New Culture Forum - April 20, 2020


2.21 Lionel Shriver: Coronavirus, Woody Allen & Defending Free Speech

2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won Dave Rubin: Defending Free Speech - Covid-19 - Trump 2020 + His New Book: "Don't Burn This Book"

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

133.18

Word count

6,335

Sentence count

312


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that today
00:00:21 we have back one of our very first guests when we started last year. Lionel Shriver is one of
00:00:28 our most celebrated novelists. She's the author of such books as Big Brother and We Need to Talk
00:00:34 About Kevin. She's a columnist for The Spectator but she's also seen more and more on different
00:00:39 media such as most recently Question Time. Thank you for coming back a year later. It's my pleasure.
00:00:47 Thank you very much. We had a good time last time. Yes we did indeed. Yeah we had a two-parter last
00:00:52 time. I wanted to start. It's very much in the air. Sorry pardon that terrible pun. It's very
00:00:58 much in the air at the moment when we're recording this the coronavirus I wanted to know what your
00:01:06 view on this was I know that you wrote an article quite recently and I think it was sort of obviously
00:01:14 relatively light-hearted but you were talking about how the whole kind of woke nonsense which
00:01:20 we addressed last time what might actually change that and you said it would be something very
00:01:25 serious happening um possibly a worldwide epidemic and and here we are i mean you know i don't mean
00:01:32 to be frivolous about this i know you weren't being but i mean it does seem to appear to have
00:01:37 wiped off you know from social media some of the more outrageous sort of stuff going on yeah for
00:01:43 now yeah um yes i've said from the beginning that uh the likes of identity politics are are an
00:01:53 indulgence. They're ultimately in entertainment, a rather poisonous form in my view. But it's
00:02:01 something that society can only afford in a condition of peace and prosperity. It's a
00:02:10 kind of thumb twiddling, really. And the one thing that could make it go away is the white
00:02:18 heat of real problems.
00:02:20 Now, the trouble with that solution is then you have to have the real problems, and then
00:02:31 we remember what trouble is.
00:02:35 And right now, I mean, I'm less concerned on an epidemiological level, it's a tongue
00:02:43 twister, than I am on a fiscal one.
00:02:47 So, tell us, you know, explain that to me.
00:02:52 Well, my readership may recall that in 2016, I released a book called The Mandibles.
00:03:01 It takes place in 2029, and it involves the economic collapse of the United States, the fall of the dollar.
00:03:13 And that's triggered by a sovereign debt crisis.
00:03:18 The president refuses to repay the national debt.
00:03:22 He cancels it.
00:03:25 I would have liked to think that it was in the realm of fantasy,
00:03:28 but actually I don't think it is.
00:03:31 And I did a lot of homework for that book.
00:03:34 It was the real pleasure of that book, actually,
00:03:37 the discovery of the world of economics,
00:03:40 which I had, I'd always dismissed it as boring. It's anything but boring now. And I came away
00:03:51 collectively with the impression that the entire international financial system was a house of
00:03:59 cards, that it was fantastically built on debt and not real money, not real value, and
00:04:11 also full of people propping each other up and lies and I didn't realize before that
00:04:24 We never had a system in place whereby every single currency in the world is a fiat currency,
00:04:31 which means there's nothing backing it up and there's nothing stopping governments
00:04:34 from producing as much currency as they want, which is what they do.
00:04:42 It was petrifying.
00:04:44 And therefore, what frightens me about what's going on with the markets now
00:04:49 is that it may have been sparked by fears of a recession and the coronavirus,
00:04:59 but eventually a virus peaks and goes away.
00:05:06 I worry that what happens when things are that disruptive
00:05:12 is that everyone starts looking down.
00:05:16 you know what you're told not to do when you're on a precipice and and everyone
00:05:25 discovers that that the entire world economy is based on debt because that's
00:05:30 of course how we got out of 2008 we lowered the interest rates to zero
00:05:34 sometimes less than zero which of course and this that was a debt crisis right it
00:05:41 was all those all those bad loans to people who couldn't pay back their
00:05:45 mortgages. And that's really what sparked it. We solved it with more debt. We made it possible to
00:05:51 borrow money for nothing. And what do you get? More debt. We've been in this debt spiral now
00:05:58 and we're not out of it. And it just keeps getting worse. Because all you do is reward debtors,
00:06:03 you punish savers, and you make money free. And I don't believe capitalism functions with free
00:06:11 money you know then why not just borrow all the money you need for your wife and then die
00:06:18 you don't have to earn anything i mean i know that's reductio ad absurdum but it's not that crazy
00:06:26 it sort of really basically means we're all bankrupt doesn't it really yeah yeah it does
00:06:32 and i'm i'm seriously where i don't know whether this is when it happens but uh in my household
00:06:39 we talk about it all the time.
00:06:43 And it's not clear how to protect oneself from it.
00:06:46 And I'm convinced that actually there is no protection.
00:06:49 When you read the Amanda Bores,
00:06:51 was it received as being somehow fantastical
00:06:58 or completely unfeasible?
00:07:02 Actually, the economists who read it that I know of
00:07:08 found it totally credible,
00:07:10 which I found both gratifying
00:07:12 and terrifying.
00:07:15 I didn't want to be right.
00:07:16 I mean, that's one of the weird things about having written that book,
00:07:18 is that I don't want to be right.
00:07:20 I don't want to be prescient, because
00:07:22 it's not just going to be
00:07:24 me sitting back and
00:07:26 being self-satisfied that I
00:07:28 was prescient, but it's going to happen
00:07:30 to me. It's going to happen to me, it's going to happen to my
00:07:32 family, and
00:07:33 my friends, and
00:07:36 I don't want it.
00:07:38 But when you take a look at the big picture, it's just unsustainable.
00:07:43 The amount of debt in the world, both private and public, and corporate, is staggering.
00:07:51 And essentially it means that we all think there's a...
00:07:55 Because debt creates money, right?
00:07:59 It creates...
00:08:00 Because the assumption is that it's going to be paid back.
00:08:03 If it's never going to be paid back, and the numbers look so frightening that, no, I don't think it is ever on any of these levels is going to be paid back, then what is supposedly an asset, because when you borrow money, then the person to whom you owe it regards that loan as an asset, all that asset is actually a big black hole.
00:08:29 It doesn't exist.
00:08:31 So, you know, I don't want to be right, and I don't know whether this is it,
00:08:38 but whenever entire monetary systems are this disturbed,
00:08:45 and we never stopped being disturbed since 2008, nothing's ever gone back to normal,
00:08:49 then there's the capacity for a lack of confidence a lack of faith in the system which is what keeps
00:09:01 it going to implode everything I mean you know we were joking at the before we started this
00:09:08 about how you know essentially the world monetary system is like belief in fairies and if you stop
00:09:17 believing in fairies, then Tinkerbell dies.
00:09:21 At what point do you think a crunch would come then?
00:09:25 If you take where we are now,
00:09:28 if the situation is as precarious as that, as bankrupt as that,
00:09:32 at what point do you think, Lionel, it would suddenly turn over into something else then?
00:09:38 At what point would the two collide,
00:09:41 the epidemic and the economic system?
00:09:45 Well, they're colliding right now.
00:09:47 I mean, yeah, I think people are torn about which issue to worry about.
00:09:56 I can stay home and I can wash my hands,
00:10:01 but I can't keep my stock portfolio from turning to dust.
00:10:06 So, you know, we do what we can do.
00:10:09 Ultimately, what I see is a dysfunction
00:10:15 and also a form of mass deceit.
00:10:21 It's bigger than we are, and we can't fix it,
00:10:24 and there's nothing to do but be fatalistic.
00:10:27 I don't know what else to say.
00:10:30 You've written about it, but on the whole,
00:10:32 would you say our culture on the whole basically doesn't address this?
00:10:36 I mean, are there other novelists or artists or playwrights
00:10:44 Well, of course, the apocalyptic narrative is commonplace in fiction.
00:10:53 But there are not very many economic dystopias,
00:11:00 and I think that's where my book tends to stand out.
00:11:06 And I do think that the fragility of economic systems
00:11:14 may be even more important than climate change.
00:11:19 And the other thing is that what we're seeing now
00:11:22 is that problems don't exist in a vacuum,
00:11:26 and they interact.
00:11:29 So economic fragility also interacts with a pandemic,
00:11:35 with climate change, with migration, you know, everything.
00:11:41 But the thing is, you do take on these sort of big issues, don't you?
00:11:45 Healthcare is another one.
00:11:46 Yes, however improbably.
00:11:48 Big brother.
00:11:50 Actually, so much for that is all about the dysfunctions of American healthcare.
00:11:55 Right, so much for that.
00:11:57 But, I mean, the point is on the whole, I think our culture, is it not,
00:12:02 is characterized by people not taking on these big things.
00:12:05 Well, part of it is, of course, rationally,
00:12:08 A lot of fiction readers don't want to read about it, so it needs to be packaged in such a way that it's a good story and is involving for its own sake and not just because it's worthy or calling your attention to something that's terribly important.
00:12:28 And first and foremost, whenever I'm writing any book,
00:12:33 whatever issue I might be addressing,
00:12:36 it's more important than anything to tell an entertaining story
00:12:40 that's well-written and funny and has lots of dialogue.
00:12:51 That's my job.
00:12:52 and therefore ultimately
00:12:54 when I take on bigger issues
00:12:58 it's always a kind of candy coating
00:13:00 I'm making it fun
00:13:04 But they're there
00:13:06 I mean that's the background to them
00:13:08 I was reminded of this
00:13:10 when you wrote recently in The Spectator
00:13:12 if I could just give a bit of background
00:13:14 you wrote recently after I think
00:13:16 one of those question time appearances
00:13:18 you sort of got notification
00:13:22 of the end of a friendship from another writer.
00:13:25 But you mentioned you did an open letter in The Spectator.
00:13:29 This is what you wrote.
00:13:30 And you said, you know, I tend to take on broader issues.
00:13:35 And I think that you said this person tended to be more intimate,
00:13:38 shall we say, in their writing.
00:13:40 But, you know, that was quite extraordinary, really.
00:13:43 This was a relatively long friendship.
00:13:45 Yeah, 13 years.
00:13:47 And what happened, actually, what happened to end it?
00:13:52 well of course
00:13:55 as a fiction writer
00:13:59 I probably shouldn't be going on question time
00:14:01 to begin with
00:14:01 the risks are too high
00:14:03 and I don't do it very often
00:14:06 but you're a columnist
00:14:07 but I am a columnist
00:14:09 and I take an interest in British politics
00:14:12 and
00:14:13 and I'm one of the people
00:14:17 they call who isn't
00:14:20 You know, on the far left, one of the few people, you know, that they used to try to balance the panel, and a non-politician.
00:14:28 So that was an episode in which once more the outrage of Boris Johnson's comparing a veiled woman to a letterbox was touted out as proof that he's a terrible racist.
00:14:53 And, you know, throughout the campaign it was also used as an example of why the entire Tory party is racist.
00:15:02 And I just said, excuse me, but what is so insulting about being compared to a letterbox?
00:15:12 I just don't think it's self-evident.
00:15:15 It's a small element of domestic architecture.
00:15:18 um it's like saying uh you look like a window sash
00:15:26 and i and i when there is i said that because i guess i get so frustrated that people take
00:15:35 take on faith how they should interpret something like that you know why don't they think from
00:15:42 themselves well hold on a minute well that's it's kind of a kooky comparison but why is that so
00:15:49 hurtful so i got into an argument with a couple of muslim women who were uh you know you know the
00:15:56 type professionally incensed and they probably hire themselves out for parties um and uh and
00:16:04 this i this this and a couple of other remarks was enough to lose me this friendship and i i did
00:16:10 find it shocking. He's a very decent, nice person and I was really disappointed. I went
00:16:31 through an interesting emotional sequence because often when people do something that
00:16:39 strikes home then your first reaction is anger which is very defensive it's like
00:16:45 and then once you get a little perspective you have to admit to
00:16:49 yourself that what you're really experiences is a sense of injury yes
00:16:53 yes and sorrow and hurt and for me it was completely to the opposite opposite
00:17:03 sequence because I felt hurt first yes and then I realized actually I'm fucking
00:17:11 furious yeah no and and to to have been sacked as a friend because I didn't
00:17:20 think that calling comparing someone to a letter letterbox was especially
00:17:25 insulting I mean that has comment potential but it you know it was real
00:17:31 real. And it made me sympathetic with a lot of other people who are having the same problems.
00:17:38 We now live in a very polarized time when relationships are conditional. And I know
00:17:47 that a lot of relationships have been severed over Brexit. And of course that was part of
00:17:53 the basket of complaints that my friend has.
00:17:56 I think we talked about this last time, but it always appeared one way.
00:17:59 I'm sorry, to me it's always appeared one way.
00:18:02 It's just that basically, in the case of Brexit, the Remainer finds it impossible
00:18:07 because this is some kind of implicit comment on them,
00:18:11 that they could even be friends with someone who voted Brexit.
00:18:14 I mean, in this case, with your friend in this particular case,
00:18:19 from what I can gather, this person said, we don't share the same values.
00:18:25 Wait a minute, 13, 14-year friendship, it would take surely a very long time, therefore, for this person to have discovered that you don't share.
00:18:36 Yeah, you would think that what my values were would be fairly apparent early on.
00:18:41 And the left always uses that kind of language when they mean that they're accusing you of being a bigot.
00:18:47 A bigot.
00:18:48 That's what not having the same values always means.
00:18:52 uh you know this has been observed plenty so it's not fresh but the the yes uh people on the left
00:19:01 now are sufficiently self-righteous that they and and believe that the uh uh correctness of their
00:19:09 causes is so self-evident that if you disagree on anything you know and because they they subscribe
00:19:16 to a set menu of opinions
00:19:18 if you disagree on anything
00:19:19 then you are not simply wrong
00:19:21 you are evil
00:19:22 this is a polarity
00:19:27 that means that you've no longer
00:19:29 got a functional
00:19:31 public discourse
00:19:34 well one of the areas that
00:19:36 should be an area
00:19:39 where discourse happens
00:19:41 of course is in the arts generally
00:19:42 and it's something that I think
00:19:44 we would agree on
00:19:45 But I saw it in black and white recently.
00:19:48 There was a report that came out from a group called Arts Professional.
00:19:52 I think that they are an employment body, as it were, of people who work in the arts.
00:19:59 And they came out with, it was reported in the Times.
00:20:02 Yeah, I saw it.
00:20:03 It was reported at an extraordinary level of a monolithic opinion.
00:20:08 And that people who sort of, in any way, resile from what is considered to be the right opinion,
00:20:15 are ostracized and this report said that some people even had things like gagging orders or
00:20:23 something put on them but it was very frightening actually but this is the well it was a documentation
00:20:29 of what we suspected anyway that the arts have across the board and that's across media
00:20:37 have become exclusively, not just left-wing, but quite hard left.
00:20:45 We're always flopping about trying to figure out what language to use
00:20:49 to identify this particular sector.
00:20:54 And it brooks no argument.
00:20:58 It also controls who gets money, who gets their plays put on.
00:21:03 there was that
00:21:06 Brexit
00:21:09 one of the rare productions
00:21:10 of people like us
00:21:12 that
00:21:14 I didn't see it I should have
00:21:16 but you know
00:21:20 it had one production it was
00:21:22 hugely popular and then never
00:21:24 no one picked it up no one took it
00:21:26 to the next level whereas there were these
00:21:28 Remainer plays all over the place
00:21:30 um you know the battle of ideas lost its uh venue the Barbican because Claire was a an MEP
00:21:44 for the Brexit party and that was it she was demonized yeah yeah you'll be talking to Claire
00:21:50 later actually really tell her I said I had no idea about that yeah that's right so I mean those
00:21:56 Those are real instances, but that's the tip of the iceberg.
00:22:04 I'm a little mystified how this happened because you would think that the arts draw
00:22:10 maverick personalities, but apparently not.
00:22:14 No, not in my experience, not at all.
00:22:18 And I was thinking about this on the way over.
00:22:23 It has to have something to do with the fact that now artists tend to go to schools.
00:22:32 They get educated in creative writing or they get degrees in visual art whereas in the olden
00:22:40 days if you wanted to be an artist of any sort you just struck out on your own and if
00:22:44 you wanted to be a writer you read a bunch of books and sat around writing stuff.
00:22:50 You didn't get a degree.
00:22:52 And that means that artists are heavily infected by what's going on in universities and that kind of groupthink.
00:23:02 One of the scariest examples of groupthink most recently is the Woody Allen story.
00:23:11 I was going to ask you exactly about that.
00:23:12 I mean, this is Woody Allen's memoir.
00:23:14 It's apropos of nothing.
00:23:16 And basically, I think in a nutshell, somebody objected to it, the publishing house, and there was a sort of walkout, I think, of people, if we are not going to publish this book.
00:23:30 What was their objection?
00:23:31 Okay.
00:23:32 First off, I thought it was pretty shameful that this memoir was sent around to all the major publishers and only one of them would pick it up.
00:23:41 And according to my editor in New York, she read it.
00:23:46 She said it's a very good book.
00:23:48 And publishing, for the most part, publishes tons of terrible books.
00:23:53 So if it was a very good book, you would think that with a famous author,
00:23:58 someone would pick it up.
00:24:00 But, you know, yes.
00:24:02 And it was picked up on the QT by Hachette.
00:24:06 They did not advertise it much, which is not like, you know,
00:24:09 that's not the way publishing is supposed to work.
00:24:11 you're supposed to go
00:24:12 so it was as if
00:24:14 it was shameful
00:24:16 and then
00:24:20 I don't know
00:24:22 what took the staff so long
00:24:25 to figure out that this book was coming out
00:24:26 because I think it was supposed to be out next month
00:24:29 that means it has to be pretty much
00:24:31 ready to go
00:24:32 oh they're pulping it
00:24:33 the staff
00:24:37 and it is my impression
00:24:39 that it is the lower level staff
00:24:41 You know, basically a bunch of editorial assistants, which means, you know, they're 12 years old.
00:24:49 And they staged a one-day walkout, and Hachette freaked out and withdrew the publication after very little pressure.
00:24:58 And I find this upsetting in so many different levels.
00:25:01 What they're upset about is this accusation by his daughter, Dylan, that he sexually assaulted her when she was seven years old.
00:25:19 This accusation has been exhaustively investigated by two different government bodies, one for eight months, one for 14 months.
00:25:27 they found nothing and her story is riddled with inconsistencies and I don't know about you but
00:25:34 when I remember barely being seven years old you know it's just like this it's a very it's a
00:25:41 that's that early on those memories are poorly formed and fragile and in early memories
00:25:50 being fragile and impressionistic
00:25:54 and made of little scraps
00:25:57 are very easy to imprint upon.
00:26:01 And her mother's a nut.
00:26:03 Her mother is a nut,
00:26:05 hated Woody Allen
00:26:07 because he married her adoptive daughter.
00:26:13 It's another issue.
00:26:17 And I think that she
00:26:19 brainwashed her kids and there's just no evidence and and yet because and and it was
00:26:30 more or less originally dismissed but then there was the me too movement and then you know we're
00:26:37 supposed to believe women it's one of the creepiest slogans i've ever heard um which is
00:26:44 as I've written before
00:26:46 right next door
00:26:47 to believe everybody
00:26:48 and then suddenly
00:26:53 we're supposed to believe
00:26:54 this story
00:26:55 and of course
00:26:56 Ronan Farrow
00:26:58 her brother
00:26:58 who's become very powerful
00:27:01 is also behind this
00:27:04 and he made a haughty
00:27:06 he took his own book
00:27:08 away from Hachette
00:27:09 in protest
00:27:10 that they are publishing
00:27:13 Woody Allen's memoir. So that added, I think, an additional economic incentive to Cave.
00:27:21 But the precedent set is horrifying. First off, there's the precedent of no due process,
00:27:31 that Woody Allen is being crucified by rumour, by impression.
00:27:38 There have never been any charges.
00:27:39 No, no. By a kind of contemporary superstition that if a woman makes an accusation, then she must be right.
00:27:50 And, you know, he has no history of child abuse or sexual assault of any kind.
00:27:56 and though in a completely cowardly manner
00:28:00 in my opinion
00:28:01 there have been a number of actors
00:28:03 who have post-MeToo
00:28:05 announced that they will never work with him again
00:28:08 more than that, regretted working with him
00:28:11 oh yes, and regretted working with him
00:28:12 there's no basis for this
00:28:17 the thing is you see Lionel
00:28:19 with this, there's no basis at all
00:28:21 but even, it's a bit of a problem really
00:28:25 even if there had been a basis.
00:28:27 Take Ronan Polanski, for example.
00:28:30 Right.
00:28:30 I think it's important to keep both stories apart.
00:28:33 Oh, you do?
00:28:34 Yeah.
00:28:34 I mean, he was convicted of rape.
00:28:37 Right.
00:28:37 Do you think, therefore, that, for example,
00:28:39 in another sort of act of censorship, if you like,
00:28:42 we are not being able to see his latest film about Dreyfus.
00:28:45 It's not going to be distributed in America.
00:28:47 It's not going to be distributed here.
00:28:49 I think it's important to keep them separate
00:28:52 because Woody Allen has never been convicted of anything.
00:28:58 It is true that if we're going to look at Polanski separately,
00:29:02 I have been a big advocate of not confusing the art and the artist.
00:29:07 So as you do, I sense, I would like to see the new film.
00:29:13 And I don't need to be morally protected
00:29:16 because the person who made it is tainted.
00:29:20 You know, that doesn't mean that he shouldn't be sent back to the U.S. to serve his sentence.
00:29:26 Fair enough.
00:29:27 But I'd like to see the movie.
00:29:30 Well, yes, I mean, the thing is, if you go back, it's a cliche, I know,
00:29:33 but if you go back through all the history of writing and visual art,
00:29:39 there are some pretty appalling people, you know, behind them.
00:29:42 Oh, yeah.
00:29:43 Yeah.
00:29:44 And I think this is an arts consumer issue.
00:29:48 It's not just a matter of protecting the artists who are all fallen angels.
00:29:56 I should know.
00:29:57 Yes.
00:30:00 But the arts consumer has a right to the stuff.
00:30:06 I want the stuff.
00:30:08 I want the books, the movies, the paintings made by these imperfect people.
00:30:16 And just because the people who made them are imperfect doesn't mean that the work
00:30:22 they make is not wonderful.
00:30:23 And you know, I've been consistent on this point.
00:30:29 I know that lots of people are very gossipy and involved in the real lives of the artists
00:30:37 they enjoy, the writers, etc., and they're fascinated by their real life story.
00:30:43 I never have been.
00:30:44 I never read literary biographies.
00:30:46 I don't care who made them.
00:30:48 I really don't.
00:30:49 I'm just interested in the books.
00:30:53 I want to look at the paintings.
00:30:54 I want to listen to the music.
00:30:56 And I don't care who made it.
00:30:58 Now, I'm not prescriptive.
00:31:00 And I'm not saying that everyone has to be that way.
00:31:02 And if you're curious about the nature of the people who make what you love or hate, fine.
00:31:10 but I'm just saying
00:31:13 I have been consistent
00:31:15 I do think there is a separation
00:31:18 between
00:31:18 people and what they make
00:31:21 and
00:31:22 I want what they make
00:31:25 to be put on the marketplace
00:31:27 I would like to be able to read
00:31:29 Woody Allen's memoir
00:31:31 Yes, I was in America recently
00:31:34 and I was looking forward to getting it
00:31:35 and I was a bit behind the loop
00:31:36 this thing of basically
00:31:38 the artist being quite separate from the work
00:31:41 there is some sort of
00:31:43 parallel here as well with
00:31:44 what you would call the general
00:31:46 now of restriction on free speech
00:31:49 in the sense that
00:31:51 rather than
00:31:52 the man or woman
00:31:55 rather than the ball
00:31:57 is played, so if they say something
00:31:59 it's basically the attack
00:32:01 tends to be on the individual
00:32:02 this seems to be a very
00:32:05 is it puritanical? I mean it's certainly
00:32:07 like the crucible you know where you are somehow something that you are or that you've done
00:32:13 is going to scar you and everything you say or do from now on and i i'm thinking of this because
00:32:20 recently uh toby young who we had on the show started the free speech union yeah which i've
00:32:25 joined and i know that you joined in fact you spoke at the well on camera at least at the at
00:32:31 the launch. I mean, what have we come to when you need, in Britain, a free speech union?
00:32:37 Well, it's depressing, isn't it? I mean, it shouldn't be necessary.
00:32:43 And I think, you know, it's a potentially useful organization because I think the experience
00:32:51 of, you know, being the subject of some kind of pylon is one of tremendous helplessness.
00:33:00 and, you know, why me and what do I do?
00:33:04 And this is providing a resort.
00:33:11 This is what you do.
00:33:12 Maybe you need a lawyer.
00:33:14 Maybe you need to go after people who are maligning you in a libelous manner.
00:33:22 So I think it's a great idea,
00:33:25 But it is a sign of the times that Toby was moved to establish it.
00:33:35 I think as well, there's another problem, isn't there, surely,
00:33:39 that when these things arise, my feeling often is, good, it's good,
00:33:45 we probably should have many more of these associations.
00:33:47 We hope in our way to do something like that here.
00:33:50 But I think that the biggest thing facing the shawling is self-censorship,
00:33:55 that these things are now so internalized, whether it's writers,
00:34:01 that somehow or other the horse has bolted and now we're locking the gate.
00:34:10 Essentially it's so now inside us that we just simply won't do or say certain things.
00:34:15 Yes, which is a larger issue than the arts.
00:34:20 I think that this is something that the entire Western public is now suffering from,
00:34:26 a sense that you'd better keep your mouth shut,
00:34:29 that if you can't keep up with the latest lingo,
00:34:33 it's better to say nothing and stay on safe subjects.
00:34:38 But the narrowing of what it is permissible to say and to abdicate
00:34:44 and to illustrate in the arts is also a loss for everyone and not just for artists.
00:34:53 It means that there is a very narrow range of subject matter and viewpoint available for purchase.
00:35:04 I mean, you know, that all the movies and all the books, basically all you can buy is racism, is bad.
00:35:10 you know and yeah racism is bad and that's just bores the pants off me i mean i am recording um
00:35:21 what's it called knots and crosses oh yeah right i haven't seen it yet and i notice that i've though
00:35:28 i've got two episodes i still haven't watched it and there's a way that i have i'm going to have
00:35:36 to force myself just because
00:35:38 it's not because
00:35:39 I'm a raving bigot, though you notice
00:35:42 that as soon as I say that, it sounds suspicious.
00:35:47 It's because I
00:35:48 can't stand moral obviousness.
00:35:52 And so
00:35:53 this is a big
00:35:54 racism is bad production
00:35:56 and I hate having that
00:35:58 shoved down my throat.
00:36:00 It's pretty much par for the course,
00:36:02 isn't it? As you say,
00:36:04 it's in all of our productions now,
00:36:06 drama or whatever these issues are shoehorned in yeah all the time um do you think that and i feel
00:36:14 condescended to oh yes but this might be one of the reasons as well why british drama particularly
00:36:21 uh i know more about that is than other dramas but it seems to have lost its place as being
00:36:27 amongst the greatest because it's always correcting history and it's always sort of saying that this
00:36:33 is the bad guy, this is the good guy.
00:36:35 Oh, well, it's the very definition of propaganda, right?
00:36:39 And who wants to watch that?
00:36:42 It's tedious.
00:36:43 So that's the thing.
00:36:45 One of my biggest concerns is not just as an artist that I feel a little hemmed in, a
00:36:51 lot hemmed in, but I don't want to consume most of this dreck.
00:36:58 and one of the horrible things
00:37:01 that seems to have happened
00:37:03 in the arts is
00:37:04 it isn't just the narrowness
00:37:06 of the viewpoint
00:37:08 but this notion seems to have taken hold
00:37:11 that the purpose of art
00:37:12 is to morally instruct
00:37:15 and I'm sorry
00:37:17 but when I watch a television drama
00:37:21 open a novel
00:37:22 I don't want to be told
00:37:27 I don't want a Sunday school lesson.
00:37:31 I want to be entertained.
00:37:32 I want something to happen that's unexpected.
00:37:36 I want to see some daring.
00:37:38 I want to see people do things that I wouldn't have thought of myself.
00:37:42 I want something that redeems the time I give it.
00:37:49 and this whole idea
00:37:54 that what motivates people to go to the arts
00:37:57 and why we have the arts
00:37:59 is just to promote virtue
00:38:01 is perverse
00:38:04 and also produces, big surprise, bad art.
00:38:12 Exactly.
00:38:15 Would you ever, as a writer,
00:38:19 an artist would you ever take on this issue in a novel when i say this issue i mean the one we've
00:38:26 been discussing i the increasing restriction on free speech would this ever would this ever form
00:38:33 the backdrop of a of a novel oh of course the big danger is is having the same problem in reverse
00:38:41 and writing more propaganda.
00:38:47 It's funny, the Alameda Theater came to me a couple of years ago
00:38:51 inviting me to write a play
00:38:56 having something to do with identity politics.
00:39:00 And while I was at first attracted to it,
00:39:03 and I put it kind of on the back burner,
00:39:04 the reason I haven't returned to it
00:39:07 is
00:39:09 I'm afraid of just
00:39:13 yeah just doing the same
00:39:15 thing and
00:39:16 and still being
00:39:18 polemical
00:39:19 and you know
00:39:21 doing a
00:39:24 kind of go
00:39:26 Jordan Peterson play which isn't
00:39:28 you know I don't have a big problem with him but
00:39:30 you have big problem
00:39:32 I do not
00:39:33 but
00:39:34 But I don't want to write a novel or a play that is too freighted.
00:39:47 I mean, there's a little section in the novel that comes out this spring.
00:39:53 Yes, as you know, this is finished and done.
00:39:56 I was going to ask if you're working on it.
00:39:57 Are you on?
00:39:58 Yeah, it's in the can.
00:39:58 I am working on something, but...
00:40:00 It will be out in the spring.
00:40:01 It will be out at the beginning of May.
00:40:03 Are we allowed a title?
00:40:04 do we know
00:40:04 it's called
00:40:05 the motion of the body
00:40:06 through space
00:40:07 the motion of the body
00:40:08 through space
00:40:09 right
00:40:09 and its primary target
00:40:11 is the cult
00:40:12 of exercise
00:40:13 okay
00:40:15 alright
00:40:16 so it's not
00:40:17 entirely about
00:40:20 you know
00:40:20 evil identity
00:40:22 identity politics
00:40:24 but it does have
00:40:25 a little back story
00:40:26 that's fascinating
00:40:28 and
00:40:28 and because
00:40:29 I have a character
00:40:30 who
00:40:31 becomes obsessed
00:40:32 with these
00:40:33 extreme endurance sports and you need something to get him there. Why was this mild-mannered
00:40:42 guy who basically a couch potato most of his life suddenly driven to become a hard body
00:40:51 like that? And so I designed a back story in which he had recently and ignominiously
00:41:00 been sacked from his job, and it was because of an altercation with an incompetent diversity hire
00:41:12 who became his boss. And of course, just the crafting of an incompetent diversity hire
00:41:19 is extremely dangerous. And I knew that. So there's probably a little element of
00:41:29 red flag to the ball there
00:41:31 because I can either
00:41:33 avoid this stuff and be
00:41:35 very cautious with that kind of self-censorship
00:41:37 which is what you were talking about
00:41:39 or I can say fuck you
00:41:43 but this art, you know, your main character
00:41:48 is this guy
00:41:48 you're not staying in your lane, you know
00:41:51 I mean, you know this whole stay in your lane
00:41:53 I know, I know, and I deliberately
00:41:55 put two black characters in the
00:41:57 book and that's by way of carving out my right to craft black characters and I
00:42:07 think that a lot of writers a lot of white writers are avoiding that now and
00:42:14 you know in some ways you may the people who are big on diversity and otherwise
00:42:21 guys big on diversity in fiction may get what they don't ever say expressly that they want,
00:42:32 which is white writers only writing about white people and you've now got this kind
00:42:40 of back to the 1950s apartheid because it's too dangerous.
00:42:46 I mean, you know, I'm sure you follow the American Dirt story.
00:42:52 When is the book coming out?
00:42:55 I think it's the 5th of May.
00:42:57 5th of May.
00:42:58 Yeah.
00:42:58 I mean, I will definitely read that.
00:43:01 Because, you know, if it's the whole issue of exercise,
00:43:04 which, of course, is it taking one issue
00:43:07 and just drawing all sorts of things about society?
00:43:10 Well, in some ways, it's me one more time
00:43:12 going for the sacred cows of the contemporary culture.
00:43:20 And exercise has become next to godliness
00:43:24 in the Western world.
00:43:28 It's the one thing that people are now
00:43:30 even touchier about than their weight,
00:43:34 though there's a little intersection.
00:43:35 You've done that with Big Brother weight.
00:43:37 Yeah, yeah, but I didn't want to do that again.
00:43:39 But I'm very interested in the fact that
00:43:41 especially during the last 20 years and nobody ever talks about the phenomenon they talk about
00:43:46 what they're doing and what their workout regime is I mean it gets incredibly tiresome
00:43:51 and there's a you know the number of events these mass events you know climbing some mountain or
00:44:01 running up and down the empire state building or not to mention all the triathlons and the
00:44:07 marathons I mean they just keep multiplying but I've just I don't notice anybody calling attention
00:44:15 to the phenomenon itself stepping back and say how did we get here why are we so consumed with
00:44:23 this why is that what everyone is talking about why is that what we're now more competitive with
00:44:28 each other about than any other thing I've always sort of thought I mean I'm a bit of a you know I
00:44:35 can't be a hypocrite here. I've always exercised
00:44:37 and everything. Although now I just do
00:44:39 boxing. But
00:44:40 I've always found it very boring. But I always
00:44:42 felt that it was all about vanity
00:44:45 in the sense that... Oh, it's mostly vanity.
00:44:47 You know, if someone brought out a pill
00:44:49 which meant that you looked fantastic naked,
00:44:51 the gyms would empty.
00:44:53 That's right.
00:44:54 Actually, that's funny. There's a
00:44:57 little passage
00:44:59 in my new
00:45:01 book in which I made up a short story.
00:45:03 I didn't actually write the story.
00:45:05 So you just get a summary of a story that I never wrote, but it's about a world of the future in which there's something called a morphotron that will work out your body while you sleep.
00:45:19 And I think it's my personal fantasy because I find exercise, I love playing tennis.
00:45:26 It's totally sacred.
00:45:29 But exercise in general is extremely tedious.
00:45:33 It's very boring.
00:45:35 And I would love to just plug in.
00:45:38 Well, look, thank you very, very much for coming.
00:45:41 Look forward to that new book in a couple of months' time.
00:45:44 I think you'll enjoy it. It's a lot of fun.
00:45:46 Yes. Thank you very much for coming.
00:45:47 Thanks for coming back again.
00:45:48 I do hope that it's not another year before you do join us again.
00:45:53 I think maybe around about the time, possibly, of the presidential election.
00:45:57 I'd be very pleased to have you on.
00:45:59 Because you have dual citizenship, don't you?
00:46:02 You can vote in America, can't you?
00:46:04 and everything
00:46:05 and I think it's going to be fascinating
00:46:06 any thoughts on what you might think
00:46:07 might happen that
00:46:08 well of course
00:46:09 at this exact juncture
00:46:11 it looks like Biden's
00:46:13 going to be the nominee
00:46:13 Trump is in big trouble
00:46:17 he's not handling this
00:46:18 virus very well
00:46:20 and it looks as if
00:46:24 he might well lose
00:46:25 but then who knows
00:46:26 what's going to happen
00:46:26 I mean it's
00:46:28 politics and the whole world
00:46:30 has become so weird
00:46:31 that making predictions
00:46:33 is foolish
00:46:34 all I can say is I hope
00:46:37 that Trump is defeated
00:46:38 I think
00:46:41 it would be really bad news for my country
00:46:43 to have him president
00:46:45 for another four years
00:46:46 you've never been a fan of his opinion
00:46:47 well in that case
00:46:50 when it's happening
00:46:51 please do come back
00:46:53 thank you very much
00:46:54 that's it for this time
00:46:57 see you next time on What You're Saying Is
00:46:59 and thank you for watching
00:47:00 bye
00:47:04 Thank you.