Off the Record - August 16, 2024


Liberals blame Stephen Harper for everything

Hosted by
Mentioned
Where on Earth is Justin Trudeau? Canada’s state broadcaster is obsessed with Kamala Harris

Episode Stats


Length

33 minutes

Words per minute

190.97

Word count

6,365

Sentence count

3

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this week's Off The Record, I'm joined by my True North colleagues William and Isac as they discuss the Canadian citizenship scandal surrounding a man who was granted Canadian citizenship and later found to be tied to an alleged IS terrorist plot.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 i saw that like conor mcdavid did like this video where he gave a tour of his have his home in
00:00:04 edmonton was pretty nice i'd love there i would imagine so he he got a lot of flack over that
00:00:11 video because i don't know he people like oh this guy has no personality and he's just so
00:00:16 he's a hockey player he doesn't need to have a personality he's like one of the world's best
00:00:20 hockey players and then something funny happened later in an interview this was months later someone
00:00:25 asked him about shoveling his his driveway and he's like uh i got heated driveways i don't need
00:00:29 to shovel living the dream yeah i love this idea that rich people shouldn't actually spend their
00:00:37 money on anything all right guys let's get it started hey everyone welcome back to off the record our
00:00:53 friday fun show i am joined today by my true north colleagues william and isaac thank you both for
00:00:59 being here thanks for having us yeah thanks for having me as well i'm sure the audience is familiar
00:01:06 with with both of you at this point i think you're regular stalwarts on off the record and uh you know
00:01:11 some weeks it's less spicy news and other weeks but this week i think we have one of like the biggest
00:01:16 news stories of the year where two men in toronto were planning a terrorist attack and incidentally
00:01:23 one of the man one of the men had been given canadian citizenship and was later found that
00:01:27 he had been allegedly tied to an isis plot and so now questions are swirling um if um you know how he
00:01:34 got into canada how he got his citizenship there you know is allegedly a video of him hacking a body i
00:01:39 believe and you know people are saying that he was a part of aggravated assault and so obviously this
00:01:45 seems like a pretty big miss from the federal government that he was able to come into canada
00:01:49 first of all and second of all that he was granted citizenship and i'm personally not terribly surprised
00:01:54 to see this because we're letting so many people into the country and the liberals have really ramped up
00:01:59 immigration and i think all of us have kind of been watching this very warily saying we're letting
00:02:03 too many people in and these people are not going to be properly vetted because we just can't
00:02:07 you know keep up with the pace of people that are coming here this is sort of blown up for the
00:02:12 liberals this week because i think it really speaks to the frustration that canadians are feeling about
00:02:16 immigration right now people are very concerned people are looking at what's happening in the uk
00:02:20 they're wondering if something like that could happen in canada and then this story happens
00:02:24 and everyone's sort of you know worst worst fears are confirmed that there are people who are living
00:02:28 in canada that haven't been properly vetted that want ill for canadian people in this case
00:02:33 planning a terrorist attack in toronto which thankfully the police caught before it
00:02:37 happened and you know the liberals are now saying they're looking at revoking this man's citizenship
00:02:42 but um instead of taking responsibility for the action the liberals are trying to blame former
00:02:50 conservative prime minister stephen harper who hasn't been in power for nine years now and uh it's just
00:02:56 absurd so here's you know jennifer o'connell speaking about this in a house committee hearing 0.98
00:03:00 this week here is is jennifer o'connell blaming stephen harper's government for this absolute failure 0.99
00:03:07 i am very pleased to see the conservatives finally realize that their cuts have consequences and
00:03:15 previously under the harper government when they cut more than a thousand cbsa employees um at the time
00:03:24 the president of the customs and immigration union said quote there will be little and in some cases
00:03:31 potentially no investigating or surveillance being done to keep these criminals out of the country
00:03:37 and out of our communities 410 also said if the government doesn't change the course and withdraw
00:03:43 its plan to implement these cuts the federal government will be putting the national security
00:03:49 and public safety of our communities at risk end quote this is precisely why we've been making
00:03:56 reinvestments to staff up cbsa to deal with the previous conservative cuts and it's exactly why we
00:04:04 continue to make investments through the budget through the fall economic statement which conservatives
00:04:10 voted against so we look forward to having these meetings so conservatives can truly appreciate
00:04:16 that their cuts have consequences to our national security and the safety of our communities so we
00:04:22 are very supportive of these amendments and having that conversation so obviously o'connell is trying to
00:04:29 redirect take the attention off of the massive failure of her government and and put it back on the 1.00
00:04:34 conservatives william do you think that she's doing this successfully is this something people are
00:04:38 actually going to believe yeah i mean nine years is a long time i i think people are starting to really
00:04:47 not even remember the harper government in any any you know real sense or clear sense uh just you know
00:04:54 an interesting point i suppose it's at least debatable whether or not the harper government uh could or
00:05:01 should have done more to prevent the entry of this person uh even though they they entered the country 0.95
00:05:07 after the liberals took power in 2015 but it was very much the liberal government that decided to
00:05:13 grant citizenship and allow this person to remain in canada which would have been years after that
00:05:19 and they would have been empowering years and so i think it's really very uh ironic to see a liberal
00:05:26 government trying to blame the harper governments for something that they were clearly responsible for
00:05:31 the fact that they're being this desperate the fact that they're trying to pin the blame on
00:05:35 someone who hasn't been in office as you stayed for nine years i think reflects a large amount of
00:05:41 the desperation they're feeling in terms of their flagging poll results particularly around issues
00:05:46 like immigration where they are so off base with where the rest of the canadian population is
00:05:53 yeah i think you raise a really good point we were talking just before this show started about
00:05:57 justin trudeau during when he was running for when he was running to be prime minister back in 2015 and
00:06:02 you know that infamous clip of him debating stephen harper and they're talking about citizenship and
00:06:07 harper saying that people who are involved and in sort of these these terrorist incidents should
00:06:11 not be given citizenship in canada or in cases their their citizenship should be revoked and just as
00:06:16 a canadian is a canadian is a canadian is a canadian is a canadian is a canadian is do you think that
00:06:19 that is something the prime minister would say today given the level of scrutiny that canadians are
00:06:25 looking at immigration with definitely not you know canada i think historically has been pretty
00:06:33 pro-immigration not not only from a a federal policies perspective but from a citizenship
00:06:38 perspective in that most canadians uh throughout history i think have been uh favorable of immigration
00:06:44 but unfortunately prime minister justin trudeau with his uh deeply flawed policies has kind of turned
00:06:51 the tables on that i mean look they're bringing in millions of people a year not none of our social
00:06:57 programs can support that and and when you bring in people in such a high volume obviously there are
00:07:02 going to be a few bad apples that fall from the tree and something i wanted to add as well was that
00:07:09 i remember the parliamentary budget officer he released a report a few months ago which was about uh
00:07:15 federal departments and bonuses and but more more importantly their goals were they meeting their
00:07:20 goals none of them are none of them are are doing an adequate job as themselves have have uh determined
00:07:27 to be so uh obviously that would apply to immigration as well and that beat that being the borders so uh is
00:07:35 every single person coming into canada the millions per year being vetted properly uh i would estimate no
00:07:43 and just if i could add rachel you know the the whole idea of a canadian is a canadian is a canadian
00:07:49 well when you immigrate to this country and become a citizen you take an oath of loyalty
00:07:54 you make a solemn vow to be loyal to your new country and to abide by the values of that country
00:08:02 committing an act of terrorism is a complete breaking of that oath and so therefore i think
00:08:08 the government will be well within its rights to rescind it on the idea that you did not fulfill the
00:08:13 commitment you made uh in front of the government and god when you became a citizen of this country
00:08:20 so for the prime minister to play like just you know play games like oh a canadian is a canadian
00:08:25 canadian well a terrorist is a terrorist is a terrorist and if you've committed an act of
00:08:29 terrorism i think canada will be well within the rights to revoke your citizenship and send you packing 0.50
00:08:35 very well put william you know one of the other aspects of this controversy that
00:08:39 just kind of bothered me as i felt like it was a little bit misguided from the liberals to put
00:08:43 jennifer o'connell as the lead on this i mean i'm surprised her answer wasn't something like boo
00:08:47 who get over it this is like not a serious political player i don't think that she's trusted
00:08:53 with the canadian people i think she often acts in bad faith and so to see her you know putting the
00:08:58 blame back on stephen harper is not surprising to me and i think she's really lost a lot of respect
00:09:03 among the canadian people because she's always playing political games and i don't think she 1.00
00:09:07 actually wants to see solutions i don't think she's working towards solutions there are some
00:09:11 parliamentarians who are better at working with the other side and do so in in good faith and there
00:09:17 are others who are only interested in playing politics and she is one of those who's only ever
00:09:20 interested in playing in politics and you know we put a compilation together of some of some other bad
00:09:24 actors within the liberal party who can can't help themselves and every time there's criticism of
00:09:29 their government they blame they blame stephen harper who as we said hasn't been in power
00:09:33 for nearly a decade take a look take a look at this i think it's important to remind people that
00:09:39 when we formed the government in 2015 there were absolutely no measures in place to detect disrupt
00:09:46 and counter foreign interference in the electoral context mr poliev was minister of democratic institutions
00:09:53 two years in 2013 cesus publicly identified the risk of interference in democratic processes the
00:10:01 previous conservative government did absolutely nothing under my watch personally i've been in
00:10:05 this role for about six and a half months i've appointed 64 judges so far and more there are more
00:10:09 to comes and the average year under the harper government they appointed 65 per year so on
00:10:14 that metric alone i'm working twice as fast as the harper government so that's the first point
00:10:18 would the conservatives actually like to know that since 2006 the five years with the highest
00:10:24 amount of car thefts in canadian history was under the stephen harper government in 2015 stephen harper
00:10:33 presented a budget that had slashed funds for policing slashed funds uh for cbsa officers a
00:10:40 slash funding for veterans affairs services and we were there to clean up the mess 0.90
00:10:48 i have to say that i really don't think jennifer o'connell wants to be playing the game about 0.99
00:10:52 in under which government where car thefts were i can assure you that back in 2015 i was in high
00:10:57 school at the time there were no reports about people in toronto taking desperate measures like
00:11:04 putting poles at the end of their driveway to stop criminals from driving off with their vehicles that
00:11:08 wasn't the reality then back in 2015 there wasn't certain parts of the country that i actively wanted
00:11:13 to avoid because i was worried if my vehicle was at a gas station and i was filling up that someone
00:11:18 might come along and carjack it things have changed drastically obviously people are feeling
00:11:22 much less safe they were now than then but but isaac what's what's your take on this whole situation i
00:11:26 mean do you think that this is just sort of par for the course in politics that the new government's
00:11:31 always going to blame the previous government when something happens or do you think that there is
00:11:34 maybe a window where that's fair to do you know maybe in the first two years maybe depending on the
00:11:39 issue a little longer and after that canadians are like you've been in power for over five years now
00:11:44 you know it's time to take responsibility for your government's action what would the timeline on that look like
00:11:49 yeah uh for just answering the first part of your question i don't know that it's par for the course
00:11:55 in politics per se but i definitely think it's par for the course for the liberals uh when when we were
00:12:01 talking about compiling a compilation of the liberals uh bashing or blaming the stephen harper
00:12:09 government for their mistakes i i was immediately thinking oh there must be hundreds of examples because
00:12:14 i'm just thinking of the the many press conferences i've watched over the years i mean i i feel like
00:12:19 the liberals do that on a weekly basis almost is blame the harper government or at least in some
00:12:26 way the conservative or polyethra government as for the window uh yeah that's a tough one you know
00:12:32 i think it really varies on the issue obviously here we were talking about a terrorist who came
00:12:39 uh into canada under the liberals's watch so i mean at that point you think you at least have
00:12:45 to take some of the accountability even if it is in reality a shared responsibility which i don't even
00:12:50 know if it is but the liberals taking accountability for any mistakes or errors that they make is not
00:12:57 something i often see them do they they instead of take accountability deflect the blame to others uh so
00:13:04 yeah i think that there's probably some room when you form government to say listen we're trying to
00:13:09 fix these issues that were created by the previous government but truthfully i think that canadians
00:13:14 writ large are not really interested in these types of excuses and it's in the best interest of any
00:13:19 government to do that as little as possible and if you are going to do that you need to clearly explain
00:13:24 what your plan is to fix these solutions in a timeline as to when we could see these issues being
00:13:28 abated i think it's used far too often in politics and in politics as an excuse for governments
00:13:33 not to be held accountable for their crappy and ineffective policies but while we're on the
00:13:37 topic of bad actors william true north commission to poll i know that you have the juicy details on
00:13:44 this what have we learned about the cbc this week yeah well the cbc and its quest to become ever more
00:13:51 hated by canadian taxpayers did another great job of convincing taxpayers that they're getting absolutely
00:13:58 fleeced uh when it comes to how their money's being spent they decided to pay their
00:14:02 bonus their executives big multi-million dollar bonuses 18.4 million in bonuses despite the fact
00:14:10 that according to their own analysis fewer and fewer people are actually watching cbc particularly cbc news
00:14:21 so uh i don't know what the metric is to decide whether or not bonuses are warranted you would think
00:14:27 people actually watching cbc might be one of the factors considered but as it turns out nobody is
00:14:34 watching cbc but but that didn't stop them from giving themselves an awful lot of our money as a job
00:14:40 well done in their view i think we see this time and time again when the government when something's
00:14:47 funded by the government whether it's a government entity or simply receiving government subsidies all
00:14:52 of a sudden there's no need for that entity to actually be successful because the government
00:14:56 dollars have been promised and they almost always keep coming anyways isaac was just talking about
00:15:01 this with the report from the parliamentary budget officer who found that you know government services
00:15:07 were not meeting their criteria they were not doing what they set out to do and the people who are
00:15:12 responsible for them are not facing any consequences for their actions oftentimes because it has to do with
00:15:16 protection in unions and things like that but instead in this case they're being given radical budgets and i
00:15:21 can't help but look at the story and wonder you know does the cbc could they help themselves a little
00:15:27 bit if they were to turn off the tops on the budgets maybe canadians would have more sympathy for this
00:15:31 or maybe this is just a situation where they actually see the writing on the wall they they see that it's
00:15:36 going to be a conservative government canadians the public has largely turned against them and they're
00:15:41 just trying to take everything they can on the way out what do you think isaac yeah something i wanted to
00:15:47 add quickly was obviously these bonuses come after recently laying off it was seven or eight hundred
00:15:52 employees so i mean that that timeline of events really doesn't make any sense to me how can you go from
00:15:58 laying off employees to dishing out tens of millions of dollars in bonuses as for the cbc taking 0.83
00:16:06 accountability i i don't even think it's really a possibility when they're getting the amount of funding that they are which is yes 1.4
00:16:13 billion dollars a year you're never going to have to be accountable because you can essentially deliver
00:16:19 a poor service uh your your ratings can all go down you the money keeps coming in and more and more of
00:16:26 it so why would you adapt to the ever-changing market that is the media industry which obviously
00:16:31 the cbc hasn't done which is why more canadians are coming to independent outlets like true north
00:16:38 instead of government funded taxpayer subsidized outlets like the cbc
00:16:44 yeah and we actually look at the bonuses correct me if i'm wrong william but wasn't it like an average
00:16:48 of 74 000 like that's more than an average canadian makes in a year so we're looking at all the bonuses
00:16:55 that were laid out after people were laid off it's like why couldn't those bonuses simply have been used
00:16:58 to keep employees on the payroll for longer no you're absolutely right i mean it is just laughable
00:17:03 that a bunch of cbc bigwigs sat around the board table and said i think we've done a terrific job 0.53
00:17:09 let's give ourselves bonuses um now we by the way we three aren't the only three who agree that
00:17:15 something is deeply wrong at the cbc true north commissioned a poll uh that was performed by one
00:17:21 persuasion and it found that more than 60 percent of canadians are in favor of either partially defunding
00:17:28 or fully defunding the canadian broadcasting corporation uh only a only a a minority of
00:17:35 people were in favor of maintaining the full funding for the cbc fewer than four in ten so
00:17:42 the fact that more than 60 percent of the country agree that cbc should not be fully funded i think is
00:17:49 very strong message to uh mr polyevra saying you had better do something about the cbc when you get
00:17:55 elected to office and i will say at a personal level if the cbc remains intact exactly the way it
00:18:01 is right now after the polyevra government has done its first term in office i personally will be very
00:18:07 disappointed in them and their lack of action yeah william i think that's a good point to raise is that
00:18:13 often we see you know conservatives running for office they they come out with these very strong
00:18:18 conservative positions and policies and then once they're elected with that typical move to the center
00:18:23 and a lot of their promises are abandoned you know we we saw this obviously with aaron o'toole
00:18:27 when he was running for conservative leader very conservative once he became the conservative leader
00:18:31 he was much more centrist and uh i think the party and the conservative base rightfully lambasted and
00:18:37 eventually tossed him for that but uh you know polyev has been very strong i think if you've ever been
00:18:43 to a pierre polyev rally or if you've seen one you you'll notice he always has that call to defund the cbc he
00:18:50 usually talks about it in the context of the housing crisis he'll say you know i can't i can't wait to
00:18:55 see a young family moving into the cbc headquarters in ottawa after i've defunded it talks about how he
00:19:01 wants to convert into housing and that typically gets the largest cheer like no matter what he says
00:19:06 in a given rally that is a thing that riles people up most is the thought of him defunding the cbc and um
00:19:14 you know he's gonna have to do something about it if he wants to hold on to his base i guess isaac
00:19:17 now turning to you conservatives are up in the polls 20 points everyone's expecting a conservative
00:19:22 government at this point do you think that pierre polyev would follow through on on that promise to
00:19:28 defund the cbc in some capacity yeah even when william was talking about after the first time i was
00:19:34 thinking to myself there's absolutely no world i can see wherein pierre polyev doesn't defund the cbc
00:19:42 with as quick as he possibly can obviously there are some processes he may have to go through but uh
00:19:47 this has obviously been one of his largest talking points uh i don't know axe attacks
00:19:52 defund the cbc and you pick the third most popular but look yeah you can't you can't
00:19:59 uh focus on something so much during your election campaign and then not follow through with it i mean
00:20:05 that's just obviously a recipe for self-destruction and i i don't see why polyev would even consider
00:20:13 that for for for a millisecond i i and i really think he is not only uh talking about it a lot
00:20:19 on his election campaign but actually deeply passionate about defunding the cbc it's something
00:20:23 he actually wants to do so then then why wouldn't he go and follow through with it right yeah and it
00:20:29 makes sense for him from a political standpoint as well uh not just because he's promised this to
00:20:34 canadians to conservatives but also because we know that the cbc and its coverage of the
00:20:39 conservatives will essentially be campaigning for the liberals so you know if he was able to to get
00:20:43 rid of some of that coverage that would be a very good thing for for his government should he be
00:20:48 elected and certainly first party either way um i think you know when we're talking about the cbc and
00:20:54 the criticism of them doling out these donuts is another big criticism of them was isaac i know this is
00:20:58 more your wheelhouse i'll let you speak to this but didn't they recently refuse to stream some of the nhl
00:21:03 games and you know that's something that canadians like would all obviously want to watch like i don't
00:21:08 even watch hockey i'll be totally transparent with you i don't watch hockey but i would totally flip on
00:21:13 the nhl game if it was easily accessible to me and and i if i'm not mistaken was that not a big
00:21:18 controversy from just a few weeks ago yeah it was even so big that it made it to a a committee debate
00:21:25 and obviously i wrote about that story a while ago but uh just from my memory i mean it's kind of
00:21:31 complicated in the sense that sportsnet holds the exclusive rights to stream nhl games but
00:21:36 they have a partnership that basically says the cbc can stream nhl playoff games whenever they want
00:21:42 and and then the big the big debate about around the cbc not streaming in this instance was the
00:21:47 oilers games and even worse yet when the oilers were playing the vancouver canucks they didn't
00:21:52 stream some games that's two canadian teams right so and and people were were listing the shows they
00:21:57 were streaming instead which was like random reruns and i mean they're like oh we committed
00:22:01 to these shows but really that's more important than an nhl playoff game and all the while the
00:22:08 nhl playoff games were setting viewership records bringing in tens of millions of viewers and i can
00:22:13 only imagine a handful of people watching what the cbc was streaming at the time
00:22:19 yeah i was just gonna laughingly say maybe they worried that too many people would start to watch the cbc
00:22:25 because apparently having viewers isn't a priority for the canadian broadcasting corporation at least
00:22:31 according to their own bonus metrics uh just you know there was one other interesting statistic true
00:22:36 north got from the poll it did on canada's media landscape and that was a cheap criticism people
00:22:43 level against the cbc is that they are simply biased that they do not fairly portray canada's
00:22:48 conservatives uh they paint them as as far right and as extremist and to be clear the cbc went so
00:22:55 far as to sue the conservative party actually in the last election and i think for a lot of people
00:23:03 that was the straw that broke the camel's back well the idea that getting taxpayer funding
00:23:08 biases reporting is not restricted just to cbc that same poll that we did and i think we just flashed
00:23:16 some of those uh metrics on but i'll bring the poll back up there 55 percent of taxpayers believe
00:23:23 that if you take government or taxpayer subsidies then you become unable to impartially report the news
00:23:32 and i think that shouldn't come as a huge surprise for people but it is really the endemic reason why
00:23:39 people don't trust the cbc is because they know that only one of those two parties really wants to give
00:23:45 them unlimited funding but for all of canada's media who do take taxpayer subsidies it harms their
00:23:52 credibility and we now know that 55 of canadians believe that they cannot take taxpayer subsidies
00:23:58 and report the news fairly true north of course we do not take government funding we rely on support
00:24:04 of individual canadians and that's why when we report we keep them in mind not the government
00:24:10 handing out the checks to the other media in this country i appreciate you saying that william because
00:24:15 i think even in the context of independent media you know that's something that is really special
00:24:21 about true north is that we don't take you know any advertising dollars or donors or sponsorships or
00:24:27 anything like that from uh from the federal government and it's just becoming increasingly we're
00:24:32 becoming increasingly unique and alone in that and it's something that i think is important and that we
00:24:36 should be proud of and that we should continue to remind people of because it is really such a rare
00:24:40 thing also very difficult to do in today's day and age you know one thing i i want to just touch
00:24:45 on quickly before we get back to the nhl because i know isaac has a good story about that is one thing
00:24:49 we might all miss with the decline of the mainstream media and you know if if pierre polyev does indeed
00:24:55 turn off the taps for them is sort of this really combative approach that he's taken to to media and
00:25:00 just the way that he has really learned to undress their comments and we were talking about canadians are
00:25:06 recognizing that the cbc is biased and that's one of the reasons they want to defund them
00:25:09 is pierre polyev is really an expert in knowing how to to uh to really reveal the the what the
00:25:16 media's questions are and to and to get the heart of the fact that they are biased they often don't
00:25:20 know what they're talking about at these press conferences they often have very loaded questions
00:25:24 with a lot of inflammatory rhetoric that they can't back up i'm thinking of course about the infamous
00:25:28 munching on the apple scene when the reporter says canadians think and then he actually didn't know
00:25:32 a single canadian who thinks that it's they use that type of language to push their own
00:25:36 left-wing agenda and often are not aware of what canadian thinks because they're so out of touch
00:25:41 with canadians so that's something i i personally will miss although i suspect it'll still be several
00:25:45 years before uh you know before we see a big correction a big correction in in media generally speaking
00:25:53 isaac uh why don't you go ahead and talk about you know the nhl we've saw a little bit of a feud
00:25:58 brewing between um between trudeau and probably uh my favorite uh american governor so so go ahead
00:26:04 and break that down for us yeah so you were speaking about being out of touch with canadians
00:26:09 but now we're gonna shift to uh desantis who of course is becoming more and more in touch with
00:26:15 canadians as he embraces uh the hockey culture uh and this clip that we're about to show was in response
00:26:22 to a question at the uh eric erickson conference which is a an american conference of conservative
00:26:27 politicians scholars and the like and the the person asked they they sent an email to eric
00:26:34 erickson and they said can you please ask my favorite american governor that being ron desantis
00:26:40 about my least favorite canadian that being prime minister justin trudeau so uh we could play the clip
00:26:45 right now if you'd like so all i can say is this um justin trudeau since he has been prime minister
00:26:53 of canada number of stanley cups for canada zero governor ron desantis number of stanley cups for
00:27:02 the state of florida since i've been governor three who's winning that battle
00:27:06 yeah so obviously uh canada hasn't won the stanley cup in like 20 20 years and uh desantis is lucky
00:27:17 enough to have two nhl teams in his state that being the tampa bay lightning and the florida panthers
00:27:23 of course and they've won three stanley cups in the last uh four or five years as he's been governor so
00:27:29 so yeah what do you guys think about governor i mean uh ron desantis kind of making a funny funny jab
00:27:36 trudeau you know it's not that serious serious i think i mean far be it from me to defend trudeau
00:27:42 for anything but in this case i initially when i heard this clip my initial reaction was i had
00:27:47 you know i said as i said i don't really watch hockey but i spoke into many hockey players and
00:27:51 they said oh it's very hard for canada to attract the best players because american players typically
00:27:57 get paid more we actually looked into this and i guess there's a cap how much you can get paid in
00:28:01 the nhl and i thought well taxes in canada are so much higher but it's not necessarily the case it
00:28:05 looks like among nhl players taxes are actually lowest in alberta go alberta and um highest
00:28:11 jurisdictions like quebec followed by you know new york and la so that wasn't really a fair comparison
00:28:16 however i do think that the quality of life in the states is probably just a little bit better
00:28:22 because your money gets you so much more in the states and also if you live in a southern state
00:28:27 warmer climate if that's something that's important to you might not be important to hockey players
00:28:31 and then also with the canadian market like canadians are just so interested and crazy about
00:28:37 hockey and so if you're a hockey player who really just loves hockey but doesn't enjoy the limelight
00:28:42 you might be more interested in playing for an american team where fans are not quite invested in your
00:28:48 personal life they're not quite as invested in your family you know we were just talking about that that
00:28:54 clip with uh conor mcdavid when he showed his his house in edmonton and he was criticized for not
00:28:59 not having like enough personality like just stuff like that you know some some players might just be
00:29:03 really interested in playing in the game playing the game but not interested in all the drama that
00:29:06 comes along with them but as i said you know i don't want to be lambasted for my comments about
00:29:10 hockey because my my knowledge is is rather limited and i wouldn't consider myself a hockey foreign by
00:29:16 any stretch of the imagination uh william what about you what's your take i mean i think it rankles
00:29:22 us up in canada a lot more when it's places that don't have ice that are succeeding in hockey that
00:29:30 really bothers us intellectually and emotionally to know that a place where there is no ice except
00:29:35 which is artificially created is winning scantily cups as opposed to the land of ice we have ice
00:29:41 everywhere for a large chunk of the year and so that i know is always a bit frustrating and as for
00:29:48 uh i i definitely think you're right that that being a uh nhl player is a bigger deal in canada
00:29:53 we treat those nhl players differently than uh they do in the states i suppose they have kardashians
00:30:00 and we have hockey players that's that's our difference and britain are royals yeah yes they do
00:30:08 um isaac i guess another criticism i've heard is you know and you might know a little bit more about
00:30:13 this is that the cra tends to go after hockey players there was sort of a case with the cra going
00:30:18 after a former toronto maple leafs captain uh john taveras and and i guess whether or not you know
00:30:24 signing bonuses are something that they should be paying taxes on so i guess you know even from a
00:30:28 financial standpoint tax is quite low in alberta but i just can't help but feel like generally in
00:30:32 the states unless you're living somewhere like really radical last like new york and la you'll probably
00:30:37 take home a little more of your money in the states that's just my two cents yeah i always thought
00:30:43 bonuses not just signing bonuses but all types of bonuses uh were tax or tax free or less taxed at
00:30:50 least which is why they were even an added incentive for players on top of just the money itself i i
00:30:55 remember seeing yeah john taveras going to war with the uh cra but i don't know how that's gone but
00:31:01 thinking of places without ice yeah i oh i remember a few years ago when uh austin matthews uh
00:31:06 the leafs captain obviously who is from arizona was the number one overall draft and i thought to
00:31:11 myself you know how does that happen eric he's coming from arizona which i can't imagine has a
00:31:18 strong child hockey market which is why we see so many kids from ontario drafted into the nhl because
00:31:25 they have such a strong hockey community these people these children are able to access the best
00:31:30 coaches in the world i mean right like austin matthews i mean he's a an anomaly in that sense that
00:31:35 he i really think he had to be more independent than say a child would have had to been in ontario
00:31:42 i don't know i think maybe we should get like a new hockey show or like a sports show going over
00:31:45 at north isa could take the lead on they obviously know a lot about this and i think there's always
00:31:49 like interesting ties for how it plays into politics but that's just an idea maybe our audience can let
00:31:55 me know if there would be english and something like that um all right everyone that's all we have time
00:31:59 to cover today on off the record thank you so much for tolerating us for the last 35 minutes
00:32:05 or so i hope that you guys have a great weekend we'll see you later and don't forget that everything
00:32:10 you heard today was off the record
00:32:20 well i had to laugh at that one story where the liberals were uh accusing pierre palievra of not
00:32:27 doing anything about foreign election interference they said pierre had two years and then he didn't
00:32:32 do anything election election interference as opposed to the liberal government we had eight years where we
00:32:37 did nothing about election interference which is a lot longer and then of course when they they
00:32:41 didn't want to do anything about election interference they had to be pulled kicking and screaming towards
00:32:47 actually taking the issue seriously so uh you know there's a bold claim for the for the trudeau government
00:32:52 to make but only is it a bold claim but it's like pierre paliev was never the prime minister
00:32:58 well sure he was a conservative mp but like ridiculous yeah just details
00:33:07 well sure 0.74
00:33:19 then