New Culture Forum - July 19, 2020


Ignorant & Insidious - Cancel Culture Threatens Our Shared Inheritance

Marc Sidwell Reads From His Book: The Long March - How The Left Won The Culture War SOS, SAVE OUR STATUES -- SaveOurStatues.org.uk -- Join To Defend Britain's Heritage

Episode Stats


Length

5 minutes

Words per minute

170.47

Word count

946

Sentence count

57


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Could anything better sum up the current state of affairs than the attempt to cancel George
00:00:16 Orwell? I'm sure he'd see the funny side of all of this, of being accused by some obscure
00:00:21 journalist on Twitter of being a government snitch, a turncoat and a traitor. The man literally took
00:00:27 a bullet in the neck fighting fascism in Spain. Not all cancellations are made equal. When
00:00:32 he returned from the front during the Spanish Civil War, he found that his militia had been
00:00:36 consumed by communist infighting and essentially outlawed. His comrades were rounded up and
00:00:41 executed while he and his wife managed to flee to France. Revolutionaries have a habit
00:00:47 of devouring each other like that. Orwell recalled the horrible atmosphere of Barcelona
00:00:51 during that time. The fear, suspicion, hatred, censorship. It shouldn't surprise us then that
00:00:58 they want to cancel him. He gave us the best intellectual tools for showing up their dangerous
00:01:02 nonsense, including words like newspeak. He had their number. He saw their loathing for the working
00:01:09 class, the detachment of the intelligentsia from the people, who took their cookery from Paris and
00:01:15 their opinions from Moscow. Not much has changed. England is still a place where the elite are
00:01:20 ashamed of being English, snigger at every institution, who would sooner steal from the
00:01:25 poor box than sing God Save the Queen. We saw it after the Brexit vote, those knuckle-dragging
00:01:31 troglodytes who shouldn't even have the vote if they're too stupid to use it properly.
00:01:35 And we've seen it everywhere in recent weeks. Take the BBC as an example, and the bunch of
00:01:40 middle-class white women laying into the new boogeyman, the Karen. Never mind the fact that
00:01:45 this is a recycled trope of the hysterical woman. The left are oblivious to their own sexism and
00:01:50 racism and think that they can act with impunity, because they can. What was most shocking was how
00:01:56 viciously snobby, crass and condescending it was. How can white women not be Karen, they asked.
00:02:03 The answer, educate yourself, read some books and shut up. This snooty elitism has an exclusive
00:02:09 language that excludes everyone from gammons to Karen. They clearly get an endorphin rush from
00:02:14 their snobbery, but it has serious implications. For all their cause to educate yourself and read
00:02:19 some books, the people at the helm have shown themselves to be profoundly ignorant. This might
00:02:24 be because facts and figures don't really matter to the activists. In my experience researching
00:02:29 extremism, this is fertile ground indeed. Just take a few examples. They wanted to remove the
00:02:35 Emancipation Memorial in the US even though it was funded by freed slaves. They vandalised the
00:02:40 statue of Cervantes, the author of Don Quixote, who was himself a slave, captured by Ottoman
00:02:46 pirates. It's a dangerous moral distortion where the founding fathers are as much fair game as the
00:02:51 confederates, abolitionists as much as slave owners. There is original sin, but there can be
00:02:57 no forgiveness. One man to whom educating yourself really meant something was the famous slave and
00:03:02 abolitionist Frederick Douglass. The son of a slave owner and a slave, Douglass taught himself
00:03:07 to read and write in secret, realizing that this was his path to freedom. He became an
00:03:12 exquisite orator, and on the anniversary of his famous speech denouncing slavery, vandals
00:03:17 tore down his statue. Without any self-awareness at all, I was told by one academic that on
00:03:22 the very spot in Oxford where in 1555 three martyrs were burnt to death, including the
00:03:27 then Archbishop of Canterbury, he saw a student shouting, burn roads. Educating yourself about
00:03:34 history undermines revolutionary zeal. A proper historical education wouldn't just include the
00:03:40 politically expedient parts, it's ideology, not history, that they want taught. A rounded history
00:03:46 would include the campaign to abolish the slave trade, the Royal Navy's role in stopping slave
00:03:51 ships crossing the Atlantic and Indian Oceans, and the horrors of the Arab, trans-Sub-Saharan
00:03:56 and Barbary slave trades. The problem is that history, in all its beautiful and dark complexity,
00:04:02 is irrelevant to the activists and iconoclasts.
00:04:06 We've allowed lazy and politicised academia to take root.
00:04:10 Examples of ignorance are ten a penny.
00:04:12 The motivating ideology says everything is complicit in white supremacy,
00:04:16 so nothing can be taken off the table.
00:04:18 It's our shared inheritance that's at risk.
00:04:20 We're custodians and have no right to let anyone destroy it.
00:04:24 Yet vicars have already shown concern that the leadership of the church,
00:04:27 by conceding an inch, have thrown our historical treasures to the iconoclasts.
00:04:31 White depictions of Jesus are already on the menu with no respect for the faithful who created them.
00:04:37 When a priest in the US tried to educate the crowd in St. Louis,
00:04:41 whose statue they wanted to pull down, he was shouted down,
00:04:44 with one person ominously saying that the cathedral was next.
00:04:48 Once you've conceded, you can't placate the mob with historical nuance.
00:04:52 They don't care.
00:04:53 What we're realising is that it isn't just the living who can be cancelled,
00:04:57 and it has terrible implications for real people and their shared inheritance,
00:05:01 but most importantly, for truth. In the past week, 150 writers signed a letter criticising
00:05:07 ideological conformity and cancel culture. Nothing could have been more apt than the
00:05:12 fact that within hours they turned on each other, with some people wanting to remove
00:05:16 their signature because they didn't agree with the other signatories. Too many people
00:05:21 throughout history have thought it was a good idea to feed the crocodile in the hope that
00:05:25 it would eat them last. If history tells us anything, once they've torn society apart,
00:05:30 they will eventually turn on each other.