New Culture Forum - October 04, 2022


Immigration: Britain Needs a Meloni Not a Truss. Truss Wants an Open Door to the World

Modern Wisdom: From Love Island Model to Acclaimed Podcaster - A Journey of Curiosity

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

159.52

Word count

6,948

Sentence count

114


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to this week's Newspeak, the New Culture Forum's current affairs program.
00:00:10 My name is Emma Webb and this week I'm joined by the director of the New Culture Forum Peter Whittle,
00:00:14 Philip Kisserley who is a senior fellow at the New Culture Forum and Alp Mehmet our special guest
00:00:20 today from Migration Watch. So this week there has been a lot in the news about immigration would
00:00:25 you like to kick us off by explaining a little bit about this this announcement of Liz Truss's
00:00:31 intention to shall we say loosen the immigration rules. Yes the funny thing is that the system has
00:00:41 already been loosened to the point of ridiculousness it's absolutely absurd that we should
00:00:48 be looking to loosen it even further it reminds me of peter mandelson when in 2014 i think it was
00:00:58 or 2013 he referred back to the start of the century when he said we're sending out search
00:01:04 parties we were sending out search parties for migrant workers that seems to be what liz truss
00:01:12 is proposing now it's absolutely absurd and certainly very unconservative so what she wants
00:01:21 to do essentially as i understand it is she wants to loosen the immigration rules in order to help
00:01:26 kick-start the economy to stimulate she thinks it will stimulate growth and she wants to do this by
00:01:32 having what looks like freedom of movement with countries like is it in india and nigeria well i
00:01:38 don't about Nigeria if there's a trade deal in the offing with them but certainly with India
00:01:42 bearing in mind the population of India is almost one and a half billion which is three times the
00:01:50 size of the EU we spent 40 years complaining about free movement not quite 40 years but certainly
00:01:57 the last 20 years complaining about free movement and here we are voluntarily placing ourselves in
00:02:04 exactly the same situation with a country that's considerably poorer I might add than the EU of
00:02:13 course they will come here if they've got the opportunity it really beggars belief. And this
00:02:18 is a U-turn isn't it because before this point the Conservatives have been talking about low
00:02:23 skilled immigration and in terms of wage depression and actually being the opposite of stimulating
00:02:30 growth so what do you think accounts for this sudden U-turn with Liz Truss thinking that this
00:02:34 is going to boost the economy in some way.
00:02:36 I don't think actually, and I don't know whether Al would agree with this,
00:02:38 but I don't think it's actually a U-turn.
00:02:40 I think it's a continuation and an intensification
00:02:44 because what I can see is that whatever they might have said,
00:02:48 whatever the rhetoric was,
00:02:51 the immigration system was liberalised considerably
00:02:54 in the past three or four years.
00:02:56 But their manifesto pledge was to,
00:02:59 even though actions speak louder than words,
00:03:01 their manifesto pledge was to lower net migration and Suella Braverman and Kemi Badenoch have
00:03:10 criticised the government for this on the grounds that they are basically going back
00:03:14 on. So Boris Johnson's last speech at the Conservative Party conference where he made
00:03:21 it very clear that there was a relationship between low skilled migration and wage suppression
00:03:26 so actually this doesn't stimulate growth.
00:03:28 It just represents a vote of no confidence really doesn't it in British industry and
00:03:39 the development of the top end of British industry it's almost as though we're sitting back on
00:03:44 low skills and just you know waiting to die in a way you know I heard it and this was just on the
00:03:53 back of the the kind of mini budget wasn't it and I was kind of quite buoyed by that
00:03:58 I have to say and then I heard this news and I just felt a wave of despair you know I thought
00:04:05 that's the future gone you know it just felt as though I just wanted to I was just saying to Peter
00:04:12 before I just wanted to put my my fingers in my ears and close my eyes and go no no no no
00:04:16 it just seemed like an absolute vote of no confidence. Do you think this is a betrayal?
00:04:21 It is a betrayal, yes absolutely. Just to go back to what Peter was saying, it is a continuation
00:04:28 of what was going on. I mean Boris Johnson was an avowed open door, I'm a great fan of immigration
00:04:37 he said when he was mayor. He continued in that vein when he became prime minister. In 2010 the
00:04:43 Conservatives said that they would get immigration down to tens of thousands. In 2015 they said
00:04:49 exactly the same thing in 2017 again they would reduce it last time they were going to control
00:04:58 it control and that would according to boris johnson also reduce immigration it did no such
00:05:06 thing and they knew it why they're doing it now allegedly it's going to kick start the economy
00:05:13 well if we need to bring in cheap labor to kick dust kick start to the economy heaven help us
00:05:19 frankly it will do no such thing cheap low scale low low low skill low pay immigration actually
00:05:29 costs the exchequer it doesn't contribute to the exchequer and that in itself is going to be a
00:05:37 problem because you've got all these people coming in needing housing over their heads
00:05:42 needing medical attention, needing all sorts of services. It's a disaster frankly.
00:05:49 What did you think about, also in the news this week, the defeat of the legal challenge
00:05:57 against the deportation of Albanians? Because according to the Home Office I found this
00:06:01 unbelievable. Six in ten of those crossing the channel are from Albania. So these
00:06:07 are not people who were fleeing from war-torn countries, they're coming mostly it seems from
00:06:11 Albania so could you tell us a bit more about that legal challenge? Well we have to be careful here,
00:06:18 the six in ten that followed some sort of research investigation as a result of a leak I believe
00:06:27 and it covered a particular period over a month or six weeks or something and during that period
00:06:36 it seems that 60% of those crossing in boats were from Albania now undoubtedly there are Albanians
00:06:43 coming now whether overall it's 60% Albanians I just wouldn't like to say nevertheless whether
00:06:51 they're coming from Albania or anywhere else they know that once they get into a dinghy the
00:06:58 likelihood is that they will end up here and they will never go anywhere else for so long as they
00:07:04 want to stay. What did you think of this Philip? Again it was it was just a wave of despair because
00:07:09 it's I've been to Albania and it is pretty much a third world country you know and the people
00:07:21 who are coming over are male and there is a an ex-prison population that is coming over as well
00:07:28 I think there was some mad statistic about how there are more Albanians or almost more
00:07:34 Albanians in British prisons in Albania. Yeah I'm not quite sure about the statistics I
00:07:40 I wouldn't quote it but again it's the same thing and if you think about that and you think about
00:07:46 it on the back of what's been going on in Leicester what's been going on outside the Iranian embassy
00:07:51 we're just importing a whole load of the world's trouble and having to deal with it and dealing
00:07:56 with it badly as well. I have to say actually on that point it's very interesting when you see the
00:08:03 the way that the police react to those demonstrations the kind of softly softly
00:08:08 approach they take you know whatever your view on vaccines or the pandemic the way that those people
00:08:16 were treated in their demonstrations as opposed to the way that these people are being treated.
00:08:20 Well it's ideological policing, it's a two-tier system.
00:08:24 Two-tier policing, but I think the thing is what worries me about this and Marie is that I think
00:08:31 absolutely alluded to it is that there are there's this two strains on the what you might call the
00:08:36 conservative side of looking. One is that we are a nation and that we are a country with a history
00:08:42 and all of those things, the other one sees the balance sheet alone right, free marketeer
00:08:48 fundamentalists right they don't really care about immigration they don't really understand
00:08:52 patriotism i don't think they don't even understand those sorts of very unquantifiable things
00:08:58 or rather they don't care about them and that seems to be the approach that seems to have
00:09:04 have won actually it seems those those people don't see the country as a country with all of
00:09:11 those cultural and heritage and history and all those things they see the country as a receptacle
00:09:16 But even on that level, surely even if you were talking on an opportunist level, I'm
00:09:24 still surprised that they actually announce this kind of thing or let it be known that
00:09:30 this is what they're going to do, given the level of public concern about it, it seems
00:09:37 quite extraordinary to me.
00:09:38 Do you think in some part it's suicidal on the part of the Conservative Party?
00:09:43 obviously Liz Truss is modelling herself after Thatcher in many ways she thinks that if she if
00:09:48 she comes out with unpopular policies that work then eventually she'll mention it now rather than
00:09:57 mention it in a year's time I suppose. But do you think that that is actually unwise and that you
00:10:03 know Liz Truss is not Margaret Thatcher and even Margaret Thatcher I mean Dutch doesn't have a
00:10:08 completely sort of clean legacy in many people's opinions. Margaret Thatcher was a conviction
00:10:15 politician she had she had views she had ideas and she had a dynamism that moved forward Liz Truss
00:10:23 is dressing up as Margaret Thatcher I was just looking at the Labour Party conference today and
00:10:28 I was thinking you know has Keir Starmer got his Paul Smith suit yet you know and Liz Truss is
00:10:34 dressing up like Margaret Thatcher or playing the Margaret Thatcher card it's like deja vu light
00:10:41 isn't it you know we want ideas we want people moving forward we don't want role play. I thought my parents had done that decade so I didn't have to.
00:10:48 Yeah Emma sorry Philip call me Emma it's all right.
00:10:55 You could be whoever you want to be. Well yeah that's the way things are going I'm afraid
00:11:01 but look I my feeling is that this isn't just bad economics and bad social policy it's actually bad
00:11:10 politics what what she is doing is actually um putting a wedge between her and the people who
00:11:20 elected the last the conservative government in such droves wave goodbye only three years
00:11:26 now you can argue that well actually there's the blue wall and perhaps they're looking to take care
00:11:33 of that I don't think they will that would be extraordinarily unpopular in the red wall because
00:11:40 there's so much concern in the red what the red ball has already said we're not voting Tory again
00:11:46 the only way that she's likely to get them back is to actually be firm on immigration because
00:11:53 that's what they want but surely there's almost nowhere in the country this would be popular
00:11:57 except for metropolitan centres like London well and they don't vote for there's a lot of seats
00:12:02 around here there's in the west country uh the ones where the Lib Dems might might win so there
00:12:09 is an argument that says that um you you can't forget those the sort of middle centre left within
00:12:16 the Conservative Party, they need to be brought on board as well. The fact is that unless they
00:12:23 can persuade those who voted for them last time all to vote for them again, it won't be that the
00:12:30 North or whoever voted for them last time in the Red Walls is going to switch to Labour, they won't.
00:12:38 But even if they, if a few do, and by and large they step back and don't vote for anyone or vote
00:12:45 for Lawrence Fox or Richard Tice or whatever the fact is that will mean no majority in these
00:12:52 constituencies they've lost. But if you if you think the politics is bad and the policy is bad
00:12:57 then what what is she playing out what do you think her intentions are here? Treasury, it's the
00:13:03 Treasury going back many many years from my days as an immigration officer onwards they've always
00:13:10 felt that high immigration is good it generates activity in the economy and
00:13:15 that in itself is a good thing. But isn't that demonstrably untrue if it's
00:13:20 low-skilled immigration which is what they would get from an open-door policy
00:13:23 with India? It may generate activity in the economy it may grow the
00:13:29 economy but the fact is that as it grows so many people come in that the actual
00:13:35 spice for you, me, Peter, Philip remains the same and it's just the balance sheet it becomes a
00:13:42 Ponzi scheme. Yeah and actually that's a good segue because one of the other subjects we're
00:13:48 going to talk about today is Georgia Maloney who has just been elected Prime Minister in Italy and
00:13:56 she has made the point that in terms of globalism about us not just being you know not a digit
00:14:04 basically on an in some kind of balance sheet so what what is your view on her election she's been
00:14:10 in the headlines she's been described as being the most right-wing leader since Mussolini which
00:14:15 i guess is something that anybody um conservative in italy is going to be taught if you if you read
00:14:21 any of the mainstream media uh articles about uh uh whenever it was monday uh the word Mussolini
00:14:28 was just mentioned over and over and over i think there's one article where it was mentioned about
00:14:32 15 times um and and she keeps being called a fascist she's a christian you know fascists
00:14:40 aren't christians that's enough yeah um she's a christian she loves her country she's proud to be
00:14:45 a woman it's all of these things which are the most family and nation banal things in the world
00:14:50 really or they were yesterday and now they're far right you know so if she's far right then
00:14:56 i'm far right then you're far right then most of the people in this country are far right and that
00:15:00 demonstrates how removed well the mainstream media is but the institutions are as well because the
00:15:07 institutions are all up in arms about it too in fact uh the bbc i think it was on radio four
00:15:14 uh the foreign correspondent woman um the level of bias was quite extraordinary in the reporting
00:15:22 yes yes well she was almost screeching you know she was just below that level of of total hysteria
00:15:30 it was bizarre you know she said millions didn't vote for her ignoring the fact that millions did
00:15:36 Rod Liddle pointed out that there was no way on earth that would have been said about a right
00:15:40 wing sorry a left-wing politician so what's very noticeable just to just go off subject a bit
00:15:45 is that can you imagine if she were of the right political stripe how the fact that she was Italy's
00:15:51 first woman prime minister would have been the top story no one's made anything about that
00:15:56 and what about Ursula von der Leyen yes didn't she say of course if someone like that is elected we
00:16:04 have ways of tools we have tools we have tools this is very interesting she's actually the
00:16:11 not only is she the first female prime minister elected in Italy but she's also the first elected
00:16:18 prime minister within 14 years and I just find that astounding I wasn't aware of this but Italy
00:16:23 hasn't had an elected leader since 2008 because of the EU.
00:16:28 They have these little backroom deals
00:16:30 and they decide who's going to run the country
00:16:32 and Bellasconi was essentially ousted by the EU
00:16:35 and replaced with somebody who I think
00:16:38 had been formally in the EU Commission.
00:16:40 So what was so incredible about Ursula von der Leyen's comments
00:16:45 is that she was basically saying
00:16:48 that countries like Hungary, Poland, Italy,
00:16:52 If they started to go in a direction that wasn't desirable, democratic, then they have
00:17:00 tools available, which is the most authoritarian thing she could possibly have said. But she's
00:17:06 trying to tar Maloney as being the authoritarian.
00:17:10 And also you can't get rid of Ursula by voting, can you? I mean, no one votes her in.
00:17:16 Which is the key point.
00:17:17 Yes, no one votes her, most people don't even know who she is.
00:17:21 washed up on the shores of the EU. What I find interesting before you as well is that one thing
00:17:28 look you mentioned it there you know you've got Maloney you've got the Swedish Democrats recently
00:17:35 you've got Viktor Orban these people and it's usually before oh but they have proportional
00:17:39 representation but apparently in Italy it's only half and half it's like half proportional
00:17:46 half first past the post which should make us think well in fact surely therefore the game isn't
00:17:51 up with us you know because that's always put forward isn't it there's a reason why other
00:17:56 parties don't make it yeah and actually i think not that long ago they had a very very tiny um
00:18:03 minority of the vote share so they've really risen quite quickly but it is worth pause for thought
00:18:08 this isn't it because we've got hungary we've got sweden now we've got italy this really is the road
00:18:15 back to europe and actually as you as you were saying before i mean even though her party has
00:18:22 historical roots in a post-fascist party i think is is right um the the values that she's actually
00:18:30 espousing in her speeches and obviously i don't know if any of you can speak italian i know i can't
00:18:35 and so i'm not 100 sure of everything that she said but just from looking at things that have
00:18:39 been translated she stands for the family she stands for the nation she stands for biological
00:18:43 sex she stands for things that everybody yesterday complete consensus on do you know what the key
00:18:51 thing is about her she speaks as though she believes it and she's authentic unlike that's
00:18:57 the key thing she's all like the bureaucrats who have previously been in charge and generally
00:19:02 the ones that the eu tend to prefer this comes back to my point she's a working-class mother
00:19:06 she's not high you know educated to a very high level but it comes back to my she's extremely
00:19:11 intelligent and very charismatic my point about liz truss and keir starmer you know they're playing
00:19:17 at be you know tony blair and margaret thatcher they're not authentic at all you know there's no
00:19:22 fresh you know dynamism there there's no new ideas this woman is it seems to me
00:19:31 it's just this woman is being herself and she's telling people from the heart what they want to
00:19:36 hear it's fantastic but just one point um can i just draw attention to the fact that be it sweden
00:19:45 be it uh italy um be it hungary the issue that has actually propelled this success for
00:19:57 the rise of censor parties should we say has been emigration yes absolutely and that really
00:20:04 I'm not sure that it's going to be possible to elect that sort of party into government here
00:20:13 but that in a way is also going to add to the frustrations and the angst that is going to be
00:20:19 felt and is being felt. But what we don't need a party what we want is a grassroots movement
00:20:25 to push the Tories into being conservative that's what we really need. I would agree with that but
00:20:32 The thing is, just like with Brexit, is that you have to frighten them with an electoral
00:20:41 tool. I mean in the sense that the only thing that makes a move is the thought that they might
00:20:46 lose their seats and that's what happened with Brexit. You know, Cameron gave that referendum
00:20:53 when in fact it really looked seriously that they might lose lots of seats because UKIP was
00:20:57 23% or something so I agree with that you know well it's one step at a time isn't it it's a
00:21:04 grassroots movement first which may emerge into something like a UKIP or a Brexit party or
00:21:08 something like that but we need the grassroots movement first a grassroots movement that then
00:21:13 elects people yeah for want of a better yeah well I'm perhaps I'm foolishly naive I think that at
00:21:22 the moment the only possible solution to our problems with regard to immigration are the
00:21:29 Conservatives. They've got to be made to see sense and I understand what you're saying Peter that
00:21:34 if there's pressure placed on them through others denying them success then they might change their
00:21:43 minds. My feeling is that as we get closer to the election they will see sense and there are those
00:21:50 on the Conservative back benches, and there are within Cabinet. Soella Braverman clearly
00:21:57 is not of the view that we should be opening up the floodgates to immigration from all
00:22:01 over the world. But going from that to actually having the policies that are going to have
00:22:07 the right sort of impact, we're a long way from that. And we've got to do what we all
00:22:13 can to persuade the Conservatives just to change and to promise and keep their
00:22:20 promises with regard to immigration. Are there any, in terms of Maloney, the
00:22:26 Swedish Democrats, Orban, are there any criticisms that you have
00:22:33 particularly of Maloney or any of these recently elected figures that you would
00:22:40 sort of contrast with what you would want to see here in the UK? I mean look you very rarely just
00:22:46 one at least I speak for myself take on the whole kind of you know as it were every single plank of
00:22:54 a policy and yeah sure there are I don't particularly like Orbán's attitude when it comes to Ukraine
00:23:01 for example I'm sure there are certain I'm not sure about Maloney I don't want to speak out of
00:23:06 term but I mean like anti-abortion maybe things like this that you know I'm far
00:23:11 more ambivalent on those sort of things so yes but there comes a point where
00:23:16 you sort of think well actually on this compelling issue I've got to be with
00:23:21 this person or that person all I can say is that when she was actually I had a
00:23:25 slight there was a sort of feeling of kind of hope I just thought wow you know
00:23:30 this is Italy this is a Western European country it's not a central European
00:23:35 countries and that was what and then it was completely um you know slashed uh away uh by
00:23:42 this this announcement of this government that we're actually going to loosen our immigration
00:23:47 control do you think this is europe's sort of brexit trump moment that they're having their
00:23:53 sort of revolt against the elites in a number of these countries do you think if you do think
00:23:58 that's what's going on would that have a kind of international effect of pressure on the uk
00:24:03 government, that they might see that if, for example, they do go ahead with this policy
00:24:08 to lucid immigration, which I'm interested to know whether you think that's actually
00:24:12 going to happen, whether it's really possible, because the idea of, you know, opening the
00:24:17 doors to potentially 1.5 billion people seems outrageous, that, you know, that that might
00:24:24 create some kind of international pressure on the UK and it might make them give it a
00:24:29 second thought, because they might think, well, maybe this is really is going to make
00:24:32 us almost permanently unelectable I think it's I think it's too early to tell yet but I think the
00:24:38 one of the things that will be a key feature is is the presidential election in America and see
00:24:44 what happens then because that might well change the music especially if Trump comes back
00:24:49 can I ask why we're still on the on the on this subject of immigration you you might be able to
00:24:55 help um we had a census didn't we uh in march 2021 um which is going to be i imagine quite startling
00:25:05 i i've no idea but why haven't we heard anything from it since can you sort of well i gather where
00:25:12 we are going to hear uh sometime in november that the latest set of figures but we have actually
00:25:20 heard quite a bit already yeah that in 10 years the population of this country grew by three and a
00:25:28 half million 10 years 10 years three birmingham's in just 10 years and we know from our own analyses
00:25:39 that something like 80 plus of that was due to immigration immigration direct and indirect
00:25:48 children born to to those who've come here and that that just cannot go on it's interesting in
00:25:55 the in the context of the cost of living crisis that you know we hear the phrase a lot and it's
00:26:03 being discussed almost constantly but we don't talk about pressures on housing we don't talk
00:26:08 about as we were saying earlier the fact that unlimited unskilled immigration suppresses
00:26:13 wages at the lower end of the wage spectrum so the idea that in in the cost of living crisis
00:26:21 that the conservatives would charge in with a policy like this which will increase more pressure
00:26:27 on the people who are at the part of the language the bottom of that economic run
00:26:32 just seems unbelievable and also a betrayal well yeah absolutely it is it is a betrayal
00:26:40 because it's broken promise after promise after promise. The Conservatives at the moment
00:26:48 frankly are in a circle and running around chasing their own tail. They really don't know
00:26:56 what they've got to do next. There are those who actually do get it, do understand not just
00:27:03 on immigration in other areas as well however it seems that number 10 apart from the fact that
00:27:12 we've taken the route that we have with regard to liberalizing the economy and giving taxes
00:27:19 which I think are a good thing whether they're going to have the desired effect within two years
00:27:25 come the next election I'm not so sure they're being very optimistic they're being very optimistic
00:27:32 and in the end if they want to win the election they better get their act together on immigration.
00:27:37 I mean I would say that wouldn't I sorry. Ultimately as well I mean what's going to
00:27:41 happen the low skilled workers will stay here but people with very high skills I'm talking about
00:27:48 postgraduate students here who come here in massive numbers and most of the postgraduate
00:27:54 taught postgraduate students in this country actually are from other countries they're not
00:27:58 they're certainly not British. They come, they learn and then they go, they take those skills
00:28:04 elsewhere. So that dynamic seems to be a ludicrous dynamic to me and any government that is happy
00:28:11 with that or even pushing that dynamic is, you know, there's no reason for us to be optimistic
00:28:16 about any of this frankly. Can I differ on that slightly Philip? They do leave but if you look at
00:28:24 those who are granted settlement something like 20% of those are they
00:28:34 start the whole process by arriving as students in addition to that they now
00:28:41 also and we've got around 600,000 overseas students here they can stay on
00:28:49 after they complete their studies for two years to work I mean that's people seem to overlook the
00:28:56 fact that they they can stay here to work any job they're not all going to become engineers and
00:29:03 brain surgeons they do menial jobs just for the sake of staying here by and large in addition to
00:29:11 that there's something like 80 000 family members who are now coming yes which is massive but there
00:29:17 is one demographic that doesn't tend to do that and it's a massive demographic and that's the
00:29:21 Chinese demographic they absolutely take their skills right back to China. So you mentioned
00:29:27 the family members coming over was that a recent loosening of immigration rules?
00:29:33 Yes yes because it's mostly postgraduate students who are bringing those
00:29:38 family members in and that it was something like 12,000 and in the last set of figures we've got
00:29:45 available for I think 2021 it was 80,000 huge that's incredible. I cannot see any justification
00:29:55 for students bringing dependents or family members I just can't see it I think this will come as
00:30:02 a bit of a shock to many people. Well I suppose there are various levels it doesn't tend to be
00:30:07 correct me if I'm wrong on this but I don't think it tends to be taught MA students it tends to be
00:30:11 PhD students and research students which is more understandable and they and they might well be any
00:30:15 age. You're right it is mostly I don't know about MA but it is mostly post grads and we've got a
00:30:22 lot of them I think part of the problem is the fact that there are a lot of universities now
00:30:29 they're they're not all brilliant however they're becoming increasingly dependent if they haven't
00:30:38 already become dependent on overseas students the higher fees and and all that and that I'm afraid
00:30:45 is one of the drivers of bringing in more and more young people I've worked overseas giving
00:30:53 visas to students who wanted to come here I know that they're not all coming here to be
00:31:00 aspiring Heinsteins they just it just there's a little bit there's a little bit of there's a
00:31:05 little bit of cultural tourism around it yeah and you know but they they they come here for as well
00:31:12 for the uh for the piece of paper that's from an English university that that does have currency in
00:31:19 in in places like China you know let's let's briefly touch on um you had one final one one
00:31:25 final point um there's something called this uh um the shortage of occupation list the SOL and
00:31:33 there's a there's a drive now to expand that. If you go on if the particular sector says you know
00:31:44 there's a shortage of I don't know care workers for example let's let's put them on the list
00:31:52 and you say well wait a minute have we tried actually paying a little bit more and changing
00:31:56 the conditions but the fact is that for anyone on the shortage of occupation list it means that they
00:32:05 can brought in unlimited numbers at 80 percent of the going rate in this country. And it's another
00:32:11 aspect to that and before we move on is that there are a very large number of vacancies in this
00:32:19 country but an even larger number of people who are unemployed and one of the problems and one of
00:32:25 of the reasons the arguments against bringing in a limited migration to fill
00:32:31 those roles is that it means that the government can get their growth without
00:32:34 actually investing in the people who are already here and getting them into work
00:32:39 and creating a more efficient system I think I read somewhere that one of the
00:32:44 one example of how certain areas of work have become more efficient is that at the
00:32:49 turn of the century we had electric car washes and now we have loads of hand
00:32:54 car washers and that's something that declined in efficiency quite dramatically so actually if the
00:33:01 government wanted long-term growth and weren't just thinking in terms of electoral cycles then
00:33:06 they would invest in the British public but instead they want that quick hit they want the
00:33:11 they're sort of a delivery government they want it they want it now so that they can save themselves
00:33:16 It's cheaper, it's cheaper. We've just finished some work on the medical sector and the number
00:33:25 of doctors who can train here is limited. The numbers of overseas trained doctors in the NHS,
00:33:36 the proportion is probably higher than any other countries in Europe. It's cheaper, you don't have
00:33:43 to train them they've already been trained they come over here and they're prepared to work for
00:33:49 less that's the cynical bit of me that says that's the only reason we're doing that it happens with
00:33:57 nurses with dentists all sorts of areas with nurses here we are recruiting nurses from countries that
00:34:04 frankly need them a great deal more than we do short as we are and I suppose just just to finish
00:34:10 that point as well at the other end of the pay scale is people working in care homes so that's
00:34:17 very cheap labour and that tends to come from Africa I think primarily and we're an aging
00:34:24 population aren't we so it's a burgeoning market. I think that you know this idea of basically
00:34:32 forgetting any chance or just dismissing any chance of retraining our own people here
00:34:43 that this is now more or less there's not even lip service given to this anymore
00:34:47 that is a huge betrayal as I see it of future generations or indeed present generations
00:34:53 young people here yeah and quite extraordinary actually that it's sort of almost openly
00:35:00 admitted and i suppose the reason being is that the the rot is very very deep isn't it so if you
00:35:07 actually are going to start doing that training people you know our own people you're going to
00:35:11 have to change the education system you're going to have to change this and that and this and it
00:35:15 goes on and on that's too much as you say for short-term merchants which is what politicians
00:35:21 are we're going to have to move on um quickly because we're running out of time but peter do
00:35:26 Do you want to tell us a bit about this British Attitude Survey?
00:35:29 British Attitude, from what I can gather is that basically it's been drawn up by people who seem to work in a certain paradigm.
00:35:37 This is something that comes up every year, is that right?
00:35:41 And I think one of the conclusions drawn from this survey was that most people feel that mass immigration has been economically and culturally beneficial to Britain.
00:35:52 And I just, I'm sorry, search me, but I just don't know how they came up with that.
00:35:58 But that is one of the headline results of it.
00:36:01 I think one of the complaints is that the questions were leading and the categories were confused.
00:36:06 So I've got a quote here.
00:36:07 It's like literally, are you, as Joe Brand used to say, are you a fat bastard?
00:36:12 It's like, you know, are you a racist bigot?
00:36:16 No.
00:36:16 so they in their section on the culture wars they set up this dichotomy basically of nasty
00:36:22 versus nice it's it's like it's like a manichean framework of good versus evil and we're horrible
00:36:27 it was liberals versus authoritarians and the authoritarians weren't regarded it was the
00:36:33 liberals it's the wrong way around yeah and the authoritarians who were anti-woke um and
00:36:38 there's a quote here from gareth roberts who wrote a great piece he's a lovely writer
00:36:42 on this and he said this is an extreme example of the public sphere using 20th century words for
00:36:48 19th century concepts in a world altered beyond recognition referring to political divisions in
00:36:55 terms of liberal versus authoritarian and quite possibly left and right is about as much use as
00:37:00 describing metaverse programming in the vernacular of the battle of trafalgar but you know there's
00:37:06 There are lots of lefty lawyers on Twitter saying well you know it's just caring it's nice it's
00:37:14 being respectful to people what's wrong with that and you know I think you know you don't think that
00:37:21 you know that's a lie we know that's a lie we know that you know that that's a lie but you'll
00:37:27 dissemble anyway and that's how work works it's about dissembling it's lies but it's bare
00:37:33 face brazen like. And it's interesting though how this can be used in this instance in the British
00:37:40 Attitude Survey that this framing can be presented as being something that is objective when it's
00:37:46 completely leading and it completely not only does it skew that the real meaning of the findings it's
00:37:53 actually twisted it completely topsy-turvy. Well I mean this business of people thinking that
00:37:59 more positive about immigration we kept hearing that time and time and time again so last July
00:38:07 we commissioned some polling from Migration Watch done by Delta poll very respectable and
00:38:15 actually something like 60% of people thought that immigration had been too too high and needed
00:38:24 to come down among Conservative voters it was over 80% for goodness sake so you
00:38:31 know I just don't as as you say if you ask a straight question you will get a
00:38:37 straight answer if you try subterfuge and trying to disguise what it is that
00:38:44 you're really saying to get the right answer that can also happen and that's
00:38:50 what's going on throughout. It's interesting to call on the name of this program it's
00:38:53 interesting news speak isn't it to refer basically to the advocates of free speech as being
00:38:59 authoritarian and those who want to clamp down on free speech as being liberals um it's just
00:39:06 completely the wrong way around last week we were talking about the paypal paypal's decision to
00:39:10 close down the free speech union account now they've reinstated after loads of backlash and
00:39:15 pressure against them, including support from various MPs who are in support of the Free
00:39:24 Speech Union and according to the framing of this British Attitude Survey, according
00:39:29 to this Spectator piece that I mentioned, they would have been regarding basically those
00:39:34 who are pro-freedom as being the ones on the side of authoritarianism.
00:39:38 Well I was going to say, it isn't just people like Peter, Ewan, Philip, who
00:39:45 think that immigration is high needs to be reduced by a lot, 34% think by a lot.
00:39:52 It's also people like me, migrants and not just those who've been here for an
00:40:01 eternity as I have but those who've come more recently. The fact is that
00:40:07 uncontrolled mass immigration has an impact on everything including
00:40:13 migrants here and if we've got any sense we really do something and also if we
00:40:19 want to talk about being humane those migrants that come through as part of
00:40:23 that unlimited flow into those low-skilled jobs they are also at the
00:40:27 bottom of that economic rung but have all of that pressure bearing down on
00:40:32 them as well along with everybody else who's already here. I'll just make one
00:40:35 point about British social attitudes on a very general basis I mean and that is
00:40:40 that the general British attitude to immigration I think has been unbelievably
00:40:46 tolerant totally and unbelievably patient and reasonable they've been
00:40:53 treated unreasonably you know for all their their trouble but people can make
00:41:02 the distinction quite easily between immigration which I think most people
00:41:07 have no problem with you know like what you might call ordinary moderate
00:41:10 migration and unprecedented mass migration of the type we've had in the past 20 years.
00:41:16 Most people can make that distinction but increasingly the powers that be are blur this
00:41:22 just like they're blurring the language I'm sure you would support me in that blurring
00:41:28 the whole language. Distorting it. I think the problem is most people will
00:41:32 make that distinction in private but if you utter that distinction in public then you
00:41:36 are just branded racist and that's the real problem. And then you're just completely open
00:41:43 to the kinds of people who are not interested in freedom of speech, they're interested
00:41:48 in freedom of spite, aren't they? They'll just call you any names because you say something
00:41:53 completely reasonable and you say something that everybody else thinks. And I'm from
00:41:58 an immigrant background myself as I've said lots of times on this show and we're not
00:42:03 against immigration we're against mass immigration and most well all sensible people are so that's
00:42:10 the note we're going to have to end on and i think that's a message there for liz trust it's
00:42:13 unreasonable so please do like comment and subscribe thank you peter thank you alp thank
00:42:20 you philip and we will see you next time on new speak thank you hello if you're enjoying the new
00:42:27 Culture Forum channel and you believe in our mission may I invite you to join our
00:42:33 membership scheme at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk
00:42:39 Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the
00:42:45 future but we can't do it without your support. From as little as three pounds
00:42:49 per month you can help ensure that we continue on our mission. As a member
00:42:55 you'll receive a range of benefits including access to exclusive content,
00:43:00 invitations to our private events including here at our studios, free copies
00:43:06 of our books and much much more including of course our famous NCF mug.
00:43:12 If you aren't able to become a member then please help us by clicking this
00:43:17 button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free, just remember to
00:43:23 also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post new
00:43:29 videos. Thank you.