Real Coffee with Scott Adams - November 25, 2023


Episode 2303 Scott Adams: CWSA 11⧸25⧸23, Bring Coffee


Episode Stats

Length

53 minutes

Words per Minute

140.48055

Word Count

7,476

Sentence Count

59

Misogynist Sentences

7

Hate Speech Sentences

25


Summary

On today's show, Scott Adams talks about the death of a police officer who was stabbed in prison by another inmate, the New York City Police Department is losing officers at an alarming rate, and the future of the voice actor industry is rapidly approaching.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 Oh
00:00:02.920 Good morning everybody and welcome to the highlight of human civilization
00:00:08.140 It's called coffee with Scott Adams. I'm pretty sure there's never been a better time in your life
00:00:12.920 and it's all looking up
00:00:15.160 right look it up and
00:00:19.120 If you'd like to take this experience to levels that nobody can even understand this beyond human experience
00:00:25.520 All you need is a copper mug or a glass a tanker Charles Ristein a
00:00:30.000 Canteen jug a flask a vessel of any kind fill it with your favorite liquid
00:00:33.680 I like coffee
00:00:34.880 Join me now for the unparalleled pleasure of the dope beef is a thing that makes everything better
00:00:40.520 It's called the simultaneous sip it happens now go
00:00:48.420 Consider yourself colonized
00:00:52.740 Well
00:00:56.240 News of the day is that I guess yesterday
00:01:00.000 Derek Chauvin the police officer who was convicted of murdering George Floyd
00:01:06.080 He was stabbed in prison by another inmate and quite seriously injured
00:01:13.040 And when did that happen
00:01:15.760 Derek Chauvin was stabbed on
00:01:18.720 Black Friday
00:01:20.480 Black Friday, he was dead
00:01:23.760 Now that's probably a coincidence, right
00:01:25.760 Probably a coincidence
00:01:27.760 Probably a coincidence
00:01:29.760 I think so
00:01:31.040 I'm not sure
00:01:33.040 All right
00:01:33.840 At the same time the documentary the fall of Minneapolis is trending
00:01:39.600 Now the fall of Minneapolis is the one that
00:01:43.040 calls out the whole
00:01:45.040 George Floyd hoax
00:01:47.040 Because it's pretty obvious I think to objective people he did not die from Derek Chauvin's actions
00:01:52.320 But rather from fentanyl
00:01:54.080 It's like really really obvious when you are when you watch the documentary
00:01:58.880 Super obvious
00:02:00.880 There's no doubt about it when you watch it
00:02:03.120 And so as a martyr made the ex-user noted
00:02:08.080 That the stabbing of Chauvin is a
00:02:11.760 Is basically a slow motion execution
00:02:16.640 We're being a white guy basically
00:02:18.080 So this is a the biggest miscarriage of justice
00:02:22.720 Since the january sixers
00:02:24.960 But we're starting to get used to white people being put in jail for political reasons
00:02:30.640 You probably shouldn't get used to that
00:02:33.200 That would be my guess
00:02:34.240 Don't get used to that
00:02:35.520 Don't get used to that
00:02:36.480 It's probably a bad idea
00:02:38.480 Well, big surprise
00:02:41.040 The new york city police force is losing police officers at an alarming rate
00:02:45.840 2,500 turned over the badges in 2023
00:02:52.240 And and the whispers are that everybody's just waiting for their 20 years to click or whenever they can get a pension
00:02:58.880 And get the hell out of there
00:03:01.920 What is not mentioned is the ethnicities of the cops
00:03:06.240 I wonder if they're leaving in roughly
00:03:10.000 You know roughly proportionate to their ethnic mix
00:03:12.720 Do you think there's any group that's more likely to believe in the police force?
00:03:19.840 I don't
00:03:20.560 Derek Chauvin would
00:03:22.560 Make me quit if I were a police officer. I'd quit immediately
00:03:26.720 Because if you don't have support from your community
00:03:30.240 Really being a police officer is a dumb idea
00:03:33.280 So wouldn't you agree if your community does not support you
00:03:37.600 Being a police officer is a terrible job option
00:03:40.320 Terrible
00:03:42.480 But you know, maybe robots won't take that job. So it's got that going for it
00:03:47.840 Uh, and in the midst of this I guess there's massive overtime because there are not enough police officers
00:03:53.760 But the massive overtime
00:03:56.560 Will make it even
00:03:58.640 Harder because there'll be fewer police officers because they'll quit
00:04:02.640 Because of the massive overtime, which I guess is a big issue
00:04:05.360 So the fewer there are the more rapidly they'll quit. So we we have a death spiral
00:04:12.560 That's that's a classic death spiral
00:04:15.120 The more people who quit the more overtime the more overtime the more people quit more overnight
00:04:21.280 That's actually a death spiral
00:04:23.600 And in the midst of all that in the immigrant
00:04:27.840 Population increasing mayor adams has canceled the next five police academy classes
00:04:33.440 So you won't have new ones and the impetus for the ones that are already there to quit
00:04:39.520 Is greater than it's ever been before
00:04:42.000 Now one of the things I would ask you is who quits the police force at first
00:04:47.760 Who are the ones that just get right out right away?
00:04:50.640 Well, there's once we're retiring of course or can retire
00:04:54.800 But I would think you would be the most capable
00:04:56.800 Because people who are highly capable can get other jobs
00:05:01.360 People who are just barely hanging on probably lucky to have the job they have
00:05:06.160 So I would expect that the quality of the police force would take a huge nosedive at the same time
00:05:13.200 But speaking of jobs
00:05:14.960 I saw some estimates it was in Forbes that half of all jobs will will be ai in two years
00:05:21.440 I don't think so
00:05:24.880 I don't think so at all. I think where we're heading is that
00:05:28.720 People will just use ai to do their job
00:05:32.400 You know where we're let me give you the the most obvious one
00:05:36.800 The most obvious one as they say
00:05:40.400 Voice work like voice dubbing and voice voiceovers will turn to ai
00:05:47.440 You know what's wrong with that?
00:05:50.160 Well, it might be that the people who used to be the voice actors will be on work
00:05:55.680 But it's still going to require a person
00:05:58.720 To tell the ai to make the book
00:06:01.920 And it's still going to take a person
00:06:03.920 To determine which voice is the one to use
00:06:06.720 And it's going to take a person to decide if it's right
00:06:09.760 And it's going to take a person to decide if you know which parts of the book to read and which ones to edit and stuff like that
00:06:16.880 I think it's just going to be a tool
00:06:19.360 So it might be true that the voice person
00:06:22.880 Loses their job, but then they're just replaced with another human
00:06:26.800 Who has to manage the ai to make sure it does the right thing to make the voice recording
00:06:31.600 I think that's the way it's going to go with all the jobs
00:06:34.640 There'll be some you know niche of jobs that definitely do go away
00:06:39.280 But then more likely we're just using it as a tool
00:06:42.160 Let's take one of the one of the things on
00:06:48.000 The jobs on the list of things that will go away is cartoonist
00:06:52.320 Do you think cartoonist is going to go away?
00:06:55.280 I don't know
00:06:58.000 Let's ask chat GPT to write us a joke
00:07:01.520 Let's do this right now. Let's see
00:07:04.480 chat GPT
00:07:07.280 Let's say let's get a good joke going here
00:07:12.560 Can you tell me a funny joke?
00:07:18.240 Sure, why did the scarecrow win an award because he was outstanding in his field?
00:07:23.840 Scarecrow won an award because he was outstanding in his field
00:07:27.360 Does that sound like a grant that's the one got a chuckle out of you?
00:07:35.040 Do you have a funnier joke that one wasn't very funny
00:07:40.240 Sure thing why don't scientists trust atoms because they make up everything
00:07:44.480 Did she just say the scientists don't don't trust atoms?
00:07:54.240 Why don't they trust me no not algorithms scientists don't trust atoms because they make up everything
00:08:00.640 It's a play on words anything else you'd like to chat about
00:08:04.720 Did you say the scientists don't trust Scott Adams?
00:08:11.440 No, not Scott Adams scientists don't trust atoms
00:08:14.960 It's a joke about the smallest particles that make up everything
00:08:17.840 Are you anything else you're curious about are you saying Scott Adams is a small particle?
00:08:25.920 No, sorry for any confusion. I was talking about atoms not Scott Adams. Well, let's switch gears
00:08:31.760 Is there a specific topic or question you have in mind?
00:08:34.480 My point is I don't think it's gonna be funny. I mean, I was funnier than the app just talking to it
00:08:50.560 Right
00:08:52.560 I was funnier than the app and the app was trying as hard as it could to be funny and I wasn't even trying
00:08:57.440 It's like you you can be funnier than AI without even much effort at all
00:09:02.560 Now
00:09:03.680 Here's your lesson
00:09:05.760 Why was it funny?
00:09:07.600 When I was talking to it, but it wasn't funny when it told the joke
00:09:11.040 Well, it wasn't funny when it told the joke. Number one, you've already heard those jokes. Those are old jokes
00:09:18.160 Number two
00:09:19.360 AI doesn't uh can't read the zeitgeist
00:09:23.360 The zeitgeist is the sort of thing that everybody's thinking
00:09:27.280 But maybe they haven't said it out loud yet
00:09:29.280 You know what? What is the feeling everybody's getting?
00:09:32.720 So for example
00:09:34.640 If the news is causing people to have an anxiety or a feeling about something in particular
00:09:39.760 Then a human humorist can feel that
00:09:42.640 Because they're part of the zeitgeist
00:09:44.640 And so then we'll make a joke about that and you'll say oh, that's new
00:09:48.000 That's just what I was thinking. That's what makes it funny
00:09:50.560 But if AI just looks at jokes that have been told before by humans
00:09:57.360 Which is currently how it learns
00:09:59.440 It's going to be a derivative boring ordinary joke
00:10:03.040 It's been around 40 years
00:10:05.360 But I can tell a joke that wouldn't have been funny a week ago
00:10:09.600 Just think about that. I can tell you a joke that wouldn't have been funny one week ago
00:10:14.400 Right because i'm i'm in i'm surfing the social feeling that the rest of you are feeling as well
00:10:22.800 so no, um
00:10:24.880 I don't think cartoonist is going to go away
00:10:27.600 Yet, and I would go further and say again that all art is dependent on the artist
00:10:34.240 Everything that you like about art your art appreciation is because of what you
00:10:42.240 Consciously or subconsciously think about the person who made it. It's not about the art
00:10:47.920 It's about the connection between the art and the person who made it
00:10:51.360 As soon as you take the person who made it out of the equation, it'll just lay there like a turd
00:10:56.960 There's there's a
00:10:58.880 AI demonstration that was on x today. Somebody made it. It shows a
00:11:03.920 lifelike singer
00:11:05.760 So the image is created by ai. It's not a real person and
00:11:10.480 This ai person is singing an ai song
00:11:14.000 Which to me sounded like every taylor swift song i've ever heard
00:11:19.040 Did I like it?
00:11:20.800 No, I also don't like taylor swift songs. I think that they're
00:11:26.720 Very ordinary
00:11:28.240 Like nothing about a taylor swift song is ever interested in me at the least
00:11:32.640 But it might be because i'm not interested in taylor swift
00:11:36.160 imagine if I were a
00:11:38.320 12 year old girl
00:11:40.720 Would I be interested in taylor swift as an artist?
00:11:44.480 Absolutely
00:11:45.600 Because she'd be like maybe what I want to grow up to be, you know, my hero or something
00:11:49.680 So if my hero makes a song, maybe I like it better
00:11:53.280 But I don't really have any connection or
00:11:56.400 Like there's nothing about I don't dislike taylor swift. She's very successful must be very smart
00:12:02.640 Yeah, but it doesn't really do anything for me
00:12:06.720 And I would argue that if taylor swift the human
00:12:10.400 Were not associated with the music you wouldn't listen to it
00:12:14.800 You would not listen to her music if the only thing you knew about it is how it sounded
00:12:19.840 And that's the problem with ai it'll just be how it sounds
00:12:23.600 You just know would never listen to that
00:12:25.680 The the fact that taylor swift does songs about her old boyfriends
00:12:30.160 How much does that matter to her?
00:12:32.880 You know how much you appreciate it a lot
00:12:36.080 The the fact that you probably think the song
00:12:38.720 Was about a real person in a real situation completely changes your impression of it
00:12:43.600 So i'm a optimist about human employment
00:12:49.360 Um the newest wrinkle in that in those tunnels beneath that chifa hospital in gaza
00:12:56.320 Remember first people were saying hey, maybe there's no tunnels under there
00:13:00.480 and then israel did a
00:13:03.440 Did a great job of finding them and excavating them you know because they've been filled in with some sand
00:13:08.320 And you know, they got rid of the booby traps and they showed you a long video of the actual tunnels
00:13:15.040 And then today we find out
00:13:18.880 Amazingly today we find out that the tunnels were built by israel
00:13:24.000 Did you see that story yet?
00:13:27.040 I'm not making this up. The tunnels under the chifa hospital were built by israel
00:13:32.640 according to israel's ex-prime minister
00:13:34.960 And that it was decades ago
00:13:38.240 And it was a favor to the hospital to give them more just more space
00:13:44.240 Because the hospital was in you know crowded area
00:13:49.040 Now some are saying
00:13:51.520 That that proves that it was not being used by hamas
00:13:54.880 Which is a whole different subject so who built them is way less important
00:13:59.200 Than whether hamas was using it as headquarters
00:14:03.120 And israel says yes
00:14:05.440 So israel says yes all the signs are there
00:14:08.080 But of course it's like every other story in the world
00:14:11.680 People will say I don't believe them
00:14:15.440 But it seems very unlikely to me that it was not being used by hamas
00:14:20.000 How many of you think
00:14:22.080 You're you're satisfied that it was exactly what it looked like it was a hamas
00:14:25.760 asset
00:14:30.080 I think so if I had to bet
00:14:34.240 Because if it had just been used by the hospital
00:14:37.840 It would have been hard to make it look like it wasn't just used by the hospital
00:14:42.320 If the hospital was using it there would have been you know supplies down there
00:14:46.560 I don't know. I don't believe any of it. I'm pretty sure it was a hamas
00:14:49.360 All right
00:14:54.240 Let me give you a history lesson
00:14:57.840 I will preface this with what I call my opinion sandwich
00:15:02.960 The opinion sandwich means that I might say something that would get me in trouble
00:15:07.200 But i'm going to sandwich it between two things that make it okay
00:15:12.080 First part of the sandwich
00:15:13.200 I completely 100% for israel's right of self-defense
00:15:19.280 And what they're doing in gaza
00:15:22.080 All right, so i'm completely behind israel
00:15:25.680 And when i'm done with what i'm saying i'm going to say that again
00:15:28.880 So that's that has to be the sandwich
00:15:31.520 And I just wondered this is a general information question
00:15:35.920 If I asked you most of you know that when israel was formed
00:15:39.760 1948 that some number of palestinian types who lived there
00:15:47.120 Were expelled
00:15:50.560 How many people do you think who lived there who would have identified as palestinian? I guess
00:15:58.320 How many of them do you think were expelled in 1948? Give me a number
00:16:04.080 I'm not going to tell you the right number until I see but but even if you don't know
00:16:09.200 Take your best guess
00:16:11.200 Like what what does it feel like?
00:16:16.160 You see numbers from
00:16:19.680 It's not 25. I'm that's the 25 is a joke when people are writing 25. That's a it's a call back to a joke
00:16:28.400 How many do you think
00:16:30.800 And then and then separately what percentage
00:16:34.400 Of the when I say palestinian? I mean that's what they would call themselves. It wasn't wasn't called the country of palestine
00:16:42.880 but
00:16:43.920 What percentage of them?
00:16:47.680 All right, so it turns out that if you try to search for it you get different numbers
00:16:52.560 So some some say 700 000 people say 700 some say
00:16:57.760 750 000
00:16:58.960 Some sources say half of the residents were
00:17:05.120 Expelled some say 75
00:17:10.320 That's a lot of people
00:17:12.800 Do you know what it was called?
00:17:15.360 How many of you know what that situation was called
00:17:20.320 by the
00:17:21.440 Palestinians
00:17:22.880 Yeah, if you see this word nakba
00:17:26.400 Which they would say is still happening
00:17:30.000 Nakba does that mean exodus what does that mean?
00:17:34.560 Yeah, so imagine imagine
00:17:38.400 700 000 palestinians and then imagine the birth rate
00:17:42.560 Of palestinians since then pretty high birth rate
00:17:47.440 Wouldn't we be talking about several million people who were
00:17:51.440 Either directly expelled or the children of people expelled
00:17:55.440 A lot of people
00:17:57.440 Yeah
00:17:58.240 Now i'm not going to give you an opinion of what is right or wrong who owns the territory. I actually am not interested in any of their history
00:18:04.560 I i'm very much
00:18:08.080 Whoever can hold the place militarily owns it. Unfortunately, you could talk all day about who should own it
00:18:15.520 But it won't make any difference
00:18:18.080 Whoever can own it is going to own it. That's just the way the world works
00:18:22.000 So you don't you know the the conversation of who should own it just sort of fun, but irrelevant
00:18:29.040 All right
00:18:33.440 And then I will sandwich that comment by saying i'm 100% beside be behind israel
00:18:38.880 In their self-defense and what they have to do to get rid of hamas
00:18:43.200 All right, uh
00:18:45.280 Marco rubio
00:18:47.280 is
00:18:48.240 Coming out strong again. He's been saying this for a while about banning tiktok. Here's what I'd like to say about senator marco rubio
00:18:56.080 Thank you for getting this exactly right
00:19:01.280 I've gotten really discouraged about our government
00:19:04.640 We're not being able to even explain tiktok
00:19:07.920 Much less have an opinion
00:19:09.920 If you can't explain it
00:19:12.160 Like what's the problem?
00:19:14.240 You really need to not be part of that
00:19:17.600 Conversation if you can't even explain the problem
00:19:20.240 so, uh
00:19:22.320 Rubio
00:19:24.320 Correctly and perfectly explains that yes, there's a data
00:19:28.640 data sensitivity problem
00:19:31.040 But it's not the big problem. The big problem is that china has a direct
00:19:34.880 User interface to american minds and you cannot compare that to an american made or an american owned company
00:19:42.160 Which also may be spreading some propaganda, but at least it's american
00:19:47.120 I mean if it's coming from china
00:19:50.080 That is a whole different conversation
00:19:52.960 Than the fact that maybe facebook is
00:19:55.600 Pushing you know one side of the political argument
00:20:00.080 That's really different
00:20:04.080 So good for you marco rubio
00:20:07.040 I appreciate that that's some that's some good governmenting there good senatoring
00:20:12.480 A good job there
00:20:14.480 uh, the who
00:20:15.440 uh, is suggesting
00:20:18.160 Masks being reinstated in china
00:20:21.040 And social distancing
00:20:22.640 You have some new kind of mystery
00:20:25.280 Respiratory illness happening there
00:20:27.040 As others have pointed out
00:20:32.400 Does all of this feel a little bit too familiar?
00:20:37.920 A little bit too familiar
00:20:39.760 Yeah, we got uh trump leading in the polls election coming up
00:20:45.280 And oh surprise
00:20:47.360 There might be another pandemic brewing coming from china
00:20:55.600 All right, um, I don't know if you heard about this but the democrats have a
00:21:00.400 Put out just before thanksgiving a handy guide for responding to your crazy mega nonsense. That's what it actually says
00:21:08.480 I'm not saying that the actual guide
00:21:11.360 Now it's tug-in-cheek
00:21:13.440 But it's also a little bit serious
00:21:17.200 It's a handy guide for responding to crazy and crazy mega nonsense
00:21:23.600 So I helpfully included the hoax quiz
00:21:27.760 So that you could take that with you to your next family gathering
00:21:31.520 A lot of people said who who would tell people to argue with their
00:21:36.320 family on a holiday
00:21:38.320 Which I say I don't think that's going to cause you to argue with them
00:21:42.640 I don't think that's what make the argument
00:21:45.120 so
00:21:46.640 Anyway, that's happening
00:21:48.800 Politico sounding the alarm as they like to say when you talk about news stories
00:21:54.160 It's one way that the traditional news always says somebody who sounded the alarm
00:22:00.320 Um
00:22:01.440 It's pretty cliche
00:22:02.880 Anyway politico is talking about biden's poll numbers aren't just bad. They're getting worse
00:22:08.640 So now biden is basically losing of every poll
00:22:12.560 And you know most of the demographics
00:22:16.240 Although the demographic about losing the young vote is still not completely agreed on
00:22:22.560 By all the pollsters, so there's a little disagreement on that
00:22:25.760 Um
00:22:29.840 How in the world
00:22:34.480 Like how are the democrats going to handle this
00:22:37.600 Do you think they're gonna have to assassinate their own candidate?
00:22:41.840 You know, I here's the thing that comes to mind
00:22:45.920 We keep thinking that
00:22:47.760 uh
00:22:48.320 Trump is at risk
00:22:49.440 Because you think about jfk jr. And i'm sorry you think about jfk
00:22:55.120 The assassination of jfk and you think wow
00:22:58.160 Could it be that our deep state blob would
00:23:01.600 Actually try to kill a candidate for president trump?
00:23:05.680 And then you think about it some more
00:23:07.840 You say wouldn't it be easier to kill biden?
00:23:10.640 Because if they replace biden they've got a fighting chance of winning the election outright
00:23:18.320 But if they keep them in there it's trump
00:23:20.960 Do you think do you think that the blob?
00:23:24.640 I'm not saying that I know anybody's planning anything like this. I'm just speculating because it's fun
00:23:30.640 But if you were if you were like the worst people
00:23:34.160 In the democrat blob, you know the people who do anything to win
00:23:37.120 Is your best play to take trump out?
00:23:41.200 Or biden
00:23:43.200 What's your best play?
00:23:46.000 I'm pretty sure the best place to take biden now
00:23:49.120 So you might have this weird situation well of both of course, but your your weird situation
00:23:55.840 That the democrats might need to assassinate their own leader
00:23:59.520 To have a chance of winning
00:24:03.120 That'd be weird now when I say assassinate I don't mean literally
00:24:07.600 I mean, they might have to just
00:24:09.600 Come up with some kind of an op that takes them out
00:24:12.800 Here's what i'm gonna here's what I expect
00:24:17.520 I think that the the blob will keep pushing biden every way they can push him
00:24:23.200 And if he doesn't get pushed because he needs to protect his family and have the pardon ability
00:24:30.080 I think they're going to drop the dime on him
00:24:32.080 I think the blob is going to tell you the stuff that you don't know about yet
00:24:39.280 Like the good stuff
00:24:40.960 The thing that the thing that everybody in washington probably knows
00:24:44.240 But nobody has quite you know proof so they don't say it out loud
00:24:48.080 I've got a feeling that
00:24:50.320 The blob is going to drop a dime on biden and it's going to happen really soon
00:24:54.880 Because the sooner it happens the better
00:24:57.840 Now I don't think it'll happen over christmas
00:25:02.000 So i'm going to look at january
00:25:06.320 When when is the first
00:25:10.080 Primary first primary is in
00:25:13.920 March first one so you don't want to wait till february
00:25:18.080 It's going to be january
00:25:21.760 You don't you don't want it to get like caught up with the holiday news
00:25:27.040 I think in january they're going to take them out
00:25:30.000 All right. Do you want to go with that prediction?
00:25:33.360 That the the blob will take out biden it won't be republicans. It'll be the blob
00:25:39.200 blob meaning democrats and people who agree with them the media agrees with them the intelligent people
00:25:45.360 All those yeah, we used to call it the deep state. I think blob is a better. I like blob
00:25:52.800 That's right. Mike Benz used that all right
00:25:58.640 Uh the vague ramaswamy is uh pitching the idea that the next gop debate
00:26:04.880 Should be on the x platform and hosted by tucker carlson
00:26:09.520 What do you think of that you think the next republican debate should be on x
00:26:14.640 I will remind you that tucker carlson's numbers for his shows
00:26:20.720 are
00:26:21.760 something like a hundred times bigger than any network
00:26:25.760 ever
00:26:27.040 Like there's no there's no comparison
00:26:29.840 to the size of the audience
00:26:31.920 x would be way bigger
00:26:33.760 so
00:26:35.040 So what would the new york post editorial group say about this idea?
00:26:39.920 The new york post being the traditional media
00:26:44.720 Um, so here's what their editorial board said
00:26:48.000 They said oops the fake ramaswamy
00:26:50.640 Just inadvertently revealed that his once promising presidential campaign has devolved into a sad bid for social media fame
00:27:00.560 I
00:27:01.120 Didn't see that in the story
00:27:02.640 What part of the story about him wanting to use the biggest platform?
00:27:09.280 For a debate
00:27:11.040 Which part is the admitting that he just wants to be a social media star?
00:27:17.040 Wouldn't it make more sense
00:27:19.040 that vivek knows he has an advantage online
00:27:23.360 And so an online debate would likely get him a better outcome
00:27:28.400 Than a television debate which would be senior citizens
00:27:32.240 But it but he probably has more young support
00:27:34.480 So if he puts on acts against more young people
00:27:37.360 Gets a better outcome
00:27:38.800 People say hey you did better in that debate
00:27:41.200 Plus more people saw it
00:27:42.800 Plus plus tucker carlson would ask better questions
00:27:47.040 And the way the new york port post says it is he's devolved into a sad bid from social media fame
00:27:53.200 That is a sad sad
00:27:55.200 Uh editorial
00:27:58.720 That is so weak
00:28:00.240 Like I am transparent
00:28:03.680 And then they say to follow up their ridiculousness
00:28:07.280 The new york post editorial says sure
00:28:10.640 He claimed it would be a way to increase viewership
00:28:13.920 But you don't get a larger audience by making something harder to watch
00:28:19.120 Has the new york post ever seen the news?
00:28:21.440 Does the new york post editorial staff not know
00:28:27.840 That tucker carlson's audiences are a hundred times bigger than traditional media?
00:28:35.840 Am I what what is the actual percentage?
00:28:37.680 It's like a hundred times bigger, right?
00:28:39.840 We're not talking about
00:28:41.760 Two things in the same category
00:28:45.040 One's a hundred times bigger
00:28:46.400 Yeah, I don't know if it's a hundred but it's a lot bigger
00:28:51.600 It's not even close
00:28:54.880 Well, that's that it's just shocking
00:28:57.760 What you can put in a in an opinion piece
00:29:01.040 So obviously this is just more about the business model of the press they want to keep it
00:29:06.800 All right
00:29:07.280 There was apparently some new UAP legislation that's brewing
00:29:14.160 Which would add transparency to all the ufo claims
00:29:18.160 And there would be some kind of law that would
00:29:20.560 Allow the public to see more than we've seen so far
00:29:24.000 Now everybody thinks that's a good idea right everybody
00:29:27.120 Don't you think the public should know everything our government knows about ufos
00:29:32.320 Just seems like an obvious good thing
00:29:34.320 Okay, but turns out
00:29:37.280 That there are four republican members of the gang of eight
00:29:41.280 And this is the people who have classified intelligence
00:29:45.280 So these are the people who do know the secrets that you don't know
00:29:50.160 There are four people who know the actual secrets
00:29:53.600 About the so-called ufos or maybe it's a new technology
00:29:57.600 And they don't want the public to know it
00:30:01.360 And as vivek says
00:30:02.640 Why what what do they know?
00:30:10.000 Hmm does it does it bother you at all
00:30:13.520 That the people who know the most about it don't believe the public should be allowed to know
00:30:20.800 Hmm
00:30:22.400 Let us speculate why that might be
00:30:25.520 Speculation number one
00:30:27.840 They believe there's something real
00:30:29.600 But there's not
00:30:33.360 That's a possibility right there could be four republicans who believe there's really something there
00:30:38.880 And they don't want you to know because you might panic
00:30:42.480 Right, so it could be they mistakenly believe something that's not true
00:30:46.880 There's a good chance of that actually
00:30:48.880 Another possibility
00:30:52.400 Is that it's
00:30:54.800 American technology
00:30:57.200 And we don't want anybody to know we have this American technology
00:31:01.520 But that wouldn't explain
00:31:03.760 Why other people who also know the top secret information
00:31:07.840 Think it would be okay for the public to know
00:31:10.800 Can you see any scenario in which the the reality of the uaps is top secret american technology?
00:31:19.120 And yet four people who know that would be willing to tell the public
00:31:24.400 I can't imagine anybody who knew that
00:31:26.880 You know knew that to be true
00:31:28.800 Would want to tell the public about top secret military technology
00:31:33.200 That doesn't make sense
00:31:35.040 So i'm going to i'm going to eliminate from the option set
00:31:40.560 I'm going to eliminate that it's america it's american technology
00:31:45.760 Now suppose we knew it was somebody else's technology like chinese technology
00:31:51.840 Would we not want to tell the public that?
00:31:56.960 I feel like we might want to tell the public that because we told them about the spy balloons
00:32:03.040 It would just be another technology
00:32:05.520 Now would it be because americans would be too afraid of the new technology?
00:32:10.720 Probably not
00:32:12.640 Probably not
00:32:14.880 So
00:32:16.960 I feel like the best
00:32:19.760 Just guess
00:32:21.440 Of why there might be four republicans who don't want you to know is that they don't know what it is
00:32:27.040 I think it's more likely that the four republicans who want to keep it close to the vest
00:32:32.320 Still don't know if it's human technology or alien or what
00:32:37.200 And they'd rather just
00:32:39.120 Not take a chance
00:32:41.440 I don't know
00:32:43.120 What do you think?
00:32:44.320 What do you think is the main reason that they wouldn't want to tell you?
00:32:47.440 But other people who know the same information
00:32:50.240 Who would be willing to tell you?
00:32:53.040 I think it has to come down to whether you believe it's real
00:32:57.760 I bet it comes down to that
00:32:59.760 It's also possible
00:33:01.600 That it would reveal something about america that we don't want to reveal
00:33:06.560 For example
00:33:08.080 We know there's one historical example where the I believe it was the cia
00:33:12.240 And it's in writing
00:33:14.960 That somebody in the cia once
00:33:17.600 Specifically recommended
00:33:19.600 Planting fake ufo stories
00:33:22.160 To divert from the real things that we're doing
00:33:25.600 So we know that that happened at least as a suggestion
00:33:29.440 Once in history
00:33:31.040 So it's not like it's unheard of
00:33:33.120 Or crazy
00:33:34.800 So here's my here's my other hypothesis
00:33:38.080 That
00:33:41.280 There are at least four republicans who know
00:33:44.480 That our intelligence agencies plant these stories intentionally
00:33:49.200 And they may not want to take that tool away from the intelligence people because maybe sometimes planting a fake story is just what you need
00:33:56.640 Maybe
00:33:57.760 I don't know
00:34:01.280 Yeah, they do it does look like an intentional distraction to me
00:34:05.840 That's what it looks like
00:34:08.720 So i'm going to go with
00:34:11.520 We'll never know probably but i'm going to go with there are four republican
00:34:16.160 Candidates who know it would reveal something about the way we operate
00:34:21.840 That would be
00:34:24.240 Unproductive
00:34:26.240 Something about the way the government operates
00:34:29.120 And informs its citizens
00:34:31.120 That's so unsavory that maybe better we didn't know
00:34:35.200 According to some people
00:34:36.240 That's just my guess
00:34:40.000 All right, what else is happening?
00:34:42.560 Um, the story and it was newsweek
00:34:46.320 That uh, there are many excess black deaths
00:34:49.840 And the reasons given are
00:34:56.240 Could be wealth
00:34:57.760 A wealth of effect
00:35:00.000 So apparently there are two things correlated one is
00:35:04.480 Poverty
00:35:05.520 So poverty is associated with
00:35:07.920 Or worse outcomes
00:35:09.680 But also the same excess deaths exist
00:35:13.120 There are more black deaths among college educated black women
00:35:20.240 Than non-college educated white women
00:35:22.640 And white women who didn't go to college
00:35:33.600 So in other words, we've narrowed it down to two things
00:35:36.720 There are two things that will cause excess black deaths
00:35:40.400 One is poverty
00:35:41.680 Poverty and the end and the other thing that will cause it is no poverty
00:35:48.560 So two situations that cause it poverty and no poverty
00:35:53.280 Because we we assume that the uh
00:35:56.400 The black women with college degrees are probably making more money than the white women without college degrees
00:36:02.080 So in both cases, if they have money or don't have money, they die
00:36:07.920 And uh, the article attributes this to systemic racism
00:36:12.400 So systemic racism is why black people will die
00:36:17.200 If they're successful
00:36:19.040 And also why they're not successful
00:36:21.360 Because of the systemic racism
00:36:24.320 That all made sense to you, didn't it?
00:36:27.120 Did did all did that sound like ridiculous nonsense?
00:36:30.000 Yeah, it sounds like ridiculous nonsense to me
00:36:35.120 I don't know what's true
00:36:37.120 I don't know what's true, but I know this is bullshit
00:36:40.560 So
00:36:44.800 And there's another study i'm not sure i believe any studies anymore
00:36:49.680 Well, i'm not even sure why i bring them up they're all going to be debunked in a month
00:36:53.840 But there's studies that says that there were uh on the on the positive side
00:36:57.600 If you like if you like this as a positive there were 32 000 extra births
00:37:04.240 probably because
00:37:06.640 Abortion became illegal in a number of states after the big supreme court decision
00:37:13.200 So do you believe this there were 32 000
00:37:16.640 Babies born that would have been aborted if it were easier to abort them
00:37:20.240 Does that sound true?
00:37:22.240 Does that sound true?
00:37:24.240 Do you think convenience was the only reason that 32 000 babies were born?
00:37:30.080 That if you had to drive somewhere or maybe pay extra
00:37:33.200 I seem to have a little problem here with one of my devices
00:37:43.760 One of my devices appears to be underpowered
00:37:48.000 Which i'm going to fix while you watch
00:37:54.160 Going in
00:37:54.640 Fixed
00:38:02.400 All right
00:38:04.240 So
00:38:06.560 And then other people are saying this is good news
00:38:10.800 Is it good news
00:38:12.640 Is it good news that these babies who would have been aborted were born?
00:38:17.360 Well, if you think that you know
00:38:20.240 Life is sacred and absolutely yes
00:38:22.720 But here's the question I asked you for morality reasons
00:38:29.040 And this is not an opinion. This is a question
00:38:33.680 For those of you who say the 32 000 extra births were sort of a blessing
00:38:41.120 How good is it to be born when you weren't wanted?
00:38:45.120 Now, I know there are lots of times that works out great
00:38:48.000 You know the mother will say you know I didn't choose this but I'm sure glad I have this baby
00:38:53.440 What what percentage of the 32 000 are going to be born into a like a hellscape of
00:38:59.040 You know no love and poverty
00:39:01.600 One parent and every problem in the world
00:39:04.880 Oh
00:39:05.840 Did that make the world a better place?
00:39:09.840 Suppose you knew that half of them
00:39:12.400 Were going to be born into a horrible situation
00:39:14.800 And the mother knew it the mother knew it?
00:39:19.520 That's why she wouldn't have done it
00:39:22.400 Would you be okay?
00:39:23.840 Let's say hypothetically. Let's just be this just a
00:39:26.960 A mental experiment
00:39:28.960 And i'm not showing you my opinion
00:39:31.600 There's no opinion of mine in this. It's actually a genuine question
00:39:35.760 If you knew you could create 32 000 extra babies by getting rid of abortion
00:39:40.880 But you also knew
00:39:42.880 That half of them would be born into
00:39:45.440 Just the worst situation
00:39:47.680 Is that still morally that's still the correct thing to do?
00:39:51.040 I see always I see no's
00:39:58.320 I see yeses
00:40:00.560 Mostly yeses some no's
00:40:03.760 A little bit of a disagreement
00:40:05.120 Now for how many of you is the question again, this is not my opinion
00:40:14.800 I'm just actually curious
00:40:17.520 For those of you who say you know life is sacred
00:40:20.800 Is that informed entirely by religious belief?
00:40:25.200 Or would you say that if you didn't have any religious belief?
00:40:29.120 Is your belief in the
00:40:31.040 The sanctity of life I guess
00:40:33.520 Is that based on entirely religious or sort of
00:40:37.920 Just feeling how it feels and thinking how you think?
00:40:42.720 Both? Depends
00:40:47.680 I'm atheist
00:40:49.840 AOC believes that
00:40:57.600 You got an anti-semite here
00:40:59.120 The rights of others are not your purview
00:41:03.600 Dickwad
00:41:05.600 What?
00:41:06.720 The rights of others?
00:41:09.360 I think you're not talking to me, aren't you?
00:41:10.720 Yeah
00:41:18.000 You know, so here's the question that comes out to this
00:41:21.840 Um
00:41:25.200 Some would say that you know life is life and if god decided there was going to be a life
00:41:31.440 Then you know who are you to take it?
00:41:33.520 I get that. I understand that point
00:41:36.080 But is there anything to quality of life?
00:41:40.400 Does quality of life have no
00:41:44.080 No impact
00:41:44.720 But let me let me make it more complicated
00:41:51.520 Just so we think this through properly
00:41:55.280 If we're looking at those hostages in gaza
00:41:57.600 What would be more valuable?
00:42:03.920 What lives are any of those lives more valuable than others?
00:42:08.560 For example, when you're if you're giving back a hostage that's 80 years old
00:42:14.160 You know, we're happy to get any hostage back
00:42:16.080 But an 80 year old has you know, maybe five years of extra life left
00:42:19.440 A child would have you know 100 years
00:42:24.240 Are those the same same value?
00:42:27.920 No, i'm not playing god i'm asking you
00:42:30.880 Would you put them at the same value?
00:42:33.200 If you had to choose, I mean you'd rather not choose but if you had to
00:42:37.600 Same value or different value because one is 100 years of life and the one is five years life
00:42:42.960 If you value life
00:42:45.280 You would value the maximum years of life on average
00:42:50.400 So I don't have an opinion on that i'm just asking you if you do all right
00:42:56.640 Secondly, which is more immoral?
00:43:03.760 Stopping somebody's life before they knew they had a life
00:43:07.680 And again, this is not i'm not giving you any opinion on abortion
00:43:11.440 I'm just asking you your opinion. Which is more moral?
00:43:15.120 To stop a fetus
00:43:18.800 From growing you would call it murder some would call it an abortion
00:43:24.240 Is that worse if you knew the person was going to be born into a life of misery?
00:43:30.880 Would it be better to for someone who's never even understood that they're alive they don't even know they're alive
00:43:36.240 They have no
00:43:37.440 No conscious understanding of even being alive
00:43:40.640 Would be better to stop that if you knew they were going to be born into misery
00:43:45.280 Which is more ethical?
00:43:47.040 Is it more ethical to create a life of misery?
00:43:50.000 Or to prevent a life of misery before anybody even knew they had a life at all?
00:43:55.360 No one right no one knows the future so you would be operating only on statistical likelihood that is correct
00:44:09.280 You'd have to make a statistical choice that doesn't really change the equation too much
00:44:15.520 How would you know no it's not about knowing
00:44:18.800 It's about statistical likelihood
00:44:21.360 So if you've got let's say a mother who
00:44:25.520 That has no employment possibilities is single
00:44:30.320 Maybe is addicted to drugs you know, whatever it is
00:44:33.840 But I think you could pretty well determine which ones are going to have a tough time
00:44:38.400 And and and does it matter that you would only be right 90 percent of the time
00:44:43.040 Would that change your decision?
00:44:45.040 Well 10 percent of the time it would be a good life
00:44:49.360 Is that is that the way you think about it?
00:44:53.920 Now don't give me the kobayashi maru of they should just not have to get pregnant like we all get that
00:45:01.360 But you know once you are pregnant, how do you make the decision?
00:45:06.560 Chaos corner says you're lost in the woods scott. Now that's cognitive dissonance
00:45:11.920 That's cognitive dissonance
00:45:15.760 Because you can't handle the questions
00:45:19.760 If you can't handle the question you you go personally after the speaker. I didn't give you any opinion at all
00:45:28.000 So why am I lost if I didn't give you an opinion?
00:45:32.080 That you're having a mental
00:45:34.080 Event because the questions are too difficult for you to kick around
00:45:37.760 That's called playing god playing god is called word thinking we're thinking is not part of the conversation
00:45:48.880 If you can replace all the thinking with like little bumper sticker phrases the plain god or it's a life
00:45:56.560 That's word thinking
00:45:58.400 We all know what it is
00:46:00.800 You know giving you the label doesn't change what it is
00:46:08.160 More brains are better for humanity
00:46:11.440 Yeah, we all play god that's true
00:46:14.320 Scott can handle the heat of the kitchen again
00:46:20.480 Um
00:46:22.480 You only playing god when you do nothing
00:46:24.480 Saying it's evil
00:46:35.200 Well, all right, let me ask you this question
00:46:37.600 How many of you believe that evil
00:46:41.120 Exists as a force as opposed to just the label you put on something you don't like how many think evil is like a real thing?
00:46:48.000 Do you think it's real and do you think it's coming from a
00:46:56.240 A source is the evil emanating from a source as in satan
00:47:03.200 How many of you believe evil is real and it emanates from satan
00:47:10.240 I know soros is the funny answer
00:47:12.720 How many and how many think that evil is real
00:47:19.840 Whether or not satan is real
00:47:25.280 I don't even understand that honestly for those who say evil is real
00:47:29.920 I I neither agree with it or disagree with it like what the fuck does that mean
00:47:36.480 You actually know what that means
00:47:37.760 But for those of you who have a solid opinion that evil is real
00:47:43.200 You must know what it is
00:47:45.920 What the hell is it is it like a force?
00:47:50.000 Is it like gravity you can measure it, but you can't grab a handful of it
00:47:55.520 You know, it's certainly something that you can measure
00:47:59.040 In terms of you know, is there more murder or less murder
00:48:02.560 You can measure that but does that mean evil exists or does it just mean that the system is created?
00:48:07.600 Or murderers
00:48:12.720 Yeah, so I can't agree with you that evil exists because I don't even understand that what you're talking about
00:48:19.680 Me that there's there's no part of my brain that could even handle that question
00:48:25.040 So I think that's a religious frame
00:48:28.480 What do you call someone who eats children hungry
00:48:30.960 There was my glib answer that's right. What do you call somebody who eats children hungry?
00:48:42.240 No, there we know that we there is a mental illness
00:48:48.320 We know there is cruelty
00:48:50.720 We know that if you take that captagon drug
00:48:53.760 You'll do things that you wouldn't do if you didn't take that drug
00:48:56.160 We know that people can be brainwashed to do the most horrible things
00:49:02.000 Is a brainwashed person operating under the force of evil or under the force of brainwashing?
00:49:08.880 Or is it the same thing?
00:49:10.720 So that the whole evil question is sort of that
00:49:14.240 How it feels to me is an escape from thinking
00:49:17.760 When when thinking is too too painful
00:49:22.400 It's easier to just replace it with a word
00:49:25.120 I don't want to think about two hearts. I'll say evil
00:49:29.120 What cause it well evil
00:49:31.360 No, maybe if you thought about this with a little more depth
00:49:34.720 You might see that some kind of cause and effect based on
00:49:38.640 you know, the person how they were born plus how they were raised
00:49:42.240 Maybe you could do something about that. No, it's just evil. Nope. Satan. Just evil
00:49:47.200 To me using evil as a explanation of anything
00:49:51.920 Is just saying you don't want to think about it
00:49:55.920 That's what that's what it sounds like to my ears because I don't think evil is real
00:50:00.560 Evil is just a word you put on something you didn't like
00:50:03.760 Evil is a summary evil is an adjective
00:50:15.520 Disagree
00:50:18.560 Well, if you have a religious interpretation then you would disagree
00:50:22.160 Of course
00:50:26.080 Do you think good is real? No
00:50:28.080 No
00:50:30.880 No, I don't think there's good and evil. I think there's just what people do
00:50:35.120 And then we put labels on it after the fact
00:50:37.760 Because I believe in cause and effect
00:50:41.920 So well, let me put it in this in this
00:50:46.080 Let me ask you this question. Here's a religious question for you
00:50:50.560 Do you have to do you have to believe that free will exists
00:50:54.960 In order for evil to exist? I don't know the answer to this question
00:50:59.920 Can you have evil if there's no free will?
00:51:07.600 Some say you can't have evil unless there's free will
00:51:12.400 Some say you can
00:51:19.520 Yes
00:51:21.520 Okay, so free will to me is a
00:51:26.960 In my to my satisfaction it's been proven
00:51:30.080 Scientifically to not exist
00:51:32.880 But I think science has proven that free will is imaginary
00:51:37.680 And a free will is imaginary then evil doesn't make a lot of sense to me just cause
00:51:43.520 So let me let me tell you why I see it
00:51:45.920 If I if I take a rock and I drop it it just drops on the ground
00:51:54.240 Is that evil?
00:51:56.080 No, just a rock dropping on the ground
00:51:58.880 If I drop that rock on my foot and it hurts my foot
00:52:03.760 Is that evil?
00:52:06.800 Just cause and effect
00:52:09.360 So to me, you know, if somebody is born a cannibal
00:52:13.680 You know, there's something about their genetic makeup and then on top of that their upbringing turns them into a cannibal
00:52:20.080 That's just like somebody dropping a rock on their foot
00:52:22.160 You don't like a rock on your foot
00:52:25.840 You don't like that the guy ate your son
00:52:29.040 Oh, I hate the rock on my foot and I hate the guy eating my son
00:52:32.000 But it was just cause and effect
00:52:34.960 You know gravity caused the rock to go down
00:52:37.920 Genetics plus environment caused the cannibal to eat your son
00:52:43.200 This is interesting
00:52:45.760 Why do I have the power plugged in and yet
00:52:48.800 YouTube that says it's going to quit
00:52:51.280 There's some kind of a power issue here going on
00:52:54.880 You don't know what it is
00:52:56.880 All right. Well, anyway, I think I'm done
00:52:58.880 Uh, youtube thanks for joining it's kind of a slow saturday after black friday
00:53:04.720 And uh, we'll have lots more interesting news
00:53:07.920 Another day, but I don't think this weekend is going to be a big news day. Thanks for joining youtube. Talk to you tomorrow