Mark Slapinski


CBC Admits Poilievre Was Right, Carney Was Wrong

Hosted by
Mentioned

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the wake of the anti-tariff ad that has ground Canada's trade negotiations to a halt, PM Mark Carney is looking for someone to blame for his broken promises, and he's blaming an ad that he approved. Meanwhile, some premiers say it's all just Donald Trump being Donald Trump.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 something really weird just happened the cbc actually admitted that mark carney and doug
00:00:04 ford were wrong and polyev he was right all along well there was a whole lot of finger
00:00:10 pointing today over the anti-tariff ad that has ground canada u.s trade negotiations to a halt
00:00:15 while u.s president donald trump is blaming the ad for ending those talks conservative
00:00:19 leader pierre polyev is blaming who else prime minister mark carney the reality is that premiers
00:00:25 are stepping up to fill the void left behind by mark carney's broken promise he said he would
00:00:31 negotiate a win he said he would have a deal by july 21st still no deal now he mark carney is
00:00:38 looking for someone to blame for his broken promises and he's blaming an ad that he approved
00:00:46 meanwhile some premiers say they think this is all just donald trump being donald trump in terms of
00:00:54 the ups and downs of what we've been living through this year i would say this is pretty
00:00:57 par for the course of what we've come to expect from the president and we need to keep pushing
00:01:04 i can tell you one thing if it wasn't this he'd pick something else that he wasn't happy with and
00:01:10 you know negotiations been going on month after month after month
00:01:13 uh this need to we need to sit down and start focusing on it in my opinion uh i take a no deal
00:01:20 instead of a bad deal so all of this and in exactly one week the carney government will deliver its
00:01:28 first budget so how will all of this uncertainty shape canada's financial future well the power
00:01:32 panel luckily is here to talk about all of that michelle cadario was deputy chief of staff to former
00:01:36 prime minister paul martin lisa rate is a former conservative cabinet minister cheryl oates was
00:01:41 director of communications for former alberta ndp premier rachel notley and shachi curl is the
00:01:47 president of the angus reid institute good to see you all michelle having worked for former finance
00:01:53 minister and prime minister paul martin have you ever had to do a budget under these kinds of
00:01:57 circumstances i mean when you look at the economic headwinds hitting canada i mean how do you even
00:02:03 begin to plot a fiscal path forward well actually we did it was a different set of circumstances but
00:02:10 you know in the 90s when we were saddled with a huge deficit and growing debt and we had the bond
00:02:16 markets kind of at our at our heels um wanting to essentially declare us bankrupt as a country
00:02:23 there was enormous pressure on the on the uh on the government at the time and uh you know i think
00:02:28 that uh mr kretchen and mr martin when they came in uh they hardly came in on a deficit fighting kind
00:02:33 of agenda or what they want that wasn't necessarily what they wanted to do but it's what they had to do
00:02:39 and uh you know good governments make uh difficult decisions in tough times and so you know i think that uh
00:02:46 you know the prime minister carney is setting himself up to uh make some big bold decisions if
00:02:51 what we're hearing is uh uh is correct and uh he's been talking about you know a generational spend and
00:02:58 you know in these wins that we're facing and such uncertainty on our trading relationships
00:03:03 um that uh i think that he's trying to bet on on canada and uh it's a long-term bet it's not going to
00:03:09 change overnight and i think that he's hoping that canadians are going to stick with him
00:03:14 uh as he goes through it so but he's got some communicating to do that's all what i would say
00:03:18 well that that may be that's a recurring theme in a lot of the conversations in this town
00:03:23 uh lisa i'm wondering what you make of what we're seeing in terms of the blame game like um
00:03:27 i don't know if mark carney had to approve doug ford's ad i know he saw it in the meeting with
00:03:31 with premier ford is what senior ontario people are are telling us didn't object to it but neither did
00:03:37 donald trump first of all i mean this political finger pointing in the face of it i mean donald trump is
00:03:42 ultimately the actor here what do you make of the dynamic that we're seeing well donald trump may
00:03:48 be the actor here but the victim is canadian business and i'm not appreciative of all the
00:03:55 noise around who did what when the reality of the situation as i see it david is that
00:04:01 real live decisions are being made by real businesses in this country about whether or
00:04:07 not they are going to move their operation to some state in the united states family offices
00:04:12 are looking at it small and medium-sized businesses are because the signal they're not getting
00:04:17 from federal and provincial government is that they actually have an idea of how to proceed
00:04:22 through this dilemma in a in a careful way that's going to end up being okay at the end there's so
00:04:27 much uncertainty right now in the business sector especially in small and medium-sized businesses
00:04:33 i don't think i've ever seen anything like this before it is really jarring to hear
00:04:38 ordinary canadian business people say i think i really got to think about closing up shop here and
00:04:43 and moving to the states because i don't know where this is all going to end yeah and cheryl like 0.89
00:04:48 michelle's right the size of the challenge they faced in the 90s but it was a known set of facts
00:04:53 right a debt the gdp burden and a debt that you had to attack and trade with the us was about to lift
00:04:59 off uh we don't know where trade with the us is going and and i wonder to lisa's point do you think
00:05:04 what what we're seeing politically is is is a good thing for for the economic health of the country
00:05:09 if people have to make these decisions well i don't think it's a good strategy to get us to our
00:05:15 end goal which ultimately is a good deal for canadians and a good deal for canadian businesses
00:05:20 as you said right now a whole bunch of finger pointing and and whose fault was it that donald
00:05:26 trump did this and whose fault was it on this day that donald trump did that and what we need is a
00:05:30 strategic reset away from the grandstanding loop everybody right now whether you're a union leader
00:05:36 a trade association a premier the prime minister everybody wants to take their political points
00:05:41 from who stood up to donald trump best and who made the most progress and who stood up for their
00:05:45 members or their constituents and that has cost us in this case our negotiating position and so rather
00:05:51 than talk about whose fault it was in any given scenario it's time for us to stop to start talking
00:05:56 about how we move forward and what we're going to do differently and in some cases that might be a
00:06:00 little bit more information sharing like it could be the case that if the prime minister were to read
00:06:05 some of the premiers in a little bit they might be less inclined to take matters into their own hands
00:06:10 but we do need a little bit of a look at what's not worked so far and what we can do better if we're
00:06:14 working towards a strategic goal goal and not just political points so actually it does remember
00:06:19 remind me of sort of the dynamic we saw at the beginning of the year when justin trudeau was still
00:06:24 prime minister and kind of there's a scattershot approach of different premiers doing different
00:06:28 things and you know in the run-up to an election you're going to see a lot of politics but
00:06:32 it wasn't coordinated right it was five fingers instead of a fist and i wonder if that's where
00:06:38 we're maybe headed back well i think there's a couple of things that we're being asked to react to
00:06:45 without having the full picture of first of all where americans are how many americans actually
00:06:50 watched that ad did it change any minds did it did it uh you know rile up enough american viewers
00:06:59 to say look i'm gonna i'm gonna call my local politician i'm gonna call my congressman or my
00:07:03 state official and and and uh you know really pressure them we don't know that we're in the
00:07:08 process of finding that out but we don't know that yet as to you know what's happened with with the 10
00:07:16 look i am not somebody who's going to leap to the defense of doug ford when you look up an antonym for
00:07:23 you know as lisa pointed out sort of careful progress or careful thoughtful process you know doug
00:07:28 ford is not the poster child for that did you hear that a cbc panelist admitted on live television
00:07:34 that doug ford is not a long-term thinker and he made a huge mistake by getting involved with this
00:07:39 whole trade war situation running that ad was a big mistake and they're gently pointing at that
00:07:46 now i want to point out that lady she didn't use those exact words however that's what she meant to 0.88
00:07:51 say now by pointing this out they're basically admitting that pauliev was right and of course he was
00:07:55 right he's rightfully calling out both ford and carney for this whole trade war mess before we go
00:08:01 any further i noticed my videos aren't getting as much traction as they normally do if you see this
00:08:05 part don't forget to like make sure you're still subscribed and let me know if you saw this part in
00:08:10 the comment section i'm doing a test thank you now let's watch the cbc give both ford and carney
00:08:16 some much deserved love taps don't forget to stick around all the way until the end for some more
00:08:21 analysis we know that about him but we also know that he plays a role uh whether it's in ontario or
00:08:30 whether it's even at the national level of being sort of the elbow in the elbows up and at this stage
00:08:37 if you talk about the politics of it that is not going to hurt him because as much as we know that
00:08:43 certain sectors are really really hurting and let me be clear one household affected by this situation is
00:08:49 one household too many but when we ask canadians you know have you suffered job loss have you
00:08:54 suffered reduced work hours are you worried about that the vast majority at this stage of people in
00:09:01 this country say the answer is no where you see the highest level is only is in ontario and at that
00:09:07 level it's it's about five percent that's not nothing that means a tremendous amount to those families
00:09:12 who are losing work or out of work as a result of what's happening but it's not so many that people
00:09:18 have shifted from that elbows up mindset mentality and beyond that uh you know i think they are they
00:09:26 are at a point where um they the antipathy towards donald trump the hostility in canada among the canadian
00:09:33 rank and fell towards donald trump is such that they're not likely to blame canadian politicians for this
00:09:40 they're much more likely to blame trump for this yeah well yes because he started it
00:09:48 oh okay all right well shachi has has lost the ability uh to hear me uh uh control i'm just
00:09:52 letting you know that um all right michelle i i mean you know shachi makes a good point that people
00:09:57 uh broadly are not feeling it as acutely as some of the key sectors probably because of the
00:10:02 the the preservation of the kuzma exemption right which which allows uh a lot of trade to keep going
00:10:08 but you know you talk to people and the future order books are getting a lot worse right and now
00:10:12 you're seeing the anxiety and the frustration there so michelle if you're the prime minister
00:10:16 and we've heard people talking about information sharing what do you think the next move needs to
00:10:20 be when mark herney gets back from asia well you know i i gotta say that i think that the end of uh
00:10:26 shachi's sentence was yet um and uh you know that's what really worries me um and i think that uh you
00:10:33 know the government is kind of trying to not take for granted that where we are today but trying to
00:10:39 look to where we might be tomorrow and you know kuzma i think we should all recognize is probably
00:10:44 very much in jeopardy and that's not something that we can kind of count on to be renegotiated
00:10:50 and certainly not at the at the current kind of level of uh enjoyment that we have right now
00:10:55 so you know i think that this budget is going to um you know it's a defining feature for mark carney
00:11:00 as a politician as a as a prime minister there are such high expectations on it from so many
00:11:07 different sectors um and uh and you know i think that the pressure to actually get it passed which
00:11:14 you know i'm not sure there's a 100 guarantee of that they've worked through um but also to meet the
00:11:20 demand that he's kind of set out there is going to be enormous and so um i hope that they've dug in
00:11:27 and done their homework and are ready to really go out and sell this budget because if canadians
00:11:31 accept the budget and canadians accept the path then i think that it will pass in the house without
00:11:36 a problem yeah we're going to talk to don davies uh the interim leader of the ndp about this because
00:11:41 they're getting some pressure from a lot of groups on what to do but you know lisa i think we got a
00:11:46 sense like not a lot of granular specifics but in the speech the prime minister gave last week
00:11:51 um sort of explaining the size of the challenge i mean it's something you've heard before i've heard
00:11:55 before but he's trying to bundle it together i guess before he went to asia about this is the
00:12:00 size of the challenge so this is why we're going to have a massive eye-popping deficit is sort of what
00:12:05 what i took away from it um do you think the country is ready for that uh kind of the need to go deeper
00:12:12 and deeper into the red though not at a covet level but not far off yeah what i hope the country is ready
00:12:20 for is to understand exactly the gravity of the situation is vis-a-vis our trading partner to the
00:12:25 south the united states of america and what it means for domestic policies here and it's not just
00:12:30 focused on the deficit it's not about a spend budget what mr carney is hearing from the asian
00:12:36 investors that he's meeting with overseas is that it's not a problem with money there is money in this
00:12:42 world to invest in canada the problem with canada is that we have too much regulatory red tape and
00:12:48 uncertainty with respect to whether or not projects get built in this country that they don't want to
00:12:55 put any money into even developing a project because they're just flushing a billion dollars
00:12:59 down the toilet that is something the government can actually do at very little cost and that's
00:13:05 what i'm going to be looking for well cheryl that it does seem like this will be a whole new chapter
00:13:10 uh for the early days of the prime minister and his government because you know as shachi points out i
00:13:15 don't know if canadians are going to blame him for things that trump does because i think the
00:13:18 world realizes trump is an maybe an unsolvable problem right but the things he can control
00:13:24 which is the other part of his pitch to canadians we'll start to see the plan for that on november
00:13:28 4th in the budget and that's where we start to see the domestic agenda at scale potentially
00:13:35 yeah i think it presents a really big challenge and a really big opportunity the challenge of course
00:13:41 that is that there is so much unknown and when we talk about economic impact and what our bottom
00:13:46 line should brace for and what the our ongoing negotiation means with the united states you've
00:13:51 seen this in provincial budgets across the country that everybody is trying to anticipate this
00:13:55 differently you can try to bake in numbers you can try to put in padding but truthfully this is all
00:14:01 unknown and it would be unknown even if we thought we were moving towards reaching a deal the big
00:14:06 opportunity is of course faced with this kind of unprecedented moment in our in our relationship the
00:14:12 united states mark carney has political cover to do giant things to steer the ship in a whole
00:14:19 different direction in a way that you typically don't even if you are a government with a new
00:14:23 mandate not i mean not that he's not but he is a continued liberal government uh he has this
00:14:29 political cover to change big things to make big spends to do things that this government hasn't done
00:14:33 before and not to say that the government the public will blindly accept that but they might be more
00:14:38 willing to consider it given the situation that canada is currently in shachi is that what you're
00:14:43 seeing as you do your work that he does have political cover to use cheryl's phrase uh to do
00:14:48 giant things do you think that's where the public sentiment is right now well certainly on on lisa's
00:14:53 points around building big things on doing resource development it's it's unprecedented levels of
00:14:59 support uh when you go back relative to the last 10 15 years we're seeing people who in the past would
00:15:05 have been very reticent resistant unsure of whether that's a direction in which canada should be going
00:15:13 who are now saying just get it done already in some ways that the hardest and the easiest thing
00:15:18 for mark carney to do will be to actually dare the conservative caucus to say hey i've put together
00:15:25 all of these things i'm going to say yes on these projects uh and and i dare you to vote against me
00:15:31 uh from a parliamentary perspective you know he's he will have the votes but from a po a political
00:15:37 perspective and the gamesmanship perspective uh i think that is a harder conversation and and
00:15:42 particularly vis-a-vis quebec and the bq where we still see the highest levels of resistance to some
00:15:49 of these major project ideas but even they're approaching 50 percent of people in the province
00:15:55 saying yeah like get it done it's interesting though michelle as you navigate these things i mean
00:16:00 you know the bloc and the conservatives obviously have to stake out hard positions on this but
00:16:04 you know melissa lance was here last week repeating the leaders demand that the deficit 0.99
00:16:08 needs to be down to about 40 billion dollars for them to support uh this budget and to be happy with
00:16:14 this budget there's no path to that with the needs and with the plans and with the economic
00:16:18 certainty unless you shut down whole chunks of the government well and you know there is the
00:16:24 whole kind of of splitting up the budget of the capital versus operating and so you know is
00:16:29 there some wiggle room in there because you know the operating budget and they and the path that
00:16:34 they want to set out upon to actually balance that within three years uh you know it's kind
00:16:39 of like your mortgage and your credit card you uh you want to pay off your credit card so you're not
00:16:43 paying ridiculous fees but you can invest in an asset into your in a mortgage um and that's the
00:16:49 long-term capital budget that the uh that the prime minister is going to set out so i wonder if
00:16:54 there's some room in there um you know i uh i don't think that canadians and you know shots you
00:17:00 would probably know this better but i don't think canadians would take it well if we're hurled back
00:17:04 into an election campaign that is not on the calendar for for most people nor do i think that
00:17:09 they would believe that that is going to have a satisfactory or different result yeah i i wouldn't
00:17:13 take it well i'm still not recovered from the last one uh but but you know lisa on the budget the
00:17:18 deficit the size of it you know the capital operating split however you want to go with that i talked to
00:17:23 francis donald last week who always has a lot of smart things to say on this she says a lot of the
00:17:27 people are going to be looking at it it's not so much the size of the deficit is what are you buying
00:17:30 with that debt are you buying productivity are you buying the economic transformation i know you talked
00:17:36 about regulatory burden and they seem to be alive to that what do you think you need to see in the
00:17:41 spending a week from today they let you know they're actually buying a productivity boost so what the
00:17:48 rating agencies are going to be looking for picking up on what francis donald said is they're going to be
00:17:52 making sure that the government has a plan to not have these continuous large deficits that
00:17:57 as she said these kinds of investments are going to actually give you revenues that are going to be
00:18:02 able to in the future allow you to pay down the debt and hopefully get to a deficit position but i
00:18:08 always start with the very fact that i don't accept the fact that the current government budget as it
00:18:15 stands right now is all good money that is all good spend i think there's an opportunity to take
00:18:22 a look internally and see exactly what are we spending it on and instead of thinking about how
00:18:27 much more we're piling on to it let's think about what is it in this deficit right now that we truly
00:18:33 don't need i mean we want to be we want it we may want it sorry but do we actually need it because
00:18:40 we are we're entering into a world where scarcity is real and we're going to be able to make sure
00:18:46 that we're putting our money in places that make sense for the future i heard a speech yesterday by
00:18:51 my outgoing ceo victor dodig and he said if you think that the last 10 years was a lost decade if
00:18:57 we continue and have another 10 years of loss of opportunity then we're actually undermining an
00:19:04 entire generation and that's what's at stake yeah and cheryl like there is there is the process 0.99
00:19:11 underway for some sort of budget rationalization but whether it's at the size and scale that will
00:19:15 satisfy you know bond reasons i don't know uh but with all of the challenges and with the spend and
00:19:21 with the need to do some sort of rationalization it's got to be packaged with this narrative of
00:19:27 it will all be worth it in the end and here's why right and and that's that's a hard thing to see
00:19:32 right now with the industries uh key industries under assault yeah and i mean this this budget has
00:19:39 so many promises we've promised austerity we've promised growth we've promised diversification
00:19:45 we've promised we've been promised efficiencies um the government has a lot to live up to and when it
00:19:51 comes to efficiencies like i've been a part of a government that is trying to find efficiencies
00:19:55 much easier said than done when you ask ministers to go scrape through their ministries and find
00:20:00 things that they don't need to be spending money on there's it is hard to come up with substantial
00:20:05 meaningful amounts of money that you are willing to take out of your budget that you're willing to
00:20:09 sacrifice and so that is a difficult exercise and then i think when it comes to demonstrating
00:20:14 that the spend or the deficit is worth it yeah again a really big task to take on how do you
00:20:20 demonstrate to canadians that under threat from what was our closest trading partner that we're
00:20:25 doing what it takes for canada to eventually become more resilient or more more economically
00:20:30 secure and how do you tell them how that will impact their lives today if the budget is passed that
00:20:36 is a really tall order and it's it's what it will take to get other parties to support it but you know
00:20:40 shachi on that on the the reduction side of things i remember in the mid 2000s when i was still a
00:20:46 provincial political reporter back in st john's they were going through a cost-cutting exercise
00:20:51 in the first danny williams budget when they had won and you're sitting around a cabinet table
00:20:55 talking about and you really feel at a provincial level cutting programs that give low-income seniors
00:21:00 eyeglasses you know that's the kind of choices you have to make and i wonder with the trump effect
00:21:05 and with all of the economic uncertainty whether there's a political climate where you can make those
00:21:09 kind of cuts in in a federal budget if if you start having people losing out as a result of it
00:21:17 it's an interesting question i think the rear view lens on this uh gives uh this government a little
00:21:23 bit of cover in that it's not so many years ago that we went through the pandemic where money rightly
00:21:31 slow uh flowed quickly in great quantity and freely out the door in order to help backstop people who
00:21:38 were being plunged into crisis uh at the household level with job loss and an economy that was
00:21:43 basically you know stopped all stopped all at once but looking back then a lot of folks realizing you
00:21:50 know i what was it the the the covid checks that were going to kids living in their parents basements
00:21:55 and that kind of thing and and so people will have some recollection of ways that money when it needs
00:22:02 to be spent quickly is perhaps not always spent best and i think that that's something that they can
00:22:07 sort of refer back on uh and beyond that crisis has a way of bringing people together and being in a
00:22:16 more uh amenable mood to follow a crisis leader so if the prime minister if the finance minister can
00:22:23 turn this into their hell or high water moment and say look we're going to do this you need to come
00:22:29 with us because everything is at stake i do think you will find a significant around amount of goodwill
00:22:35 around that the politics are always going to be the politics around the edges yeah but but the
00:22:39 responsibility is to number one leverage that moment but number two not screw it up by doing the 0.97
00:22:46 unnecessary or the stupid spending now it really seems like cbc is playing this weird game and let 0.85
00:22:51 me explain on one hand they're trying to criticize polyev as much as they can and they're doing it rather 0.97
00:22:57 unfairly on the other hand they're gently admitting gently alluding to the fact that polyev was right all
00:23:04 along and canadians made a huge mistake by electing carney that's what i'm getting and what i think is 0.68
00:23:10 happening is that these clowns they know that carney's days are numbered it's only a matter of 0.74
00:23:15 time before polyev gets into office so on one hand they want to slow that process down but on the other 0.91
00:23:20 hand they want to make sure that polyev doesn't go too hard on them however once polyev does get into
00:23:26 office he should go hard on them and punish them he should immediately end all the media bailouts do that on
00:23:32 day one defund the cbc abolish the cbc and then use all their abandoned buildings to help the homeless
00:23:40 it's brilliant and then he should go a step further he should file big strong powerful lawsuits against
00:23:47 the media companies that are still around and hold them accountable for defamation these media
00:23:52 companies have been defaming conservatives for years and they need to be held accountable and then
00:23:57 he can take the money he gets from those successful defamation lawsuits and use it to offset the
00:24:03 deficit do you think that's a good idea let me know either way polyev will be in office soon enough
00:24:09 if it's not before christmas it'll be shortly after have a great night talk to you tomorrow patriots