alone today
00:08:17.540 Alone today
00:08:20.780 How long
00:08:24.780 Must we sit and breathe
00:08:28.780 Yesterday
00:08:30.780 Yesterday
00:08:33.780 Yeah
00:08:35.780 Yeah
00:08:37.780 Out
00:08:51.780 For this consolation
00:09:08.540 Hazardous
00:09:10.780 Hazardous
00:09:13.780 That's all I take
00:09:17.780 That's all I take
00:09:18.780 That's all I take
00:09:19.780 My body
00:09:20.780 Can I let me out
00:09:23.780 Can I let me out
00:09:26.780 How long
00:09:30.780 Must we sit and breathe
00:09:33.780 Yesterday
00:09:36.780 Yesterday
00:09:37.780 How long
00:09:40.780 Must we sit and breathe
00:09:43.780 Yesterday
00:09:44.780 Yesterday
00:09:45.780 How long
00:09:47.780 Must we sit and breathe
00:09:48.780 Make it anyway
00:09:50.780 Yeah
00:09:51.780 Make it anyway
00:09:52.780 You
00:09:53.780 Make it
00:09:54.780 Why
00:09:55.780 It's
00:09:56.780 Time
00:09:57.780 For this
00:09:59.780 isseurs
00:10:04.780 You
00:10:06.780 How long
00:10:07.780 Are wasn't
00:10:08.780 You
00:10:09.780 An
00:10:24.780 All right, well, Daniel,
00:10:53.760 thank you so much for agreeing to speak with me.
00:10:59.880 Your book, This Ain't Rock and Roll,
00:11:02.640 Pop Music, The Swastika in the Third Reich,
00:11:05.100 is an important and powerful book,
00:11:08.220 and I'm looking forward to writing about it
00:11:10.360 and telling people about it.
00:11:12.420 Can you tell me a little bit more about your background?
00:11:16.380 You're a musician, your background,
00:11:18.060 and how you came to be involved in this subject?
00:11:21.040 Well, I was a musician for a good couple of decades.
00:11:29.980 I'm not anymore.
00:11:31.320 I guillotined that career when I started writing books,
00:11:35.220 and the idea to write this book,
00:11:41.320 I think, has its genesis in childhood
00:11:45.960 and the duality of hearing the Sex Pistols,
00:11:51.820 falling in love with the Sex Pistols.
00:11:54.500 And as part of that,
00:11:56.560 I would happily sing Belsum was a gas.
00:11:59.060 At the same time, I was introduced to,
00:12:04.920 or a similar time,
00:12:05.960 I was introduced to the Holocaust.
00:12:08.060 I was a schoolboy,
00:12:09.220 and I remember my parents,
00:12:13.440 and my mother came home with a video cassette,
00:12:16.500 and it simply had the strap line on their spine,
00:12:21.280 the type word Holocaust,
00:12:22.700 and she said that we can watch this together at some time,
00:12:27.340 but you really mustn't watch this on your own
00:12:30.020 because of the content.
00:12:31.400 It will be harrowing for you.
00:12:33.500 And so it's hidden on the top shelf of a high bookcase.
00:12:39.480 And of course,
00:12:39.880 the first time they went out shopping on a Saturday afternoon,
00:12:42.840 my hand went up to the top of the shelf,
00:12:44.840 and the tape came down into the VCR.
00:12:47.860 And I watched what I remember being an hour of compiled footage
00:12:53.100 of the liberation of the Nazi death camps,
00:12:57.180 and those images have indelibly pressed onto my mind ever since,
00:13:03.200 but that coupled with culture and singing Belsum was a gas
00:13:10.460 and having images of Sid Vicious wearing a swastika T-shirt,
00:13:14.800 and that confusion and juxtaposition,
00:13:20.440 I think, has been with me ever since.
00:13:23.420 And in many ways,
00:13:25.280 the book is an attempt to try and understand
00:13:29.200 what I couldn't understand as a child
00:13:32.140 and continue to be confused by
00:13:35.380 as my love for rock and roll has deepened.
00:13:39.680 The book is 400 pages long.
00:13:45.000 And as I say,
00:13:45.940 people really need to read it.
00:13:48.340 And it is,
00:13:49.760 I'd love to tell people it's uplifting,
00:13:52.720 but it is not.
00:13:53.800 It is,
00:13:54.620 it's a depressing picture.
00:13:56.860 And, you know,
00:13:57.500 I'm a student of rock and roll too.
00:13:59.800 It's far worse than I thought,
00:14:02.420 than I knew.
00:14:04.460 And I,
00:14:05.500 you know,
00:14:05.800 I was surprised by artists that I had admired.
00:14:11.080 I guess the biggest disappointment I got was Bowie,
00:14:14.880 as I was going through what you documented in the book,
00:14:18.160 but not just him.
00:14:21.140 What was the surprise to you as you were doing the research here,
00:14:24.660 which is considerable?
00:14:25.620 Well,
00:14:26.100 I'm sorry,
00:14:29.500 it's depressing.
00:14:31.500 We're not going to be selling many books on the back of that.
00:14:35.960 I mean,
00:14:36.100 it was incredibly difficult to write.
00:14:42.620 One,
00:14:43.240 because it incorporates a history of persecution against Jewish people during the 1930s,
00:14:50.720 particularly,
00:14:51.400 and then into the extermination camps.
00:14:54.040 But as you rightly say,
00:14:57.480 those histories are only presented when they're relevant to the actions,
00:15:05.160 the writings,
00:15:06.500 the behavior of rock stars that we love.
00:15:11.420 And David Bowie is certainly an artist that I've loved throughout my life.
00:15:16.220 I've practically got all of his records.
00:15:18.860 And,
00:15:19.780 but,
00:15:22.060 you know,
00:15:23.240 going back,
00:15:24.260 you know,
00:15:24.520 even to Hunky Dory,
00:15:25.700 there's so many references on,
00:15:27.160 on that record to the,
00:15:29.860 the coming of the,
00:15:31.540 the coming race and the homo superior and himless sacred realm.
00:15:36.420 And Bowie was making comments from the late sixties all the way through into the eighties to reference his fascination with the third right with Nazism.
00:15:50.680 And that went very deep for him.
00:15:53.460 And,
00:15:54.040 you know,
00:15:55.720 the,
00:15:55.920 the,
00:15:56.360 the thing that I've come across most,
00:15:58.180 I think is people want to think the best of our heroes.
00:16:02.920 I want to think the best of my heroes,
00:16:04.640 but we mustn't excuse them.
00:16:07.260 And we mustn't put words into their mouths.
00:16:12.320 And the one thing that I didn't do when I wrote this book was to make any form of assumption.
00:16:18.400 So the assumption that David Bowie was on cocaine and didn't really know what he was saying or doing was really fascinating to look into.
00:16:26.960 Because if we,
00:16:27.800 if we,
00:16:28.540 for example,
00:16:30.020 which was to accept that he was on cocaine and not,
00:16:33.200 not in control of his faculties and therefore why he might be making comments about Adolf Hitler being the first rock and roll superstar or the,
00:16:40.920 the coming of a new Hitler for Britain,
00:16:43.080 et cetera.
00:16:43.940 Then we must also disregard virtually every record he made in this period because he didn't have control of what he was writing,
00:16:51.520 recording,
00:16:52.240 how he was dressing,
00:16:53.280 how he was presenting himself live,
00:16:55.740 you know,
00:16:56.140 and what,
00:16:57.280 what is the truth of the matter is he was,
00:17:00.300 had a huge Nazi memorabilia collection.
00:17:02.380 He was researching into a film about Goebbels.
00:17:06.460 He owned Goebbels desk.
00:17:08.600 Can you imagine what was signed at that desk?
00:17:12.660 And it was a deep flirtation or that infiltrated every part of his creative output.
00:17:23.420 He,
00:17:24.020 when he was called out for various moments,
00:17:30.140 moments,
00:17:30.580 whether it was apparently Zeig Heilig at Victoria station in London or,
00:17:35.080 or having a,
00:17:36.960 his collection being found by the Russian police KGB.
00:17:42.480 he apologized or tried to make sense of it and particularly did so into the nineties.
00:17:49.720 He was still talking about it at length.
00:17:51.660 He always talked about the,
00:17:53.900 his fascination with the Holy Grail and,
00:17:59.800 you know,
00:18:00.260 you know,
00:18:01.440 like a,
00:18:02.080 like a Marty Python sketch,
00:18:03.920 the idea that did the,
00:18:05.720 did the Nazis come to the Glastonbury tour and was the,
00:18:08.720 the,
00:18:09.120 the,
00:18:09.420 the,
00:18:09.860 could you trace the area and race back to Atlantis or these kinds of ideas that the SS and Himmler were exploring and he was looking into too.
00:18:19.720 But he never really talked again to my knowledge about his fascination with Goebbels and those kinds of elements.
00:18:27.240 So yeah,
00:18:28.040 lots of things like that.
00:18:29.320 Bowie was a big one.
00:18:31.320 No,
00:18:31.800 he was indeed.
00:18:33.120 The,
00:18:33.400 the one thing you use the word flirtation and that was the excuse given to you.
00:18:40.840 You,
00:18:41.140 you tried valiantly to get people to speak to.
00:18:44.120 And of course,
00:18:44.620 a lot of them disappeared behind their public relations people.
00:18:49.060 But,
00:18:49.240 you know,
00:18:50.520 many of them would say to you or to other writers,
00:18:53.780 oh,
00:18:54.060 it's just a flirtation.
00:18:55.280 It's just,
00:18:55.860 we're just trying to shock.
00:18:57.580 Susie,
00:18:58.240 for example,
00:18:58.840 said that often that,
00:19:00.980 you know,
00:19:01.240 it's just to,
00:19:02.200 to upset old people.
00:19:04.680 And,
00:19:05.360 and of course that's,
00:19:06.400 that's bullshit.
00:19:07.600 But,
00:19:08.320 you know,
00:19:08.520 what was your assessment of that excuse?
00:19:11.760 Because you heard that excuse many times in your,
00:19:14.240 your research.
00:19:15.780 Yeah.
00:19:16.500 And,
00:19:16.740 and to the,
00:19:18.340 the,
00:19:18.640 the most typical one coming from Malcolm McLaren,
00:19:21.380 Vivian Westwood,
00:19:22.400 which spawned punk and the swastika.
00:19:25.780 Malcolm McLaren introduced the swastika.
00:19:27.240 Swastika to punk.
00:19:28.980 And the artist like Susie that,
00:19:30.860 that bought into all of that.
00:19:33.100 The,
00:19:33.320 the common excuse was to say that we wanted to demystify.
00:19:38.480 Now,
00:19:39.000 I thought about that.
00:19:40.060 And then I thought,
00:19:41.340 well,
00:19:42.300 demystify implies there was a mystery.
00:19:46.020 So what was the mystery?
00:19:47.620 What is the mystery of the swastika?
00:19:50.100 There is no mystery.
00:19:51.320 It was,
00:19:51.740 it was,
00:19:52.320 it was up front and absolutely clear.
00:19:54.980 So it,
00:19:55.340 it was the,
00:19:56.480 the,
00:19:56.880 the kind of the excuses were vacuous,
00:19:59.400 you know,
00:19:59.660 on one hand,
00:20:00.960 somebody like Susie Sue would be saying that we're fed up of people talking about the war.
00:20:05.560 So we're shoving it back in your face.
00:20:07.160 And at the next,
00:20:08.380 they were released in singles talking about elements of the war,
00:20:12.820 you know,
00:20:13.060 like the single Mittergesen,
00:20:15.180 which was about Hermann Göring.
00:20:18.840 And the,
00:20:19.460 the difference between the,
00:20:20.620 the German nation in the thirties needing iron ore,
00:20:24.140 not butter,
00:20:25.060 which is a very nuanced understanding of a German social history.
00:20:29.460 And yet that was part of the lyric writing of her.
00:20:33.160 She said that we're fed up of the war.
00:20:35.120 And yet they talked about influential films like the Night Porter or Salon Kitty,
00:20:39.960 which were about the war,
00:20:41.680 you know,
00:20:41.960 and about a brothel in,
00:20:43.760 in Berlin that high ranking officials used to use and was manned by Heydrich and his cronies,
00:20:51.300 you know,
00:20:52.240 such things like this and their own obsession in their own,
00:20:56.120 in their own,
00:20:57.240 in the,
00:20:58.640 in the creative areas that they liked,
00:21:00.620 but at the same time saying that they didn't like British television showing endless comedies or war films.
00:21:07.860 It was everything as contradiction,
00:21:09.760 you know.
00:21:10.540 And that contradiction,
00:21:11.900 it's not just a uniquely British,
00:21:15.160 as you point out in the book,
00:21:16.960 it was a problem on this side of the pond as well with Kiss and like Patty Smith,
00:21:23.900 what you found about Patty Smith was so disappointing.
00:21:27.240 And artists like that,
00:21:30.620 and including artists like the Ramones,
00:21:32.900 half the band was Jewish and they were just idiotic about some of these issues.
00:21:37.620 What about the ones who would say to you,
00:21:40.120 oh,
00:21:40.300 well,
00:21:40.520 you know,
00:21:40.740 I've got,
00:21:41.160 we've got a black member or we've got a Jewish manager like Danny Fields or what have you.
00:21:46.480 What about that excuse that they're using?
00:21:48.780 Some of,
00:21:49.100 you know,
00:21:49.320 some of my best friends are Jews.
00:21:50.860 How many of them did you find would attempt to use that,
00:21:55.940 that ridiculous excuse?
00:21:58.380 Well,
00:21:58.660 Lemmy,
00:21:59.120 Lemmy,
00:21:59.640 who again was another person with a huge Nazi memorabilia collection that he openly flaunted.
00:22:06.120 As,
00:22:06.240 as you'll know,
00:22:07.520 or listeners will know when he invited cameras into his LA house for his documentary,
00:22:11.760 he happily showed them all of his collection,
00:22:15.740 which was vast swastika flags on the wall and all kinds of military paraphernalia dressed up in his SS uniform and went off in a German 1930s tank.
00:22:28.060 You know,
00:22:30.400 and he would say,
00:22:31.480 well,
00:22:31.620 I had a black girlfriend,
00:22:33.140 you know,
00:22:33.480 and then say,
00:22:34.440 well,
00:22:34.560 how impressed would the Führer be with that?
00:22:37.180 You know,
00:22:37.460 there was never,
00:22:38.240 he never really offered excuses or justification or explained why he did all of this stuff.
00:22:44.520 But the,
00:22:44.840 the,
00:22:45.140 the,
00:22:45.940 I mean,
00:22:46.340 strangely enough,
00:22:47.940 and this echoes what was happening in Britain in the late seventies and early eighties,
00:22:52.140 Nazism in,
00:22:53.580 in its purest form was not directed at black people.
00:22:56.560 It was directed primarily at Jewish people and,
00:23:00.920 and then Roma and Sinti,
00:23:03.340 gay people,
00:23:05.300 Polish people,
00:23:07.180 Slavs.
00:23:08.520 There were so few German people.
00:23:11.240 They,
00:23:11.480 they are talked about,
00:23:13.280 I mean,
00:23:13.600 black people,
00:23:14.200 they're talked about by Hitler and Mein Kampf,
00:23:16.180 but it's a very,
00:23:17.240 very minor aspect of the,
00:23:20.420 the killing regime that was the Third Reich.
00:23:24.940 The,
00:23:25.160 so,
00:23:27.240 you know,
00:23:28.480 it's a strange thing.
00:23:30.080 Mostly,
00:23:30.640 I think about when Jewish people in rock and roll history have used the swastika,
00:23:36.540 as you say,
00:23:37.240 the Ramones and having a Jewish manager and many,
00:23:40.560 and,
00:23:40.820 and,
00:23:41.120 and Patsy Smith who became,
00:23:43.340 I think you say a philomite is it,
00:23:47.240 is that how you pronounce it when somebody who becomes obsessional about Judaism,
00:23:50.960 when in,
00:23:52.520 in earlier accounts,
00:23:54.400 she was allegedly anti-Semitic in,
00:23:58.380 in,
00:23:58.560 in a lot of the vocabulary she used in the early seventies.
00:24:02.520 It's a complex character for sure.
00:24:07.420 But yeah,
00:24:07.960 I don't know.
00:24:08.440 Malcolm McLaren was Jewish and,
00:24:10.520 and,
00:24:11.520 and grew up and was bar mitzvah and grew up in a community in North London amongst Jewish people.
00:24:16.520 And yet,
00:24:17.320 as I say,
00:24:17.860 was the person that introduced the swastika to punk at the same time,
00:24:21.260 the manager of the clash,
00:24:22.360 Bernie Rhodes,
00:24:23.740 whose,
00:24:24.040 uh,
00:24:25.080 uh,
00:24:25.380 grandparents who were survivors and also victims of the Holocaust.
00:24:28.580 He stood against Malcolm McLaren and they,
00:24:33.480 and that early co-management of the sex pistols broke up over the use of the swastika.
00:24:40.740 It's,
00:24:41.440 um,
00:24:42.140 it's very hard to kind of reconcile or understand why that happens.
00:24:46.740 One of the things that,
00:24:48.480 um,
00:24:49.260 you decry in the book,
00:24:50.580 and I certainly share the sentiment is so few writers and journalists and commentators,
00:24:57.760 called any of these stars,
00:25:00.320 these rock stars to account.
00:25:02.720 Hey,
00:25:02.820 like,
00:25:03.000 cause all of this stuff was happening in plain view.
00:25:05.940 I mean,
00:25:06.640 Susie was wearing swastika armbands from the very start.
00:25:10.240 They weren't hiding it,
00:25:11.800 but nobody called them out on it.
00:25:13.920 Why is that?
00:25:16.700 Why is that?
00:25:17.820 I don't know.
00:25:18.460 I mean,
00:25:18.620 that's the,
00:25:19.640 one of the major themes of the book and the book is not only about us as fans,
00:25:26.080 the artists,
00:25:26.880 the record industry at whole,
00:25:29.680 uh,
00:25:30.160 large,
00:25:30.740 the managers,
00:25:31.860 the agents,
00:25:32.900 the art,
00:25:34.240 the art,
00:25:34.920 people in the art department.
00:25:36.700 It's calling to account.
00:25:39.000 All of us has been culpable,
00:25:40.820 uh,
00:25:41.580 and allowing this to happen.
00:25:43.180 And nobody operates in a silo in the music industry.
00:25:47.400 And you do,
00:25:48.780 there are incidents where journalists or,
00:25:52.800 uh,
00:25:53.240 um,
00:25:54.120 explain or,
00:25:55.280 or do account or call out,
00:25:58.500 but it never lasts for more than a day or two,
00:26:01.100 or,
00:26:01.720 and more often than not,
00:26:03.700 there is no accountability.
00:26:06.120 And that's,
00:26:07.000 what's frightening really.
00:26:08.860 And we still up to the present day,
00:26:11.240 kind of,
00:26:11.980 um,
00:26:12.340 reproduce images related to the Holocaust,
00:26:16.180 related to the third,
00:26:17.200 right,
00:26:17.540 relate,
00:26:17.960 uh,
00:26:18.200 directly to the swastika artists with no explanation.
00:26:20.500 And we would not now do that.
00:26:23.720 I argue in the book with,
00:26:26.080 uh,
00:26:27.080 racism,
00:26:27.660 according to the color of somebody's skin or misogyny since the death of George Floyd,
00:26:34.000 since the me too movement,
00:26:35.520 the,
00:26:36.540 it's a lot harder now to,
00:26:39.080 to say,
00:26:40.360 for example,
00:26:40.920 if we,
00:26:41.780 if we took away the swastika and replaced it with an image of a lynching of a black person and a South say,
00:26:48.040 that would not go untalked about leave.
00:26:51.960 And you get into the whole area of people being canceled.
00:26:54.480 If there was images of a woman being raped or attacked by a man,
00:26:58.600 these are things that are not acceptable anymore in rock and roll.
00:27:02.640 They still happen,
00:27:04.200 but they are,
00:27:05.840 there is a huge spotlight on it.
00:27:08.820 And yet only,
00:27:10.580 um,
00:27:12.420 within the month,
00:27:14.200 Primal Screen played a gig in London,
00:27:16.980 which caused a huge furore for a couple of days because they,
00:27:22.220 at the roundhouse in,
00:27:23.460 in North London,
00:27:24.380 they screened a swastika,
00:27:27.800 uh,
00:27:28.700 integrated into the star of David.
00:27:31.540 And,
00:27:32.260 uh,
00:27:32.480 and it made national news across,
00:27:35.040 uh,
00:27:36.120 broadsheets and tabloids.
00:27:37.740 And I think beyond the UK.
00:27:39.860 I did.
00:27:40.340 I am.
00:27:40.940 No,
00:27:41.100 it was beyond.
00:27:42.020 Yeah.
00:27:42.760 And,
00:27:43.240 uh,
00:27:43.480 but that it soon,
00:27:46.080 I,
00:27:47.100 that last,
00:27:47.580 as I say,
00:27:48.100 last a couple of days and it seems to have disappeared again.
00:27:50.740 And the,
00:27:51.680 I know,
00:27:52.020 I know that one concert of Primal Screen scheduled for next,
00:27:55.380 this autumn coming has been canceled,
00:27:57.240 but it'd be really interesting to see how that now plays out.
00:28:01.640 And only a few weeks before that,
00:28:03.500 you had Albanese,
00:28:04.360 the Australian prime minister,
00:28:06.840 stepping out,
00:28:08.400 out of a plane,
00:28:09.380 wearing a joy division t-shirt.
00:28:11.380 And he was challenged by the leader of the opposition to say,
00:28:15.220 you know,
00:28:16.440 what is the meaning of joy division?
00:28:18.760 You know,
00:28:19.060 the origin of the name.
00:28:20.460 And he denied not knowing,
00:28:22.280 knowing what it was only for it to be discovered.
00:28:24.900 He talked about it several years earlier and no,
00:28:28.120 and he,
00:28:28.640 he knew it was a brothel in Auschwitz.
00:28:32.020 And again,
00:28:33.560 you've got a certain amount of publicity because of 24 hour news.
00:28:39.940 And then it just fades away again.
00:28:41.900 And,
00:28:42.000 you know,
00:28:42.780 that I think that incident is,
00:28:45.240 is,
00:28:45.580 is very compelling when we know what then subsequently happened on Bondi
00:28:51.900 beach and the accusations of last large sways of the Jewish community to
00:28:58.400 warnings of antisemitism in their country.
00:29:01.260 And they,
00:29:01.860 the demand of their government to step up and increase measures to prevent any
00:29:10.900 atrocities.
00:29:12.140 And then lo and behold,
00:29:13.120 there's one of the great atrocities the country's ever experienced.
00:29:16.640 Mm-hmm.
00:29:17.900 The,
00:29:18.300 one of the,
00:29:20.120 the,
00:29:20.720 I guess,
00:29:22.000 to step into the psychology of all of this,
00:29:24.940 because I,
00:29:25.780 you know,
00:29:26.080 you're,
00:29:26.580 you're a musician.
00:29:27.680 I've been a musician.
00:29:28.400 I've been a musician.
00:29:29.800 And,
00:29:30.400 you know,
00:29:30.600 people in music who may be terrific musicians,
00:29:34.980 but don't,
00:29:35.620 don't have the greatest grasp of public affairs.
00:29:38.620 But they,
00:29:39.680 you know,
00:29:40.120 the excuse that you see in the book and that you hear periodically is,
00:29:45.620 and actually I've heard this from Jewish survivors of the Holocaust.
00:29:49.540 They will say,
00:29:50.620 you know,
00:29:51.180 with the passage of time,
00:29:53.140 it becomes harder for people to realize the reality of it.
00:29:58.420 I mean,
00:29:58.740 is that a,
00:29:59.400 is that a legitimate excuse playing devil's advocate for rock and rollers that,
00:30:04.660 oh,
00:30:04.700 it's a long time ago.
00:30:05.740 And I didn't know that.
00:30:06.920 Can they get away with that kind of claim?
00:30:10.320 I think that the knowledge of the atrocities of the third Reich and the death camps,
00:30:17.140 particularly extermination camps was not common knowledge or up to a certain point in rock and roll history.
00:30:30.640 And we can loosely put that to maybe the late seventies,
00:30:35.960 you know,
00:30:36.140 until the,
00:30:37.480 the NBC and NBC drama Holocaust starring Meryl Streep that had a profound influence,
00:30:44.160 I would say on not only the American public,
00:30:47.940 but then when subsequently,
00:30:49.420 when the series came to the UK and to Germany was seen by millions and millions of people.
00:30:55.320 And thereafter,
00:30:56.660 there was a greater momentum and knowledge.
00:30:59.880 And this is kind of backed up by incredible statistics that I learned that it was not until 1991 in the UK that the Holocaust was taught on,
00:31:16.980 on the school syllabus.
00:31:20.320 It was still not across the UK was not in Wales Island or Scotland,
00:31:25.660 but England,
00:31:26.440 it took 40 over 40 years since the Nuremberg trials,
00:31:32.160 since the trial,
00:31:32.880 the Adolf Eichmann trial,
00:31:34.500 the full knowledge of the why,
00:31:37.700 how,
00:31:38.300 why 6 million people were murdered under the Nazi regime and all the other minorities,
00:31:43.980 not until 91.
00:31:44.980 And then we also get into another extraordinary statistic,
00:31:49.680 which is Holocaust Remembrance Day was not introduced into the UK and into the,
00:31:57.320 into the States until the early 2000s.
00:32:00.980 And to my knowledge now,
00:32:03.600 to my knowledge,
00:32:04.480 less than half of the States in the U S teach the Holocaust.
00:32:09.840 Now that explains a lot to me when you get musicians who are using the symbols,
00:32:18.440 like say,
00:32:19.940 for example,
00:32:20.340 the dead boys did turning up a studio with Genia Ravan,
00:32:24.480 who,
00:32:24.820 you know,
00:32:25.280 who's going to produce their record.
00:32:26.520 And she refused to do it because there was a swastika on their,
00:32:30.000 their flight cases.
00:32:31.460 And when she called them out,
00:32:32.860 they said,
00:32:33.300 well,
00:32:33.580 it's just the sign.
00:32:34.400 What we don't know what you're talking about.
00:32:36.320 And she had to educate them.
00:32:37.560 And then when you learn that,
00:32:39.340 well,
00:32:39.760 that probably came from a state,
00:32:41.220 I don't know if Cleveland's one of those,
00:32:42.780 but a state where they don't teach it,
00:32:44.540 it's kind of extraordinary.
00:32:47.100 Why,
00:32:47.420 why is it not being taught mandatory to every single child that goes through an
00:32:54.420 educational system in any country in the world?
00:32:57.500 This is,
00:32:58.180 you know,
00:32:59.100 so,
00:32:59.360 so yes,
00:33:00.000 that's how I make sense to a great degree of why many musicians don't even
00:33:05.500 know what they're playing with.
00:33:08.420 That leads me to my next and final question.
00:33:12.220 You've kind of answered it already.
00:33:13.980 What,
00:33:14.280 what is the solution?
00:33:16.440 You know,
00:33:16.620 how do we,
00:33:17.780 because,
00:33:18.360 you know,
00:33:18.820 young people for good or for ill,
00:33:21.660 you know,
00:33:22.820 the,
00:33:23.140 the posters they have on their walls are not of Keir Starmer or Mark Carney or
00:33:27.980 what have you,
00:33:28.720 you know,
00:33:29.640 it's these bands,
00:33:31.020 well,
00:33:31.240 like in behind me here,
00:33:32.740 you know,
00:33:32.980 all the bands that I loved when I was growing up.
00:33:35.820 And how do you educate the musicians to educate the millions and millions of
00:33:44.160 people who follow them and listen to their every word and their every utterance?
00:33:49.120 How do you educate them apart from getting them to read your excellent book?
00:33:54.500 How do you change this problem?
00:33:57.440 Well,
00:33:57.600 I certainly wouldn't want to educate anybody.
00:34:00.340 I mean,
00:34:00.560 I'm sitting here talking to you and I can see a Joy Division poster behind you.
00:34:04.320 Yeah.
00:34:04.860 Yeah.
00:34:05.020 You're advertising a brothel in Auschwitz,
00:34:07.880 you know,
00:34:08.360 where there was legalized rape by the sanction by the state.
00:34:12.880 It's not,
00:34:13.400 it,
00:34:13.620 you know,
00:34:14.000 it's about saying that rock and roll's made mistakes.
00:34:20.180 We have to acknowledge what our history is.
00:34:22.980 And that acknowledgement hasn't even happened.
00:34:25.980 You know,
00:34:26.320 as I say,
00:34:27.040 we've reconciled or rock and roll is reconciling itself with racism and misogyny,
00:34:33.600 but not with the tropes of narcissism.
00:34:36.540 So that's the first point.
00:34:39.240 And I think if that was to be widely acknowledged,
00:34:43.440 then we go into a new era,
00:34:46.520 you know,
00:34:46.980 of how we contextualize the use of names and images,
00:34:55.220 which is not happening at the moment.
00:34:58.180 I'm certainly not advocating for the burning of records.
00:35:02.100 You know,
00:35:02.840 we know where that leads to books,
00:35:05.760 burning records,
00:35:06.560 but it's just when you,
00:35:08.860 as the one thing that's really come to light since the publication of this
00:35:12.640 ain't rock and roll in the UK,
00:35:13.900 just a couple of months before it comes out in the States is people saying,
00:35:19.100 I didn't realize how far reaching this was when you compile it all together.
00:35:25.920 And I think that's hopefully what the power of the book is to say,
00:35:30.460 when you do contextualize it and put everything together and you see a pattern emerging as you do,
00:35:37.800 then this is,
00:35:38.980 it's a short step to say,
00:35:41.020 this is too much,
00:35:42.680 you know,
00:35:43.020 and we've,
00:35:43.960 we've,
00:35:44.380 we hadn't recognized,
00:35:46.540 seen that and noticed the extent to which it's at.
00:35:50.000 Now we can do something about it.
00:35:52.120 And that's not a responsibility of,
00:35:55.680 of any single person.
00:35:58.040 It's collectively all of us who belong to rock and roll.
00:36:01.380 And as I say,
00:36:02.420 that is fans,
00:36:03.600 musicians,
00:36:04.840 labels,
00:36:05.620 managers.
00:36:06.780 It's a huge,
00:36:07.380 it's a huge family.
00:36:09.800 And we all,
00:36:10.760 we are all culpable and are all responsible for leading us into a more positive direction.
00:36:17.760 And that's why you get within the book.
00:36:19.860 I know you said at the beginning,
00:36:21.300 it's a depressing read,
00:36:22.600 but there are a couple of chapters of a lot of positivity in there by many,
00:36:27.180 many artists who have talked in brilliant ways.
00:36:30.760 from the,
00:36:32.700 about,
00:36:33.200 about these issues from the Indigo Girls to Frank,
00:36:36.400 to Leonard Cohen,
00:36:37.720 to Bob Dylan,
00:36:38.640 to Paul Weller.
00:36:39.740 There's many,
00:36:40.240 many people.
00:36:40.740 with doubtless life,
00:37:00.060 the prior void,
00:37:01.900 neath every flower a serpent coiled,
00:37:03.740 and every sweetness of things spoiled,
00:37:06.740 as tethered as a shadow.
00:37:10.740 The single breath that sets us all,
00:37:12.740 a course from where we can't recall.
00:37:16.740 With each succeeding rise and fall,
00:37:18.740 we share it deep and shallow.
00:37:22.740 It's true that I'm you,
00:37:25.660 and we're always becoming new.
00:37:28.520 I just know,
00:37:30.440 I'm an auto-boy.
00:37:34.240 We still reflect,
00:37:37.680 in the salience that we connect,
00:37:40.460 and pursue.
00:37:41.100 It's true that I'm you,
00:37:44.480 I'm you,
00:37:47.420 I'm you,
00:37:50.480 you.
00:37:52.680 Let not our image catalyze,
00:38:07.740 the individual disguise,
00:38:10.980 in which your nothingness denies,
00:38:13.880 the likeness of our frame.
00:38:16.000 I am you,
00:38:18.180 and you are me,
00:38:19.780 we co-pronounce reality,
00:38:23.000 but without you,
00:38:24.340 what would I be,
00:38:26.100 but love that has no aim.
00:38:29.040 It's true,
00:38:30.200 that I'm you,
00:38:32.040 and we're always becoming new.
00:38:34.800 I just know it,
00:38:36.880 I'm an auto-boy.
00:38:40.600 We still reflect,
00:38:43.440 in the salience that we connect,
00:38:46.920 and pursue.
00:38:48.460 It's true,
00:38:49.700 that I'm you.
00:39:01.440 I'm you.
00:39:02.440 It's true,
00:39:27.160 that I'm you,
00:39:28.840 and we're always becoming new.
00:39:31.260 I just know it,
00:39:33.620 I'm an auto-boy.
00:39:37.560 We still reflect,
00:39:40.840 in the salience that we connect,
00:39:43.940 it's true,
00:39:45.620 I'm you.
00:39:53.940 Ryan Lilly,
00:39:55.340 working so-called,
00:39:56.420 how are you?
00:39:57.400 I'm well,
00:39:58.180 how are you?
00:39:58.640 Good,
00:40:00.380 I'm up at the cabin,
00:40:01.740 surrounded by snow,
00:40:03.240 and labs,
00:40:04.420 and it's pretty awesome,
00:40:05.960 but I'm watching the world,
00:40:07.320 with a jaundiced eye,
00:40:09.300 and I just thought,
00:40:10.920 we would do a lot of,
00:40:11.900 international chit-chat,
00:40:13.280 but start very quickly,
00:40:14.500 with one domestic story,
00:40:15.940 which is,
00:40:16.840 Pierre Polyev's fate,
00:40:18.420 iPolitics got a story,
00:40:19.820 saying he's easily,
00:40:21.160 quote unquote,
00:40:21.640 going to pass the review,
00:40:22.840 that is taking place,
00:40:24.280 this month,
00:40:25.160 in Calgary,
00:40:26.340 but that he's not,
00:40:27.400 out of the woods yet,
00:40:28.280 and that he can't make any,
00:40:30.320 errors,
00:40:32.860 in the way that,
00:40:33.800 they believe that he has,
00:40:35.780 and wanted to get your take on that.
00:40:38.340 That's what I've been saying,
00:40:39.540 for quite a while,
00:40:40.260 is that he's,
00:40:41.300 going to pass,
00:40:42.200 you and I both believe,
00:40:44.240 you'll get between 70,
00:40:45.300 and 80% I believe.
00:40:46.520 Correct.
00:40:47.160 What I find weird,
00:40:48.500 is that on TV,
00:40:49.380 and elsewhere,
00:40:49.860 I keep hearing,
00:40:50.460 oh he's going to get over 80%,
00:40:51.940 I'm thinking,
00:40:52.600 are these guys setting up,
00:40:53.640 for failure,
00:40:54.280 so that when he gets 73,
00:40:55.560 or 74,
00:40:56.380 they say,
00:40:57.100 see,
00:40:57.840 he failed,
00:40:58.700 he needs to resign.
00:41:01.180 I don't think,
00:41:02.060 he's going to get over 80,
00:41:03.660 easily I think,
00:41:04.500 between 70 and 80,
00:41:05.740 but wow,
00:41:06.600 this over 80 stuff,
00:41:07.620 I don't understand,
00:41:09.820 and look,
00:41:12.000 as I wrote a while ago,
00:41:13.660 when he passes the review,
00:41:15.820 he's very popular,
00:41:16.960 with the base,
00:41:18.020 he's still on notice,
00:41:19.160 by the caucus,
00:41:20.020 because they passed,
00:41:21.280 the reform act,
00:41:22.240 the conservatives agreed,
00:41:23.840 that they would,
00:41:24.580 follow the rules,
00:41:25.360 of the reform act,
00:41:26.200 no other party does that,
00:41:28.100 that allows the caucus,
00:41:29.340 to kick him out,
00:41:30.860 with a secret vote,
00:41:32.540 in the caucus,
00:41:33.240 so he's,
00:41:34.140 basically on,
00:41:36.140 he's going to be living,
00:41:37.340 like a broadcaster,
00:41:38.560 and,
00:41:39.380 what do I mean by that,
00:41:41.360 in broadcasting,
00:41:42.840 such as it still exists,
00:41:44.760 you're only as good,
00:41:45.540 as your last show,
00:41:46.620 and,
00:41:47.720 you can be fired,
00:41:48.620 at any moment,
00:41:49.880 so he's on,
00:41:51.380 permanent,
00:41:52.460 constant review,
00:41:53.420 by the caucus,
00:41:54.520 is there anybody,
00:41:55.820 organizing,
00:41:56.780 in the caucus,
00:41:57.520 against him,
00:41:57.940 at this point,
00:41:58.480 no,
00:41:59.220 but,
00:42:00.080 that's kind of the state,
00:42:01.120 he's going to be in,
00:42:01.960 and so he's,
00:42:03.060 he's going to make sure,
00:42:03.700 he's not screwing up,
00:42:04.800 he's got to make sure,
00:42:05.480 the fundraising is still good,
00:42:07.020 he's got to,
00:42:08.220 you know,
00:42:08.960 improve his caucus management,
00:42:10.300 which I'm told,
00:42:11.720 he's doing,
00:42:12.540 with regular breakfasts,
00:42:13.920 and lunch,
00:42:14.440 over at Stornoway,
00:42:15.520 where he invites a few of them over,
00:42:17.360 talks to them,
00:42:18.240 hears them out,
00:42:19.780 as opposed to,
00:42:21.060 previously,
00:42:22.120 where his,
00:42:22.800 his saying in caucus is,
00:42:24.960 you can have your say,
00:42:26.420 but you won't have your sway.
00:42:28.800 Ouch.
00:42:30.360 Well,
00:42:30.980 somebody who,
00:42:32.140 has got some sway,
00:42:33.540 at the moment,
00:42:34.020 as measured by the polling,
00:42:35.280 is Mark Carney,
00:42:36.500 the prime minister,
00:42:37.220 who is now,
00:42:39.280 about to become,
00:42:40.340 the first Canadian prime minister,
00:42:42.160 in nearly a decade,
00:42:43.780 to meet with the leadership,
00:42:45.580 in China,
00:42:47.160 and a lot of people,
00:42:49.000 I guess me included,
00:42:50.420 are concerned about that,
00:42:53.080 you know,
00:42:53.540 interfering with our elections,
00:42:54.940 in 2019,
00:42:55.960 and 2021,
00:42:57.580 setting up,
00:42:58.560 secret police,
00:43:00.240 stations,
00:43:01.000 across Canada,
00:43:02.800 subjecting Canadian,
00:43:04.100 Chinese Canadian citizens,
00:43:05.140 to surveillance,
00:43:06.940 and of course,
00:43:07.860 kidnapping,
00:43:08.980 illegally,
00:43:09.600 two of our citizens,
00:43:11.340 and holding them,
00:43:12.860 illegally,
00:43:14.080 is Mark Carney,
00:43:15.980 moving too soon,
00:43:17.120 on this overture,
00:43:18.420 to China,
00:43:19.020 should he have waited?
00:43:20.500 Why are you such a right winger?
00:43:22.080 Just embrace China,
00:43:23.280 love China,
00:43:24.700 just,
00:43:25.400 you know,
00:43:25.680 let China do whatever they want,
00:43:27.340 they're wonderful,
00:43:28.720 it's,
00:43:30.320 look,
00:43:30.660 I haven't had a prime minister,
00:43:31.900 that hasn't disappointed me,
00:43:32.920 on China in a long time,
00:43:34.000 Stephen Harper came in,
00:43:35.140 and was very much,
00:43:37.160 you know,
00:43:38.080 going to take a different view,
00:43:39.180 on China,
00:43:40.600 was going to stand up,
00:43:41.940 to their harassment,
00:43:42.980 at that point,
00:43:43.560 they had a guy,
00:43:45.200 who I still don't think,
00:43:46.240 has ever been released,
00:43:47.580 a Uyghur,
00:43:48.400 named,
00:43:48.940 Silil,
00:43:51.100 and,
00:43:51.960 he pushed back,
00:43:53.400 against China,
00:43:54.200 and the business community,
00:43:55.420 just,
00:43:56.440 you know,
00:43:56.920 were on him,
00:43:58.780 like you wouldn't believe,
00:44:00.200 because they just want,
00:44:01.420 access to China,
00:44:02.300 that's,
00:44:02.780 the eastern Canadian establishment,
00:44:05.000 especially in Montreal,
00:44:06.820 is enamored with China,
00:44:08.480 so,
00:44:09.480 he's doing what the business community wants,
00:44:12.300 we need to,
00:44:14.960 you know,
00:44:15.380 find better markets,
00:44:16.840 for our product,
00:44:18.740 I don't know what he's going to do,
00:44:19.860 on canola,
00:44:20.600 and EVs,
00:44:21.540 you know,
00:44:21.900 I'm really worried,
00:44:22.720 that he'll do something stupid,
00:44:23.700 on EVs,
00:44:24.380 they are a massive threat,
00:44:25.740 to our auto industry,
00:44:27.140 they are spying machines,
00:44:30.020 that's,
00:44:30.400 that's not craziness,
00:44:32.300 you know,
00:44:32.580 we're all worried,
00:44:33.180 about the,
00:44:33.760 the Americans,
00:44:35.060 having a kill switch,
00:44:35.900 on the F35,
00:44:37.260 imagine if your whole,
00:44:38.460 auto fleet,
00:44:39.120 is Chinese EVs,
00:44:40.400 and they can literally,
00:44:41.420 shut them down,
00:44:42.640 by pushing a button,
00:44:45.680 so,
00:44:47.220 I,
00:44:47.520 I,
00:44:47.820 I've got a lot of concerns,
00:44:49.300 about what he's going to do,
00:44:50.280 so he should tread carefully,
00:44:52.200 we have to deal with them,
00:44:53.300 but we shouldn't be,
00:44:54.380 cozy with them,
00:44:56.300 unfortunately,
00:44:57.140 you and I are,
00:44:58.140 in the minority on that,
00:44:59.400 we sure are,
00:45:00.240 including my,
00:45:01.280 former boss,
00:45:03.320 Jean Cretzio,
00:45:04.040 who's celebrating,
00:45:04.620 his 92nd birthday today,
00:45:06.080 happy birthday,
00:45:06.740 Prime Minister Cretzio,
00:45:07.800 happy birthday,
00:45:08.920 Mr. Cretzio,
00:45:09.620 I talked to him yesterday,
00:45:11.060 he's always been,
00:45:12.260 favorable to trade,
00:45:14.180 with China,
00:45:15.000 but,
00:45:15.340 I mean,
00:45:16.180 I guess,
00:45:16.540 the Kearney,
00:45:17.900 the Kearney guys,
00:45:18.980 would probably argue,
00:45:19.700 well look,
00:45:20.320 Warren,
00:45:20.800 Brian,
00:45:21.180 we don't have any choice,
00:45:22.900 we've got this Trump threat,
00:45:24.200 you guys gave us a mandate,
00:45:25.920 to,
00:45:26.280 establish better,
00:45:28.140 and more trade,
00:45:28.780 with the rest of the world,
00:45:29.440 that's what we're doing,
00:45:30.520 what about his argument there?
00:45:32.920 All right,
00:45:33.820 sure,
00:45:34.680 but don't be,
00:45:35.280 cozy with them,
00:45:36.860 and,
00:45:37.420 you know,
00:45:38.240 Cretzio is part of that,
00:45:39.560 Quebec,
00:45:40.360 business establishment,
00:45:41.880 that is,
00:45:42.780 you,
00:45:42.960 you won't,
00:45:44.100 until you spend time in it,
00:45:46.640 you,
00:45:46.920 you don't understand,
00:45:47.880 just how enamored,
00:45:48.800 the Quebec business establishment,
00:45:50.700 is with China,
00:45:52.280 it,
00:45:52.600 you don't see it,
00:45:54.140 to the same degree,
00:45:55.340 in Toronto,
00:45:56.700 but in Montreal,
00:45:58.060 it is massive,
00:45:58.980 and that's where,
00:45:59.660 Cretchen comes out of,
00:46:01.180 and,
00:46:02.800 to those who say,
00:46:04.780 yeah,
00:46:04.940 we have to,
00:46:05.700 pivot there,
00:46:07.500 don't pivot too hard,
00:46:08.920 because,
00:46:09.600 they're not going to replace,
00:46:10.600 the US,
00:46:11.440 and,
00:46:12.280 we don't want to,
00:46:13.280 annoy the US,
00:46:14.520 but,
00:46:14.800 you know,
00:46:14.980 we should also be looking,
00:46:15.900 I've been arguing for 20 years,
00:46:17.760 we need to be pivoting to India,
00:46:19.720 and,
00:46:21.100 we're still not doing enough trade,
00:46:22.420 with India,
00:46:23.520 Carney has made some overtures there,
00:46:25.520 he's,
00:46:26.420 fixed some things,
00:46:27.300 that Justin Trudeau broke,
00:46:28.440 that's good,
00:46:29.660 but,
00:46:30.700 India should be our focus,
00:46:31.960 and not China.
00:46:32.720 Well,
00:46:32.920 let's talk about the United States,
00:46:34.500 then,
00:46:34.980 the United States,
00:46:37.080 to my astonishment,
00:46:38.700 I,
00:46:39.140 I still can be surprised,
00:46:40.280 by the Trump administration,
00:46:42.080 is,
00:46:42.900 apparently,
00:46:43.940 apparently,
00:46:44.460 seriously,
00:46:45.140 talking about,
00:46:46.560 some kind of forceful,
00:46:48.800 action on Greenland,
00:46:50.460 which they want to own,
00:46:51.840 quote unquote,
00:46:53.120 somewhere between,
00:46:54.780 military action,
00:46:55.840 or purchasing it outright,
00:46:58.100 like,
00:46:58.400 if there,
00:46:59.200 and,
00:46:59.480 and then there's stories,
00:47:00.540 about the Brits,
00:47:01.460 and the French,
00:47:02.060 starting to move ships,
00:47:03.180 towards Greenland,
00:47:04.440 like,
00:47:04.880 like,
00:47:05.520 if there's military action,
00:47:07.340 I can't believe,
00:47:08.000 I'm having to ask this question,
00:47:09.500 of you,
00:47:10.560 like,
00:47:10.900 does it not signal,
00:47:12.240 the end of NATO,
00:47:13.540 at the very least,
00:47:15.460 okay,
00:47:16.460 pay attention,
00:47:17.140 to Marco Rubio,
00:47:18.340 and don't pay attention,
00:47:19.660 to other people,
00:47:20.520 you know,
00:47:22.040 tell us why,
00:47:22.740 Marco Rubio,
00:47:24.360 is,
00:47:25.040 the smart guy,
00:47:26.240 in the administration,
00:47:27.520 Trump is,
00:47:29.040 no American president,
00:47:30.340 should actually,
00:47:30.840 ever take military action,
00:47:31.980 against any country,
00:47:32.880 off the table,
00:47:34.100 but this all started,
00:47:36.400 this idea,
00:47:36.940 that they're going,
00:47:37.320 to invade Greenland,
00:47:38.680 because Jake Tapper,
00:47:39.800 tried to get,
00:47:40.900 Stephen Miller,
00:47:41.680 to say,
00:47:44.260 that he would,
00:47:45.360 rule out military action,
00:47:47.460 and what he actually said was,
00:47:49.420 no one's going to fight,
00:47:50.600 the United States,
00:47:51.700 militarily,
00:47:52.500 over Greenland,
00:47:53.880 and he's right,
00:47:55.120 they won't,
00:47:56.420 like,
00:47:56.640 who would do that,
00:47:58.100 57,000 people,
00:47:59.660 you've got the,
00:48:00.800 you know,
00:48:01.180 biggest,
00:48:01.680 most sophisticated,
00:48:02.620 most technologically advanced,
00:48:04.060 military,
00:48:04.240 But why is it even,
00:48:05.380 a subject matter,
00:48:06.500 why is it even being discussed,
00:48:07.540 like,
00:48:07.700 this is crazy,
00:48:08.620 isn't it?
00:48:08.940 But they're not,
00:48:09.660 they're not looking,
00:48:10.640 to do that,
00:48:11.720 Marco Rubio,
00:48:12.640 briefed,
00:48:13.800 the,
00:48:14.500 a joint session,
00:48:17.260 of the House,
00:48:18.440 and the Senate,
00:48:19.200 both parties,
00:48:20.700 on what was going on,
00:48:21.900 with Venezuela,
00:48:22.900 people,
00:48:23.340 asked him about Greenland,
00:48:25.360 and he said,
00:48:25.880 no,
00:48:26.040 we're looking,
00:48:26.740 at a purchase option,
00:48:28.320 now you can think,
00:48:29.340 that's crazy too,
00:48:30.940 but,
00:48:31.740 they did purchase,
00:48:32.760 the US Virgin Islands,
00:48:34.240 off of Denmark,
00:48:35.680 in 1917,
00:48:36.580 and the reason,
00:48:38.420 they did that,
00:48:39.360 was for national security,
00:48:41.820 because the,
00:48:43.380 it's the middle,
00:48:44.320 of the first world war,
00:48:46.800 the Germans,
00:48:48.420 are doing a lot,
00:48:49.220 of submarine warfare,
00:48:50.680 in the Atlantic,
00:48:52.600 and the US Virgin Islands,
00:48:54.660 is not that far,
00:48:55.680 off the coast,
00:48:56.340 close enough,
00:48:57.500 that the Americans,
00:48:58.280 were worried,
00:48:59.180 they said,
00:49:00.160 if Germany captures,
00:49:02.040 Denmark,
00:49:03.540 they will take control,
00:49:04.560 of these islands,
00:49:05.560 and then be close,
00:49:06.360 to us,
00:49:07.380 and so,
00:49:08.020 in 1916,
00:49:09.100 they entered,
00:49:09.920 before they entered the war,
00:49:11.840 they entered conversations,
00:49:13.420 under Woodrow Wilson,
00:49:15.000 to buy,
00:49:16.040 those islands,
00:49:17.160 and they bought them,
00:49:17.780 for 25 million dollars,
00:49:19.600 it's the equivalent,
00:49:20.420 at just under 700 million,
00:49:21.780 today,
00:49:22.920 and,
00:49:23.780 that's what they're,
00:49:24.940 looking at doing,
00:49:26.100 Trump has asked,
00:49:27.220 Rubio to update,
00:49:28.440 his proposal,
00:49:29.080 because he's had it before,
00:49:30.620 he wants to buy,
00:49:32.500 Greenland,
00:49:32.960 he doesn't,
00:49:33.520 they're not looking,
00:49:34.540 at doing a military,
00:49:35.760 intervention,
00:49:37.060 and so,
00:49:37.940 well it doesn't,
00:49:38.920 make any sense,
00:49:39.380 you've got,
00:49:40.120 as you and I,
00:49:41.500 have talked about it,
00:49:42.180 they've got US troops,
00:49:43.020 there already,
00:49:43.680 they have an agreement,
00:49:45.060 with the,
00:49:46.200 with Greenland,
00:49:47.040 and the Danes,
00:49:47.880 to have an ongoing,
00:49:49.400 military presence there,
00:49:50.580 I just don't understand,
00:49:51.960 it's craziness,
00:49:52.960 well,
00:49:54.780 if they stick with,
00:49:55.800 buying it,
00:49:56.880 I have no issue,
00:49:58.260 I do not think,
00:49:59.240 that they're,
00:49:59.640 seriously considering,
00:50:01.060 a military intervention,
00:50:02.480 on Greenland,
00:50:03.220 like,
00:50:03.720 what would that entail,
00:50:05.700 they would show up,
00:50:06.600 and say,
00:50:07.120 it's ours,
00:50:08.580 they wouldn't have to,
00:50:10.360 fire a shot,
00:50:10.920 what's Denmark going to do,
00:50:12.980 yeah,
00:50:13.220 no,
00:50:13.480 it's,
00:50:13.880 so,
00:50:14.700 it's not going to happen,
00:50:16.380 they're going to make,
00:50:17.000 an offer,
00:50:18.420 or,
00:50:19.360 you know,
00:50:19.600 my view has always been,
00:50:22.280 that they just want,
00:50:23.100 more control,
00:50:23.920 and,
00:50:24.380 more presence there,
00:50:26.340 even Carney admitted,
00:50:28.120 you know,
00:50:28.380 when Mark Carney,
00:50:29.300 was asked about this,
00:50:30.600 he didn't jump,
00:50:31.580 into the fray,
00:50:32.220 he was smart,
00:50:32.920 he was in Paris,
00:50:34.380 for that,
00:50:35.260 session on Ukraine,
00:50:39.080 and,
00:50:40.020 he was asked about it,
00:50:41.880 and he didn't jump,
00:50:42.880 into the,
00:50:43.600 the deep end of the pool,
00:50:45.340 he,
00:50:45.940 he stayed above the fray,
00:50:47.340 with it,
00:50:48.060 and,
00:50:48.620 he alluded to the fact,
00:50:50.260 that China and Russia,
00:50:51.440 do have ships there,
00:50:52.260 you know,
00:50:52.780 I'm seeing people say,
00:50:53.980 that's not true,
00:50:55.380 it's absolutely true,
00:50:56.620 just like China and Russia,
00:50:57.780 have ships in our Arctic waters,
00:50:59.980 and we have to,
00:51:00.900 take that seriously,
00:51:02.500 and find a way to,
00:51:03.320 to stop that from happening,
00:51:05.140 they also have ships,
00:51:06.520 in the,
00:51:07.620 waters around,
00:51:09.240 Greenland,
00:51:10.760 even,
00:51:11.340 even that,
00:51:12.160 Russian oil vessel,
00:51:13.600 that the American sees this week,
00:51:15.640 was,
00:51:16.800 picked off between,
00:51:17.920 Greenland and Iceland,
00:51:19.380 they,
00:51:19.600 they stocked it for two weeks,
00:51:21.420 one of these ghost ships,
00:51:23.520 and they picked it up there,
00:51:25.320 there,
00:51:25.660 there are security concerns,
00:51:27.240 sure,
00:51:27.700 that's,
00:51:28.400 that's legit,
00:51:29.660 how you handle it,
00:51:31.380 is another matter,
00:51:32.820 so,
00:51:33.200 watch Rubio,
00:51:34.480 don't pay attention,
00:51:35.660 to Stephen Miller,
00:51:37.000 and,
00:51:38.160 you know,
00:51:38.700 Trump,
00:51:39.120 Trump is out there,
00:51:39.860 and he distracts,
00:51:40.880 and then,
00:51:41.760 other people do things,
00:51:42.980 in the background,
00:51:43.860 good advice,
00:51:44.380 good advice,
00:51:45.920 I'm keeping an eye,
00:51:46.520 on the clock here,
00:51:47.720 wanted to ask you,
00:51:49.320 one final question,
00:51:50.580 which is again,
00:51:51.260 about the United States,
00:51:52.680 and what it's going to do,
00:51:53.680 or not do militarily,
00:51:55.560 Iran,
00:51:56.540 so,
00:51:57.060 it looks very much like,
00:51:58.160 I mean,
00:51:58.360 there's an internet blackout,
00:52:00.520 obviously guys like you,
00:52:01.840 and I,
00:52:02.300 are not there,
00:52:03.080 reporting on what's taking place,
00:52:04.460 on the ground,
00:52:04.880 but it looks like,
00:52:06.220 there is this country-eyed,
00:52:07.840 uprising,
00:52:08.620 against this,
00:52:09.200 Islamic dictatorship,
00:52:11.680 that has run,
00:52:13.560 Iran,
00:52:13.900 since 1979,
00:52:15.160 what do you think,
00:52:16.200 is going to happen,
00:52:16.820 what is,
00:52:17.300 what should the world,
00:52:18.060 be doing,
00:52:18.940 to facilitate,
00:52:20.560 the return of democracy,
00:52:21.740 or some kind of democracy,
00:52:23.300 to Iran?
00:52:25.740 Yeah,
00:52:26.340 well,
00:52:26.760 I think that we have to support,
00:52:28.360 those who are actually,
00:52:29.300 in favor of democracy,
00:52:30.420 because revolutions,
00:52:31.260 can go sideways,
00:52:32.140 they did in 1979,
00:52:33.960 nobody expected,
00:52:36.000 to become the,
00:52:37.020 fundamentalist,
00:52:38.260 Islamic republic,
00:52:39.600 that it is now,
00:52:40.380 and go backwards,
00:52:41.240 the way they did,
00:52:41.780 for so many decades,
00:52:43.280 so,
00:52:44.360 you know,
00:52:44.620 if we're going to support people,
00:52:45.900 support those who are actual,
00:52:48.020 actually in favor of democracy,
00:52:49.760 and not those who want,
00:52:51.060 a dictatorship,
00:52:52.120 or a different type,
00:52:52.940 of fundamentalist,
00:52:53.960 theocracy,
00:52:55.380 revolutions,
00:52:56.340 can always go sideways,
00:52:57.880 you want an American revolution,
00:52:59.580 not a French revolution,
00:53:00.520 where everyone gets killed,
00:53:01.920 in retribution,
00:53:03.000 after the fact,
00:53:04.160 and you don't want,
00:53:05.040 a repeat of 1979,
00:53:06.660 so,
00:53:07.400 well said,
00:53:08.620 very little,
00:53:09.460 that we can do,
00:53:10.180 from the outside,
00:53:10.940 but,
00:53:11.800 you know,
00:53:12.160 I know,
00:53:13.100 Elon Musk,
00:53:13.680 is not a popular guy,
00:53:14.760 right now,
00:53:15.960 but the Iranian regime,
00:53:17.100 shut down internet,
00:53:18.040 and cell phone access,
00:53:19.540 he made Starlink free,
00:53:21.300 in Iran,
00:53:22.160 and there,
00:53:22.800 there are folks,
00:53:23.440 on the ground,
00:53:23.920 distributing,
00:53:24.400 Starlink receivers,
00:53:26.820 so that people,
00:53:27.400 can actually communicate,
00:53:28.540 that's a good thing,
00:53:29.300 support democracy.
00:53:30.460 It is,
00:53:30.960 and I give him credit,
00:53:31.980 just to conclude,
00:53:33.060 he's said,
00:53:34.060 that he's going,
00:53:34.520 to be opening,
00:53:35.720 creating,
00:53:36.280 Grok,
00:53:37.140 as open source,
00:53:38.060 so people can see,
00:53:38.900 how that algorithm works,
00:53:40.040 because a lot of people,
00:53:40.700 have been making allegations,
00:53:42.320 about how harmful it is,
00:53:43.760 so much to discuss,
00:53:45.060 this week,
00:53:45.660 but you've covered it,
00:53:48.140 with your usual skill,
00:53:49.780 and precision,
00:53:50.960 and I'm most grateful,
00:53:52.520 so thank you very much,
00:53:53.480 my friend.
00:53:54.440 Thank you.
00:54:04.860 Raindrops bouncing off my heart,
00:54:08.260 everyone's a touch of you,
00:54:11.700 Your picture fades,
00:54:14.880 in the silent night,
00:54:17.140 but I can hear,
00:54:18.620 your voice somehow,
00:54:21.980 the question,
00:54:23.540 in your eyes,
00:54:25.160 slipped through,
00:54:26.280 I still can't shake,
00:54:27.700 this waking dream,
00:54:31.100 I know,
00:54:32.240 it's all pretend,
00:54:34.280 I don't care,
00:54:35.440 I will stay lost,
00:54:36.840 as long as I need,
00:54:39.580 You never said,
00:54:42.300 a word,
00:54:44.500 but I can hear it anyway,
00:54:48.880 What is my life,
00:54:51.480 but an echo,
00:54:53.200 of your dream,
00:54:56.440 Snowflakes melt,
00:55:00.960 the tears on glass,
00:55:02.860 must I remain,
00:55:04.300 this frozen boy,
00:55:06.580 I wish I knew,
00:55:09.560 what to dream,
00:55:11.140 tonight,
00:55:12.020 I try to reach you,
00:55:13.860 through the void,
00:55:17.080 a whisper,
00:55:18.100 in your mind,
00:55:20.080 flash by,
00:55:21.640 it blinds me,
00:55:23.140 when I sleep,
00:55:25.980 I know,
00:55:27.160 your truth,
00:55:28.480 it could be mine,
00:55:30.340 or I'll stay wrong,
00:55:31.720 as long as I need,
00:55:33.560 You never said,
00:55:37.280 a word,
00:55:39.360 but I can hear it anyway,
00:55:43.680 What is my life,
00:55:46.280 but a shadow,
00:55:48.840 of your dream,
00:55:52.400 You saw me lying,
00:55:55.840 I'm undenying,
00:55:59.240 I'm undenying,
00:56:00.380 but I don't wait,
00:56:04.240 to give you hope,
00:56:09.120 Don't wake me,
00:56:14.360 till this time,
00:56:16.340 I'll be free,
00:56:17.960 Don't wake me,
00:56:19.580 to kill me,
00:56:20.200 I'm undenying,
00:56:22.840 I'll be free,
00:56:25.520 itas,
00:56:27.520 I'm undenying,
00:56:28.000 but I don't know,
00:56:29.320 I can't,
00:56:30.660 I don't know,
00:56:31.060 I can't hear it,
00:56:31.420 but I can't hear it,
00:56:31.580 I can't hear it,
00:56:32.080 but I can't hear it,
00:56:32.520 although I need,
00:56:33.100 I can't hear it,
00:56:33.780 you never said,
00:56:34.380 you never said it anyway,
00:56:34.420 I can't hear it,
00:56:34.660 I can't hear it,
00:56:35.640 but I don't know,
00:56:35.980 I can't hear it,
00:56:36.940 I can't hear it,
00:56:38.080 that I'm coming to see you,
00:56:38.260 and you never said it,
00:56:39.080 you never said it,
00:56:39.820 it can't hear it,
00:56:40.700 you never said it,
00:56:41.820 but I love it,
00:56:42.080 I can't hear it,
00:56:43.000 Pain has not said of my heart
00:57:01.800 Everyone's a toucher
00:57:06.000 I don't care if I will say wrong
00:57:11.000 As long as I breathe
00:57:15.000 So, the obvious question, maybe not so obvious, but in the United States, these protests against, on the issue of immigration as well, have resulted now this week in the tragic, in my view, death of a mother who was shot by an ICE officer.
00:57:41.000 And it has resulted in hundreds of protests involving thousands and thousands of people across the United States.
00:57:47.880 You've been warning people on this podcast and elsewhere that Canada seems to be heading in to that sort of direction.
00:57:58.060 Is that still your view? Do you think that we are at risk of that kind of tragic outcome?
00:58:04.460 I do. Unfortunately, I do believe that that is the case.
00:58:10.460 I will say that even if we bring it back to yesterday for a second, even though that was more decisive and dramatic than we've seen, it still doesn't rise to the level of violence that occurs in the US.
00:58:28.080 So, we are a different landscape in Canada. It's not identical.
00:58:32.080 But the underlying factors are all present.
00:58:38.080 And, you know, there's so much that's striking about this situation in the US.
00:58:43.460 So, first and foremost, and I think this is an observation I've made before, people are watching the same video and having completely different takeaways on culpability, on the significance of words uttered, on, you know,
00:59:04.340 to describe a state of mind to the human involved in what would have been an extremely high-pressure situation with snap-second judgments and, you know,
00:59:17.920 the court of public opinion in some ways imitates a court of law where people will pull out evidence and make their arguments,
00:59:27.400 but not always with the context of this, this is happening in the span of a few seconds, right?
00:59:36.880 And there's lead-up to it and there's context that's relevant, but that, you know, everyone is coming away with different takeaways, even though we're looking at the same sources.
00:59:47.140 And part of why I think that something similar could happen in Canada is we have a normalized sense of defiance toward authority, toward law enforcement,
01:00:05.640 where a very high level of flagrant disrespect has been tolerated.
01:00:12.740 And there's also people who are on a steady diet of existential crisis and believing themselves to be actual, literal soldiers on a front line, right?
01:00:28.380 Fighting these big ideological battles.
01:00:31.940 And, you know, that has to do with being heavily online, the information that's consumed online, being in echo chambers.
01:00:40.880 Anger.
01:00:41.460 Anger.
01:00:42.060 It warped anger, absolutely, a diet of fear and anger and, at times, hate, and that warped people's minds.
01:00:53.420 And, you know, that's evident in what played out, but also in the reaction to what has played out and just the lack of, unfortunately, humanity in what I agree with you is a tragic situation, right?
01:01:10.220 There's no real winner.
01:01:10.860 There's no real winners in this, you know, and, yeah, there's no real winners in this.
01:01:19.020 Final question.
01:01:20.060 I mean, you've represented plaintiff, you've represented defendants, you've done criminal practice, and, of course, you're watching all of these things develop more closely than anybody I know in the world.
01:01:33.660 So, you've seen, I presume, you've seen, I presume, some of the video, maybe all of the video coming out of Minneapolis.
01:01:41.260 What was your reaction to it as a lawyer and as a person?
01:01:45.920 So, my thoughts are jumbled on this because there are so many things that come to mind.
01:01:57.240 You know, first, it is irresponsible for activist groups to encourage supporters to take on actions that put them in the line of fire by law enforcement.
01:02:13.160 To assume that law enforcement won't take drastic steps is a disservice to people who maybe are well-intentioned and want to do good.
01:02:26.600 So, all of these Tumblr-style bullet lists of, you know, encouraging obstruction, encouraging de-arrest, that culture needs to be addressed, is my first thought.
01:02:45.540 Because there were clearly orders to get out of the car, and kind of not just an unwillingness to do that, but, you know, you see the car move.
01:02:56.560 And it's impossible to know what was in the, what was in her state, like her state of mind in the moment, right?
01:03:04.320 Do you hit the wrong pedal, right?
01:03:07.400 Like, what's going on?
01:03:09.380 We do know that in the lead-up to this, the vehicle had been blocking the street for at least three minutes.
01:03:16.740 That's not a capital offence, but an officer who perceives themselves to be in line of being mowed down, whether or not that was the actual intent, if it is subjectively and objectively, if that fear is reasonable, I think that a lot of deference will be afforded to that officer.
01:03:42.320 And we're already seeing those signals from the highest levels of authority in the U.S. government that they are standing behind this ICE agent, who apparently had been in a separate, unrelated incident involving a vehicle.
01:04:00.000 And that would have informed his understanding of what's happening, I think.
01:04:04.860 So, ultimately, what's the upshot here?
01:04:10.200 I do think that self-defense will come into play, you know, in justifying or attempting to justify this use of force.
01:04:22.060 And because one of the parties was in uniform, the law, there are so many presumptions that already are in their favor.
01:04:34.640 So, that will be a tough pill to overcome from the side representing the interests of the deceased.
01:04:43.400 But it looked to me like, you know, and again, we're all being Reddit warriors here looking at videotape and it's partial and, you know, it's just a fraction of the evidence.
01:04:56.180 It's the, you know, the fucking bitch after she's been shot and his position vis-a-vis the vehicle and so on.
01:05:07.680 I mean, I agree with you, self-defense is going to come into play, but it doesn't look like it would totally exonerate his actions.
01:05:14.320 Again, I think it will depend on his subjective state of mind and whether that was objectively reasonable in the circumstances.
01:05:27.840 It's one thing for us to have access to multiple angles and to parse it out and to do slow-mo and look, her wheels were actually turning.
01:05:37.320 She wasn't trying to hit him.
01:05:38.640 She was trying to drive away from him, you know, and everything like that.
01:05:43.580 The parties involved would have seen it from one angle in real time and that's it.
01:05:50.840 That's what would have informed everything that that transpired.
01:05:56.820 So, I do think that there is a case there for self-defense.
01:06:02.200 And, you know, in an ideal world, this does actually play out in court.
01:06:08.320 So, all of these theories and arguments can be tested and decided upon by a judge to kind of, it won't lay everything to rest, but at least it will create a proper public record.
01:06:24.380 Well, we will see in the coming months, God knows, we're going to be hearing a lot more about this case and hopefully not others, but I suspect you're right.
01:06:34.300 I think that people are just getting angrier and feeling more and more licensed to have these types of clashes and it's not good for society.
01:06:45.760 It's not good for people.
01:06:46.700 So, but I thank you for keeping an eye on it for us and for giving us your insights.
01:06:54.040 Thanks as always for having me.
01:06:55.460 I've considered suicide by police
01:07:01.640 I do it myself
01:07:04.200 But I'm far too angry
01:07:06.020 And that's the way this thing's gotta be
01:07:08.640 For now
01:07:10.320 And when the time comes you'll know
01:07:15.120 Because you've become a widow
01:07:17.660 Organizing all those things that you disliked about me
01:07:23.060 And I hope peace by peace
01:07:24.760 I didn't find you no peace at all
01:07:27.540 I didn't find you no peace at all
01:07:34.400 Never had a smile that lit up every room that I came into
01:07:47.180 All those intentions were self-serving
01:07:51.180 If my eulogy reads like a scene from some bad Hollywood movie
01:08:01.180 It would seem that none of you knew me
01:08:05.100 How much of this time's been wasted
01:08:11.460 Singing these rhymes you hated
01:08:14.860 Nothing's except the joy of life quite like truth
01:08:18.920 So we spend our nights getting wasted
01:08:25.200 Line after line with numb faces
01:08:28.400 Turning pipe dreams into pipe bombs with you
01:08:32.920 Beneath some rubble
01:08:37.640 Buried in a modern concrete tomb
01:08:40.920 With western comforts
01:08:42.920 With western comforts
01:08:44.920 They will find the remains of our youth
01:08:47.920 In a venture box
01:08:50.920 They'll uncover letters and mixtapes
01:08:53.920 Left a trail of breadcrumbs
01:08:55.920 Left a trail of breadcrumbs
01:08:57.920 That will never lead to any place
01:09:00.920 I've considered suicide by police
01:09:03.920 I've tried myself but my fingers missing
01:09:05.920 So I guess I'll stare at a wall and scream
01:09:06.920 For now
01:09:07.920 I've broken and defeated for no particular reason
01:09:09.920 Quick escape
01:09:11.920 If I'm okay on the day I die it will be self-explanatory
01:09:13.920 There won't be a letter for you
01:09:15.920 Life was just painfully boring
01:09:20.200 How much of this time's been wasted
01:09:22.200 Singing these lines you hated
01:09:24.200 Nothing's except the joy of life quite like truth
01:09:26.200 So you spend the nights getting wasted
01:09:30.200 Right after line with numb faces
01:09:32.200 Turned pipe dreams into pipe
01:09:34.200 And I'm not sure
01:09:35.200 If I'm okay on the day I die it will be self-explanatory
01:09:36.200 There won't be a letter for you
01:09:37.200 Life was just painfully boring
01:09:39.200 How much of this time's been wasted
01:09:40.200 Singing these lines you hated
01:09:42.200 Nothing's except the joy of life quite like truth
01:09:47.200 So you spend the nights getting wasted
01:09:50.200 Line after line with numb faces
01:09:54.200 Turning pipe dreams into pipe bombs with you
01:10:01.200 Turning pipe dreams into pipe bombs with you
01:10:05.200 And we're going to get right to it with Warren Kinsella
01:10:08.200 Postmedium columnist as well as author of the upcoming book
01:10:11.200 The Hidden Hand
01:10:12.200 The Information War and the Rise of Anti-Semitic Propaganda
01:10:16.200 Warren what's going on?
01:10:18.200 Thanks man thanks for having me on
01:10:20.200 No worries it was harder to get you on the line than my ex-girlfriend
01:10:23.200 I appreciate you
01:10:26.200 But before we get into this Mark Carney stuff
01:10:28.200 I just want to ask you about your initial reaction
01:10:30.200 To what the media is going crazy about
01:10:33.200 About this ICE situation in Minneapolis
01:10:35.200 And the fatal shooting that took place
01:10:37.200 Well I tried to watch the tape objectively
01:10:40.200 I warn everybody who's seeking it out
01:10:43.200 It's pretty horrible
01:10:44.200 Yeah
01:10:45.200 It's pretty gory
01:10:46.200 What I saw was those agents telling her to leave
01:10:51.200 And she was trying to leave
01:10:52.200 And then one of them shot her
01:10:54.200 So it looked very much like an execution to me
01:10:57.200 And I mean we're going to have a full investigation
01:11:00.200 The FBI is now involved
01:11:03.200 People are taking sides
01:11:04.200 But you know they can decide with their own eyes
01:11:06.200 If they can stomach the tape
01:11:08.200 It looks pretty clear that this agent
01:11:11.200 Acted inappropriately to say the least
01:11:14.200 Yeah you know we've had a lot of different opinions
01:11:16.200 We've had cops on
01:11:17.200 We've had everybody on
01:11:18.200 And that's the thing
01:11:19.200 Is that everyone who comes to talk about the video
01:11:22.200 Has a very different way about talking about it
01:11:24.200 And I guess you've been involved you know for a long time in politics
01:11:28.200 Have you ever seen there be a bigger political divide right now
01:11:33.200 In the United States than between the right and the left
01:11:36.200 Never never
01:11:37.200 And as you know like full disclosure I volunteered for Biden
01:11:41.200 And Harris and Clinton
01:11:44.200 So I'm you know I'm not completely objective on the subject
01:11:47.200 But you know I'm also pro police
01:11:49.200 I've been a cop reporter
01:11:51.200 I know lots of cops
01:11:52.200 I've worked with cops in the past
01:11:54.200 And cops make mistakes like everybody else
01:11:57.200 Not everything they do is right
01:11:59.200 And you know this this woman was a poet and a mom
01:12:03.200 With her car stuffed with stuffed toys
01:12:06.200 Right but I do want to say Warren
01:12:08.200 The video that's going out majority is from the rear version
01:12:11.200 Where you see her rear license plate
01:12:12.200 There is a video that came out this morning
01:12:14.200 From the front license plate
01:12:15.200 Where you do clearly see her hitting him before
01:12:18.200 So there was an interaction before
01:12:20.200 So that's
01:12:21.200 Standing right in front of the vehicle
01:12:22.200 I mean we can all
01:12:23.200 Yeah but you don't you don't drive your car towards a police officer
01:12:26.200 You know like that's
01:12:27.200 Yeah they had told her to leave
01:12:29.200 You can hear that on the tape
01:12:30.200 Right but
01:12:31.200 They told her to leave
01:12:32.200 I've seen that tape
01:12:33.200 But there is a different one
01:12:34.200 That is the reverse angle of that
01:12:36.200 Which clearly shows her hitting
01:12:38.200 Not the way that we're seeing the one from the rear view
01:12:40.200 Which is her pulling out and not making contact with the police officer
01:12:43.200 So did she deserve to die?
01:12:45.200 No I don't think anyone deserves to die
01:12:47.200 I think the life the loss of life is is is horrible
01:12:50.200 I just think that you know in the rush for media to get this story out
01:12:53.200 It's inflamed this up to a point where it's gone
01:12:56.200 Did she deserve it?
01:12:57.200 God no
01:12:58.200 Well let's put it this way
01:12:59.200 I'm not one to say
01:13:00.200 I I think the loss of life is absolutely horrible on every level
01:13:04.200 I I'm not a police officer I couldn't have made that decision
01:13:07.200 Do you know what I mean?
01:13:08.200 That's where my moral compass stands where it's I don't know
01:13:11.200 I'm not in that I I would hate to be a police officer making that choice
01:13:14.200 I'd hate to go through my training
01:13:16.200 I would hate that you know I I police officers they're ice agents
01:13:20.200 Right but they don't even have formal training the police officers do
01:13:24.200 And you talk to any cop you know who's had training
01:13:27.200 They will say no you're not supposed to do that when you
01:13:30.200 Well we did have two cops on today that both said that you know
01:13:33.200 Hank and Zygna and Ron Chinzer were both on saying that they conducted themselves properly
01:13:37.200 Well shame on them because I disagree I don't think that woman deserved to die to be shot in the face
01:13:43.200 Yeah a guy standing in front of her vehicle
01:13:45.200 Yeah no and it's a fair point everyone has to everyone has jumped on this one like it's
01:13:50.200 But this is what the US does right they do it better than everyone they take a situation like this
01:13:55.200 And then they divide it down the middle there's a line in the sand and then no one is pouring water on it
01:14:01.200 They're all pouring gas on it
01:14:03.200 Well I mean this is a consequence of them electing Donald Trump
01:14:08.200 He you know is actually just doing what he said he was going to do
01:14:12.200 He said he would send the military send police into major cities
01:14:17.200 Major these mainly Democratic cities
01:14:19.200 Yeah and that's what he's doing
01:14:21.200 And everybody was warned that this would happen
01:14:24.200 That these clashes that take place
01:14:26.200 But most tragically the one who's paid the ultimate price is a mother
01:14:31.200 Who did nothing wrong other than try and leave the scene after being told to do so
01:14:35.200 See I agree with your statement outside of the nothing wrong because I don't know that so I can't make that
01:14:41.200 But it is tragic that a mother was shot dead 100% I'll agree with that
01:14:45.200 You sighed for your mind
01:15:04.200 I bring myself to the side
01:15:10.200 And then
01:15:13.200 Caught inside
01:15:18.200 Hammer
01:15:23.200 What brings you under
01:15:27.440 Reflection leads
01:15:30.200 To the Ч
01:15:30.700 To the Cine
01:15:32.200 Hammer
01:15:33.200 What brings you adults
01:15:37.200 It's all I need to hide
01:15:41.200 It's all I need to hide
01:15:52.200 It's all I need to hide
01:15:56.200 It's all I need to hide
01:16:10.200 Your happiness, happiness
01:16:13.200 Turn around, turn around
01:16:16.200 To take the world, to take the world
01:16:19.200 Overcome, overcome
01:16:22.200 I'm a man, I'm a man, I'm a man, I'm a man
01:16:38.200 Infrastructures, where inmates, they tell
01:16:49.200 The joy of what you're feeling, right, wide, wide
01:17:00.200 Outside, outside, outside, outside, outside, outside, outside, outside
01:17:11.200 I know what brings you under, she screams at me from outside
01:17:18.200 I know your mind
01:17:21.200 I know your mind
01:17:26.200 Me.
01:17:29.700 Boat.
01:17:36.100 Boat.
01:17:38.100 Baseball.
01:17:38.960 Baseball.
01:17:40.200 Baseball.
01:17:41.200 Baseball.
01:17:42.700 Baseball.
01:17:43.900 Baseball.
01:17:45.440 Baseball.
01:17:47.800 Baseball.
01:17:49.480 Baseball.
01:17:50.460 Baseball.
01:17:56.200 I want to bring in Warren Kinsella to the conversation,
01:18:19.360 president of Daisy Group, former political strategist for Jean Chrétien
01:18:22.700 and author of a new book coming out very, very, very shortly,
01:18:26.680 The Hidden Hand, which will be extremely revealing.
01:18:29.840 He joins us now. Thank you.
01:18:32.040 Thanks, my friend.
01:18:33.020 When does that come out? What's the day? It should be soon, right?
01:18:35.180 Next month. It comes out next month. I can't believe it's happening.
01:18:39.060 So it's coming out as e-book first, and then the hardcover shortly thereafter
01:18:42.880 and is being published around the world.
01:18:44.440 How stressful. How stressful, right?
01:18:46.280 It's like it's so much work to get these things going,
01:18:48.920 and then it's like you get it done. It's a lot of work.
01:18:51.340 So congratulations. But it's also timely. It's also very important work.
01:18:55.440 But we've talked about, you know, the funding of protests, right?
01:18:59.920 We've talked about, and you certainly revealed it.
01:19:02.200 You reveal more of this in your book.
01:19:04.440 My question is, though, Warren, is that we've got all these pop-up protests,
01:19:07.980 and it doesn't seem to matter the cause or the cost or the propaganda,
01:19:11.840 which it's spreading. It is being protected in this country by a charter.
01:19:14.840 It is. And, you know, protests are legitimate and are protected by Section 2 of the Charter
01:19:22.480 and, you know, the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. That's all fine.
01:19:26.940 But, you know, the column I wrote for Post Media, and actually the book, too,
01:19:32.820 talks about this, is we need to pay attention to what's happening in our streets
01:19:36.720 and what's happening online.
01:19:38.040 Because these people who hate democracy, they hate the West, they hate Israel,
01:19:43.280 they hate the governments of Canada and the United States,
01:19:46.440 want to destroy our way of life.
01:19:48.620 They'll say that. Like, they're quite honest about it.
01:19:51.380 And, like, Alex, they're getting way better at what they're doing.
01:19:54.880 Just on Saturday, okay?
01:19:56.440 So the invasion, or the incursion, rather, into Venezuela to get Maduro,
01:20:02.080 who is a war criminal and an abuser of human rights.
01:20:05.740 Trump was right to do what he did.
01:20:07.920 That started at 1.35 a.m. Caracas time.
01:20:12.300 Almost immediately, this far-left, anti-Semitic, anti-Israel, anti-U.S. fringe
01:20:18.720 was broadcasting it live.
01:20:20.760 They were broadcasting it before CNN did.
01:20:23.700 And within 10 minutes, they had started to plan a rally
01:20:29.420 that would take place in Times Square that same morning.
01:20:32.580 Like, that's organization. Like, that is organizational skill
01:20:36.860 that, you know, some political parties don't possess.
01:20:40.620 I know. Yeah, no kidding.
01:20:41.820 But that, you know, we've seen this.
01:20:43.300 We saw it against in the environmental movement, right,
01:20:45.260 where you get these very kind of tough people and very strong,
01:20:48.980 backed by very big millionaires, billionaires who have the money,
01:20:52.280 and they run shrewd operations.
01:20:54.220 But in this case, we're talking, like, funded by, what, China?
01:20:57.640 Maybe by Iran, maybe the Muslim Brotherhood.
01:21:00.260 These are, you know, countries that are interfering,
01:21:03.740 and those who are funding these things are working against our interests, right?
01:21:07.980 They sow division.
01:21:09.380 And, again, that should not be...
01:21:10.720 No, it should not.
01:21:11.600 And so the banker, you know, for the anti-Israel stuff
01:21:14.800 has largely been Qatar.
01:21:16.760 Yep.
01:21:17.080 The campaign manager always for all of this stuff is Iran,
01:21:21.180 although they're tied up with a problem of their own domestically at the moment.
01:21:25.480 Albeit, albeit, can I just step in there, Warren?
01:21:27.460 Because don't forget, Qatar, apparently, Anita Annan says,
01:21:29.680 we share our values with them.
01:21:30.760 And I would point out, Iran's people who are fighting for their lives in the streets,
01:21:35.280 where are all the protesters here who you would think would be supporting them, right?
01:21:39.520 Nowhere to be found.
01:21:41.320 And pretty hard to find coverage as well.
01:21:43.660 And then on the front line, you know, these, the banker and the campaign manager,
01:21:47.840 all these people, the Russia and China, who act as an echo chamber for this stuff,
01:21:53.220 are Hezbollah and Hamas, and then individuals in Canada and the United States
01:21:58.900 who are overseeing these protests.
01:22:01.540 And in the case of Canada, you know, we had protests happening the same...
01:22:06.140 Like, before Majuro was even arraigned in Manhattan,
01:22:10.420 there were protests taking, well-organized protests with signage and organizers
01:22:14.960 and all the bells and whistles were taking place in Montreal, Vancouver, Ottawa, and Montreal
01:22:20.040 within 24 hours of Majuro being taken out of Venezuela.
01:22:26.520 That suggests a degree of organization, an organizational skill,
01:22:31.020 that I don't think a lot of people realize.
01:22:32.800 No, but you know what? Kareem Assad certainly has been out there doing the work of, like, 50 newsrooms.
01:22:38.660 Like, literally, what she has done and documented,
01:22:40.980 I think, I don't think we realize how valuable it will be
01:22:43.760 because she has documented from the start and been able to find groups.
01:22:47.440 And she doesn't weigh in on her opinion on them, but she's laying out the facts, right?
01:22:52.340 And so she's been watching this.
01:22:54.640 There are others watching this.
01:22:56.000 And the question then becomes, Warren, who's going to do something about it?
01:22:59.080 Because the damage is not small.
01:23:01.780 I mean, there are very real divisions, very real costs.
01:23:05.100 And the fact that the leaders will not, like, the fact that Olivia Chow, even Doug Ford,
01:23:11.200 none of them will stand up and actually do anything when you, Kareem Assad, Tristan Hopper,
01:23:16.240 there are enough reports now that we know that nefarious characters are behind this,
01:23:21.180 but they won't do anything.
01:23:22.180 And there are governments that are, and it's working.
01:23:26.320 You look at what Ron DeSantis, as you know, I've volunteered, full disclosure, for the Democrats,
01:23:31.340 but I applaud what Ron DeSantis is doing in Florida because he's going after the Muslim Brotherhood.
01:23:36.540 He's going after the kind of extremist Muslim organizations who are funding and facilitating this anti-democratic activity.
01:23:47.700 Because at the end of the day, that's what it is.
01:23:50.060 These are attacks not just on Israel.
01:23:52.360 As Israelis themselves point out all the time, this is an attack on democracy.
01:23:57.520 It's an attack on our way of life.
01:23:59.240 Right.
01:23:59.600 And we need to wake up to the magnitude of the threat.
01:24:02.020 So my book that's coming out talks about that, how they fund themselves, how they organize themselves,
01:24:07.620 how they recruit people, their messaging, their tactics, all that kind of stuff.
01:24:11.880 Because there is no question.
01:24:14.000 It's not a conspiracy theory.
01:24:16.140 These guys have gotten, you know, I'm paying tribute to them almost.
01:24:19.740 They've become really good at what they do.
01:24:21.560 What they're doing is evil and undemocratic, but they become extremely effective.
01:24:26.320 And we need to wake up to that threat.
01:24:28.500 I would suggest they become very good at what they do because they've had very little resistance.
01:24:32.320 Like, honestly, I mean, if you look at the pipeline activism, with some of it being incredibly violent,
01:24:36.540 you never hear about it.
01:24:37.800 That's why they seemingly get away with it.
01:24:39.600 Right.
01:24:39.800 And then, you know, you see our approach to interference and, like, the joke and how we treat it.
01:24:46.400 Like, why wouldn't these countries do it?
01:24:47.980 We let them do it.
01:24:49.340 So shame on us because it is very obvious that this is going on.
01:24:54.200 But it is.
01:24:55.320 And that's been the case at the federal level.
01:24:57.340 And the Trudeau government, sadly now under the Carney government.
01:25:00.400 You know, the guy I worked for, Kretzian, the show in against Wrangler,
01:25:04.380 when he was dealing with protesters who were too aggressive, he'd take it into his own hands.
01:25:09.240 Like, there is a way of dealing with this.
01:25:11.300 It doesn't matter what party you belong to.
01:25:13.780 Everybody needs to recognize the threat that we're facing to our way of life and our democracy
01:25:18.720 and that these people are becoming more and more effective at what they do.
01:25:22.860 And where does it stop?
01:25:24.300 Where does it stop?
01:25:25.100 Because, yeah, like, if they know this, they can just keep hijacking our own interests.
01:25:28.720 And we've been stupidly polite about this.
01:25:32.520 Stupidly.
01:25:33.700 And look at the city of Toronto.
01:25:35.160 You know, we've got a mayor who is indebted in some way, I don't know how, to these people.
01:25:41.680 And has allowed, you know, a situation to grow where we've got schools for little Jewish
01:25:47.160 kids being shot up once, twice, three times, businesses being firebombed.
01:25:52.380 You know, Heather Reeson's bookstore, like a bookstore being attacked.
01:25:56.780 Like, if there's, I can't think of a greater symbol of a democracy in decline
01:26:00.920 when a bookstore is being attacked by thugs.
01:26:04.200 And Olivia Chow and Dem Q, our chief of police, have allowed that to happen.
01:26:09.320 And so I think we need to make a change in both of those offices.
01:26:14.080 So we have somebody like the new mayor of Calgary or, you know, Wob Canoe in Manitoba.
01:26:19.240 It doesn't matter what party you're thinking of.
01:26:21.520 There are leaders who know how to deal with this stuff and how to condemn it and how to
01:26:25.280 fight it.
01:26:26.220 Sadly, in the city of Toronto, we don't have that.
01:26:28.600 No, we do not.
01:26:29.380 Not nearly enough.
01:26:31.160 So people like you, yourself and others standing up for it.
01:26:34.340 So I appreciate that.
01:26:35.460 We'll talk again.
01:26:37.060 Thanks, my friend.
01:26:37.840 There you go.
01:26:38.120 Warren Kinsella, and of course, he does have a book coming out, and it is The Hidden Hand
01:26:41.980 coming out next month.
01:26:42.820 So we will, of course, we'll get him on to talk about that.
01:26:47.220 Was it all by design?
01:26:50.840 Was it coordinated time?
01:26:54.300 Felt worth it to mention.
01:26:56.760 The world still moves when I don't pay attention.
01:27:01.800 Choke to say I'm doing well.
01:27:03.760 Amongst the bars of the strip mall, I'm doing well.
01:27:05.540 Amongst the bars of the strip mall, I'm looking for the liquor store.
01:27:11.620 It's hard to imagine more.
01:27:13.360 Complaining about the traffic, but I'm part of it.
01:27:23.900 Looking for the problem when I'm the one that started it.
01:27:30.060 And every day I wake up saying, what is this feeling I've carried for so long, glaring inside a broken car alarm?
01:27:41.780 What is this feeling I've carried for so long, glaring inside a broken car alarm?
01:27:56.520 What is this feeling I've carried for so long, glaring inside a broken car alarm?
01:28:00.300 What is this feeling I've carried for so long, glaring inside a broken car alarm?
01:28:04.300 It felt so toxically precise.
01:28:07.900 I need an open field to scream.
01:28:11.700 Walk through their imagined worlds.
01:28:14.560 It's barbaric.
01:28:16.680 It's a scheme we had.
01:28:18.920 Every chance to change, but we've lived somehow.
01:28:22.820 I thought we knew better by now.
01:28:25.720 I thought we knew better by now.
01:28:28.600 I thought we knew better by now.
01:28:32.520 Woo!
01:28:33.640 What is this feeling I've carried for so long, glaring inside a broken car alarm?
01:28:55.780 What is this feeling I've carried for so long?
01:29:03.640 Convince myself it's all pretend I am crawling, I am building, it's collapsing, again it was short-lived, it was something I missed.
01:29:18.280 Complaining about the traffic, we're a part of it Looking for the problem when I'm the one who started it
01:29:32.600 And every day I wake up, and every day I wake up, and every day I wake up, the shame