Making Sense - Sam Harris - April 07, 2026


#468 — More From Sam: Gratitude, Bad Conversations, Conspiracy Addiction, Waffle House Teleportation, and More

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
#467 — EA, AI, and the End of Work #469 — Escaping an Anti-Human Future

Episode Stats


Length

32 minutes

Words per minute

194.02

Word count

6,323

Sentence count

269

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

27

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Making Sense with Sam Harris, the show's host, Sam, sits down with writer and essayist Alex Blumberg to discuss Iran, AI, and what it means to be grateful for what we do have.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 You're listening to Making Sense with Sam Harris.
00:00:04 This is the free version of the podcast, so you'll only hear the first part of today's
00:00:07 conversation.
00:00:09 If you want the full episode and every episode, you can subscribe at samharris.org.
00:00:14 There are no ads on this show.
00:00:16 It runs entirely on subscriber support.
00:00:18 If you enjoy what we're doing here and find it valuable, please consider subscribing today.
00:00:24 Welcome back to another episode of More from Sam.
00:00:26 Once again, we are taping this live in front of subscribers where anything goes.
00:00:31 We've had them submit questions in advance of the show, and I will try to get to as many
00:00:34 of those as possible.
00:00:35 And then we've asked them to provide any follow-ups using the chat feature so that Sam can address
00:00:39 their feedback in real time.
00:00:41 This worked really well last week or last episode, I should say.
00:00:44 And it's very helpful to have a bunch of smart people feeding me lines.
00:00:47 So please keep those comments coming.
00:00:49 All right.
00:00:50 Before we get to our first topic, I just want to give a quick rundown of the guests you'll
00:00:54 be recording with on the podcast over the next few weeks.
00:00:56 we have Tristan Harris, Lloyd Blankfein, Rahm Emanuel, Francis Fukuyama, Ben Shapiro,
00:01:01 Michael Pollan, and Siddhartha Mukherjee. And that's just April.
00:01:05 Yeah, a lot coming up. Yeah.
00:01:07 Yeah. So if anyone wanted more content from you, got a lot coming up. And I'm hopeful that
00:01:12 you'll have another essay for us soon. Nobody does them quite like you do. And I'm certain
00:01:16 the audience agrees with me. All right, let's get to our first topic. We're going to get your
00:01:21 updated thoughts on Iran, AI, and other concerns. But first, a lot of people feel overwhelmed
00:01:26 by many things these days, including the pace of change and the fear of being left behind in an
00:01:30 increasingly AI-driven world. Yet, even with some legitimate fears, there's still so much to be
00:01:35 grateful for, but it feels like no matter how much better things get, things feel worse. Maybe
00:01:39 you could remind us what we still have to be grateful for and how to best navigate this moment.
00:01:46 Well, I think it's just useful to ask yourself the question. Even if your job in some sense is
00:01:52 to pay attention to risk or the downside of things or to criticize bad. I'm just thinking
00:01:58 personally how I navigate this. I spend a lot of time thinking about what's wrong and the needless
00:02:04 own goals we score on ourselves as a society. All of that can be depressing, but the filter I use
00:02:11 to do that is to ask myself, how unhappy do I have to be in the meantime? Is my being unhappy
00:02:17 contributing anything useful you know on the side of my own motivation to do any of this work or
00:02:23 my ability to communicate well about it or i mean just is it useful and you know almost always the
00:02:30 answer is no right so like there really is a potentially a radical disjunction between even
00:02:36 paying attention to scary and depressing things and being scared and depressed in one's life
00:02:42 moment to moment i mean i just i just think that second piece isn't actually necessary i'm not i'm
00:02:48 not saying there's there's never bleed through but it's um there can be surprisingly little when
00:02:53 you reflect on just how lucky you are moment to moment even with all the things you might be
00:02:59 concerned about so and obviously there are many people whose jobs are nothing like mine and they
00:03:04 they can withdraw their attention from current events and from you know things like existential
00:03:08 risk and they can do it knowing that for the most part they can't do anything about those
00:03:13 things right they're not they don't have a job that requires them to be up to the minute on
00:03:18 whatever it is you know pandemic risk or you know or nuclear proliferation or any other sort of
00:03:24 damocles that's hanging over our heads there is no good reason to um simply become morbid in the
00:03:31 way you pay attention to the world right i mean it's just not it's not useful right and so i really
00:03:37 think only mindfulness gives you the capacity to make these choices moment to moment i mean if you
00:03:42 really and if you don't know what i mean by mindfulness then there's really nothing there's
00:03:45 no um there's no foothold to grab there i mean you really just have to learn something about it
00:03:50 but if you can notice the moment to moment consequences of paying attention to things and
00:03:56 and and how you use your attention being consequential it allows you to decide you know
00:04:02 to kind of wisely curate the contents of your own consciousness and withdraw your attention
00:04:08 from things when that when your attention on them serves no good purpose and i don't know
00:04:12 just kind of break the addiction of being unhappy in the usual ways right i mean many of us get sort
00:04:17 of stuck in the rut of conforming to various patterns of attention and you you can just
00:04:23 decide to break break those habits so yeah obviously you can think in the stoical vein of
00:04:28 all the people in the world whose prayers would be answered if they could simply be in your exact
00:04:32 situation right now. I mean, think of all the bad things that haven't happened to you that if they
00:04:36 had, you know, what you'd pay just to get back to where you are right now. I mean, those are useful
00:04:40 reflections. But, you know, it is just in fact true that life is very, very good for so many of
00:04:45 us. And it's very easy not to be aware of that moment to moment. So how do you help people
00:04:50 navigate the anxiety around their jobs if they think that their job's going to be going away?
00:04:54 I mean, so many people are talking about right now, is it going to be months?
00:04:57 Is it going to be weeks?
00:04:59 Maybe a little bit longer before I lose my job.
00:05:01 And if you're looking out there looking for a job right now, if you're a young kid out
00:05:05 of college, it's great if you have expertise in good taste because AI sort of plays like
00:05:10 this infinite boardroom for you of experts.
00:05:13 But if you don't have the experience and the higher skilled people aren't going to hire
00:05:18 you, the anxiety is real.
00:05:21 I mean, how does mindfulness help those people who are looking to...
00:05:23 Well, so specifically on that point, I mean, I think, I don't think you can, you can boycott
00:05:27 AI at this point.
00:05:28 I mean, I just, I think the right thing to do is figure out how to use it in beneficial
00:05:33 ways, you know, for your career and for your personal life.
00:05:36 I just think it's, I mean, some people can ignore it, but for the most part, certainly
00:05:40 if you're in any kind of job or hoping to be in a job that focuses on information, I
00:05:45 mean, if it's a job you can do sitting behind a desk, I think AI needs to become your friend
00:05:50 leaving aside all of the other issues we might have about it and the other concerns about
00:05:54 alignment and all of that. I think in the limit, when we start to see the real evaporation of
00:06:02 jobs because of how good AI is getting, we as a society are going to have to figure out how
00:06:07 to navigate that. And that I think is probably coming sooner than many people expect. I think
00:06:13 it is definitely coming. Many people expect that it's not coming. AI is just going to create a
00:06:18 bunch of new jobs that we don't have names for yet. And really, there will be no radical
00:06:22 displacement. I think that's just happy talk. But there are people who, there are smart people who
00:06:26 believe that by analogy to previous breakthroughs in technology. But I do think, I think we as a
00:06:31 society are going to have to figure out how to absorb productivity gains that don't ultimately
00:06:37 entail people becoming more productive, right? I mean, so that the AI starts doing work that
00:06:43 people are doing now and um there's job cancellation i think that's coming people can't solve that by
00:06:49 themselves though really i mean once it comes at any kind of scale society has to solve it 0.62
00:06:53 well i get that but i'm talking about the delta between where the shit gets bad and before it 0.81
00:06:58 gets better and so for people like you say make ai your friend that's great because you have good 0.92
00:07:03 taste and expertise so you can tell ai what you want but if you're somebody on the other's other
00:07:08 into that and you're somebody whose job it is to do admin or coordination or some of the other
00:07:13 tasks, if you're a paralegal or even a junior lawyer or any of the other examples, again,
00:07:20 the anxiety is real. How does mindfulness help here? How do people navigate it? Because I mean,
00:07:25 again, I understand what you're saying is so much of it, it's in our heads, but there is a reality
00:07:29 that this is different. Mindfulness helps with everything because in each moment, there's either
00:07:34 There's something for you to do or there isn't, right?
00:07:36 So if there's something for you to do, well, then you just do that thing, right?
00:07:40 I mean, again, this applies even in emergencies, right?
00:07:42 The house is on fire, and you now need to get your kids out to safety, and so you have
00:07:48 to escape, right?
00:07:49 So action's required, and you don't need to suffer over performing that action.
00:07:55 You just have to do the thing, right?
00:07:57 Now, if there's nothing you can do to change your situation or to change the risk you're
00:08:02 confronting, well, then your misery is adding nothing to that occasion either. Now, in either
00:08:07 case, your misery is extra, right? Now, this can be a high bar to clear for people who don't have
00:08:13 a mindfulness practice, but once you do, you can actually differentiate these components to your
00:08:19 engagement, you know, with your life, moment to moment. I mean, you can have a highly energized,
00:08:26 you know, motivated, even adrenalized experience that isn't a miserable one, right? You can be
00:08:31 responding to an emergency and not be miserable. You can be making decisions over a longer time
00:08:36 horizon that entail a lot, that are, you know, kind of scary decisions, right? It's like you
00:08:40 could say, okay, now I need a surgery and it's, you know, in two weeks I'm going to have a surgery
00:08:45 which I'm, you know, anxious about, right? But, you know, all things considered, it is just the
00:08:49 right decision and now I've got, now the surgery's on the calendar and now I've got this thing looming
00:08:54 and so, okay, so now, but now the question is, over the next 14 days, how much time are you going
00:08:59 to spend being miserable because you're anxious about the surgery. All of those moments are
00:09:04 discretionary once you know how to be mindful. Once you've decided what you have to do, there
00:09:09 really is no more to think about, really, right? Now, you will helplessly be knocked around by
00:09:14 your thoughts, but that's where mindfulness comes in. And again, if you don't have a mindfulness
00:09:19 practice, you are going to be the mere hostage of those thoughts, right? So you'll be as anxious
00:09:24 and as fearful and as worried and as sleepless as you'll be because your mind is completely out of
00:09:30 control for the next two weeks. But there simply is no alternative to mental training once you
00:09:38 get into a situation like that. I mean, the time to develop a mindfulness practice is before you
00:09:43 really need it, not when you're in the middle of that maelstrom. But it really, I mean, it is there
00:09:48 this is a capacity you can develop and it really does provide relief. I mean, every time you find
00:09:56 yourself suffering, you can recognize that you're thinking without noticing that you're thinking
00:10:01 and then wake up from that dream. And it doesn't change the fact that you still might have to have
00:10:05 surgery in two weeks, right? But again, all of the suffering that precedes it is unnecessary
00:10:10 and the same will be true afterwards, right? I mean, again, you're just going to be in the
00:10:16 company of your thoughts 99% of the time. Well, speaking of relief, the New York Times reports
00:10:21 that after decades of religious decline, people have stopped leaving churches. Now, it doesn't
00:10:25 point to a revival necessarily, but maybe people like the feeling of something familiar in uncertain
00:10:30 times. How does that sit with you? That might be, yeah. I just don't know how durable that
00:10:36 change is. I mean, the larger trend is of kind of a massively secularizing change in our culture
00:10:44 over the last you know quarter century but um no i could well imagine people want community and they
00:10:50 want you know real world experiences and it's comforting to be inside a church and i love
00:10:55 churches right you know i love sitting in churches so i get it but yeah i don't know i don't know what
00:11:01 to draw from that headline well i want to play a video for you and get your thoughts on this can
00:11:06 we play the um rubio clip speaking of religion here we were all created every single one of us
00:11:14 before the beginning of time by the hands of the god of the universe an all-powerful god did you
00:11:19 see this no and created us for the purpose of living with him in eternity god this is rubio
00:11:25 the atheists don't make content anywhere near this inspiring 1.00
00:11:29 took on the form of a man and came down and lived among us i don't find this inspiring this is oh
00:11:35 that music died like a man all right i think we'll see enough yeah okay yeah i i mean i haven't
00:11:41 really tracked uh rubio's level of religious fanaticism i mean you know i want to when i
00:11:46 think of someone like pete hegseth i get quite worried because he clearly is someone who's
00:11:51 making decisions based on his bible thumping but well i was going to ask you that because i thought
00:11:56 like if you had to pick one Republican to take over in 2028, if you had to do that, I would have
00:12:01 assumed it would have been someone like a Rubio. And then seeing this video, I thought, wait a
00:12:05 second, where did this come from? But even with this video, I'd still think. I mean, who knows
00:12:09 what this guy believes, right? This is very few people have shown themselves to be this malleable
00:12:16 in the face of, you know, political imperatives. You know, he is someone who rightly identified
00:12:24 had Trump as a con man who was destroying conservatism, and now he's secretary of state 0.96
00:12:29 and just a odious lickspittle. I mean, so I think the only reason why I view him differently 0.65
00:12:36 from someone like Pete Hegseth is that he was a sort of normal politician with a normal degree
00:12:43 of qualifications for his role, right? So he's not egregiously unqualified to be secretary of
00:12:50 state or president or any other. I mean, he's just, he's a normal, normal candidate for these
00:12:56 kinds of roles. Whereas, you know, Pete Hegseth is mostly a Fox News personality, though he can
00:13:02 bench press 300 plus pounds, which is genuinely impressive and just a proper religious maniac 0.99
00:13:08 by all appearances. So he seems quite a bit scarier to me, but yeah, maybe this is sincere
00:13:14 from Rubio. I don't know. I mean, he's just, he's just a shape-shifting opportunist as far as I can
00:13:19 help speaking of people sound like religious maniacs did you see that um video i want to play
00:13:23 this for you of greg phillips from fema who claimed that he had time traveled to a waffle house
00:13:29 i forgot who it was yeah i know the story yeah can we play that clip real fast we had a teleport
00:13:36 incident two of them um which uh which transported me about uh 40 miles from
00:13:45 from where I was in near Albany, Georgia, to the ditch of a church. I ended up at a
00:13:55 Waffle House like 50 miles away from where I was. It was an incredibly frightening moment
00:14:01 to experience yourself in your car flying through the air. It was possible. It was real.
00:14:09 i want to be hanging out with her after that interview ended jesus he's at fema yeah we can
00:14:21 all sleep peacefully at night knowing that that our emergencies will be responded to by
00:14:25 a man who's convinced of the physics of teleportation who among us hasn't teleported
00:14:31 at some point to a waffle house jesus i think 50 miles is reasonable yeah he would have claimed 0.95
00:14:36 500 i thought he was shit yes to be unconscious while driving 50 miles that seems normal i think 0.85
00:14:43 you've had ambient ambient experiences like that i don't think it's been that far unbelievable 0.96
00:14:48 uh the last time we went to the moon you were a kid how do you feel about this latest mission to
00:14:54 the moon i'm amazed at how little bandwidth it's taken up for anybody i mean i i haven't seen
00:14:59 me in a different time we would see a lot of press coverage of this i haven't seen
00:15:05 nearly as much as you know it's sort of at the level of this guy teleporting to a waffle house
00:15:10 in my algorithm i mean i think it's great i you know i i think it's amazing that we do this
00:15:15 this sort of thing but it's amazing how little bandwidth we have for nice news stories like that
00:15:22 yeah we had a very uniting if short-lived moment when the u.s hockey team won the gold medal earlier
00:15:27 this year do you do you think this mission will do anything for us on that level uh maybe when
00:15:32 they have a parade when they get home or no one's going to care? No, I think we're pretty jaded at
00:15:38 this moment and distracted for obvious reasons. I'd be surprised if the ticker tape parade got
00:15:44 much coverage. There'll be 100,000 old people on CNN watching it. Right, like the Rose Parade?
00:15:49 Yeah. What do you think we could do as a society to bring us closer together? Is there anything
00:15:53 we could do right now? Get off social media. I think that would be to uncouple us from all the
00:15:59 maniacs from the you know the 10 percent of us that are that are trolls and lunatics and bots 0.71
00:16:03 and grifters and uh just dial down some of that noise so that we can get a little more signal i 0.96
00:16:09 think that would that would be good if all the social media people pulled the plug on social
00:16:14 media i think they would all deserve i told jack dorsey this you know when he was running twitter
00:16:19 if he just pulled the plug on twitter saying sorry this just this didn't work out guys he
00:16:24 would deserve the noble peace prize and and uh i think that's still true it's probably even more
00:16:28 true now. I'm going to shift topics here. It's a great question from a Substack subscriber.
00:16:34 You said conversations with people you strongly disagree with can be unproductive, hard to fact
00:16:38 check in real time, prone to confusion. But you've also argued that conversations are only
00:16:42 alternative to violence. And your early debates on religion showed you engaging calmly and
00:16:47 rigorously across deep disagreement. In recent years, many of your guests seem to largely share
00:16:52 your views with differences mostly in emphasis. There's a real value in surfacing expertise,
00:16:57 reinforcing important ideas, but do you worry it comes at the cost of one of your genuine strengths,
00:17:02 modeling how to engage thoughtfully with opposition? Most real-world disagreements
00:17:06 are messy and emotionally charged. Isn't there still value in demonstrating how to navigate
00:17:12 those well, even if the conversation isn't perfectly clean? Yeah, up to a point. I mean,
00:17:17 I think some of those conversations are useful, and I keep looking for the ones that I think will
00:17:21 be useful. I mean, I think there's generally greater utility in when there's something to
00:17:27 learn about an issue or something to figure out, bringing on someone who really knows their stuff
00:17:32 and just, you know, helping me learn more in real time in front of my audience. So I'm thinking
00:17:38 about, you know, the consequences of Trumpism and having Trump for a second term, you know,
00:17:42 and just the way the rest of the world perceives us and, you know, the loss of American leadership
00:17:47 and et cetera, all of that.
00:17:49 If I bring on someone who I know I'm going to agree with, but who just knows much more
00:17:54 about certain details than I do, I bring on someone like Anne Applebaum, right, who can
00:17:58 just give me the view from the other side of the world with much more historical context
00:18:03 and who's just deep in the weeds on the way propaganda works and the way democracies unravel
00:18:10 and all the relevant historical analogies, right?
00:18:13 I'm not going to disagree with Ann about much, if anything, but that's not the point.
00:18:17 The point is to hear what she has to say and to learn a little bit more each time I do
00:18:22 that.
00:18:22 I think that's usually more useful than me getting some person on who stridently disagrees
00:18:30 with a position I already have, and I just know going into it that it's just going to
00:18:34 be an exercise in my attempting to showcase their errors, which I already understand to
00:18:41 be errors.
00:18:41 right? So someone who doesn't really understand jihadism at all and doesn't believe in it and
00:18:45 thinks it's all economics and politics and bluffing, okay, I can get that person on for
00:18:50 another two-hour round of, you know, brain damage. But it really is just brain damage, right? Now,
00:18:56 it's not to say that it's not going to be useful for some people in the audience to see me hit
00:19:01 those pitches again and again. But I've done it so many times, I'm not sure about the value of
00:19:07 continuing to do it and and it also runs the risk of being confusing to some people anyway because
00:19:14 certain moves are reliably confusing right well i think people like the conversations you're having
00:19:20 i think it's just it feels as though you've been just avoiding the chance at having a bad conversation
00:19:25 and they feel that many of them can learn from a bad conversation i just don't see like i like
00:19:31 who are we talking about i mean like i'm going to talk to someone like hassan piker would that be
00:19:35 fun no not really i mean it just i i don't think i don't think anyone should be listening to this
00:19:40 guy right so it's like it just seems like well that's a different point i think what they're
00:19:44 saying is there are bad conversations that they're constantly having and they can still learn how to
00:19:50 have a good conversation in a bad conversation or how to navigate a bad conversation and with you 0.95
00:19:55 lately just saying fuck it i'm not going to have bad conversations anymore because this is not 0.96
00:19:59 the best use of my time or i'm not going to spend two hours on this i think that a lot of people 0.98
00:20:04 are saying, well, even from those bad conversations, I don't think they mean the
00:20:07 Omar Z's conversation examples. Well, I mean, so I'm going to talk to Ben Shapiro. I anticipate
00:20:12 that being a potentially bad conversation, at least for half of it. I mean, half of it will
00:20:18 agree about certain things, but part of it will be exposing a fair amount of daylight between us
00:20:24 around Trump and current American politics. So I'm going to go into that thinking we both might
00:20:30 get somewhat uptight in this conversation, at least for part of it. And I'm not avoiding it.
00:20:35 I think it's useful because Ben is a serious enough person with a big enough audience that
00:20:40 it's useful to try to kind of make some sense in his direction. Would I talk to Candace Owens? I
00:20:46 don't think so. I mean, she's got an even larger audience, but she's a total lunatic. And I'm not 1.00
00:20:53 sure, I mean, apart from, I mean, I could approach it the way I approached the conversation with
00:20:58 Doug Wilson, the pastor who I knew just how far out he was as a fundamentalist, but I
00:21:05 approached that differently than I might have.
00:21:09 I mean, I was not looking for conflict.
00:21:10 I was looking, I trust, in that case, I trusted my audience to understand what's wrong with
00:21:16 a pastor who will sign off on maybe one day bringing chattel slavery back because it's 0.97
00:21:21 in the Bible, right?
00:21:22 So that's obvious enough that I can, I don't have to dunk on that point.
00:21:27 i don't have to say oh well like i just hope it's clear that i'm against chattel slavery i mean so
00:21:31 it's just you can just be more of an anthropologist there rather than a you know somebody who's going
00:21:36 to dig in and really have a debate you know my conversation with ross doubt that right like we
00:21:41 did not agree that was had the quality of a debate about religion i think he's more of a
00:21:47 religious extremist than people appreciate and i i feel some of that came out in our conversation
00:21:52 i mean he's surprisingly extreme in his claims to to you know his faith claims given that he's
00:22:01 also trying to function as a normal journalist at the new york times so those are not totally
00:22:06 those are somewhat adversarial conversations but they're not to talk to someone like i don't know
00:22:11 again i just brought up hassan piker at random someone like him i mean he's just kind of a
00:22:15 performance artist. I mean, he's a deeply confused, I think, fairly amoral, fairly juvenile person in
00:22:24 his ethics, right? I mean, he's just a, and he's just a bit of a nutcase and dishonest. And so 0.99
00:22:29 it's just, it's such a mess. I mean, there's so much bad faith that you have to anticipate going
00:22:34 into a conversation like that. My first question is why do it? Because it can stand the chance of
00:22:40 being genuinely confusing, certainly to anyone who's sort of in his audience, right? Because
00:22:46 there's just so much, it's asymmetric warfare. It's so much easier to make a mess than to clean
00:22:51 it up, right? That's why I wouldn't talk to someone like RFK Jr. I mean, RFK Jr. is basically
00:22:55 a nutcase, right? I mean, there's something wrong with the guy. He's a liar, absolutely a liar, 0.95
00:23:01 but he's also a kind of a confabulator. He's a bullshit artist. And also I just think a little 1.00
00:23:06 crazy, right? So he's, you're dealing with all of that. It's very hard to do in real time. Again,
00:23:12 for the kinds of things he's crazy about, what you want is someone who's deep in the weeds on
00:23:19 the science of vaccines and immunology and just, you know, virology and all of it, right? So I'm
00:23:25 the wrong guy to have that conversation. I've always said that. It's not to say I couldn't
00:23:28 take a month of my life and get up to speed on some of that, but it's just not worth a month
00:23:32 of my life to do that. So all of it is just, at this point, you have to have a life is too short
00:23:39 module in your brain and consult it occasionally. And for many of these conversations that people
00:23:44 seem to want me to have, I have to say life is too short for many of them. It's not to say, I mean,
00:23:50 given the right candidate, you know, I might jump at the chance. Again, I mean, you know,
00:23:55 the monk debates, I think, they asked me to debate Tucker Carlson, and I was surprised
00:24:00 to find myself saying yes without any reservation, really, because Tucker has become such a fixture
00:24:07 in our politics. But that seems to have evaporated. So I don't know what happened there. I'm sure he
00:24:12 said no. But so I would do that. I would do something like that. But again, it really has
00:24:18 to be worth it. Well, Rogan has said he doesn't want to talk to you publicly until you've debated
00:24:22 Brett Weinstein. Is that something you consider doing?
00:24:25 Oh, well, no. I mean, for the same reasons, I wouldn't debate RFK Jr. I mean, it's just
00:24:30 It's very disconcerting not to know whether someone has lost their mind, right?
00:24:37 Because when you look at someone like Brett Speak, he just seems to be the picture of
00:24:42 reasonableness, right?
00:24:43 He's not getting blown around by his emotional life, certainly not in any obvious way when
00:24:49 he's certainly not on a podcast with Rogan.
00:24:52 So he's not an Alex Jones-like character where you look at the way he's delivering the lines
00:24:58 and you think, okay, this is kind of a case study in, in, you know, chemical imbalance or something,
00:25:04 right? Like what we need is a psychopharmacologist before anything else happens here so that we can,
00:25:09 we can try to get this guy back to some physiological baseline. That's not happening
00:25:12 with Brett at all. And yet the things he says are equivalently crazy and the certitude with which he
00:25:18 says them, it's totally indefensible, right? So you take his recent appearance on Rogan and you
00:25:25 stick his claims into any LLM and what you get is just a litany of obvious errors. And I did that
00:25:32 for Joe. I sent him a link to my chat GPT session. Like, Joe, just here's a sanity check. Listen to
00:25:39 what the robots say about what Brett was giving you on this most recent podcast. And he didn't
00:25:43 seem to want to do that. So he's still convinced that Brett was right about everything, though
00:25:47 Brett thinks that 17 million people were killed outright by the vaccines and that ivermectin is
00:25:52 still worth taking. I don't know how to interact with that, but what it requires is if it were
00:25:58 going to be done at all. I mean, Brett is just the right, you know, Brett is not someone to take
00:26:01 seriously on this topic, but you know, if you were forced to take him seriously because he's
00:26:05 made so much noise about it, what you want is someone who's deeper in the weeds on the relevant
00:26:10 science than either of us are and let that guy or gal have the debate. And that's what I urged
00:26:17 joe to do i mean joe was wrong there i wasn't urging that i do a post-mortem on covid about
00:26:23 you know rfk jr or or brett or anyone else any other lunatic he's had on his podcast i was urging
00:26:29 that he have the relevant experts do it right i mean is that it's not my wheelhouse right it
00:26:34 shouldn't you know i'm not going to unlike many of these guys i'm not going to pretend it's my
00:26:39 wheelhouse uh knowing that i can be a quick study and and uh sound like i know what i'm talking
00:26:45 about. I'm not an immunologist. I'm not a virologist. I'm not an epidemiologist. You want
00:26:51 to be all three of those things. Like everyone else on the internet? Yeah, yeah, to have this
00:26:55 conversation responsibly. But I know enough of what mainstream science thinks about what happened
00:27:01 during COVID to know that Brett doesn't make any sense on this topic. Yeah, another question while
00:27:06 we're on Rogan. You've been critical of Rogan's irresponsibility in the spread of misinformation,
00:27:09 but he's taken basically the same approach since he was bullshitting stoned in his living room with
00:27:14 an audience of a few thousand. Not his fault. His audience has become huge. Isn't the real problem
00:27:18 that the epistemic institutions have trashed their credibility and the audience is lacking
00:27:23 discernment? Well, it's both, but I think I sent you this clip of, um, that the algorithm served
00:27:28 me of, of Joe talking to Theo Vaughn and Theo was, you know, just kind of melting down around his
00:27:34 anxiety about everything. It seemed, um, super worried about the war in Iran and, and, um,
00:27:39 worried about Israel, I guess. I mean, I forget about some of the specifics of the clip, but
00:27:45 they went on for like 10 minutes, kind of casting doubt on everything. And then they had seemed to
00:27:49 have a lot of time for some, I think it was CIA conspiracy theory, which was getting delivered
00:27:55 to them on what looked like a short YouTube clip or a TikTok video by someone they liked. And it
00:28:00 was probably a rehash of MKUltra or some old story about the CIA putting LSD in the water,
00:28:06 or something they did in the 1950s.
00:28:08 But, you know, it was a-
00:28:10 Which they need to do again now.
00:28:11 Yeah, but it was a completely paranoid story 0.97
00:28:13 about the CIA trying to make us all dumb 0.99
00:28:16 so we'll be more bovine and compliant. 0.99
00:28:19 And, I mean, the image I got
00:28:21 is just two kind of pyromaniacs 0.58
00:28:24 just lighting matches
00:28:25 on a landscape that they had spent years
00:28:28 soaking in gasoline, right?
00:28:30 It's like there's, I mean,
00:28:32 and this really is,
00:28:33 it's relevant how large the audience is for this. It's relevant just how much cultural damage is
00:28:39 being done every time these guys basically play the just asking questions routine on socially
00:28:48 combustible topics with tens of millions of people listening, right? It's just, it's completely
00:28:54 irresponsible. It is genuinely dangerous. It's genuinely corrosive of our culture. It's genuinely
00:28:59 misleading of their audience. And because they're not journalists, they feel no responsibility to
00:29:05 get their facts straight. They certainly don't correct their errors. And I mean, they don't
00:29:10 have the mechanism by which to correct their errors. It's just not...
00:29:12 They'll even admit that this might be some tinfoil...
00:29:16 I think Theo said that in the middle of this clip. Yeah, like this might be tinfoil hat time.
00:29:20 But still, they're still just flicking matches at everything, right? And the worst thing about
00:29:26 all of this, is there addiction to a conspiratorial framing of everything? That is, if you can
00:29:33 extract any lesson from what's happened to our politics in the last decade and the role that
00:29:40 people like Rogan have played in the unraveling of everything and the way in which social media
00:29:46 has weaponized all this and the rise of people like Tucker and Candace and Nick Fuentes and
00:29:51 And the fact that we've got Trump a second time around and central to all of it is this
00:29:57 addiction to conspiracy thinking and contrarianism and, you know, what I've called the pornography
00:30:04 of doubt, right?
00:30:05 And Joe has been as addicted as anyone and has brought it to scale perhaps more than
00:30:12 anyone.
00:30:13 And it's totally unprincipled.
00:30:15 It is genuinely confusing to millions of people. 1.00
00:30:18 I mean, you've got young people getting raised on a diet of this bullshit. 1.00
00:30:22 It's divisive. 1.00
00:30:24 It amplifies the worst in us.
00:30:26 And it's undermining of, you know, yes, our institutions have done something to lose credibility,
00:30:32 right?
00:30:33 They have become politicized in ways that they shouldn't have become politicized.
00:30:36 Yes, all of that's true. 0.93
00:30:37 The remedy for that is not a torrent of bullshit from podcasts and the platforming of proper 0.96
00:30:44 lunatics and people who think they were denied the Nobel Prize when they have almost no scientific 0.97
00:30:49 reputations to protect. No, the remedy is more good science and good journalism and real
00:30:56 intellectual integrity and holding institutions to account in serious ways, not spreading lies
00:31:02 and half-truths and cockamamie conspiracy theories. And I mean, really, you'd look at that
00:31:08 clip of uh joe and theo who are both good guys i mean i mean that what the paradox here for me
00:31:15 ethically is that this what i'm talking about is a species of evil right given its consequences
00:31:20 it's a species of evil right it's it is like at the top of the list of what ails us in our society
00:31:27 it is the thing that is preventing us from solving real problems in this world there's no question
00:31:32 it is getting people killed and will continue to get people killed it is absolutely toxic and yet
00:31:38 many of the people participating in this are just good guys who are just having fun, who are just
00:31:42 entertaining. They think there's no stakes, right? They're just like athletes, right? They're just
00:31:48 having fun. They're just playing a game. Joe's just playing a game. But it's a game with real
00:31:52 consequences, right? It's like, how would you play tennis if you knew that every time you lost a
00:31:58 point, people would die, right? I mean, that's the kind of game that's being played with information
00:32:04 now. And so people like Joe and Elon and people who have audiences in the tens and even hundreds
00:32:11 of millions have a real responsibility to get their heads out of their asses. And they're not 0.97
00:32:17 showing any aptitude for doing that. I'm going to move to another question. I don't like that
00:32:21 you seem to use the term woke in the same pejorative way that those on the right do.
00:32:34 podcast player.