New Culture Forum - July 19, 2020


Do The Left-Leaning Arts Deserve A £1.5 Billion Bailout? Who Gets It? A Right - Wing Opportunity?

Marc Sidwell Reads From His Book: The Long March - How The Left Won The Culture War SOS, SAVE OUR STATUES -- SaveOurStatues.org.uk -- Join To Defend Britain's Heritage

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

167.63

Word count

5,776

Sentence count

164


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whitfall. Now you might have heard and read in
00:00:18 recent weeks during the Covid crisis of the enormous challenges facing the arts in Britain
00:00:26 and the creative industries we've heard lots about how our theaters might actually have to
00:00:32 close indeed how many of them most of them in fact are facing oblivion but this is just
00:00:38 an arts-wide problem it's not just the theater a couple of weeks ago the government announced
00:00:45 a bailout of about 1.57 billion but what really will the crisis first of all covid and indeed
00:00:54 for that matter, the cultural crisis we've had afterwards, Black Lives Matter, protests
00:00:59 and so forth. What effect will these have on the future of the arts and what in fact
00:01:04 has been exposed in terms of our attitude to the arts? Now to discuss these questions
00:01:10 today I'm delighted we've got four guests. Robin Akin, who's been on the show a couple
00:01:16 of times before, he is a former BBC reporter, he is author of Can We Trust the BBC and the
00:01:22 noble liar. William Cook is a writer and contributor to, amongst others, The New Statesman, The
00:01:30 Spectator, The Guardian, and also was once theatre critic. Jacob Phillips is Associate
00:01:36 Professor at Queen Mary's and writes about the arts and culture. And of course, our resident
00:01:42 here, resident guest, Rafe Hadle-Mancou of the New Culture Forum, commentator and historian.
00:01:48 Thank you very much for joining me, all of you.
00:01:51 Can I start? I want to ask one question, and I will start with you, if I may, William.
00:01:57 Do you think that the arts sector should have got 1.57 million bailouts?
00:02:06 Gosh, that's a tricky question. I'll do my best to give my opinion as to the answer.
00:02:12 Just to update you a little bit on your intro, I guess the people I'm writing mainly for these days
00:02:17 are The Spectator, The Independent, and The Oldie.
00:02:20 I did write quite a lot for The Guardian and The New Statesman,
00:02:23 but haven't done that for quite a long time.
00:02:25 Right.
00:02:27 I always feel a bit kind of awkward about money going to arts institutions,
00:02:33 particularly the performing arts.
00:02:35 Obviously, I mean, I think it is something like looking after museums
00:02:38 or looking after galleries.
00:02:40 That's one thing.
00:02:41 But the big problem when you give public money to performing arts
00:02:45 is in the end, somebody's got to decide who gets how much, whether some people get a lot
00:02:51 and some people get a little and some people get nothing at all. And it's the same old
00:02:56 question, who decides and what criteria do they decide on? I guess in my sort of fantasy
00:03:03 political world, the solution I'd like to see is a sort of basic universal income for
00:03:10 artists. You know, obviously, I don't want to see anybody not
00:03:14 be able to pay their mortgage or not be able to pay their
00:03:18 supermarket bill or anything. But I think the individuals if all
00:03:21 the individuals got 1000 pounds a month, and we're told to get
00:03:25 on with it. And you know, that covered any any kind of other
00:03:29 payments or whatever, I think that would be a lot more
00:03:32 straightforward, because then we get away from this problem of
00:03:35 somebody uh deciding who gets what money and whether some people don't get any at all
00:03:43 but how would then one you know decide who is an artist or not would that be a subjective uh
00:03:49 evaluation well so yeah then we're on to completely uncharted waters i guess i'm
00:03:56 you know that uh i you know obviously some subsidy is needed to to to keep the precious
00:04:03 institutions going that I enjoy visiting as much as anyone else but I think with
00:04:07 regards to the performing arts the thing that makes me uneasy I have no
00:04:11 simplistic solutions to it but the thing that makes me uneasy is the idea of
00:04:15 people deciding who's worthy to get public cash. Is that something you would
00:04:21 agree with Jacob do you do you think or what William has said there or indeed
00:04:27 the more general point as well about the government giving the money to the arts after I have to say
00:04:35 many weeks of protests from the arts I mean what is your view on it well I mean in principle I
00:04:41 think given the severity of the crisis Rishi Sunak's interventionism or even red Toryism you
00:04:46 could call it is it's necessary but I really do share Williams fears about these decisions about
00:04:52 who gets what and the arts sector uh the arts establishment if you like have um have not filled
00:05:00 me with great faith that um you know funds will be distributed wisely and equitably they seem to be
00:05:05 very ideologically driven um i mean you raised a very good point there peter of who how do they
00:05:10 decide who an artist is well if you look at let's create the strategy document of arts council
00:05:14 england they don't actually use the word artist because art art is considered high art um and
00:05:20 therefore some sort of toxic term so we can't say artists we say creative practitioners um if we're
00:05:26 in a context where even the word artist itself is a problem then you know we do have to ask
00:05:31 ourselves how is this money going to just be distributed and you know what are the checks
00:05:35 and balances on the clear um ideological motivations which seem to be very prevalent
00:05:40 in the sector at the moment uh but in principle jacob you you have no problem with the money being
00:05:48 given no no i think it's necessary we're in such uncharted territory i think that radical
00:05:55 interventions are necessary at the moment economically um robin and rave there is an
00:06:02 argument going on and it it actually happens it's not a left right thing actually for what it's
00:06:07 worth it so i think it's actually mostly happens if you like on the center right of politics there
00:06:12 are many people who would agree with william jacob that the arts should have this money
00:06:16 And then you've got the others, the sort of free market fundamentalists who say, absolutely not.
00:06:21 Where do you start?
00:06:22 Well, I would look at it more in terms of a job creation scheme.
00:06:28 So what I mean is that the money which has been given to the arts, which seems to me substantial and even generous in some terms,
00:06:38 has to be looked at in the context of what the Chancellor is attempting to do.
00:06:44 So it isn't that he wishes, I think, probably.
00:06:47 I don't think the government has a positive wish to preserve the arts.
00:06:53 I think they see the arts as another industrial sector.
00:06:56 And like other industrial sectors, it needs support at this moment.
00:07:00 Because if it doesn't get it, there could be long-term damage to the arts infrastructure.
00:07:05 And that's something that clearly the government would wish to avoid.
00:07:08 So it's really, I mean, I take the point about how the money will be divvied up between all the various organisations, but I mean, that is a judgment which will be made by people in arts administration.
00:07:28 I don't think the government will be that bothered about that, the detail of it.
00:07:34 I think what they're interested in is saying the arts need some money
00:07:37 and we need to preserve jobs in the arts because in a couple of years' time
00:07:41 they'll be productive and we'll need them.
00:07:44 I think that's what it's about.
00:07:45 That's right.
00:07:45 I think we have to look at this really as being one arrow in the quiver of the new New Deal for Britain.
00:07:51 This is one of the industries which I think singles Britain now.
00:07:54 britain is ranked in the top four countries in the world for as a cultural soft power um and so
00:08:00 even though we may not like the i call them cuckoos in the nests of our theaters and institutions
00:08:06 artists and actors who perhaps don't reflect the true british values the buildings that they're in
00:08:11 the institutions that they are that they are occupying do deserve uh being saved not only
00:08:16 for cultural values but pure economic values the amount of money that is brought into the economy
00:08:21 through the theatres and through live music venues,
00:08:24 the number of people that are employed.
00:08:25 Rishi Sunak said that there are 700,000 people employed here.
00:08:28 This includes museums,
00:08:30 and it includes the National Museum of Coal Mining
00:08:33 and railway museums, as well as theatre and the arts,
00:08:35 all of which are vitally important.
00:08:37 So I think there's an importance to preserve that for posterity,
00:08:41 and if there's a way in which the government had any sort of
00:08:45 Trumpian magnetism behind it,
00:08:50 it would try and tie this to basically some sort of agenda
00:08:53 and say if you are an organisation that has silenced
00:08:56 other playwrights and directors and so forth
00:08:59 you won't be getting this funding.
00:09:01 But of course the funding is allocated by the Arts Council for England
00:09:03 by the Heritage Lottery Foundation and the British Film Institute
00:09:06 and there has to be I think some sort of requirement behind this funding
00:09:10 that it comes with caveats.
00:09:16 Well the trouble with that is
00:09:18 I mean, I kind of agree in theory it would be nice if you could do that.
00:09:22 But the point is, actually translating that into practical action, I think, would involve all sorts of judgments which would bring the odium of the arts world down upon the government.
00:09:33 The point is that this isn't, I don't think this is an aesthetic government.
00:09:37 I think this is not an aesthetic judgment by the government.
00:09:41 It's an economic judgment.
00:09:42 And it has to be looked at in those terms.
00:09:44 Now, I know, obviously, there are major considerations which people are talking about now, you know, these things which you are discussing about who should get the money, but that's not the way the government's seeing it, I don't think.
00:09:57 I think it's a question that they just see it as an imperiled industrial sector.
00:10:06 And they know that in the medium term, when tourism of a type returns, one of the reasons people come to London and have always come to London is because they can have a cultural experience here which is varied and actually very good quality.
00:10:23 And that is something which, you know, you don't have to be an economics genius to work that out.
00:10:28 It's not really about... So that's what I guess the government is doing here.
00:10:34 Jacob, I want to pick something up you said there when you were talking about the Arts Council England
00:10:39 and the fact that they don't use the word arts, you know, that they use creative practitioners.
00:10:45 um this is something it seems to me that's at one with a lot of what we might have learned about our
00:10:52 institutions over the past couple of months it seems to be that they don't quite believe in what
00:11:00 they're meant to be doing or rather they've lost faith in what they're meant to be doing is that
00:11:04 something do you think that's a valid valid point i do and i mean the document i had in mind this
00:11:10 document called let's create the 10-year strategy for arts council england um it not only won't use
00:11:16 the word artist it says that the concept of art is a problem because it means high art of which
00:11:21 it gives the examples of ballet and opera as if there can't be you know low art forms or examples
00:11:27 of ballet and opera which there clearly can i mean there's a there's a there's a problem with
00:11:30 the literacy the artistic literacy considering that this comes from arts council england but
00:11:35 it we we get back to this point i mean i agree that um the the current administration are making
00:11:40 an economic decision and saving jobs and creating jobs even and that's very worthy but with someone
00:11:47 like arts council england i mean they have at the moment in that 10-year document um that they will
00:11:52 be uh imposing or encouraging targets um on the basis of these investment principles of inclusivity
00:12:00 and relevance so although the government aren't saying anything or aren't interested really on
00:12:05 where it goes as long as jobs are created and uh you know money is spent um it is going to be
00:12:11 filtered through people who do have quite clear agendas and i think that is a concern no i mean
00:12:15 you know that is a fascinating point and to be honest um you know i had not thought of that but
00:12:20 you make a very you make a very plausible case there and i would think that um the difficulty
00:12:27 as I see it is how if you were a politician and you wished to in some way discriminate
00:12:38 in the arts and select organizations which you felt were creating something worthwhile
00:12:46 and which was within your ideological tradition, if you like.
00:12:51 So I'm thinking of the right, I mean, I'm sure I, like everybody, all of us, I imagine,
00:12:57 I feel when I consume the arts, and I'm not a sort of passionate consumer of the arts,
00:13:05 but I do go to things, obviously.
00:13:07 I rarely find that I am confronted by a production which is uplifting,
00:13:14 which has a respect for British culture in a, I don't mean in a solemn and sort of pompous way
00:13:24 but I mean a recognition of the real worth of British culture
00:13:31 and actually the things which lie deep within it which are very worth preserving.
00:13:37 When I go to the theatre I too often find myself confronted by a sort of diatribe
00:13:43 by some ideological liberal
00:13:46 which I find deeply off-putting
00:13:49 and I don't suppose I'm alone
00:13:51 Robin, you're absolutely right
00:13:53 and your opinion is one that's reflected by the majority of the population of this country
00:13:57 I would imagine
00:13:58 or indeed any sane person would be sure to share those views
00:14:01 and that's why I think there's an opportunity here for the government
00:14:04 to actually reconnect with its potential future voting base
00:14:08 in the Red Wall and elsewhere
00:14:09 who share these concerns about British culture
00:14:11 is cultural security as much as economic security, which is at risk here.
00:14:15 And that's why I think, you know, Trump can see this in America, right?
00:14:19 You saw that wonderful speech he made on July the 4th, Independence Day,
00:14:23 calling out an all-out war, essentially, on those who are the extreme fascists of the left
00:14:28 and the illiberals who are trying to silence opposition and try to have ideological conformity.
00:14:33 If there can be a way in which the government can try to halt this sinister force
00:14:38 going through the arts right now it would be to actually make a statement and say if you are
00:14:43 anti-diversity of thought and anti-diversity of opinion then funding will not be allocated
00:14:48 towards you and that means you know an overhaul of the arts council of england's appointments
00:14:52 process to ensure that there are people on the arts council who actually understand and
00:14:56 and see the dangers inherent in the way that culture is going in this country and the same
00:15:01 thing goes for heritage lottery foundation grants if these actually can be tied the government can
00:15:06 only use money now as a way to try to influence this and i think that's that's something which
00:15:10 a government with balls would actually um should seize upon jacob do you have any sort of sympathy
00:15:17 with the with the view that basically we should you did say we should support the government's
00:15:25 1.5 billion um and i'm not anti public spending on the arts at all but can you see why people
00:15:33 might be less sympathetic now because essentially it does seem like there is an entirely monolithic
00:15:39 sort of set of attitudes now in the arts i mean my background is also in the arts in arts television
00:15:46 i used to make arts programs for itv um and i i'm sure that it has got much much more censorious
00:15:52 and much more constricted yes i mean i i can understand those fears and um you know i can
00:16:00 really i can also see william's point that the last thing we want is the minister for digital
00:16:04 and culture to be deciding you know where the money should go nobody wants that um however
00:16:10 little faith one might have in some in people like arts council england but i think
00:16:13 what what worries me about the censoriousness as i've heard of it and read about it and witnessed
00:16:20 it is that it plays on um things which are integral to the arts like being exploratory
00:16:26 you know experimenting and challenging and dynamic um and yet it's the opposite of all those things
00:16:33 and i think that's what's very concerning it would be much more punk rock or much more exploratory now
00:16:39 if you know to go to an exhibition of turner or constable than it would to whatever's going on
00:16:45 in the tape modern and i think it all comes back to this this incredibly vexed term diversity and
00:16:50 I would just, I would like to be in a situation where there is a diversity of arts, you know, mainstream national institutions of art sponsoring and encouraging art, which understands things like the preservation of tradition, art as edifying and cultural transmission beyond this very narrow censoriousness.
00:17:12 Yes, you mentioned there the Tate Modern. The head of Tate Modern, Francis Morrison, I believe it is, recently said that, in fact, when we come out of COVID, if you like, the agenda should be that climate change awareness should be at the very heart of all curating.
00:17:34 Now, wait a minute, that doesn't exactly fill one with confidence. Is that something that the head of the Tate should be saying, Ray?
00:17:41 Well, the problem there, of course, is that you're moving away from notions of excellence.
00:17:45 And this has been commented on before, the fact that we've gone from a situation now where excellence was rewarded and promoted
00:17:51 and having years of experience under your belt and that was encouraged through grants and so forth,
00:17:57 to now apparently using ideology and agendas as a basis for funding, irrespective of merit.
00:18:03 And the art surely is an area where merit should be paramount in terms of support or recognising new talent,
00:18:10 rather than this idea, this equality of outcome,
00:18:13 this idea that everybody is now an artist,
00:18:15 in which case I want to self-identify and have a grand as an artist.
00:18:19 So, yes, I mean, it's very dangerous when suddenly ideology
00:18:22 rather than the actual, the virtue of art itself
00:18:26 becomes the raison d'etre for an institution.
00:18:29 Yes, I think that also Nicholas Sorota, who's the head of the Arts Council,
00:18:34 said that, you know, this is an opportunity for the arts to reset.
00:18:38 Now, we're hearing this word a lot, reset.
00:18:40 what actually, what do you think that reset would look like?
00:18:46 What do you think it would look like in the future?
00:18:48 Well, Peter, you and I shared a letter, did we not, a few months ago.
00:18:53 Yeah.
00:18:54 Which, now, this is a fascinating letter, actually.
00:18:58 It was a private letter to you, wasn't it?
00:18:59 And he was a writer, and a writer of great experience, as I recall the details.
00:19:06 and he found it impossible to place his work
00:19:15 because he felt that in television
00:19:18 minds were set against the sort of subjects
00:19:22 and the treatments that he wished to give them.
00:19:26 So he was unable really to go on working.
00:19:29 I have no direct experience of trying to work for the arts
00:19:36 But my impression of the arts is, as an outsider I mean, is that it is a closed world and it's not a world which would very much welcome the intervention of outsiders who have heretical ideas.
00:19:55 I mean that's just my impression of it.
00:19:57 But that letter came to mind as we were talking because it was telling that letter.
00:20:02 Do you know, if we, I remember it very well, if we look at this thing of the arts going forward, you know, the resetting of the arts,
00:20:14 isn't this, is this going to be an arts world that is drenched in identity politics?
00:20:19 I mean, you might say it already is, but I'm just thinking now, now that we've had the protests that we've had over the past couple of months,
00:20:28 you know, now that we are talking in an era where statues are coming down and all these sort of things,
00:20:32 I mean, basically, do you think that this is actually will intensify, you know, that rather than having a freeing up, I think this kind of thing that you're having in the arts now, like this, there is this saying, stay in your lane, you know, we're having actors now being, you know, apologetic for having played a part that was not integral to their genetics, you know.
00:20:56 what do you say to that, William? I mean, do you see this as a problem for the arts
00:21:01 politically or not? Well, it hasn't impacted on me very much. I mean, I don't want to dismiss
00:21:08 other people's concerns. I mean, you know, just to put the contrary view, I'm somebody who prefers
00:21:16 going to take Britain than going to take modern. But I'm at liberty to do either. And both are
00:21:23 there. And I know another bunch of people who would prefer to
00:21:27 go to Tate Modern. So we, I go to Pimlico, and they go to the
00:21:30 South Bank, and we're, we're, we're all fairly happy, I think,
00:21:34 in, in that regard. And again, I, you know, and this is just to
00:21:39 sort of open up the discussion and not to dismiss other
00:21:43 sincerely held points of view. But if I take a walk down
00:21:45 Shaftesbury Avenue, I don't feel that I'm in a sort of left
00:21:51 wing kind of ghetto there it seems to be fairly sort of mainstream entertainment that's on offer
00:21:57 there so i would say that um there is from the point of view of a punter there seems to be
00:22:04 something for everyone um i i don't sense that certain points of view are being um forcefully
00:22:11 excluded but maybe that's because it's not my point of view um i do think there's a pretty wide
00:22:17 choice out there at the moment um and uh i my my feeling is the more artists performers call them
00:22:25 what you will are left to get on with it um the wider that choice remains do you think it's a wide
00:22:32 choice jacob so i have sympathy with what william's saying and i'm casting my mind back to
00:22:39 shardsbury avenue before lockdown and it certainly doesn't feel like a left-wing ghetto and i think
00:22:45 there's a much broader range to the arts than what's often connected with that term and yes
00:22:49 when you think about the mainstream theatre as things you get on Shaftesbury Avenue then
00:22:53 I think William has a really good point. At the same time I think when you talk about what many
00:22:59 people call high art and things like that and I cast my mind back to a statement that was released
00:23:03 in June when the reopening of the galleries was announced. That statement given out by the Tate
00:23:12 Sophie, could you come here?
00:23:17 Oh, sorry, there's someone talking over my head.
00:23:18 It's okay, carry on, carry on.
00:23:20 Right, okay.
00:23:22 For the Tate Gallery and the V&A, et cetera,
00:23:25 a statement went out saying that our role
00:23:26 is at the current time to deal with critical issues
00:23:31 around racial equality, social justice, and climate change.
00:23:34 My first thought was, why?
00:23:36 Why has that become the racial connection of the arts?
00:23:39 Why has that become the modus operandi?
00:23:41 I would expect it to be one element. One expects there to be socialist or activist art here and there, but to have all the major national institutions of the capital city saying that this is their primary function, if you like, not to cultivate political discussion, but to lead the political discussion in one particular direction, if we're honest, then that for me is a cause for concern, not least because it's exactly the same point of view which is being expressed by high street banks and major corporations as well as most of the media.
00:24:11 I mean, I'm sorry to go on a bit about this, but it struck me then when I was listening just now
00:24:16 that this conversation is actually much more helpful and insightful to me than any other conversation
00:24:20 I've witnessed in, you know, what might be called the mainstream media.
00:24:24 And this is the sort of thing which one used to get on, you know, BBC Two or The Late Show or on Radio Four.
00:24:29 And the fact that we're having a conversation, the fact this conversation is such a high quality
00:24:33 and it's actually happening on a YouTube channel, I think sort of it makes the point I'm trying to make.
00:24:38 The thing is that, you know, with this statement you've just talked about, Jacob, I mean, to me, I find it quite chilling, right?
00:24:47 But not just because it's anti-pathetic to my view, but it's not, the arts should not be there for social engineering.
00:24:58 I mean, that is not what they're about, surely, William?
00:25:02 Well, absolutely.
00:25:03 I mean, and, you know, I guess we're not going to have a, I come back to the point about setting a template, a precedent for future administrations.
00:25:15 You know, it seems to me that the less administrators, even curators, have to do with the arts, the performing arts, the visual arts, the better, really.
00:25:28 One of the reasons I enjoy going to the National Gallery in particular is because it feels very
00:25:35 lightly curated. There doesn't seem to be an overview at all really. I mean the paintings
00:25:42 are put in there, they're very nicely presented and one takes a look around and one becomes one's
00:25:48 own creator, curator in a sense. There are other institutions where the curatorial eyes is more
00:25:56 avert and then one feels as if one's sharing someone else's vision rather than producing
00:26:03 one's own. What excited me, for instance, about some of these rather more anarchic theatre
00:26:10 productions that happened in the past that I was writing about in The Spectator, there
00:26:14 was one particular example. In East Berlin, when the war came down, there was a big old
00:26:19 department store called Tackle, or they called it Tackle afterwards. It was like Selfridges,
00:26:24 like a german selfridges it was bombed out during the war the east germans never got around to
00:26:30 repairing it and after the war came down a lot of artists performers all sorts of people moved in
00:26:36 and it was an absolute free-for-all and this place became the most exciting art space in europe for
00:26:44 a while i think um anytime you went in there um there were all sorts of things going on whether
00:26:50 it was dance or theatre or art or music or whatever, the space was entirely uncurated.
00:26:58 Anybody could go there and do whatever they wanted, and you could turn up at any time
00:27:04 and see pretty much anything you wanted.
00:27:07 As an economic model, it was pretty ruinous in that I don't think anybody got paid anything
00:27:12 for doing it, but as an artistic space it was very exciting simply because there were
00:27:19 very few administrators or curators involved and these were people and and I
00:27:25 say this is somebody who wants less curation of the left or the right in the
00:27:29 future I mean that they some it was a very creative space because there are
00:27:34 very few curators well I just want to go back and say that that I agree very much
00:27:44 with what Jacob was saying because I think that there is that there is a
00:27:46 separation that you can easily draw between you know the Shaftesbury Avenue, the West End, the
00:27:50 Cameron Mackintosh theatres which are far more commercial institutions really catering to a
00:27:54 tourist crowd. I mean they want bums on seats and you have to appeal to the public. Other arts
00:27:59 institutions don't really appeal to the masses and so you know you have Thriller the musical,
00:28:03 you've got Tina Turner the musical, ABBA the musical, all those sort of things going on in
00:28:07 the West End. But you know there is a cultural crisis happening right now, this idea of a
00:28:11 monoculture this cancel culture where if you dare to disagree even in the slightest way or even to
00:28:17 espouse something which was mainstream a mainstream views 10 years ago will now lead to you being
00:28:22 cancelled by people in the arts by publishers by by art galleries by by theatres there there's a
00:28:28 problem i mean our show is called counterculture and i've heard a few comments over the months
00:28:32 from people who said well you're you chaps are conservative how can you be the counterculture
00:28:36 that's the irony we have now become the counterculture and the establishment are actually
00:28:40 now the radical left and that's why i'm saying that a radical times call for radical measures
00:28:45 and it's time for the right or at least those who are mainstream center left and center right
00:28:49 to into it to it to espouse radical proposals now i'm not saying at all that there should be a
00:28:55 minister a minister of culture whose dictates where the funds go or in any way tries to influence
00:29:01 the type of productions that are being put out there or the type of exhibitions what i'm saying
00:29:04 is that if an institution or its directors are in any way supporting this cancel culture or in any
00:29:11 way stifling the variety and breadth of expression that's out there, then funding should be cut from
00:29:18 those institutions. And that's what I'm trying to say. We should encourage all types of performance
00:29:24 and expression and funding should be allocated to those institutions that allow for that wide
00:29:30 display. I mean, I agree in principle. It would be lovely to see some of the more egregious
00:29:37 examples of cultural bias in the arts establishment punished for their relentless promotion of
00:29:48 their ideology. That would be great to see. But practically, I don't see how a government
00:29:54 could intervene because it would become terribly legalistic and it would become politically
00:30:00 dynamite I mean you would have the you would have the you would have the liberal establishment
00:30:07 down on you like a ton if you attempted any such thing but I just wanted to pick up on something
00:30:12 that William said which I think is is is perhaps a truism but what happened in Berlin in the years
00:30:21 after Germany regained its unity, that the art which sprang up was, of course, the creation
00:30:33 of the political moment. And that is true of all art, that all art exists within a political
00:30:42 moment. And the culture of that moment inevitably affects the arts. Now, I think what's happened
00:30:49 in Britain at the moment, is that it comes down to the simple principle of free speech.
00:30:57 I think that many people are muzzled, actually.
00:31:00 And this would be true for the arts, as it is true for many other areas of life.
00:31:07 It isn't just about the arts.
00:31:09 It is about wider society.
00:31:12 And, of course, the arts reflect wider society.
00:31:14 But I think the point is that the arts, I would say, always have, they have, they pride themselves on being free thinkers. Traditionally, they pride themselves on being edgy and provocative. They pride themselves on being challenging. And indeed, you know, the beacon of free speech. None of these things are really true anymore, are they?
00:31:36 I mean, you know, they're just, if anything, I sort of see them as the kind of visual display unit for the kind of ruling orthodoxies.
00:31:46 I mean, Peter, you know, something that Noam Chomsky, right, Chomsky is very clear about free speech.
00:31:54 What he says is that free speech, in its essence, means that you listen to people whose views you detest.
00:32:02 And actually, we hear none of that in the arts.
00:32:05 so actually I agree with you entirely
00:32:08 there is no freedom
00:32:09 of political speech within the
00:32:12 arts space at the moment in the UK
00:32:13 I mean
00:32:14 there we are
00:32:17 do you think
00:32:18 do you think that
00:32:20 the arts now have become
00:32:23 simply a part of the
00:32:25 leisure industry would you say
00:32:27 Jacob stop with you
00:32:30 I think
00:32:31 if I can just explain
00:32:33 If I could just explain that, if they don't really take on many of the issues that, you know, people feel are relevant, you know, whether it's Brexit, whether it's immigration, whether it's Islam, all of these things, which the arts do not go near, right?
00:32:51 They are surely losing their kind of broader relevance.
00:32:56 They just become a nice thing to do.
00:32:59 Yes, I think that's right.
00:33:00 and i think i personally hesitate with the term creative industries i don't really like it because
00:33:06 it over economizes um you know a free space if you like um i mean i think what we need
00:33:13 well i think the problems go back very very far and i think we need um a profound discussion really
00:33:20 about what the arts for and what culture is and we've completely lost our our sense of that
00:33:25 I think that was around in the early 90s and I think the free space in Berlin that William described
00:33:31 I really like the idea of a light touch curation and that realm of free expression but I think at
00:33:37 the moment the idea that you know we have institutions who bear a great responsibility
00:33:41 to preserve and guard and transmit things which are our collective inheritance and I'm very
00:33:49 concerned that we've lost that yeah well look gentlemen thanks very very much on that note
00:33:55 a rather downbeat ending
00:33:56 but I'm afraid
00:33:56 an appropriate one
00:33:58 I would say
00:33:58 thank you very much
00:34:00 to Jacob Phillips
00:34:01 thank you very much
00:34:02 William Cook
00:34:02 Rafe of course
00:34:04 and Robin Akin
00:34:05 that's it for
00:34:06 Counter Culture
00:34:07 this week
00:34:08 please do subscribe
00:34:10 won't you
00:34:11 it's very important
00:34:12 that you subscribe
00:34:13 and I look forward
00:34:15 to seeing you
00:34:16 next time
00:34:16 thank you very much
00:34:25 Thank you.