Rebel News Podcast - November 28, 2018


It's sad that GM's factory in Oshawa is closing — but why did their union work to block Alberta pipelines?


Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

155.71124

Word count

5,964

Sentence count

410

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

General Motors is closing a factory in Ontario, Canada, laying off up to 2,800 workers. It's a tough blow for the families in the town of Oshawa, but it's not the first time GM has laid off workers in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 Tonight, I feel bad about the GM factory in Ontario closing, but why did their union go to court to block Alberta oil sands pipelines?
00:00:08.260 It's November 27, and this is the Ezra Levant Show.
00:00:16.560 Why should others go to jail when you're a biggest carbon consumer I know?
00:00:20.360 There's 8,500 customers here, and you won't give them an answer.
00:00:24.060 You come here once a year with a sign, and you feel morally superior.
00:00:27.040 The only thing I have to say to the government about why I publish it is because it's my bloody right to do so.
00:00:37.740 We've all heard the news about General Motors and their plan to shut down its Oshawa, Ontario factory next year, laying off up to 2,800 people.
00:00:47.360 That's a tough blow. Although it's simply the latest, there used to be 40,000 people building cars in Oshawa.
00:00:53.440 But as the president of Magna, the auto parts company, put it this spring, it just doesn't make sense to build cars in Canada.
00:01:02.260 Canada's the highest cost location in North America to build cars.
00:01:05.760 Add in Justin Trudeau's looming carbon tax and Donald Trump's tax cuts.
00:01:11.540 It just doesn't make sense.
00:01:13.300 But don't bother Justin Trudeau with any of that boring, real-world stuff.
00:01:17.280 He's got much more exciting things to do.
00:01:19.200 He's about to fly to Argentina, people.
00:01:22.160 There's going to be some great photo ops down there.
00:01:24.880 He's already tweeting about it, guys.
00:01:27.600 This week, I'll travel to Argentina for the 2018 G20 Summit to work with leaders from around the world to keep building stronger economies that work for everyone.
00:01:37.180 Fight climate change, promote gender equality, and discuss the future of work.
00:01:42.840 Got it. So our boy is still prattling on about global warming and gender equality while GM is shutting down factories.
00:01:51.360 Haven't they heard of Trudeau's inspirational speech about the future of work?
00:01:54.940 I mean, come on, get with it, guys.
00:01:56.660 Back in real life, 12 months into the future, 2,800 families in Oshawa will be looking for work.
00:02:02.880 That's the future of work.
00:02:04.480 It's tough. I'm obviously sympathetic to these 2,800 families, and I'm obviously skeptical of GM like Bombardier.
00:02:12.300 They were happy to take massive cash bailouts from Canadian taxpayers and then shut down factories here to move to cheaper jurisdictions.
00:02:19.880 I do blame Justin Trudeau and Kathleen Wynne for making Canada so uncompetitive in the first place.
00:02:27.540 But at the end of the day, GM took the cash.
00:02:30.260 I suppose maybe you can't blame someone for taking billions of dollars of free money and running if it's technically legal.
00:02:39.340 But you have to admit it's gross, like Bombardier is gross.
00:02:43.880 Now, Donald Trump wasn't happy because although 2,800 Canadians are being laid off, about 3,300 Americans will be laid off too,
00:02:53.180 including in Ohio, a battleground state where they make a compact car called the Chevy Cruze.
00:02:59.860 I should point out that GM is shutting down that tiny car, and they're completely shutting down the Chevy Volt, GM's electric car.
00:03:08.140 No one wants to buy them.
00:03:10.620 People like SUVs and trucks.
00:03:13.380 Now, there's a lot of BS when it comes to tiny cars, fuel-efficient cars, electric cars.
00:03:17.640 Everybody knows they're supposed to like them, supposed to say they like them, but no one does.
00:03:22.600 Here's Barack Obama six years ago.
00:03:24.360 At GM's Hamtramck plant in Detroit, where I got to get inside a brand-new Chevy Volt, fresh off the line,
00:03:33.760 even though Secret Service wouldn't let me drive it.
00:03:35.660 But I like sitting in it.
00:03:44.060 It was nice.
00:03:46.560 I'll bet it drives real good.
00:03:49.900 And five years from now, when I'm not president anymore, I'll buy one and drive it myself.
00:03:55.340 Yeah, no, he didn't buy one.
00:03:59.440 No one did, other than a few public sector showboats, like Barack Obama himself was there.
00:04:05.780 They're almost always spending government money on them.
00:04:08.480 That's being shut down.
00:04:10.980 Donald Trump has never been a big booster of green schemes.
00:04:13.300 He's always mocked the global warming lobbyists, calling it a scam on Twitter.
00:04:17.640 He just wants factories.
00:04:18.900 And here's what he said yesterday about that Chevy Cruze factory closing.
00:04:23.240 Well, we don't like it.
00:04:25.000 I believe they'll be opening up something else.
00:04:27.700 And I was very tough.
00:04:29.400 I spoke with her when I heard they were closing.
00:04:32.320 And I said, you know, this country's done a lot for General Motors.
00:04:35.180 You better get back in there soon.
00:04:36.600 That's Ohio.
00:04:37.720 And you better get back in there soon.
00:04:39.500 So we have a lot of pressure on them.
00:04:42.000 You have senators.
00:04:42.840 You have a lot of other people.
00:04:43.940 A lot of pressure.
00:04:45.220 They say the Chevy Cruze is not selling well.
00:04:48.620 I say, well, then get somebody to get a car that is selling well and put it back in.
00:04:53.660 So I think you're going to see something else happen there.
00:04:56.020 But I'm not happy about it.
00:04:57.880 Their car is not selling well.
00:05:00.000 So they'll put something else.
00:05:01.360 I have no doubt that in a not too distant future, they'll put something else.
00:05:05.620 They better put something else in.
00:05:08.180 Now, who knows what that will translate into in real life.
00:05:11.140 But if I were the CEO of General Motors, I'd be more concerned about that comment by Donald
00:05:16.260 Trump than this comment by Jerry Diaz, the president of the auto workers union here in
00:05:21.940 Canada called Unifor.
00:05:23.640 He was talking to workers.
00:05:24.820 And according to this report, he said he will, quote, use every tool possible to show
00:05:29.480 GM it will not betray Canadians again.
00:05:33.580 What does that mean?
00:05:34.740 I don't quite know.
00:05:35.780 Well, I don't know what he can do.
00:05:37.860 I mean, the fact is GM's factories have about a million cars a year in excess capacity.
00:05:44.940 They're going to shut down the least profitable factories. 0.99
00:05:48.200 And as we showed you yesterday, that means the Canadian ones.
00:05:52.720 Here's a former CEO of Chrysler saying he wouldn't be surprised if other car makers shut
00:05:58.840 down their most costly plants in Canada, too, including in Brampton.
00:06:04.160 It sounds like you're saying that how we got here was through a lack of leadership and a
00:06:09.140 lack of vision, either on the part of the unions or on the part of the government.
00:06:12.600 I think it's both.
00:06:15.560 And the government does not and never wanted to support the industry.
00:06:20.920 You know, Brampton's next.
00:06:22.820 You know, what's the government going to do there?
00:06:25.120 I don't know what they're doing at Chrysler because I have been away for nine years now.
00:06:30.360 But the bottom line is, what are they going to do for these people?
00:06:34.280 Instead of worrying about what Mexico's pay rates are, why doesn't Canada focus on and
00:06:41.060 the union focus on their current members?
00:06:43.460 Because this is going to spread.
00:06:46.540 Now, I don't quite understand his advice.
00:06:49.820 And of course, Chrysler took a huge bailout 10 years ago, too.
00:06:53.840 But I think his prediction is probably right.
00:06:55.400 Frankly, I think what's going to happen is there's going to be some negotiation now.
00:06:59.760 GM and Chrysler will see what concessions they can get over the next year.
00:07:04.280 To maybe get their expensive plants to become affordable?
00:07:08.540 That's either concessions from the unions or concessions from the governments involved.
00:07:14.320 I wouldn't doubt that Justin Trudeau would throw a few billion dollars to keep him going.
00:07:18.820 And again, can you blame a for-profit company like GM or Chrysler from taking free money?
00:07:24.100 It's like a hockey team getting a free stadium.
00:07:26.960 It's immoral, sure, but you'd be dumb not to take the free cash.
00:07:31.580 It's hard to get to the heart of things here, don't you think?
00:07:35.040 It's hard even to get the accurate reports because the Trudeau slush fund media,
00:07:39.700 the ones who are about to pocket their own bailout of $595 million in free money,
00:07:45.260 they're so biased.
00:07:46.800 I mean, look at these two stories.
00:07:48.580 In the same newspaper, the Toronto Star, on the same day.
00:07:52.100 Do you see that?
00:07:52.700 They're both November 26.
00:07:53.740 Trudeau has been in office for three years.
00:07:58.020 Doug Ford, just a few months.
00:07:59.900 So look at the one where they're talking about Trudeau.
00:08:02.060 That's on the left.
00:08:03.580 So Ottawa is looking at all options as GM closes Oshawa plant.
00:08:08.700 So it's framed with Trudeau as the helpful save here.
00:08:12.920 But look at the one on the right.
00:08:15.080 GM shows Doug Ford's Ontario isn't so open for business.
00:08:19.040 Yeah, Doug Ford is clearly driving out the factory.
00:08:22.720 He's been premier for a few months.
00:08:24.200 Look, they're already fleeing.
00:08:25.040 Look, you can't trust the media, can you?
00:08:28.260 But I want to add one more layer to things today.
00:08:30.900 We got the, you know, the...
00:08:31.800 I would agree with Jerry Diaz that the big three automakers are amoral.
00:08:40.160 And I agree that politicians are to blame for tax policy and other high costs.
00:08:46.420 But let's talk about something that no one has really delved into yet.
00:08:50.360 And that is Jerry Diaz and Unifor the union itself.
00:08:54.940 I'm going to separate it, the union and their bosses from the 2,800 families who are soon out of work.
00:08:59.660 I want to talk about the union leadership itself.
00:09:03.240 Because Jerry Diaz is angry.
00:09:05.400 He's making weird and vague threats about GM.
00:09:08.260 He's making demands.
00:09:10.040 Obviously, he'll take handouts of Trudeau, I'll give them.
00:09:13.340 And maybe that's his job to do that.
00:09:15.360 It's just a fact that Canadian factories are more expensive than American or Mexican factories.
00:09:19.720 And Trump and Trudeau are both making that gap bigger.
00:09:22.340 And Jerry Diaz had a seat at the table in the NAFTA renegotiations and I don't think he helped much.
00:09:26.840 But could you imagine if that factory in Oshawa and that Chrysler factory we heard about in Brampton
00:09:34.820 had been the target of a 10-year propaganda campaign to shut them down with foreign money?
00:09:42.860 10 years of demonizing these factories, of pointing out their carbon footprint, how much pollution they cause.
00:09:48.780 10 years of publicizing every error or accident or misstep, anything going wrong at the factory,
00:09:53.860 every time there was a car accident on the street.
00:09:56.660 And if it was a GM brand of vehicle made in Oshawa, I know it sounds crazy,
00:10:01.180 but imagine if someone were paid by a foreign lobby group to do nothing but track car accidents in Canada.
00:10:09.900 And whenever a car from that Oshawa factory had an accident, and I know this sounds crazy,
00:10:14.940 imagine if there were a press release attacking that GM factory in Oshawa.
00:10:19.480 Never GM factories in other countries, never, let's say Toyota, let's say it was a Toyota-financed propaganda effort
00:10:26.820 that just hated that factory, just Oshawa.
00:10:30.820 Imagine if there were protests outside the Oshawa plant, paid protesters.
00:10:35.780 Imagine if there were lawsuits against that factory, alleging pollution, or, I don't know,
00:10:41.440 even suing that anyone who would still build a fossil fuel car in 2018 was killing our planet, whatever.
00:10:45.720 I know that's unthinkable, I know that's too crazy, but of course that is exactly what has been done to Alberta's oil industry for a decade or more.
00:10:54.640 Defamation, smearing, protests, lawsuits, lies, hugely funded, well-organized.
00:10:59.480 Imagine the rage and the sorrow and the feeling of betrayal of those 2,800 families in Oshawa
00:11:05.080 if it were in part because of a well-financed 10-year smear campaign.
00:11:09.860 We'll now multiply that rage by 40 because there are at least 100,000 oil and gas families still unemployed in Alberta.
00:11:20.120 The Trans Mountain Pipeline alone would have employed triple the number of families laid off in Oshawa.
00:11:26.840 The Energy East Pipeline, as you know, the construction alone was a $15.7 billion jobs project.
00:11:34.340 No bailout needed.
00:11:35.400 Where was the sympathy then?
00:11:39.020 Where was the national wailing?
00:11:40.960 There was none.
00:11:42.460 There was jubilation and celebration from the far left, the eco-left, and quiet smirks from the liberals.
00:11:49.180 Here's Gerald Butts condemning the fossil fuel economy for pipelines.
00:11:54.420 Now he's Trudeau's right-hand man.
00:11:56.360 Imagine if such a man were to have said this exact same thing,
00:12:00.520 but instead about pipelines, about car factories.
00:12:06.380 Truth be told, we don't think there ought to be a carbon-based energy industry by the middle of this century.
00:12:12.020 That's our policy in Canada, and it's our policy all over the world.
00:12:15.540 You can choose to fight this fight on locking us into a high-carbon economy for five decades.
00:12:20.920 And I think that's a very reasonable perspective to take.
00:12:26.620 In fact, it's one we do take.
00:12:29.200 So we don't think that, we think that the oil sands have been expanded too rapidly
00:12:33.240 without a serious plan for environmental remediation in the first place.
00:12:38.300 So that's why we don't think it's up to us to decide whether there should be another route for a pipeline.
00:12:45.120 Because the real alternative is not an alternative route.
00:12:49.720 It's an alternative economy.
00:12:52.040 So why is that okay when it's against oil and gas and pipeline families, but not auto families?
00:12:59.520 But Unifor itself is the worst.
00:13:02.260 Jerry Diaz's union itself is a job killer.
00:13:04.820 Here's a press release two years ago by Unifor itself.
00:13:08.540 Let me read it to you.
00:13:10.780 Unifor is disappointed with the National Energy Board's short-sighted decision to support the Trans Mountain Expansion Project,
00:13:16.900 one that poses risks for the economy, Canadian jobs, and food security.
00:13:21.440 Oh, food security, eh?
00:13:23.100 The Kinder Morgan Expansion Project is all risk and no gain for the public or our environment,
00:13:28.560 said Joie Warnock, Unifor's Western director.
00:13:32.320 Despite applying conditions for approval, in the absence of any realistic and forceful regulations,
00:13:36.980 the NEB failed to consider the very serious risks a project of this magnitude has for residents and our economy.
00:13:43.980 Oh, so even though it was approved as safe by experts, by neutral exports, by Trudeau's experts,
00:13:52.440 Unifor campaigned against it.
00:13:53.940 They helped destroy it.
00:13:55.120 And here's Unifor now actually going to court to stop the Northern Gateway pipeline.
00:14:01.400 Let me show you another press release they put out a couple years back.
00:14:05.660 The process was rigged from the start and they ignored important testimony from Canadians,
00:14:09.720 said Joie Warnock, Unifor's Western director.
00:14:12.040 If Stephen Harper refuses to protect our coast, we have no choice but to fight them in court.
00:14:17.460 Unifor went to court to stop a jobs project in Western Canada.
00:14:21.360 Here's Unifor on the Keystone XL pipeline. Ready?
00:14:25.260 Canadians don't benefit from pipelines that ship unrefined oil to other countries.
00:14:29.260 Plain and simple, said Unifor National President Jerry Diaz told the Union's BC Regional Council in Vancouver.
00:14:37.700 Keystone XL, Northern Gateway, and the new Kinder Morgan pipeline all have one thing in common.
00:14:42.160 They steal Canada's natural resort wealth and leave us with nothing to show for it.
00:14:47.000 Unifor is calling on the federal government to enforce greenhouse gas emission targets
00:14:52.280 by limiting the future expansion of bitumen production.
00:14:56.600 Really, eh?
00:14:58.780 When was the last time there was a carbon emissions analysis of an auto factory?
00:15:05.600 When was the last time you had union bosses from Alberta flying out to Ontario
00:15:11.440 to campaign against car factories or even sue them?
00:15:15.440 When was the last time you had extremists in cabinet call for a gender analysis of a car factory 1.00
00:15:21.800 like that clown Catherine McKenna does for pipelines? 1.00
00:15:25.680 It's a sign of how broken Canada is that not just union bosses,
00:15:30.100 but the media and the courts and political leaders and civil society, including charities,
00:15:35.440 take it for granted that it's okay to attack oil and gas jobs
00:15:40.260 and to campaign and sue and protest oil and gas jobs into submission,
00:15:44.120 but God forbid a car company wants to move away from Trudeau's uncompetitive tax regime.
00:15:50.420 Well, it's a national crisis, and Trudeau had better come in with a bailout.
00:15:54.120 Yeah, I'm sympathetic.
00:15:56.020 I truly am sympathetic to those 2,800 families.
00:15:59.540 I really am.
00:16:00.060 But I'm 40 times more sympathetic to the 100,000 oil and gas families
00:16:08.780 who were attacked by Trudeau and Butts and McKenna and Morneau.
00:16:13.940 Oh, yeah, and Jerry Diaz and his dues-paying Unifor union members.
00:16:20.400 Yeah, I'll get around to laying a wreath for those dead jobs in Oshawa
00:16:24.380 once I'm done going through the other 100,000 dead jobs.
00:16:28.260 As the Unifor itself helped cause, without a peep of protest, I should add,
00:16:34.540 from those 2,800 union members whose dues were weaponized against the oil and gas industry.
00:16:42.260 Stay with us for more.
00:16:58.260 Welcome back.
00:17:00.520 Well, one of the quirky things about the Nazi regime in Germany some 70, 80 years ago
00:17:07.020 was that although they were quite murderous, they were against smoking.
00:17:12.460 Hitler in particular, in fact, so much so that for years after the Second World War,
00:17:18.880 Germans associated bans on smoking with Nazism.
00:17:23.160 And so they were one of the last countries in Europe to bring in social justice laws against smoking.
00:17:29.600 Hitler himself was a vegetarian extremist, an animal rights activist, anti-vivisectionist.
00:17:37.440 He held himself to morally exquisite levels on that
00:17:43.620 while he masterminded the murder of tens of millions.
00:17:47.140 Well, I'm interested in a new book that follows on this subject.
00:17:53.220 It's a book written by a rebel viewer from Grand Prairie.
00:17:58.520 It's called The Green Swastika, Environmentalism in the Third Reich. 0.92
00:18:06.180 And it's written by William Kay, who joins us now via Skype.
00:18:11.820 William, it's a pleasure to see you again.
00:18:13.680 We've spoken before about environmentalism.
00:18:16.320 You're the editor of the website Environmentalism is Fascism.
00:18:19.940 So you've been on this beat for a while.
00:18:22.340 I think it would surprise...
00:18:22.980 Over 20 years.
00:18:23.860 Yeah, I know.
00:18:25.620 And you're a meticulous researcher.
00:18:27.740 I think it would surprise a lot of people that the Nazis were environmentalists.
00:18:34.800 I mean, people think of the Nazis as destroyers.
00:18:37.620 Why did they love environmentalism so much?
00:18:39.840 Well, first point, it certainly would not surprise academics.
00:18:45.520 I have condensed over 24 books on my website, published by Princeton, published by Oxford,
00:18:52.600 Cambridge, that really detail this.
00:18:54.980 There's a few books even by the German government that were put out a few years ago to sort of
00:18:59.980 manage this damaging information.
00:19:01.780 But of course, they managed to give even more incriminating information by doing it.
00:19:06.640 So whereas the public at large might not be aware of it, this is not really that debatable
00:19:12.440 within the academic and within the historical community that much.
00:19:16.160 Environmentalists dread this information getting out, and they've gone to great lengths to sort
00:19:20.180 of manage it and suppress it.
00:19:21.620 But this is not really even that controversial.
00:19:24.240 The question was, why the Nazis were green? 0.55
00:19:28.160 Yeah.
00:19:30.360 Well, the key to understanding environmentalism, the key to understanding fascism is to understanding
00:19:36.520 the dynamics of land use politics.
00:19:40.360 And the core of the European fascist movement were the aristocrats.
00:19:45.540 And what they dreaded more than anything else was a free market in land, like capitalism in
00:19:51.280 land, where land would be just any other commodity circulating.
00:19:54.740 These were people that wanted to cartelize land.
00:19:58.120 They were corporatists in general and in land in particular.
00:20:02.440 And so they were the force behind land conservationism.
00:20:06.820 And they were definitely the nucleus of the fascist movement.
00:20:10.400 We should really view fascism of that era as aristocratic restoration.
00:20:17.060 They were trying to regain the powers that they had lost after World War I and return to
00:20:22.100 a far less than democratic system, where these sort of old land barons dominated the political 1.00
00:20:28.420 process.
00:20:29.600 So the connection is really there.
00:20:31.740 It's a violent opposition to free market in land.
00:20:37.340 And it's also an effort by the old land barons to regain political control.
00:20:43.480 That's a surprising answer.
00:20:44.740 I was certain you were going to say two other things.
00:20:47.360 I should say I haven't had the chance to read your book yet.
00:20:49.620 This is just an introduction to it for me.
00:20:51.860 But the more we talk, I'm getting more interested by the minute.
00:20:54.860 I would have thought you would have said, well, Hitler had a hostility towards Christianity,
00:21:02.400 towards the Pope, towards Judaism. 0.59
00:21:04.260 But he had sort of a paganism, an echo from a pre-Christian era.
00:21:11.580 I thought you were going to say that perhaps he would rediscover that paganism through the
00:21:15.840 environment.
00:21:16.720 And I thought at core, well, Hitler was about control and authoritarianism. 0.82
00:21:22.100 And if you control the environment, you control the means of production.
00:21:24.920 You control everything.
00:21:26.260 That would have been my theory.
00:21:27.660 But you're saying it was, I suppose you're saying something similar when you're saying it
00:21:30.580 was about control of land.
00:21:31.580 It was, there's a dynamic tension between the land barons and the entrepreneurs.
00:21:39.280 That was the driving force behind the American Revolution, behind the French Revolution.
00:21:43.760 But picking up on what you're saying about the religion of nature, officially, the Third
00:21:50.460 Reich remained ostensibly a Christian country.
00:21:56.080 They got what referred to as positive Christianity.
00:21:58.460 There were a lot of Lutheran ministers that supported them.
00:22:01.520 They had very difficult relations with the Catholic Church.
00:22:04.880 But nevertheless, they got a lot of support from that as well.
00:22:07.960 But the Nazi elite, the vanguard, you are correct. 0.94
00:22:11.200 These were people who were anti-Christian.
00:22:13.340 And they wanted to replace Christianity with a religion of nature.
00:22:17.240 But this was more of a cultural epiphenomenal thing.
00:22:20.360 I will say this in passing.
00:22:21.700 There is an encyclopedia called the Encyclopedia of the Religion of Nature.
00:22:28.240 And it came together by a bunch of academics who, for other reasons, realized that there
00:22:32.920 was a really strong connection between fascism, Nazism, and this nature worshiping.
00:22:38.420 I've read that encyclopedia.
00:22:39.800 And I found over 400 paragraphs and entire entries that deal with the topic of the overlap between
00:22:47.460 Nazism and environmentalism and Nazism and fascism and this religion of nature.
00:22:53.760 And that's one thing you'll find when you actually read a lot of the original fascist and original
00:22:59.700 Nazi writings.
00:23:00.940 It's just full of this mother nature, mother earth, nature in capital and stuff.
00:23:06.380 But that was the Nazi vanguard. 0.83
00:23:09.200 There were certain elements within the Nazi government who were really talking about,
00:23:13.320 you know, replacing Christianity in Germany with a full-blown sort of paganistic, pantheistic
00:23:19.520 religion.
00:23:20.380 But they were shot down.
00:23:21.940 They were proposing that during World War II.
00:23:24.820 And a lot of the other ministers, cabinet ministers, said, no, this is no time to be sort
00:23:28.480 of, you know, monkeying around with that.
00:23:30.680 But yeah, there was this strong element of that.
00:23:33.160 And if you read their literature of the sort of the Nazi vanguard, like Himmler and Rosenberg
00:23:38.280 and that, you'd think you're reading a Greenpeace track, you know.
00:23:42.100 We're talking with William Kay.
00:23:43.560 He's the author of The Green Swastika, Environmentalism in the Third Reich.
00:23:47.580 William, I'm still processing what you said about the aristocracy and land.
00:23:55.060 Because in my mind, environmentalism and Marxism are the closest cousins.
00:24:01.380 I don't know if it's a coincidence, but Earth Day, for example, just happens to be Lenin's
00:24:07.260 birthday, if I'm not mistaken.
00:24:09.480 And there's so many, you know, we've heard the phrase watermelon, green on the outside,
00:24:14.780 red on the inside.
00:24:15.860 It's the catch-all excuse for nationalizing things.
00:24:19.660 I thought that, you know, the Marxists would have been the environmentalists.
00:24:26.240 I suppose in his own way, I mean, Hitler was a national socialist. 0.66
00:24:32.040 Can you compare the Nazi environmentalism with Marxism or Leninism? 0.74
00:24:39.880 They really are not connected.
00:24:44.320 They're actually polar opposites.
00:24:46.240 In every fascist regime, the first thing they did was annihilate the far left.
00:24:50.820 It's difficult for people who have come through the Cold War.
00:24:54.800 They tend to view any effort towards some sort of highly statist authoritarian system
00:25:00.220 as a movement towards socialism.
00:25:03.100 Now, at the core of the Nazi party, you would find some of the wealthiest of the Germans. 0.68
00:25:07.900 And you'll see this again with the environmental movement.
00:25:10.720 If you look at the boards of directors of the main funding agencies and what have you,
00:25:15.340 these aren't the, you know, the working class rising up.
00:25:17.900 These are elite groups that would be militantly opposed to any sort of sweeping expropriation
00:25:22.960 of their assets.
00:25:24.400 You have to think in terms of threes.
00:25:26.280 People are trapped in a binary of a sort of right-left.
00:25:29.240 There is multiple political ideologies out there.
00:25:32.820 Corporatism, fascism.
00:25:34.220 It represents a section of very wealthy people, certainly not all of them, that want to see
00:25:41.740 a highly centralized, highly regulated form of government.
00:25:45.140 But they are actually militantly, violently opposed to the left.
00:25:48.780 You know, time and again, when you have a fascist regime come into power, first thing they do
00:25:54.120 is round up the left.
00:25:55.700 The first concentration camp in Germany, Dachau, was for the left.
00:25:59.620 They had, you know, 15,000, 20,000 people in prison within months, and those were all people
00:26:04.100 who were members of leftist organizations.
00:26:06.900 No, there's multiple political tendencies out there.
00:26:10.240 There's a very common mistake these days to confuse the radical left with the environmental
00:26:16.220 movement.
00:26:17.200 To make it even more confusing, a lot of fascist groups historically have masqueraded as leftist
00:26:23.340 organizations, and they have a certain amount of leftist verbiage in their titles and names
00:26:28.280 and what have you.
00:26:28.880 But these are quite distinct political traditions.
00:26:31.660 You know, you're making me think of some Soviet propaganda.
00:26:35.860 There was always the factory and get production up.
00:26:39.400 I mean, one thing I say to the modern left is at least the communists believed in the means
00:26:44.440 of production.
00:26:45.120 They believed in the factories.
00:26:46.200 They just wanted the factories owned by the state.
00:26:50.040 I suppose today's far left, they don't want the factories at all.
00:26:53.220 They want to shut down the coal-fired power plant.
00:26:55.480 They want to shut down the factories. 0.64
00:26:57.600 I suppose that's one difference.
00:26:59.820 But maybe, let me follow up on your theme.
00:27:02.320 I see so many of the funders of the extreme environmental movements, and they are the Rockefeller
00:27:10.320 Brothers Fund, you know, perhaps the wealthiest family in history.
00:27:14.500 And so many of these ultra-rich heirs, not the first generation entrepreneurs who, like the
00:27:22.760 Carnegie's and whatnot, but two, three, four generations down, yeah, they are extremists.
00:27:32.680 If you look at most of the environmentalist money coming into Canada, it's not moms and 0.75
00:27:37.640 dads chipping in 20 bucks, 50 bucks.
00:27:39.980 It's foreign foundations chipping in six, seven, even eight figures.
00:27:44.480 And that is one of the features that it shares with fascism.
00:27:51.440 There's this myth that fascism was this plebeian uprising.
00:27:55.000 It never was.
00:27:57.700 That information has been concealed.
00:27:59.960 There is a priceless book called The Reich and the Royals, and it was published by Oxford
00:28:04.580 in 2005, and it concludes with a list of all of the German princes who were members of the
00:28:12.480 Nazi party.
00:28:13.320 And that information was not revealed until 2005.
00:28:16.920 And the list of princes who were members of the Nazi party was 290.
00:28:22.260 And the author of that book was a detective with these groups that are still looking for
00:28:26.840 the looted art of Europe.
00:28:28.700 A third of all the artwork in France was stolen during World War II.
00:28:32.080 That happened in other countries as well.
00:28:34.560 They're still looking for this art.
00:28:36.080 And some of the detectives involved in investigating that ultimately got access to some of the databases
00:28:41.320 that some of the army intelligence people had.
00:28:44.260 And yeah, sure enough, the German aristocracy were almost to a person active members of fascist 0.72
00:28:51.720 organizations and the Nazi party itself.
00:28:54.540 And if you look at who was the center of the social nucleus of the German conservationist movement,
00:29:00.260 the nature protection movement, it's the same list of people.
00:29:04.180 Now, your book's 185 pages long, 400 footnotes.
00:29:06.980 Would you call it a scholarly work or is it more a work for interested lay people?
00:29:12.420 You've referred to a lot of studies and a lot of research.
00:29:15.200 What's your goal with this book?
00:29:18.200 Well, I believe in exposing and opposing environmentalism.
00:29:21.660 I'm someone who lives in Western Canada.
00:29:24.000 The biggest political problem we have in Canada, in North America, and in many other places
00:29:29.100 in the world is the suppression of economic activity by the environmental movement.
00:29:35.340 And one of the mechanisms by which they curry favor amongst the masses is a sort of masquerading
00:29:41.020 as somehow a voice of the people, what have you.
00:29:43.780 No, this is a very elite groups of people that have no interest in seeing the hinterland develop
00:29:49.520 whatsoever.
00:29:51.120 And, you know, we would be really experiencing a tremendous economic boom in prosperity in
00:29:56.420 North America, but for the activities of the international environmental movement.
00:30:01.980 These are people who seriously do not care about the general prosperity, the general well-being
00:30:07.940 of the broader masses.
00:30:10.120 Let me ask you one last question about that and to move away from your book, which is historical,
00:30:15.260 to talk about the world today, I think Donald Trump smashed a lot of the illusion of unanimity
00:30:23.780 on global warming, carbon taxes, the United Nations, globalism.
00:30:28.880 I think he's being undermined in terms of the bureaucracy of the United States, but he's at
00:30:35.220 least made it acceptable to challenge rhetorically what was going on.
00:30:40.200 And I think on the ground, he's, you know, he's roaring back with a fossil fuel-based economy.
00:30:49.260 Is the environmental movement around the world in retreat, whether it's China or the removal
00:30:58.900 of the massive solar and wind subsidies in Europe?
00:31:02.940 It seems to me that the only place that this carbon tax global warming mania still takes
00:31:08.640 hold is in the academy or the UN or, I suppose, Justin Trudeau's cabinet.
00:31:13.760 It seems to me like that the rest of the world doesn't actually live that creed.
00:31:17.640 Am I wrong?
00:31:19.380 Well, there's a number of points there.
00:31:21.220 A lot of the, you know, countries like India and China, they bought into it.
00:31:25.640 They paid lip service to it because they knew that they would not have to actually do anything.
00:31:29.720 The global warming campaign is centered around Europe.
00:31:34.320 It is centered around Germany and France and Sweden and Denmark and countries that do not 0.91
00:31:38.740 have any fossil fuels.
00:31:40.540 And they are determined to transition the entire world away from fossil fuels and to be on the
00:31:45.800 ground floor of the wind, solar, electric car industries for this new future world.
00:31:51.720 Um, I'll say this about Trump.
00:31:55.800 You know, I've never was so happy in my life regarding a political event as when he was
00:32:00.820 elected.
00:32:01.200 And I'm someone who came out of, you know, decades ago of being in the very far left.
00:32:06.740 No greater slander out there than to accuse Trump and the Brexiteers and the populist movement
00:32:13.660 as being, as being fascist.
00:32:15.780 And they are often tarred with that.
00:32:17.260 They're called right wing and what have you.
00:32:19.040 We were well on our way down the road towards a uniparty system, which is basically a one
00:32:25.160 party state with a media party, as you call it, which was basically turning into a ministry
00:32:30.400 of propaganda with a deep state.
00:32:32.920 These are all features of fascist regimes.
00:32:36.120 And we were way down the road towards that being really locked down.
00:32:40.480 The populist movement, the Trumpeteers, the Brexiteers, this is an anti-fascist movement.
00:32:46.500 And I think that is a message that has to get out there.
00:32:50.840 And a lot of them, because they were politically socialized during the Cold War, they tend to
00:32:55.860 formulate what they're doing as though they're fighting against the left.
00:32:59.040 The left is almost insignificant in this.
00:33:02.320 You know, the Rideau Club, the Laurier Club, what have you, these are not leftists at all.
00:33:06.100 These are corporatists.
00:33:07.120 These are elitists.
00:33:07.940 These are authoritarians who want to just sort of lock down this existing system and exclude
00:33:13.420 any sort of diversity of opinion.
00:33:16.780 Well, very interesting.
00:33:18.480 William Kay is the author of The Green Swastika, Environmentalism in the Third Reich.
00:33:22.960 I'm familiar with William's work and his meticulously documented website, Environmentalism
00:33:29.160 is Fascism, which is fascinating reading for those who are interested in the subject.
00:33:34.240 William, thanks for your time.
00:33:35.380 You've convinced me to download the book.
00:33:37.720 And I should have done that before our interview today.
00:33:39.560 I just didn't have time to read it, but I wanted to get you on.
00:33:42.240 It's like you gave me a primer to get going on the book, because I am interested in the
00:33:47.680 subject, and I'm interested in environmental extremism, and I am curious, as I think so
00:33:52.720 many are, about how things went so wrong in Europe 70, 80 years ago.
00:33:59.160 It'll be interesting to see the crossover.
00:34:00.700 Thanks for your time today.
00:34:02.780 My pleasure.
00:34:03.420 All right.
00:34:04.540 Well, we'll put a link to the Amazon page for The Green Swastika underneath this video
00:34:11.120 if you're interested in following up with the book as well.
00:34:14.440 Stay with us.
00:34:15.420 More ahead on The Rebel.
00:34:27.700 Hey, welcome back.
00:34:28.620 On my monologue and interview yesterday about General Motors closing its Oshawa plant,
00:34:32.120 Betty writes.
00:34:34.080 At least now Jerry Diaz has some real work to do, trying to salvage his union members'
00:34:38.080 jobs instead of focusing on being the political resistance to conservatives.
00:34:42.460 Yeah, it'll be interesting to see if he can wring more money out of Justin Trudeau.
00:34:46.800 Wouldn't surprise me.
00:34:47.800 I mean, it's a tit for tat.
00:34:49.600 He'll campaign for Trudeau.
00:34:50.920 He'll get his journalists in the journalism side of his union to campaign for Trudeau.
00:34:55.460 I mean, he just got a $595 million slush fund, so he's going to have to work extra hard for,
00:35:02.240 I don't know, an extra billion for that plant, but he'll work at it.
00:35:05.000 And I'm sure Trudeau will say yes, why wouldn't he?
00:35:07.560 It's only money.
00:35:09.740 Jerry writes,
00:35:10.340 I don't understand where you're coming from from that.
00:35:28.220 I just don't get it.
00:35:30.060 But I think that's, I think we just need more independent journalists of the left and the
00:35:38.180 right persuasion, I suppose, independent, neutral.
00:35:42.120 You can't be an independent journalist if you're cashing a check from Trudeau, though.
00:35:44.860 That's my point.
00:35:46.000 I mean, whatever you say about Fox, they're not on the Trump payroll.
00:35:49.140 They may seem like it because they support Trump, but they're not actually cashing a check
00:35:53.940 from Trump.
00:35:54.540 Every CBC journalist cashed a check from Trudeau, and now $595 million worth of private journalism
00:36:02.020 will cash a check from Trudeau, too.
00:36:05.460 Norbert writes,
00:36:06.760 Good reporting, Ezra.
00:36:07.960 In the 70s, I was both a member of the UAW and the CAW.
00:36:11.560 We had some great leadership with Bob White and then Buzz Hargrove.
00:36:14.740 I was greatly distraught when CAW came under the umbrella of Unifor.
00:36:17.980 The moniker Unifor does not inspire much confidence in the auto sector, neither does the current
00:36:25.980 president.
00:36:27.680 Well, look, I just don't know enough about internal union politics.
00:36:33.480 I know that there was a compilation of the communications and electrical workers and the
00:36:43.380 auto workers, and it was sort of a big amalgam.
00:36:46.940 So I don't know which tribe Jerry Diaz comes from.
00:36:52.360 There's a certain point where the size of your caucus, let's say, the size of your coalition,
00:36:58.860 means if you're fighting for one, you're fighting against the other.
00:37:01.580 I mean, that whole anti-oil sands crusade that Jerry Diaz has been on,
00:37:06.900 there are Unifor workers in Fort McMurray in the oil patch.
00:37:11.300 How can they countenance this?
00:37:13.720 How can they lie back and take it?
00:37:15.240 And frankly, how could auto workers support an anti-fossil fuel campaign?
00:37:22.340 Even if it was in the near term, aimed only at those Westerners in the oil patch,
00:37:29.580 surely the dues-paying Unifor members in Oshawa would know that if you build up hatred for oil
00:37:38.120 and gas, it'll eventually seep into machines that use oil and gas, like cars.
00:37:44.960 I don't know.
00:37:46.100 But of course, we'll have 2,800 people with a lot of time on their hands to think about that for a while.
00:37:50.740 That's our show for today.
00:37:52.460 Until tomorrow, on behalf of all of us here at Rebel World Headquarters, good night.
00:37:56.420 Keep fighting for free.
00:37:57.320 Keep fighting for free.
00:38:17.840 Keep fighting for free.