Mark Slapinski


CTV Makes SHOCKING CONFESSION About Poilievre

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Pierre Polyev faces the biggest test yet to his leadership this week, as Conservative Party of Canada members vote Friday on whether he stays or goes as leader. How will he fare at the party's convention in Calgary on Friday? We speak with Shachi Krill, President of the Angus Reid Institute, and Abacus Data CEO David Colletto to try and answer that question.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 If there was a single doubt in your mind that Polyev would ace his leadership review
00:00:03 and become the next Prime Minister of Canada, you simply have not been paying attention.
00:00:08 But don't take it from me. Take it from the fine folks at CTV.
00:00:12 He's set to face the biggest test yet to his leadership this week.
00:00:15 Party members will decide on Friday whether Polyev stays or goes as leader.
00:00:20 How will he fare at the convention vote in Calgary?
00:00:23 I spoke with Shachi Krill, President of the Angus Reid Institute
00:00:26 and Abacus Data CEO David Colletto a little earlier.
00:00:30 Hi, Shachi. Hi, David. Thanks so much for joining us. Appreciate you making the time.
00:00:35 Hey there.
00:00:36 Shachi, I'll start with you.
00:00:37 Before we get into the sort of mechanics of the party itself and conservative supporters,
00:00:42 top-line numbers, what are you seeing in the electorate right now
00:00:45 for the conservatives versus the liberals and Polyev versus Carney?
00:00:50 So right now, I mean, the conservatives, and we'll have new numbers early next week,
00:00:55 but they are holding their own within a couple of points of the liberals.
00:01:00 Sometimes a statistical tie.
00:01:01 So, you know, when we talk about the challenges for Pierre Polyev, you know, certainly conservatives
00:01:08 will push back and point out, well, if we were doing so badly, you know, why are we in very
00:01:14 good competitive situation with the liberals?
00:01:17 But that doesn't account for the fact that it's still not enough mathematically in terms of
00:01:24 percentage of popular vote or the number of seats they return to parliament to be in a position to
00:01:29 form a majority and that anybody but conservative sentiment continues to prevail.
00:01:36 In the era of Donald Trump, you will find block voters, NDP voters, even green voters who may hold their noses
00:01:42 and vote for the liberals because the narrative or the perception of Polyev, you know, sort of being
00:01:49 too close to that right-wing side of politics, too close to Trumpian politics, has been just absolutely toxic for him.
00:01:57 It's been kryptonite.
00:01:58 The lady in the video is saying the same thing that I've been saying for a while.
00:02:02 Liberals and conservatives are still tied right now, which is great.
00:02:06 And that's with Donald Trump in the picture.
00:02:08 The second that Donald Trump gets out of the picture, gets out of voters' minds, that's when the liberals are going to go down in the polls
00:02:14 and the conservative party is going to go up and up.
00:02:17 Donald Trump obviously won't be around forever.
00:02:19 And considering how bad his polling numbers are right now, there's a good chance he could lose the midterms.
00:02:25 The faster that Trump gets out of office, the faster we can get Polyev in office.
00:02:29 And you also start to see, Vashi, some wobbles and some doubts among past conservative voters.
00:02:36 So when we talk to people who voted conservative just about a year ago in that 2025 spring election,
00:02:43 only about 60% of those voters, an important distinction, those aren't paid up conservative party members.
00:02:49 They're people who voted, who now say only about 58%, 60% basically say Polyev should stay.
00:02:57 About a quarter of them think he should go.
00:02:59 So that is the concern, you know, in terms of the broad electorate.
00:03:04 What the party thinks of him, what his true faithful grassroots members think of him, obviously another story.
00:03:10 And David, you've done a deep dive into those numbers as well.
00:03:13 How would you explain sort of the different factions that make up a Polyev supporter base?
00:03:21 Yeah, well, I think if you look at what we call the conservative base, right,
00:03:25 those would be people who say, I'm not going to vote for any other party.
00:03:28 It's conservative or nothing.
00:03:29 They represent about one in four Canadians.
00:03:31 So it's a substantial number that make up its base.
00:03:34 It's always had that.
00:03:35 It's always had the advantage of a really high floor, and it's larger than the Liberals or the New Democrats or any other party.
00:03:42 But the problem is, as Sashi just highlighted, the ceiling is also quite low.
00:03:50 But if you look at those who are in that base, not only do they really like Pierre Polyev.
00:03:56 In fact, they tell us they trust him far more than they do even Stephen Harper or Doug Ford or Danielle Smith.
00:04:03 But they actually think overwhelmingly that he makes the party more electable, right?
00:04:08 And so that's, I think, a really important point about his relationship with that base.
00:04:13 They agree with him in not just his tone.
00:04:16 They want more confrontation.
00:04:18 They think the system is rigged against them.
00:04:21 They think, you know, the media is not reporting anything fairly.
00:04:24 They have deep suspicions around a lot of public institutions.
00:04:28 And yet, almost every other Canadian disagrees with that perspective.
00:04:32 And that's the paradox facing Polyev's leadership, in that at once he is likely going to do very, very well next weekend.
00:04:40 But at the same time, the more that people learn that, the more they might be off-putting for the exact reason that Sashi said at the beginning around the connection with Trump.
00:04:49 There's this weird thing sometimes in politics, and the three of us have talked about this before,
00:04:53 but, Sashi, where something feels really inevitable or really certain, and then all of a sudden it isn't.
00:04:59 And I've covered lots of stuff like that.
00:05:01 And I feel like it's almost impossible for Mr. Polyev not to do well in this leadership review,
00:05:08 given the support, as David mentions, he does have among the base of the party.
00:05:12 Is there a world in which that's not going to happen?
00:05:15 Like, what do you think is going to happen?
00:05:17 My God, it would be breathtaking, right?
00:05:20 Like, it would be a jaw-dropping moment if we didn't see what the political class,
00:05:27 or however we want to describe ourselves, view as him not receiving a threshold high enough to continue.
00:05:35 Because we have to remember, this is, as David's pointed out, Polyev's party.
00:05:40 The guy won the leadership with, what, like 90% of the vote?
00:05:45 So you would have to see a tremendous amount of defection from, you know,
00:05:50 a near-unanimous endorsement from him when he took the leadership.
00:05:54 And when we've asked conservatives in the past to kind of debrief and reflect on what went wrong in the last election,
00:06:01 you know, who do you blame?
00:06:03 Conservative voters at that time, and those diehards that David was talking about, 1.00
00:06:07 but even those who cast a, let's call it a warm or a friendly vote, if not, if not, you know,
00:06:13 until a death to us part loyalty vote, they didn't blame Polyev.
00:06:18 They blamed Trump.
00:06:20 They blamed Carney.
00:06:22 They blamed circumstances.
00:06:24 But they didn't blame the leader's approach in that last campaign, which arguably cost him the election.
00:06:31 So to see a level of defection that really calls his leadership into question, I do think would be, you know,
00:06:38 we can all doubt ourselves and, you know, talk to me in the wee hours, I guess, over the weekend morning to find out where things are at.
00:06:46 But it would be, I think, a really gobsmacking moment if he didn't have it.
00:06:51 The other piece of it is at least publicly, and yes, there have been floor crossings, and yes, there have been sort of voce grumblings about, you know,
00:07:00 from within conservative ranks, but you don't right now see an alternative.
00:07:05 And I find that, you know, for people to defect or to go somewhere else, it's not just should Polyev stay or go, it's what's my alternative.
00:07:15 And that alternative piece, you're not seeing or hearing within the ranks of the party or the caucus.
00:07:19 It feels like a very unique situation, David, in that, and I could be misinterpreting this,
00:07:24 but in that, like, I do feel as though Mr. Polyev's leadership of the party has taken the base
00:07:29 and the size of the scope of the level of support for the party to do heights.
00:07:34 At the same time, among the rest of the electorate, it does feel like that same leadership,
00:07:41 that is such a benefit to the party in some ways, is a real detriment in others.
00:07:44 It is, and let's be clear.
00:07:47 Historically, that's been a problem for conservative, particularly at the national level, conservative leaders, right,
00:07:52 who have always had a difficult time expanding beyond a certain number.
00:07:56 Even Stephen Harper did.
00:07:57 There was, you know, he hit 41, and he could not break past that when he won his majority.
00:08:02 The problem is that in the current context, where we have more or less a two-and-a-half-party system
00:08:09 with the bloc in Quebec, but really two parties outside of it, means that's not enough.
00:08:15 It's not enough to have assembled a coalition that's larger, maybe, than you've ever been able to do,
00:08:20 as long as, one, you've got a stronger liberal party,
00:08:23 and two, that Polyev is so off-putting to so many more people
00:08:28 that you may be inclined to vote NDP or green or bloc, but you're going to actually say,
00:08:32 you know what, no way, I'm going to go and vote liberal just to stop this guy.
00:08:36 And so that is the, that's the fundamental problem.
00:08:39 And I agree, I'm not sure there's someone who at once can both speak to the base of the party
00:08:45 and also grow it, right?
00:08:47 I don't believe that if Jean Charest was leader of the Conservative Party today,
00:08:51 that one, they would have won the last election,
00:08:53 or two, that they'd be in any stronger position,
00:08:55 because about a quarter of the Conservative base would look at Mr. Charest and say,
00:09:00 you're the exact problem that I want to see blown up and seen broken down and seen changed.
00:09:05 And so this is, this is the challenge that, that, that I think is not going to go away
00:09:11 if you replace Pierre Polyev.
00:09:13 It's going to continue because of the, what I call the opinion architecture
00:09:17 of the Conservative movement in Canada right now.
00:09:19 So let's summarize this, and I'll give you my interpretation of what they just said.
00:09:23 Polyev is going to ace his leadership review, and even CTV acknowledges it.
00:09:28 There is nobody else that's qualified to lead the Conservative Party,
00:09:31 and at least in my opinion, there's nobody else qualified to become the next Prime Minister of Canada.
00:09:36 That role belongs to Polyev and nobody else.
00:09:39 Now, when the mainstream media, which is obviously very biased against Polyev,
00:09:44 says good things, or things that are sort of in the middle,
00:09:47 that's a great sign, and that means Polyev is doing really well.
00:09:51 And I'll be the first to admit that politics is complicated, it's tricky,
00:09:55 and there's not a clear path to Polyev winning the next election.
00:09:58 However, he's got a new campaign manager, he has a new team,
00:10:02 and I think he's smart enough to approach the next election
00:10:05 a little bit differently than he approached the last election.
00:10:07 He did a great job last election, and he got some good numbers,
00:10:11 but unfortunately, he didn't win.
00:10:13 When you look at polling, the Conservatives lead in so many areas.
00:10:17 Canadians trust Conservatives when it comes to the economy and the cost of living.
00:10:21 So, on those issues, normal Canadians, they have a lot of faith in Polyev.
00:10:26 The only wild card right now, perhaps ironically, is the United States President.
00:10:30 Whenever the United States President starts acting up,
00:10:33 saying silly things like he wants to take over Greenland,
00:10:36 that pushes people away from the Conservative Party and into the arms of people like Carney.
00:10:41 So, a big part of the next election will be whether or not Trump decides to
00:10:45 stop saying stuff like that, or whether he keeps acting up.
00:10:49 Conservatives win on a lot of issues.
00:10:51 Canadians trust Polyev when it comes to the economy, cost of living.
00:10:55 The only thing the Liberals really dominate in is with Trump.
00:10:58 Now, if Trump just keeps his mouth shut, the Conservatives should do fine. 0.95
00:11:02 But whenever Trump starts saying silly things like he wants to annex Greenland, 0.79
00:11:07 all that does is push people away from people like Polyev and push them into the arms of people 0.98
00:11:11 like Carney.
00:11:12 And I hope people understand that.
00:11:14 Obviously, Canada and America are better off as allies.
00:11:17 And I think both Canada and America would have been better off if Polyev was in office,
00:11:22 and both Trump and Polyev work together.
00:11:24 But for whatever reason, Trump doesn't seem to understand that.
00:11:27 And I don't understand why he does what he does, but it's definitely not good for our
00:11:32 country, specifically Conservatives.
00:11:34 That being said, I'm still optimistic.
00:11:36 I'm still optimistic.
00:11:37 There's still a path to victory, however tricky it is.
00:11:40 And we're going to win, and we're going to win big.
00:11:42 So, thanks for tuning in.
00:11:44 I love you all.
00:11:45 Talk to you tomorrow, Patriots.