Anarcho-Tyranny In Action
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
174.3417
Summary
The McSpencer Group discusses how the federal government is getting more involved in policing the protests, riots, and chaos that s taking place across the U.S. in response to the Black Lives Matter protests in cities across the country.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
It's Sunday, July 26th, 2020, and welcome back to the McSpencer Group.
00:00:06.620
We submit to the Schmidt. Joining me today are Edward Dutton and Tyler Hamilton.
00:00:16.820
America, it seems, is breaking down. The BLM demonstrations just won't end,
00:00:22.640
and these peaceful protests are getting really violent.
00:00:26.320
Cities look like war zones. Elected officials are joining in and getting gassed.
00:00:32.480
Boomers, who just wanted to grill, now look like they're ready to kill.
00:00:37.140
A federal response from the Trump administration was all but inevitable.
00:00:41.180
But instead of the police or National Guard taking back the streets,
00:00:44.740
we get shadowy, masked figures in camouflage, driving minivans, swooping in to apprehend organizers.
00:00:52.880
Does Washington view its own territory, much like it does the Middle East?
00:00:57.720
A place full of foreigners, where the only form of engagement is black ops.
00:01:09.040
when it comes to dealing with the protests and riots and chaos
00:01:16.060
that have eventuated after the George Floyd incident.
00:01:21.340
So we are, I don't even know what week we're on this.
00:01:25.740
I guess the bigger question is when this will ever end.
00:01:29.600
But we've seen protests of the goofy, quasi-religious nature.
00:01:39.320
We've seen a semi-sovereign state in the middle of Seattle for a little bit by Roz Al-Soundcloud,
00:01:51.900
And we are now seeing some kind of federal response.
00:01:57.200
Now, I would say that people like us, along with probably the majority of conservatives,
00:02:05.780
wanted to see a kind of outright, open, mano-a-mano suppression of the riots and violence.
00:02:18.460
They wanted the police to come out in force and put it down.
00:02:23.720
Maybe the National Guard, Trump, indicated that he was interested in doing that a few weeks ago.
00:02:31.140
The other night, I re-watched The Dark Knight Rises.
00:02:34.320
And in the climactic moment of that film, all of the Gotham City police officers who were stuck out of ground
00:02:43.680
just come out in broad daylight and fight Bane and his thugs alongside Batman.
00:02:50.300
I think that that movie is a conservative film, and it's, I mean, for better and for worse.
00:02:55.060
And clearly, Bane is a kind of almost like conservative nightmare of BLM or Occupy Wall Street
00:03:09.120
But again, they were openly put down by the police.
00:03:12.760
In the words of Matthew Modine, there's only one police force in this town.
00:03:17.640
But I don't think we're ever going to see that.
00:03:20.540
And instead, what we seem to be seeing, what seems to be the ultimate solution by Trump and company,
00:03:28.320
is to treat the U.S. kind of like they treat the Middle East, and that is black ops.
00:03:35.480
Now, these aren't entirely black because in the sense of being completely secretive,
00:03:44.220
And we're now seeing countless images of camouflaged masked men in minivans, of all things,
00:03:55.980
going around and sometimes grabbing the leaders of the protest movement,
00:04:04.120
There have been some, you know, some scenes of a transsexual antifa or BLM or whatever leader
00:04:12.100
being pressed to the ground and thrown into a van.
00:04:17.980
And so basically, the United States is kind of becoming like the Middle East.
00:04:21.640
And so this organization called BORTAC, which is connected with the border control,
00:04:28.280
seems to be the organization that is being used.
00:04:31.320
And actually, the leader of that group has openly confirmed that.
00:04:35.320
There are actually some new information that Trump might very well be using such techniques
00:04:41.600
in Chicago, where not only have there been, you know, COVID, massive COVID outbreaks, massive protests,
00:04:49.460
there's also just been Chicago being Chicago in the summer, which means serious death.
00:04:55.740
And there's actually been a lot of very heartbreaking deaths of infants and children.
00:05:05.920
There's not going to be an open suppression done by the police.
00:05:10.620
Instead, we are going to treat the United States as the Middle East and engage in black,
00:05:20.080
And there's this weird situation where there's an almost constitutional crisis.
00:05:24.840
I'm not sure it's going to amount to much, but where these local liberal officials are
00:05:30.420
kind of saying, you know, we have our constitutional rights and the federal government's encroaching
00:05:39.160
Our state's rights almost sounds a little bit like that, although I don't think it will
00:05:49.440
Do you want to pick up on some of these threads or bring in something new?
00:05:55.920
Yeah, well, it's interesting because one thing I noticed is that some of them, like the representatives
00:06:00.220
in Portland, were actually outright saying, you know, shouldn't conservatives be defending
00:06:04.360
us because they historically have been defending the idea of states' rights?
00:06:08.300
And they've been using this, like, secondary mode of resistance against the federal government
00:06:13.580
by trying to prop up their own authority on the local and state level against the federal
00:06:20.280
And so you have this situation where it's like they're openly saying, like the mayor,
00:06:24.800
for example, the mayor Wheeler, he outright said, you know, the reason Trump is doing this
00:06:28.240
is because his numbers are staggering and he needs to attack the Black Lives Matter movement
00:06:35.820
And then at the same time, they're saying they're trying to stop this peaceful protest,
00:06:42.080
which is obviously you have to, like, rewrite reality when you say something like that because
00:06:48.760
And they're saying they're trying to stop the spread of Black Lives Matter.
00:06:52.000
That's what Trump's trying to do, to appeal to his racist base because his numbers are staggering.
00:06:56.180
So you have this inter-elite warfare going on at the level of rhetoric and who they're
00:07:02.020
And so I think this goes back, I guess, to the whole question of anarcho-tyranny, which
00:07:06.560
Francis was talking about before, where you have this weird situation in which there's
00:07:12.380
an over-policing when it comes to law-abiding citizens that we've seen in the past few weeks.
00:07:18.840
When it comes to, like, the couple outside of their house, with their weapons.
00:07:23.820
And there's been quite a few instances of that, or the pregnant woman who pulled a gun
00:07:30.240
And so you have this, but then you have a situation where you can just quickly look at
00:07:34.680
You could see buildings being burnt down, police stations attacked, people beaten in the
00:07:41.880
And Trump's just trying to stop her peaceful protests.
00:07:46.960
And the state's rights, it's not the federal right to intervene on this.
00:07:50.320
So then you have, of course, Trump's new tactic, what's going on here, which is, like
00:07:55.900
you said, it's not like actually just bringing in full force and just putting a stop to it.
00:08:00.660
It's this weird tactic of bringing, grabbing people here and there, pulling them in for
00:08:05.200
questioning instead of just clamping down on it right away, which would actually, of
00:08:12.080
So it's a really newer situation for America, I think.
00:08:15.960
I mean, back even in the 60s, when they had these kind of riots going on, they were just
00:08:21.220
But now when they send to the National Guard, they do the Macarena with the protesters.
00:08:26.860
But it's it's it's a different, interesting situation.
00:08:32.060
I'll throw it to Ed for now before I say any more on it.
00:08:36.420
I think that it is a it is an interesting it's not an unpredictable situation.
00:08:44.800
It reminds me of the sort of Jonathan Haidt, Five Moral Foundations kind of idea.
00:08:48.880
The Five Moral Foundations are care, fairness, hierarchy, disgust and group loyalty.
00:08:54.180
And there's research from Haidt, which has found that conservatives are roughly equal in
00:08:59.540
all of those, although extreme conservatives tend to be very high in hierarchy, disgust
00:09:04.220
and loyalty and not so high in fairness and care.
00:09:06.620
Whereas the leftists are high in fairness and care, but they are pretty much absent in
00:09:13.320
terms of things like hierarchy, disgust and in group loyalty.
00:09:16.280
And what that means is that the leftists can hijack people on the right because the right,
00:09:22.440
the people on the conservatives, they can empathize with those on the left because they
00:09:26.680
have a sense of care and a sense of fairness as well, a sense of equality, whatever.
00:09:31.560
But the left cannot understand those who are on the right at all because they don't
00:09:38.360
They don't share any sympathy for the things which affect and which are important to people
00:09:43.940
And so you can see how people that are on the left can basically use this relationship
00:09:48.360
to hijack and to manipulate those that are on the right and push things in an ever more
00:09:54.160
leftward direction, push the culture in an ever more leftward direction, manipulate people
00:10:01.460
This is what's happened since the war, really, but particularly in the last 30 or 40 years,
00:10:05.800
ever more concerned with care and fairness, equality.
00:10:09.280
Those are the big things, care, harm avoidance and fairness, equality.
00:10:16.700
I mean, at my son's nursery school, they were asked, we were asked, if you don't send your
00:10:23.720
kid in with birthday invitations to give out because it might hurt the feelings of the
00:10:30.680
Instead, here's a list of all the parents' phone numbers, ring up the parents and invite
00:10:39.160
And so we have a society that is so brainwashed with the importance of care and harm avoidance
00:10:44.780
and is so unable to cope with the idea of harm, the idea of hurting yourself, the idea of
00:10:49.180
violence, that to send in the army or the National Guard or the police or whatever, he's got to
00:10:55.000
get that balance right between doing something, between not offending against a society that
00:11:01.220
is so, even conservative people that are so concerned about the idea of care and harm
00:11:07.440
and, oh God, you know, we can't have that, we can't have hurting people, we can't have
00:11:10.020
people hurting, getting even slightly injured, even emotionally injured.
00:11:13.840
And the fact that what you end up with when you have extreme leftism and why there's always
00:11:17.900
a backlash, always there's a backlash, a right-wing backlash, eventually, is that you have a
00:11:23.380
society that is increasingly an evolutionary mismatch.
00:11:26.540
We are evolved to find all five of these foundations important.
00:11:30.520
The average person involves all five of these foundations important.
00:11:33.460
The leftist can hijack society because of his extreme concern about care and fairness and push
00:11:41.060
it in that direction to such an extent that the other three foundations are neglected.
00:11:44.880
And then, of course, the result is we have an evolutionary mismatch and people are unhappy.
00:11:50.220
But those people have been indoctrinated and brainwashed with this importance of care and
00:11:59.060
Well, one way is that you don't have anything public.
00:12:01.460
You don't have a Tiananmen Square type of situation.
00:12:05.580
But you clearly are doing something to redress the balance behind the scenes and letting that
00:12:12.640
So I think in a society that's utterly brainwashed with the importance of care and harm avoidance
00:12:17.900
and, you know, my child cried because my child didn't get a party invitation or whatever,
00:12:22.860
this is perhaps the most sensible tactic to engage in.
00:12:26.420
And as for Richard's comment about a foreign country, and Richard and I were discussing this
00:12:33.320
I thought that was very interesting because if you think about it, when you go into a
00:12:39.420
foreign country as soldiers, part of the reason why you have to engage in black ops, part of
00:12:44.600
the reason why you have to be very cautious, because you don't know how they're going to
00:12:53.580
And in a society that's utterly polarised, where the left is so extreme, so unhinged,
00:13:02.640
They say falseness is truth and truth is falseness and right is wrong and whatever, you know,
00:13:11.720
And so therefore, the best thing to do is to treat them like foreigners.
00:13:15.280
We're so polarised that we're basically two separate foreign groups.
00:13:19.980
And so to go in there, maybe that's when the North went into the South during the Civil
00:13:24.440
Would they have treated them more like foreigners?
00:13:26.640
But you treat them more because that's what they kind of are, because they're so different
00:13:32.640
Well, yeah, I mean, they reconstructed them to a very serious degree, although that did start
00:13:41.100
But yeah, they were definitely treated as a foreign enemy that needed to be educated,
00:13:49.580
So that would be Congress with this idea that what you've got is that America is so come
00:13:55.280
apart, in the words of whoever it was, is it Charles Murray who said that?
00:13:59.040
But it's so divided, so polarised that you're treating them as foreigners because there's
00:14:04.380
no fundamental way on which you think in the same way.
00:14:07.940
Whereas perhaps in the late 60s, when it was all the riots around the time that Nixon was
00:14:12.160
elected and around that time, then at least there's a certain level on which you kind of
00:14:17.840
trust each other, kind of, kind of all Americans.
00:14:23.040
And this is a usurpation within that group, and you can put it down.
00:14:27.800
You're dealing with a level of hatred and difference that is so profound that perhaps
00:14:33.000
the best way is to treat them like what they really are, which is foreigners.
00:14:37.020
I mean, these are an occupying power within part of America.
00:14:46.000
Um, yeah, I mean, I'm glad that that Tyler mentioned an arc of tyranny because the Sam
00:14:51.640
Francis concept and I and I think it's a it's a very valid one, but I almost feel like it's
00:15:00.400
I think the black ops engaged in by Bortak or whatever, are almost like the the other
00:15:07.220
side of the coin of the what all of these horrifying images that we saw of, you know, National
00:15:14.440
Guard or police doing the Macarena with people or kneeling or joining the protests themselves.
00:15:21.580
That was the an almost like comical expression of soft power.
00:15:28.760
I mean, why do you have a police force if it's not to maintain order in your society?
00:15:34.740
Why do you have an army if it's not to go kill people with it?
00:15:39.000
I mean, that is the essence of these types of organizations.
00:15:42.360
They are they are the brutal end of the spear tip of the spear of the state.
00:15:47.620
And yet in our kind of postmodern world, we've we've depicted these as almost not what they
00:15:55.700
Navy is a global force for good, as they describe themselves.
00:15:59.040
So they're like a humanitarian organization or charity or something.
00:16:06.680
You know, we're not here to, you know, do anything to.
00:16:09.100
Is it this weird kind of velvet glove, you could say, on an iron fist or kind of so on?
00:16:16.000
But then it's kind of the other side of the coin, which is things are kind of getting out
00:16:22.880
They the you know, the even the Roz Simone thing, which, you know, didn't eventuate into
00:16:28.500
anything outside of a three week long, you know, weird, semi sovereign state that just doing that
00:16:37.020
you're you're you're testing the limits of what the state will tolerate.
00:16:43.140
This these protests are not just some like simulated corporate act.
00:16:48.920
They can get out of control and the state has to respond.
00:16:54.540
It has to respond of like the National Guard during the Macarena or the flip side of that,
00:17:00.360
the black ops and weird minivans and mass characters, you know, grabbing people off the
00:17:14.220
It can't be itself in a way that will go ahead.
00:17:21.940
I think if it acts too openly, then you will inflame the leftist nutters even even further
00:17:28.740
and you will get more more degeneration into more violence.
00:17:32.960
But if you don't act at all, then they will they will come, as I say, as I would suggest,
00:17:37.820
a kind of right wing backlash or sort of a backlash against the entire system, a reassertion
00:17:42.840
of these three moral foundations that have been ignored for so long.
00:17:46.300
So many people feel unhappy about and they don't want that either because it would also
00:17:56.560
And that would I suggest be what they're doing.
00:17:58.900
And as for a narco tyranny, what does narco tyranny involve?
00:18:02.520
Basically, it's the idea that you need to brainwash the population so that they don't
00:18:06.740
question the ruling class or the managerial class or the class that makes money.
00:18:14.980
You let that sort of you don't really bother controlling that.
00:18:17.880
You let that control itself through through protection rackets, I suppose, or whatever
00:18:22.240
you end up with in response to a lack of law and order.
00:18:27.480
Well, what's the difference between this narco tyranny?
00:18:29.980
He's he's coined Sam Francis and just the concept of just Tudor England.
00:18:34.740
I mean, that's what that's what that's what a lot of a lot of countries now around the world.
00:18:41.600
That's what it's what 16th century England was like.
00:18:43.940
You have a system where the ultimately the population have to be kept in line,
00:18:49.440
arguably, so they don't fundamentally question the system.
00:18:52.440
The state lacks the power, really, to enforce the law.
00:18:58.480
You therefore have a gangland where gangs black lit out and the law is occasionally enforced
00:19:03.440
on a corrupt basis, depending on who has power and who decides to do so.
00:19:07.340
And lots of people can just get away with crimes.
00:19:09.500
And that was the system of just corrupt society.
00:19:20.740
But what I was pushing towards is how it's a little bit outmoded, because let me try to
00:19:24.880
get at some of the kind of contradictions that are that are going on.
00:19:27.760
So, I mean, I mentioned the Dark Knight Rises and Bain came in and, you know, brought Gotham
00:19:35.020
And, you know, if you can go to these protesters and find revolutionary statements in a way
00:19:44.660
that you could not find revolutionary statements like that in, say, the Charlottesville protest
00:19:51.100
No one said we're taking over the government or we're we're bringing about chaos or something.
00:19:56.100
You can find everyday protesters saying we are going to end the United States as you
00:20:04.140
We are going to fundamentally transform with Roz Al-Simon.
00:20:08.640
There was a bit of a revolution there going on.
00:20:15.420
He was questioning sovereignty and questioning law and order.
00:20:18.460
At the same time, the on the other side of this, what we've seen is that the BLM protests
00:20:27.720
I mean, there were some amazing images that I was reposting on Twitter a couple of weeks
00:20:33.340
embassy in many of these countries having big rainbow flags and saying BLM and like Black
00:20:40.420
Lives Matter in Korea or whatever, you know, gay rights and wherever Somalia, wherever the
00:20:47.120
And so there's this weird contradiction where the protesters are at one point saying that
00:20:56.560
The system, it's not even that it's corrupt so much as it is wicked, that it's white supremacists,
00:21:03.700
They are at least rhetorically directly challenging the state.
00:21:07.680
And to some degree, they are actually attacking federal buildings.
00:21:13.220
At the same time, they're doing it through the ideology of the state.
00:21:23.200
military empire doesn't fundamentally disagree with the protest.
00:21:31.140
It's a bizarre situation where I think it's almost anarcho-tyranny on kind of a new level.
00:21:36.380
Listen, this was what I was getting at when I was saying this is an unprecedented new example
00:21:42.820
compared to how these things were dealt with in the past, like looking at the 60s, is that
00:21:47.100
the idea that they're putting forward while they're saying we need to dissolve the American
00:21:51.380
state, we need to completely dissolve the United States of America, is like you were saying,
00:21:56.080
they're doing it through the ideology of the state.
00:21:58.160
Like you watch the clips, you're seeing priests clapping along, you're seeing a lot of the
00:22:02.240
people being arrested are like attorneys and they're actually a part of the managerial
00:22:06.100
You have the mayor of Portland getting in on this, right?
00:22:09.900
You have people in positions of political authority supporting this message.
00:22:14.180
And so this tied in a lot to actually what we recently talked about on EBL, which was
00:22:19.600
we did a show on Foucault, Birth of Biopolitics.
00:22:22.960
And we talked about, which fits in there very nicely with anarcho-tyranny, is the way in which
00:22:27.120
the trace from liberal government up to neoliberalism is this discovery of the natural rationalization
00:22:34.340
of institutions, where you're trying to homogenize society and to figure out the most effective
00:22:38.660
way to rationalize it as a part of the managerial class.
00:22:45.860
It's not that they're incompetent, they're fully competent, they're aware of what they're
00:22:49.840
But it plays into the role of their ideology because it's a method of affecting a means of
00:22:56.820
biopolitical control where you are enforcing that same, you know, spirit of resistance
00:23:03.500
that they're bringing up themselves, like through Black Lives Matter, right?
00:23:08.120
It's a part of the state's functioning, but it's also through the rhetoric of being anti-state.
00:23:13.040
And so if the mass is going through this process where this is an accepted protest, it's something
00:23:19.620
socially allowable and socially promoted and enforced, then you're not going to crush down
00:23:25.580
on them because that's who you want to appeal to, right?
00:23:28.420
That's who the corporations want to appeal to, and that's why they're all a part of the
00:23:33.220
But if you're looking at, like, it's not that they don't have the ability, and this
00:23:38.140
is why it's anarcho-tyranny, is because they can crack down on it pretty easily and a lot
00:23:43.700
Just look at what they do to people on, you know, loosely speaking, the right.
00:23:48.000
They've shown that they very clearly can crack down on it and end it, but they don't choose
00:23:53.220
So the question now that comes with anarcho-tyranny is why they choose to, like, what's the function
00:24:02.160
And it's because they're a part of the managerial state themselves, right?
00:24:06.620
And so it's weaponizing that rhetoric against the federal government.
00:24:11.040
And the federal government themselves, the Trump administration, is also a part of pushing
00:24:15.720
So it's not that the Trump administration is really stopping the left.
00:24:18.760
I mean, if you look at the executive order, he actually outright said, gave him a bunch
00:24:23.100
of brownie points, like, well, if you look at these monuments, some of these guys were
00:24:26.720
fought the KKK and fought the Confederacy, like, they're historically illiterate.
00:24:34.640
It's about effective rationalization policies of dealing with a mass, and it's a part of the
00:24:39.820
And that resistance, because it's being taken up by the state, is not really a threat to the
00:24:46.560
I don't think, yes, I don't think we can, we need to sort of overcomplicate this.
00:24:55.920
We need to get, we need to get to its bare essence.
00:24:58.500
And I think the best way you can do that is by comparing it to things that have happened
00:25:04.500
And so if you look at it, if the whole notion of this virtue signaling, this virtue signaling
00:25:12.620
So the way that reasonably intelligent people tend to operate is they tend to play for status
00:25:18.540
by taking that which is the view of the establishment, which is the establishment view, and pushing
00:25:25.140
it in a more radical direction, a more extreme version, as it were, of the establishment view.
00:25:33.220
Not a version, not the opposite of the establishment view, a more exaggerated version of the establishment
00:25:38.900
And that's how these things spiral out of control.
00:25:41.540
That's how Protestantism spiraled out of control.
00:25:44.060
That's how, you know, whatever, that's how these kinds of things spiral out of control.
00:25:47.560
But they then become useful to the state that has the more nuanced, diluted version of the now extreme view,
00:25:56.680
because these people can be used as these stormtroopers, these shocktroopers of the state.
00:26:00.700
They can be used to sow discord and to make people obey and whatever and to scare people.
00:26:05.940
And so it's not a bad thing for the government to have people who have a much more extreme
00:26:11.900
But they need to be clamped down on occasionally, in the same way that Putin, he's perfectly
00:26:15.860
happy to have nationalists operating in Russia.
00:26:17.900
But when they go too far, they get clamped down on.
00:26:20.920
But that is basically a more, it's the other way with Putin.
00:26:24.260
So it's a more extreme version of his own situation.
00:26:28.480
And so it strikes me that if you look at something like, well, let's say religion, let's say
00:26:32.060
something like Christianity, when Christianity was established and it was the religion of
00:26:35.160
the Roman Empire, then you have the people that are the most extreme, like these are the
00:26:38.980
equivalent of these Oregon protesters or whatever, who are the monks who take it too
00:26:42.680
far and it becomes this extreme spiraling out of control and so on.
00:26:50.520
But ultimately, and they have to be reined in occasionally.
00:26:55.220
But ultimately, they are taking the state view.
00:27:02.380
And they are taking that state view to an extreme.
00:27:06.480
And therefore, they are radical, in a sense, even though it is the state view that they
00:27:11.120
are taking and they are just pushing it to an extreme degree.
00:27:13.880
So that, I think, solves the paradox of how you can be both a functionary of the establishment
00:27:22.360
And in doing so, you can be a slight danger to the establishment because you can then start
00:27:27.540
As we discussed on the thing with Keith, the way in which you have these Anabaptists who
00:27:32.420
came out of Protestantism and then turned on the original Protestants and the original
00:27:38.460
I think it's just the same kind of relationship.
00:27:40.440
So I kind of get the feeling that although it seems so bizarre, it's very much a kind
00:27:44.760
of Ecclesiastes, you know, there is nothing new under the sun.
00:27:49.000
I think this could be directly compared to other manifestations, other points of breakdown
00:27:57.120
But I mean, like the complicated question for me is to have the situation where it's not
00:28:03.380
just you have a virtue signaling mass that gets out of control from within the own ideology
00:28:07.860
that it's given to them by the state and they have to rein it in every now and then.
00:28:11.460
It's that you have a situation like importantly, where the political authorities are openly
00:28:15.780
against the federal government and they're using this political rhetoric and they're denying
00:28:19.840
reality openly and they're saying they're fully a part of the radical politics.
00:28:28.800
So you as a person that wants to gain power can use this as a means of leveraging more power
00:28:37.420
And I think the question here is what is the purpose of the inter-elite conflict going
00:28:42.680
on right now when it comes to the Portland authorities versus the federal government?
00:28:47.920
Like, I don't doubt that there's obviously like similar phenomena with the Protestant Reformation
00:28:53.280
Like there definitely is all throughout history.
00:28:55.180
There's been a situation of subsidiary authority versus sovereign authorities and the way in which
00:28:59.840
they weaponize the masses, like kind of like the so-called wars of religion where
00:29:04.360
princes change religions overnight to appeal to a different crowd, right?
00:29:08.800
Like, so it was very little to do with religion.
00:29:11.640
But now in this situation, it's I'm simply trying to get the question of what is the function?
00:29:19.100
I think I think that in terms of how these kinds of political operators work, they want
00:29:24.380
They want to come across as alpha male equivalent, whatever they are, you know, alpha non-binary.
00:29:29.700
And one of the ways you can do that is by, you know, you play for status in the same way
00:29:38.220
that Pete Buttigieg, is he a queer, played for status with his, you know, fruitless attempt.
00:29:45.160
There's no way he was going to be the Democrat candidate, obviously.
00:29:48.040
But it's just a play for status, which then empowers him within whatever state he was from,
00:29:52.180
Indiana or whatever it was, as a means of running for governor or something like that.
00:29:56.700
And so in much the same way, I guess that one of their strategies is just gain prominence
00:30:02.600
for themselves to elevate their status within the Democrat Party or whatever it is.
00:30:09.960
I guess my my ultimate question is, is there a legitimacy crisis or is there in a kind of
00:30:16.740
funny way, not one in the sense that, you know, if you listen to some of these people,
00:30:23.460
you would get a sense that there's a serious legitimacy crisis or at the very least,
00:30:42.800
But then at the same time, I mean, I think it's almost like the genius of the American Empire.
00:30:48.080
And it might kind of drive us crazy because we have these, you know, id like right wing
00:30:56.220
We kind of want to live in Prussia, you know, where our leaders are badasses and wear military
00:31:01.760
garb and, you know, like say, you know, let's say moi, you know, we just that's kind of how
00:31:08.620
But the genius of the American Empire is that it's its own contradiction.
00:31:16.140
It's, you know, it comes here not to conquer you, but to liberate you.
00:31:22.400
And at this point, it's almost like we are liberating you from the white supremacy inherent
00:31:28.020
It's this kind of like weird, contradictory, ongoing process that actually has been successful
00:31:36.020
There is no, I mean, China, okay, there is no real threat to the unipolar world, even
00:31:44.500
though from our standpoint, we see it as kind of, you know, inherently contradictory and
00:31:53.860
There's almost no legitimacy crisis at the end of the day.
00:31:57.500
There's no one really fundamentally questioning American individualism and liberation.
00:32:03.900
Saying these, these people that are saying, we want to bring down the system, those that
00:32:13.280
One way of understanding is, it's just like Christian ascetics or something in a Christian
00:32:18.340
There's a minority of, they play, they play a certain purpose in the, in the overall scheme
00:32:22.720
of things, but it's not obviously going to go their way ever.
00:32:25.320
Because if it did, then the group, the group, that group would just be crushed and destroyed.
00:32:29.460
But, but, you know, they, they play a purpose in kind of religiously inspiring people that
00:32:34.560
are towards the center and pushing the society in a more left-wing sort of direction.
00:32:44.220
Again, it's, it's on the, although it does penetrate things that are relatively mainstream.
00:32:48.820
So now they're saying, it used to be that they had blind auditions for orchestras to
00:32:54.840
So you sit there, you can't see who's auditioning and the person, the death musician gets through.
00:32:58.860
Now they're saying, oh, more important than basically good music is that you represent
00:33:05.480
demographically, racially, the, the area that you're playing for.
00:33:10.680
And so that's the, what Bruce Charlton, my colleague, Bruce Charlton, he has a book called
00:33:16.960
It's, it's not just that we're becoming more stupid, so we can't come up with more
00:33:22.580
We've literally moved away from an ideology of trying to be the best towards an ideology
00:33:30.720
So, you know, so there is some mainstream elements to it, but yeah, you're right.
00:33:34.160
These people ultimately, a few of them extreme, they want to live in tents or whatever, but
00:33:37.420
ultimately they don't, they want their iPhones and their internet connection.
00:33:40.160
And frankly, so many of them suffer from mental illnesses and depression and anxiety and things
00:33:44.080
that if these things were taken away, they'd go bonkers.
00:33:47.440
There's not a challenge to the American uniprolar world yet.
00:33:50.780
I mean, China is overrated when people say it's going to combat that.
00:33:54.120
I mean, the fact is their economy is fully bound up with American manufacturing, right?
00:33:59.340
So there's, there's, there's no way that they could rise up to challenge American hegemony.
00:34:04.520
And even if we're talking on a grand ideological scale, their authoritarian capitalism is still
00:34:13.580
And I'll pose that against like Benoit's and maybe even Dugan's hope in this regard.
00:34:18.460
But either way, that being said, there is certainly a lot of truth in what you're saying, Richard,
00:34:23.960
because you look at what the complaints they're making about the police or about the system,
00:34:29.900
like in general, like who gets a job if they're not represented enough.
00:34:33.460
You have the right to become an identity you want.
00:34:37.880
They're basically saying all these things are not liberal enough, right?
00:34:41.400
And so the American empire, it's entirely a part of its own ideology.
00:34:46.020
It's just saying, it's just pushing it to its conclusion, right?
00:34:49.580
And so it's a mode of governance where you're governing by having them actually fully conformed,
00:34:55.620
this rational set of market principles within their own side of resistance.
00:34:59.360
And so then they're just affirming American identity from what was latent in the very beginning.
00:35:08.340
And then that's becoming like, and it's an interesting thing where there's no real mask behind it, right?
00:35:14.060
Like the lie is that they're like in The Dark Knight Rises, that they're like Batman,
00:35:18.520
that they're like fascists coming to stop the anarchists.
00:35:21.740
But in actuality, the reality that they're doing the Macarena with them is the real face of American strength.
00:35:32.000
In the Industrial Revolution in Wales, you have this situation where on Sunday,
00:35:41.800
And on a Sunday, you can be the Methodist preacher.
00:35:51.340
As long as on Monday to Saturday, you work in the mine and shut up and contribute to the empire.
00:36:07.460
Make them think that they're doing something such that their life has eternal significance.
00:36:13.060
As long as they, you know, work their very dull job, which they commute to for an hour a day and commute an hour back and put lots of data into computers they don't understand and shut up and pay tax.
00:36:27.100
I'm seeing I'm seeing pictures of attorneys with very poorly fitted suits and then pictures of them arrested with these masks covering their face.
00:36:37.060
And is there is there that much is there that much of a difference?
00:36:40.100
But I think between the Methodist preacher who works down a coal mine, but he's someone radical and important.
00:36:46.980
He's so doing something for the betterment of the world on Sundays.
00:37:08.240
Tyler, you've combined a metal hoodie with a cowboy hat.
00:37:19.920
Now that Brooke's brought it on, this is what I have to wear.
00:37:27.980
It's kind of the ultimate the ultimate kind of alt right where traditional cowboy hat plus black metal.
00:37:48.600
I think black metal is the shouty one, isn't it?
00:37:51.580
It's the one where they just go, ah, I'm not so much.