Mark Slapinski


THE END: No Confidence Vote Coming Soon ⚠️

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

PM Mark Carney finally faces a No Confidence vote on his first budget, and it looks like it's going to be a doozy. But what does that mean for the PM and the rest of the country?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 now this is the moment we've all been waiting for mark carney finally faces a no confidence vote
00:00:05 which will happen next month is this the end let's take a look in about five weeks we're going to
00:00:11 learn just how much the government is spending that's when prime minister mark carney's government
00:00:15 the finance minister and minister champagne will table his first budget recently i said that this
00:00:21 prime minister was just as irresponsible with money as justin trudeau and i now realize that
00:00:26 that was unfair to justin trudeau how is it even possible for this prime minister to be more
00:00:31 fiscally incompetent than the drama teacher this government is conducting a comprehensive spending
00:00:39 review this government is building houses this government is building projects in the national
00:00:46 interest this government is building canada strong come join us and you can come join us on november
00:00:53 fourth when we cover that budget because the prime minister is warning of a substantial deficit
00:00:57 and that could be losing mark carney some key potential parliamentary votes wow cbc just admitted
00:01:04 that mark carney is going to lose votes over his disastrous budget but just wait that's not the
00:01:10 worst part that part's coming up they will face canadians and quebecers with the 1.00
00:01:15 the unbelievable deficit which looks like madness i don't see how i do not i cannot see how
00:01:27 we could support a budget which is first based on some taxes reductions electoral gifts
00:01:37 and some fantasies in many regards i cannot support that i don't see how we could support that
00:01:44 yes you heard that right the blog is putting a no confidence vote back on the table and i'll
00:01:49 explain what that is and what that'll look like later in the video okay so kate a couple of things
00:01:54 jump out for me there one justin trudeau still catching strays he's gone very unfair um but second
00:02:01 uh the bloc évecois was looking for a permanent increase in the old age security uh payments last
00:02:06 year right which is billions of extra dollars excuse me while i pick my jaw up off the floor
00:02:10 the bloc évecois talking about the inappropriateness of electoral gifts yes but but that is uh you know
00:02:18 we haven't seen the budget we we have no what the pbo says you know what other people we don't know
00:02:22 what the deficit actually is but uh that is not a good sign in a minority parliament no for for that
00:02:28 position to be taken today uh no um and i think the bloc is in a pretty reactive place we also saw
00:02:34 news today that you know the us is lobbying hard but not to anybody's surprise but lobbying very hard for
00:02:39 uh a crack at the the dairy market obviously they have key industries that are being hit hard in
00:02:44 the province by tariffs um and a lot of change happening in the province as it relates to you
00:02:49 know critical minerals and failed battery plants and a number of things that are going on so um they
00:02:53 are reacting to a moment i think where they are seeing quebec not achieve much uh and so they are
00:02:58 dangling early uh i think what they would what they would like to see or at least letting the
00:03:02 government know that um they uh they will need to be convinced in order to uh in order to support
00:03:09 this and when you look at the dynamics of the house in terms of how that plays out in numbers
00:03:12 puts the nep in a very challenging spot to almost definitely support this i know don davies was not
00:03:17 uh particularly effusive one way or the other but um yeah i think that this is the opening of a
00:03:23 negotiation i would think for the block as it always is around budget time uh if you want our support
00:03:28 show us the money yeah i i i don't know if mark hardy will negotiate with the block uh jordan based
00:03:33 on you know his answers when he's asked about a parliamentary arrangement with the ndp back after
00:03:37 the election don davies i mean he recklessly said he won't pre-judge a budget he hasn't seen
00:03:42 but you know the math does uh math against him right and that the ndp who do not want an election
00:03:48 right now might be forced either abstain or support uh or else risk parliament here well look it's early
00:03:54 days we still have this is i think you're exactly right this these are the opening rounds in in a
00:03:59 bargaining situation that maybe prime minister carney's unaware that he's in but he is in it
00:04:04 he's got a lot of negotiations always be horse trading particularly when votes are going to be
00:04:09 as close as they are and i think you know it's important to remember that we are talking about
00:04:13 a pretty slim number of votes that would be required in terms of people uh getting the you know
00:04:19 the parliamentary flu or staying home in some other way it's you only assuming the liberals have
00:04:25 all their votes you only need three from any party so it's not a terribly tall order to find that i
00:04:31 don't think it means that the new democrats need to support this budget and in fact i have a really
00:04:35 hard time imagining that there's any scenario in which it makes political sense for them to support
00:04:40 the budget this has been framed up as an austerity budget that's going to be making serious cuts to
00:04:46 public services that's going to be rolling back on climate commitments where we haven't seen robust
00:04:52 support for workers and people who are facing unemployment there's not a lot in the window for
00:04:56 the ndp right now and it's tough to see what what the prime minister might be willing to give them that
00:05:02 could bring them on board so i think it's it's going to be a math game for the government um i hope
00:05:07 their whips office is very well rested um but you know at the end of the day i think it's still very
00:05:13 likely this budget is going to pass but accidents do happen yes austerity and investment jordan this
00:05:19 is yes we'll see i look forward to that i mean look i i understand what they're saying just we
00:05:25 need to see the details and look i i am not uh amanda trying to you know gin up any false drama that we're
00:05:31 headed to an election and the government's going to fall on this but but it could force you to alter
00:05:36 your plans right in terms of what you want to do in the budget versus what you have to do in the budget
00:05:40 to get things through i mean what do you make of what mr blanchette had to say and and how you see
00:05:44 this dynamic maybe playing out well there's theater and then there's blanchette's theater
00:05:50 and we are very familiar with what this looks like we remember all of the you know the many votes
00:05:57 of the last sessions and he would find his time to get up to the mic uh prior to those votes and make
00:06:04 his grand standing case and this works well for him right because i think otherwise where is the
00:06:09 relevance on the federal scene like how does he how does he attract that kind of attention and i
00:06:16 think that this is one area that he's quite successful at when you know he makes these uh
00:06:21 these big statements uses a lot of rhetoric that he knows will play well in his home province uh of
00:06:26 quebec uh at the same time i agree with everything jordan said this is a numbers game there there are three
00:06:32 votes away i don't think anyone thinks that this budget won't pass i think that that would be uh crazy
00:06:38 because nobody wants to go to an election right now just a quick note i'm pretty sure a lot of
00:06:43 conservatives would like to have a new election at least that's what people say in my comment section
00:06:48 it looks like cbc is back to its old practice of hiring pro carny characters uh so well i would
00:06:54 just chalk it up to a little bit of theater on blanchette's part and potentially yes the beginning
00:06:58 of a bit of a negotiation although i know i'm not sure how much negotiation is necessary on the part of
00:07:04 the government right now well and tanya there's no big demands out there i know that the pierre
00:07:07 polyev basically says pass all of my ideas as sort of his solution to things but there's no big
00:07:12 car he's working on it i was going to say wait long enough i think you might get it as well
00:07:16 touche but like that's what polyev's blanchette said today you know you have pierre polyev in the
00:07:21 prime minister's office you know he's a he's a conservative in a red dress so uh he didn't say dress
00:07:28 that was a really dumb comment of course carney stole all of polyev's good ideas however
00:07:34 carney will never be half the politician that polyev is i'm not sure where cbc finds all these 0.91
00:07:39 bimbos let's not start any rumors here on the show but but you know what what is there to negotiate 0.94
00:07:44 here is what i want i don't know that there's something to negotiate because i think two things
00:07:48 i took away from that scrum with mr blanchette and by the way i love blanchette theater in french and
00:07:54 english um but he pretty clearly said there's no consultation going on whatsoever with this pmo and
00:08:01 any of the opposition parties and i find that interesting uh you know 30 days out from roughly
00:08:07 a budget that's billed as and i'm going to say austerity budget because the rest is you know
00:08:12 let's see uh there's no talking to the opposition parties in a minority parliament interesting and the
00:08:20 other thing i took away from what he said is he criticized pretty much all the you know on the
00:08:25 postal strike on the deficit everything you can think of federally that's being done right now the
00:08:30 the projects an oil pipeline he slammed the federal government at every turn as a centralizing force
00:08:37 that's not well managed and so that's playing into his argument in quebec in a year ahead of what's
00:08:43 expected to be an election that will see an independent or a sovereignist party elected and
00:08:48 potentially leading down the road to a referendum he has promised to build that case in parliament and
00:08:52 outside parliament this year and i think we always have to hear him in that context you know kate i i
00:08:58 don't know what consultation is happening with the various parties i do uh earlier today i was going
00:09:04 to try to open up this email elizabeth may was asked about the budget uh pre-question period she
00:09:08 confirmed she is going to have a meeting with the prime minister very soon so there they will be
00:09:13 speaking to the greens i don't know that's one vote no yeah there you go i need two more but i don't
00:09:18 know if you then move your way up through the standings is that how you do it you know um i i don't
00:09:23 know but uh there's some conversations seemingly happening these people really annoy me they seem
00:09:28 to think the politics is a joke they're laughing they're having fun they're clowning around but
00:09:34 what's funny what's funny about the fact that immigration and crime are out of control what's 0.94
00:09:39 funny about the fact that our economy is falling off a cliff these people really need to be defunded
00:09:45 i don't think it is um a stretch to suggest that a lot of the consultation is happening at 80
00:09:51 wellington street and nowhere else i think about some of the recent announcements that have happened
00:09:56 and they seem to take members of the liberal caucus by surprise in terms of of the details contained
00:10:00 therein uh so the the central agency and the pmo is behaving very much as a central agency uh you you
00:10:07 had the house leader on a couple weeks ago when parliament started talking about you know who he was
00:10:11 willing to work with and maybe those that he wasn't so willing to work with um if this is being
00:10:15 developed in a vacuum the budget being developed in a vacuum and negotiations around it uh i think that
00:10:20 would be very typical of the prime minister's management style today well stephen mckinnon
00:10:24 in the morning of that day of that interview jordan said we're gonna have a budget in october
00:10:28 and then when he sat down with me at five o'clock he said well we'll have it soon and then we found
00:10:31 out it was november so things are changing when the defense policy was announced while the minister
00:10:36 was on a plane like there's a real pattern in in that behavior and you know and i think and this is
00:10:42 this is something that tanda wrote about this week this is a government that has a problem
00:10:46 communicating not just with canadians about what it is that they're up to and how they're
00:10:52 delivering results but even within their own caucus so they have a significant challenge
00:10:56 ahead of the budget to tell the story about the sacrifice that they're talking about for the
00:11:01 potential long-term gain that they're laying out but they need to be communicating more with
00:11:06 canadians about what's going on and that hasn't really been happening it's very internally focused so i
00:11:10 think that they've got challenges there not just in communicating with the other parties but in
00:11:15 in building the overall narrative uh for this budget in a way that actually makes sense to
00:11:20 people on the ground now i want to add carney isn't communicating with the public because he
00:11:24 hasn't accomplished anything if he accomplished something he'd be telling people the reason he's
00:11:29 not saying anything is because he hasn't done anything the way i see it this isn't a communication
00:11:34 issue this is a competence issue amanda do you see it that way that there's an issue communicating
00:11:39 with canadians here that the public opinion numbers would suggest that the prime minister's
00:11:42 personal numbers remain high even if there has been some erosion since the election which is
00:11:48 a normal course of things i mean do you think they're in that kind of a situation yet because
00:11:52 this is going to be a complex budget by all signs and it's going to need a it's going to
00:11:58 need a narrative yeah well i think it's just it's the nature of the complex time though as well
00:12:04 it's not just solely focused on the budget and delivering the budget messages we have you know
00:12:09 the prime minister in different areas of the globe negotiating with other leaders to find
00:12:15 new arrangements in the wake of the trump tariffs and so there's a lot of narratives at play at the
00:12:19 same time although they're doing quite a bit of telegraphing they're talking about a substantial
00:12:23 deficit they're saying that it's a result of uh the tariff supports of tax cuts for affordability
00:12:30 so they're and for defense spending so they are telegraphing some of it um and i would say the other
00:12:35 thing on on you know whether or not the prime minister is speaking to blanchette or speaking
00:12:40 to anybody else just because he's not speaking to blanchette or the office isn't speaking to
00:12:43 blanchette doesn't mean that they're not speaking to others so i i don't know that that's necessarily
00:12:49 um an accurate portrayal of what's happening i would imagine with the budget just being a few
00:12:53 weeks away that those discussions are underway and i don't think they're just happening in the pmo
00:12:58 tana on the communications issue i mean there's communications issues that this town and this
00:13:03 profession gets seized with and then there's the bro you know there's normal canadians and their
00:13:07 uh communication and conversation with you know the the direction of government how do you see it do
00:13:12 you think there is a broader challenge uh that this government is facing in terms of reaching the
00:13:16 people who just selected them back in october uh i think six months five six months into kearney's
00:13:21 government um we have seen a pattern of a a reluctance of reticence to um be more open to
00:13:29 canadians more broadly and i'm not talking about answering emails from journalists i'm talking
00:13:34 about explaining rationales for policy debates around policy options explaining once the policy
00:13:40 is adopted what's really going on behind it for example you know the latest yesterday's uh
00:13:46 loan to algoma i mean trying to parse through exactly what the government's conditions are for
00:13:52 that and the rationale for it has taken us two days um so i just uh i do see that they have a bit of a
00:13:58 problem and a reticence to do some of this work and i think to jordan's point it's not just about
00:14:04 political marketing of something it's also social acceptance of something i think that if the
00:14:09 government is planning uh you know the cuts at the level that they seem to be telegraphing
00:14:15 you get buy-in from people if you treat them like adults and explain some of it and so maybe
00:14:20 yeah sure we can all wait till they start spinning it november 5th but um i think that the government
00:14:25 itself could do uh everybody a favor by speaking about its tariff strategy its trade talks uh its
00:14:33 international discussions with ceos abroad on trade diversification on budget cuts all of that i think
00:14:40 they could do a better job of explaining that to canadians and um i no i think it is very much
00:14:46 sort of a corporate uh his corporate leanings it's it's it's mark carney as ceo of an asset
00:14:53 management firm called the government of canada yes he doesn't want to communicate on process but
00:14:56 more decision points and outcomes yeah actions and we'll let you know when we have something to let you
00:15:00 know about and that's stephen harper my god how many times we tell us i'll tell you i'll make an
00:15:05 announcement when i have something to announce and but stephen harper also did a fair bit of retail
00:15:09 politics that's what's missing for prime minister that's the difference so if prime minister
00:15:14 carney is unable to articulate uh for canadians in a you know a palatable way the status of trade
00:15:20 diversification the negotiations with canada us all of the things that he was elected to do and he's
00:15:26 also unable to communicate on crime and immigration and housing and affordability policies what on earth
00:15:32 is he communicating on and he was elected to do the former not hearing much there and he's therefore
00:15:37 leaving the lane open on the retail political issues okay so what to say here despite cbc's attempts
00:15:42 at whitewashing the situation i truly believe carney is on his way out the ndp wants nothing to do
00:15:48 with him the bloc wants nothing to do with them the conservatives want nothing to do with them
00:15:52 and most canadians want nothing to do with them he simply doesn't have the support to continue so
00:15:57 what is a no confidence vote anyway a no confidence vote is a motion that declares that
00:16:02 the sitting government has lost majority support if it passes the government is either forced to
00:16:07 have a new election or the prime minister has to resign if it passes the government either dissolves
00:16:13 and there's a new election or the prime minister is forced to resign now there is a history of
00:16:18 successful non-confidence votes even in canada if we go back to 2009 paul martin's liberal government
00:16:24 was successfully defeated by a no confidence vote more recently the prime minister of france was
00:16:30 booted out due to a no confidence vote now france has a different political system than we do but
00:16:35 it's similar now like i've said a hundred times before i truly believe mark carney's days are
00:16:40 numbered the cbc is turned on him or mostly ctv is turned on him his budget officer turned on him
00:16:47 his liberal mp was caught on tape admitting his gun buyback program is a complete scam
00:16:53 now we have the ndp turning on him the bloc turning on him and it seems like everyone is turning on him
00:16:58 every day carney goes lower and lower in the polls whereas polyev and the conservative party go higher
00:17:04 and higher it's only a matter of time before mark carney gets forced out or he decides to leave have
00:17:09 a bit of faith have a bit of patience we'll get what we want very very soon i promise you that have
00:17:16 have a great weekend patriots
00:17:21 you