#459 — More From Sam： Corruption, Immigration, The End of White-Collar Work, and More
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
191.93681
Summary
On this episode of the Making Sense Podcast, Sam sits down with Sarah Longwell, Tim Miller, and Sarah's husband, Tim, to talk about their recent podcast crossover event with the progressive podcasters Sarah and Tim. They discuss why it was so well received, and why they think there should be more crossover events like this.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Welcome to the Making Sense Podcast. This is Sam Harris. Just a note to say that if you're
00:00:11.780
hearing this, you're not currently on our subscriber feed, and we'll only be hearing
00:00:15.740
the first part of this conversation. In order to access full episodes of the Making Sense
00:00:20.100
Podcast, you'll need to subscribe at samharris.org. We don't run ads on the podcast, and therefore
00:00:26.260
it's made possible entirely through the support of our subscribers. So if you enjoy what we're
00:00:30.240
doing here, please consider becoming one. Welcome back to another episode of More From Sam. Hey Sam,
00:00:39.160
it was nice seeing you a few minutes ago and seeing you again here. A long time no see. Yeah, we just
00:00:43.880
did a Substack Live. I thought that was really good. Yeah, yeah. It actually kind of surprised me that
00:00:48.660
Live still feels like something different, right? I mean, obviously the experience of looking at a
00:00:53.880
camera and talking is identical, but just the knowledge that is live and that you can't take
00:00:58.320
any of your words back is somehow thrilling or gets your attention. So I like it. We didn't give
00:01:05.120
subscribers much heads up at all. We will do that in the future, but we just had thought of it at the
00:01:10.420
last minute. And anyone who would like to join us for one of those in the future, you can become a
00:01:15.660
subscriber and join us over there. We will give you more time. And I thought it was really cool that
00:01:21.060
we were able to take some questions from the audience and do that in real time. It's a different
00:01:25.400
experience being live than recording, but we'll do more of those and we'll see where we can learn and
00:01:30.800
figure out how to improve those. Yeah, it was fun. And I think we can record them. I don't know,
00:01:36.660
like in this case, I think it was just if you were in the room, you were in the room, you know,
00:01:40.960
which is frankly kind of nice, you know, to treat it like a live event as opposed to yet another
00:01:46.120
podcast, you know, piece of content that we're just going to record and put out there. So,
00:01:50.540
you know, I think we should give people a heads up so that they can, they can be there if they want
00:01:54.380
to be. All right. So I woke up this morning thinking about your conversation with Sarah
00:01:57.640
Longwell and Tim Miller from the Bulwark, that media empire they have, and just thinking why it
00:02:03.380
was so well-received by your audience. And I don't even know what their positions are on most issues,
00:02:07.540
but I'm sure they're more conservative than yours. They're conservatives, correct?
00:02:11.240
You know, I don't even know where there's daylight between us and interviews. I mean,
00:02:14.960
yes, they, they, you would expect there to be differences because they're both
00:02:18.420
formerly Republicans, right? So they, they're coming from the other side. They're both gay.
00:02:22.920
So that, I mean, I don't know how conservative they could be socially, but-
00:02:27.220
My point is it doesn't even matter. It seems like it didn't even matter anymore.
00:02:30.380
There was such a sense of relief hearing you guys speak together. It's almost like
00:02:33.440
we never really cared about some of those other differences. And we've realized that now we just
00:02:38.460
care about decency, decorum, sanity, having somebody on the other side, just see,
00:02:43.500
at least see everything the same way that you see things.
00:02:46.320
Yeah, yeah. And also they're, they're much closer to the political history there. I mean,
00:02:52.340
they're just, obviously having spent all their time right of center, they see how Trump and
00:02:57.920
Trumpism bent everything into this awful shape. And they, you know, they have relationships,
00:03:03.560
many more relationships than, than I had. They got distorted by these changes. So yeah,
00:03:09.720
it's great to talk to them. I'm just a huge fan of both those guys and they're just very fun.
00:03:13.200
And they're so trustworthy and likable. They just feel like, you know, listening to the three of
00:03:18.420
you talk, it just felt like, you know, three of my friends were getting together and I'm certain
00:03:22.720
the audience felt the same way that there was this FOMO. Like I just, I wish I could have been in there
00:03:26.740
with you guys. I saw a comment on YouTube and thought this was a nice note from them. It says,
00:03:31.400
as a progressive, I probably don't agree on many policy issues with Sarah and Tim,
00:03:34.840
but I've come to trust them to tell it straight over almost anyone else, including most of the
00:03:39.560
progressive podcasters I listened to. So I don't know. I mean, I'm, it just seems that everybody
00:03:44.180
liked hearing you guys speak. I can't help my mind thinking that there, you know, perhaps this,
00:03:49.540
we should make this a quarterly podcast crossover event where, you know, it appears on, on both
00:03:55.000
podcasts. I think the audiences would enjoy it. And then even putting a, maybe a few live dates
00:04:00.220
together, I'm getting ahead of myself, but I definitely think people would like to see
00:04:03.920
the three of you guys. I think they're touring. I think they're touring right now. They're going
00:04:07.560
to Minneapolis to do a live event there. I think I noticed, yeah. So people should check them. I
00:04:13.240
mean, they're taking their podcast on the road to some degree. So. Oh, I am certain they are a lot
00:04:18.140
of fun to hang out with. So good for them. According to the Wall Street Journal, President Donald
00:04:23.320
Trump's cryptocurrency firm, World Liberty Financial, it sounds so official, sold a $500 million
00:04:29.520
stake to a member of the Emirati royal family shortly before his inauguration last January.
00:04:33.840
Months later, the Trump administration agreed to supply the UAE with highly coveted American-made
00:04:38.640
AI chips. Now, we've talked about this before. Is there anything to add with this
00:04:42.620
latest information? No, it's just as tawdry and as dangerous and as self-serving and as corrupt as
00:04:49.520
anyone could have imagined, right? I mean, the crucial detail here is that we're giving chips,
00:04:54.460
our most advanced chips, to the UAE that does military exercises with China. And these are chips that
00:04:59.160
precisely the chips we don't want China to have. And we're not, we're relaxing those security concerns
00:05:04.320
because Trump and his family managed to get hundreds of millions, arguably billions in the
00:05:11.160
transaction. You know, so what's wrong with that? You know, if you pretended to care that Hunter Biden
00:05:15.440
got some money, you know, serving on a board in Ukraine that he was not qualified to serve on
00:05:20.760
because of his, the name association with Joe Biden, and you thought maybe even Joe Biden in the worst
00:05:26.400
case scenario got some of that money and you're looking at those, those emails. And when they say
00:05:30.860
10% to the big guy, you thought, oh, that's a smoking gun. How awful. Let's just destroy this guy's
00:05:36.460
presidency and burn everything down because of how corrupt and unseemly this is. You're that person
00:05:41.900
who cares about the integrity of our politics to that fine degree. Hunter Biden and his grifting are
00:05:49.100
intolerable. And yet now magically he's some, you know, look, go look in the mirror, see how much
00:05:54.000
you care about a president who's managed to extract billions of dollars over the course of months by
00:06:00.140
materially undermining the, the leadership role and military preparedness and actual safety of our
00:06:08.440
country on the world stage. Right. I mean, it's just, just like everything, our alliances have eroded
00:06:13.340
all of these tariffs, you know, whether you believe that he's earned a 1 billion or 4 billion,
00:06:19.080
depending on whose estimate you trust at this point, you know, he has just sold out our country
00:06:23.580
every which way he could. So as to profit and to have his family and friends profit.
00:06:29.080
I know we keep talking about AI, but it seems like the timelines keep moving up daily. I want you to
00:06:33.600
watch this clip from the CEO of Microsoft AI in a recent interview with the Financial Times. Let's play
00:06:38.960
that clip for Sam. You talk about superintelligence. Most of your rivals talk about AGI, artificial
00:06:46.760
general intelligence. Explain the difference between AGI and superintelligence. I prefer the
00:06:53.420
definition that focuses first on what would it take to build a system that could achieve most of the
00:07:00.500
tasks that a regular professional in a workplace goes about on a daily basis. Think of it as a
00:07:05.840
professional grade AGI. How close are we? I think that we're going to have a human level performance
00:07:11.440
on most, if not all, professional tasks. So white collar work, where you're sitting down at a computer,
00:07:18.640
either being, you know, a lawyer or an accountant or a project manager or a marketing person.
00:07:23.940
Most of those tasks will be fully automated by an AI within the next 12 to 18 months. And we can see
00:07:31.960
this in software engineering. Many software engineers report that they are now using AI-assisted coding
00:07:37.840
for the vast majority of their code production, which means that their role has shifted now to this
00:07:43.480
meta function of debugging, scrutinizing, of doing the strategic stuff like architecting, of, you know,
00:07:51.780
et cetera, et cetera, putting things into production. So it's a quite different relationship to the
00:07:55.940
technology. And that's happened in the last six months.
00:07:59.320
Well, so I know Mustafa a little bit, a very nice guy. And obviously he's, he's very close to this work.
00:08:04.420
I mean, he, he came from DeepMind. He was one of the founders of DeepMind and moved over to, to Microsoft.
00:08:11.380
So I, I think his prognostications are probably as credible as anybody's at this point. You know,
00:08:17.700
it's pretty alarming when you, when you think of the, the societal implications of you, if in a year
00:08:22.920
we have, um, the complete cancellation of the need for human cognition of the white collar type,
00:08:31.800
you know, I mean, that's, that's, I don't know how many people that is, but it's a lot of people.
00:08:35.540
And it's basically, um, certainly most of the high status jobs, right? I mean, the, one of the, um,
00:08:41.700
ironies and surprises here is that the robots are coming for the lawyers and doctors and software
00:08:48.600
engineers before they're coming for the janitors and massage therapists and nurses and plumbers.
00:08:54.960
And so if you went to college and incurred $200,000 in debt, and that degree enabled you to get to the
00:09:03.220
rung on the ladder with it, where you're currently standing, it's very likely that part of the ladder
00:09:09.040
is, um, in the process of disappearing, right? And the entire ladder, I mean, Mustafa is saying that
00:09:16.040
the ladder itself is, is, uh, evaporating. So what, what he's saying now is in principle already true
00:09:23.540
of the bottom rung. If you'd like to continue listening to this conversation, you'll need to
00:09:29.960
subscribe at samharris.org. Once you do, you'll get access to all full-length episodes of the Making
00:09:35.820
Sense podcast. The Making Sense podcast is ad-free and relies entirely on listener support. And you can