New Culture Forum - April 20, 2020


2.23 Tom Holland: Impact of Plagues, Pandemics & Christianity in the West

2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won Dave Rubin: Defending Free Speech - Covid-19 - Trump 2020 + His New Book: "Don't Burn This Book"

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

152.68

Word count

6,502

Sentence count

189


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now we're living in very strange
00:00:23 times. If you're at home, which I'm sure you are watching this, and I hope you are bearing up under
00:00:28 what are extraordinary circumstances. Over the coming weeks we at the New Culture Forum will
00:00:34 continue doing our broadcast. We're going to continue doing our interviews with So What
00:00:38 You're Saying Is and indeed our discussions with counterculture, only with slightly technical
00:00:45 tweaks as you will see. I'm delighted that my guest this week is the eminent and award-winning
00:00:53 historian Tom Holland. Tom is the author of numerous books. He's also the translator of
00:00:59 classical texts. He has presented documentaries on television. He's a presenter of Radio 4's
00:01:06 Making History. His most recent book came out last year. It's called Dominion, The Making of
00:01:12 the Western Mind, and it's about how Christianity has informed our value system and our structures
00:01:20 of our society right up to the present time thank you very very much for coming on tom thank you
00:01:26 uh beautiful display of books there um how are you
00:01:33 how are you bearing up well i have to say that by and large my life has greatly changed right
00:01:43 i i meant to be finishing a translation of suetonius for uh
00:01:47 Penguin Classics, which I was mentioned handed in for Christmas, and for various reasons
00:01:52 my life's been very busy. So in a way I'm quite grateful for the opportunity that it's
00:01:58 given me to just sit down and absolutely nail it. Having said that, obviously I'm starting
00:02:04 to really want to get out.
00:02:06 Yes, yes, exactly. I want to start out, you wrote a fascinating piece, I thought, in the
00:02:13 Sunday Times quite recently when you were looking at the various plagues that had come in the
00:02:20 ancient world particularly in Athens and Rome and you were talking I think the title of the
00:02:27 piece was that you know you think it's bad now you know what it was like then I mean I wonder
00:02:33 whether in fact there are any parallels with what happened for example under Pericles in ancient
00:02:40 Rome, in Athens rather, and then also in Rome. Are there any parallels with what we're going through
00:02:48 today? Well the great thing about Thucydides' account of the plague of Athens, which is the kind
00:02:55 of primal account of the impact of an epidemic, is that he analyzes what the plague, whatever it was,
00:03:03 probably a form of typhus, typhoid fever, of the individual. And Thucydides knew all about this
00:03:10 because he himself had recovered from it.
00:03:12 But what he also does is to recognize that there is a kind of political apology,
00:03:18 that the impact of the disease has a terrifying impact on the democracy
00:03:24 and on the social structures of Agnes.
00:03:27 And so that also is widely included in his history of the Peloponnesian War,
00:03:31 because he sees in the long run that the impact of the plague is measurable
00:03:36 in the effect that it has ultimately on the way that Athenian society functions, the strategy
00:03:41 that it pursues in the war, and ultimately all this is unspoken.
00:03:47 I think to that degree, the way in which the impact of this disease is not just on individuals
00:03:57 but on the whole of society, that is something that was absolutely understood by the classical
00:04:02 authors as well.
00:04:04 Having said that,
00:04:07 the point of the article
00:04:08 was hopefully a mildly
00:04:10 encouraging one, which is the
00:04:12 terrible, though
00:04:14 the impact of
00:04:16 COVID-19 is on
00:04:17 individuals and on our society
00:04:20 generally, its impact is nothing
00:04:22 compared to that
00:04:24 of plays back in classical
00:04:26 activity, and I hope that that offers
00:04:28 some financial insurance.
00:04:31 Can you just explain
00:04:32 little bit because a lot of people watching will not know necessarily very much about that plague
00:04:37 the athens plague i mean how did it come about and and what was the result of it can you can
00:04:42 you just tell us a bit about it well the the context for it is uh the pelotonnesian war which
00:04:49 is um the the great war between athens the the maritime democracy and sparta the it's still a
00:04:58 insular crowd xenophobic military power so kind of the classic war between an elephant and a whale
00:05:04 and the athenian strategy based on the fact that it's a great naval power and a great um
00:05:11 trading power is that the athenian people will hide behind their walls and let the spartans
00:05:18 move into acta burn the crops and then kind of like a wave breaking and retreating before a great
00:05:24 rock go back to sparta and for the first year this works but the second year plagiarize and
00:05:31 it's been a distant rumor in athens for several months it's it's appeared in egypt it's appeared
00:05:36 in persian empire and then it appears in perez the indelian port and spreads up and
00:05:42 it's um its impact is devastating because it's it's enhanced by the fact that uh
00:05:49 Athens is crowded with refugees from the countryside all around.
00:05:54 And what is, of course, also fascinating from our point of view is that Athens, unlike Sparta, is a very globalized state.
00:06:03 It's the main trade power in the Eastern Mediterranean.
00:06:06 It has trade links with Egypt and the vast hinterland of diseases that Africa contains.
00:06:12 It has trade links with Persia and then beyond that, the vast hinterland of diseases that are contained within Eurasia.
00:06:17 So this is something that over the centuries that follow will increasingly buffet the world of the Mediterranean, particularly under Rome, because what Rome does is to unite the whole of the Mediterranean under a unitary power, and Rome, even more than Athens, has trade links with both central Africa and with central Eurasia.
00:06:38 And that means that all kinds of terrifying germs and diseases hit the Roman Empire
00:06:47 in ways that have a countable offense.
00:06:51 What was the nature of these places?
00:06:53 I mean, you know, compared to what we're talking about now,
00:06:58 I mean, were they, you know, were they sort of like Ebola, for example?
00:07:03 Or what was the nature of them?
00:07:06 There's a plague in the mid-3rd century, which is known as Cyprian's Plague, after the church father, St Cyprian, who became bishop of Carthage, and who wrote about its impact and about its effect.
00:07:24 and to the degree that it's possible to work out what a disease was from very ancient accounts
00:07:33 people have seriously suggested that this perhaps was a form of Ebola
00:07:38 the descriptions sound familiar, blood kind of coming out of the eyes
00:07:42 limbs falling off at the end, I mean horrible, horrible way to die
00:07:47 And there seems to have been a recognition that corpses themselves were highly infectious, which of course is part of Ebola.
00:07:58 So that's quite a well-grounded theory.
00:08:03 Right. You said that the most important thing is how it changed, for example,
00:08:09 you were talking about Athenian society and now Roman. What were the changes?
00:08:14 changes? Was it collapse? I mean, did these societies collapse?
00:08:19 Well, he simply says of Athens that nothing had a greater impact on the cause of the war
00:08:24 than the plague. And by that, he meant that the survivors had a kind of giddy lack of
00:08:31 patience. They felt that because they had survived, therefore, in a way, nothing could
00:08:36 harm them. And so this leads them to increasingly rash strategies, which the culminating rash
00:08:42 strategy is an invasion of
00:08:44 Sicily, which ends up wiping out
00:08:46 large quantities of Athenian ships
00:08:48 and men, and basically
00:08:50 doomed Athens
00:08:51 to defeat by Sparta.
00:08:54 And so the city absolutely traces
00:08:56 this to the kind of long-term
00:08:57 impact of the plague, which
00:09:00 happened decades before. In
00:09:02 Rome, there are
00:09:04 three great plagues.
00:09:06 There's Cyprius plague that I mentioned, there's a
00:09:08 plague earlier, before that, at the end of the
00:09:10 2nd century, called the Antonine Plague, because it hits in the reign of the Antonines, Marcus
00:09:18 Aurelius. And then the Plague of Justinian, which happens in the 6th century. Each of
00:09:24 these have a kind of cumulative effect. The Antonine Plague comes from the east, seems
00:09:34 to come from Persia, it sweeps the whole of the Roman Empire, and although it doesn't
00:09:42 bring the empire down, it leaves it vulnerable to the further shock that is the plague of
00:09:49 Cyprian. And Cyprian's plague, insofar as we can tell, kind of unleashes a meltdown
00:09:58 of Roman society. And the reason we have to say insofar as we can tell is because we don't
00:10:03 really have very good sources for that period and that may be again a reflection of the impact of
00:10:08 the plague but to the extent that we do know what's going on we know that the roman empire
00:10:12 essentially implodes this is a period of increasing anarchy empire emperor butchers
00:10:18 emperor often within the space of a few months the empire fragments into several portions and
00:10:25 it's only with a huge effort of will that it's brought together again and when it emerges at
00:10:30 the end of the 3rd century, beginning of the 4th century, the Red Empire is a very different
00:10:34 beast. It's a beast that is much more muscle-bound, much more top-heavy. Again, in the context
00:10:43 of what we're talking about, how to fight COVID, it ends up as a kind of surveillance
00:10:48 society. There are tax collectors, there are soldiers, there are spies everywhere. And
00:10:55 this in turn means that in the 5th century, when again there is a kind of process of
00:10:59 fragmentation, the western half of the empire is unable to cohere, and it splinters and
00:11:04 collapses. That leaves the eastern half of the empire, which under the rule of its greatest
00:11:09 emperor Justinian, looks as though it's making a comeback. Justinian sends military expeditions
00:11:14 to win back Africa, to win back Italy, to win back chunks of Spain even. But then in
00:11:21 541, plague hits Alexandria and spreads to Constantinople, and from Constantinople spreads
00:11:29 westwards, ultimately as far as Britain and Ireland, eastwards into the Persian Empire.
00:11:35 And that, again, has a completely devastating impact.
00:11:40 It's now almost certainly accepted that this was a bubonic plague, so the first manifestation
00:11:45 of the plague that in the 14th century would lead to the death of perhaps a third of Europe.
00:11:50 And so that's the scale of casualties that we're almost certainly talking about in the
00:11:54 context of the 6th century.
00:11:56 And the impact of that on the great urban empires of Constantinople and of Persia is absolutely devastating because the impact on urban centers is much greater than it is on those in the peripheries, particularly in the desert peripheries.
00:12:13 And so I think it's entirely reasonable to see the collapse of both the Persian and the Roman empires
00:12:21 before what would become Islam as, in part at least, due to the impact of the plague in the 6th century.
00:12:29 So these are world-shaping events.
00:12:33 Do you think that when we come right up to date, or should I say at least in historical terms up to date,
00:12:40 to, for example, the Spanish flu after the First World War.
00:12:45 Do you think that there are any parallels
00:12:48 between what's happening now and that, for example?
00:12:52 I mean, we hear that journalists,
00:12:55 journalists particularly at the moment,
00:12:56 are talking about pandemics and plagues almost interchangeably.
00:13:01 But from what you're saying,
00:13:02 it seems to me that what we're having at the moment
00:13:04 is not exactly a plague in that sense.
00:13:08 But the Spanish flu was.
00:13:10 I have to say what historians always do is it's not my period.
00:13:15 I have no great knowledge of the Spanish flu or anything like that.
00:13:19 What I would say in the context of the classical plagues is that they are an index of globalization.
00:13:29 And in a sense what's happening goes back to the Bronze Age, which is the first period where you start to get large settled communities in the forms of cities
00:13:38 and trade routes linking them to other areas of the world perhaps with animals
00:13:44 where there are diseases capable of making crossover and you get trace
00:13:49 elements of plagues in you know it's there in the Iliad it's there in the
00:13:54 Old Testament the reason why they're so devastating in the context of the Roman
00:13:59 Empire is is that the Empire exists on the kind of the the crossroads of these
00:14:04 two great breeding grounds of Central Africa and Central Asia and in a way
00:14:10 the their impact is so devastating precisely because they there's nothing
00:14:16 like them has ever been seen before nothing on that scale yeah and again
00:14:20 the Black Death is another reverberation of that since the era of
00:14:25 authentic globalization the knitting together of nations across the entire
00:14:31 world what's happening now is clearly something that's been waiting to happen
00:14:36 for the same reasons that the plague hit hit the Roman Empire and I suppose that
00:14:42 that in a way we can count our blessings and it hasn't been as bad as it might
00:14:45 right and in a sense it's a kind of warning shot across our vows that
00:14:50 perhaps the next pandemic will be something where far more people die so
00:14:57 So, yeah, lessons from history are, you know,
00:15:02 I've tried to offer a cheering take for drawing from history,
00:15:04 but there is also that negative one that you kind of, you know,
00:15:08 it's like sitting on the San Andreas 4, you're waiting for the big one.
00:15:11 You know it's going to come.
00:15:13 I know that I've spoken to enough historians to know that you hate being asked
00:15:18 to give predictions, as it were, and to look into the crystal ball.
00:15:20 But what do you see as being, broadly, as far as we can tell,
00:15:27 so far the general changes that might happen to our society as a result of this i mean people a
00:15:34 lot of people are speculating at the moment i'm seeing more and more articles about the way in
00:15:39 which this will fundamentally change us but how do you see things going forward politically
00:15:45 well you're right i'm not remotely qualified i'm no more qualified to to offer prognostications
00:15:53 than anyone else but having said that since you've asked me um there are there are kind of two
00:15:59 alternatives one and both of which sanctioned by the by historical exemplars the first is that it
00:16:05 won't really change anything very much um the impact of spanish flu is is is measurable the
00:16:12 fact that basically everyone forgot about it uh people ain't talking about it now because of what
00:16:17 we're going through. The impact of the current epidemic is so seismic precisely because we
00:16:24 have no phone memory of the Spanish flu and it's perfectly possible, I thought, that this will come
00:16:29 and go and then everything will kind of go back to normal. Against that, I think we have to wait
00:16:37 and see what the impact of this is going to be on countries that are much less fitted to cope
00:16:45 with it than we are. It's clear that the Asian countries like South Korea, Singapore, precisely
00:16:55 because they have already been through the mill of SARS, so they are ready for it. So
00:17:00 they are best qualified. So they, I think, are going to be the kind of... Their soft
00:17:06 power status, let alone their economic status, so the weight of this is going to be enormously
00:17:09 enhanced i think that that this is going to be very damaging to the prestige and indeed the kind
00:17:17 of self-confidence of western powers it looks as if the united states might be in in considerable
00:17:24 trouble i would thought that trump will lose the election now um but what will the impact be on
00:17:30 on countries that don't have the healthcare systems that that are currently i mean our
00:17:36 Our health care systems, they may be in the process of being overwhelmed, but we have health care systems.
00:17:40 What about countries that don't have any like that?
00:17:44 I'm thinking particularly of countries that are suffering massive stress.
00:17:48 So Venezuela, what's the impact they're going to be?
00:17:51 What's the impact going to be on Iran?
00:17:53 That seems we've gone completely silent.
00:17:55 Are we really meant to think that it's just stopped?
00:17:57 I didn't think so.
00:18:00 You can see all kinds of tremors building up there, perhaps on Saudi Arabia.
00:18:04 I mean, we don't know.
00:18:05 So I would have thought that it will be an amplifier on where there are stresses, it will amplify those stresses.
00:18:13 Do you think, I mean, do you, again, sort of looking at the situation at the moment, do you sort of tend to go with one view, which is that basically this is going to strengthen the re-emergence of the nation state, for example, you know, or do you think that that is sort of an exaggeration?
00:18:35 I mean, many people are looking and saying, well, look, you know, borders have arrived again, and the EU appears to be relatively irrelevant in this situation.
00:18:43 I mean, these are quite big developments, are they not?
00:18:49 Well, I mean, it seems to be so, Kupert.
00:18:52 Everyone, every country has essentially drawn back on its own resources.
00:18:57 Borders have gone up.
00:18:59 And it's clearly not, it's not working out well for the European Union.
00:19:05 It's coming under enormous stress, and I think that kind of pan-national organizations
00:19:10 like the World Health Organization seem to have been behaving disgracefully.
00:19:14 Again, I offer no specialist opinion on that, but purely from reading about it, it really
00:19:22 doesn't seem to have measured up at all.
00:19:24 So it may well be that in the short term, there will be a sense that every country is
00:19:31 going to want to make sure
00:19:32 that it has access to
00:19:34 the kind of resources that
00:19:37 a country like Britain simply hasn't had.
00:19:41 I would have thought that in the
00:19:43 wake of this, we're going to want to do that.
00:19:45 Equally, however,
00:19:47 I would have thought that the long-term
00:19:49 effect will be to recognize that
00:19:51 we are now
00:19:52 we are a global
00:19:55 society and
00:19:56 for instance, putting up
00:19:59 The drawbridge against, say, Africa goes into meltdown with this, that's not going to help Europe.
00:20:06 So there's going to have to be some, again, I'm not, I'm aware I'm not giving you a straight answer,
00:20:12 but I think that there are going to be contrary stresses here.
00:20:15 There will be the instinct to draw up the drawbridge.
00:20:18 Equally, there's going to be a conscious of the fact that we can't really afford to do that
00:20:22 because the world's ability to cope with this pandemic is going to be as strong as its weakest link.
00:20:29 Yes. You've just written a book last year, a very well-received book called Dominion, as I said in the introduction, which is about the influence of Christianity essentially on our modern societies and how it's all-encompassing, and in a way that maybe we didn't fully appreciate before.
00:20:50 I wonder whether you could explain to us
00:20:54 because you've written extensively about Islam too
00:20:56 and I wonder whether there is any difference
00:21:00 or what are the big differences
00:21:01 in the big religions in the world
00:21:04 in their response to, for example, what is happening now
00:21:07 would they look at these things in a different way?
00:21:13 Well, the thesis of Dominion
00:21:17 as you say, is that people in the West are much more Christian perhaps than many of them would think.
00:21:27 And the analogy that I was thinking of when I was writing the book was that we're goldfish
00:21:33 and the waters that we swim in, in our goldfish bowl, are Christian ones.
00:21:37 Then I watched the HBO series about Chernobyl and was struck by a different metaphor,
00:21:44 which is that in that show many of your viewers have seen it there's a scene
00:21:50 where two of the characters are right up close to the leaking reactor and you can
00:21:54 see the radiation coming out because it's ionizing the air but of course the
00:21:58 impact of this leak in the long run is invisible you can't see it if you're in
00:22:04 Kiev or in Scandinavia or in a sheep farm in Cumbria but it's still
00:22:08 affecting you and that's really how i see that the the impact of christianity is that um not to
00:22:16 say that it kills you or makes your hair fall out or anything like that so that if you're up close
00:22:20 to it of course you can see it you know if you're looking at cathedral if you're contemplating
00:22:23 bunion um of course christianity's impact is absolutely in your face but its impact is also
00:22:31 there, even if you may not see it. And so, for instance, the question of the idea of
00:22:37 world religions, the idea that there are things called religions, this may seem a given. You
00:22:44 may just assume, well, of course there are things called religions. There have always
00:22:47 been things called religion. But in fact, this is an example of the way in which, kind
00:22:51 of like, you know, you don't have to see radioactivity to be affected by it. You don't have to be
00:22:57 aware of Christianity's impact for it to affect the way you think because in fact the idea of what
00:23:03 world religions is a very very Christian one because it's Christianity that provides the
00:23:08 prototype for a religion and the reason that it does that is that by the 18th century the complicated
00:23:15 theological and historical reasons Christians in Europe have arrived at a very very strange
00:23:21 and culturally distinctive notion which is that there is a space called the secular
00:23:27 which is assumed to be neutral a kind of neutral space and then there are things at tangents to
00:23:34 the secular called religions and religions are what you believe in they want you you know your
00:23:41 personal relationship with the deity and so this is a way of understanding society that christians
00:23:49 export with them kind of like you know people carrying the virus if you like you know you you
00:23:56 take it with you you don't even realize you'll take it with you yeah and so they for instance
00:24:00 the british arrive in india and they call it hindustan they call the big inhabitants of hindustan
00:24:06 hindus and the british understandably say well what is the religion of the hindus but it's a
00:24:12 bad question because they don't have a religion because religion is an entirely weird culturally
00:24:18 distinctive 18th century way of seeing things back, you know, based in Europe. But because the British are governing India, and because Indians increasingly come to speak, or at least elite Indians come to speak English, without even being aware of it, they come to absorb this idea that there is something called the secular, and that there are things called religions, and the notion that the word that the British invent, Hinduism, is something that Indians themselves come to take on.
00:24:47 They come to think of themselves as belonging to a religion called Hinduism.
00:24:51 And by the time the British go, the leaders of the independence movement in India are perfectly happy.
00:25:00 Indeed, it's fundamental to their vision of India's future to think of it as being a secular republic.
00:25:05 And to this day, India is a secular state.
00:25:08 And the fact that it's a secular state is a kind of witness to Christianity's impact.
00:25:13 And in the book, I cite an Indian scholar who brilliantly sums it up. He says that Christianization proceeds in two ways. It proceeds through conversion, that's obvious. But it also proceeds through secularization. And so when you look at countries that in no way would you think of as being Christian, India, Japan, Turkey, all these countries define themselves as secular and say, to that degree, they've been Christianized.
00:25:42 And I think that the degree to which Muslims think of themselves as belonging to a religion called Islam is also reflective of the way in which Christianity has impacted Islam.
00:25:54 and so in a way that's what I wanted to write about
00:25:58 was the way in which
00:26:01 Christianisation has had this almost invisible impact in the world
00:26:08 and it's had an impact on people
00:26:11 who would absolutely not think of themselves as Christians
00:26:14 not just atheists but people who would see themselves as belonging to very different traditions
00:26:19 in our sort of society
00:26:22 people who are proudly secular
00:26:24 don't think that there's any
00:26:26 religious context at all
00:26:28 to their secularism, do they?
00:26:30 I mean, they think it's something that almost
00:26:32 arrived sort of out of a strange
00:26:34 kind of humanism, arrived almost
00:26:36 out of nowhere.
00:26:38 Well, they...
00:26:40 Because secularism
00:26:42 essentially is what provides
00:26:44 the basis for our multicultural
00:26:46 societies, in all their different
00:26:48 forms, be it the French, the British,
00:26:51 even the American forms,
00:26:52 it's pretty important
00:26:54 to the successful functioning of secularism
00:26:57 that it is thought to be neutral
00:26:59 that it is thought to adjust
00:27:00 and magically materialize like
00:27:02 a sunny day or something
00:27:03 if you start
00:27:06 asking yourself to those people
00:27:09 where does this idea come from
00:27:10 then you have no choice but to recognize
00:27:13 that it's deeply, deeply rooted
00:27:15 in profoundly Christian assumptions
00:27:16 and that's why it's much
00:27:19 much easier for Christians
00:27:20 and for people who come from a Christian cultural background
00:27:23 to just accept that the idea of a secular
00:27:27 is something that everyone should take if you're out of it.
00:27:30 But it is safe and acceptable for Jews.
00:27:32 And in a way, this has been evident
00:27:36 from the emergence of the kind of idea
00:27:40 of the ACK in France,
00:27:42 which is the first overtly militantly secular society
00:27:45 under the revolution.
00:27:46 Jews are allowed, they're given citizenship
00:27:49 of the French Republic, but there is a kind of proviso, and that is that they are no longer
00:27:54 allowed to think of themselves as belonging to a people, which is what they'd always
00:27:57 previously done, always thought of themselves as the people of Israel. They'd never thought
00:28:01 of themselves as belonging to a religion called Judaism. Judaism is a Christian
00:28:07 melodism, it's a word that Christian thinkers had basically coined in the second century
00:28:12 AD. No Jew had ever used it, but over the course of the 19th century, the quid pro
00:28:19 quote for Jews becoming citizens of European secular states is that they have to accept
00:28:24 that they belong to something called Judaism. And so both Reform and Orthodox Judaism, as
00:28:31 it emerges over the 19th century, are kind of different attempts to construct a kind
00:28:37 of model of Jewish practice that can correspond to the Christian concept of a religion. And
00:28:47 And the same kind of thing is now happening with Muslims, who likewise face a kind of similar dilemma that they are given by Western states freedom of religion, yes they can practice Islam as a religion, but that requires them to accept that Islam is a religion, that it is something that is sneaked and abstractable from the secular, and that's something that most Muslims in the West are perfectly happy to accept, but there are, of course, minorities who do not accept that, and it's not surprising that they don't accept it.
00:29:17 Because, basically, they're asked to make Islam into something that is more Christian.
00:29:23 And, inevitably, that imposes stresses.
00:29:26 And so the lure of the idea of a kind of global umma, the idea of a caliphate,
00:29:30 the idea of this kind of global polity, where Islam is not a religion,
00:29:36 that it is something far profaner than that.
00:29:39 It is part of the fabric of people's lives, which is what Islam always was until the 19th, 20th century.
00:29:47 the appeal of that is obvious
00:29:49 and I think it explains why
00:29:51 you know, the Clare call
00:29:53 of the Caliphate, the Clare call of joining
00:29:55 a global other was so profound
00:29:57 Do you
00:29:59 believe yourself
00:30:01 actually, Tom
00:30:03 I mean, are you sort of
00:30:04 you've written the book
00:30:06 the implication
00:30:08 perhaps I'm wrong, tell me, but
00:30:10 is that the influence of Christianity on the whole
00:30:13 has been quite a positive thing
00:30:14 um but do you therefore are you do you believe in in god so why would you call yourself a christian
00:30:21 well um the reason that the influence of christianity i think is liable to seem a
00:30:27 positive one is because our standards of what are good and bad are basically christian right
00:30:32 so we're christian christian being judged and kind wanting so the crusades violent um uh the
00:30:39 Inquisition, brutal killing of innocent people.
00:30:44 Why do we think war is bad?
00:30:45 Why do we think the killing of innocent people and the torture of them to death is bad?
00:30:50 Because Christ told Peter to put up his sword and said, turn the other cheek.
00:30:58 That is the ideal of Christian pacifism.
00:31:01 And why is the idea that inquisitors might torture to death innocent people so offensive to us?
00:31:06 because the central image of Christianity is a man tortured to death of an image of torture.
00:31:11 So even when people condemn Christianity, they do it for deeply, deeply Christian reasons.
00:31:17 And essentially, what I have come to realize, and the reason I wanted to write the book,
00:31:22 was that pretty much everything I think and believe,
00:31:29 by the standards of a kind of exacting rationalism, is mythical.
00:31:34 Human rights do not exist.
00:31:36 there is no obligation to show compassion or charity to those who are
00:31:41 less fortunate than you there is no reason why bloodthirsty conquest
00:31:48 shouldn't be celebrated there's no objective reason why racism shouldn't be
00:31:53 celebrated the reason that I what holds to the values that I have don't reflect
00:32:05 human nature they reflect kind of objective reality they reflect the huge
00:32:11 weathering effect of centuries and millennia of history upon me and upon
00:32:17 the society in which I've been raised and the family in which I've been raised
00:32:20 and therefore I essentially have the choice of jettisoning all the people
00:32:28 becoming embracing a kind of existentialism or whatever or
00:32:35 accepting that the myths can be true and in the end of the book I quote
00:32:42 Tolkien who basically says is that myths can be true and I suppose that that's
00:32:47 where I am I if I'm asked well you know where was where was God when when the
00:32:54 the asteroid hit the planet at the end of the Cretaceous, where is God in the
00:33:00 vast, inky depths of space, then you know I can't really believe in God. But if I
00:33:07 think what do I believe, what do I value, what do I find the most compelling
00:33:15 narrative that I know, it is the kind of the passion and resurrection. And the
00:33:23 experience of reflecting and think about it over four years and more has been to
00:33:31 open up to me the degree to which all that I believe as a kind of secularist as a humanist
00:33:38 is simply a watery and anemic version of Christian myths and that those Christian myths are so
00:33:48 potent, so beautiful often, so illumined by the thinking of minds immeasurably greater
00:34:04 than mine, certainly, that I feel almost a kind of arrogance not to accept that I exist
00:34:12 by virtue of these bits, and that therefore my relationship towards them cannot simply
00:34:17 be one of doubt and repudiation. So to that extent, it's obviously complicated, incredibly
00:34:26 complicated. And you may feel that I'm not giving you a straight answer. Perhaps I'm
00:34:31 not giving you a straight answer is because I think it's too complicated for a straight
00:34:34 answer. And that in that, I think that I'm not in any way unusual. I actually think that
00:34:41 the relationship of people in the West to this Christian inheritance is more complicated
00:34:47 than most people think and the moment you do stop to seriously consider it and contemplate it
00:34:53 you have no choice but to accept that yes i i the reason i ask is that this is something that
00:34:59 bothers me occasionally and i've had conversations about it where i tend not intellectually to
00:35:04 believe in in in in god um but nevertheless i i've i've i've rather settled on this phrase
00:35:12 cultural christian do you know um i don't know whether that means anything to you yes yes it does
00:35:19 and i think that that is basically i mean i think you don't have to accept it to be a
00:35:22 cultural christian i think by and large the west is profoundly culturally christian and i think
00:35:28 furthermore that the kind of the the non-belief in a cultural christian society is in itself a
00:35:35 kind of belief yes because it's defined by what you don't believe in so in that sense it's the
00:35:39 kind of you know it's it's it's it's the negative of a photo but you don't have the negative without
00:35:44 the original photo so in that sense um secularism humanism whatever we would call it remains a
00:35:51 belief system there's nothing obvious about it it requires commitment it requires belief it
00:35:56 it has priesthoods it has um you know it has heretics it's very it's it's it's it is in a way
00:36:05 a kind of, you know, if you think of the medieval church, which is born in a kind of great cultural
00:36:12 revolution in the 11th century, and then Constantism, which is born in a very similar
00:36:16 cultural process of reformation in the 16th century, what is now the kind of, the dominant
00:36:24 way of understanding the world is the product of the 18th century and its kind of reverberation
00:36:29 through the Enlightenment, French Revolution, the 60s, and so on.
00:36:34 But I think that I'm more than culturally Christian.
00:36:39 I think that there is a kind of nexus, a kind of intersection of the Venn diagram
00:36:47 between belief and disbelief, where I find myself currently.
00:36:51 I do believe in the Christian myth, let's put it like that.
00:36:56 I do, I think, the Lord Jesus Christ rose on the third day. I'm not sure, but I kind of believe that there is a power in that myth that goes beyond simply, yeah, simply kind of the rationalist ability to explain it.
00:37:12 Do you think, you know, this is a very, very big question, but do you think that situations that we're going through at the moment, say, for example, with COVID-19, do you think they tend to give a boost to religion or do they tend to diminish it in the long term?
00:37:29 I think that Christianity's power is founded on its ability to provide comfort to those
00:37:43 who are suffering, ultimately. I think that was evident right from the start. The idea
00:37:53 that um you know it wasn't caesar who was the son of god it was someone who had suffered the most
00:38:02 humiliating death imaginable had suffered the death of the slave and therefore there's a kind
00:38:08 of um death charge there which burns very slowly throughout history but containing the idea that
00:38:16 perhaps you know the slave is closer to God than the king and this manifests
00:38:23 itself in times of extreme stress which plays an absolutely example in offering
00:38:29 reassurance to people that there is love for those who are suffering terribly and
00:38:38 there is hope and there is purpose now whether theologically you can provide
00:38:44 sanction for that is it's a problem but I think it's indisputable looking for
00:38:53 instance at the testimony of Cyprian that the bishop watching people died
00:38:59 very very horribly all around him there seems to be no doubt that the
00:39:08 Christianity is better able to provide people in suffering those terrors with
00:39:13 the sense of hope
00:39:15 and of purpose, the sense that there is
00:39:17 love for them from their fellow men
00:39:20 as well as from God, because
00:39:21 one of the things that
00:39:23 Christianity seems to inspire in a way that it
00:39:25 doesn't among other people
00:39:27 suffering from this plague is readiness to go
00:39:29 and help those who are suffering.
00:39:32 So,
00:39:33 I think for all those reasons,
00:39:36 you might think that
00:39:37 plagues or wars or earthquakes
00:39:39 or whatever
00:39:40 would get people to question the idea
00:39:43 of an all-powerful God, you know, famously it did for Voltaire and the aftermath of the
00:39:49 destruction of Lisbon in the earthquake. But actually it seems to work in the other way,
00:39:56 that it's when you feel the profound grief, it's when you're in the valley of the shadow of death,
00:40:02 that perhaps you most want what Christianity can offer. And so I'm interested to see whether
00:40:11 whether it leads people to lose faith
00:40:12 or to gain faith or to...
00:40:14 They're like interesting to see.
00:40:16 Tom, it's great to talk to you about this.
00:40:19 I have been looking back at your output,
00:40:23 which is prodigious, extraordinary,
00:40:25 all the things that you've done
00:40:26 from the very early novels you were writing
00:40:30 right through to now.
00:40:32 And I noticed that you were writing an opera.
00:40:35 You're writing an opera about Cleopatra.
00:40:38 I was wondering that now that we have...
00:40:40 know you've told us that you've actually you've got your work hard out as it is but
00:40:43 are you sort of progressing with that at the moment or well it's done it's done it's uh yes
00:40:50 it's it's a kind of operatic mama mia um i've got two friends who are both very useful uh far more
00:40:57 musical than i am um they're married one is a singer one is one one is a director and we've
00:41:04 been kind of working on various ideas for music for years and years and our most recent one was
00:41:08 we were going to do a musical about Nero as a rock star and we thought wouldn't it be great if we could chuck in a bit of 1-2-30 into it or handle as angrippina and then we said well actually there's no reason why we couldn't and it's out of copyright and from that the idea spiraled that let's do a tell story of Cleopatra but using the most famous arias imaginable from 19th century high opera and so that's what we're doing.
00:41:38 and it's been showcased at the Albert Hall really when would that be and so that was last spring
00:41:47 and now we're in the process of talking to all kinds of people and it's just kind of building
00:41:51 up to a head and then coronavirus hit so it's all gone back into spaces again but
00:41:57 put this cross well great so we will actually it will at some stage be performed
00:42:04 yeah god or um isis or whoever willing tom thank you very very much uh it's great thank you for
00:42:12 joining us and for giving us so much time and uh well look um i hope uh you know stay strong and
00:42:18 stay well thanks very much for watching uh so what you're saying is uh look forward to seeing you
00:42:23 next time. Please do keep subscribing won't you and also do stay safe and stay well. Thank you.