#375 — On the Attempted Assassination of President Trump
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
139.93471
Summary
Sam Harris reflects on the near assassination of former President Trump, and offers a sober assessment of the dangers of political violence in the wake of Saturday s attempted assassination of Donald Trump. Sam's thoughts on what we should do now that we know the identity of the shooter, and what we can learn about the man who attempted to kill him, and the dangers he poses to our democracy, and why it's time to confront the truth about the actual risk to democracy posed by political violence by Donald Trump and his policies, and how we must confront the third truth about him, which is that he poses a much greater risk than most presidents in modern history, and that he is a dangerous danger to democracy than any other president in modern times. The problem for Democrats is that any observation of this second truth, a truth that seems likely to darken and expand in the aftermath of yesterday s events, will now be seen as an incitement to further political violence, and a symptom of a political disease we must cure, not just about the risks Trump poses to democracy, but about the dangers that he presents to our political order, and about our democracy itself, as well as what we learn about him and what it means about him that could be done to restore civility and basic decency to our politics. Make sense of it, and asks the question about what it might mean for our democracy in the post 9/11 world. What does it mean for us to do about it? The Making Sense Podcast makes sense of the possibility of a return to civility, decency, and respect for the rule of the rule and rule of law in our democracy? What is it about Trump and the rule, and our democracy and what does it really mean about it, really mean, and is it really about him? And what does he really mean? -- -- and why does he still pose a threat to our democratic order? -- and what is it possible to be a good president? -- is it a good person? -- makes sense, and doesn t it really? -- or is it not? -- of the threat to us? -- -- of it? -- does it matter? -- why it matters? -- what it matters, and what it really means? -- how does it serve us better than it does? -- can it really matter, or doesn't it matter, What it matters to us, and does it make us have a chance to be?
Transcript
00:00:00.000
welcome to the making sense podcast this is Sam Harris okay well not much happening in the world
00:00:30.000
I'm recording late in the day on Monday so about 48 hours after the attempted assassination of
00:00:38.920
former President Trump I'm sure I'll have more to say about this when I speak to Ann Applebaum
00:00:45.360
on the podcast later in the week over at Substack I've written a flurry of short posts in the last
00:00:54.560
two weeks or so all on politics all of them arguing that the Biden campaign is over whether
00:01:02.980
or not Biden and his team realize it and I think that's even more true today I don't see how Biden
00:01:11.280
runs against Trump in the aftermath of this near assassination which as horrible as it is and was
00:01:20.040
and I'll talk about that the net result for Trump is about as good as you could imagine had this been
00:01:27.880
stage managed by Satan it could not have been better for Trump so let's just say that I think
00:01:34.240
the Biden campaign is even more doomed than it was last week but perhaps any democratic campaign
00:01:42.800
is doomed at this point that remains to be seen obviously Biden hasn't dropped out yet so all of
00:01:50.480
this is academic for the moment but after Saturday I think you have to expect we will have a second
00:01:58.420
term of President Trump I don't know what prediction markets are saying at this point but it has been an
00:02:03.880
extraordinary 48 hours I think I'll just read the short post I wrote yesterday about the attempt on
00:02:11.980
Trump's life first one thing I didn't say in the post is had the shooter succeeded whatever you think
00:02:20.700
about Trump and the risks he poses to our democracy that outcome would have been catastrophic nothing good
00:02:30.860
would have come from a successful act of political violence which is a very long and callous way of saying
00:02:38.040
that I am very happy the shooter missed obviously one person did die a man protecting his family
00:02:45.880
that is absolutely tragic and I believe two people are in critical condition so the whole thing is
00:02:53.340
awful but for anybody out there who imagines it would have been better all things considered if
00:03:00.720
Trump had been killed again even from a completely callous point of view that cares nothing for the man
00:03:07.740
or his family or his friends or anyone else if you're just hoping for a certain political outcome
00:03:15.560
I think you're completely delusional if you think blowing his head off on television would have resulted
00:03:22.640
in something good in America our entire society quite literally dodged a bullet along with the man himself
00:03:31.120
which as everyone has observed and everyone must concede the fact that he was almost entirely unharmed
00:03:40.340
and with the difference of an inch would have been certainly killed that part was astounding but also
00:03:47.520
his behavior in the immediate aftermath and the resulting photos and video although the photos have been most
00:03:55.240
impactful you just have to join the chorus of amazement especially given his persona and his political
00:04:03.540
needs his upraised fist his attitude the man had the presence of mind to stage manage his own
00:04:12.660
near assassination perfectly and i don't mean to make a cynical point here that was genuinely impressive
00:04:19.700
anyway i don't know how any democrat successfully runs against that imagery especially because of points
00:04:28.900
i raise in this piece on substack the title is stepping back from the precipice in the aftermath of
00:04:37.780
yesterday's events we must hold three truths in mind simultaneously the first is that political
00:04:45.060
violence of any kind is horrific and obscene despite the widespread moral confusion evident on social
00:04:51.940
media the attempted assassination of former president trump was simply a tragedy for our country and in
00:04:59.220
response to this truth we must do whatever we can to restore civility and basic decency to our politics
00:05:06.020
but there's a second truth now all but unutterable and it is this no one has done more to destroy
00:05:14.260
civility and basic decency in our politics than donald trump no one in fact has done more to increase the
00:05:21.700
threat of political violence unlike any president in modern history trump brings out the worst in both his
00:05:28.340
enemies and his friends his influence on american life seems almost supernaturally pernicious the problem
00:05:36.340
for democrats is that any observation of this second truth a truth that seems likely to darken and expand
00:05:43.060
in the aftermath of yesterday's attack will now be condemned as rancorous and immoral or worse as an
00:05:49.620
incitement to further political violence every necessary criticism of trump's authoritarianism fondness for
00:05:56.420
dictators fraudulence personal corruption hostility to the rule of law and fathomless dishonesty will
00:06:04.660
be mistaken for or cynically construed as a symptom of the very political disease we must cure telling
00:06:12.020
the truth about the actual risks that trump and trumpism still pose to our democracy just became much more
00:06:18.580
difficult as we await further details about the gunman it is important that we embrace a third
00:06:24.980
truth whether or not it becomes easy to detect a coherent motive or set of influences we must recognize
00:06:31.620
that he represented no one and nothing beyond his own abomination and depending on what we learn about
00:06:37.140
him this truth could prove dangerously elusive it may even seem to contradict the second truth adduced above
00:06:43.700
didn't i just suggest that trump himself has behaved so irresponsibly as to increase the risk of
00:06:48.980
political violence yes and he has done so repeatedly for instance in 2016 candidate trump mused that a
00:06:57.620
staunch defender of the second amendment might want to kill hillary clinton to prevent her from appointing
00:07:02.900
judges that could threaten our gun rights this single utterance represents a shocking and unprecedented
00:07:09.220
violation of a political norm merely one among hundreds that trump carelessly shattered both
00:07:15.140
as a candidate and as president however had there been a subsequent attempt on clinton's life it would
00:07:20.740
have been wrong to have held trump directly responsible for the violence because there was a vast gulf
00:07:26.340
between his words however reckless and a sincere incitement to murder and there is a further gulf between
00:07:33.860
incitement and the act of climbing a roof with a rifle and attempting to kill another human being
00:07:40.260
we cannot allow the lunatic behavior of a disturbed young man to further derange our politics let me state
00:07:48.180
the second truth more starkly in case the third still isn't clear there are tens of millions of americans
00:07:55.460
who believe that the world would be a better place without donald trump in it and if he were to die in
00:08:01.380
his sleep sometime before election day they would not mourn him i suspect that literally millions of
00:08:07.780
americans would celebrate the man's natural death this is not merely a sign of how politically unhinged
00:08:14.660
we have become as a nation it is a sign of how unhinged trump has made us fully half of our neighbors are
00:08:22.500
desperate to have this man out of their lives but very few of them would defend what happened yesterday
00:08:30.340
for obvious reasons the first is surely that they don't support murder but most of them also
00:08:36.660
understand the first truth above political violence in any direction for any stated purpose harms us all
00:08:45.060
if an ordinary republican like ronald reagan george bush john mccain or mit romney had been shot under
00:08:52.740
identical circumstances what would happen next this is a surprisingly easy question to answer we can be
00:09:00.660
confident that any of these men would soon step before the cameras very likely in the company of
00:09:06.740
his democratic opponent and call for unity in america having been brought to the precipice a normal
00:09:14.180
republican would seek to lead our nation back to safety he would emphasize not his personal magnificence
00:09:21.220
the heroic sacrifices he has made for his supporters or the vengeance he will soon unleash upon his
00:09:27.780
enemies but the necessity for calm he would assert his confidence in the strength of our democracy
00:09:34.740
and the integrity of our electoral process above all he would speak about the sacred significance of a
00:09:40.500
peaceful transfer of power is this what anyone expects from trump in the coming days his first words to the
00:09:47.700
crowd fist raised appear to have been fight fight fight what will his next words be will he try to unite our
00:09:56.820
country or will he talk about the democrats as quote scum the press as quote enemies of the people and claim
00:10:05.300
that only he can save our country from the evil that assails it as never before from within and without
00:10:11.300
let's wait and see and where is the democratic candidate who can effectively campaign against trump
00:10:19.300
now so that's what i wrote i do think we have a problem in that the appropriate response to the
00:10:27.940
attempted assassination of a former president which is of course horror and sympathy and a concerted effort
00:10:36.180
to get to the bottom of what happened all of this will serve as so much has in trump's life to normalize
00:10:44.740
him as a political figure but he is not a normal political figure the fact that we could rationally worry
00:10:53.220
that our society might be pitched into something like a civil war had that bullet done more than grazed
00:10:59.220
his ear we are here in large measure because of what trump has done to our society he has poisoned
00:11:07.780
our political landscape with lies lies about a stolen election it's not just trump it's also social media
00:11:16.500
and now it's figures like elon who have become fairly trumpian it's this taste for conspiracy theory
00:11:23.860
but trump has been stoking this and riding atop all of it for nearly a decade this moment is as
00:11:31.300
perilous as it is in large measure because of trump and the fact that talking about that now will be
00:11:39.860
condemned everywhere right of center as an incitement to further political violence as yet another instance
00:11:47.300
of dangerous hyperbole that almost got trump killed all of this is upside down right no one has turned
00:11:55.540
up the temperature more than trump when nancy pelosi's husband got his head bashed in by a hammer wielding
00:12:02.980
maniac and trump supporter trump joked about it that's the environment that has been created here the
00:12:10.580
democrats have contributed very little to those kinds of norm violations i've said a lot about what's
00:12:17.860
wrong with the left but you cannot accuse the biden team of normalizing political violence trump has been
00:12:25.860
normalizing political violence for nearly nine years but the fact that it is now even more difficult to
00:12:34.260
talk about who he is the fact that now he gets to go to the republican convention and pretend
00:12:40.500
to be a uniter rumor has it that he intends to take the moral high ground here it will be interesting to see
00:12:48.900
how long he can maintain that pose that's not the sort of person he is everything we knew about trump before
00:12:57.300
saturday is still true even though he was almost killed by an assassin's bullet but i will be the first to concede that
00:13:06.500
the democrats are in a very difficult position compounded of course by the fact that they can't
00:13:12.020
seem to figure out how to get a truly unelectable candidate out of the way so that they can run
00:13:18.500
somebody who can speak fluidly about the most important issues we face as a country what such a
00:13:25.460
person will be able to say about trump in the aftermath of this that will be politically palatable
00:13:31.540
that will be a very interesting high wire act but we shall see anyway as i said i'm planning to speak
00:13:39.540
with ann applebaum later in the week no doubt she'll have a thought or two on this topic until next time