Mark Slapinski


Carney’s Budget Officer Sounds Warning Bell

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A new report from the Interim Parliamentary Budget Officer Jason Jakes raises concerns about Canada's ability to spend on defense. He talks about the lack of money being spent on equipment and equipment purchases, and the implications for the upcoming budget.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Mark Carney's right-hand man has an urgent warning.
00:00:03 If the Canadian Prime Minister doesn't immediately resign,
00:00:05 Canada is going to go bankrupt.
00:00:07 It's unclear what strategy the government will actually employ politically,
00:00:11 but opposition parties are also figuring out
00:00:13 if they're willing to force an election over this budget
00:00:15 due to be tabled Tuesday.
00:00:17 On the content of the budget,
00:00:18 government sources tell us the document itself has not been finalized.
00:00:22 So what do we need to watch for?
00:00:23 Jason Jakes is the Interim Parliamentary Budget Officer.
00:00:26 Hi, Mr. Jakes. Pleasure to welcome you back to studio.
00:00:28 Thanks for making the time.
00:00:29 Oh, my gosh. Thank you so much for the invitation.
00:00:31 We're all, of course, thinking of and looking ahead to the budget.
00:00:34 You've got a new report out today on capital spending on defense
00:00:38 that I think is kind of interesting in the context of the budget.
00:00:41 You make two very specific findings about how much they're spending now
00:00:45 and also how much they've been unable to spend.
00:00:48 What do you think Canadians should know about that
00:00:51 in light of the budget coming down the road?
00:00:53 Well, I think on your first point,
00:00:55 I think that's one of the key highlights,
00:00:57 and that we currently have within the government of Canada's spending plan for defense.
00:01:03 So this is the capital plan.
00:01:04 So this is the F-35s along with the Navy and other types of armaments.
00:01:11 We're looking at around $300 billion over the next 20 years,
00:01:14 and that's only for NATO 2%.
00:01:17 So this goes back, the data we're looking at goes back to June.
00:01:20 It does not include the additional commitment that's been made since that period of time
00:01:24 to get up to NATO 5%.
00:01:26 So if we're at 2%, $300 billion at 2%, we're looking at substantially more.
00:01:32 So additional potentially hundreds of billions of dollars on defense in order to hit those targets.
00:01:37 So let me translate what he's saying here.
00:01:39 Canada is in serious trouble and Carney needs to step down.
00:01:43 Of course, he's being a bit more gentle with his words than I am,
00:01:47 but I'm going to say it straight.
00:01:48 He's saying that Carney needs to go.
00:01:50 Put it this way, if Carney doesn't step down or he's not forced out next week,
00:01:55 Canada is going to be in more debt than it's ever been in before.
00:01:58 Just a quick note, I'm being heavily censored on YouTube.
00:02:02 So if you see this part, let me know in the comment section,
00:02:04 give me a quick like, and make sure you're still subscribed.
00:02:08 Thank you.
00:02:08 Now let's watch Parliamentary Budget Officer Jason Jakes
00:02:11 continue to give Canada more bad news about the upcoming budget.
00:02:14 In historical context, like how much is that?
00:02:18 How much money is that compared to what we usually spend?
00:02:22 It is, historically, it is a multiple of what most Canadians would be familiar with.
00:02:27 I know there are probably some viewers who would remember World War II,
00:02:32 so we're getting close to that period of time,
00:02:35 a little bit after probably the 1950s or so.
00:02:38 I think during the 1980s and 1970s,
00:02:41 we would see defense spending at around 3% of GDP, 3.5%,
00:02:45 going up to 5%, even with the dual purpose aspect.
00:02:49 So spending on infrastructure that could be used for defense as well as other areas,
00:02:53 even with that, it's a very high number.
00:02:56 And critically, it's a really big increase within a very short period of time.
00:03:01 So in that context, I actually want to ask you,
00:03:03 because part of your analysis also reflected on the allocation of money,
00:03:07 but not spending it over time.
00:03:09 And I'm wondering, given that the scope of the planned increase,
00:03:12 if that would be a concern for you moving forward?
00:03:15 I think it's less of a concern for us,
00:03:20 because we only keep track of the numbers in the budget.
00:03:22 It definitely should be a concern for the government,
00:03:25 because as you point out, what we've seen,
00:03:27 at least in the first five or six years of the original plan,
00:03:30 was that there's close to $20 billion that they planned to spend on equipment.
00:03:34 That was not spent.
00:03:36 And in the situation where not only do you have to spend the money
00:03:39 to achieve the NATO commitment,
00:03:40 but as everyone realizes there are very real and imminent threats
00:03:44 the Canada faces at this point,
00:03:46 you actually need to procure the equipment and the material.
00:03:49 And as time goes by, if you're not able to spend the money,
00:03:52 you're not able to procure the equipment.
00:03:54 And as well, from an accounting perspective,
00:03:56 everyone knows how pernicious inflation is.
00:03:59 And so if you don't actually acquire the equipment in the time period provided,
00:04:05 by the time you do, the money is worth less.
00:04:08 So potentially you have to buy less than when you originally anticipated,
00:04:12 or you have to pay more, or a combination of the two.
00:04:15 So the overall budget is under a week away.
00:04:18 When you get that budget and you're able to look at it,
00:04:21 what kinds of fiscal anchors will you be utilizing to assess the sustainability?
00:04:26 I think the first one is the one that most economists would look to.
00:04:32 And I'd say it's the one that the government of Canada has looked to in the past,
00:04:35 and that's the debt-to-GDP anchor.
00:04:38 So what does debt look like in comparison to the overall economy?
00:04:43 And is debt growing faster than overall economic growth?
00:04:46 And the government of Canada itself has indicated that a declining debt-to-GDP ratio
00:04:51 is a very important indicator of fiscal sustainability,
00:04:54 as well as important for ensuring or securing Canada's AAA credit rating.
00:04:58 It's also something that the Liberal Party of Canada campaigned on
00:05:01 as part of their election platform in April.
00:05:04 And most recently, the Prime Minister indicated, I believe it was September 17th,
00:05:10 that declining debt was something that was part of the fiscal anchors
00:05:13 for the current government.
00:05:14 So that's definitely the first thing that I'll be looking at.
00:05:17 Based on what you've seen announced thus far,
00:05:20 and quite a bit has come out about what their intended spending is,
00:05:23 we don't know necessarily exactly what they're going to do
00:05:27 on the spending where government operations are concerned.
00:05:30 But based on what you've seen so far,
00:05:32 do you think it is realistic that that ratio would go down?
00:05:36 It's definitely possible.
00:05:38 And I think certainly, again, we don't have a lot of clarity right now,
00:05:42 precisely what the government has in mind.
00:05:44 One could foresee a situation where spending and the deficits
00:05:48 are substantially higher in the initial years,
00:05:50 and there's a substantial increase in spending on capital.
00:05:53 And at the same time, in the outer years,
00:05:56 economic growth as a result of those investments starts to pick up.
00:05:59 And as a result of that,
00:06:00 you have a declining debt-to-GDP ratio in the outer years.
00:06:04 And that's, again, what one would hope to see
00:06:06 with the potential additional spending that's on the table.
00:06:09 The other point of consideration,
00:06:11 and something else that we're going to be looking at in detail
00:06:13 on this coming Tuesday on the budget, are the cuts.
00:06:17 So the Prime Minister has used the word austerity.
00:06:20 And I was working for the Parliamentary Budget Office in 2012
00:06:23 with Kevin Page,
00:06:25 when Kevin had to take the government to court
00:06:27 around the transparency or lack thereof
00:06:29 with respect to the impact of the cuts.
00:06:32 So something we're going to be looking at in detail is,
00:06:35 are the cuts actually provided?
00:06:37 Is there a listing of the cuts?
00:06:38 Can we see the cuts by program?
00:06:41 Do we know which public servants are being laid off across those programs?
00:06:45 And can the government actually articulate clear service-level impacts?
00:06:50 Because if...
00:06:51 Is that what constitutes transparency in your mind?
00:06:53 Like, those things need to be spelled out?
00:06:55 You can't just say, you know,
00:06:56 we're going to adjust the workforce by 10,000?
00:06:59 Oh, no.
00:07:00 And again, going back to the precedent set by Kevin
00:07:03 and the office as part of Budget 2012,
00:07:06 that's the foundation.
00:07:07 Without that information,
00:07:08 parliamentarians,
00:07:09 they really won't know what they're voting on
00:07:11 in terms of spending constraint and cuts.
00:07:14 So that's something that we're definitely going to be looking at in detail
00:07:16 as soon as we get our hands on the budget.
00:07:19 One final question for you on the scope of those cuts.
00:07:21 Because yesterday, the finance minister said something very interesting,
00:07:24 which I had not heard him say before
00:07:26 in response to questions about what you just mentioned.
00:07:28 In that, basically, the size of the public service
00:07:32 had to get to a more sustainable level.
00:07:35 Sustainable is the word, I believe, that he used.
00:07:37 And he referenced a period before COVID.
00:07:40 If you look at the size of the public service now
00:07:42 versus pre-pandemic,
00:07:44 what would the scope of that kind of cut look like?
00:07:48 Yeah.
00:07:49 If you go back to pre-pandemic,
00:07:52 you're looking at tens of thousands of positions
00:07:55 potentially eliminated across the public service.
00:07:58 Again, on our end,
00:08:01 something, it's less about the people
00:08:03 and it's really about the programs.
00:08:05 So public servants are hired to support government programs
00:08:08 that the people of Canada benefit from.
00:08:11 And that's why, notwithstanding,
00:08:13 it's a good starting point to figure out
00:08:15 how many public servants might be affected
00:08:17 by the budget on Tuesday.
00:08:18 What we're more interested in is
00:08:20 what are the actual service-level impacts
00:08:22 and what are Canadians going to feel?
00:08:25 Because on our end,
00:08:26 one of the things that,
00:08:27 as an independent parliamentary budget office,
00:08:29 one of the things we've seen in the past
00:08:30 is if the government doesn't have a clear sense
00:08:33 of the service-level impacts,
00:08:34 there's a very high risk of retrenchment.
00:08:36 So if something is announced,
00:08:38 the service-level impacts are significant,
00:08:40 and politically,
00:08:41 it's not sustainable to actually carry it out
00:08:43 or actually implement
00:08:44 what they've initially announced.
00:08:46 And just to be clear,
00:08:47 is it acceptable if they say
00:08:48 stage one in this budget is the volume,
00:08:51 stage two is figuring out how that unfolds?
00:08:55 I guess it comes back to,
00:08:56 as a transparency organization,
00:08:59 absolutely not.
00:09:00 Okay.
00:09:00 Yeah.
00:09:01 Canada is at a very important crossroads right now,
00:09:03 arguably more important than any other crossroads
00:09:06 that we've ever been at before,
00:09:08 even more so than World War II.
00:09:10 On one hand,
00:09:11 we have the option of MPs doing the right thing
00:09:13 and forcing Carney out of parliament.
00:09:15 On the other hand,
00:09:16 MPs can vote with Carney,
00:09:19 and his budget will destroy our economy
00:09:21 and the lives of her children
00:09:22 and her grandchildren.
00:09:24 Now, Carney would be right to resign.
00:09:26 However, a man with an ego as big as his
00:09:29 simply will not do the right thing.
00:09:31 Now, of course,
00:09:32 Carney's PBO,
00:09:33 the parliamentary budget officer,
00:09:35 didn't directly call for Carney's resignation.
00:09:38 But if you listen closely,
00:09:39 if you read between the lines,
00:09:41 that's exactly what he's saying.
00:09:43 If this budget passes,
00:09:44 we're going to be living under austerity measures
00:09:46 that are worse than World War II,
00:09:49 and that's with the sky-high trillion dollar deficit
00:09:52 that comes along with it.
00:09:54 Carney misled Canadians.
00:09:56 He misled voters.
00:09:57 He misled the liberals.
00:09:59 He misled everyone.
00:10:00 He's supposed to get a deal with Donald Trump.
00:10:02 It's been eight months.
00:10:03 There's no deal.
00:10:04 Actually, we have worse tariffs
00:10:05 than we did before he got into office.
00:10:08 He was supposed to fix the economy.
00:10:09 He was supposed to get projects going.
00:10:11 Build, baby, build.
00:10:12 Those were his words.
00:10:14 Where are the projects?
00:10:15 Canada doesn't have one major project
00:10:17 that has been passed by him
00:10:19 since he's been in office.
00:10:21 Let that one sink in.
00:10:22 All Carney has done
00:10:23 is use the prime minister's office
00:10:25 to enrich himself,
00:10:26 and he's using taxpayer money
00:10:28 as his personal ATM.
00:10:30 He's flying all over the world,
00:10:32 staying at nice hotels,
00:10:34 eating fancy meals,
00:10:35 burning money like it doesn't mean nothing.
00:10:38 And of course,
00:10:39 your money doesn't mean anything to him
00:10:41 because he can take it
00:10:42 whether you like it or not.
00:10:44 And on top of that, 1.00
00:10:45 he's got a bunch of stupid people 1.00
00:10:46 that will vote for him 1.00
00:10:47 no matter what he does.
00:10:48 People in Canada,
00:10:49 including children,
00:10:50 are literally starving.
00:10:52 And I'm not being hyperbolic.
00:10:54 Food bank usage in this country
00:10:55 has more than doubled since 2019.
00:10:58 Trudeau created the mess,
00:11:00 and Carney is making it worse.
00:11:02 Now I hope more Canadians are waking up 0.87
00:11:04 and realizing that Carney is a fraud.
00:11:06 Now, of course,
00:11:08 most liberals will never wake up,
00:11:10 but all we need is enough liberals
00:11:11 to wake up,
00:11:12 admit that they made a mistake,
00:11:14 and vote blue next time.
00:11:16 The good news is that
00:11:17 we might have a Christmas election.
00:11:19 So if Canadians come to their senses,
00:11:21 some of them realize
00:11:22 they made a mistake,
00:11:23 the liberal ones,
00:11:24 they vote Polly Eve,
00:11:25 we could have a majority,
00:11:27 possibly a supermajority.
00:11:29 Once again,
00:11:30 have some faith,
00:11:31 have some patience,
00:11:32 we're going to win,
00:11:33 and we're going to win big.
00:11:34 Have a great night,
00:11:35 have a great weekend,
00:11:37 happy Halloween.