Mark Slapinski


CTV Panelists SLAM Carney Over Affordability Concerns

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

What are the political implications of Trump's latest threat, particularly ahead of the return of the House of Commons tomorrow? Here to weigh in is our Sunday strategy session with Kathleen Monk, James Moore, and Scott Reid, former communications director to Prime Minister Paul Martin.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 People are worried about the same thing they were worried about last year and the year before, a lack of affordability.
00:00:05 Carney is in big trouble because his puppets at CTV randomly decided to turn on him and ask the million-dollar question,
00:00:13 does Carney have a plan to deal with the affordability crisis?
00:00:16 And you can guess what the answer to that question was.
00:00:19 Now, the segment starts off with CTV doing what it normally does and giving undue praise to the prime minister.
00:00:25 Listen to this.
00:00:25 What are the political implications of Trump's latest threat, particularly ahead of the return of the House of Commons tomorrow?
00:00:32 Here to weigh in is our Sunday strategy session.
00:00:34 Kathleen Monk is former director of communications to the late Jack Layton.
00:00:38 James Moore is a former conservative cabinet minister.
00:00:41 And Scott Reid is former communications director to Prime Minister Paul Martin.
00:00:45 Hi, everybody.
00:00:46 Good to see you on this Sunday.
00:00:47 I appreciate you making the time.
00:00:48 Scott, I'll start with you.
00:00:50 The prime minister stopped to talk to reporters today, didn't engage too much on any communications with Trump,
00:00:55 just kind of downplayed actually how significant whatever happened with China was.
00:01:00 What does that tell you?
00:01:02 And how big of a deal do you think this is politically for him?
00:01:06 Well, it's significant.
00:01:07 But I liked I thought the prime minister's tone was bang on inappropriate because Donald Trump is a presidential equivalent of a metal spoon in the microwave these days.
00:01:20 He's sparking and lighting up all over the place.
00:01:22 It's not just Canada.
00:01:23 He unloaded 70 true social postings.
00:01:26 So he's lashing out at everyone.
00:01:28 We have to take serious his posting and his suggestion that he may oppose a 100 percent across-the-board terrorist.
00:01:35 But I'm not sure that it is a serious threat.
00:01:38 And in that context, taking a bit at a time, pointing out that Canada is not negotiating a free trade agreement with China, as Minister LeBlanc did,
00:01:46 pointing out, as the prime minister did, that there would be severe downsides to Donald Trump actually taking that kind of action.
00:01:52 Imagine the increase in the price of gas at the pump for Americans.
00:01:58 So taking a breath, not panicking, just being steady and sensible seems to me to be the right play at this moment,
00:02:06 particularly as you look at the broader context with how Donald Trump is conducting himself,
00:02:11 the isolation he's experiencing internationally, and the divisions he's provoking domestically.
00:02:15 Yeah, it's interesting because on the face of it, when you see a threat like that from a U.S. President, James, to Scott's point,
00:02:23 you have to take it seriously.
00:02:24 At the same time, we're just a few months, you know, a few weeks out from the last tariff threat of an additional 10 percent that Trump levied against us,
00:02:31 which was supposed to come because of that Ronald Reagan ad and then was, like, never spoken of again.
00:02:37 An important point that you just made.
00:02:39 Donald Trump has threatened three times more tariffs than he's actually ever imposed.
00:02:42 So the keep calm, carry on prose of the prime minister is the appropriate response.
00:02:48 You know, you can't react to everything Donald Trump says and does, but you do have to respond as a nation.
00:02:55 And the prime minister obviously had a very good moment in Davos to the point where you have Pierre Polyev for the first time,
00:03:00 I think, ever praising a sitting liberal prime minister because Pierre Polyev recognizes the moment
00:03:05 and the prime minister seems to recognize the moment coming out of his cabinet retreat,
00:03:09 that it's time to pivot and move forward and not be, you know, be disappointed, be internally angry, be publicly stoic.
00:03:16 And then when parliament comes back and as we move forward, there's never been a bigger barn door open for the prime minister of this country
00:03:22 with a union of solidarity behind him that is nonpartisan to go forward and do big things and be significant about that.
00:03:31 You know, the Super Bowl is around the corner a couple of weeks away.
00:03:33 We're supposed to have these sort of installments of major projects across the country.
00:03:37 There's a moment here for the prime minister to do something really significant and show Canadians that we are united
00:03:42 and we're doing big things as a country.
00:03:44 You know, it will be a really interesting, it feels like Kathleen returned to parliament tomorrow
00:03:49 for exactly the reason that James lays out.
00:03:52 The opportunity for the government is massive.
00:03:54 And to the point about Pierre Polyev, like, there's a ton of rhetoric from the opposition,
00:03:59 including the conservatives actually at this moment, about advancing those priorities together,
00:04:04 which is not something, to be honest, that, like, on any side, you normally hear ahead of a return to parliament,
00:04:10 like, at least not in the last little while.
00:04:12 And it speaks to the change in tone and what's needed, right?
00:04:16 And that tone shift for the conservatives is remarkable, that they're willing to cooperate,
00:04:20 possibly do joint negotiations with the U.S.
00:04:22 But what I found interesting from this morning and the prime minister was really the pushback that he got from one journalist.
00:04:28 He got basically one question put to him this morning, and it was,
00:04:31 how do you mortgage Canadians' affordability because you've angered Trump?
00:04:35 And bringing it back to those key issues that Canadians care about, about, like, how people are struggling day to day.
00:04:41 And Wob Canoo said it best in your last interview, which was just like,
00:04:45 he's got to do all the things at all the time, Prime Minister Carney.
00:04:47 He's got to deal with the affordability threats, the political threats,
00:04:50 and the electoral instability that the minority is, and then also deal with the geopolitical stuff.
00:04:56 But I think what was fascinating is that he did say this morning, the prime minister,
00:05:00 that there would be some affordability measures coming soon.
00:05:04 So what are they? Are they on the agenda?
00:05:06 How does he deal with the conservatives' pushback on affordability, immigration, crime?
00:05:10 Can he solve those political challenges so if there is an election,
00:05:13 the liberals are poised to do better or at least answer that big question of affordability on the problem?
00:05:18 We've seen them cut taxes in the past. Will they do more in the future?
00:05:21 And here's the part where Vashley decides to break ranks of the liberals and ask the million-dollar question.
00:05:26 Now, before I show you this, I want to remind you I'm being heavily censored on YouTube.
00:05:29 If you see this part of the video, let me know in the comment section.
00:05:32 Give me a like. Make sure you're still subscribed.
00:05:35 And as a bonus, let me know what city you're coming from.
00:05:37 I always like to know where people are coming from.
00:05:40 All right. Let's watch Vashley do her back. 1.00
00:05:42 Yeah. To what degree, Scott, do you think there needs to be like something tangible on that front?
00:05:48 I know we're all consumed at this sort of esoteric level with everything going on with the United States
00:05:52 and moral clarity and all those things.
00:05:54 But like people are worried about the same thing they were worried about last year and the year before,
00:05:59 a lack of affordability.
00:06:00 I'm not sure now is the exact moment where we need to just, you know, stencil a check and send it to every household.
00:06:07 I don't know that that's the appropriate response.
00:06:09 I think giving voice to the concerns that people have, making certain that Canadians don't watch the prime minister,
00:06:15 see how he's involved in these discussions, both internationally and across the border with Donald Trump,
00:06:21 and worry that maybe the prime minister and the government have forgotten about the daily struggles that people are experiencing.
00:06:26 Scott Reid just said it right there.
00:06:28 He was gentle with his words.
00:06:29 He was careful with his words.
00:06:31 However, I don't get paid by CTV.
00:06:33 I don't get paid by the liberals.
00:06:34 So I can say things a little bit more directly than he can.
00:06:38 Carney has been so busy globetrotting and virtue signaling
00:06:41 that he's forgotten that Canadians have very real issues in Canada.
00:06:45 The liberals don't have a plan to deal with the affordability crisis.
00:06:48 And even if they say they do, it's definitely not a very good one.
00:06:52 Carney's not too big on affordability.
00:06:54 That's his weakness.
00:06:56 That's his kryptonite.
00:06:57 And conservatives with Polyev, they dominate in that area.
00:07:01 The only thing keeping the liberals alive right now is Trump.
00:07:04 That was their main selling point for their last election.
00:07:06 And unfortunately, it worked quite well for them.
00:07:09 However, once Canadians realize that Carney is not living up to the expectations he set in dealing with Trump,
00:07:14 and that her economy is getting worse and not better,
00:07:16 they're going to start turning on the liberals.
00:07:18 And that's when the conservatives are going to win.
00:07:20 You've got to make certain that you connect all of this instability that stems from Trump
00:07:24 with the challenges that people are feeling and with your policy remedies.
00:07:28 But I don't know that they need to do something in the immediate term, again, in a panicky way.
00:07:33 And that really is not the recipe the prime minister tends to follow.
00:07:37 I think more important than anything, we shouldn't underestimate the connection that Canadians themselves make
00:07:44 between Donald Trump's erraticism and their own economic situation.
00:07:49 I do think Canadians lay this at the feet of Donald Trump.
00:07:53 And that's why it was smart of Pierre Polyev to ignore all those conservatives who are jamming the pages of the National Post
00:07:59 with numbskull commentary, trying to align themselves and, you know, say, ah, you know, actually, Trump's right.
00:08:05 That is not the play that Pierre Polyev supported.
00:08:07 He knows that that is electoral disaster.
00:08:10 And instead saying we've got to chart a similar course.
00:08:14 I've got 30 seconds left for both—30 seconds for James and 30 seconds for Kathleen.
00:08:18 James, what do you think about that?
00:08:20 I think that's exactly right.
00:08:21 One of the reasons Donald Trump's domestic support is cratering is because he's talking about golden domes and Greenland and Nobel Prizes.
00:08:28 The prime minister of this country and Pierre Polyev, who aspires to be the prime minister of this country,
00:08:33 needs to focus on the things that Canadians care about and not get sidetracked.
00:08:36 The difference between us and the United States is that the cost of living crisis, if you're an autoworker,
00:08:41 Donald Trump is your cost of living crisis because he's threatening your job.
00:08:44 So these two things are not actually mutually exclusive.
00:08:46 They're combined.
00:08:47 If you farm canola on the prairies, access to that Chinese market is a job issue and it is a cost of living issue.
00:08:54 So focus on the horizon.
00:08:56 Keep selling products to the world.
00:08:58 Don't get bullied by Donald Trump and Canada first.
00:09:00 That should be the ethos for everybody.
00:09:03 I'll crystallize it in one line. 0.54
00:09:05 Americans are watching as President Trump chooses to kidnap and kill his own citizens as opposed to lowering prices.
00:09:11 Canadians are watching that in horror and want our government to chart a new path and a new way forward.
00:09:17 It's funny how the CTV panel is saying exactly what I've been saying.
00:09:21 Polyev is playing the game like a true chess master because the best move he can make right now is to separate himself from Donald Trump.
00:09:27 Aligning himself with Donald Trump would be political suicide.
00:09:30 And I applied Polyev for doing the right thing and not listening to the more radical elements of his base.
00:09:36 Canadians deserve a more efficient government.
00:09:38 They deserve lower income taxes, immigration reform. 1.00
00:09:42 And those are all things that Polyev can deliver on.
00:09:44 And when I say immigration reform, I don't mean what Donald Trump is doing in the United States.
00:09:48 The whole world, including myself, was rightfully horrified when they saw an ICU nurse being shot in broad daylight.
00:09:57 And if you don't think that's what happened, I encourage you to watch the video in slow motion.
00:10:01 Don't listen to other people's interpretations because they're lying, they're gaslighting.
00:10:05 Just watch the video and see what happened to yourself.
00:10:08 Trump is really on a collision course.
00:10:09 And if he keeps up this bad behavior, he's all but guaranteed to lose the midterms.
00:10:13 Now, I understand a lot of my followers, they're on Team Trump.
00:10:16 However, I'm not on Team Trump.
00:10:18 I'm on Team Canada and Team Polyev.
00:10:21 I still have faith that Polyev is going to win and her country is going to get back on track.
00:10:25 It's just going to take a little bit more time than I previously thought.
00:10:28 So just hang in there.
00:10:29 Have some faith.
00:10:30 We're going to win.
00:10:31 Talk to you soon, Patriots.