New Culture Forum - July 31, 2020


An Elder Statesman Of Conservatism On The Culture War (BLM, Cancel Culture & Covid - 19) Conundrum

SOS, SAVE OUR STATUES -- SaveOurStatues.org.uk -- Join To Defend Britain's Heritage Laurence Fox: The Battle Of Our Time Is A Defence Of Britain & Its Values

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

139.94

Word count

6,410

Sentence count

143


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today,
00:00:27 I hope he won't mind if I describe him as one of the eldest statesman of conservatism.
00:00:34 John O'Sullivan is currently head of the Danube Institute, which is based in Budapest and Washington.
00:00:41 He's also editor-at-large of the National Review, and he's written for numerous international publications.
00:00:50 He was also an advisor to Margaret Thatcher.
00:00:53 Thank you so much for joining us, John.
00:00:55 thank you um john we don't hear in the press here actually very much about how the covid thing is
00:01:07 being dealt with in central europe i mean what is it like there what what is it like if you
00:01:14 on a daily basis what is life like at the moment well of course it's different in different
00:01:20 countries but in general central Europe has done pretty well really from the start of the emergency
00:01:27 by that I mean the Czech Republic, Poland, Hungary and Slovakia but also Slovenia
00:01:38 and Croatia and others. The death rates have been quite low. Partly that's because the
00:01:46 the governments acted very quickly at the beginning of the emergency,
00:01:50 particularly on restricting entry into particularly Hungary.
00:01:56 And recently, although most of the regulations have been relaxed,
00:02:05 for example, the shops are open, restaurants are now open.
00:02:09 I think cinemas and theatres are opening next week.
00:02:12 and people still are expected to wear masks in shops,
00:02:18 but otherwise, as I say, things are fairly relaxed.
00:02:21 But that doesn't apply to restrictions of exit and entry.
00:02:25 They've tightened up.
00:02:27 And most people think that that's been a success.
00:02:32 And, of course, we all know there might be a second surge,
00:02:38 a second wave of infections and presumably, therefore, deaths.
00:02:42 But for the moment, at least, Central Europe seems to have done a good job and, of course, far better, unfortunately, from your standpoint, from Western Europe, particularly better than Italy, better than France, better than Britain.
00:03:00 Not, I think, better than Germany or Austria, which have got very similar performances.
00:03:05 And I think the Hungarians modelled their actions on Austria.
00:03:10 in britain now basically the coverage is now pretty much dominated by the economic results
00:03:19 of all this is and basically there is a sense you know on one hand of we're facing almost oblivion
00:03:27 and on the other hand people saying oh no wait a minute you know this is this will be fine we'll
00:03:32 have a v-shaped recovery is it in your in in hungary is there that kind of discussion going on
00:03:38 about the economic toll that's been taken yes and i think it's fair to say that the government has
00:03:46 been straightforward about saying that there's going to be a recession following the lockdown
00:03:53 when the lockdown ends and we start the economic recovery um i would be somewhat optimistic
00:04:01 actually because there are signs during there have been signs during the lockdown um of quite
00:04:07 interesting entrepreneurial activity, particularly in Budapest.
00:04:12 I mean, for example, the restaurants all had to close
00:04:15 and some of them just closed down and didn't do any business
00:04:19 except people selling pizzas and low-rent restaurants.
00:04:26 But they had very successful food delivery businesses
00:04:32 and the rest of the restaurant sector saw the success of these
00:04:38 and it expanded dramatically.
00:04:41 The restaurants returned after about two weeks of lockdown
00:04:44 and you could do takeout and carryout and get the food delivered.
00:04:51 And all over the city, when there was very little other traffic,
00:04:54 you would see these young people on their bikes whizzing around.
00:04:57 They dominated the streets.
00:04:59 And I think that they, I was talking to the manager, well, the owner, actually, of one of the, one of these food delivery services.
00:05:09 And he said they had a certain amount of capital.
00:05:11 So what they'd done is they'd gone along to the restaurants, which they knew were in trouble and said, look, we're going to give you a decent loan here so you can keep going.
00:05:20 And I said at the end, he said to me at the end of it, I think we've now got fast friends, people who will stay with us.
00:05:27 and we have a second business or they have a second business when they reopen as they now
00:05:33 have done um they'll get customers back again but they'll also have a lot of customers who are going
00:05:38 to be order over the phone and then i think our business is going to expand now that's one business
00:05:44 but in general i think there's a feeling that the hungarians have reacted with a certain amount of
00:05:49 enterprise to the threat so there's some optimism um as you probably know before uh the uh before
00:05:57 the epidemic and before the lockdown, there was a fair amount of optimism about the economy here.
00:06:04 It had had three good years of growth, maybe more, maybe four actually, and it was looking forward
00:06:10 to that continuing. Now, of course, we can only guess, but as I say, there's a certain amount of
00:06:16 optimism. Yeah. John, would you count yourself as a kind of Covid skeptic? I mean, you know,
00:06:23 know, here people such as Peter Hitchens or Toby Young, their general view that this has been a
00:06:30 kind of quite catastrophic overreaction in terms of pandemics of the past. Would you go along with
00:06:37 that or not? Well, that's my disposition in a way, but I'm also very cautious because I don't think
00:06:46 we will know what the actual impact of the pandemic is really for another year um i mean
00:06:53 for example is there going to be a a second wave and indeed a third or a fourth um much of the
00:07:00 argument for the lockdown has been that there is inevitably going to be that but if there isn't one
00:07:06 um and if really the performance of the economy is badly hit by the lockdown um and people look
00:07:13 for example to sweden and say yes the swedish death rates were higher than most of the um
00:07:20 most of their neighbors in the in the baltic and in scandinavia but nonetheless their economy is
00:07:26 recovered better if that's what people think i think we will be justified in saying that lockdown
00:07:32 was too severe um wasn't properly thought through but as i say i'm a cautious skeptic i want to see
00:07:39 what happens in terms of second and third waves obviously we've we sort of had a bit of a well
00:07:46 would you call it a perfect storm i don't know but we've had the lockdown and then we've had over the
00:07:51 past six weeks here you know what what amounts to a kind of cultural onslaught that's been going on
00:07:58 uh ever since the ever since the death in america of george george floyd i i wonder what your view
00:08:05 on that is john when you're looking at it from hungary when you see this happening in britain
00:08:13 um how seriously do you take the you know statue toppling the the protests that we've seen how
00:08:21 seriously do you take it well i think i take it seriously both in the united states and here
00:08:28 And there's a good deal of interest in Hungary about this kind of the fiesta of anarchy that
00:08:37 is spreading in both countries. I have just written a piece actually for the Hungarian Review
00:08:46 comparing in some ways the Chinese Cultural Revolution of 66 with what's going on in both
00:08:54 countries and and of course there are a lot of comparisons i don't think i want to go into them
00:08:59 in detail but let's take one um the chinese cultural revolution was in fact caused by the
00:09:06 decision of mao to take on his enemies who were ganging up on him after the failure of the great
00:09:11 leap forward and use in a sense invite young people to rise up embrace revolutionary egalitarianism
00:09:21 destroy his enemies in the party and in the university, in the professions, which they did
00:09:30 in an uncontrolled and horrible way with murders, with beatings, with tortures really of professors,
00:09:41 doctors, anyone in a position of authority and quite a lot of people who are not in positions
00:09:46 of authority. And that was all in the sense that Mao had in mind that would re-establish
00:09:52 his authority. Well, it did. He defeated his enemies. And after a while, they got controlled
00:09:59 back of his own revolutionary student supporters. But of course, it was a temporary victory.
00:10:07 Maoism was in effect defeated after his death when the Gang of Fourth collapsed.
00:10:12 And then there was the complete reversal of Mao's policy with the arrival of Deng Xiaoping and his decision to, in a sense, take a capitalist road.
00:10:26 Now, if you look at what's happening in America and Britain, you see something, I think, similar.
00:10:33 What you have is a huge cultural clash between, on the one hand, the President's administration, the Trump administration, and its support in the country.
00:10:42 and you have the opposition which is widespread and which is both democratic on the one hand
00:10:49 and revolutionary on the other and the people in authority so to speak the democrats and
00:10:56 are turning a blind eye very often well turning a blind eye quite a lot to these the attacks on to
00:11:04 the burning of buildings the attacks on people uh in hoping that this is going in a sense to
00:11:10 help to bring about the defeat of Trump, which it may do, and the election of a democratic
00:11:18 president. Now, that may be at a very high cost and it may not succeed. I think in Britain,
00:11:26 a lot of people who were angry with the Boris Johnson Tory party and government over Brexit
00:11:35 have used this opportunity as well to encourage people to in a sense reject it i don't think we
00:11:43 can say that this is entirely this is really a struggle for racial justice um in america it's
00:11:50 damaged the minority and poor communities it's destroyed their small businesses the people
00:11:57 and now now what you have is a kind of attempt to purge anybody who's expressed um um i would say
00:12:06 well this express express what i would call colorblind anti-racism such people are now being
00:12:13 denounced as racists and not conservatives mainly mainly actually not conservatives mainly liberals
00:12:21 and the attempt to purge newspapers of people. Andrew Sullivan, for example, probably
00:12:30 the single best political writer in America today, has effectively been let go. Maybe he
00:12:37 voluntarily disappeared because he could see something coming, let go from New York Magazine.
00:12:42 That's an incredibly bad decision by New York Magazine, and it's a disservice to their readers.
00:12:48 So I think everywhere what you see is a tolerance of violence and of dogmatic extremism
00:12:58 by some of the authorities in order to defeat their political enemies. And I don't think
00:13:07 in the end those tactics will succeed in Britain. At the moment you can't say they may not succeed
00:13:14 in the united states trump looks as though he's in serious trouble do you what do you think of the
00:13:21 view uh john which uh i think you sort of touched on there but that essentially the nature of this
00:13:28 thing happening is is quite different in that it is almost an uprising by people who are irritated
00:13:37 at being disagreed with i you know you've had brexit in in britain you've got trump in america
00:13:44 And they still, they are out for revenge, basically, because, you know, all of this is happening not, OK, we're seeing it on the streets.
00:13:53 But what is most striking is the way that the institutions are just simply, you know, crumbling.
00:14:00 I mean, the way that they are, in fact, just giving in and sacking people or cancelling them.
00:14:05 Yes. I think one of the problems is in all of these revolutions, what you have is a statement
00:14:18 which people want to represent the society and future. It's a kind of demand that we all are
00:14:24 sent to a particular set of ideas. And the ideas in the United States, it's clearer and sharper
00:14:31 there than in britain the idea is there as follows um we are asked to say black lives matter
00:14:38 at without any qualification or without recognizing that black lives matter because
00:14:43 all lives matter well and as as a statement that america at present um america as we've known it
00:14:51 is a racial racially unjust society governed by white supremacist institutions now to say that
00:15:01 That society, the society described as fundamentally racist and white supremacist, that society twice elected Barack Obama as its president.
00:15:13 It is simply absurd. One could say in moral terms, it's a wicked lie to describe America in those terms.
00:15:21 Yet once you stand up and say black lives matter, not because you want to assert that wrong has been done to black people and it should be remedied, but because you want to transform society, to reverse the fundamental racial injustice and to reverse white supremacy.
00:15:45 Once you've signed on to that, then you've signed on to a whole set of other ideas.
00:15:50 And if you're a newspaper like the New York Times and somebody says, well, if we're a fundamentally racist society, why are we running articles by Republicans who are supporting this society?
00:16:06 We can't have that.
00:16:08 And senior members of the paper might stand up and say, look, traditionally, we in liberal journalism,
00:16:15 we've always insisted that all sides deserve to be heard, that we believe in genuine debate.
00:16:24 And if we don't include half of the country in that debate, it can hardly be called a debate, let alone genuine.
00:16:31 And when they say that, they're swept aside by angry, young, passionate, quote, idealists who have decided that any resistance, any qualification to the idea of this fundamental injustice is therefore unacceptable.
00:16:54 You are, if you express qualifications of that kind,
00:16:57 people say you're a racist.
00:16:59 And if you're a racist, we don't want to listen to you.
00:17:01 We're not going to, we regard you as being on the wrong side of a moral barrier.
00:17:05 Not someone expressing disagreement, but on the wrong side of a moral barrier.
00:17:09 And on that side are the lost.
00:17:14 They are finished.
00:17:15 We want nothing to do with them.
00:17:17 So that's the problem.
00:17:18 Once you, in a sense, elevate this idea, any idea, any one idea, to the central truth of politics,
00:17:27 then anyone who dissents ceases to be a decent, respectable person.
00:17:32 And once that happens, people resort, if they're resisting, others resort to violence against them.
00:17:40 And that's what we've seen.
00:17:41 Do you think, it seems to me that if Trump is re-elected, or if he is just just elected, just re-elected, you know, there is a possibility of real, real civil convulsion. Do you think that is overstating it?
00:18:02 Well, I think I should first say that I think it's a complete fantasy to think that if he is not elected, that Trump will try somehow to stay on.
00:18:11 Now, you hear sensible people in important positions in American society, in the university, in journalism and elsewhere, in politics, saying that this will happen.
00:18:21 I think that's absurd. And I don't believe there's the slightest prospect of it. And if it were to happen, he would simply be ignored.
00:18:31 If you give orders as president which are illegal and people ignore you, then you cease to be president in a more fundamental way than if you simply have not been re-elected.
00:18:44 So I don't believe that. Your point? Would there be problems if he is elected? Frankly, I doubt that.
00:18:51 I'll tell you why
00:18:52 the claim of rioters
00:18:56 the claim of protesters
00:18:57 the claim of people who can assemble
00:18:59 large numbers of people in the streets
00:19:02 whether it's for a riot
00:19:03 or whether it's for a peaceful protest
00:19:05 their claim is
00:19:06 this shows we have the support
00:19:09 of the people
00:19:10 if they lose an election
00:19:13 an election absolutely trumps
00:19:16 any number of demonstrations
00:19:18 I would say
00:19:19 we know that from 1968 when everybody thought that all of the left and the trade unions said
00:19:27 uh they represented the people the bourgeoisie responded with their own demonstration and in the
00:19:33 following election to goal one of landslide victory and the party that represented the
00:19:39 students most um faithfully that party got about four percent of the vote now you're painting a
00:19:46 somewhat different scenario i i know that um and of course it's a very close election you'll have
00:19:51 may have all kinds of allegations but my feeling is that in america there is a solid common sense
00:20:00 for most people and if joe biden loses i think he will say to his supporters you may be upset you
00:20:07 may be angry but we'll win next time i may be wrong about that um he looks at times to me a
00:20:13 bit too much like Kerensky in 1970, a man who might be swept away by his own supporters and by
00:20:22 more ruthless operators on his own side. But that speculation, I do believe that he wouldn't in fact
00:20:30 voluntarily, in a sense, try to get an election overturned by violence in the streets. I think
00:20:37 he'd be horrified by that yes do you think that you mentioned there about you know liberal people
00:20:45 being slightly perplexed bewildered by this new kind of what we could call it sort of
00:20:53 totalitarianism in a way cultural totalitarianism i think that's a term that melanie phillips used
00:21:01 it's almost like they have spawned and a more extreme version of themselves would you say or
00:21:06 not well i do think um liberal people are perplexed by this um generally speaking what
00:21:14 what happens on such occasions this would be my view um i think well i think it's also
00:21:20 dostoevsky's view if you read his marvelous novel the the the possessed um is that liberals
00:21:27 make concessions to revolutionaries which they think um are enough to keep the revolutionaries
00:21:34 satisfied and to keep society more or less stable they have good intentions um but then having having
00:21:41 said um the having in a sense assented to the principle of the revolutionaries they then find
00:21:48 no way in which they can stop moving in their direction and um i think for example if you say
00:21:56 black lives matter not because they do but because you're assenting to the that slogan as a
00:22:02 representation of a kind of a new revolutionary America. If you say that, well, if you're a
00:22:08 corporation CEO, if you're university president, whenever a new demand is made, you'll be told,
00:22:16 well, you said that, this isn't, we're implementing it here. Are you a hypocrite? Are you a traitor?
00:22:24 And I think that again and again, people of decent feelings on the left find themselves
00:22:32 dragged along in one of these terrible epidemics of revolution. And my own feeling is that
00:22:45 this will not happen, it won't happen this time. But let me give you another slogan, or rather
00:22:52 another idea um the idea that justice in a multi-racial society is represented by the idea
00:23:02 of proportionality if you have 50 whites uh 25 blacks 25 hispanics all institutions should
00:23:13 somehow um be include that breakdown and then you get people saying well that's not true for
00:23:20 parliament no and that's not the representation there well of course um when you vote for for
00:23:29 in an election um you you can never get from a free vote of um in 650 constituencies you never
00:23:38 get a free vote people electing an exact cross-section representative of the whole society
00:23:45 so increasingly people think that um something is unjust if you don't have um an absolutely
00:23:53 um as i say representative cross-section in any institution might be the bbc for example um
00:24:01 which um unless the representation um has an under-representation of the majority then they
00:24:09 don't mind they don't think that's a problem just as they don't really mind about white boys at
00:24:15 school white working class boys at school they don't worry about the fact that all of the
00:24:21 institutions that are designed to produce a more representative um britain never seem to be worried
00:24:28 about social class that's never a big factor compared to ethnic and gender considerations
00:24:36 now i think all of these considerations are worth thinking about and worth doing something about but
00:24:42 you can't accept a proportionality um ethnic and gender proportionality as an overriding principle
00:24:51 otherwise you undercut and you discredit every institution in the world in the country because
00:24:57 none of them are ever going to be precisely proportionate it's uh well it's it's basically
00:25:03 equality of outcome isn't it as opposed to equality of opportunity in a way it says it
00:25:08 somehow you know that as you say the only way you can justify yourself is if you have this outcome
00:25:15 well that is right and it's fundamentally by the way uh literally a soviet concept i mean
00:25:22 obviously the soviet union was not a democracy we all know that and they knew it themselves
00:25:28 but they wanted to claim the mantle of democracy and so what they did was they tried to ensure
00:25:35 that in all the institutions they controlled uh of the society that there was um were necessary
00:25:42 ethnic proportionality gender proportionality now they didn't do a very good job of that but they
00:25:48 but they did in they did try to make this claim so that as um anthony daniels wrote um theodore
00:25:55 Dan Rumpel wrote in one of his books about this, one of his articles. In the Soviet Union,
00:26:03 all minorities dance. Wherever you went, they were always going to give you a kind of folkloric
00:26:12 display in order to show how varied and multi-ethnic the Soviet Union was.
00:26:19 and they had all kinds of institutions, paper institutions, in which every possible
00:26:32 group in society was represented. But of course, all those institutions were meaningless because
00:26:39 they simply followed the instructions of the Soviet Politburo essentially.
00:26:44 and so there were all of them really were nothing little better than ventriloquist dummies
00:26:51 and in a way that's the aim of a lot of people on the left they want to have any number of
00:26:59 institutions which include all aspects of society and the right proportions but they all want them
00:27:07 singing from the same hymn book so political diversity is the one diversity that that kind
00:27:13 of revolutionary theory is not interested in it is in fact resolutely opposed to it and that's one
00:27:21 of the factors that's one of the things we're now seeing well in in the riots in britain but
00:27:27 more powerfully in the united states uh you you mentioned there the institutions i mean
00:27:32 one of the striking things that's happened over the past what two months here since we've been
00:27:37 having these protests and you know statues coming down etc is a remarkable supplication on the part
00:27:47 of whether it's the church or the police or the national trust or whoever you like
00:27:53 this does give credibility really to the idea that there has been a long march through the
00:28:00 institutions and i i know you very kindly john wrote the forward to our recent book by mark
00:28:07 civil the long march but you've written about this for absolutely years i know and and do you think
00:28:15 that really that this this has some bearing on what we're seeing now that in fact you've got an
00:28:21 archbishop of canterbury for example who talks about going through the statues in canterbury
00:28:26 Cathedral and maybe revising them. Is this sort of, people are quite bewildered by this actually,
00:28:33 but I think in a way we're not so surprised, are we?
00:28:39 Well, I think that all of the Christian clergy are subject to loss of faith. Now the loss of faith,
00:28:51 if you're a victorian poet philosopher was a profound wrenching experience which changed your
00:28:59 life utterly and often rendered you wretched and unhappy or sometimes of course giving you more
00:29:06 a feeling of greater power as you approached the world with new completely new religious eyes
00:29:12 but that's not the way faith is lost it seems to me in the modern world it gradually
00:29:19 is it suffers a gradual erosion and is replaced by a semi-faith or some other religion some cases
00:29:29 some other religion entirely but in the case of christianity it's replaced by um what i'd call
00:29:36 a post-christian humanism um humanitarianism rather um now obviously we all have human we all
00:29:44 want ourselves and others to have humanitarian feelings but the difference between a post
00:29:49 christian humanitarianism and between christianity and real christian realism is that the christian
00:29:57 if he was pays attention to what his faith has taught realizes that you can't eliminate evil in
00:30:04 life and consequently when you're helping others or when you're trying to change society you've
00:30:10 got to be aware that some of your allies are not anxious to do what you're anxious to do but they
00:30:17 want power at all costs and the second element in that is um if you're you're aware of your own
00:30:25 weaknesses i think and and or should be and um and you're subject to um because you you're losing
00:30:35 your own faith and searching for something else um when you look at self-confident uh ideologies
00:30:43 that you think um are the children of your own religion you're very apt to overlook their faults
00:30:50 to go along with them to think somehow well back 40 50 years ago people said things like
00:30:58 communism is christianity in a hurry and um and we're seeing something similar in that now and
00:31:06 and ordinary christians and people who are not christians but regular um people who've got a
00:31:14 christian culture but no christian belief and i don't reflect much on these things they tend to
00:31:19 be swept along by a kind of sentimentalism um of goodness which which doesn't reflect reality
00:31:27 It doesn't phase up to the reality that some of the political movements are not
00:31:35 intent on bettering humanity, but intent on seizing power and imposing a false
00:31:42 virtue on people, which is what the Soviet Union was like.
00:31:49 On this subject of a long march of the left to the institutions, you coined a phrase a while ago,
00:31:56 john the lumpen intelligentsia i think it was and can you explain what you meant by that
00:32:03 well we all know of course that the intelligentsia in uh in society it tends to be the group of
00:32:11 people which causes the most trouble not necessarily a bad thing of course but but
00:32:17 they are they tend to be uh particularly um today but in in earlier societies they tend to be
00:32:25 university educated people who haven't got a position commensurate with what they think
00:32:32 graduates should have. And they're the people who are at the forefront of many of the radical
00:32:38 movements we see. And that was true in the past in other countries. When in Britain we used to look
00:32:44 at countries like Egypt which had large numbers of unemployable graduates and we could see the
00:32:49 damage they were causing to the society because they were unwilling to do the kind of jobs that
00:32:54 a country like egypt could offer them at that time and it's not just egypt but you could say that
00:32:59 about european countries too now um there's another group of people in society i think
00:33:06 who are very important and in a traditional society what you have you have some what might
00:33:12 be called the foreman class, the junior manager, the policeman, the social worker, the people who
00:33:23 represent the established ideas of common sense in dealing with the rest of society and who
00:33:31 respect such things as respectability and and deplore such things as either semi-criminal
00:33:39 behavior or behavior which other people would regard, I mean drunkenness, mild forms of violence
00:33:48 which you might not worry about but nonetheless are dangerous. Now these people no longer represent
00:33:57 those kind of ideas in our society because they've been, we have what I call a lump of
00:34:04 intelligentsia which is to say that's the part of society that in a sense administers and transmits
00:34:12 the values of the leading figures in society to the mass of the population but in a form
00:34:20 that represents the latest ideas in university and colleges and then you see this all the time now
00:34:28 where local government and where the cops for example are more intent on chasing down somebody
00:34:39 who is tweeting out something racist on the internet than they are concerned about
00:34:47 protecting people from burglary or mugging and so forth. But this is a standard thing and I think
00:34:54 that it's very interesting for a society when its form and class becomes a kind of lump of
00:35:00 intelligentsia. People who have been, who imbibed in an odd kind of form the latest radical ideas
00:35:09 and now impose them on the rest of society in a way that the rest of society can't quite
00:35:16 understand why are why are the police behaving in this way why are they now
00:35:24 somebody call them the um the police with the phrase uh oh yes the paramilitary wing of the
00:35:31 guardian and um and i think that that's that expresses something um which is real
00:35:39 also i would say possibly teachers as well in a big way you know teachers primary school
00:35:44 Yeah, well that's right. And of course when you actually talk to people in those positions,
00:35:51 junior teachers and so on, their actual grasp of the ideas which they passionately believe in
00:35:58 and want to impose on their pupils is pretty thin. I mean, we're not talking about people
00:36:05 who are going to be professors of ethics, we're talking about people who've got a very vague set
00:36:09 vague set of notions which have been hammered out over 20 years in sociology and cultural studies
00:36:15 departments and increasingly imposed incidentally on the hard sciences and and um and the economics
00:36:22 and elsewhere these ideas um you know the idea that um only whites can be racist for example
00:36:29 or that racism is defined as something which somebody perceives as racist those um those
00:36:37 ideas um are not the ideas that ordinary people come up with in a general way they're ideas which
00:36:46 as you know i imbibed as clever brilliant new insights but imbibed in a very diluted and
00:36:55 half understood way so that as i say when you have to have to grapple with these ideas in the
00:37:01 talking to people then they are very much skin deep and uh and yet of course they're imposed
00:37:10 on others in a and we see that particularly you know in such matters as the new gender uh
00:37:18 gender uh fluid gender concepts john i mentioned at the beginning of the program that uh you had
00:37:26 had been uh you knew um margaret thatcher well and you were an advisor to margaret thatcher
00:37:32 her battles for largely economic ones really um and i wondered you know whether you would just
00:37:40 uh ruminate a bit do you what do you think her reaction would have been to the cultural crisis
00:37:46 that is sort of taking place now in britain in america i would because i've been and i know a lot
00:37:54 people have very disappointed in the lack of voices that coming from the government what
00:38:01 what do you think her reaction would be um it's always it's always a slightly illegitimate enterprise
00:38:10 to predict what someone who's no longer with us would react to some such situation um and
00:38:16 particularly a new situation like this but i think we can get some clues if you remember
00:38:23 the most difficult year of her premiership was probably 1981 when you had demonstrations against
00:38:30 her she was more unpopular than any other prime minister had been in history she had to couple
00:38:37 she had to tackle the fact that inflation was still rising was resistant to her policies and
00:38:44 and there were demonstrations throughout the country in liverpool and and from all the way
00:38:49 from Liverpool down to Brixton. Now, what did she do? Well, she didn't launch a paramilitary response
00:38:57 to them. She was very cautious and sensible. She essentially backed the police in resisting
00:39:07 riots. She appointed a minister named Michael Haseltine, actually, to look seriously at what
00:39:17 might be some of the social causes of this in rebuilding liverpool and launching the dockland
00:39:23 scheme and so on and making changes in society to make things better and she did that subsequently
00:39:30 in the middle eight middle 70s sorry middle 80s with her third manifesto um but and and so on but
00:39:39 she in the house of commons at prime minister's question time in her interviews in the television
00:39:45 she resolutely refused to say that the rioters had any justification
00:39:51 for what they were doing. And she set her face like flint against that,
00:39:58 against saying that these riots are justified. She pointed out that the majority of people who'd
00:40:04 been arrested for the rioting were not unemployed, so unemployment wasn't the explanation for them.
00:40:10 and many of them were in middle class occupations just as today many of the people inciting and
00:40:16 carrying out riots in both america and britain are in fact um middle class and upper middle class
00:40:24 white people far more than they are poor and minority poor minority black people indeed
00:40:29 they are the principal victims so i think the very first thing you have to do is to say
00:40:35 that you're going to tackle what are perhaps practical reasons for the riots, practical
00:40:41 problems that require reform. But you've got to be clear that you do not accept these things
00:40:50 could possibly be an argument for riot, for disorder, for anti-democratic action. And I think
00:41:02 that the role of a political leader politically is very often they have power to do things but
00:41:12 sometimes the most important power they have is the power of speech, the power of rhetoric, the
00:41:18 power of defending the legitimacy of the society, the legitimacy of political authority. I think
00:41:27 that that is something that has really been forgotten by an entire generation including
00:41:33 conservatives unfortunately and i think it has to be rediscovered um in both america and britain
00:41:40 so some degree it's been rediscovered by trump but on the other hand that's offset by so many of
00:41:48 trump's other blunders that it's very hard to make him at the cake you know say that he's a good
00:41:55 example of leadership in society and he in some ways he is but in some ways he
00:42:01 undercuts himself I think this is a point made actually during the recent
00:42:06 protests and civil disorder that President Macron just was quite clear
00:42:12 and said this is French history for better or worse it is not being changed
00:42:18 and that's all people really wanted to hear John here they just didn't hear it
00:42:23 you know that that is right and and i also think that um you're going to have people uh on your
00:42:30 side the side of order so to speak who are bad guys i mean i'm thinking here uh you know neofascists
00:42:37 and so on and i think it's important to distance yourself but i think it's important that you don't
00:42:44 actually treat people who are mistakenly and sometimes viciously coming to the defense of
00:42:51 order you can't treat them worse than the people who are creating disorder in the first place
00:42:57 so i think i i would have reacted somewhat differently with those ex-servicemen and others
00:43:03 who came to protect churchill's statue i don't think i would have treated them from the word go
00:43:09 if they if they embarked on violence yes you have to have to defeat them and you have to control
00:43:15 them but i think the first instance you say i understand why you're doing this um you know
00:43:21 we're going to arrange for you to march down here salute the statue and march off we're not going
00:43:26 to have a row between you and others i mean um i think that's important and i think that um
00:43:31 sometimes the authorities want to demonstrate too strongly that they have no sympathy for the
00:43:37 extremists of the right i think that in those circumstances what we've got to do is to make
00:43:41 planar disagreement with them but at the same time say as long as you as long as you um
00:43:49 express your opinions in in a non-violent and respectable and respectful way we let you do so
00:43:56 but then we want you to get on the bus and go home and we don't want lots of fights in the streets
00:44:03 well john thank you very very much for joining us uh we've had a few attempts in the past which
00:44:09 have not worked out anyway this because of a technological thing uh it has this time uh thank
00:44:14 you very much john for coming on the show and uh maybe talk to you again in a few months time uh
00:44:20 around the time maybe if the uh around the time of the american election that would be great
00:44:26 now i would like that very much but also i want to say the the book which you invited me to write
00:44:32 the introduction to um the long march is an absolutely wonderful book i'm not talking about
00:44:38 my introduction, but about the authors. A very careful, interesting historical account
00:44:47 and very sensible analytical dissection of how so many of our institutions came to be under the
00:44:57 control of people who have no passionate love of democracy and are trying to carry out a kind of
00:45:05 revolution um well in a sense revolution on the quiet in the shadows and try and by the tactic
00:45:14 of wearing us down boring us to death um rather than the tactic of in a sense um overthrowing
00:45:24 society violently though of course some of their pupils are doing attempting to do just that
00:45:30 that. Thank you very much. Thank you for riding the forward to it, John. Thank you. Okay.
00:45:37 Well, that's it. That's it for what you're saying is this week. We'll be back next week.
00:45:44 Please do subscribe, won't you, in the meantime. Thank you very much. Bye-bye.