Willie MacBeth of Save Calgary joins me to talk about the We Charity scandal, the Conservative Party Leadership race, and why Mayor Naheed Nenshi is trying to raise taxes on an already seriously unemployed Calgary populace.
00:01:57.940I'm Sheila Gunn-Reed, and you're watching The Gunn Show.
00:02:00.240Up to 30% of downtown Calgary's commercial real estate sits vacant.
00:02:23.460The entire country is struggling with the coronavirus shutdown-inspired unemployment,
00:02:29.900and Calgary is no different, and things were already bad before the coronavirus came along and made it worse.
00:02:36.560Alberta still doesn't have access to Tidewater for our greatest and best resources, our oil and gas.
00:02:42.440But Justin Trudeau is not the only politician in the country deciding to raise taxes in the middle of the worst economic downturn in about 100 or so years.
00:02:54.260Calgary's mayor, Nahid Nenshi, is considering several new tax and fee grabs on the long-suffering residents of Calgary, Alberta.
00:03:04.460Joining me tonight in an interview we recorded earlier in the week is my dear friend William Macbeth from Save Calgary
00:03:13.000to discuss first the Conservative Party leadership race, and then the ever-unfolding We Charity scandal,
00:03:21.640and also why Calgary City Council can't seem to realize it has a spending problem and not a revenue problem.
00:03:34.460Joining me now from Calgary is my friend Willie Macbeth from Save Calgary.
00:03:49.740William, thanks for coming on the show.
00:03:52.040Before we get to anything else, I want to talk to you about the We scandal,
00:03:59.920because that's all anybody can talk about, including me.
00:04:02.000You've been a conservative activist for a long time, longer than me even.
00:04:08.180I think you've been politically engaged in the machinery and outside.
00:04:12.440Is this scandal going to harm Justin Trudeau, or is this just going to go by the wayside?
00:04:21.120The likes of Blackface, the Kokanee Grope, the Aga Khan, and the whole trip to India, Bollywood fiasco.
00:04:30.560Is this actually something that's going to hurt him with his base, or just with Conservatives who don't like him anyway?
00:04:38.300It's always hard to tell exactly how a scandal is going to unfold and what the long-term impact would be.
00:04:46.620You know, had you asked me in the last federal election about the photos of the Prime Minister wearing blackface,
00:04:52.880I would have said that that would have been terminal to a politician, but here he is, still Prime Minister, still breaking ethics laws, it seems.
00:05:02.840So I think what's different, though, in this case is how many Liberal MPs appear to be unhappy with the actions of the Prime Minister.
00:05:13.380You know, normally, when there's a failure on the part of the Prime Minister or his team,
00:05:19.640you can count on a legion of Liberal MPs to leap to the Prime Minister's defence.
00:05:25.840My favourite one was, after Canada lost its Security Council bin, we had an Ontario Liberal MP,
00:05:32.520I believe it was MP Rodriguez, saying, well, he can't believe that people are trying to make this a partisan issue against the Prime Minister,
00:05:41.600when everybody knows that's exactly what the Liberals did when Stephen Harper lost a Security Council seat.
00:05:47.520So normally, they all leap to defend the Prime Minister, but you're not seeing that so much this time.
00:05:52.860I think you're seeing a bunch of Liberal MPs start to wonder if Justin Trudeau might not harm their ability to get re-elected.
00:06:00.520And we're in a minority government, we could be entering an election cycle this fall,
00:06:05.840and a lot of those Liberal MPs in Southern Ontario are starting to look at poll numbers
00:06:10.120and wonder if Prime Minister Trudeau or Justin Trudeau is the right man to lead them into the next election.
00:06:16.320You know, and I think there could be a secondary motive for not speaking up to defend the Prime Minister,
00:06:22.000and I think that might be because it might focus attention on that specific MP.
00:06:25.660For example, we know Bill Morneau is ensnared in all of this, and I don't know how deep the layers of that onion go.
00:06:33.580So I would be immediately sceptical of an MP who moved to defend Trudeau.
00:06:39.900I would say, OK, I'm going through your portfolio now.
00:06:43.240I'm going to go through, you know, if you're the Heritage Minister or whatever,
00:06:47.300I'm going to start tearing through that to see if there's any contracts or dealings there or dealings with their own family.
00:06:54.640So I think a lot, maybe some of them are just keeping their mouths shut just to make sure that they don't end up
00:07:00.120with a little bit more scrutiny than they normally would get.
00:07:03.900And I think you're absolutely right, Sheila, that in this case, since the scandal is still unfolding,
00:07:10.780we don't entirely know the full scope of the issues that are being looked at now by the Ethics Commissioner
00:10:59.820I think Peter McKay is running because he never really got to be PC party leader when he won back in 2003.
00:11:12.220That leadership lasted only for a few months before the new Conservative Party of Canada was formed.
00:11:20.480You have Aaron O'Toole, who I think is running more closely to the Harper ticket.
00:11:26.920He was a Harper cabinet minister and sort of espousing this fairly safe position for the Conservative Party.
00:11:41.780I think the bigger problem, though, the Conservative Party has is looking at how many people say they're open to voting for the Conservative Party.
00:11:51.700And right now that number is, in some cases, under 40%, which means that even if they got every single vote of people who might possibly vote Conservative,
00:12:03.940it still isn't enough to get the Conservatives into majority government territory, particularly given how weak the New Democrats are under Leader Jagmeet Singh.
00:12:13.640And so I think it's why people are starting to look at Leslie Lewis and others as an alternative, because they see it as a shake-up.
00:12:22.860They see it as a way of changing perceptions about the Conservative Party.
00:12:27.320And I think that's a great conversation to have.
00:12:29.320I don't know if Leslie Lewis is the right person for that.
00:12:33.580I'm a little bit nervous that the fact that she's never been an elected official before creates a real problem or challenge for her.
00:12:41.540But I think, you know, if there's one word I would choose to describe this leadership race, it would be sort of uninspiring.
00:12:49.720Yeah, and, you know, we could have, I think maybe the potential for a surprise is in all of this, because Leslie Lewis has the potential to be a lot of people's second choice, particularly with the Sloan people.
00:13:08.420I think she could be a second choice with the O'Toole people.
00:13:12.740And, of course, she's a first choice for her own people.
00:13:17.640So, you know, she has the potential to do really well.
00:13:21.860And I think that speaks to the false narrative about the Conservative Party that you hear from the Liberal camp, that, you know, it's not diverse, that they don't care about women in politics, that we, you know, we're racist by the nature of being Conservative.
00:13:41.100But, you know, we have an accomplished woman of colour on our side of the aisle running to be the leader, and she's a serious contender.
00:13:53.380And I think that the fact that the media and the Liberals still treat the Conservative movement as though it's behind the times, while defending the man who wore blackface at least three times, it's a sad state of affairs here in Canada.
00:14:08.120And I think that's a great segue into why we need the Independent Press Gallery.
00:14:15.020And Aaron O'Toole so far has said that he will recognise the Independent Press Gallery, a venture by Candice Malcolm and the folks at True North, this press gallery that basically all you have to do is not take government money.
00:14:31.980And you can think for yourself and you can join.
00:14:35.860I think that's also going to be a real game changer.
00:14:39.440And I think it's going to put a lot of people on their toes in Ottawa.
00:15:04.300And I thought to myself, but they're also getting hundreds of thousands, if not millions of dollars in taxpayer funding from the Liberal government, who is having a scandal with the We Charity, who they're a media partner for.
00:15:17.360And my goodness, haven't we reached the point where our mainstream media has become so tied up in the people that they're supposed to be holding into account?
00:15:28.520How on earth could we expect them to do that hard work and to be tough when they're taking money from a bunch of different groups and are involved with a bunch of different groups who are highly questionable?
00:15:40.520So I'm looking, I think that the Independent Press Gallery has some really big things that it wants to accomplish.
00:15:47.760The first is, right now, media have been able to sort of gang up.
00:15:51.600Media and politicians have been able to gang up on independent media, deny them the right to attend certain press conferences and press events.
00:15:59.640You would think that mainstream media will be champions for independent journalists coming to cover these things.
00:16:05.980They look at independent media as the poor cousins that, frankly, don't play the game the way they're supposed to.
00:16:14.740Certainly, the prime minister has gone out of his way and his government has gone out of their way to keep independent media from covering major events.
00:16:23.600I know both the rebel and true north had to sue their way into covering, being able to cover the federal leaders' debates during the last federal election because the liberal government fought tooth and nail to prevent it.
00:16:36.980So I'm hoping that the whole strength by numbers argument is one of the things that the Independent Press Gallery will have going for it.
00:16:42.880It's no longer going to be a random series of independent media voices trying on their own.
00:16:49.440There's going to be a group of people working together to advance the cause of better journalism in Canada.
00:16:55.500And so, you know, the other thing I think is so funny is just how out of date the Parliamentary Press Gallery is when it comes to how they recognize media.
00:17:06.620These are people who, first of all, didn't want to let television into the Parliamentary Press Gallery.
00:17:11.440They don't want to, they don't recognize that, you know, journalism is now an online endeavor.
00:17:17.060They thought, you know, prevent online journalists from getting the same kind of access as others.
00:17:39.200You can, you know, go with the status quo and the mainstream media,
00:17:43.440or you can support a group who actually want to ask the hard questions.
00:17:46.920And, you know, to your credit, Sheila, a group of journalists in the mainstream media who often take the work you've done
00:17:52.320and then, you know, make it their own and claim that they wrote the story when we know that it was actually you who came up with that story first.
00:18:03.240And then they claim that they need, for example, in the CBC's case, $1.5 billion to basically newsjack what I did.
00:18:09.860Now let's, I want to move on to another area of your expertise, and that is the City of Calgary
00:18:19.140and how out of control the City of Calgary City Council is.
00:18:24.140Save Calgary, the little advocacy group that could.
00:18:28.120You guys have found eight different tax hikes and revenue grabs, tax grabs, fees that the City of Calgary is imposing on the long-suffering taxpayers of Calgary,
00:18:42.820homeowners of Calgary, facilities users in Calgary, in the midst of, and I say this all the time,
00:18:50.460the worst economic downturn in probably 100 years, and yet the City still has their hands in people's pockets.