New Culture Forum - February 22, 2021


A Problem With Porn? Should, Or Can, Anything Be Done?

Mike Graham: The Media - Past, Present & Future. Tales From The Frontline. The Continuing Scandal Of Muslim Grooming Gangs & The Failure Of Our Institutions To Deal With It

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

162.49

Word count

6,734

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittall now here are a few interesting stats
00:00:17 for you something like 4.7 billion people on the planet can access the internet 25% of searches
00:00:27 are for pornography and it was recently calculated that if you took the one site alone porn hub
00:00:36 and wanted to watch all the material on it it would take you precisely 173 years that's truly
00:00:44 mind-boggling now has porn become as we're told all the time entirely mainstream without a stigma
00:00:52 attached well there are certain problems which certainly have been highlighted in recent years
00:00:58 and we want to discuss those and to discuss as well whether in fact there is still such a thing
00:01:03 as a moral panic around porn and indeed what are the political responses to it now to discuss this
00:01:10 today i'm very pleased we have three guests we have mary sharp who is ceo of the reward foundation
00:01:18 which is a sex and relationship education charity. Paula Hall, a psychotherapist who
00:01:25 specialises in sex addiction and porn and is the author of Understanding and Treating
00:01:30 Sex Addiction. And from Civitas, Emma Webb. Thank you very much for joining us. Could I
00:01:38 start really with you, Mary? Could you sort of tell us, there are sort of certain areas
00:01:44 that people who study porn or in fact where it comes into their work there are certain areas now
00:01:51 where where there's great cause for concern particularly for men who use porn could you tell
00:01:56 us what they are well in recent years there's been a staggering increase in the rates of sexual
00:02:04 dysfunctions particularly erectile dysfunction in men under 30. now up until about 2002 the research
00:02:14 indicated about three to five percent of men were experiencing erectile dysfunction
00:02:21 usually and with partners and it's generally considered an old man's condition something if
00:02:27 you've got a congenitive heart failure obesity or such like but that two to three percent changed
00:02:33 so from about 2008 onwards the research search just showed steady increases and we're now seeing
00:02:40 rates of around 30 to 35 percent of men under 30 experiencing sexual dysfunctions that's a thousand
00:02:47 percent increase in that period from the time that internet pornography went on stream
00:02:54 so so it was just purely about you know on porn going on stream or about you know the
00:03:01 is it where the times involved you know the the um uploading and things like that it all became
00:03:07 much quicker didn't it yes well everything became quicker and the youtube type sites are called tube
00:03:14 sites because they they're little videos two minute videos that are readily available thousands and
00:03:20 thousands as you said you know hundreds of years worth of material thousands of videos are suddenly
00:03:25 available and they're hardcore most of them hardcore pornography so and since most people
00:03:31 access pornography via a smartphone between the ready availability accessibility and anonymity
00:03:40 of porn through smartphones and all this high definition huge amounts of material being
00:03:47 available it's just flooded the market and it's made it available to everybody and it's mainly
00:03:54 free so this has changed and porn today is totally different from pornography in the past
00:03:59 in terms of the way that it impacts on the brain,
00:04:03 particularly adolescent brains.
00:04:05 I mean, we hear, you know, I don't know if any of you could tell us,
00:04:08 but at what kind of age now does your average person
00:04:13 first get to know about porn or first see it, would you say?
00:04:18 It's about 11 or 12.
00:04:20 About 11 or 12.
00:04:21 But also much younger.
00:04:23 I mean, if they've got access to phones and the parents
00:04:25 don't know necessarily how to use filters
00:04:28 or they don't turn the filters on or kids at school are sharing files the key thing is that
00:04:34 around the age of puberty which is around 10 to 12 14 depending on the individual they are naturally
00:04:41 curious about sex so they're seeking it out and what they're finding of course is hardcore pornography
00:04:48 am i right you're saying both uh mary paula that you're not actually anti-porn as such are you
00:04:53 you no i'm not no i mean i'm a psychosexual therapist as well so and of course many many
00:05:00 millions of people enjoy pornography recreationally in the same way as many of us
00:05:05 enjoy alcohol recreationally um but we we are aware of the potential risks of developing an
00:05:13 addiction or compulsivity to alcohol so we have drink aware campaigns uh we now have gambling
00:05:19 aware campaigns and gamble responsibly campaigns because we do understand those connections but
00:05:26 we're not necessarily trying to boycott it for everybody and I think this is the challenge that
00:05:32 we really need to begin to face in society is how we do provide the appropriate education for
00:05:39 people and as Mary says particularly young people and provide services for people for whom it does
00:05:45 become compulsive i mean do you think that i'm sorry go ahead i'm just going to say that while
00:05:51 alcohol and gambling are serious problems in society there's no doubt about that
00:05:56 we don't actually have brain structures for gambling or alcohol they piggyback on the brain
00:06:02 structures for sex and pornography deals directly with those structures in the brain that have
00:06:08 evolved to help us mate and have lasting relationships so it's actually destroyed
00:06:15 not that destroys our ability to have relationships do you think uh i mean you know we we hear
00:06:21 addiction uh you know a lot today about whole different areas do you think there is such a
00:06:28 thing as sex addiction do you do do you think it is something that actually changes well obviously
00:06:33 the science would seem to suggest it is yeah i mean i i think that uh from the evidence that
00:06:39 i've seen i'm no expert in this subject and i'm not a scientist but the fact that there seems to
00:06:44 be this sort of as you would expect with drug use this uh ever increasing need for a harder hit in
00:06:52 order to to um to to i guess get that that buzz from the pornography the fact that it escalates
00:06:59 the fact that it results in people going to hardcore porn or child pornography I think suggests
00:07:05 that not only is it an addiction but it's an addiction that firstly has a really detrimental
00:07:11 impact on the way that people relate to others and to society in ways that are unacceptable
00:07:18 but also as was already mentioned by Mary I think the fact that it disrupts people's
00:07:25 relationships with others either through sexual dysfunction or simply through you know if you're
00:07:31 if you're 10 or 11 years old and the first exposure you have to human sexuality is this
00:07:40 exaggerated and sometimes aggressive and unnatural view of what sexuality is like
00:07:52 you're going to sort of go through puberty marinating in something that is not only
00:08:00 unhealthy for you but actually has a long-term impact on your ability to function sexually
00:08:07 either from a psychological or a physical perspective so i think even even whether
00:08:12 you class it as an addiction or not i think the the evidence suggesting all of that you know it
00:08:18 should probably be treated as an addiction regardless because it's just such a big issue
00:08:23 but i think i think a lot of what you're saying emma can actually be i mean i don't disagree but
00:08:29 can be counteracted also by good education so a lot of young people will be introduced to car
00:08:35 driving through watching things like grand theft auto but thankfully we do teach young people how
00:08:41 to drive and they get in the car with other people they have other places where they can learn
00:08:45 So, I mean, young people pick up all sorts of things through the Internet and regrettably, well, maybe not regrettably, but we'll never be able to control that.
00:08:54 But I think it makes it ever more important to have really good sex and relationship education within schools and from an early age.
00:09:04 If the only education a young person gets is from online pornography, that is where we hit the really serious problems.
00:09:12 But, of course, what we need to ensure is that if we're not able to control that, and we never will fully, that it is balanced by good, solid, realistic sex and relationship education.
00:09:26 One of the big issues, of course, is that erectile dysfunction certainly is an issue, although that doesn't tend to manifest until they perhaps had several years of using hardcore porn.
00:09:38 so it's late teens and early 20s that we're seeing that develop but with younger children
00:09:45 the problem is the violence and coercion that they're seeing in porn and then they're acting
00:09:50 that out with school pupils and just this morning I was reading a law case where a young man lost
00:09:57 his appeal this is in Scotland he lost his appeal against having his name on what's called the
00:10:04 children's list because he committed sexual acts i mean fumbling and touching but persistently and
00:10:11 coercively with three girls in his class at school when they were in their early teens now that's on
00:10:18 his record and he's worried that when he finishes his law degree that will stop him being able to
00:10:24 get a job as a lawyer what a lot of people and a lot of children don't realize is that the law is
00:10:30 taking sexual offending very seriously and so even sexting or abusive um behavior when you're young
00:10:39 can have many many years of impact when you're trying to apply for jobs later and so it's
00:10:46 up paul is right and emma too it's critical that we teach kids about this we've got a series of
00:10:52 free lesson plans available for scotland england and wales and ireland on the impact of pornography
00:11:00 on health, on law, and on social relationships.
00:11:04 Can I ask you, if you look at it more,
00:11:07 if you look at it broadly, sort of culturally,
00:11:09 it's my impression, you know,
00:11:11 that if you look at dating sites,
00:11:13 which young people and teenagers obviously do,
00:11:16 Tinder and all those sorts of sites,
00:11:19 is that the effect of porn has actually reached there, hasn't it?
00:11:23 I mean, people sort of put up very easily
00:11:26 what you would call really quite you know sort of daring pictures or naked pictures or whatever
00:11:32 is wouldn't you say that that's a direct result really of the pornification of the mainstream
00:11:37 well I think you can take it either way can't you I mean I think that there's no way of knowing of
00:11:42 which one came first we're in a chicken and egg scenario here and I think there you know we have
00:11:49 to be aware that times are changing I mean once upon a time the Victorians were hiding you know
00:11:55 piano legs because it was perceived as being you know inappropriate times have changed young people
00:12:01 do have different attitudes towards sex and sexuality and i think we have to be careful
00:12:07 that we're not applying you know old judgments of normality sexuality has always evolved throughout
00:12:13 all cultures all times across all continents it evolves and i mean i i think i i understand what
00:12:22 Mary means when she says the term hardcore pornography but actually even the definition
00:12:27 of hardcore has changed considerably over the last 30 years and I think you know it's so easy
00:12:35 to get into these judgments about what is okay and what is not okay how much of a leg a cleavage
00:12:42 a torso is considered permissible but I think it's more important to look at the the kind of
00:12:48 effects of that because otherwise we start going into that moral panic yeah i suppose
00:12:54 yes sorry maria has been a dramatic rise in child and child sexual abuse there was a 78
00:13:03 percent rise in england and wales between 2012 and 2016 and a 34 percent rise um during the
00:13:11 equivalent time in scotland now this is phenomenal and you know it has um so much one of the most
00:13:19 popular genre of porn is actually incest porn and kids you know think they can perhaps act this out
00:13:28 because most of the the child and child sexual abuse is perpetrated within the family or the
00:13:34 friendship circles so i mean and this has a huge impact i say not just on the perpetrators
00:13:39 but on the people receiving the abuse on the other side so sorry you're saying incest porn
00:13:45 by the way or you obviously mean faked up sort of scenarios is that what you mean or not yes but
00:13:50 the brain doesn't know the difference between what's what what the porn industry euphemistically
00:13:55 call full incest and actual incest they just see you know somebody having sex with their sister
00:14:02 or their stepsister or or their mother and this causes massive problems within families
00:14:08 so i mean there's all kinds of mental health issues but when children are acting out the
00:14:14 type of pornography they're seeing and then they get told it's wrong they don't know what the
00:14:18 boundaries are they don't know you know what's acceptable or not and then that sends them right
00:14:23 back to more pornography because that seems like a safe area which is why the education is so
00:14:29 important i i do want to really clarify here we are talking about in some sentences about sexual
00:14:35 addiction or pornography addiction and porn compulsivity and we're talking about offending
00:14:41 these are not necessarily the same things and i feel very very strongly about this because one
00:14:46 of the biggest barriers to people getting help for pornography addiction or compulsive pornography
00:14:52 use is the fear of stigmatization and when we start assuming or saying that pornography addiction
00:14:59 leads to offending not only is that inaccurate yes there's a percentage who do but we have no
00:15:07 reason for not thinking they wouldn't have done in the first place and this is the difference
00:15:11 between causation and correlation which is really important to understand so it's a tiny percentage
00:15:17 of people who use it compulsively who may then go on to offend and that is very different from
00:15:24 the issues that that mary's talking about which i wholeheartedly support and agree with but it's not
00:15:30 an automatic consequence of addiction at all and that thinking stops people from getting help
00:15:36 i'm really interested to know what um mary and paula think of the development in uh the sort of
00:15:46 i guess the way that explicit images are hosted on the internet so things like only fans in
00:15:52 relation to child sexual abuse because i've seen some suggestions that some of the people on only
00:15:58 fans are you know can be quite young that the the age limit isn't necessarily always um accurate
00:16:07 um particularly because of what mary said about um the way that these things piggyback
00:16:15 on our psychology about sex in relation to gambling because there are some elements of
00:16:20 only fans that are akin to gambling the the expectation of um getting content that is sort
00:16:27 of locked and then people pay for it and it's it's um different from the sort of i guess different
00:16:35 from the psychology surrounding just getting images images or videos a click away for free
00:16:42 And that's almost like fast food, like a quick fix. People seem to have sort of now shifted to wanting the anticipation of things like OnlyFans, which in a way kind of mimic almost like a long distance relationship or something where they can talk to the person and they pay money for access to private videos and things like that.
00:17:03 does that have an impact on the way that particularly young people
00:17:10 will relate to other people because of their experience of that kind of pornography?
00:17:15 Can you explain, actually, OnlyFans, right, for people who don't know?
00:17:18 So OnlyFans seems to have been something that has kind of peaked during lockdown for obvious reasons.
00:17:24 It's a kind of, I guess, I mean, I don't know, but it's a platform of...
00:17:28 None of us know.
00:17:29 it's it's it's it's a it's a it's a platform where people can and again it's really important
00:17:37 to understand how the porn industry has evolved so only fans really has been set up by people
00:17:42 putting their own content online so this isn't all about pornographers going out there with a
00:17:48 camera finding some porn stars or unsuspecting whatever these are you know many of them are
00:17:55 young women who are deciding to create images of themselves to take videos of themselves to put
00:18:02 online and then you can subscribe and follow whoever it is um i mean the age is a really
00:18:08 really interesting thing emma and i think it's a problem we have with the world wide web only
00:18:13 fans was set up by someone in russia initially uh the age of consent is different around the
00:18:18 whole world which again is where we end up with so many problems when it comes to trying to legalize
00:18:24 this content so these are typically young women who are posting their own videos and getting fans
00:18:31 to follow them subscribe pay money so it's a different way of producing pornographic
00:18:39 content and that is changing as well all the time so whenever we're having these conversations about
00:18:45 pornography um yes of course the tube sites revolutionize pornography but it is continuing
00:18:52 to evolve all the time and there are new ways of doing it and some of that hardcore stuff is
00:18:57 actually becoming less and less popular now because of the the own creation porn through
00:19:03 things like only fans i think that's because it feels more relational it feels as though you're
00:19:08 having more of a relationship with that person which you know as emma's alluding to i think
00:19:13 mimics offline relationships which many people are looking for and haven't been able to have
00:19:20 during covid my understanding is that only fans is predominantly sex workers who use it
00:19:26 so if children are using it it fits in with what we've been hearing about in schools where a lot of
00:19:32 young people want career advice on how to become a porn performer because they think it's glamorous
00:19:39 and fun and they can make lots of money the sad reality make lots of money many of us yeah yes
00:19:45 some can but the sad reality is that most porn performers don't last more than three to six
00:19:51 months because of the tremendous mental and physical health impacts of acting in porn sites
00:19:59 but the thing about the internet in general and emma's right you know looking at it a little bit
00:20:05 like gambling sites or or gaming sites it's the constant novelty at a click and this sort of
00:20:12 heightened reality that this excitement everything seems so much better than everyday reality and
00:20:19 what happens over time is that a young person's brain becomes desensitized they have a numbed
00:20:25 pleasure response to everyday pleasures and everyday reality the only thing that gets them
00:20:30 excited is porn so forget about school work and we're hearing this from teachers that kids are
00:20:36 just not as interested in their work they can't pay attention they're not getting enough sleep at
00:20:41 night um they come in exhausted and you know you can see why you know that this would happen
00:20:47 it's curious um one of the areas i was looking at was the work developed um at stanford university
00:20:54 by a professor bj fogg who in the mid 90s developed what's called the persuasive technology lab
00:21:01 and for instance one of the the students that he had he's had many students but one of them
00:21:06 was at one of the co-founders of instagram which now has more than two billion followers
00:21:13 the they deliberately they teach their students as i've read in this this um lab and how they
00:21:20 teach them about the reward system of the brain and how to get people hooked so they use neuroscience
00:21:27 and psychology to tap into people's most vulnerable the most vulnerable part of their brain
00:21:33 to get them hooked and to actually make them want to repeat the behavior so that level of manipulation
00:21:41 is what's being used across the internet to make people um keep going back i mean i think that
00:21:48 that's another whole debate about social media and facebook and uh u.s elections potentially
00:21:54 and goodness knows what else isn't it that uh that comes just the problem is regarding sex
00:22:01 it's having a serious impact on young people and the uk the government are very slow i mean they're
00:22:07 trying but they're so slow to do anything in response to i mean the digital economy act was
00:22:13 brought out in 2017 but they failed to implement part three that dealt with age verification
00:22:18 legislation this is what i was going to actually ask because i i think that this is something that
00:22:23 most people would think is a kind of common sensical uh measure you know just age verification
00:22:28 are we saying that we actually don't have that yet i mean this i i mean going back to
00:22:34 was it david cameron's time i think this came up didn't it it was it was around about then
00:22:39 and and that would just mean that you had to show that you were over what 18 or 16 or yeah
00:22:44 anybody can access pornography from any device including playstations remember playstations and
00:22:50 xboxes they're all attached to the internet as well and that's that's a device that that people
00:22:55 will often forget um yeah anybody can access it anywhere and there are some porn blockers porn
00:23:01 protectors but if you want to know how to get one around one of those ask a 12 year old boy and he'll
00:23:07 show you how to get around it i think if you if you like we were talking about social media as
00:23:12 well that you're sort of looking at holistically the environment that kids who are you know like
00:23:18 12 or going through puberty that they're surrounded by there's the constant draw of as as Mary
00:23:26 mentioned the social media like Instagram constantly scrolling through their feeds
00:23:31 constantly hankering after likes I think I saw something on Twitter the other day where
00:23:35 someone had gone to buy a notebook and found that the only thing that available for young kids as a
00:23:40 journal planner for 2021 that they could find was how to be an influencer and it had things like
00:23:46 where to list your likes and follows and things like that that they're surrounded by almost like
00:23:52 the social equivalent of fast food this quick hit culture where they just want to get the likes and
00:23:57 the endorphins and everything and the fact that that's all mixed up with this uh probably i would
00:24:03 say the increasing sexualization of children just within the media generally um things like cuties
00:24:11 that i don't think we would have seen 10 years ago that wouldn't have been acceptable um the the
00:24:16 The way that children present themselves on these platforms as well, and that all muddied up with the quick fix of porn and all of that kind of sort of endorphin here.
00:24:28 I think that's the thing that really worries me, because if you think about not just with lockdown, but before, the just general atomization of society and the ways that we relate to each other, we obviously have some kind of crisis in our social world.
00:24:43 And I think the pornographic side of that is really important, because if we think like 10 or 20 years from now, when those kids are grown up and adults, you know, we already have plummeting birth rates.
00:24:56 The last thing in the world we need is loads of sexual dysfunction and people who don't know how to properly relate to each other.
00:25:00 that's a good point also this other point uh more generally you're talking about you know the effect
00:25:06 on young people um but isn't it also has a big effect surely culturally on body image you know
00:25:14 in the sense that what the people that are in porn now um are quite different to the poor
00:25:20 the people who were in porn in the 1970s it's a bit of a cliche joke isn't it but but the thing
00:25:25 thing is it's gone into the whole culture so you know even actors in hollywood now look they're
00:25:31 always ripped you know they're always sort of like careless uh and all this must have the most
00:25:37 enormous effect surely on how young people see see their bodies but i think that i mean that is one
00:25:42 side of it but you can find anything in pornography you can find absolutely anything and some of those
00:25:49 yet exaggerated hips and other parts and what have you that have been ever since you know
00:25:56 pre-Raphaelite days we've been kind of celebrating the human form in a slightly exaggerated way
00:26:01 that has always been around and yes that is certainly in pornography but there is also a
00:26:07 lot more kind of amateur pornography older generation grandma milf pornography around
00:26:15 that ever used to be before these are all very new kind of genres and again I think I suppose
00:26:22 I'm very mindful there are lots of people out there who think that um porn addiction is is just
00:26:28 a complete myth it's something that's made up by you know prudes puritanical prudes who are trying
00:26:35 to um you know go back to the sort of days of um you know there being absolutely nothing available
00:26:41 at all prohibition and i i think we need to be careful not to be falling into the common trap
00:26:47 of this actually becoming an anti-porn discussion yeah no no one so i don't think this i don't think
00:26:54 anyone's saying it's an anti-porn discussion i don't think any of us are anti-porn as harsh but
00:26:58 i mean it is it's a question it's a question of unless i don't know if you are but i mean um you
00:27:03 know i what i would say is with this is for example i think probably i'm about to fall into your trap
00:27:10 that you just mentioned um but uh you know what difference in terms of relationships if for example
00:27:17 one partner in a relationship is looking at porn an awful lot is that the same as being unfaithful
00:27:23 i mean is that the sort of thing that basically would bring some a marriage to to break up or a
00:27:31 partnership to break up i mean or are we changing our attitude there yeah what what you said being
00:27:37 unfaithful what what damages the relationship and i'm a relation you know sex and relationship
00:27:42 psychotherapist that's what i specialize in what what breaks up a relationship is a breach of trust
00:27:47 whatever that relationship is if you break the trust within a relationship if you cheat
00:27:52 on your partner then yes that's going to cause problems that every relationship will have a
00:27:58 different definition of what that is so you know there are many people out there living in very
00:28:04 happy content open non-monogamous relationships where actually but they still have rules they
00:28:10 still have their their kind of conditions of what is okay and what is not okay and that
00:28:15 and how they should operate so if you are breaching trust in your relationship by watching
00:28:21 pornography then yes that is going to be as detrimental to the relationship as having a
00:28:28 flesh-on-flesh encounter with somebody if you're in a monogamous relationship so but no
00:28:34 every person who's watched porn has not brought the end of their their relationship um so it's
00:28:39 it's down to what's okay in your you know between you and your partner um well loathed as i am to
00:28:45 go back to the subject of only fans um somebody said on twitter the other day that if you if your
00:28:50 girlfriend has only fans you don't have a girlfriend i think the changes in i mean
00:28:56 there's um to some extent i think this is a moral and ethical problem and i expect i probably
00:29:02 differ slightly on my sort of moral view of pornography not just people who um well I think
00:29:12 that both taking part in pornography and watching pornography is morally questionable um but you
00:29:20 know it's interesting that you know people have different views on on this and it actually tends
00:29:27 to be that people on the right the libertarian right have the most permissive attitude towards
00:29:34 porn not just pornography on sort of like the traditional pornography but also things like
00:29:38 only fans and even the wide availability of pornography on things like twitter um and it's
00:29:46 actually tends to be people from the left from the sort of maybe not the woke left but more
00:29:51 feminist left um probably the same sorts of people who would overlap with being accused of being 0.99
00:29:57 a turf who would say that pornography is detrimental from a to women from a
00:30:05 feminist perspective so I think there's a whole separate moral discussion to be 0.94
00:30:11 had around that we don't really seem to be able to have a moral discussion about
00:30:14 it because I think we've given up on morality yeah I think there's too much
00:30:19 because I'm coming at this from a Christian perspective and so my views on
00:30:23 this or what you would expect a christian perspective to be um but i think that we have
00:30:28 it's mill's classic problem of um you know when you have an agreement about custom in society
00:30:34 then you can have a discussion but we're too morally diverse and i think on the pornography
00:30:39 um subject there's such a wide range of of moral opinions on it and they don't fit in the political
00:30:47 categories that you would usually expect them to be in i think that's very true i mean sorry
00:30:52 I think also, Emma, there's such a huge definition of honest pornography. So once upon a time, Michelangelo's David would have been considered pornographic. And I don't think any of us disagree that child abuse images, underage images of children who have been sexually abused are wrong, are morally reprehensible and wrong.
00:31:19 and that anybody who is on the internet grooming young people it's absolutely wrong you know
00:31:25 that's pretty unequivocal but there are different definitions so when is something
00:31:31 sex education when is something you know somebody who from a diverse sexual group looking for other
00:31:40 people in a similar situation online where it is liberating where it's actually providing
00:31:45 opportunities for them to connect and actually have a healthy sex with them and there are those
00:31:51 people out there it all depends what you are talking about and this is what makes it so
00:31:56 difficult there is no doubt a lot of porn is unethical but i do believe some of it is and each
00:32:04 of us will have a different definition of what that is i don't think it's just the child sexual
00:32:10 abuse material that is reprehensible or morally debatable i'm using that as an example i'm saying
00:32:17 we would all that's the most extreme example but there's plenty of um incest porn as i say
00:32:25 torture porn there's lots of um types of porn that are really not helpful to people strangulation
00:32:32 one of the biggest the fastest growing areas just now is strangulation porn now it's part of
00:32:39 There are kink communities, BDSM groups, bondage, domination, sadomasochism, who agree, consent amongst themselves that if the pain is too much, they have a safe word and can say it, and then the other person stops. 0.96
00:32:57 But children are watching this. And in fact, there was a survey done in 2019 by the Sunday Times and of the Gen Z, the under 22 year olds, BDSM and rough sex were one of the most popular porn genre amongst them. 0.75
00:33:16 now you you can that's not child abuse material but this this they are a lot of people are
00:33:22 acting this stuff out without having a safe word without having the safety that maybe adults in the 0.81
00:33:28 kink community might use but sorry the kink community okay yes yeah so um one of the sexual 0.94
00:33:37 minority groups sexual adventurers if you like but they are acting that stuff out so if it's done 0.82
00:33:43 within you know consenting adults who've got safety words that's what they might do but there's
00:33:48 a lot of children watching this stuff because they get a bigger sexual high the more um you know
00:33:56 anxiety making the material is they get adrenaline that mixes with other neurochemicals that gives
00:34:01 them a bigger sexual high being strangled where there's actually a restriction on um oxygen to
00:34:08 the brain gives a bigger sexual high but that can go too far and the person ends up dead
00:34:13 but even even without even if it's non-fatal strangulation there's been excellent research
00:34:20 we've got a blog on our website about it a doctor says a lot of the the damage is hidden
00:34:26 so when somebody's being strangled it can cause a stroke it can cause a miscarriage
00:34:32 it can cause all kinds of brain damage that is not even showing up when the police investigation
00:34:38 is done so you know there's and given that that is such a popular genre amongst young people
00:34:46 is really quite worrying can i can i emma did uh bring something up actually which i just wanted
00:34:51 to go into just a little bit um which was about the political response which i think is very very
00:34:56 important that you know if you grew up in the 70s like i did we had mary whitehouse as you mentioned
00:35:01 earlier um but we also it was definitely a case that you that the um porn was um a sign of you
00:35:10 know a disintegrating society that basically you know we had to ban it or at least it was it was
00:35:17 it was a bad thing right um it seems to me that the position emma has actually already said that
00:35:23 on the what you might call the right or certain there is there's no feeling of that anymore it's
00:35:28 very much you know if there's a market for it then there's a market for it and great you know
00:35:32 do what you want to do so long as it doesn't you know frighten the horses or whatever but
00:35:36 but basically on the other hand I wondered and this is a bit of an off the wall question but
00:35:41 is there is there a woke position on porn pornography is there a woke one you know we
00:35:49 hear about woke an awful lot we discuss it endlessly on this show what is the woke attitude
00:35:54 to porn? I would suggest that amongst feminism, now Emma mentioned, brought up feminism earlier, 1.00
00:36:04 there are two types, two main groupings of feminists around the pornography issue. There's 1.00
00:36:11 the old style radical feminists who say that all porn is bad because it's objectification of women 1.00
00:36:20 for the male gaze and therefore it's bad and that was the andrea dworkin type position from the 70s 0.95
00:36:26 and and going forward gail dynes dr gail dynes is one of the main proponents of that um today um 0.93
00:36:34 but the modern the so-called liberal feminists would say porn's good because it's liberating
00:36:41 it's empowering women women can do it but there's this failure to understand the impact it's having
00:36:47 on the brain the impact that it's having on their need for for increasing levels of porn and more
00:36:55 extreme porn in order to get the sexual high but that doesn't happen for everybody mary no i didn't
00:37:02 suggest for a minute and we both we both work with the people for whom that does happen
00:37:07 they i mean the normal center particularly in through covid our inquiries have doubled with
00:37:13 young people struggling with porn addiction including women we keep talking about men this
00:37:17 is affecting more and more women so yes for those people where it escalates absolutely but it doesn't
00:37:22 happen for everybody and i think this is where you end up getting caught between camps so and
00:37:29 being able to have a conversation and not yeah not get into this kind of porn panic debate because
00:37:35 for some people they can watch it sensibly and that doesn't happen to their brain any more than
00:37:40 they get addicted to alcohol well i didn't suggest first of all that it was happening to everyone far
00:37:47 from it but since the problems tend to escalate over a period of time or rather incubate over a
00:37:54 period of time we don't know um nestle you know that it um that it wouldn't lead for some for some
00:38:03 to compulsive sexual behavior disorder or even addiction i think we need protection for young
00:38:09 people on the internet because i think mary is absolutely right that there's no way of um knowing
00:38:15 kind of the impact it has particularly on young people's brains and they don't have the access to
00:38:20 the other information as well we need that and we need education good sex and relationship education
00:38:27 and age verification or whatever it would take and i think that that proved to be very challenging
00:38:33 unfortunately is absolutely what we need and this should be something that's cross-party looking at
00:38:40 the fact that actually pornography has evolved and we need new ways we can't put it on the top
00:38:46 shelf anymore we need new ways of managing something that is very new and we just do not
00:38:53 have that at the moment i think uh just uh just one other final point is that when i was talking 0.97
00:38:59 about what i mean i think that the what what you said mary about there about uh feminist attitudes
00:39:04 to porn i think those those are the ones i i recognize you know that they've been around for 0.82
00:39:09 quite a while i i think that what is interesting is that you might start to get interference or
00:39:14 views at least expressed about the various types of pornography i sexual politics that comes into
00:39:21 it you know all of that aspect i think that because as you said it there's virtually nothing
00:39:27 that you can't see now but i mean you know i i'd imagine depictions even in porn will start to
00:39:33 actually come under scrutiny of uh woke censorship maybe actually i this is a really i think this is
00:39:39 a really interesting subject the mash-up between not just you know like political opinions of porn
00:39:47 but the mash-up between natural mash-up i think between sexuality violence and politics because
00:39:54 i was doing some work last year on grooming gangs and so i was following some of these
00:40:00 pretty horrendous hashtags um i won't say what they are because i don't want anyone to go looking
00:40:06 them up um but they these hashtags lead you down a horrific rabbit hole um and at the time of all
00:40:12 of the blm stuff there was loads of sexually explicit images even available on twitter um
00:40:19 you know i guess you would call it blm porn but it wasn't really so much you know sexual it was about
00:40:25 um a pretty toxic dynamic in race relations let's say euphemistically that's how i'm going to put it
00:40:33 um and i think that is something that is um pretty toxic in terms of social relations because
00:40:41 people will look at that and it won't only affect their sexual relationships with others or social
00:40:47 relationships with others it also meshes into this entire sort of toxic um political atmosphere
00:40:54 and so I you know it's I think that's something that's really worrying that
00:41:00 never really gets discussed but yeah I think we have to leave it there because
00:41:08 you know it's it's getting on for lunch time I know some of you could have
00:41:12 rushed off for lunch but thank you very very much Paula thank you very much
00:41:16 Mary for joining us thank you Emma very interesting discussion thank you
00:41:21 That's it for Counterculture this week, and we shall see you next time.
00:41:25 Thank you. Bye.