#430 — ＂More From Sam＂： Trump, Gavin Newsom, Class War, DOGE, & Rapid Fire Questions
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
183.7788
Summary
In this episode of the Making Sense Podcast, host Alex Blumberg sits down with Sam Harris to discuss the new president, Donald Trump. They discuss how he got elected, why he s a terrible president, and why he should have won the Nobel Peace Prize.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Welcome to the Making Sense Podcast. This is Sam Harris. Just a note to say that if you're
00:00:11.740
hearing this, you're not currently on our subscriber feed, and we'll only be hearing
00:00:15.720
the first part of this conversation. In order to access full episodes of the Making Sense
00:00:20.060
Podcast, you'll need to subscribe at samharris.org. We don't run ads on the podcast, and therefore
00:00:26.240
it's made possible entirely through the support of our subscribers. So if you enjoy what we're
00:00:30.200
doing here, please consider becoming one. Welcome back to another episode of More From Sam.
00:00:39.320
Hi, Sam. How are you? Good to see you. Here's me. More of me. Yeah, there's more. As a reminder,
00:00:45.080
the goal of this series is to get more from Sam more often, and since we've been getting a lot
00:00:48.400
more of you lately, Sam, we haven't had an episode for a while. Along with subscriber input, I may
00:00:53.160
issue my own positions, exaggerated versions of my positions, or play devil's advocate and jump
00:00:58.080
between them seamlessly, and because I'm here in service of Sam, your ideas. I may also abandon
00:01:02.680
any position I authentically hold if I think I can get more from you. Thank you again to all our
00:01:07.160
subscribers for submitting your questions and comments. If you'd like to submit topics for a
00:01:11.380
future episode, you'll need to become a subscriber, and you can do that at samharris.org. And one more
00:01:16.520
announcement quickly. Sam currently has five shows on sale. Seattle, San Jose, New York, Boston,
00:01:20.760
and Chicago. I think Boston is sold out. There might be a few remaining tickets in New York,
00:01:25.040
and you can find all the details and ticket links at samharris.org. Okay, on to our first topic.
00:01:31.680
Is it fair to say that what concerns you most about Trump is what's yet to come? What happens
00:01:35.600
to our country after Trump? What happens to our democracy going forward? No, no. I'm concerned about
00:01:42.820
what's already happened. I think our democracy has eroded to an impressive degree that a few people
00:01:49.880
right of center seem prepared to acknowledge. I think when you have senators and congresspeople
00:01:55.020
not voting their conscience in the aftermath of January 6th because they're afraid they might be
00:01:59.720
killed or their families might be killed, something has gone wrong with our democracy, right? That's a
00:02:04.400
very new spot on the map, and it's quite close to tyranny, frankly. And that's years ago, right? That's
00:02:13.740
where we're coming from there. I'm more wondering if you're concerned that it's going to get worse
00:02:19.040
from here, meaning what Trump is doing now and where we are now. Are you not more concerned with
00:02:24.060
what does the future look like? Well, yeah. If the future gets worse, that's obviously a bad thing,
00:02:30.140
and I'm worried about that. But really, all of my criticism of Trump is based on what has already
00:02:37.240
happened. None of it is hypothetical. I mean, yes, I have on the hypothetical side of the ledger,
00:02:43.260
I have all these things I'm worried about, right? I mean, you know, because we don't know what
00:02:47.420
challenges we're going to face as a society going forward, but we know having a greedy, incompetent,
00:02:54.580
self-dealing ignoramus in charge is not optimal. We're putting him in a room with Putin, right,
00:03:01.300
to try to negotiate the end of a war in Europe. He's one of the last people I could think who's
00:03:07.460
qualified to do that. I mean, first, he's showing every sign of being easily manipulated by Putin,
00:03:12.280
and by default, he's anchored to Putin's view of the history of that war, right? He literally spouts
00:03:19.600
old Kremlin talking points in how he describes the war in Ukraine. He sounds like a guy who's
00:03:27.600
really thinking about what a great real estate deal he might do in Moscow when this whole thing
00:03:31.540
is over, right? I mean, if that's what was the only thing going on in his brain, if you could have
00:03:35.940
some South Park episode that showed the condo deal he was really worried about invading his entire
00:03:43.180
frontal cortex, that would explain it. But he pretends he's strong, but he's the most easily
00:03:49.420
manipulated president we've ever had. And again, he's anchored, his bias is on the side of, in this
00:03:57.840
case, the dictator who launched a war of aggression into Europe. Well, speaking of that, Hillary Clinton
00:04:03.740
said she'd nominate Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize if he helped broker an end of the war without
00:04:07.880
capitulating to Putin. Would you? Well, that final phrase is crucial, right? Without capitulating to
00:04:12.840
Putin. Of course. Let's see how that goes. Right. But if he did, would you support nominating him
00:04:18.800
for Nobel Peace Prize? I mean, yeah, but who cares? I mean, the Nobel Peace Prize has been so devalued.
00:04:23.700
I mean, Obama got it before he did anything, right? It's a farce. Arafat got it, right? Well,
00:04:28.400
what we know about Arafat's contributions to peace in the Middle East. I mean, nobody should care about
00:04:34.140
the Nobel Peace Prize. He gets a peace prize for refraining from killing anyone. That was the bar
00:04:39.780
there. You've often mentioned that when Trump is out, we're going to need to rewrite the laws
00:04:43.880
and change everything in order to keep this from happening again, right? You know what I'm talking
00:04:48.820
about? Where you'll say, like, on a go-forward basis, let's shore up the norms and make rules that
00:04:53.780
avoid the loopholes from being exploited? Yeah, I have no hope we're going to actually do that.
00:04:58.340
But yes, I think one of the things we realize is that we have norms that are shoring up our
00:05:04.100
democracy in places where we really should have laws. I mean, because the fact that we don't have
00:05:10.120
laws and we only have norms testifies to the assumption that people aren't going to traduce
00:05:15.420
those norms for corrupt or otherwise self-serving reasons. But Trump has broken all that,
00:05:22.100
all that kind of invisible structure. So yeah, we need real structure that makes it illegal to
00:05:27.160
do certain things. You shouldn't be able to launch a cryptocurrency that is just a mechanism by which
00:05:33.480
you can take bribes from the entire world and enrich yourself to the tune of billions of dollars
00:05:38.520
and use U.S. foreign policy and tariff policy so as to do that better, right? Like there should,
00:05:45.400
there's no, apparently there's, you know, it remains to be seen, I guess maybe, maybe one of
00:05:48.820
these court cases is explicitly on that point, but it remains to be seen whether any of that stuff is
00:05:55.240
illegal. Right. The problem I see with having to rewrite the laws is that anytime you enter into
00:05:59.900
any sort of agreement with somebody, a contract is only as good as the people that are involved.
00:06:04.420
There's a lot of good faith that's required. Well, that's not true. A real contract that's
00:06:08.580
enforceable by law has at the end of it, when you don't live up to your end of it, people with guns
00:06:14.480
showing up at your house and sticking those guns in your face. Of course, I understand that. I'm
00:06:18.700
saying that generally speaking, when you enter into agreement with somebody, if you're going to
00:06:22.280
make a deal with somebody, there's a spirit that you're trying to pay attention to. Instead, the idea,
00:06:28.340
what I'm getting at is that the history of the success of our country has come from the respect,
00:06:35.820
the relationship between the founding documents and its executors. And now we're being forced to
00:06:40.580
rewrite everything to protect ourselves against the enemy within. And that's sort of not really
00:06:45.900
the point. The point is, if you have to enter an agreement with somebody and you have to...
00:06:49.540
No, it's become the point. And this was something that the founding fathers, I think it was,
00:06:53.960
I think it was Madison somewhere, anticipated this explicitly. Like, well, you can't have an evil
00:06:59.760
person in the role of the chief executive and expect this system to work. I forget how it was put,
00:07:06.680
but there's some lines to that effect. It should be foreseeable. I mean, we're capable of being so
00:07:13.600
confused and so at odds with one another that the creative and not boring demagogue can win 51% of
00:07:23.020
the vote. Okay. So now we know that about ourselves and the rest of the world knows it too.
00:07:30.040
Unless you have anything else to add there about Trump.
00:07:31.700
Well, this is just, you now need to price in all of the damage that has been done to our
00:07:37.000
reputation. I mean, even if we get rid of Trump and we don't elect the opportunist J.D. Vance in
00:07:43.580
2028, and we get some sane and ethical president, Republican or Democrat, and we try to reset the
00:07:54.660
world's expectations, it's very hard to see how we do that. And we have announced to the world that
00:07:59.560
we potentially stand for nothing other than the whims of the next guy or gal we put in office.
00:08:05.060
Right. Right. Well, I did like the take that you and Ann Applebaum discussed, which J.D. Vance,
00:08:10.800
the idea that he's sort of like tofu, or he sort of takes on the flavor of whatever room he's in at
00:08:16.140
any given time. That was interesting. All right. Let's move to Newsom. I know we debated this a few
00:08:22.440
months ago, but I'm going to say it again. Gavin Newsom is going to be the Democratic candidate for
00:08:26.580
2028. Any updated thoughts there? No. I'm just, I will wait and say, I mean, I just can't imagine
00:08:33.580
that's a winning ticket. I'm not disputing the guy's talent and charisma in certain contexts,
00:08:40.440
but I just think it's too much baggage to sell to 49 other states. Yeah. I mean, but what else,
00:08:47.580
what worse could we hear about Newsom at this point? Well, we can't, but we know that 49 other
00:08:52.220
states and their inhabitants more or less despise him. Right. I mean, I haven't seen national
00:08:57.800
polling, but I, I'd be willing to bet that forget about him as a, as a person and his, his, um,
00:09:04.820
his Clintonian indiscretions. It's just the bad PR baggage that California as a state has for the
00:09:10.920
rest of the country. I mean, I think a lot of that PR is misinformation at this point, but it's fairly
00:09:16.360
indelible, right? People think California is virtually a failed state. It's like the number
00:09:21.960
four economy on earth at this point. And it subsidizes all the dysfunction of the 49 other
00:09:27.720
states, but the other states think California sucks. Yeah. I think Gavin makes that case really
00:09:32.880
well. And I think he'll have to stand behind some of it. That's no match for the, the, uh, Vox Pop
00:09:39.360
interview with the homeless addict in downtown LA or downtown San Francisco who says, yeah, it's so great
00:09:46.280
here. They gave me a lawn chair and all the fentanyl I can take. And it's, it's awesome.
00:09:50.840
Right. California go California. Yeah. Yeah. Again, I think we need, we're going to need somebody
00:09:56.400
who is as shameless as he is. And he's really a great communicator. He's got a lot of talents.
00:10:02.380
Again, I'm not a fan of his, but I can just see what he's doing and whoever's working with him behind
00:10:07.920
the scenes and advising him, or if it's him, I just don't see that anyone else is playing that level
00:10:13.400
of Trump politics from the left, you know, that style. But again, who is he going to convince?
00:10:19.960
Right. I mean, it's just, you have to picture people who voted for Trump now voting for Newsom
00:10:25.380
and that only one or 2%. Yeah. But I think he's handsome enough and communicates well,
00:10:30.600
and he'll be able to put out enough good content that he persuades him. Anyway,
00:10:34.020
we don't have to get stuck on this. I'm just, I'm planning my flag. Talk to me in a year about that.
00:10:38.040
I may have another thought. I want to come back to your,
00:10:40.320
your hobby horse for a second and discuss wealth inequality and make two entry points for you. As
00:10:45.800
Scott Galloway has publicly stated a number of times, and I know you share this belief,
00:10:48.940
if you hit your number, 50 million, a hundred million, 250, whatever it is,
00:10:52.480
and then you don't start enjoying it by spending it on friends and family and being charitable and
00:10:56.280
helping others, then you're really missing out on the greatest joy of having wealth, right?
00:11:01.740
And the second part is rich people should be most invested in keeping the pitchforks from the
00:11:06.860
gates. They have won the lottery. So maybe stop building compounds and invest in communities.
00:11:12.400
Thoughts? Yeah. Well, so I'd be to take it from the top down. I mean, the ultra rich people who
00:11:16.900
don't think they have a stake in the common good and who think they can just jet off to New Zealand
00:11:22.240
if things ever get really tough here. I mean, that's one, it's just patently delusional.
00:11:28.340
I was like, I mean, if you're gaming out those end of the world scenarios, you know,
00:11:32.300
you have to think of who's going to protect you and who you're going to just, your pilot on your
00:11:39.200
private plane is not going to leave without his family to go to New Zealand when the world ends,
00:11:44.700
right? So you need to take the pilot's family. And what about your bodyguard's family? And who's
00:11:50.320
going to protect you from your bodyguards when your bodyguards understand that you really have
00:11:53.920
no power now. You're just a guy who bought this compound in New Zealand. It's a ridiculous end game
00:11:59.680
to think that you can privately ensure your survival when the shit really hits the fan,
00:12:05.560
right? So you have as much a stake in civilization not failing as anyone else, as anyone who doesn't
00:12:13.880
have nearly the resources you have. You should have more of a stake.
00:12:17.480
We have more of a stake, yeah, because life is or should be so good, right? And like you won the game,
00:12:22.000
right? Like you should be nothing but dessert at this point. So the fact that they don't see that
00:12:27.220
and they're wasting any time, rather than shoring up civil society and improving the government in
00:12:33.580
all kinds of ways that we should improve it, they're engaged in this private effort, like this
00:12:38.860
concierge prepping for the apocalypse. That just seems crazy and just a frank misappropriation of
00:12:45.720
their moral capital and to say nothing of their actual capital. But yeah, I mean, in addition to that,
00:12:51.700
they should be much more generous in trying to build a functional society wherein other people
00:12:59.080
are happy and secure, right? I mean, they have a stake in other people seeing their dreams realized,
00:13:07.100
right? I mean, do you want to be surrounded by desperate, angry, envious people? Or do you want
00:13:11.840
to be surrounded by people who are basically happy and thriving? And the answer is so obvious.
00:13:17.420
At any level of wealth, it's so obvious. Now, what's really corrupt here is that we all have a
00:13:23.240
sense, an understandable sense, that our tax dollars are often wasted, right? They're spent on things that
00:13:29.700
we wouldn't approve of if we could kind of line item veto some of these expenditures. We all have this
00:13:38.040
some version of a doge idiot in our head. Now, some of that is probably totally unrealistic and
00:13:45.700
irrational, right? I mean, I'm sure one of the lessons of doge is that there's far less fraud
00:13:52.000
and waste in government than anyone suspected, right? I mean, they went in there just guns blazing
00:13:57.320
looking for fraud, and they found like $15 worth, and then they just started cutting good projects to
00:14:03.140
the bone and alienating every person who's working for the government, and many of whom are quite
00:14:09.320
talented and could be working in the private sector and are taking a significant pay cut to serve the
00:14:14.720
country. I'm not saying I don't think there's waste in government, and I'm not saying that I don't
00:14:19.020
think we could spend our tax dollars more wisely, but what we need is a judicious and transparent and
00:14:25.800
nonpartisan and sane look at all that, not some dummy on ketamine with a chainsaw and bad sunglasses.
00:14:34.460
You can't privatize everything. It's the government that's going to fight our wars. It's the government
00:14:39.200
that's going to tell us what the hell to do when the next pandemic happens. It's the government that
00:14:42.880
needs to make sure the food supply and the drug supply.
00:14:47.180
If you'd like to continue listening to this conversation, you'll need to subscribe at
00:14:51.220
samharris.org. Once you do, you'll get access to all full-length episodes of the Making Sense podcast.
00:14:57.780
The Making Sense podcast is ad-free and relies entirely on listener support,