Pearl - November 19, 2024


The Broken Legal System EXPOSED! | Pearl Daily @TheBrancaShow

Topics
Mentioned
Titanic is the Worst Movie Ever! Rose is the OG Modern Woman! | Pearl Daily Father FIGHTS to Save His Son From GENDER TRANSITION Nightmare | Pearl Daily

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 21 minutes

Words per minute

189.49

Word count

15,486

Sentence count

847

Harmful content

Misogyny

26

sentences flagged

Toxicity

27

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Pearl Daily, I sit down with the world's leading expert in self defense law, Dr. Andrew Bruegma, to discuss the importance of self defense in self-defense cases, and why the criminal justice system is not well-suited to deal with good guy self defense cases.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 what up guys welcome to another episode of pearl daily welcome to the show today i have a special
00:00:13 guest on the show our first ever in studio guest welcome to the show andrew brinka thank you very
00:00:19 much it's a pleasure to be here he is the world's leader the country's leading expert in self-defense
00:00:25 law with over 25 years of experience and you have the youtube channel law of self-defense
00:00:30 i do more than 30 years of experience i keep getting older every year and you are the author
00:00:36 of our best-selling book the law of self-defense principles which by the way
00:00:40 we give away for free at law of self-defense.com free book and so you teach men and women how to
00:00:50 legally shoot somebody. That's one way of putting it. I prefer to say that I teach people where the
00:00:57 legal boundaries are for the use of force. So they do have to defend themselves. They're not
00:01:02 only well positioned to win the physical fight, which is the most important thing, but they're
00:01:05 also well positioned to win the legal fight that happens. You don't want to survive the physical
00:01:09 fight only to spend the rest of your life in a cage someplace. You want to be free to live your
00:01:13 life with your family and all the things that make life worth living. And so what's interesting,
00:01:17 um because guys we went shooting today so we went shooting and i've spent kind of the day
00:01:23 hanging out with andrew and um you said something earlier about many people get convicted even
00:01:31 though they're innocent or they didn't do anything on the books wrong why is that well part of it is
00:01:38 just noise in the system uh so specifically in this context we're talking about good guy cases
00:01:42 of self-defense right not criminals just making up self-defense but someone's had to defend them
00:01:47 themselves against some kind of attack, they don't really know where the legal
00:01:51 boundaries are. They may think they know, but in fact they generally don't know
00:01:54 what they're allowed and not allowed to do. And the system itself is not well
00:01:59 suited to deal with good guy cases of self-defense. By the system I mean the
00:02:03 criminal justice system. When you think of that phrase, criminal justice system,
00:02:07 the most controlling word in that three-word phrase is system. It is a
00:02:13 system. It's a machine, like a steampunk-era machine with giant wheels and gears. It doesn't
00:02:19 care about you personally. It doesn't care about fairness. It's just a bureaucratic machine for
00:02:24 administering what we call justice, the rules of law to different people. And the second most
00:02:29 operative term in that phrase, criminal justice system, is criminal. It's a system that's optimized
00:02:35 to deal with criminals. For them, it does a pretty good job. But when you feed a normal law-abiding
00:02:40 person into that system, it generally doesn't go very well. And because the system's optimized
00:02:45 for dealing with criminals, there's at least always a 10% chance that you'll get convicted
00:02:50 if I have to put you in front of a jury. That's what we call the justice part of the criminal
00:02:54 justice system. 10%? That seems so high. It's low. Many criminal defense attorneys will tell
00:03:00 you it's higher because most criminal defense attorneys or clients are actually criminals.
00:03:04 That's the nature of the business. For someone who has a criminal history who's put in front
00:03:09 of a jury they could be completely innocent of this particular charge they're looking at more
00:03:13 like a 50 percent chance of conviction wait say that one more time so they're the normal person
00:03:19 who's fed into the criminal justice system is a criminal they have a criminal background they've
00:03:23 done criminal stuff before okay they're just back for another ride on the carousel of the criminal
00:03:28 justice system if that person goes in front of a jury it's more like a 50 chance of getting
00:03:32 convicted even if they're technically innocent of the particular charge this time okay so who are
00:03:37 your typical clients when you defend somebody in a self-defense case? So most of the cases I work
00:03:44 on, the clients tend to be normal law-abiding people, never been in trouble with the law a day
00:03:49 in their life. Some of them have never had a speeding ticket in their entire lives, typically
00:03:52 between the ages of 35 and 50. Now, I should be clear, I have a consulting practice, so I don't
00:04:00 take clients directly. All the cases I work on, somebody used for somewhere in the country,
00:04:05 They ended up with a criminal charge.
00:04:07 They hire a local attorney to be their lead counsel on their case.
00:04:10 My client is their attorney, so I'm consulting to their attorney.
00:04:14 Oh, okay.
00:04:15 And what are typical cases that somebody gets into that, like, winds, like, is it a bar fight?
00:04:23 Is it a home invasion?
00:04:27 Like, what is the typical self-defense case?
00:04:29 So the most common criminal charge we're defending against is aggravated assault with a deadly weapon.
00:04:35 we do murder cases we do all level of cases but the most common is aggravated
00:04:39 assault with a deadly weapon because what happens is the client was facing
00:04:44 something scary frightening them and they're carrying a gun legally carrying
00:04:49 a gun and they pulled the gun out and they pointed it at that person and they
00:04:52 said stay back I'm prepared to defend myself which sounds like perfect self
00:04:56 defense right that same conduct checks all the boxes for a criminal charge of
00:05:01 aggravated assault with a deadly weapon. What is assault? It's putting someone else in fear of
00:05:06 harm. But what are you doing when you're pointing a gun at someone? You're putting them in fear of
00:05:10 harm. You're telling them, I will hurt you if you don't stop doing what's scaring me. It's aggravated
00:05:16 because you're threatening them with deadly force harm, and it's with a deadly weapon because you're
00:05:20 doing it with a gun. Collectively, in most states, that's good. That's a felony good for 10 to 20
00:05:25 years in prison. Keep in mind, I'm talking about mothers, fathers, people who've never been in
00:05:30 trouble with the law a day in their lives are now looking at a 20-year felony sentence.
00:05:35 Right. And so have you had any cases where, maybe not you, or like what are examples of cases that
00:05:43 commonly innocent people end up going to prison? Like what's like a common case that that might
00:05:49 happen? Well, it can happen in any case. Like I said, there's at least a 10% chance, no matter
00:05:53 how innocent you are, that you'd get convicted. We have a very, very high success rate at law
00:05:58 self-defense. We have almost 100% success in getting charges dismissed or people put into
00:06:03 a diversion program. So if they keep their nose clean for a certain period of time, the charges
00:06:07 go away. Or if we go to trial, we have a very high rate of acquittals. So we're pretty good at what
00:06:12 we do. The cases that really trouble me is the ones where I actually see innocent people being
00:06:17 convicted and going to prison. And they tend to be many of the high profile, politically energized
00:06:22 cases out there. The George Zimmerman case, the Kyle Rittenhouse case. Now, those two guys happen
00:06:27 to get acquitted, but they were at risk of conviction. They would have spent the rest of
00:06:31 their lives in jail. Derek Chauvin is another case. There was reasonable doubt in that case,
00:06:37 but he got convicted anyway, and he'll die in prison. George Zimmerman, can you tell me what
00:06:44 the media said about it and what actually happened? Sure. So the way it was portrayed in the media was
00:06:49 that George Zimmerman was a white Latino, a phrase invented for his trial. A white Latino.
00:06:56 White Latino. He was some kind of pseudo-white supremacist who saw a 13-year-old black boy 0.98
00:07:03 walking through his community and decided to kill him and shot him dead for the crime of that boy 0.99
00:07:10 walking around minding his own business with iced tea and candy. What actually happened was George 0.96
00:07:17 Zimmerman was a neighborhood watch volunteer for his community that was beset by a tidal wave of
00:07:22 home invasions and burglaries and thefts. He saw Trayvon Martin, who was not 13 years old,
00:07:27 but it was a 17-year-old, well-muscled high school football player. Wait, he was 17? 17.
00:07:34 Wow. Okay, keep going. Trayvon Martin was a street fighter. In other words, he engaged in
00:07:40 fights in the street as entertainment. We know this because we have video of him fighting on
00:07:45 his own cell phone. His chosen technique was to punch people in the face, knock them down,
00:07:49 and then mount them and beat them into the ground. 0.96
00:07:52 Well, Trayvon Martin saw that George Zimmerman
00:07:54 was on the phone with police
00:07:56 reporting a suspicious character, Trayvon Martin.
00:07:59 So he ambushed George Zimmerman,
00:08:01 punched him in the face, 0.96
00:08:02 knocked him down, mounted him, 0.96
00:08:03 was beating him into the ground, 0.96
00:08:05 smashing his head into a sidewalk.
00:08:07 There's eyewitness testimony for all of this.
00:08:09 And in the last desperate moment to save his life,
00:08:11 George Zimmerman drew his legally carried pistol,
00:08:14 fired a single round that killed Trayvon Martin
00:08:17 in lawful self-defense.
00:08:19 and then there was all these riots, and they made it politically motivated.
00:08:25 But somehow Zimmerman still got acquitted, right?
00:08:29 Yeah, when I first looked at the case, I thought,
00:08:31 well, surely there must be something from the prosecution here that would suggest guilt,
00:08:34 because everything I'm seeing is totally consistent with lawful self-defense.
00:08:37 And there simply wasn't anything.
00:08:41 But what was happening was it became an opportunity for a local prosecutor
00:08:45 who was having difficulty getting reelected in her black community,
00:08:49 She had prosecuted a couple of cases involving black people that were very unpopular in the
00:08:54 community.
00:08:54 She was going to lose her re-election.
00:08:57 And then she saw the opportunity with George Zimmerman and said, you know what?
00:09:00 If I prosecute this guy for shooting that black high school student, I'll be in favor 1.00
00:09:05 with the black community again. 0.68
00:09:06 Now, George Zimmerman was acquitted.
00:09:08 So that prosecutor lost that trial.
00:09:11 If you define winning as getting a conviction, she didn't get a conviction.
00:09:15 But if you properly understand what motivated her, it was not to get a conviction.
00:09:18 it was to get re-elected. And that worked. When she was going to lose re-election,
00:09:23 she prosecuted Zimmerman, and she got re-elected instead of losing.
00:09:28 So that's how politics get involved in the law, because the prosecutors are elected.
00:09:35 Right.
00:09:36 And so then they have to be political.
00:09:38 That's correct.
00:09:40 So it's got to be heavily dependent on the prosecutor in your area, too.
00:09:44 right so in fact the prosecutor in george zimmerman's area he was pressured to bring
00:09:50 charges against george zimmerman and he quit he resigned his job rather than prosecute george
00:09:55 zimmerman so the prosecutor who ended up taking the case was from a completely different part of
00:09:59 florida who flew in to take over that case for political advantage how can they do that because 0.99
00:10:05 isn't it based on where you are yeah but once the original prosecutor quit it left the vacuum
00:10:10 It needed to be replaced by somebody, and she raised her hand.
00:10:14 It got picked by the governor.
00:10:15 Oh, so the governor appointed her to go do it?
00:10:18 Essentially assigned her to go into that empty district and take over the prosecutor's role. 1.00
00:10:23 And because they made it like a race issue, then the facts didn't even matter.
00:10:29 Right.
00:10:30 So there's a cliche in the law, and it says, if you're a lawyer and the law is on your
00:10:34 side, you argue the law to the jury.
00:10:36 And if the facts are on your side, you argue the facts to the jury.
00:10:39 And if neither the law nor the facts are on your side, you pound the table.
00:10:44 And so that whole prosecution was table pounding.
00:10:47 The facts were not on their side.
00:10:48 The law was not on their side.
00:10:50 It was the cleanest case of self-defense I've ever seen brought to trial.
00:10:53 Their prospects of actually getting a conviction was shockingly low, probably just that 10%
00:10:58 that's noise in the system.
00:11:00 So I don't think they really had an expectation of getting a conviction, although it could,
00:11:04 of course, happen.
00:11:05 The whole point was for her to win re-election. 0.58
00:11:07 And in that respect, she won.
00:11:09 Right. And so it's almost like innocent people get like, they're like innocent bystanders in
00:11:16 the process where innocent people get thrown in jail because politicians are trying to get
00:11:23 reelected. That's exactly right. And they're just, they're just like a twig floating along 0.99
00:11:27 the river. They're completely helpless. Oh, and that's why they, oh, okay. You just
00:11:32 made something make sense. That's why they hated Kamala, right? Because I guess she was known for 1.00
00:11:41 having some unfair prosecutions. She was really contemptible. First of all, she put a lot of 0.99
00:11:47 young black men in jail for marijuana crimes at a time when it was becoming clear the social
00:11:52 sentiment towards marijuana was becoming more favorable. You didn't need to give these people
00:11:56 long sentences. Then she kept them in prison longer than California law required. She could 0.97
00:12:01 have allowed them to be released earlier and she wouldn't. Then there were many cases in which
00:12:05 they had hidden exculpatory evidence, evidence consistent with innocence on these guys. So they
00:12:10 were appealing their cases because the courts had hid that evidence favorable to them. And she
00:12:15 argued against getting them released. So she was holding people in prison she knew did not belong
00:12:21 in prison. Well, what would be her motive for doing that? She thought there was political
00:12:25 advantage in it. She wanted to be able to run eventually as someone who was tough on crime. 0.98
00:12:29 oh so and did you look at any of those cases super in depth i'm just curious if you think that
00:12:38 the cases they bring up were fair or no so the the ultimate merits of the case are hard to know
00:12:45 right whenever this guy did what he was charged with i wasn't in the room so i don't really know
00:12:49 in any absolute sense what happened but i do know that when the defense is saying hey we have
00:12:54 exculpatory evidence that's favorable to our client and the state is arguing for that not to
00:12:58 be admitted, that's a problem. Yeah, because you would think that would be illegal for them not
00:13:04 to bring up evidence, right? At a trial, it would be. It gets a little squishier when we're talking
00:13:10 about the appeals process. But if you're a prosecutor and you're genuinely interested
00:13:14 in justice and not just a score, you seek justice by allowing the evidence in. Right.
00:13:19 interesting how do you think so what what do you think about like false accusations and how can i
00:13:29 don't know i know it's a little bit off of self-defense but no it's fine how can men protect
00:13:35 themselves from false accusations well you really you really can't except to not associate with
00:13:40 people who might bring false accusations there's crazy people out there don't be in their company
00:13:45 Don't date them. Don't marry them. In terms of what I think should happen to people who make
00:13:51 false accusations, and we need to be careful because sometimes someone may make a claim
00:13:56 that they believe is true, but they just have the wrong person, right? It looks like the person who
00:14:01 attacked them, for example. That's obviously not the case if we're talking about people in a
00:14:05 relationship who know each other well. But I think that if anybody makes a false accusation about
00:14:10 anything let's use a woman making a false she knows it's a false accusation of rape against a 1.00
00:14:16 man and she's caught and it's proven she did that beyond a reasonable doubt she should serve whatever
00:14:21 prison sentence that man would have served if her accusation had been believed and why is it so hard
00:14:27 for things like that to get passed like why won't shouldn't that be cut and dry well because most of
00:14:33 the people making the false accusations tend to be women making those kinds of false accusations 1.00
00:14:37 And women are treated, as in life generally, with softer gloves than men are treated.
00:14:43 They get shorter prison sentences.
00:14:44 They get more favorable treatment in court.
00:14:46 They're less likely to get convicted in the first place on essentially identical facts.
00:14:52 Society just treats women differently than men, especially when they're going to be put to some kind of duress.
00:14:57 Yeah.
00:14:58 What about Kyle Rittenhouse?
00:15:01 Another case that was – there was literally zero evidence inconsistent with self-defense.
00:15:06 And that's important to keep in mind because you don't have to prove you acted in self-defense.
00:15:10 The state has to prove you did not act in self-defense.
00:15:13 And they have to prove that beyond any reasonable doubt.
00:15:16 So by like 90% of the evidence, they have to disprove your claim of self-defense.
00:15:21 Well, if 100% of the evidence is favorable to self-defense, there's no way they can get a conviction on the legal merits there.
00:15:28 Kyle Rittenhouse didn't shoot anybody who was not actively trying to kill him in the moment he shot that person.
00:15:33 Every single one of those uses of force was completely lawful.
00:15:36 The prosecution had nothing to go on on the law and on the facts.
00:15:40 So what did they do?
00:15:41 They pounded the table.
00:15:43 They made a bunch of smoke and mirrors.
00:15:44 They complained about him carrying a rifle in the first place.
00:15:47 Sorry, that was completely lawful under the circumstances.
00:15:51 They just shout about a lot of things.
00:15:54 But there was nothing there in the merits.
00:15:56 Kyle Rittenhouse got lucky.
00:15:57 He could have been convicted too.
00:15:58 It would have been a wrongful conviction.
00:15:59 But it could have happened.
00:16:01 Thankfully, the jury came back with the right verdict.
00:16:02 so do you think all of these cases are disincentivizing men from stepping up in
00:16:09 situations where they hypothetically could so you know Kyle Rittenhouse I'm
00:16:14 fairly certain he actually went there to help yeah so he went there medical
00:16:19 training he brought his first aid kit yeah he was treating people's cuts and
00:16:23 abrasions and things like that and you know for I don't know how long the trial
00:16:26 was but he probably had to put his life on hold he probably had death threats
00:16:30 That's, you know.
00:16:31 Right, so even when these people are acquitted,
00:16:32 like George Zimmerman or Kyle Rittenhouse.
00:16:34 So they won, right?
00:16:35 They're acquitted.
00:16:36 They walk out of the courtroom a free man.
00:16:39 They were at risk of conviction.
00:16:41 The trials go on for weeks.
00:16:43 And in the case of Zimmerman,
00:16:45 it was like a year between the event and the trial.
00:16:47 So think about it.
00:16:48 If you're like a 25-year-old guy, you're married,
00:16:50 you're going to school, you're working a job,
00:16:53 and this happens.
00:16:55 And now your lawyer tells you,
00:16:56 listen, in a year from now, we're going to go to trial,
00:16:58 and they're going to decide
00:16:58 whether you spend the rest of your life in a cage.
00:17:00 What do you do during that year?
00:17:02 You still go get your 10 credits that year
00:17:04 at the community college?
00:17:06 Do you start a family?
00:17:07 Do you have a child?
00:17:08 Do you do anything substantive?
00:17:10 Your life is frozen for that year
00:17:11 and you never get that year back.
00:17:13 So even if you have the best possible outcome
00:17:15 and you get acquitted,
00:17:16 you lost that year of your life forever.
00:17:18 In the case of George Zimmerman,
00:17:20 he lost everything.
00:17:21 He lost his job.
00:17:22 He lost his wife.
00:17:23 He lost, in a sense-
00:17:25 His wife left him?
00:17:26 His wife divorced him.
00:17:27 No way.
00:17:28 And I didn't know George at the time of the trial,
00:17:30 but I've come to know George since then.
00:17:32 He's just a genuinely nice guy, but he was traumatized.
00:17:36 Wait, you met him?
00:17:37 Yeah.
00:17:37 No way.
00:17:38 Yep.
00:17:39 Really?
00:17:40 Have you had an interview with him?
00:17:42 Not online, but I've talked with him about the case.
00:17:44 I know the lawyers on his side from the case very, very well.
00:17:47 Wow.
00:17:48 Now they're good friends of mine.
00:17:50 But George was, so you hear about George after the trial,
00:17:53 after the acquittal.
00:17:53 Sometimes you'd see him in the news.
00:17:55 He did something crazy.
00:17:56 Well, he was a broken man.
00:17:58 He had PTSD from that experience.
00:18:00 You know, he wanted to be a prosecutor himself.
00:18:02 That's what he was going to school for.
00:18:03 And so in his own mind, he's the good guy, right?
00:18:06 He wants to be a good guy in society, keep society safe from evil predators.
00:18:10 And the system tried to put him in a cage for the rest of his life for doing nothing wrong.
00:18:15 And how long do you think George Zimmerman would have survived in general population in a Florida prison?
00:18:20 Had he been convicted of being a racist murderer of a 13-year-old black boy for having iced tea and candy?
00:18:27 Weeks? Maybe? 0.72
00:18:28 How does that happen where these guys get, like, don't they have guards and stuff?
00:18:33 How do they get stabbed in prison?
00:18:35 It's just like a dorm.
00:18:37 Everyone's mixed in.
00:18:39 You're in your cells at night, and then in the morning the cells open up,
00:18:42 and everyone just mingles in a central area.
00:18:44 Yeah, you would just think that they would be, the prison would be responsible.
00:18:49 Like, how are they getting the weapons?
00:18:51 They shouldn't, like, how are they getting them?
00:18:53 Okay, so, yeah, we like to think of prisons as being these secure facilities
00:18:57 where you can't get stuff in.
00:18:58 Every drug you can buy in the street, you can get in prison.
00:19:01 They take guns off of prisoners in prisons.
00:19:06 So how do they get into the, and that's not even counting the weapons that they can just
00:19:10 fabricate by materials they secure in the prison.
00:19:13 You know, prisons are made out of cinder blocks.
00:19:15 You take a piece of steel, a piece of spring, anything, and you grind it.
00:19:19 You got plenty of free time in prison.
00:19:21 You grind it on a cinder block, you have a knife. 0.97
00:19:23 Wow.
00:19:24 And who brings that stuff into the prisons?
00:19:26 It's mostly the guards.
00:19:26 so he would just be because that's what happened to um chauvinah right he just got stabbed like 20
00:19:34 times in prison or i think it was maybe two or three years ago with shanks just pieces of metal
00:19:39 they sharpened up on on cinder block and what do they do they just throw them back in yeah wow so
00:19:46 it's like he gets stabbed and then he just has to fend for himself imagine wow i mean many of us
00:19:52 when we were kids were bullied in school right that was a miserable experience chauvin's facing
00:19:56 the death bully experience wow so but the world doesn't care because the world's been brainwashed
00:20:04 into thinking that he's the the horrible racist murderer of saint george floyd i think there's a
00:20:10 he has a good amount of support though i do think um sorry not simmerman but um chauvin i think um
00:20:17 because i spoke to his lawyer um i was trying to get an interview with him potentially and um
00:20:24 um he his lawyer said that they get a call like every week from people that are just still upset
00:20:31 about it and it's been like eight years or seven however long right but those people don't have the
00:20:36 power or authority to change anything yeah so so but Zimmerman um so you know him personally and
00:20:45 he's in the news now not anymore so that this all happened 12 years ago now so I would say for five
00:20:53 or six years after the trial he was he was messed up uh but since then he's gotten his life together
00:20:58 he's moved on to other things and he seems to be doing pretty well now did he like change his name
00:21:03 like he did yeah he and what is he is he in like a normal job now or how is how did i don't really
00:21:09 want to give too many details because he's obviously changed his name so people wouldn't
00:21:13 find him yeah that's fine but wow because i just can't i don't even know how you would move on from
00:21:18 that like i don't know what you would do next um oh yeah and brianna taylor is another one i have
00:21:30 listed yeah so that kind of falls into the category of um i have the cough you're okay you're okay
00:21:37 brianna taylor kind of falls into the category of what i call bad outcome cases meaning
00:21:44 you can imagine a shooting that might occur where the person who was killed really deserved it
00:21:49 really had it coming they were firing bullets at the police and the police were shooting back and
00:21:53 they just got killed in a gunfight that's not really what happened with Breonna Taylor she
00:21:56 was in an apartment with her boyfriend the apartment was served with a search warrant
00:22:01 by the police they were doing a drug raid essentially the police kicked in the door
00:22:08 as the search warrant allowed them to do and when they came in Breonna's boyfriend started
00:22:13 shooting at the police. He would later say that he thought he was being the victim of a home
00:22:17 invasion, which could be true. Maybe he did believe that. In which case, it can
00:22:21 be lawful to shoot at the police. If you don't know they're police, if you think they're home invaders, you're just defending your
00:22:25 home. But of course, when you shoot at the police, they tend to shoot back. And the
00:22:29 police did shoot back, and one of those rounds struck and killed Breonna Taylor.
00:22:33 Was she trying to harm the police? No. Did the police have a reasonable expectation that the
00:22:37 person they were serving the warrant on was trying to kill them? Yes.
00:22:40 so their shots fired in her direction at the source of the gun shooting at them
00:22:46 was a lawful use of force she just got caught in the crossfire so it's not a good death i mean
00:22:52 nobody wanted her to die but a lot of times you have these cases where it's technically a legal
00:22:58 killing under the law even though everybody involved wished it had never happened
00:23:02 so what are the best ways for people to protect themselves in those situations
00:23:10 okay my nose started running and also guys if you have any questions for him you have to go
00:23:20 to the audacitynetwork.com and you sign up for our monthly memberships there's a live chat and
00:23:27 Every now and then I'm going to check it to see if you guys have any comments or questions.
00:23:33 You don't have to super chat.
00:23:34 You just put it in the chat.
00:23:36 Like Bob says, I've worked in corrections for over 30 years and the percentage of the population is not guilty.
00:23:44 What percentage, Bob?
00:23:46 I don't understand fully.
00:23:47 And then also, guys, we do have a sponsor for this episode.
00:23:52 So we're going to take a quick break and we're going to hear from our sponsors.
00:23:57 days it's no wonder you see testosterone levels of men declining one percent a year
00:24:06 the average testosterone levels are half of what they were 50 years ago this is one of the
00:24:11 foundational physiological reasons why society's crumbling and in the state that it's in these
00:24:17 women are getting away with murder and there is a synth epidemic testosterone levels are so low 0.84
00:24:23 and something needs to be done about it.
00:24:26 Chalk is on a mission to save mankind from extinction by boosting your vitality.
00:24:31 When you boost your testosterone, you'll have more mental clarity.
00:24:35 You're more capable of taking risks and making decisions.
00:24:39 Having high testosterone will also affect your pheromones,
00:24:42 so women will find you more attractive subconsciously. 1.00
00:24:46 Get the Chalk Male Vitality Stack on Chalk.com.
00:24:49 That's C-H-O-Q.com. 0.98
00:24:51 chalk provides the highest quality herbal supplements clinically studied to boost your
00:24:57 testosterone their tongue cat is wild harvested from the malaysian rainforest and is studied
00:25:02 in double blind human trials to boost free testosterone levels 87 percent in 21 days
00:25:09 use my name pearl as your coupon code and you'll get 25 off site wide on chalk.com
00:25:16 that's c-h-o-q dot com coupon code pearl boost your testosterone naturally supercharge your
00:25:23 masculinity and don't be a sim guys make sure you get some chad mode when you use my code
00:25:33 it helps the show it helps us get oh wait did i say it too early okay okay guys make sure you
00:25:39 get chad mode because it does help the show and it's actually pretty good i've tried it myself
00:25:44 i really like it so if you can get the chad or get the chad mode it helps support the show
00:25:51 okay so you were saying brianna taylor was awful there said in the chat it's awful but lawful yep
00:25:57 that's the that's the phrase we use so it's it's not good but it happens all the time because um
00:26:03 two people could be involved in a fight and they both legitimately think they're acting in self
00:26:07 defense this happens a lot with police on police shootings uh where they each mistake the other
00:26:12 especially if they're in plain clothes. They're both in plain clothes. They're being told,
00:26:17 hey, go find a guy who's walking around with a gun. And they turn a corner and there's a guy
00:26:20 with a gun. It's another cop. And they shoot at each other. One of them kills the other.
00:26:25 Under the law, it doesn't, the law of self-defense doesn't really care about what was actually
00:26:29 happening. It's all about what was your reasonable perception when you fired that shot.
00:26:33 And if you had a reasonable perception that you were facing an imminent deadly force threat,
00:26:37 you can use deadly force in self-defense. You're not required to be correct in that assessment.
00:26:42 We're not required to make perfect decisions in self-defense.
00:26:45 We're only required to make reasonable decisions in self-defense.
00:26:48 Mistakes are allowed, as long as the mistakes are reasonable mistakes.
00:26:52 So how can you protect yourself when you're in an altercation?
00:26:56 Like, what are the best ways to, when you're in a situation where you have to use self-defense,
00:27:02 like Zimmerman or any of these, you know, the guy on the subway, Daniel Penny?
00:27:09 Penny.
00:27:09 Penny, yeah.
00:27:10 When they're in those situations, what is the best way to protect themselves?
00:27:14 Well, of course, there's two fights we're talking about, right?
00:27:16 There's the physical fight.
00:27:17 You have to win the physical fight or nothing else really matters, right?
00:27:20 You lose the physical fight.
00:27:21 Who cares about the legal stuff?
00:27:22 Right.
00:27:23 And that really involves what I would call tactical decisions.
00:27:26 Like, do you have a gun?
00:27:27 Do you have a knife?
00:27:27 Do you know how to use them?
00:27:28 Do you do some martial art like Brazilian jiu-jitsu?
00:27:32 If you don't train for the physical fight, you're going to lose the physical fight.
00:27:35 People don't win because they're going to go, I don't know, crazy mode or something.
00:27:40 That's not reality.
00:27:41 You don't rise to your aspirations or your imaginary capabilities.
00:27:45 Your performance is going to be what you can demonstrate cold on any given day at a range or in a dojo or wherever you prepare for the physical fight.
00:27:53 So I would encourage people to do that, prepare for the physical fight.
00:27:56 I know personally I carry a gun every day of my adult life for personal protection.
00:28:00 I do BJJ several times a week so I can have a non-gun answer to problems, a barehanded answer, to maintain that proficiency myself.
00:28:10 So first, you've got to do what needs to be done to win the physical fight.
00:28:13 The next question is, what can you do to win the legal fight?
00:28:17 You want great legal counsel, for sure.
00:28:20 And most lawyers are not particularly good.
00:28:22 Like any profession, lawyers aren't a bell curve.
00:28:24 80% of them are in the middle.
00:28:26 They're okay. 1.00
00:28:27 10% of them suck. 1.00
00:28:28 10% of them are really good. 1.00
00:28:30 You want one of the 10% that's really good.
00:28:33 But even having done that, it's important to keep in mind that your lawyer is not a magician.
00:28:38 He can't turn a bad shoot into a good shoot.
00:28:42 Your lawyer is stuck with the facts you give him.
00:28:45 If you give him good facts, you'll have a great defense.
00:28:48 In fact, you can make yourself super hard to convict.
00:28:50 That's what we teach at Law of Self-Defense is how to be hard to convict.
00:28:53 But if you give your lawyer bad facts, that's going to be a really, really difficult case to have a good outcome in.
00:28:59 Bad facts.
00:29:00 Bad facts.
00:29:01 So what did you do?
00:29:02 Was your conduct actually within the legal boundaries of self-defense?
00:29:06 If it was, you're hard to convict.
00:29:09 But your lawyer can't change that retroactively.
00:29:11 You have to have made the right decisions in the moment when you were defending yourself.
00:29:15 How do you know what those right decisions are?
00:29:17 Well, stuff like this.
00:29:18 Learn the actual law of self-defense.
00:29:20 If you do that and you stay well within the legal boundaries, you're really difficult to convict, and you're unlikely, because you're hard to convict, to be charged in the first place.
00:29:28 If it's a political ploy, does it matter?
00:29:32 Yes and no.
00:29:33 So having made the right decisions will not keep you from going to trial if it's a politically energized case.
00:29:39 You're going to go.
00:29:40 But George Zimmerman went to trial, and Kyle Rittenhouse went to trial, and they got acquitted.
00:29:45 They got acquitted because their use of force was inside the legal boundaries.
00:29:48 So is it still important to know the legal boundaries
00:29:51 and stay within them in a politically charged case?
00:29:53 Yeah, because if you don't do that,
00:29:55 your conviction's easy.
00:29:56 You're done.
00:29:57 Well, what was the difference between them
00:29:59 and like Derek Chauvin?
00:30:00 Like why did Derek go to prison and they didn't?
00:30:04 One of the reasons was the case just came later.
00:30:07 Every time these politically energized cases come up,
00:30:10 the people who want to drive,
00:30:12 say the racism angle in the case,
00:30:14 they get more sophisticated.
00:30:15 They get better at what they're doing.
00:30:17 There were some of the facts in the Chauvin case were particularly subject to manipulation.
00:30:22 So, for example, while Chauvin is kneeling on George Floyd, a technique that was trained in the police academy for him to use just didn't come out of the blue.
00:30:32 He was a 20-year officer.
00:30:33 I bet he'd done that 10,000 times before.
00:30:36 No suspect had ever died.
00:30:37 But while he's kneeling on George Floyd, and George Floyd is saying, I can't breathe, because he just took a mouthful of drugs and had coronary artery disease and had fought four police officers for 10 minutes.
00:30:48 But he's saying, I can't breathe.
00:30:49 There's 15, 20 people standing on the curb watching this.
00:30:52 They're all outraged.
00:30:54 They believe they see a man being murdered.
00:30:56 Every single one of those persons testified in court.
00:31:00 One after another, after another, after another.
00:31:03 in a proper criminal prosecution,
00:31:06 that would never have been allowed to happen
00:31:07 because they all basically saw the same thing.
00:31:10 It would have been called cumulative evidence,
00:31:12 which normally is not allowed.
00:31:14 One or two of them could have said, I saw this.
00:31:16 We know the other people all saw the same thing.
00:31:18 But when you allow 20 people to tell the same story,
00:31:21 it makes it sound as if their evidence
00:31:23 is 20 times as strong as it actually is.
00:31:26 Another factor was Derek Chauvin had one defense lawyer.
00:31:31 The prosecution team had 10 or 15 lawyers
00:31:33 working for it. So they would argue all day in court, and then the prosecution team would file
00:31:38 a whole bunch of motions that had to be reviewed overnight by the defense team, the one lawyer,
00:31:43 defense lawyer. So not only was that guy working all day, he was basically working all night
00:31:47 handling these motions. He could not sleep for the several weeks of the trial.
00:31:52 So why was it so one-sided? Is it because he couldn't afford more lawyers, I'm guessing?
00:31:59 Well, however much you can afford, the state can always afford more.
00:32:04 So the state's resources are effectively infinite, and nobody can match infinite resources.
00:32:09 But why didn't that happen with the Zimmerman case?
00:32:13 So in Zimmerman, it was one of the first of these politically energized cases, and George Zimmerman set up a GoFundMe type of platform, and he was allowed to collect a lot of money.
00:32:24 He collected $1.5 million.
00:32:26 Now, his legal defense ended up costing closer to $2 million.
00:32:31 But nevertheless, with the $1.6 million he raised, that's a lot of resources for a criminal trial.
00:32:37 So they were more in parity with what the prosecution could bring to the table.
00:32:41 After that, these GoSemi-type organizations, and I don't want to pick them out.
00:32:45 It's just the only one whose name I can remember.
00:32:47 But many of them now, if you try to raise money for a legal defense, they'll shut you down.
00:32:51 They won't let you raise money.
00:32:52 No way.
00:32:52 Yep.
00:32:53 Because they said, well, you've been credibly accused of criminal activity.
00:32:55 we're not going to let you use our platform
00:32:57 to raise legal defense funds
00:32:58 so a lot of that's off the table now
00:33:01 right so Chauvin
00:33:03 couldn't even raise the money for his case
00:33:05 because none of the platforms would let him
00:33:07 I expect none of them would
00:33:09 that case
00:33:11 I just can't believe
00:33:14 the police chief turned
00:33:15 on him that was amazing
00:33:17 I couldn't
00:33:19 I mean I guess I would expect
00:33:22 it maybe
00:33:22 from like the witnesses and stuff,
00:33:27 but you would think there'd be some honor, I guess,
00:33:30 with the police chief.
00:33:32 Yeah, you have to keep in mind
00:33:33 when someone becomes a police chief,
00:33:36 when they've hit that top level within the department,
00:33:38 they're not a cop anymore.
00:33:40 They're a politician now.
00:33:41 They get that job because the city council
00:33:43 or whoever the governing body is
00:33:45 chose them for that position.
00:33:46 Those people are elected.
00:33:48 Effectively, the police chief is elected by them.
00:33:51 And so when he's faced with a Derek Chauvin type of position, he can say, well, this guy
00:33:56 is just going to be sacrificed.
00:33:58 It's obvious they're going to do everything in their power to sacrifice this guy, regardless
00:34:01 of the law or the evidence.
00:34:03 I can either join him in going to the guillotine, or I can join the team sacrificing him and
00:34:09 keep my career.
00:34:11 I'm not saying it's the right thing to do, but it's not hard to understand why people
00:34:14 would make that decision.
00:34:15 So do you think that police officers are going to have a hard time recruiting people?
00:34:20 they can't recruit right now most major urban police departments are are hundreds or thousands
00:34:25 of people short really in terms of how many police officers they need yeah because why would why would
00:34:30 you do it especially if you're seeing them throw you know men doing their jobs under the bus and
00:34:36 when they can recruit they're not getting top level people right those top level people can
00:34:41 go become computer programmers or sell cars or do something else so what do you think will happen
00:34:47 in the future? Well, we're at an interesting inflection point. We have a new president coming
00:34:53 in. I think he's going to be looking to, many of these prosecutors got their offices, these
00:35:02 politically energized prosecutors who bring these cases, became prosecutors because they were
00:35:08 elected to those positions with the financial help of George Soros or one of his foundations.
00:35:14 George Soros is a very far-left individual, a billionaire.
00:35:18 Most prosecutor races traditionally, if you had two guys running for that prosecutor's office,
00:35:23 they might each spend $5,000 or $10,000 for that race.
00:35:27 George Soros comes in and drops a quarter of a million dollars behind his candidate.
00:35:32 He just bought that seat.
00:35:33 They're running TV ads.
00:35:35 They're running newspaper ads.
00:35:36 The normal prosecutors are not competitive anymore.
00:35:39 Once George Soros gets his prosecutor into that office,
00:35:42 they're in there specifically for political decision-making.
00:35:46 So they do things like say,
00:35:48 we will no longer prosecute property crimes.
00:35:50 If you go in and you loot your local CVS pharmacy,
00:35:53 we're not going to prosecute you.
00:35:54 So what happens?
00:35:56 All the CVS pharmacies get looted.
00:35:58 And then they also say,
00:36:00 well, if you're a cop and you shoot somebody, 0.98
00:36:01 we're going to go after you hard. 0.99
00:36:04 So these become,
00:36:05 the entire criminal justice structure
00:36:07 in those jurisdictions becomes politically energized george so i always hear about him
00:36:12 i want to see what he looks like now his son has taken over the empire his son's name is
00:36:17 alex soros how did they get rich can we show him on screen he looks kind of scary
00:36:22 i don't you see him yeah yeah well how did he get rich do you know i don't know
00:36:31 financed by billionaire so he this is the guy that funds a lot of this stuff right and so
00:36:39 basically a prosecutor will run and they can't make it unless they go with his agenda essentially
00:36:45 so traditional prosecutors are generally old guys or they could be gals in the legal community
00:36:50 they've practiced law there for decades they've been lower level prosecutors for decades and they
00:36:55 decide you know what i'd like to throw my hat in for the big seat for the prosecutor's office
00:36:59 but they don't have much money they don't have much political expertise and they're just normal
00:37:04 run-of-the-mill prosecutors they're well-intentioned civil servants just trying to do a good job for
00:37:08 their community George Soros will pick someone who's a firebrand left-wing lawyer and say I want
00:37:16 you to be the prosecutor and do left-wing things in that office here's a quarter of a million dollars 0.71
00:37:21 and buy him the seat.
00:37:25 So it'll be interesting to see what Trump does,
00:37:28 if this stuff will still be able to happen,
00:37:31 or what do you think?
00:37:33 Because that's so much money.
00:37:35 How do you go up against that?
00:37:37 Yeah, unless you can match the money,
00:37:38 how would you go up against it?
00:37:39 I think we're going to find it's going to require
00:37:43 some creative legal opportunities.
00:37:47 Now, the federal government has a lot of implicit authority,
00:37:50 Strictly speaking, of course, I mean, how much should the federal government have to do with a local prosecutor, right?
00:37:55 But all these cities get a lot of money from the federal government.
00:37:58 The federal government starts saying, listen, unless you start prosecuting property crimes again, we're cutting off the spigot.
00:38:04 Could apply enough pressure to get someone else in the job.
00:38:06 And every once in a while, increasingly, these Soros prosecutors are getting thrown out of office.
00:38:11 I know the one in L.A. or San Francisco, for example, just lost his run for re-election.
00:38:15 7 billion dollars i'm gonna check really quick the chat see um pearl ask him if you have the
00:38:28 right to deny jurisdiction to the original court no matter what happens so you can get
00:38:34 the co-fiction overturned or conviction i can keep that overturned on appeal
00:38:39 so i'm not exactly sure what he's asking jurisdiction is not a difficult issue in
00:38:46 criminal courts you committed an alleged crime in the county for example the court has jurisdiction
00:38:52 in that county that's it they have jurisdiction there are a group of people who refer to themselves
00:38:56 as sovereign citizens they believe they're not subject to the laws of the united states they
00:39:01 believe that u.s courts simply have no jurisdiction over them at all they're kind of crazy so i'm not
00:39:06 sure if he's one of those people and he's trying to ask the question from that angle. But I can
00:39:12 tell you, you can yell at a court all you want that the court does not have jurisdiction over
00:39:17 you. The court does not care. Okay. The other, Craig Thomas says, I've heard during World War
00:39:25 II, he printed, he pointed German, Craig, I can't say that on YouTube. I'm not going into that.
00:39:32 um guys comments that are relevant i can't i can't this isn't that topic um anyways
00:39:40 so
00:39:43 michael brown was another yeah guys i can't say that um so michael brown was another one
00:39:54 and that was was that the one with zimmerman it's kind of some of these happened when i was
00:40:00 in high school so i'm trying to think back michael brown was in ferguson missouri uh he was a uh a
00:40:06 very large uh black gentleman who was walking down the middle of a street and a patrol car came up
00:40:11 and yelled at him to get on the sidewalk get out of the street and michael brown attacked that
00:40:15 police officer in his patrol car fought him for control of the officer's pistol we know this
00:40:20 because the pistol in the struggle discharged inside the patrol car and took a chunk of michael
00:40:26 brown's a little piece of michael brown's hand his dna was found inside the car so we know there
00:40:31 was a fight for the gun there then michael brown ran off the police officer chased him on foot
00:40:35 police officer said halt police michael brown turned around michael brown was about 250 pounds
00:40:42 the police officer was about 160 michael brown turned around looked at the officer and charged
00:40:47 at him hands extended and the officer shot him as he was being charged and killed him the news
00:40:55 stories were that this officer executed Michael Brown for no reason. Michael Brown had his hands
00:40:59 up, is the narrative. Hands up, like he was surrendering. He had his hands up. He was reaching
00:41:04 for the officer's throat when the officer shot him. And the officer knew this guy was going to
00:41:09 fight him for his gun because he'd already done it. That was a perfectly lawful shooting. But
00:41:14 here's an interesting example. So the prosecutor in that jurisdiction said, well, I'm going to
00:41:18 present the facts and the law to a grand jury and let the grand jury decide whether this goes to
00:41:23 trial. Normally, a grand jury is a completely one-sided affair because the prosecutor is not
00:41:29 obliged to share evidence of innocence with the grand jury. They're only obliged to share evidence
00:41:34 of guilt. And if we ever only hear one side of a story, it sounds pretty compelling, right? So
00:41:40 normally a grand jury only hears from the prosecutor. They only hear the prosecutor's side.
00:41:44 So they return an indictment, guaranteed. What this prosecutor did was say, you know what,
00:41:49 grand jury, I'm going to show you all the evidence. The evidence consistent with guilt and the
00:41:53 evidence consistent with innocence all of it which he doesn't have to do the grand jury looked at all
00:41:57 that evidence and they refused to indict that police officer know what happened next that
00:42:02 prosecutor who had been the prosecutor in that jurisdiction for more than 30 years the next time
00:42:07 he was up for re-election george soros came to town financed a competitor against him and that
00:42:13 guy lost his career to a george soros finance candidate and is it difficult to become a
00:42:18 prosecutor is that something that's hard to like competitive I don't really know I mean it would
00:42:23 vary by jurisdiction you know in big cities prosecutors have more power and influence so
00:42:28 it would be more competitive most people don't live in big cities they live in rural areas and
00:42:33 there it's again generally it's just some guy who's been around a long time in the legal
00:42:37 profession been a prosecutor for a few years and decides he'd like that job for a little while
00:42:41 I'm just wondering if he loses his career as a prosecutor can he get hired again like what oh he
00:42:47 wouldn't need it i mean he was probably 60 by this point so i'm sure he just retired right
00:42:52 that's so crazy so the prosecutors are often and that's a lesson by the way yeah that was done as
00:43:00 a lesson that was done as a lesson to every other prosecutor in the country if you have a case like
00:43:05 this and you present a fair narrative to the grand jury when we want you to go after that cop
00:43:10 we're going to cost you your career we're going to come in here give a competitor quarter of a
00:43:15 million at your next election and you're going to lose. So now other prosecutors are looking at this
00:43:19 and what happens when you think when they get a case like this? You think they're going to treat
00:43:23 it in a fair way with the grand jury? Or you think they're going to get on board like that police
00:43:27 chief and say, well, either I can be destroyed with this police officer or I can join the team
00:43:32 destroying him. Right. So there's incentive to basically be unlawful in a lot of these cases.
00:43:43 if they become you really want to avoid getting anything politically motivated yeah like in these
00:43:50 self-defense cases you want to be off the radar screen you don't want anyone to know about your
00:43:53 case yep so wow sorry i'm like kind of blown away by some of this stuff um craig thomas that's about
00:44:05 Soros. Okay. So in your career as a lawyer, what are some of the most interesting cases you've had?
00:44:20 Well, they're all interesting in their own ways. So there's, you think about the ways that people
00:44:25 can screw up a claim of self-defense, people find every way to screw it up. There's basically five
00:44:32 things you need for a valid claim of self-defense. So it's not rocket science. It's not 500 things.
00:44:36 It's not 50 things. It's only five. And I call these the five elements of self-defense. Innocence,
00:44:42 imminence, proportionality, avoidance, and reasonableness. Innocence meaning you didn't
00:44:46 start the fight, which should be obvious, right? If you start the fight, you can't claim self-defense.
00:44:51 Imminence meaning what you're defending yourself against is happening right now.
00:44:54 It's not someone who punched you yesterday and now you're getting them back. It's not somebody
00:44:58 who's threatening to harm you in the future but isn't a threat right now. It has to be a threat
00:45:02 that's occurring right now. Proportionality basically means you're not using deadly force
00:45:06 to defend yourself unless you're facing a deadly force threat. So if someone shoves you, you can't
00:45:11 go to the gun. That would be a disproportional response. Avoidance has to do with whether or
00:45:16 not you have a legal duty to retreat before you can defend yourself. There's only 11 states that
00:45:21 require that, so most states don't. And then reasonableness. Everything you perceive, you
00:45:27 decide you do in self-defense has to be that of a reasonable person. So it's not imaginary.
00:45:33 It's not speculative. It's something that another reasonable person in your circumstance would share
00:45:39 the same belief that you have. Could I get an example of reasonable versus unreasonable?
00:45:45 Yeah. So I had a case where a woman was in the parking lot of a Walmart and she was putting her 1.00
00:45:51 stuff in the trunk of her car. And a guy walks up and says, hey, do you have a light for a cigarette?
00:45:55 it and she pulled out a gun and pointed it at him now she was probably afraid this guy was going to 0.89
00:46:01 mug her muggers in fact use this kind of approach language all the time you have some change you
00:46:06 have the time do you have a light because they're trying to keep your brain occupied while they
00:46:11 close proximity to get close enough to hurt you or grab your purse or whatever that's probably
00:46:16 what she perceived was going on did she shoot him no she just pointed the gun but that guy ran back
00:46:23 into the Walmart, and he called the police, said, there's a crazy woman in the parking lot just 1.00
00:46:27 pointed a gun at me. The police showed up, and now they have to ask the woman, why did you point a
00:46:32 gun at that guy? For her to have a reasoned response, she would have had to say, well,
00:46:37 I saw these things that made me think he was a deadly force threat. He verbally said something,
00:46:43 he showed a weapon, some evidence to which she applied her powers of reason.
00:46:49 That would be a reasonable belief. She wasn't able to say anything like that.
00:46:52 so she got charged with a felony oh wow did you take her case
00:46:57 i did advise on the case she ended up taking a plea agreement 1.00
00:47:02 okay so still a felony but she didn't have to do time 0.97
00:47:05 so because i guess that would be an overreaction but i could see why she would do it 0.92
00:47:14 but that would still be in the eyes of the law unreasonable
00:47:18 Well, the prosecutor has to believe he can argue it was unreasonable to a jury.
00:47:23 And then a jury would make a call.
00:47:25 Now, this one ended up not going before a jury.
00:47:28 But the argument the prosecutor was going to be able to make was sufficiently compelling that we didn't want to risk a jury, which is why she took the plea.
00:47:34 Right.
00:47:35 And so what would be like an example of a reasonable one?
00:47:39 Say, for example, she had told the police, listen, this guy asked me for a light behind me.
00:47:44 And when I turned around, he was holding something shiny up at my face.
00:47:47 oh okay well yeah now maybe that would have been a pack of cigarettes not a weapon at all so maybe
00:47:53 technically she made a mistake about it being a weapon but a reasonable person might have seen
00:47:57 that flash of shiny light and thought it was a weapon reasonably right under the circumstances
00:48:03 that might have been enough to get her out of the conviction so what are some of um i guess going
00:48:08 back to the questions like are there any cases you've had over the years that really stand out
00:48:13 to you as being particular like have you ever um defended someone or maybe seen someone be
00:48:19 defended that you believed was innocent and went to jail uh not the cases i've worked
00:48:26 but we do get interesting cases we had one out of california a couple years ago it was a it was
00:48:31 a murder case it was a young woman i'm not sure she was 21 and she had a one-night stand with a
00:48:36 guy and they got into some kind of argument she says he attacked me she was quite petite and he
00:48:42 was much larger than her she had a little tiny folding knife that her dad had given her for
00:48:47 self-defense and she takes out this folding knife and this guy rushes at her and she stabs him once 0.97
00:48:53 in the chest with this little tiny knife well that little knife cut his aorta in his chest
00:48:58 which is the highest pressure blood vessel there is in the body the entire apartment in the forensics
00:49:04 photos it looked like someone had taken a hose of blood and sprayed everything and the guy falls
00:49:10 down a flight of stairs that gets all covered in blood and he dies at the base of the stairs
00:49:13 and the police show up she calls them and they question her and in every officer who spoke with
00:49:21 her wrote in his report she had a very cold demeanor she did not appear to be emotionally
00:49:27 upset that's what led to them charging her if she had been crying and weeping she might not
00:49:34 have been charged with murder but because who knows maybe she was in shock maybe she just has
00:49:39 good emotional self-control because of her calm demeanor that's what ended up with her being
00:49:44 charged with murder we got her acquitted by the way so you got her oh wow and do you do you think
00:49:52 their reactions mean anything like in your experience does that stuff matter no not
00:49:58 necessarily but the lesson here is that the people who are evaluating our use of force after the fact
00:50:05 or we're making decisions about whether we're going to go to trial,
00:50:09 run that risk of getting convicted, spend the rest of our life in a cage.
00:50:12 It's not a system that's like a big computer
00:50:13 where you put law and facts into one end and you crank a handle
00:50:16 and you get justice at the other end.
00:50:18 Inside that machine is human beings
00:50:20 with all their biases and frailties and prejudices.
00:50:25 And so these cops were just making an emotional judgment call
00:50:28 about how they felt about her demeanor.
00:50:30 And that's true at every step of the process.
00:50:32 Prosecutors are making those emotional judgment calls.
00:50:35 We like to think we're all rational, critical thinking people, but we're not really.
00:50:39 Humans are mostly emotional.
00:50:41 Our rationality is largely a veneer.
00:50:44 And then, of course, you have the jury.
00:50:46 And the jury is made up of emotional human beings too.
00:50:48 And the prosecutor makes emotional arguments to them to rev up their emotions.
00:50:52 That's not how it should work, but we're all human beings.
00:50:55 It's a process of human beings, and it's imperfect.
00:50:58 What do you think about Daniel Penny in New York?
00:51:07 Do you think he's going to get off, or do you think they're going to convict him?
00:51:10 I think he has the typical 10% chance of getting convicted.
00:51:14 I don't think he should be convicted, but I think he's running that chance.
00:51:17 And frankly, it's another bad outcome case.
00:51:19 I think no one was more surprised that Jordan Neely died than Daniel Penny.
00:51:25 I think he had no intention of causing harm to that guy at all.
00:51:28 He was just going to restrain him for police.
00:51:29 I don't believe he was choking him for more than a few seconds.
00:51:32 I think he was just restraining him with an arm around him.
00:51:36 But he was positioned to apply what we call a rear naked choke.
00:51:42 It's a particular choking technique from Brazilian jiu-jitsu.
00:51:45 And we apply it in the gym all the time.
00:51:47 I've applied the rear naked choke to hundreds of people.
00:51:49 I've had it applied to me hundreds of times.
00:51:51 No one in our gym has ever died of it.
00:51:53 but I think
00:51:55 what often happens is people get trained in this
00:51:57 technique and Daniel Penny was trained in the Marine Corps
00:51:59 on this technique I'm sure he applied it
00:52:01 to Marines they didn't die
00:52:03 his fellow Marines applied it to him
00:52:05 he didn't die but all the people we're
00:52:07 talking about are relatively young
00:52:09 healthy fit people
00:52:11 and I think when you take that same technique
00:52:14 and you apply it to someone with a compromised
00:52:15 physiology because they're homeless
00:52:17 or they're a lifelong alcoholic or they're
00:52:19 a drug addict or they have metabolic
00:52:21 disease or they have they're just
00:52:23 messed up physiologically they're frail you apply that same technique to them that never kills
00:52:29 anybody in your experience and that person that person with the frail physiology they just turn
00:52:34 off they just die i think that's what happened here now importantly jordan neely was actually
00:52:40 alive when the police arrived and daniel penny he had a pulse oh he was oh wow yep uh so it wasn't
00:52:48 You know, you would think if you were choking someone to death, they've got to be dead when you stop choking them.
00:52:54 If they're not dead yet, they start breathing again.
00:52:57 And we know Jordan Neely had a pulse.
00:52:58 We know the other people on the train have testified at his trial.
00:53:02 We hear from news reports that Jordan Neely was, in fact, threatening them with harm.
00:53:05 He wasn't afraid to go to jail, all this kind of stuff.
00:53:09 They were terrified.
00:53:11 So the evidence is overwhelmingly in Daniel Penny's favor.
00:53:14 The law is in his favor.
00:53:15 You're allowed to use force in defense of other people as well as yourself.
00:53:19 But it's a bad outcome case because we have a dead person.
00:53:22 And nobody wanted that person dead.
00:53:24 I'm sure Daniel Penny did not want Jordan Neely dead.
00:53:27 I'm sure no one was more surprised than him.
00:53:29 But here we have a dead body.
00:53:30 And now the prosecutor sees an opportunity to gain political advantage.
00:53:34 Of course, Daniel Penny is white. 0.75
00:53:35 Jordan Neely was black.
00:53:37 So we have that racial energized component again.
00:53:41 So is there anything he could have done differently?
00:53:45 Yeah, he could have not intervened.
00:53:46 Well, yeah.
00:53:48 And if he was going to intervene,
00:53:51 was there anything he could have done differently from your perspective?
00:53:54 You know, I do say in my own gym to my fellow students
00:53:58 that we need to be very careful with these chokes
00:54:01 because we're probably not going to be defending ourselves
00:54:03 against another member of our gym.
00:54:05 We're going to be defending ourselves out on the street
00:54:08 from someone who may well be homeless, alcoholic, drug addict,
00:54:12 and have this frail physiology. 1.00
00:54:14 and you might apply a choke and just kill this person. 0.98
00:54:16 I worked a murder case personally. 0.96
00:54:18 Well, we had a person from our gym
00:54:20 put a choke on a homeless person who was attacking him
00:54:22 and that guy died.
00:54:24 And my fellow gym student got charged
00:54:26 with murder, manslaughter, and criminally negligent homicide.
00:54:29 I had to testify as an expert witness at his trial.
00:54:31 Got him acquitted too, by the way.
00:54:34 But I advise people, listen,
00:54:35 if you have to do a choke to live,
00:54:37 you got to win the fight.
00:54:38 That's the most important thing.
00:54:39 But if you have an option other than a choke,
00:54:41 if you have a joint lock, something else you can do,
00:54:44 because you can put a joint lock on someone's elbow
00:54:46 and destroy their elbow, 0.63
00:54:48 but you're not gonna kill them by destroying their elbow.
00:54:51 Then you avoid that risk of the person just turning off
00:54:53 because you put a choke on them.
00:54:55 So would you advise your clients not to get involved
00:54:58 when they see something happen?
00:55:00 Would you just say it's not worth the risk?
00:55:02 It's a great question.
00:55:03 So I don't tell people what to do.
00:55:06 Everybody has kind of a different moral line
00:55:09 where they feel what the appropriate conduct is.
00:55:12 It's not my job to tell people to intervene or not intervene.
00:55:14 What I try to do is help people make an informed decision.
00:55:19 So if they're intervening,
00:55:20 they know what risks they're incurring.
00:55:22 And the risks of intervening are death and life in prison.
00:55:27 Those are the risks.
00:55:28 You go hands-on in a physical fight,
00:55:31 the risk of losing, of dying in that physical fight
00:55:33 is never zero.
00:55:34 It's something greater than zero.
00:55:37 You get involved in that legal fight,
00:55:38 you get fed into the criminal justice system,
00:55:40 the risk of conviction is never zero.
00:55:42 It's always more than zero.
00:55:44 So I tell people, just imagine
00:55:46 it's gonna go sideways on you.
00:55:48 Let's pretend you survived the fight
00:55:49 because otherwise we have nothing to talk about.
00:55:52 But that you do everything right,
00:55:53 but you still get convicted.
00:55:54 You get convicted, you get sentenced to jail for 20 years.
00:55:57 What's worth 20 years in prison?
00:56:00 There are things.
00:56:01 I'd rather be alive in prison than dead outside of prison.
00:56:04 I'd rather spend 20 years in prison 0.73
00:56:06 than watch my wife or children be killed.
00:56:08 But after that, I kind of run out of reasons I'd be willing to go to prison for 20 years.
00:56:11 Yeah, women you don't know. 1.00
00:56:14 Now, that's just how I think about it.
00:56:16 There are people out there who are going to say, no, it's the right thing to do to intervene and save that person.
00:56:20 And I'm not telling you not to do that.
00:56:22 I'm not telling you not to do that, audience.
00:56:25 If you want to intervene, intervene.
00:56:26 Just make an informed decision knowing what the risks are.
00:56:31 I think if it was me, I mean, because I was on Tim Pool a couple of months ago.
00:56:36 and i'm not i mean you've seen my channel it's not super into politics we just touch on maybe
00:56:43 like the men's rights stuff but one of the stuff one of the topics on the show was i think there
00:56:50 was people on a train watching a woman get um assaulted or raped on it nobody intervened and
00:56:56 everyone looked at me like i was crazy when i said why would he because you know men see this
00:57:01 stuff on the news. And if you don't know her, I don't think that's worth 20 years in prison 0.98
00:57:08 or your life. I got stuff to do. I got four kids to raise. It's a pretty high threshold for me to
00:57:15 be willing to go to prison. Yeah. And you see... By the way, I also think to myself, you know,
00:57:19 when I became an adult, I went out, I got a gun. I got a license to carry that gun. I got trained
00:57:26 in how to use it. I learned what the laws were. I consider that a fundamental adult responsibility.
00:57:30 The ability to protect myself and the people I have a duty to protect from criminal predators.
00:57:36 That person could have done that.
00:57:38 Where's their gun?
00:57:39 Why aren't they defending themselves?
00:57:41 Equal rights, equal left.
00:57:41 Why is their failure to do that make me responsible now for their safety?
00:57:46 Well, in New York, too, you can't...
00:57:49 I'm assuming it's so left you can't carry a gun, right?
00:57:52 It varies a little bit across the state.
00:57:54 So you have kind of the New York City center and then the area around the city.
00:57:57 And then you have upstate New York, which is more rural.
00:58:00 and the the gun laws vary in all those different places within new york city it's all but impossible
00:58:05 to get a concealed carry permit and if you get one in some other part of the state it's not valid
00:58:09 in new york city so what if someone's getting attacked in new york and they shoot them with a
00:58:16 gun that they're not allowed to carry what happens that actually happened so in the i want to say the
00:58:22 1980s there was a guy riding on a subway his name was bernie getz he'd been previously mugged on the
00:58:27 the subway. He'd gone and he'd applied for a New York City concealed carry permit, which technically
00:58:32 exists, but is impossible to get. And they refused to give him one. He went out and got a revolver
00:58:37 anyway. So he was carrying a revolver unlawfully in New York. And sure enough, he gets attacked on
00:58:42 the subway again by four young men with sharpened screwdrivers, threatening him with weapons. He
00:58:47 pulls out his revolver, he shoots him. And then he flees. He actually runs off to Connecticut, 0.99
00:58:53 doesn't report the shooting, but of course it's in all the media, right? A subway vigilante shot
00:58:58 these four young black men on the subway. There's a manhunt out for him. He turns himself in and
00:59:04 he's prosecuted. He's prosecuted for the shooting, the use of force crime, the shooting these four
00:59:09 people, and he's prosecuted for the gun crime. Well, when the jury comes back with a verdict,
00:59:13 they acquitted him of all the use of force crimes. So the shooting itself was lawful,
00:59:18 lawful self-defense. And they convicted him of the gun crime because it was in fact unlawful
00:59:23 for him to have the gun.
00:59:24 So in that kind of situation,
00:59:25 we end up dealing with the use of force stuff,
00:59:28 the self-defense claims on the one hand,
00:59:30 and the gun law stuff on the other hand.
00:59:33 And he was cleared for the shooting
00:59:34 and convicted of the gun.
00:59:36 So did he go to jail?
00:59:38 He went to jail.
00:59:38 For how long?
00:59:40 I think it was a few months.
00:59:42 And then I think he was sentenced maybe to eight months,
00:59:44 and he did four, and then he was released.
00:59:46 But in that case, I mean, that would be worth it
00:59:49 because, I mean, eight months versus...
00:59:53 maybe being dead yeah again i don't tell people what to do so i'm not telling anyone to carry a
00:59:58 gun unlawfully um you know if you kind of do the math and decide well you know would i take a gun
01:00:03 conviction over being dead i don't know people have to make their own choices i never thought
01:00:08 about it like that they might move to a place where it's lawful to carry a gun i mean there's
01:00:14 like 45 states that make it routinely possible to carry a gun lawfully for personal protection
01:00:19 I know because I carry guns in all of them.
01:00:22 I never thought about it like that with the gun.
01:00:26 Like, I mean, we can make money just like the men. 0.93
01:00:28 We can protect it.
01:00:29 Now we have guns, so we can protect ourselves just like the men.
01:00:32 So there's not really an excuse to be in that situation, really.
01:00:36 I mean, you can always carry a gun for the most part.
01:00:40 I will say, you know, it's a little inconvenient to carry a gun.
01:00:44 It's another hunk of metal you have on your body.
01:00:47 It's a responsibility, right?
01:00:48 You have to make sure it's always secure that no unauthorized person can access the gun.
01:00:53 You need to be proficient with it.
01:00:55 So if you're going to use it, you're using it effectively and you're not just sending bullets down the street to strike innocent people.
01:01:01 And you need to be determined enough to use it should it come to that so somebody just doesn't take the gun off you.
01:01:06 And none of that's impossible.
01:01:08 It's not even really very difficult.
01:01:09 We went shooting today.
01:01:10 It was the first time you ever shot a handgun.
01:01:11 You did great.
01:01:12 You were fantastic.
01:01:13 So it's not hard to learn to shoot a handgun well enough for personal protection.
01:01:17 but I think people have to make the affirmative choice to do that and commit themselves to doing
01:01:23 what they need to do to acquire the low but necessary expertise and mindset to be able to
01:01:29 bring it to bear. So I just thought I had a question in my head but I forgot it and it's
01:01:37 really bothering me. Wisdom just wiped it out. No it was such a good question and it's it was
01:01:42 something about oh I can't remember this is going to drive me nuts. I'm going to remember it later.
01:01:47 Faisal Lay says, on October 10th, a driver accused me of hitting his equipment, got aggressive, and shot me, but missed.
01:01:54 Police arrested him.
01:01:55 I may be subpoenaed.
01:01:56 Do I need legal representation?
01:01:59 I mean, if it's easy for you to have legal representation, I would do it.
01:02:03 My general rule of thumb is, you know, people say when you're interacting with the police, just don't talk to the police.
01:02:08 Never talk to the police.
01:02:09 That's the cliche.
01:02:10 I think it's more subtle than that.
01:02:12 I think if you're a criminal, never talk to the police.
01:02:15 So if you're actually a criminal, please don't talk to the police.
01:02:17 Nothing good will happen to you.
01:02:19 On the other hand, if you're attacked and you defend yourself and you're calling 911,
01:02:23 you're calling the police, you're talking to them.
01:02:27 You're telling them what happened.
01:02:29 It doesn't make sense to me that you would defend yourself, call 911,
01:02:33 and it goes, ring, ring, ring, 911, what's your emergency?
01:02:35 And you're literally not going to say anything.
01:02:37 Why bother calling them?
01:02:39 Right.
01:02:40 I do think that it's a fair position kind of in the middle where you're not a criminal.
01:02:44 but you didn't call the police the police called you they want to they just called you we'd like
01:02:51 to ask you questions you can cooperate if you want it's possible to say things that get you in
01:02:57 trouble and you're perfectly entitled and I think it's a reasonable choice when the police when the
01:03:02 police call you and say we have questions to tell them I don't answer questions polite not rude
01:03:11 I'm sorry, I just don't answer questions.
01:03:13 And there's really nothing they can do with that.
01:03:15 If they have probable cause to believe you've committed some crime,
01:03:17 they can arrest you, but they could do that anyway.
01:03:19 You're not giving them more ammunition to use against you.
01:03:25 Or you can just go back to the 1950s
01:03:28 and answer all the questions the cops ask you,
01:03:29 and I just hope it doesn't go sideways.
01:03:33 In the 1950s, it was different?
01:03:36 I think, well, who knows for sure.
01:03:39 We'd like to believe it was a kinder, gentler nation then where there was less law enforcement, malevolence, less of this political dynamic.
01:03:48 I don't know.
01:03:49 I suppose if I spoke to someone who had to deal with the police back then, maybe they would tell me that it's just a figment of my imagination.
01:03:58 Is there a difference between self-defense with the different types of weapons?
01:04:05 so I would imagine the laws are pretty much the same even if it's like a gun a
01:04:11 knife in terms of it's still reasonable doubt or sorry not reasonable doubt
01:04:17 the law doesn't really care what weapon you use it cares a lot about the amount
01:04:22 of force you're using so the law of self-defense puts force into two buckets
01:04:26 there's non-deadly force force not likely to cause death or serious bodily
01:04:30 injury and there's deadly force which means more than death that can kill you
01:04:34 it means force that can cause death or serious bodily injury so a maiming injury a broken bone
01:04:40 that's deadly force even if you would never have died from it um so once you're in the deadly force
01:04:47 bucket you're being threatened with deadly force and you're using deadly force in self-defense
01:04:51 the law doesn't care how you do that it could be using a knife it could be using a gun it could be
01:04:58 running someone over with your car it could be something from the wily coyote cartoons where you
01:05:03 drop a piano from a great height onto their head it doesn't really matter uh the law cares a lot
01:05:09 about whether the conditions for deadly force have been met but it doesn't really care a lot
01:05:13 about what form the deadly force takes yeah that makes sense but again it's a lot more efficient
01:05:20 uh yeah using a knife or a piano from a great height well i'm in london or i would not anymore
01:05:25 but i was in london so it was all stabbings there right i was more it would be weird because
01:05:30 in america it's all it's guns yeah guns but there you would hear about people getting stabbed with
01:05:37 like a machete yeah right and just personally i'd rather get shot than stabbed if i have to go
01:05:43 yeah i can tell you from personal experience that gunshots are way easier uh than than bladed
01:05:49 injuries uh sharp blades create unbelievably grievous injuries you get shot 80 percent of
01:05:55 people in america who are shot with a handgun survive which actually tells us another lesson
01:06:00 which is that if anyone's thinking they're going to point a gun at a bad guy and the bad guy is
01:06:05 just going to run away, that happens a lot, but it's not guaranteed. A lot of bad guys out there,
01:06:10 they've been shot. They're that 80% that's been shot before and survived. They're still bad guys.
01:06:15 They're still on the street. They're not all that scared of your gun. They've been shot before and
01:06:19 they're still here doing bad guy stuff. So you really have to be prepared. If that gun comes out,
01:06:25 you have to be prepared to use that gun. It doesn't mean you have to use the gun.
01:06:29 Maybe they will run away, and then you don't need to shoot them.
01:06:33 That would be nice.
01:06:33 That would be a good outcome.
01:06:35 But you need to be prepared to use it.
01:06:38 What do you mean by prepared?
01:06:40 Like you have to know how to shoot?
01:06:42 You have to be willing to use the gun.
01:06:45 Oh, you can't be scared to pull the trigger because they'll sense that.
01:06:48 They'll know for sure.
01:06:50 Yeah.
01:06:51 Most police officers who are shot are shot with their own guns.
01:06:54 No way.
01:06:55 Yep. 0.90
01:06:55 The bad guy takes the gun off the cop and shoots him with his own gun.
01:06:59 no way how does that happen is it just because they hesitate it's because it's very easy to take
01:07:05 a gun off of somebody it's shockingly easy really yep for one thing the grip on a gun
01:07:13 is generally shorter than the length of the slide so if you're holding the grip you have a short
01:07:19 lever and if they grab the slide they have a long lever they have more leverage than you do 0.83
01:07:23 um so if someone's coming like to grab you just have to shoot them like right away as far as i'm
01:07:31 concerned if they're grabbing for your gun it's no different than they were reaching for a gun on the 0.98
01:07:35 table yeah in fact it's worse because if they're reaching for a gun on the table they're reaching
01:07:40 for a gun but you still have yours if they grab your gun they're arming themselves and disarming
01:07:44 you at the same time i've seen uh in prison surveillance video of prisoners practicing with
01:07:49 each other how to strip guns away they practice with each other how to strip guns away
01:07:56 so they're training are you training no not you but i mean if anyone out there is carrying a gun
01:08:07 and hasn't taken a class in weapons retention how to how to mitigate the risk of having the gun taken
01:08:12 that they're doing it wrong there's an update you need to articulate what you did
01:08:19 i can't understand bob's comments he said 70 percent are shot oh they're shot off duty
01:08:27 of cops oh i don't know about that oh you don't think that's true or you don't know i just never
01:08:33 heard that statistic i'm not sure where it's coming from yeah he said this guy in the chat
01:08:37 says yes it's from bob bob well you can't trust bob isn't he one of the minions what isn't he one
01:08:44 of the minions i don't he um they just pay to get in the live chat and i'll read their stuff
01:08:49 um what do you think's the worst case you've seen in the media where um would you because for me
01:08:59 it'd be derek chauvin would that be the worst one you've seen in terms of like innocent guy
01:09:04 getting put no because i see a lot of bad ones uh there was one recently um i believe the officer's
01:09:10 name was aaron dean police officer he's called to a house in the middle of the night burglary in
01:09:15 progress it's the winter all the doors are open in the house so it looks like it's been ransacked
01:09:20 he shows up there and the first thing he's been trained to do is first search the outside of the
01:09:26 house make sure there's not people lurking so he's walking around the outside of the house with his
01:09:30 flashlight he peers into a window of the house and the other side of the window someone's pointing
01:09:35 a gun at him so he has his own gun in his hand because he's looking for a burglar and he shoots
01:09:40 it turns out the person inside the house was the resident of the house i was a young black woman 0.95
01:09:45 who lived in the house she probably thought it was the burglar a burglar outside the house 0.92
01:09:50 right that she was pointing the gun at and this is a classic example of a a shooting i would say
01:09:57 was awful, but lawful, right?
01:10:00 She didn't need to die.
01:10:01 She wasn't doing anything criminal.
01:10:03 But did he have a reasonable perception
01:10:05 based on the information he knew
01:10:07 that he was facing an imminent,
01:10:09 unlawful, deadly force threat?
01:10:10 He did.
01:10:11 And he got convicted.
01:10:12 I think that was a horribly unjust conviction.
01:10:15 He went to jail?
01:10:16 Yeah, he's in jail right now.
01:10:17 No.
01:10:19 Another case just happened very recently.
01:10:22 Before you go, was there a robber in that one?
01:10:23 No.
01:10:24 Oh, there wasn't even a...
01:10:27 So she just thought there was and there wasn't.
01:10:29 He was searching around the outside of the house.
01:10:31 She probably heard him walking around outside.
01:10:33 It's 2 a.m., 3 a.m. in the morning.
01:10:35 So she probably thought, holy cow, there's somebody sneaking around outside my house.
01:10:39 But she wasn't the one who called the cops?
01:10:41 No, the neighbors across the street called the cops because they called.
01:10:45 They said, hey, we're looking at our neighbor's house.
01:10:47 All the windows and doors are open.
01:10:49 We think there's a burglary going on.
01:10:51 Can you send the cop to check it out?
01:10:52 Because it's the middle of winter at 2 a.m. and the doors are open.
01:10:55 Why were they open?
01:10:56 I don't think we ever knew, actually.
01:10:59 Maybe she's smoking weed or something. 1.00
01:11:01 Well, who knows?
01:11:02 People might smoke funny things.
01:11:04 That's the only reason I could think of.
01:11:07 Or maybe they burned something in the kitchen,
01:11:10 they opened up the doors, and then they fell asleep
01:11:11 or passed out or whatever and forgot the doors were open.
01:11:14 Who knows?
01:11:15 There was another case recently, just this year,
01:11:17 in Wisconsin, the Apple River stabbing case.
01:11:20 Nikolai Mew was 50-ish, fat, quadruple bypass.
01:11:25 a heart patient, floating on the river with his wife and some friends.
01:11:30 One of his friends lost her cell phone in a little floaty bag,
01:11:33 so he wandered around looking for it.
01:11:35 Got into close proximity of some very drunk and high school boys
01:11:38 who started taunting him.
01:11:40 The taunting turned into a fight.
01:11:42 They were beating him into the river, 13 to 1.
01:11:45 And when he came out of the river, he came out with a pocket knife.
01:11:48 And basically, they threw themselves onto his knife.
01:11:51 He stabbed, I think it was three people, one of them fatally.
01:11:55 He didn't stab anyone who wasn't attacking him,
01:11:58 but he was brought to trial and he was convicted.
01:12:01 And I think that was a completely unjust conviction.
01:12:03 I think he had more than a reasonable perception
01:12:05 that he was facing an unlawful, deadly force fight,
01:12:07 that he was going to die in that river
01:12:09 if he didn't take out that knife and defend himself.
01:12:12 But nevertheless, he's convicted.
01:12:13 He's going to spend the rest of his life in prison.
01:12:15 Was it on camera?
01:12:16 What was his name?
01:12:17 It was.
01:12:17 It was caught because the tubers all had their phones out.
01:12:21 What was his name?
01:12:21 I believe it's Nikolai
01:12:24 If you Google Apple River Stabbing
01:12:26 That would probably be the best
01:12:27 He's Romanian so his name has an odd spelling
01:12:30 River Stabbing
01:12:32 That's it, that's the video
01:12:36 That's him
01:12:37 I mean you know this
01:12:39 Is this going to get me flagged on YouTube
01:12:41 I don't know how far they go
01:12:43 I would not play it
01:12:45 Don't put it on the screen, I'm just going to watch it though
01:12:48 One of the victims gets literally
01:12:50 Disemboweled in the river
01:12:51 okay they can't see it so that's it they're yelling at him they're gonna in a moment he's
01:13:03 gonna get punched um so he's looking for his friend's cell phone but why were they attacking
01:13:12 him they were just they were all drunk and they were just making fun of him like teenage boys 0.54
01:13:17 will do they were acting like a little lord of the flies gang he starts walking away from them
01:13:23 here but he's down river so everything's floating towards him so they catch up they're calling him
01:13:30 a child predator they're shouting all kinds of insults at him and he's not doing anything
01:13:37 offensive here they're screaming yelling and right about now he's going to get punched 0.98
01:13:44 a girl is going to come up and yell at him 1.00
01:13:48 right there
01:13:51 what are they yelling at him for?
01:13:54 they're all drunk
01:13:55 yeah but I've been drunk before
01:13:59 and I've never, like for what?
01:14:01 well the others have been calling him a child predator
01:14:03 she may think he's a child predator
01:14:04 she's telling him get away from these kids
01:14:06 oh because he's just kind of not an attractive guy
01:14:11 and so they're just kind of bullying
01:14:12 and a stranger
01:14:13 not part of their group
01:14:15 and that woman comes up and screams in his face again 1.00
01:14:22 he puts his hand up
01:14:23 right there, maintain distance
01:14:25 and one of the guys takes a fence
01:14:28 and punches him into the water
01:14:29 he's surrounded
01:14:36 13 to 1 here
01:14:37 there wow imagine the chaos all these people screaming like there he goes he's in the water
01:14:47 kicked him he's on he's face down they're pushing him down and now he's got the knife in his hand
01:14:53 he doesn't pursue anyone the only people who get stabbed are the people who come to him
01:14:59 that guy got cut pretty bad oh so he came at him
01:15:07 and at this point in the video they realize that people are bleeding and they all start
01:15:13 screaming how could this have happened like they weren't involved i can't believe wow
01:15:21 that's insane so they all attacked him and he went to jail yep prison he's convicted what was
01:15:32 his name i want to get that because i think nicolai mu i believe his last name is miu
01:15:36 a river stack because i think the what i think i saw was him crying like he was a trial was he
01:15:43 saying sorry to them or something yeah i believe this was a sentencing so wow he lost a ton of
01:15:49 weight he lost a ton of weight yep wow you know his wife divorced you can his wife they always
01:15:57 leave no this is why because they knew they were going to get sued so they divorced they agreed to
01:16:04 divorce so she could protect some assets and she testified at trial and the defense lawyer says
01:16:09 did you love your husband that day on the river she said yes do you still love your husband yes
01:16:14 i do did they protect any of their assets i don't know or no i didn't follow it the oh this is really
01:16:22 long okay i was there was some clip i saw which was i think him apologizing to
01:16:29 wow
01:16:32 I don't think he did anything wrong
01:16:33 but once you're convicted and you're going to be sentenced
01:16:35 you say what you need to say to try to get a
01:16:37 mitigated sentence
01:16:38 yeah I don't think
01:16:40 they all frustrated
01:16:43 witness frustrated during cross
01:16:45 examination
01:16:46 witness says Mew defended himself
01:16:50 how did the
01:16:51 teenagers the ones that were 0.86
01:16:53 watching did they all take whose side
01:16:55 I'm assuming they took their friend's son
01:16:57 so one of their friends died
01:16:59 So now this is a mission to avenge their friend.
01:17:03 So one person died?
01:17:05 Yeah, one got disemboweled in the river.
01:17:07 He lived, believe it or not.
01:17:08 What does disemboweled mean?
01:17:09 His abdomen was opened up and his gut spilled into the river.
01:17:13 Oh, my goodness.
01:17:15 So he looks like a different person.
01:17:18 Wow, the system really, if it gets politicized,
01:17:23 that seems to be like the kiss of death is when politics become involved.
01:17:27 Well, it certainly means you're in a fight for your life.
01:17:29 So it doesn't mean you'll be convicted.
01:17:31 Zimmerman wasn't convicted.
01:17:32 Rittenhouse wasn't convicted.
01:17:34 But it certainly ups the stakes, and you're definitely going to trial.
01:17:38 So it's very common in a killing case where a self-defender has been charged with murder or manslaughter
01:17:43 to spend in excess of $200,000 before you even get to trial, and then it just goes up from there.
01:17:50 But if they don't have the money, where does it come from?
01:17:52 To get a public defender.
01:17:53 And those guys are really overworked, right?
01:17:56 They're overworked is the fair way to put it.
01:17:58 They get a bad reputation, like they're bad lawyers.
01:18:01 They're not bad lawyers.
01:18:02 In fact, I would advise anyone who's thinking about going to the law,
01:18:05 if you want trial experience, become a public defender.
01:18:08 You'll get more trial experience there than anywhere else in the world.
01:18:12 If you join a private firm, you won't see the inside of a courtroom for years.
01:18:16 If you're a public defender, you'll be in a courtroom all day, every day of the week.
01:18:19 Often they're the best lawyers, but they are way overworked.
01:18:23 Instead of having one client or five clients at a time, they have 50 or 100.
01:18:26 it's unmanageable and so so i'm guessing more people can be put in jail like unjustly then
01:18:33 because they're that's part of the process they just don't have the time so you know a trial is
01:18:39 a war it's a battle and just like any other war how many resources you can bring to the fight
01:18:44 matters right if you had two nations and one of them had a million people and one of them had a
01:18:48 hundred million people it's not hard to predict who's going to win right that's an interesting
01:18:53 by the way the prosecutor knows this right the prosecutor can see whether or not you have a
01:18:57 public defender or an expensive private lawyer he knows how many resources you have wow it's
01:19:02 so interesting because we grow up thinking that the justice system is fair and i i guess it's
01:19:08 probably more fair than some parts of the world item that would i think it's the best system
01:19:12 anywhere yeah but it still has profound defects yeah because it's run by humans right so
01:19:18 So do you think that money buys freedom, then, by that?
01:19:24 I think it's better to have more resources than fewer resources, for sure.
01:19:28 That's such a lawyer answer.
01:19:31 That's such a good one.
01:19:33 Okay.
01:19:34 Is there anything else important that you think the audience should know about self-defense?
01:19:38 Yeah, they should get my free book, Law of Self-Defense Principles.
01:19:44 Most people read it in an afternoon.
01:19:47 And, again, it's free.
01:19:47 Get it at lawofselfdefense.com slash free book.
01:19:51 Check it out on Amazon.
01:19:52 It's got 1,500 reviews.
01:19:53 It's five-star rated, but don't buy it on Amazon because they'll charge you,
01:19:57 I think it's $20 or $25 for the book, plus shipping and handling.
01:20:00 We only ask you to cover the cost of sending the book to you.
01:20:03 The book itself is free, lawofselfdefense.com slash free book.
01:20:08 That is the best marketing that you can read it in the afternoon
01:20:11 because people that don't read will still get it.
01:20:13 Yeah, I hope so.
01:20:15 I was like, that's such a good tagline.
01:20:17 Okay, well, tell the people where they can find you, too, YouTube, Twitter.
01:20:22 Yeah, I'm on YouTube.
01:20:25 I am on Twitter, but mostly it's like political opinion,
01:20:28 so I don't know if I can encourage people to do that.
01:20:30 But you can find me on Twitter, Law Self-Defense, at Law Self-Defense.
01:20:34 I'm on YouTube.
01:20:37 We're on other social media, but it's all marketing people doing that stuff.
01:20:40 I'm not on there personally, so I don't really know what those people do.
01:20:43 lawofselfdefense.com is the website slash free book for the free book well thanks so much for
01:20:50 coming out and being our first in person it's a nice studio right so i get like a number one
01:20:56 medallion or something no maybe we'll you know we could have like um someday we could have like a
01:21:01 wall signing or something for people that come i don't know but all right guys thanks so much for
01:21:06 watching please make sure you like the video and subscribe on your way out and also if you guys
01:21:11 want to see me imagine imagine that I could interview Chauvin or some of these guys that get
01:21:17 that the whole media is against butt pearl the only way I can do that is if I have a lot of you
01:21:24 on the audacitynetwork.com so please go there like the video on your way out and subscribe
01:21:30 to the channel bring that notification bell and I will see you next time
01:21:41 You