Rebel News Podcast - October 30, 2021


EZRA LEVANT | The Supreme Court says a comedian’s jokes aren’t illegal, but the vote was five judges to four


Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 5 minutes

Words per minute

170.38219

Word count

11,105

Sentence count

776

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

25

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Supreme Court rules that a comedian's jokes aren't illegal, but the vote was 5 judges to 4, and it takes one more judge to switch sides, and those jokes will be banned. Ezra takes you through the ruling, and the dissent.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.400 Hello, my friends. I take you through a Supreme Court ruling today on the case of Mike Ward,
00:00:06.240 the Quebec comedian who made fun of a disabled kid called Jeremy Gabriel. Now, the court
00:00:11.500 sided with Mike Ward's freedom of speech and his right to make jokes, but that's not
00:00:16.620 interesting to me. What's interesting is that the ruling was five to four. All it takes
00:00:22.380 is one more judge to switch sides, and those jokes will be banned. So I'm not going to
00:00:28.760 read the majority ruling. I'm going to take you through the minority ruling, the dissenting
00:00:32.240 ruling, and I'll show you what the four censorship judges have to say, because I reckon that'll be
00:00:39.840 the law in, what, five years? Stay with me for that, but before we get to that, let me invite you to
00:00:45.180 become a subscriber to Rebel News Plus. That's the video version of this podcast. Just go to
00:00:50.440 rebelnewsplus.com, click subscribe, eight bucks a month. My show, Sheila's show, David's show,
00:00:55.820 Andrew's show, lots of shows, lots of content, eight bucks. But the real reason to do it, besides
00:01:01.440 the fact that I think it's good viewing, is because we rely on viewers like you. We don't
00:01:05.880 take a dime from Trudeau. 99% of the media does, we don't. So if you can help us out,
00:01:11.540 please go to rebelnewsplus.com. All right, here's today's show.
00:01:14.180 Tonight, the Supreme Court says a comedian's jokes aren't illegal, but the vote was five
00:01:35.700 judges to four. It's October 29th, and this is The Ezra LeVant Show.
00:01:41.600 Why should others go to jail when you're a biggest carbon consumer I know?
00:01:45.320 There's 8,500 customers here, and you won't give them an answer.
00:01:49.380 The only thing I have to say to the government, the why I'm publishing, is because it's my bloody
00:01:54.260 right to do so.
00:01:55.240 Mike Ward is a Quebec comedian. He's one of the few comedians in Canada who's funny enough
00:02:06.240 to make a living at comedy. Most comedians in Canada either have to move to the U.S.
00:02:11.160 to make a go of it, or just do it as a hobby, or as many do, go work as a government comedian
00:02:17.280 at Trudeau's CBC State Broadcaster. I don't think it's possible to be a government comedian,
00:02:22.080 just like I think it's impossible to be a government rock band. A government rock band
00:02:28.020 isn't singing rock music. It's, I don't know, singing a jingle like an advertising song, and
00:02:33.120 some of those can be really nice, but they're still ads. Same with government comedians.
00:02:39.080 Basically, Liberal Party policy spoken with a laugh track. Do you doubt me?
00:02:44.140 If the old saying is true, that you're only as sick as your secrets, oh my, the Harper
00:02:50.860 government must be rotted out with disease and illness, because it's all hush-hush in
00:02:55.920 Harperland. Makes you wonder, though, what kind of unspeakable evil they're getting up
00:03:00.280 to, to need that kind of impenetrable veil of secrecy, doesn't it? I mean, what is their
00:03:06.600 dark agenda? What are they roasting puppy dogs on sticks back there? 0.96
00:03:10.800 So, help save poor Stassi Steve this season. God knows here Harper doesn't have enough sense 0.96
00:03:19.920 to save himself, so let's bring him a load of sense.
00:03:23.760 Yeah, put aside how gross it is to imply that Stephen Harper, the most pro-Israel Canadian
00:03:28.600 prime minister in Canadian history, is a Nazi. My bigger beef in this context is, she's just 0.94
00:03:35.480 not funny. Now, you could say that about Mike Ward. Some comedians work clean, as they say,
00:03:42.540 never swearing, never too dangerous. I'd put Jerry Seinfeld in that category. You can call
00:03:49.020 him dad jokes. Hey, working hard or hardly working, that kind of joke. Mike Ward is rougher. He's
00:03:56.760 not to everyone's taste. And one of the things he joked about was this guy, Jeremy Gabriel,
00:04:03.780 who was actually just a kid at the time. As you can probably tell by looking at him, he
00:04:08.900 has a rare disability called Treacher-Collins Syndrome. It's tough. It's tough to look at.
00:04:16.540 Imagine how tough it is to be him, to be his family. And he was a kid at the time, and Mike
00:04:22.760 Ward made fun of him. That's definitely not to everyone's taste. I think it's very important to
00:04:27.700 note that Jeremy Gabriel was not a private person, though. He was a celebrity, like a child actor,
00:04:35.180 like Greta Thunberg was, until, like so many child actors, she aged out and became just an actor,
00:04:41.640 which has less cachet. Jeremy Gabriel was a celebrity because he was born deaf, but when he
00:04:48.920 turned six, he got a special hearing aid that allowed him to hear. And he began to sing, and
00:04:55.980 that's how he became a celebrity, because he was a child with such a punishing disease, and yet he
00:05:02.100 still had dreams, and he tried to reach them. I suppose he did. He even sang for the Pope and
00:05:07.400 Celine Dion. I think we can all agree that mocking little Jeremy is punching down. He wasn't an
00:05:15.240 immoral person. He was a kid. He didn't do anything wrong. In fact, he did a lot with what little God
00:05:21.100 had given him. Maybe that is doing a lot, actually. He was a celebrity, and Mike Ward took a run at him.
00:05:30.260 So the kid's parents took Mike Ward to the Quebec Human Rights Commission. I know a bit about that.
00:05:34.860 In 2006, I published the Danish cartoons of Mohammed as part of a news story about them being banned
00:05:40.840 and the riots against him, etc., and I was taking one of those kangaroo courts myself. The claim
00:05:46.220 in that case was that I was mocking Mohammed, who, by the way, died many centuries ago. 0.82
00:05:53.200 But publishing those cartoons in that context was a very important journalistic act, if I may say so
00:06:00.420 myself, not because the cartoons were inherently interesting. I would never have published them
00:06:05.460 or even known about them were it not for the boycott against them, the banning of them, the riots that
00:06:10.440 killed more than 200 about them, and later the terrorist attacks against other cartoonists. I believe
00:06:16.140 what I did was journalistically and legally and morally important, very valuable, and the human rights
00:06:21.920 complaint against me was odious for those reasons, but also because even if my publication of those
00:06:28.180 cartoons was not important, it's still my right, because we're a free country. I'm not here to tell you that
00:06:34.300 Mike Ward's jokes about a disabled boy were journalistically and morally important or valuable, but I'm here to 1.00
00:06:39.800 tell you that despite that, or maybe even because of that, they're important to defend. Because you have to
00:06:44.860 fight for free speech, even for people you don't agree with. You don't have to think jokes are funny to approve of
00:06:51.260 them legally. He can be mad at Mike Ward. You can say so. You can ignore him. But saying mean words is not a crime.
00:06:58.160 I acknowledge they hurt the lad. Here's what he told the Human Rights Commission. He said,
00:07:03.320 I was 12 or 13 when I saw those videos. I didn't have maturity to be strong in the face of this.
00:07:10.400 I lost confidence and hope. It made me think my life is worth less than another's because I'm
00:07:14.340 handicapped. I accept those comments. It's true. But what is the rule for jokes? They can't make fun of
00:07:21.420 people? On what grounds? And if they're under 18 or over 18? What if they're a child celebrity
00:07:30.280 promoted by their parents, as in this case? What if the joke teller themself is disabled?
00:07:37.000 What's the rule for that? And what exactly is disabled? What's the definition? And who gets to
00:07:42.720 decide? Again, I'm not saying I like picking on the kid. But you're seriously going to ban mean jokes?
00:07:48.000 And who decides what's mean? And does it matter if it's a funny joke? Some mean things can be really,
00:07:55.780 really funny. Oh, and by the way, can a disabled person tell jokes about disabled people? Can he tell 1.00
00:08:02.640 jokes about himself? I actually see a lot of that these days on Twitter and places like that. It's
00:08:09.080 kind of reclaiming the words just the same way many black people use the N-word because they want to 0.99
00:08:14.380 take it back, take the power and hurt out of it. Lots of Jewish comedians tell Jewish jokes. 1.00
00:08:19.900 Frankly, many female comedians tell jokes that could be called anti-women and even more tell jokes 1.00
00:08:25.240 that are definitely anti-men. Are you going to make up some rules? Because in this one case,
00:08:30.820 Mike Ward was objectively mean. He'll admit he was mean. Do we have a joke tester general who gets to
00:08:37.720 decide? Don't be surprised if you're allowed to make fun of people, um, or not based on their
00:08:44.020 politics. You've never seen anything more racist or sexist or anti-gay than a liberal who sees a 0.79
00:08:51.740 minority or a woman or a gay person who's conservative. Or the viciousness that comes out 1.00
00:08:57.460 then. But that's okay, naturally, because reasons. And comedy of all things. Remember, and we've talked
00:09:05.000 about this before, that a jester isn't just about making us feel good and laugh a bit.
00:09:10.640 Jesters often speak truth to power. This is Will Summers, the court jester to Henry VIII.
00:09:17.160 He was the one man in the court who was allowed to joke at the king's suspense to say things that
00:09:23.200 embarrassed the king that everyone else was thinking but was afraid to say. You can imagine how important
00:09:29.460 that would be with a bit of a tyrant like Henry VIII. I mean, the court fool, the court jester had to be
00:09:36.400 careful. But he had an enormously useful role, speaking truth with a laugh to get the king to think twice
00:09:44.420 about things. Which is why most tyrants don't have a court jester. They ban comedy or ban joking that 0.83
00:09:53.100 embarrasses him. Stalin did it. The Ayatollahs did it. So what about Canada? Well, the Human Rights Commission in Quebec
00:10:01.040 convicted Mike Ward. They said he discriminated against young Jeremy. And the Quebec Court of Appeal upheld that.
00:10:09.460 They said that Jeremy Gabriel had a right to dignity. And that was more important than Ward's right to make a joke,
00:10:15.260 even in a comedy show that explicitly took on sacred cows. See, I haven't actually, I don't think, told you any of the
00:10:22.320 jokes that Ward made, have I? I've only told you who Jeremy Gabriel is and how he was a kid who was disabled.
00:10:28.960 Are you curious about Ward's jokes? You think it's possible they were funny? I mean, is it possible?
00:10:36.100 I've heard some comedians tell jokes about the most atrocious subjects. Sarah Silverman, who's Jewish, 1.00
00:10:41.320 obviously, tells Holocaust jokes, tells rape jokes. I won't lie, I actually laugh at them. Is it okay 0.98
00:10:50.320 for her to tell a Holocaust joke because she's Jewish? Can she tell a rape joke because she's a 1.00
00:10:56.400 woman? Can I laugh at a Holocaust joke because I'm Jewish? If neither of those things were the case, 0.63
00:11:01.600 would it still be okay? Isn't laughing about things like that taking back some of the power from it in
00:11:06.660 some way? I don't know. Who gets to decide these things? A bunch of crusty old judges who probably
00:11:11.480 haven't been to a comedy club in 50 years. And by the way, do you really think that these judges
00:11:16.200 would have the power to stop you from actually listening to jokes on the internet in this era?
00:11:21.400 Other than punishing a comedian who has already been punished by nearly a decade in the court
00:11:26.040 system, what have they done? They perhaps scared more comedians from making politically incorrect
00:11:32.320 jokes, but I assure you that that's only above ground. I put it to you that underground jokes continue
00:11:38.220 as they will till the end of time, as humans continue to want to laugh at themselves,
00:11:42.080 at others, at the absurdities of life, and at power too, and occasionally at vulnerable people.
00:11:48.700 And maybe that's not funny, but you're not going to stop it. I tell you, it's not far from banning
00:11:53.100 jokes against a disabled boy to banning jokes against, oh, I don't know, a public health officer
00:11:58.580 like Teresa Tam or banning jokes against Justin Trudeau. Once you ban a joke, then all that remains
00:12:06.100 is which jokes are to be banned. And really, what's the difference amongst them? They're just jokes.
00:12:10.440 By the way, are you curious what Ward's jokes were? Do you want to hear what sent him all
00:12:16.780 the way to the Supreme Court? Do you want to hear the jokes that these judges weighed and
00:12:20.200 measured? You know the saying, analyzing a joke is like dissecting a frog, and at the
00:12:25.040 end of it, the frog is dead. But of course, you'll want to hear them. Of course you do.
00:12:29.120 And you can hear them, right? Because you're, you, I don't know about other people, but you
00:12:34.720 are a proper person, and you have the moral fiber to handle a bad joke without being corrupted
00:12:40.300 by it, right? That's what these judges say. They wanted to hear the jokes for themselves
00:12:46.080 to rule on them. They could handle it. Isn't that odd? They get to hear the jokes and judge
00:12:52.740 them, but you can't. At least that's what the Human Rights Commissioner and the Court
00:12:56.660 of Appeals said. They said that they were moral enough, they were strong enough, they were
00:13:00.560 righteous enough, they were uncorruptible, so they could hear bad jokes about a kid without
00:13:05.120 turning evil themselves. Just you aren't. They'll do the thinking for you. Well, hang
00:13:11.920 on, I'm a grown-up. This was grown-up comedy. There were no kids in those comedy clubs. What
00:13:18.120 can't we each decide for ourselves? So the Supreme Court ruling came out today, and as usual
00:13:23.340 with our Supreme Court, it's monstrously long. It's just awful, these multi-hundred-page rulings.
00:13:28.300 In this case, 136 pages, mercifully brief, as this court goes, and they ruled in favor
00:13:35.140 of Mike Ward. Not that they thought his jokes were funny, but that they thought that his
00:13:39.840 jokes were not illegal. That if the young man wanted to sue in defamation, for example,
00:13:44.400 he could have done so, but there wasn't a human right not to be offended. That's a counterfeit
00:13:48.820 human right. Five judges said that, but four judges said no. Ban the jokes. Punish the jokester.
00:13:56.480 That's how close things were today. A reminder of one of Stephen Harper's two great failures.
00:14:02.700 He could have totally remade the courts with truly conservative judges. He was prime minister
00:14:06.360 for nine years. He made half a dozen appointments. He didn't. That's what the left would have
00:14:11.400 done. Harper simply didn't. He appointed one truly conservative judge. And one of the censorship
00:14:16.820 judges today was actually one of Harper's appointees. The other Harper failure, if you want to know,
00:14:22.620 is that he just kept the CBC and actually increased his power. I'm going to read you some lines from
00:14:29.060 the four dissenting judges, because I want to show you what is an inch away from becoming the law in
00:14:34.460 Canada. And remember, three out of the four judges here are liberal. What happens when, because Aaron
00:14:40.500 O'Toole lost the election, Trudeau appoints another judge and another judge? So I'm not reading for you
00:14:47.560 the law as it is in its final moments with five judges for free speech. I'm going to read for you
00:14:53.180 from the dissenting four judges to show you what is coming.
00:14:57.720 It is a case about the rights of vulnerable and marginalized individuals, particularly children
00:15:02.140 with disabilities, to be free from public humiliation, cruelty, vilification, and bullying that singles them
00:15:08.720 out on the basis of their disability and the devastating harm to their dignity to results.
00:15:14.880 I agree that this was a child and that he was marginalized, but who else is marginalized? Well,
00:15:20.440 everyone these days. Everyone on the left says is marginalized. Women, minorities, sexual minorities,
00:15:26.260 immigrants, the disabled, the poor, Quebecers, Newfoundlanders, Aboriginal people, etc. It's probably
00:15:31.860 80% of people. So really, unless you're making jokes at the expense of white men, jokes are banned.
00:15:39.720 I wonder if that applies to Dave Chappelle. He had a very popular comedy show on Netflix the other day
00:15:45.880 that made fun of trans people and they objected. So who wins in that battle of political correctness?
00:15:51.840 A black comedian or a white trans activist? So far, the answer is actually green. He's just worth too 0.93
00:15:59.200 much to Netflix for them to cancel him. But does this mean you're not allowed to make fun of
00:16:03.640 marginalized people at all? Is that just a new rule now? No jokes? I'm not saying these jokes that
00:16:10.540 Mike Ward made are funny, but I'm not saying they're not. I'm saying, imagine four Supreme Court
00:16:15.220 judges saying they have the right to listen to a comedy routine and then determine whether or not
00:16:19.580 it's legal. Let me give you an example of one of the jokes. I wasn't going to tell you, but I'm going
00:16:24.920 to. Here's what Ward said. He said, I went online to see what his illness was. You know what's wrong
00:16:30.980 with him? He's ugly. Oh, okay. So you're going to ban that? Give the guy a huge fine? And if he
00:16:40.080 doesn't pay it, I don't know, maybe throw him in prison for contempt? Calling someone ugly. Woo! Oh, hot
00:16:44.900 stuff. Here's some more. Then after he sang for the Canadians, the hockey team, people complain again.
00:16:51.520 He sings badly. He's off key. He's no good. Christ, he's living out a dream. Let him live out his
00:16:57.840 dream. He sang for Celine Dion. Again with the, he really sucks. He's off key. He sings badly.
00:17:03.700 Christ, he's dying. Let him live out his dream. I defended him, except now five years later, he's
00:17:08.680 still not dead. Now that's sort of actually true. They thought he was going to die. He's very much
00:17:16.660 alive. I'm very glad to say that. That was sort of the joke part that Mike Ward was
00:17:21.500 saying, hey, stop picking on how bad his singing is about to die, but he didn't die. He said
00:17:26.020 some other things too, but four judges in Canada went through what I just read and said, that's
00:17:30.300 illegal. The four censorship judges acknowledge that Mike Ward was taken to task by many people
00:17:37.880 in Quebec society, including other media, including other comedians. The judges point
00:17:43.420 out that Mike Ward was in his own way vilified and marginalized because of his conduct. And one
00:17:50.000 interview that the judges repeat, Mike Ward himself admits there's a good point to it,
00:17:56.080 that he was bullying a kid. Not in person. He was just telling jokes about a celebrity
00:18:01.300 kid who was disabled. He sort of admits that it was lowbrow. But that was not enough for 0.99
00:18:06.800 these four judges. Him being taken to task publicly, him admitting maybe he went too far.
00:18:11.520 That's not enough for these judges. This kind of behavior is never tolerating in Barakwa. You
00:18:18.440 shout like that, they put you in jail right away. No trial, no nothing. Journalists, we
00:18:24.380 have a special jail for journalists. But look at this. The judges pointed out that Mike Ward
00:18:28.800 admitted he was a bit of a bully. But they say it doesn't matter that he admitted it. They
00:18:35.020 say it doesn't even matter if Ward intended to mock this kid or not. The only thing that
00:18:41.540 matters is if the kid felt mocked. The intention of the comedian has nothing to do with that.
00:18:48.320 Let me quote.
00:18:48.720 We see no reason to depart from this court's jurisprudence confirming that it is the
00:18:53.660 impact of the conduct that matters, not the intention. Rejecting the proposition that it
00:19:00.100 is acceptable to discriminate if it results from treating likes alike. And that freedom 0.76
00:19:05.040 of expression includes the right to discriminate. Mr. Ward's justifications that he did not
00:19:09.720 intend to discriminate, that he was treating Jeremy Gabriel like any other celebrity, and
00:19:14.400 that his artistic license as a comedian gave him a right to mock a disabled child have, as 0.95
00:19:18.660 a result, no basis in law. So Mike Ward said he was having fun, not discriminating, whatever
00:19:25.260 that means. He didn't, you know, kick anyone out of an apartment or fire from the job. He's
00:19:29.760 told jokes. And he did so because the kid was a celebrity, which is obviously true. So
00:19:37.960 what say the judges? Imagine how that would play out, say, against you. You told a joke.
00:19:44.340 You didn't mean to pick on anyone. You didn't mean to be bigoted or unwoke. But someone felt
00:19:49.600 that way. Again, not your intention. It's how someone felt. So you're guilty. Four out of
00:19:54.380 nine judges said so. I just read you their words. They say it again more clearly. I'll read
00:19:59.300 it again. At this stage of the analysis, it is immaterial whether Mr. Ward intended to
00:20:05.420 mock Mr. Gabriel because he has a disability, whether Mr. Ward was joking or being serious,
00:20:11.000 or whether Mr. Gabriel was skewered in the same way as other celebrities. The issue is not
00:20:16.000 Mr. Ward's stated intention not to discriminate against Mr. Gabriel. The issue is the impact
00:20:22.260 of Mr. Ward's comments on this child with a disability. Do you get it? Now, Mike Ward pretty
00:20:28.320 much admitted to everything here, other than he said he chose the kid because he was famous,
00:20:32.440 which is obviously true. It's inconceivable that he would have singled out some private
00:20:36.940 person with a disability. All his jokes were about, you know, the kid singing to the Pope
00:20:42.180 and singing to Celine Dion and being off key. But the court says whether Ward was making jokes
00:20:47.100 or not, whether they were serious or not, whether he meant to be mean or not, what he said was
00:20:52.860 illegal. Nothing matters about what he did other than the kid's feelings were hurt. I read it to
00:20:58.540 you two different versions now. You can't call a kid ugly. You can't say a kid sang out of tune.
00:21:03.980 You can't if the person is marginalized. Even if you don't intend to be hurtful, you're guilty. By the
00:21:09.500 way, I look forward to these same judges of the Supreme Court being this dainty and hypersensitive with
00:21:16.200 something, oh, just a wee bit more hurtful than a joke being told at a comedy club. How about treating
00:21:21.820 someone, I'll use the language, who is marginalized for health reasons, for medical reasons, or
00:21:27.240 religious reasons, and, oh, I don't know, can't take a vaccine, and is fired from their job
00:21:32.020 intentionally, on purpose, with real direct harm, real discrimination, not just jokes.
00:21:39.300 Will these judges be as generous to those people? Or are the marginalized just whoever the judges
00:21:47.420 happen to agree with? Here's another quote from the dissenting four judges.
00:21:52.840 In this case, Mr. Ward's message about Mr. Gabriel, albeit one said in jest, was that he was
00:21:58.700 disposable, and that society would be better off without him. Unlike other sacred cows targeted
00:22:04.580 by Mr. Ward, Jeremy Gabriel fell victim to a stark power imbalance here. The focus of the jokes was not
00:22:10.980 only on Mr. Gabriel's disability, but on, but was connected to harmful, dehumanizing notions associated
00:22:17.020 with the worth of children with disabilities. This is quite something coming from a court that is
00:22:22.520 completely in favor of assisted suicide, eugenics, and abortion. I'm delighted they've suddenly found 1.00
00:22:28.420 their humanity and don't believe in marginalizing the weak. But you'll notice that the words they use
00:22:33.960 is not actually what Mike Ward said, which is important. The judges had to rephrase his joke
00:22:39.540 in order to make their point. And they're saying that a comedian was powerful, as opposed to a child
00:22:45.600 singer. I don't know, that could be. And the jokes here were dehumanizing. All right, could be.
00:22:52.000 It's a matter of opinion. But can we apply that new leftist rule to, I don't know, a cisgender, 0.87
00:22:59.180 privileged, white male settler, millionaire, son of privilege, denormalizing and dehumanizing
00:23:05.640 vulnerable people with disabilities. Yeah, by that, I mean, Justin Trudeau talking about the
00:23:10.400 unvaccinated. They are putting at risk their own kids and they're putting at risk. Our kids as well 0.92
00:23:19.040 are putting us all at risk. Those people are putting us all at risk. Yeah, no, something tells me that
00:23:25.960 these judges don't plan on taking on the truly powerful and their dehumanizing of the marginalized.
00:23:32.040 Just comedians who make jokes they don't like. They're the minority today, these four judges,
00:23:37.560 but don't expect that to last long. Stay with us for more.
00:23:55.960 Welcome back. Well, one of my favorite guys is Dave Rubin. He's the host of The Rubin Report. I first
00:24:03.040 came across him when he was touring with Dr. Jordan Peterson, sort of like a warm-up act.
00:24:09.660 And I thought, well, that's my kind of guy. And he's not just a content creator, as they say,
00:24:15.420 he's a bit of an entrepreneur. And he founded a free speech-oriented social media site called
00:24:23.500 Locals. And it really caught on not only with people who are free speech-oriented,
00:24:29.420 but for people who want to control of their data. What I mean by that is we have 1.5 million
00:24:34.820 subscribers on YouTube, but we don't know who they are. YouTube won't tell us. And so YouTube can
00:24:41.700 break the bonds between us and our subscribers, and there's nothing we can do about it. Locals 0.99
00:24:47.060 actually connected content creators and their users. Well, the big news this week
00:24:54.560 is that Locals is merging with Rumble.com. And for those of you who watch our show, you know what
00:25:02.460 that means. They are a video rival to YouTube with a free speech orientation. Full disclosure,
00:25:09.860 I have a teeny tiny sliver of a share of Rumble. I couldn't believe this good news. And I thought,
00:25:15.100 well, let's get Dave on the line and find out what it means in terms of defying the tech giants,
00:25:21.460 free speech, and other good things. And joining us now via Skype from LA is our friend Dave Rubin. Dave,
00:25:27.420 great to see you. Normally, you're interviewing me about the civil liberties crisis in Canada. But
00:25:32.100 today, you've got some good news about a civil liberties solution, I think.
00:25:38.060 Yeah, well, first off, Ezra, I did not know that you had a teeny tiny sliver in Rumble. And now I'm
00:25:43.960 very happy to report that hopefully, if this thing goes as I plan it will, you're going to be doing
00:25:49.940 all right one of these days. That's the plan, Ezra Levant. Well, tell our viewers a little bit more
00:25:56.020 about the thinking that went into Locals. And sure. And why it's I mean, when I heard it, I thought,
00:26:03.960 oh, my God, that is a perfect fit. But I'd like to hear it through your words, because I don't know
00:26:08.940 if I understand it completely. Go ahead. Sure. Well, your intro was quite good, actually,
00:26:13.680 because bringing up your 1.5 million subscribers on YouTube, and that it's not only that you don't
00:26:18.460 know who they are, you have no ability to get a message out to those people. So you know, when we
00:26:22.880 all got on YouTube, everyone thought, oh, if someone subscribes to your channel, and they tap
00:26:27.720 that notification bell, the implication is that you're going to see those videos, that creator's
00:26:33.900 videos in your feed. That's what we all thought. I think that's what most people actually think to
00:26:38.340 this day. Well, that's just not how it works. We know that through algorithmic tricks, and for
00:26:43.800 whatever reason, I'm not even implying that they're all nefarious. YouTube does not send out all of
00:26:49.440 your videos to your subscribers. We know that often, if they don't like your political opinion,
00:26:54.500 they can actually put recommended videos that could completely sway your opinion or send you down
00:27:00.240 some other rabbit hole. As I always say, when it comes to big tech, it's not the things that we know
00:27:05.060 that I'm worried about that we know they're doing to us. It's the things that we don't know.
00:27:08.340 So a couple of years ago, it was actually just less than three years ago, I sort of had the idea
00:27:13.000 that, well, if I was going to be truly independent, really independent from these platforms, what would
00:27:18.560 I need? And I would need, A, I would need a subscription service. So, you know, I would need
00:27:23.000 my audience to be able to fund my program. So I would be free of outside influence in terms of the
00:27:28.480 political and cultural things that I was talking about. So we built a subscription model. Then we
00:27:33.300 thought, all right, well, we need a great video player. Let's build that. We need a great audio
00:27:36.680 player. Let's build that. Let's make sure that I have direct communication with my audience. So we
00:27:41.160 have, at first we started with live text chat, but now we have live video streaming from your phone
00:27:46.140 or your desktop. Then we thought, well, we want to make sure that you as the creator own the user
00:27:50.860 data so that if someone subscribes to me and let's say I get kicked off YouTube, I have a way of
00:27:55.220 communicating with them. So we have great push notifications that go out to people so that
00:27:59.460 you may remember, Ezra, at the end of July, I was kicked off Twitter for saying that vaccine
00:28:05.420 mandates were coming. Well, I wasn't completely incapacitated because I was still able to
00:28:10.840 communicate with my locals community. So I was live streaming a minute later, able to get my
00:28:16.680 message out to people. Then they could share it on their social media channels. And then we got
00:28:21.300 there to be enough public pressure that Twitter not only brought me back, but they said it was an
00:28:25.480 error that I was banned in the first place. So I think we had most of the pieces lined up properly
00:28:32.060 for a partnership like we're now doing with Rumble to come into place. And I'll add one other thing,
00:28:37.260 which you described Rumble as a sort of a YouTube alternative video site. It's actually much more
00:28:42.200 than that. What they have done there, and Chris, who's the CEO of Rumble, who's a great guy and he's
00:28:46.080 been working on this for over a decade, they have truly built infrastructure. I mean, servers and all of
00:28:54.000 the infrastructure needed to host all sorts of websites. So the big one, of course, was when
00:29:01.160 Parler got blown up after January 6th, Amazon just pulled the plug. And that's no way to run a
00:29:07.900 business, knowing that the people that you're renting space from, so to speak, can just take
00:29:11.980 you out at any moment. So Rumble has not only a great video service that we're working on fixing
00:29:16.980 some of the interface and all that kind of stuff, but they really have the underbelly of the internet
00:29:21.600 stuff to make sure that big tech can't just blow up the Rebels website or my website or anyone else.
00:29:27.500 So I think this is a really important week in the fight back against big tech.
00:29:32.820 I'm really glad to hear that. And, you know, I like Rumble in that they're taking steps not just to be
00:29:40.220 our, quote, right-wing alternative. They've signed up quality programmers like Glenn Greenwald,
00:29:47.600 who's an iconic man of the free speech left, Tulsi Gabbard, the Hawaiian Democrat who ran for
00:29:54.860 president. These are not right-wing voices, but they're voices that believe in free speech.
00:30:00.200 I'm really excited about that. Tell me what it means that locals and Rumble are merging or
00:30:08.500 acquiring. I don't know what the term is, but what will it mean for people on either system?
00:30:14.140 What will it mean for folks who follow videos on Rumble now? What will it mean for folks who
00:30:18.780 use locals right now? Yeah, great. So in essence, it's a merger acquisition. So I have sold
00:30:25.060 the company locals to Rumble, so they fully own it. I do not own locals anymore. However, myself and my
00:30:32.760 partner Asaf, who really was the brainchild behind this and the architect, we're staying on as part of
00:30:38.680 the team so that I'll be doing this sort of thing, public talking about our ideas and our policies and
00:30:44.760 things of that nature, PR in essence, and helping guide some of the policy. Asaf will continue to
00:30:50.120 run local. So you can think of it sort of how, although this sounds a bit nefarious, I suppose,
00:30:54.900 how Facebook owns Instagram, but they're still separate brands and separate companies,
00:30:58.640 but they obviously share infrastructure, human resources, things like that. So Rumble,
00:31:03.940 which is really well funded, it now adds a tremendous amount of resources for us. But in
00:31:08.220 terms of the user side of things, well, locals will be the official subscription provider for all
00:31:15.420 Rumble creators. So if you're a Rumble creator, yeah. So that's huge because that allows us to
00:31:22.700 scale, right? That's the key piece for us in this is how do we scale, not just bring on a few creators
00:31:28.740 every day, or if I know somebody, bring them on board. This is, if you are a Rumble creator,
00:31:33.760 you will be officially connected to locals so that that can be the real financial engine for your show.
00:31:41.320 You know, then we have a lot of other things that we're sort of putting the pieces together with
00:31:45.120 right now. So for example, when I do my show, which now we live stream every day on Rumble,
00:31:49.900 right now, I allow for chat in my locals community. So there's no bots, there's no trolls,
00:31:56.340 there's no angry people. This is good, enlightened, interesting, honest discussion
00:32:00.240 that happens during my live stream. We're going to start bringing that on board the Rumble platform
00:32:05.180 as well. So it'll be your paid subscribers who will be chatting. So not only is that an engine
00:32:09.800 of revenue for a creator like you guys, but it also allows us to have a much more decent
00:32:15.560 conversation online. You know, one of the reasons that the online conversation sounds so terrible is
00:32:20.740 because people have 20 burner Twitter accounts to harass people all day long. I'm not saying they
00:32:25.740 can't have it, but we want to create something better. So you're going to see a lot of ways
00:32:31.220 that we tie these bonds. And you know, the other part, Ezra, and you know this, is that in 20 years
00:32:36.540 of, you know, 20 years ago, it was MySpace or just the beginnings of MySpace, the beginnings of
00:32:40.800 social media. We didn't know what we were all signing up for. We had no idea. You're friends with
00:32:45.360 your grandma on there. Next thing you know, you see a picture of Trump and a terrorist attack and a
00:32:49.400 baby and you're having crazy emotions. None of it makes sense. Why is your grandmother
00:32:54.340 and your, you know, friend that you just reconnected with from fifth grade? Why are
00:32:58.620 they on the same page arguing about politics? It doesn't make sense. But now it's 20 years
00:33:02.860 later and we can assess that and say, well, what would a better internet look like? What
00:33:09.140 would a better social media ecosystem look like? So look, we're going to build communities,
00:33:13.340 but we're also going to build the underbelly of the internet. This is going to come along
00:33:16.340 with payment processors and a whole bunch more. I can't say everything.
00:33:19.500 Dave, what you just said there at the end is so important because of course you can find
00:33:24.900 a replacement video server. Like we were suspended for a week from YouTube and it really shook us to
00:33:30.420 the core. We thought, okay, we're back on YouTube, but we'd better find plan B, C and D. And when
00:33:36.220 PayPal gave us the boot on a Friday night at 6 PM Eastern in an unsigned email, no explanation,
00:33:43.880 no warning, no appeal. I thought, oh my God, that is the next step of de-platforming and we need plan B,
00:33:51.340 C and D there. If you guys at Rural and locals can find a payment solution, because that's the scary
00:33:58.980 part. When they ban people from even having the ability to earn a living, that kind of deep
00:34:05.280 platforming is so horrific in terms of the wreckage it can do to ordinary people. That's the most
00:34:14.220 interesting thing you said here. I'm excited about it. Well, I'm glad you're excited. I remember when
00:34:19.300 that happened to you guys and 100% crystal clear, we are working on it. There will be solutions. We
00:34:25.440 should not be beholden only to PayPal, Stripe, and a couple banks because, you know, the next level of
00:34:31.700 this, Ezra, of course, is not just that, say, PayPal is going to say, oh, Rebel News is too scary
00:34:37.540 for us. It's that they're going to say, oh, the viewers of Rebel News are too scary or the viewers
00:34:43.000 of the Reuben of Purchase is scary. And then should they have access to a Stripe account where they can
00:34:47.480 share these videos, right? Like, are they going to do that? So we really, that's why I keep saying
00:34:52.800 this idea of we have to build a parallel ecosystem. Let them have all of their things. I am not here
00:34:59.740 to destroy YouTube or Stripe or anything else. What I would like to do is leverage their audiences
00:35:04.580 to build a better product, and that's exactly what we're going to do. So, yes, payment processors,
00:35:11.060 video hosting, community building. How do we get around the iOS and Android store, the Google Play
00:35:18.140 store? I mean, there's all sorts of things. But I think for the first time in a long time,
00:35:23.580 we had a good week, those of us that are fighting this stuff, because this is just the beginning.
00:35:27.720 Dave, you know what? I'm so, I mean, I was happy when I saw this news, but hearing, you've obviously
00:35:34.680 been thinking about this for a long time, and we like the guys at Rumble, and for you guys to team
00:35:39.160 up is really great. My one piece of advice is make sure you have foreign currencies for the payment
00:35:44.860 processor, because obviously you're in America. We're up here in Canada. There's people all across
00:35:51.280 the Anglosphere, UK, Australia, but even all around the world. I mean, whether it's in Brazil or France,
00:35:58.740 where, you know, Facebook deleted 40,000 accounts on the eve of the French election, or Germany, which
00:36:04.380 is one of the most censored places in the free world. I know that a lot of people in a lot of different
00:36:10.200 languages and currencies, boy, the sky's the limit. If you have an alternative, anti-fragile,
00:36:18.240 you know, resilient system. I am very excited. Dave, I wish you good luck. Couldn't happen to a
00:36:25.120 better guy. Congrats. I remember when you started Locals. I was thrilled by it, and I'm grateful for
00:36:30.020 you popping by today. I know how busy you are, so thanks for the personal update. Ezra, I thank you
00:36:36.040 for the kind words. You know, we're all in this fight together, and we've all found allies in places
00:36:40.800 we didn't think we were going to find allies, and I don't know that they'll let me in Canada
00:36:44.960 anytime soon. But if they will let you into America, I look forward to breaking bread with 0.64
00:36:49.380 you one of these days. Well, thank you. Hopefully, I'm not coming there as a refugee. We got a few 1.00
00:36:54.040 more fights up here. In fact, I might try and conscript you into that. Ezra, if you come in
00:36:59.440 as a refugee, don't come in through Canada, because we don't give you anything. But if you come in 1.00
00:37:02.720 through Mexico, apparently, we're going to give you 450 grand on your way in. So get down there first.
00:37:07.320 Yeah, that's my retirement plan. I forgot to tell you. All right. Well, Dave, it's great to catch up
00:37:11.060 with you. There he is, everybody. Dave Rubin, the boss of Rubin Report, the founder of Locals.
00:37:15.760 And the big news is, of course, they're merging with Rumble.com, the free speech alternative
00:37:19.740 in video. Stay with us. More ahead.
00:37:34.440 Hey, welcome back. Your feedback. Carol Bergman writes,
00:37:36.780 Mr. O'Toole is from now to be known as Mr. O'Fool. I will never vote conservative again.
00:37:43.440 I mean, what is the point of him? I'm not even kidding when I say he really could be a Trudeau
00:37:49.580 cabinet minister. The difference between him and Trudeau is microscopic. I don't even think you
00:37:55.760 could slide a sheet of paper between him and Trudeau. They're so close. Barbara Baxter says,
00:38:00.940 not sure I'd want to be treated by those who don't mind working under Premier Horgan's yoke.
00:38:05.460 You're talking about the decision in BC to sack 4,000 nurses and doctors. I mean,
00:38:10.180 don't you want ethical people who will stand on a point of courage or principle? Like you're
00:38:15.680 seriously weeding out. I mean, you're weeding out some people who have a religious objection.
00:38:20.800 You're weeding out some people with a medical objection. But in every case, you're really
00:38:24.840 weeding out people who say, I'm going to take a stand on principle at great personal cost.
00:38:29.060 aren't those actually the best people? I, I, all I can think of was Jody Wilson-Raybould though,
00:38:35.300 the one ethical cabinet minister in Trudeau's cabinet. So the one he had to throw out and
00:38:41.340 Jane Philpott left too, cause she felt the same way. Aren't we doing that on mass? Like
00:38:46.600 in every institution, aren't they throwing away? Even if you're vaxxed, even if you believe in 0.65
00:38:50.520 vaxxed, you're throwing out people who on principle say, I'm not going to be forced.
00:38:56.120 What are you doing? Someone with a nickname, a noodle Mac says, Saskatoon city council passing
00:39:02.140 a bylaw to restrict gatherings, unvaxxed, not allowed in other homes. Yeah. I mean, it's out of
00:39:09.060 control. I don't know how they'll possibly enforce that, but listen, I've seen nothing stopping any
00:39:16.120 police in any place in the world. Like really tell me a judge who stopped anything in a meaningful
00:39:21.400 way. Well, that's the show for today until Monday, on behalf of all of us here from rebel world
00:39:27.120 headquarters to you at home, good night and keep fighting for freedom. And let me leave you with
00:39:32.220 our video of the day from Drea Humphrey, who went to a hundred mile house to speak to some nurses
00:39:37.720 about this very subject. Goodbye. Well, I am pretty much terminated. So I've been off on unpaid leave
00:39:47.780 since the 12th of this month. And on the 26th, I will be terminated. I have opted to hold off with
00:39:57.200 getting the vaccine. I'm just not happy with the information that I've not been given. And I'm not
00:40:05.240 comfortable with the fact that I don't get to actually consent or refuse. Absolutely.
00:40:12.600 Myself during this whole thing, I, um, have a daughter that lives in the UK and my forethought
00:40:19.380 is I'm going to wait. Yes. I want to travel and see my daughter and everything else, but I'm going
00:40:24.560 to wait. I want to see what's going to happen, where we're going with this. What, um, if there's
00:40:33.020 any adverse reactions, what are they going to be? Uh, for myself, I have opted out. I have done my
00:40:40.140 research. Um, I believe in medical freedoms. I believe in the rights of and freedoms of all
00:40:46.700 Canadians to choose for themselves as they know best for themselves. Uh, a stranger should not be
00:40:52.260 choosing how care should be done for you and put potentially putting at you at risk, not knowing
00:40:57.340 what your circumstances are.
00:41:02.460 Drea Humphrey here with Rebel News. I'm sitting here with Colleen, Laura and Teresa, all frontline
00:41:08.620 workers. Uh, just let us know what, what you guys do. I'm a trained healthcare professional. I am a
00:41:16.140 healthcare professional acute care, a hundred mile hospital. I'm a long-term care aide for 16 years.
00:41:21.500 Right. And so, unless you've been living under a rock, depending on your lady's vaccination status,
00:41:28.860 or whether or not you were comfortable disclosing that you guys are either terminated laid off without
00:41:35.260 paid pay or about to experience that at the time of this report. So let us know where you are with that
00:41:42.460 right now. Well, I am pretty much terminated. So, uh, I've been off on long-term or sorry, I'm unpaid
00:41:51.980 leave since the 12th of this month. And, uh, on the 26th, I will be terminated. And how many years were
00:42:00.620 you working in the field? 18 years. And what about the hospital? You guys are all at the same hospital.
00:42:05.980 This is a fairly smaller area. And site. And site. Yeah. And so how many years were you there?
00:42:12.060 I've been here for, um, pretty much the 18 years. I did a little bit of traveling, uh,
00:42:17.980 down in the Kootenai region. I worked there for a brief period of time, but ultimately this is my
00:42:23.420 location. Wow. And how about yourself? How long have you been doing your job and specifically in this
00:42:29.500 area? Um, I've been doing in the healthcare field for 18 years. Um, I moved up to a hundred mile house
00:42:36.940 five years ago and I've been here for five years, over five years now. And same question for you.
00:42:42.300 I've been doing, uh, curating for 16 years. I've worked complex care, multi-level, uh,
00:42:47.980 extended care and hospice and brain injury for 16 years. And I've been in a hundred mile for 10 years,
00:42:54.620 10 years. Yeah. Wow. Now who can speak to you if anybody can get guests about the estimation on the
00:43:02.620 size of the population that you guys care for? Like I'm assuming based on this, you guys are the primary
00:43:09.100 hospital to treat it. People, you know, need care. We are a rural community. Um, we have,
00:43:18.380 we have a community that is larger than ours, uh, north of us. That would be Williams Lake. And then
00:43:24.060 of course the primary tertiary center is Kamloops. And then of course, Kelowna, we probably service
00:43:31.900 approximately plus or minus a total area of about 18,000 people. And so when we talk about the
00:43:41.180 vaccine, are you guys comfortable giving your vaccination status right now or? Yes. Yes. And
00:43:47.020 so, so what is it? And, um, if you're comfortable sharing, I'm assuming that it's, well, I have opted
00:43:55.340 to hold off with getting the vaccine. I'm just not happy with the information that I've not been given
00:44:03.980 and I'm not comfortable with the fact that I don't get to actually consent or refuse.
00:44:10.300 Absolutely. Myself during this whole thing, I, um, have a daughter that lives in the UK and my
00:44:18.700 forethought is I'm going to wait. Yes. I want to travel and see my daughter and everything else,
00:44:23.980 but I'm going to wait. I want to see what's going to happen, where we're going with this. What, um,
00:44:32.380 if there's any adverse reactions, what are they going to be?
00:44:35.020 Uh, for myself, I have opted out. I have done my research. Um, I believe in medical freedoms. I
00:44:43.580 believe in the rights and freedoms of all Canadians to choose for themselves as they know best for
00:44:49.980 themselves. Uh, a stranger should not be choosing how care should be done for you and potentially
00:44:55.660 putting you at risk, not knowing what your circumstances are. I think that it's, um, on the
00:45:01.740 one hand, it, it kind of made sense. I'm not saying the mandates made sense at all,
00:45:06.220 but that they pick sort of the acute care and long-term to start this. Um, but it should have
00:45:12.700 been surprising to most of the people, how many, um, across Canada in your industry were not ready to
00:45:19.660 get the vaccination. So what do you say to people who, um, kind of think maybe you guys are sort of
00:45:24.540 villains or something for not just jabbing and doing it, uh, doing your part?
00:45:31.020 I would say it's called, um, critical thinking. We were educated to critically think.
00:45:38.940 Um, it's called ethics on doing your research, asking your questions, knowing
00:45:46.220 uh, your demographics and that, and, um, just looking at it and seeing what's out there. And
00:45:55.100 you know what, I mean, the peer reviews are not being seen right now. And that is the biggest thing
00:46:01.500 is that they are being silenced. Um, Brown Institute, um, has peer reviews of this. Um,
00:46:09.900 um, you know, and that is the biggest thing is looking at your peer reviews and being open-minded.
00:46:17.180 And I just want people to know that yes, people say, oh, it's been around for years or
00:46:26.620 all that other thing. But the thing is though, is that it was still in the emergency use.
00:46:32.540 It was, that's all it was. They haven't finished the trials. They haven't finished the clinical trials.
00:46:40.540 It's ongoing. And even they'll say that it's, it's, they don't know the long-term effect.
00:46:47.500 They're going to try and, and put it, this onto children, children that they haven't even tried it
00:46:53.820 on at all. There has been no clinical trials and outcomes for children.
00:46:59.980 Well, we've seen that I believe it's Denmark and Sweden when it comes to Moderna has, uh,
00:47:06.300 at the moment held off on giving it to young people. Pfizer read on its fact sheet from the FDA
00:47:13.740 says that, uh, you know, that trials are still on and you might have severe reactions. So it's kind
00:47:19.900 of concerning that we're giving this to children. What about the reactions in your experience? Are you
00:47:26.700 coming across those, how are they being deal dealt with and how are they being tracked?
00:47:32.620 I'm from my personal story. Yeah. And like I said, um, my daughter lives in the UK. She chose to get 0.95
00:47:40.860 the vaccine. So this is when all the restrictions were down that you couldn't travel, you couldn't
00:47:47.020 go anywhere. There was lockdowns. So your daughter faced or messaged you and talks to you and says,
00:47:54.460 mom, I'm not feeling good. I'm tired. Um, my heart's pounding. Sometimes I get short of breath.
00:48:01.180 All I want to do is sleep. This is after the first vaccine. So I'm thinking, here's a 26 year old girl,
00:48:09.020 my own daughter phoning me and saying, what do I do? I'm not feeling good. And this is about three
00:48:16.940 weeks after the vaccine. And, uh, I kept telling her go to the hospital, go to the hospital. But
00:48:23.260 the UK system is much different than ours. And finally, after two days, like, I mean, she ended up
00:48:28.940 having rashes and that, and she ended up going to a hospital and they just kind of just swept it under
00:48:36.060 the carpet and that. And, um, how do you think a mother feels with her daughter on a 12 hour flight
00:48:44.700 away? There is nothing you can do. And you tried to educate her to not get it, but she wants to travel.
00:48:52.540 She's young. She has faith in the people that are telling, giving you this information. She has faith
00:48:59.020 in the scientists that are pushing this. And, um, we've seen, you know, the lies come out
00:49:07.580 and people being exposed and, um, scientists, the healthcare professionals that are on TV.
00:49:14.940 Um, and she, you know what, there's millions and millions and billions of people that are trusting
00:49:21.180 these people. And for me, it's all about being very, very straightforward. These are the facts.
00:49:30.940 And, um, that's what it has to come down to is facts and truth.
00:49:37.020 So tell us a little bit about what this means to be laid off without pay or terminated for you guys.
00:49:44.300 How is that going to affect your livelihood? Well, um, no money is a big deal. Uh,
00:49:52.700 it is problematic. Yeah. Uh, we, we have been told that once we are terminated, there will be no
00:50:01.420 severance. There is talk about, uh, being denied the ability to collect any form of EI. Um,
00:50:10.060 we may, there, there's threats of losing our pension. There's threats of losing our licenses.
00:50:18.540 Um, we don't know if these are all factual. There's just lots of talk. Um, and then just being able to
00:50:25.820 figure out, okay, what else are we going to do? You know? So, so the uncertainty of not really knowing
00:50:32.220 where to go from here because our careers, I mean, we pretty much a good chunk of our life,
00:50:38.460 we have, we've cared for people. That's what we love to do. That's why we're, you know,
00:50:44.300 that's why we're doing this. This is not an easy decision. Um, it is very hard because we are giving
00:50:50.460 up a lot and, um, it just seems that people aren't really understanding that. Uh, I think that they feel
00:51:00.460 that we're quite evil and we're horrible people when in fact, we're the very opposite. We love what
00:51:06.940 we're doing and we love our patients. We love the people we work with and, um, it's, it's heartbreaking
00:51:13.580 to us. And so, so that part is, um, is a big loss. This is a huge, huge sacrifice we're making.
00:51:22.780 Absolutely. Does anybody else want to talk about that? Yeah. Like for me, I believe that our rights
00:51:27.340 have been violated right across the board. Um, you know, our livelihoods are being destroyed. It's
00:51:32.700 discriminative. Um, we're being singled out. Um, we're not being treated with the same privileges
00:51:39.340 over an experimental vaccine that potentially is looking like it's quite harmful to many people.
00:51:44.860 I have a couple of friends and family who've had injuries from these, um, shots and I don't
00:51:50.300 like calling it a vaccine because it's actually an MRNA gene therapy drug and it is not proven to be
00:51:56.380 effective. Um, yeah, I just, I don't know. I just, I can't, I just can't wrap my head around how
00:52:04.620 somebody would take something experimental and how the government wouldn't offer, you know,
00:52:09.020 the short-term and the long-term effects on the data. Um, they haven't been open and, uh, you know,
00:52:16.300 honest and factual about, you know, their findings. In fact, they didn't even have a proper reporting
00:52:20.460 center set up. A lot of doctors aren't even aware of where to report these. And, and often, um, they
00:52:26.460 will be, um, diagnosed by their symptoms and not related to the adverse reaction of a shot.
00:52:35.020 And rashes have been very common. Um, some of my friends and family had, uh, swollen lymph nodes
00:52:41.580 for several weeks after very painful, very tired, not feeling good, short of oxygen. Um, just not
00:52:48.300 feeling well at all, feeling sick and not knowing what's wrong with them. Uh, no, that's it. Yeah.
00:52:54.940 Yeah. And then it becomes an assessment of risks versus cons. I mean, the younger you get and the
00:52:59.980 healthier you get and things like that, because I hear that all the time, like, oh, for a week,
00:53:04.220 I was so sick and it, you know, they're like 20 years old and that's from the shot. What would it
00:53:09.100 have been like to have COVID? Right. Um, so what about overwhelmed hospitals? So it's just
00:53:16.060 flabbergasting to me that the whole thing, almost the last 18 months, let's not overwhelm the
00:53:21.500 hospitals. Let's not overwhelm the hospitals. And here we are in one room with three of you being
00:53:27.180 let go from the hospitals. Can you, any of you speak to what overwhelmed hospitals was like prior to
00:53:35.180 COVID-19 versus during COVID-19 and versus more recently? We had difficulty, um, maintaining baseline
00:53:44.620 in residential, um, due to the fact that there wasn't enough staff. It's a hard job. The demands
00:53:50.300 were much higher. It became more complex. Um, dementia is on the rise. And unfortunately,
00:53:56.140 we were always told it wasn't in the budget to be able to hire more staff to take care of them.
00:54:00.380 So we were run off our feet literally, and there wasn't any room for, um, you know, people calling in
00:54:07.180 sick or, you know, having some time off. It was mentally and physically draining for everybody.
00:54:11.980 Everybody was very, very, very tired mentally, emotionally, physically, you know? Um, and I
00:54:17.900 think it hardens you after a while because you're looking after so many people and it then becomes a
00:54:24.060 matter of, you know, feeling like you're on a production line because you don't have the time
00:54:27.980 to look after anybody anymore. And I, and I hate to even say that, but we were forced into that to be
00:54:34.140 able to look after everybody. Right. And when you think of that, if it was this big bad pandemic,
00:54:41.500 it seemed like they needed to bring more people in so that you guys were working with less people
00:54:46.860 and not as tired and things like that. But here we are seeing the opposite happen. Um,
00:54:52.700 so I guess my question is, is what do you guys think of the healthcare system overall? I know you
00:54:57.740 you can't necessarily speak too specific to, to your hospital right now, but just healthcare in
00:55:03.340 general, how are we going to manage an earthquake or something like that? If COVID is so highly
00:55:09.900 survivable and we're in our fourth wave to the point that we have to actually can people who have
00:55:16.620 the skills to care for people in a rural area, what has the government, in your opinion, how have
00:55:22.940 they failed to actually set people up for a more significant disaster?
00:55:29.420 There's no way we would be able to sustain any type of disaster. I don't think most communities
00:55:34.620 would be prepared for such a thing. British Columbia has been shortstopped right across the board
00:55:40.940 in every, every department. You know, I mean, it's a tough job. Yeah, it's a tough job.
00:55:47.820 Now I see you've got papers in front of you. You've got the order in front of you,
00:55:52.540 the order of the provincial health officer for hospital and community healthcare and other
00:55:58.460 services, COVID-19 vaccination status information. What did you want to touch on about this order?
00:56:06.060 My biggest thing is, is, um, you know, section G, it says vaccines would prevent or reduce the risk
00:56:13.260 of infection with SARS-CoV-2 have been continually available to residents of the province.
00:56:20.940 Yes, they are available, but do they prevent it? Do they prevent you from getting COVID? No.
00:56:30.860 Especially with the Delta, right?
00:56:32.220 Yeah. They don't prevent you from transmitting it. They don't do any of that. It, it,
00:56:37.500 I'm not an anti-vaxxer. I am fully vaccinated. I am a fully vaccinated healthcare professional.
00:56:45.820 Um, you know, we give our vaccination status as per, you know, our heps, our MMR, our diphtheria,
00:56:56.300 our mumps, measles. I mean, I'm fully vaccinated. I really am. But to say that this and to falsely,
00:57:04.220 and this is my biggest thing is a false narrative that the provincial government and Bonnie Henry
00:57:11.580 is saying to our public on the media, and I'm going to say this. And when I think of the media in general,
00:57:25.020 I'm going to go with the fourth estate. And that just, you know, I mean, the media has been bought
00:57:33.180 off. Um, the large media corporations, I don't watch the news anymore. I don't watch TV anymore.
00:57:40.220 Um, they are dictated to on what to say from the governments. How many million did the federal
00:57:49.660 government give to the media? I don't know. Billions. It was billions. I think it was 6 billion.
00:57:54.380 Yeah. So then, and I mean, this is before an election. And then also, then you have
00:57:59.820 Mr. Trudeau saying, and that's used very loosely, um, that, you know, he's going to give
00:58:07.180 a billion dollars to the provinces that mandate these passports. I'm a healthcare professional.
00:58:16.540 I love my job. I'm good at it. Um, I want to see good healthcare. I want to see honest healthcare.
00:58:25.340 I want to see healthcare that every person, no matter who they are and where they're from in this
00:58:31.340 province deserves good healthcare, honest healthcare, honest politicians that are supposed to be
00:58:40.300 protecting our elderly, our first nations, our children.
00:58:47.020 We, and the citizens of British Columbia deserve that a hundred percent. We deserve transparency from
00:58:57.500 the government and that's what we're not getting. And we're not anti-vaxxers. We're pro care,
00:59:06.780 but we're also pro science on peer reviews because there are out there and they're just being covered
00:59:14.620 up. And so what about treatment too? I mean, there's so much going out there. Oh my gosh,
00:59:20.060 don't take a horse paste and all of this stuff. Um, but it's definitely something we've dropped the
00:59:26.380 ball on. Am I right? Does anybody want to talk about that? Yeah. I mean, I, it says here, you know,
00:59:31.980 that, um, there's no other measures that are effective for SARS-CoV. Um, but you know what,
00:59:40.300 we've become a healthcare system that treats the sick. We're not, um, being very preventative
00:59:48.620 and the prevention has been said time and time again of, you know, vitamin D, vitamin C, zinc,
00:59:56.220 magnesium. Um, you know, I mean, there's multiple things that we could be taken. I mean,
01:00:02.540 we get outside, we get the fresh air, we get our exercise. You know what? We're not perfect.
01:00:07.580 Eat healthy. Yeah. We're cut down on the fast food. But the thing is though, is that,
01:00:11.580 you know what the mandates have done? You don't need a, you don't need a health passport to get
01:00:16.620 in a fast food place, but to sit down and have an honest, good dinner, you need a health passport.
01:00:22.620 How does that go for preventing and dealing with the wellness of our province, of our country?
01:00:32.140 It's a class system. Part of the thing that, um, part of the thing that bothers me too is,
01:00:38.860 is a simple fact that when we were going through our training to become healthcare professionals,
01:00:46.540 um, we were taught to respect choice. We were taught that we might not agree with somebody's
01:00:54.540 decision regarding their care, but we need to respect it and work around that. We need to include
01:01:01.980 them in their care. It's about including them in their care. They make the decisions. We give them
01:01:08.060 information. They make a decision. It's called informed consent. That's not happening right now.
01:01:13.980 We are not allowed to say no, or I'd like to hold off or, you know, whatever it might be. We are
01:01:25.260 just basically told, this is what you must do. And this is totally contrary to what we have ever
01:01:31.500 been taught. And so, you know, I, it just really bothers me because, um, I, I feel that for me,
01:01:42.060 I have always supported people in their decisions, uh, around their care. Even if I didn't really feel
01:01:47.980 that they were the right decisions, I respected those and I tried to work with them. Um, but this
01:01:52.940 absolutely is not happening now. And that's bothersome to me. And the other thing that's really bothersome to
01:01:57.820 me is the fact that they're going after our children and our grandchildren now. And that
01:02:02.300 for me is a huge issue because the children don't need these shots. Absolutely. It's very apparent that
01:02:09.740 the government has made this very political and it's not about healthcare. It's not about looking
01:02:13.820 after anybody. This is about complying, um, with whatever their nefarious agenda is from, you know,
01:02:21.420 from what I, I've seen, um, you know, it's, they've been reckless, irresponsible,
01:02:28.460 and they need to be held accountable. They don't answer emails. You know, we've, we've called out,
01:02:34.220 we've sent emails, we've been in touch with our MLAs and not even they can get an answer.
01:02:39.420 They're, they're not responding and asking like, you know, Hey, you know, like there's some things
01:02:43.900 going on here that we should probably look at, but they don't, they put the order out and they turn
01:02:47.820 and they walk away. They do not respond to anybody. Do as I say, they're not there to listen to you.
01:02:55.020 And the biggest thing I think is when Bonnie Henry, uh, came out and this is to Bonnie Henry,
01:03:00.620 um, came out and said for healthcare professionals, uh, if you're not getting the shot,
01:03:05.900 there will be consequences. It's a threat. And she has no little patience for you guys. 0.98
01:03:10.780 That's right. And, and I mean, even with Trudeau, you know, there's going to be consequences. Well,
01:03:17.100 you know, I'm sorry, but you work for us. We pay your wage as, as taxpayers, and you need to start
01:03:27.100 telling the truth because enough is enough. That's right. Don't threaten me and my family
01:03:34.460 as a government official. Amen. All right. Well, I want to thank you guys for your bravery. I can tell
01:03:41.180 you this, I speak to many health professionals that haven't been able to do what you're doing.
01:03:47.100 We're seeing more of it right now and we desperately need it. So I just want to applaud you guys for
01:03:51.500 standing in truth and informing the people when our government and leaders lack doing so. And thank
01:03:57.340 you guys to our supporters who have already joined us in fighting this medical tyranny. If you don't know
01:04:02.940 what I'm talking about, you can pull out another device or go to another screen and search fightvaccinepassports.com.
01:04:10.940 We are challenging governments, including the BC government for their tyrannical vaccine passports.
01:04:16.700 And we are also taking on cases we can't take them all on, but what we're doing is taking on
01:04:22.060 plaintiffs that represent the whole group and individual plaintiffs. And we are challenging employers
01:04:29.180 as well. So we can't do that alone. Every penny you donate at fight vaccine passports goes to our
01:04:35.340 civil liberties charity. Not a penny goes to rebel news, and that's in partnership with the democracy
01:04:40.940 fund. So you also get a charitable donation receipt back. I'm Draya Humphrey. This is rebel news.
01:04:47.420 And here, this is what heroes look like.
01:04:53.660 If you appreciate that rebel news fearlessly brings you the other side of the story and brings
01:04:58.300 you interviews like this. Just know that we don't take a penny for the federal government.
01:05:03.500 And so if you want to support our journalism, you can do so by donating at realreporters.ca.
01:05:09.420 We appreciate your support.