New Culture Forum - February 16, 2021


New 'Citizens Advice' Service For Employees & Other Victims Of Woke Culture

Dave Rubin - What Now For USA Under Biden? How Can Non-Woke In UK & USA Fight Back In Culture Wars?

Episode Stats


Length

30 minutes

Words per minute

144.13

Word count

4,458

Sentence count

84


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now one of the features of
00:00:28 our times you'll know only too well is cancel culture and there are lots of high profile cases
00:00:34 which we see in the newspapers they come via twitter celebrities saying the wrong thing and
00:00:40 all of that but one of the most important things which comes through to us when we get feedback
00:00:47 from you the viewers is people worrying more and more about what they can say and think in the
00:00:53 workplace, whether it is in private companies or in the public sector. There is a growing
00:01:00 restriction perceived by many people on what they can say, think or do. Now quite often they want to
00:01:07 know what they should do. Well there is actually a possible help at hand. There is a new organisation
00:01:14 called Counterweight which has been launched this week. I'm very pleased that the person behind that
00:01:20 is with me today. Helen Pluckrose is best-selling author. Her book Cynical Theories was out last
00:01:28 year, very critically acclaimed, and she is with me now. Thank you very much for joining me, Helen.
00:01:34 I'm delighted to be here. Could you just explain a little bit more about
00:01:38 counterweight? First of all, maybe why you started it up?
00:01:42 After the death of George Floyd and the BLM protests, a lot of companies, universities
00:01:52 and schools started implementing policies and training procedures which are based very
00:01:59 much on the Robin DiAngelo school of thought, the idea that everybody is socialised into
00:02:07 white supremacy and that we have to be taught to see our unconscious bias and dismantle it
00:02:15 um and as as well as this there's also um obviously there's the gender issue as well
00:02:22 as that always comes up with um trans activists um and um and sort of prestige in society so
00:02:34 people started writing to those of us who'd been critical of these ideas um in their thousands
00:02:41 and we just couldn't manage them all so i set up a discord server in order to triage the people in
00:02:49 immediate danger of being fired um for not believing the right thing about race or the
00:02:56 right thing about sex and gender um and provide resources more generalized advice in the community
00:03:03 for people with less urgent problems so this has grown organically there are now organizations
00:03:10 forming around teaching social work engineering tech all these different areas in which people
00:03:18 find themselves being compelled to affirm beliefs they don't actually have or that they don't think
00:03:24 are ethical and that are not based on good science the implicit association test is is not good
00:03:30 science what kind of communications then did you have helen i mean you said you had thousands there
00:03:38 what what was the sort of cases what were what would people be worried about you know why would
00:03:43 they be coming to you it's interesting because most often when white people are concerned um
00:03:50 it's because they're being expected to claim to be racist when they don't believe that they are
00:03:56 and they spend a lot of time telling me how not racist they are
00:04:01 and how much they care about racial equality.
00:04:04 When non-white people, often South Asian or black Brits,
00:04:10 get in touch with me, they're concerned about being pressured
00:04:13 to testify to a certain experience of racism
00:04:16 that they don't believe that they've had.
00:04:19 And there's a feeling there often where they'll tell me
00:04:24 how successful they themselves have been somewhat demeaned by this narrative that
00:04:35 they are second-class citizens and that white privilege is the thing that permeates everything
00:04:42 and so you know if if that's what they feel or if somebody can how will counterweight be able
00:04:48 to advise them what what will happen what generally so so we have a sort of three-tier system
00:04:55 because it depends what level of problem you have we know that there are employers out there who
00:05:02 want to put into place a much more liberal and open policy for anti-discrimination because
00:05:10 they're getting in touch with us and we're helping them to do that so we're saying to people if you're
00:05:15 just hearing about, you know, non-discrimination and new policies don't immediately jump to the
00:05:23 conclusion that this is going to be a critical social justice authoritarian.
00:05:45 to approach your employer you need to make sure that they're aware of the scientific critique of
00:05:56 these methods if they're aware of the ideology underlying everything and that it isn't compatible
00:06:03 with with people who believe themselves to have free will um to evaluate reject or accept certain
00:06:13 ideas so that's liberals um who believe in the power of the individual the marketplace of ideas
00:06:19 it's also conservatives who believe in personal responsibility marxists believe that everything
00:06:26 comes down to class is it right really to say that this is sort of something which is perceived
00:06:34 to be at least you know popularly that it's only people on the right who get you know worked up
00:06:40 about this kind of thing um but in fact you know you're not on the right you're how would you
00:06:46 actually describe yourself politically i'm um an ex-socialist who um grudgingly accepts that we
00:06:54 have to have capitalism but wants to tax rich people a lot right and um focuses and thinks
00:07:02 that gender, racial and LGBT equality are very important.
00:07:06 I believe that we have almost entirely succeeded
00:07:12 with gender equality.
00:07:14 I have not found myself to be discriminated against in any way.
00:07:18 I think we still have a way to go with racism and homophobia
00:07:22 and I think trans people are a particularly vulnerable group,
00:07:27 although it's trans activism itself,
00:07:29 which I think makes sort of a greatest hostility against trans people.
00:07:36 One thing that people seem to know quite a lot about,
00:07:38 or we hear a lot about, is unconscious bias training.
00:07:41 Would that be something that would come, you know, within your concern?
00:07:46 Is that something that you feel is something that people shouldn't have to do?
00:07:50 Yeah, there's two concerns with the unconscious bias assumption.
00:07:56 firstly um it doesn't seem to work it's based on the implicit association test which people
00:08:04 have found can show different results on the same day taken by the same person um and it doesn't
00:08:10 seem to link to racist attitudes either so it's and it unconscious bias training has been shown
00:08:19 in some cases to have no effect whatsoever or to increase um racial tension so it doesn't seem to
00:08:26 work um but on another level um it people's unconscious biases whatever they are are really
00:08:35 their own business this is something which doesn't get discussed enough we hear a lot about whether
00:08:42 or not it works to train people to think in certain ways and less about whether we should
00:08:49 be trying to get into people's heads and discovering, insisting we know what they think
00:08:56 and trying to change how they think. Of course, a liberal would argue that people can believe
00:09:03 whatever they want. An employer, a society has an expectation that they will not behave
00:09:09 in abusive ways or ways that arm other people but you know freedom of conscience is something that
00:09:18 that everybody should have so we particularly hear from gender critical feminists who again
00:09:23 are on the left who are expected to put their gender pronouns down to signify their gender
00:09:33 identity and they don't believe in gender identity they have an ethical objection
00:09:37 to gender identity up to the concept of gender which they believe incorrectly in my view to be
00:09:43 a social construct but they have the right to believe that so um if they are being compelled
00:09:49 to pretend to have a gender identity then that is um i i would say that goes beyond the allowances
00:09:59 of freedom of belief and freedom of expression it's not a matter of them insulting their trans
00:10:05 colleagues or making them feel uncomfortable it's a matter of private conscience which is
00:10:10 nobody else's business really the point is why surely is that with a private company you know
00:10:16 people say oh well you know a private company it can do what it wants and all the rest of it you
00:10:21 know obviously it can't please people it shouldn't please people's thoughts but what is the sort of
00:10:26 position of an employee who say for example doesn't want to take the unconscious bias training course
00:10:32 I mean, can they be compelled to? What is the legal position?
00:10:37 As far as I know, there is no legal compulsion for an employer to do any kind of diversity training.
00:10:44 As far as I know, and I'm not the one dealing with the legal side of things, there's just a strong pressure to do so.
00:10:52 And I know this because a lot of people, one of the things Counterweight is going to provide is a consultancy service for employers who want to provide a kind of diversity training, which includes diversity of thought, you know, and it will be, it will allow people to oppose prejudice and discrimination from their own ethical framework.
00:11:17 where does your uh new organization where does it fit in if at all with uh for example the free
00:11:25 speech union we've had toby young on the program when he launched that i mean it is it sort of
00:11:32 compliments it in a way doesn't it it does um when people come to us when they're they're having a
00:11:40 quite clear problem we advise them to join the free speech union but our aim is for them not
00:11:47 to need it right our aim is to help them to sort out their problem internally it's if we fail and
00:11:55 they face disciplinary action then that's when they need the free speech union so most often
00:12:01 when we have had successes and we've had quite a lot nobody ever knows we were involved we have
00:12:07 just helped out with template letters we've practiced with people um via zoom uh provided
00:12:14 resources and um and and helped people to sort things out internally we're particularly proud
00:12:21 that we've managed to get a major charity to back off from spending a lot of resources on diversity
00:12:30 training and instead spend those resources on um very vulnerable um people lacking basic food and
00:12:37 medicine in other parts of the world so yes but no nobody will know that we've been involved in
00:12:43 this because we're responding to individuals often the employee but sometimes the employer
00:12:50 will come to us and ask us how can i do this um in a way that will meet expectations but doesn't
00:12:57 require me to believe in critical race theory or queer theory or post-colonial theory those three
00:13:03 theories there that you just uh enumerated you actually went into some considerable detail in
00:13:09 your book which i mentioned in the uh intro uh cynical theories which i think is a play isn't
00:13:15 on critical theories the actual title um helen you know the whole point of your book is i think
00:13:21 the subtitle was why these particular theories seem to dominate and why they're harmful uh i
00:13:28 know that it's a whole book you've written on it but what would you say if you had to sum it up what
00:13:34 you know why are they harmful i think we all know but i'd like to hear you say why are they
00:13:39 harmful and how come they have become so dominant i think that the greatest harm that is happening
00:13:46 here is the the idea that people are divided by race gender sexuality into different kinds
00:13:54 of knowledges that there are these um consistent systems of oppressive power running through
00:14:00 everything and we can't see them we need these critical theorists to point them out to us
00:14:06 and then we can dismantle them but this means that the assumption that those um those power
00:14:14 systems are always in play are there and we're always looking for them this is why we called it
00:14:18 cynical theories so at the moment i a woman i'm talking to you a man and there would be a power
00:14:26 dynamic here in which it would be assumed that you would not um believe uh my point of view very well
00:14:33 you'd not accept that i could be knowledgeable or intelligent or know what i'm talking about
00:14:38 because you have been socialized to believe that it's men who are
00:14:43 knowledgeable and and intelligence and competent so somebody who is using one
00:14:50 of the kind of intersectional feminisms which which sees patriarchy and
00:14:54 everything could look at our conversation and they would find
00:14:58 something in your your body language something in the way you speak that will
00:15:03 prove what it was they were looking for in the first place so it really is a
00:15:08 are kind of interpreting these power systems and reading them into everything and the worst thing
00:15:16 I think of this is that people who are then trained to see the world this way are going to
00:15:22 be much more afraid of entering it. I considered myself feminist until very recently and I'm not
00:15:30 very happy with the disempowerment of women that comes along with the idea that um we're
00:15:37 generally regarded as less credible and less competent than men yeah i don't think it helps
00:15:45 but it's also the case is it not that the these particular the critical theory critical race theory
00:15:53 ones you just mentioned they did originate in the academic world uh largely and so a lot of the
00:16:00 people that you know have been taught them have ended up in for example human resources haven't
00:16:06 they and they've ended up in the kind of departments that would actually put such
00:16:11 things into practice yes we've seen an industry growing i would call it the social justice
00:16:17 industry so it's been since around 1989 that these branches of um of theory have really taken off and
00:16:28 they've become um actionable so since then a lot of people have learned and they've graduated
00:16:35 they've gone into various different um spheres so we see as we see it a great deal in the humanities
00:16:42 and in the caring professions in the arts we see it less in things like engineering and
00:16:49 agriculture and that kind of thing but it's still having an effect on on stem i i've just heard from
00:16:57 somebody today who is extremely concerned about what's happening in his biology department and
00:17:04 i'm hoping to help him address that so it's not as though anyone is really safe but it's certainly
00:17:12 affecting the the arts and the humanities to a greater extent at the moment i know this sort of
00:17:18 sounds maybe a strange way of putting but how sincere are the beliefs that we're talking about
00:17:26 here i mean or are they just simply being used entirely for political ends so i think i'm often
00:17:34 asked this question and i i'm sure that there are opportunists who will always take advantage of
00:17:41 any system of power, same as, you know, far back as Chaucer talking about, you know, priests taking
00:17:50 advantage of the power that the church gave them. But for my purposes, I think we need to assume
00:17:56 that everybody is sincere, and we need to address the ideas as though they're sincere. Otherwise,
00:18:03 we just start saying, well, you're applying sort of nefarious motivations to people rather than
00:18:09 addressing what they're actually saying then we're going to fall into the same trap that the
00:18:15 critical theorists do for example they will suggest that I'm actually secretly um far right
00:18:21 or that I'm making an enormous amount of money out of um annoying almost everybody or that
00:18:28 some way or other I am I am insincere and um you don't actually have to pay any attention to what
00:18:34 i'm saying so i i would say yes i'm sure there are some opportunists in there but address the
00:18:40 ideas rather than the people and uh mind reading their motivations although at the same time when
00:18:48 you when you talk about you know people wanting power and this is a way of wanting power maybe
00:18:52 uh one way of doing that is to is to construct a very obscure set of rules isn't it and you
00:18:58 you could say that uh in the case of these critical theories uh that in fact it's the
00:19:03 way in which they are explained in the academic context which is almost impenetrable isn't it i
00:19:10 mean it's almost designed to keep people from actually understanding it it was i mean if you
00:19:17 tried to read homie baba or um judith butler who were writing in the 1990s you'd have great
00:19:23 difficulty but since about 2010 the theorists have become so sure of themselves and so confident
00:19:32 that they're much much clearer now i think a 10 year old could read robin de angelo's white
00:19:38 fragility and understand it she um it's um it's it's it's good because we can now get at it we
00:19:46 can get at those ideas and we can show the problem with them but it also makes them much more
00:19:51 infectious because it gives people a very simplistic and satisfying framework to put on
00:19:57 the world and to feel that they're doing good by following it do you think that's a harmful book
00:20:03 helena uh white virginity it's um it essentially exists to explain away why some white people
00:20:13 might disagree with critical race theory ideas of of white supremacy so it just it closes down
00:20:22 any possibility of legitimate disagreement. According to D'Angelo, defensive moves which
00:20:31 depict white fragility include disagreeing, arguing, staying quiet or going away. So the
00:20:38 only way not to suffer from white fragility is to stay put and agree that we do all live in a
00:20:46 white supremacist society and we are all socialised into being white supremacists.
00:20:51 I see. It's a sort of, it's a no-win situation, isn't it, really? I mean,
00:20:55 if you criticise it, that's proof of what you are. Isn't that right?
00:20:59 Exactly. It's, you know, the Catch-22 or the Kafka trap. And this is what we've criticised
00:21:06 the theories for. It's less of a problem that bad ideas arise in the academy and they become
00:21:12 unpopular because this always happens but we have to be able to argue with them and we have to be
00:21:19 able to point out the problems with them and these kind of theories simply don't submit themselves
00:21:25 to the marketplace of ideas because you have the choice either you agree with the theories because
00:21:30 you can see them you have critical consciousness or you are woke to these systems of power and
00:21:36 privilege or you're speaking into dominant discourses because of your socialization
00:21:41 there isn't the possibility that you could actually legitimately disagree because you
00:21:48 have a different worldview so the marxists um for example they have been criticizing
00:21:54 um this kind of theory the longest of all so they've um they believe that their focus on race
00:22:02 divides the working class and it's actually a bourgeois plan to take the left into the academy
00:22:10 and away from the working classes and you know liberals we've been arguing with them for less
00:22:18 long but we are trying to get across the idea that perhaps if you can see these systems of
00:22:28 power and privilege, perhaps we can see how society works as well. Isn't there a room for
00:22:33 discussion there? Is it possible for somebody to disagree with you? Isn't reality actually a bit
00:22:41 more complicated than you're suggesting? It's more complicated, but also the one glaring
00:22:46 omission in all of this is class, isn't it? Largely, yes. You get some mention of
00:22:55 anti-capitalism so and there will be some people particularly activists who describe themselves as
00:23:04 both Marxists and social justice activists which doesn't really work too well together because
00:23:11 Marxism and post-modernism are essentially antithetical so you'll get that kind of mix
00:23:18 but you'll very seldom see much focus on the plight of the working class
00:23:24 because too many of them are straight white men.
00:23:28 So the traditional Marxists will criticise social justice on these grounds.
00:23:35 But the social justice, and that's where some good scholarship
00:23:39 is actually coming from, particularly in post-colonial theory.
00:23:43 That's where you see a big divide between the materialists
00:23:46 from the Marxist tradition and the post-modernists and you get a good scholarship into economics,
00:23:53 law, government, how the world is affected in material terms as an aftermath of colonialism
00:24:01 which is worthwhile and then this scholarship is generally undermined by the what I would say
00:24:09 was the post-modern kind of post-colonial scholarship in which we all have to have
00:24:14 hysterics if a white person has dreadlocks or if twerking isn't considered a um a sort of major
00:24:22 art form or anything this sort of cultural appropriation and decolonize everything and
00:24:28 tear tear everything down this comes very much from the attitudes biases microaggressions which
00:24:34 come from post-modernism which are Foucault not not Marx yes exactly the interestingly a few years
00:24:41 ago as well and you were part of a it got a lot of publicity but you were part of a very interesting
00:24:46 project whereby you effectively created as it were fake essays what if you put them in for peer
00:24:54 review uh in the academic world and used all the right tropes and the right language and the right
00:25:00 ideas i mean and and they were passed and they were passed as being they were treated as being
00:25:05 entirely genuine weren't they i mean can you tell us a bit about that because a lot of our viewers
00:25:10 won't know about that yeah we got seven of our papers published in the end we took the worst
00:25:17 of the worst scholarship and we used it to argue um for things completely consistently with what
00:25:25 was coming out of those fields anyway so essentially we were producing the the scholarship
00:25:32 it's um it's a bit of a mistake really to think of what we were doing as hoaxes i mean some of it
00:25:37 It seems very silly. For example, we examined, we claimed to have looked at 10,000 dog genitals in three dog parks in Oregon and then applied black feminist criminology to it to discover that men should be trained like dogs in nightclubs.
00:25:56 So, you know, it was very, very silly, a lot of it, and that was why we got caught.
00:26:03 It wasn't that the journals themselves recognised that it was ridiculous.
00:26:06 It was that the public did, and journalists started digging around and found out that the authors didn't actually exist.
00:26:14 But all of our papers, they cite the theorists correctly and accurately.
00:26:22 they used the concepts. Really, if they believed these ideas, they shouldn't have retracted any of
00:26:29 our purely theoretical papers. Obviously, some of our papers had fabricated data. We used
00:26:37 impossible or implausible data and then drew conclusions from it that weren't warranted
00:26:42 because we wanted to see what the journals would do with that. Those papers need to be retracted
00:26:47 because that you know they have false data but the ones which are purely theoretical um if they
00:26:54 believe those ideas they should keep them up there you wouldn't see a say a biology um journal um
00:27:03 retracting a sound paper on some area of evolution if the um individual then said actually i'm a
00:27:09 creationist and i didn't believe a word i said if the the paper is either good and sound or it isn't
00:27:15 do you think where do you think we are in the in in the chronology of this particular phenomenon
00:27:23 do you think that it sort of is flowering at the moment you you know you you talked about
00:27:29 the writers of the 90s and and how they've become far less prolix far less obscure actually and
00:27:35 they're confident so do you think that we are at the peak of this or of influence going down
00:27:42 the other side maybe i i think so i mean my perception at the moment is we've seen this
00:27:48 bubbling up this ideology it's bubbled up in places like evergreen college in the united
00:27:54 states where the ideas of robin d'angelo really took over and caused the whole riot situation
00:27:59 the police they couldn't even have graduation there it's bubbled up in young adult writing
00:28:05 where people have had to retract their books and the knitting um community where of all things so
00:28:12 We've seen these sort of little eruptions of this social justice thing.
00:28:16 And at the moment, I think what we're seeing in the U.S. particularly
00:28:19 is a genuine attempt at a cultural revolution.
00:28:23 The wide-scale protests really, I think, have hit the peak.
00:28:29 I am very concerned for the U.S.
00:28:33 I feel as though we here in the U.K. and also Australia,
00:28:39 we have more chances of turning back.
00:28:42 We haven't gone that far.
00:28:45 We can see how it's playing out in the US.
00:28:49 And I'm hopeful that some of the pushback
00:28:54 that we're seeing now is going to take hold
00:28:57 and we're going to step back before we get to that stage.
00:29:02 But you think America is over that point?
00:29:07 I'm quite scared for America, yes.
00:29:09 I don't, you know, it sounds melodramatic, but I don't think the possibility of civil war is zero.
00:29:21 You know, I think there is a realistic chance of full-scale riots involving, in the end, the military, the sort of right against the left.
00:29:33 And a lot of violence could take place.
00:29:37 There's too much extremism sort of coming out of the US
00:29:44 in both the critical social justice ideas and the response to it.
00:29:49 Yes.
00:29:50 Well, look, in the meantime, Helen,
00:29:52 how do people, is there a website they can go to
00:29:55 to find out about Counterweight?
00:29:58 Yep, counterweightsupport.com is where you will find us.
00:30:02 And there you can either ask for help
00:30:06 or you can offer help you can find resources to help you understand how it works better template
00:30:11 letters um or you can seek out our services for um consulting if you're an employer and you want to
00:30:21 do something a bit better something a bit more ethical and effective to oppose discrimination
00:30:26 in your workplace well great well look thank you very much helen pluck rose thank you very much
00:30:31 and um all the very best with it as well so it sounds like a brilliant initiative thanks very
00:30:35 much indeed for coming good talking to you yeah that's it uh for this week so uh we shall see you
00:30:42 next time in the meantime please do subscribe won't you take it bye