Making Sense - Sam Harris - October 01, 2026


#495 β€” Foreign Policy for Sale

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
#494 β€” A Coin Toss for the Future #496 β€” The Oldest Lie

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

173.31

Word count

3,130

Sentence count

167

Harmful content

Hate speech

18

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 you're listening to making sense with sam harris this is the free version of the podcast so you'll
00:00:06 only hear the first part of today's conversation if you want the full episode and every episode
00:00:11 you can subscribe at sam harris.org there are no ads on this show it runs entirely on subscriber
00:00:18 support if you enjoy what we're doing here and find it valuable please consider subscribing today
00:00:22 i am here with ann applebaum and it's great to see you again thanks for having me
00:00:29 I must confess, I bring you on because you're one of the great observers of the unraveling of America and our stature on the world stage, but also I really always have a covert agenda, hoping you will perform psychic surgery on a few primary relationships in my life where I've got some very close friends who have been unconcerned all the while about what is happening in America, and I have not gotten through to them, and I keep hoping you will.
00:00:59 You're really the first person on the A-team who I'm drafting, again, covertly.
00:01:05 I'm making it explicit now, but you're performing the work of important relationships in my
00:01:10 life, so keep going.
00:01:11 I'll do my best.
00:01:12 Okay.
00:01:13 And I'm sure this is true for many people in the audience as well.
00:01:16 So, well, I want to use your recent Atlantic cover story as a jumping off point where you
00:01:21 discuss how American foreign policy has become an instrument of corruption in a way that
00:01:28 we really haven't seen. And there's this ideological and even in your terms, revolutionary
00:01:35 agenda to spread this kind of graft and lawlessness beyond our borders and to make common
00:01:43 cause with authoritarian regimes that already operate this way. What do most people do you
00:01:49 think not understand about the level of corruption we're seeing in the second Trump term?
00:01:55 So first of all, I think people don't understand the degree to which, as you say, this is a revolutionary project. That means that there is a team of people. It's not Trump himself. Trump has his own agenda, his own narcissistic agenda, his desire to win at all costs and so on.
00:02:13 But there is a group of people around him who are very happy to destroy existing institutions and bureaucracies and customs and to replace them with themselves, essentially.
00:02:29 And in the case of foreign policy, what this looks like is clearing away diplomacy, removing experts, removing ways of doing business that Americans have stuck to for the last 70, 80, 90, maybe 100 years, and instead substituting business people, friends of friends of the president, in some cases ideologues, and letting them be the voice and the face of America.
00:02:59 And the reason I compare it to a revolution is that when you have a revolution, there's always an ideological component, right? There's a big idea. And then the people bearing the big idea knock things down. But then lots of other people come in after them and alongside them.
00:03:14 And in the case of this American Revolution, we have different kinds of ideologues. We have people who believe in their version of what they would call Western civilization or white supremacy. There are Christian nationalists who want to replace the American secular state with a Christian state. There are people who want to destroy what they call the administrative state, which the rest of us call the American government.
00:03:37 And then there are people who want to take advantage of the vacuum and make money out of it.
00:03:43 And I think the consistency of it and the frequency of the patterns, whether it's in Canada, whether it's in Latin America, whether it's in Europe, whether it's in Asia, is pretty overwhelming.
00:03:54 And a lot of it gets reported.
00:03:56 You know, there are stories here and there, but it's very rarely put together and explained as a pattern.
00:04:03 So just for example, you know, it's pretty clear that the Trump administration inside
00:04:08 the state department elsewhere in the government have people who are interested in building
00:04:15 ties between the U.S. government and the far right, especially in Europe, because they
00:04:19 care a lot about what they would call European civilization.
00:04:23 And it also happens that a lot of the far right parties are parties who are so-called
00:04:27 enemies of regulation or libertarians.
00:04:30 And that means those are political parties who oppose regulation. And so therefore, you often have cryptocurrency companies supporting them because they don't want to be regulated or tech companies supporting them who don't want to be regulated. And so you have a team really of ideologues plus tech plus crypto working together, for example, to support the AFD in Germany, the far right party or the far right in France or in Poland or Romania.
00:04:56 And this is now, you know, this is American foreign policy. You would have more and better and closer relations between many people in the Trump administration and opposition parties, because these are for the moment opposition parties in Europe, whom they would like to help have come to power rather than with the governments themselves.
00:05:16 And that's pretty new. You know, you can say America has done terrible things in its foreign policy over the last many decades, but supporting far-right political movements in Europe in order to overthrow existing governments, in order maybe to take apart the European Union, which is seen by some American companies as a hassle, this is a new way of operating on the world stage.
00:05:40 And so, you know, pay attention to the details because it's in the details that you understand the story.
00:05:46 Well, I think I can forgive many people for being confused about a lot of this because, I mean, so for instance, when you talk about support for the far right or let's say the AFD in Germany, I can imagine there are gradations of this kind of ideological capture, which, and some of which I think I'm in touch with personally.
00:06:07 Obviously, I have no fondness for the far right anywhere, but I understand the, quote, 0.52
00:06:12 civilizational concerns when you look at the problem of Islamism and unchecked immigration,
00:06:19 you know, the level of anti-Semitism.
00:06:20 It's hard to imagine that the far right in the end is a friend to the Jews, but the anti-Semitism
00:06:25 on the left and the kind of so-called red-green alliance, the leftist Islamist alliance that
00:06:32 we've seen, perhaps we'll come back to that at the end of this conversation.
00:06:35 I can see how there are people who don't see the risk of a group like the AFD just deciding that, well, there's nobody else to do the job of defending Western civilization and open societies, you know, liberal values, free speech, et cetera, from their genuine enemies.
00:06:56 And so, you know, there might be some aspects of this that we don't want to support.
00:07:01 But if we can cut a few regulations as well, that's all to the good.
00:07:05 You know, I'm not a Nazi.
00:07:06 These guys aren't Nazis.
00:07:08 What's the problem here?
00:07:10 We're just recognizing that there are very few voices left of center who are willing to do this particular job.
00:07:16 So that's, first of all, not exactly true.
00:07:19 And I don't know, you probably don't want to break it down country by country.
00:07:22 But I live in Poland part of the time, and the Polish government, which is a centrist, center-right governmentβ€”actually, at the moment, it's a coalition between the, I would say, center-left and center-rightβ€”has been stricter on immigration than the previous government, which was a far-right government or a nationalist government, as it would have defined itself.
00:07:42 You know, in most European countries right now, there are one or two exceptions, you have a very clear change of emphasis in policy. So it's not true that borders are open. It's not true that people are flooding in. It's not true that civilization is in danger in the way that the ideologues would have you believe.
00:08:03 On the contrary, the problem with the far right parties, I mean, again, they're different in each country and they have different roles and so on. But if you just stick to the AFD, the AFD is a pro-Russian party. It's openly and aggressively pro-Russian. It does have neo-Nazis in its team of members of parliament. It does seek to change the nature of the modern German state. 0.67
00:08:26 It would pull Germany out of the European Union, as it says it would. This would cause profound economic chaos and disorder. It looks to me from theβ€”I've been following it for a long timeβ€”it's a party that's really interested in undermining Europe, in removing the judicial and the legal boundaries that have made Germany such an important, stabilizing influence in Europe over the last many decades.
00:08:54 So, you know, it's also a strange position for the U.S. government, which is on the one hand calling on Europeans to defend themselves, calling for the rearmament of Germany, which has begun. And so there's a strange question. So you're going to rearm Germany, okay, and then you're going to hand Germany over to a political party that talks about Western Poland as German territory, and you're going to hand it over to a party that doesn't want to use the weapons to fight Russia, so who else is it going to use to fight them?
00:09:23 it's a peculiar group of people. 0.52
00:09:25 It's not, you know, their central issue
00:09:28 is not saving anything that you would recognize
00:09:31 as Western civilization.
00:09:33 So it's a, you know, when you delve into the,
00:09:36 when you get away from the stereotypes
00:09:38 and you delve into who the people are,
00:09:41 what exactly we're doing,
00:09:42 why exactly we're supporting them,
00:09:44 it all looks a lot uglier.
00:09:46 But of course, it's not the only,
00:09:48 that was not the only argument of my article.
00:09:50 The other part of the argument was that
00:09:53 The use of many of this, you know, there's a kind of ideological hard line, but there are also ways in which U.S. companies, and especially companies close to Trump, are using American foreign policy to do business.
00:10:06 And I think that's part of the story in Europe as well.
00:10:08 Well, in your response there, you turned up yet more evidence of how hard this is to parse. I mean, take the rearmament of Germany. One of the only silver linings anyone has conceded to the chaos that Trump has introduced on the world stage and the unraveling of the world order as a result has been that Europe has acknowledged that it should take responsibility for its own defense, right?
00:10:38 that relying entirely on the U.S. was untenable, we had a massive free rider problem, and it's all
00:10:44 to the good that Europe is rearming, and yet now you've shown a possible negative implication of
00:10:52 that. How would you assess just that piece on its own? So the reason Europe is rearming is not
00:11:00 because of Donald Trump. Europe is rearming because Europe has now a very clear threat on
00:11:07 its eastern border that europe has finally understood and it took a long time you wouldn't
00:11:12 credit trump's lack of um consistency as an ally as part of that certainly trump's lack of
00:11:18 consistency and ally has helped but if it weren't for the threat of russia there would be no need
00:11:25 to rearm there would be no you know there would be a terrorist threat from the south or from
00:11:30 you know from elsewhere but that that wouldn't require rethinking mobilization rethinking you
00:11:38 know how you how you create large armies rethinking the drone industry doing deals with
00:11:42 ukrainian drone industry which is a big part of this none of that would be necessary but what you
00:11:47 do have now is an emboldened and escalating russia which is carrying out frequent now 0.74
00:11:54 sabotage attacks, assassination attempts, cyber attacks all over Europe. There was an armed drone 0.54
00:12:01 founded a German airport a few weeks ago. There was an attack on a, which fortunately failed on
00:12:05 a Polish passenger train. There have been bombs and missiles that have fallen right next to the
00:12:09 Polish border. You know, these are the things that have changed the atmosphere in Europe and
00:12:15 changed the conversation. And in that, you know, looking at it from the European point of view,
00:12:20 They see a threat, a genuine threat from Russia, not just some kind of online or hybrid threat, but a real threat.
00:12:28 They see the war in Ukraine escalating, and they see Trump playing a kind of neutral role.
00:12:35 So the United States is not in solidarity necessarily with European allies.
00:12:40 The United States is ambivalent about Ukraine, and the United States is often, I won't say aligning with Russia because that hasn't happened yet, but certainly not criticizing Russia.
00:12:50 And so the reorientation that's happening in Europe is, I mean, I wouldn't say it's because Trump was so clever and he persuaded them to rearm.
00:13:00 It's more the sense of, right, we see the world differently now.
00:13:04 The United States is not necessarily on our side.
00:13:07 We have a genuine threat.
00:13:09 We need to think about rearmament.
00:13:10 And you see that especially in Scandinavia.
00:13:13 You see it in the U.K.
00:13:14 You see it in Germany.
00:13:15 You see it in Poland, Baltic states, Netherlands, and a few other places.
00:13:20 Southern Europe feels it less and they're rearming less. And I think that's, I don't have a,
00:13:24 it's hard for me to argue with that. But as a whole, you know, the continent now looks out
00:13:30 into the world and sees something completely different from what it saw a decade ago. And
00:13:35 that's, it's to do with Trump. It's to do with Putin. It's to do with Xi. It's to do with an
00:13:40 understanding that the United States is not the guarantor of stability or even, it's not even
00:13:46 about military security. The United States is not a reliable partner and therefore Europeans need to
00:13:51 rely on themselves. Well, on the point of military security, does anyone believe that we would honor 0.95
00:13:56 our Article 5 obligations to NATO at this point? I mean, it depends who you ask. I mean, there are
00:14:03 a lot, very few European leaders would say in public, we don't believe it, but privately, many
00:14:08 don't believe it. I think a lot would depend on what happens. I mean, one of the fears now is that
00:14:14 there will be an attack that doesn't clearly look like an attack. So a missile falls on a
00:14:20 German city and kills a lot of people. And the Russians say, oh, we're sorry, that was an
00:14:25 accident. What does NATO do? Or a band of border guards crosses the border into Estonia and does
00:14:33 carries out some kind of raid. What does NATO do? Those are the kinds of things that Europe is
00:14:39 anticipating? And would the U.S. intervene in those circumstances? Pretty hard to say.
00:14:45 So let's talk about Ukraine. What is the actual state of the war at this point?
00:14:50 The state of the war is that on the front line, the actual war where the, you know,
00:14:54 the two armies fight against each other, the front line is either not moving or the
00:14:59 Ukrainians are winning and taking back territory. I think most people aren't aware the degree to
00:15:04 which this is a new kind of war. So there is now what the front line looks like is it's a kind of
00:15:09 20 or 30 or maybe it's a little wider now kilometer strip inside that territory. Everything
00:15:17 is totally visible. Ukrainians can see everything. Russians can see everything. And so whenever
00:15:21 anybody goes into the strip, into the front line, into the no man's land, whether it's a person or
00:15:28 a tank or some guy on a motorcycle, whoever it is, the drones can see them and take them out. 0.56
00:15:33 And so this means effectively the Russians can't move forward.
00:15:37 Ukrainians have been able to maneuver a little bit and move forward in the last few weeks. 0.59
00:15:40 Russians are not able to move forward. 0.63
00:15:42 And instead, what they've been doing is sending waves of men into the strip anyway. 0.95
00:15:47 And this is why you have these huge Russian casualty figures, you know, thousands of people every month killed and wounded. 0.63
00:15:53 And that's what the war looks like.
00:15:55 The war also has two other faces, though.
00:15:57 One is the escalation in Russian bombardment and destruction of Ukrainian civilians in cities.
00:16:05 So, I mean, literally in the last few days, kindergartens, hospitals, the Ukrainian Academy of Sciences in Kiev, you know, factories, not necessarily military factories, civilian factories of all kinds. 0.83
00:16:17 It looks like what the Russians are doing is the policy they carried out in Chechnya and Syria, which is just destroy everything, just try and wreck as much of the society, as much of the economy as they possibly can. 0.85
00:16:29 And they're targeting Kiev in a way that they didn't earlier in the war. Kiev was pretty safe, actually, through a lot of the war. And that's changed. And that's changed the atmosphere inside Ukraine quite a bit. 0.98
00:16:40 I mean, the things that felt safe until very recently don't feel safe now. 0.74
00:16:45 And the Russians, this is their technological changes.
00:16:47 The Russians now have these jet-powered drones. 0.92
00:16:49 Ukrainians are working on how to counter them. 1.00
00:16:50 Maybe that will happen. 0.99
00:16:52 We'll see.
00:16:52 The other thing that's really new and different, and this is true over the last few months,
00:16:56 is that Ukraine is now able to hit very long-range targets.
00:17:00 So they can hit Russian refineries.
00:17:02 And they're hitting very regularly.
00:17:05 I mean, there are daily rates, some more successful, some less.
00:17:08 They can hit refineries in Moscow. They can hit them a thousand miles from the border.
00:17:13 And they've taken out, as I understand it, something like 30 to 40 percent of the Russian refining capability, which is huge.
00:17:19 Does anyone think that Ukraine is capable of actually winning this war?
00:17:25 Members can hear the full conversation by subscribing at SamHarris.org.
00:17:29 Subscribers get a private RSS feed you can use with your favorite podcast player.
00:17:33 There's lots of evidence that the legitimate leader of the Venezuelan opposition, who was the figure behind an electoral victory in 2024, this is Maria Carina Machado, as we speak, is being prevented from going back to the country.
00:17:47 She's made multiple attempts. Her planes get turned around in the air, and the U.S. seems to have played a role in that, too.
00:17:53 The United States is not fixing the criminality or bringing the rule of law.
00:17:58 What the U.S. is doing instead is partnering with the criminals and seeking to benefit from it.