00:00:00you're listening to making sense with sam harris this is the free version of the podcast so you'll
00:00:06only hear the first part of today's conversation if you want the full episode and every episode
00:00:11you can subscribe at sam harris.org there are no ads on this show it runs entirely on subscriber
00:00:18support if you enjoy what we're doing here and find it valuable please consider subscribing today
00:00:22i'm here with jonah goldberg jonah it's great to see you again it's great to be back thanks
00:00:29for having me. So I can only imagine that you have done 12 podcasts and been on CNN 15 times
00:00:36post midterms, but I've yet to talk about it. So if you're not too sick of the sound of your
00:00:43own voice, I want you to be my oracle here. There's really nobody I would rather talk to
00:00:48about the aftermath. But before we jump into the election postmortem proper, did you see the 60
00:00:54Minutes interview with Trump last night? I did. I thought it was great. Yeah, I thought Ross did
00:00:58a great job i i don't know what i was expecting going in but i felt that his i i mean trump is
00:01:04successfully evasive in ways that are still fairly supernatural but ross cut in with rational
00:01:12questions again and again and again i thought it was really um i have nothing but respect for how
00:01:17he handled his side of that interview yeah i do think it's a bit of a triumph for i mean ross is
00:01:21a friend and i was i was nervous for him because a lot of people have been steamrolled by trump oh
00:01:26and i'd say it's probably the with the exception of jonathan swan who did a really fantastic
00:01:33interview with him a while back i would say it's it's the best one i can remember and i want to
00:01:38give a little shout out to print people um because there is something about tv broadcasters that i
00:01:45don't want to cast dispersions to colleagues at any of the networks or anything but like there
00:01:49is something about ross's way of doing things from being a print guy i think that lends itself
00:01:56really well to this about you know and recognizing that trump wants to do the weave right and go on
00:02:03his normal talking points and and ross went in just very prepared as you know as is his want
00:02:08so i thought it was good there were some people were complaining about the interruptions but i
00:02:12think the interruptions were vitally necessary oh yeah oh yeah because otherwise it was just0.98
00:02:16going to be the same bullshit like you know meandering you know nursing home patient0.96
00:02:20wandering off into the snow kind of stuff and i i thought you know there's some answers i would0.99
00:02:25have loved to hear a more fulsome answer, but I think Ross's instinct was that Trump was looking
00:02:31for all sorts of exit ramps to evade. And so he had to intervene. And I thought it was great.
00:02:37Yeah. He managed to do it without being adversarial in a way that Trump would have
00:02:43had a bad reaction to. I really thought it was a very impressive high wire act on death's part.
00:02:49And I don't know if there's anything in the interview that you want to reflect on. I mean,
00:02:54I mean, the first thing I was going to say about the election is that the most gratifying thing from my point of view is that we have proven to ourselves that we can hold an election that is really incontestable.
00:03:05And maybe it's merely because of what a trouncing it was that really you just can't lie about it.
00:03:12But I've noticed that since the interview last night, Trump has begun to lie about it and claim election fraud.
00:03:19But in the interview, he simply admitted that the Republicans lost for a variety of reasons.
00:03:25Yeah. I mean, I saw those, you know, him backpedaling on the stolen election stuff,
00:03:29which, you know, we don't have to spend a lot of time on. We'll talk about whatever you want,
00:03:33but like it is so flatly preposterous that, you know, there's these Trump accounts. They're
00:03:40talking about these voter shifts in Texas and how this is impossible. Oh, it's not impossible
00:03:46because it actually happened. But second of all, it's what's impossible is the idea. This is
00:03:51something I've had these arguments for so long. These people who want to claim that like ballots
00:03:56were faked and all of these kinds of things. One of the great features of our system is how local
00:04:02our elections are. And you can go into an election in your neighborhood and the ballot will be
00:04:08different than one five minutes further up the road because you have a different dog catcher on
00:04:13the ballot, you have a different superintendent for schools, you have a different, you know,
00:04:17local, you know, commission for this, that, or the other thing on it. And the idea that you could
00:04:23go to Kinko's and get these doctored ballots at literally tens of thousands of different locations
00:04:29without anybody noticing, you know, is just so preposterous when you think about it. I remember
00:04:34Roger Stone, who I think is, you know, a carbuncle, but he had this great thing where he said,
00:04:40i know for a fact after the 2020 election that north korea has shipped shipped fake ballots that
00:04:47they unloaded in maine yeah and then imagine the graphic design on those ballots yeah yeah like
00:04:53because the north koreans really have a granular understanding of who ran for dog catcher in peoria0.99
00:04:58you know it's just all so stupid and but it's kind of it's not as surprising as i thought it0.99
00:05:04would be that he would eventually backslide into this because i think it's now dawning on him1.00
00:05:08how total the rebuke of him was. And that's one of the problems we've got with, we're in this
00:05:16weird moment where it starts a few days before an election and it continues for about three weeks
00:05:22after an election where partisan factions of all sorts want to put their stamp on the official
00:05:30narrative about why so-and-so won or so-and-so lost and that kind of thing. And it's not just
00:05:36democrats want to say it was this and republicans want to say it was that it's that the dsa wants
00:05:41to say it was their very progressive agenda and the the normie moderate dems want to say no it's
00:05:46like we returned to sanity and that's why we won these red states which i think there's a lot of
00:05:50truth to that vance want which we'll get to i'm sure vance wants to say it was all about the iran
00:05:55war and nothing else and the reason why everyone's scrambling so much so fast right now is because
00:06:02pretty soon the narrative congeals and then there'll still be, you know, people who dispute
00:06:09it, you know, and, and have their counter narratives, but the conventional wisdom becomes
00:06:14kind of locked in, in terms of how reporters talk about it, how the parties mount a, either
00:06:22for the Republicans, a comeback operation, you know, or how Democrats determine what,
00:06:28you know, where the Overton window is for what they can get done.
00:06:31And everybody kind of recognizes this and everybody wants to sort of, while the clay is still malleable, wants to get their thumbprints in it. And that's what we're seeing right now on just all across Washington.
00:06:42Do you think there's any chance he's going to get traction with claims of election fraud?
00:06:47Not really, in part because he's a lame duck and the various factions who are looking to
00:06:552028, they might do it as a lot of Republicans did as lip service to MAGA populists and that
00:07:03kind of thing, but it'll get laughed out at courts.
00:07:07Look, there might be legitimate legal stuff in Alaska and Mississippi because
00:07:11the recount stuff is narrow and hard but this idea that there was sweeping voter fraud it can't go
00:07:18anywhere in courts and it'll further brand the republican party as this extension of sort of
00:07:26trump's narcissism and conspiracy stuff and i just think there are too many republicans who realize
00:07:32there's no percentage for the for them in that now and also you know there's a lot of reporting
00:07:37and from some people I've talked to as well is that, you know, Rupert Murdoch has zero desire
00:07:42to go back down the Dominion lawsuit path. And they kind of think Trump is a, is a increasingly
00:07:49spent force and passed his sell-by date. So the idea that it'll get traction in, I can't speak
00:07:54for OAN or Newsbacks and those places, but the idea that it'll get major traction from Fox
00:07:59is unlikely. And without that, you know, I just don't know how far it could go,
00:08:03even if there was some superficial false, but superficially plausible rationale behind it.
00:08:09So I think Trump may in, you know, as the West wing becomes a reenactment of a downfall video,
00:08:16he may lean into it more and more, but I just don't think it'll have much purchase
00:08:21where it would matter. Well, what percentage of Americans do you think fall into the just
00:08:28irretrievable mega bitter ender camp i mean is there what do you have a sense of the people who
00:08:34for whom there's literally nothing trump could do or that could be said about him or that could
00:08:39happen as a result of his policies that would pry them loose from the cult i mean obviously when
00:08:46we're talking about large numbers individual people are different and you know but as a as a
00:08:52block i think it's the lion's share of what's left of his positive favorability rating right i mean
00:08:57I think the, so that's what it was at 30%, 35%. It's in the low thirties, depending on the poll
00:09:02that you're looking at, that kind of thing. And I, if I had to guess it's, you know, it's probably
00:09:0828%, 26%. And I don't think all of those people, I don't think it's fair to say all those people
00:09:14are, are the cultists. Some of them are just so polarized and anti and defensive about their
00:09:21choices, right? And anti-left, anti-democrat, anti-mainstream media, anti-establishment and
00:09:29all that kind of stuff, that they won't countenance the idea of saying they dislike Trump to a pollster
00:09:36or something like that. But they're still out there for sure. There's just a half-life to it,
00:09:43I think. So obviously these election results were in some sense overdetermined. I mean,
00:09:48everyone can find their favorite reason why the Republicans lost so many seats. But I do worry
00:09:55that some of the reasons why they lost were bad ones, or at least suggest something dysfunctional
00:10:02in the future about our politics. For instance, if the war is the reason why Republicans lost,
00:10:10I mean, if J.D. Vance is right there, if it's the war plus Israel's manipulation of the president0.60
00:10:16into the war, so the scheming Jews behind the war, that is depressing on at least two0.95
00:11:06This war was always going to be wrong no matter how we waged it.
00:11:09And I think that's a scary lesson to draw if that is the reason why. If, in fact, the right war, no matter how you wage it, is going to raise gas prices for a period, we're proving ourselves to be a nation that can't stomach that. I don't know if I'd feel free to react to that.
00:11:26So, yeah, if you give me a second on this one, because I think you're absolutely right, but I think you're offering, I don't want to shock you, too rosy a scenario.
00:11:35I'm rarely convicted of that, so I would love to hear that.
00:20:03Jonah, doesn't a lot of the polling suggest that corruption was also high on the list of
00:20:08people's concerns? Huge. And let us say, so the Vance autopsy does not mention the word corruption
00:20:15at all. And Vance, let no one forget, is the Trump administration's official anti-corruption czar.
00:20:24I missed that somehow. He fired all the inspectors general, but he put Vance in charge of routing
00:20:31out corruption in the government and that was because what what they meant by that was looking
00:20:35at corruption in minnesota and the somali stuff and all that which i think there is a lot of
00:20:39corruption there but he doesn't care about he doesn't talk about the corruption his biggest
00:20:44mentor is don jr who you know had a russian oligarch paper his wedding you know and it is
00:20:50all in on the crypto stuff and so the fox poll says and again it's a fox poll right which should
00:20:57have some credibility in Megaland, says 50, I think it's 55% said it was a crucial issue
00:21:06in why they voted. And an additional 35%, it gets to 90% said it was either a major or crucial issue
00:21:14for why they voted. And they just, he just airbrushes that out too. I mean, and so that's,
00:21:20this is what I'm getting at about the conventional wisdom formation stuff. It's so important because
00:21:24If we come out of this with the Republican Party taking away this idea that defenestrating Israel,
00:21:30turning our back also on Ukraine, because that's embedded in a lot of this stuff,
00:21:34is the reason for the lost election, then you're committing the Republican Party to that path
00:21:42going forward. And there's just an enormous number of the sort of new right MAGA intellectual types
00:21:48who are pushing extremely hard on that narrative. And they're memory-holing the fact that Kevin
00:21:55Roberts of the Heritage Foundation and lots of other people celebrated the war when it started.
00:21:59And now they just want to say, oh, it's just those perfidious neocons who did this. And there
00:22:04are no neocons in this administration. And so it's an attempt at myth-making for the benefit
00:22:10of Vance and the sort of Tucker Carlson wing of the right.0.62
00:22:15Well, it seems that both parties are drawing the lesson that the U.S. needs a reset with Israel, right? I mean, like the Democrats and the Republicans have drawn this lesson and don't, I mean, how do you map that onto the poll you just cited? What was it, 80% of Americans think?
00:22:3480% of Republicans. Okay. So it's got to be quite different among Democrats, I would imagine.
00:22:38Yeah. I don't know what the numbers of Democrats, but I'm sure it's different.
00:22:40Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, if even if the Republicans are poised, well, maybe maybe maybe these vapors will dissipate and the Republicans will not be making these noises about Israel as we go into the 2028 campaign.
00:22:54It'll just be the Democrats. Let's talk about both the Republicans and the Democrats here and the lessons they can plausibly draw.