Off the Record - July 12, 2024


An unhinged Elizabeth May

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
John A Macdonald gets memory-holed Trudeau buys $9m luxury condo for former journalist

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

189.11

Word count

8,164

Sentence count

441

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

16

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this week's Off The Record, Andrew Lawton is joined by True North Chief Operations Officer, William McBeth, and our Alberta correspondent, Isaac Lamoureux, to talk about all things halal chicken and KFC.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 You're dressing down today, Isaac.
00:00:02 Yeah, like, I mean, it's almost unbearable in my house heat-wise, so I thought that a
00:00:10 suit would be a bit too hot, even right now, without the fan on.
00:00:15 Even with the fan on, I'm barely surviving here.
00:00:19 And I think you're wearing the same thing you were last time, William, so I have no
00:00:22 comments about your apparel.
00:00:23 I think so.
00:00:24 I was going to say it was 35 degrees here in Calgary yesterday, but of course, we are
00:00:29 in the middle of Scampede, and the best weather for Scampede is hot and sunny.
00:00:32 That's what you want it to be for the whole 10 days, so I'm not complaining, because this
00:00:37 is a beautiful time to be in Scampede.
00:00:40 All right, let's get this thing on the road.
00:00:50 Hello and welcome, everyone, to another exciting, or at least I hope exciting, edition of Off
00:00:55 the Record.
00:00:55 This is our Friday kickback show.
00:00:57 We cycle through a rotating cast of the True North characters, and we chit-chat about
00:01:02 the stories we have covered through the week, some of the ones we didn't get to.
00:01:06 We try to find the lighter side in this turbulent, chaotic, and crazy world as much as we can.
00:01:11 As I've joked with a couple of people, the worse things are for the country, the better
00:01:14 they are for our shows.
00:01:16 And Off the Record is no exception.
00:01:18 I'm Andrew Lawton, with you for the next However Long This Takes, joined by True North
00:01:22 Chief Operations Officer.
00:01:24 Or is it Chief Operating Officer?
00:01:25 I don't know, I just call you COO usually, William McBeth, and our Alberta correspondent,
00:01:30 Isaac Lamoureux.
00:01:31 Good to have you both with us.
00:01:33 How's the Alberta summer treating you?
00:01:36 It's great here in Calgary.
00:01:37 As I said, Scampede season, everybody's happy.
00:01:40 It's hot.
00:01:41 It's sunny.
00:01:41 We have water again.
00:01:43 Everything's coming up, Calgary.
00:01:46 Yeah.
00:01:47 It's okay here, I guess.
00:01:48 Really hot.
00:01:49 I'm dying in my house.
00:01:50 And all my friends are at the Stampede.
00:01:52 I guess they don't have to work nine to five jobs, so they can just go whenever they'd
00:01:55 like.
00:01:56 But I'm obviously in my office working.
00:01:59 Yes, and don't you forget it.
00:02:02 You're also in Edmonton, so it's not like, it's not like we're the reason, it's not like
00:02:05 I'm keeping you from Stampede.
00:02:07 Geography is keeping you from Stampede.
00:02:09 Now, what we did do is force Isaac to turn off his fan before the show began, because it
00:02:13 was like coming through to the microphone.
00:02:15 So if he's like, just like melting into a puddle by the end of it, that will be why.
00:02:19 So this is the benefit of live to tape.
00:02:22 Anyway, I must say, despite how people may make an assumption based on my appearance,
00:02:27 I'm not a huge fast food person.
00:02:29 Certainly, I could not tell you the last time I was at a KFC, but KFC has been in the news
00:02:36 this week, Isaac.
00:02:37 What's going on?
00:02:38 Yeah, I actually can't tell you the last time I've been to KFC either, but I definitely don't
00:02:44 plan on going anytime soon, given the recent news, which is that Ontario KFC restaurants,
00:02:50 sorry, Ontario KFC restaurants are going halal friendly or Muslim friendly with halal chicken
00:02:57 and the removal of pork products from their menu.
00:03:01 So all of the restaurants in Ontario, except those in Thunder Bay and in Ottawa, have switched
00:03:06 to halal chicken and removed pork products like bacon from their menu, except for the
00:03:13 joint KFC and Taco Bell locations.
00:03:16 Do you still get your bacon if the KFC is sharing a roof with a Taco Bell?
00:03:20 That's right.
00:03:21 So if you really want your bacon, you're going to have to go to a shared location.
00:03:26 And when we were discussing this on Monday, when we weren't even sure if it were true
00:03:30 or not, I thought for sure that it would be the case that it was just one radical owner
00:03:36 at one KFC location.
00:03:38 But all across the province, I mean, this is very surprising for me, especially considering
00:03:42 I like to think that Western culture sees bacon as one of their favorite foods, whereas when
00:03:50 I was looking at the data, the Muslim population in Ontario is about five to six percent.
00:03:55 So you're really alienating a lot more people than you're catering to, I'd say.
00:04:00 What do you guys think?
00:04:01 Yeah, and also I would say everyone's focusing on the Ontario bit, but if you can put that
00:04:05 letter back up, this is a letter that KFC sent out to community leaders.
00:04:10 So I believe it was sent out to like the heads of various Muslim organizations and mosques
00:04:14 back in May.
00:04:15 It says this will be followed by the rest of Canada by year end.
00:04:20 So by the end of the year, they'll have taken this Ontario project and made it national.
00:04:25 So this is causing a bit of a moral panic of sorts on Twitter.
00:04:28 You've got some people that are saying, you know, boycott KFC.
00:04:31 I don't want to eat that halal chicken. 1.00
00:04:32 I actually am of the mindset that I don't really care.
00:04:35 I've had halal chicken.
00:04:36 One of my favorite go to things if I am out in the world is shawarma and shawarma restaurants
00:04:41 are almost all halal.
00:04:42 I do think that whenever a company makes a decision like this, you always have to wonder
00:04:47 why is it because they're looking at a decision that's being made for commercial reasons
00:04:53 or is it that they're doing something to try to pander?
00:04:56 And apparently, I didn't realize this until I was looking into this story.
00:04:59 Almost all the chicken chains in Canada are halal, like Mary Brown's is halal, Popeye's 1.00
00:05:05 is halal.
00:05:05 So KFC in that way is a bit of a laggard.
00:05:08 I'm more intrigued by the removal of bacon because it's one thing to add something to the
00:05:13 menu that doesn't really change anything for anyone else.
00:05:15 Like you're not, you don't become a Muslim when you have halal chicken, but taking away something 1.00
00:05:19 the consumers wanted, that to me is a bit more, that to me, I find a bit more interesting
00:05:26 here.
00:05:27 What do you think, William?
00:05:28 Yeah, I was thinking about the bacon thing and I don't recall the last time I was at
00:05:33 a KFC and I'm not sure if anything they sell has bacon on it, but then I thought-
00:05:39 They said they were removing pork from the menu, so it must have been on the menu in some
00:05:43 form.
00:05:43 I guess so.
00:05:44 I mean, logically, yes, that would make sense.
00:05:46 I guess now I was thinking though, that if you think about big fast food chains like
00:05:50 McDonald's or Burger King or even Subway and I mean, Starbucks has breakfast sandwiches.
00:05:56 All of these places have bacon and it can't be that Muslim people don't go to any of those
00:06:03 fast food restaurants, right?
00:06:05 Like I can't imagine that that precludes people from going there and ordering, like if you're
00:06:11 at McDonald's, I don't know, the Filet-O-Fish, which probably has very little bacon on it
00:06:15 altogether.
00:06:15 So that led me to think this was more about virtue signaling than it was about specifically
00:06:22 addressing the religious dietary requirements of a segment of the Canadian population.
00:06:28 And virtue signaling, of course, is something that companies love to do without always thinking
00:06:32 through, well, it cuts both ways.
00:06:34 It signals good things, but then what other signal does it send maybe to the rest of Canada?
00:06:38 So something to think about.
00:06:39 Yeah, and when it comes to like kosher food and kosher restaurants, some Orthodox Jews 1.00
00:06:45 do have very strict requirements on the facilities and even on the plates, like they can't even
00:06:50 eat off of a plate that at one point had non-kosher meat or meat and dairy mixed or something
00:06:55 like that.
00:06:55 I'm not aware of Islam being so strict.
00:06:59 And again, that's just like Orthodox Jews. 1.00
00:07:01 So I don't even think there is a facility rule where if bacon was served on something else, they can't have even the
00:07:07 halal chicken on the menu.
00:07:08 I don't know about that.
00:07:09 But what was the reaction like to this that you saw, Isaac?
00:07:14 Yeah, well, firstly, I was actually looking at the stock price.
00:07:18 This is from Yum Food or Yum Brands, which is the parent company of KFC.
00:07:23 And I was like, oh, maybe because obviously Legacy Media has picked up this story now.
00:07:28 So I thought, OK, the story is getting around.
00:07:30 We'll see if their stock price has dropped.
00:07:31 And to my surprise, it hasn't really, although it did drop over the last month, but not in relation
00:07:36 to this news from what I can tell just based on the timeline there.
00:07:39 But of course, people on X are always more critical than any other public sphere.
00:07:45 So yeah, there was definitely some backlash on X, but it hasn't really reflected their stock price.
00:07:49 So I don't know that that's obviously what they're going to care about most as a company in regard
00:07:55 to public backlash.
00:07:56 So if their stock hasn't taken a hit, I don't think they're going to see a fault in their action
00:08:00 personally.
00:08:02 Yeah, and it's also like one of these things that seems very online.
00:08:06 Like the average consumer would have no idea going into a KFC on one day that, oh, this
00:08:12 chicken tastes halal versus the time before.
00:08:14 Now, I don't know.
00:08:15 I don't know if the restaurants are now like in some areas putting up big signs that say,
00:08:18 you know, now halal.
00:08:20 Like I don't know how much attention they're drawing to it.
00:08:22 What I found interesting and one of the reasons I found this to be suspect originally, because
00:08:26 what happened was this letter that we put up on the screen earlier, we're circulating
00:08:30 online.
00:08:30 The letter is dated May.
00:08:32 We're now July 11th.
00:08:34 So anytime you see something that you're like, okay, why now?
00:08:37 And I had wondered if it was photoshopped or if it was faked or something like that.
00:08:40 So the fact that it's taken this long means that KFC, it seemed like in May when they
00:08:45 made this change, was really just quietly announcing it to members of the Muslim community.
00:08:49 They weren't trying to draw a lot of attention to it.
00:08:52 And when we wrote the story, I don't even think KFC responded.
00:08:54 Did they?
00:08:57 No, from what I read in the story, it said that they didn't.
00:09:00 Yeah.
00:09:01 Yeah.
00:09:01 And so that I found quite interesting.
00:09:03 So again, like at the end of the day, who cares?
00:09:05 It's a company.
00:09:06 They can do what they want.
00:09:07 But I'm always just so skeptical of any corporate decisions now, that they're not rooted in anything
00:09:14 resembling what they're supposed to be.
00:09:16 And the great example I give about that is that I live not too far from General Dynamics
00:09:22 Land Systems, which in my city of London, Ontario, is known for exporting armored vehicles
00:09:27 to Saudi Arabia.
00:09:28 So it's amusing when you drive by and you see like the trans-friendly pride flag up in
00:09:34 front of the facility manufacturing Saudi tanks.
00:09:38 And you're like, well, why don't you just put one of those on every one to Saudi Arabia?
00:09:40 Why don't you just slap that on the vehicles there?
00:09:43 Oh, because you don't actually believe this when it's about your business that you're pandering
00:09:47 to.
00:09:48 Yeah.
00:09:49 And I had to laugh that if I guess if KFC really wanted to drive home the point, every
00:09:53 location would have a cutout of the Prophet Muhammad eating a chicken sandwich.
00:09:58 Or something, which I doubt is what they're going to do.
00:10:02 I don't think we're going to see that in KFC time soon.
00:10:05 But yeah, every time you see a company try to virtue signal or put out something that
00:10:10 seems to be more about style than substance, you have to wonder if, is there an ulterior
00:10:17 motive or is this simply a business decision as usual and everybody should go about their
00:10:23 lives?
00:10:23 I mean, personally, I'm waiting for Chick-fil-A to open up here again in Calgary and solves
00:10:28 all my problems.
00:10:29 So yeah, we have a Chick-fil-A in London now.
00:10:32 And the problem is it's like clean on the other end of town.
00:10:34 So I've never actually been to it, although there was a time I would have killed for it.
00:10:37 And I don't know if Chick-fil-A is halal.
00:10:39 I don't think so.
00:10:41 I couldn't tell you.
00:10:42 Don't know.
00:10:43 Probably I'm not going to do the homework on it either, if I'm honest.
00:10:46 So one thing I will say, when you mentioned earlier, William, other restaurants that have
00:10:50 bacon and pork, the thing that's interesting, I've actually been to the Middle East.
00:10:54 I've been to, well, Egypt is not Middle East, but it's a Muslim country.
00:10:57 And I've been to the United Arab Emirates.
00:10:58 And you don't realize how important pork is until you go to a breakfast buffet in a Muslim 1.00
00:11:06 country and you realize that pork sausages are better than any other sausages and pork
00:11:12 bacon is better than any other bacon.
00:11:13 Like they all have the alternatives, but they really, really pale in comparison to the real
00:11:18 thing.
00:11:19 Well, and let's be clear.
00:11:20 It's not bacon if it's not made from pork.
00:11:23 No matter what the soy lobby tells you, soy bacon is not bacon.
00:11:27 Or turkey bacon, beef bacon.
00:11:29 I mean, turkey bacon, which is better than soy bacon, is still not actual bacon.
00:11:33 It's a poor imitation at best.
00:11:36 Yeah.
00:11:37 If you gave me a turkey bacon, let's say, and said it was sausage or something, I'd be less
00:11:41 disappointed because once you hear the word bacon, you know, you think of what bacon is,
00:11:45 the taste, the smell, everything that makes it so wonderful.
00:11:48 And then you taste turkey bacon, for example, and it's like, oh, you're just going to be disappointed
00:11:52 because it's not comparable in any way.
00:11:55 All right.
00:11:56 Well, we can all agree on the importance of bacon.
00:11:59 Anyway, let's move to the next topic, which I've very much forgotten.
00:12:03 So excuse me while I desperately try to find where we are in our rundown here.
00:12:07 Oh, I'm not even doing it.
00:12:08 It's you.
00:12:09 William, speaking of the Middle East, what has Canada been exporting there?
00:12:12 Yeah.
00:12:13 Well, you know, if you watch international news, you usually see the prime minister embarrassing
00:12:18 Canada on the international stage.
00:12:20 He's, I believe, down in the United States right now at a NATO summit pledging that Canada
00:12:26 will finally meet its 2% GDP goal, although he's providing precious few details on how that
00:12:32 will achieve.
00:12:33 But one area where apparently Canada is just thundering forward and leading the way is in
00:12:40 intersectional feminism. 1.00
00:12:42 According to our representative in Lebanon, she attended a conference and she was proud
00:12:48 to say that good news, people of Lebanon, Canada's intersectional feminist approach to foreign
00:12:56 policy is going great.
00:12:58 Now, let's roll the clip before we unpack this further.
00:13:02 Yep.
00:13:04 As for Canada, it has been implementing a feminist foreign policy since 2016. 1.00
00:13:10 Canada's feminist foreign policy seeks to be inclusive, intersectional, transformative, and 0.51
00:13:16 grounded in human rights.
00:13:18 It takes into account the diverse experiences of women, men, and non-binary people facing multiple
00:13:25 and intersecting forms of discrimination and exclusion, like income, race, religion, sexual
00:13:32 orientation, gender expression, language, ability, and age.
00:13:37 This allows us to be more responsive to systemic inequalities, specific needs and circumstances,
00:13:43 and to avoid unintentional harm.
00:13:46 Our feminist foreign policy is also cross-cutting. 1.00
00:13:48 It applies across all of our international efforts, including diplomacy, trade, security, development,
00:13:56 and consular services.
00:14:01 That was Sylvie Michaud, who is a diplomat at the Embassy for Canada in Lebanon, speaking in
00:14:09 Beirut at the Asfari Institute for Civil Society and Citizenship.
00:14:15 Okay.
00:14:18 I'm a little bit, just, our colleague Cosman Georgia wrote about this, and he's noted that
00:14:25 perhaps the intersectional feminist foreign policy has not necessarily been well-received
00:14:31 in Lebanon, which has a child marriage and basically takes a very anti-woman view on anything
00:14:39 to do with family law.
00:14:41 So it's not really working, is it, Isaac?
00:14:44 Yeah, no, what came to mind actually was I saw a clip earlier of Trudeau speaking at the
00:14:50 NATO summit where they questioned him on the GDP spending, and he said Canada was punching
00:14:54 above its weight class, which obviously isn't true in regard to defense spending.
00:14:58 We have no plan to get to 2% of our GDP requirement as required by NATO allies.
00:15:04 But where Canada might be punching above its weight class actually is foreign investments
00:15:10 in anything to do with gender diversity, any DEI terms that come to mind, like intersectional
00:15:18 feminism. 1.00
00:15:20 So, I mean, I don't know, I kind of laughed even watching this, I was like, I don't really
00:15:26 even understand what's happening here.
00:15:29 And so it's like the flags on the GDLS vehicles, you know, you can send them there, but probably
00:15:35 not.
00:15:36 William, you worked for the Harper government previously, and that was a time when Canadian
00:15:40 foreign policy looked vastly different than it does now.
00:15:44 I mean, would you ever have imagined there that even under a liberal government, this
00:15:47 would be the way that we're portraying ourselves abroad?
00:15:50 Yeah, I mean, you know, this isn't to say, by the way, that advancing equality and human
00:15:56 rights for women isn't important. 1.00
00:15:58 It absolutely is the important thing.
00:16:01 The problem is the woke speech that so many of our diplomats now seem to employ at the behest
00:16:08 of our current government does tend to make countries like, say, example, Lebanon,
00:16:13 who is possibly going to go to war with Israel at some point in the near future, possibly it
00:16:20 seems out of step with the everyday concerns of people who are living in that country, that
00:16:25 maybe focusing on intersectional feminism is a luxury compared to, say, fundamental human 1.00
00:16:33 rights, the abolishment of religious courts, which tend to persecute minorities, women, and
00:16:39 people of different sexual orientations, or the fact that large swaths of the country
00:16:42 still don't have the infrastructure and quality of life that you would expect.
00:16:48 So, you know, when we show up in these places and preach about woke nonsense, it diminishes
00:16:56 Canada's standing in the world.
00:16:57 And certainly, say what you will, about Prime Minister Harper, he was taken far more seriously
00:17:03 and treated with far more respect than the current incumbent is right now.
00:17:08 I think there's something to the idea of leading by example rather than preaching.
00:17:14 And, you know, one of the things that the Stephen Harper government did was ensure there
00:17:18 was a path for gay people who were being persecuted in their home countries.
00:17:23 This was something they've done and the liberals have continued.
00:17:25 And showing that you respect gay rights, that projects a positive image to the world.
00:17:30 The problem when you go into countries that have vastly different worldviews and you start
00:17:34 telling them how they're supposed to do things, it just doesn't work.
00:17:38 And I mean, Saudi Arabia is an interesting example of it.
00:17:40 I saw this week there's a Nike ad that has been made that's in Saudi Arabia that is all
00:17:46 about basically women's empowerment. 0.89
00:17:48 It shows, you know, younger females that aren't wearing hijabs, that are doing sports, that 0.98
00:17:52 are swimming, running around, playing.
00:17:54 And again, the idea that an ad like that in Saudi Arabia, which again, a country that I will 1.00
00:17:58 not say is at all a bastion of liberalism for women's rights or any other minority rights,
00:18:04 but that that ad could be made there would have been unheard of.
00:18:07 But you don't get there by finger wagging.
00:18:09 And that's, I think, what the Canadian government is doing on a lot of these things.
00:18:14 Yeah, that's another thing that came to mind here was, I mean, why would Lebanon listen to 1.00
00:18:19 what we have to say?
00:18:20 Why would they care?
00:18:21 You know, we can tell them, oh, you have to do this.
00:18:23 You have to do that.
00:18:23 But as you alluded to, William, if Trudeau and Canada as a whole don't really have international
00:18:29 respect, they're not going to listen to us.
00:18:31 That's that's something people always brought up about former President Donald Trump was
00:18:35 like he said things, sure, but he he also commanded leaders his respect.
00:18:41 So I don't know.
00:18:42 And another thing that I wanted to mention was.
00:18:45 Call me a nationalist, I guess, but I just think of all the issues happening here in Canada
00:18:50 and maybe maybe I don't agree with investing hundreds of millions and billions of dollars
00:18:57 abroad when we have so many problems to fix in our own country.
00:19:02 Well, I know you're right about that.
00:19:03 I mean, the entire foreign aid discussion is one that I think desperately needs a reset,
00:19:08 because I've seen little to no evidence that the Canadian approach to foreign aid even works
00:19:13 and is yielding dividends.
00:19:16 I mean, the problem is that the countries that need the help the most are countries that typically
00:19:19 have rampant corruption and money ends up just in the pockets of dictators far more than
00:19:24 it helps any people.
00:19:27 Yeah, no, it's a sad reality that so much of foreign aid, well intentioned foreign aid is
00:19:32 simply going to make thugs and criminals wealthy in these countries that desperately need help.
00:19:38 But it requires, I think, some really new thinking and using the new technology that we have available
00:19:44 to us.
00:19:44 You know, there are examples of where governments are bypassing NGOs and governments entirely
00:19:50 and simply loading money onto the cell phones of individual people living in very desperate
00:19:56 circumstances because it's the only way that they can get around the pickpocketing that happens
00:20:01 for so many foreign aid budgets.
00:20:03 But you're absolutely right.
00:20:04 And of course, foreign aid comes at a cost.
00:20:06 You know, money we spend on foreign aid is money we can't spend on Canadian health care,
00:20:12 is money we can't spend on our armed forces, is money we can't spend on any other of the
00:20:16 thousand priorities that exist.
00:20:18 So, you know, when you see Canadian diplomats traveling the world and talking about things
00:20:24 like intersectional feminism, it does make you wonder, really, how much bang for our bucks 1.00
00:20:30 we're getting on this dog and pony show that we call foreign affairs.
00:20:33 What we really need when it comes to projecting an image of Canada to the world is the austere
00:20:40 reverence of Elizabeth May.
00:20:43 Roll it.
00:20:44 I've got another grandbaby coming at the end of October and I feel very, very committed
00:20:51 as I think everybody my age should.
00:20:55 Baby boomers have f***ed this planet and we can't walk away and leave it for our kids to 1.00
00:21:01 fix it. 0.99
00:21:02 And I'm sorry I just used the F word out loud, but I think kids understand what I'm saying.
00:21:06 I'm a very, I'm a 70 year old, angry, cranky version of Glitta Thunberg.
00:21:11 And am I ready?
00:21:12 You bet.
00:21:13 I feel like you could Photoshop in like a giant overflowing wine glass there in the shot
00:21:18 and it would just, it would be probably even more believable.
00:21:22 Now, this is a woman who in the past, I would remind you all, has kind of become the civility
00:21:29 tone checker in the House of Commons.
00:21:32 This was her taking aim at Michelle Rempel Garner back when she was just Michelle Rempel for
00:21:37 using a different F word in the parliamentary precinct.
00:21:42 Why does this government treat Alberta like a fart in the room that nobody wants to talk
00:21:47 about or acknowledge?
00:21:49 That is where my constituents have been at with this government for over a year.
00:21:53 The Honorable Member for Saanich Gulf Islands.
00:21:56 I interrupt my friend in her speech, but I heard her say a word that I know is distinctly
00:22:03 unparliamentary and I think she may want to withdraw it.
00:22:06 The word was F-A-R-T.
00:22:09 Are we, are you serious, Mr. Speaker?
00:22:11 Like, is my colleague actually serious?
00:22:12 I just gave an impassioned speech about supporting Alberta jobs.
00:22:16 And that's what the leader of a political party stands up and has to say.
00:22:20 No, I don't withdraw it.
00:22:22 Decorum is important and respect is important to this place.
00:22:26 I remind those who are now heckling me that you are breaking the rules of this place when
00:22:30 you do so.
00:22:32 Okay, just, just again, let's go back to the other Elizabeth May clip, Elizabeth May this
00:22:36 week.
00:22:37 I, I just want to get that sense of decorum.
00:22:39 Baby boomers have f***ed this planet and we can't walk away and leave it for our kids to 1.00
00:22:45 fix it. 0.98
00:22:46 I, I'm not one of these profanity pearl clutchers.
00:22:50 I, I keep profanity out of my show and we generally keep it out of True North.
00:22:54 If you want to get Elizabeth May uncensored, you can, you know, do that on Twitter.
00:22:58 Um, so I, again, I'm not, so I don't really care, but it's a little rich for her to, you
00:23:02 know, take aim at Michelle Rempel using a four letter F word for flatulence while dropping 0.99
00:23:07 the mother of all F-bombs, uh, herself. 0.83
00:23:10 Again, I, am I, am I reading, am I paying too much attention to Elizabeth May, Isaac?
00:23:14 This is, I'm totally prepared to accept that.
00:23:16 Uh, I don't think so.
00:23:18 And look, a lot of the chatter online, let's say has, has, has, uh, alleged, I guess that
00:23:26 she was drunk or whatever.
00:23:27 And I don't want, I don't want to speak to that because I don't know whether she was or
00:23:30 not, but I am slightly, I will say concerned about Elizabeth May.
00:23:34 Like, is she okay on numerous occasions.
00:23:37 Now we've seen very odd things most recently from when she had a completely different interpretation
00:23:43 of the, uh, NSOP report than Jagmeet Singh did.
00:23:47 Cause of course he said, he said there were treacherous MPs and she said, oh no, there's
00:23:50 no, there's no treacherous MPs.
00:23:52 Uh, the media blew it out of proportion, which are two very, very, very different things to
00:23:55 say about our report.
00:23:56 Very different.
00:23:57 So I, I'm, I'm, I'm very concerned, uh, about Elizabeth May.
00:24:02 Uh, also her co-leader, uh, or whatever, Jonathan Pedneau just resigned.
00:24:07 And he said it was family issues, but of course there could be something deeper to that story
00:24:12 as well.
00:24:12 I'm not, I'm not really sure.
00:24:14 I don't know.
00:24:15 And Elizabeth May is kind of all over the place. 1.00
00:24:17 She also, uh, just said that it was quote obvious that it was time for Justin Trudeau
00:24:21 to step down, which I, I wouldn't say I disagree with, but I mean, she's really putting herself
00:24:25 out there more than we may have been used to in the past.
00:24:28 She's basically made herself out to be the permanent leader of the green party.
00:24:32 There was that brief break from her with Anna May Paul, who was probably one of the
00:24:35 more credible, sensible people that party has.
00:24:39 And now we're like right back into Elizabeth May being just the, the permanent, the permanent
00:24:44 party leader for the greens.
00:24:47 Yeah.
00:24:47 You know, I mean, I, maybe I have a soft spot.
00:24:49 I enjoy an Elizabeth May press conference because they're rarely dull.
00:24:52 You never quite know what you're going to get.
00:24:54 And she opens her mouth and starts sharing her things.
00:24:58 And on this, where was it she did?
00:24:59 Like she played the welcome back Cotter theme song and Lisa Raid had to pull her off stage. 1.00
00:25:04 Was that the parliamentary press gallery dinner?
00:25:06 I, yeah, I think it was.
00:25:07 You're talking about Omar Cotter and called him like that.
00:25:10 It was weird.
00:25:11 Yeah.
00:25:11 You know, in, um, in classical times, we would refer to politicians who, uh, maybe had a glass
00:25:17 or too much to drink as tired and emotional, looking tired and emotional.
00:25:21 But, uh, just on the whole, um, use of foul language, perhaps Elizabeth May was more upset 1.00
00:25:27 about the word fart, because of course that involves the release of greenhouse gas emissions,
00:25:33 which we know she's quite passionate about.
00:25:35 So maybe that's what drove her to the double standard.
00:25:40 As soon as you started that sentence, I'm like, is he going, is he, yeah, he's going there.
00:25:45 She's offended by methane, not, uh, not profanity.
00:25:48 Uh, it's a, you know, it's a big part of the greenhouse gas cocktail.
00:25:53 But I think methane contributes more to parliamentary decorum than anything Elizabeth, that's come
00:25:59 out of Elizabeth May's mouth.
00:26:01 Uh, quite possibly, but I'd say, you know, at least she isn't dull. 0.71
00:26:05 At least we are getting just another boring talking point filled speech.
00:26:10 Oh, so I just looked it up.
00:26:11 The, the Elizabeth May, uh, thing on Omar Cotter, it was 2015.
00:26:14 It was during the parliamentary press gallery dinner and she used the F word there too.
00:26:18 She said, Omar Cotter had more class than the whole effing cabinet.
00:26:21 So it really, and so, and this was before she tone policed Michelle Rempel, uh, now Michelle
00:26:27 Rempel-Garner.
00:26:28 So my goodness.
00:26:29 Okay.
00:26:30 Oh, Elizabeth May, there we go.
00:26:31 Uh, we'll move on to our next topic today.
00:26:35 Uh, I keep, I keep going away from the screen that has the topics on it.
00:26:38 Oh, this one is also yours, William.
00:26:39 This is, uh, speaking of emissions, uh, some, uh, one of our favorite things to talk about
00:26:44 here, climate hypocrisy.
00:26:46 Yeah.
00:26:46 And, uh, and how to get yourself a government travel agent, because I can tell you, I'm pretty
00:26:52 jealous about where some of these people get to jet off with in this case are, um, and believe
00:26:57 it or not, we have one, our climate change ambassador who's been on the job for just about
00:27:02 two years, spending a quarter of a million dollars on travel expenses, which in, you got
00:27:09 to admit in two years, that's an, um, pretty impressive level of spending.
00:27:13 You have to, I think you really have to quite work at spending that much money in such a
00:27:17 short period of time.
00:27:18 But of course, what so infuriates ordinary Canadians like us, you know, what, what it was
00:27:23 just a few weeks ago where Mark, um, Holland chastised anybody who was thinking of taking
00:27:29 a summer road trip as being a climate killer.
00:27:32 That's going to let the planet burn. 0.99
00:27:34 And then meanwhile, you've got the ambassador for climate change, crisscrossing the country
00:27:40 on flights and staying in these very expensive hotels and achieving no one knows exactly what
00:27:46 certainly not a reduction in our greenhouse gas emissions.
00:27:49 I would imagine hers are vastly higher than the average Canadian.
00:27:53 So, uh, yeah, just another example of climate hypocrisy, uh, a government that says, do as I
00:28:00 say, not as I do.
00:28:03 Yeah.
00:28:03 And I remember John Kerry was the one criticised in the U S cause he's their climate envoy and
00:28:08 he was taking private jets and he was asked about this at one point and he very glibly
00:28:12 said, well, he's too busy.
00:28:13 He can't always fly commercial.
00:28:15 And I had actually asked John Kerry about that when I saw him in Davos, where he is a bit
00:28:20 of a mainstay.
00:28:21 And it's the same sort of glibness you get from these people because they believe that
00:28:25 they're more important than you.
00:28:27 So they need to fly around the world because they have a really, really important job to
00:28:31 do.
00:28:32 The rest of us, plebs, no, no, no, we don't get to. 0.99
00:28:35 Yeah. 0.64
00:28:35 This is a nice, uh, transition, I suppose, considering we just went from seeing the hypocrisy of Elizabeth
00:28:40 May now to the hypocrisy of these high flying elites, let's call them.
00:28:45 And we've seen this with many Canadian ministers like Guibo, Trudeau, criticizing, uh, normal
00:28:52 Canadians for, I mean, simply trying to live their everyday life as they fly their private 0.51
00:28:57 jets around the country, uh, on a daily basis, what it seems like.
00:29:01 So I don't know what it would take for this hypocrisy to end, but you know, it's, it just,
00:29:07 it's interesting to me whenever these ministers, uh, let's say propose, uh, some sort of guideline
00:29:14 for, I don't know, carbon emissions, let's say, uh, uh, a carbon footprint, a personal
00:29:20 carbon footprint, let's say it's like, well, well, could you live within that?
00:29:23 I, I highly doubt that the answer would be yes.
00:29:25 Yeah.
00:29:28 And I, I kind of take the view, I mean, France, for example, uh, within the last year, I think
00:29:33 it was banned domestic air travel and, you know, it seemed ridiculous on the surface.
00:29:37 And then you think, okay, well, at least in France, you have a way to get around quite
00:29:41 easily.
00:29:41 They've got a rail system that's quite good, but a lot of the eco radicals would not
00:29:46 hesitate to push something like that in Canada as well.
00:29:49 And, you know, David Suzuki famously would fly all around the world, uh, with a huge carbon
00:29:53 footprint, I think always in business class telling Canadians that, oh, no one should
00:29:58 be able to, you know, politicians who don't act on climate change should be put in jail.
00:30:02 It's okay.
00:30:02 Well, why are you so different than them?
00:30:04 Your carbon footprint is better, uh, is, is higher than the average Canadian that you're
00:30:09 trying to force to pay this insane carbon tax.
00:30:12 Yeah, I absolutely think it's the hypocrisy that's, that turns so many Canadians off the
00:30:17 whole, uh, preachiness of government.
00:30:19 You know, we talked about how preachy this government's been in foreign affairs and, and on other
00:30:23 things, but that's one of the things the government likes to do most is to preach.
00:30:26 It likes to say, you know, you, dear Canadian are not living up to our, our vast and high 0.98
00:30:33 standards.
00:30:34 And the problem is you.
00:30:36 It's not how any of us are living our lives.
00:30:38 And now correct me if I'm wrong.
00:30:39 I did read the article, but, uh, I want to make sure I get this right.
00:30:43 Did it say she took a flight from Ottawa to Toronto and it cost $10,000?
00:30:49 Is that, uh, is that somewhere in there?
00:30:51 Now I apologize if I read that part wrong, but, uh, part of me wonders what part of the
00:30:56 world could you even fly to that's going to cost $10,000?
00:31:00 Like you can get from Toronto to Sydney, Australia, which I would argue is pretty well the most,
00:31:06 the furthest, uh, uh, you could go, uh, from Canada.
00:31:09 And, uh, I, I think that even wouldn't cost you.
00:31:12 No, I think it was the, the conference attendance, uh, cost that I think.
00:31:16 Oh, yeah, the whole trip.
00:31:18 Yeah.
00:31:18 But I think she was putting on a little thing still, still quite insane.
00:31:21 And by the way, why didn't she take the train from Ottawa to Toronto?
00:31:23 That's one where you have a lower carbon alternative.
00:31:26 And, you know, why doesn't she look for some cheaper options when staying in hotels or when 0.97
00:31:30 taking flights?
00:31:31 You know, oftentimes if I, you know, as a true North employees can attest when they submit
00:31:36 proposals for travel, my first reaction is often to see if there's a cheaper way of being
00:31:41 able to do the trip.
00:31:42 Can we send you in a day before?
00:31:44 Can we put you in a nearby town as opposed to right next to where the event is happening?
00:31:50 That's in a different country.
00:31:52 That is dangerous for, uh, for having a deal with, uh, my cost.
00:31:55 But I was, again, I was being far more cost efficient than Mark Carney and our climate ambassador
00:32:00 are when they go to Davos.
00:32:01 But it's almost like they purposely choose the most expensive option whenever they travel.
00:32:06 And that really grates on Canadians who are having to be so careful with how they spend
00:32:12 their money these days.
00:32:13 You know, I don't think a lot of people object to the fact that sometimes our politicians and
00:32:17 government people are going to have to travel for their work.
00:32:20 You know, we're not going to ask Justin Trudeau to zoom in to the NATO meeting.
00:32:24 We think maybe there's value in him being there.
00:32:26 But do we absolutely have to choose the single most expensive way of getting politicians from
00:32:30 point A to point B, having them stay in the nicest hotels?
00:32:33 Uh, I think that's what really bugs Canadians when they see their hard earned tax dollars
00:32:37 being just squandered on luxury for politicians and the elite.
00:32:42 There was one time, I think it was in Washington DC, actually, where I was booking a hotel room
00:32:47 and it was, you could choose the rate and it was, you know, the AAA member, CAA member rate,
00:32:54 the regular rate, whatever.
00:32:55 And I recall, I looked at the government rate and just cause I was going through them and
00:33:00 it was higher than the regular rate.
00:33:02 Now it might've just been a fluke, but it might not have been because, you know, you
00:33:05 have cities where they know that governments are going to come in that don't care about
00:33:10 the price of things and they'll just get mad, mad cash from governments.
00:33:15 And I think travel is no different there.
00:33:17 These people are not price shopping and why would they?
00:33:20 And so there was the climate hypocrisy angle and there's also just the government waste angle
00:33:24 of this.
00:33:25 Um, this is a one that is related.
00:33:27 We don't trust government.
00:33:28 We also don't trust media, but you have government and media getting into bed together.
00:33:32 And what's the answer?
00:33:33 What comes out of that, Isaac?
00:33:35 Yeah.
00:33:36 So this comes from a new poll, which was conducted by public square research, and they were trying
00:33:41 to gauge the public's trust in different types of Canadian news media.
00:33:46 And then also the views on, um, media that received government subsidies.
00:33:52 So how, how do Canadians feel about government funded media versus obviously media like true
00:33:57 north that receives no government funding.
00:33:59 And interestingly, yes, 70% of Canadians were not supportive of government subsidies for
00:34:04 the salaries of private news organizations.
00:34:07 So private news organization would be like the global mail, Toronto star, Toronto sun, national
00:34:11 post, those kinds of things.
00:34:12 Well, yeah, only 4% of Canadians said they were very supportive of this while it was 26%
00:34:18 that were somewhat supportive leaving.
00:34:20 Yes.
00:34:20 Seven in 10 Canadians, either not very supportive or not supportive at all.
00:34:24 Well, it's just insane that no one sees this because, you know, we trust journalists to hold
00:34:30 government to account.
00:34:31 So if government is the lifeline for journalists and government is the lifeline for journalism,
00:34:36 how are you at all going to expect it to be doing what you needed to do?
00:34:40 So, yeah, I mean, the trust issues in media are outweighing just this aspect of it, but
00:34:46 it certainly is going to, is only going to exacerbate the problem.
00:34:49 And William, I mean, it's just fundamental.
00:34:51 And some journalists have criticized it because they see this, but many have just demanded more
00:34:56 and more money from the government.
00:34:58 Yeah.
00:34:58 I mean, every journalist swears up and down that the fact that some or even most of their
00:35:03 salary that is being paid for by the government has no impact on how they choose to, uh, to
00:35:10 report on things.
00:35:11 But the fact is, is that taken as a whole, if you look at the legacy media, they often
00:35:17 obsess about the, the pet issues of this current government.
00:35:22 You know, how many stories in a typical edition of the Globe and Mail talk about climate change
00:35:27 or talk about, you know, some example of, uh, of, uh, of, uh, uh, someone who's dealing
00:35:34 with a gender issue and, and isn't it terrible that they couldn't transition at three and a
00:35:39 half years old?
00:35:40 And, you know, that's just the worst.
00:35:42 And if you, and these are not issues that Canadians want to endlessly read about.
00:35:47 What are Canadians concerned about?
00:35:48 They're concerned about housing costs.
00:35:50 They're concerned about grocery prices.
00:35:52 They're concerned about, you know, the fact that, uh, they can't pay their bills every
00:35:56 month.
00:35:57 Those are things that are really of concern.
00:35:59 And yet legacy media doesn't pay them nearly as much attention as they should.
00:36:02 I would say one of the reasons why True North has been so successful is we've actually looked
00:36:08 at what ordinary Canadians from one end of the country to the other are concerned about.
00:36:13 And we tried to make that the central focus of our news and reporting.
00:36:17 And as a result, I think Canadians in increasing numbers are tuning into us as they tune out
00:36:24 from the legacy media.
00:36:26 So if that trend continues, I think you are going to see the legacy media either becoming,
00:36:32 you know, solely dependent on government funding to stay in power, or we will simply see the
00:36:37 end of Canada's legacy media as a whole.
00:36:40 So yeah, yeah.
00:36:42 Oh, go ahead, Isaac.
00:36:43 Yeah.
00:36:43 Just something interesting.
00:36:44 The, the, the study brought up, which was that it said that most Canadians were completely
00:36:49 unaware on how much funding these legacy media journalists were receiving.
00:36:54 They estimated that there was up to 50% subsidy on those journalists salaries of up to 85,000
00:36:59 a year.
00:37:00 And then just speaking quickly on, on trust and legacy media, they, they cited a 2023 study
00:37:05 in this research that showed that the decline in legacy media was 50 or sorry, the trust
00:37:10 of legacy media was 55% in 2016, declining to 40% in 2023, which Trudeau was speaking on
00:37:17 an Alberta talk show in February, where he said that quote, conspiracy theorists and social
00:37:23 media drivers were the ones undermining mainstream media to prevent people from essentially believing
00:37:29 a common truth, which is why the legacy media was failing.
00:37:32 However, the recent polling showed that only 12%, 12% of Canadians felt that they were getting
00:37:40 the truth from mainstream news.
00:37:41 I mean, what a low number.
00:37:42 And then, uh, another 20% said that they believed news coverage in Canada was fair and transparent.
00:37:50 Yeah.
00:37:50 And you know, the one thing that I've talked about this on my own show, anytime the institutions
00:37:55 talk about trust and the trust deficit, they always point the blame at everyone else.
00:37:59 It's when we don't trust the media.
00:38:00 Oh, it's because of disinformation and we don't trust the government.
00:38:03 Oh, it's because of the far right. 1.00
00:38:04 It's like, no, it's because you are morons a lot of the time. 1.00
00:38:09 Absolutely. 1.00
00:38:09 Or you covered something with such a biased slant or ignored such an incredible part of
00:38:16 it that, you know, reasonable people watching it simply say that is a lousy, lousy job you've
00:38:23 done.
00:38:23 Um, and if you're lying to us about this, what else are you, are you lying to us?
00:38:29 Yeah.
00:38:30 And I've always been, I guess, prideful in the work that True North puts out because
00:38:34 obviously I'm very skeptical when I, when I read anything legacy media, okay, what in
00:38:40 here is actually true because I often find faults in their work, whether that's intentional
00:38:43 or not.
00:38:44 But even in, in other independent medias, when I'm reading their stories, I often find
00:38:48 errors.
00:38:49 So I like to think that, that we, we produce, uh, uh, uh, stories that generally contain
00:38:56 very little, uh, errors, uh, in comparison to, to, to the rest of the industry.
00:39:01 So yeah, I just wanted to say that.
00:39:03 Well, no, you're right.
00:39:04 And one point, and I mean, I'm the managing editor of True North, so I I've insisted on
00:39:08 this, but I think a lot of our team does it anyway, is primary sources.
00:39:12 Like don't just report on someone else's report on a report, find the report itself, find the
00:39:17 documents yourself.
00:39:18 And I know Isaac, you've had me tell it.
00:39:20 I mean, I actually, Isaac is really good at that because Isaac loves reading the report
00:39:23 and then you'll end up with like, oh, sorry, I am late because I have to write, you
00:39:26 know, read this 179 pages to do.
00:39:29 And I was like, well, I technically asked you to, so I can't really complain, but, uh,
00:39:32 but it's so key because oftentimes, especially with academic studies, like I used to do this
00:39:35 all the time on my old radio show, you'd get like a news story about an academic study that
00:39:39 would have this fantastic headline.
00:39:40 You're like, wow, that's great.
00:39:41 And then you're just like looking at the study and you're like, but it doesn't, doesn't
00:39:45 say that at all.
00:39:46 And it's, so you've got like a journalist that either is putting sensationalism first or
00:39:51 a journalist that doesn't understand what they're writing about, but give your primary
00:39:54 source.
00:39:55 And the one thing also that we're good at in True North is linking to the primary source.
00:39:58 Like we don't want to be information gatekeepers.
00:40:01 We want you to have access to the same thing we did.
00:40:03 A lot of media will reference something, but not actually direct you to the original.
00:40:09 They'll say, oh, in these documents we've obtained, but they don't show the documents.
00:40:12 Whereas we embed them because yeah, we want you to check our work that keeps us accountable.
00:40:16 So my favorite example on this is there's a claim that is recited ad nauseum by legacy
00:40:23 media.
00:40:23 And it's that there are 300 far right hate groups or white nationalist groups active in
00:40:29 Canada.
00:40:30 And they just state that as a fact.
00:40:32 Now, when we've dug into that, we know that it comes from a single professor at one university
00:40:38 who's done a quote-unquote.
00:40:39 Not even a particularly top-tier university.
00:40:42 It's like the Ontario Tech University.
00:40:44 And it's not a slight against them, but it's not Harvard or something.
00:40:47 I would, well, I'm not convinced that Harvard is wrong.
00:40:50 Fair enough.
00:40:51 It once was.
00:40:52 But it comes from this one person.
00:40:54 And this person, despite multiple requests, has never released their work.
00:40:57 They have never released the list.
00:40:59 They have never released the methodology on how this list was put together.
00:41:02 When we pushed on it, the university turned down our ATIPs, turned down our requests.
00:41:07 And yet, if you read any news story that the legacy media publishes about quote-unquote
00:41:13 hate groups, you will see that 300 hate group number quoted as if it is a stone-cold fact.
00:41:20 And the truth is, it's not.
00:41:21 As near as we can tell, it's something that one professor may or may not have just made
00:41:25 up one day because she absolutely refuses to publish anything about it that supports it.
00:41:31 Far from even putting out a list of them.
00:41:33 Oh, yeah.
00:41:33 For all we know, it's, you know, she was going by Facebook groups or something.
00:41:37 You know, there's a Facebook group that posted something she didn't like.
00:41:39 So, oh, let's put it up on the list of 300 anyway.
00:41:42 So, Barbara Perry, it's not too late to show your work.
00:41:45 We'll take it.
00:41:46 We'll take it.
00:41:46 We'll publish it in full.
00:41:47 You should be happy as a researcher drawing more attention to your work, unless that is
00:41:52 you don't stand behind it.
00:41:53 But anyway, that does it for us for today.
00:41:56 My thanks to Isaac Lamoureux and William Macbeth for coming on the show.
00:41:59 As always, and all of you for tuning in, we'll talk to you next week.
00:42:02 But have a great weekend, everyone.
00:42:11 And Cosman's been fighting over that Barbara Perry list for like two years now or something,
00:42:15 isn't it?
00:42:16 Yeah.
00:42:17 I think it's a personal sort of campaign for him now.
00:42:20 It should be.
00:42:21 Yeah.
00:42:21 It's like before the Ontario Privacy Commissioner now.
00:42:23 So, yeah.
00:42:24 When Cosman A-tipped it, the university came back and basically said, oh, it's research
00:42:29 in progress.
00:42:30 Therefore, we can't release it.
00:42:32 Except it's been research in progress for years and years.
00:42:36 And she's still releasing the claim, which suggests that that part's not in progress.
00:42:40 Absolutely.
00:42:40 She's still making this claim without a shred of evidence.
00:42:45 And as a result, you know, I think if you read any of those legacy media stories, they
00:42:50 provide none of that context.
00:42:51 None of them are saying, oh, and by the way, this is just this one person's thing from a
00:42:56 report she won't produce from a list she didn't cite, how she compiled.
00:43:00 Oh, and we can't see the list.
00:43:01 Like, you know, it's just infuriating for those of us who actually like to click on those
00:43:06 links and resource documents to try and figure out what the real story is.