Off the Record - September 27, 2024


CTV News shows its true colours

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
A carbon tax REVOLT? Canadians say NO to electric vehicles

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

162.81

Word count

6,170

Sentence count

316

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

14

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

This week, CTV News caught red-handed splicing a video of Conservative Leader Pierre Polyev to make it look like he said something he entirely did not say. And they fired two of their own journalists for their part in the mess.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I have to wonder if there's been a stupider week in the House of Commons than the one we just had. 0.98
00:00:04 I know we're going to talk about it in a bit, but if you guys can think of a stupider moment 0.89
00:00:10 in Canadian politics than we've had this week, I think one of you deserve a bonus on the next 0.59
00:00:15 paycheck. It might be Elbowgate, if you guys remember Elbowgate. Yeah, that was probably
00:00:21 up there. You know, question period's always kind of been pretty dumb. And I say that from 0.99
00:00:29 people who have been in opposition and on the government side, you know, non-questions being
00:00:34 given non-answers. But sometimes you wonder, couldn't our elected officials and the thousands
00:00:39 of people we employ to support them be doing something better or at least more productive
00:00:46 with their time, maybe even less costly? I don't know. I guess we'll talk about it when we get going.
00:00:53 Leah, let's get started.
00:00:59 Well, happy Friday, everybody. Hope you had a great week. You know, Friday, we like to take
00:01:07 a more casual tone, kick back. It's a little early where I live, so we haven't poured ourselves a
00:01:12 drink quite yet, but you feel free to go right ahead and do so. You've got us for Off the Record
00:01:18 this week. I'm joined with Isaac Lamoureux. Say hi, Isaac. Hello. And Cosming, Georgia, out in BC.
00:01:27 And as I was reminded how to pronounce my own name, I'm William Macbeth, and I'm excited to be here
00:01:32 being your guest host. So, yeah, as I said, a little pre-roll there. We've had a very stupid week
00:01:37 in the House of Commons. Some serious stuff, but some not so serious stuff. But why don't we get 1.00
00:01:43 started first with the big liars in the mainstream media? Cosman, you want to tell us about CTV News
00:01:49 who got caught doing some fibbing? Yeah, for sure. So for those not in the media, there's an unwritten
00:01:56 rule that journalists are not supposed to become the story. But this week, we've seen CTV News
00:02:03 essentially launch themselves into the national news scene because they were caught red-handed
00:02:11 splicing a video of conservative leader Pierre Polyev to make it look like he said something
00:02:18 that he entirely did not say. So they took a clip of him talking about a carbon tax election completely
00:02:26 out of context and spun it so that it looked like he was opposing the liberal government's
00:02:32 dental care plan. So we've got a couple clips here. The first one is actually the original
00:02:39 unedited version of this clip. So let's launch that now.
00:02:45 That's why it's time to put forward a motion for a carbon tax election.
00:02:54 So that's the unedited clip. That's what Pierre Polyev actually said. Here is the clip
00:03:01 that CTV News spliced and used. That's why we need to put forward a motion.
00:03:10 So that was prefaced by a CTV News reporter talking about the liberal dental care plan and opposition
00:03:18 to it, which is not true. So the conservatives, their director of communications, called out CTV News
00:03:26 for this tweet, for this video, essentially saying that it was entirely edited, taken out of context
00:03:35 and spliced and demanding that CTV News account for this. Now, CTV News officials actually came out
00:03:43 and gave a sort of muddied statement, you know, half an apology, half an admission of guilt,
00:03:51 but they didn't really actually say sorry. And this led the CPC to come back at CTV News
00:03:59 and blacklist any MPs, any member of caucus from actually taking interviews showing on appearances
00:04:06 on CTV News. So this has been going on pretty much the second half of this entire week. And it's
00:04:14 become a scandal in the legacy media because it really shows their bias. And the latest development
00:04:22 is CTV News saying they've let go the two editors, I presume responsible for this clip splicing. And
00:04:31 they put out a statement, essentially saying, admitting that this was wrong, but they don't
00:04:37 actually say that it was done purposefully in that statement. So I'm going to put it to you,
00:04:41 Isaac. Is this enough from the CTV? Well, that's a tough question, Cosmin. And
00:04:50 I'll put it this way. The statement on Monday that CTV issued got ratioed completely, having far more
00:04:57 comments than likes and people just bashing them completely. Whereas their newest statement on
00:05:03 Thursday, where they announced firing the journalists, it had a lot more likes than comments,
00:05:08 first of all. But the comments were largely filled with people noting their surprise that CTV took any
00:05:15 accountability at all. So that was interesting for me. People at least are celebrating that they did
00:05:21 take accountability. However, on the flip side of things, there were people suggesting that the CTV
00:05:29 News just essentially scapegoated these two journalists, whoever they are, from something that
00:05:35 came from the higher ups, likely. So it's hard to say whether they truly are taking accountability,
00:05:39 because as you said, they didn't necessarily apologize for what they did. But something else
00:05:45 that comes to mind here is, I've seen other people celebrating the conservatives for essentially
00:05:52 standing up to legacy media and CTV in this instance for slandering them, if you want to call it that,
00:05:58 or splicing these clips. I mean, this is just a complete fabrication of facts, especially with the
00:06:02 video. I can't believe they went to this extreme measure. Like, you really thought you were going
00:06:07 to get away with this, splicing videos together? I mean, it's ridiculous, especially as a journalist 0.69
00:06:13 myself, thinking about journalistic integrity. Who could possibly imagine doing something like this?
00:06:18 Now, William, Pierre Polyev has sort of made himself this anti-legacy media figure,
00:06:25 a politician willing to stand up to media lies and mistruths that are propagated out there. Did the
00:06:33 CTV play into the conservatives' hands with this blunder? Yeah, I mean, you gotta wonder what CTV was
00:06:42 thinking when they came up with this cartoonishly evil plan to try and splice together a fake quote
00:06:48 to misrepresent what Pierre Polyver was saying. You know, I used to work for the government back in the
00:06:54 day for the Harper government. And whenever one of our ministers was doing a press conference or a
00:06:59 press event, you would always see a political party staffer or a ministerial staffer recording
00:07:05 the press conference on their own phone. And media used to say, well, why would you do that? And our
00:07:10 answer was honestly, because we don't trust you to accurately report what we said at this press
00:07:17 conference. And they would say, oh, we would never take someone's words out of context. And we would
00:07:23 never splice a quote to give it an unfair meaning. Well, when arguably the second largest, maybe even
00:07:31 the largest, I don't know, the viewing figures, they're also terrible now for legacy media, it's
00:07:34 hard to tell. But one of Canada's largest news broadcasters can't be trusted to put together a
00:07:40 simple story without inventing a whole fictionalized narrative that Pierre Polyev was trying to hold an
00:07:46 election over the national dental care strategy. You know, it brings out the question of real trouble.
00:07:52 And as Isaac's pointed out, I've really enjoyed some of the fallout, you know, because now I'm seeing
00:07:58 former liberal staffers say, oh, this poor working single mother has lost her job because of Pierre 0.96
00:08:05 Polyev's attack against the media. It's like, you know, pretty certain that the person who faked the
00:08:11 clip lost her own job when she decided not to do news anymore. But fiction. And I don't think she's
00:08:19 got anyone to blame but herself. Certainly, I know conservative supporters have argued for a long
00:08:24 time that the legacy media are not fair, that they're biased, that they don't like the conservatives,
00:08:29 that none of them come even close to voting conservative in election. And I think you're
00:08:33 now seeing again, an example of that bias on full display. And when they get knocked off their high
00:08:38 horse, yes, conservative party supporters do tend to enjoy that experience.
00:08:42 Well, I just wanted to add because you would expect this sort of behavior from CBC, which is a
00:08:48 publicly government funded outlet that receives all of its money due to the graces of the liberal
00:08:54 government. But as you were correct to mention, William, CTV News is I'm pretty sure the biggest
00:09:00 privately owned media company in Canada. They're owned by Bell Media. And to see this like blatant
00:09:08 anti conservative bias. It's funny, actually, yesterday, they did a segment here in British
00:09:15 Columbia, where the BC conservatives are surging, they're actually tied with the BC NDP, they did a
00:09:20 segment about john rustat talking about how climate advocates have been pushing people to, you know,
00:09:27 adopt eating insect proteins, alternative proteins instead of meat to save the climate. And they tried
00:09:34 to mock him. But then I found a clip from a year before where they went to a bug bake off talking
00:09:41 about how great it is to eat bugs. So the bias is so obvious. And I think more Canadians are waking up
00:09:47 to this evident fact that there is an anti conservative leaning in the legacy media.
00:09:55 Yeah, I mean, Isaac, your background has a bit of, of, well, maybe not full legacy media,
00:10:00 but certainly we would say non independent media. What was your experience like when you had to
00:10:06 cover stories? Did you ever find there was either an explicit or maybe implicit direction? If it's a
00:10:13 conservative, you know, try and hurt them, mock them, make fun of them, spin them, maybe don't give
00:10:19 a full story. I'm just guessing, you know, you can tell me that never happened. And I would accept it.
00:10:23 But yeah, no, obviously, for those who don't know, I worked for various French legacy media,
00:10:30 but my editors were pretty respectful, I guess, in the sense that they knew I was a conservative. So
00:10:37 they really didn't make me do any media bias in the political sense. Although I did have to cover a few
00:10:44 conferences on like, yeah, climate craze, let's call it where where where they would be, I'd go as far
00:10:54 as saying indoctrinating kids regarding eco stuff. And the main thing I the main problem I had with
00:11:01 those conferences would they they would raise all these concerns and raise all these problems, but
00:11:04 they would offer no solution. So it's like, well, you're saying all of these things, you're saying
00:11:08 this is the worst thing that's ever going to happen to you. These kids are scared for their lives. But
00:11:11 it's like, well, what's the solution you you haven't offered any. So that was the main thing
00:11:17 with with me working in legacy media. Last thing I wanted to mention, which I almost forgot was I saw
00:11:22 a statement issued by Anna Polievre, Pierre's wife, obviously. And she said, quote, my husband is a
00:11:30 fighter, and I couldn't be more proud. Canada needs a leader with unwavering principle and conviction,
00:11:36 someone who stands firm for what's right. Even when the media critics and so called experts
00:11:41 try to tear him down. He's strong, smart, and exactly who this country needs. The fight for
00:11:46 a better Canada continues. And then in parentheses, yes, the media bias is real. But conservatives
00:11:53 will keep fighting for the people. So that kind of speaks to what you're saying, William feeding into
00:11:56 this media bias story. You know, I'm sure the statement of support from Sophie Trudeau for her
00:12:04 husband will be coming out any moment now. The ex-husband.
00:12:10 So, of course, this was all beginning with the comments related to the non-confidence motion that
00:12:17 happened earlier this week, following the famous tearing up of the supply and confidence agreement
00:12:23 by Jagmeet Singh. There was a motion of non-confidence put forward in the House of Commons by the conservatives.
00:12:29 And as we know now, that motion wasn't successful. But I think it kicks off the season of no confidence
00:12:37 votes in Ottawa. And we have a bit of a clip showing the end of that confidence vote and some of the
00:12:43 subsequent analysis, quote unquote. Now, I should say this is a CTV news clip. We believe that this is
00:12:49 accurately what happened. But as we maybe have learned over the past week, take it with a grain of salt in
00:12:55 case. CTV had also done some splicing and dicing on this one.
00:13:03 This was the first but not the last test of the liberal minority this fall. The conservative-led push
00:13:09 to bring down the government was defeated, despite pressure from Pierre Paliève to send Canadians to
00:13:15 the polls. He wants a climate change election. Let's have that election in the right time.
00:13:20 Will he call it today? The Bloc and NDP voted with the government, stating they still have confidence
00:13:26 in Justin Trudeau. But before the vote was even called, Bloc leader E. Francois Blanchet issued an
00:13:32 ultimatum, giving the government until the end of October to help enact a pair of Bloc bills about 0.98
00:13:38 pensions and supply management or risk an election before the new year.
00:13:42 There's not so much room for discussion. Wasting no time, the Conservatives are set to serve up
00:13:48 another non-confidence motion on Thursday, a move the Liberals called lame parliamentary games.
00:13:54 But I think it shows the desperation of Mr. Paliève.
00:13:59 I do love that analogy. That's what has been the desperation of Mr. Paliève. Well, yes,
00:14:04 along with millions of Canadians desperate to have an election. Also, was it my imagination or in that
00:14:10 vote? Did Jagmeet Singh bring a baby into the House of Commons? I'm not sure what that was in
00:14:16 aid of. Maybe he just couldn't get affordable childcare, despite that being a major promise of
00:14:21 his once coalition partner. So with all of that, you know, do you think it's interesting, of course,
00:14:28 that political parties like the Bloc and the Democrats, who have been routinely attacking the
00:14:32 government, when asked to put their money where their mouth is, actually aren't following through
00:14:37 and voting down this government to cause an election? Cosman, what do you what do you think?
00:14:42 For sure. I think the Liberals are in a precarious situation. They are backed in a corner. And the
00:14:49 Bloc are salivating at the opportunity to get every last ounce of concessions from this government, 1.00
00:14:56 because they have the upper hand here. The NDP has backed away. And now the next, you know,
00:15:02 cannibal party that feasts on the corpse of this liberal government is going to take what it can.
00:15:09 And it's, it's, it's just the situation we're in, we're gonna, it's going to be a volatile period
00:15:15 in the House of Commons, you're going to see these pushes for non confidence motions. But honestly,
00:15:22 I have my doubts that either the Bloc or the NDP want an election right now. I know the Bloc had a good
00:15:30 running in the recent by election, but I'm not so sure that will translate in a general election.
00:15:38 And Isaac, you know, thinking about the other opposition parties, the ones who aren't the
00:15:42 conservatives, the Democrats, the Bloc, do you think there's any impetus for them to pull the
00:15:48 plug on this government? Or do you think they're, they're, you know, in the case of the NDP in
00:15:52 particular, do you think they're afraid to face the electorate in an actual general election?
00:15:57 Yeah, William, it's, it's funny, I still remember the feeling I initially had when I heard that Jagmeet 1.00
00:16:04 Singh was going to rip up his supply and confidence agreement, which unfortunately did was short lived,
00:16:10 because then I realized that that really doesn't mean anything, especially as we've seen Singh
00:16:16 continue to prop up his government. But now, it's almost as if we're in a worse position than we were
00:16:23 prior to this development, let's call it, because now both the Bloc and the NDP have shown that they
00:16:28 will prop up this Liberal government. And at least the Bloc are doing it for some gain. Obviously, 0.56
00:16:36 Blanchet said he'd give the Liberals until October 29, to meet his demands, whereas Singh, I don't even
00:16:42 know what they're getting out of this agreement right now. But both of these parties would have to
00:16:47 turn against the Liberals, which, as Cosmin mentioned, I really don't think either of those
00:16:52 parties would benefit from an election right now, because they have to be essentially weighing the
00:16:56 odds in the sense that, are we going to benefit more from a Trudeau government or a Prolivre
00:17:02 government? And I don't see Pierre going to either of those parties and saying, hey, let's do this
00:17:11 together. I'll give you what you want. Otherwise, he probably already would have done that. And then
00:17:16 that might be what it's going to take to bring down this Liberal government.
00:17:19 Now, Cosmin, do you think that one of the factors might be happening is the fact that we have a
00:17:26 provincial election happening in BC right now, a very competitive one between the BC NDP and the
00:17:32 BC Conservatives? We have an election, I think, scheduled next month in Saskatchewan, another place
00:17:39 where the New Democrats are probably going to be, if not strong contenders, actual contenders,
00:17:46 which they're not in a lot of other parts of this country. Do you think the calculus on the part of
00:17:51 the NDP is they don't want an unpopular federal leader dragging down the support for their provincial
00:17:59 cousins in these two provincial elections?
00:18:03 No, for sure. And I'll just add, Ontario Premier Doug Ford has also talked about an early election as
00:18:08 well. So there's definitely the provincial elements at play 100%. Let's remember that Jagmeet Singh was
00:18:18 elected in a by-election in Burnaby. That's where his seat is in British Columbia. So there's no way
00:18:25 that he wants to detract attention from the BC NDP's shot at forming government again. I think that is
00:18:34 definitely at top of mind for Jagmeet Singh. But I also wanted to mention, off of what Isaac said,
00:18:41 Canadians are hurting right now. They're suffering from financial woes, cost of living, inability to
00:18:49 get housing. And I think what's happening in the House of Commons right now, with all these parties
00:18:56 vying to get what they want out of this government with the bloc and the NDP trying to get concessions,
00:19:02 it comes across as very self-interested, cynical politics. And I think it leaves a really bad taste
00:19:09 in Canadians' mouths. 0.52
00:19:11 Yeah, here in my province of Alberta, the new New Democrat leader, former Calgary Mayor Nehed Nengshi,
00:19:17 has gone so far as to say he doesn't want to be affiliated with the federal NDP anymore. I think
00:19:22 he probably even wants to change the provincial party's name to something new. And part of that is
00:19:29 simply, it's tough to run as a new Democrat here in Alberta. Fair enough. But also, I think he
00:19:35 particularly doesn't like the association with Mr. Singh, who, of course, has been so anti-Alberta in
00:19:41 many of his policy positions, opposes the oil sands, opposes the construction of pipelines,
00:19:45 opposes Alberta's major industries. And so, you know, if his own cousins aren't willing to support him,
00:19:53 I guess Mr. Singh probably thinks that Canadians from coast to coast won't either. Now, unfortunately,
00:20:01 that wasn't the only thing that happened in Ottawa this week. And the next part is probably the genesis
00:20:09 of my Is the House of Commons Occasionally Stupid theme that I put on. We had an argument over a bathtub 0.99
00:20:15 and whether or not there was a suggestion that the prime minister might be gay in that bathtub, 0.93
00:20:22 you know, if you interpreted the remark in that way. Why don't we start by watching
00:20:27 this clip, which was following Pierre Polyevre, opposition leader Pierre Polyevre, talking about
00:20:33 the apartment the Government of Canada bought for New York Consul General Tom Clark and just how luxurious
00:20:39 it is with its quartz countertops, a $5,000 bathtub, and a bunch of other very special amenities.
00:20:46 This is the prime minister's defense of that luxury apartment.
00:20:51 Mr. Speaker, engaging with international leaders on fighting climate change,
00:20:58 on solving global crises, on standing up unequivocally for Ukraine.
00:21:03 Mr. Speaker, don't worry on this side of the house. We're used to casual homophobic comments
00:21:15 from the other side of the house.
00:21:18 Now, in case you couldn't hear, that was what has now been identified to be conservative MP
00:21:24 Garnet Jenuous asking if the prime minister or the consul general
00:21:29 was entertaining world leaders in the bathtub. And I actually think Garnet has a perfectly
00:21:36 legitimate question. There might be an argument to say we need a government-owned apartment
00:21:41 in a city like New York, where a lot of world leaders, business leaders, and other people
00:21:45 come on a frequent basis. And maybe we need it to be sufficiently large to accommodate a reception.
00:21:52 But do we really need the $5,000 bathtub in order to maintain cordial relations with some of
00:21:58 these foreign leaders? How many of them are we entertaining in the bath? And if we are, 0.99
00:22:03 should we be worried about foreign interference on one level or another? So do you think that this
00:22:10 was a homophobic joke? Or do you think this was an MP pointing out the lunacy of why we needed a 0.52
00:22:18 $5,000 bathtub? Isaac, what do you think?
00:22:20 Yeah, I definitely do not think it was a homophobic joke. And you mentioned, or Trudeau did,
00:22:27 how people were interpreting it. No, I don't think anyone would have interpreted it that way before
00:22:33 he brought up the homophobia. But we've seen this from Trudeau in response to completely unrelated
00:22:40 things. He'll always tie it back to his main talking points, which are homophobia or LGBTQ
00:22:46 rights, climate change. You've heard them all before. I don't see how this has anything to do
00:22:52 with that, though. And Cosman, what do you think? House of Commons, valuable democratic institution
00:22:58 or place where stupid stuff gets yelled about? Well, we've got a drama teacher for a prime minister. 1.00
00:23:05 He's engaging in theatrics every opportunity he can. And I think it's just deflection. Let's be
00:23:13 serious. It's an attempt to get off of the issue about why did taxpayers spend so much money for this
00:23:21 extravagant apartment and all of these extra features that, as you're right to mention, are not
00:23:26 necessary for hosting guests. And just in case you thought that maybe upon reflection, the prime
00:23:32 minister would back down from his ludicrous assertion that this was a drive by homophobic attack
00:23:39 when asked to clarify or reiterate his position leaving the House of Commons. This was the prime
00:23:44 minister's response. Sounds like the guy could use a nice relaxing bath with one or more of his
00:23:59 closest personal friends in order to de-stress. Yeah, I must admit, when I read the rundown of
00:24:06 show stories, I was initially opposed to doing this one out of the opinion that it would add to 0.99
00:24:12 global stupidity. And I'm sorry to say I still find this entire affair to be pretty dumb. But let's 0.99
00:24:20 move into, I guess you could argue it's a related area. I guess we're going to talk a little bit
00:24:25 about ass there, Isaac. Do you want to give us the lowdown? Yeah, related in the sense that this is 0.96
00:24:32 another odd comment, let's call it. So Ontario Premier Doug Ford let able-bodied homeless people who
00:24:41 aren't working know that he's sick and tired of them. So he was asked about the more than a,
00:24:47 sorry, a thousand people currently on wait lists for affordable housing at a completely unrelated
00:24:52 news conference on Monday. And then he said the following, let's just roll the clip quickly.
00:24:56 Do you know what the best way to get people be able to get out of the encampments,
00:25:01 get out of the homeless, get an application and drop it off one of these companies and start
00:25:06 working? You need to start working if you're healthy. Bottom line, if you're unhealthy, I'll
00:25:12 take care of you the rest of my life. Your life will take care of you. But if you're healthy,
00:25:16 get off your ASS and start working like everyone else's. Very simple. 0.99
00:25:20 And then I'll just cover a few other things that Ford mentioned at the press conference,
00:25:27 which was firstly, he said that Ontario is the fastest growing jurisdiction in North America.
00:25:33 He said they added 800,000 people last year, which was largest or sorry, larger than the biggest two
00:25:39 states in the United States combined. He went on to say that 136 companies came to invest in Ontario,
00:25:46 creating over 12,500 jobs, which really doesn't seem like that many jobs when we're talking about 800,000
00:25:52 people coming there. So while I appreciate Ford treating able-bodied homeless people like adults 0.89
00:26:01 saying, look, if you want to change your woes, you got to start working. I don't know that it's that simple.
00:26:07 Obviously, when 800,000 people immigrate to your province and then use the next citation you make is adding
00:26:12 12,500 jobs. Obviously, there's going to be a discrepancy there. And we've seen the unemployment
00:26:19 rates in Ontario, which are quite high. Do you guys think it's as simple as Ford is trying to make it
00:26:25 out to be? Well, I'll just start. I found his comment to be a little bit of a non sequitur because he was
00:26:32 asked about an affordable housing waitlist. And we talked about this on Daily Brief. Affordable housing
00:26:38 doesn't mean you're homeless. There's cutoffs for $100,000 a year to get into affordable housing.
00:26:45 There's a lot of ordinary middle class people who rely on affordable housing, sadly, in Canada today,
00:26:51 so that they can have a place to live because they can't afford the multi-thousand dollar rents in
00:26:58 Vancouver, Toronto, or Montreal. But you're right to say that immigration has a huge impact on this
00:27:06 because the fact is, if you look at the statistics, a lot of new immigrants, international students,
00:27:13 temporary foreign workers are going into those entry level jobs that somebody who's coming off
00:27:19 the street coming out of, you know, living in their car would rely on to get a step up and be able to
00:27:26 afford a place to live. And it's just astounding that nobody really touches on that issue. Our politicians
00:27:33 don't admit that we're importing more people than we can afford to take care of. And they're also going 0.96
00:27:42 into homeless shelters, the places where people who are on the street go to halfway houses, homeless
00:27:49 shelters, to have that transition from being homeless to actually being a functioning member in society.
00:27:57 So if we're not going to deal with the causes of this problem, just saying, go get a job, it's not
00:28:03 quite that simple, right?
00:28:05 So when I heard the comment, it reminded me, I phoned Rob Ford, sorry, Doug Ford, God rest Rob Ford,
00:28:13 Doug Ford to be channeling his inner Ronald Reagan, because the president was famously asked about social
00:28:18 program funding. And he said that the best social program out there was a job. Do you think
00:28:24 there's a belief that some people are simply taking advantage of Canada's generosity, as opposed to
00:28:32 doing what the rest of us do, which is to get up each morning, go to work, work at a job, earn a living
00:28:38 and use that to pay for our bills and our living expenses? Do you think there are some people who
00:28:43 said, nah, I'd rather not work and take advantage of Canada's generous social programs instead? Do you
00:28:49 think it's a problem? Yeah, I do. And some people, for many streams, not just the immigrant side of 1.00
00:28:56 things, but also Canadian employers, we've seen have exploited, in some instances, the temporary
00:29:01 foreign worker program, for example, where they're only supposed to be hiring temporary foreign workers
00:29:06 when they have an essential need for them. But of course, they're going with them instead of Canadians 1.00
00:29:10 because they can pay them less, or other instances. So yeah, I mean, there's very, there's many
00:29:15 different streams of exploitation, let's call it, but we've seen the videos in Toronto for these
00:29:21 entry level jobs. I mean, the lineups for them are hours long. So so as you mentioned, Cosmin, for
00:29:26 someone who's homeless and would rely on a job as such to get back on their feet, if you will,
00:29:34 it's not as simple as just going to McDonald's and getting a job when these places are pretty much
00:29:40 impossible to get a job at. And I'll just say this, as somebody was born in a different country, 1.00
00:29:47 Canada, barring Scandinavian countries, is one of the hardest countries to become homeless in.
00:29:54 Let's be real. There are so many opportunities, so many safety nets for people to rely on where they
00:30:00 don't have to be in that situation. Now, I'm not going to discount the serious things such as like
00:30:05 addiction, mental health issues, you know, trauma, being a victim of abuse, having to flee an abusive
00:30:12 household. Those are very real. But there are definitely people who choose to be out on the
00:30:18 streets. Here in Vancouver, in, you know, downtown Eastside, there's a lot of people who decide to be
00:30:25 there because it's a lifestyle for them almost. They don't want to get a job. They do get either,
00:30:32 you know, employment insurance. They have other means to get social grants and money. And they'd
00:30:39 rather be out here than actually live their life. And that asks, begs the question, what has happened
00:30:46 where people are choosing that over a meaningful life where they can be productive members of society?
00:30:52 I think there's some fundamental questions we need to ask about why people are choosing that path. And
00:30:58 with the drug crisis, a lot of these people are actually young men, men between the ages of 20 to
00:31:05 40, who have just found no purpose in society any longer. I'm just reading a quick note from the
00:31:13 producer saying that I should have given a warning that I was going to use the word ass. This is now a 0.94
00:31:18 PG-13 segment. And that segment should not have been watched by young children without prevental
00:31:24 supervision. True North apologizes for anyone scandalized by the use of that word. Just heading
00:31:31 into just a related story there, Cosman, about affordable housing and homelessness. We see a
00:31:38 quote unquote innovative housing strategy coming out of British Columbia. Some actually aren't convinced
00:31:45 it's innovative at all. What is happening on the affordable housing front in British Columbia's election?
00:31:49 Right. So in the last week, premier David Eby has made two significant housing announcements,
00:31:57 but what they essentially entail is they are leasehold schemes. So we have a situation where
00:32:06 the government is partnering with first nations and certain private investors to build these homes
00:32:14 that will still be owned by the land. At least we'll be owned by the first nation, but 0.93
00:32:19 people will be able to essentially sign up for a 99 year lease, 40% of which is funded by taxpayers.
00:32:30 So the government will be using taxpayer money to spend on 40% of the value of these properties,
00:32:36 whereas 60% the buyer will be able to put a down payment on. But like I said, this is a leasehold.
00:32:43 So if you know anything about real estate, a leasehold means that you might have some stake on the
00:32:49 building, but you don't have the land title. So you don't actually own the piece of land that the
00:32:54 property is on. And that raises a lot of consequences. First of all, the property doesn't
00:33:01 appreciate. So when you go to resell it, you're not going to make any sort of profit on it. And then
00:33:07 secondly, the person who owns the land could kick you off theoretically if they really wanted to.
00:33:13 So it's very troubling. And I spoke to a realtor from Vancouver who was, who put this in plain
00:33:20 terms that this is glorified rentals. The government is becoming a land Lord. So you're going to have
00:33:26 people who need housing and, and premier David Eby is calling this a housing owner, home ownership
00:33:33 dream as if this is what people want. They want to lease a property for 99 years from the government.
00:33:39 That's not it. They want something they can have for their entire life and then pass it on to their
00:33:44 next generations. So William, what's your, like, is this the solution to the housing crisis?
00:33:51 Yeah. I was going to say, it sounds almost like a timeshare plan where you buy in for a set amount
00:33:56 of time and then it reverts to the property owner. And certainly the idea that your house isn't going
00:34:01 to gain any value. And in fact, we'll lose value over the course of you owning it is not attractive
00:34:07 for a lot of people who see their property as a place to build some equity, to build up some
00:34:13 revenue, some, or some wealth that they can use in order to fund their retirement or, or something
00:34:18 else. So, uh, Isaac, what do you think? Uh, the dream of home ownership or government scheme that you
00:34:24 try and get sold upon visiting a hotel in Mexico and say, Oh, you could, you could live here full time
00:34:30 for only nine 99. Yeah. So many different things. Uh, I want to mention about this first, we'll start
00:34:38 off with the quote from EB home ownership dream. I mean, that in itself is a lie. You don't own the
00:34:44 land. How is it home on a home ownership dream? Uh, and you mentioned one of the two most important
00:34:50 things, uh, that I think, uh, of owning property are firstly, as you said, building equity, but next
00:34:56 owning the land, you literally own land that, that those are the two most important things of
00:35:01 owning a property in my opinion. And obviously one of these things just is not true with these
00:35:05 something that you didn't mention Cosmin, which I think needs to be, uh, said was the price of these
00:35:12 properties are $850,000 to $1.5 million. So, uh, we were talking about affordable housing. This is far
00:35:21 from, uh, affordable who, who can afford this. Of course you take 40% off of that. It's still a
00:35:27 ridiculous price. Well, yeah, I want to jump in on that, Isaac, if I may, because the, I was astounded
00:35:33 by how the housing minister arrived at these property valuations. If you actually look at where this
00:35:40 property is, it's in the dead center of, of Vancouver in a neighborhood called Canby. And it's
00:35:47 not a special area. It's literally in the middle of a metropolitan area, but for, and this is the
00:35:52 three bedrooms are valued at 1.5 million. This is the market valuation that the government arrived at
00:35:58 for these properties in this area, but you can get a leasehold property on, uh, with, with a ocean view
00:36:06 on false Creek for $1.5 million with a beautiful view of the Harbor for the exact same amount of money.
00:36:14 You can find a leasehold for three bedrooms, uh, in, in Kitsilano for $999,000. So it doesn't make
00:36:25 sense. And, and the reason they put this valuation so high is because they wrote into this deal a profit
00:36:32 for the private developers and the first nations developers. That's the reason they, they get the
00:36:37 payout. You know, the question that goes through my head is how much is the bathtub worth? If it's not
00:36:43 worth 5,000, then I'm not dropping 1.5 million on a home. Uh, I think that's completely outrageous.
00:36:49 So, uh, well, I think that brings us to the end of our, uh, of our new segment there. Um, you know,
00:36:55 I'm, I'm always amazed at the value for our tax dollars. We get whenever we take a good look at
00:37:00 what our governments are up to across the country. So I hope that we haven't depressed our viewers too
00:37:06 much by telling them just how much their tax dollars were wasted. And of course, a general reminder
00:37:11 that everything you've heard today is off the record. Well, now I'm worried that we're actually
00:37:26 going to have a segment of our viewers who own very expensive bathtubs, and I'm going to be accused
00:37:31 of being pejorative or, uh, bigoted against the wealthy bathtub community. That is not what I'm
00:37:37 saying. I'm saying if you own an expensive bathtub that you paid for yourself, that's perfectly fine.
00:37:43 Uh, it's the publicly funded bathtubs are the ones that I object to. So just to clarify for anybody
00:37:49 with a very expensive bathtub, it's not you, it's when it's paid for by taxpayers.