New Culture Forum - April 20, 2020


2.22 Simon Evans - Today's Comedy: A Right Laugh or Too Left Wing?

2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won Dave Rubin: Defending Free Speech - Covid-19 - Trump 2020 + His New Book: "Don't Burn This Book"

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

197.72

Word count

10,110

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that this week
00:00:21 I guess he's one of Britain's most popular comedians. Simon Evans has been at it now for
00:00:26 over 20 years he's appeared right across the media and shows such as live at the apollo and
00:00:33 his own radio 4 series simon evans goes to market he's also been on question time he's currently
00:00:40 touring with a new show which is called the work of the devil and he's with me now thank you very
00:00:45 much indeed simon thank you this this new show the work of the devil this is well it's quite a
00:00:51 personal one isn't it it's very personal and the personal element is unfortunately something i
00:00:56 can't talk about because i'm trying to maintain the coup d'etat the the sort of great revelation
00:01:01 in the final third of the show uh in which i introduced the unexpected element much as it
00:01:07 was introduced into my life just over a year ago right and um and i'm enjoying seeing a crowd react
00:01:13 to that and fall silent with shock as the uh as the implications of what's unfolding before them
00:01:18 sink in it's unusual in that uh respect because stand-up shows are normally just a collection of
00:01:24 routines and to some extent you tie up a few loose ends at the end to give people the impression
00:01:28 that you've given it a moment's thought before you started but but it doesn't generally have a
00:01:32 sort of arc you know in the way that a play does but um but this one does it has there's there's a
00:01:39 degree to which not only actually in the show itself but and i know this is a frustrating and
00:01:45 sort of irritatingly teasing but the the nature of this sort of revelation has
00:01:50 thrown a new light on my entire career as a stand-up really yeah yeah it's quite
00:01:55 I mean it is a personal revelation with I mean it's about family and that sort
00:02:00 of thing but it's it's really unexpected and it's quite extraordinary I think I'm
00:02:04 justified in saying that enough people have told me that that's that's been
00:02:08 their impression that their response was it's that's quite something to do that
00:02:12 in front of an audience isn't it yeah actually and it is yes and it wasn't i wasn't at all sure
00:02:18 how i would feel about it myself but performing the show at the edinburgh festival last year to
00:02:23 where you do about 26 nights on the trot one night off in the middle of that um it was actually an
00:02:28 extraordinarily therapeutic experience it's it's it's not something i'd done before even sought
00:02:33 the uh the sort of personal intimate revelatory confessional style of comedy um in fact i think
00:02:41 of anything you would probably characterize me as you know on the arch you know ironic detached
00:02:46 end of the spectrum but it's very rewarding the only experience I've previously had of it was in
00:02:52 my own at my own wedding when I you know you have the groom the best man and the father take it in
00:02:58 turns and because I was a comedian and I didn't want to try and get into some kind of you know
00:03:04 antler locking mentality with my best man I said listen you do the jokes I'm just going to deliver
00:03:09 quite a short and emotionally raw you know vote of thanks to my family and to
00:03:17 you into my wife's family and so on and that was the first time I'd addressed a
00:03:20 crowd and and spoken from the heart you know and and acknowledged the value and
00:03:26 and the the glow of love in my life you know and it was an extraordinary
00:03:34 experience I remember thinking afterwards God I wish I could find
00:03:37 some way of incorporating that into a live show without doing it without
00:03:40 cheapening that you know without seeking cheap emotion but 15 years passed and
00:03:46 there were no opportunities to do so and then suddenly I don't know where this
00:03:49 one arrived and it is lovely the actual that really what it is I suppose is is
00:03:53 the the final resolution amounts to an expression of gratitude which is a great
00:04:00 thing to do in front of people I mean there are of course large very
00:04:05 very profitable organisations which essentially offer people the chance to stand up and express
00:04:11 gratitude and honesty and self-revelation in front of other crowds of people and so on.
00:04:15 If you can provide the infrastructure for doing that, I think a lot of people would
00:04:19 regard that as a little bit Californian, you know, for their taste, but there's no denying
00:04:24 the power it can have.
00:04:26 Do you still, I mean, you've been doing stand-up now for 23 years?
00:04:30 Yes, 1996, in fact, so it'll be 24 years in May.
00:04:33 24 years do you still get nervous of it well not most did you get nervous oh i did get nervous god
00:04:40 yes well i mean initially i think and i don't think i'm unusual in this respect initially i
00:04:44 i regarded stand-up comedy as more like a an extreme sport than a possible career it was i
00:04:50 i had no expectation of earning money out of it i was hoping to get a journalism career started
00:04:55 and i i did stand up because somebody asked me to write a story about it but um so it was that
00:05:01 it was that simple was it you it was actually there's Camden and St Pancras Chronicle a local
00:05:06 newspaper and they asked me to write a story about some people who were teaching improv in
00:05:10 Red Lion Square just off Hobarton I think it is yes and um and so I went along to this sort of
00:05:16 adult education center it was Wednesday nights and it was a it was that kind of thing where
00:05:19 everyone's in barefoot on squeaky floorboards you know kind of like doing some sort of
00:05:24 visualization exercises and then you start doing the improv there are a set of conventions which
00:05:29 enable you to interact creatively with other people you know essentially just being positive
00:05:33 not blocking building with their suggestion allowing their vision of what's unfolding
00:05:38 you know in this in this virtual space to influence yours and so on and it was extraordinarily
00:05:45 um addictive I loved it I wanted to be there all the time I annoyed my friends by trying to
00:05:50 introduce sort of improv games into car journeys and things you know and from that after about two
00:05:55 years of that somebody said you know you can do stand-up as well there are places where you can
00:05:58 just try that out for fun and again I had no interest in making a career out of it but again
00:06:04 just very addictive very quickly and I think the nerves there were a big part of that because
00:06:09 you know immediately my first five minutes which was on a night where the entire night was open
00:06:15 spots as they're called just doing five minutes there were no professionals in the room at all
00:06:18 the rest of the crowd were all people who come there to give moral support to an individual
00:06:23 member and at least half the room were there to give support to a lesbian comedian who I've lost
00:06:29 contact with I haven't seen her for ages she mainly did maths comedy but I remember there
00:06:32 was this room I was a little bit afraid of them because they were quite militant looking lesbians
00:06:36 to my mind and in fact they were fantastic they were the warmest and most supportive crowd of
00:06:41 people if they if they turned against me on that night not that there was any reason why they
00:06:45 should have done but I don't know that I would be sitting here now but anyway um yeah I mean
00:06:50 you're in and out of the lavatory you know every five minutes for about three hours beforehand and
00:06:54 then you come off stage and you are absolutely flying you know because you've got away with it
00:06:58 it's like doing a skydive the first time you know you said that you were possibly thinking of being
00:07:03 a journalist at the time but uh we were talking a little bit before we started filming and when
00:07:08 i've watched your your your stuff you it does have a rather right rightly feel about it it you know
00:07:16 it feels very rendered and complete and you know that's relatively unusual now
00:07:22 isn't it? I think it is in stand-up I think it might always have been in
00:07:26 stand-up although having said that some of the really classic routines if you
00:07:29 look at Woody Allen's routines from the early 60s there's one about a moose
00:07:33 which he shoots in upstate New York and then takes to a costume party where
00:07:38 which is which is the most dense I mean it performs turns every third word
00:07:43 you're presented with a new scenario and it's worth studying the transcripts almost like
00:07:48 scriptures but then there's a lot of other stand-up that is yeah it's more i mean billy
00:07:52 connelly would be one of the great giants and and he just feels like a chap who's had a couple of
00:07:56 drinks at the bar and is just garrulous and wherever his mind takes him you know but my
00:08:01 heroes comedically i think were always writers actually i didn't grow up loving stand-up comedy
00:08:06 i didn't have any particular um i mean i like anybody else i there would be you know the people
00:08:12 you would enjoy but to be honest most of the big stand-ups that we would watch on
00:08:17 VHS when I was at university for instance were Connolly, Eddie Murphy, Steve
00:08:23 Martin these aren't people I've emulated at all so a lot of American humor
00:08:27 they seem to be like raising the temperature faster it like taking it
00:08:33 further more quickly there were some great I mean I emerged but I started
00:08:38 doing it in about 96 I think Harry Hill Dylan Moran I think Eddie Izzard had kind
00:08:44 of was like playing small theatres by then there were some pretty creative
00:08:47 acts but they weren't they hadn't like turned on a light in my head in the way
00:08:52 that say Douglas Adams did when I first read him or or Alan Corrin for me you
00:08:57 know in the probably the first sort of adult humour that I really enjoyed was
00:09:01 was who were his columns you know in Punch and so on what about I think we're
00:09:05 roughly the same age uh what about sort of growing up what about the people that you might have seen
00:09:10 on tv i mean who who did you like i i adored les dawson i always was great but again no influence
00:09:17 on me at all i mean he but they he seemed of a completely i did feel and i still feel actually
00:09:23 that stand-up comedy rightly or wrongly but i think rightly if i'm honest was quite a regional
00:09:28 you know it was like an expression of your folk identity almost les dawson that's very anchored
00:09:34 in the northwest you know it felt like it was a postcard from a particular we
00:09:38 didn't have mothers-in-law of that kind you know it just didn't make any sense
00:09:42 but I watched my nan used to watch Coronation Street so I understood the
00:09:46 sort of milieu that that kind of idea came out of and and then you know there
00:09:51 was Dave Allen again who hilariously funny but was obviously like rooted in
00:09:57 in sectarian Irish Irish culture you know there was all of that flavor it was
00:10:03 like it was folk music i think that good stand-up comedy should be rooted in place you know a bit
00:10:08 like that david goodhart somewhere anywhere division you know i think stand-up at its best
00:10:13 is an expression of somewhere you know but what about these people such as you know more common
00:10:19 wise the two one is people like this victoria wood yeah 15 million views okay i know the whole
00:10:26 technological situations change but 15 20 25 million um that seems to have been an that is
00:10:36 an entirely disappeared format isn't it would you call that stand-up or would they just variety
00:10:42 entertainers interesting Malcolm and Wise one of the things that's well known in in our business
00:10:46 I don't know how well known it is beyond is that they had a live show which they would not touch
00:10:50 for the television yeah and there is one recording of it I think it was recorded at maybe Fairfield
00:10:55 halls in Croydon somewhere in Croydon anywhere which you can get on VHS I think
00:10:59 on eBay whatever you know which is of the live show and I've never seen it but
00:11:04 the yes so everything they did for television was purely done for
00:11:10 television that was nothing like live at the Apollo live at the Apollo every
00:11:14 comedian for instance will come on and do a set they've done countless times in
00:11:20 clubs you know and occasionally if they've accelerated a bit beyond their
00:11:29 capacity to deliver they might create some new material for the night but it
00:11:32 will usually show if they have because to be honest you want stuff that you're
00:11:36 so comfortable in it's like it you can do it without thinking you know like
00:11:39 driving the car whereas yeah Morecambe and Wise and as you say two Ronnies and
00:11:44 so on I mean the famous thing with the two Ronnies was that Ronnie Barker was
00:11:46 writing half the material but under an alias so that it would be accepted on its merits you know
00:11:52 but we didn't know that at the time we just thought they were two actors essentially and
00:11:56 funnily enough i was in a hotel room two nights ago in keswick and actually after keswick but i'd
00:12:00 driven three three hours afterwards anyway it had um the tv was tuned to one of those strange
00:12:05 channels that just shows reruns from the 70s either documentaries about hitler and then in
00:12:10 evening it cuts to um it cuts to the two writers i don't know exactly what that market is but it
00:12:17 must have focused grouped very well and um anyway so i was watching and and normally now when you
00:12:23 see the two runners it'll be a tribute evening and they will cull the best and the stuff that
00:12:28 survived you know in the four hand four candles and so on when you see a show in the raw now just
00:12:33 like uncut from 1978 or whatever it it's it shows its age you know i mean it's i understand the
00:12:40 sentimental appeal and the affection on the nostalgia but there's no getting away with it
00:12:44 you know they are extraordinarily sexist a lot of the jokes are kind of playground humor really
00:12:52 they had enormous charm and skill as performers you know but i i think it would be a mistake to
00:12:57 look back with through two heavily tinted spectacles at that era i think actually comedy
00:13:03 is probably in a healthier state now really yeah i would say so even though they have
00:13:07 yes it was lovely that they could unite the nation but that material would not unite the
00:13:13 nation now and could not even if the bbc were to take a deep breath and just go do you know what
00:13:17 i mean yes mrs brown's boys is probably the closest to that and it does win huge amounts of
00:13:22 votes and the rest of the industry goes really that's your favorite you know but you know it's
00:13:28 like democracy and and you know you have to accept it but I can't in my in my heart and in all
00:13:34 honesty say that I I miss it I miss I do miss a collective culture I do miss a sense of British
00:13:41 identity gathered around the hearth yes but if if it were that that it were gathered around I don't
00:13:47 think it would work anymore because it was it was it's it's dated you know and things have moved on
00:13:52 and and not without casualties but broadly speaking for the better wouldn't you say this
00:13:57 is one of the reasons why for example sitcoms don't work really as they used to i mean we do
00:14:02 have a few sitcoms don't we but again you're talking about these massive sitcoms and only
00:14:07 fools and horses i know that these are cliches but one of the reasons they're cliches is because
00:14:12 says they're good um that that still works i think and if you watch it it stands up funny enough that
00:14:17 i guess that's a little bit more recently is it the 90s it goes up to the 90s yeah um interesting
00:14:24 i mean those you know obviously there was a baton handed over very much from ronnie barker to david
00:14:28 jason i mean they would you know quite literally in open all out my son who is 12 adores friday
00:14:36 Night Dinner which is a sitcom about a Jewish family essentially Jewish that's
00:14:40 the Jewish Friday night dinner set in North London as far as I can understand
00:14:44 it but has sort of traditional wacky neighbors you know a series of quite
00:14:48 traditional British grotesque and he binge watches that like three or four in
00:14:53 a go you know and they love various American sitcoms like Modern Family and
00:14:58 Brooklyn 99 I think the idea of a sitcom where you're just presented with the
00:15:01 same characters in the same situation is still got very much got legs but but
00:15:07 there is an expectation now of I think a faster pace I think the the joke rates
00:15:13 they come faster they are slightly more modulated they they did used to be a bit
00:15:18 like set up punch yeah you know and now it's it's more like slalom skiing you
00:15:24 know there's this kind of rush you watch Modern Family I don't know if you've
00:15:27 watched it I remember the first time I watched that I finished it on a on an
00:15:30 airplane and it almost you almost feel high you know the the speed and technical skill that's
00:15:38 being demonstrated by the uh just the rhythm of it it's it's delirious but I suppose in a way as
00:15:46 well you're saying that you know is it even though you like the idea of you know a country coming
00:15:51 together around the heart and watching something um that wouldn't be possible now but also it
00:15:56 requires shared assumptions doesn't it and that's what pretty much is gone would
00:16:01 you say the assumptions have gone but I think yes absolutely I mean my father
00:16:05 still watches he's 89 and he still watches Last of the Summer Wine which
00:16:10 is again always available on one of those channels and and I went up to see
00:16:15 him recently my mum was in hospital so I was absolutely there to provide moral
00:16:19 support for him and and I didn't question this at all but we watched about
00:16:23 seven on the trot the joke is always the same and it's this kind of you know there's that there's
00:16:30 the old fella who's got the young slightly kind of brash bet bet mid not bet bet lynched style
00:16:37 girlfriend you know with the blonde you know i mean these are very dated caricatures but they're
00:16:42 not dated in my dad's head because that's how human beings are they don't continue to move with
00:16:47 the times at the same speed you know and to be honest i mean most of his memories most of his
00:16:52 conversation now go going backwards you know he's as time goes on he is more and
00:16:58 more anchored in his national service days that's where a lot of his anecdotes
00:17:03 and so on come out of now I think that's what happens families are that you know
00:17:08 they live longer now and people you know they are expanding people live less in
00:17:14 extended families you know there's all kinds of demographic changes that are
00:17:18 going to affect how people and of course as you say technology is shattered
00:17:21 at the expectation that you watch what's on you've got three programs to choose from well no you
00:17:26 haven't you've all got a screen and you've got the entirety of everything that's been made ever
00:17:30 yes you know to watch so it's extraordinary actually that we can still get together around
00:17:36 certain things but it does require a little bit of determination when you started doing this
00:17:42 turn-up you said about 96 yes uh we were just on the cusp of having the blair government weren't we
00:17:48 Yeah, that ruined everything for me.
00:17:51 I mean, was it sort of when you went and started doing your first stand-up,
00:17:55 maybe before you were on doing TV and radio,
00:17:59 was it political?
00:18:01 I mean, or was it in a way that we understand now or not?
00:18:05 My early stand-up wasn't political, no,
00:18:07 but I think I was feeling my way for quite a long time, actually.
00:18:11 And what I did as a stand-up,
00:18:13 and I think a lot of stand-ups would do this,
00:18:15 is you have to, it's almost like sonar initially.
00:18:18 know it's echolocation you're listening for the reaction that you get and not just in terms of a
00:18:23 laugh but whether the laugh is immediate and like feels like you've hit hit a you know right a solar
00:18:30 plexus or you that what you want is that's the laugh you want not that kind of you know nothing
00:18:37 polite you've got to get a strong visceral reaction from the crowd and when you realize
00:18:42 i mean i went on for instance just on the most superficial level dressed inappropriately you
00:18:48 know for my material on several occasions i thought i'm going to go on in black jeans
00:18:52 black t-shirt black leather jacket because that's who i want to be on stage i want to be like young
00:18:57 you know and um and they were like what do you think you are you look ridiculous you know or at
00:19:05 least it doesn't go with the persona they immediately can tell that no you're a failed
00:19:10 barrister you're not a you know so then you start so then for a while I had this quite it was a
00:19:17 little bit like Rob Newman in his Mary Whitehouse days I don't know if you remember him but he had
00:19:20 this character called Jarvis who was a sort of louche lounge lizard type character slightly
00:19:24 disreputable picked up again in the far show with a similar character he's me here with some
00:19:29 Catholic school girls but anyway it was a sort of double-breasted crushed velvet um sort of
00:19:36 smoking jacket type thing which was and that that started to i started to find the persona then and
00:19:41 gradually and i just lucked out with this line something along the lines of you may be struggling
00:19:46 to place my accent it is in fact educated and that was and that always worked brilliantly well
00:19:52 in certain like in newcastle they love that because they could immediately get it was a
00:19:56 caricature in london itself of course they were like no just um a bit australian
00:20:01 but anyway gradually you build up a persona and then you start to understand yourself you know
00:20:07 but a lot of it initially is trying to understand how they are seeing you you know and politics
00:20:13 didn't really come into that at all i did a few bits that i remember i think probably the first
00:20:18 time i really started to dab with politics was probably the gulf war and even then it was more
00:20:22 to express bafflement and bemusement about what was going on or what were the tactics or what
00:20:27 will be hoping to do that we're invading a country because he's got weapons of mass destruction you
00:20:32 would think the war would be the perfect opportunity to use them that sort of thing
00:20:36 and um but at the same time i was working in a radio for comedy show called the way it is we
00:20:43 did eight series of that and there i played a an anchor who was roughly in the sort of jeremy
00:20:49 paxman stroke chris morris mold so we attach political issues in that mode but that was part
00:20:55 of a sort of collective but again they knew that i was a little bit of a i was a counterbalance to
00:21:01 the rest of the team i think who were quite left liberal sort of leaning in that respect but so it
00:21:05 was basically your persona that they assumed yeah you know that it would never be coming from the
00:21:11 right yeah it was a certain curmudgeon is that right they tried to write me they tried to write
00:21:15 me into different directions but i could only really do like slightly right well reactionary
00:21:21 i suppose it's the word isn't it i mean that's i mean i'm sure you wrestle with this like what
00:21:25 is conservative what is right wing what blah blah blah i think you know it's a kind of peter
00:21:30 hitchensy sort of um you know well there's nothing worth conserving anymore anyway it's that black
00:21:36 pilled kind of attitude that's comic you know you're not actually trying to lay out policy
00:21:41 suggestions you know that would be pointless and the truth is in any stand-up situation people
00:21:46 don't want to think very in detail about about any political issues they're just they just want to
00:21:51 see a kind of archetype that they can find amusing do you i mean do you do you kind of balk when
00:21:59 people say right-wing comedian simon evans i think somebody a journalist said that to you
00:22:04 yeah i see it quite often i mean i do see it on twitter occasionally on twitter this this will
00:22:10 sound appalling and far worse than being right-wing but i do occasionally uh name search
00:22:15 myself just to see what people are saying about me but behind my back as it were and and also
00:22:20 occasionally to find out if any venues are advertising a geek i need to retweet or even
00:22:25 occasionally to find out where i'm supposed to be tonight but um but occasionally you see things and
00:22:30 and nine times out of ten it will be somebody somebody has said there are no right-wing
00:22:36 comedians or there are no funny right-wing comedians or there are no right-wing comedians
00:22:39 on the television they're either saying in a good way or an angry way and then somebody else will go
00:22:44 oh i think simon evans is quite right wing isn't he and then somebody else go i don't think he's
00:22:48 right wing i just you know and they nobody can quite be sure and that's how i like it i think
00:22:52 i think it's good that you don't feel jeremy hardy was a left-wing comedian he was a brilliant
00:22:57 comedian he could make my father who was a dyed in the wool tory he could make him bark with laughter
00:23:01 because he was a very skillful comedian but um but he was unapologetically left wing there was
00:23:06 no two ways about it you know he made documentaries about palestine whereas i i don't that's not who
00:23:11 I want to be you know but I have noticed in the last three years because of Brexit you know
00:23:16 that has thrown everything into much sharper relief than it used to be and I think that's
00:23:22 been the point at which a lot of people have suddenly gone well that's odd there don't seem
00:23:26 to be any not so much right-wing comedians as pro-Brexit comedians you know there is Jeff
00:23:30 Norcott who you're probably aware of who was quite bravely and also skillfully you know developed a
00:23:36 has identified a path there's lee hurst too is lee but lee's i mean lee is a nice guy lee i like him
00:23:43 very much and he's a skillful comedian but there's no escaping the fact that his tv you know he had
00:23:48 his years on they think it's all over and he's kind of he's almost retired now i think he's
00:23:52 been plagued with quite serious back problems and um you know he's he's not like kind of somebody
00:23:58 who's rising to that challenge he's just expressing his views you you have written about this and you
00:24:03 I think you quoted Marcus Brigstock who basically was shocked at people walking
00:24:09 out yeah when you go outside of the M25 walking out of shows or whatever because
00:24:15 he was maybe rude about Brexiteers I think you said it was almost like a
00:24:20 poison that had been injected into comedy yes I wouldn't say it was
00:24:26 necessarily a poison there was a moment when I think it was suddenly exposed
00:24:30 that such an overwhelming majority of comedians
00:24:33 had just presumed a consensus about Europe
00:24:36 that wasn't shared outside of their bubble.
00:24:39 I mean, that's a slightly sort of scabrous term, but yeah.
00:24:42 And I think they were going into the shires
00:24:44 with that presumed consensus
00:24:46 and discovering that it wasn't there.
00:24:48 Having said that, also with all these things,
00:24:51 it's always in layers because to some extent
00:24:54 comedians will sort of talk about this sort of thing
00:24:57 in order to get some sort of traction with the press anyway.
00:24:59 So you can never be sure how serious it is.
00:25:01 Marcus is a skilled comedian.
00:25:02 I'm sure he can turn a room around or acknowledge what's going on or step back a bit there.
00:25:08 I have seen some comedians, I won't name names, who made me feel uncomfortable on behalf of anyone in the audience who was pro-Brexit.
00:25:16 And I don't think that's right, personally.
00:25:18 I mean, I just think that's wrong.
00:25:20 I don't think you should make anyone feel uncomfortable in the audience for being black or for being gay or any other.
00:25:24 and you know you might say well those are immutable characteristics and Brexit is a
00:25:29 political opinion well it is but it's not like being a Nazi and they're sort of suggesting it
00:25:32 is you know but I don't think that was very common but there was certainly I think everyone
00:25:37 was brought up short by a sudden realisation that the comedy community had sort of drifted into this
00:25:44 quite narrowly confined space which was quite surprising. I think it's not just comedies I
00:25:50 I mean, in the sense that there was a report out recently.
00:25:52 My background is in the arts, you know, TV producing and writing about them.
00:25:58 Right.
00:25:58 But there was a report out recently, last week,
00:26:02 which talked about the fact that not only are the arts generally,
00:26:07 the creative sphere, monolithically on the same page about almost everything,
00:26:13 not just Brexit.
00:26:14 But they actually have really started, you know,
00:26:16 in some ways penalise people
00:26:19 who have different views
00:26:20 now that is a situation that
00:26:23 seems very recognisable to me I have to say
00:26:25 I mean so it's not just comedy
00:26:27 and you know it's theatre
00:26:29 it's all of these areas I would have thought
00:26:31 and when I watch or listen
00:26:33 to the BBC it does appear to me
00:26:35 I know it's a cliche that it's just
00:26:37 endless just left wing
00:26:39 comedy
00:26:40 well I think yeah I mean I have to be careful what I say
00:26:43 about the BBC because I hope to continue a career with them
00:26:45 But I do sometimes think they do seem to have almost a death wish at precisely the moment at which they are struggling to demonstrate the legitimacy of the license fee.
00:26:55 I can't see how they can claim there is anything other than an absurd level of bias.
00:26:59 The news, I think, is pretty good.
00:27:01 I think news and current affairs, there are definitely some right-wing journalists and you can identify them.
00:27:05 And there are some left-wing journalists and they get some stories wrong, but they seem to attract fire from both sides, at least.
00:27:11 you know i do think um the the comedy and drama departments i don't watch a huge amount of it you
00:27:19 know but it it is extraordinary how often you will hear somebody complaining that they can no longer
00:27:25 watch such and such a show because it's become very woke this is usually the adjective that
00:27:30 describes not just left-wing but sort of sanctimoniously preachy you know yes i do think
00:27:36 there is a a danger of that whether it's a long-term thing i don't know whether it's something
00:27:40 that is i think it's quite interesting even yesterday i don't know if you saw this on twitter
00:27:45 the royal institute scientific body had put out a tweet in which they were trying to understand why
00:27:52 women weren't engaging with their video content as much as men were something like a ratio of
00:27:58 seven to one uh they had discovered on their youtube videos and so on and they put out this
00:28:03 tweet saying if you identify as a woman we'd like to hear from you about you
00:28:10 know and immediately attracted a lot of people on Twitter saying what do you
00:28:13 mean identify as a woman if you're trying to ask women just ask women now
00:28:18 you know I think it's interesting although I felt irritated I think you
00:28:23 what you can see there is you know there's a there's a lot of people in the
00:28:27 role of social media you know operative for these organizations who are
00:28:33 desperately trying to work out how to navigate and steer their way through very turbulent waters
00:28:41 in this regard you know maybe things will settle down quite soon i don't know but this this is i
00:28:46 think what's happening as much as anything else you know i think the problem is really is when
00:28:54 it comes to say your era comedy and and the bbc is that you know there's this thing is in comedies
00:29:02 there of punching down and punching up you know yeah you should if if anything you should try and
00:29:06 punch up you know and go for the establishment but uh increasingly one feels that actually the
00:29:12 the punching is downwards it's towards these awful people who voted brexit and by yes by extension
00:29:18 conservative people you know and you're watching it i watch it and i sort of i used to enjoy the
00:29:23 new uh have i got news for you i used to enjoy it but now i sort of look at it and i sort of think
00:29:28 you would disapprove of me why therefore can i laugh at you yes well i understand that feeling
00:29:35 i don't know that they would i think paul merton is pretty good actually in terms of maintaining
00:29:39 balance and obviously it does depend who hosts it but without looking at that particular program i
00:29:42 do agree with you that the punching down punching up thing is not as straightforward as it sounds i
00:29:47 mentioned that on that radio 4 show that i did last last year uh simon evans is right which you
00:29:52 You can still hear on the Sounds app, which is, it is deceptive because, you know, the in-group, out-group thing,
00:29:59 it's a genuine dynamic, but it isn't always immediately apparent who's got the upper hand in any given situation.
00:30:06 And what can amount to the establishment doesn't necessarily mean in the old terms of who owns the property and who has the ear of the queen.
00:30:14 You know, it can be, as you say, within the media group, it can be the people who have the correct opinions,
00:30:19 the high status opinions who can demonstrate that they can afford to be like pro-refugee or whatever
00:30:25 and then of course if you're anti-refugee then the just you know to take an extreme example
00:30:31 if you are skeptical about open borders then if you can both sides can say well you're punching
00:30:39 down because one side will say well you're making jokes that are about you know the refugees are
00:30:43 the most marginalized and vulnerable people in the world but on the other hand the jokes that
00:30:47 at the expense of somebody who would rather maintain border controls those people as you say
00:30:53 don't necessarily feel they have any power which is why i always say every good comedy routine should
00:30:59 be more like a boxing match you know you should punch up down sideways and you should land a few
00:31:03 blows on yourself as well you know this is what people want to see they want to see a flurry of
00:31:07 punches not just this relentless you know on the same target do you find though that audiences
00:31:14 come to see certain comedians you know because they want things confirmed in
00:31:19 their mind I mean there there is I'm sorry to interrupt but I think everyone
00:31:23 wants that I mean I do think it's one of the great illusions of stand-up comedy
00:31:27 that many of us cherish is that you can change minds or that people like to make
00:31:32 you think they don't like to be made to think I mean almost nobody likes to be
00:31:36 made to think afterwards you might kind of go that was interesting I found that
00:31:40 funny but on reflection you know I suppose what you were saying there was
00:31:42 actually probably you know that might happen a little bit but thinking and laughing are anathema
00:31:50 you have to you have to circumvent you have to bypass the part of the brain that reflects and
00:31:57 ponders and and untangles you have to make people laugh like that otherwise it's dead
00:32:04 one thing i'm sure that is the case now that wouldn't have been the case in 1996 when you
00:32:08 started doing stand-up uh is this extraordinary culture now we have of the giving or taking of
00:32:15 offense i mean this has huge implications surely for comedy doesn't it in fact sometimes it appears
00:32:21 to be only about comedy yes what people say in comedy i mean is this affected the way that you
00:32:27 do your stand-up the trick and the really tricky thing about it is it's it's annoying if you feel
00:32:33 like you can't just crack a joke and somebody might go on it's a bit you know east or phobic
00:32:39 or whatever but on the other hand I think even worse is is trying to create comedy I mean there's
00:32:45 one person who gets away with it which is Ricky Gervais probably who's created his whole brand
00:32:49 now as a stand-up and even that is only really works because he's already created such good
00:32:53 television you know with his sitcoms and so on that he has that the authority but where you can
00:32:58 kind of go I don't care I don't care you know I'm going to say offensive things you see I don't you
00:33:03 know what I mean at the Golden Globes or whatever and everyone laughs and loves
00:33:06 that but that can be really irritating as well you know I've always thought the
00:33:10 thing with with all good stand-up comedy throughout the the ages has been you
00:33:15 find out where the edges in the room you're playing and then you you like
00:33:19 hop back and forth across it you know you're a little bit but and so
00:33:25 technically and in theory it don't shouldn't matter what people find
00:33:30 offensive whether whether you live in an era where you know you can use the n-word uh half a dozen
00:33:36 times in your set nobody will care or whether you live in an era in which you so much as suggest
00:33:40 that uh that uh that a husband and wife may not have uh biologically indistinct preferences is
00:33:48 is horrifically beyond the pale as long as you know where the where the border is you can go
00:33:53 back and forth it but of course what is problematic now i think in audiences is not people taking
00:33:59 offense themselves or feeling offended genuinely it's people projecting and second-guessing what
00:34:04 other people might feel on their behalf and that becomes impossible that if too much of that goes
00:34:09 on it doesn't happen very often i think the only occasion i've had it probably in my own stand-up
00:34:14 has been in corporate environments corporate events are more difficult i like to think i'm
00:34:18 pretty good at them and i think other comedians you know have would acknowledge that this is one
00:34:23 of the reasons they're tough is because the the person who's booked you is terribly worried that
00:34:28 you might offend this client or or that department or you know they want to make
00:34:34 it more you know inclusive or not inclusive you know in various ways and
00:34:40 they have the corporate culture which they might be offended or anxious on
00:34:45 behalf of as well as the people who are actually in the room but there was this
00:34:47 case recently wasn't there with the comedian I'm afraid I can't remember his
00:34:50 name but it really put the nose out of joint of this corporate bash he was
00:34:54 doing um uh is it anish kapoor oh nish kumar well that was that wasn't a corporate that was i was
00:35:01 at that event that was uh the lord's taverners um that was a charity lunch right uh there were i
00:35:06 mean people were there in connection with their work they'd book tables or whatever but it wasn't
00:35:10 a company do yeah the lord's taverners uh lunch that was at the grovener hotel it's the biggest
00:35:16 corporate room in the country it's about 1200 seater and um i was i was on the front row for
00:35:23 that it was quite interesting he came on and did at least five maybe ten minutes to really supportive
00:35:29 laughter and applause you know and again quite self-deprecating about his own ethnic background
00:35:33 and immigrant experience and what have you and then he decided quite quite deliberately to start
00:35:40 doing stuff about how much of a racist boris johnson was and how bad brexit was and um and
00:35:46 there was a bit of oh no not this again rather than no no no get off it was more like oh no
00:35:53 really and then somebody threw a role but in a kind of quite light-hearted way
00:35:57 but then the whole thing did just sort of deteriorate quite I think quite
00:36:00 unexpectedly really I've not seen that there before but I mean I'm not gonna
00:36:05 tell Nish what he has to do whoever booked it must have known that's the
00:36:08 kind of comedian he is you know you can't book Nish Kumar and expect him to
00:36:12 come on and do you know a Dave Allen routine you know most I mean this is the
00:36:16 thing being a booker for a for a big corporate event they earn a lot of money
00:36:21 they quite often will you know we'll take the comedian's fee and double it
00:36:26 you know and have half of that so you know you have to earn your keep but not
00:36:29 for that one I think that was probably because it's a charity event you know
00:36:33 probably somebody said oh this will do it for you you know and they didn't
00:36:36 perhaps look into it quite as deeply as they should but again is that just that
00:36:41 thing of consensus really you know just assuming that everyone's on the same
00:36:44 page and maybe they're not I remember seeing Joan Rivers doing a stand-up
00:36:49 towards the end of her life actually
00:36:51 and she was one of my favourites
00:36:53 yeah it's great
00:36:54 and basically someone did stand up
00:36:57 she was making a joke about deaf people
00:37:00 and he said
00:37:01 my son's deaf and everything
00:37:02 and she went for this
00:37:04 don't you start telling me
00:37:06 don't you start
00:37:08 she got the audience on side
00:37:11 if you have enough confidence
00:37:13 and she has a confidence in the moment
00:37:16 and also a huge hinterland
00:37:17 you know 50 years of being an abrasively offensive comic you can't go to her gig and then go how dare
00:37:23 you you know my son has this rare neurological disorder I mean you know they know what they're
00:37:28 getting and there are a lot of people I mean Frankie Boyle who has pushed the envelope you
00:37:32 know on a fence quite a lot you know had um people in the front row he will do material about this
00:37:39 that or the other marginalized group vulnerable people immutable characteristics and then and
00:37:45 they're laughing their heads off and then he will say the one thing about the one thing they have a
00:37:49 family and they're like oh no you can't you know it's absurd hypocrisy yeah i think uh it is does
00:37:56 seem to be a very problematic thing now which comedy is on the absolute knife edge of and as i
00:38:03 say and that is in the whole identity area in the work which you've referred to um but you say that
00:38:09 comedy's in a healthier place now I think it's in I think it's in I mean like a lot of comedy is
00:38:15 working in very you know the the cold face of of identity politics and all that kind of stuff
00:38:23 it's still trying to work out how to deal with that but I do think if you look at for instance
00:38:27 you know the strong American sitcoms you know and people like Tina Fey and 30 Rock I mean that's
00:38:33 not brand new you know Parks and Recreation those kind of shows they are faster more sophisticated
00:38:39 more multi-layered they're they're more satisfying you know they're more intelligent to be honest
00:38:45 than a lot of the sitcoms that we have a kind of unexamined nostalgia for in Britain
00:38:50 and and I think the most woke kind of stuff is it is a little bit crazy and there is a sense at
00:39:01 the moment not just comedy I mean like the Labour Party look quite realistically like making
00:39:08 themselves completely unelectable over over some an issue which affects much less than one percent
00:39:13 of the population in truth so it's you know there is a certain kind of insanity at large
00:39:18 you know in the world and it is for comedy to address that but I wouldn't want to say that it
00:39:24 was a serious problem affecting comedy at the moment it's just an aspect of comedy that you
00:39:30 can become fixated upon if you want to see funny enough from another from almost the exactly
00:39:36 opposite direction to what i assume you know we share as a political view it was nick cohen
00:39:42 yesterday um in uh is it standpoint yeah magazine complaining that right-wing satirists were failing
00:39:49 to take advantage of the lunacy on the left at the moment i think he's right he's right that
00:39:53 they're not that they're not great at doing it but at the same time it's not necessarily the job
00:39:58 of the right-wing satirist to attack the left actually that can be done by the left who are
00:40:03 trying to make the left electable again I mean you could you know you could
00:40:07 definitely make that case yes you could but you know the ruling classes were
00:40:11 satirized brutally in the 1960s a real sea change in society by the ruling
00:40:16 classes people like Peter Cook and Jonathan Miller were you know coming
00:40:21 from that stock they understood the weakness and the hypocrisy and the
00:40:25 and the preposterous absurdity of trying to maintain an aristocracy in that day
00:40:30 and age and that's why they were so great at satirizing they were great
00:40:33 but the big point really
00:40:35 is that the establishment now is left-wing
00:40:38 there's no question about it
00:40:39 the progressive ideology goes through
00:40:41 all of it, so why aren't people making
00:40:44 jokes, I mean
00:40:44 if you look at, take spitting image
00:40:47 I know it's not, but take spitting image
00:40:49 basically you could have a go
00:40:52 at the royal family, you'd have a go
00:40:54 particularly politicians
00:40:55 you look at it now
00:40:57 I think they tried to revive something like it
00:40:59 a while ago and it didn't
00:41:01 it didn't because basically people are too frightened to take on yes things
00:41:05 yeah and there's even even the Simpsons now there was a hideous thing which was
00:41:09 shared on Twitter about a year ago I don't remember when Donald Trump he
00:41:16 made some arguably quite unacceptable remark to the effect that Ilhan Omar
00:41:21 should go back to Somalia and sort that place out before she started shouting
00:41:25 about American politics being broken and of course this created a certain there
00:41:29 was a british um bbc presenter bbc breakfast presenter i think that's accused of being who was
00:41:36 accused of being out of order because she said it was racist and so on but the simpsons satirized
00:41:40 it by having donald trump being chased through you know the white house by these three women of
00:41:46 color of whom ilhan omar as well i can't remember the other two were you know and and it was so
00:41:51 one-sided and it was so and it was done as a sort of song you know and it was just you know it that
00:41:57 was really icky to the point where you just go oh my god you've actually made me you you know i'm
00:42:01 now sympathizing with trump here you know because this is so you know so woke but then you look at
00:42:07 south park i don't know if you watch south park at the american animated show and that has probably
00:42:14 been the single most deft fearless and and and just witty and funny and bravura you know the
00:42:23 display of scepticism about social justice politics for the last 10-15 years you know ahead of
00:42:29 many of us in this country even realising what was going on but you're right it has become they
00:42:34 are the establishment in terms of the media you know whether it was a genuine long march through
00:42:39 the institutions or whether it has just naturally occurred whether it's an emergent phenomenon or
00:42:43 whether there has been some sort of determined effort to sort of penetrate and work from the
00:42:48 inside there has definitely been a twist and the shape has changed and there are an awful lot of
00:42:54 people now working in the sort of commissioning process who who share a collective view which is
00:43:02 not shared by the wider public you know that is true and then they do i think to some extent
00:43:07 throw them a bone in the shape of mrs brown's boys or whatever occasionally rather than say
00:43:11 we want to see really intelligent scabrous vicious satire from the right or of the South
00:43:19 Park variety or whatever that takes no prisoners and regards everyone as fair game we want to see
00:43:23 that we will commission that a lot of people will say well if you want to see that kind of comedy
00:43:28 why don't you write it why don't you do it but there is definitely you know the reality is that
00:43:32 if you don't feel it's likely to get picked up if it's if there's no kind of if there's no door
00:43:37 open for that if there's no port willing to accept your cargo then it kind of is a suppressive effect
00:43:42 as has been understood by television because for you know 15 years ago every year you would go to
00:43:48 the Edinburgh festival every newspaper would be carrying a story saying why are there no
00:43:52 female comedians why are there no women comedians are women not funny and it was it was genuinely
00:43:58 discussed you know on that kind of is there some neurological reason or cultural reason why there
00:44:03 and a decision was made or a series of decisions were made in the BBC and elsewhere that they were
00:44:09 going to start putting women onto panel games like Mock the Week and so on regardless of the
00:44:14 fact that there were probably no more than maybe a ratio of 10 to 1 male to female comedians in
00:44:22 in the country as a whole in the life circuit maybe not even that many female comedians when
00:44:27 i started but they said we are going to put some on because that will create a you know a momentum
00:44:36 in the direction we want to see the the industry go we want to see more female comedians and so we
00:44:42 start putting them on and so if you were a good a half decent female comedian 10 years ago certainly
00:44:47 you suddenly had a pretty good chance of getting onto these shows because you were you were in
00:44:51 short supply and that did create a greater um impetus to become for female comedians to be
00:44:59 drawn into it to have the confidence that there was a place for them and that it wasn't just a
00:45:02 thing that blokes did and now I would say it's a fairly even split and if you go to a comedy
00:45:06 evening in a comedy club in provincial Britain chances are there'll be at least one possibly
00:45:11 you know 50-50 you know whereas before it would be really quite unusual you know it was uh it was
00:45:17 almost a bit of a oh here we go yes i think it's a i remember a while ago similarly nicholas heitner
00:45:22 national theater then director national theater said uh you know what we need we need some good
00:45:28 i remember his words it's like naughty right wing plays you know the sort of the implication being
00:45:34 that come on let them have a few yeah you know let them have a few but what emerged then is exactly
00:45:39 what you've just said which is that it's a kind of it becomes this um vicious circle people don't
00:45:45 put things forward they say well we just don't have any work-wing people putting
00:45:47 stuff forward they don't because they think they're not going to be and also
00:45:51 they haven't seen we all need templates nobody creates work work a handful of
00:45:55 people create work in a vacuum and very often I mean you look at something like
00:45:59 The Beatles extraordinary creativity if you look more closely it's because you
00:46:03 know they were influenced by Bernard Cribbins and Spike Milligan rather than
00:46:06 just by Jerry Lee Lewis that was that's you know sometimes you just need to have
00:46:10 different so if you're a left-wing playwright you can basically rewrite
00:46:14 something that you or three or four you can rewrite some brett you bring in a
00:46:19 bit of Tom Stoffer actually not to be fair he's probably quite right-wing but
00:46:22 you can bring him one of the few yeah exactly it's a lodge whatever out of my
00:46:28 depth already but the the fact is art advances incrementally I think
00:46:34 Elvis Costello said something that I always thought was brilliant which I
00:46:37 heard early on he said there are very few people who are deliberately creative and create anything
00:46:42 new most people start out in the arts trying to copy their heroes and getting it slightly wrong
00:46:47 that's actually how how the arts moves forward you know most of us in in you know the punk thing
00:46:53 we're just trying to get back to the to the rock the rawness of rock and roll we weren't trying to
00:46:58 create anything new we just wanted to get back to the excitement of and that's how it plays and
00:47:03 that's how comedians operate you know most comedians will go on channeling
00:47:07 somebody else to some extent initially until you find your own voice you've
00:47:10 just got to be able to see that there is somebody else you can go I could do I'll
00:47:13 be like that you know do you think Simon comedy is an art and and if so do you do
00:47:21 you do you think of yourself as an artist I mean the reason I'm I used to
00:47:24 write for the culture of Sunday Times culture law right and they always were
00:47:27 very big on comedy indeed comedy now is reviewed in if you like the arts pages
00:47:32 it's considered to be one of the R's
00:47:35 I mean you don't see it as an R's
00:47:36 these are slippery words
00:47:39 aren't they but
00:47:39 I think it's part of culture definitely
00:47:42 I think any definition of culture includes it
00:47:45 but then
00:47:46 who was I listening to
00:47:47 Stephen Pinker or somebody talking about the difference between
00:47:50 culture with a capital C and culture with a small c
00:47:53 I suppose there's always that kind of
00:47:55 is it just
00:47:56 everything that everyone does all the time
00:47:59 no I think very specifically they're talking about
00:48:00 being an art form
00:48:01 with a big C
00:48:02 yeah
00:48:02 I think the Sunday Times culture
00:48:05 somebody told me
00:48:05 was partly inspired by
00:48:07 was it the modern review
00:48:08 Toby Young and all that
00:48:09 and that idea of raising up
00:48:11 you know
00:48:11 the writing for
00:48:12 Coronation Street
00:48:12 and so on
00:48:13 well the way
00:48:15 the degree to which
00:48:16 I reject the idea
00:48:17 that it's art
00:48:18 and I think
00:48:18 it can be elevated
00:48:20 to the level of art
00:48:20 but there's something
00:48:21 actually I like the fact
00:48:23 that it isn't really an art
00:48:24 I think it's more like
00:48:25 a folk art
00:48:28 you know
00:48:28 I think it's a folk tradition
00:48:30 I think it's at its best
00:48:32 when, you know, its best practitioners
00:48:34 are kind of drawing and channeling
00:48:36 the kind of psyche of the people
00:48:39 of their people
00:48:39 it doesn't have to be of their region
00:48:41 it can be, you know, some other organizing principle
00:48:45 but they're not
00:48:45 I don't feel it's like Michelangelo
00:48:49 you know what I mean?
00:48:50 or Van Gogh
00:48:51 I think it's more like
00:48:53 I mean, Billy Connolly really
00:48:54 is the kind of motherlode of British stand-up comedy
00:48:57 really, you know
00:48:58 And then you have the sort of Jewish tradition from New York resorts or whatever.
00:49:02 But, you know, it's like the bit of banter between songs, really, you know.
00:49:06 I think most comedians feel more comfortable when they're not being held to that kind of standard.
00:49:13 And if you get to the point where you deliver a routine that's so perfectly worded, the timing and everything is so great,
00:49:21 you find yourself thinking, that's bloody art, that is.
00:49:24 Well, that's great because that's a moment.
00:49:26 just like seeing a batsman play such a glorious you know cover drive that you just go oh that's
00:49:33 art you know but it's the very fact that you've registered that it's been elevated for that
00:49:38 moment you know it's not the whole thing isn't art really any more than cricket is art for the
00:49:44 whole five days it's like there are moments where it elevates to that level and that's fine but
00:49:49 really it's a craft and a it's a it's a it's a folk act I don't know I want to
00:49:56 say a folk art but that means like you know what I mean yes almost like
00:50:00 painting or something it can be every bit as worthwhile it's not to diminish
00:50:04 it it just doesn't feel like it's the state of mind that you would try and
00:50:08 enter in order to create art you're touring at the moment where are you
00:50:12 going to be next where can people where can people come and see you and maybe
00:50:16 we have to see a few moments of a few moments where it elevates I should be
00:50:23 elevating in in Devon in the first week of March and I think then the Midlands
00:50:28 in the second week of March Nottingham and Birmingham I think and one or two
00:50:32 others all on my website if you want to have a look it's the Simon Evans the
00:50:38 Simon that's my website yeah and I have a gigs page on there and knocked up for
00:50:44 me very recently as a brand new nice shiny website i'm very pleased with well as i mean thank you so
00:50:50 much for giving us so much of your time you know thank you very much and congratulations as well
00:50:54 on the on the tour thank you um there you go so it's the simon evans.com if you want to come and
00:50:59 see this man and uh thank you very much for watching and we will see you next time please
00:51:05 remember to subscribe won't you thank you bye