00:00:00what the heck happened at the UN climate change conference in Turkey and how much money did
00:00:05Canadian taxpayers fork over for climate fear. I'm Sheila Gunn-Reed and you're watching The Gunn Show.
00:00:30Well, it is November, and that means it is the annual gathering of the United Nations Climate Change Conference.
00:00:37You'll hear it referred to as COP, and then they put another number behind it.
00:00:41COP, I think it's 31 this year, but it's, you know, where the world's leaders get together and they transfer wealth from wealthy first world nations to first and second world nations.
00:00:54so developing nations and they do it under the guise of climate change where they say to places0.63
00:00:59like canada you got to get off coal while giving money to china to continue to keep their coal
00:01:04mines open and of course it it costs us there's always billions of dollars in commitments taken
00:01:10from the pockets of struggling canadians to give to brazil to protect the rainforest um
00:01:17when maybe that should be a problem brazil deals with anyway joining me today is tom harris from
00:01:26the international climate science coalition and he's going to explain his new project to bring
00:01:30climate reality to the people and what happened in turkey when we weren't looking take a listen
00:01:47The idea that there is a climate crisis that we can somehow prevent by transitioning to alternative energy is leading to massive changes that seriously threaten our prosperity.
00:01:59Yet after 40 years and $16 trillion globally in expenditures, there's never been convincing proof that there's either a climate emergency or that humans can control climate in the first place.
00:02:17so joining me now is good friend of climate realism and good friend of rebel news
00:02:24tom harris from the international climate science coalition and as regular viewers of the show know
00:02:30it's november so that means it's climate advent the world gathers in uh you know a cloistered place
00:02:40in a far-flung place where everybody has to fly in on private jets to lecture us about our
00:02:45fossil fuel carbon footprint uh this year it was in turkey so we're going to talk about that but
00:02:51before i do uh tom tell us about your latest eight part series where you bring some truth
00:02:59and honesty to the climate discussion yeah for sure if people go to the canadians for sensible
00:03:03climate change or sorry canadians for sensible climate policy cscp website at sensiblechange.ca
00:03:10and they click on resources and then podcasts they'll come to the eight session podcast that
00:03:16we've actually just started three of the podcasts are up we've actually done five
00:03:20tomorrow i interview mark morano who's coming back from turkey he was he was there at cop 31
00:03:26and uh yeah so it's an attempt to give canadians the ammunition they need to actually fight against
00:03:32these silly climate plans of mark carney and and others and so far we've had linnea lucan she was
00:03:38in podcast number two she's speaking about the fact that wind and solar are not cheaper than
00:03:44fossil fuels that's for sure and of course there's all sorts of other problems in the number three
00:03:49we had john robson and he was talking about the silly idea that you've spoken to michelle sterling
00:03:55often about and that is carbon sequestration pumping co2 underground you know that's a fun
00:04:01interview uh richard de carrie is the next one he's uh it'll be up actually later today
00:04:07And what he talks about is how Quebec are finally starting to realize, oh, we have all
00:04:13this hydrocarbon resources, maybe we should develop it.
00:06:45There's no private sector proponents stepping up to participate in the building of this pipeline. There's only one pipeline company that's sort of on the engineering side consulting on it with 10% in. And there are no upstream oil and gas producers committing to supply the pipeline.
00:07:06Because you just can't say, okay, well, we're going to build a pipeline. You need oil to put in it. And so you need companies who are willing to commit capital and assets to put that oil into the pipeline. None of them have stepped forward. On the flip side, the Bridger-Southbow pipeline, which is dubbed Keystone XL Lite, that's full. That's full.
00:07:30It hasn't been completed yet, but the oil and gas companies have committed to fill it.
00:07:37So that tells you how the industry actually feels about the potential for this pipeline to go forward.
00:07:43Right. And they're likely to be much more pragmatic and practical than our media, than Mark Carney himself, because it's their money they're going to have to put up.
00:07:53And we have to remember, Mark Carney is not likely, you know, Leopard don't change their spots.
00:07:58I mean, he was he was the UN special envoy for climate change.
00:08:02He started this silly G fans organization, you know, concerning global financial initiatives to try and cripple our financial system with all kinds of silly restrictions on companies as to what they can do.0.83
00:08:16You know, so, I mean, he's had a long history and he wrote that book Values, you know, in which he's promoting the idea that we have to stop climate change.
00:08:24So to think that he's actually changed his spots, I don't think so.
00:08:27I think he knows there's and, you know, he may know exactly what you just said, that the companies aren't going to come forward anyway because it's too big a risk.
00:08:36Right. I mean, I'm glad you brought up GFANS because part of his job at GFANS was finding ways to make oil and gas projects unfinanceable or unfeasible through onerous banking restrictions and requirements.
00:08:51And so now he's doing that with this pipeline, throwing in all these little poison pills along the way, like expensive, outlandish, carbon capture, seeking approval, not consultation from Indigenous groups.
00:09:05These are poison pills where he could say, look, I supported the pipeline, but what do you want me to do?
00:09:10um so i mean the it's it feels doomed from the beginning and the only way that it will get built
00:09:19unfortunately is the least um is the least desirable way and that will be the way that
00:09:26trans mountain got built where taxpayers pony up 35 billion dollars to build a pipeline that was
00:09:33going to be built for five billion dollars in the private sector yeah it'll be very interesting to
00:09:37hear what Bob Lyman says in my podcast next week because you know he's very practical as well and
00:09:43he he recognizes these limitations and you know of course there's this OSPI group which Michelle
00:09:49and you have spoken about a lot the office of the superintendent of financial institutions
00:09:53they have something called guideline b15 and they're talking about all these requirements
00:09:58for reporting and believe it or not they're even talking about having scope three reporting
00:10:04So oil companies would have to look into how are their products being used by customers, you know, and tracking all that down, which to some extent is impossible.
00:10:12So, I mean, they have to just do estimates.
00:10:15But, yeah, there's so many hurdles that have to be overcome that I'll bet you anything Bob will agree with us on when I interview him next week.
00:10:23Well, it turns out there's four groups that are working together.
00:10:26It's the Canadians for Sensible Climate Policy, who are the leaders.
00:10:29They're actually hosting the podcast on their site.
00:10:32There's ourselves, ICSC Canada, the Heartland Institute.
00:10:36And interestingly enough, we have Richard de Carie.
00:10:38And you might remember Richard was a candidate for leadership of the Conservative Party.
00:10:43And he now has a very prominent YouTube podcast, I guess you call it.
00:10:49And it's Climatique Realisme, or something like that, which is really quite fun.
00:11:13If people go to sensiblechange.ca and then they scroll down a little bit, they have to go down one page and they click on resources and then podcast and it comes up right away.
00:11:25By the time this broadcast, it might actually be four.
00:11:28so we'll see how it goes well that's excellent i look forward to it um now i hinted off the top
00:11:36of the show that the u.n climate change conference is ongoing or close to wrapping up now in turkey
00:11:44uh there yes there are a couple of reasons why i wasn't there um one of them is that it was held
00:11:50in Turkey and I'm not accredited to be inside of the UN facilities which is generally fine by me
00:11:58it's very boring the real sort of investigative journalism happens outside of it but they are
00:12:05not friendly to journalists or anybody who is critical of the government for that matter and
00:12:11I would have ended up in the slammer so I thought it was better that I would spent my time going to
00:12:16Nigeria, of all places, to document the plight of the persecuted Christians there. But you have
00:12:23laid out what a hypocritical host Turkey is. And, you know, it's not just journalists that1.00
00:12:30they go around arresting. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Actually, there's two reasons why it's pretty
00:12:34hypocritical. You know, one of the main sort of focuses of COP are social justice themes. Okay,
00:12:40they talk about climate justice, fairness between countries, workers' rights, the concept of a just
00:12:45transition. But Turkey itself is a severe violator of human rights. You know, it's interesting
00:12:51because they've launched a, last September, they launched a nationwide operation to target LGBTI
00:12:57organizations, and they arrested over 100 people. A thousand social media accounts of activists and
00:13:03journals were blocked. Then in October, just last month, they raided and seized control of the
00:13:08opposition television station. They halted broadcasts, detained 11 people, and installed
00:13:14the government official at the station. You know, when the local people protest against all the
00:13:20mining that's going on in Turkey, well, what's the response? Authorities use tear gas, water
00:13:25cannons, and pepper spray to disperse non-violent protesters, followed by arrests and fines.0.74
00:13:31You know, so, I mean, it's ironic that Turkey would be promoting the whole idea of social0.97
00:13:36justice because they're one of the worst offenders. Yeah, and yet it's not mentioned0.99
00:13:43in the mainstream media none of the politicians are mentioning it they're just going there for
00:13:47their photo ops and to hand out money which we'll get to in a second but um you posed the question
00:13:54to me has the united nations given up yeah i hope so but i just want to add one thing and that is
00:14:01it's also weird from an energy um transition perspective that they're hosting it in turkey
00:14:07because turkey wants to become a major energy transmission hub okay they've announced things
00:14:13that actually result in a tripling of their natural gas fields in the in the black sea
00:14:18you know they're boosting coal they're promoting coal i love coal i think it's great if you use
00:14:23the right technology so yeah it's also a total contradiction actually that's interesting point
00:14:28because i was checking the last four cops three of them were at petro states and you were in
00:14:36right in brazil and now this is a state that wants to be a petro state so i mean what do
00:14:42you think's going on they keep having these cop events talking about an energy transition
00:14:47at countries that would never want an energy transition i and i think it's because it's not
00:14:54even about the environment anymore for the host countries that was the vibe at least i got when i
00:15:00was in poland i mean poland didn't even try they brought out the coal miners marching band
00:15:04to open up the event they hosted the event right across from the coal miners museum
00:15:12I think many of these countries just want the 30 to now whatever it is 80,000 delegates to
00:15:21converge on their region showcase the region basically it's a tourism trade show more than
00:15:29anything these days. So I don't begrudge some of these places for wanting to have 80,000 well-heeled
00:15:35delegates come and spend a bunch of money and use up the hotel rooms. I'm with you. I don't even
00:15:41think the UN's trying anymore. Well, that's right. And you look at some of the reductions in their
00:15:45targets. I think the biggest one is they finally admitted they have a report called the United
00:15:50Nations Environment Program Admissions Gap Report. OK, it's called the point of return.
00:15:55Maybe they should have said the point of no return.
00:15:58Anyway, they admit that limiting warming to 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial levels is no longer possible.
00:16:05In fact, Secretary General Antonio Gattari, he said that the mission now is to make the overshoot as small and as short as possible.
00:16:12Now, I think the next step, they'll say, well, you know, originally we actually agreed to two degrees.
00:16:17So now we're changing to, you know, so it's going to keep shifting.
00:16:21And there's no money, no additional money for new funding commitments at COP31. I think that's a big one, which is going to really stagnate the negotiations. But perhaps the funniest one is you might remember in Brazil, they published a voluntary roadmap to transition away from fossil fuels. And you remember it was blocked by Saudi Arabia and a number of other countries.
00:16:45well now brazil have come out with a new voluntary roadmap but official and i'll read this here but
00:16:51official stress that it was a call to voluntary action and not a document to be negotiated at
00:16:56cop 31 and in fact the phase out of fossil fuel is no longer even a formal agenda at the cop 31
00:17:03process they're saying now that the transition is tailored to the circumstances in individual
00:17:10countries which of course China and others will say well we're going to tailor it to promote coal
00:17:15because it's the cheapest and most effective energy source to pull our people out of poverty so
00:17:20I think that and you know the same thing with this electricity transition Canada sadly and we'll get
00:17:26to Canada's agreement shortly because it's kind of sick when you see the world backing away from it
00:17:31Canada's going all all nuts on it all in yeah giving more and more money but they have this
00:17:37thing that turkey proposed it was that globally there'd be electrification such that it's currently
00:17:4320 of world energy uh they're saying they want to have it 35 by 30 20 35 but they didn't specify
00:17:52how they're going to generate the coal or how they're going to generate the electricity and
00:17:56of course what's going to happen then is a lot of countries like turkey will say sure yeah we'll
00:18:00boost our electricity production by the way if canada tries it's not possible and we'll see that
00:18:06in a second but um but they're going to use coal so i mean people like al gore and others are saying
00:18:12what the heck you want to electrify but you're not telling them how you know so they want i mean
00:18:17gore and company wanted to be with uh wind and solar power but um yeah so i mean i think the u.n
00:18:23is is basically backing away they no longer even require that the delegates all agree to the final
00:18:28statement it can be a you know just a basic prep they call it a presidency led main decision for
00:18:35COP31, just put together by Australia and Turkey, who are the two main sort of sponsors. And the
00:18:41other countries may not even agree at all. So I think that, you know, Kearney and Canada are being
00:18:47tricked because the world, even the UN, are backing away from a lot of this. Although, as you point
00:18:53out, it's a wonderful tourist attraction. Yeah, it's great. Go see the cathedral that once was
00:19:01the seat of the holy roman empire like you know um if you're there um this is an aside something
00:19:09that you'd laugh at um my mom did our family tree back to before charlemagne and it turns out that
00:19:16we're actually descended from the holy roman emperor like there's probably there's probably
00:19:21about a million people who are so when people ask me what's your pronoun i say your majesty
00:19:57Um, I'll start caring about the Amazon trees when the people of Brazil do, because it was quite literally an ocean of garbage, um, in, in the Amazon river and the water flowed out into the ocean and passed the two cruise ships that they brought in for the delegates to stay in because, and this is no shade on the nice people of Bulem, but they wouldn't want to have stayed there.0.98
00:20:24The sanitation is at medieval levels there.0.98
00:20:28Most of the city is not hooked to a general sewer system.
00:20:31It's just a gutter system that flows into the street and then it rains because that's
00:20:36what they do in the rainforest and then it floods into outflows that backwash into the
00:27:29Yeah, and it's not even desirable because they're basically talking about replacing large amounts of gasoline in cars, diesel in trucks, natural gas in buildings, fossil fuels in industrial products.
00:27:41They want to replace all that with electricity, you know, which is nuts.
00:27:46I mean, we want to keep using gasoline in our cars.
00:27:49I have no desire to buy an EV, thank you very much, living here in Ottawa.
00:33:08they were trying to get climate change to be number one. And it came back after 9.8 million
00:33:14voters, mostly in developing countries, that climate change was dead last. And not by a little
00:33:22bit. It was hugely dead last, like half or something of the higher candidates, the higher
00:33:27things that were considered important. Because if you're lacking fresh water, electricity,
00:33:33security, if you're in the middle of a war, and you don't have a job, those things obviously
00:33:38come way way above any concerns about climate change in the year 2100 and you know even in
00:33:44developed countries it wasn't the top issue no so the UN you know what they did is they pulled the
00:33:50poll off of the website but happily I got a screen capture I'll email it to you for fun
00:33:56I got a screen capture which showed the results after over 9 million votes
00:34:01of votes around the world and it was dead last climate change well and if you ask the un there's
00:34:09nothing climate change can't do um you know again going back to my nigeria experience the united
00:34:16nations says that the violence perpetrated by the islamic fulani militias against the christian
00:34:23villagers there is driven by climate change which caused scarcity of resources climate change isn't
00:34:30dragging the priests out of the pulpit and killing them in the streets that's islamic
00:34:36radicalism but they aren't just blaming climate change for everything now yeah and i guess that0.93
00:34:40is a real genocide in contrast to gaza right 100 percent um tom uh we're over the 30 minute mark
00:34:49although i could talk to you all day and it's been too long since i did um tell people it always is0.64
00:34:54tell people how they can find out more about your work for international climate science
00:34:59coalition canada sure i'll direct you to three websites america out loud dot news because on
00:35:05america out loud dot news if you click on podcasts we have a weekly podcast they're called the other
00:35:10side of the story our home page is icsc-canada.com and i alert people go to set plan sensible change
00:35:19dot ca click on resources podcasts and you can follow the series it's going to be especially
00:35:25interesting tomorrow to see what mark morano has to say about cop 31 he's a fire he's so fun
00:35:30he's so fun he's a riot you know he goes into those places and it really raises cane
00:35:35oh when we were in germany for the climate change conference i ran into him there he was dressed as
00:35:42the captain of the love boat and he was going to board the greenpeace ship oh because the night
00:35:49before they had illegally boarded a coal barge that was going through uh on the river there
00:35:55behind the climate change conference all day long just coal barges going back and forth nobody seemed
00:36:00to notice except me and so they had illegally boarded a coal barge the night before so he
00:36:05thought what's good for the goose is good for the gander and he got his little costume and he went0.99
00:36:10to board the green piece with their little stupid little boat that was there they called the cops0.94
00:36:15Well, people have got to check out his website because it's covered with COP31 videos and all sorts of things. It's really quite exciting webpages, climatedepot.com. You know, it's run by CFAC, Committee for a Constructive Tomorrow. And they're a wonderful group. They even parachuted into one of the COP meetings, you know, so they are dynamic, that's for sure. So he's going to be fun. People should check it out when I interview him, probably be up in about a week.0.87
00:36:40yes uh tom thanks so much for coming on the show we'll have you back on again very soon
00:36:47i know it's been too long um but we're both very busy people okay well thank you sheila
00:36:53well the last portion of the show always goes to you at home because without you there is no rebel
00:37:05news i'll give you my email address right now at sheila at rebelnews.com if you've got viewer
00:37:09feedback for my interview with tom harris from the international climate science coalition canada
00:37:14send it to me at sheila at rebelnews.com and i look forward to hearing from you but don't let
00:37:21that be the only way that you get in contact with us for example if you are watching our other
00:37:26videos clips of my show on youtube or rumble leave a comment there it helps us in a couple of
00:37:32different ways um so it helps us get higher in the youtube algorithms or the rumble algorithms
00:37:39it shows that our content is more engaged with. And so because of that, they show it to more
00:37:45people, they say, Oh, people like this, maybe more people like that. So that helps us, because it
00:37:52helps us spread the message. Because I'm just not talking to, you know, the converted, I don't want1.00
00:38:00to preach to the choir, I want to change hearts and minds. So doing that helps us. But it also
00:38:06well, get us closer to 2 million YouTube subscribers. This little network that could
00:38:10is like this close to 2 million YouTube subscribers. So I would love it if you could
00:38:16help us do that. Now, today's comments come to me by way of the YouTube comment section on my
00:38:23friend Lise Merle's video about what happened in the aftermath of kids in Regina and the greater
00:38:34Regina area, being taken to see a sexually explicit show called Little Red Warrior and
00:38:41His Lawyer. They were taken there under the guise of reconciliation and the arts. What they were
00:38:49exposed to was a sexually explicit drag show, which actually, as we find out, engaged in contact with
00:38:57one of the students. And so we got all the internal emails. Lise goes through them meticulously.
00:39:04Friends, it is like a 24-minute video, but it's riveting because it's so detailed.