New Culture Forum - April 20, 2020


Counterculture 1.09 Has the Feminist Civil War alienated women?

2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won Dave Rubin: Defending Free Speech - Covid-19 - Trump 2020 + His New Book: "Don't Burn This Book"

Episode Stats


Length

59 minutes

Words per minute

163.61

Word count

9,735

Sentence count

250


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Does the world need more feminists, like a fish needs a bicycle?
00:00:04 Hello and welcome. I'm Mark Sidwell, and this trigger warning is Counterculture,
00:00:10 the cultural discussion show that believes in discriminating against bad ideas and lazy thinking.
00:00:16 Today we're talking about feminism and the future of the feminine.
00:00:20 Feminist ideas hold sway in the mainstream media, in the policies of blue-chip companies,
00:00:35 and in the minds of a rump of activists. But for the vast majority of women today, they
00:00:40 don't identify as feminists. What explains the disconnect? And is there any way to improve
00:00:47 the situation. Well, joining me to discuss this today and stop any more mansplaining,
00:00:53 we've got a fantastically talented panel of women. We've got the novelist Lionel Shriver,
00:00:58 we have the journalist Ella Whelan, who's also the author of What Women Want, we have
00:01:03 the conservative commentator Emily Carver, and we have Claire Fox, Director of the Institute
00:01:08 of Ideas and, until recently, a Brexit Party MEP. Thank you all very much for joining me.
00:01:16 Now, I'm going to start by putting an idea on the table, and I want anyone to jump in and tell me what's wrong or what's right with this.
00:01:25 Women today are in denial.
00:01:28 They have, on paper, legal equity, but they are in fact living in a system designed by men and for men
00:01:35 that oppresses them in all sorts of ways, that imposes damaging stereotypes,
00:01:40 exposes them to the possibility of sexual assault
00:01:43 and holds them back in their careers
00:01:45 and sees them even paid less for the same work.
00:01:49 And the only answer to this ramification of patriarchal oppression
00:01:53 is more feminism.
00:01:57 Does everyone agree with that?
00:01:59 Any problems there?
00:02:01 I think, as you say, there's always this tendency for feminists
00:02:05 to look at any issue and see it through the prism of sexual discrimination.
00:02:08 And that's the case when we look at the narratives around the gender pay gap.
00:02:12 It's the same when we look at parts of the Me Too movement and different areas of the feminist lobby.
00:02:19 And I think that the discussion tends to be sort of selected around an elite sort of metropolitan group of women that have very little to say about the ordinary lives of women and increasingly very little to say about motherhood.
00:02:33 We see with the gender pay gap that statistics are skewed in a way as to create these headlines that are deeply misleading.
00:02:40 So, for example, we're told that women stop working at this day or that they only start working at this day in the year.
00:02:46 And this is very misleading because at the moment there is no pay gap for women under the age of 40.
00:02:55 It's only after that point that the pay gap begins to widen.
00:02:59 and there's a lot of reasons for that but it seems that the most the biggest reason is that
00:03:04 this is actually a motherhood pay gap this is the moment that as we see in women's lives women take
00:03:10 a time out of the workplace and that of course has an impact on their you know their their earnings
00:03:15 and their lifelong earnings and there's conversations we can have about whether men
00:03:19 should be taking more time out to look after children and what decisions women should be
00:03:25 making but seeing everything through this prism of discrimination i think actually does women a
00:03:30 disservice who on the whole are excelling in the workplace and doing very well and ella that that
00:03:37 point about it being for a particular group of sort of maybe upper middle class women professional
00:03:41 women the feminism has become you know for a very particular group of society do you think that's
00:03:46 that's fair is there something there well um it's a difficult question because the fact is that
00:03:51 in the case of the law and in the case of social norms there are still differences between men and
00:03:59 women um there in terms of reproductive rights women do not have the same legal ability to take
00:04:05 control of their bodies um in terms of general social norms part of what you're talking about
00:04:09 with the motherhood pay gap is that chiefly it is still women who are expected to be the primary
00:04:13 caregivers and that's not to say that women are kind of blindly walking through uh the patriarchy
00:04:19 and a life filled with misogyny, not realising it.
00:04:23 But it's that the problem is with contemporary feminism,
00:04:27 make that particular distinction of the feminism that's come around
00:04:29 in the last sort of 20 years, fourth wave or whatever it's called these days.
00:04:34 Instead of looking at the actual concrete ways in which women are still not free,
00:04:40 there's a general sense of men are just mean to women
00:04:44 and women feel like they're not represented.
00:04:47 women are worried about how um they their identity is sort of realized in the world it's all this
00:04:54 kind of very fluffy stuff which lends itself to what i've called the kind of middle class
00:04:59 professional feminism which is that the most important thing you've got to fight for in terms
00:05:05 of women's rights is you know our ability to speak up in boardrooms or how many women are on
00:05:10 the footsie 500 or you know whether or not uh you can walk down the street without being wolf
00:05:15 whistled out and it's it's sort of nebulous and it often lends itself to a kind of patronizing
00:05:20 tone which says you know the word that you use women are in denial is really important because
00:05:26 that's a lot of the time what contemporary feminists argue that women just don't get that
00:05:32 they are being discriminated against in fact actually most women do know that they are being
00:05:36 discriminated against but they choose to act upon it or deal with it in different ways well my big
00:05:42 problem with fourth wave feminism and I have trouble keeping track is that its
00:05:49 marker seems to be self-pity and I don't feel sorry for myself and furthermore
00:05:58 there was a general feeling when I was younger that what we were moving toward
00:06:04 was a kind of blurring of the line between the sexes and increasingly we
00:06:11 were encouraged to look at each other just as people with with our differences and not even
00:06:17 saying that there were not some differences between the sexes on average but there was so
00:06:22 much and in this this is statistically true there is so much intersection between the qualities that
00:06:28 we call male and female that on an individual level you can almost trade places sometimes
00:06:36 I and I felt comfortable with that I felt comfortable with not being hung up on what
00:06:49 we are now calling gender and I'm you know for for most of my life I've called myself
00:06:56 a feminist because I don't know what else I don't know what other use word use okay
00:07:01 Because what does it mean? I mean, I grew up understanding that men and women were equal and should be treated equally in a legal sense and should be paid the same thing for the same jobs.
00:07:16 You know, kind of stopped there. And so since I don't know any other word that means that, then I continue to use it.
00:07:26 But it keeps being transformed so much that it's a dangerous word.
00:07:30 And that's, you know, you asked why do so many people, women, not identify as feminists.
00:07:37 That's because it has so much baggage.
00:07:42 It's one of those words that means many different things to different people.
00:07:46 And for a long time it seemed to indicate that you have no sense of humor
00:07:50 and that you're obsessed with your sex
00:07:57 and are on the lookout for offense
00:08:00 and you have a chip on your shoulder.
00:08:03 And I think a lot of women don't have a chip on their shoulder,
00:08:07 just want to get on with it.
00:08:09 Or if they do have a chip on their shoulder,
00:08:11 it doesn't have to do with being female,
00:08:12 but the fact that they hate their job or they're underpaid
00:08:16 or they're afraid of the coronavirus or whatever it is their big problem is.
00:08:21 It's not necessarily to do with what their sex is.
00:08:25 And I don't care that I was born a woman.
00:08:30 And I wish I'd hear this more often.
00:08:33 I do not give a shit.
00:08:36 It's true that I was born female.
00:08:39 I'm not in denial.
00:08:40 I'm okay with that.
00:08:41 I had to be one or the other.
00:08:43 I had to be assigned one or the other.
00:08:45 and I'm cool with that
00:08:48 because both sexes have their problems
00:08:50 and their crosses to bear
00:08:51 but it is not very interesting to me
00:08:54 and I also, as a writer, as a thinker, as a commentator
00:08:59 I do not want to have it imposed on me
00:09:02 that I have to do this kind of panel
00:09:04 into which I was dragged
00:09:06 but I don't want it necessarily to be my subject matter
00:09:11 Claire, does it still speak to you
00:09:14 or is it a dangerous word for you?
00:09:16 Well, a little bit like Lionel maybe,
00:09:20 I never know what word to use.
00:09:22 I struggle with it.
00:09:23 So I associate myself with the women's liberation movement
00:09:28 in as much as I believe in freedom
00:09:30 and I wanted women to be liberated.
00:09:32 And they definitely, at a period in the recent history
00:09:36 and even when I was growing up,
00:09:39 it was kind of the aftermath of this,
00:09:41 there was a sense in which there were different expectations of women and men
00:09:47 and there was assumed to be certain stereotypes of what women would do.
00:09:52 And it was, as we all know, and this was in the 70s,
00:09:57 that you would have ridiculous situations whereby people didn't see you necessarily as equal.
00:10:04 And I thought they should.
00:10:05 and I really rebelled when I was young against what were considered to be
00:10:10 feminine virtues and masculine virtues drove me mad that you know people would
00:10:16 say you know masculine was kind of rational you know cold and you know and
00:10:21 women were caring and soft and all that you know it was like you know that's not
00:10:25 a masculine they're not masculine they're strong and independent that's
00:10:29 not masculine that's human it's an aspiration we should all have men aren't
00:10:33 allowed to just have it themselves you know what i mean and i don't want to be the soft
00:10:36 you know we should all be you know striving for emotional honesty and to be able to express our
00:10:44 feelings this is not just a feminine it's a it is a natural desire of the human state to to be to
00:10:54 to feel and to express i agree so it wasn't that the that that's perfectly reasonable but it was
00:11:01 posited much more as a kind of set of vulnerabilities that required you to be protected
00:11:06 from things and that drove me mad you know it was kind of this sense that you needed a chaperone
00:11:12 now what's so ironic which we're going right back to exactly this is what is so ironic so the women's
00:11:17 liberation movement feminism might be all the rage in this sort of uh polite society and in you know
00:11:23 in in amongst uh you know everyone that matters in society but the reality is is that actually
00:11:30 the women's liberation bit has been totally betrayed by those people who call themselves
00:11:36 feminists today, because what we now have is a situation whereby contemporary feminism
00:11:41 argues that women need to be protected, that they have a set of values and virtues that
00:11:46 they would say are better than the masculine values, so they are demonising, as we speak,
00:11:52 independence, autonomy, rational, cool, analytical approaches. They try and say that the feminist
00:12:00 values or that the essentially women's values can be expressed by if we have more female MPs
00:12:07 we'll have consensus because we'll all get on better because we're all more empathetic which
00:12:11 seems to me to be a reinforcing of those stereotypes of the past but dressed up in a
00:12:15 kind of right-on language and then they're constantly saying that we are a threat largely
00:12:21 from men but that's why we have to be protected from dangerous ideas, dangerous words, dangerous
00:12:28 men escorted everywhere in a me too era so that seems to me to have been a completely
00:12:32 you know retrograde step regressive and so in that sense I hate feminism as it's become I think
00:12:41 it is a disaster that we posit our trying to gain support for ourselves as victims only just one
00:12:48 other thing to say though is it is not the case that everything is okay for women and I draw
00:12:54 attention to for example the not discussed enough grooming gangs because I stood as an MEP in the
00:13:02 northwest this is where a lot of these grooming gangs occurred and there's a report brought out
00:13:10 by Manchester City Council which as we speak exists but has had no publicity and we know I'm
00:13:16 not particularly wanting to discuss the fact that people are scared of this report in case they get
00:13:21 accused of racism because it's largely Pakistani men and or Muslim men. I'm not even trying
00:13:26 to get into that. There was the wholesale systematic sexual abuse of young women in
00:13:31 the North West, not just the North West, but in the North West. And that is because they
00:13:36 were young women. So one wouldn't want to underestimate the fact that there is also
00:13:40 something to be said about the fact that real sexual violence can be directed at women.
00:13:47 it's just that what drives me mad is when it's relativised in a me too era where we're not
00:13:53 allowed to discuss that because it doesn't fit into a certain narrative but we're to constantly
00:13:58 assume that every time a man pays a woman a compliment or touches them uh i mean i'm
00:14:05 frightening the period of coronavirus might get done you know somebody kind of goes are you all
00:14:09 right dear or something in a term of affection this is enough to get you done over right and
00:14:14 if you're a man and I think that that makes women into kind of pathetic victims of aggression but I
00:14:21 don't want to suggest there's never any aggression around because there is such a thing as sexual
00:14:24 violence. I think that's definitely why people are so sick of the current feminist movement because
00:14:28 as you say feminists seem to be ignoring the actual horrors that are going on in our country
00:14:33 because it doesn't appeal to them or they tend to be sort of left-wing liberal and find it hard to
00:14:38 discuss issues that involve culture or issues that involve race and I think it's really doing a
00:14:43 disservice to all those young women as you say who've been who've been abused for such a long
00:14:47 time that we've just chosen to ignore that and the feminist movement has focused on as you say
00:14:52 the touch of a knee um you know an awkward interaction at a bar instead of looking at
00:14:58 ways that we can really change women's lives and it's really disappointing and as you say as well
00:15:04 the freedom element i mean the me too movement has sort of sidelined freedom um they put as you
00:15:10 say, the protection of women above freedom. And I think that to have freedom, you have
00:15:16 to put, as a woman, you have to be able to put yourself at risk. You have to be able
00:15:20 to put yourself at risk of being sexually assaulted because that is your freedom. And
00:15:24 I would prioritise that over the fear of being discriminated against or, God forbid, abused.
00:15:33 Sure. And that's very reasonable. But I mean, on the Me Too question, what does that mean
00:15:37 practically because clearly Harvey Weinstein was a rapist we now we now know that in court
00:15:42 these were real cases of abuse there's something to be said for pushing back what what's the the
00:15:48 liberal way to deal with that that sort of problem when it occurs to to rely on women to to stand up
00:15:55 for themselves or no I mean first of all there's some things that are a matter of law Harvey
00:16:00 Weinstein is one of those cases but because Harvey Weinstein is a rapist doesn't mean that
00:16:05 every sexual harassment case is a Harvey Weinstein case.
00:16:09 It's also the case that in a period of...
00:16:14 If you assess people as being autonomous and self-determining and free,
00:16:18 then women can and should be able to negotiate how they relate to men.
00:16:24 And I do mean that there are ways and strategies that one deploys,
00:16:29 whether it's making it known to everyone in a workplace
00:16:32 that somebody's a, you know, dirty old man and leering and all the rest of it
00:16:37 and humiliating them and or, you know, giving them a kick or any of these things.
00:16:42 I mean, there's a range of ways that one has deployed over the years, let's say.
00:16:46 They're not the first women now.
00:16:47 And I don't mean to make light of what can be a really annoying, unpleasant series of things.
00:16:55 And also those men who assume that because you're a woman,
00:16:59 you know, that they can take advantage of you if they're your boss.
00:17:01 I mean, you know, they really deserve a metaphorical kick in the best of terms.
00:17:06 But the point is we've lost all sense of distinction.
00:17:08 And that would be where I, all I want to say is I want to be able to have these conversations.
00:17:12 I want to be able to say which bit of this is sexual harassment, which bit is actually flirtatious or awkward behaviour, you know, all of these things.
00:17:21 I was kind of quoting in a speech I gave the other day where, you know, one MP was saying, you know, no, actually it was a female police officer was saying, well, you know,
00:17:31 We should be able to intervene if a woman says that somebody is following them out of a shop
00:17:36 and is going to give them unwanted advances.
00:17:40 That could be seen as a misogynist hate crime.
00:17:43 And I said, well, how do you know if it's unwanted?
00:17:44 I mean, how are you ever going to chat anyone up at this rate?
00:17:47 And I wasn't trying to be glib about it.
00:17:50 What I'm saying is, but anyway, even to have that conversation,
00:17:53 and this is where we go back to freedom again,
00:17:55 is now to be a betrayer of the sisterhood.
00:17:58 you know you cannot have complicated conversations about me too look at the way that even the great
00:18:06 margaret atwood the feminist icon was called a feminist a what was it the wrong feminist or
00:18:14 yeah and so on absolutely and she actually said my goodness there's a kind of i'm an apostate you
00:18:20 know i'm a traitor and you look at the way that women are treated who've tried you know catherine
00:18:26 to nerve the French feminists. All of these people
00:18:28 who sort of said, look, is there a danger
00:18:31 that we're actually undermining
00:18:33 women's agency in negotiating
00:18:34 sexual relations here?
00:18:36 And they were accused of having, you know,
00:18:39 being
00:18:40 lobotomised, you know, internal misogyny,
00:18:42 all of these things. So
00:18:44 the biggest failure of feminism
00:18:46 at the moment is that it
00:18:48 essentialises feminism into a one
00:18:50 tick-box version of events.
00:18:52 You have to follow this script.
00:18:54 There's a suite of opinions. If you
00:18:56 don't agree with them you're a bad feminist that was the word they used well that's what that's
00:19:00 why it's part of this larger identify identity politics basket of let's mix our metaphors
00:19:08 basket of worms um and i think one of the things that has motivated the me too movement which is
00:19:16 under observed is that everybody needs to be a victim now in order to have standing in order to
00:19:24 have moral authority and me too has been primarily driven by white women white women who are
00:19:32 generally fairly prosperous and no one was feeling sorry for them right they really they they were
00:19:40 right just barely above white straight men on the victimhood totem pole and me too has vaulted them
00:19:48 to near the top and uh and it's my big objection to it and i think claire and i see eye to eye
00:19:57 is that it's motivating women to to be offended and because everyone needs their their their
00:20:08 story of of outrage everyone needs to have have been attacked or abused in some way and
00:20:15 And that's as opposed to being motivated to getting over in whatever way you might have
00:20:22 been mistreated and also, as you are advocating, employing your own agency and being able to
00:20:30 negotiate the workplace and the romantic landscape in a competent manner.
00:20:38 And that's where we really need to go back to making a distinction between what is legal
00:20:44 and illegal behavior, because if we're talking about what Weinstein did, he broke the law,
00:20:55 and there is a mechanism for dealing with that. And if all he did was put his hand on
00:21:01 your knee, then you can get rid of it.
00:21:04 It's part of what is going on here. It interests me that there's also tremendous
00:21:10 interest from from power bases you know you see politics big companies they're all getting in on
00:21:15 the act and the other side of the victim coin of course is that is that victims need as Claire
00:21:20 was saying someone from outside to support them and be their their big white knight so there's
00:21:24 become this strange alliance between power that's that's looking for a victim to to look after which
00:21:30 sort of justifies their they're doing more and more rather than leaving them to be autonomous
00:21:33 and that sort of created an unhealthy dynamic from two directions.
00:21:37 Well, for me, it genuinely boils down to a question of tactics almost
00:21:42 because I think that the biggest shame
00:21:45 and the biggest problem that's come out of the Me Too movement
00:21:48 is that I genuinely think you have a generation of young women,
00:21:52 perhaps certain sections of society, not all,
00:21:54 but certainly a significant number of young women
00:21:56 who are genuinely afraid,
00:21:57 genuinely have interpreted the unwanted attention at the bar
00:22:05 as something that is going to drastically change their mental health,
00:22:09 their ability to go out again.
00:22:12 And I resist the idea of being cynical about the,
00:22:15 too cynical about the expressions of the Me Too movement
00:22:18 because if we all sit down and dredge through our past,
00:22:21 I'm sure we can all find several, if not many, things
00:22:25 that men and other people have done to us
00:22:27 that if you wanted to fixate on it would make you quite upset um and it it's really it does
00:22:33 boil down to a question of tactics because there are still things that we need to change
00:22:36 there are still behaviors that i would like to see shifted and part of this is generational i
00:22:41 think like you know as this new you know people deride the woke generation there's a lot to
00:22:46 criticize in it but attitudes towards equality and rejection of sexism all that is changing and
00:22:52 that's a good thing but if you're going to breed essentially fear into young women's minds that
00:22:57 they have to attend to all areas of their life whether it's workplace or their interactions
00:23:03 with men or going out with a level of trepidation with there's life is a set of dangers to manage
00:23:09 rather than experiences that could go wrong but also most of the time are going to go quite well
00:23:14 and be exciting and you that's the most disempowering thing you can do and so that's
00:23:20 the it's sort of the the contradiction in contemporary feminism is that the more they
00:23:25 tell women to be afraid and speaking out about hashtag me too this is meant to be incredibly
00:23:29 empowering but actually you're just essentially creating a politics of fear and as claire was
00:23:36 saying the upshot of that is that you then have a wholesale implementation of protective measures
00:23:42 so the question of the of making misogyny a hate crime which was piloted in nottingham a number of
00:23:48 years ago and um i think they had like a handful of cases um it wasn't successful in terms of how
00:23:55 they would uh deem it to be but was also suggested this would be rolled out nationwide would amount
00:24:01 to quite literally policemen watching women on the street waiting for something to happen
00:24:08 and if you if you you know dress that up in feminist terms that's arguing that women have
00:24:14 to be watched by men and as lionel said when did that used to happen in victorian times and so in
00:24:21 terms we want the end point is you want to reach a situation in which women feel free to be as soft
00:24:27 or as hard as they like without any intervention from men or otherwise and you don't get that by
00:24:34 creating a generation of young women who are afraid of their shadow basically but i do think
00:24:39 that a big mistake that the feminist movement is making is to completely leave men out of the
00:24:44 conversation just demonize them and completely leave them out of the conversation if you look
00:24:49 at businesses for example in the private sector when you have panels on women's issues when you
00:24:54 have panels on whether it's me too or just women doing well at work or or whatever issue it is
00:24:59 there are never any men there on the panel this is quite rare that even you're a man sitting here
00:25:03 token. And to defend this event, there was supposed to be a male. Yes, to be fair, Ray
00:25:14 had an election on the way. This is an accident that it's all women. Men are our friends,
00:25:19 men are our brothers, our fathers, our whatever, our lovers. They need to be part of this
00:25:24 conversation. And I think demonising them in that way is poor. And I think also in the
00:25:29 feminist movement and in the me too movement there's definitely a lack of forgiveness and
00:25:34 giving people the benefit of the doubt we've had stories of young men who have got into awkward
00:25:39 situations have been pulled up across social media through the courts for making minor indiscretions
00:25:44 and we've seemed to have lost the ability to sort of just say sorry and to sort of um move on from
00:25:50 scenarios there was a young man in manchester i believe who had awkwardly approached a woman you
00:25:55 probably saw it in the news awkwardly approached a young woman and touched her on the arm and it
00:26:00 ended up going to the courts he ended up getting a criminal commission and it turned out that he'd
00:26:04 been looking um previously that evening about how to make friends online not even how to find a
00:26:10 girlfriend and it's just that sort of um lack of lack of forgiveness and lack of dealing with
00:26:16 things in a civil way um things don't have to be sort of i think we've definitely distorted
00:26:21 inter-personal relationships this way the only thing that i would be cautious of and i even i
00:26:28 was thinking when you were introducing this program i mean it might be that all of the places
00:26:33 that i give talks or whatever is a particular type of person but i i mean i think everybody
00:26:38 uh there's a there's very rare to meet people who don't sign up to being feminist and there's
00:26:42 nothing worse than the room full of male feminists yeah to drive you to distraction and you know
00:26:49 Sadiq Khan announced that he wants to bring in a crime against misogyny as a hate crime.
00:26:56 He started off just before International Women's saying, and he says it every time,
00:26:59 but, you know, I am a feminist.
00:27:01 I mean, it's the great boast, and you were making the point about corporates and so on and so forth.
00:27:06 And I've just spent some time in the European Parliament
00:27:10 where when they talk about diversity, it has to be in relation to men and women
00:27:15 because it's definitely all white, so they've got this kind of...
00:27:18 But it's the most diverse commission ever, and it was half women and half men.
00:27:22 But, you know, every man, obviously I'm exaggerating, but, you know, everyone's a feminist.
00:27:26 It's the thing that you sign up to.
00:27:28 So in certain circles, that's the case.
00:27:31 Just in terms of, but the awkwardness in relation to interpersonal relations is that we, I think that we are not all gaining from this.
00:27:40 Because what's happened is that there is a loss of confidence about how to relate to each other.
00:27:46 that is the cost that you pay for undermining agency in general.
00:27:50 And to follow on from what Alice said, it's very important to understand.
00:27:54 Oh, and also make men so paranoid.
00:27:57 Yeah, men are paranoid.
00:27:58 It's not worth it to make a pass or to express sexual interest in someone.
00:28:04 Which is why I think that we can see that people are making connections through apps.
00:28:11 I mean, they're still having sex, but it's much more transactional.
00:28:13 Oh, that's sex, though.
00:28:15 Men are having far less sex than they used to.
00:28:17 No, but the point I'm making is you're not able to chat people up,
00:28:20 so you do a transactional thing, which is,
00:28:22 I want this, are you round the corner?
00:28:23 That's the point I'm making, which is, you know, fine.
00:28:26 I'm not making a moral point.
00:28:27 I'm old. It's okay. I'm not. That's fine.
00:28:30 What I'm saying is that it's because of the murky world
00:28:35 of negotiating your way through.
00:28:37 But what I was going to say was that young women are scared.
00:28:40 That is one consistent feature whenever I talk.
00:28:44 They are scared that they are going to be victims.
00:28:49 And why I think that the problem of free speech is important
00:28:53 or inability to have these conversations is
00:28:55 if you are being socialised into a world at the age of 14 or 15
00:29:00 that tells you that if somebody wolf whistles or chats you up
00:29:05 or says something crass sexually,
00:29:08 that that's going to mean that you're about to be abducted,
00:29:11 raped and tortured in a dungeon and that you'll never get rid of it.
00:29:14 Or even that says, maybe you won't be abducted and raped and tortured,
00:29:20 but if you have been disrespected with the wrong words, then it's the same thing.
00:29:26 It's the same thing, and then you'll never get over it.
00:29:27 This whole idea that words can be vile.
00:29:30 Exactly.
00:29:30 And they then say, and there's proof that shows that if you are exposed to the wrong kind of ideas,
00:29:38 it might traumatise you, that this will destroy your life,
00:29:41 lead to long-term mental health problems
00:29:43 and alcoholism and drug addiction.
00:29:45 I mean, this is literally the literature.
00:29:47 But if you're 14 and then somebody wolf whistles you,
00:29:51 you think you're on a hiding to nothing, right?
00:29:53 So, understandably, you develop a misanthropic,
00:29:58 you know, you're kind of genuine,
00:29:59 and I don't think it's put on,
00:30:01 because I do think, well, that's not a good...
00:30:03 You know, we used to reassure young people
00:30:06 who were frightened, you know, of, you know, children,
00:30:09 and they would be frightened of the bogeyman behind them.
00:30:12 We would, as adults, say, look, honestly, it's OK.
00:30:15 We reassure you.
00:30:16 Now we say it's much worse than even your worst imagination
00:30:19 and give them nightmares.
00:30:20 And I think that softens up their capacity
00:30:23 to deal with the challenges of interrelationships
00:30:28 that sometimes can get messy.
00:30:29 I was thinking at the same time,
00:30:31 there's this extraordinary focus on kick-ass heroines
00:30:33 and how you have to tell every girl in every story
00:30:36 that she's fantastic and she can be a superhero
00:30:38 who can kick men's heads off and beat them up
00:30:41 if they try and rape and kidnap her.
00:30:43 I mean, that's a sort of massive thing in the culture now.
00:30:45 Is that a help?
00:30:47 Is that needed to get over the scaredness?
00:30:49 Or is that just completely sidestepping the issue
00:30:51 while actually really women aren't feeling like that at all?
00:30:54 I'd actually like to see a bit more of that.
00:30:56 There's quite a lot of it around, surely.
00:30:59 Every film at the cinema.
00:31:00 Yeah, and you get discussions about what Disney characters should you be showing
00:31:06 your little girls to make her you know all this these new heroines who are kick-ass as you say
00:31:12 but actually the more general sense is and I've had this before where I've you know you make kind
00:31:17 of jokes saying um when I go out I you know wear steel toe caps and longs gonna mess with me and
00:31:23 you get told that by promoting that idea of women being those qualities that were perhaps previously
00:31:31 attributed to masculinity um that that's victim blaming that if you and I often hear this that
00:31:37 if you say well it's a woman's job in an interaction messy interaction or negative
00:31:42 interaction with a man who's behaving badly that it's the woman's job to stand up for herself and
00:31:46 deal with that um we're talking about non-criminal things here uh then you're you're victim blaming
00:31:51 you're saying that this you know and time and time again I get women saying to me why should
00:31:55 i have to deal with this um it's not it's not my job to be the kick-ass feminist and i'm afraid it
00:32:01 is because how else does the world change it's the same as you know there's this i think more
00:32:06 often than not actually um contemporary feminism is arguing that women don't have to be go-getters
00:32:13 don't have to be brave and bold and uh you know tough in their exterior but actually that we
00:32:20 should be mentioned the feminine and the concept of femininity and softness and we should be
00:32:25 prioritizing that so just to take an example you know the whole thing of a uh the way women
00:32:31 interact in the board in in workplaces in boardrooms there are like apps now about teaching
00:32:36 women how to um get their voices heard because the assumption is that women are naturally
00:32:42 quiet mouses who need to have this app to teach them how to lean in you know this whole
00:32:48 the Charles Hamburg concept, which is just completely alien to me
00:32:54 and is alien to anyone I've ever met.
00:32:56 I can tell you, Ella, you don't need an app.
00:33:00 I think there is a place for that sort of thing, though,
00:33:02 because I do believe that there are some women who do find it hard to raise their voice
00:33:06 if they are in maybe an industry that is dominated by men.
00:33:10 Well, you know, they're boys who don't know how to raise their voice.
00:33:13 It doesn't have to be jaded necessarily, no, I agree with you on that,
00:33:16 But I think that in male-dominated industries, I think there can be a...
00:33:20 Yeah, but isn't that the point?
00:33:24 But that is part of what the women's liberation movement
00:33:28 and what feminism had an aspiration to be,
00:33:30 which is you would walk in as a woman into a male-dominated situation
00:33:34 and you would say, and that was the struggle,
00:33:37 I'm equal, don't treat me as inferior.
00:33:40 Now, the difficulty is if you then start, A, shouting at all the men
00:33:44 saying you've got to let this poor woman speak
00:33:46 or be sending her off on a course in assertiveness training
00:33:49 or give her an app.
00:33:51 The whole thing is not equal
00:33:52 because you're then treating them differently.
00:33:54 But there's a woman seeking out that app for herself, right?
00:33:56 It wasn't done by the corporation themselves.
00:33:59 No, but there is an assumption.
00:34:02 There is an assumption.
00:34:03 All I'm saying is that is the fight.
00:34:05 That is the struggle, if you want.
00:34:06 And I think that, of course, any woman, any of us,
00:34:11 and maybe at a certain age, you can say,
00:34:14 you know we've all been treated you know i've walked in on situations um where you know four
00:34:20 or five men are standing around and i've maybe been on a panel with them where they've just
00:34:23 completely ignored me i mean i might as well not been there and this is like now not you know and
00:34:29 they actually treat you you know it's like sort of like some and it by the way it's it's not all
00:34:33 because you're a woman i mean it's also you're not in the club you're not in that you know they
00:34:37 don't know who you are you're an outsider but as a woman and you know it's infuriating but the way
00:34:43 that i think that we want to encourage young people to deal with that is then to go on that
00:34:47 panel and be absolutely twice as good as them and humiliate them and show them up right and i can
00:34:53 assure you afterwards they never forget that who you are or anything else but you have to learn to
00:34:57 do that of course you know when you're 16 it's hard when you're 20 it's hard but that was the
00:35:02 very aspiration of in a way the feminist movement you know what i mean we are equal don't you dare
00:35:10 And it was an equality that you took for yourself.
00:35:13 Exactly.
00:35:13 You do not sit around waiting to be given.
00:35:16 And you were encouraged by other women to make that intervention.
00:35:20 And I'm concerned that at the moment it's the men that are seen to be the problem.
00:35:25 Young women are then over-accommodated to help them out as though they kind of can't.
00:35:28 What about the women who don't want that?
00:35:30 What about the women who don't want to be on the panel,
00:35:33 who don't want to be a high-flying careerist?
00:35:35 Fine, fine. I've got no problem.
00:35:37 No problem with that.
00:35:38 But I think the thing that Claire mentioned was, you know, we talk about the sisterhood today and it gets thrown around and actually more often than what it means, a club of professional feminists who are often who say this is the right way to be a feminist.
00:35:52 And if you don't support the sisterhood, then you're at the club.
00:35:54 But actually at the start of the women's liberation movement, it actually meant something very serious in terms of different S words, solidarity, where it was like you had an, there was an onus on women to support other women who were coming up against these battles.
00:36:10 And it was a genuine political fight against genuine sexism.
00:36:15 But I think the problem today is that we, you know, it's like going back to the kind of the key feminist phrase of the 60s, the personal is political.
00:36:27 You have this sense now in which personalities, whether you're a quiet person, whether you're a ballsy person, gets mixed up with the politics.
00:36:35 and the politics is should be for women's liberation that a woman should be free to be
00:36:40 whatever kind of woman she wants to be and more often than not feminine contemporary feminism
00:36:45 today says there is a correct way not only to be a feminist but a correct way to be a woman and
00:36:50 that means that if that for one example um that i am fixated on i'm doing in the middle of doing a
00:36:57 documentary for bbc radio 4 on feminism and one of the key examples that we're looking at is
00:37:02 the case of the good boobs bad boobs argument which happened a number of years ago funny title
00:37:08 was very serious actually when there was the uh the campaign to ban page three um in newspapers
00:37:14 succeeded and uh there was this absolutely fantastically interesting uh interview with
00:37:21 harriet harman who was uh key in that campaign and she said the reason why we want to get rid
00:37:27 of glamour models in the sun and other tabloids is because it's not feminist it's not empowering
00:37:32 this is degrading for women and it's not news and we should ban it and they won banning it
00:37:37 in the same interview she talked about how empowering it was to see kim kardashian celebrities
00:37:43 um good feminists that was the way she put it bearing their chest because this was empowering
00:37:50 and essentially the distinction there was that there was certain women who were able to own
00:37:54 their bodies and display them and be a good kind of feminist and then there were women who were
00:37:58 just fodder for male readers and male editors and the big elephant in the room there was that there
00:38:03 was a class distinction happening and i think that's the problem that particularly irks me
00:38:08 about contemporary feminism is that it's patronizing not just for all women but actually
00:38:12 particularly for the women who can't i always get that what about the women who can't do that
00:38:17 and they usually mean the mass of women out there who you know are so slavish in their
00:38:23 blindness to the patriarchy that they they can't achieve like me and my ceo position or you know
00:38:30 me and my uh high-flying uh career when i'm exactly not not the case go out in faces in
00:38:37 essex and you'll meet far more high achieving tough women than you would in the doors of the
00:38:42 bbc well i mean you talk about the sisterhood there and of course it's the opposite of that
00:38:46 now isn't it i mean we've talked about it a bit earlier as a riven by civil war and disagreements
00:38:50 about who's the right kind of feminist and the right kind of woman.
00:38:53 I mean, the trans issue has been extraordinary in the way
00:38:56 that that sort of un-personed people who are at the top of the feminist tree.
00:39:00 I mean, Germaine Greer is almost an un-person in certain circles now,
00:39:04 which is extraordinary.
00:39:05 The most fascinating and surprising thing about the trans debate
00:39:09 is that I have never called myself a feminist
00:39:12 and I've been critical of not just contemporary feminism
00:39:15 but feminist movements of the past and the whole personal political thing
00:39:18 and blah, blah, blah.
00:39:19 But on this debate, the trans issue, I found myself standing shoulder to shoulder with feminists who I would have disagreed on everything else, because the problem is not that that we shouldn't have discussions about trans or that it's not something to consider or that, you know, there are some people who argue that it's just the kind of genuinely transphobic.
00:39:42 But the issue at the moment is that women who have fought for women's liberation for years, Julie Bindle, Devane Greer, who's kind of high profile feminist figures, are now being told that they're not allowed to talk about women.
00:39:55 They're not allowed to use the word woman. It gets put an X through it. And they can't define for themselves what it means to be a woman.
00:40:03 And you have to pick a side in that battle and you have to pick the side of that's being silenced.
00:40:09 And in this case, that is feminists, feminists, and they're called TERFs, which is a terrible term and used as a kind of slanderous accusation.
00:40:19 But really, they are old school feminists who have a particular view, who have been told that despite their years of fighting for what they consider to be women's freedom, they're not allowed to talk about themselves as women any longer.
00:40:31 I mean, it's a difficult issue, that one. It causes huge ruptures online. Anyone else have views on it?
00:40:37 We've seen how it's played out so badly in the political sphere in our politics.
00:40:42 I mean, you've seen the Labour Party tear themselves apart over this.
00:40:46 I mean, you've had Dawn Butler saying, you know, biology doesn't exist.
00:40:51 Babies aren't born with a sex.
00:40:52 You've had, you know, Lisa Namdi getting in all sorts of difficulties
00:40:56 when it comes to lobby groups like Women's Place
00:41:00 who are just concerned with the issue of self-identification from what I can see
00:41:03 and concerned about the safety of women when it comes to refuges
00:41:07 or just the women's only places and i think that um this conversation is just so damaging for the
00:41:14 feminist movement and it's so damaging for their cause because we see such a such a conflict um
00:41:20 that doesn't need to be there if we just have sensible discussions around of course there's
00:41:24 transphobia but that doesn't mean that you should suddenly uh suddenly a woman isn't a woman that
00:41:29 biology suddenly doesn't matter so it's uh well like you are transphobic for that i mean you're
00:41:33 done. I mean, I think it is extraordinary.
00:41:37 Your life is over.
00:41:39 The 50th anniversary of the Women's Liberation Movement, only last week, was completely destroyed
00:41:45 by this civil war within the feminist movement in relation to trans and the deplatforming
00:41:52 of a feminist historian and all that subsequently went on. But the fact that it was the 50th
00:41:57 anniversary of the Women's Liberation Movement meant to be a celebration and turn into the
00:42:03 most acrimonious vicious you know and censorious atmosphere is is is telling of the moment but i
00:42:09 think that it's um it's a very peculiar situation that feminism has to now i'm going to say that
00:42:17 those old-time feminists also have to take some responsibility intellectually so because
00:42:21 what i think has happened is that if you think that feminism was happy to go along with the
00:42:28 worst aspects of identity politics i mean so many feminists will say you know as a woman right i
00:42:34 find that offensive or as a woman you know you know and and they would take upon themselves that
00:42:39 as a woman they were going to be able to uh um have the last word on issues and the whole lived
00:42:47 experience question all of these different trends and also very much emphasized that identity was
00:42:54 the trump card and that people should be able to assert their identity and define who they were and
00:43:00 some of these aspects then this awkwardness emerges which is that then what emerges is
00:43:07 the idea of self-identification that a biological male can simply declare
00:43:12 I identify as a woman I am a woman how dare you challenge my identity and everybody kind of goes
00:43:20 oh, now we've got a problem, right?
00:43:22 Because identity politics is suddenly kind of,
00:43:24 its potential for narcissism has suddenly emerged
00:43:28 in the most gross and grotesque way as against.
00:43:32 Not just a narcissism, but to the point where
00:43:35 we embrace subjective reality and say that's reality.
00:43:42 No, that's right.
00:43:43 And I think that's dangerous for the entire society.
00:43:46 No, that's right.
00:43:47 But all I'm saying is that was accepted as part of feminism.
00:43:52 In fact, it was championed by many feminists,
00:43:55 the subjective experience above all else,
00:43:58 that's what I'm saying, about identity politics.
00:44:01 And even the essentialising of women and so on
00:44:05 and their unique ways of looking at things
00:44:08 because they subjectively saw it that way.
00:44:10 So then what do you do when people subjectively turn up on your patch
00:44:13 and say, well, I subjectively am a woman?
00:44:15 and what are you going to do about it and you want to go well actually you're a man and and then and
00:44:20 then it's like so the whole thing is becoming very acrimonious but it's also a sorry sorry last bit
00:44:26 which is just the the the difficulty is you can't have this conversation and i think the fact that
00:44:33 feminism is now associated and liberation movements like the lgbtq plus movement is now
00:44:40 associated with censorship
00:44:42 closing down debate, not
00:44:44 allowing any of the discussion or nuance
00:44:46 to emerge about whether
00:44:48 transitioning
00:44:51 sexually is
00:44:52 what do we think about it, it's obviously
00:44:54 a peculiar thing, how has it become
00:44:56 no, you've got to go along with this
00:44:58 I'm afraid that feminism
00:45:00 sowed some of the seeds for that
00:45:02 but absolutely, as Alice says, now
00:45:04 I absolutely stand
00:45:06 by Linda Bellos, I mean
00:45:08 most of the feminists I stand by are going
00:45:10 oh my god who needs an ally like her we've been fighting with her for ages but i don't care you
00:45:14 know they are have put themselves on the line to fight for women's equality and women's liberation
00:45:19 over the years and they are now called bigots and that at the very least is utterly ridiculous and
00:45:25 i mean the important thing to mention about the women's liberation conference um and the history
00:45:29 of that is when it was first set up in the first meeting they had four aims um you know equality
00:45:35 of equality of opportunities and there was issues that they wanted free 24-hour child care they
00:45:41 wanted abortion on demand which today we understand is the decriminalization of abortion
00:45:46 things that actually haven't happened yet and are still their objectives and they spent the entire
00:45:51 time rowing about the fact that they'd removed selena todd from it and had spent ages tip-exing
00:45:55 her out of the programs and lo and behold the actual issues that women still want to have
00:46:01 answered don't get discussed and it's very right to say that actually there is there is a legacy
00:46:07 there because take for example something like women only uh short lists or women only you know
00:46:13 50 50 quotas and that kind of argument that feminists have been making for a very long time
00:46:16 and the the baseline of it is that because women are inherently different and like as i was saying
00:46:22 because they're more predilected to not being able to get the leg up to not being able to fight their
00:46:26 corner because they're quieter and softer and more oppressed we have to have this recognition
00:46:32 of me as a woman having this position on the board in terms of representation and so then
00:46:38 logic follows if you have a this different category trans women or whatever it is saying
00:46:45 actually we need ourselves represented then it all comes into conflict and you know the answer
00:46:50 for me is always we'll just get rid of any of these kind of get rid of the obsession with
00:46:53 representation and let people be people but it's these warring identity politics that has ended up
00:46:59 in this mess and the really important thing to say is the vast majority of women who are not
00:47:05 commentators who are not journalists who are not politicians who are not campaigners don't give a
00:47:09 crap i mean they really don't and and this passes them by and you know if you go out and stop a
00:47:16 woman in the street in any kind of city or area in perhaps other than london and say what is
00:47:23 your main uh political issue what do you identify as i bet my life saving small as they are that
00:47:29 they wouldn't say feminist and they wouldn't actually be that interested by the trans debate
00:47:33 other than saying what's all that going on over there so it's about that's why i wrote a book
00:47:38 about saying what women want because most of the time the discussion of what should be happening
00:47:42 for women what feminism needs to do for women bypasses the political desires of most women
00:47:47 yeah well that's fantastic we're nearly out of time so i just want to go around quickly and
00:47:52 you know on that what should feminism do what what do the vast majority of women need from it
00:47:58 that they're not getting now just just very quickly i mean ella if you want to i don't think
00:48:02 i think that the number one thing that we have to do as women who are interested in women's freedom
00:48:07 is to counter and argue against the contemporary feminist narrative of victimhood i think it's a
00:48:13 real uh barrier to women's freedom it's a barrier to arguing for very important things that we need
00:48:20 like the decriminalisation of abortion, which inherently needs a belief in women's agency,
00:48:25 a trust of women, a sense of women as autonomous individuals.
00:48:29 And I would like to see perhaps the issue of women's liberation, women's freedom,
00:48:34 put on the map politically more often.
00:48:37 I think there are questions of access to childcare that are very serious and relevant for women.
00:48:42 But you have to have the baseline as a politics that treats women like adults
00:48:47 and treats women like agents of their destiny.
00:48:50 and that means you have to have that's why the subtitle of the book that i wrote which no one
00:48:54 ever wants to read out because it makes people grimace is what do women want fun freedom and
00:48:59 an end to feminism lana um i definitely agree to the to the point that there is a
00:49:09 a continuing battle it should be uh restricted to matters of substance and um like child care
00:49:19 like the fact that women are constantly getting stuck with social care that's real that has to
00:49:27 do with what people have to do with their lives nobody other else is stepping up there are
00:49:31 institutional answers um it's an issue for government but otherwise stop banging on about
00:49:39 being women and what women are like and how women have had a hard time i'm just sick of it
00:49:47 Emily?
00:49:48 I mean, I would push back slightly on the conversation here.
00:49:52 I'd just say that I think that when you have statistics showing
00:49:56 that now one in four pregnancies are ending in abortion in England and Wales,
00:50:00 I think that the feminist movement needs to speak more about,
00:50:03 make the positive case for motherhood,
00:50:04 because I think a lot of women see the feminist movement
00:50:07 as seeing motherhood as a sort of obstacle, as a burden, something to overcome.
00:50:13 A form of slavery.
00:50:15 Yeah, and I think that we need to be talking about how motherhood can be one of the greatest privileges and joys of being a woman,
00:50:21 and that's something that only women can do, and it's something to celebrate.
00:50:24 So I think that the feminist movement needs to stop judging women for their choices and start celebrating their choices,
00:50:30 and not every woman wants to be a CEO, not every woman wants to be on the board of a top FTSE 100 company,
00:50:36 but a lot of women have very different choices, they make different choices, and we need to celebrate those.
00:50:41 That's great, thank you.
00:50:42 It is also true that those women who might choose to be mothers, of which there are millions
00:50:47 in the majority, would need to be married to a member of the FTSE 500 board in order
00:50:53 to pay for childcare.
00:50:55 Childcare is a big issue, yes.
00:50:57 But in all seriousness, it is therefore not resolved.
00:51:01 I mean, choices are held back by material problems, right?
00:51:05 And so, you know, I want to remove the barriers for women to be able to be equal in society
00:51:10 and make whatever choices they want, and there are some practical problems.
00:51:14 And I do think that there are issues around the kind of jobs that women do,
00:51:18 because it does drive me mad that we talk about the pay gap all the time,
00:51:21 but it is also the case that every care home in the country is staffed by women
00:51:27 trying to negotiate, earning some money to pay for the childcare,
00:51:30 to get in some extra money, and they are paid very poor wages,
00:51:34 and they are treated as unskilled workers, and so on and so forth.
00:51:39 I definitely agree with you that we don't value care
00:51:41 exactly, what I'm saying is
00:51:43 it's their jobs and what I'm saying is
00:51:45 they're not paid enough, I'm just making the point
00:51:47 that I would
00:51:49 not think that our job is yet
00:51:51 done, I don't think that equality exists
00:51:54 but huge steps forward
00:51:55 have been made in terms of attitudes and I am
00:51:57 not trying to overplay the victim card
00:51:59 it's just that I think there's things that one can fight for
00:52:01 the thing
00:52:03 that really was important that
00:52:05 was said earlier on by Lionel was
00:52:07 I want people to forget that they are women.
00:52:12 It is not the most significant feature of my life.
00:52:15 This is just the point.
00:52:16 I want each and every one of us to be respected for our views,
00:52:24 I mean, or disrespected for our views,
00:52:26 to be treated seriously as individuals.
00:52:30 This seems to me to be hugely important.
00:52:32 And I'm not trying to say that I would joylessly not walk around
00:52:36 making jokes about how incompetent men are of which that's often the case but you know and
00:52:41 there'll kind of be all the banter between the sexes i mean i'm not saying there's no differences
00:52:44 i get that but this is the least interesting thing because the truth of the matter is i just
00:52:49 was born a woman and i say that in absolute defiance of dawn butler and all the nonsense
00:52:55 about whether i was described it you know i was born a woman it's not an achievement i want to be
00:53:00 recognized for my achievements and so that's one important way forward that we have that as the
00:53:04 aspiration. And secondly, that feminism has now got to stop being associated with closing down
00:53:11 debate and discussion through playing the victim card. I mean, nobody will ever believe that
00:53:17 feminism has got anything to do with liberation if it becomes illiberal, censorious, and basically
00:53:24 doesn't allow anybody to be free. I mean, how is that a step forward? So at the moment, I'm of the
00:53:30 opinion that feminism is the problem and i can understand that and i actually think it has to be
00:53:37 confronted and dealt with even though i'll defend the old-style feminists against the
00:53:42 the trans activists i actually think feminism itself is probably redundant now
00:53:47 well we'll have to leave it there thank you to all my guests thank you so much for watching
00:53:53 we'll see you next time this has been counterculture
00:54:00 Bye.
00:54:30 .
00:55:00 .
00:55:30 .
00:56:00 .
00:56:30 .
00:57:00 .
00:57:30 .
00:58:00 .
00:58:30 .
00:59:00 Thank you.