Reaction to Mark Carney's disastrous start to his term as Bank of Canada's Governor, Ezra Levant takes a look at his cabinet ministers, and asks the question, if Alberta were not part of Canada, would it agree to join Canada on the current terms?
00:00:00.000Hello, my friends. Four statements from Carney cabinet ministers, four little disasters. That's
00:00:06.300today's show. I want to show you video clips of these four cabinet ministers. So I want you to
00:00:10.440get the video version of this podcast. I mean, the audio version, of course, is fine, but I want you
00:00:15.200to see them say these crazy things. And to do that, you need what we call Rebel News Plus. It's our
00:00:20.400video subscription. Go to rebelnewsplus.com, click subscribe. It's eight bucks a month,
00:00:24.860which is not bad. It's, you know, what the cost of one fancy coffee at Starbucks. And we need the
00:00:31.120dough because we don't take any money from the government and it shows. So please consider
00:00:35.420helping us by going to rebelnewsplus.com and subscribing. Oh, one more thing. Thanks for
00:00:41.020tuning into this podcast. If you appreciate the news that Rebel brings you, consider being a part
00:00:47.400of what makes it possible. You can do so by subscribing to our exclusive content at rebelnewsplus.com.
00:00:54.860That means get exclusive shows, documentary, behind the scenes, and more. And it's for a cheap price
00:01:03.160as low as $8 to start. We appreciate your support.
00:01:07.080Tonight, Mark Carney's government is off to a disastrous start. It's May 15th, and this is
00:01:28.180the Ezra Levant Show. Shame on you, you censorious bug.
00:01:43.960I'm back in Toronto at our world headquarters, and I keep thinking about the question that I heard when
00:01:49.060I was in Alberta this week. And it's this. If Alberta were not part of Canada right now,
00:01:54.940would it agree to join Canada on the current terms? As in, if Alberta were independent,
00:02:00.860would it give up its independence and join as a province and a country where there are more
00:02:06.080federal cabinet ministers from the city of Brampton than the entire provinces of Alberta and Saskatchewan
00:02:12.060combined? Where the key national financial program, equalization, hoovers up billions of dollars
00:02:18.260from Alberta from workers there to give as a gift to less industrious workers in other provinces.
00:02:26.320And yet where the workers who earn that money, typically in oil and gas, are constantly demonized,
00:02:32.340not celebrated. Their jobs are threatened. They're told to transition to non-existent green jobs and to
00:02:38.220pay for those green jobs in Ontario and Quebec through investments of their tax dollars in foreign
00:02:43.820corporations like those electric vehicle schemes that the private sector obviously doesn't want
00:02:48.980to invest in, but Trudeau and Carney do. And that's just the money stuff. The disrespect,
00:02:54.380the constant demonization and ridicule. It really reminds me of a few lines from the U.S.
00:03:00.180Declaration of Independence. I don't know if you've ever read it. It's a list of complaints
00:03:03.780about the king. He has erected a multitude of new offices and sent hither swarms of officers to
00:03:10.700harass our people and eat out their substance. For cutting off our trade with all parts of the
00:03:16.200world. What's that other than blocking our tankers and pipelines? For imposing taxes on us without our
00:03:21.800consent. I mean, there's a ton of overlap, isn't there? But I think it's more than just things you
00:03:26.360can count. More than just tangible things. It's soft things, emotional things. The kind of ties that
00:03:31.520bind people together into a meaningful nation with common loyalty and common destiny. I think
00:03:37.060a lot of people in politics, a lot of the institutions in the country, I think they just
00:03:43.420hate the West. The regime media certainly does. It always made me chuckle when Donald Trump would
00:03:49.360talk about making Canada a cherished 51st state. I shouldn't laugh. It was talk like that that gave
00:03:55.500Carney the election by spooking boomers in central Canada into liberals. But when was the last time any
00:04:02.380institution of power in this country? Media, University of Toronto, Royal Bank ever spoke
00:04:12.240about cherishing Alberta? They just don't use that language. They do it for Quebec. They talk about how
00:04:19.200much they cherish Quebec, but never the West. But not just the West. How about Sir John A. Macdonald?
00:04:26.300How about any of our traditions or values, our history, our true stories? Not the false slander that
00:04:32.180we're a genocidal country. I mean, I can think of about 15 billion reasons a year why Alberta wouldn't
00:04:38.200want to join Canada today if it were independent. But I don't know if a lot of other parts would too.
00:04:43.080Would you? We're losing our freedom of speech. Our Canadian dollar is like the peso. We get poorer and
00:04:49.420we don't even see it. Our economy is in a recession on a per capita basis. No young people can afford to
00:04:55.680buy homes in the big cities so they can't afford to start a family. Our streets are choked with
00:05:00.480foreign migrants, some of whom turn to crime and some of whom turn to advocacy for terrorism,
00:05:06.060celebrating terrorism, all under the approving eye of government and police. Yeah, if Alberta is the
00:05:11.880first province to leave, I promise you it will not be the last. One of the things we talked about in our
00:05:17.780western town halls was mottos for a separatist movement. In 1995, Quebec's official motto for the
00:05:24.720separatist side was in French, yes and it becomes possible. As in vote yes and it becomes possible. It
00:05:33.740being whatever you want it to be. You could tweak that, anything is possible. That could have been
00:05:40.940Canada's motto, you know, but no one would believe that now. Or how about this for a motto?
00:05:46.020We can do so much better. Don't you think that's true for Albertans? We can do so much better. And
00:05:53.420if you're in Ontario or Quebec or Atlantic or BC or the north, don't you think that you could do so
00:05:57.240much better than the liberals? And our system, Mark Carney, the slippery banker who seems to have a
00:06:01.820problem telling the truth and gets hostile whenever a journalist asks him a real question,
00:06:06.320which is pretty rare. We'll talk later in the show today with Franco Teresano about the fact that
00:06:11.180Canada hasn't had a budget in over a year and we likely won't get one this year either. Oh, I thought
00:06:16.280Carney was a master of all things dollars and cents. But look at this. Let me show you four little
00:06:21.740vignettes all from the same day. You tell me whether or not you're from Alberta. Don't you think you could
00:06:27.300do so much better? Let's start with the Hamas wing of the Liberal Party, Anita Anand, now the foreign
00:06:32.960minister who goes full Hamas, just full anti-Semitic here. Take a look.
00:06:38.060Israel is blocking food and aid to Gaza. What do you think of that decision? And is the Canadian
00:06:43.260government doing anything to stop that? We cannot allow the continued use of food as a political
00:06:52.800tool. The prime minister has been very clear about that. Over 50,000 people have died as a result.
00:07:02.960of the aggression caused against the Palestinian and the Gazan people in Palestine. And using food
00:07:14.660as a political tool is simply unacceptable. We need to continue to work towards a ceasefire. We need
00:07:22.700to ensure that we have a two-state solution and Canada will continue to maintain that position.
00:07:28.900So it's Israel that's the aggressor. So Gaza is now Palestine. So Israel is the one using food
00:07:35.900as a weapon, not a word about the hostages, not a word about terrorism, not a word about how Hamas
00:07:40.920takes the food aid and sells it. Or look at this guy. He's ready to work from home 20 hours a week
00:07:46.820for sure for nearly $400,000 a year. Take a look at this guy.
00:07:49.820When you decided not to run again, you said it was because you wanted to spend more time
00:07:53.820with your family. And you said when you were coming back again that you worked out a deal
00:07:56.820with Mr. Carney that you're able to, you know, have a little bit more work-life balance. How does that
00:08:00.820jive with your new role? Well, I expect what you're going to see is when the House Commons is not sitting.
00:08:04.820Given the nature of the portfolio, a lot of the stakeholders we have are less interested
00:08:08.820in having you attend groundbreakings, the openings of new buildings that you may have funded,
00:08:12.820and are quite accustomed to having meetings virtually. So I anticipate during constituency weeks
00:08:17.820I'm going to be based in my hometown a little more than I was before. There may be an opportunity,
00:08:21.820depending on what's going on in the House, to avail myself, not all the time of course,
00:08:24.820but once in a while of the virtual abilities to participate in the House of Commons proceedings.
00:08:29.820So we're going to figure some of this out as we go. I'm very proud to have the support of my family to come back.
00:08:33.820My kids in particular are very excited, even though the little guy is only three years old.
00:08:37.820My daughter at nine has a better understanding. And it's going to take work on my part.
00:08:41.820Yeah, talk about failing upward. He thinks his job as Justice Minister is to do groundbreaking for buildings,
00:08:49.820opening buildings, cutting ribbons. He's the Attorney General and Justice Minister.
00:08:53.820He wants to work from home. What a lazy, entitled loser.
00:08:57.820Don't you think the Liberal Party needs about a decade in the wilderness to get over themselves?
00:09:02.820Or this guy? He's back at the Heritage Department where he's in charge of censorship and media subsidies,
00:09:07.820but he thought he'd freestyle a little and announce no new pipelines will be allowed.
00:09:12.820Premier Smith says that she's still concerned that you're part of the Cabinet and also the new selection of Mr. Rosen for the Environment Minister.
00:09:17.820She says it's too close of a tie to you. What do you say in response to that?
00:09:21.820I think we will have to agree to disagree with Premier Smith. We think that protecting the environment,
00:09:26.820fighting climate change is important. Lots of Canadians believe that as well.
00:09:30.820It was a central element of our platform and we will make good on our commitments.
00:09:35.820The Prime Minister last night on TV seemed to open the door to potentially changing the emissions cap or the IAA to get projects built.
00:12:26.820We need to be delivering more affordable housing.
00:12:28.820The government of Canada has not been building affordable housing since the 90s.
00:12:33.820And we've created a huge shortage across Canada.
00:12:36.820That's where the big need is right now.
00:12:39.820And I'm very encouraged that the prime minister and our commitment right now in government is the double construction and focus on the affordable side.
00:13:15.820We need to be delivering more affordable housing.
00:13:17.820The government of Canada has not been building affordable housing since the 90s.
00:13:22.820And we've created a huge shortage across Canada.
00:13:25.820That's where the big need is right now.
00:13:27.820And I'm very encouraged that the prime minister and our commitment right now in government is the double construction and focus on the affordable side.
00:16:34.820Canada, as we careen through economic crises, immigration crises, affordability crises, tax crises, we have not had a budget.
00:16:46.820The government of Canada has not had a budget since April of 2024, more than a year ago.
00:16:53.820But hey, if Mark Carney has some more of these theatrical signing ceremonies, I guess that's all we need joining us now to talk about this and other related matters is our favorite tax fighter, our friend Franco Teresano from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:17:08.820You know, the liberals have always been masters of optics and visuals.
00:17:13.820But at the end of the day, sometimes you actually have to govern, you have to have parliament called, you have to debate, you have to vote.
00:17:19.820And the basic document of any government, in some ways the most important one, is the budget, because from there all things flow, whether it's taxes or spending.
00:17:28.820Has Canada ever gone this long without a budget before, Franco?
00:17:32.820Well, unfortunately, yeah, right, because the Trudeau government didn't put in a budget in 2020.
00:17:38.820So this isn't the first time that we've seen the liberal government not bring in a budget, but this is really a big deal, right?
00:17:45.820Number one, it's look, it's democracy 101 that a government tables a budget, right?
00:17:50.820They're spending hundreds of billions of dollars of our money.
00:17:54.820A budget is probably the biggest time of the year where Canadians, where taxpayers can actually look into the state of our finances, but then also hold the government accountable on its spending plans.
00:18:06.820Hey, Ezra, not to mention members of parliament who are supposed to be our elected representatives who are supposed to be voting on spending and tax bills.
00:18:15.820Well, how in the world are they going to make an informed decision if the government won't even release what the state of our finances are?
00:18:22.820You know, I thought you were going to go in a slightly different direction when you mentioned the MPs, because here's one thing I know.
00:18:28.820Every April Fool's Day, the MPs automatically get a raise in pay.
00:18:32.820And I have to tell you, Franco, if they didn't get that raise in pay until they did their work and got a budget, we would have had that budget yesterday.
00:18:40.820And so they certainly took care of themselves first.
00:18:43.820Do we know when parliament is set to resume?
00:18:46.820I presume I see here that it'll it'll be some weeks yet still.
00:20:17.820Let me just quote a line from your piece today.
00:20:20.820He said, Carney plans to add an extra $225 billion to the debt over the next four years, according to his election platform.
00:20:30.820For comparison, the Trudeau government planned on increasing the debt by $131 billion over those years, according to the most recent fall economic statement.
00:20:39.820So Mark Carney is spending 50% more in terms of the debt.
00:20:49.820And like you say, this is the guy who was supposed to bring, you know, it was Trudeau who said the childish thing, budgets balance themselves.
00:20:58.820Who said the naive thing, I don't think about monetary policy, who said the foolish thing, you know, we'll build the economy from the heart out.
00:21:07.820But it's Carney who's blowing up the debt.
00:21:10.820Carney's making Justin Trudeau, it's making me pine for the days of Justin Trudeau.
00:21:16.820Well, I bet you weren't, you didn't think you were going to say that today.
00:21:19.820But look, it turns out, turns out we learned that budgets don't balance themselves.
00:21:24.820And I guess budgets don't write themselves either.
00:21:27.820Look, it took what, Trudeau 10 years to double the debt, right?
00:21:31.820So in all of the hundred plus years that Canada has been around, you had prime ministers, all of them rack up $600 billion of debt.
00:21:40.820And, you know, if that wasn't bad enough, well, now we have Carney who wants to add about $100 billion more of debt than what even Trudeau was planning to do.
00:21:50.820OK, you know, the banker was supposed to be better with the numbers than the drama teacher.
00:21:55.820But it's not looking that way anymore.
00:22:36.820I mean, look, whenever you have a minority government, they're going to have to find a dance partner, right?
00:22:40.820So unless they're going to try to get the conservatives on board with some tax cuts, maybe some spending reductions.
00:22:45.820Like, I don't know how likely that is, but if they're looking for the NDP or the Bloc, yeah, I think everyone should worry that the spending and the debt is going to go even higher than the $225 billion of debt that Carney was running on during the election.
00:22:59.820So I think that's a very fair thing to be worried about, absolutely, because as you mentioned, I mean, look, the NDP, you know, as crazy as the liberal government has been, the NDP hasn't seen a type of dollar that they don't want to tax away or a new spending program that they don't like.
00:23:15.120You know, I want to ask you one more thing. I don't know if you saw my videos, but over the last few weeks, I've been going to some of these tax havens where Mark Carney stashed Brookfield Asset Management corporate shells.
00:23:28.960I went to the Isle of Man. I went to Bermuda. And it's clear what's going on there.
00:23:34.960And I think Brookfield would say that it's perfectly legal what they're doing, namely, they're just being smart tax avoiders, not evaders, and they're complying with all the laws.
00:23:47.360That's what they would say. But, you know, I think there's something, even if it's not illegal, something weird or even unethical about the same prime minister setting up ways
00:23:59.840to avoid Canadian taxes, who is the imposer and collector. And, you know, he's the guy enforcing the Canadian taxes that he himself evades.
00:24:13.240And he's evading them to this day, Franco, because he still has $6.8 million with a Brookfield stock options.
00:24:19.380And we all know that he's put it behind a blind trust, but he knows what he put in there. It was just a few weeks ago.
00:24:25.200I don't know what to make of this. I'm trying to, like, I don't want to condemn people for being smart tax planners,
00:24:31.460but there's something weird about the prime minister collecting different taxes from you than he pays himself.
00:24:40.380Well, look, my thoughts on this is that there's two fundamental problems with Canada's tax system, okay?
00:24:45.860There's two fundamental problems as I see it and where the government has to address it.
00:24:49.760Number one, taxes are just outrageously high, right? And that's across all levels of government.
00:24:54.480Essentially, folks, take your paycheck, rip it in half, because that's the tax man's, okay?
00:24:59.920So, number one, taxes are just way too high. And look, if you want to attract businesses, you want to attract investment,
00:25:04.940you want to bring in the tax dollars that way, well, we're going to have to lower taxes.
00:25:08.960Like, we're less competitive than the United States on both businesses and income taxes.
00:25:13.280So, Canadians are paying way too much tax because government spending and debt has become out of control.
00:25:18.560The second issue that I see with Canada's tax system is that it's way too complex, right?
00:25:23.340Like, look, like, you essentially, like, need an army of lawyers and accountants to navigate the income tax system.
00:25:30.780Like, let's just cut the number of taxes, cut the overall tax rates, and let's actually make it that normal Canadians can figure out this dysfunctional tax system.
00:25:39.940Yeah. You know, there's certain things about Bermuda and the Isle of Man that I wouldn't want Canada to be like.
00:25:44.340I think they turned a bit of a blind eye sometimes to money laundering or other things that we might find questionable.
00:25:52.200But wouldn't it be something if Canada were a jurisdiction that people wanted to put their money into because we had such modest taxes?
00:26:00.940We're going in all the wrong directions with taxes and with debt.
00:26:04.800Franco, I'm so glad you're out there to be a watchdog and keep an eye on things.
00:26:08.840We're going to need it more than ever.
00:26:09.880Let me just throw one more question at you.
00:26:49.460What do you know about him from a finance point of view as opposed to a foreign affairs point of view?
00:26:53.480Well, I'm worried because I believe he was the minister, at least around the cabinet table, right, when they're announcing the billions of dollars in corporate welfare to the multinational corporations to build those battery factories in, what, southwestern Ontario and Quebec, right?
00:27:09.460You're talking about what the government put taxpayers on the hook for about $30 billion in corporate welfare to what, Volkswagen, Stellantis, you had Northvolt and Honda.
00:27:19.000And I believe if he wasn't the industry minister, he was right around the cabinet table for all that.
00:27:24.340So that's what I'm really worried, given Canada's, like, what, $1.3 trillion debt right now.