New Culture Forum - November 09, 2021


History Debunked: Multiculturalism is Not Part of Britain's History -- So Why Do We Pretend It Was?

Cop26: Hypocritical Eco-Circus + Online Safety Bill - Widdecombe, Webb & Woberts Nick Buckley: How I Fought Back Against Cancel Culture and Won

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

167.91

Word count

4,970

Sentence count

139

Harmful content

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is i'm peter whittle now on the new culture forum we talk
00:00:24 about history an awful lot. Over the past few weeks we've had David Starkey on and Andrew Roberts.
00:00:31 That's because people love it and also because it's one of the great subjects which seems to
00:00:36 be popular generally on the internet. So I'm delighted that today my guest is Simon Webb.
00:00:43 Simon is host of History Debunked. It's a channel which despite being relatively new
00:00:50 has got something like 20 million views behind it and a hundred thousand subscribers so well
00:00:56 first of all congratulations on that thank you thank um it's great to see you history debunked
00:01:02 we're living in a time where everyone around us apparently seems to be wanting to debunk some
00:01:10 history what what what is the what's the mission behind your channel the mission is really simple
00:01:16 I've written quite a few books on history, particularly little-known aspects of history,
00:01:22 the things that people don't realise to do with the First and Second World War, the Victorian
00:01:29 period. And when I started the channel, that was the purpose, to look at those things. Gradually,
00:01:36 though, I became interested in the way that history is being slanted to make Britain look
00:01:43 like a multicultural country from thousands of years ago. And this is not only being done
00:01:50 academically, this is also being done in popular culture. So you might have heard of a television
00:01:56 series called Bridgerton on Netflix. The Queen of England there was shown to be black, which is
00:02:04 really grotesque, but that's been a view that's been propagated by the mainstream press. So I
00:02:12 i wanted to look at that and see why it was being done and how it was being done well why do you
00:02:19 think it's being done i mean is this because is this uh i mean this is sort of thing we hear about
00:02:24 a lot of times i mean like whether it's in advertisements on tv or for example uh with
00:02:30 the series about anne boleyn recently um is it to try to convince people that this was ever thus
00:02:37 is that what you're saying i think it is and it's partly because it's fashionable people
00:02:42 um get in get the idea into their heads if they're making an historical series
00:02:47 they had better throw in some people of color otherwise it they're going to have trouble
00:02:53 getting advertisers and funding do you see that um a lot of time now if you want to get funding
00:03:00 for something a lot of television programs have got some sort of funding or backing
00:03:04 there are diversity policies that have to be complied with so they have to have a certain
00:03:09 number of black actors and a certain number of indian actors and so it naturally comes about
00:03:15 that they work them in yes it in fact i think it's actually in the rules as you say like the
00:03:21 bafta rules that when it comes to being nominated for awards you have to have shown certain level
00:03:28 of diversity either in front of or behind the camera but the problem surely with this is like
00:03:33 you said Bridgerton and I watched a bit of Bridgerton um is that in fact by giving a the wrong
00:03:38 impression it sort of it doesn't maybe help if you like uh the multicultural lobby in the sense
00:03:46 that you know if you have mixed race couples walking about in Regency London which could was
00:03:53 not the case um some people will look at it and say well what are you complaining about it was
00:03:58 always like it erases racism yes the same thing happened with the new adaptation of the H.E. Bates
00:04:04 novels the Darling Buds of Spring in those you have a tax inspector who's black you have a pub 0.96
00:04:10 landlord who's black the village school teacher is black all in a little rural community in Kent 0.98
00:04:16 in the 1950s I remember the 1950s a black person would have would a have stuck out like a sore thumb
00:04:24 and b you'll be made very unwelcome and yet there's no racism shown everybody is shown getting on as
00:04:31 well as they would today well that yes exactly so that is actually a lie isn't i mean you know in a
00:04:35 way it's sort of it's not actually telling the truth and there's two different ways of looking
00:04:40 at that um you said that the you started off looking at various uh issues in history but this
00:04:48 has become in other words more political for you yes it has become more political because the more
00:04:54 see it happening the more irritating i find it and the more that i find that people are unable to
00:04:59 speak about it for fear of being called racist even raising a topic even asking about advertisements 0.97
00:05:07 and why all advertisements have to feature mixed-race couples which they nearly all do these
00:05:12 days even asking that question will get people looking at you as though you're there's something
00:05:17 suspicious about you as though you're a neo-nazi or white supremacist and do you get that of course
00:05:22 Yes I do get it. I've had death threats via email and all sorts of things. There are some people on
00:05:29 my channel who complain about every video I make every single day. I usually put up two videos a
00:05:35 day and I've seen some of the commenters there boasting on Twitter that they complain to YouTube
00:05:41 about every single video as a matter of principle. And what do YouTube do vis-a-vis you? I mean have
00:05:48 they suspend me they suspend me for a week or two weeks right and if you get three strikes in three
00:05:55 months they simply terminate the channel and that's the end of it right yes it's right three
00:06:00 strikes and you're outside that's it and you're permanently banned then from youtube when you
00:06:05 started this which was what 18 months ago you said uh did you were you surprised how are you
00:06:10 surprised how it's taken off yes i thought it was a fairly obscure idea i didn't think most people
00:06:16 were interested because you seldom see debate about this in newspapers people don't even like
00:06:22 to talk about it in public on trains in case someone takes offense i was surprised that once
00:06:28 i started discussing it and putting on youtube so many people were interested in talking about it
00:06:34 um and and is it it's fair to say basically now that this is your this is your main
00:06:43 a motor stop around, i.e. the political side of it? I mean, or do you still do subjects that are
00:06:50 not really anything to do with? I do from time to time, yes, but I have to say in the main it is
00:06:56 political, it's looking at today's society and seeing how history, you could say that it's
00:07:01 keeping to the theme of history debunked because the history that we're seeing now increasingly
00:07:07 is not true it's not factual the history that's being projected uh we're being told for example
00:07:13 that there was a black roman emperor and that he died in britain and there were black soldiers
00:07:19 state roman soldiers in britain that's completely untrue it's absolute nonsense but it's being put
00:07:25 into children's books and it's being taught at school um why did you get interested in history
00:07:33 I mean you said you've written before I mean was this something you've had since you were growing
00:07:38 up or? Yes I mean I've written for magazines and newspapers but the writing of the books only
00:07:44 started a few years ago I say a few years ago perhaps 10 or 11 years ago it started with
00:07:49 education I'm a home educator I didn't send my daughter to school at all and I wrote a book
00:07:57 about that. So you homeschooled your daughter? Yeah, my daughter didn't go to school at all.
00:08:03 Really? And the reason was for these reasons? No, no, the reason was that I didn't see the
00:08:09 point in sending to school. I knew that I would be able to teach her more effectively. You know,
00:08:16 one-to-one tuition in a relaxed domestic setting is far more efficient than having 30 children in
00:08:22 a class taught by one person. So I knew that it would be more efficient if I did it myself.
00:08:27 Oh I see, so it wasn't a political thing? No, it was simply I wanted to have a good education.
00:08:33 And so what about your interest in history? Was that self-taught or...?
00:08:38 Largely self-taught, yes, but also inspired by the difference. There's a rather a dislocation
00:08:46 between what you see people saying in real life people reminiscing say about the first world war
00:08:54 and what you read in history books so my grandfather fought in the first world war
00:08:59 through all the great battles and i remember he was a huge fan of hague you know field marshal hague
00:09:06 every remembrance day he had hague's picture up on the mantelpiece and that's really the how a lot
00:09:12 of old soldiers viewed Haig and yet if you look at history books and talk to people today the
00:09:18 impression is that Haig was a callous butcher. So there's a difference between the history that
00:09:24 ordinary people experience and the history as it is written by upper middle class people and
00:09:30 academics. So where is the debunking there then? I mean you know you know were you saying you
00:09:39 talk about Haig for example in your time, are you saying he was actually a good guy or is that
00:09:44 and the demunking is that he's been taught as a bad guy? Sure, in schools today, the secondary
00:09:49 schools, they use clips of Blackadder to teach First World War history which is grotesque and
00:09:56 so the view that the children are being indoctrinated with is a view of a left-wing
00:10:01 comedian. But Haig himself was a decent soldier. The Somme, far from being a disaster, was a turning
00:10:07 point in the first world war it was what one german general described as a muddy grave of
00:10:13 the german field army as far as the germans were concerned it was a disaster for them
00:10:18 and from some onward from 1916 britain was almost bound to win uh something that happened after the
00:10:27 first world war which i noticed when i was looking through your slides i found fascinating was about
00:10:32 1919 i think you call it britain's unspoken revolution or could you tell us about that i
00:10:38 mean that's the sort of thing that you know we don't know about really well firstly the reason
00:10:43 we don't know about it is because things that happened just before or just after a world war
00:10:49 tend to be neglected a world war is such an immense event that we tend to lose track of
00:10:55 things that happened near near to it if you see what i mean so 1919 was really a continuation
00:11:01 of the industrial unrest that took place before the First World War. 1911 was known as the Great
00:11:07 Unrest because there was so much industrial action, troops called in, troops killed people
00:11:15 in Welsh mining towns at that time and so Britain was simmering on the brink of a great change before
00:11:22 the outbreak of war in 1914. There was quite a bit of anarchism as well wasn't there? Yes there was,
00:11:27 Yes, the anarchists were involved very heavily. After the First World War there were two strands
00:11:35 to this. The first strand was that the British army didn't demobilize troops immediately. They
00:11:42 didn't want to have a lot of demobilized soldiers, some of them without jobs, milling around the
00:11:47 streets. It was a recipe for anarchy and disorder. So instead they sent them off to fight in Russia
00:11:53 and kept them in camps in France.
00:11:57 They weren't being demobilised.
00:11:59 That led to a lot of mutinies in the army,
00:12:01 which meant that the British government couldn't rely upon the army.
00:12:05 And that's an absolute disaster.
00:12:08 I mean, the Russian Revolution, 0.91
00:12:10 the moment in which it became certain that it was all over with the Romanov dynasty,
00:12:15 was when the army wouldn't obey orders.
00:12:17 And in Britain, the same thing was looking as it would happen.
00:12:21 Troops weren't obeying orders and they were mutineering.
00:12:23 So that made a very dangerous situation.
00:12:27 Then you had the Triple Alliance of the rail workers and the miners and the transport people.
00:12:32 They were threatening a strike, so they needed troops to prevent that.
00:12:38 It was a very, the whole of Europe was in a revolutionary fervor.
00:12:42 There was even talk of a revolution in Switzerland.
00:12:45 There were armoured cars patrolling the streets of Zurich.
00:12:49 We forget this.
00:12:50 we forget that there were a lot of russia wasn't the only soviet republic that was set up the
00:12:55 soviet republics were set up in hungary germany actually had a revolution that no one ever talks
00:13:01 about now so it was a fairly dicey time for britain and there were these sort of uh in liverpool
00:13:08 battleships and stuff yes that's right they because they used troops in liverpool to combat
00:13:14 and the police went on strike and every time you have a police strike inevitably there is looting
00:13:21 and trouble it happened more recently in Canada in the 1960s there was a police strike the army
00:13:28 weren't able to restore order there were some army units called in and they were staged
00:13:34 bayonet charges they opened fire people were killed and it simply wasn't working so the
00:13:39 The government called in two warships from Scarpa Flow and brought them to the harbour.
00:13:47 And they were in the harbour with their guns trained on Liverpool as a sign, a bit of sabre-rattling,
00:13:53 to show people that if need be, the government were prepared to shell the city.
00:13:58 How Bolshevik was it, you know, in terms of what was behind?
00:14:04 I'm not at all sure it was Bolshevik.
00:14:06 Some of the main people, the agitators, were the British Legion, you know, the ex-servicemen organisations, because they came home when they were demobilised finally, they thought they were going to be treated as heroes, they thought that they would be getting a different sort of life, and it was obvious that they weren't going to, and so that caused a huge amount of discontent.
00:14:28 The thing is that when you describe that situation, I would say that that is obviously something not popularly really known, and also it would sort of tend to go against the kind of, would you call it, the weak view of history or whatever, that we've been remarkably civically unviolent as a country, all of this, and that things have just evolved, we've had a good relationship with the police and all of that.
00:14:57 So one could say that that debunking is actually quite a left-wing thing. I mean, can you see what I mean?
00:15:04 I see exactly what you mean, but then I suppose I don't really think in terms very often of left-wing or right-wing.
00:15:12 When I was invited to come here I didn't think, oh gosh, this is a right-wing place that I'm going to.
00:15:18 I tend to look at things and then ask myself what seems sensible, what seems right to me and accurate.
00:15:25 Yes. So you don't, you say you don't have a particular political, you don't, you don't have a party or anything like that? No.
00:15:34 I suspect you've got a healthy scepticism about the whole party thing, have you?
00:15:39 Yes, I have. I wouldn't trust the Prime Minister to look after my house for the weekend. But having said that, I wouldn't let Kish Starmer near my possessions either, because I don't trust any of them.
00:15:52 no um history obviously is right to the fore at the moment all the statue business and everything
00:15:59 sure um again you know i was last year horrified by what i saw as this topping of statues and
00:16:08 defacing it was and everything but would you say as well that this has happened regularly throughout
00:16:13 history yeah of course in this this country yes not quite some i mean there's been iconoclism
00:16:19 you think of the reformation a lot of statues and images of saints were smashed up then it
00:16:25 happens from time to time less often in this country probably but it has happened um but
00:16:34 what is your what would your solution be to this problem of now history basically being
00:16:43 taught to kids through a very particular lens which you've already mentioned how would you
00:16:52 deal with that it's an extraordinarily difficult question to ask because an awful lot of teachers
00:16:59 do tend to be a bit left with you and um a bit yeah well quite so even if we were to draw up an
00:17:06 entirely new curriculum they would find ways to frustrate it they would find ways of not teaching
00:17:11 it and i've seen this happen i used to teach at one time i know a lot of teachers still and if
00:17:18 they're given orders to do a certain thing they will simply avoid doing it the union will cut up
00:17:24 so it it's a problem i suppose you'd have to start with training teachers in a different way
00:17:30 so this would take a generation yes we've done some work on on the new culture forum and it does
00:17:38 you know it's the teacher training side of things I remember Lord Pearson saying that
00:17:42 back in the 80s when he looked into it there was this attempt to drench the syllabus in gender
00:17:50 race and and class actually at that point that seems to have gone now um but here we are what
00:17:58 a generation later two generations later and indeed those are the things of course which are
00:18:02 drenching every sort of, not just history, it's sort of other science. It seeps in everywhere,
00:18:09 that's absolutely right. I mean do you feel a sense of foreboding about the future
00:18:18 as someone who's interested in history or do you not see it that way? Well there's two points here,
00:18:24 firstly I'm no longer a young man, I'm going to die relatively soon, speaking at a wide span of
00:18:32 things so it probably won't affect me all that much right but yes thinking of the future now
00:18:40 i'm not particularly optimistic about the future of young people because unless they are taught
00:18:49 facts unless they learn the reality and real things they're going to be in a bit of a pickle
00:18:57 in their lives well the point is surely isn't it that it's just like a human being if you don't know
00:19:02 what you were before how can you possibly live in the future how can you be ready for things in the
00:19:10 future if you have no idea of what you are it's the same for a country isn't it it's the same for
00:19:14 the country but for children it's absolutely catastrophic because it cuts them off from a
00:19:19 whole lot of british culture and a whole lot of high culture i'll give an example i'm a great fan
00:19:24 of um anthony trollope and dickens too come to that now in some of those books the whole point
00:19:31 Dr Thorne by Trollope and Bleak House by Dickens
00:19:34 both centre around women who are illegitimate 0.99
00:19:37 and it's a huge scandal 0.94
00:19:39 they're set in Victorian England
00:19:41 and illegitimacy was an enormous scandal then
00:19:45 and the whole themes of the book
00:19:47 the plots hinge around it
00:19:48 no young person today
00:19:51 unless they've studied history
00:19:52 will be able to make any sense of either of those books
00:19:55 unless they've got a proper grounding in history
00:19:59 they'll read those books
00:20:00 they won't understand what on earth is going on, because of course illegitimacy today is nothing at all,
00:20:06 it's the rule rather than the exception. So in that way not being familiar or acquainted with history
00:20:13 is going to prevent them from being able to appreciate great literature, just to give one example.
00:20:20 The problem is, so I would say, is that the great literature is itself under attack.
00:20:25 It is.
00:20:25 I mean, during last year's, you know, riots and disturbances, someone had a go at Dickens'
00:20:34 house down in Broadstairs, didn't they?
00:20:36 Yes.
00:20:37 I think they just put graffiti on it, in fact, that's what they did.
00:20:40 But I mean, essentially, we talk about history, but yes, you're hearing, for example, of European
00:20:48 classical composers of the stature I would call, you know, geniuses, you know, people
00:20:53 Mozart and Beethoven, gradually being undermined. Same with literature. This is a cultural-wide thing,
00:21:01 is it not? Yeah, it's an attack on high culture, which is partly based, it's partly racism,
00:21:06 it's partly also class, because the idea is that working-class children and ethnic minorities
00:21:14 should be given something other than high culture, that high culture is predominantly white and male,
00:21:20 and so we'll have to do away with that. But it actually used to be, before this became the 0.77
00:21:25 emphasis, because I remember discussing it a huge amount, like 20 years or so ago,
00:21:29 it became, oh well we can't expect those people to like this, so we've just basically got to teach
00:21:35 this form of music, pop music, or something like that, you can't expect, whereas when I was at
00:21:41 school, which was an ordinary primary school, I remember us being taken along to the festival hall,
00:21:46 that's right and okay it would just eat a nutcracker or something like that but essentially
00:21:51 the point was that you you could make your mind up no one was forcing you but it seems to me that
00:21:57 that it's assumed now that this this is forget it there's no hope in that it is assumed that's
00:22:03 absolutely correct the idea at one time certainly when i was a child at school the idea was to try
00:22:08 and draw children up especially i come from despite how i speak i come from very working class
00:22:14 background and i went to a very working class school where was this story uh simon where did
00:22:20 you grow up uh i was born in custom house oh when the east end yes oh right okay so that's changed a
00:22:27 bit you may well say something but now the emphasis seems to be on going down the emphasis
00:22:36 seems to be in catering for the lowest thing so whereas in music classes when i was young
00:22:41 They might have tried to get people to appreciate classical music. Today, it's got to be just pop music or African drumming.
00:22:50 Nothing that smacks of high culture wishes to be 0.99
00:22:55 used. Yes, I think in before, I think now it might well be, oh, because this is seen as
00:23:01 Eurocentric and white and everything. But I think before it was a form of kind of elitism in an odd way.
00:23:07 You can't be expected to. Yeah, of course.
00:23:10 That's a big turnaround isn't it? It is, yes. So you grew up in Custom House, when did you leave
00:23:18 London? I was born in Custom House, I've lived in all sorts of different places, I lived in Israel
00:23:24 for some years, I've moved about a lot in my life. I was born in Custom House and I grew up in East
00:23:30 London yeah another part of East London yes and you know because I'm a Londoner as well
00:23:39 and a lot of people are now leaving London a huge amount of people are leaving that
00:23:44 well yes you say that but the population is soaring 30 years ago the population of greater
00:23:50 London was just under 7 million today it's 9 million so yes 2 million more people have come
00:23:56 but an awful lot of people have left which accounts I mean you can see it on the streets 0.84
00:24:01 it's no secret that this is a product of immigration nearly all the immigrants that
00:24:06 come to this country want to live in southeast England particularly London yeah and there's a
00:24:11 big fuss if attempts are being made to send some Afghan immigrants to parts of Wales and Scotland
00:24:18 and they're being resisted furiously because those people want to live in London yes yes 1.00
00:24:25 Well, you can sort of see why they would want it. I mean, you know, because you can...
00:24:28 I don't blame them at all for wanting it, but it's the same reason before I lived in the Epping
00:24:33 Forest District for a little over 20 years. Before that, I was living in Tottenham. But
00:24:38 Tottenham became such a place that it was not a safe environment, and it wasn't a pleasant
00:24:43 environment, and so we moved out into Essex. And yes, it's known in America as a white flight, 1.00
00:24:51 obviously, you'd see a lot of it in London. Actually when you mentioned America there, 0.65
00:24:57 there's this whole 1619 project, isn't there, which is, just in case anyone, it's basically
00:25:04 an attempt to essentially delegitimize the founding fathers, isn't it, and to make the
00:25:09 foundation date of America's when the first slaves came, I think. That's right, yeah. 0.53
00:25:13 And this, but this is sort of, this seems to have, are you surprised, as someone who, you know, loves history, at the speed with which this has happened, say like in America, so quickly, this kind of turnaround?
00:25:28 Yeah, I am slightly surprised at it. But sometimes once the ball gets rolling, things happen really, really quickly.
00:25:36 And things do become fashionable. You know, fashions change in history and culture just as they do in everything else.
00:25:44 And at the moment, the fashion is very much to emphasise ethnic minorities, to emphasise black and brown people, 0.77
00:25:50 and to try and, if possible, neglect white people. It's just how things go. It might change again. 0.73
00:25:57 What is the kind of, I suppose, you know, what is the sort of reaction of your, you have obviously very loyal viewers, right, what do you think they get out of your broadcasts?
00:26:10 I'm saying what they think, but dare not say. I'm saying the sort of things that they wouldn't even say probably, in fact I know this, that they wouldn't say in public on a bus or a train,
00:26:21 because they're afraid that people will either call them racist
00:26:25 or they might be abused or assaulted for saying so.
00:26:29 So I'm giving a voice to white people in particular,
00:26:32 white working class people,
00:26:34 who feel that they cannot speak their minds,
00:26:37 that they can't say what they are thinking.
00:26:40 And I'm often told this by people that get in touch with me
00:26:45 that aren't wanting me to be shot.
00:26:48 i'm told that they are grateful because i'm giving them a voice yes yes hey are you a nostalgic man
00:26:56 or not or i mean because i had this conversation recently with someone else uh but basically
00:27:00 there we always you know people who tend to talk about past they're always sort of you know
00:27:08 tarp with this brush if somehow or other you know they're nostalgic for another time or
00:27:13 but but would you say you are a kind of you live in the present i mean even though you've got
00:27:18 views about the present that you you live in the present of course i live in the present
00:27:22 well no some people don't well i i don't think that the past certainly you know you look back
00:27:29 60 or 70 years was particularly brilliant you know it's it's wonderful to be able to have
00:27:35 color televisions in your own home it's wonderful to be able to carry a color television around
00:27:40 and have unlimited access to any knowledge in the world just by tapping a few keys.
00:27:45 I think the present is a brilliant place, but it's not perfect.
00:27:50 So I can see things that are wrong and things that were better in the past.
00:27:53 But no, I'm not nostalgic for the past.
00:27:56 Will you carry on doing the channel as it stands,
00:27:59 or are there any new things you're thinking of doing, plans for it?
00:28:04 Well, OK, the thing is, I've written a book.
00:28:07 I got a grant from an American think tank, the Conrute Foundation, to enable me to write a book about race and how ideology rather than science now dictates our ideas on race.
00:28:23 That book is going to be published in PDF format.
00:28:27 We're just going to give it away to people.
00:28:29 So I'll probably be setting up a website to distribute that book.
00:28:34 It's not being done through a publisher at all.
00:28:36 this is being done entirely as a private enterprise both by the conroe foundation and me
00:28:43 so we'll be distributing that book and it's quite a long way it's 115 000 words and it's fully
00:28:49 referenced right okay it's quite a hefty volume are you finished right it's finished it's all
00:28:54 ready to go so yes that will be the next project okay right well look thank you very much for
00:29:01 telling us all about the channel and you don't do interviews on Noel do you on yours or do you
00:29:08 well as I say I only have a little flip video mini video camera right from about a hundred years ago
00:29:16 so no unless someone wants to come into my house and take it in turns to put their head in front
00:29:20 of the screen it's not possible oh well you know it says it sounds like a way but thank you very
00:29:26 much for joining us I've really enjoyed it thank you all the very best you that's it for so what
00:29:31 you're saying is this week we shall see you next time thank you very much