Off the Record - August 02, 2024


Guilbeault tries to be hip and cool

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Too many immigrants in Canada? Where on Earth is Justin Trudeau?

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

187.19

Word count

6,511

Sentence count

392

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

23

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Off The Record is back with a new co-host, Noah Jarvis, and new guests, Isaac Lamoureux and Rachel Ward. They talk about a man who was caught pooping in a Tim Hortons cup, and the controversy surrounding it. Plus, a story about Indian immigrants pooping on beaches.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 You guys, my computer died in the last show that I was doing.
00:00:02 So hopefully that doesn't happen this time.
00:00:04 But Noah, you're in charge if I disappear.
00:00:08 I'm in charge.
00:00:09 Am I like the senior member?
00:00:10 No, it's you, Noah.
00:00:11 I'll just be in the background.
00:00:13 You're just my DEI pick.
00:00:17 Ouch.
00:00:18 That would hurt, you know.
00:00:19 But, you know, I don't know why.
00:00:21 The Kamala Harris of off the record.
00:00:23 That would really hurt.
00:00:24 I can't do that ever again.
00:00:25 I'm glad I'm not a lib.
00:00:27 Jesus Christ.
00:00:28 What really hurt?
00:00:28 That was awful.
00:00:31 Being a DEI pick, I mean, that one hurt the soul, Rachel.
00:00:36 I think, you know, you might be a DEI pick.
00:00:38 You've got the woman's status. 1.00
00:00:39 I don't know.
00:00:40 What's higher on the intersectional hierarchy?
00:00:42 Being a man or being a woman or being black? 0.81
00:00:45 Being a person of color is definitely higher. 0.99
00:00:47 It is.
00:00:47 It is.
00:00:49 I would know, you know.
00:00:52 Yeah, you would know.
00:00:53 You've probably dealt with some of that.
00:00:58 Being a person of color?
00:01:01 Yeah.
00:01:03 I'm on the lowest ranking of the DEI list as a single white male.
00:01:08 Oh, well, we've got to boost those numbers up.
00:01:12 Let's get you into a wig and get you some brass and you'll be good to go. 1.00
00:01:17 You'll shoot right up the rankings.
00:01:20 You probably can get it paid for by the government too, Isaac.
00:01:22 So, seems like a good idea.
00:01:25 Yeah, I'm not going to go down that road.
00:01:27 Okay, guys, let's get it started.
00:01:30 Hey, everyone.
00:01:39 Welcome to Off the Record, our Friday fun show.
00:01:43 Before we get started, I have some bittersweet news for all of you.
00:01:46 If you haven't already heard, our colleague and usual host of the show, Andrew Lawton,
00:01:51 has left us all.
00:01:52 He's taken a leave of absence from Trudorth as he is seeking a conservative nomination.
00:01:56 So, we are very excited for him.
00:01:58 We wish him the best on his campaign and his hopeful candidacy.
00:02:02 However, he will be deeply missed here at Trudorth.
00:02:05 And I guess for the time being, you are stuck with us.
00:02:07 Joining me today are my colleagues, Noah Jarvis and Isaac Lamoureux.
00:02:11 Thank you so much for being here, guys.
00:02:12 Great to be here, and hopefully I'm not a drag on the show now that Andrew's gone.
00:02:19 Not a drag on the show that Andrew's gone.
00:02:21 You're just a drag on the show because you're a DEI.
00:02:25 Good to be here as well.
00:02:27 Maybe I'll be a more common entity of Off the Record now that Andrew's gone.
00:02:32 Who knows?
00:02:33 So, it's been sort of an exciting week over at True North.
00:02:36 I know that we sometimes struggle to find funny stories to talk about on this show,
00:02:41 but I think today we had no shortage of them.
00:02:43 Starting off, I feel like our colleague Harrison just sort of lit X on fire this week.
00:02:47 I don't know if he was the first person to post this image, but he was definitely one of the first.
00:02:51 Basically, I'm sure you guys have heard the drama of some immigrants pooping, 1.00
00:02:56 pooping in places that you shouldn't poop, 0.82
00:02:59 like parking lots and beaches has been one of the other commonly one.
00:03:01 I also saw today a video of a man pooping on someone's lawn in Niagara Falls, Ontario.
00:03:07 So, that's been sort of just a trending story.
00:03:09 So, of course, naturally, when Harrison posted a photo of a man pooping outside of a gas station
00:03:15 in a Tim Hortons, he had like a Tim Hortons cup in his hand.
00:03:18 I don't really know what was going on.
00:03:20 I'm not sure if the man was like hoping to like poop into the cup or if like,
00:03:24 based on the photo, it appears that's what's happening.
00:03:27 So, Harrison posted this photo online.
00:03:30 He wrote, Brampton man just couldn't walk the 15 yards to the bathroom.
00:03:33 Mass immigration is totally working.
00:03:36 This tweet blew up.
00:03:37 And I think part of the reason it blew up is just because it's such a hot topic right now,
00:03:41 considering we just recently had the story of, you know, Indians,
00:03:44 Indian immigrants are pooping on beaches. 1.00
00:03:46 And then the city came out and said that wasn't true. 0.97
00:03:48 And all the people who live in the city were like, no, this is true.
00:03:50 I think that was at Wasaga Beach in Ontario.
00:03:52 So, then a former Liberal MP commented, he quote tweeted on Harrison's post.
00:03:56 And he said, I own this property and this did not happen.
00:04:00 It's photoshopped, do better.
00:04:01 And then his rebuttal of Harrison's post also got like a ton of traction online.
00:04:07 And then a whole bunch of people chimed in saying this is totally fake. 0.97
00:04:10 You know, Harrison, you're a racist. 0.90
00:04:12 And a lot of other people had posted this image as well. 0.97
00:04:14 And I think some people were even being threatened with a lawsuit.
00:04:17 So, everyone who was kind of like watching on the sidelines, like waiting to see what was happening.
00:04:21 But the thing that everyone kept pointing to is you can see this man's reflection in the car.
00:04:26 And it would be extremely difficult to photoshop that.
00:04:28 I mean, I know photoshop has gotten pretty good.
00:04:30 But I would say the average social media user is not very good at it.
00:04:35 And so, it seemed very unlikely that the image was photoshopped.
00:04:37 But then Harrison had the receipts.
00:04:40 And he actually had, it's sort of a little video.
00:04:42 It was actually just basically the live version of the photo.
00:04:46 So, if you have an iPhone, I don't know if it's the same for Android users.
00:04:49 You can actually take like a live photo.
00:04:51 And it takes like a little video.
00:04:52 And then you can choose where in the photo you want to stop.
00:04:54 So, Harrison was able to post that live photo.
00:04:57 Which is essentially a small video.
00:04:59 Which proved that the photo is in fact real.
00:05:02 And that it was not photoshopped.
00:05:04 So, the thing that I think is most interesting is the people who are still claiming that the photo is photoshopped.
00:05:10 They're not backing down.
00:05:10 They're not retracting their tweets or issuing apologies.
00:05:13 They're just doubling down.
00:05:14 And it seems like it's just sort of a war of you're going to believe what you want to believe at this point.
00:05:19 It doesn't matter what the truth is.
00:05:20 What did you make of this whole situation unfolding on Exus Week, Noah?
00:05:25 Well, I thought that, you know, you're exactly right.
00:05:28 That it is kind of inexcusable that you especially have a liberal MP who won't retract the statement that, you know, is proven to be false.
00:05:35 And this is because Harrison is sort of on the wrong side.
00:05:38 He's, you know, a conservative, he talks about mass immigration, and he talks about things that, you know, is really a big thorn in the side of the Liberal Party.
00:05:48 And so, you know, just spreading misinformation on the internet, and you could even call it disinformation if you think that Raj Grewal purposefully spread this falsehood.
00:05:58 You know, spreading these sorts of falsehoods, it's fine, you know, if it's against a conservative or it helps to disprove a conservative's argument.
00:06:07 But, you know, users on Exx did provide the receipts, and it's a great thing that, you know, we have a greater understanding of what the truth is and what is not.
00:06:18 Because under this liberal MP's just sort of pronunciations, just sort of anything he says, it's not going to be really accurate.
00:06:29 I think it's really concerning that this liberal just sort of dismissed Harrison's pretty, you know, fair concerns without, you know, trying to, you know, investigate why, you know, someone might be mad about this.
00:06:45 Because the liberal government, they've created this immigration problem in which, you know, we have people coming into the country that don't share Canadian values, don't share the same sort of values of sanitation and hygiene. 0.96
00:06:56 I think that's a really basic Canadian value. Go to the washroom if you're going to take a crap. 0.99
00:07:02 But, you know, I think that, you know... 0.99
00:07:05 It's complicated stuff.
00:07:07 It's really complicated. I really, you know, took a while to learn that.
00:07:11 But I think that if you just dismiss these concerns out of hand, you're going to create resentment among the Canadian populace.
00:07:21 And you're going to create a more anti-immigrant sort of environment in Canada.
00:07:26 So Raj Grewal, he's actually...
00:07:29 What he's done is actually pretty counterproductive for his cause.
00:07:32 So I think that if you are a, you know, pro-immigration liberal, just dismissing, you know, immigration critics' concerns about people crapping in public is not going to bring people onto your side.
00:07:46 It's actually going to, you know, create people who are more anti-immigrant.
00:07:50 You're going to have neutral observers who see this interaction on Twitter and say, hey, you know, maybe the pro-immigrant people are, you know, just crazy misinformation spreaders and, you know, the type of people who just seek to deny the truth, you know, for their own political purposes.
00:08:05 Yeah, no, I think you raise a really good point when you talk about the fact that just dismissing concerns about mass immigration and some of the problem that it brings, like different understanding of what sanitation is and different understanding of what is appropriate in a given country versus the country where you might have originated from.
00:08:22 Just dismissing those concerns outright is going to cause resentment among the Canadian people.
00:08:25 I think we're already at that point.
00:08:27 I think that Canadian people, by and large, are feeling resentful.
00:08:30 And this is like a very typical playbook that we see from the left.
00:08:32 Oh, you can't talk about that. 0.99
00:08:33 You're a racist.
00:08:34 Just dismissing concerns outright and instead throwing a label, sort of like a Band-Aid fix on someone so they won't talk about these things.
00:08:43 But the one thing, like, that I just can't get past is just that there's so many people who still believe that this image was fake because of how loud it's being voiced.
00:08:50 And I think we're seeing something very similar playing out in the American election right now.
00:08:54 I covered this on my show on Wednesday, Rachel and the Republic, which you should absolutely go and watch if you haven't seen it yet.
00:09:01 But essentially, there's been so many things that have happened in the past that now people are trying to rewrite.
00:09:05 So, for example, Kamala Harris being named the Borders are as vice president because the border is such an issue. 1.00
00:09:11 Now people are trying to say, oh, she was never the Borders are.
00:09:13 And in some cases, this is being done quite successfully.
00:09:16 And I think it has the ability to to change the election if it goes unchecked.
00:09:20 So when we talk about this disinformation, Isaac, do you think that X is really a place to for people to go and to disseminate what truth is?
00:09:28 Or do you think a lot of the times people leave with more confusion, more questions than answers?
00:09:34 Yeah, that's a good question.
00:09:35 And obviously, Elon Musk, who owns X, has been very vocal in purchasing X, that he was doing it to protect freedom of speech.
00:09:44 Many people have touted him as the savior, if you will, of a freedom of speech because of all the.
00:09:50 We've seen all the other social medias like Facebook and other meta owned social medias, and we know that they have.
00:10:04 Stopped certain information from getting out there intentionally, the Hunter Biden laptop story, of course, is one that most people like to cite and remember.
00:10:13 But yeah, I mean, X is also where I remember seeing a study years ago that at the time, Twitter was the most where the social media where the most politics were discussed.
00:10:28 So obviously, freedom of speech in that sense is very important, especially when we're talking about election integrity and the like.
00:10:36 So obviously, people are discussing primarily politics on X.
00:10:40 Yeah, and just going back to the photo quickly, I mean, the fact that people are still trying to say that's photoshopped when there is a live photo, literally a video version that your iPhone automatically takes.
00:10:52 I mean, it's a ridiculous defense to hang on to.
00:10:56 And I also wanted to say that I read True North's article on that story, and we obviously we tried to reach out to the gas station who the employee said he didn't know what was going on.
00:11:06 And then they wouldn't provide the CCTV, which I found odd, because obviously, if you wanted to prove what happened, you could just provide the unedited raw video from the CCTV.
00:11:17 So I don't know why there's any secrecy remaining around that.
00:11:22 But yeah, I know. I mean, oh, sorry, you could just go.
00:11:25 Yeah, it was just absolutely like, again, I think we really saw the people who posted this image initially.
00:11:30 They came with the receipts, and I think it was fairly obvious to everyone that it would have been difficult to Photoshop that given.
00:11:35 But, you know, just another day, some more drama on X.
00:11:38 Another kind of funny thing that happened was a video that Stephen Guibault posted, you know, very unpopular environment minister of Canada right now.
00:11:44 And he's trying to sort of catch on the bandwagon of some trends that we're seeing in the States.
00:11:48 You know, why don't you take the lead on this one?
00:11:50 I'm just I'm just too frustrated with it at this point.
00:11:52 Go ahead and explain what happened here.
00:11:55 Well, you know, just for some context, in the United States, Joe Biden has dropped out.
00:12:02 And Kamala Harris is the presumptive nominee for president for the Democratic Party.
00:12:07 And pretty soon after Kamala Harris, you know, stepped forward and basically claimed the Democratic nomination, this social media trend, I would say it was a little manufactured.
00:12:20 But the social media trend emerged, basically saying that Kamala is brat. 1.00
00:12:26 Now, it is just like this stupid Gen Z thing. 0.99
00:12:29 I'm part of Gen Z, so it's like, you know, self-generational criticism. 0.99
00:12:32 But, you know, there's this stupid Gen Z thing where, you know, there's this artist, pop artist named Charlie XCX. 0.96
00:12:40 She has this album coming out and, you know, she has this, I guess, clever marketing scheme where she's like, you know, XCX is brat or whatever. 1.00
00:12:47 I don't understand it too much because I don't listen to Charlie XCX.
00:12:51 I'm not on those corners of the Internet.
00:12:53 But basically, Kamala Harris and her team, they took this Charlie XCX trend and they basically, you know, repurposed it for their own campaign purposes.
00:13:04 They are trying to say that Kamala Harris is brat. 1.00
00:13:06 What does brat mean?
00:13:08 You know, it means anything to anyone.
00:13:10 You know, it means what you wish brat to mean. 0.99
00:13:13 You know, which in and of itself, it just makes the whole concept stupid. 0.99
00:13:18 But, you know, they've branded their campaign HQ around it. 0.96
00:13:22 You know, the sort of online campaign war room.
00:13:24 And it seems as if this has caught in the attention of Canadian politicians.
00:13:29 So, notorious Trudeau cabinet minister, Trudeau's environment minister, Stephen Giebeau,
00:13:34 So, he decided that it would be a good idea to basically repurpose Kamala's, you know, you see it there on screen, repurpose Kamala Harris' branding and say that, you know, this is a brat summer and that affordable housing is brat.
00:13:50 You know, what is that supposed to mean?
00:13:52 I have no idea.
00:13:53 And I thought it was really cringe.
00:13:55 I advised Stephen Giebeau to delete the post because that's what any, you know, good person, anyone who wanted the best for Stephen Giebeau's life, you know, they would tell him to take that post down.
00:14:06 You know, I don't know what his communications people, his communications staff was telling him.
00:14:11 But, you know, they should be fired immediately.
00:14:13 It is horrible.
00:14:14 It's the worst if I was to, you know, persuade Trump.
00:14:16 But, you know, I think it really just goes to show that politics, especially in Canada and the United States, it's become sort of, you know, vapid and, you know, sort of hollow.
00:14:28 And that, you know, it's a joke.
00:14:30 Exactly.
00:14:30 You know, we don't really discuss, you know, really, you know, substantive issues.
00:14:34 We just say that housing affordability is brat.
00:14:37 And, you know, just put that out in the air.
00:14:39 It's not like I saw housing prices come down anytime soon.
00:14:42 Actually, housing starts, starts on homes being built, have gone down in recent months.
00:14:49 You know, compared to last year, housing starts are down, I think, 50%.
00:14:53 So it's not like they're doing anything to make housing affordable.
00:14:56 They just declare the housing affordability is brat.
00:14:58 And boom, housing prices shoot down 50% in the next week.
00:15:02 What do you guys think of this thing that Stephen Giebeau did?
00:15:07 Well, I had looked into this trend a little bit in my coverage of the American election, and I was, like, looking into this trend of brat because I didn't really understand it either.
00:15:15 I might be a Gen Z, but I actually, you know, tend to fit in more with, like, 60-year-olds and that demographic.
00:15:21 So I was lost as to what this trend was.
00:15:23 So I was looking it up.
00:15:24 So apparently the trend of being brat means to be being bold and uncomfortable, and it's to be the unexpected.
00:15:31 And that's why they pick sort of that odd green color that you don't see too much of because it was unexpected.
00:15:35 I think it's funny that essentially Stephen Giebeau was saying that affordable housing is unexpected, which it certainly is in Canada.
00:15:43 We definitely don't expect that anymore.
00:15:46 What's the average median home price in Ontario is, like, something around half a million dollars.
00:15:51 And then The Atlantic also described it, and they said that brat is a collection of nightclub bangers celebrating female hedonism.
00:16:00 So, no, I thought it was interesting when you said, well, it's kind of whatever you want it to be,
00:16:03 because it doesn't seem like there's really a clear definition of what brat is.
00:16:07 But whatever it is, Stephen Giebeau definitely didn't know what it was when he made that post.
00:16:11 Like, they have no idea what they're talking about.
00:16:13 They're trying to fit into a trend that it obviously, you know, sure, you could repurpose this trend if you wanted to.
00:16:19 But in terms, and, you know, here we should really just be accusing the Americans of, 0.53
00:16:23 we should be accusing Giebeau of importing American-style politics into Canada.
00:16:27 Like, he's so clearly taken this trend from the Kamala Harris campaign.
00:16:30 He isn't even fully aware of what it is.
00:16:32 They might have been able to repurpose it for something,
00:16:34 but I don't think they would have been able to repurpose it for affordable housing.
00:16:38 And I think this is sort of falling on flat.
00:16:39 I don't think it's causing any clarification on the policy methods that they're actually trying to get forward.
00:16:43 Isaac, what's your take on this whole thing?
00:16:45 Yeah.
00:16:45 So, obviously, I didn't know as much background information about the Gen Z brat thing as you, Noah, and maybe you, Rachel.
00:16:53 But first thing I did when I saw this video, I thought I knew what a brat was. 0.97
00:16:56 But just to be sure, I looked up the definition, which read,
00:17:00 a child, typically a badly behaved one, which is, I might think, is how some people would describe Stephen Giebeau.
00:17:08 And, you know, I mean, you're the environment minister of Canada.
00:17:12 Why are you even talking about housing in the first place, especially, especially in light of what just happened in Jasper?
00:17:18 I really think you'd have bigger concerns on your plate.
00:17:22 And then just touching briefly on housing, a July survey from the Angus Reid Institute showed that newcomers to Canada were more likely to leave than Canadian-born citizens.
00:17:33 But even three in 10 Canadian-born citizens were considering leaving the province and their country due to housing affordability concerns,
00:17:40 whereas 39% of newcomers were considering leaving.
00:17:46 And we'll remember Canada's housing affordability reached an all-time low back in April.
00:17:51 And then Trudeau promised to build 4 million homes by 2031, which would equate to 1.096 houses per minute,
00:17:58 which would require Canada to double its housing starts.
00:18:01 And as you said, Noah, they have not been going up but down, let alone double for seven years straight.
00:18:07 At this point, it's more than that because, obviously, the housing starts have been falling, not rising.
00:18:12 And then the recent news that came out and came into effect on Thursday,
00:18:18 which is the promise made by the Liberals in the 2024 budget to offer 30-year mortgage amortizations.
00:18:24 And I talked at length about this with various mortgage brokers and economists.
00:18:30 I kind of went down into the calculations to see, hey, is this actually a good thing?
00:18:35 And sorry, the part that came into effect on Thursday was only for first-time homebuyers purchasing new builds.
00:18:43 So it's a very limited demographic.
00:18:45 But anyways, in June 2024, the average house in Canada cost $696,179.
00:18:52 So after accounting for the minimum possible down payment, which equates to 5% on the first $500,000 and 10% on the remaining sum,
00:18:59 or a minimum of 20% if the house exceeds $1 million,
00:19:02 a 25-year mortgage would result in monthly payments of $3,789.
00:19:09 And for a 30-year mortgage, this would fall to $3,477.
00:19:13 Wow, that sounds great.
00:19:14 However, this drop in price would cost Canadians almost $115,000 over the full realization of that mortgage.
00:19:23 So for a 25-year mortgage on that $696,000 home,
00:19:27 Canadians would pay a total of $1,136,853.
00:19:34 That would be $651,561 in principal cost after removing the down payment,
00:19:41 and then $485,292 in interest.
00:19:45 And a 30-year mortgage would see obviously the same principal,
00:19:47 but the interest would rise to $600,274.
00:19:50 So yes, an increase of $115,000 in interest just by increasing your mortgage over five years
00:19:56 to bring down the monthly cost, which...
00:19:59 I talked to economist and McDonald-Daurier Institute fellow, Jack Mintz,
00:20:04 who is a very renowned economist,
00:20:06 and he told me that prospective buyers should only consider this
00:20:10 if they have absolutely no other choice and that it's really not a great option.
00:20:15 And surprise, he offered a different solution that the feds should explore,
00:20:18 which he said, quote,
00:20:20 build baby build and control immigration that is pushing population growth and demand for housing. 0.73
00:20:27 So yeah, I mean, look, all these issues always come down to the same issue of immigration.
00:20:30 Yeah, like I think you raise a really good point that why is...
00:20:35 I mean, Guibo talking about this when we just had the fires in Jasper,
00:20:38 and maybe he's trying to distract a little bit.
00:20:39 But also, you know, this gimmicky sort of announcement,
00:20:42 this gimmicky advertising and marketing,
00:20:44 it doesn't do anything to abate the concerns
00:20:48 and honestly just the sadness and anger that Canadians are feeling about not being able to own a home.
00:20:53 And what was that number that you said 3 in 10 people who were born in Canada
00:20:56 are considering leaving because of the cost of living?
00:20:59 Like those are shocking numbers.
00:21:00 I mean, I'm Canadian born.
00:21:01 I've definitely considered at times maybe that maybe leaving to live somewhere that's more affordable.
00:21:06 Have either of you ever, you know, actually had those considerations?
00:21:10 Well, in the pandemic, I was especially thinking like,
00:21:12 hey, you know, this is, you know, pretty, it was pretty tragic, you know,
00:21:16 prices I think peaked during the pandemic.
00:21:18 And around those times, I was thinking like, you know, I don't have, you know,
00:21:23 I do have, you know, roots in Canada.
00:21:26 But at the end of the day, if I, you know, need to be able to buy a home,
00:21:30 you know, I can probably get a home that's worth half of a Canadian home in the United States
00:21:36 for about the same size home while making a bit more money
00:21:39 because your average American makes more money.
00:21:41 Like what?
00:21:41 That's a pretty good deal.
00:21:43 Wouldn't want, you know, that sort of opportunity, you know.
00:21:45 And while, you know, I think I'm going to stay in Canada for the rest of my life,
00:21:49 you know, because I do really love this country.
00:21:52 I want to also, you know, be able to live in a country where we don't have to,
00:21:56 you know, deal with these significant concerns.
00:21:59 I think that, you know, the roadmap in Canada now for a young person is to,
00:22:04 you know, try and, you know, do as well in school, get a good job,
00:22:07 you know, save up as much money as possible for several years.
00:22:10 You know, maybe when you're in your 40s, you get to buy a home.
00:22:13 And instead of taking out a 25-year mortgage,
00:22:15 now you take out a 30-year mortgage so that you pay it off instead of when
00:22:19 you're 65, you pay it off when you're 70.
00:22:21 So you can't really retire until you're 70 or even, you know, older.
00:22:25 So that's sort of like, you know, the ideal roadmap for a Canadian in Trudeau's
00:22:30 Canada.
00:22:31 And I think, you know, all Canadians want to, you know,
00:22:33 bring back the Canadian dream because it is lost,
00:22:37 especially for a lot of young Canadians who, you know, just, you know,
00:22:40 trying to do what, you know, their parents had done
00:22:43 and are experiencing significant difficulties in trying to establish their lives.
00:22:49 So definitely, you know, Steve and Gabo talking about BRAT housing affordability
00:22:56 or housing affordability being BRAT.
00:22:59 I don't think that's really helping a lot with the problems we're facing.
00:23:03 There you have it.
00:23:04 You know, two out of three Gen Z, mostly talented Canadians,
00:23:08 you know, we're thinking about leaving.
00:23:09 I'm not sure about you, Isaac, or we've thought about it before. 0.97
00:23:11 They're just chasing away talent, chasing away talent with these dumb policies. 0.72
00:23:16 The States, I think a lot of people think about the States as an option. 0.79
00:23:18 Then they realize how difficult it would actually be to get a visa
00:23:21 and to live there permanently.
00:23:23 I think people kind of reconsider.
00:23:24 But at least for the time being, you know, we can sit back here in Canada
00:23:28 and we can enjoy all the drama unfolding in the States, mostly on X.
00:23:32 I know Elon Musk got himself in a little hot water.
00:23:34 I think maybe Pierre Polyev should take a note out of Elon's books
00:23:39 and have a new strategy for attacking Trudeau or whoever replaces Trudeau more accurately.
00:23:44 But Isaac, why don't you explain what happened here?
00:23:46 What did Elon do that got people's panties so wound in a knot?
00:23:51 Yeah.
00:23:52 So Elon Musk shared a parody with real photos and videos of her on the campaign trail.
00:23:56 And then the 40th governor of California, Gavin Newsom,
00:24:00 said that manipulating a voice in a, quote, ad like this one should be illegal.
00:24:06 Newsom went on to say that he'd be signing a bill in a matter of weeks to make sure it is.
00:24:12 However, something interesting I found in the comments and then looked into was that
00:24:15 the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously agreed 8-0 in Hustler v. Falwell that a parody,
00:24:22 which no reasonable person expected to be true, was protected free speech.
00:24:26 And in fact, it was more than that.
00:24:27 It was protected by the 1st and the 14th Amendments in the U.S. Constitution.
00:24:31 So sharing parody videos like this is a constitutional right.
00:24:36 And I mean, Elon Musk is a pretty smart guy.
00:24:39 I'm sure he might have had some knowledge of that, which is why he took such a
00:24:44 lackadaisical approach, let's call it, in these replies.
00:24:48 What do you guys think?
00:24:49 Yeah, I think, do we have a copy of that video?
00:24:51 Let's just play it now so people can get a sense of exactly what the parody was.
00:24:55 I, Kamal Harris, senior Democrat candidate for president,
00:24:58 because Joe Biden finally exposed his senility of the debate.
00:25:02 Thanks, Joe.
00:25:02 I was selected because I am the ultimate diversity hire.
00:25:05 I'm both a woman and a person of color.
00:25:07 So if you criticize anything I say, you're both sexist and racist.
00:25:12 I may not know the first thing about running the country, but remember, 0.96
00:25:15 that's a good thing if you're a deep state puppet.
00:25:19 I had four years under the tutelage of the ultimate deep state puppet,
00:25:23 a wonderful mentor, Joe Biden. 0.62
00:25:25 Joe taught me rule number one, carefully hide your total incompetence.
00:25:31 So basically, she's just saying what every sane person in the American public is thinking right now.
00:25:36 I know Isaac talked a little bit about how the right for parody was protected.
00:25:40 But, you know, I think we've seen a lot of people's charter protected rights here in Canada
00:25:45 and constitutional protected rights in the States have been trampled on in the past number of years.
00:25:49 Do you think that there's actually going to be a problem?
00:25:51 Do you think the individual who made this video and those who've been sharing it,
00:25:54 do you think they might actually find themselves in any legal troubles, Noah?
00:26:00 Well, I would hope not.
00:26:01 I mean, if someone really does get arrested over this or, you know, gets sued or whatever,
00:26:06 I think that there's going to be a massive backlash and it's going to have that sort of the Streisand effect.
00:26:12 If you guys are not familiar with the Streisand effect, it basically refers to the phenomenon
00:26:17 where someone or a company tries to, you know, get rid of something, sort of scrub something from public existence.
00:26:24 And, you know, it has the opposite effect.
00:26:26 It has the effect of amplifying the thing that they are trying to censor.
00:26:30 So, in this case, if, you know, someone, you know, the Paris campaign or some Democrat PAC,
00:26:37 they want to, you know, try and sue the gentleman who made this video and try and get the video taken down,
00:26:44 I think it's just going to result in a mass proliferation of the video around the Internet.
00:26:48 And it really should be because censorship should be viewed with scorn.
00:26:53 I mean, there isn't really many legitimate reasons why you should be censoring a government or, you know,
00:27:00 the massive corporations should be censoring anything because, you know, it is something that free speech is a value
00:27:07 that we're supposed to take very seriously, especially in the Anglosphere, in the United States, in Canada.
00:27:12 It is a value that should be protected.
00:27:14 And, you know, parity is part of free speech.
00:27:16 You should be able to make mockery of Kamala Harris for serving under a president that is more than likely senile 0.74
00:27:24 and whose, you know, cognitive abilities are declining.
00:27:27 You should be able to mock Kamala Harris for being a sort of DEI hire, for getting picked by Joe Biden
00:27:34 because she's a black woman and, you know, she's the Democratic nominee unopposed 0.99
00:27:39 because the optics would look bad about deposing a black woman. 1.00
00:27:43 You know, you should be able to mock someone about that like that.
00:27:45 Now, when you bring AI and you have this sort of impersonation of Kamala Harris's voice,
00:27:51 I think, you know, there are certain cases in which you can have a video that is, you know, meant to deceive,
00:27:58 that is blatantly manipulative and makes, you know, Kamala Harris or even Donald Trump or Joe Biden
00:28:03 or whatever politician you want to name, it makes them look bad in a way that, you know, is meant to deceive the audience.
00:28:10 However, I think this video is clearly a parody video.
00:28:12 I mean, Kamala Harris is obviously not going to refer to the president that she's serving as,
00:28:17 as I forget the word, but basically as being senile.
00:28:22 I think that's the word.
00:28:23 Yeah.
00:28:24 She's not going to refer to Joe Biden as senile, realistically.
00:28:27 She's not going to, you know, be nearly as cynical as that.
00:28:32 And I think any observer should be able to tell that difference.
00:28:36 So, you know, I think the outrage, especially the CBC's outrage about this really, you know, has no basis.
00:28:44 And why Canada's public broadcaster is getting involved in this debate out of, you know,
00:28:50 out of all the other debates that we could be talking about in Canadian politics, it's really beyond me.
00:28:55 I don't see why that's within the CBC's mandate.
00:28:58 I mean, CBC shouldn't even be covering American politics.
00:29:01 That seems pretty straightforward to me.
00:29:02 Their mandate is the Canadian public broadcaster, fine, you know, they can cover some Canadian heritage moments
00:29:07 or some important news happening here in Canada.
00:29:09 I don't even disagree.
00:29:10 I don't even agree with their mandate.
00:29:11 I think, you know, they've sort of sold themselves out and the Canadian public has no interest in them,
00:29:15 but there certainly is no argument to be made for them covering American news.
00:29:19 So obviously they shouldn't be wading into this debate, but it is an interesting one to have
00:29:23 because I'm not sure if you guys remember this happening back in 2016.
00:29:26 There was a man who was making memes about Hillary Clinton during the election, Douglas Mackey,
00:29:31 and he was actually found guilty.
00:29:32 I think he was charged federally for making memes, which essentially told people to stay home and vote
00:29:37 and just to text a certain number to vote.
00:29:39 And he was found guilty of a crime for that.
00:29:41 So it'll be interesting to see if the left kind of just threatens and says this is illegal
00:29:45 or if they actually pursue it, because we've seen them time and time again pursue legal action
00:29:50 where they feel that they are losing.
00:29:51 I mean, that's essentially what we saw with Donald Trump.
00:29:53 They threw everything they could in the book at him because, you know,
00:29:57 they understood his popularity and they understood the threat that he was.
00:30:00 And so they threw every legal case they could find.
00:30:02 And obviously most of those have now fallen apart around them.
00:30:05 And so instead now they're turning back to the corporate media to do their dirty work for them
00:30:08 and to make it appear as if there's all this momentum behind Kamala's campaign.
00:30:12 But, you know, Noah raises an interesting point that maybe there is an ethical question as to
00:30:16 how far can we actually go when we're doing parody and when we're using AI especially.
00:30:21 And Isaac, I wonder if you think this is something that could be effective here in Canada
00:30:27 or if you think maybe the Canadian people have perhaps a lesser tolerance for those sort of grey areas
00:30:31 and it wouldn't be, you know, a popular thing to try here with, let's say,
00:30:36 whoever takes Justin Trudeau's place as leader of the Liberal Party in the next election
00:30:39 if he does indeed step down, as I think we all expect him to.
00:30:42 Would it be a good idea for opposition parties or maybe just organizers to try to paint that person
00:30:49 by using AI especially to poke fun at them?
00:30:55 Yeah, I guess this could be a useful tactic.
00:30:58 And just talking quickly on whether it should be allowed or not,
00:31:03 that is deepfake in general.
00:31:04 I mean, it's such a crucial line to walk, you know,
00:31:10 because as Noah kind of covered, like any, let's say, deepfake video
00:31:16 that was intentionally trying to lie and deceive people
00:31:20 or show them something that just simply wasn't true
00:31:23 and it wasn't clearly a parody as was this video.
00:31:26 So, you know, obviously that's going to be harmful, especially during elections,
00:31:31 you know, especially if people come online and maybe they're not so tech savvy, let's say,
00:31:37 and they just see a video of a political leader doing something crazy
00:31:40 that might have been a deepfake.
00:31:42 You know, that's obviously something that needs to be addressed.
00:31:44 But when thinking about any regulations or similarly that could come into place surrounding this,
00:31:52 you know, you just have to think about how it could be used negatively, obviously,
00:31:57 which is to essentially censor freedom of speech.
00:32:00 So I really don't know what the answer is in regard to legality.
00:32:04 I do think that when something is clearly a parody, it's fine.
00:32:10 And maybe on the flip side, if it's clearly intentionally trying to deceive someone
00:32:16 and suggest that something that didn't happen in reality is true via deepfake,
00:32:23 then that is something that should be completely taken down from the Internet.
00:32:27 But again, walking the line between control and freedom of speech
00:32:31 is such a tough line to walk in modern society.
00:32:36 Yeah, I think you've sort of hit the nail on the head here.
00:32:39 I think things that are obviously parody and are being created to be humorous
00:32:43 should be allowed and, you know, potentially even encouraged to bring a lighter side to politics,
00:32:48 help people to laugh at some of the darkness that we're seeing.
00:32:50 And when things are a deepfake or being created to pass itself off as truth and reality,
00:32:56 when it is not, I think those types of things should definitely be discouraged.
00:33:01 Fortunately, that's all the time we have today for our Friday fun show.
00:33:04 Let us know what you think of this episode in the comments below
00:33:06 and give us some suggestions as who you would like to see host the show in weeks to come.
00:33:11 As I mentioned, our colleague Andrew will be gone for at least a couple of weeks,
00:33:14 if not a couple of months, and we will certainly miss him.
00:33:16 But wish him the best of luck.
00:33:17 So let us know who you would like to see host off the record in the weeks to come.
00:33:21 And don't forget that everything you heard today was off the record.
00:33:33 Did it, guys.
00:33:33 37 minutes.
00:33:34 I think Noah should host next week.
00:33:36 You know, it would be funny if, you know, I host and then Andrew comes back and you're like,
00:33:43 yeah, you know, Noah, great hosting job, but I got to say that all those insults
00:33:48 that you threw my way while you're hosting, all those jabs,
00:33:53 it's going to result in the extinguishing of your tenure with the True North, Noah.
00:33:59 I think your job is more protected than you think it is, Noah.
00:34:01 Oh, yeah, because I'm the DEI hire.
00:34:05 Just, you know, go to the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, you know,
00:34:08 just walk down the block and say, hey, these True North fellers, man,
00:34:12 they're exactly what you thought they were.
00:34:15 Exactly.
00:34:16 Can you imagine a human rights case against us?
00:34:18 The public would love it.
00:34:19 People would be like, we knew it.
00:34:21 Yeah.
00:34:22 Yeah.
00:34:23 Yeah.
00:34:24 Yeah.
00:34:25 Yeah.
00:34:25 Oh, yeah.
00:34:27 Yeah.
00:34:28 Yeah.
00:34:29 Oh, yeah.
00:34:30 Yeah.
00:34:30 Yeah.
00:34:31 Yeah.
00:34:32 Yeah.
00:34:44 Oh, yeah.
00:34:46 Oh, my God.