Off the Record - May 17, 2024


Taxpayers on hook for “climate disinformation” rap

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Cities clash with province over Alberta’s election reform bills Liberals resort to abortion scare tactics

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

200.35

Word count

8,760

Sentence count

334

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

23

sentences flagged

Hate speech

38

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Andrew Lawton, Isaac Lamoureux, and Rachel Emanuel are back with another edition of Off The Record! This week, the crew talks about the devastating wildfires in Alberta, the CO-Vaccine controversy, and the carbon tax.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I used to be unable to smile in photos because it would just look so like weird.
00:00:06 I'd be like Chandler.
00:00:06 Well, that's a dated.
00:00:07 You're too young for friends, both of you, but it's like, it would be like Chandler and
00:00:10 friends.
00:00:10 I'd be like, I've seen the whole series, so I don't know.
00:00:13 Oh, okay.
00:00:14 There you go.
00:00:15 Yeah.
00:00:16 You watch, watch friends, Rachel.
00:00:18 I have seen it.
00:00:19 Yes.
00:00:20 And speaking of even older sitcoms, I'm like almost done Seinfeld.
00:00:23 So yeah.
00:00:24 Rachel's not engaging in the pre-show banter.
00:00:27 She looks very aloof right now.
00:00:28 Oh, I'm sorry.
00:00:28 I've had a very, very stressful couple of days.
00:00:32 All right.
00:00:33 Well, I guess let's get things started then.
00:00:43 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:46 Happy Friday.
00:00:47 We are heading into the long weekend, so it's not just a regular old Friday.
00:00:50 It is a Friday that hopefully precedes a few days of deserved and in this climate needed
00:00:56 R&R.
00:00:57 It is my pleasure to be with you again once on off the, wait, no, my pleasure to be with
00:01:01 you once again.
00:01:02 I was like speaking like Yoda there.
00:01:05 Pleasure, pleasure with you are it is, but it is off the record.
00:01:09 I am Andrew Lawton and joining me are Isaac Lamoureux and Rachel Emanuel.
00:01:15 Good to have you both on.
00:01:17 You were on last week, but I wasn't.
00:01:18 So this is the first time for this particular trio.
00:01:21 Welcome.
00:01:21 Not only are we both, I'm sure, happy to be back, but I think we're also pretty relieved
00:01:26 that you're back to hosting again, Andrew.
00:01:28 I was away last week.
00:01:29 I didn't watch it.
00:01:30 Was it like a train wreck?
00:01:31 You don't need to go back and watch it.
00:01:33 I don't think you're missing anything.
00:01:35 I'm surprised that I was invited back.
00:01:36 You've successfully promoted it better than, probably better than our social media desk
00:01:41 did, but I am here.
00:01:43 You guys are both our token Albertans.
00:01:45 How have things been in my, one of my favorite, well, I don't want to pick favorites now because
00:01:49 then the Ontarians are going to say a game of me, but a province that I love.
00:01:53 How are things over there?
00:01:54 Things here are hectic as always.
00:01:56 If I could be so bold as to tease my show on Saturday, there's been some interesting
00:02:02 developments with the COVID-19 vaccine, the United Conservative Party board has actually
00:02:06 decided to take a stand against the COVID-19 vaccine and they're urging the premier to
00:02:10 amend the policy so that it's not being recommended for kids anymore, which I think is a, is a
00:02:14 pretty big stance that they're taking and it's a pretty interesting development.
00:02:16 So I'll be covering that on Saturday.
00:02:18 If any of you viewers want to head over to my show Saturday afternoon to take a look at
00:02:21 that.
00:02:22 All right.
00:02:23 An unscheduled PSA for the, for the Alberta roundup.
00:02:27 Isaac, how are things in your corner of the world province?
00:02:29 Yeah.
00:02:30 I don't know how it's going in Calgary there, Rachel, but it's been a lot of
00:02:32 pouring rain all day here in Edmonton, which is good, especially with the fires going on
00:02:38 in Fort McMurray, though it's obviously further from Edmonton, but yeah, the rain is a welcome
00:02:43 sign for the Alberta wildfires that have been plaguing the province.
00:02:48 And despite all of them, except one being man-made, I'm glad you mentioned the fires.
00:02:55 I should have pulled the clip, but Justin Trudeau earlier was saying like Canada is burning
00:02:59 and Pierre Paulyev is happy with Canada burning because he supports the carbon tax being repealed.
00:03:04 And I'm like, wow, you're, um, you're just like taking it right up to like drama teacher
00:03:08 grade, uh, grade 11 there.
00:03:09 Uh, in any event, the climate change debate in Canada brings us all sorts of fun things.
00:03:14 Uh, the most cringeworthy of them all.
00:03:18 No, it's not the carbon tax.
00:03:20 It's not the plastic straw ban.
00:03:21 Uh, it's not even the fact that the government spent $3 million sending a delegation to Dubai
00:03:26 for the COP28 climate summit.
00:03:29 It was specifically what happened at the Canada pavilion at the climate summit for the UN COP28
00:03:37 in Dubai.
00:03:38 This was $1.3 million that was spent on hosting a Canada pavilion to showcase Canada.
00:03:44 And you think, okay, what are we going to do to show Canada off to the world?
00:03:47 Are we going to serve them poutine?
00:03:49 Are we going to put up a hockey game?
00:03:51 Are we going to show a reel of all the great comedians from Canada, show them some John Candy
00:03:56 and some Dan Aykroyd, or are we going to showcase the best of Canadian music?
00:04:02 They chose that option.
00:04:07 All right, I don't even know what it says.
00:04:15 Climate disinformation, get that immunization.
00:04:19 The vaccine for bad meme infiltration.
00:04:22 Climate misinformation, it leads to polarization, which leads to radical conspiracy ideation.
00:04:28 Simultaneous translation between conspiracy theories and violent means of change embracement.
00:04:34 Economic incentives or ideological basis.
00:04:38 It doesn't matter, because either way, it's still disinformation.
00:04:42 Climate change is upon us, and emissions are like a bomb.
00:04:45 As the wave of increasing heat carries on and on, the wave of disinformation keeps on getting
00:04:50 shared online.
00:04:52 Trapped by the lab of Marie-Yves Carignan from Université Sherbrooke.
00:04:56 According to her book, the anti-government left and right now share a yearbook.
00:05:01 And when it comes to floods, droughts, and wildfires, even today's environmentalists can
00:05:06 be climate deniers.
00:05:07 Those are the yoga QAnon people up in the mix. 0.95
00:05:11 Marie-Yves tracks the patterns with the acronym FLICK.
00:05:14 False X-words, fallacious logic, unrealistic expectations.
00:05:18 Cherry-picking and conspiracy theory ideation.
00:05:21 That's FLICK.
00:05:21 Advertisers can help us find a fix.
00:05:24 The climate host is exposed.
00:05:26 Brought to you by Wix.
00:05:27 From the false promotion of bad pollutions and tricks.
00:05:30 To the outright denialism saying it doesn't exist.
00:05:33 There's a reason for the IPCC.
00:05:36 It doesn't make assumptions.
00:05:37 Make your advertising conscious.
00:05:39 Take it from Jake Dubbins.
00:05:41 Yes, we need free speech to get the facts in the fight.
00:05:43 But like Jake said, ad revenue is not a human right.
00:05:46 You know the exchange rate is bad.
00:05:51 That was 50 Canadian cent right there.
00:05:54 50 Canadian cent is worth a lot less than regular old 50 cent. 0.50
00:05:59 Boy, that was...
00:06:01 I mean, I don't want to say it cost us $1.3 million,
00:06:04 but it certainly cost a fair bit.
00:06:07 We flew Baba Brinkman, the Canadian rapper,
00:06:12 and coincidentally son of a Liberal member of Parliament.
00:06:15 So this is if you're a Liberal MP
00:06:17 and you need to get your son employed,
00:06:18 you can say just like make a rap so bad
00:06:21 that Eminem will just like, you know,
00:06:25 want to just cross the border and replace him perhaps.
00:06:28 That, yeah, I don't know which of you is the rap aficionado.
00:06:32 I'm, no one has ever looked at me and said that I'm, you know, hip.
00:06:37 But just what the hell was that?
00:06:41 I think Isaac's probably the one to go to here.
00:06:44 You know, I'm a little too old for rap music, Isaac.
00:06:47 Take it away.
00:06:48 Yeah, honestly, just at the start of his set, let's call it,
00:06:53 he said, I don't even know the words,
00:06:54 but then he seemed pretty well versed
00:06:56 in the kind of the flow of the song.
00:06:58 So I was like, does this guy really not know the words?
00:07:00 Because I feel like if I were just reading the screen
00:07:02 and listening to the beat for the first time
00:07:04 and tried to rap that song,
00:07:06 I probably wouldn't have done nearly as good of a job as him,
00:07:09 like from the actual flow perspective.
00:07:13 But yeah, I mean, Canada does have some pretty big name rappers,
00:07:18 notably Drake, The Weeknd, I guess he's kind of a rapper.
00:07:21 Yeah, that was the weekday we just saw.
00:07:23 That was the weekday.
00:07:26 And yeah, he didn't get to the Stephen Guibault part,
00:07:29 but he gives Stephen Guibault a special shout out.
00:07:31 So that's nice.
00:07:32 Yeah, it was funny.
00:07:33 I think I saw yesterday on X,
00:07:34 Guibault was tweeting about the Fort Mac fires
00:07:36 and of course climate change.
00:07:38 And I'm like, I'm pretty sure all those fires were man-made,
00:07:41 but I don't see why we're attributing that to climate change.
00:07:44 That kind of applies to what he was rapping about just now
00:07:47 in the song, climate misinformation.
00:07:49 Is that not the same thing?
00:07:51 Stephen Guibault is funnier than Johnny Carson.
00:07:54 He doesn't tell us that the fires were actually arson.
00:07:56 I don't know.
00:07:57 I'm keeping my day job.
00:07:59 Rachel, what's your arts correspondent take on this?
00:08:02 You know, I don't really even want to make fun of him
00:08:05 because you can really tell he gave that his all.
00:08:07 Like he really-
00:08:08 It wasn't as bad as I expected it to be.
00:08:10 For a white guy, it wasn't half bad.
00:08:12 And you could tell he was 100% into it.
00:08:14 He obviously spent a lot of time memorizing those words.
00:08:19 He found a rhyme for University of Sherbrooke.
00:08:21 Like that's never been done in the history of music.
00:08:23 He really gave it his all.
00:08:24 And while I don't really want to make fun of him
00:08:26 because it just feels a bit mean
00:08:27 because of just how hard he tried,
00:08:29 I'm going to because ultimately it was my tax dollars
00:08:31 that paid for it.
00:08:32 And it was a waste of money 1.00
00:08:33 and it was still fairly stupid. 0.99
00:08:35 But, you know, we were just talking about Justin Trudeau 0.99
00:08:38 and how he was, you know, he's always so theatrical
00:08:40 with the things he says about Pierre Polyev.
00:08:42 And I think when we're looking at the Liberal Party
00:08:44 as a whole, they're just really,
00:08:45 they seem stuck in high school.
00:08:47 This is something that I would have done in high school.
00:08:49 Like I remember we, like my friends and I
00:08:51 would come up with raps
00:08:52 and we would do them in class.
00:08:53 And, you know, we thought we were really cool and clever
00:08:55 and the rest of the class enjoyed it.
00:08:56 But we're well beyond that now.
00:08:58 The Liberals really seem, you know,
00:09:00 stuck in their youth, unable to grow up.
00:09:02 So that's pretty much what we're seeing here.
00:09:04 I looked him up on Wikipedia
00:09:07 because I'm like, if we're going to do this,
00:09:08 let's go all in.
00:09:09 And apparently he's made like a name for himself
00:09:12 doing science rap and environment and ecology rap,
00:09:17 which to be honest,
00:09:18 he's like the greatest capitalist known to mankind
00:09:21 because he knows that all of these like UN climate summits
00:09:24 around the world want to be hip and cool.
00:09:26 And they're like, well, we have a guy
00:09:27 who will rap about the climate.
00:09:29 He'll rap about the IPCC.
00:09:30 Why wouldn't we want to do that?
00:09:32 That's great. 0.97
00:09:32 Like, so he's done something so ridiculous 0.94
00:09:35 that he's guaranteed he's the only person 0.97
00:09:37 in the world that can do it,
00:09:39 which to which I say,
00:09:40 very, very much rewarding him
00:09:43 for the entrepreneurialism.
00:09:45 Yeah.
00:09:45 Sometimes I regret that I'm someone
00:09:46 who has such strong morals
00:09:48 and would just despise taking government money
00:09:50 for frivolous reasons.
00:09:50 Because think about how wealthy
00:09:51 we could all be otherwise.
00:09:53 Doesn't take much.
00:09:55 Yeah.
00:09:55 So that video,
00:09:57 so I only learned about this,
00:09:58 just to give the context,
00:09:59 that happened in December,
00:10:00 November, December.
00:10:01 And I only learned about it
00:10:03 because there was an order paper question
00:10:06 that I think Dan Mazur,
00:10:07 the liberal or the conservative MP
00:10:08 had filed to get the costs
00:10:10 for the Dubai delegation,
00:10:13 for the Canadian delegation to Dubai.
00:10:15 And the Canadian Taxpayers Federation
00:10:17 poured through this as well.
00:10:17 And they found that we had
00:10:19 at the Canada Pavilion this rap.
00:10:20 And the guy uploaded it himself.
00:10:22 Like he was very proud of this.
00:10:24 And then I looked into it.
00:10:25 He's founded a company called Event Rap,
00:10:28 a custom rap agency
00:10:30 featuring a roster of independent hip-hop artists
00:10:32 who write and perform original works
00:10:34 for live events.
00:10:36 So we should get like at True North Nation,
00:10:38 we should get some like independent media rap.
00:10:40 I don't know what rhymes with defund the CBC.
00:10:45 Give me, Isaac, say something
00:10:46 and I'll try and think of this.
00:10:49 You want me to find a rhyme for defund the CBC?
00:10:52 Well, you can.
00:10:52 And I was just saying more talk
00:10:53 while I try to come up with one.
00:10:54 She's hot like double D's. 1.00
00:10:57 Oh my God.
00:10:58 What?
00:11:00 That's not the road I would have gone.
00:11:02 Yeah, that's, yeah.
00:11:03 Rachel's getting our clean tag 1.00
00:11:04 taken away more and more.
00:11:05 I can say it.
00:11:06 I can say it.
00:11:07 Defund the CBC.
00:11:08 It's paid for by you and me.
00:11:11 Oh, that's good.
00:11:12 I mean, I'm hearing a bit of like Jackson 5 though.
00:11:14 Like ABC, defund the CBC.
00:11:18 Yeah, what rhymes with Rosie Barton? 0.94
00:11:19 They don't deserve no money free.
00:11:22 Okay, wait.
00:11:25 Okay, we got to find rhymes for Mansbridge,
00:11:27 rhymes for Rosie Barton.
00:11:31 You know, when we defund the CBC,
00:11:33 we'll be carton away their property,
00:11:36 including Rosie. 0.98
00:11:37 But no, that sounded weird.
00:11:38 This is why we need to leave it to the pros
00:11:40 like Mr. Baba Brinkman.
00:11:43 Okay.
00:11:44 $1.3 million for the Canada Pavilion.
00:11:46 Do you feel that Canada has been sufficiently sold
00:11:48 on the world stage now?
00:11:49 Sorry, I'm looking up words on rhyme dictionary.
00:11:56 Isaac, take it away.
00:11:57 I like the, by the way,
00:11:58 I love that we're doing the preparation for the show
00:12:01 midway through the show.
00:12:03 None of us knew we were going to go down this road
00:12:05 enough to think ahead of time
00:12:06 of like maybe plan something out.
00:12:07 Next week we'll have to come prepared
00:12:08 with like a full wrap,
00:12:10 a full True North wrap.
00:12:12 Yeah, I started preparing about three minutes
00:12:13 before the show
00:12:14 because I had to try on a bunch of different shows.
00:12:17 All right.
00:12:17 So if you're in the comments
00:12:19 and you want to come up with your
00:12:20 defund the CBC rhymes,
00:12:22 I think actually Isaac,
00:12:23 I think was the best at this so far
00:12:25 because he actually came up with something.
00:12:27 I'm still like trying to like find a rhyme
00:12:28 for Peter Mansbridge.
00:12:30 You know, there's not a lot of results on here
00:12:32 for Barton.
00:12:35 Well, Barton, like carton, like milk.
00:12:37 Oh, I got it.
00:12:38 I got it.
00:12:38 Let's get rid of Rosemary Barton. 1.00
00:12:40 Around the truth,
00:12:41 she's always darting.
00:12:43 Oh, okay.
00:12:45 I mean, I like Rosie Barton. 0.78
00:12:46 I don't think we need to like, 0.97
00:12:46 you know, crap on her, 0.98
00:12:47 but I admire the rhyme at least. 0.99
00:12:49 So well done, Rachel.
00:12:51 You're holding your own.
00:12:52 You're going to be repping
00:12:53 the West Side wrap thing before long.
00:12:57 I should, we should just,
00:12:58 everyone has laughed.
00:12:59 No one is watching the show anymore
00:13:01 except for someone who like
00:13:03 walked away to the kitchen
00:13:04 and left their YouTube
00:13:05 or Spotify running.
00:13:07 But anyway,
00:13:08 I believe we can move on.
00:13:11 And mercifully to the next topic here.
00:13:13 Other things that we are spending
00:13:15 millions and millions of dollars on.
00:13:17 Rachel, why don't you take us away on this?
00:13:19 So taxpayers are on the hook
00:13:22 for $224 per day
00:13:24 to claimants for illegal immigrants
00:13:26 for their housing, food,
00:13:28 and essential items.
00:13:29 This was revealed
00:13:30 from Conservative MP Leanne Root
00:13:32 who asked the government
00:13:33 last week what goods and services
00:13:35 are being provided
00:13:36 to asylum seekers in Canada,
00:13:37 which means those
00:13:38 without approved applications.
00:13:39 And she published
00:13:40 the order paper response question,
00:13:42 which found that the federal government
00:13:44 has approved $140 per night
00:13:46 per room
00:13:48 and roughly $84 per day for food
00:13:50 totaling $224 per claimant.
00:13:53 And I'm looking for the full amount here.
00:13:57 So that's an all-time high of,
00:13:59 there's over 42,000
00:14:01 pending refugee claims
00:14:02 in Canada right now.
00:14:05 So if you're wondering,
00:14:06 you know, you can't make ends meet,
00:14:07 I hear from a lot of people
00:14:08 who are about $100 short a month
00:14:09 for making groceries.
00:14:10 Where's all our money going?
00:14:11 This is where it's going.
00:14:12 It's going to illegals 1.00
00:14:13 who have no right to be in Canada, 0.58
00:14:15 putting them up at hotels,
00:14:16 and we're paying for their food.
00:14:18 Andrew, what do you make of this?
00:14:20 Yeah, it's, I mean,
00:14:21 you touch on the dollar value issue,
00:14:23 but the one thing,
00:14:23 and I pointed this out
00:14:24 on my show earlier this week,
00:14:25 that's important to keep in mind as well
00:14:27 is that it's a symptom of another problem
00:14:30 because the cost per day on asylum seekers
00:14:33 is a consequence of the number
00:14:36 of asylum seekers we have.
00:14:38 So many that they have to be put up
00:14:39 in hotels and fed.
00:14:40 And the reason we have so many
00:14:41 is because the government's
00:14:42 not actually securing the border.
00:14:44 So we are forced into this
00:14:46 because they're not dealing
00:14:48 with the other problem,
00:14:49 which is people who are in the United States,
00:14:51 which is a safe, free democratic nation,
00:14:53 whatever you may think
00:14:54 of Joe Biden's politics,
00:14:55 that say, okay,
00:14:57 I think I'll have a better go in Canada.
00:14:58 So they enter Canada illegally, 0.94
00:15:00 claim asylum.
00:15:02 Most of these claims
00:15:03 are going to get denied
00:15:03 and the people are going to be sent home.
00:15:05 But while they are waiting
00:15:07 for that decision,
00:15:08 which could be months,
00:15:08 it could be well over a year,
00:15:10 we're paying for them
00:15:11 and loading up these hotels.
00:15:13 And this has been an issue
00:15:14 that's been ongoing for,
00:15:16 I mean, it's been ongoing for years,
00:15:17 but for a decade,
00:15:18 it's been at, I'd say,
00:15:20 unsustainable levels.
00:15:21 And I know you in Alberta
00:15:23 are not dealing with this
00:15:24 as much as in Ontario,
00:15:25 but you look at places
00:15:26 like Niagara Falls
00:15:27 and I know like you have family
00:15:29 in that area, Rachel,
00:15:30 like it's absolutely crazy.
00:15:32 And you have hotels
00:15:33 that have just been commandeered
00:15:34 by this asylum program.
00:15:36 What do you make of this, Isaac?
00:15:38 Yeah, that does seem crazy to me,
00:15:40 specifically the fact that,
00:15:41 let's say the majority
00:15:43 of these asylum seekers 1.00
00:15:45 will be essentially deported.
00:15:47 So what reasoning would Canada
00:15:51 have to essentially pay
00:15:52 for their cost of living
00:15:54 in the interim?
00:15:55 But at the same time,
00:15:56 I'm trying to find,
00:15:59 I guess, the alternative,
00:16:01 which would be maybe
00:16:02 they wouldn't get paid for
00:16:03 and then they're homeless.
00:16:04 I remember I was writing
00:16:05 an article earlier
00:16:06 about homelessness
00:16:08 and hospital stays.
00:16:10 But as background,
00:16:11 I saw True North's exclusive
00:16:12 that said that nearly half
00:16:14 of Ottawa's homeless shelters
00:16:17 were filled with new refugees
00:16:19 and asylum claimants.
00:16:21 So that would obviously
00:16:23 be exacerbated
00:16:24 if the funding were pulled.
00:16:25 So I don't know.
00:16:26 What do you think
00:16:27 the best alternative would be
00:16:29 as opposed to paying
00:16:30 for these asylum claimants
00:16:33 to stay in hotels?
00:16:34 Well, I think it kind of goes back
00:16:35 to what Andrew was saying
00:16:36 about how the issue is
00:16:37 that these are large people
00:16:38 who are coming in
00:16:39 across the U.S. border.
00:16:41 So, I mean,
00:16:41 if this is foot traffic
00:16:42 that we're looking at,
00:16:42 I think the best thing
00:16:43 would be to reinforce
00:16:44 those borders
00:16:44 so they're not coming
00:16:45 across the border at all
00:16:46 because even if they are
00:16:47 being deported,
00:16:48 we're also paying
00:16:48 for those flights
00:16:49 to get them back
00:16:50 to their home countries.
00:16:51 So I think we could look
00:16:52 at saving a lot of money
00:16:53 if we're just stopping
00:16:54 these people right
00:16:54 at the U.S. border
00:16:55 and we're not letting
00:16:56 them into Canada.
00:16:57 You know, the U.S.
00:16:57 obviously has its own
00:16:58 border crisis
00:16:59 and I think there's
00:17:00 a certain extent
00:17:01 at which we're going
00:17:01 to be feeling the effects
00:17:02 of that because they just
00:17:03 have millions
00:17:04 of illegal migrants 0.98
00:17:04 pouring through
00:17:05 their southern border
00:17:06 and so people are being
00:17:07 pushed upwards
00:17:08 throughout the country.
00:17:08 So this is actually
00:17:09 going to become probably
00:17:10 a bigger and bigger problem
00:17:11 if we don't take some action
00:17:12 and seal that border
00:17:13 sooner rather than later.
00:17:16 Yeah, and I think that,
00:17:17 again, when we're stuck
00:17:19 with it once they're here,
00:17:20 so you have to go back
00:17:21 to basics and actually
00:17:22 secure the border
00:17:23 in the first place.
00:17:23 Like the whole point
00:17:24 of what caused a lot of this
00:17:26 was this thing called
00:17:27 the safe third country.
00:17:28 I know I always say
00:17:28 we have to keep off
00:17:29 the record fun
00:17:29 but then I have to
00:17:30 explain things sometimes.
00:17:31 It's the safe
00:17:32 third country agreement
00:17:33 which basically said
00:17:33 it was a deal
00:17:34 between Canada and the U.S.
00:17:35 that if you land
00:17:36 in one country,
00:17:37 it's considered a safe country
00:17:38 so you can't then
00:17:39 go to another one.
00:17:41 The loophole in that
00:17:42 was if you cross
00:17:43 the border illegally.
00:17:45 So that was what
00:17:46 was causing this.
00:17:47 You couldn't actually
00:17:47 drive from Windsor
00:17:49 to Detroit
00:17:49 or Detroit to Windsor
00:17:51 at the sanctioned
00:17:52 border crossing
00:17:53 and do this
00:17:53 but if you do it illegally,
00:17:55 you were able to
00:17:56 and then Canada
00:17:56 has to do it.
00:17:57 Because you're right, Isaac,
00:17:58 once you talk about
00:17:59 the options that people have
00:18:01 that Canada has,
00:18:02 you either put them in jail
00:18:03 which is a legitimate option
00:18:06 available to government
00:18:07 but it's more expensive.
00:18:08 Housing inmates in jail
00:18:09 is costlier
00:18:10 and let's face it,
00:18:11 it's also,
00:18:12 you raise moral questions
00:18:13 depending on the asylum seeker
00:18:15 and so you're left with that
00:18:17 or leaving them homeless
00:18:18 or this kind of quasi measure
00:18:20 of putting them up in a hotel.
00:18:22 But then the other issue
00:18:23 we get to
00:18:23 is if their claims are denied,
00:18:26 are we actually tracking them down
00:18:28 and deporting them?
00:18:29 And Canada has an abysmal,
00:18:30 abysmal record
00:18:31 at deportation.
00:18:32 So like all of these
00:18:33 are flowing
00:18:34 from that initial border issue.
00:18:36 Yeah, I still maintain that.
00:18:41 When no one says anything,
00:18:42 I assume I just made so much sense
00:18:44 that no one possibly
00:18:45 can add or refute anything.
00:18:47 That's where I was at, yeah.
00:18:49 You really did hit the nail on the head.
00:18:50 I just maintain,
00:18:51 I think the best thing
00:18:52 would be to really seal
00:18:52 those borders.
00:18:53 This isn't an issue
00:18:54 I've covered a ton of.
00:18:55 I think we've seen a lot
00:18:56 of good stuff from Lindsay Shepard
00:18:57 on this.
00:18:58 As you've mentioned, Andrew,
00:18:59 like I'm out here in Alberta.
00:19:00 It's true.
00:19:00 This issue is particularly bad.
00:19:02 I know in Quebec,
00:19:03 I know in Niagara Falls,
00:19:04 certainly we've seen
00:19:05 some of the effects
00:19:05 of just the high levels
00:19:06 of migrants living in that area
00:19:08 and how that trickles down
00:19:09 to the whole Niagara region.
00:19:10 And we even see a rise
00:19:11 in things like crime
00:19:12 and car accidents.
00:19:13 There's just a whole lot
00:19:14 of issues going on.
00:19:15 But I mean,
00:19:16 at the end of the day,
00:19:16 this is also affecting
00:19:17 Western Canada as well
00:19:19 because what we're seeing
00:19:20 in places like Toronto
00:19:21 is we're seeing
00:19:22 just a flood of immigrants 0.99
00:19:24 and not all of them illegal.
00:19:25 Many are legal.
00:19:26 Many of them are allowed
00:19:27 into the country,
00:19:27 but it's just so many people
00:19:28 in one region
00:19:29 that we're seeing
00:19:30 a lot of people look,
00:19:30 okay, where else in Canada
00:19:32 can I flee to?
00:19:33 And many people
00:19:33 are coming out to Calgary
00:19:35 and Alberta was once seen
00:19:37 as a place
00:19:37 with the Alberta advantage.
00:19:38 You'd come here,
00:19:39 you'd get to keep
00:19:39 more of your money,
00:19:40 you'd have a lower cost of living,
00:19:42 you'd have a better chance
00:19:43 at owning a home.
00:19:44 And a lot of that
00:19:44 just isn't really the case
00:19:45 anymore for Western Canada.
00:19:46 I know that there's been
00:19:47 some frustration
00:19:48 with Alberta Premier
00:19:49 Daniel Smith
00:19:49 and her Alberta
00:19:50 is calling campaign
00:19:51 as a result
00:19:52 because people would really
00:19:53 like to slow down
00:19:54 and say,
00:19:54 let's stop welcoming people
00:19:55 here for the time being
00:19:56 and really just kind of
00:19:57 let things even out
00:19:58 before we continue to say,
00:20:00 hey, why don't you come
00:20:00 to Alberta?
00:20:01 We're looking to grow
00:20:01 our population,
00:20:02 we're looking to grow
00:20:03 our economy.
00:20:04 So when we see
00:20:05 this many people
00:20:05 flood into a region,
00:20:06 it really does put
00:20:07 so many pressures
00:20:08 on every aspect of life,
00:20:09 housing, schools,
00:20:10 hospitals, everything.
00:20:13 Yeah, this from the
00:20:14 legal migration aspect of it,
00:20:16 I mean, Alberta
00:20:17 has been setting
00:20:18 records on pretty much
00:20:20 a monthly basis
00:20:21 for interprovincial migration,
00:20:23 which I guess
00:20:24 can be expected
00:20:25 as the cost of living crisis
00:20:26 rises with Alberta
00:20:28 being one of the most
00:20:29 not only affordable provinces
00:20:31 but where you can also
00:20:32 make the most amount
00:20:32 of money, right?
00:20:33 When you balance
00:20:34 those two things,
00:20:35 it's definitely a good place
00:20:36 to be economically,
00:20:38 which I think is why
00:20:38 so many people
00:20:39 from eastern provinces
00:20:40 are looking to migrate here.
00:20:42 Yeah, very well said.
00:20:44 On that note,
00:20:45 Isaac, since you're already
00:20:46 talking, why don't you
00:20:47 kick off our next story here?
00:20:49 Yeah, so this next one's
00:20:50 pretty fun.
00:20:51 Well, fun.
00:20:52 Yeah, Andrew was saying
00:20:53 to come up with a fun story
00:20:55 and I thought, well, anger's...
00:20:56 I said light, light story,
00:20:58 but anyway.
00:20:59 I was thinking anger
00:21:00 might be an antonym of fun.
00:21:01 Well, not exactly,
00:21:02 but anyways.
00:21:04 Yeah, so basically,
00:21:06 anger in Canada
00:21:06 towards government,
00:21:08 economy, and policies
00:21:09 has reached a record high.
00:21:11 This from the Polera's 1.00
00:21:13 Rage Index,
00:21:15 which they have been tracking
00:21:16 for about two years.
00:21:19 And interestingly,
00:21:19 this monthly edition
00:21:21 of the index
00:21:22 had a specific focus
00:21:23 focus on the budget
00:21:24 with some data
00:21:26 that was quite surprising
00:21:28 to me.
00:21:28 For example,
00:21:29 I had seen previous polls
00:21:30 which showed that
00:21:31 21% of Canadians,
00:21:33 I know a low number,
00:21:34 supported the federal budget,
00:21:35 but this Rage Index
00:21:36 showed an even lower one
00:21:37 wherein only 9%
00:21:39 of Canadians
00:21:39 had a positive outlook
00:21:40 on the budget.
00:21:41 This was separated by
00:21:42 pleased or moderately happy
00:21:44 and very happy
00:21:45 with the latter,
00:21:46 only 1% of Canadians
00:21:47 belonging to.
00:21:49 And it also broke down
00:21:50 political parties,
00:21:52 which was cool.
00:21:52 As you might expect,
00:21:54 conservative supporters
00:21:56 were the angriest
00:21:57 and liberals
00:21:58 the least angry.
00:22:00 But what might be
00:22:02 more interesting
00:22:02 is that the Bloc Québécois
00:22:04 and the NDP
00:22:04 pretty much mirrored
00:22:06 each other
00:22:06 in percentage of anger
00:22:08 on this index.
00:22:09 I think it was 54%
00:22:09 and 53%,
00:22:10 if I remember correctly.
00:22:11 But you might have expected
00:22:12 less,
00:22:15 or sorry,
00:22:16 more anger
00:22:16 from the Bloc Québécois
00:22:17 supporters
00:22:17 and less so
00:22:18 from the NDP.
00:22:19 I guess I'm curious
00:22:22 when Andrew said
00:22:23 lighter story,
00:22:24 what about you were like,
00:22:26 I'm going to talk
00:22:26 about the rage index.
00:22:29 Andrew,
00:22:31 your audio
00:22:32 is not working.
00:22:34 And,
00:22:34 oh,
00:22:35 oh,
00:22:35 yeah,
00:22:36 no,
00:22:36 I thought I was muted.
00:22:37 And no,
00:22:37 I said it's okay,
00:22:39 but rage index
00:22:40 is just a funny name.
00:22:41 I guess that's why.
00:22:42 So I was just being
00:22:43 like childishly immature
00:22:44 about it.
00:22:47 Yeah,
00:22:47 well,
00:22:47 I mean,
00:22:48 I find this study
00:22:49 like a little bit depressing.
00:22:50 I mean,
00:22:50 I think Isaac and I
00:22:51 are both in this category,
00:22:52 although Isaac just got a house
00:22:53 recently,
00:22:53 which is pretty big.
00:22:54 Congratulations.
00:22:55 But being in that category
00:22:56 of younger Canadians
00:22:57 who are really feeling
00:22:58 the impacts
00:22:59 of the Trudeau liberals
00:23:00 and their really poor policies
00:23:02 and the impact of that
00:23:03 on Canadians
00:23:04 and those of us
00:23:05 who are struggling to,
00:23:06 you know,
00:23:06 have a newer vehicle
00:23:07 or own a home.
00:23:08 So I get really worked up
00:23:10 when I read stories like this
00:23:11 because I'm like,
00:23:11 yeah,
00:23:11 like I'm there
00:23:12 and I'm angry
00:23:13 and I'm really pissed off
00:23:14 about what the Trudeau liberals
00:23:15 are doing to our country.
00:23:16 So someone who finds
00:23:17 the story a bit lighter
00:23:18 maybe,
00:23:19 you know,
00:23:19 maybe has to take it away
00:23:20 here,
00:23:20 Andrew.
00:23:21 I don't find it lighter per se.
00:23:24 I guess it's interesting
00:23:25 that it's just so explicit
00:23:26 because a lot of people,
00:23:28 especially Canadians,
00:23:29 really try to mute
00:23:30 their emotions
00:23:31 and they try to say,
00:23:32 well,
00:23:32 you know,
00:23:33 I'm a little frustrated
00:23:33 and how many people,
00:23:34 I've spoken to so many
00:23:35 over the years
00:23:36 who really tried it,
00:23:37 like they feel guilty
00:23:38 about being dissatisfied
00:23:40 where they'll say things like,
00:23:41 well,
00:23:41 oh well,
00:23:42 I know,
00:23:42 I mean,
00:23:42 I don't have it as bad
00:23:43 as other people do
00:23:44 and they really do not want
00:23:46 to just come out
00:23:46 and say it
00:23:47 and the fact that now
00:23:47 you have people
00:23:48 that are explicitly saying,
00:23:50 yeah,
00:23:50 I'm pissed off,
00:23:51 yeah,
00:23:51 I'm angry,
00:23:51 I think that's actually
00:23:52 a sign of just how bad
00:23:53 things have gotten.
00:23:55 Yeah,
00:23:55 I think that's fair,
00:23:55 especially when you consider
00:23:56 what you said about Canadians
00:23:57 typically being not quick
00:23:58 to complain
00:23:59 and being a little bit
00:23:59 more apathetic
00:24:00 when it comes to politics
00:24:02 but yeah,
00:24:03 now that people
00:24:03 are really feeling
00:24:04 that frustration
00:24:04 and willing to voice it
00:24:05 and I think,
00:24:06 you know,
00:24:06 it's not even necessarily
00:24:07 saying like,
00:24:08 oh,
00:24:08 you know,
00:24:08 I know other people
00:24:09 don't have it as bad
00:24:09 but let's compare
00:24:10 to where our country
00:24:10 was at 10 years ago
00:24:12 or our country's declined
00:24:13 rapidly in the last 10 years
00:24:14 or the cost of living
00:24:15 has increased exponentially
00:24:16 or the Canadian dollar
00:24:17 is worth less
00:24:17 or Canadian mental health
00:24:19 is poor. 0.68
00:24:21 You know,
00:24:21 we can study all these metrics
00:24:22 and see that they've
00:24:23 actually gotten worse
00:24:24 over the last 10 years
00:24:24 so I think we should
00:24:25 really be comparing things
00:24:26 to,
00:24:27 you know,
00:24:27 just even what it was
00:24:28 a decade ago
00:24:28 and I don't think
00:24:29 there's anything wrong
00:24:29 with saying,
00:24:30 you know,
00:24:31 I would like to get back
00:24:31 to the Canada that we had,
00:24:32 that Canada felt
00:24:33 more optimistic,
00:24:34 that Canada felt
00:24:35 more hopeful
00:24:35 and more promising
00:24:36 for me and for my family
00:24:38 and so I think
00:24:38 if you look at it
00:24:39 from that way
00:24:39 it's actually
00:24:40 a very fair metric
00:24:41 and even for myself
00:24:42 like growing up
00:24:44 I didn't necessarily think
00:24:45 that we had
00:24:46 the most amazing house
00:24:48 and now looking at it
00:24:48 it's sort of like a dream
00:24:49 to think,
00:24:50 oh,
00:24:50 we had a house
00:24:51 with four to five bedrooms
00:24:52 and two washrooms
00:24:53 and everyone had their own room
00:24:54 and we had a little bit
00:24:55 of a backyard
00:24:55 and,
00:24:56 you know,
00:24:57 we even had a driveway
00:24:57 and a shed out back.
00:24:58 Those things are really hard
00:24:59 for people to get now
00:25:00 and there's nothing wrong
00:25:01 with saying
00:25:01 I would at least like
00:25:02 to be able to offer my kids
00:25:04 the same upbringing
00:25:05 and the same quality of life
00:25:06 that I had growing up
00:25:07 and I think
00:25:07 we shouldn't accept
00:25:08 that we are declining
00:25:09 in those metrics
00:25:10 as a country
00:25:10 when there's no reason
00:25:12 that we shouldn't be
00:25:12 improving of them
00:25:13 that we really should be able
00:25:14 to offer our families
00:25:15 a better quality of life.
00:25:18 Yeah,
00:25:19 I think you're right about that
00:25:20 and the idea
00:25:21 of like the starter home
00:25:22 I think
00:25:23 it's coming back
00:25:24 but there was a time
00:25:25 where I think a lot of people
00:25:26 I mean,
00:25:26 certainly millennials
00:25:27 were looking at houses
00:25:30 and everyone wanted
00:25:30 the giant dream home
00:25:32 that no one would really
00:25:33 reasonably expect
00:25:34 to be able to buy
00:25:36 just out of school
00:25:36 or whatever.
00:25:37 I think it's changing
00:25:38 a little bit.
00:25:38 I think now you see
00:25:39 a lot of younger people
00:25:40 that are willing to
00:25:41 say I'll be in a less
00:25:42 desirable neighborhood
00:25:43 or I'll have a really
00:25:44 small house
00:25:44 but even then
00:25:45 they're finding it
00:25:47 like just completely
00:25:47 unaffordable.
00:25:48 Like you look at some
00:25:49 of the property listings
00:25:50 in places like Toronto
00:25:50 and Vancouver
00:25:51 and it's like $1 million
00:25:52 for a place
00:25:54 that you might get shot
00:25:55 just going from your bathroom
00:25:56 to your bedroom.
00:25:57 I mean,
00:25:58 it's not even that much
00:25:58 better in Calgary though.
00:25:59 Like I had Councillor Dan McLean
00:26:00 on my show the other week
00:26:01 we were talking about
00:26:02 the rezoning going on
00:26:03 in Calgary
00:26:03 which has passed now
00:26:04 by the way
00:26:04 and I was saying
00:26:05 you know,
00:26:06 a lot of these
00:26:06 modest bungalows
00:26:08 are going to be torn down
00:26:08 and replaced with
00:26:09 duplexes
00:26:11 that'll be worth
00:26:11 quite a bit
00:26:12 and he was like
00:26:12 in some cases
00:26:12 these duplexes
00:26:13 are going to be worth
00:26:14 a million dollars.
00:26:15 So you're paying
00:26:16 a million dollars
00:26:17 for duplexes.
00:26:17 You've got neighbors
00:26:18 on both sides of you.
00:26:19 You might have a unit below you.
00:26:20 You might even have
00:26:20 the unit in the back of you.
00:26:22 So you've got absolutely
00:26:22 no privacy
00:26:23 no space to yourself.
00:26:25 I guess we can all agree
00:26:25 the World Economic Forum
00:26:27 has been more successful
00:26:28 than we care to admit.
00:26:30 Although Isaac
00:26:31 Isaac got a house
00:26:32 so maybe he's like
00:26:33 sitting on some giant
00:26:34 like Scrooge McDuck
00:26:35 sized pile of cash
00:26:37 that we don't know about.
00:26:38 Yeah.
00:26:41 Changing topics.
00:26:41 He blushes and tugs
00:26:42 at his collar.
00:26:43 All right, never mind.
00:26:44 No, no, no.
00:26:45 There was two more things
00:26:45 I wanted to mention
00:26:46 from the study quickly
00:26:47 which firstly
00:26:48 this obviously focused
00:26:49 on the rage index
00:26:51 towards the federal government
00:26:52 but they also pulled
00:26:53 people from provinces
00:26:54 and asked them
00:26:55 about their feelings
00:26:55 towards the provincial government
00:26:57 which was pretty interesting
00:26:58 because anger
00:26:59 towards the provincial government
00:27:00 was highest in Ontario
00:27:01 at 60%
00:27:02 but anger in British Columbia
00:27:04 towards the provincial government
00:27:06 grew at the highest rate
00:27:07 which was a 16% jump
00:27:09 from 38% in January
00:27:11 to 54% in April.
00:27:14 And then some
00:27:15 one other point
00:27:15 I did want to mention
00:27:16 because this was interesting too
00:27:18 you might think
00:27:19 that the oldest generation
00:27:20 would be the angriest
00:27:22 however
00:27:23 in this study
00:27:24 Gen X
00:27:25 which they listed
00:27:26 as 44 to 59 years old
00:27:28 was the angriest generation 1.00
00:27:29 so yeah
00:27:31 if you two want to weigh in
00:27:32 on that
00:27:32 anything that I just said
00:27:33 that
00:27:33 the provincial thing
00:27:37 I find interesting
00:27:38 because
00:27:38 during COVID
00:27:39 I think we saw
00:27:40 government
00:27:41 was like an amorphous mass
00:27:42 like people were mad
00:27:43 at government
00:27:44 and I don't think
00:27:44 they really cared
00:27:45 which level it was
00:27:46 so in that sense
00:27:48 I do find it interesting
00:27:49 that Ontario
00:27:49 has borne the brunt of it
00:27:51 the Gen X one 0.92
00:27:52 I'm surprised by
00:27:53 because I think
00:27:54 Gen Xers 1.00
00:27:55 are better off
00:27:56 than millennials
00:27:57 who are better off
00:27:58 than Gen Z 0.99
00:27:59 in a lot of ways
00:28:00 although I'm not
00:28:00 yeah I don't know
00:28:02 that's a confusing one
00:28:03 the Gen X 0.63
00:28:03 would be the generation 1.00
00:28:04 just below the baby boomers 0.99
00:28:05 and
00:28:06 yeah Gen X
00:28:07 is the friend
00:28:07 the friend's generations
00:28:08 I mean Gen Xers 1.00
00:28:09 are yeah
00:28:09 now like 50 years old
00:28:10 so it's the
00:28:11 it's the age
00:28:12 of the cast of friends
00:28:13 basically
00:28:13 I'm actually not
00:28:14 super surprised by this
00:28:15 because the baby boomers 0.99
00:28:17 have always been regarded
00:28:18 as like the generation 0.89
00:28:19 that got all the blessings
00:28:20 they have all the wealth
00:28:21 I know a lot of people
00:28:21 are saying with
00:28:22 the Trudeau liberals
00:28:23 new changes to taxes
00:28:24 are really targeting
00:28:24 the baby boomers 0.99
00:28:25 and their wealth there
00:28:26 and my mom is a Gen X
00:28:28 and she always complains 0.99
00:28:28 she's like if I had just
00:28:29 been born a little bit earlier
00:28:30 I would have had a little
00:28:31 bit more money
00:28:32 the baby boomers 0.99
00:28:32 have it so much easier
00:28:33 so I feel like the Gen X 0.57
00:28:35 generation is maybe
00:28:35 that generation 0.76
00:28:36 that always feels like
00:28:37 they just kind of missed out
00:28:38 you know if they've been
00:28:38 born a few years earlier
00:28:40 maybe they would have had
00:28:41 the wealth of the baby boomers 0.97
00:28:42 so I don't know
00:28:42 I'm not super surprised
00:28:43 to see this number
00:28:44 they're also still
00:28:45 in the generation
00:28:46 that they're not retired
00:28:47 they're working
00:28:48 towards retirement
00:28:49 and with the changes
00:28:50 that we're seeing
00:28:51 with the cost of living crisis
00:28:52 they're probably looking
00:28:53 at this and thinking
00:28:54 huh I'd hope to retire
00:28:55 in 5 to 10
00:28:56 10 to 15 years
00:28:58 and that's not
00:28:59 going to happen
00:29:00 right now
00:29:00 I'm going to actually
00:29:01 have to work way past
00:29:02 the age I plan to retire at
00:29:03 because I'm not putting
00:29:04 away as much money
00:29:05 into my retirement
00:29:06 as I'd hoped to
00:29:07 I'm not making as much
00:29:08 all those things
00:29:09 so I'm not actually
00:29:10 super surprised
00:29:11 by those numbers
00:29:12 yeah I think
00:29:14 you've dated yourself
00:29:15 by saying that
00:29:15 your mother is in Gen X 0.90
00:29:17 because you even
00:29:18 made me feel old
00:29:18 because my parents
00:29:19 are boomers
00:29:20 I dated myself
00:29:22 yeah
00:29:22 oh
00:29:23 like you've dated yourself
00:29:25 you've established
00:29:27 not like you've gone out
00:29:28 on a romantic date
00:29:29 with yourself
00:29:29 I mean you've like
00:29:30 yes I get it
00:29:31 well here I'll just
00:29:31 I'm the oldest generation
00:29:33 of Gen Z
00:29:34 I'm the oldest generation
00:29:35 of Zoomers 0.99
00:29:36 so
00:29:36 okay
00:29:37 not that old
00:29:38 but
00:29:38 anyway what were you
00:29:39 saying Isaac
00:29:40 yeah sorry
00:29:41 just my theory
00:29:42 when I initially saw
00:29:43 the Gen X thing
00:29:45 was that
00:29:46 and especially
00:29:47 because I've spoken
00:29:48 with many people
00:29:48 in this generation
00:29:49 and the recurring issue
00:29:50 I see with them
00:29:52 is that they're worried
00:29:52 about their children
00:29:53 and I think people
00:29:54 in this generation
00:29:55 probably have children
00:29:56 that are teens
00:29:57 and maybe even
00:29:58 becoming adults
00:29:59 like Rachel said
00:29:59 your mom's in that
00:30:00 I'm becoming an adult
00:30:01 so I'm slowly
00:30:03 becoming an adult
00:30:04 and then yeah
00:30:05 so I think
00:30:06 they're worried
00:30:06 about the generational
00:30:09 economic damage
00:30:10 that their children
00:30:11 are going to have
00:30:12 to deal with
00:30:13 right
00:30:14 so that's my best theory
00:30:15 they don't really
00:30:16 go into it in the study
00:30:17 but
00:30:17 yeah
00:30:17 the word of the day
00:30:19 from or the term
00:30:19 of the day
00:30:20 from Trudeau
00:30:20 for the last two weeks
00:30:21 has been generational
00:30:22 fairness
00:30:22 that's what he
00:30:23 thinks he is delivering
00:30:25 so take from that
00:30:26 what you will
00:30:26 this
00:30:27 we're jumping a little
00:30:28 ahead of the schedule
00:30:29 here but
00:30:29 this one is interesting
00:30:31 Rachel
00:30:31 you flagged this 0.98
00:30:32 ridiculous shoppers 0.98
00:30:34 story 0.97
00:30:34 which I think
00:30:35 actually speaks
00:30:36 to the rage
00:30:36 and opportunity
00:30:37 explain what
00:30:38 happened here
00:30:39 so shoppers
00:30:40 a location
00:30:41 in Toronto
00:30:42 Ontario
00:30:43 posted a
00:30:44 job advertising
00:30:45 for a part-time
00:30:46 employee
00:30:47 the only thing
00:30:48 is that it
00:30:48 actually isn't
00:30:49 a job
00:30:49 it's a position
00:30:50 for an unpaid
00:30:51 volunteer
00:30:52 the listing here
00:30:53 says
00:30:54 this is a part-time
00:30:55 on-site volunteer
00:30:56 role at shoppers
00:30:57 drug mart
00:30:58 in Toronto
00:30:58 Ontario
00:30:58 as a volunteer
00:30:59 you will be
00:31:00 responsible for
00:31:01 assisting with
00:31:01 various tasks
00:31:02 and providing
00:31:03 support to the
00:31:04 staff
00:31:04 this may include
00:31:05 helping customers
00:31:06 find products
00:31:07 restocking shelves
00:31:08 organizing inventory
00:31:09 and maintaining a
00:31:10 clean and organized
00:31:11 store environment
00:31:12 your role as a
00:31:13 volunteer is crucial
00:31:14 in ensuring that
00:31:15 our customers have
00:31:16 a positive and
00:31:17 seamless shopping
00:31:18 experience
00:31:18 so obviously you
00:31:19 can see very
00:31:20 clearly from the
00:31:21 description there
00:31:21 that this is
00:31:22 indeed a job
00:31:23 something that
00:31:24 someone should be
00:31:24 paid at least
00:31:25 minimum wage for
00:31:26 but I think
00:31:27 what's happening
00:31:28 here is we've
00:31:29 all seen those
00:31:30 videos
00:31:30 well maybe not
00:31:32 all of us
00:31:32 but I'll describe
00:31:33 it for over
00:31:33 years haven't
00:31:34 seen it
00:31:34 if you if you
00:31:35 spend a long
00:31:35 time on X
00:31:36 as all of us
00:31:36 on here do
00:31:37 you've often
00:31:38 seen videos of
00:31:39 people in
00:31:40 Toronto lining
00:31:41 up at job
00:31:41 fairs for jobs
00:31:42 that something
00:31:43 like maybe say
00:31:43 Canadian Tire
00:31:44 or Tim Hortons
00:31:45 or McDonald's
00:31:45 and there's just
00:31:46 lines of people
00:31:47 down the street
00:31:48 you look like
00:31:48 these lines look
00:31:49 hours long and
00:31:50 sometimes there's
00:31:51 just people hoarding
00:31:52 the doors and
00:31:53 they're trying to
00:31:53 hint in their
00:31:54 application and you
00:31:55 even seen videos
00:31:55 where people are
00:31:56 like so
00:31:56 we're no longer
00:31:57 accepting applications
00:31:58 just hundreds and
00:31:59 hundreds of people
00:32:00 showing up at
00:32:00 jobs fairs for
00:32:01 very basic
00:32:02 minimum wage
00:32:03 part-time jobs
00:32:04 and so what we're
00:32:05 really seeing here
00:32:06 is there's just
00:32:06 not enough demand
00:32:07 and I can't help
00:32:08 but think that
00:32:08 maybe shoppers
00:32:09 thought eh
00:32:09 you know there's
00:32:10 so much demand
00:32:11 obviously this has
00:32:12 lowered the value
00:32:13 of wages
00:32:13 maybe we can get
00:32:14 someone who would
00:32:15 be desperate
00:32:15 enough to just
00:32:16 get some
00:32:16 experience to put
00:32:17 something on their
00:32:18 resume that could
00:32:19 later on lead to
00:32:20 a part-time job
00:32:21 since we've got so
00:32:21 many people who are
00:32:22 clearly out of work
00:32:23 that's my
00:32:24 suspicion
00:32:24 and you know
00:32:25 of course this
00:32:26 again falls back
00:32:26 to immigration
00:32:27 the high levels
00:32:27 of immigration
00:32:28 that we're seeing
00:32:28 particularly concentrated
00:32:30 in the GTA region
00:32:32 that's really what's
00:32:33 causing this impact
00:32:34 and I know that's my
00:32:35 suspicion as to why
00:32:36 shoppers posted this
00:32:37 position
00:32:37 I will say that
00:32:38 they have been
00:32:39 ruthlessly mocked
00:32:40 online for it
00:32:41 and they have since
00:32:42 pulled the job
00:32:43 posting from LinkedIn
00:32:44 but what do you guys
00:32:45 think?
00:32:46 yeah just well just
00:32:47 on that they
00:32:47 they pulled it
00:32:48 corporate weighed
00:32:49 in and said it
00:32:50 was a mistake
00:32:50 and then they also
00:32:51 said well it was
00:32:52 the the local
00:32:53 franchisor because
00:32:54 with shoppers the
00:32:54 pharmacist owns the
00:32:55 store so I don't
00:32:56 think it was a
00:32:57 mistake I think the
00:32:57 pharmacist was being
00:32:59 an absolutely you
00:33:01 know just predatory
00:33:02 human being in
00:33:03 trying to get people
00:33:04 to work for him for
00:33:05 free and I'm hoping
00:33:07 that you know the
00:33:07 whip is coming down
00:33:08 behind the scenes on
00:33:09 that but no it's 0.59
00:33:10 ridiculous and look I
00:33:11 mean internships have 0.99
00:33:12 in and of themselves
00:33:14 gotten a bad rap as
00:33:15 of late but at least
00:33:15 an internship is an
00:33:17 environment in which
00:33:18 you're supposed to
00:33:18 learn it's typically
00:33:19 part of studying but
00:33:21 but even then unpaid
00:33:22 internships are very
00:33:23 controversial this
00:33:24 doesn't even pretend
00:33:24 to be that this is
00:33:25 just hey come and
00:33:26 work for us for free
00:33:26 yeah I don't know and
00:33:29 I wouldn't necessarily
00:33:30 say there's anything
00:33:31 wrong with an unpaid
00:33:33 internship if you're
00:33:34 learning like a
00:33:34 specific skill and
00:33:35 maybe an industry you
00:33:36 want to go to but
00:33:36 come on restocking
00:33:37 shelves like just give
00:33:38 the person $11 $13
00:33:40 an hour whatever it
00:33:41 is call it a day
00:33:41 Isaac what do you
00:33:42 think?
00:33:43 yeah I've never
00:33:44 personally been a
00:33:45 supportive of unpaid
00:33:46 internships but to
00:33:49 play devil's advocate
00:33:50 for shoppers here I
00:33:52 they didn't hide like
00:33:54 it the header of the
00:33:55 job the did say
00:33:57 volunteer so it
00:33:58 wasn't like they were
00:33:59 saying oh you can be
00:34:00 a whatever their
00:34:01 employee title would
00:34:02 be called a stock
00:34:04 associate let's say
00:34:05 and then at the end
00:34:06 they're like oh but we
00:34:06 won't pay you so at
00:34:07 least they were just
00:34:09 saying that yeah this is
00:34:10 a volunteer role like
00:34:11 they weren't trying to
00:34:12 hide that at least and
00:34:13 I don't know how
00:34:15 abnormal it is to post
00:34:16 volunteer jobs to
00:34:19 LinkedIn but obviously
00:34:21 this is a job that you
00:34:22 you would normally
00:34:23 expect to get paid
00:34:24 for I mean it's an
00:34:26 interesting business
00:34:27 model join a market
00:34:28 that's so desperate for
00:34:31 work that you can just
00:34:32 post jobs that people
00:34:34 apply to because I think
00:34:36 I've always believed that
00:34:37 work gives work in
00:34:38 general just gives
00:34:39 humans a desire to 0.97
00:34:41 live right like it's a
00:34:43 really an important
00:34:44 part of life in my
00:34:44 opinion so yeah just a
00:34:46 good business design
00:34:48 there which is post your
00:34:50 jobs as volunteer work
00:34:51 because people are so
00:34:52 dying to work that
00:34:54 they'll just come work
00:34:54 for you for free yeah
00:34:55 I think you're actually
00:34:57 looking and then
00:34:58 there's the capitalist in
00:34:59 me that's like well
00:35:00 okay if people are
00:35:01 willing to do it then
00:35:02 you know it's no skin
00:35:02 off anyone else's back
00:35:03 but that but it's still
00:35:04 I think is is really I
00:35:07 I hope this hasn't
00:35:08 been going on for
00:35:09 long in fact I hope
00:35:10 this was the first
00:35:10 time this has ever
00:35:11 been done and we all
00:35:12 just see how terrible
00:35:13 it is and it never
00:35:14 happens again much
00:35:16 like I hope the
00:35:17 government never puts
00:35:18 1.7 million dollars
00:35:20 of your and my tax
00:35:22 money into funding
00:35:23 the manufacture of
00:35:25 pasta in Brampton
00:35:26 this is a thing that
00:35:29 happened this week the
00:35:30 federal government
00:35:30 announced 1.7 million
00:35:32 to Italpasta which is
00:35:34 a company that's going
00:35:35 to create a massive
00:35:35 massive economic benefit
00:35:37 with this they're
00:35:37 going to take the
00:35:38 1.7 million dollars
00:35:40 they're going to you
00:35:41 know turn it into
00:35:42 dough they're going to
00:35:43 need it they're going
00:35:43 to run it through the
00:35:44 machine and at the
00:35:45 end of it 10 jobs are
00:35:47 created 10 jobs that is
00:35:50 a cost per job of
00:35:51 170,000 dollars it
00:35:53 would be more
00:35:53 advantageous I think
00:35:54 just to walk around
00:35:55 in Brampton and give
00:35:57 people $10,000 each
00:35:58 until the 1.7 million
00:36:00 runs out you'd
00:36:00 probably have more
00:36:01 economic benefit there
00:36:02 Isaac what's your
00:36:03 take on this yeah I
00:36:06 don't disagree with
00:36:06 you about the economic
00:36:07 benefit part you give
00:36:09 those people the $10,000
00:36:10 they'll spend it which
00:36:11 I guess is the premise
00:36:13 of GDP but I mean
00:36:15 $170,000 per job to
00:36:16 make pasta here this
00:36:18 does seem a bit wild
00:36:20 and I mean this isn't
00:36:22 so much public sector
00:36:23 it is publicly funded
00:36:24 but we've seen the
00:36:25 public sector job
00:36:27 market balloon whereas
00:36:28 obviously private has
00:36:29 taken a huge hit in
00:36:31 Canada over the last
00:36:31 few years so yeah and
00:36:34 I don't know why why is
00:36:36 the federal government
00:36:36 funding this project I
00:36:38 haven't really looked
00:36:39 into the story as much
00:36:40 of my life but I don't
00:36:41 understand why why the
00:36:43 federal government would
00:36:43 have their toes in this
00:36:44 at all and why are
00:36:46 taxpayers paid for these
00:36:47 jobs they just want to
00:36:48 run around handing out
00:36:49 checks in an election
00:36:51 year or as in election
00:36:52 years anyway it seems
00:36:55 like general vote buying
00:36:56 and you know we are
00:36:57 seeing this with the
00:36:58 liberals time and time
00:36:58 again they're spending
00:36:59 millions billions of
00:37:01 dollars to create for
00:37:02 example in Ontario 1.5
00:37:04 billion dollars for an
00:37:06 EV battery plant that
00:37:07 will create a thousand
00:37:08 jobs I think there's been
00:37:09 a couple of those
00:37:10 announcements been
00:37:11 reported and you just
00:37:12 look at this and you're
00:37:13 like why is this
00:37:14 happening this seems
00:37:14 so ridiculous but really 0.92
00:37:15 it's a sign of a broken 0.92
00:37:16 economy when the
00:37:17 government is coming in
00:37:19 and they're spending
00:37:20 millions and billions of
00:37:21 taxpayers dollars to
00:37:22 create a handful of
00:37:22 jobs it doesn't really
00:37:23 make sense in a
00:37:24 functioning economy you
00:37:25 know the natural supply
00:37:27 and demand system would be
00:37:28 creating jobs while
00:37:29 paying jobs from private
00:37:31 money there would be no
00:37:32 need for the federal
00:37:32 government to get
00:37:33 involved here so this is
00:37:34 really a broken system
00:37:35 that we're seeing it's
00:37:35 just so frustrating the
00:37:37 amount of money we're
00:37:37 spending on a handful of
00:37:38 jobs and also for the
00:37:39 EV battery plant I mean
00:37:40 that's its own loaded
00:37:41 statements on its own
00:37:42 we're creating all these
00:37:43 batteries no one really
00:37:43 wants electric vehicles
00:37:44 they haven't been
00:37:45 successful I don't think
00:37:46 they are going to be
00:37:47 very successful in the
00:37:47 next few years I think
00:37:48 people have kind of seen
00:37:49 what they have to offer
00:37:50 and chosen other options
00:37:51 so it's extremely
00:37:53 frustrating as a consumer
00:37:54 and a taxpayer to watch
00:37:55 this yeah fair enough
00:37:57 all right just before we
00:37:59 go well actually you know
00:37:59 I got one thing for us
00:38:00 before we go but before
00:38:01 that thing happens
00:38:03 Rachel you had this
00:38:04 story which you wanted
00:38:05 it doesn't even really
00:38:06 fit anywhere but it was
00:38:07 just weird are we
00:38:10 putting it up on what
00:38:11 story is this Peru oh
00:38:13 yes so Peru has
00:38:15 officially classified 0.86
00:38:16 trans people as mentally 1.00
00:38:17 ill I saw this and I 0.99
00:38:18 you know thought for a
00:38:19 minute maybe that some
00:38:19 mistake had been made
00:38:20 but someone had to say
00:38:23 the quiet part out loud
00:38:23 yeah I don't think
00:38:27 Canada has sent enough
00:38:28 money to Peru which is
00:38:29 why this has happened
00:38:30 because obviously the
00:38:31 feds keep sending money
00:38:32 to these foreign 0.78
00:38:33 countries to bolster their
00:38:35 LGBTQ community so I
00:38:37 think the liberals
00:38:38 haven't invested enough
00:38:39 of our tax
00:38:40 don't give them any ideas
00:38:41 Isaac don't give them 0.89
00:38:42 any ideas
00:38:43 I asked so Sean is our
00:38:45 producer he produces my
00:38:47 show and this one and I
00:38:48 asked and he's Peruvian
00:38:49 so I asked him what he
00:38:51 thought about it and he
00:38:52 said he forgot he was
00:38:53 Peruvian so 0.93
00:38:54 which is a convenient way
00:38:56 to sidestep having an
00:38:57 opinion on this
00:38:57 take some pride
00:38:58 what was that Rachel
00:39:01 can take some pride in
00:39:02 it now
00:39:02 yeah I always thought
00:39:04 that a lot of those
00:39:05 like Latin American 0.84
00:39:06 like the Central and
00:39:08 South American countries
00:39:08 were like really really
00:39:09 uber progressive like
00:39:10 played but I guess not
00:39:13 necessarily so I don't
00:39:15 know maybe they're
00:39:15 turning a corner I
00:39:16 don't pretend to know
00:39:16 anything about Peruvian
00:39:17 politics so Sean weighs
00:39:19 in now he's had some
00:39:20 time to think about he
00:39:21 says as a Peruvian I
00:39:23 can say they are quite
00:39:23 conservative when it
00:39:25 comes to LGBTQ stuff so 0.98
00:39:26 okay so maybe it's
00:39:27 actually nothing new
00:39:28 from them
00:39:29 as our home Peruvian
00:39:31 expert has spoken I
00:39:33 think also we're seeing
00:39:34 the future Peruvian
00:39:35 ambassador to Canada or
00:39:37 Canadian ambassador to
00:39:38 Peru he forgets he's
00:39:38 Peruvian but as long as 0.97
00:39:40 he doesn't forget he's
00:39:40 Canadian he's eligible for
00:39:41 the gig
00:39:42 I also think we're
00:39:44 really seeing the
00:39:44 pendulum like swinging
00:39:45 back hard on a lot of
00:39:46 these issues
00:39:47 no I agree
00:39:48 all right so earlier on
00:39:49 we were all struggling to
00:39:50 come up with raps in
00:39:51 real time and as my
00:39:53 true north colleagues
00:39:53 know and are no doubt
00:39:54 infuriated by I have
00:39:56 just developed this like
00:39:58 weird affinity for AI
00:39:59 generated music as of
00:40:01 late so while people
00:40:02 were talking I
00:40:03 produced or had I
00:40:04 didn't do it I did
00:40:05 like nothing I typed in
00:40:06 one sentence an AI
00:40:08 generated rap about
00:40:10 defunding CBC now I
00:40:12 have not heard this yet
00:40:13 so this could be
00:40:14 terrible but we're
00:40:15 gonna put it up and
00:40:16 we're gonna listen to
00:40:17 it for this is the
00:40:18 world debut of a song
00:40:19 that the AI app
00:40:21 Suno has titled
00:40:22 defund the broadcast
00:40:23 yo it's time to
00:40:27 address a topic that's
00:40:29 been on my mind
00:40:30 CBC you claim to
00:40:31 represent the people
00:40:32 but you're far behind
00:40:33 causing taxpayers money
00:40:34 it's getting out of
00:40:35 control time to defund
00:40:36 the broadcast it's time
00:40:37 for your reign to
00:40:38 fold CBC used to be
00:40:40 the voice of the nation
00:40:41 but nowadays all I hear
00:40:42 is propaganda and
00:40:44 misrepresentation you're
00:40:45 out of touch with
00:40:46 Canadians you don't
00:40:47 understand our plight
00:40:48 it's time to cut the
00:40:49 funding we need to
00:40:50 change and we need it
00:40:51 right you claim to
00:40:52 be unbiased but it's
00:40:53 clear that ain't the
00:40:54 case reporting with
00:40:55 agenda pushing
00:40:56 narratives in our face
00:40:57 you forgot your core
00:40:58 mission the reason you
00:40:59 exist it's time to
00:41:01 defund the broadcast
00:41:02 it's time for you to
00:41:04 resist
00:41:04 I gotta say that's
00:41:18 better than the Dubai
00:41:19 climate disinformation
00:41:21 rap I think
00:41:22 that was quite good
00:41:23 I guess I'm actually
00:41:24 the one who's behind
00:41:25 the times because
00:41:26 while you were working
00:41:26 away at your little
00:41:28 song I was kind of
00:41:29 just looking up words
00:41:30 on rhyme dictionary
00:41:31 trying to come up with
00:41:32 some more rhymes and
00:41:33 in the whole time I
00:41:34 only got one and I
00:41:35 don't even remember it
00:41:36 now
00:41:36 I was Barton and
00:41:39 Darton you had done
00:41:40 Rosie Barton and
00:41:41 Darton
00:41:41 but I've been also
00:41:42 working on rhymes
00:41:42 throughout the show and
00:41:44 it definitely wasn't as
00:41:45 fast as your AI song
00:41:47 okay this is why we're
00:41:49 all going to be out of
00:41:49 work when the the
00:41:50 machines rise up and
00:41:51 take their rightful
00:41:52 place on the throne of
00:41:53 civilization all right
00:41:54 on that happy delightful
00:41:56 note thanks to Rachel
00:41:58 Emanuel and Isaac
00:41:59 Lamoureux for coming on
00:42:00 the show thanks to all of
00:42:01 you for tuning in hope
00:42:02 you have a fantastic long
00:42:04 weekend and remember
00:42:05 everything you've heard
00:42:06 was please please please
00:42:08 remember this because I
00:42:09 don't want this getting
00:42:10 out it was all off the
00:42:11 record
00:42:11 Sean wants to know if
00:42:21 the rap counts as
00:42:21 Canadian content I I
00:42:24 don't know so I'm
00:42:24 Canadian and I did the
00:42:25 prompt but the computer
00:42:26 might not be Canadian so
00:42:28 I don't know if it's a
00:42:28 Canadian artist
00:42:29 we'll just you know
00:42:32 jiggle the words a little
00:42:33 bit so the CRTC doesn't
00:42:34 flag it
00:42:35 oh no I if it is
00:42:36 Canadian because when the 0.73
00:42:37 online streaming act comes
00:42:38 in maybe this is like what
00:42:39 we can just do to like
00:42:40 the front page see I
00:42:42 think that we you know
00:42:43 need to just do away with
00:42:45 AI so we can all use our
00:42:46 brains a little more you
00:42:47 know flex our skills we're
00:42:48 all becoming too lazy you
00:42:50 came up with one rhyme in
00:42:51 45 minutes Rachel
00:42:52 but it's a good one you
00:42:54 want to hear it Rosie
00:42:55 Barton sues sue the
00:42:57 Tories that action is 0.98
00:42:59 damn the Tory 0.98
00:43:00 we need an AI model on the 1.00
00:43:04 website that wraps all of
00:43:05 our articles out for the
00:43:06 for the
00:43:07 I put Andrew's AI song into
00:43:08 my podcast
00:43:09 I know I did people like
00:43:11 that I forget it's very
00:43:12 mixed it's half and half
00:43:14 um a lot of people like the
00:43:16 song and then a lot of
00:43:17 people are like oh I can't
00:43:19 stand that it's AI but
00:43:20 otherwise they like the
00:43:20 song and then there's also
00:43:21 a good number of people who
00:43:22 are like it's super cringy
00:43:24 Rachel like you need to take 0.97
00:43:25 it off I have to skip your
00:43:26 intro now
00:43:27 ah oh well
00:43:28 all right
00:43:29 it's my show I make the
00:43:31 decisions
00:43:32 so
00:43:37 you
00:43:39 you
00:43:39 you
00:43:39 you
00:43:39 you
00:43:40 you
00:43:42 you
00:43:43 you
00:43:43 you