Pearl - June 15, 2025
The Myth of Masculinity: How History and Modern Dating Are Lying to You w⧸ @ItsComplicatedChannel
Episode Stats
Words per minute
206.92874
Harmful content
Misogyny
26
sentences flagged
Toxicity
1
sentences flagged
Hate speech
17
sentences flagged
Summary
In this episode, I sit down with a man who is a historian and writer to discuss the history of masculinity in America and how it has changed over the past century. We discuss how masculinity has changed since the early 20th century and how that has impacted the way we view masculinity in modern America.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
so what do you think is different today than like sorry what part do you mean it wasn't this way
00:00:06.160
for all of history wouldn't you say for most of history men like were the head of their household
00:00:11.840
like they did provide to some extent i know there was the dowry that women brought but it came from
0.82
00:00:17.200
her dad not her right um well like uh okay let's let's go back to like maybe the 1970s i wasn't
00:00:23.280
necessarily alive then but i'm saying yeah yeah if you talk about you know back then it was
00:00:27.360
you know make love not war um i think that we were kind of like a little bit more um uh headed
00:00:34.080
towards equality uh uh back then i think that uh okay look at it this way you had during the vietnam
00:00:41.120
war you had women actually marching for you know men being sent off to die in war oh i see and now
00:00:47.920
today it's like you're not a real man if you don't fight in war okay not not only not only that but i
00:00:53.520
i mean look at the the male um deletion rate right and it's like okay so um why aren't women
1.00
00:01:01.120
marching for those for those lives today yeah you could you didn't they do like a million man march a
00:01:07.600
while ago you're talking about like in the 90s yeah yeah i know i know that's i was thinking like
00:01:12.480
it was in the night like no time recently yeah i don't think that i think that was more uh uh due to um
00:01:18.160
police brutality and you know and racism and stuff like that i think it had more to do with that than it
00:01:22.400
had to do with just kind of like oh really as far as i remember i think it had something to do with
00:01:27.840
like the rodney king oh i did i totally thought it was for me i don't know i wasn't a lot or if i was
00:01:33.600
i was like five so yeah well we're trying to like i said we're trying to um do forensic investigations on
00:01:39.040
you know what happened in the past and you know how it correlates in a modern context yeah and that's
00:01:44.720
the tough thing women are so good at rewriting history too so you have to like sift through so
1.00
00:01:49.280
many historical documents to even find like the like um i just said this is sean the channel and
00:01:54.800
he was um talking about the dowry in depth and i couldn't believe like why don't conservatives talk
00:02:00.560
about that yeah i mean exactly and uh so just just more people should ask like what is a dowry and uh
00:02:08.640
i just did an episode on this um inspired kind of like by what he was talking about he actually did a
00:02:15.200
a fantastic conversation with paul elam about this bringing this up and so it's like okay when you
00:02:22.080
think about it you know some of the most masculine men throughout history like you know julius caesar
00:02:27.440
and uh king henry the eighth they took dowries and yet today we're being told that you're not a real
00:02:33.440
man unless you pay 100 of the bills to put the woman in her feminine so when you talk about rewriting
1.00
00:02:39.600
history this idea that you know men just have to this is the way it's supposed to be and it
00:02:46.000
couldn't possibly be any other way even though when you look back in history it wasn't always that way
00:02:51.360
so why are we conveniently ignoring those those arguments so i i want to see more kind of people
00:02:58.880
being challenged on what they're saying and not just the feminists but i want to see you know a lot
0.97
00:03:03.600
of these influencers and masculinity coaches and pickup artists and stuff like that i want to see them all
00:03:08.560
get challenged because at the end of the day we're all just searching for truth but i don't like like
00:03:14.160
when i ask questions i'm not necessarily trying to tell people what to think i just want them to
00:03:18.240
think for themselves and i'm trying to extract the truth and sometimes i have a perception of what i
00:03:23.360
think the truth is but by no means am i saying i have all the answers i'm just you know go ahead
00:03:29.200
and change my mind let's let's try to figure this out but you know these are real issues and these
00:03:33.360
are real problems and we want to have real solutions and not just sit here and you know try to sell
00:03:37.920
people a fantasy that is unattainable so how would you how do you think child care should go so like
00:03:45.520
you get past that you go 50 50 on the relationship now you're both working the kids under three need
00:03:52.960
someone to watch them who does it well i mean i know there's the with the tender years doctrine and
00:03:58.320
you know people typically go to the idea that women are better um i don't think that so well i mean
00:04:04.480
obviously if women are having abortions and stuff i mean you know do they really um i'm just curious
00:04:09.520
because you were saying you'd like to see um you'd like to see some of the masculine duties be
00:04:15.600
challenged and so i was just curious how you would see the like young years of a kid going i think uh
00:04:22.960
well i think that that men can be good fathers if uh you know it really just comes down to who has the
00:04:31.760
opportunity to be um to who has the opportunity to be present who wants to be present and who wants
00:04:39.200
to you know have uh um a strong connection with their children i i haven't really thought that much
00:04:45.120
about it to be honest okay i think that that it's something that uh like someone said to me okay who
00:04:49.920
would you trust uh running a daycare center a bunch of women or a bunch of men right and automatically
0.86
00:04:55.600
most people assume that you know i would leave my child with a bunch of women instead of a bunch of men
1.00
00:05:00.160
and you know yeah i'd trust the men more really okay well just because i've looked at like child
00:05:06.000
abuse stats like women are more violent towards kids okay well like i said that uh that's something
0.91
00:05:12.320
that obviously you know should be looked at more so yeah okay i was just curious because it's like
00:05:16.640
under five who like i mean once they're in preschool and up it's like a different story where both parents
00:05:23.520
can work but i think one parent has to you know i'm not saying it should be the man or the woman but i was
00:05:28.880
just kind of curious i've had a lot of women say things like you know now that women are expected
1.00
00:05:33.520
to uh be breadwinners along with the men um you know women almost feel like oh well you know we have
00:05:40.160
to you know um uh be the homemaker the caretaker and uh and also make money and the men are just you
00:05:48.640
know the breadwinners so the men need to step up more and help us more around the house i think kind
00:05:53.440
of where we're headed is kind of everyone's kind of going to be expected to do everything
00:05:56.720
um but it just depends on what's more convenient obviously if a woman is pregnant then it makes
1.00
00:06:02.720
sense for the man to definitely step up and you know help her but at some point my mom ran a marathon
00:06:08.800
six months pregnant i think they over exaggerate well i mean to to a degree but i'm saying that
00:06:13.760
obviously um you know uh someone wrote a really excellent comment that i you know i mean i learned
00:06:18.800
more things from my comments as well but someone wrote that um a uh an employer is going to basically
00:06:25.840
expect a woman to get back to work after 12 weeks so at some point you know why can't a husband do
0.99
00:06:32.560
that because women what's the uh the question i had is like why are women more willing to submit to their
0.99
00:06:38.160
employer than they're going to submit to their husband and children so so what do you think um
00:06:44.880
you mentioned that you'd like to see some things change in the space um what are they there's too much
00:06:52.960
blame on men and i think there's too much focus on masculinity and not enough focus on the misandry
00:06:59.520
and whenever we do talk about misandry we only talk about the misandry that comes from women we
00:07:05.360
don't talk about the misandry that comes from other men we look at shaming women as hate but when we shame
00:07:11.760
men it's motivation and i think why aren't they both hate why why why have we come to assess the average
00:07:20.320
man is unacceptable and he has to change and improve what's what's wrong i mean you know i i get it like
00:07:25.920
i'm not against the idea of self-improvement i'm not telling men like be a loser and don't ever you
00:07:30.720
know achieve anything but you know sometimes men have a right to enjoy life yeah yeah yeah and and
00:07:38.720
sometimes i mean i see rants online from guys who are good-looking guys and shouldn't even have a
00:07:43.440
problem and they're exhausted they they run into burnout because they feel like you know it's it's never
00:07:48.320
going to be enough and so um and and the other thing is it's like there's this idea that just because
00:07:54.320
you know men are appreciated somehow that validates a lot of the sacrifices that men are expected to
00:07:59.440
make and i think that you know we can't just um like like why would women appreciate the sacrifices
0.85
00:08:06.800
that men make if they're just going to continue making those sacrifices so i think that either women
00:08:11.200
have to have a duty or neither one of them have to have a duty or something like that but it's the
00:08:15.680
double standards in our society that persist that you know have to change um and what's interesting
00:08:22.240
is it's like well why does the manosphere complain about double standards but then just say well men
00:08:26.480
and women are different well then so are you saying double standards are okay so there's there's a lot
1.00
00:08:31.440
of contradictions i see in the manosphere that i'd like to challenge them on but then if i call out the
00:08:36.640
manosphere for some inconsistencies then they're going to label me a feminist and say i'm clearly not a
0.85
00:08:41.680
feminist have you done a back and forth with myron ever have you ever like done a debate not really
00:08:47.760
i would love to i think he would i think he'd maybe do it it would i would love to watch it just as a
00:08:52.720
viewer because i know he does a lot with his call-in shows or he tells them to like like i watched this
00:08:58.640
one and i like this is not me throwing shot at him i like myron he's a good guy but i saw him like do a
00:09:05.920
call-in show where um what was it he had a couple on the show and they both made money and he basically
00:09:14.880
told like the girl was a little bit ahead in her career because she was like military or something
00:09:19.840
okay um and he was telling the guy that he wasn't doing enough but i was looking at her i'm like she's
00:09:24.480
fat yeah like you can like i was like i'm like she's got to get on the tread you know what i mean
00:09:32.960
before we're gonna say she deserves uh uh like do you know what i mean i'm like she's got to be in
00:09:39.120
shape to at least like well that's that's the thing when you when you're talking about all the
00:09:43.360
expectations placed on men you know you gotta you gotta be jacked and you gotta be six feet tall and
00:09:47.600
six figures and it's like well women can't even do the bare minimum and just be you know eat less
1.00
00:09:52.560
yeah we don't even have to work out we just have to eat less right is it harder to grow muscles or
00:09:56.800
just not overeat yeah or is it harder to lose lose weight or gain height you know what i mean so so
00:10:01.360
there are things that men are shamed for that we can't even control women have more control over
0.61
00:10:06.000
the things that you know that we shame them for i mean obviously when it comes to like men being
00:10:10.080
shamed for being incels and women being shamed for being sluts women control their body count way
1.00
00:10:15.280
more than most men do because women are the control axis yeah the gatekeepers and stuff so so um but as far
0.94
00:10:21.760
as um the other thing also i think that that there's this concept going around the manosphere
00:10:26.880
called hoflation right men have to work men today have to work five times harder than their grandfathers
00:10:31.600
did for women 20 times worse than their grandmother what their grandmothers were and yet if we're telling
00:10:38.480
men that women have these delusional expectations now go out and meet fulfill those delusional expectations
0.85
00:10:45.680
are we not feeding the very hoflation problem that we're complaining about yeah i just think there's always
00:10:51.280
going to be guys that are like that's my only choice do you know what i mean i'm not i'm not
00:10:56.000
saying they should or they shouldn't i'm really not here to tell guys how to date i don't i've never
00:11:00.880
dated women so i just don't have an opinion on like that uh but i just you know like i've interviewed
00:11:07.600
guys where they're just like like i had a friend in london i'd never met him i'd never he had never had
00:11:15.040
a girlfriend that like expected him to not cheat like it was always a one-sided open thing and
00:11:21.280
talking him out of like because he kind of did all the stuff like he got the muscles he's a really
00:11:26.400
success i'm not i'm not going to say the industry but he was very like good in his field and i'm like
00:11:32.320
if you would tell him well you're feeding women's delusional expect he would say i don't care
1.00
00:11:37.760
like i have my five women i don't like i do not care right and like the way he would i just i know
00:11:46.560
him so he what he would say is he'd say something like well then why don't like i did all this work
00:11:51.680
why didn't you do all this work right um i'm not saying that's right or wrong but i'm just curious
00:11:57.360
how you would respond to something like that i mean typically you know when the man does the work it's
00:12:02.240
it's the you know the mindset where why does a society that tells a man he doesn't deserve a
00:12:07.040
woman when he's broke i have any right to tell that man he only deserves one woman when he's rich
00:12:11.840
so the man is going to say well i've done the work now i'm a high status high value man now i'm going
00:12:16.640
to exercise my options and so are women willing to you know share those men or are they willing to
00:12:22.080
settle for more average men if they want the loyalty so it's kind of you know i saw this guy do
00:12:28.400
like i was like he he would bring like two like two girls that he was like hooking up with to a
00:12:36.560
party he just did not care he's like leave me well that's what i'm saying i think that that modern
00:12:43.280
women today are are almost like concert groupies they just want to be with a rock star or they want
1.00
00:12:48.560
to be you know i mean they want to be that trophy that arm candy and stuff you know i will say though
00:12:53.680
i used to think the money mattered more to women than it does i've seen a lot of women from the
1.00
00:12:59.600
show just sleep with like bar like guys in certain positions like they really like bartenders like
00:13:05.840
aren't club promoters broke and they're always yeah well i mean so they'll go for a broke chad basically
00:13:10.640
someone who's just yeah or just in the right like comedians they're kind of like a lot of them aren't
00:13:16.640
like super good looking but they're funny yeah you know i was wondering about that also it's kind of
00:13:21.360
like when you look at like you know the sexiest men alive you know we're we're you know you know
00:13:26.480
famous comedians on there and stuff or you know i don't know but you know obviously they've they've
00:13:31.600
always said that you know women love you know men who make them laugh i just this reminds me of
00:13:36.480
something i saw where it was like this guy was at a party and he was getting no attention from women
00:13:41.360
and he was like screw this so he went and got his guitar and came back yeah but i mean yeah and i'm not
00:13:48.240
saying it's right but i'm like the guys that like figure out a cheat code i'm like you're not gonna
00:13:53.760
talk them out of like five women good luck yeah but i mean but but you know then you talk to these
1.00
00:14:00.400
guys who are like passport bros and you know they go overseas and then what i call passport bros is
00:14:05.920
almost like it's a shortcut to becoming a high value man because you know your average man is already
00:14:11.680
kind of considered a high value man in the eyes of foreign women he's already good enough yeah and so
00:14:16.320
um i think that uh you know that's why you you hear these stories about guys going to thailand
00:14:22.960
and then you know they'll get all these matches on a dating app and then women will drive you know
1.00
00:14:27.920
two three four hours to come see you and and and drive you around and take you around and stuff so it's
00:14:33.920
it's kind of like that that role reversal um going back to what i was saying about the uh you know some
00:14:39.680
of the issues i have with the the manosphere um i kind of believe that a lot of the advice or the
00:14:45.440
prescriptions even though we're told that red pill doesn't give prescriptions but i think it does
00:14:50.160
um we're kind of just told move or improve um you know be a passport bro or you know work on yourself
00:14:58.800
um but work on yourself for you but you know don't do it for women do it for you even though
00:15:03.360
we're not shaming the migtaos who aren't even playing the game you know it's like why aren't we
0.92
00:15:07.760
shaming migtaos to improve for themselves anyway um i think a lot of it's just coping it's not
00:15:14.080
you know it's basically just saying this is what we're kind of stuck dealing with now you made
00:15:19.520
a great point once where you said um you know if men had 20 30 beautiful women in their inbox
00:15:27.440
dming them saying let me come over and let me cook for you and massage you and everything
0.70
00:15:32.560
don't you think it would be hard to get a man to commit oh yeah so impossible that guy is
00:15:39.040
that the guy i i know he's cheating for life he's like it's just never gonna happen so so once again
00:15:44.880
it comes down to the fact that now that's exactly the position women are in they have all these thirsty
1.00
00:15:49.440
simps after them so women are basically have the privilege of being more picky because they have
1.00
00:15:55.200
more options so you know men would probably do a lot of the same things if they had the options as
1.00
00:16:02.640
well i think the problem is the game is so rigged to one side that we just don't have the ability
00:16:09.200
to have any bargaining power i think that our bargaining chips have taken away have been taken
00:16:13.600
away from us our bargaining chip used to be the idea that you know we were the ones who who made the
00:16:19.360
money but then ever since you know women got equal employment opportunities in the workforce and
1.00
00:16:23.440
they're taking half the jobs now i mean i you asked this question um if we want men to be providers
00:16:30.000
are we going to remove equal employment opportunities which are preventing men from
00:16:33.760
fulfilling the provider roles that we're advocating for so so you know women want to have their cake and
1.00
00:16:39.280
eat it too while men can't even have a cake can't have a cake or even eat one so we have to look at
0.99
00:16:45.280
what's going on culturally and within the laws and i think you know we're we're identifying the symptoms
00:16:52.320
but we're not looking at the root cause what's causing these things
00:16:59.440
are we going to take the feeling we're identifying the answers that oh