Real Coffee with Scott Adams - Episode 2310 Scott Adams： CWSA 12⧸02⧸23 Don't Miss My James Carville Impression, Pre-Trumpers, More

00:00:00.000 Good morning, everybody, and welcome to the highlight of human civilization.

00:00:12.000 It's called Coffee with Scott Adams, the best thing you've ever experienced,

00:00:15.400 and if you want to take it up to levels that nobody will ever achieve again,

00:00:20.260 well, all you need for that is a cup or a mug or a glass, a tank or a chalice or a stein,

00:00:24.620 a canteen jug or flask, a vessel of any kind.

00:00:27.320 Fill it with your favorite liquid, I like coffee, and join me now for the unparalleled pleasure.

00:00:33.240 It's the dopamine, at the end of the day, the thing that makes everything better.

00:00:36.220 It's called a simultaneous sip, and it happens now. Savor it. Go.

00:00:45.440 Oh, all the way to my bones. I feel this coffee in my toenails.

00:00:53.860 Mmm, feels pretty good.

00:00:57.320 Pretty, pretty good.

00:01:00.500 Well, I've got a show for you, and it's got a theme.

00:01:04.880 The theme will be revealed as we go along, because they're better with a theme.

00:01:10.340 But first, top of the news, Vivek Ramaswamy has coined a new term that I'm going to borrow,

00:01:18.660 which is another word for stealing. I'm stealing it. I'll call it borrowing.

00:01:22.660 And Vivek posted on X today, the left says our race and sexuality govern who you are and what you can achieve.

00:01:32.120 If you question them, they call you a racist.

00:01:35.260 This is psychological slavery.

00:01:38.600 Ooh, hello, yes, yes.

00:01:42.840 It is psychological slavery.

00:01:44.640 You're not allowed to say what you think, or you will be destroyed in civilization.

00:01:50.980 It's psychological slavery.

00:01:54.460 That culture of fear has completely replaced our culture of free speech,

00:01:58.040 and Vivek says, I am running for president to fix it.

00:02:02.400 Damn.

00:02:05.320 Damn.

00:02:06.640 That is so good.

00:02:07.560 Anyway, I saw a graph showing that 45 million immigrants,

00:02:17.040 counting legal and illegal immigrants,

00:02:19.900 make up our country of, I don't know, what are we up to?

00:02:23.580 380 million or something?

00:02:25.460 What's the current population of the United States?

00:02:28.380 380?

00:02:29.140 350?

00:02:29.960 It's only a 350?

00:02:32.480 I thought it was more than 350 now.

00:02:34.440 Is that the current number?

00:02:37.560 350?

00:02:38.240 Oh, okay.

00:02:38.940 People say 350.

00:02:40.320 All right, so 45 million of the 350 million are immigrants, legal and illegal.

00:02:46.160 And, you know, I think the point of the post I saw was that there are too many immigrants. 1.00

00:02:52.800 Now, certainly it's a huge burden on the system to have too many immigrants too quickly. 1.00

00:03:00.160 So it's a flow rate problem.

00:03:02.260 It's not a question of immigrants, yes or no.

00:03:04.880 It's just a flow rate issue.

00:03:06.620 However, I think that the context has to be that, and by the way, this is showing that

00:03:14.160 there's been a huge increase since 1980 in immigration.

00:03:18.060 Now, what would have happened if there had not been?

00:03:21.400 Because this is what I like to teach you, you know, with my background in economics,

00:03:27.460 that if you don't say, what would it have been if it hadn't happened?

00:03:30.660 Like, would it have necessarily been better?

00:03:33.480 And would it be just different?

00:03:35.940 Now, it could have been better or worse.

00:03:42.740 I don't know.

00:03:43.280 But here's the thing that we don't know.

00:03:47.140 Would the population of the United States have declined without immigration?

00:03:53.180 Would we have a declining population?

00:03:55.660 Or, alternately, a population that's growing but not fast enough?

00:04:00.020 Because one of the things that Elon Musk is sort of brilliant about explaining to us

00:04:06.120 is that overpopulation is far less of a problem than underpopulation

00:04:15.060 because you can't pay for your old people.

00:04:18.060 Probably it wouldn't be a problem if old people weren't living so long, 1.00

00:04:21.100 but you can have a real big population of non-workers to workers under the current situation.

00:04:28.400 So really, success is a pyramid scheme.

00:04:32.560 I hate to say it.

00:04:34.100 But the only way you can succeed in the long run is a pyramid scheme

00:04:38.260 where you're having lots of new babies that have to work hard to pay for the older people.

00:04:44.700 As soon as you're not bringing in new people at the bottom of the pyramid,

00:04:48.180 the top falls apart, too, eventually.

00:04:51.780 So, let me agree with you who are all screaming in your brains,

00:04:56.500 but Scott, but Scott, it would have been far better to control immigration

00:05:02.360 so we vetted the right immigrants,

00:05:04.900 and to financially incentivize big families.

00:05:11.740 Would you agree with that?

00:05:13.420 Would have been better to control immigration, 1.00

00:05:16.560 get plenty of it, but control it so you get the right mix,

00:05:19.800 and then also financially incentivize the population?

00:05:26.000 That's good.

00:05:26.880 I agree with that.

00:05:28.260 And can we also agree that we should use our time machines

00:05:31.800 to go back in time and fix it?

00:05:34.040 Who's with me?

00:05:37.540 Time travel?

00:05:40.020 Anybody?

00:05:41.760 My point is, you don't get to compare it to the thing you didn't do

00:05:46.140 and that you wouldn't have done.

00:05:49.180 That's not the right comparison.

00:05:50.260 The only thing I'm saying is that the past is already over.

00:05:54.480 If you're comparing it to the future,

00:05:57.280 then you want to bring in this, let's do good vetting,

00:06:00.760 let's maybe incentivize families of people who are already here.

00:06:04.620 In the future, that's the way to go.

00:06:09.240 No doubt about it.

00:06:10.980 But you really can't change the past.

00:06:12.960 I'm just saying, would we be better off

00:06:15.380 if we didn't have 45 million immigrants 1.00

00:06:18.040 who came in without as much vetting as we could have had?

00:06:21.920 And the answer is, I don't know.

00:06:24.440 I don't know.

00:06:26.100 If you think you know the answer to that question,

00:06:29.700 I'm pretty sure you don't.

00:06:31.340 In the short run, I would agree it's bad.

00:06:35.500 In the short run, it's a burden on the system.

00:06:39.340 But how many of those people are homeless?

00:06:43.180 Prior to the most recent surge, which is over the top,

00:06:48.300 for 20 or 30 years, how many immigrants became homeless?

00:06:53.680 About zero.

00:06:56.180 And I'm going to say something super, super racist,

00:06:59.960 but it's okay because it's about white people,

00:07:02.260 so I'm allowed to do that.

00:07:04.300 Have you ever tried to get a white guy to mow your lawn? 0.70

00:07:10.780 Ever tried to get a white guy to do some work on your house?

00:07:15.000 It depends where you live.

00:07:17.660 It depends entirely where you live.

00:07:19.680 But I've got to tell you, there's a huge part of the economy

00:07:23.740 that wouldn't work at all without immigration 1.00

00:07:26.360 because you just can't get people to do that work

00:07:29.100 for whatever reason.

00:07:31.460 It doesn't pay enough or whatever.

00:07:33.360 I don't know what the reason is.

00:07:34.800 But you're not going to get white people to do that work. 0.55

00:07:37.420 They just won't.

00:07:38.660 They'll just sit around and die instead.

00:07:41.060 I don't know why.

00:07:42.700 Yeah, good luck with the teenagers.

00:07:44.080 And in the comments, somebody says,

00:07:46.180 well, you could get the teenagers to do that work.

00:07:49.120 Good luck.

00:07:50.620 Good luck.

00:07:52.220 All right?

00:07:52.660 Try your way.

00:07:53.800 Now, I don't know.

00:07:55.120 So let me be very careful about this.

00:07:57.580 I don't know that we're better off.

00:08:00.000 But I think more likely yes than no.

00:08:03.540 Now, even with all the negatives,

00:08:06.500 of which there are tremendous negatives,

00:08:08.800 I think we probably net out okay in the long run.

00:08:11.700 In the short run, maybe not.

00:08:14.040 You know, last four years, probably more bad than good.

00:08:17.840 But you have to look at the longer run.

00:08:19.840 Most of them will have kids who went to American schools

00:08:23.540 and really bought into the American dream.

00:08:27.920 You know, the immigrants are pretty much more American

00:08:30.260 than the ones who are here.

00:08:32.540 Let me say that again.

00:08:34.720 A lot of our immigrants, not all of them,

00:08:37.840 and that's a problem,

00:08:38.620 but a lot of the immigrants,

00:08:40.420 especially the ones coming from south of the border,

00:08:42.960 are more American than the Americans.

00:08:46.260 They're more American than the Americans. 0.88

00:08:49.140 They want to work hard.

00:08:51.780 They worship their God.

00:08:54.520 They're huge on family.

00:08:56.520 And they want America to do well

00:08:58.060 because it's their new country.

00:09:00.540 But that's as American as you can get. 0.77

00:09:02.660 And, by the way, they're not woke.

00:09:04.700 They're not woke at all.

00:09:05.740 They're not even a little woke.

00:09:07.960 They're not even slightly woke.

00:09:10.760 You telling me they're bringing the average down?

00:09:14.200 I don't think so.

00:09:15.920 Have you seen the people who are here?

00:09:19.020 Yeah.

00:09:19.460 All right.

00:09:19.880 Well, I just want to put some doubt in your mind

00:09:23.700 about the mix and the quality of immigrants

00:09:27.860 and what that looks like in the long run.

00:09:30.040 It might be more good than you think.

00:09:31.380 Well, the Disney bashing is at an all-time high.

00:09:38.800 We have some stats that say

00:09:40.560 the child grooming content on the X platform

00:09:44.360 has reduced by 83% recently.

00:09:48.020 Wow.

00:09:48.960 Child grooming on X is down to 83%.

00:09:52.000 And that's because Disney pulled their ads.

00:09:56.720 Okay, that's the Babylon Bee's joke.

00:09:58.900 Babylon Bee is just killing it.

00:10:01.380 Yeah, the Babylon Bee has gone to national treasure level

00:10:07.840 to the point where you feel sorry

00:10:10.200 if somebody isn't watching it every day.

00:10:12.620 That's some good stuff.

00:10:14.920 That is some really good stuff.

00:10:16.960 So the mockery guns are firing nonstop now.

00:10:20.380 So yesterday I posted this

00:10:24.900 because I like to pile on.

00:10:27.600 I said, does Bob Iger know

00:10:29.540 Disney no longer makes relevant products

00:10:31.660 and their theme parks have all the fun of Gaza

00:10:34.440 during wartime?

00:10:36.560 So that's what I said.

00:10:38.700 And I looked at the comments today.

00:10:40.680 One of the comments on that was from Elon Musk.

00:10:43.080 And he says, Disney has a major content problem.

00:10:46.900 Almost their entire upcoming slate is unwatchable.

00:10:50.800 They are the world's biggest example of go woke, go broke.

00:10:54.680 LOL.

00:10:57.100 LOL.

00:11:00.460 Now, is it my imagination

00:11:02.820 or is it now obvious that there's more than one Elon Musk?

00:11:08.640 There's more than one, right?

00:11:11.540 Because how do you explain

00:11:12.920 that there are 8 billion people in the world

00:11:16.020 and I can wake up

00:11:17.080 and see the richest person in the world

00:11:19.800 commenting on my post?

00:11:21.820 That's not possible.

00:11:25.340 I mean, just consider the odds of that.

00:11:27.460 That's not actually possible.

00:11:29.620 He's running, you know, the major companies.

00:11:31.880 He's on every podcast.

00:11:33.860 You know, he's commenting to people.

00:11:37.460 I think AI has already cloned him.

00:11:40.640 I think there are at least

00:11:42.060 five to seven Elon Musks.

00:11:47.400 Possibly robots.

00:11:49.440 Possibly.

00:11:50.920 No, I don't know.

00:11:51.540 I'm just making that up.

00:11:52.680 But I honestly don't know

00:11:54.460 how he does all the things he does.

00:11:56.440 It just seems like there's

00:11:57.940 way too many things happening in the world

00:12:00.560 where he's the most important player in that thing.

00:12:04.700 I mean, I get that he's the most important player in space.

00:12:08.620 I get that.

00:12:09.900 I get that he's the most important player in social media.

00:12:13.600 Okay, I get that.

00:12:15.460 But why is it like he's also

00:12:16.800 he's also the main person like posting on X.

00:12:20.000 How is it possible to do all those things?

00:12:22.960 Yeah, EVs, et cetera.

00:12:26.080 Well, there's some stats that show that TikTok and Instagram

00:12:29.100 are like an order of magnitude worse than X

00:12:32.940 in terms of anti-Semitic comment.

00:12:35.140 Why is it obvious to everybody that anti-Semitism on the X platform

00:12:50.460 had nothing to do with why the advertisers pulled out?

00:12:54.040 Well, it's really obvious that it's just political, right?

00:12:58.620 Everybody can see that.

00:13:00.240 Now, I get that businesses have to respond to their customers

00:13:03.080 and it's just one less thing they think they have to worry about.

00:13:06.820 But do you think that any of these companies are going to do better

00:13:09.500 because they pissed off 45% of the country?

00:13:13.080 Or whatever is pro-Elon Musk, I guess,

00:13:16.020 or pro-X or pro-free speech, however we want to put it.

00:13:18.560 But I'd like to, again, read the names of these companies

00:13:21.760 because these companies are just shit on this topic anyway.

00:13:28.920 I mean, I have no respect for these companies.

00:13:31.240 These are major respected, they were respected,

00:13:34.260 but this decision is so despicable and so counterproductive,

00:13:40.600 I just want to read their names again

00:13:42.500 so you can hear who's the assholes, right? 0.51

00:13:45.080 Apple Computer, Disney, Washington Post, Paramount, NBC,

00:13:49.400 Marvel, IBM, Sony Pictures, CBS, The Colbert Show,

00:13:54.040 Comcast, Lionsgate, Warner Brothers, and now Walmart.

00:13:59.140 I guess the president of Walmart was a college buddy of Hunter Biden.

00:14:05.220 Everything's about who knows who.

00:14:07.940 If you don't know that part of a story,

00:14:09.880 you usually don't know the story.

00:14:11.160 That's the real part, is who knows who.

00:14:12.680 But yeah, these companies got some explaining to do.

00:14:17.900 I saw a post today that says that Apple iPhone

00:14:21.740 has a you've been stopped by the police app.

00:14:26.220 Is that real?

00:14:28.920 Have you heard of that?

00:14:30.800 That you can tell your phone,

00:14:33.320 you can talk to the S-I-R-I app,

00:14:36.500 and tell it you're being stopped by the police,

00:14:39.120 just verbally,

00:14:40.340 and apparently it turns the screen off

00:14:43.180 but it starts filming and recording

00:14:44.840 so you can have a recording of it.

00:14:47.600 The screen is off so it doesn't look like

00:14:49.520 the phone is doing something

00:14:50.560 but the front camera is working.

00:14:53.460 And it records it

00:14:54.800 and it also sends a message to

00:14:57.480 whoever you designate

00:14:58.820 to tell them that you've been stopped

00:15:00.780 and just to monitor the situation.

00:15:03.340 Is that real?

00:15:06.400 I've only seen one reference to it

00:15:08.240 but is that real?

00:15:09.380 I'm seeing a yes.

00:15:11.440 That's pretty cool.

00:15:13.520 I would like to remind you

00:15:15.320 that when Black Lives Matter was first

00:15:18.420 protesting and George Floyd was in the news

00:15:22.300 and they were looking for solutions

00:15:24.740 for all the alleged police problems

00:15:27.800 with black pedestrians

00:15:29.580 or black innocent people 0.68

00:15:31.340 or some of them being arrested

00:15:33.340 for real reasons but still.

00:15:37.980 Wouldn't it have been nice

00:15:39.340 if the tech companies said,

00:15:41.680 hey, we could do something about that.

00:15:43.960 We're working on a product.

00:15:46.080 But I don't think at any point

00:15:47.460 Black Lives Matter was serious.

00:15:49.860 I think they were very invested

00:15:51.200 in keeping the problem the problem

00:15:52.800 because that's how you raise funds

00:15:54.540 for the people who run the organization.

00:15:56.360 You can't solve the problem.

00:15:59.420 That would be very economically unwise.

00:16:03.800 Unwise.

00:16:05.820 All right.

00:16:07.240 A number of people on the right

00:16:08.780 are noticing that John Fetterman

00:16:10.860 is making sense

00:16:14.040 and doing things that you would want

00:16:15.780 an elected official to do.

00:16:18.800 What?

00:16:20.320 Here's what John Fetterman said

00:16:22.140 about a politician in his own party.

00:16:25.680 about a prominent Democrat.

00:16:28.560 He said, quote,

00:16:29.680 we have a colleague in the Senate

00:16:31.080 that's actually done

00:16:32.120 much more sinister kinds of things.

00:16:34.760 And the context was the Santos expulsion.

00:16:38.640 And he said,

00:16:39.560 he needs to go.

00:16:40.960 If you're going to expel Santos,

00:16:43.120 how can you allow Menendez?

00:16:45.320 Remember, Menendez is in his own party.

00:16:48.200 How can you allow Menendez

00:16:49.440 to remain in the Senate?

00:16:50.980 Menendez is really a senator for Egypt,

00:16:53.060 not New Jersey.

00:16:55.680 who exactly predicted

00:17:05.760 that John Fetterman

00:17:06.860 would do something

00:17:07.980 that is unambiguously positive

00:17:09.860 for the United States

00:17:11.640 while being negative

00:17:13.020 for his own party?

00:17:15.080 Didn't see it coming.

00:17:16.920 You know what?

00:17:17.620 I can see his appeal now.

00:17:18.840 I never saw it before.

00:17:22.700 But I can see why people liked him.

00:17:25.820 Right?

00:17:26.100 Now, that doesn't mean

00:17:27.100 I like everything he does.

00:17:28.480 I'm not going to support him

00:17:29.640 for president, etc.

00:17:31.260 But you've got to call out

00:17:33.200 good behavior when you see it.

00:17:36.460 So I'm going to go against

00:17:38.480 a lot of Republicans on this.

00:17:42.600 I actually am kind of happy

00:17:47.340 that there were enough Republicans

00:17:48.760 to, you know,

00:17:51.260 treat Santos as an outsider,

00:17:53.240 basically,

00:17:53.720 to vote against him.

00:17:54.920 And I like the fact

00:17:56.060 that Fetterman is willing

00:17:57.260 to vote against

00:17:58.000 a prominent member of his team.

00:18:01.320 Those are good signs.

00:18:03.260 Now, I know some people are saying,

00:18:05.020 hey, you know,

00:18:06.260 the Republicans are acting like losers.

00:18:08.180 I think Sticks and Hammer

00:18:09.240 made this point.

00:18:10.360 You're not playing to win

00:18:11.300 if you're going to take out

00:18:12.740 your own person

00:18:13.520 for something that wasn't

00:18:14.500 even a crime.

00:18:15.780 I mean,

00:18:16.600 at least he hasn't been

00:18:17.400 convicted of a crime.

00:18:19.180 So it seems like the Republicans

00:18:20.360 were being too hard

00:18:21.460 on their own side

00:18:22.480 and not hard enough

00:18:23.940 on the opponents.

00:18:25.020 I get that.

00:18:26.560 I get that.

00:18:27.900 But, you know,

00:18:28.900 they were also acting

00:18:29.900 under principle.

00:18:32.720 And they were trying

00:18:33.900 to do something

00:18:34.500 that they thought

00:18:35.120 maybe was good

00:18:35.820 for the party

00:18:36.360 in the long run.

00:18:37.020 Maybe it was good

00:18:38.200 for the country

00:18:38.700 in the long run.

00:18:39.680 I'm not going to complain

00:18:40.560 about that.

00:18:41.960 I'm not going to complain

00:18:42.680 about that.

00:18:45.620 Yeah.

00:18:46.840 So,

00:18:47.660 I'm not going to compare

00:18:50.500 the two

00:18:51.000 and say which was worse.

00:18:52.500 I'm just going to say

00:18:53.460 that both parties,

00:18:56.320 you know,

00:18:56.560 through Fetterman

00:18:57.220 on one side

00:18:57.960 and the Republicans

00:18:58.840 on the other,

00:18:59.720 have shown a willingness

00:19:00.780 to police their own side.

00:19:04.160 That's not terrible.

00:19:05.040 That's not terrible.

00:19:08.640 Yeah.

00:19:09.060 It could be a lot better.

00:19:10.920 You know,

00:19:11.140 again,

00:19:11.800 you'd like them

00:19:12.620 to handle Menendez

00:19:13.620 as much as the Republicans

00:19:14.960 handled Santos.

00:19:15.920 I get that.

00:19:16.780 Those are good points.

00:19:18.560 But trend-wise,

00:19:20.100 directionally,

00:19:21.780 to have two prominent instances

00:19:24.000 of people looking

00:19:25.080 at their own team,

00:19:27.660 yes.

00:19:29.020 Yes on that.

00:19:30.820 Yeah.

00:19:31.140 No,

00:19:31.340 I get the counter-argument.

00:19:32.700 I have full respect

00:19:35.460 for the counter-argument

00:19:36.560 that you play to win.

00:19:37.860 I get that.

00:19:39.360 But I don't hate the fact

00:19:40.440 that people are trying

00:19:41.260 to do what's right as well.

00:19:42.640 I don't hate it.

00:19:44.100 All right.

00:19:47.280 I saw a Robbie Starbuck

00:19:48.760 post that

00:19:49.920 there's some

00:19:51.280 Christian Tennessee

00:19:52.500 trucking company

00:19:53.300 that got fined

00:19:54.240 $700,000

00:19:55.140 by the Biden administration

00:19:56.520 for trying to make sure

00:19:58.740 they don't hire

00:19:59.500 illegal workers.

00:20:00.500 So they were requiring

00:20:02.240 people to show

00:20:02.940 that they were

00:20:03.400 legally citizens

00:20:04.940 of the United States

00:20:05.800 and they're being fined.

00:20:09.000 Do I even need

00:20:10.200 to add any commentary

00:20:12.040 to that?

00:20:13.060 Or could we all

00:20:14.200 just say,

00:20:14.880 what?

00:20:16.380 What?

00:20:17.700 Is that really happening?

00:20:19.440 Yeah.

00:20:21.180 Absurd.

00:20:22.540 Jumping the shark.

00:20:24.020 Going too far.

00:20:26.120 You know,

00:20:26.420 it's one thing

00:20:27.560 to open the borders

00:20:29.200 too far.

00:20:30.340 It's another thing

00:20:31.040 to say that

00:20:31.640 an American,

00:20:32.720 here's my problem

00:20:33.720 with it.

00:20:34.900 Here's my problem.

00:20:36.400 I do,

00:20:37.340 you know,

00:20:37.600 I'm kinder

00:20:40.100 on the immigrant issue

00:20:41.760 than many of my audience.

00:20:43.660 So that's stipulated.

00:20:46.060 But can somebody

00:20:47.740 give me a fact check

00:20:48.920 on the following question?

00:20:50.700 My understanding

00:20:51.620 is that if you're

00:20:53.160 an employer

00:20:53.800 and you hire illegals 0.79

00:20:56.280 and you know it

00:20:57.820 and you know it

00:20:59.180 that you're in big trouble

00:21:01.420 with the law.

00:21:03.100 Am I wrong about that?

00:21:04.700 It used to be the case

00:21:05.800 if you knowingly

00:21:07.040 hired illegals

00:21:09.340 that your whole company

00:21:11.060 would be shut down.

00:21:13.540 Now,

00:21:14.400 the way people

00:21:15.820 got around that

00:21:17.860 in the past,

00:21:18.640 do you know how

00:21:19.120 they got around it

00:21:19.840 in the past?

00:21:20.380 It was not illegal

00:21:23.080 to be fooled

00:21:24.080 by the immigrants.

00:21:26.320 So as long as

00:21:26.980 they had documentation,

00:21:28.700 which they often do,

00:21:29.840 you know,

00:21:30.040 forgeries and stuff,

00:21:31.260 as long as they had

00:21:31.900 some kind of fake ID

00:21:33.680 that you couldn't tell

00:21:34.740 because you're just

00:21:35.420 an employer,

00:21:36.260 you're not a forgery expert.

00:21:38.680 So as long as

00:21:39.340 they had something,

00:21:40.720 then the employer

00:21:41.920 was safe

00:21:42.560 because they could say,

00:21:45.380 well, we checked,

00:21:46.380 you know,

00:21:46.780 they lied to us,

00:21:47.680 what are you going to do?

00:21:48.540 So that was okay.

00:21:49.580 And that worked,

00:21:51.240 even though it was

00:21:51.740 kind of stupid,

00:21:52.560 but it worked.

00:21:54.300 Now the situation

00:21:55.500 looks to me

00:21:56.400 like if they try to check

00:21:59.740 using the minimal amount

00:22:01.800 of intrusive investigation,

00:22:04.300 which is,

00:22:05.080 do you have ID?

00:22:07.300 You know,

00:22:07.540 do you have a,

00:22:08.500 whatever they asked for

00:22:09.700 must have been

00:22:10.200 demonstrating

00:22:10.800 they were citizens.

00:22:11.860 The most basic,

00:22:13.720 you know,

00:22:13.980 the most basic thing

00:22:15.000 you would ask is,

00:22:16.040 is it legal for me

00:22:17.400 to hire you?

00:22:17.980 Imagine this,

00:22:20.760 that the employer

00:22:21.820 can't ask

00:22:22.800 if they would be

00:22:23.900 breaking the law.

00:22:25.460 If I hire you,

00:22:26.580 would I be

00:22:27.120 breaking the law?

00:22:29.000 Can't ask that.

00:22:31.480 Crazy.

00:22:32.460 Crazy stuff.

00:22:33.700 Now there might be

00:22:34.260 more to this story

00:22:34.880 than we know.

00:22:35.960 That's always the case.

00:22:37.540 But,

00:22:38.260 it certainly

00:22:40.760 raises an eyebrow.

00:22:41.640 Somebody on

00:22:44.520 X-Platform

00:22:45.400 posted a survey.

00:22:47.860 Now this was

00:22:48.420 like 20 years ago,

00:22:49.940 but it's relevant today.

00:22:51.640 And the survey showed

00:22:52.500 that the college majors

00:22:54.560 that were,

00:22:57.820 you know,

00:22:58.200 the really hard ones

00:23:00.140 like chemistry

00:23:01.060 and engineering

00:23:02.540 and physics

00:23:04.160 and all that

00:23:04.800 were like 90% men.

00:23:07.400 and that the

00:23:09.220 occupations

00:23:10.860 at the lower level

00:23:12.180 of the IQ spectrum,

00:23:14.560 this was the point

00:23:15.340 made by the poster,

00:23:16.240 not me,

00:23:17.280 that the lower IQ jobs

00:23:19.120 like social worker

00:23:20.320 and teacher

00:23:21.300 and therapist

00:23:23.980 were done

00:23:25.380 mostly by women.

00:23:28.120 Now,

00:23:29.260 the male-female part

00:23:31.820 of that

00:23:32.180 didn't interest me

00:23:33.280 too much.

00:23:34.580 To me,

00:23:35.240 that wasn't

00:23:35.660 the main point.

00:23:37.260 But,

00:23:38.180 I doubted

00:23:38.940 that this chart

00:23:40.200 could be true

00:23:40.740 in general

00:23:41.220 because it was arguing

00:23:42.600 that the highest IQ people

00:23:45.300 were going into jobs

00:23:47.080 in technology

00:23:48.100 and that the low IQ people

00:23:51.280 were going into jobs

00:23:52.200 like teachers

00:23:53.380 and therapists

00:23:54.220 and stuff.

00:23:54.960 Now that can't be true

00:23:56.100 because this is

00:23:57.960 20 years ago.

00:23:59.280 If this had been true

00:24:00.480 20 years ago

00:24:01.280 and stayed true,

00:24:02.460 what would we see?

00:24:03.660 I mean,

00:24:03.920 what we'd see

00:24:04.640 is,

00:24:05.820 I mean,

00:24:06.100 if that were true,

00:24:06.960 so obviously it's not true,

00:24:08.420 but if that were true

00:24:09.260 you'd see these amazing

00:24:10.480 advances in technology.

00:24:12.920 You'd be seeing

00:24:13.700 stuff like,

00:24:14.820 I don't know,

00:24:16.240 rockets

00:24:17.000 getting ready

00:24:18.260 to go to Mars,

00:24:19.240 bullshit like that.

00:24:20.560 You'd be seeing

00:24:21.300 what else?

00:24:22.740 Like artificial intelligence.

00:24:24.660 You'd be seeing

00:24:25.140 like artificial intelligence,

00:24:26.580 stuff like that.

00:24:27.500 So,

00:24:27.980 if all the geniuses

00:24:29.200 were going to technology,

00:24:30.420 you'd be seeing rockets

00:24:31.420 and AI

00:24:32.280 and shit like that.

00:24:34.880 And if it were true

00:24:35.660 that the

00:24:36.180 unintelligent people

00:24:37.340 were going to

00:24:37.880 teaching

00:24:38.640 and therapy,

00:24:41.240 I mean,

00:24:41.380 what kind of a world

00:24:42.120 would that be now?

00:24:43.140 I mean,

00:24:43.440 obviously that didn't happen

00:24:44.660 because you'd be seeing

00:24:46.280 that the school system

00:24:47.440 was totally fucked

00:24:48.620 and if you went

00:24:49.980 to a therapist,

00:24:51.120 you're basically

00:24:51.960 a masochist

00:24:52.800 because they don't know

00:24:53.800 anything that you don't know.

00:24:54.900 And we know

00:24:56.820 that's not the case.

00:24:58.100 We know our school system

00:24:59.460 is humming along perfectly

00:25:00.700 and if you go to therapy,

00:25:02.640 you'll probably be cured

00:25:03.520 by the third session.

00:25:05.880 And technology

00:25:06.880 hasn't done anything

00:25:07.620 interesting for years.

00:25:09.580 So,

00:25:10.220 I'm going to debunk that

00:25:11.580 that the smart people

00:25:12.840 go into those professions

00:25:14.020 because we'd see

00:25:15.320 signs of it by now.

00:25:17.080 I feel like we'd see

00:25:17.860 something like that.

00:25:19.160 Don't you?

00:25:21.980 All right.

00:25:22.700 Do you know

00:25:25.020 Nate Silver?

00:25:26.700 Nate Silver.

00:25:28.240 He worked with

00:25:29.080 the New York Times

00:25:30.380 before.

00:25:30.980 Is that correct?

00:25:31.900 Give me a fact check.

00:25:33.500 Before he left,

00:25:34.700 he was in the New York Times

00:25:35.740 then he went to 538.

00:25:37.500 He sold that

00:25:38.520 and now he's

00:25:39.200 sort of independent.

00:25:42.120 I always thought

00:25:43.280 that Nate was,

00:25:44.900 you know,

00:25:45.140 sort of a centrist

00:25:46.060 but maybe leaning

00:25:47.420 a little bit left.

00:25:50.060 That's what I always thought.

00:25:51.920 But,

00:25:52.440 you know,

00:25:52.640 he tried to,

00:25:54.020 I always thought

00:25:54.720 he was a

00:25:56.240 fair observer

00:25:57.700 of the world.

00:25:59.460 But here's something

00:26:00.160 he's saying today.

00:26:01.960 Well,

00:26:02.380 November 30th

00:26:03.220 he posted this.

00:26:04.260 If I were hiring

00:26:05.080 right now,

00:26:05.720 I'd prefer high-achieving

00:26:06.820 state school students

00:26:08.500 undifferentiated,

00:26:11.520 better than

00:26:13.260 undifferentiated

00:26:14.320 Ivy League students.

00:26:15.640 Not a remotely

00:26:16.640 close call.

00:26:17.480 so undifferentiated

00:26:21.500 undifferentiated

00:26:23.040 Ivy League students.

00:26:25.300 I don't know

00:26:26.020 what he means

00:26:26.360 exactly by

00:26:27.080 undifferentiated

00:26:28.220 but he would

00:26:29.520 prefer a high-achieving

00:26:31.180 state school

00:26:31.900 over the Ivy Leagues

00:26:32.860 because what we're

00:26:34.000 seeing

00:26:34.420 really kind of

00:26:36.800 suggests their brains

00:26:37.660 are being destroyed

00:26:38.480 by the Ivy League

00:26:39.480 experience.

00:26:40.740 so I agree.

00:26:44.960 Now,

00:26:45.640 this is the beginning

00:26:46.480 of my theme

00:26:47.360 for today.

00:26:49.380 So the theme

00:26:50.440 is going to be this.

00:26:51.400 I'm introducing

00:26:53.980 a new term.

00:26:56.560 You know there are

00:26:57.340 people who are

00:26:57.940 anti-Trump

00:26:58.720 and you know

00:26:59.140 there are people

00:26:59.540 who are pro-Trump.

00:27:01.020 You certainly know that.

00:27:02.760 And not too many

00:27:03.620 people are undecided.

00:27:06.500 But there seems

00:27:07.680 to be a new category

00:27:08.600 that I'm going to call

00:27:09.620 pre-Trump.

00:27:12.400 Pre-Trump.

00:27:13.960 They're not pro-Trump.

00:27:15.360 Oh,

00:27:15.680 oh no,

00:27:16.200 no,

00:27:16.600 no,

00:27:16.820 no,

00:27:17.080 no,

00:27:17.440 no,

00:27:17.820 no,

00:27:18.400 no,

00:27:18.860 no,

00:27:19.240 don't get me wrong.

00:27:19.880 They're not pro-Trump.

00:27:22.820 But they're not

00:27:23.840 anti-Trump.

00:27:25.440 They are

00:27:26.480 Trump-curious.

00:27:29.220 They are

00:27:30.120 open.

00:27:31.380 They're open.

00:27:32.460 They're open to it.

00:27:35.900 I would put,

00:27:37.920 I'm going to put

00:27:40.800 Nate

00:27:43.420 in that category.

00:27:48.100 Yeah,

00:27:48.800 I think Nate Silver

00:27:49.680 and I don't want

00:27:51.660 to put any words

00:27:52.240 in his mouth

00:27:52.760 so let me be clear.

00:27:54.180 He's not pro-Trump.

00:27:56.320 There's nothing about him

00:27:57.560 that suggests pro-Trump.

00:27:59.540 But

00:28:00.020 I don't see a lot

00:28:01.720 of suggestion

00:28:02.280 that he's pro-Biden

00:28:03.820 if you know

00:28:05.280 what I mean.

00:28:06.500 So

00:28:06.940 I'm not suggesting

00:28:08.060 he might go

00:28:08.820 full Trump

00:28:09.540 but he feels

00:28:11.660 pretty close to

00:28:12.740 pre-Trump.

00:28:14.940 A little bit

00:28:15.620 of pre-Trump

00:28:16.260 going on.

00:28:17.640 You know

00:28:17.860 what I mean?

00:28:18.180 Let's watch

00:28:19.740 for that.

00:28:21.300 All right.

00:28:23.440 DeSantis

00:28:23.940 is

00:28:24.840 on his

00:28:27.200 debate

00:28:28.680 with Newsom.

00:28:30.000 He avoided

00:28:30.980 the question

00:28:31.620 of whether

00:28:32.280 he would support

00:28:32.900 a national ban

00:28:33.860 on abortion.

00:28:35.320 Do you think

00:28:35.720 that was the right play?

00:28:37.560 Because Newsom

00:28:38.280 banged him

00:28:39.020 on it pretty good.

00:28:40.240 Do you think

00:28:40.760 DeSantis

00:28:41.240 should avoid

00:28:42.460 answering the question

00:28:43.600 about a federal

00:28:44.620 ban on abortion?

00:28:45.800 I say yes.

00:28:50.180 That's the better

00:28:51.020 way to play it.

00:28:52.660 Yeah.

00:28:52.960 And I think

00:28:53.600 I don't know

00:28:54.740 what Trump

00:28:55.220 will do

00:28:55.720 but I think

00:28:57.240 he's smart

00:28:58.060 enough

00:28:58.440 to say

00:28:59.820 let's leave

00:29:00.480 it to the states

00:29:01.320 because leave

00:29:03.640 it to the states

00:29:04.300 is the most

00:29:05.040 consistent thing

00:29:06.020 to say.

00:29:06.460 So that

00:29:07.400 explains

00:29:08.140 everything

00:29:09.680 really.

00:29:10.920 And it's hard

00:29:11.740 to argue

00:29:12.240 with the state

00:29:14.200 has the closest

00:29:15.280 approximation

00:29:16.060 of what the

00:29:17.140 citizens of the

00:29:18.420 state want.

00:29:19.540 It's the place

00:29:20.360 where you capture

00:29:21.120 their preferences

00:29:22.280 better than

00:29:23.840 at a federal level

00:29:24.720 where everybody

00:29:25.280 gets averaged

00:29:25.880 together.

00:29:26.960 So it's really

00:29:28.040 hard to argue

00:29:28.840 that you should

00:29:30.120 use a federal

00:29:31.480 average when the

00:29:32.660 states are very

00:29:33.300 different in their

00:29:33.980 preferences.

00:29:34.400 it's not really

00:29:35.680 a good argument.

00:29:37.700 You know

00:29:37.840 even if you

00:29:38.780 prefer like

00:29:39.980 using a hammer

00:29:40.840 to make it

00:29:41.360 illegal.

00:29:42.820 It's not the

00:29:43.580 best argument.

00:29:44.620 So I think

00:29:44.940 the best argument

00:29:45.500 is leave it

00:29:45.960 to the states.

00:29:48.560 Well Tucker

00:29:49.160 Carlson was

00:29:50.480 on the all-in-one

00:29:51.300 pod and man

00:29:52.320 can that guy

00:29:52.860 make news.

00:29:54.300 Do you remember

00:29:54.820 when Tucker

00:29:55.600 was not so

00:29:57.380 pro-Trump?

00:30:00.080 You remember

00:30:00.880 that right?

00:30:02.240 There have been

00:30:02.940 times that Tucker

00:30:03.940 has been

00:30:04.380 absolutely

00:30:05.740 insulting to

00:30:06.820 Trump.

00:30:08.500 But what is

00:30:09.280 he now?

00:30:11.880 He's turned.

00:30:13.740 Now he went

00:30:14.380 all the way

00:30:14.860 from pre-Trump

00:30:15.800 to absolutely

00:30:17.360 Trump.

00:30:18.600 So he's a

00:30:19.500 turnaround case.

00:30:20.620 Another turnaround.

00:30:22.000 But he was

00:30:23.240 talking about

00:30:23.620 Gavin Newsom

00:30:24.340 and this is

00:30:24.760 interesting.

00:30:25.440 It's interesting

00:30:26.100 because I think

00:30:27.760 Tucker is an

00:30:29.320 honest broker

00:30:30.380 especially about

00:30:31.960 his personal

00:30:32.560 experience.

00:30:33.200 I think

00:30:34.200 when Tucker

00:30:34.620 is talking

00:30:35.000 about his

00:30:35.360 personal

00:30:35.740 experience

00:30:36.300 as opposed

00:30:36.860 to an

00:30:37.160 opinion,

00:30:38.480 I think

00:30:38.940 it's always

00:30:39.540 true.

00:30:40.620 I don't

00:30:41.020 believe he

00:30:42.480 has a lying

00:30:43.240 bone in his

00:30:43.900 body.

00:30:44.880 I've disagreed

00:30:45.640 with him a

00:30:46.640 number of

00:30:47.020 times and I

00:30:48.280 thought he's

00:30:48.700 gotten some

00:30:49.160 things wrong

00:30:49.900 factually.

00:30:51.100 Just like

00:30:51.780 everybody in

00:30:52.340 that business,

00:30:52.940 right?

00:30:53.180 That's really

00:30:53.740 saying nothing.

00:30:54.300 but I've

00:30:56.220 never picked

00:30:57.420 up a

00:30:57.880 whiff,

00:30:58.820 not a

00:30:59.320 whiff,

00:31:00.360 that Tucker

00:31:00.880 ever lied

00:31:01.600 to you

00:31:02.080 about an

00:31:04.080 actual direct

00:31:04.780 experience.

00:31:06.180 Like I've

00:31:06.580 never seen

00:31:06.940 that.

00:31:07.740 I don't

00:31:08.000 think that's

00:31:08.420 happening.

00:31:09.460 So when he

00:31:10.080 says what his

00:31:10.780 direct personal

00:31:11.700 experience is,

00:31:12.600 I always give

00:31:14.020 that more

00:31:14.340 credibility than

00:31:15.160 most things in

00:31:15.860 the news.

00:31:16.980 And he talks

00:31:17.580 about Gavin

00:31:18.440 Newsom.

00:31:18.980 He says,

00:31:19.300 one thing I

00:31:19.780 know for a

00:31:20.220 fact about

00:31:21.180 Gavin Newsom,

00:31:21.900 it's really

00:31:22.780 an opinion,

00:31:23.400 it's not a

00:31:23.760 fact,

00:31:24.080 but he

00:31:24.260 says,

00:31:24.860 I know

00:31:25.180 for a

00:31:25.480 fact about

00:31:25.920 Gavin Newsom

00:31:26.480 that he

00:31:26.740 has the

00:31:27.040 capacity to

00:31:28.640 beat a

00:31:29.120 lie detector

00:31:29.700 test,

00:31:31.180 which is

00:31:33.380 really good

00:31:34.120 persuasion,

00:31:35.620 because you

00:31:36.000 can see the

00:31:36.600 lie detector

00:31:37.220 test,

00:31:37.660 can't you?

00:31:38.780 You can see

00:31:39.500 the device,

00:31:41.200 and you see

00:31:41.640 him hooked

00:31:41.960 up to it.

00:31:43.380 That's way 0.98

00:31:44.100 better communication

00:31:45.180 than just saying

00:31:45.900 he's not

00:31:46.340 honest.

00:31:47.140 You can

00:31:47.460 actually see

00:31:48.160 the device,

00:31:49.020 that's visual

00:31:49.560 persuasion.

00:31:51.900 He says,

00:31:53.000 Gavin Newsom's

00:31:53.640 palms don't

00:31:54.200 sweat,

00:31:54.540 his respiration

00:31:55.100 doesn't

00:31:55.440 increase,

00:31:56.020 his body

00:31:56.460 temperature

00:31:56.820 doesn't

00:31:57.160 change,

00:31:57.560 nothing

00:31:57.760 changes in

00:31:58.420 Gavin Newsom

00:31:58.920 when he

00:31:59.160 lies to

00:31:59.560 your face.

00:32:02.180 I don't

00:32:02.840 know.

00:32:04.100 I watched

00:32:04.920 him in the

00:32:05.880 debate for

00:32:07.180 like one

00:32:08.240 minute,

00:32:08.980 and I told

00:32:09.420 you this,

00:32:10.060 the moment

00:32:10.540 he looked

00:32:11.340 at the

00:32:11.680 camera and

00:32:12.160 said with

00:32:12.500 a straight

00:32:12.900 face,

00:32:13.320 several times

00:32:14.220 that more

00:32:15.320 people were

00:32:15.840 moving from

00:32:16.400 Florida to

00:32:16.980 California than

00:32:17.780 the other

00:32:18.080 way,

00:32:18.880 I said to

00:32:19.440 myself,

00:32:20.280 my God,

00:32:21.200 he could lie

00:32:21.720 about anything

00:32:22.240 right to

00:32:22.560 your face.

00:32:23.860 I guess he

00:32:24.640 can.

00:32:26.440 But then

00:32:27.120 Tucker said

00:32:27.720 that it's

00:32:28.600 well understood

00:32:29.200 that California

00:32:29.920 is the most

00:32:30.560 fixed state

00:32:31.920 for politics,

00:32:33.260 meaning that

00:32:34.020 if the people

00:32:35.140 in charge

00:32:35.600 want Newsom

00:32:36.500 to be

00:32:36.840 governor,

00:32:37.420 he'll be

00:32:37.720 governor,

00:32:38.780 et cetera.

00:32:40.260 So I

00:32:41.800 don't know.

00:32:42.500 I don't know

00:32:43.460 what the

00:32:43.660 evidence of

00:32:44.220 that would

00:32:44.500 be,

00:32:45.580 but I do

00:32:46.120 think that

00:32:46.600 Tucker is

00:32:47.140 closer to

00:32:47.740 that world

00:32:48.140 than I am,

00:32:48.740 so if

00:32:49.780 he says

00:32:50.140 California

00:32:50.700 is the

00:32:51.120 most corrupt

00:32:51.820 state

00:32:53.060 politically,

00:32:54.180 I'm inclined

00:32:55.100 to believe

00:32:55.560 him.

00:32:57.100 There might

00:32:57.700 be some

00:32:58.000 competition

00:32:58.480 for it,

00:32:59.020 but I'm

00:32:59.880 kind of

00:33:00.140 inclined to

00:33:00.680 believe it

00:33:01.020 might be

00:33:01.340 the most

00:33:01.740 rigged

00:33:02.080 state.

00:33:02.760 And you

00:33:02.960 know what,

00:33:03.160 I never

00:33:03.440 thought about

00:33:03.920 it that

00:33:04.180 way before.

00:33:05.740 I gotta

00:33:06.480 honestly say,

00:33:07.820 I just

00:33:08.260 thought that

00:33:08.720 California

00:33:09.160 had lots

00:33:09.620 of Democrats.

00:33:11.360 To me,

00:33:11.860 I thought

00:33:12.220 that was

00:33:12.480 a whole

00:33:12.660 story.

00:33:13.940 But it

00:33:15.260 might be

00:33:15.860 completely

00:33:16.720 non-democratic

00:33:17.900 according to

00:33:18.600 Tucker,

00:33:19.180 and I

00:33:20.000 can't dispute

00:33:20.660 it,

00:33:21.380 but I'd

00:33:21.780 have to

00:33:22.040 see more

00:33:22.380 evidence

00:33:22.780 before I

00:33:23.280 buy into

00:33:23.660 that point

00:33:24.140 of view.

00:33:26.880 All right.

00:33:29.760 And Tucker

00:33:30.540 is talking

00:33:30.980 about how

00:33:31.600 even if

00:33:32.340 when he

00:33:32.660 was on

00:33:33.020 Fox,

00:33:34.240 he was

00:33:34.700 very aware

00:33:35.300 that if

00:33:36.300 you talk

00:33:36.720 against the

00:33:37.480 interests of

00:33:38.040 your corporate

00:33:38.580 sponsors,

00:33:39.840 eventually bad

00:33:40.720 things will

00:33:41.140 happen to

00:33:41.520 you.

00:33:43.000 So he

00:33:44.680 would say

00:33:45.220 things about

00:33:45.780 the vaccinations

00:33:46.480 that the

00:33:48.100 sponsors of

00:33:48.860 the network

00:33:49.700 probably didn't

00:33:50.240 like.

00:33:50.980 So he knew

00:33:51.740 it was a

00:33:52.240 ticking time

00:33:52.840 bomb, 0.51

00:33:53.360 and he was

00:33:53.700 not surprised

00:33:54.320 at all that

00:33:54.880 eventually he

00:33:55.400 got kicked

00:33:55.820 off,

00:33:56.620 and took it

00:33:57.520 completely

00:33:57.940 professionally,

00:33:59.160 because it's

00:33:59.540 just part of

00:33:59.980 the deal,

00:34:00.420 which I do

00:34:01.040 respect about

00:34:01.820 Tucker,

00:34:03.080 that he took

00:34:03.640 it as a

00:34:04.040 business decision.

00:34:05.680 It's just

00:34:06.140 professional.

00:34:07.820 You don't

00:34:08.360 have to hate

00:34:08.800 the people

00:34:09.160 involved.

00:34:10.380 I get that.

00:34:11.720 I respect

00:34:12.180 that.

00:34:13.000 But that

00:34:15.360 does make

00:34:15.900 you wonder

00:34:16.360 if somebody

00:34:17.340 is taking

00:34:17.900 advertisement

00:34:19.740 from Big

00:34:20.680 Pharma or

00:34:22.140 from TikTok,

00:34:24.840 can they

00:34:25.800 speak as

00:34:26.740 honestly as

00:34:28.480 they might?

00:34:29.580 Because they

00:34:29.920 don't need to

00:34:30.360 be instructed

00:34:31.100 to not speak

00:34:32.940 out against

00:34:33.400 their sponsors.

00:34:34.560 Nobody needs

00:34:35.140 to be told

00:34:35.640 to do that.

00:34:36.280 when I

00:34:39.080 spend every

00:34:39.760 day on

00:34:40.500 live stream

00:34:41.320 saying the

00:34:41.920 Washington Post

00:34:42.700 was fake

00:34:43.260 news,

00:34:44.740 did I know

00:34:45.620 that I would

00:34:47.180 eventually be

00:34:47.840 cancelled by

00:34:48.400 the Washington

00:34:48.880 Post and

00:34:51.060 other papers

00:34:52.360 too?

00:34:52.640 Of course I

00:34:54.060 did.

00:34:54.980 I knew it was

00:34:55.500 the risk.

00:34:56.540 So like

00:34:57.100 Tucker, I had

00:34:58.240 the same reaction

00:34:58.960 to it.

00:34:59.940 What?

00:35:00.560 Oh, wow.

00:35:01.120 Kind of

00:35:01.680 shocking at

00:35:02.280 first.

00:35:03.280 But I never

00:35:04.180 felt mad.

00:35:07.420 I didn't feel

00:35:09.880 mad at

00:35:10.400 anybody who

00:35:10.880 cancelled me

00:35:11.440 because I

00:35:12.160 understand the

00:35:12.800 forces at

00:35:13.380 work.

00:35:14.180 It was obvious

00:35:14.900 that I was

00:35:16.180 playing with

00:35:16.700 fire.

00:35:18.340 It's just what

00:35:18.920 happens.

00:35:19.740 And as Tucker

00:35:20.340 says, and I

00:35:21.280 respect him for

00:35:21.960 this, if you

00:35:23.000 get into this

00:35:23.680 line of work,

00:35:25.300 don't act

00:35:25.960 surprised when

00:35:26.860 things that

00:35:27.360 happen all the

00:35:28.080 time in this

00:35:28.800 line of work

00:35:29.480 happen to you

00:35:30.720 in this line

00:35:31.240 of work.

00:35:32.320 Like if you're

00:35:33.140 not willing to

00:35:33.700 accept that as

00:35:34.440 part of the

00:35:34.820 deal, you're in

00:35:36.080 the wrong line

00:35:37.180 to work.

00:35:38.280 Anyway,

00:35:38.800 different topic.

00:35:41.620 Here's Michael

00:35:42.380 Schellenberger

00:35:42.960 summing up what

00:35:43.760 we know about

00:35:44.340 what I call the

00:35:45.060 brainwashing

00:35:45.780 industrial complex.

00:35:47.660 I think others

00:35:48.740 call it the

00:35:49.500 censorship

00:35:50.260 industrial complex,

00:35:52.880 but censorship

00:35:53.700 doesn't quite

00:35:54.980 capture it.

00:35:56.820 Censorship

00:35:57.300 is more like

00:35:59.260 getting rid of

00:36:00.120 something that

00:36:00.660 they think is

00:36:02.480 untrue or they

00:36:03.320 don't want you

00:36:03.700 to say.

00:36:05.120 But brainwashing

00:36:06.220 is that

00:36:06.980 plus making

00:36:07.980 you believe

00:36:08.420 things that

00:36:08.900 are clearly

00:36:09.300 not true.

00:36:10.720 It's way more

00:36:11.560 about brainwashing

00:36:12.480 than it is

00:36:13.620 about just

00:36:14.220 censoring.

00:36:15.460 Censoring is

00:36:16.000 too weak.

00:36:17.140 I call it the

00:36:17.960 brainwashing

00:36:18.860 industrial complex

00:36:20.140 or the BIC.

00:36:21.980 Anyway,

00:36:23.500 Schellenberger

00:36:23.940 says,

00:36:24.320 we discovered

00:36:24.880 DHS,

00:36:26.040 Department of

00:36:26.680 Homeland Security,

00:36:27.820 employees volunteering

00:36:28.800 to use psyops

00:36:29.740 and disinformation

00:36:30.540 tactics against

00:36:31.560 the American

00:36:32.060 people.

00:36:33.620 Is that an

00:36:34.360 exaggeration?

00:36:35.020 Does the

00:36:38.280 research show

00:36:39.380 that Department

00:36:41.060 of Homeland

00:36:41.460 Security employees

00:36:42.520 volunteered to

00:36:44.160 use psyops and

00:36:45.940 disinformation

00:36:46.520 tactics against

00:36:47.520 the American

00:36:48.040 people?

00:36:49.420 Yes,

00:36:49.760 it does.

00:36:51.240 Yeah,

00:36:51.720 the record

00:36:52.420 clearly shows

00:36:53.140 it.

00:36:54.360 They blamed

00:36:55.080 social media

00:36:55.660 platforms for

00:36:56.380 Trump's election

00:36:57.060 victory in

00:36:57.600 2016.

00:36:58.680 True?

00:36:59.560 Yes,

00:37:00.300 it's documented.

00:37:01.960 Absolutely true.

00:37:02.640 So they

00:37:04.880 used tactics

00:37:05.580 developed abroad

00:37:06.420 by the U.S.

00:37:07.060 military and

00:37:07.660 turned them

00:37:08.020 against the

00:37:08.520 American people.

00:37:09.680 Gosh,

00:37:10.220 that sounds

00:37:10.600 like hyperbole.

00:37:12.200 They didn't

00:37:12.600 really use,

00:37:13.540 I mean,

00:37:13.820 they didn't

00:37:14.060 really do

00:37:14.500 this,

00:37:14.860 did they?

00:37:15.060 Did they

00:37:15.320 really use

00:37:15.840 techniques

00:37:16.400 and tactics

00:37:17.080 used by the

00:37:18.140 military to

00:37:19.000 propagandize

00:37:20.540 other countries

00:37:21.220 and they used

00:37:21.720 it against

00:37:22.060 the American

00:37:22.480 people?

00:37:23.060 Yes,

00:37:23.940 that's documented.

00:37:25.620 That's a

00:37:26.060 fact.

00:37:27.780 They used

00:37:28.500 these tactics

00:37:29.000 in order to

00:37:29.560 change the

00:37:29.960 conversation online

00:37:30.760 and engage

00:37:31.260 in mass

00:37:31.600 censorship,

00:37:32.740 which is

00:37:33.260 what we

00:37:33.520 saw in

00:37:33.760 the Twitter

00:37:34.040 files,

00:37:34.560 Facebook

00:37:34.820 files,

00:37:35.320 and of

00:37:35.500 course,

00:37:36.220 now part

00:37:36.680 of the

00:37:36.860 Missouri

00:37:37.180 versus

00:37:37.560 Biden

00:37:37.880 case.

00:37:38.600 Facts.

00:37:39.740 Absolutely

00:37:40.220 proven facts.

00:37:41.960 James Baker,

00:37:42.860 the next part

00:37:43.560 I'm not going

00:37:43.920 to read because

00:37:44.240 I think

00:37:44.500 there's a

00:37:44.800 typo in it.

00:37:47.080 What we

00:37:48.740 saw was an

00:37:49.300 effort by

00:37:49.700 existing FBI

00:37:50.580 agents and

00:37:51.160 former FBI

00:37:51.920 agents to

00:37:53.160 spread disinformation

00:37:54.220 about the

00:37:54.740 Hunter Biden

00:37:55.200 laptop and say

00:37:56.140 outright to the

00:37:56.740 American people

00:37:57.240 that it was

00:37:57.620 a Russian

00:37:57.900 hack and

00:37:58.800 leak

00:37:59.040 operation.

00:37:59.540 And of

00:38:00.920 course,

00:38:01.220 Biden

00:38:01.580 repeated this

00:38:02.620 in the

00:38:03.080 debates.

00:38:04.580 All true.

00:38:06.020 All true.

00:38:07.120 Now here's

00:38:07.560 your test.

00:38:09.560 Find any

00:38:10.340 Democrat in

00:38:11.100 the United

00:38:11.460 States who

00:38:11.980 is aware of

00:38:12.600 these facts.

00:38:14.800 Any.

00:38:16.220 Find any

00:38:17.180 Democrat,

00:38:18.440 any Democrat

00:38:19.360 in the United

00:38:19.920 States who

00:38:21.060 will say,

00:38:21.720 yes,

00:38:21.920 these are

00:38:22.220 facts.

00:38:23.960 None.

00:38:25.680 Partly because

00:38:26.520 it's complicated

00:38:27.260 and partly

00:38:28.260 because there's

00:38:28.960 enough bold

00:38:30.440 faced lying

00:38:31.220 that they'll

00:38:32.100 just say it

00:38:32.560 didn't happen.

00:38:33.740 Well,

00:38:34.040 this happened.

00:38:34.640 No,

00:38:34.840 it didn't.

00:38:36.520 Well,

00:38:36.940 we have it

00:38:37.300 documented.

00:38:38.100 No,

00:38:38.360 you don't.

00:38:39.620 Well,

00:38:39.860 here's the

00:38:40.200 document.

00:38:41.220 I don't

00:38:41.620 see it.

00:38:42.200 Here it

00:38:42.520 is.

00:38:43.020 Here it

00:38:43.380 is.

00:38:44.620 Yeah,

00:38:45.060 no,

00:38:45.280 I don't

00:38:45.480 see anything.

00:38:46.520 Sounds

00:38:46.800 like you're

00:38:47.160 lying again.

00:38:47.800 What,

00:38:47.940 are you

00:38:48.060 gaslighting

00:38:48.540 me?

00:38:48.900 Here it

00:38:49.260 is.

00:38:49.740 Here it

00:38:50.000 is.

00:38:50.140 Look,

00:38:50.400 look,

00:38:50.700 it's

00:38:50.820 right here.

00:38:52.480 I don't

00:38:52.880 see anything.

00:38:54.880 And the

00:38:55.420 Democrats,

00:38:56.020 that works.

00:38:57.260 It works.

00:39:00.900 All right.

00:39:05.400 Do you

00:39:06.020 remember when

00:39:06.740 Trump got

00:39:07.660 interrupted by

00:39:08.560 that NBC

00:39:09.360 hack,

00:39:10.840 Kristen Welker,

00:39:12.060 and Trump

00:39:12.820 said that the

00:39:13.380 January 6th

00:39:14.040 Committee destroyed

00:39:14.820 all the evidence

00:39:15.580 of their

00:39:16.220 investigation,

00:39:17.820 and she

00:39:18.320 pushed back,

00:39:18.940 oh,

00:39:19.120 there's no

00:39:19.480 evidence that,

00:39:20.120 no,

00:39:20.340 that's not a

00:39:20.780 fact.

00:39:21.760 But now it's

00:39:22.480 confirmed.

00:39:24.000 They destroyed

00:39:24.800 it all.

00:39:25.340 Who destroys

00:39:27.540 all of their

00:39:28.100 data from

00:39:29.140 something that's

00:39:29.880 like the most

00:39:30.480 important thing

00:39:31.100 that happened

00:39:31.480 that year?

00:39:32.700 Nobody.

00:39:34.160 Nobody destroys

00:39:35.300 it accidentally,

00:39:37.540 and nobody does

00:39:38.960 it intentionally

00:39:39.640 unless they're

00:39:40.300 trying to hide

00:39:40.800 a crime.

00:39:42.340 They're obviously

00:39:43.220 trying to hide

00:39:43.840 a crime.

00:39:45.160 I'm going to

00:39:45.840 add this to

00:39:46.740 my prediction

00:39:47.400 that Trump

00:39:48.840 would start

00:39:49.300 looking better

00:39:50.360 every day

00:39:51.940 from 2020

00:39:54.080 on.

00:39:56.000 That his

00:39:56.640 reputation

00:39:57.220 would rise

00:39:58.000 and you

00:39:58.340 can't stop

00:39:58.940 it.

00:39:59.880 And here's

00:40:01.120 the reason

00:40:01.380 why.

00:40:02.160 I think the

00:40:03.000 brainwashing

00:40:03.760 bubble has

00:40:05.220 too many

00:40:05.620 cracks in it.

00:40:06.860 It's starting

00:40:07.260 to dissolve,

00:40:08.480 and you're

00:40:09.140 creating a

00:40:09.600 bunch of

00:40:09.940 pre-Trumpers

00:40:10.700 who are

00:40:11.620 saying,

00:40:12.280 I'm not

00:40:13.600 sure this

00:40:14.600 whole story

00:40:15.200 we've been

00:40:15.680 told the

00:40:16.200 whole time

00:40:16.940 is exactly

00:40:18.280 true.

00:40:18.860 I feel

00:40:20.120 like maybe

00:40:20.640 people lied

00:40:21.360 to me,

00:40:21.800 and maybe

00:40:22.120 I was

00:40:22.520 better off

00:40:23.120 under

00:40:23.420 Trump.

00:40:25.660 So you

00:40:26.340 can see

00:40:26.660 all the

00:40:27.080 forces that

00:40:27.700 would cause

00:40:28.080 the pre-Trumpers.

00:40:29.460 So the

00:40:29.720 biggest force

00:40:30.420 is that every

00:40:31.120 day that

00:40:31.480 goes by,

00:40:32.540 something

00:40:33.000 Trump said

00:40:34.360 that he

00:40:34.720 was attacked

00:40:36.240 for turns

00:40:37.540 out to be

00:40:38.020 true,

00:40:39.020 and hoaxes

00:40:39.940 that he was

00:40:40.400 blamed for

00:40:41.140 are being

00:40:42.400 debunked

00:40:43.040 over time.

00:40:44.680 So his

00:40:45.140 reputation

00:40:45.800 is just

00:40:47.860 rising every

00:40:48.540 day,

00:40:48.980 just one

00:40:49.500 tick at

00:40:50.640 a time,

00:40:51.120 one news

00:40:51.700 story,

00:40:52.620 one more

00:40:53.060 news story,

00:40:53.840 polls go

00:40:54.400 up,

00:40:54.720 one more

00:40:55.140 news story.

00:40:56.120 Here's

00:40:56.360 some more.

00:41:00.700 Well,

00:41:01.220 first of

00:41:01.520 all,

00:41:01.660 let me

00:41:01.820 talk about

00:41:02.160 Bill Maher.

00:41:03.680 He had

00:41:04.000 some interesting

00:41:04.460 things to

00:41:04.860 say.

00:41:05.160 He had a

00:41:05.440 good joke

00:41:05.900 at his

00:41:06.660 monologue.

00:41:07.680 He was

00:41:07.920 talking about

00:41:08.340 the Newsom

00:41:09.240 and DeSantis

00:41:09.640 debate,

00:41:10.140 and he

00:41:10.260 said,

00:41:10.600 at the

00:41:10.880 end of

00:41:11.560 the day,

00:41:11.940 nobody's

00:41:12.340 mind was

00:41:12.740 changed

00:41:13.060 about

00:41:13.300 anything.

00:41:14.020 What's

00:41:14.280 going to

00:41:14.620 make the

00:41:14.940 difference?

00:41:15.840 Gavin

00:41:16.120 Newsom is

00:41:16.720 six foot

00:41:17.220 three with

00:41:17.760 a smile

00:41:18.240 like a

00:41:18.620 movie star,

00:41:19.520 and DeSantis

00:41:20.220 is 5'10

00:41:21.040 in heels

00:41:21.520 with the

00:41:21.940 forced

00:41:22.240 smile of

00:41:22.900 a serial

00:41:23.340 killer.

00:41:26.140 Okay,

00:41:26.780 that was

00:41:27.060 perfect.

00:41:29.000 That was

00:41:30.020 perfect.

00:41:33.180 Yeah,

00:41:33.980 that was

00:41:34.780 exactly,

00:41:35.800 he summed

00:41:36.380 it up.

00:41:37.260 That's it.

00:41:38.560 That was the

00:41:39.240 whole thing.

00:41:40.200 All right,

00:41:41.120 so that was

00:41:41.740 good.

00:41:41.980 Bill Maher

00:41:44.940 was talking

00:41:45.380 with James

00:41:46.940 Carville

00:41:47.380 and Dave

00:41:48.400 Rubin

00:41:48.680 was there

00:41:49.060 on the

00:41:50.500 panel.

00:41:52.120 And

00:41:52.140 Bill Maher

00:41:55.380 was talking

00:41:55.720 about how

00:41:56.100 Trump

00:41:56.520 wants to

00:41:58.120 teach school

00:41:58.820 kids to

00:41:59.380 love America

00:42:00.080 because they're

00:42:01.300 not being

00:42:01.700 taught that.

00:42:02.260 They might

00:42:02.540 be taught

00:42:02.880 the opposite.

00:42:04.640 Now,

00:42:05.480 this is a

00:42:06.740 concrete

00:42:07.160 example of

00:42:08.900 somebody who

00:42:09.420 was very

00:42:09.800 anti-Trump

00:42:10.480 who's now

00:42:11.180 saying

00:42:11.480 something

00:42:12.020 leading

00:42:14.060 pro-Trump.

00:42:15.320 He's definitely

00:42:15.860 not saying

00:42:16.360 he's going

00:42:16.700 to vote

00:42:16.960 for Trump.

00:42:17.760 So he's

00:42:18.140 not a

00:42:18.440 pro-Trumper,

00:42:19.320 but is he

00:42:20.820 an anti-Trumper?

00:42:22.740 I don't

00:42:23.320 think he

00:42:23.620 is.

00:42:24.760 I mean,

00:42:25.040 there are

00:42:25.220 things he

00:42:25.620 hates,

00:42:26.460 and he may

00:42:27.280 hate him

00:42:27.640 personally.

00:42:29.300 But he's

00:42:29.680 sort of a

00:42:30.060 pre-Trumper,

00:42:31.700 meaning that

00:42:32.500 it's not

00:42:33.740 out of the

00:42:34.160 question that

00:42:34.700 he would

00:42:34.920 vote for

00:42:35.340 him.

00:42:36.540 He's not

00:42:37.160 saying he

00:42:37.580 will,

00:42:37.860 and I'm

00:42:38.100 not predicting

00:42:38.680 it.

00:42:39.800 But it's

00:42:40.260 within the

00:42:40.740 realm of

00:42:41.200 possibility.

00:42:42.000 He's a

00:42:42.260 pre-Trumper.

00:42:43.820 But it

00:42:44.220 goes further.

00:42:50.640 At one

00:42:51.380 point,

00:42:51.880 James Carville,

00:42:53.200 in responding

00:42:54.000 to this

00:42:54.500 topic,

00:42:55.680 throws in

00:42:56.300 something that

00:42:57.520 has nothing

00:42:58.040 to do with

00:42:58.520 the topic.

00:42:59.440 It's just

00:42:59.940 bad for

00:43:00.420 Trump.

00:43:01.860 So in

00:43:02.220 other words,

00:43:02.700 even Carville

00:43:03.480 couldn't find

00:43:04.200 anything wrong

00:43:05.040 with teaching

00:43:06.200 schoolchildren

00:43:07.020 to like

00:43:07.520 America,

00:43:08.020 because that

00:43:09.520 was the

00:43:09.820 topic.

00:43:11.200 What are

00:43:11.740 you going

00:43:11.960 to say

00:43:12.240 about that?

00:43:13.340 Except that,

00:43:14.160 well, okay,

00:43:14.660 Trump's right

00:43:15.180 about that.

00:43:16.160 But if you're

00:43:16.680 Carville,

00:43:17.580 you can't

00:43:18.480 say Trump's

00:43:19.000 right about

00:43:19.360 anything.

00:43:20.180 You can't

00:43:20.520 give him

00:43:20.880 even one

00:43:22.340 little sliver

00:43:23.020 of positive.

00:43:25.400 So Carville,

00:43:26.260 instead,

00:43:27.120 he starts

00:43:27.600 melting down,

00:43:29.160 and it looks

00:43:29.520 like maybe

00:43:30.060 he's lost

00:43:30.520 his step.

00:43:31.060 I don't

00:43:31.240 know how

00:43:31.440 old he

00:43:31.760 is,

00:43:32.000 but he's

00:43:32.520 not the

00:43:32.820 old James

00:43:33.340 Carville,

00:43:33.860 let's just

00:43:34.140 say the

00:43:36.340 Bidenization 0.98

00:43:37.140 of James

00:43:37.880 Carville has

00:43:38.500 begun.

00:43:39.980 You know

00:43:40.240 what I

00:43:40.440 mean?

00:43:41.180 The

00:43:41.440 Bidenization? 0.92

00:43:43.060 Yes.

00:43:44.120 So Carville

00:43:46.880 brings up

00:43:48.300 the fine

00:43:49.580 people hoax

00:43:50.380 in Charlottesville,

00:43:52.600 and he wants

00:43:53.900 to sell that

00:43:54.560 as a fact

00:43:55.280 before he

00:43:56.280 makes his

00:43:56.860 next point.

00:43:58.340 So here's

00:43:58.800 what he

00:43:59.040 does.

00:43:59.460 He says,

00:44:00.380 as a question,

00:44:01.240 he goes,

00:44:01.600 were there

00:44:03.320 good people

00:44:03.860 on both

00:44:04.260 sides in

00:44:04.680 Charlottesville?

00:44:05.720 Now,

00:44:06.280 you have to

00:44:06.740 see it to

00:44:07.800 know that

00:44:08.140 he brings

00:44:08.600 this up

00:44:09.240 completely

00:44:10.520 out of

00:44:10.860 context.

00:44:11.860 He just

00:44:12.240 needed something

00:44:12.880 anti-Trump

00:44:13.520 to throw

00:44:13.920 in.

00:44:14.740 So he

00:44:15.040 looks at

00:44:15.320 the audience,

00:44:16.260 he looks

00:44:16.560 at Dave

00:44:17.180 Rubin,

00:44:18.400 he looks

00:44:18.780 at Bill

00:44:19.560 Maher,

00:44:19.940 and he

00:44:20.100 says,

00:44:21.240 were there

00:44:21.500 good people

00:44:22.020 on both

00:44:22.420 sides in

00:44:22.860 Charlottesville?

00:44:23.820 Did I

00:44:24.260 hear that?

00:44:24.960 Here's the

00:44:25.340 best part.

00:44:25.820 He goes,

00:44:26.420 did I hear

00:44:26.980 that or

00:44:27.440 did I

00:44:27.780 make that

00:44:28.240 up?

00:44:30.260 Dave

00:44:30.620 Rubin,

00:44:31.600 sitting

00:44:32.840 right next

00:44:33.360 to him,

00:44:34.780 turns to

00:44:35.280 him,

00:44:36.040 and a

00:44:36.360 foot away

00:44:36.760 from his

00:44:37.140 face,

00:44:38.040 says in

00:44:38.620 deadpan,

00:44:40.180 he didn't

00:44:41.280 say that.

00:44:42.480 A few

00:44:42.840 seconds later

00:44:43.460 he said,

00:44:43.840 I'm not

00:44:44.100 talking about

00:44:44.600 the neo-Nazis

00:44:45.400 and white

00:44:45.720 supremacists.

00:44:49.380 Right to

00:44:50.000 his face,

00:44:51.120 a foot away

00:44:51.780 from him,

00:44:52.960 in front of

00:44:53.540 the world.

00:44:55.040 Now,

00:44:55.420 what did

00:44:55.980 Carville say?

00:44:58.840 Did Carville

00:44:59.480 defend himself

00:45:00.380 and say,

00:45:00.820 oh yes,

00:45:01.600 he definitely

00:45:02.300 said that?

00:45:05.780 I want to

00:45:06.620 play for

00:45:07.140 you what

00:45:07.820 he did

00:45:08.140 say before

00:45:09.320 I give

00:45:09.740 you my

00:45:10.180 impression

00:45:10.640 of James

00:45:12.060 Carville

00:45:12.460 answering this

00:45:13.360 question.

00:45:15.100 So there's

00:45:15.920 a little

00:45:16.400 preamble.

00:45:17.400 I see

00:45:18.000 when I see

00:45:18.500 kids

00:45:18.880 demonstrating

00:45:19.800 these

00:45:20.400 progressives

00:45:22.060 demonstrating

00:45:22.580 for Hamas

00:45:23.400 the most

00:45:23.720 illiberal

00:45:24.100 people

00:45:24.540 in the

00:45:24.920 world

00:45:25.300 that,

00:45:26.180 oh good,

00:45:26.540 we're going to

00:45:26.820 give America

00:45:27.420 it's come up

00:45:28.040 it's asshole 0.92

00:45:28.720 America.

00:45:29.580 This is,

00:45:30.080 they kind of

00:45:30.660 have been

00:45:31.060 indoctrinated

00:45:31.760 this way.

00:45:32.880 And Chuck

00:45:33.260 Schumer

00:45:33.580 made a speech

00:45:34.300 this week,

00:45:35.440 he said,

00:45:35.940 anti-sevism

00:45:36.560 is a five

00:45:37.600 alarm fire

00:45:38.440 that must be

00:45:39.840 extinguished.

00:45:40.520 This is the

00:45:41.020 highest ranking

00:45:41.840 Jewish politician

00:45:42.860 we've ever had

00:45:43.480 in this country.

00:45:44.280 Wait for it.

00:45:44.880 We talked about

00:45:45.280 when Jewish people

00:45:46.020 hear chants like

00:45:46.800 from the river

00:45:47.320 to the sea.

00:45:48.020 Do you understand

00:45:49.660 that means

00:45:50.240 wipe us out

00:45:51.100 by any means

00:45:52.260 necessary?

00:45:55.660 Vulnerabilities

00:45:56.140 in the party,

00:45:56.980 James,

00:45:57.700 the Democrats

00:45:58.280 have a big split

00:45:59.360 generationally

00:46:00.720 on this issue.

00:46:01.500 Wait.

00:46:02.380 The kids

00:46:02.980 seem to be

00:46:04.040 with the

00:46:04.800 Palestinians

00:46:05.280 and the

00:46:07.120 older generation

00:46:08.020 seems to be

00:46:08.720 with Israel.

00:46:10.340 Well,

00:46:10.460 the kids

00:46:10.680 are with

00:46:10.900 TikTok.

00:46:11.620 They're with

00:46:11.980 whatever TikTok

00:46:12.560 felt them to be

00:46:13.280 for,

00:46:13.540 basically.

00:46:14.300 Perfect.

00:46:14.800 Well,

00:46:14.940 that is

00:46:15.280 for a lot

00:46:15.700 of their

00:46:15.920 good people

00:46:17.500 on both sides

00:46:18.140 of Charlottesville.

00:46:19.800 I don't know.

00:46:20.660 Did I hear that?

00:46:21.380 I'll make that up.

00:46:23.040 Trump said

00:46:23.600 they're good people

00:46:24.100 on both sides.

00:46:24.840 He didn't say that.

00:46:25.880 He did not.

00:46:26.800 Well,

00:46:27.140 he said it

00:46:27.680 in a sentence

00:46:28.400 later.

00:46:28.960 He said,

00:46:29.440 I'm not talking

00:46:30.020 about the white

00:46:30.480 supremacists

00:46:31.180 and the Nazi.

00:46:32.640 Yeah.

00:46:34.680 It's like,

00:46:35.360 you know,

00:46:35.600 it was badly phrased.

00:46:37.740 I think we can

00:46:38.300 agree on that.

00:46:38.760 It was inelegant.

00:46:39.740 Yeah,

00:46:39.940 it was inelegant.

00:46:42.360 Now,

00:46:42.860 the first thing

00:46:43.480 you need to understand

00:46:44.400 is that Bill Maher

00:46:46.620 backed up

00:46:48.060 Dave Rubin.

00:46:50.120 When Bill Maher

00:46:51.400 says it was

00:46:52.060 inelegant,

00:46:53.500 he's saying

00:46:54.120 directly he

00:46:54.800 didn't say it.

00:46:56.860 He's saying

00:46:57.600 he didn't say it.

00:46:59.940 So,

00:47:00.480 here's Carville

00:47:01.320 who's got

00:47:02.960 two,

00:47:03.400 he's got

00:47:03.880 Dave Rubin

00:47:04.720 who was,

00:47:05.260 you know,

00:47:05.460 born a Democrat

00:47:06.300 but,

00:47:06.900 you know,

00:47:07.220 now I would

00:47:07.760 call him

00:47:08.040 more independent

00:47:08.700 and he's got

00:47:10.340 Bill Maher

00:47:10.980 very associated

00:47:12.300 with the left

00:47:12.820 and they're

00:47:13.720 both debunking

00:47:14.720 him to his

00:47:15.460 face

00:47:15.960 in front of

00:47:17.880 the world.

00:47:19.900 So,

00:47:20.140 did you hear

00:47:20.580 what Carville's

00:47:21.360 response was

00:47:22.200 when Dave

00:47:23.240 fact-checked

00:47:23.900 him right

00:47:24.500 in front of

00:47:24.960 him?

00:47:26.760 I'd like to

00:47:27.560 give my

00:47:27.960 impression

00:47:28.460 of James

00:47:29.600 Carville

00:47:30.000 getting fact-checked

00:47:31.560 by Dave Rubin.

00:47:33.380 First,

00:47:34.180 Dave Rubin.

00:47:36.320 Well,

00:47:37.000 he didn't say

00:47:37.720 that because

00:47:38.780 a few seconds

00:47:40.180 later he

00:47:40.860 clarified that

00:47:42.100 he was not

00:47:42.620 talking about

00:47:43.100 the neo-Nazis

00:47:43.980 and the white

00:47:44.360 supremacists.

00:47:45.700 And now

00:47:45.960 James Carville

00:47:46.780 fact-checked

00:47:47.860 on the biggest

00:47:48.400 hoax in

00:47:48.880 American politics.

00:47:53.380 Would you

00:47:57.400 like to see

00:47:57.860 it again?

00:48:00.100 Yes,

00:48:00.380 you would.

00:48:01.360 James Carville

00:48:02.260 explaining his

00:48:03.480 side of his

00:48:04.900 opinion of

00:48:05.740 what Trump

00:48:06.200 said in

00:48:07.180 Charlottesville.

00:48:10.860 maybe the

00:48:19.240 finest day

00:48:19.880 in American

00:48:20.380 politics.

00:48:23.020 How long

00:48:23.940 have I been

00:48:24.440 waiting for

00:48:25.020 this?

00:48:27.780 How long

00:48:28.900 have I been

00:48:30.400 trying to

00:48:32.740 get rid of

00:48:33.220 this stupid

00:48:33.780 hoax?

00:48:36.580 Now,

00:48:37.280 this won't

00:48:37.840 get rid of

00:48:38.240 the hoax,

00:48:38.900 because the

00:48:39.420 people who are

00:48:39.860 sold on it

00:48:40.440 will still

00:48:40.760 be sold

00:48:41.100 on it.

00:48:41.780 But here's

00:48:42.280 what we do

00:48:42.760 know.

00:48:44.520 James Carville

00:48:45.360 knows it

00:48:45.860 was a hoax.

00:48:48.160 We do

00:48:48.760 know that.

00:48:52.820 Now,

00:48:53.840 you tell me,

00:48:55.780 do you think

00:48:56.320 anybody in the

00:48:57.100 audience caught

00:48:58.560 this?

00:48:59.320 Do you think

00:49:00.040 that at least

00:49:00.960 the Democrats

00:49:01.580 were watching

00:49:02.040 the show,

00:49:02.920 do you think

00:49:03.360 that they

00:49:03.660 caught that?

00:49:04.140 I don't know.

00:49:07.040 But maybe a few.

00:49:07.880 maybe a few

00:49:09.440 people just

00:49:10.120 became

00:49:10.760 pre-Trump.

00:49:16.000 All right.

00:49:21.140 What do you

00:49:21.880 think will

00:49:22.320 happen if

00:49:23.140 Biden dropped

00:49:24.220 down and

00:49:24.820 it's Newsom?

00:49:27.420 How do you

00:49:28.140 think the

00:49:28.500 matchup would

00:49:29.180 be between

00:49:29.800 Newsom and

00:49:30.640 Trump?

00:49:32.120 Just give me

00:49:32.820 your first

00:49:33.200 impression.

00:49:33.920 How would

00:49:34.560 it be as a

00:49:35.140 matchup?

00:49:35.620 Now,

00:49:35.880 remember,

00:49:37.100 Newsom would

00:49:37.600 have the

00:49:37.940 full power

00:49:38.600 of the

00:49:38.880 Democrat

00:49:39.200 machine,

00:49:40.300 which is

00:49:41.180 awesome.

00:49:43.140 What do you

00:49:43.760 think?

00:49:45.840 Here's what

00:49:46.460 it feels

00:49:46.920 like.

00:49:49.380 Imagine,

00:49:50.020 if you will,

00:49:50.560 the biggest

00:49:51.120 complaints about

00:49:52.020 Trump.

00:49:53.220 What are the

00:49:53.640 biggest complaints

00:49:54.340 about Trump?

00:49:57.400 Let's see.

00:49:59.060 He's a

00:49:59.580 lying,

00:50:00.460 womanizer,

00:50:01.800 older,

00:50:03.400 white guy.

00:50:05.620 You see

00:50:08.080 where I'm

00:50:08.380 going with

00:50:08.820 this?

00:50:10.360 They're both

00:50:10.900 six-foot-three

00:50:12.380 older white

00:50:13.320 guys who

00:50:16.920 have womanizing 1.00

00:50:17.820 problems and

00:50:19.680 are accused

00:50:20.360 of being

00:50:20.700 serial liars.

00:50:23.820 The only

00:50:24.760 thing Biden

00:50:25.400 had going

00:50:25.920 for him is

00:50:26.920 that people

00:50:27.340 didn't yet

00:50:28.080 know he

00:50:28.680 was the

00:50:29.040 bigger liar. 0.84

00:50:31.640 That's all

00:50:32.300 they had.

00:50:33.080 The only

00:50:33.820 thing they

00:50:34.200 had was

00:50:34.560 they didn't

00:50:34.860 know that.

00:50:36.620 And, you

00:50:38.120 know, of

00:50:38.360 course I'm

00:50:39.460 being superficial

00:50:40.160 because that's

00:50:41.000 how voting

00:50:41.500 works.

00:50:42.720 On a

00:50:43.000 superficial,

00:50:43.780 what do you

00:50:44.020 feel about

00:50:44.620 it?

00:50:45.240 Do you

00:50:45.560 think Newsom

00:50:46.200 can get

00:50:46.640 women? 1.00

00:50:48.380 Well, he

00:50:48.940 can get

00:50:49.260 women, that's 1.00

00:50:49.740 the problem.

00:50:50.700 But can

00:50:51.000 he get

00:50:51.220 them to

00:50:51.480 vote for

00:50:51.960 him once

00:50:53.120 the

00:50:53.960 Republican

00:50:54.680 machine

00:50:55.240 turns him

00:50:56.740 into the

00:50:57.420 Harvey

00:50:58.740 Weinstein

00:50:59.460 of politics?

00:51:02.860 You don't

00:51:03.640 think the

00:51:03.960 Republicans are

00:51:04.680 going to turn

00:51:05.060 Newsom into

00:51:05.640 Harvey Weinstein?

00:51:07.020 He's going

00:51:07.400 to be the

00:51:07.760 Me Too-er of

00:51:08.440 all Me Too-ers 0.65

00:51:09.180 by the time

00:51:09.640 they're done

00:51:09.980 with him.

00:51:11.320 And if they

00:51:12.100 try that with

00:51:12.800 Trump, people

00:51:14.320 are going to

00:51:14.680 shrug it off.

00:51:15.420 It's like,

00:51:15.780 okay, we

00:51:16.160 already did

00:51:16.660 this.

00:51:17.920 We already

00:51:18.400 told you we

00:51:18.920 don't care.

00:51:20.060 We're way

00:51:20.600 past that.

00:51:21.220 I feel

00:51:24.340 like, in

00:51:25.760 some ways,

00:51:27.380 I feel

00:51:28.840 like Newsom

00:51:29.280 is the

00:51:29.740 worst match

00:51:30.980 against

00:51:32.220 Trump.

00:51:33.220 But he

00:51:33.680 does have,

00:51:34.720 presumably,

00:51:35.340 the Democrat

00:51:35.920 machine behind

00:51:36.780 him, which

00:51:37.680 I think is

00:51:38.200 part of their

00:51:38.620 problem.

00:51:40.300 If Newsom

00:51:41.500 were the

00:51:41.940 best match

00:51:42.740 you could

00:51:43.000 imagine against

00:51:43.700 Trump, and

00:51:45.140 he had the

00:51:45.600 whole Democrat

00:51:46.140 machine behind

00:51:46.900 him, he

00:51:47.800 would already

00:51:48.200 be the

00:51:48.540 nominee.

00:51:48.840 I mean,

00:51:50.900 they would

00:51:51.500 just force

00:51:52.140 Biden to

00:51:52.800 bow out.

00:51:53.780 I think

00:51:54.340 their lack

00:51:55.000 of an

00:51:55.520 acceptable

00:51:56.280 nominee is

00:51:57.720 the only

00:51:58.020 problem, is

00:51:59.000 the only

00:51:59.200 reason he's

00:51:59.620 still there.

00:52:02.240 And I

00:52:02.960 think that

00:52:03.440 Newsom is

00:52:04.180 the,

00:52:06.180 unfortunately,

00:52:07.320 he got

00:52:07.660 ripe, you 0.99

00:52:08.900 know, ripe

00:52:09.360 for the

00:52:09.780 presidency at

00:52:10.800 the wrong

00:52:11.180 time, because

00:52:12.320 he got ripe

00:52:13.000 at exactly

00:52:13.560 the time

00:52:13.960 he'd be

00:52:14.300 running

00:52:14.540 against the

00:52:15.080 worst

00:52:15.620 possible

00:52:16.340 choice,

00:52:17.700 just the

00:52:18.380 worst

00:52:18.560 choice.

00:52:18.840 Yeah, so

00:52:20.700 the problem

00:52:21.080 is that, in

00:52:23.280 my opinion,

00:52:24.020 Newsom is

00:52:24.820 the poor

00:52:25.700 man's

00:52:26.460 Trump.

00:52:27.700 He's a

00:52:28.060 womanizing,

00:52:28.840 lying, white

00:52:29.340 guy who

00:52:29.780 owns a

00:52:30.120 winery and

00:52:30.920 doesn't think

00:52:31.520 the rules

00:52:32.000 apply to

00:52:32.500 him.

00:52:34.620 Let me

00:52:35.140 say it

00:52:35.400 again.

00:52:36.760 Newsom is

00:52:37.300 a divorced,

00:52:38.900 womanizing,

00:52:39.540 lying, white

00:52:40.000 guy who

00:52:40.340 owns a

00:52:40.660 winery and

00:52:41.140 doesn't

00:52:41.400 think the

00:52:41.780 rules apply

00:52:42.300 to him.

00:52:45.020 How's he

00:52:45.600 going to

00:52:45.800 win against

00:52:46.200 Trump?

00:52:46.500 He's

00:52:49.020 got all

00:52:49.460 of the

00:52:49.680 bad

00:52:49.920 stuff

00:52:50.200 without

00:52:50.360 any

00:52:50.620 of

00:52:50.700 the

00:52:50.780 good

00:52:50.960 stuff.

00:52:52.300 That's

00:52:52.780 an

00:52:52.920 exaggeration,

00:52:53.640 of course.

00:52:55.440 Yeah, that

00:52:55.900 French laundry

00:52:56.540 thing will

00:52:56.900 haunt him.

00:52:57.540 I think

00:52:57.820 that's the

00:52:58.180 least important

00:52:58.720 thing that

00:52:59.060 ever happened,

00:52:59.620 the French

00:52:59.940 laundry, but

00:53:00.560 politically it'll

00:53:01.740 haunt him.

00:53:02.100 All right, let's

00:53:02.960 talk about

00:53:03.580 Gaza.

00:53:06.020 So it

00:53:06.240 looks like

00:53:06.720 behind the

00:53:09.880 scenes, this

00:53:10.520 is being

00:53:10.820 reported by

00:53:11.600 an Israeli

00:53:12.860 publication,

00:53:13.840 Haaretz.

00:53:16.020 So people

00:53:17.040 have different

00:53:17.480 opinions about

00:53:18.080 how much you

00:53:18.520 can believe

00:53:18.960 that publication,

00:53:19.860 but they're

00:53:20.120 reporting that

00:53:21.260 behind the

00:53:21.840 scenes almost

00:53:22.400 every Arab

00:53:22.980 leader is

00:53:23.460 urging Israel 1.00

00:53:24.140 to not

00:53:24.820 stop fighting

00:53:26.980 Hamas until

00:53:27.700 it's destroyed.

00:53:29.260 I believe

00:53:29.740 that.

00:53:30.020 I do

00:53:30.780 believe that

00:53:31.360 every leader

00:53:34.540 in the Arab

00:53:35.020 world wants

00:53:35.700 Hamas destroyed

00:53:36.600 because Hamas 0.73

00:53:38.820 is their

00:53:39.480 enemy as

00:53:40.060 well as

00:53:40.580 Israel's.

00:53:42.440 Not

00:53:42.640 Qatar? 0.56

00:53:45.060 Not

00:53:45.660 Qatar? 0.56

00:53:46.500 Are you

00:53:46.760 sure?

00:53:49.000 I'm not so

00:53:49.960 sure.

00:53:50.940 I think things

00:53:51.620 are complicated

00:53:52.200 over there.

00:53:53.280 I think just

00:53:53.740 because Qatar

00:53:54.480 is keeping

00:53:56.600 the leadership

00:53:57.220 protected,

00:53:59.140 it doesn't

00:53:59.740 necessarily mean

00:54:00.680 they want

00:54:01.080 them to

00:54:01.360 win.

00:54:02.960 Not

00:54:03.220 necessarily.

00:54:04.520 It's

00:54:04.760 complicated

00:54:05.180 over there.

00:54:06.800 All right.

00:54:09.280 The ceasefire

00:54:10.320 is over

00:54:10.980 apparently because

00:54:11.860 part of what

00:54:12.680 Hamas did 1.00

00:54:13.580 not do is

00:54:15.400 they had

00:54:15.620 agreed to

00:54:16.220 hand over

00:54:16.700 all the

00:54:17.000 women and 0.99

00:54:17.400 children and

00:54:18.040 they did

00:54:18.360 not do

00:54:18.760 that and

00:54:19.520 no Americans.

00:54:20.820 So clearly

00:54:21.320 they're gaming

00:54:21.860 the system and

00:54:22.740 so Israel's 0.52

00:54:23.640 saying,

00:54:24.040 all right,

00:54:24.260 we're done

00:54:24.560 with that.

00:54:25.660 We're pulling

00:54:26.200 our negotiators

00:54:27.020 out and it's

00:54:28.020 back to war.

00:54:28.800 Now some

00:54:29.980 are speculating

00:54:30.680 that they

00:54:31.180 can't release

00:54:31.880 the women 0.97

00:54:32.400 because the

00:54:34.940 worst possible

00:54:35.840 reason.

00:54:36.880 You know what

00:54:37.300 the reason is,

00:54:37.900 right?

00:54:39.140 When the

00:54:39.700 women are 1.00

00:54:40.080 released,

00:54:40.500 they're going

00:54:40.680 to have

00:54:40.880 stories to

00:54:41.520 tell.

00:54:41.820 Well,

00:54:42.780 that is a

00:54:43.340 possibility,

00:54:44.860 very much

00:54:45.420 a possibility,

00:54:46.480 but even more

00:54:47.460 than that,

00:54:47.900 they're going

00:54:48.140 to tell stories

00:54:48.940 of,

00:54:50.840 you know,

00:54:51.820 I'm not even

00:54:52.800 going to say

00:54:53.140 it.

00:54:53.960 You know what

00:54:54.540 stories they're

00:54:55.080 going to tell.

00:54:55.520 And Hamas 0.83

00:54:58.040 is not going

00:54:58.920 to be benefited

00:54:59.560 by releasing

00:55:00.340 people who

00:55:01.020 tell those

00:55:01.500 stories.

00:55:03.360 So,

00:55:04.280 and in my

00:55:04.940 mind,

00:55:05.980 Israel has 1.00

00:55:07.000 the greenest

00:55:07.800 of green

00:55:08.300 lights because

00:55:10.540 by not

00:55:11.420 releasing the

00:55:12.260 women, 1.00

00:55:14.820 they have

00:55:15.480 now activated

00:55:16.720 the deepest

00:55:18.700 male kill 0.99

00:55:20.760 switch.

00:55:21.200 let me

00:55:25.020 say that

00:55:25.360 again.

00:55:28.380 If you

00:55:29.140 convince all

00:55:29.760 the men

00:55:30.260 in Israel,

00:55:31.340 which I

00:55:32.020 guess they

00:55:32.360 just did,

00:55:33.900 that the

00:55:34.380 remaining

00:55:34.820 hostages are

00:55:35.720 probably past

00:55:36.720 or current

00:55:37.420 rape victims,

00:55:39.160 you're not

00:55:39.920 just incentivizing 0.96

00:55:41.480 the soldiers

00:55:42.200 to fight

00:55:43.000 because they

00:55:44.340 already have

00:55:44.820 that.

00:55:45.980 You're giving

00:55:47.080 them the

00:55:47.580 kill switch

00:55:48.220 of all

00:55:48.600 kill switches,

00:55:49.500 as in,

00:55:49.980 if they

00:55:51.020 ever wanted

00:55:51.500 to capture

00:55:52.040 you before,

00:55:53.320 they don't

00:55:53.800 now.

00:55:55.640 They're just

00:55:56.320 going to kill

00:55:56.740 them all.

00:55:57.880 And I

00:55:58.140 think,

00:55:58.960 what are

00:56:01.800 you going

00:56:01.960 to do?

00:56:02.760 I mean,

00:56:03.020 Hamas created 1.00

00:56:03.760 this situation.

00:56:05.060 If you

00:56:05.620 incentivize

00:56:06.580 your enemy

00:56:08.340 to kill

00:56:09.600 you completely,

00:56:10.640 don't be

00:56:11.420 surprised when

00:56:12.040 they do.

00:56:13.540 So,

00:56:14.140 I would say

00:56:14.900 that this is

00:56:15.540 Hamas' 0.99

00:56:16.400 biggest mistake

00:56:17.600 so far,

00:56:18.220 is that

00:56:19.460 when you

00:56:20.280 do this

00:56:20.720 with their

00:56:21.100 women, 1.00

00:56:23.080 they're going

00:56:24.000 to kill

00:56:24.300 all of you.

00:56:25.480 They're just

00:56:25.980 going to kill

00:56:26.400 all of you.

00:56:27.280 There's no

00:56:27.860 going back

00:56:28.340 from that.

00:56:29.840 And I

00:56:30.940 support Israel

00:56:31.740 100% on

00:56:32.920 the Hamas

00:56:33.360 stuff.

00:56:35.420 Elon Musk

00:56:36.120 said about

00:56:36.720 the Tesla's

00:56:37.960 version of

00:56:38.440 AI.

00:56:39.300 Now,

00:56:39.580 keep in

00:56:39.880 mind,

00:56:40.760 Musk has 0.97

00:56:41.320 two versions

00:56:41.980 of AI,

00:56:42.680 at least,

00:56:43.260 maybe more,

00:56:44.280 working.

00:56:44.900 There's the

00:56:45.380 Tesla version

00:56:46.160 that's being

00:56:47.060 trained at

00:56:47.740 the moment

00:56:48.120 primarily on

00:56:48.960 video.

00:56:50.100 So,

00:56:50.300 it watches

00:56:50.620 a gazillion

00:56:51.480 videos of

00:56:52.200 cars driving,

00:56:53.440 and just

00:56:53.980 from the

00:56:54.340 video,

00:56:55.320 it gains

00:56:55.940 intelligence

00:56:56.680 on how to

00:56:57.320 self-drive.

00:56:58.660 So,

00:56:58.980 he thinks

00:56:59.340 his is way

00:56:59.900 above,

00:57:00.800 he says it's

00:57:01.520 the best

00:57:02.000 real-world

00:57:03.320 AI.

00:57:05.500 And it

00:57:05.840 might be,

00:57:06.520 because of

00:57:06.920 the video.

00:57:08.240 But,

00:57:08.740 he also has

00:57:09.480 Grok,

00:57:10.740 you know,

00:57:11.220 in beta

00:57:11.560 right now,

00:57:12.360 so that the

00:57:13.060 Twitter

00:57:13.400 platform

00:57:15.380 will have

00:57:15.880 its own

00:57:16.200 AI,

00:57:16.920 and that's

00:57:17.520 separate.

00:57:18.480 That's

00:57:18.840 different from

00:57:19.340 the one

00:57:19.740 Tesla's

00:57:20.500 using with

00:57:20.940 the video.

00:57:21.860 So,

00:57:22.080 the Grok 0.79

00:57:22.540 AI probably

00:57:24.200 will have

00:57:24.700 access,

00:57:26.480 I don't

00:57:26.720 know,

00:57:27.160 do you

00:57:27.360 think the

00:57:27.680 Grok

00:57:28.040 AI will

00:57:29.040 have access

00:57:29.700 to whatever

00:57:30.860 was trained

00:57:31.640 by the

00:57:32.100 video?

00:57:33.640 Because they

00:57:34.260 are separate

00:57:34.720 companies.

00:57:36.760 I don't

00:57:37.340 know,

00:57:37.840 maybe.

00:57:39.640 If it

00:57:40.300 did,

00:57:41.300 then I

00:57:41.780 would immediately

00:57:42.440 agree with

00:57:43.040 him,

00:57:43.280 it's the

00:57:43.560 most powerful

00:57:44.080 AI.

00:57:44.900 But on

00:57:45.200 top of

00:57:45.580 that,

00:57:46.520 Grok is 0.98

00:57:47.000 going to

00:57:47.220 have

00:57:47.360 something

00:57:47.660 that

00:57:47.900 chat

00:57:48.140 GPT and

00:57:49.080 the others

00:57:49.500 do not

00:57:49.900 have,

00:57:50.520 which is

00:57:51.280 immediate

00:57:51.820 real-time

00:57:52.360 access to

00:57:53.300 Twitter.

00:57:54.500 Now,

00:57:55.540 here's what

00:57:56.400 you get

00:57:57.180 with immediate

00:57:57.920 real-time

00:57:58.400 access to

00:57:59.060 Twitter.

00:58:01.840 Grok's 0.99

00:58:02.480 access to

00:58:03.580 the reactions

00:58:04.860 of Twitter

00:58:05.520 users is

00:58:07.140 very analogous

00:58:08.400 to your

00:58:09.420 brain's

00:58:10.140 access to

00:58:11.180 your five

00:58:11.720 senses.

00:58:13.040 Your five

00:58:13.940 senses are

00:58:14.940 what's

00:58:15.180 informing your

00:58:15.900 brain in

00:58:16.480 real-time.

00:58:19.680 Grok will 0.96

00:58:20.760 be informed

00:58:21.400 by this

00:58:21.980 body of

00:58:22.520 human beings

00:58:23.220 reacting to

00:58:24.160 real-time

00:58:24.640 stuff as

00:58:26.000 it happens.

00:58:27.600 That's a

00:58:28.340 body.

00:58:30.280 More

00:58:30.580 specifically,

00:58:31.460 it's a

00:58:31.700 cyborg,

00:58:33.120 where there's

00:58:34.180 a human

00:58:34.560 element,

00:58:35.220 the users,

00:58:36.420 on X,

00:58:37.180 and then

00:58:37.920 there's a

00:58:38.600 non-human

00:58:39.340 element that

00:58:40.260 may have

00:58:41.100 some

00:58:41.320 control.

00:58:44.320 Elon Musk

00:58:45.060 has invented

00:58:45.800 the Borg.

00:58:50.320 It's going

00:58:51.040 to be a

00:58:52.040 collective

00:58:52.460 in which

00:58:53.860 there's a

00:58:54.300 centralized

00:58:54.680 brain and

00:58:56.140 all the

00:58:56.480 individuals are

00:58:57.320 feeding into

00:58:57.940 it, and

00:58:58.700 then they

00:58:59.020 have access

00:58:59.540 to the

00:59:00.800 intelligence

00:59:01.200 from the

00:59:01.720 main brain

00:59:02.300 that they

00:59:03.000 help create

00:59:03.500 access to.

00:59:04.160 That's the

00:59:05.280 Borg.

00:59:06.320 That's a

00:59:07.000 collective

00:59:07.520 cyborg.

00:59:09.980 It will be

00:59:10.880 an entity

00:59:11.360 of its own,

00:59:13.020 logically.

00:59:16.100 That's so

00:59:16.900 wild.

00:59:18.100 Now, if

00:59:18.520 you're not a

00:59:19.000 Star Trek fan,

00:59:20.140 the Borg is

00:59:21.180 these aliens

00:59:22.300 that absorb

00:59:23.860 other planets

00:59:24.580 and turn them

00:59:25.220 into half

00:59:26.280 cyborgs, and

00:59:27.240 it's all part

00:59:28.080 of a collective.

00:59:30.680 But if you

00:59:32.200 take what

00:59:33.000 Tesla can do

00:59:33.800 with video and

00:59:35.200 add that to

00:59:35.820 what Grok 0.96

00:59:36.480 can do

00:59:37.120 connected to

00:59:38.120 real live

00:59:38.680 users in

00:59:39.280 real time,

00:59:41.640 nobody else's

00:59:42.640 AI is even

00:59:43.480 in this

00:59:43.900 class.

00:59:46.380 I think

00:59:47.220 that he's

00:59:48.100 probably two

00:59:49.980 weeks away

00:59:50.480 from lapping

00:59:51.300 ChatGPT and

00:59:53.220 Google's

00:59:53.760 BARD and

00:59:54.420 everything else.

00:59:56.680 I think

00:59:57.060 maybe.

00:59:58.480 It looks

00:59:58.940 like he's

00:59:59.280 just going

00:59:59.680 to leave

00:59:59.880 them behind.

01:00:01.560 The

01:00:01.920 Borg-ing 1.00

01:00:02.360 company.

01:00:03.800 The

01:00:04.100 Borg-ing 1.00

01:00:04.620 company.

01:00:05.160 That's

01:00:05.320 pretty funny.

01:00:06.700 I wish

01:00:07.000 I'd thought

01:00:07.320 of it.

01:00:08.760 All right.

01:00:13.460 So,

01:00:14.040 basically,

01:00:14.780 Elon Musk

01:00:15.560 is creating

01:00:17.060 the Borg,

01:00:18.160 but it's

01:00:18.980 more of a

01:00:19.380 subscription

01:00:19.880 model Borg.

01:00:22.020 That's the

01:00:22.560 big difference.

01:00:23.660 It's like

01:00:23.980 the Borg,

01:00:25.380 but a

01:00:25.780 subscription

01:00:26.240 model.

01:00:27.960 I don't

01:00:28.380 know why

01:00:28.600 that's funny

01:00:29.060 to me.

01:00:29.360 I think

01:00:31.020 you'd have

01:00:31.340 to be a

01:00:31.680 Star Trek

01:00:32.120 fan to

01:00:32.820 know why

01:00:33.140 that's

01:00:33.380 funny.

01:00:34.180 It's the

01:00:34.560 Borg,

01:00:35.480 but

01:00:35.740 subscription

01:00:36.460 model.

01:00:38.140 All right.

01:00:38.560 Trust me,

01:00:39.020 that was

01:00:39.220 funny.

01:00:41.180 All right.

01:00:43.460 And that,

01:00:44.260 ladies and 0.98

01:00:44.620 gentlemen,

01:00:46.140 is the

01:00:47.180 conclusion of

01:00:48.060 my excellent,

01:00:48.960 excellent

01:00:49.420 commentary,

01:00:50.880 not to

01:00:51.420 mention

01:00:51.720 impressions

01:00:53.360 that will

01:00:54.520 last

01:00:55.000 forever.

01:00:56.040 ever.

01:00:57.920 So,

01:00:58.480 I'd like

01:00:59.840 to think

01:01:00.200 that my

01:01:00.720 impressions

01:01:02.240 are as

01:01:02.680 good as

01:01:02.980 my

01:01:03.200 commentary.

01:01:05.720 Every bit

01:01:06.360 is good.

01:01:07.980 I'm enjoying

01:01:08.720 being a

01:01:09.280 disgraced

01:01:09.920 cartoonist,

01:01:11.700 canceled

01:01:12.280 everywhere.

01:01:13.240 So far,

01:01:13.740 it's working

01:01:14.100 out for me

01:01:14.660 perfectly.

01:01:17.060 I don't

01:01:17.620 know if I

01:01:17.960 gave you

01:01:18.240 this update

01:01:19.020 or only I

01:01:19.940 did it in

01:01:20.320 the man

01:01:20.600 cave.

01:01:21.380 Tell me

01:01:21.720 if this

01:01:22.060 is a

01:01:22.340 repeat.

01:01:25.020 But,

01:01:25.460 so I

01:01:26.100 got canceled

01:01:26.680 February of

01:01:27.640 last year,

01:01:28.180 so it's

01:01:28.480 eight or

01:01:28.760 nine months

01:01:29.260 ago.

01:01:30.700 And it's

01:01:31.760 kind of a

01:01:32.120 scary thing

01:01:32.760 if your

01:01:34.120 entire career

01:01:34.960 just disappears

01:01:35.760 at the same

01:01:36.260 time.

01:01:37.180 But,

01:01:38.100 I'm kind

01:01:39.620 of hard

01:01:40.400 to kill.

01:01:42.100 So,

01:01:42.600 I want to

01:01:42.920 report to

01:01:43.380 you that

01:01:43.760 nine months

01:01:44.280 later,

01:01:44.900 my income

01:01:46.560 has regenerated

01:01:47.560 up to

01:01:48.200 break-even

01:01:49.500 cash flow,

01:01:51.000 which means

01:01:51.460 I can pay

01:01:52.320 my employees

01:01:52.940 and pay

01:01:53.440 my expenses

01:01:54.040 and I'm

01:01:56.000 a break-even.

01:01:57.580 But,

01:01:58.620 as long as

01:01:59.740 I'm a

01:02:00.000 break-even,

01:02:01.380 you can't

01:02:01.760 kill me.

01:02:03.920 I'm

01:02:04.380 unkillable.

01:02:05.900 So,

01:02:06.340 if it had

01:02:07.240 been more

01:02:07.780 of a

01:02:08.080 financial

01:02:08.500 disaster,

01:02:09.860 you know,

01:02:10.060 maybe I

01:02:10.360 have to

01:02:10.640 disappear

01:02:11.160 and get

01:02:11.440 a real

01:02:11.680 job.

01:02:12.680 But,

01:02:13.120 thanks to

01:02:13.980 all of

01:02:14.380 you,

01:02:15.560 YouTube

01:02:16.240 and especially

01:02:17.040 locals,

01:02:18.100 my beloved

01:02:19.320 locals

01:02:19.920 people,

01:02:20.420 you made

01:02:22.240 it possible

01:02:22.840 by becoming

01:02:24.160 the counter

01:02:24.760 force to

01:02:25.420 my

01:02:25.620 cancellation,

01:02:27.040 you

01:02:27.220 collectively,

01:02:29.540 individually

01:02:30.220 formed a

01:02:32.460 protective

01:02:32.980 coat around

01:02:33.940 me so

01:02:35.160 that I

01:02:35.480 could

01:02:35.700 continue

01:02:36.260 being the

01:02:37.800 spear.

01:02:39.080 Because,

01:02:39.640 for a lot

01:02:39.960 of you,

01:02:40.280 I become

01:02:40.580 the spear.

01:02:42.100 I'm the

01:02:42.700 one who's

01:02:43.060 poking people

01:02:43.700 that you

01:02:44.020 can't poke

01:02:44.640 because you're

01:02:45.580 going to get

01:02:45.860 fired and

01:02:46.460 I'm willing

01:02:47.300 to take the

01:02:47.800 chance.

01:02:48.980 So,

01:02:49.820 just know

01:02:50.800 that your

01:02:51.120 plan worked.

01:02:53.000 Your plan

01:02:54.140 for me

01:02:55.440 worked.

01:02:57.760 You wrapped

01:02:58.640 me in a

01:02:59.280 protective

01:02:59.960 coating,

01:03:00.860 which I

01:03:01.540 could feel

01:03:02.020 on the

01:03:02.400 first day.

01:03:03.800 On the

01:03:04.420 first day,

01:03:06.000 that protective

01:03:06.880 coating formed

01:03:08.060 around me

01:03:08.660 and has

01:03:09.920 protected me

01:03:10.620 to this

01:03:10.980 day.

01:03:12.020 Thank you.

01:03:13.600 Thank you.

01:03:15.180 So,

01:03:15.980 YouTube,

01:03:16.760 thanks and

01:03:17.240 I'll see you

01:03:17.620 tomorrow.

01:03:18.120 Bye.

01:03:20.820 Bye.

01:03:21.220 Bye.

01:03:21.400 Bye.

01:03:37.720 Bye.

01:03:38.200 Bye.

01:03:38.740 Bye.

01:03:39.960 Bye.

01:03:40.680 Bye.

01:03:45.480 Bye.

01:03:47.560 Bye.

Real Coffee with Scott Adams - December 02, 2023

Episode 2310 Scott Adams： CWSA 12⧸02⧸23 Don't Miss My James Carville Impression, Pre-Trumpers, More

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript