Mark Slapinski


🚨 I Could Be Going To Jail For Doing Journalism

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Bill C-9 expands the scope of hate crimes and expands the state's power to prosecute hate crimes. Conservative MP Andrew Lawton speaks in support of the bill, and why he's worried about the impact on freedom of speech.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I have an announcement, and this is serious.
00:00:03 If the Liberal government has its way, I could be going to prison.
00:00:06 And it's not just me.
00:00:08 Other Conservatives that do what I do are also at risk.
00:00:11 I'm going to show you a clip of Andrew Lawton, an MP,
00:00:14 speaking about this issue in Parliament,
00:00:16 and then I'm going to explain at the end why I'm really worried.
00:00:19 Thank you very much, Madam Speaker.
00:00:21 It is a privilege to be able to speak to Bill C-9.
00:00:26 Although I have grave concerns with not the objective,
00:00:31 but the manner in which the Liberals have gone about trying to achieve that.
00:00:34 Let me, from the outset, say that I'm grateful the Liberals have finally recognized
00:00:38 that there is a wave of hate sweeping this country.
00:00:41 I'm glad they've realized what the Jewish community in this country,
00:00:45 among others, has been crying out for for years,
00:00:47 which is a government that will listen to these concerns
00:00:49 and understand the very real threats that are targeting them on a regular basis.
00:00:55 But just as the Liberals have done with Bill C-2,
00:00:57 just as they've done on the firearms file,
00:00:59 they take a legitimate issue and they offer a remedy
00:01:03 that attacks the rights of citizens and expands the state's power,
00:01:09 often without the checks and balances necessary.
00:01:11 Now, Bill C-9 does five things.
00:01:14 It repeals the requirement that the Attorney General
00:01:16 consents to proceedings for hate charges.
00:01:20 It creates an offense of willfully promoting hatred
00:01:22 against an identifiable group by displaying certain symbols in a public place.
00:01:27 It creates a hate crime offense for committing an offense
00:01:31 that is motivated by hate.
00:01:33 It creates an offense of intimidating a person
00:01:35 to impede them from accessing certain places
00:01:37 predominantly used for religious worship.
00:01:40 And it creates an offense of intentionally obstructing
00:01:43 or interfering with a person's lawful access to such places.
00:01:47 Now, of these five things, three of them are already covered by existing laws.
00:01:53 Creating an offense of willfully promoting hatred by displaying a symbol.
00:01:57 Section 319-2 of the Criminal Code already targets the willful promotion of hatred.
00:02:04 It targets incitement of hatred.
00:02:06 And the courts have been very broad in their interpretation
00:02:09 of how that communication must take place.
00:02:11 Symbols are a part of that.
00:02:13 And I could actually give an example from my own writing
00:02:16 where someone was charged just within the last two weeks
00:02:20 in central Elgin, Ontario with a hate charge under 319-2
00:02:25 after having mowed a swastika into their front lawn.
00:02:28 The display of a hate symbol led to a hate charge under the existing law.
00:02:35 Creating a hate offense is also redundant
00:02:37 because hate motivation is already an aggravating factor
00:02:40 under Section 718-2 of the Criminal Code.
00:02:44 And it has been consistently applied by the courts.
00:02:48 Creating offenses for intimidation and obstruction at places of worship
00:02:52 already criminalized under Section 423 of the Criminal Code,
00:02:57 Section 431 and 434.1
00:03:00 as well as under the laws pertaining to threats, 264.1.
00:03:04 And so what we are left with when we strip away these three things
00:03:10 which are already covered by existing laws are two things.
00:03:14 C9 really does two things.
00:03:17 Number one, it removes the requirement for the Attorney General to consent.
00:03:20 Now this has been viewed by activists and advocates
00:03:23 on the left and the right in this country
00:03:25 as a necessary safeguard against overzealous and political prosecutions
00:03:31 by law enforcement or by Crown attorneys
00:03:36 or by law enforcement that simply don't understand this
00:03:39 because it is a rarely applied provision of the law.
00:03:43 And the next part of it, and this is the most egregious part
00:03:46 and where I will spend the remainder of my time, Madam Speaker,
00:03:49 the government is codifying a new definition of hate.
00:03:54 A new definition of hate.
00:03:56 Now, Bill C-9 describes hatred as, quote,
00:03:58 the emotion that involves detestation or vilification
00:04:02 and that is stronger than disdain or dislike.
00:04:06 Now, the government has said this is adapted from the Keegstra Supreme Court decision,
00:04:11 a seminal free expression case in Canada,
00:04:14 but it actually changes something very key.
00:04:17 In Keegstra, the court held that hatred connotes emotion
00:04:19 of an intense and extreme nature
00:04:22 that is clearly associated with vilification and detestation.
00:04:25 This was expanded on in the Watcott decision,
00:04:28 which says hate is extreme manifestations of the emotion
00:04:32 described by the words detestation and vilification.
00:04:36 The word extreme does not appear in Bill C-9.
00:04:40 Now, the government is very proud of this bill.
00:04:43 The government has had all summer to work on it.
00:04:45 They have had, I don't know how many stakeholders,
00:04:47 staffers, bureaucrats, lawmakers and lawyers look over it
00:04:51 with every, I imagine, every clause with a fine-tooth comb.
00:04:55 Omitting a word, an operative word,
00:04:59 a very key word in a very key section of this bill is no accident.
00:05:03 The government is, to use a legal term,
00:05:05 willfully lowering the threshold on what constitutes hate
00:05:09 by extension expanding the state's power
00:05:12 and lowering the threshold of what can be regarded
00:05:15 as free expression in this country.
00:05:17 Now, why this is so important to me and to the Canadians
00:05:21 who have been speaking out about Bill C-9 to this point,
00:05:23 Madam Speaker, is because this government has been,
00:05:25 to its credit, very transparent
00:05:27 on where it wants to go on free expression.
00:05:30 In the last two parliaments,
00:05:32 the Liberal government has introduced sweeping censorship bills
00:05:35 that have been decried by voices on the left and the right
00:05:38 under the auspices of tackling so-called online harms.
00:05:41 Now, the Liberals have told us, as recently as last week,
00:05:45 that this is coming back.
00:05:48 The online harms bill is still very much a live issue.
00:05:52 So we cannot look at Bill C-9 in isolation.
00:05:55 We cannot disentangle it from this Liberal government's
00:05:58 stated attitudes already about freedom of expression
00:06:01 and, quite frankly, the contempt in which they hold
00:06:05 free expression and open debate.
00:06:07 Now, I'm going to quote someone that I believe the Liberals
00:06:11 have a great affinity for,
00:06:12 and that is former Canadian Chief Justice Beverly McLaughlin.
00:06:15 In her Keegstra dissent, she wrote,
00:06:19 If the guarantee of free expression is to be meaningful,
00:06:22 it must protect expression which challenges
00:06:24 even the very basic conceptions about our society.
00:06:28 A true commitment to freedom demands nothing less.
00:06:31 Freedom of expression, I should say, demands nothing less.
00:06:34 We do not need to look far to see what happens
00:06:37 when the threshold for hate is lowered.
00:06:40 In the United Kingdom, police are not even rarely
00:06:43 knocking on doors and arresting people over mean tweets.
00:06:48 Because the same desire that we're seeing behind
00:06:51 some of the negative and concerning impulses in C-9
00:06:54 is criminalizing hate based on the grounds
00:06:58 that words are violence.
00:07:00 Censors justify their limitations on freedom of expression,
00:07:03 by elevating speech to violence.
00:07:07 It is not for the state to discern,
00:07:09 let alone prosecute, hate that may exist in one's heart.
00:07:12 The law is to punish action,
00:07:14 and the existing laws already do this.
00:07:18 Now, I'd be remiss to not point out
00:07:19 that the Liberals only get tough on crime
00:07:22 when they're talking about thought criminals.
00:07:24 These are the only people that the Liberals
00:07:26 want to put behind bars.
00:07:28 So let's look at some of the real hate crimes
00:07:30 across the country.
00:07:31 According to Juneau News,
00:07:32 130-some-odd churches have been vandalized
00:07:35 or victimized by arson since 2021.
00:07:39 Synagogues in Canada have been firebombed
00:07:41 and vandalized,
00:07:42 and Jewish schools have been shot at.
00:07:44 If the Liberals were serious about real hate crimes,
00:07:48 they would be seeking mandatory 10-year prison sentences
00:07:50 for these heinous assaults on places of worship.
00:07:53 Again, the law should punish bad behavior
00:07:56 and not bad feelings.
00:07:59 And to be fair, we cannot confront
00:08:01 the hatred that exists in Canada
00:08:03 and in Canadian society
00:08:04 without acknowledging some of the root causes of it.
00:08:07 The crisis of hate
00:08:09 is a direct consequence of 10 years
00:08:12 of divisive Liberal identity politics
00:08:14 and the reckless breaking of the immigration system
00:08:18 by this Liberal government.
00:08:19 We cannot talk about hate
00:08:21 without talking about
00:08:23 the breaking of the immigration system
00:08:25 that has resulted in the importation
00:08:26 of foreign conflicts
00:08:27 and, in some cases,
00:08:29 very hateful ideologies into this country.
00:08:32 Now, much of this happened
00:08:33 on the watch of the Justice Minister
00:08:35 who tabled this bill.
00:08:37 He was the Immigration Minister
00:08:38 who looked at the first six years
00:08:40 of Justin Trudeau's government
00:08:41 and how immigration was bungled there
00:08:43 and said,
00:08:43 don't worry, I can do worse.
00:08:45 And he did.
00:08:46 It's no coincidence
00:08:47 that hate crimes have risen
00:08:49 as Canada has become less discerning
00:08:51 and more reckless
00:08:52 in its handling of the immigration system.
00:08:55 This is a crisis of the Liberals' creation.
00:08:58 I do not trust those who caused the problem
00:09:01 to solve it.
00:09:03 And I think all people
00:09:04 who may agree with the motivation
00:09:06 behind this bill
00:09:07 should be very cautious
00:09:09 to hand over this level of power
00:09:11 to the Liberals
00:09:12 when they have already demonstrated
00:09:14 where they want to go.
00:09:16 They have already demonstrated
00:09:17 what they want to do.
00:09:19 I'll return to another quote
00:09:21 by former Chief Justice McLaughlin
00:09:23 because she says,
00:09:26 it is not to say
00:09:27 that it is always illegitimate
00:09:28 for governments to curtail expression,
00:09:30 but government attempts to do so
00:09:32 must be viewed with suspicion.
00:09:36 This Liberal government
00:09:37 does not deserve the benefit
00:09:38 of the doubt on hate.
00:09:41 It does not deserve the benefit
00:09:42 of the doubt on protecting
00:09:43 charter liberties.
00:09:44 It does not deserve
00:09:46 the benefit of the doubt
00:09:47 on any of the problems
00:09:49 that it has been instrumental
00:09:51 in either allowing to fester
00:09:53 or in some cases outright cause.
00:09:56 So Bill C-9, 0.92
00:09:58 the good is already done
00:10:00 by additional laws.
00:10:01 The bad should send a warning sign
00:10:04 and the Liberals should be very ashamed
00:10:06 of trying to sneak this
00:10:07 through the back door
00:10:08 with a lower threshold for hate
00:10:10 in a country that needs to protect
00:10:11 and double down on free expression.
00:10:13 Thank you.
00:10:15 Questions and comments?
00:10:18 Hamilton West, Ancaster, Dundas.
00:10:20 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:10:22 We've got the real Conservative A-Team
00:10:23 this afternoon.
00:10:26 Repeated Conservative conspiracy theories
00:10:28 over and over in the House.
00:10:30 If we want to talk about real hate crimes
00:10:32 and I'm not quoting, you know,
00:10:34 alt-right so-called alternative news,
00:10:37 talking about Jewish members
00:10:39 in my community
00:10:40 who are covering their Jewish identity
00:10:45 in public.
00:10:45 That is the hate that we're talking about
00:10:47 that this bill seeks to address.
00:10:49 So I'm trying to understand
00:10:51 what is the members opposite
00:10:53 real objection to this legislation.
00:10:57 And when they talk about freedom of expression,
00:10:59 it seems more and more likely
00:11:02 that what they're talking about
00:11:04 is freedom for their members
00:11:06 to say whatever they want
00:11:08 without consequences.
00:11:09 Is that the real objection?
00:11:11 Thank you.
00:11:12 The Home Member for Elgin St. Thomas, London South.
00:11:15 Mr. Speaker, I wish the member
00:11:16 had spent less time working on
00:11:17 what he thought was a zinger
00:11:18 and more time listening to my speech,
00:11:20 where I detailed in excruciatingly
00:11:23 and I will argue painful detail,
00:11:26 real hate that is occurring
00:11:28 against Christians, 0.92
00:11:28 against the Jewish community. 0.54
00:11:29 I mentioned the firebombing of synagogues, 1.00
00:11:31 the shooting of Jewish schools.
00:11:33 And by the way,
00:11:33 the members should be well aware
00:11:35 that the Jewish community
00:11:36 has looked at this liberal government
00:11:38 and been absolutely ashamed
00:11:40 to be represented by people
00:11:42 that have cozied up with the very people
00:11:44 who are responsible for Jew hatred 0.97
00:11:46 in this country.
00:11:48 So I do not take any cues from this member
00:11:50 who wants to accuse conservatives
00:11:51 standing up for freedom
00:11:52 of being conspiracy theorists.
00:11:54 He should be ashamed of that.
00:11:56 Here, here, here, here, here.
00:11:57 Just the honour and commentaire,
00:11:58 the honour of the deputy de Jean-Kierre.
00:12:00 The honourable member for Jean-Kierre.
00:12:03 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:12:05 I was listening to my colleague.
00:12:07 He said we should have mandatory minimums
00:12:10 for church-based or synagogue-based vandalism.
00:12:16 I can see where he gets this idea.
00:12:21 But if you take it further,
00:12:23 if you take it further,
00:12:24 I wonder if my colleague would agree
00:12:26 that the religious exemption
00:12:28 for hate speech should be abolished or not.
00:12:33 What does he think?
00:12:34 Should we get rid of the religious exemption 1.00
00:12:35 in this bill?
00:12:36 Thomas London South.
00:12:38 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:12:39 And I thank my colleague for his question
00:12:40 and his commitment to actually interrogating
00:12:43 what is not in this bill.
00:12:45 And the reason I raised what I did
00:12:47 about the lack of stiff penalties
00:12:49 for people who assault in heinous ways
00:12:53 places of worship
00:12:54 is because this is something
00:12:55 that is not theoretical.
00:12:56 It's not hypothetical.
00:12:57 We see it happening
00:12:58 on a sadly regular basis in this country.
00:13:00 And it is not covered by this liberal law.
00:13:03 And liberals in the past
00:13:04 have actually been endorsing
00:13:07 or rationalizing
00:13:08 to some of these assaults on churches.
00:13:10 So I think this is an important discussion
00:13:12 and I want to see real action on real hate,
00:13:15 not lowering the threshold
00:13:16 on how we define it.
00:13:18 Questions and comments?
00:13:20 The Honourable Member
00:13:20 for Aurora Oak Ridges, Richmond Hill.
00:13:23 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:13:24 Mr. Speaker, peculiarly,
00:13:26 this bill that the Liberals have put together
00:13:29 addresses things that are already covered
00:13:32 by the Legal Code of Canada.
00:13:35 There are already laws protecting
00:13:37 and actually speaking to things
00:13:40 like the swastika and other things.
00:13:42 Could the Member elaborate a little bit further
00:13:44 on why he thinks those things
00:13:46 that are already covered by law in Canada
00:13:48 are virtually being signaled
00:13:51 by these Liberals in debate here in the House?
00:13:56 The Honourable Member for Elgin St. Thomas, London South.
00:13:58 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:13:59 And thank you to my colleague.
00:14:00 And that is indeed one of the glaring issues with this.
00:14:02 The parts of the bill that there's no objection to
00:14:06 from me or my colleagues
00:14:07 are things that are already illegal in Canada,
00:14:10 making this redundant in a lot of ways.
00:14:12 And I pointed to a recent case
00:14:14 where someone was charged for displaying a hate symbol
00:14:16 under existing hate laws.
00:14:18 Now, I have to draw attention to the fact
00:14:20 that not half an hour ago,
00:14:21 I pointed this out to the Parliamentary Secretary,
00:14:24 to the Justice Minister, a lawyer herself,
00:14:26 and she had no idea.
00:14:27 She had no answer.
00:14:28 So if the Liberals have not prepared
00:14:29 for the most basic challenging of this,
00:14:32 what else have they not actually investigated
00:14:34 on their own legislation?
00:14:36 Time for a brief question.
00:14:37 The Honourable Parliamentary Secretary,
00:14:38 the Government House Leader.
00:14:39 Mr. Speaker, providing clarity
00:14:41 and providing strong legislation
00:14:44 is really critically important.
00:14:45 We are seeing that in this bill.
00:14:47 The question I have for the member is,
00:14:48 would he apply the very same principle
00:14:50 that he is saying now with respect to this bill
00:14:53 to private members' bills,
00:14:55 which are numerous coming from the Conservative Party,
00:14:57 where the criminal law already covers it?
00:14:59 Would he suggest that we...
00:15:00 Logan St. Thomas, London South, 25 seconds or less.
00:15:03 Thank you.
00:15:04 I don't need that much time to say what I've already said
00:15:06 because the member I don't think was listening,
00:15:08 which is that we need to enforce the existing laws
00:15:10 where they already cover what's happening
00:15:12 in this country on hate.
00:15:13 But moreover, we cannot allow the Liberal government
00:15:15 to sneak into law a lower threshold for defining hate
00:15:19 that will be used to curb free expression in this country.
00:15:23 That was a brilliant speech by Lawton,
00:15:25 and I commend him for doing that.
00:15:26 In case you're unaware,
00:15:28 Andrew Lawton was a long-time political commentator
00:15:30 for right-wing news organization True North.
00:15:33 And it looks like he's putting his political commentary skills
00:15:35 to good use.
00:15:37 And I also believe that very few people understand
00:15:39 Conservative politics as much as somebody
00:15:42 who made a living talking about Conservative politics.
00:15:45 So I just wanted to add that.
00:15:47 But I do agree with Andrew Lawton about this bill.
00:15:50 Bill C-9 is bad news.
00:15:51 There's serious concerns with this bill.
00:15:53 Canada already has laws against hate speech.
00:15:56 However, because freedom of expression is enshrined in the Charter,
00:16:00 the standard that has to be met for someone to be charged is really high.
00:16:04 And the standard that has to be met for someone to be convicted is even higher.
00:16:08 Only the worst of the worst get convicted of hate speech in Canada.
00:16:11 And rightfully so.
00:16:12 The Liberal government is now trying to change this,
00:16:15 meaning that journalists and political commentators will have to walk on eggshells.
00:16:18 Now to be fair, this legislation isn't as bad as Trudeau's online harms bill.
00:16:22 However, this does show the Liberal government is willing to pick up where Trudeau left off.
00:16:27 Quite frankly, I don't approve of hate speech laws at all.
00:16:30 While the government says these laws are to prevent against hate speech,
00:16:33 they could be used to censor people that are critical of the government.
00:16:37 That's why it's a slippery slope and we need to push back.
00:16:40 The fact of the matter is that Canada is becoming more and more like the United Kingdom every single day.
00:16:44 In case you're unaware, in the United Kingdom, you can literally be sent to jail
00:16:48 for criticizing mass immigration or radical Islam.
00:16:52 If Carney gets his way, that'll be the end of civilization as we know it in Canada.
00:16:57 That being said, it's still legal for me to make these videos right now.
00:17:01 However, if the Liberals have their way, people like me will in fact be sent to jail.
00:17:06 I'm not fear-mongering.
00:17:08 I'm not being hyperbolic.
00:17:09 That's the reality we're faced with.
00:17:11 And that's why we need PolyEv in office.
00:17:13 We really need to get PolyEv in office.
00:17:16 Or else, every street corner is going to have a mosque 1.00
00:17:19 and kids will start learning Arabic and the Quran in elementary school.
00:17:23 I'm not joking.