New Culture Forum - April 20, 2020


Peter Hitchens: Hysterical reaction to Covid19 & public support of lockdown is scary & dangerous

2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won Dave Rubin: Defending Free Speech - Covid-19 - Trump 2020 + His New Book: "Don't Burn This Book"

Episode Stats


Length

33 minutes

Words per minute

171.04

Word count

5,812

Sentence count

152


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. I hope you are bearing up
00:00:22 under these surreal circumstances. Now I'm delighted that my guest this week
00:00:27 is the author, journalist and columnist for The Mail on Sunday, Peter Hitchens.
00:00:33 Peter was a guest on this show last year.
00:00:36 It turned out to be one of our most popular interviews.
00:00:40 He got something like 175,000 views.
00:00:42 So I'm delighted that he's come back to talk to us specifically today
00:00:46 about his views on the British response to the coronavirus crisis.
00:00:52 Good afternoon to you, Peter.
00:00:54 Good afternoon.
00:00:55 Thank you very much for coming on. I wanted to start by asking you something which seems to have happened just over the past couple of days, which is that suddenly the sort of tone and the emphasis of coverage in the media seems to have sort of changed onto much more overtly economic things. Do you perceive that?
00:01:16 I think something has happened. I think it began last week with Fraser Nelson's extraordinary
00:01:26 article in the Daily Telegraph, which was obviously the fruit of some very high-level
00:01:31 briefing expressing serious alarm at the economic consequences of the government's policy. I
00:01:38 think it almost certainly expresses a very strong view at a high level in the government
00:01:43 that things have gone quite badly wrong economically
00:01:46 and they didn't predict what happened.
00:01:49 The difficulty for the government is this.
00:01:52 They have persuaded the public
00:01:54 that the threat of COVID-19 is so great
00:01:57 that the public have responded with far more enthusiasm
00:02:01 than they ever expected.
00:02:03 This is also something which Fraser pointed out
00:02:05 and indeed are probably now more committed
00:02:08 to the government's programme than the government themselves
00:02:11 who increasingly feel that if this goes on for much longer,
00:02:15 then we face something closely resembling national bankruptcy
00:02:18 and want to find a way out of it.
00:02:21 So now I think what's going on is that the public are being prepared for a retreat.
00:02:25 And I don't doubt for a moment that the government is briefing its friends in the media
00:02:30 to ensure that that retreat is prepared for.
00:02:32 This is how these things are done.
00:02:33 I've never seen it more blatantly done, but this is how they are done.
00:02:37 Is this a bit frustrating for you, Shoy?
00:02:39 because i mean you've you know been writing pieces for pretty much from the start of this thing
00:02:44 um pointing out that this was maybe the wrong way to go um and it seems that possibly that view
00:02:53 is becoming if you like more accepted now because you pretty much did you know you got it in the
00:02:59 neck didn't you for some reason i live under always be right never to be believed and that's
00:03:09 what's happening in in this case again i it wasn't there was no doubt about my position
00:03:15 when it started and hesitate i felt at the beginning that the government's response was
00:03:19 disproportionate uh not so much wrong it's not wrong to try and prevent the spread of disease
00:03:24 if you can it's not wrong to take any rational action to reduce harm if it's within your powers
00:03:29 to do so but it just seemed to me that closing down a very large part of an economy which is
00:03:34 is increasingly a service economy,
00:03:37 and therefore was particularly vulnerable
00:03:39 to the sort of closed-down doctrine,
00:03:40 was very dangerous.
00:03:41 I also thought,
00:03:42 and this is a subject
00:03:43 which has been pushed to one side,
00:03:45 that the assault on personal liberty,
00:03:48 which was involved in it,
00:03:49 was intolerable
00:03:50 and should not have been attempted
00:03:51 by any government in a free country,
00:03:53 and also that people
00:03:54 should have objected to it more.
00:03:55 I certainly don't think
00:03:56 that it's the business of government
00:03:57 to interfere in the private lives
00:03:59 of people to the extent
00:04:00 that's going on.
00:04:01 But the economic thing
00:04:02 just seemed to me
00:04:03 to be quite obviously very dangerous and I said again and again again there is no evidence that
00:04:10 crashing your economy saves a single life whereas there's a great deal of evidence that severe
00:04:15 economic damage costs lives in the near term and in the long term. In fact from the beginning I
00:04:21 used to quote Professor Sucherit Bakhti of the University of Mainz in Germany who made this
00:04:25 warning particularly about the danger of long-term isolation to the healthy old which has been a
00:04:31 major part of this i think an awful lot of old people in this country up to now living productive
00:04:36 interesting and active lives confined to their homes prevented from making contact with their
00:04:43 with their friends except through electronic means are actually suffering in mental and physical
00:04:47 health as a result of this in ways which will cost us greatly and as for the economic cost
00:04:53 it doesn't take much imagination to work out what will happen to the national health service which
00:04:58 we're all supposed to value so highly if the tax base collapses you simply cannot afford to have
00:05:04 a national health service on the scale which people want if you have a lower tax base what
00:05:08 will happen if more and more people are unemployed as an absolute key factor in the development of
00:05:14 ill health there are so many ways in which this this threatens health and therefore as i say
00:05:20 repeatedly this isn't a matter of money against life it's a question of life against life both
00:05:26 the calculations involved lives and both both sides in this argument i think have to be assumed
00:05:31 to be acting out of goodwill in the hope of doing good i just don't think that the government are
00:05:36 correct i think they made a mistake in what they did and i i suppose i should mind uh that what i
00:05:44 was met with when i first raised these criticisms was derision and abuse but i'm so used to it that
00:05:49 i don't really if if the thing now does begin to moderate and reverse then that will be good and
00:05:54 I think it may have something to do with the fact that someone could raise a small banner of protest against it from the start,
00:06:00 which in any free country was our duty and something which we were absolutely entitled and right to do.
00:06:09 When we are talking about this, now that this is being emphasised, possible economic consequences,
00:06:15 this seems to perhaps have come from this new report from the Office of Budget Responsibility that came out.
00:06:24 yesterday um and these were quite horrifying figures were they not um i i think i have seen
00:06:31 you talking before about your experience of being in societies which are in a slump i mean are we
00:06:37 talking slump sort of territory here well i don't it may be so i remember before this started the
00:06:45 world particularly the western world was already on the on the brink of the serious economic crash
00:06:51 Anyway, the stock markets have begun to fall very precipitately.
00:06:56 The pound sterling was also falling.
00:06:59 There were a number of other indicators that we were entering a pretty severe recession,
00:07:04 possibly on the scale of 2008 and possibly even worse.
00:07:10 So, yes, I think that the danger of something very bad is there.
00:07:14 The problem is people simply can't imagine it.
00:07:16 We've had for so long so much security and safety and prosperity
00:07:22 that it is very, very difficult indeed for people even to imagine
00:07:26 the possibility that they might live through a period of serious penury,
00:07:31 very large-scale unemployment, downward pressure on wages,
00:07:34 taxes intolerably high, even levied on the poorest.
00:07:39 And I think that is a great difficulty,
00:07:41 which people find a huge problem in imagining.
00:07:46 One thing, actually, Peter,
00:07:48 we've had these briefings that have been going on,
00:07:51 and what I think it was Philip Johnson today pointed out,
00:07:56 that at the beginning it was said that actually,
00:08:00 of course, it would be terrible,
00:08:01 certain people would be badly affected,
00:08:02 but that a lot of people, or most people indeed,
00:08:05 would maybe get rather mild symptoms from this thing.
00:08:08 And he made the point that, in fact,
00:08:10 you no longer have those reassuring voices, actually, in briefings now.
00:08:16 Is that something that you've noticed?
00:08:19 No, I don't think I do.
00:08:21 But I think, actually, the predictions have so far largely been borne out.
00:08:26 Some people were always going to suffer very badly from this disease and have done,
00:08:30 and some were going to die and have done and are still doing.
00:08:34 This has always been a major concern that one would try to prevent it.
00:08:38 but a very large number of people will have the disease without symptoms or quite likely.
00:08:45 I think that remains true and I think the great difficulty here is in working out what is the
00:08:52 proportionate response to what is going on. I find almost all the figures which are given
00:08:56 are given without a context. At the beginning of this I was shocking people quite often
00:09:02 And by stating the fact that 1,600 people die normally every day in the United Kingdom, this happens.
00:09:10 It's not grievous for those involved and distressing and not to be taken lightly, but it happens.
00:09:18 People do die.
00:09:19 And so when you look at the figures which are given for the numbers of deaths, you have to take that into context.
00:09:24 Similarly, when you look at the figures which we're now beginning to see in excess of the normal average figures for the time of year, quite considerably according to yesterday's figures, you can see that obviously people are dying in considerable numbers.
00:09:40 There are bizarre quirks to these figures, such as that quite large numbers of them are not said to be necessarily COVID-19 related.
00:09:48 But that may be the result of what seem to me to be extraordinarily varied ways of deciding whether someone has died from COVID-19 or not.
00:09:58 I don't know. I've never, people have accused me of this, and it's not true, I've never sought to predict a level of death.
00:10:07 I've never minimised the danger of the disease.
00:10:11 What I have done is doubted in the extreme
00:10:14 all the predictions that came from Imperial College,
00:10:17 the 510,000 prediction if we did nothing,
00:10:21 the quarter of a million prediction if we did milder shutting down,
00:10:27 and the, I think, fewer than 20,000 prediction if we did a tight shutdown.
00:10:32 I don't think that the last one is probably the most realistic of the three, but I thought the 510,000 was probably based on, how shall I put it, guesswork.
00:10:44 And it was that figure which impelled the government into adopting the, as it were, ultra policy of the almost complete economic shutdown, which it did adopt.
00:10:56 and it was that figure which or something similar which the swedish government examined
00:11:01 decided was not something they wished to follow and so they chose a more a more moderate policy
00:11:09 of encouraging social distancing and and isolation when necessary but not going for the almost total
00:11:17 shutdown of the economy that we've chosen the interesting thing is that sweden having taken
00:11:20 in what appears to me to be a moderate, thoughtful, and rational policy,
00:11:24 is constantly depicted in almost all the media
00:11:27 as some kind of wild, eccentric outlier.
00:11:30 And every report that's written from Sweden
00:11:32 is written on the basis that any minute now,
00:11:35 Sweden will be engulfed in hecatumns of death
00:11:37 and will regret its decision.
00:11:38 Well, maybe that's so. Who can predict the future?
00:11:41 But I think that there's been an almost total dismissal
00:11:46 of any thought that any policy other than the one adopted by the government is right.
00:11:50 And that dismissal began to come to an end really over the weekend and especially yesterday when we began to discuss much more seriously than before the economic dangers of what's going on.
00:12:02 Peter, why would there be that dismissal? I mean, we were talking presumably about the media. I mean, forget about that.
00:12:09 It's not just the media, it's the people.
00:12:12 I don't claim to speak, I never have, but I certainly on this occasion don't claim to speak for any kind of silent majority of people who object to the government's policy.
00:12:23 On the contrary, my experience is that the opinion polls which state something in the region of 93% support for what the government's doing are pretty much right.
00:12:32 I have
00:12:34 I've come up against this
00:12:37 among people whom I regard as intelligent
00:12:39 and thoughtful, they've completely and utterly
00:12:41 bought the government
00:12:43 view that the threat
00:12:45 from the coronavirus is so serious
00:12:47 that the only proper response was
00:12:49 to shut down the country
00:12:50 and it's very very widely
00:12:53 believed and it's not, I observe
00:12:55 social distancing, sometimes even
00:12:57 when I go to the supermarket I get a scarf
00:12:59 and wrap it around my face like a
00:13:01 bound it uh because i i feel it might comfort other people not because i actually believe that
00:13:08 this stuff will necessarily do any good though i don't think it does any harm but because i think
00:13:12 if people on the wide scale do believe it then it would be both rude inconsiderate and arrogant of
00:13:17 me to go around ignoring it so i don't i observe it i recommend other people to to observe it
00:13:22 but i don't feel myself uh that the danger justifies it and i don't i think we are we're
00:13:29 overdoing it. I think there is a danger of this disease but there's no
00:13:33 evidence whatsoever from any of the countries where there have been
00:13:36 outbreaks that the sort of measures adopted by the British government will
00:13:40 save any lives beyond those which are being saved in Sweden. There's a
00:13:44 fascinating example on the continent of this, two neighbouring very similar
00:13:47 countries, both of which I know quite well, Belgium and the Netherlands. The
00:13:51 Netherlands has adopted a lighter touch and Belgium a much more heavy-handed
00:13:57 regime. Both of them are suffering deaths, but in fact the one which is
00:14:02 suffering more deaths is Belgium, not Netherlands. I don't think this is
00:14:05 actually has anything to do with the policies. It will be some other factor
00:14:09 which we don't actually understand. There is nothing which seems to me to
00:14:12 demonstrate that this policy is effective in reducing deaths. If it
00:14:16 really were, then there would be a much stronger argument for it, but people have
00:14:19 bought it. I think one of the ways of getting people to support a government
00:14:25 is fear and i think people are very much very afraid of special things they can't see
00:14:31 it's one of the reasons why nuclear power is frightening you can't see radiation and with
00:14:37 a virus you can't see that either and once you think it's there all around you it could strike
00:14:41 and kill you without you're even seeing or knowing it once you fear that you might this is not just
00:14:45 a wholly selfish thing of worrying about yourself if you think i might take home a virus which will
00:14:50 kill somebody i love and people will be captivated by this and will take it very seriously and i
00:14:57 think what again what fraser nelson wrote was the government was amazed by just how much voluntary
00:15:03 support its policy got the the ludicrous heavy-handedness of some of the police forces
00:15:08 in trying to make people stay at home and not go sunbathing or the rest of it didn't reflect in
00:15:15 any way the reality in the country the reality in the country was almost everybody was very keen to
00:15:20 observed this there are very few people who weren't and that remains the case and this is
00:15:26 this is um as a fear uh is the basis in the sort of hobgian pact between state and people where the
00:15:33 people clustered around the skirts of government begging to be safe from danger and almost nothing
00:15:40 will persuade them to stop and it's for someone like me who was brought up very much to be a free
00:15:45 person who was skeptical of government and never believed uh what he was told without checking on
00:15:51 the old Otto von Bismarck principle and never believe anything until it's been officially
00:15:54 denied. To see people I know educated intelligent experienced people uh taking this stuff as red as
00:16:01 if it's all certain and true has been uh actually quite frightening for me. I thought that I lived
00:16:07 in a society of free confident people concerned to protect their limiters and I find out in a
00:16:13 a country which actually longs to swoon
00:16:18 into the outstretched arms of Big Brother.
00:16:21 Well, in that case, what changed then, Peter?
00:16:23 What changed?
00:16:24 Why, I mean, what is so different about this one?
00:16:27 I think a huge number of things have changed.
00:16:29 This is the nature of the Cultural Revolution,
00:16:31 which I'm constantly going on about.
00:16:33 An education system,
00:16:34 which was previously taught certainly an educated elite
00:16:37 how to think rather than what to think
00:16:39 has been largely dismantled.
00:16:41 the the enormous power of electronic and then social media to enforce conformism is always
00:16:49 underestimated this is one of the things they do very very quickly they create a mob feeling or
00:16:55 they create a feeling of emulation people when color television first began to be important
00:17:00 people wanted to look like the sort of people they saw on television and sound like the same
00:17:05 sense of humor the same jokes the same tastes in clothes and food and everything else very rapidly
00:17:10 became almost universal and the same taste in thought as well and social media have a have an
00:17:15 even more powerful effect on this because especially twitter but other places as well i think
00:17:21 and those who do not fit in with the with whatever is the agreed and accepted point of view
00:17:28 come under quite unpleasant attack i mean i i can speak of this because it happens to me
00:17:33 i personally imagine this attack as being a few people uh sitting in basements quietly converting
00:17:39 fizzy drinks into human lard
00:17:41 while posting rude remarks on the internet
00:17:43 I'm not afraid of them
00:17:44 but other people actually think this is genuine
00:17:47 force of emotion
00:17:48 and it's a kind of thought policing
00:17:50 and people are afraid of it
00:17:53 and if you haven't been exposed to it a lot
00:17:55 and if you take it too seriously
00:17:57 then it will indeed frighten people
00:18:00 and it can
00:18:01 it can destroy, we've seen
00:18:03 it can destroy people
00:18:04 employers are frightened of it
00:18:07 and they will sack people who come under certain forms of pressure.
00:18:11 So it is a conformist force, and I think those are the two main things.
00:18:15 The collapse of old-fashioned elitist education,
00:18:18 which believed that you needed in a country a group of people
00:18:21 who would stand up responsibly, think for themselves,
00:18:24 not be told what to do, were prepared to say boo to a goose
00:18:27 and say to a government, you might be wrong.
00:18:30 That's gone.
00:18:31 And a hugely, toughly enforced conformist idea
00:18:36 of what everybody should think.
00:18:39 Also, presumably part of that is that, you know,
00:18:41 when one talks about the kind of British, you know,
00:18:48 belligerence, if you like, about liberty
00:18:49 and questioning authority, certainly.
00:18:53 And if that's gone, then presumably this is because people
00:18:55 don't really know about it also.
00:18:58 They don't know about the sort of traditions
00:19:00 that may be of Magna Carta and this sort of thing in Britain.
00:19:04 They don't.
00:19:05 I don't think David Cowan used to go on
00:19:08 this is an Etonian Oxford graduate
00:19:11 supposedly with a first class degree
00:19:13 in philosophy, politics and economics
00:19:14 who apparently he kept on saying
00:19:17 that we ought to have a British Bill of Rights
00:19:20 he apparently didn't know that we had one
00:19:21 and I doubt very much whether he's read it
00:19:23 or knows the history of it
00:19:25 he claimed not to know what Magna Carter meant
00:19:27 maybe this is an elaborate Cameroonian joke
00:19:30 I don't know but I have a horrible feeling
00:19:32 it might have been true
00:19:33 a lot of people don't know very much about what i was brought up to call the glorious revolution
00:19:39 and the constitutional effects of that they are they don't understand the importance of jury
00:19:43 trial the presumption of innocence the police increasingly don't and large numbers people in
00:19:48 the legal profession seem not to grasp it either so it's not very surprising if uh if these things
00:19:54 die liberty exists in the hearts of the people who have it and my own view is that we're probably
00:19:59 to need to rewrite quite a lot of our national songs when this is all over rule britannia i
00:20:03 think especially needs a good rewrite now what do you think i mean if you what would you want
00:20:10 to happen actually if what what would be the uh the course of action that we should take now if
00:20:18 it's up to you well i think we've done this thing mobilizing a huge and as i say fundamentally
00:20:27 benevolent public opinion people believe that they're doing good and right by engaging in this
00:20:33 so it's going to have to be brought to an end slowly gradually by a salami slicing process so
00:20:39 you take something for instance which a lot of people will welcome when it comes and i think it
00:20:43 will the reopening of the primary schools uh that will that will be the beginning i think of the
00:20:49 transformation and then bit by bit various sectors it's ludicrous for instance that supermarkets can
00:20:55 open but garden centres can't and all kinds of other shops which are which are not allowed to
00:20:59 open people are going to bit by bit uh going to reopen for instance cafes will reopen as
00:21:08 as takeaways uh increasingly i see this happening but the traffic will begin to come back onto the
00:21:16 roads people will feel less conspicuous about being out and about i think it can only be managed
00:21:20 gradually and personally i would love it if it could be ended uh very swiftly because of the
00:21:25 damage i believe it's doing and the good it's failing to do but i i accept that it's a difficult
00:21:31 political problem for the government to march people back down the hill having marched them
00:21:34 all the way up and they're not going to be able to do it easily or quickly so i think there will be
00:21:39 there will be a continued official shutdown with various bits and pieces of it being relaxed we'll
00:21:48 probably all end up i shudder at the thought of this uh three four five months from now they're
00:21:54 going to the shops wearing face masks and not because there'll be a law about it but i would
00:21:59 imagine a lot of shops will say you can't come in unless you wear one another and there'll be a lot
00:22:03 of social pressure to do so and things like that the the effects of it will linger on for a very
00:22:08 long time but the core of it the core of it leading to the shutdown of the economy will begin i think
00:22:14 to be dismantled piece by piece
00:22:18 in maybe two or three weeks' time
00:22:20 and accelerating from there.
00:22:22 That's a guess.
00:22:23 And that's how I would do it if I were them,
00:22:25 because you can't ignore the public feeling
00:22:29 which you've created, and nor should you.
00:22:32 What do you think, we've sort of alluded to,
00:22:35 if you like, the midterm future,
00:22:37 but what do you think the permanent marks
00:22:40 will be on our culture?
00:22:42 Well, I don't know.
00:22:43 I think that it would be very, very hard for us to continue to claim to be a people particularly concerned with our own liberty.
00:22:50 I think relations between the police and the public, already pretty bad, will deteriorate.
00:22:54 I think a lot of people have seen the police in a new light.
00:22:58 None of this has surprised me, by the way.
00:23:02 There remain, as one must say, plenty of perfectly decent people in the police force, but there are the other kind as well.
00:23:10 and that the distance between the police and the public has grown greatly
00:23:15 since they ceased to patrol preventively on foot
00:23:18 and they tend to view the public as civilians and themselves
00:23:21 as sort of pseudo-military professionals
00:23:23 and I think that it will not, unless there's a really serious attempt
00:23:29 made to rebuild public trust and good relations, I think that will...
00:23:33 I don't I think that what will preoccupy people will be the living in in a world
00:23:42 which is economically so much poorer than one we had before this began I think
00:23:47 people will be shocked when they discover just how I people are going to
00:23:52 experience such things as pay cuts really something not experienced in this
00:23:56 country since the 1930s I can't see how the tax increases which will be
00:24:01 necessary to sustain public services uh will not affect the poor as well as the rich because you
00:24:06 won't be able to raise enough money allies i i for instance would be amazed if the the long
00:24:12 holiday on rises in fuel duty can be sustained so everybody who drives a car for the purposes of
00:24:18 going to work is almost certainly going to have to pay more all kinds of travel is going to is
00:24:22 going to cost more foreign travel and holidays are going to be quite shockingly more expensive
00:24:26 and people are just going to be living
00:24:28 in a bleaker state than they were before
00:24:32 and quite a lot of people will have no jobs
00:24:34 and people who spent years of getting into debt
00:24:38 and working all the hours that God sent
00:24:40 building up flourishing but narrow margins
00:24:44 and small businesses will have been destroyed by this
00:24:47 and will have no way back.
00:24:48 What will happen to them?
00:24:49 I think that will be the most profound difference
00:24:52 and I don't know what the long-term political consequence
00:24:56 would be that who will be blamed and what form that blame will take but it worries me because
00:25:02 it seems to me to threaten the stability of the state if you have large amounts of people who have
00:25:06 in effect been deprived of perfectly reasonable livings by government action which may well
00:25:13 in time be seen to have been precipitous and mistaken do you perceive in any way any kind
00:25:20 of political divide Peter in response to this between left and right I mean do you have you
00:25:26 noticed any particular consistency between the the two sides? Not really it's been interesting
00:25:34 to see how many people in of the left who what six months ago would have regarded Al Johnson as
00:25:42 as all kinds of rude words some which I won't repeat here and would have treated him with
00:25:49 contempt rallying behind him and i i i think that the the performance of the official opposition
00:25:59 in parliament has been supine in fact that's one of the things which has struck me about this
00:26:04 all the supposed breaks and safety valves in our competition designed to prevent foolish decisions
00:26:11 and to prevent wild, downhill rushes into dangerous politics.
00:26:18 All of them completely failed.
00:26:19 The opposition didn't oppose.
00:26:20 Parliament didn't debate.
00:26:22 Parliament accepted the highly suspect COVID coronavirus act
00:26:29 without even dividing from vote, for goodness sake.
00:26:32 The legal profession, where were they?
00:26:33 All the people who were so ready to take the government to court
00:26:36 over the European issue,
00:26:38 silent over very considerable limitations on personal liberty which are the business of the
00:26:45 courts it seems to me not a word much of the media uh silent or against supine uh civil society in
00:26:53 general uh demonstrated that faced with a determined government wanting to impose measures
00:27:00 of quite radical importance
00:27:03 on the population
00:27:04 did nothing.
00:27:06 So I think our own self-applaus
00:27:09 as a great democratic state
00:27:12 is going to have to stop it.
00:27:14 I would like to see
00:27:15 a re-examination of that,
00:27:17 but I'm not sure it would
00:27:18 do all that much good
00:27:19 because you will still have
00:27:20 the huge forces for conformism
00:27:22 which helped to bring us about.
00:27:24 I don't see a good future
00:27:27 for politics in any of this.
00:27:28 it makes me, if it's possible, slightly more pessimistic than I was before.
00:27:33 As for the churches, which again feebly gave in instructions to lock their doors,
00:27:44 all kinds of things.
00:27:46 I tell this as a joke, the church that I attend is so sparsely attended
00:27:50 that we could easily stand 20 feet away from each other without any difficulty at all.
00:27:56 but no when the church wardens went to the church authorities
00:28:00 we could perfectly well no no absolutely not there's no flexibility
00:28:03 nothing at all and I think the locking of the churches that you couldn't even go
00:28:07 in in them for prayer and thought and solace was an extraordinarily bad
00:28:19 mistake and I think they will suffer from that as well I think people will
00:28:22 feel that their spiritual path is rather abandonment during this period that
00:28:26 all the damage to the extent that that matters most to me,
00:28:29 because I know it doesn't matter with a lot of other people,
00:28:30 but I think it's an example of how things have failed.
00:28:35 Just to round off, Peter, when one talks about the reaction of the British,
00:28:41 it's disproportionate.
00:28:44 Then quite often the answer you get back is, yes,
00:28:46 but the whole world is in this position.
00:28:48 The whole world is responding like this.
00:28:50 I mean, you know, they look to America maybe particularly.
00:28:53 I mean it's not quite you look at countries which I have a sort of soft
00:29:03 spots for including Japan where there's been a lot of formal passing of states
00:29:09 of emergency but in fact the people have by large been allowed to act
00:29:12 responsibly on their own behalf as British people have also done but
00:29:16 without without the oppressive side of it and I have to say that so far the
00:29:23 outcome of this has certainly been no worse than what's happened here and it's
00:29:28 dangerous to say before the whole thing is over but there's certainly no current
00:29:33 indication that Japan's policy has caused more difficulty and more deaths
00:29:38 than our policy. The Netherlands as I say has been, has used a lighter touch, it's
00:29:43 kept quiet about it, a lighter touch than its immediate neighbour and sort of
00:29:47 twin Belgium and I don't think there's any evidence that that has caused any
00:29:51 great danger and there remains
00:29:53 say the great example of Sweden
00:29:55 which simply has
00:29:57 done what grown up
00:29:59 maybe what grown up governments
00:30:01 do. Now if it turns out
00:30:03 and I have to say
00:30:05 every single thing I say about this is predicated
00:30:07 on the understanding that I might be
00:30:09 wrong and if I'm wrong
00:30:11 then it's far too important for me to stand
00:30:13 around saying no no I was right all along you're
00:30:15 right. If I'm wrong I admit it
00:30:18 and I'll say okay so I'm mistaken
00:30:19 if the Swedish government finds
00:30:21 that it was wrong and that its policies can be shown to produce more
00:30:28 dangers to the population then I have no doubt whatsoever that the Swedish
00:30:31 government will alter its policy and that would be a sensible thing to do but if
00:30:37 that doesn't happen and the Swedish government gets through this, Sweden gets
00:30:41 through this without a terrible number of deaths and without trashing its
00:30:45 economy then that seems to me to be a reproach to those who behaved otherwise
00:30:49 That's why the whole Swedish history was so important
00:30:51 and why almost all media coverage of Sweden in this country
00:30:55 is hostile and based, let's say, on the view that any minute now
00:30:59 it's all going to go terribly wrong and they're wildly eccentric.
00:31:05 Well, look, Pina, thank you very much for coming on.
00:31:08 How are you actually sort of like, how has your life changed at all,
00:31:13 you know, now that we're in sort of this kind of lockdown thing?
00:31:15 Well, I hate not being able to go to the office.
00:31:19 My late brother used to say that he worked in Fleet Street
00:31:23 so he didn't have to run the newspapers to find out what was going on.
00:31:26 I love all the stuff that you get in the office
00:31:30 that doesn't ever get into the paper.
00:31:32 And I love the contact with colleagues and all the others.
00:31:35 I don't like living in London,
00:31:37 but I love going to London five times a week
00:31:39 and sampling the atmosphere of the great capital of the major country
00:31:44 and feeling it in the way that you can't
00:31:47 when you're far away
00:31:48 and so those are the things
00:31:51 I greatly miss, I miss
00:31:52 the routine, I've worked from home before
00:31:54 I worked from home when I was a correspondent in Moscow
00:31:57 and in Washington, I never found
00:31:59 it very satisfactory then, I don't think you'd like it
00:32:01 now either, that's the main
00:32:03 thing that I
00:32:05 have missed, it's been
00:32:07 otherwise there's been curious
00:32:08 I wouldn't call them blessings
00:32:12 but there have been curious aspects of it
00:32:14 All the time, some nights of this, I've lain awake listening to the economy collapsing,
00:32:20 which is a nasty noise to listen to, and to freedom dying, and thinking that this is difficult.
00:32:28 Then I go out, I live in Oxford, which is at any time of any one of the most beautiful places on the planet,
00:32:35 and under these circumstances, within this heartbreaking beautiful spring,
00:32:41 is, of course, more lovely than I've ever seen it
00:32:46 with the full clarity of the air,
00:32:48 the absence of traffic noise, which I hate.
00:32:50 I hate motorcars.
00:32:52 I'd love to see motorcars disappear from the face of the earth.
00:32:55 And they have.
00:32:56 But for all that,
00:32:58 you get a vision of how different the world could be
00:33:02 if it were differently organised.
00:33:04 But at the same time, it also looks, as well as very beautiful,
00:33:07 like a large, well-ordered cemetery.
00:33:09 and there's something very dispiriting
00:33:12 about what you know as
00:33:14 and have lived in for more than half a century
00:33:16 a lively and a very active place
00:33:21 suddenly reduced to an empty museum
00:33:24 of lovely buildings
00:33:26 with the clear light shining on them
00:33:28 and hardly a sound to be heard.
00:33:31 On that beautiful note,
00:33:33 thank you, Peter, for coming on again.
00:33:35 Thank you very much.
00:33:36 And, well, I do hope that maybe
00:33:38 in a few weeks or months time you'll be you'll be back and maybe in person but
00:33:43 thank you very very much indeed thank you it's a pleasure thank you that's it
00:33:51 for this week so what you're saying is and we'll look forward to seeing you
00:33:55 next time thank you very much