New Culture Forum - April 20, 2020


Counterculture 1.10 What has covid19 revealed about British culture? How has the media reacted?

2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won Dave Rubin: Defending Free Speech - Covid-19 - Trump 2020 + His New Book: "Don't Burn This Book"

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

169.39

Word count

7,536

Sentence count

148


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittall now here we are in the third week of
00:00:13 the UK's version of a lockdown because of the corona crisis it's the perfect time maybe to
00:00:20 discuss what this actually shows about the state of our culture now what we can expect to happen
00:00:27 culturally in the future what will what will we have more of what will we have
00:00:32 less of also we'd like to discuss today how the media has treated the crisis and
00:00:38 in particular how it's treated people who have what you might say are
00:00:42 dissenting views now my guests today I'm very pleased to say are Daniel Johnson
00:00:48 Daniel was the founder and editor of Standpoint magazine he before that was
00:00:55 the leader writer for The Times and The Telegraph and is now the editor of the online magazine
00:01:00 The Article and the contributing editor to The Critic. Brendan O'Neill has been a former guest
00:01:08 on our show. Brendan, of course, is editor of Spiked Online. He is the host of an extremely
00:01:13 successful podcast and is well known to us for all his appearances on British television and
00:01:19 American and Australian television. And finally, Rafe Hadle-Mankou from the New Culture Forum,
00:01:25 who is a commentator and historian. Thank you very much for joining us today. I'd like to start
00:01:30 with you, if I may, Daniel. This is a very broad question, and please feel free to everybody to
00:01:37 chip in. But what do you think this crisis has told us about the general health of our culture?
00:01:44 I mean, if you like, in the public response and the way it's been handled.
00:01:49 What has it told you about the sort of state we're in?
00:01:54 Well, I'm often very critical of the state of our culture anyway.
00:02:02 And obviously what the pandemic has done is to shine a rather unforgiving light on the whole of our civilization.
00:02:12 and if we take the broadest possible view, looking at the whole West, not just at Britain,
00:02:19 we can see that we were unprepared for this kind of test. We've struggled, I think, to make sense
00:02:29 of it. We have found that many of the props, many of the pillars of our society and our culture
00:02:38 have been turned out to be rather shaky uh you know if we think for example of the response of
00:02:44 the churches um it hasn't been terribly impressive uh that's not entirely their fault the fact that
00:02:50 all the churches are closed by order of the government means that uh priests can't do their
00:02:56 normal job but even so uh i feel that we could have had much more inspiration and consolation
00:03:05 from our spiritual leaders. I think it's been the same with the arts and literature and the
00:03:13 academic world. The response has been, at best, rather shaky. There have been a few impressive
00:03:21 interventions, but in general, I don't think most of us have found very much comfort or
00:03:28 consolation from those quarters. The universities in particular, I think, have really struggled
00:03:34 to to keep going online in the way that you and a few others are doing and many
00:03:44 students feel very let down by the response of universities sorry if we
00:03:52 look at finally at the way that if you like the public sector that the
00:03:57 government and the civil service and so on have responded i mean i hesitate to be too critical
00:04:06 because i think it really has been an unprecedented uh crisis this and everyone has had to improvise
00:04:13 and i don't want to knock the the work that the nhs of course and uh the government more generally
00:04:21 has been doing i mean obviously millions literally millions of individuals are working very hard
00:04:27 and have been unbelievably brave and impressive.
00:04:30 I've been talking to a few of them,
00:04:32 people who are being forced to do things
00:04:34 they've never done before.
00:04:36 But clearly mistakes have been made
00:04:39 and we, the media,
00:04:43 have, I think, been rather weak
00:04:47 at asking the right questions
00:04:49 and eliciting the facts.
00:04:51 We could have done a lot better.
00:04:54 We are, I think, gradually improving,
00:04:56 but it's been a very steep learning curve.
00:04:59 Is that something that you would agree with, what Daniel said there?
00:05:02 Very much so, and I'd add to that in the case that I think that what we've seen now
00:05:07 is that Britain is a much more divided country in the sense of the fact
00:05:14 that we aren't really seeing the true face of Britain in the media.
00:05:18 When you look at, for example, the great army of volunteers
00:05:22 that we were told have been coming forward to lend their time which is extremely encouraging to see
00:05:28 they do tend to be of a certain type of person they are tend they are basically
00:05:33 from the same sort of people that I would see in the audience of Graham Norton or on Antiques
00:05:40 Roadshow they aren't reflective of the diverse country that we're often told that we are and I
00:05:46 wonder why when we're told that Britain is such a wonderful mosaic, why we're not seeing that
00:05:54 reflected so much in the public sphere at this time of crisis, particularly when we're now
00:06:02 getting all this feedback about how our diverse society, the more diverse elements are the ones
00:06:09 who are being adversely affected by coronavirus. So I think that's rather telling in the sense
00:06:13 the media isn't portraying the reality do you would you is that something you recognize brendan
00:06:19 would you go along with that um i i agree with much of what daniel has said i think
00:06:27 what the coronavirus has really shown is that we were both practically ill-prepared and morally
00:06:33 ill-prepared for something like this i think we were practically ill-prepared that can be seen in
00:06:37 the kind of sclerotic nature of the response and the slowness of the response i i wouldn't pin that
00:06:43 on Boris Johnson's government directly they haven't been in power for very long
00:06:48 I think the Boris bashing that we're seeing on the back of the virus is a bit cheap and cynical
00:06:53 and opportunistic and I don't like that at all but it absolutely raises questions about
00:06:59 the state and the bureaucracy and the civil service and the speed or lack of speed and
00:07:05 thoroughness with which they are able to respond to problems like this which many people knew was
00:07:11 coming we all knew that a pandemic was going to come at some point um so there's lots of questions
00:07:16 to be asked about the practical ill-preparedness i think partly that is down to um uh the kind of
00:07:23 hysterical culture we live under we're so often told today that we're told that so many problems
00:07:28 are actually catastrophes and are actually calamities you know climate change for example
00:07:34 or obesity or people's drinking habits we've developed this apocalyptic language to discuss
00:07:40 every single issue and i think that actually means that we take our eye off the ball you know we
00:07:44 basically cry instead of crying wolf we cry apocalypse everything is an apocalypse and then
00:07:49 when something comes along i don't think this is an apocalypse but i think it's a serious health
00:07:53 crisis and when something like this comes along we're not prepared because we've been staring so
00:07:58 many other phony calamities down the face for so long so i think the hysterical culture we currently
00:08:04 live under has a lot to answer for but the thing that worries me most is the moral ill preparedness
00:08:09 for this crisis. We struggle to give this crisis any meaning at all. There's no moral
00:08:18 direction, there's no sense in which, there's no mechanism really or ideas or outlook through
00:08:25 which people can make sense of it and that makes it more scary than it necessarily is.
00:08:30 I think when you live in a society that struggles to give meaning or which struggles to live
00:08:36 with uncertainty and to live with risk and which struggles being in everyday
00:08:41 lives then when something like this happens take on these kind of epic
00:08:46 terrifying proportions so as a consequence of the kind of sclerotic
00:08:51 nature of the huge bloated bureaucracies we live under in Western Europe and as
00:08:56 a result of the crisis of meaning and the crisis of morality I think COVID-19
00:09:02 is hitting our societies harder than it should have could i could i come in
00:09:09 um there is one very notable exception to all all these criticisms which i totally agree with
00:09:16 uh that we've all made and that is her majesty the queen i did think that her broadcast uh was
00:09:24 a perfect example of how a head of state and of course she's far more than just a head of state
00:09:30 she is in a sense the matriarch of the nation of the whole commonwealth uh she's admired really
00:09:37 around the world i i was fascinated to see that millions and millions of french people tuned in
00:09:42 to watch her um because they're not getting that from president macram uh and and in america too
00:09:50 absolutely absolutely probably not literally at the same moment but but later on they've all been
00:09:55 watching it on online and i i think that tells us something about what's wrong with the rest of our
00:10:03 authority figures in our society uh what the queen is getting right uh tells us something about what
00:10:11 others are getting wrong um and this is another reason why i am distressed to put it no stronger
00:10:18 by the suggestion that there is a sort of huge generational divide in our society that the young
00:10:24 don't care about the old, that the old are selfish and don't care about the young,
00:10:29 that's not my feeling. Of course there are tensions because the old are much more vulnerable
00:10:36 to Covid-19 but I have not been getting the feeling from the young people that I talk to
00:10:42 that they are impatient and unfeeling and just think you know these oldies should sort of
00:10:52 shuffle off this mortal coil rather than holding them back. I'm not getting that kind of vibe at
00:10:58 all from the young and I think the fact that the Queen was able to speak really to the whole nation,
00:11:04 to all age groups, to all people of all backgrounds, shows that our older generation still
00:11:13 has a real role to play in our society, that they are still precious and valuable, that that
00:11:19 experience and wisdom still counts for something isn't uh i mean for me i i think it was extraordinary
00:11:25 the speech uh but the cultural importance for me was not just that it was i think probably the
00:11:30 best speech she's ever made was the fact that so many people watched it i mean isn't that the
00:11:35 cultural the cultural point in a way away from you say it's 24 million yes absolutely well as
00:11:41 a royal historian and also um someone who specializes in churchill that was a very
00:11:46 a Chilean speech but to me again it just sort of symbolized how society has changed because
00:11:52 that was a perfect speech to capture a former Britain a Britain that in my view is is basically
00:11:58 on its last legs and I don't see that Britain reflected in contemporary society it was certainly
00:12:03 a speech that I would have loved to have seen Boris Johnson give but I don't think really that
00:12:08 it reflects the reality of society when you see people unable to abide by these lockdown rules
00:12:13 You know, we saw yesterday people playing cricket, being chased by the police.
00:12:17 We're seeing now motor vehicle rides are going up again after only two weeks of being in lockdown.
00:12:22 People are now flouting the rules.
00:12:25 We'll see this Easter weekend with the great weather, people going out and about again.
00:12:29 And when you think about the great generation that sacrificed so much during the Second World War
00:12:33 for true hardship and true self-sacrifice, the fact that we can't just stay home
00:12:38 and abide by the very basic things about just simply being a couch potato,
00:12:41 So if that's all that's required in this great sacrifice is to sit at home and watch Gogglebox and we can't even do that.
00:12:47 I'm not quite sure that the wonderful example set by the Queen and her generation really holds true.
00:12:54 And the other problem I have unfortunately is that I agree with Daniel about the huge importance and the iconic status really that the older generation should have in our hearts.
00:13:06 But unfortunately, I think this is just another case of a gerontophobic society actually risking further derision of the legacy of the old.
00:13:16 Because we've seen that with Brexit, how people were wishing people would die off and have another referendum.
00:13:22 I'm sure we'll see people saying, oh gosh, actually, you know, behind closed doors, maybe we can have another referendum after this has happened and cleared out the top drawer of old racists.
00:13:31 And Britain is one of the most gerontophobic cultures in the world.
00:13:35 I mean, you don't see any intergenerational interaction as you get in other countries.
00:13:39 Just go to any social gathering and you won't see that.
00:13:42 And you look at the housing crisis and how people are thinking that old people basically are holding on to the housing stock
00:13:47 and have these great pensions and so forth.
00:13:49 And my great fear is that as this progresses, there will be more resentment towards the older people
00:13:54 and that you're going to see an increasing chasm opening up between young and old.
00:13:58 And that does worry me if this doesn't come to a conclusion in a relatively near time.
00:14:03 Is that a fear of yours, Brendan, that basically this? I know that, Daniel, you wrote recently, didn't you, about ageism? And it seems to me that, yes, there is a sort of, as we've just said, you know, we have this shocking, to me, it was a bit of revelation, the way that people talked about old people during Brexit. Do you think that this is a real danger, that this is going to kind of just intensify this?
00:14:26 Yes. I think we live in an ageist society. I think we have done quite a while now. I
00:14:35 think it really exploded to the surface during the Brexit discussion when all people were
00:14:39 talked about in the most horrific way imaginable that people were willing them on to die and
00:14:45 hoping that their deaths would cause a positive demographic shift in how people view the European
00:14:51 Union really repulsive and also the kind of boomer bashing that we've seen in recent years the idea
00:14:57 that they are you know bedroom blockers in their big houses with all these this space that they
00:15:02 could be given to Millennials which by the way is not true there's a huge problem pension of
00:15:09 poverty in the United Kingdom the notion that everyone born in the boomer years as well office
00:15:13 or and had free university education and bought their house for 24 years old is a complete and
00:15:19 utter myth. In the 1960s, for example, around 7% of people went to university. Many, many
00:15:27 other people left school at age 15 and started working and had outside toilets and lived
00:15:32 in cramped housing and there were actual slums. When boomers were children, there were still
00:15:36 slums in the United Kingdom which you don't have anymore. So, so much of the contempt
00:15:41 that is held at that generation is simply based on myth and on a kind of generational
00:15:47 envy which i think is incredibly destructive of the social fabric so i think we're seeing a kind
00:15:52 of truce at the moment there is i think a widespread concern for the older population
00:15:58 um i'm not sure how much longer that truth will hold i think it's quite fragile but the generational
00:16:03 conflict is something that worries me enormously um in relation to the queen i'm a republican but
00:16:09 i found myself deeply moved in fact by her speech and i agree it was the speed of her life i find
00:16:16 it deeply fascinating that she's probably the only person in the country who could have made
00:16:21 that speech i think that probably speaks to a crisis of politics and a crisis of democracy i
00:16:27 can't think of a single politician who could have given that speech and not being greeted by cynicism
00:16:33 or shoulder shrugging or a twitter storm but the queen could give it and did connect with people
00:16:39 The thing that fascinated me most about her speech was how dramatically it contrasted with some of the media coverage of the COVID crisis.
00:16:48 Because the media coverage is completely doom-laden and horrific, in fact.
00:16:53 They're just pushing this wall of death at us day in, day out.
00:16:56 If you watch the TV news, it's horrific and deeply upsetting, often bereft of analysis and context.
00:17:02 context and you have this new ritual in this country where people are waiting
00:17:07 for the daily death toll and one writer refers to it as pandemic porn I think
00:17:12 there's a lot of that going on and then along comes the Queen with a message
00:17:15 that was deeply humanist in fact and very very positive and saying we will
00:17:20 succeed we can do this and I thought that was a great contrast not just to the
00:17:26 kind of you know shallowness and amateurishness of modern politics but to
00:17:31 the kind of hysteria that we've seen in sections of the media class it was exactly i think what
00:17:35 people wanted to hear i'm not surprised at all that so many people watched it and were so relieved
00:17:40 by me as pro-bridge pro-human and very positive about the future i want to pick up something
00:17:48 actually that rave brought up uh when he he was talking about why you know that this speech did
00:17:53 not reflect really the reality of britain because people you know why can't they even just you know
00:17:58 stick to the rules and stay at home. I know that, Brendan, for example, you recently talked to Peter
00:18:03 Hitchens, and Daniel, obviously, you know what Peter Hitchens has been saying, which he's been
00:18:08 very depressed that this, in fact, has shown how supine British people have become, quite the
00:18:13 reverse, that, in fact, you know, we are a country that's always kicked against the pricks, that we
00:18:18 have a very strong sense of liberty, and that he's amazed, in fact, utterly depressed, and in fact,
00:18:24 people seem to have just gone hook, line and sinker for it.
00:18:27 I mean, what's your view on that, Daniel?
00:18:29 Would you go along with Peter on that?
00:18:31 I mean, have we become supine?
00:18:34 Peter is an old friend of mine,
00:18:37 but I totally disagree with him about the lockdown.
00:18:40 Peter thinks this is turning Britain into a police state.
00:18:44 And he's had support in that view
00:18:47 from no lesser person than Lord Sumption,
00:18:50 the retired Supreme Court judge.
00:18:54 And I'm afraid Jonathan is also a friend of mine, but I don't agree with him either.
00:18:58 I think the lockdown is, of course, incredibly damaging to the economy, incredibly difficult for many people and has required all kinds of sacrifices, many of which we cannot even see.
00:19:13 My mother-in-law, for example, who's of the same generation as the Queen, Cynthia Thompson, died last week. Not of coronavirus, she died of old age, but undoubtedly the fact that being in a care home, no more visits were allowed, I think hastened her death.
00:19:37 And in our care homes across the country, many people are dying, not just of the virus, but also of loneliness.
00:19:46 And I feel that that kind of sacrifice is not being recognised.
00:19:54 But on the other hand, we do need this lockdown.
00:19:59 If we hadn't had it, the death toll now would be measured in the tens of thousands, not just the thousands.
00:20:05 And I don't think it is an unfair sacrifice to ask people to make.
00:20:13 I mean, I think staying at home compared to what people like my wife's mother or the Queen and her generation had to make in the Second World War.
00:20:26 I mean, Cynthia went off at the age of 15 to man radar stations along the south coast at great risk.
00:20:37 You know, she was plotting the German bombers arriving and sending that information to our fighter squadrons during the Battle of Britain.
00:20:45 And these radar stations were targets.
00:20:48 This is what young people had to do in the 1940s.
00:20:52 They're not being asked to do anything like that now.
00:20:54 And I've noticed that it's actually the guilt-ridden middle-aged or older people who are claiming that the young are in open rebellion.
00:21:07 Lord King, for example, the retired governor of the Bank of England, said this last week in a webinar for policy exchange.
00:21:15 And I don't sense that the young are about to rebel.
00:21:20 it's true that some are disobeying the rules just as some older people are but the vast majority of
00:21:27 people in this country are abiding by the rules and and rightly so you know I think this is this
00:21:33 is this is unfortunately an economic cost that we are going to have to bear and I believe that
00:21:41 the private sector will rise to this challenge I think many people in the private sector are
00:21:46 feeling they're being ignored and not listened to by civil servants and politicians but I know
00:21:53 that's not true of Boris Johnson I know that Boris has at his heart you know the idea of
00:22:00 turning Britain again into the great workshop of the world the great enterprise society
00:22:05 that's the whole point of Brexit and I'm sure that once he is restored to health
00:22:10 and we've beaten this virus, that Britain will be back there leading the charge, leading the world,
00:22:20 leading free enterprise and capitalism back again.
00:22:26 I don't believe that, I mean, this is a point we haven't covered,
00:22:31 that China and societies, communist societies like that have somehow demonstrated
00:22:37 that they're better at dealing with a challenge like this.
00:22:40 That I don't think.
00:22:41 Well, I suppose if you are a totalitarian regime,
00:22:44 you can actually just lock people and nail them up in their houses,
00:22:48 and it's much easier to do that.
00:22:51 I mean, I would have thought...
00:22:52 I'm very interested when you were talking,
00:22:55 Brendan, you mentioned the media and the kind of, you know,
00:22:58 the obsession with death.
00:23:01 You know, there is a slice of opinion
00:23:03 that is what you would call maybe sceptical about this situation?
00:23:08 I mean, I would say that from what you've written,
00:23:11 you would broadly be of that.
00:23:13 This idea that to some people there is something not quite right
00:23:16 about this situation, that in fact, you know,
00:23:19 to use the kind of cliche, you know,
00:23:21 the cure is going to be 10 times worse than the actual thing.
00:23:25 I mean, do you think, it seems to me that when anyone does
00:23:28 say anything like that, the media sort of shut them up.
00:23:30 I mean, more or less entirely.
00:23:33 yeah it is becoming quite difficult to have a rational decent open discussion about what's
00:23:43 the best way to tackle this virus um which is always makes me quite um suspicious you know why
00:23:48 is it so difficult to talk about this thing whether it's climate change transgenderism or now
00:23:55 the lockdown you know when when it becomes very difficult to ask questions that's when i think it
00:23:59 probably becomes quite important to ask questions and I actually think the jury
00:24:04 is out on whether the lockdown was the right response to what is undoubtedly a
00:24:09 serious health crisis and a serious new virus. You know there are people who
00:24:14 argue for example that the lockdown in Italy could have made the problem worse
00:24:18 not least by sending young people home from universities and from schools to
00:24:23 live in huge intergenerational family settings in which there were large
00:24:28 numbers of old people for example because italians tend to live together or certainly mixed together
00:24:33 much more than british families tend to um david l katz who is yale griffin prevention center in the
00:24:40 us and is a a very smart uh expert in in viruses he argued that the lockdown in the us would risk
00:24:48 spreading uh the virus precisely by putting young people home to live with older people so we do
00:24:54 have to factor a lot of these questions in I won't I don't think we will know
00:24:58 what was the right response whether it was our response or the Swedish
00:25:02 response which is more open I don't think we'll know the answer to that
00:25:05 question for a long time but I do think I think there's a class dynamic to the
00:25:10 lockdown as well if I'm being honest I think it's easy for some people to be at
00:25:14 home they can carry on working they might have a garden they might never
00:25:19 live in a house for other people it's very difficult to be at home and I don't
00:25:23 think this is simply about saying well it's a sacrifice and early generations
00:25:27 made greater sacrifices I agree with that but I think when there is a
00:25:31 mark over the course of action we are taking and when there is no moral sense
00:25:38 of moral purpose attached to it when instead it becomes this instruction from
00:25:43 on high often delivered by a policeman in a park that doesn't move people that
00:25:47 doesn't inspire people that in fact that gets people's backs up I think the
00:25:51 difference between today and the blitz spirit and the blitz spirit we do what
00:25:55 we would think there was a moral drive there was a political drive we did feel
00:25:59 that we were together in a grand battle to do something to save something right
00:26:05 now because of the absence of those things if a policeman taps you on the
00:26:09 shoulder and says get off the bench and stop sending a text message which to me
00:26:12 in high five weekend you bristle and you smart and you say well well why so I
00:26:20 I think there's an issue with the lockdown in terms of its long-term impact on the economy
00:26:26 and the knock-on effect on people's health and the question of whether that could prove
00:26:31 to be worse in the long term than the impact of the virus.
00:26:34 Well, I was going to say, I mean, firstly, I think that the lockdown was clearly necessary
00:26:40 in the short term.
00:26:42 I'm sympathetic to Law Sumption and Peter Hitchens in the sense that the idea that you're going
00:26:47 to have this enforced by some sort of new gestapo to use churchillian language in the 1950s that
00:26:54 he used against the labor party um that certainly is a worry but you know the idea that people would
00:27:00 have their own free will want to stay at home and stop and stop the spread of coronavirus
00:27:04 that's another thing rather than having the state enforce it i mean that's what's happening in
00:27:08 sweden i mean they are being encouraged to stay home even though some places are open but you
00:27:13 know the idea of a moral obligation i think that does exist there is there is a moral purpose to
00:27:17 the lockdown but the problem is that it's a very basic concept about trying to save lives as if
00:27:24 humanity is purely concerned about stopping someone from dying. I think the great moral
00:27:30 dilemma is going to occur over the next few weeks and months when the huge economic cost
00:27:35 and the cost of our civil liberties becomes something that's weighed in the balance against
00:27:40 the cost of losing the lives of the elderly and the vulnerable and I think that's the moral
00:27:45 dilemma that we're going to be facing in the future and it's something which I'm not sure
00:27:49 whether people are going to be prepared to have because the media seem to be unwilling to actually
00:27:54 countenance the idea that there are there is a the humanity is more than just stopping death is
00:28:01 actually allowing people to continue their lives in the second world war we sacrifice the lives
00:28:06 of our brave young soldiers in order to preserve our way of life that was a moral dilemma which
00:28:12 we had to do and so this is another sort of a conflict and another and another issue that we
00:28:16 have to to to value and decide what is the value of life do you think i mean how do you think that
00:28:23 the media will come out of this generally if i can ask you all really because it seems to me that
00:28:28 they were they really damaged themselves during brexit um i now find that i have to simply watch
00:28:35 one news bulletin a day and that is it because i i feel that that kind of fear is being ramped up
00:28:41 Is that something you recognise or not?
00:28:48 Last night on Newsnight we had Emily Maitlis
00:28:53 editorialising, giving a little speech about
00:29:00 to talk about the Prime Minister being a fighter
00:29:05 and more seriously um saying that uh what britain needed was a new settlement uh which would do away
00:29:15 with inequality after this um well she's entitled to her views uh as are as everyone is but i think
00:29:23 if you're using the national broadcast if you're you're the bb the voice of the bbc then you should
00:29:29 be very careful about giving what are really very partisan uh rants uh of that kind um and we got
00:29:38 very used to that during the brexit period um and i think a lot of these bbc journalists uh feel
00:29:45 somehow that they're now entitled uh to pontificate in that way um and i i very much hope there will
00:29:53 be a bit of a backlash against that and that if we are to continue to have the bbc in its present
00:29:58 form which is an open question uh then uh it must return to proper impartiality um but more generally
00:30:08 i think the media has failed badly in these daily press conferences to ask the right questions to
00:30:15 stick to facts to be brief and concise um to do the old journalistic virtues the kind of things
00:30:22 that george orwell used to write about you know brevity and uh being short and sharp uh ask the
00:30:31 politicians questions they can't wriggle out of you know robert peston and people like that
00:30:37 drone on with their long-winded sort of loquacious uh windbaggery and um of course that enables the
00:30:44 politicians to wriggle out um and sometimes we really do need to know the answers uh and i
00:30:51 don't think we've covered ourselves we journalists with glory in these occasions but um having said
00:30:57 that we do have a free press more or less just about still and thank goodness we do because
00:31:04 when you look across to someone like china and you realize how any criticism of the government's
00:31:10 response there and my goodness you know uh xi jinping does bear a very heavy responsibility i
00:31:18 I think for the spread of this virus around the world,
00:31:20 literally hundreds of thousands of lives
00:31:23 will probably be lost because of the cover up in China.
00:31:28 And nobody there can even discuss it or read about it.
00:31:33 So I suppose we should be grateful for the fact
00:31:36 that we are still part of Western civilization
00:31:38 and we do still have the right to criticize our leaders.
00:31:43 But right now, I think most of the country
00:31:45 wants this to be over.
00:31:47 we want to remain broadly united and therefore if we are going to criticize the prime minister or
00:31:54 the rest of the government it's got to be well informed factual sort of criticism not prejudice
00:32:01 and ideology yeah doesn't this really mean the the the authority of the media as it as it might
00:32:08 have once been has gone i mean amongst ordinary people i'm not just talking about tory mps who
00:32:14 might get angry about lack of um you know lack of um impartiality i'm talking about people who
00:32:20 watch the news they don't necessarily take it seriously anymore or rather they don't look to
00:32:25 it for authority anymore would you would you say brendan uh yes absolutely um i've stopped watching
00:32:33 the tv news which i've never done before and i've never particularly been in favor of media bashing
00:32:39 I think the media gets blamed for lots of things it's not really responsible for.
00:32:44 But I think the TV news in particular has covered this crisis terribly, really terribly.
00:32:50 I think it's making people ill.
00:32:53 My mother, for example, phones me often and says she feels terrified because of things that she's seen on the news.
00:32:58 because what we are getting is this daily diet of often context-free, analysis-free coverage of death,
00:33:06 for example, particularly when Italy was in its lowest point.
00:33:10 That was the daily coverage of the Italian crisis in a way that was not helpful at all.
00:33:16 Or we just get this kind of gotcha journalism where you have these journalists at the daily news conferences
00:33:24 and they're not really asking. I completely agree with Daniel's description of them.
00:33:27 I don't think they're asking questions at all, even if it looks like it's a question.
00:33:31 It's really a statement. It's really a pose very often.
00:33:35 It's really them saying something about themselves.
00:33:37 You know, aren't I clever? Look at my long question.
00:33:40 You know, maybe I'll get maybe I'll go viral on Twitter.
00:33:44 I don't like that approach at all. It's not serious.
00:33:47 And I think journalists have got ideas above their station to a certain extent.
00:33:51 You know, they really in a particularly in a crisis, they really ought to be uncovering as much useful information.
00:33:57 as possible um i totally agree about the right to criticize the government i think
00:34:02 even anyone should be allowed to say anything about the government at all whatever they want
00:34:07 to say that's fine but i think what we currently have is actually criticism of the government that
00:34:12 it's not really a deep interesting moral political criticism at all it's often just sniping and
00:34:19 insulting and you know if you look at the way in which dominic rabe and others were attached for
00:34:24 calling Boris a fighter. It's so petty and ridiculous. That's a term people use
00:34:29 when somebody's struggling against an illness. It's perfectly normal. People use it and yet
00:34:34 media obsesses over it and it was part of Emily Maitlis' ridiculous, worthy
00:34:39 lecture that she gave to the Nation of Youth Night, this notion that it was
00:34:42 something terrible to make that suggestion. The media, I think, is losing
00:34:47 public trust. It had been already. I think it's going to get worse and I
00:34:53 think the media is going to come out of this crisis particularly badly actually that brings
00:34:57 me to the final section of our talk really because uh uh one of these things that happened
00:35:03 you talk about the kind of egotistical self-regarding comments of journalists uh the sky political
00:35:08 correspondent best rigby um tweeted out that she was very angry that there were no women i mean
00:35:14 she managed to draw in to this thing that there were no women at these press conferences um so
00:35:20 we will ride back to the good old days of identity politics you know and wokeism and i want to ask
00:35:27 i mean do you think one thing that i have been struck by is that the news agenda does now
00:35:33 appear to be about things that are happening as opposed to things people have said or not said
00:35:39 so much of our news was actually about what people were saying and how whether it was wrong or not
00:35:45 do you this is something do you think that that the obsession that we would have been sitting
00:35:49 here talking about only three weeks ago about free speech and about the the progressive ideology
00:35:55 of wokeism have we seen the last of that or or not do you think because of this absolutely not
00:36:02 it's too embedded and people have too much riding on it in their careers to say that it's had
00:36:07 anything other than a brief hiatus due to due to the coronavirus a normal service shall resume
00:36:12 shortly and we've seen that as as Brendan was just saying you know the attacks on the attacks
00:36:18 and Dominic Raab for saying that Boris Johnson
00:36:20 is a fighter, I mean, that's what you say
00:36:21 about anybody who is going through a struggle
00:36:24 and you want to say that they've got great
00:36:25 resolve and to turn that against them I thought
00:36:27 was very churlish. But yeah, and on the
00:36:29 whole media side, I mean, to have people
00:36:32 even like Nick Watt asking basic questions
00:36:34 about who runs the government
00:36:35 when everyone knows that there's cabinet, you know,
00:36:37 there's a cabinet government that's
00:36:40 being run and it's almost as if
00:36:41 they've never graduated from sixth form,
00:36:44 you know, the basic questions of
00:36:45 politics that are being asked. But, you
00:36:47 know and but now we're seeing again you know in terms of boris johnson having coronavirus we're
00:36:53 told that this is a great level now we're hearing some more of this wokeism going out that oh no
00:36:57 actually it is people from the the working classes who are more prone to this you know do we need to
00:37:03 have this distinction made everyone is struggling with this at the moment in fact you know if you're
00:37:07 male and obese you are most at risk i mean that's why boris johnson had it and one third of the
00:37:12 nation are obese but you know obese white men are not going to necessarily be deemed to be
00:37:18 sufficiently woke to get people uh marching about that but if you come from a disadvantaged
00:37:22 background or you're from an ethnic minority then you're seeing you're seeing that highlighted when
00:37:26 actually boros johnson should be the poster boy of exactly who are who's most likely to get it
00:37:32 yes exactly that is the point he's creeping back isn't it i mean now you know some of the the usual
00:37:38 suspects on media are actually saying oh this is actually uh i think minorities are bearing the
00:37:43 brand or whatever uh it's sort of dividing they're kind of already dividing so so would you agree i
00:37:48 mean would you agree to say what rave said that basically normal service on these issues is going
00:37:52 to be resumed after a decent interval well of course i don't quite know what the permanent
00:38:02 legacy of this crisis will be. I think Rafe may be right that at least some people will go back
00:38:11 to the bad old days of wokeism. But I do think we've been through quite an ordeal here. I think
00:38:20 the moment when the news spread that Boris had been taken into intensive care, many people I
00:38:28 talked to were even people who had not voted for him who were not his fans were really shaken and
00:38:36 upset by that news it all suddenly became tremendously real to them and I think experiences
00:38:44 like this do change a country in interesting and unpredictable ways so while there will be
00:38:52 of course many people particularly in the academic world and probably in the cultural world too who
00:38:58 will go all the name calling and virtue signaling and all that stuff um i think the rest of us
00:39:07 will be able to see just how trivial and shallow that sort of behavior that whole
00:39:14 brand of identity politics has become it might actually even become a bit passe
00:39:19 a little it might go out of fashion um once people are confronted with the reality
00:39:25 of life and death it does change them and that generation we were talking about earlier the
00:39:31 queen's generation um they emerged from the second world war with tremendous moral purpose they they
00:39:38 they i mean not everything they did was right you know the the atlee government did many things which
00:39:43 mrs thatcher later had to reverse but uh she too mrs thatcher was part of that generation
00:39:50 And I think when people have faced the possibility of death directly, they do become more serious.
00:40:03 So I think we can at least hope that something will have fundamentally changed and that we won't just go back to the rather depressing culture of the early 21st century, that perhaps the 2020s will be a rather different decade as a result of what we've now experienced.
00:40:28 I would love to I would love to agree with you there Daniel I I fear that I am a little bit
00:40:34 more with Rafe on this I think it's so entrenched that they're just biding their time I mean that
00:40:38 that's my feeling slightly although I would say though one area that I think is that Brexit now
00:40:43 seems to be to have basically been forgotten about and if anything that the fissure of Brexit
00:40:48 has been healed over whether it's a scab that can be unpicked in the future or whether it will be
00:40:53 allowed to heal uh and go away with bailey a scar we'll see and again also in america to see
00:40:59 whether democrats and republicans can actually unite over something like there's been if brexit
00:41:03 and the american political divide can be healed somewhat by coronavirus i'll count that as one
00:41:07 victory what about you uh brendan to to round off do you think that uh we've seen the end of woke
00:41:14 um i don't think so actually i i agree that it's deeply entrenched not only in the sense that it's
00:41:22 it's um supported by influential people i think it runs through every significant institution
00:41:28 in society particularly educational institutions political institutions cultural institutions i
00:41:34 think it is a deeply ingrained way of looking at the world through an identitarian lens through a
00:41:39 very divided lens and i think it it will take more than even this virus to shake that off so i expect
00:41:46 it will come back but this um period we're living through is definitely shaking it up and i think
00:41:52 what it has demonstrated is the extent to which that identity politics was so
00:41:56 obviously the enemy of social solidarity because it's such an
00:42:01 endlessly divisive fragmentary way of understanding the world it's
00:42:05 completely anti-humanist it's obviously completely
00:42:07 anti-anti-nation and it treats everyone as kind of
00:42:11 just this free floating individual part of a kind of ethnic
00:42:15 or cultural group and nothing more beyond that and that just doesn't work
00:42:19 in a time of crisis when people genuinely need to pull together regardless of their
00:42:24 backgrounds so there are some inspiring moments you know huge numbers of people signed up to be
00:42:29 volunteers um whether the government will let them be volunteer because some of them don't have
00:42:34 criminal background checks and obviously we live under a very bureaucratic state that makes
00:42:38 volunteers and volunteering very difficult but huge numbers of people want to volunteer
00:42:44 in my area there's a whatsapp group that many people joined and we're helping do shopping for
00:42:49 elderly people and deliver medicines and so on that's going on around the country that's the
00:42:54 kind of thing i think the queen was talking about too that sense of social solidarity social
00:43:00 connectedness national connectedness um so the reminder of that stuff you know out of necessity
00:43:07 as it happens i think will definitely deliver a blow to the elite politics we've seen developing
00:43:12 over the past couple of decades whether it will defeat it or not i think largely depends on what
00:43:18 we do as a society and what and what priorities we push you know there's no natural you know for
00:43:25 example when the black death came to england in 1348 and killed around 40 of the population it
00:43:31 wasn't the black death that radically transformed england although it had a terrible impact it was
00:43:36 really the peasants revolt a few decades later in which people stood up to some of the um economic
00:43:41 consequence of the black death it was really that process those discussions those actions
00:43:47 which radically transform the country. So when we come out of COVID-19, I think a lot of it will
00:43:51 depend on what we say, what we do and what moral priorities we put forward as being better for the
00:43:57 nation. Just to myself that maybe it will change people's attitudes slightly to technology. What
00:44:03 I've noticed simply on an anecdotal level is that people simply can't walk along anymore just
00:44:09 looking at their phones because they've got to look where they're going. I hope that that continues.
00:44:14 thank you very much for joining me brendan thank you very much daniel too and rave
00:44:19 that's it for this time on counterculture we'll be back next week with more on the
00:44:24 coronavirus but in the meantime i do hope you stay well thank you