Mark Slapinski


CTV Panelists Sound Alarm Over Carney's Budget

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

It's been a long time since Canada has had a budget, and it's finally here. But what exactly will it say about the economy, and what will it mean for the future of the country's finances? To find out, our three economic experts John Manley, Jean-Francois Perrault and Amanda Lang join us to discuss.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 CTV now admits that Kearney's days, they're numbered.
00:00:03 And when I say numbered, I mean it could all come crashing down as early as tomorrow.
00:00:08 But right now we want to drill down on the possible content of this budget.
00:00:11 It's significance to Canadians and of course really to the economy more largely.
00:00:18 This budget comes after a long wait.
00:00:20 It's been since spring of 2024 that we've seen a budget tabled.
00:00:23 There was of course last December a fall economic statement,
00:00:26 but that was buried by Chrystia Freeland resigning that day. 0.89
00:00:30 So it's been a long time coming, I guess you could say.
00:00:33 And here to help us unpack the potential significance from an economic perspective of this budget,
00:00:39 our three experts in the field.
00:00:40 Former Finance Minister John Manley is with us.
00:00:42 He's the chair of Jefferies Financial Canada and the chair of the Telescorp board.
00:00:46 Jean-François Perrault is Scotiabank's senior vice president and chief economist.
00:00:51 And rounding us out this evening is CTV News chief financial correspondent Amanda Lang.
00:00:55 Hi everybody, it's good to see you tonight.
00:00:57 Thank you very much for making the time.
00:00:59 Amanda, I will start with you because I noticed today,
00:01:01 and my colleague Abigail Beeman was reporting earlier,
00:01:04 the finance minister did not call this today a budget of investment and austerity,
00:01:08 like we heard the prime minister say a few months ago.
00:01:10 He used the word investment over and over again.
00:01:13 What does that tell you?
00:01:15 I mean, I think it tells us that they want us to focus on where we're going.
00:01:19 This is a budget that will be a vision of what Canada can do
00:01:22 in the face of some pretty dire circumstances.
00:01:24 It's also obviously going to have to lay out some details around what it does
00:01:28 in the face of lower revenue and a real economic challenge.
00:01:32 So I've actually wondered, Vashi, whether that word austerity from the prime minister
00:01:35 wasn't so much about the cuts he's going to present,
00:01:38 although we do expect to see some of that,
00:01:40 but about what the government itself is dealing with.
00:01:43 It is actually dealing with, of course,
00:01:45 arguably a weaker revenue outlook in the face of everything that's going on,
00:01:49 and yet it has to spend.
00:01:50 So it's this weird kind of push-full situation.
00:01:54 Former finance minister Manley must be being glad he's not there trying to do it,
00:01:58 where you have to invest and you've got less money to do it with.
00:02:02 John, let me jump off that point and ask you,
00:02:04 like what kind of conundrum in that vein do you think this government faces?
00:02:07 Well, first of all, they've got to worry about our fiscal situation.
00:02:13 We haven't really followed a fiscal anchor in quite a long time in Canada,
00:02:18 and eventually that catches up with you.
00:02:22 You know, we reached a point in the early days of the Khrushchev government
00:02:26 when we almost couldn't float our bonds on the international markets
00:02:29 because, strangely enough, when you borrow money,
00:02:32 the people lend it to you, want to be sure that they're going to get repaid
00:02:36 and that they're going to earn a return on it.
00:02:37 So what's the fiscal anchor going to be is one big question.
00:02:42 The prime minister in his campaign promised a different way of accounting,
00:02:47 a capital budget and an expenditure budget or a consumption budget, if you like,
00:02:53 the capital budget being for investments,
00:02:56 and said that we'll balance the other budget, the expenditure budget,
00:03:00 while we're borrowing to do capital investments.
00:03:03 Well, let's see what that actually means.
00:03:06 How do they define it?
00:03:08 An investment to me means you're putting money into something that's going to pay a return.
00:03:13 You know, we've seen lots of things called investments over the past.
00:03:17 They don't necessarily pay returns to the government.
00:03:19 All right.
00:03:20 So let me break this down for you.
00:03:22 Canada is going bankrupt.
00:03:24 That's just a nice way of saying it, what he said.
00:03:26 I'm saying it a little bit more directly.
00:03:28 All Carney is doing is he's using nice words to cover up the fact that Canada is going to go bankrupt.
00:03:35 Like I said in yesterday's video, our country, Canada, has more resources than Saudi Arabia.
00:03:41 But you look at Saudi Arabia, everyone's driving around nice cars.
00:03:44 They have nice pets.
00:03:45 They live in big houses.
00:03:46 You look at Canada.
00:03:47 People are literally starving.
00:03:49 And I'll have more to say on that later in the video.
00:03:51 Before we go any further, I want to remind you I'm being censored.
00:03:55 If you see this part, let me know in the comment section.
00:03:57 Give me a like and make sure you're still subscribed.
00:04:00 People complain all the time.
00:04:01 They say, Mark, I subscribe to you, but I don't see your videos.
00:04:04 Or they say I subscribe to you, but YouTube unsubscribed me against my knowledge.
00:04:10 So just double check.
00:04:11 Jean-François, I wondered if you could paint a picture for us of the level of uncertainty in the economy that they face right now.
00:04:18 Like what are the headwinds that in part this trade war has brought upon us?
00:04:23 Yeah, and I think that's an extremely important way to think about the budget that will be announced tomorrow.
00:04:31 And the government of the Bank of Canada has talked about this extensively as well.
00:04:34 I mean, the economy is weak.
00:04:36 There's no question about that.
00:04:37 But it's weak for two reasons.
00:04:40 It's weak in part structurally.
00:04:41 It's weak because productivity has been low for a long time.
00:04:43 Investment has been low.
00:04:45 And that creates kind of a weak economy with which to deal with the types of shocks that we're dealing with now.
00:04:52 But importantly, what's going on in the context of this trade conflict with the Americans and this broader realignment of economic activity is a need to transform the economy, which, of course, the prime minister campaigned on very effectively.
00:05:05 And that will entail a need for significant amounts of investments, ideally by the private sector, but obviously with some government assistance of some form, to help the economy kind of transition from the world in which we've been operating to the world in which we will be operating over the next few years and then maybe longer than that.
00:05:24 So that's a tricky thing for governments to manage.
00:05:27 You know, how do we how do we think about fiscal policy in that context?
00:05:30 How do we think about the size of the budget deficit that is required?
00:05:34 Is the budget deficit required to kickstart the economy, kickstart this transformation?
00:05:38 Of course, the government is making that an informed decision.
00:05:41 I suspect that that is the case, that we do need some government assistance, some government help to, you know, start that transition to catalyze investment.
00:05:50 But, of course, how effective they will be will depend to some extent on what's in the budget tomorrow and how they go about convincing us that they are doing the right things for us.
00:05:59 So the finance minister asks you, Amanda, you know, what advice do you have for me?
00:06:03 I want to catalyze private investment because exactly what Jean-Francois said in that vein is what we have heard.
00:06:08 The prime minister in particular say that will be the objective of either policy or the investments ultimately that they make on that so-called side of the ledger.
00:06:17 What kinds of policies or investments, in your view, would be effective in that manner?
00:06:22 So the problem here, Vashi, is there's nothing new.
00:06:25 They're not reinventing anything.
00:06:27 The way you catalyze investment is create circumstances that create confidence.
00:06:32 So you want to invite capital in, which means that you're reducing your red tape and your government regulations.
00:06:38 You could lower corporate taxes.
00:06:39 You could do things to incentivize investment by business.
00:06:42 But we've done those things in the past and we haven't seen a massive return and we're in an emergency.
00:06:49 So the real problem here is we actually need government spending that actually creates almost a near term return.
00:06:56 So when we think about this new ledger they're going to present with this long term kind of capital investment spending, it sounds great.
00:07:02 And there is a real benefit in that.
00:07:04 But you can say we're building a mine in northern Ontario that the actual economic payoff of that is way down the road.
00:07:12 And housing, you know, you can create construction jobs in the near term fashion by investing in housing.
00:07:16 Housing is kind of non-productive to productive capital investment.
00:07:19 So how do you actually create economic growth in Canada?
00:07:23 It's with trade.
00:07:24 We have to trade with the rest of the world.
00:07:25 And that's not necessarily an investment so much as trade deals and policies that spur activity.
00:07:31 Did you hear that? 0.99
00:07:32 CTV is basically admitting that Canada is fucked. 0.99
00:07:35 And we're fucked because we're not doing enough trade with the rest of the world. 1.00
00:07:38 And remind me for a second. 0.99
00:07:40 Whose responsibility was it to get us on track?
00:07:43 Hmm.
00:07:43 Maybe the prime minister?
00:07:46 Maybe the same guy that said he was going to get a good deal with Donald Trump?
00:07:49 Maybe the same guy that sold us, sold himself as the person, this economic genius that was going to sort everything out.
00:07:56 Maybe that guy?
00:07:57 Now, of course, these liberal hacks, they all got their checks in the mail.
00:08:00 They won't say the quiet part out loud.
00:08:02 But that's what I'm here for.
00:08:03 Are you concerned at all, John, about sort of what Amanda lays out there?
00:08:08 Which is, when we say the word transform, like, by its own nature, that's not something that happens overnight.
00:08:14 So, like, what will be or what could be stimulative in the near term without adding to the fiscal issues that you already laid out?
00:08:25 Well, I think there are a few items that Amanda's already mentioned.
00:08:29 I mean, clearly, you've got to get your investment climate right.
00:08:32 We're net importers of capital.
00:08:34 We need the capital to do the works that need to be done, whether they're long-term or short-term.
00:08:39 And that means that investors have to have some confidence that they can get to a yes when they want to build a project.
00:08:47 They have to be satisfied that the returns they're going to get are as good or better than the returns they can get elsewhere.
00:08:55 And that means, in part, we've got to be able to demonstrate that we have access to international markets, including the United States.
00:09:02 It doesn't have to be tariff-free.
00:09:03 We can deal with tariffs.
00:09:06 But other markets as well.
00:09:08 We're rich in natural resources.
00:09:11 We've been very poor at getting those out of the ground and into foreign hands, where we want to sell them in order to get the returns on them.
00:09:21 But that's the quickest way for us to earn the kind of money that we need to make, is to get those resources to markets.
00:09:29 And it means regulatory reforms, and it means that we've got to have the prime minister and a cabinet and provincial premiers that are out there saying, we can do this.
00:09:42 We are going to do this.
00:09:43 We're going to strip down those interprovincial trade barriers once and for all.
00:09:47 We're going to build the infrastructure necessary in our ports, on our highways, our transportation systems, not just pipelines, but all of the other things that we need to do in order to get our goods into foreign hands.
00:10:00 Now, I do know a politician that was willing to do all those things.
00:10:04 I forget his name, though.
00:10:05 He was a tall, muscular, good-looking guy.
00:10:08 He's got his hair slicked back.
00:10:09 He used to wear glasses.
00:10:11 Now he doesn't.
00:10:12 I think his wife is South American, maybe Colombian, Venezuelan.
00:10:16 If you know his name, let me know in the comments section.
00:10:20 Jean-François, what is your perspective on, and what we've kind of talked about in laying out things they can do near-term, mid-term, long-term, your perspective on the fiscal situation?
00:10:30 There's been a ton of conversation, sometimes debate about how sustainable or not the federal government's finances are.
00:10:37 What is your level of concern about, let's say, a $75 billion deficit?
00:10:42 What does it mean to you?
00:10:43 I'm not overly concerned with the short-term deficit number.
00:10:50 Clearly, it's going to be a big number.
00:10:51 It's the $75,000, $80,000, $100,000.
00:10:53 I mean, we'll see.
00:10:54 What I'm worried about or what I'm more interested in is the path going forward as a kind of a secondary consideration to what you're actually getting for the $75,000, $80,000, whatever the deficit's going to be in the short run.
00:11:06 If you have a deficit that generates growth that, again, catalyzes an investment that leads to stronger private sector investment next year, and even more so hopefully beyond that, that's an entirely different context in which you evaluate whether a budget deficit is sustainable or not.
00:11:22 And historically, of course, that's not been the case.
00:11:25 We run big deficits.
00:11:25 It's not led to the type of investment that would increase what we call potential output growth or median term growth.
00:11:32 If there's elements of this budget that stream transformation that are clearly going to lead to higher private sector investment, that will lead to higher productivity, you know, if that costs us a little bit in the short run to kickstart that, I think that's okay.
00:11:49 Now, if this time next year we're having this conversation and we've done the $75 or $100 billion deficit and productivity hasn't turned around, there isn't any early evidence that the private sector is doing anything differently, then it's a very different story, very different conversation we're going to have.
00:12:03 But right now, you know, we've got a government that seems to understand the challenges we're facing, that we need a lot more investment.
00:12:08 They're focused on that.
00:12:09 Part of the reason I think they have this split between operating capital is to signal that they're really serious about the capital side of things.
00:12:16 And that gives me a greater degree of comfort that they will do the right things tomorrow and in months beyond that relative to, say, previous governments who were less focused on, you know, increasing capital stock.
00:12:31 Amanda, the government has signaled a lot about what they want Canadians to know will be in this budget.
00:12:36 Is there something that they haven't signaled yet that you would like to see explained, you know, detailed in the budget in some way?
00:12:46 Do you know what, Vashti, as we have this conversation, what I'm really thinking about is I want to be surprised by something.
00:12:50 I want to see something they haven't shared with us yet that's really visionary that makes me say, yes, this gives me confidence.
00:12:58 You know, to GF's point, you can spend an awful lot of money.
00:13:01 And if you're fighting off an emergency, your house is on fire, you need to put the fire out.
00:13:07 If you've ever seen a house after it's been fire hosed, it doesn't look very good.
00:13:11 You can spend a lot of money and not get anywhere.
00:13:14 And then you've got this massive debt.
00:13:16 What we would all, I think, like to see is something we haven't heard yet, something that will actually propel the country in some direction where the investment makes sense and will actually kind of galvanize, not just us, but foreign investors as well, that there's a real kind of vision for the future here.
00:13:32 I'm not saying we're going to get it.
00:13:33 I'm just that's what I wish for, because that's that's really what we need right now.
00:13:37 This is an emergency, but we can't waste the opportunity and spend on things that don't make a difference.
00:13:42 So there you have it. CTV is literally admitting on live television that Canada is going bankrupt and Carney is to blame.
00:13:49 Of course, they can't say it as directly as I can, but that's really what they're getting at.
00:13:53 And based on their assessment, which aligns with my assessment and the assessment of many conservatives, Carney is not going to be around much longer.
00:14:01 Think about it. If you're a prime minister and you sold yourself as an economic genius and now you have plans to literally bankrupt the country, you're not going to stick around very long.
00:14:11 Eventually, people are going to figure out what's happening and they're going to turn on you.
00:14:15 And I believe the way Carney is going, it's only a matter of time.
00:14:18 Now, of course, I can't predict the future and I hate to make predictions, but two things are going to happen.
00:14:23 Either the budget goes through and Carney sticks around or the opposition parties can vote against it and Carney's gone.
00:14:31 Now, I really don't want to say which one is more likely, but I'll tell you what I want to happen.
00:14:36 I'll be straight with you. Conservatives have seen a promising rise in the polls, and that's great.
00:14:41 However, I don't think we're ready as conservatives for a Christmas election.
00:14:45 It's too early.
00:14:46 In a roundabout way, I think it's actually better if the budget vote does pass and Carney sticks around a little bit longer.
00:14:53 But hear me out here.
00:14:55 Having Carney stick around a little bit longer gives them a bit more time to make mistakes.
00:14:59 It gives Canadians a bit more time to realize the mistake they made in voting for him, at least the liberals.
00:15:04 And it gives us time to get our plan together.
00:15:07 Because I believe the conservatives are going to win, and they're going to win big.
00:15:10 And we're going to get a supermajority, but it's going to take a little bit more time.
00:15:14 Now, I know, I know that's not the news you want to hear.
00:15:18 But we've got to look at the long game.
00:15:20 I'm looking at 10, 15 years of a conservative supermajority government.
00:15:24 And that's going to take time.
00:15:26 We've survived 10 years of the liberals, so I think we can hold on just a little bit longer.
00:15:30 But worry not, it's only a matter of time before we're living like the Saudis. 1.00
00:15:34 We're going to be driving nice cars, living in nice mansions, owning exotic animals, and going on trips at least twice a year.
00:15:42 Just hang in there.
00:15:43 Have some more faith.
00:15:44 Have a bit more patience.
00:15:46 We're going to win, and we're going to win big.
00:15:48 Have a great night.
00:15:49 Talk to you tomorrow, patriots.