Trump's triumphant speech at Davos shows the world how to act like a leader
Episode Stats
Words per minute
151.20381
Harmful content
Misogyny
15
sentences flagged
Hate speech
10
sentences flagged
Summary
Trump's speech to the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland is actually a great one, which is why the media won't show it anywhere. Trudeau's speech is hollow, vain, narcissistic, and full of empty platitudes.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hey there, today I've got a podcast I think you're going to like, mainly because I don't
00:00:07.080
I want to show you his speech that he gave at the Davos World Economic Forum the other
00:00:11.740
day, and I bet you have not heard this speech anywhere because why on earth would the media
00:00:17.600
I mean, it's actually a great speech, which is why they don't want to show it to you.
00:00:22.480
I give you my thoughts in between various segments.
00:00:25.520
I'd encourage you to become a premium subscriber.
00:00:29.740
Just go to premium.rebelnews.com, and it's basically this podcast with me and visual
00:00:36.100
elements, clips, audio charts, stuff like that, and of course I interview a guest every day
00:00:42.780
You also get Sheila Gunn-Reed's show and David Menzies' show, so I think it's well worth the
00:00:59.040
Tonight, Donald Trump goes to Davos and does his job talking about America's economy,
00:01:14.200
It's January 23rd, and this is the Ezra Levant Show.
00:01:17.080
Why should others go to jail when you're a biggest carbon consumer I know?
00:01:22.860
There's 8,500 customers here, and you won't give them an answer.
00:01:26.920
The only thing I have to say to the government about why I publish it is because it's my bloody
00:01:32.780
Every January, the world's business elites gather in the town of Davos, Switzerland, for a giant
00:01:44.680
jamboree of wealth and power called the World Economic Forum.
00:01:49.280
Billionaires go there, corporate tycoons, but also politicians and other grifters, schemers,
00:01:56.320
They smell the wealth and the power and want to get in on it.
00:01:59.860
Just months after Trudeau was elected in late 2015, he went to Davos.
00:02:05.540
Here's a picture of that meeting with George Soros there.
00:02:10.440
Look at how Trudeau was sitting and how Soros was sitting.
00:02:21.820
They assigned Aaron Wherry to do stories about Justin Trudeau's socks.
00:02:29.820
Imagine going to journalism school, getting hired by a media company and being assigned
00:02:36.340
That's North Korea-style state broadcaster cult behavior.
00:02:41.520
I don't know if there's a connection between Jeffrey Epstein and Davos, but it's that kind
00:02:46.200
Kevin Spacey, the accused molester, loves to go to Davos.
00:02:50.100
He was with Trudeau and Aaron Wherry at a party, and Aaron Wherry was so excited to
00:02:57.400
Prince Andrew, who was fired by the Queen for his activities with Epstein, he used to
00:03:06.020
He's a head of government, but there's no there there.
00:03:10.700
Normally, it's the empty celebrities like Kevin Spacey who have to impress with things like
00:03:15.920
The heads of government, the heads of business, actually go to talk government and business.
00:03:26.300
But you need to take as much effort to talk to your sons, my eight-year-old boy and my
00:03:31.900
two-year-old, so little young still, about how he treats women and how he is going to
00:03:36.940
be grown up to be a feminist just like Dad.
0.99
00:03:39.600
Imagine having the world's investors in a room and talking about what a feminist you
1.00
00:03:44.780
This from the groper, the fireer of Jody Wilson-Raybould and any other woman who got in his way.
00:03:53.020
It's not really Donald Trump's kind of place, I don't think.
00:03:57.660
Before Donald Trump ran for president, he was a celebrity, too.
00:04:07.940
They'd all have loved him before, but they all hate him now.
00:04:12.420
But still, he went this week and he gave a speech.
00:04:14.900
And it was completely opposite the hollow, vain, narcissistic, woke emptiness of Trudeau's
00:04:21.600
I want to play some clips of Trump's speech for you because I am completely certain the
00:04:25.460
CBC did not show you any of this, and you'll see why.
00:04:28.240
When I spoke at this forum two years ago, I told you that we had launched the great American
00:04:36.520
Today, I'm proud to declare that the United States is in the midst of an economic boom,
00:04:43.540
the likes of which the world has never seen before.
00:04:47.600
We've regained our stride, rediscovered our spirit, and reawakened the powerful machinery
00:05:00.640
And yes, America is winning again like never before.
00:05:05.500
Now, it's a room full of arrogant, vain narcissists, true.
00:05:08.860
But in some cases, I guess they have good reason to be arrogant and vain.
00:05:12.680
I mean, if you're a billionaire, if you're a head of state, if you're royalty, if you're
00:05:15.760
a superstar, you have some reason to be proud, even too proud.
00:05:19.100
But the thing about Davos is that they all fake being woke and selfless and righteous.
00:05:23.900
They all flew there on their private jets, but they're all nodding along piously to St.
00:05:31.140
So yeah, they're all rich and powerful and proud, but unlike Trump, they don't dare say
00:05:35.800
who they are, either because they're too politically correct, or they lack the courage to be who
00:05:40.180
they are, or they support Greta and the other woke ideologies simply because those are great
00:05:45.740
ways to increase your power over people through laws or regulations or taxes.
00:05:50.680
Don't think Greta isn't being used by various power.
00:05:56.560
Just last week alone, the United States concluded two extraordinary trade deals.
00:06:02.040
The agreement with China and the United States-Mexico-Canada agreement, the two biggest trade deals
00:06:11.580
They just happened to get done in the same week.
00:06:13.440
These agreements represent a new model of trade for the 21st century, agreements that
00:06:20.700
are fair, reciprocal, and that prioritize the needs of workers and families.
00:06:27.340
America's economic turnaround has been nothing short of spectacular.
00:06:32.920
Who would have imagined that Apple would be building computer factories in America?
00:06:37.420
And though I wish Trump drove a harder bargain on China, he got more from them than anyone
1.00
00:06:42.660
I think he's the first one to even try by staring them down, by tariffing them, by speaking
00:06:47.600
truth to power, and by showing that he isn't scared of them.
00:06:50.520
He literally warned China about getting too tough with Hong Kong right in the middle of
00:06:58.080
But it also showed China that Trump simply didn't care if they pouted or if they quit the
00:07:07.820
He's pushed China's economic growth to its lowest in a generation.
00:07:14.240
And it's a good message for Trump to take to the blue-collar Rust Belt states in 2020,
00:07:19.240
that unlike the Democrats, Trump actually went to fight China and he won.
00:07:24.880
When I took office three years ago, America's economy was in a rather dismal state.
00:07:31.220
Under the previous administration, nearly 200,000 manufacturing jobs had vanished.
00:07:41.460
Almost 5 million more Americans had left the labor force than had gotten jobs, and more
00:07:47.220
than 10 million people had been added to the food stamp rolls.
00:07:51.500
The experts predicted a decade of very, very slow growth, or maybe even negative growth,
00:07:59.680
high unemployment and a dwindling workforce, and very much a shrinking middle class.
00:08:07.880
Millions of hardworking, ordinary citizens felt neglected, betrayed, forgotten.
00:08:18.940
Before my presidency began, the outlook for many nations was bleak.
00:08:24.760
Top economists warned of a protracted worldwide recession.
00:08:29.620
The World Bank lowered its projections for global growth to a number that nobody wanted to even think about.
00:08:36.860
Pessimism had taken root deep in the minds of leading thinkers, business leaders, and policy makers.
00:08:45.720
He goes on like that, but let me stop for a moment.
00:08:49.000
I don't know if you remember, but Barack Obama was asked why he doesn't have growth in factories and jobs.
00:09:06.040
He just says, well, I'm going to negotiate a better deal.
00:09:09.440
Well, how exactly are you going to negotiate that?
00:09:18.380
I wish we had someone in Canada who cared about jobs the same way Trump does.
00:09:24.820
We would be if we were building $100 billion worth of oil and gas and pipeline projects that Trudeau has killed.
00:09:32.980
For the first time in decades, we are no longer simply concentrating wealth in the hands of a few.
00:09:40.080
We're concentrating and creating the most inclusive economy ever to exist.
00:09:45.980
We are lifting up Americans of every race, color, religion, and creed.
00:09:51.020
Unemployment rates among African Americans, Hispanic Americans, and Asian Americans have all reached record lows.
00:10:00.680
African American youth unemployment has reached the lowest it's ever been in the history of our country.
00:10:08.220
African American poverty has plummeted to the lowest rate ever recorded.
00:10:12.920
The unemployment rate for women reached the lowest level since 1953, and women now comprise a majority of the American workforce.
00:10:26.240
The unemployment rate for veterans has dropped to a record low.
00:10:30.700
The unemployment rate for disabled Americans has reached an all-time record low.
00:10:36.680
Workers without a high school diploma have achieved the lowest unemployment rate recorded in U.S. history.
00:10:45.600
Wages are rising across the board, and those at the bottom of the income ladder are enjoying the percentage by far largest gains.
00:10:55.720
Workers' wages are now growing faster than management wages.
00:11:02.060
Earnings growth for the bottom 10% is outpacing the top 10%, something that has not happened.
00:11:10.740
Paychecks for high school graduates are rising faster than for college graduates.
00:11:16.640
When was the last time that any politician on the left spoke that way?
00:11:20.160
Actually cared about blue-collar workers, outdoor workers, manual laborers, skilled trades, truck drivers.
00:11:25.800
You can't if you prefer the environmentalists set to the working class.
00:11:30.060
If you're for a carbon tax, you hate coal miners.
1.00
00:11:34.540
I like that phrase Trump used at the beginning of that clip.
00:11:37.680
You know, Jeremy Corbyn's U.K. Labor Party had the slogan,
00:11:45.140
For the first time in decades, we are no longer simply concentrating wealth in the hands of a few.
00:11:52.460
We're concentrating and creating the most inclusive economy ever to exist.
00:11:58.380
We are lifting up Americans of every race, color, religion, and creed.
00:12:04.680
Unemployment rates among African Americans, Hispanic Americans, and Asian Americans have all reached record lows.
00:12:12.160
African American youth unemployment has reached the lowest it's ever been in the history of our country.
00:12:20.580
African American poverty has plummeted to the lowest rate ever recorded.
00:12:25.720
The unemployment rate for women reached the lowest level since 1953,
00:12:30.920
and women now comprise a majority of the American workforce.
0.98
00:12:37.820
The unemployment rate for veterans has dropped to a record low.
00:12:43.360
The unemployment rate for disabled Americans has reached an all-time record low.
00:12:49.980
Workers without a high school diploma have achieved the lowest unemployment rate recorded in U.S. history.
00:13:00.280
and those at the bottom of the income ladder are enjoying the percentage by far largest gains.
00:13:09.260
Workers' wages are now growing faster than management wages.
00:13:14.440
Earnings growth for the bottom 10% is outpacing the top 10%,
00:13:23.100
Paychecks for high school graduates are rising faster than for college graduates.
00:13:34.180
They prefer the myth that America is about rapacious capitalists in top hats, the 1%.
00:13:39.460
They like historically illiterate leftists better,
00:13:43.860
like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez calling for socialism,
00:13:47.440
even though capitalism is what's actually lifting up poor people.
00:13:50.900
We have created 1.2 million manufacturing and construction jobs,
00:13:58.420
After losing 60,000 factories under the previous two administrations,
00:14:03.940
hard to believe when you hear 60,000 factories,
00:14:09.280
America has now gained in a very short period of time 12,000 new factories under my administration,
00:14:16.080
and the number is going up rapidly, we'll be beating the 60,000 number that we lost,
00:14:22.260
except these will be bigger, newer, and the latest.
00:14:26.700
It must be nice to have a country that lets you build things without a gender analysis first.
1.00
00:14:32.560
Gender impact, how does that fit into a pipeline approval process?
0.99
00:14:35.240
So I'm really glad you asked that, because I think people are like,
00:14:38.780
Well, imagine that you have a huge number of people going to a remote community, many men.
00:14:48.580
What is the impact on women in the community?
1.00
00:14:50.580
And actually, once again, smart proponents understand this,
00:14:55.600
It's just taking a smart approach to thinking about,
00:14:58.100
okay, what's going to be the impact of a major development in a particular area?
00:15:08.780
But then he talks about nationalism as opposed to globalism.
00:15:13.640
And this is what surely bothered the George Soros set the most.
00:15:17.180
A nation's highest duty is to its own citizens.
00:15:21.800
Honoring this truth is the only way to build faith and confidence in the market system.
00:15:27.280
Only when governments put their own citizens first
00:15:30.500
will people be fully invested in their national futures.
00:15:35.020
In the United States, we are building an economy that works for everyone,
00:15:41.520
restoring the bonds of love and loyalty that unite citizens and powers nations.
00:15:49.020
Today, I hold up the American model as an example to the world of a working system,
00:15:55.100
a free enterprise that will produce the most benefits for the most people in the 21st century and beyond.
00:16:03.060
A pro-worker, pro-citizen, pro-family agenda demonstrates how a nation can thrive
00:16:08.760
when its communities, its companies, its government, and its people work together for the good of the whole nation.
00:16:15.960
How opposite to Trudeau, who cares for foreign countries more than he cares for entire provinces
00:16:24.840
Trudeau loves the UN, certainly more than he loves Alberta.
00:16:31.040
Trump is doing one thing Stephen Harper didn't do.
00:16:37.340
Harper could have completely remade the judiciary in Canada over his nine years, but he didn't.
00:16:42.500
Some of that blame goes to Peter McKay, his former justice minister,
00:16:46.100
who's now running for the Tory leader in Canada.
00:16:48.940
We are also restoring the constitutional rule of law in America,
00:16:52.980
which is essential to our economy, our liberty, and our future.
00:16:58.860
And that's why we've appointed over 190 federal judges, a record, to interpret the law as written.
00:17:08.300
190 federal judges, think of that, and two Supreme Court judges.
00:17:11.760
Hey, could you imagine Trudeau even saying the following words?
00:17:17.400
To every business looking for a place where they are free to invest, build, thrive, innovate, and succeed.
00:17:23.920
There is no better place on earth than the United States.
00:17:27.920
Yeah, no, yeah, Trudeau preferred to talk about his own feminism.
00:17:31.440
You've got a room full of billionaires, and you talk about your own feminism.
1.00
00:17:35.860
Before I was elected, China's predatory practices were undermining trade for everyone.
00:17:42.340
But no one did anything about it except allow it to keep getting worse and worse and worse.
00:17:49.380
Under my leadership, America confronted the problem head-on.
00:17:52.640
Under our new Phase 1 agreement, Phase 2 is starting negotiations very shortly.
00:17:59.460
China has agreed to substantially do things that they would not have done,
00:18:05.640
measures to protect intellectual property, stop forced technology transfers,
00:18:12.540
remove trade barriers, remove trade barriers and agricultural goods and on agricultural goods where
00:18:18.460
we were treated so badly, open its financial sector totally, that's done,
00:18:24.620
and maintain a stable currency, all backed by very, very strong enforcement.
00:18:31.180
Our relationship with China right now has probably never been better.
00:18:36.120
We went through a very rough patch, but it's never, ever been better.
00:18:40.140
My relationship with President Xi is an extraordinary one.
00:18:44.740
He's for China, I'm for the U.S., but other than that, we love each other.
0.96
00:18:51.760
I think Xi Jinping hates Trump very much, and I think Trump loves beating up on Xi Jinping.
00:18:58.360
I mean, he's doing it right here, right now in this speech.
00:19:01.480
It's Trump's way of saying he'll fight you, and he'll keep fighting you,
00:19:08.400
That's a man who's negotiated a thousand deals, tiny and huge, in his career.
00:19:14.760
One of the toughest industries in the world, New York City real estate.
00:19:18.180
I mean, if you're not dealing with the unions, you're dealing with the mob,
00:19:21.160
you're dealing with government regulators, you're dealing with competitors.
00:19:25.060
Imagine how tough it is to do business in Manhattan.
00:19:37.880
To protect our security and our economy, we are also boldly embracing American energy independence.
00:19:44.500
The United States is now, by far, the number one producer of oil and natural gas anywhere in the world.
00:19:52.940
While many European countries struggle with crippling energy costs,
00:19:57.500
the American energy revolution is saving American families $2,500 every year in lowering electric bills and numbers that people said couldn't happen.
00:20:10.940
And also, very importantly, prices at the pump.
00:20:14.640
We've been so successful that the United States no longer needs to import energy from hostile nations.
00:20:22.540
With an abundance of American natural gas now available, our European allies no longer have to be vulnerable to unfriendly energy suppliers either.
00:20:33.500
We urge our friends in Europe to use America's vast supply and achieve true energy security.
00:20:42.260
With U.S. companies and researchers leading the way, we are on the threshold of virtually unlimited reserves of energy,
00:20:50.920
including from traditional fuels, LNG, clean coal, next generation nuclear power, and gas hydrate technologies.
00:20:59.980
You wouldn't know it, but Canada actually has about five times the oil reserves in the United States.
00:21:05.380
We have more oil in Canada than any other country besides Venezuela or Saudi Arabia,
00:21:09.980
but we produce a fraction of what America does.
00:21:14.760
Instead, we're bringing in carbon taxes, calling for gender analysis of projects,
0.89
00:21:19.340
and importing oil from Saudi Arabia and from America by rail, if you can believe it.
00:21:24.900
And you know, when Trump talks about the environment, and he does, he doesn't talk about made-up problems like a puff of carbon dioxide,
00:21:33.060
which is not a real problem. It's not pollution. It's natural.
00:21:36.680
Donald Trump talks about, you know, the environment.
00:21:39.980
At the same time, I'm proud to report the United States is among the cleanest air and drinking water on Earth,
00:21:48.520
And we just came out with a report that, at this moment, it's the cleanest it's been in the last 40 years.
00:21:56.020
We're committed to conserving the majesty of God's creation and the natural beauty of our world.
00:22:03.720
Today, I'm pleased to announce the United States will join One Trillion Trees Initiative,
00:22:09.720
being launched here at the World Economic Forum.
00:22:15.640
And in doing so, we will continue to show strong leadership in restoring, growing,
00:22:30.540
We have a trillion trees in our northern forests already.
00:22:33.960
We don't actually have to plant any more trees at all, ever, in our future.
00:22:39.200
We have more trees than we ever need, ever will need.
00:22:41.760
But at least, at least if Trudeau were planting trees, he wouldn't be destroying the country, killing jobs,
00:22:48.340
and I suppose we'd have some pretty parks in the cities.
00:22:51.100
Instead, we've got a global warming cult leader who believes that oil is actually evil.
00:22:56.600
This is the opposite of Trudeau's climate cult.
00:22:59.380
This is the opposite of Greta Thunberg shouting at everyone.
1.00
00:23:15.800
because this is a time for tremendous hope and joy and optimism and action.
00:23:20.640
But to embrace the possibilities of tomorrow, we must reject the perennial prophets of doom
00:23:30.520
They are the heirs of yesterday's foolish fortune-tellers.
00:23:35.160
And I have them, and you have them, and we all have them.
00:23:38.040
And they want to see us do badly, but we don't let that happen.
00:23:42.500
They predicted an overpopulation crisis in the 1960s, mass starvation in the 70s, and an end of oil in the 1990s.
00:23:54.180
These alarmists always demand the same thing, absolute power to dominate, transform, and control every aspect of our lives.
00:24:01.740
We will never let radical socialists destroy our economy, wreck our country, or eradicate our liberty.
00:24:10.520
America will always be the proud, strong, and unyielding bastion of freedom.
00:24:16.400
In America, we understand what the pessimists refuse to see.
00:24:22.040
That a growing and vibrant market economy, focused on the future, lifts the human spirit,
00:24:28.000
and excites creativity, strong enough to overcome any challenge, any challenge by far.
00:24:38.740
And he's not mean most of the time in this speech.
00:24:46.120
Centuries ago, at the time of the Renaissance, skilled craftsmen and laborers looked upwards
00:24:52.800
and built the structures that still touch the human heart.
00:24:58.300
To this day, some of the greatest structures in the world have been built hundreds of years
00:25:04.880
In Italy, the citizens once started construction on what would be a 140-year project.
00:25:14.000
The Duomo of Florence, incredible, incredible place.
00:25:21.200
While the technology did not yet exist to complete their design, city fathers forged ahead anyway,
00:25:32.200
These citizens of Florence did not accept limits to their high aspirations.
00:25:41.320
In France, another century-long project continues to hold such a grip on our hearts and our souls
0.95
00:25:48.200
that even 800 years after its construction, when the cathedral of Notre-Dame was engulfed in flames
00:25:58.940
Such a sad sight to watch, unbelievable sight, especially for those of us that considered
00:26:05.480
it one of the great, great monuments and representing so many different things.
00:26:12.200
The whole world grieved through her sanctuary, now stands scorched and charred and a sight that's
00:26:27.440
When you got used to it, to look at it now, hard to believe.
00:26:31.760
But we know that Notre-Dame will be restored, will be restored magnificently.
00:26:40.440
The great bells will once again ring out for all to hear, giving glory to God and filling
00:26:51.880
All right, I've shown you a lot, but I wanted to because I know no other media in Canada
00:26:55.220
and precious few in the U.S. media party would show you.
00:26:59.900
Above all else, we will forever be loyal to our workers, our citizens, and our families,
00:27:05.580
the men and women who are the backbone of our economies, the heart of our communities,
00:27:14.020
Let us bring light to their lives one by one and empower them to light up the world.
00:27:25.640
God bless your countries and God bless America.
00:27:29.020
Yeah, that's what a world leader sounds like, America's leader, but also the leader of the
00:27:36.580
He praises himself, sure, but mainly he praises his country and its workers and builders and
00:27:50.020
Well, in nine days, the United Kingdom will formally leave the European Union.
00:28:08.660
It was a referendum that passed in 2016, even before Donald Trump was elected.
00:28:14.760
But finally, Brexit will happen at 11 p.m. on January 31st.
00:28:21.040
Wexit is being discussed seriously in Alberta and Western Canada in reaction to Eastern Canada's
00:28:32.420
And of course, for decades, Quebec has talked about secession.
00:28:36.620
Well, is anyone talking about the United States?
00:28:42.080
As anyone who compares the politics of, say, Silicon Valley with that of the heartland
00:28:50.140
Well, now, a new book suggests that perhaps there's a time to break up the United States.
00:28:56.780
It's a shocking thesis, and it's in a book called American Secession, The Looming Threat
00:29:05.800
The author is a guest who's appeared on our show several times before to great audience
00:29:12.560
I'm talking about Professor Frank Buckley, a professor at George Mason University's Scalia
00:29:20.420
We've talked to him in the past about his book, The Republican Workers' Party, Fascinating
00:29:24.780
Thesis, and I'm delighted that he joins us now via Skype.
00:29:32.040
American secession, it would not have come to mind.
00:29:34.660
I mean, America, by so many measures, is a great success.
00:29:38.400
Why do you think American secession is something that needs to be considered?
00:29:44.280
Well, maybe it's because I'm here, Ezra, as a refugee from Quebec.
00:29:48.420
So secession, and I'm originally from Saskatchewan, so secession seems perfectly natural.
00:29:55.060
I mean, it's the history of pretty much the whole world.
00:29:58.380
Well, the whole world is pretty much staring down a secession movement, and we've been
00:30:04.960
But on the other hand, we've never been so divided.
00:30:07.200
I mean, we were frankly, I think, less divided in 1860 in many ways.
00:30:11.260
But we've got the wokiest parts of the country in places like Oregon and California, and then
00:30:21.180
you've got some more traditional states, like, well, my own used to be that way, in Virginia.
00:30:28.960
And yet we think we can have one set of laws for the whole darn country, and it's not working
00:30:38.380
And so I think for a lot of reasons, we should expect to see something like a secession movement.
00:30:45.940
And the great thing is, this time it'll be politically correct, because we'll see it from
00:30:53.840
I mean, you know, as you're aware, politics in America have become crazy, and I have a
00:31:02.420
Back in 1992, Irving Kristol said the culture wars are over, the left won.
00:31:07.840
Then Donald Trump got elected in 2016, and at that point, it became clear that, you know,
00:31:14.000
the left had not quite won the war and may indeed be losing the war.
00:31:18.560
And as that happens, I think the left is going to start wondering, do we really want to be
00:31:23.520
a part of a country when we think half of its members are deplorable?
00:31:28.340
And, you know, and the divisions are geographic, right?
00:31:31.780
I mean, they weren't totally geographic here in 1860.
00:31:35.780
Virginia took three votes on secession in 1861, and the first two failed, and it was only when
00:31:41.900
Lincoln called up the troops that the third one passed.
00:31:44.720
And as for us, take a look at that 2016 map of how we voted, and it's not just that there
00:31:51.760
are reds and blues that are very geographic, but the reds are deep reds, and the blues are
00:31:56.840
deep blues, and the sense of alienation from the other part of America is very strong.
00:32:02.960
Well, listen, I get what you're saying, and if you look at a county-level map of red and blue,
00:32:11.120
and we'll put that on the screen now, I mean, Donald Trump enjoys looking at this map because
00:32:14.900
if you just measure county by county, almost the entire map is red, but those blue counties in the
00:32:22.960
big cities in New York, Chicago, California's cities, especially San Francisco, but also LA,
00:32:32.320
they are geographically small, but like you say, they're extremely liberal. Like, I don't know what
00:32:37.220
the math was in Manhattan, but I'd be shocked if the Republicans got 10% there, and that's Donald
00:32:42.020
Trump's home borough. So, I mean, really, aren't you talking about a separation of some cities?
00:32:49.860
I have not had a chance to tuck into your book yet, but it's very interesting. I mean, Singapore
00:32:55.300
is a city-state. Hong Kong used to be a city-state. Is that really the answer? Get Manhattan out of
00:33:02.380
things, get San Francisco and LA and Chicago out of things, maybe Miami, and the rest is one big
00:33:07.520
right-wing country? Well, you're right. The states themselves are very divided. If secession were to
00:33:14.000
happen, however, it would be on a statewide basis. You'd see a referendum in some place like California,
00:33:22.240
and obviously, there'd be a lot of people who disagree, but nevertheless, it would be a state-led
00:33:27.220
initiative. On the other hand, as you note, there are pockets of, you know, unionists in California,
00:33:35.440
for example. So another possibility here would be if California actually proceeded with it,
00:33:42.400
you'll see movements for breakups within a state as well. New York upstate would be totally unionist,
00:33:50.160
on my scenario, and, you know, Manhattan, the New York City itself would be separatist. Staten Island
00:33:58.660
would be totally unionist. So you'd get the kind of divisions where people in San Diego County would
00:34:06.520
be asked, do you really want to be part of the same state as Los Angeles? And I think we know what
00:34:11.740
the answer is. So, you know, the jigsaw puzzle can break up that way. Well, let me ask you this. I'm,
00:34:18.620
I mean, I admire America, but I am not American. I don't have a deep knowledge of the Civil War. I know
00:34:25.040
two things about it. First of all, it was by far the bloodiest of all of America's wars. In fact,
00:34:31.000
if I'm not mistaken, more Americans died in the Civil War than all other wars combined. Correct me
0.97
00:34:35.420
if I'm wrong on that, Professor. And it's the pain of that and the legacy of that continues to this day.
00:34:44.760
So to, to propose secession, I'm not sure if you're quite proposing it as much as observing it.
00:34:51.160
Let me start by asking a basic question. Is it even legal? I mean, I don't think Abraham Lincoln
00:34:57.320
thought it was legal. Is it legal for a state to leave the union?
00:35:02.380
Well, two questions there. One is, would it be bloody as the Civil War was bloodied? My answer
00:35:07.700
is no. And, you know, here I am channeling my experience in Quebec. There was violence in Quebec
00:35:14.800
in the 1960s and early 70s, but the violence completely stopped when the hotheads realized
00:35:22.100
they could get their way through legal means, through secession. Right? So there's no violence
00:35:26.880
in Quebec after 1976 and the election of the PQ government. You know, the other thing is,
00:35:33.080
well, what about the Anglos in Quebec? Well, you know, you, you know the story well, so do all
00:35:37.920
Canadians, right? We English Montrealers spoke of bill 101 and how it suppressed English rights,
00:35:45.260
but we also called it bill 401, right? Because we thought, you know, what's going to happen is
00:35:51.260
we'll take the 401 down to Toronto, which about 300,000 English Montrealers did. You know, so my,
00:35:58.120
you know, my, my advice, my suggestion is don't worry about violence, but buy stock and U-Haul.
00:36:04.280
The next question is, is this illegal? You know, and, and the, the Supreme Court in 1868,
00:36:13.960
once the civil war was good and over said, secession is illegal. But if you had to look
00:36:19.280
at this prospectively, right, before there was a conflict, I think the Supreme Court might well
00:36:27.560
hesitate before empowering the president to send in the troops and invade the way they
00:36:34.260
invaded my Alexandria in April, 1861. And Virginia was unionist until it saw itself under attack.
00:36:44.560
So I, you know, so I, I don't think anybody would want to create an Abraham Lincoln again. I mean,
00:36:51.460
we'd be more likely to see a James Buchanan. But the other thing here is if it, you know,
00:36:56.400
this would inevitably end up before the Supreme Court. And I think two, two things would happen.
00:37:02.120
Number one, the originalists on the Supreme Court would recall that the framers of the Constitution
00:37:09.640
believed that the country could split apart. They, they didn't believe that there was an
00:37:14.400
indissoluble union. They actively contemplated a breakup of the country that was very much on the table.
00:37:21.380
The other thing that might, that the US Supreme Court might look to, frankly, is the Canadian Supreme
00:37:30.100
Court on the clarity reference. And what the Canadian Supreme Court said, I thought made a heck of a lot
00:37:35.860
of sense. It said, number one, there's no absolute right of secession. On the other hand, a secession
00:37:41.940
referendum is not a nullity. But rather, it's a sort of thing that should get people talking.
00:37:47.300
And if people started talking once there were, it was a secession referendum. Well, you know, at that
00:37:55.060
point, a number of things would be on the table, like how do you split up the federal debt? But, you know,
00:38:00.740
also, you know, a kind of renewed federalism of the kind we used to enjoy before the federal government
00:38:09.860
thought it could rule everything. And before the US Supreme Court, you know, armed with the idea of an
00:38:16.420
expansionary imperialistic liberalism, saw fit to dictate what our laws as to abortion and the like
00:38:24.900
should be. So, you know, we're not going to want to do the civil rights revolution in any state.
00:38:30.820
But, you know, if Alabama wants to tighten laws as to abortion, I don't see why California should have
00:38:42.420
In Canada, the secession movement in Quebec, which is now 50 years old, or older actually,
00:38:51.460
drained so much energy and attention and morale and focus. And it hijacked so much of the national
00:38:59.540
conversation. And I sense that WEXIT, Western Canada, seeking an independent status, if unchecked,
00:39:07.220
will do the same. It just seems, I mean, there may have been legitimate grievances in Quebec.
00:39:13.860
I believe there are legitimate grievances in Western Canada. But I know that the secession conversation
00:39:21.060
had such a cost to it. And it dominated other issues. And I look at America now, and I can see for
00:39:28.820
myself cultural divides. We saw that huge rally of gun owners in Virginia versus gun grabbers. So yeah,
00:39:36.900
there are issues. But I just can't imagine America being so strong economically, strong militarily,
00:39:42.900
strong on huge things that matter, if it were fighting a 5-, 10-, 20-year internal fight over
00:39:52.740
breaking up. I mean, I accept that there are great differences between San Francisco and,
00:39:58.420
let's say, Wyoming or West Virginia. But I don't know, it just seems like this would be a 10% tax on
00:40:07.860
the economy and morale and conversation of America. I'm just brainstorming here.
00:40:13.540
Well, you're right about one thing. Secession is a bit of a tough sell for Canadians, because Canadians
00:40:20.980
went through that experience for a 50-year period. And it was profitless. It diverted attention from
00:40:28.260
things that needed to be done. But it's a little different here. Number one, we don't have the
00:40:32.820
historic memory of, you know, how messy it was in Canada. And number two, we've got a different
00:40:40.260
constitutional structure where things just don't get done. I mean, we'll have, we have permanent
00:40:45.300
grid law under the separation of powers in America, which one doesn't have in a parliamentary system.
00:40:53.620
So, you know, if you're worried about things not getting done, believe me, they won't get done
00:40:58.340
under any circumstances. The only way of getting things done actually would be probably to secede,
00:41:03.140
right? And, you know, at that point, the Erring sisters might depart in peace and pass whatever
0.62
00:41:09.780
kind of woke legislation they want. So it's, you know, it's the separation of powers in this country
00:41:16.740
that creates an incentive for secession. And then you have those great divisions. I mean,
00:41:21.940
here I am in Alexandria across the river from DC, and every morning, the Washington Post arrives in my
00:41:27.860
doorstep. And it's one more argument for secession, right? It's just gripping with contempt for the kind
0.75
00:41:33.620
of people who might disagree with its stance. And, you know, and, and, you know, the thing is,
00:41:39.860
the left doesn't have a stop instinct. So they won the gay marriage debate, and they instantly shifted
00:41:48.420
to transgender rights, right? So there is not almost no paper, almost no edition of the Post,
00:41:57.540
that won't have something on, on transgender people. I mean, I don't know where they, you know,
00:42:02.100
if they won that one, which they are, I don't know where they'd go next. I don't know what's left,
00:42:07.060
basically. Well, in your blurb, which I've reviewed, I haven't read the whole book yet, but boy,
00:42:14.340
you've tantalized me. You talk about a secession light. And I first saw, well, that sounds like
00:42:19.460
sovereignty association that was pitched by the Quebecers. What it, and that seems to suggest
00:42:26.980
that you think that maybe there's a baby step or a halfway step, maybe to let out some of the
00:42:32.500
pressure that's short of breaking up the union. I have to tell you, it would make me very sad
00:42:36.900
if the United States were to break up. Sentimentality is no reason to stop doing something. But I like the
00:42:44.500
fact that America is mighty. As you point out, it's one of the largest countries in the world,
00:42:48.820
both geographically and population wise. I like that because I, I want a strong counterweight to
0.86
00:42:55.300
China and Russia. And I don't, it's, it would make me sad if America were to be lessened in some way.
00:43:02.340
Is there some halfway house? What do you mean by secession light?
00:43:05.220
Well, you got a couple of questions there. First of all, um, to session light would be,
00:43:13.300
yes, something like sovereignty association. It would in fact be a form of devolution where we've
00:43:19.620
reversed federal encroachments on state rights over the last 50 or 80 years, uh, particularly through
00:43:26.580
the Supreme court. And I, you know, I think that would be great. I mean, you know, here I am in,
00:43:31.860
in Virginia, I couldn't care less what the gun laws in Massachusetts are. You know,
00:43:36.900
if they want to live in an unsafe state, that's their business. But, you know, don't tell me that
00:43:41.860
what our laws have to be here with respect to same sex marriage and the like. So, you know,
00:43:47.460
that would be by way of calling a truce in the culture wars. The other thing you talk about is,
00:43:54.180
is how you're happy with America being strong, you know, and living here,
00:43:59.940
you know, trying to get a feel as somebody who's moved to the country about how Americans feel
00:44:05.540
about their country. I, I, I believe that for many of them, you know, the great attachment is to the
00:44:12.900
glory of belonging to the country that owns all the guns in the room. That is its military might,
00:44:21.380
but there's such a thing as too much of a good thing. And Americans voted against,
00:44:26.180
you know, the military might or the military expansionism in the 2006 congressional elections
00:44:35.060
that gave the house to the Dems. And in 2016, I mean, Donald Trump, and I, you know, I, I advise
00:44:42.420
Trump on policy matters. Donald Trump explicitly rejected the neocon desire to wage war in foreign
00:44:50.900
countries. I mean, he wanted to bring us back to Washington's farewell address, where he said,
00:44:55.700
look, you know, here we are in North America, we don't have to worry about being invaded by
00:44:59.860
neighboring countries. We're not in Europe, thank God, and let's profit from that.
00:45:04.580
You know, and yet we spend more on the military than the next 21 countries put together,
00:45:10.980
right? Military budget, about 680 billion a year. So if we split into two countries and have that,
00:45:18.820
I mean, would that be such a bad thing? Nobody would invade us, we wouldn't have to worry about
00:45:23.940
things. And, and a lot of Americans are beginning to think we don't have to be the world's policemen.
00:45:29.620
And as for those woke states like California, if you told the Californian,
00:45:36.180
on secession, you don't have to put the bill for the country's military budget,
00:45:41.860
and that'll save you enough money to have a form of national health for Californians.
0.80
00:45:50.340
Well, it's very interesting. I have not heard these ideas before. And I, I wonder if,
00:45:58.420
if the real impact of this book and these ideas will simply be to get Americans thinking about
00:46:05.700
how they can solve some of the problems you outline in less dramatic ways in full secession.
00:46:11.620
You're talking about devolving powers, respecting the original intent of the constitution,
00:46:15.220
getting out of foreign adventurism, as Washington suggested. Those would all be happy outcomes.
0.99
00:46:22.100
I don't know. I just, it, I'm a foreigner, so I, I don't have a direct stake in America,
00:46:28.100
but I think many people around the world see it, see its strength in the, and its glory as a,
00:46:36.740
as a form of protection and as a form of a role model. I tell you, I look at those protesters in Hong
00:46:42.980
Kong, flying American flags, playing the American anthem, talking about American ideas. And I think that,
00:46:53.300
that greatness, I wouldn't want it to be diminished. I wonder what Hong Kongers think
00:46:58.980
is the essence of America. I've been thinking a lot about them because I think in some ways they,
00:47:05.540
they are the most outstanding freedom-oriented people in the world right now. I just am endlessly
00:47:11.940
impressed by that. I don't know where my question is going here, other than I just,
00:47:16.660
as a foreigner, I, I, I'm grateful that America is great. Last word to you, Professor.
00:47:22.980
Well, I agree with everything you said, but the crucial point to understand here is that
00:47:28.580
only Americans get to vote on American policy, not people in Hong Kong and not people in Canada.
00:47:34.740
So, and that's been the Trump message. The Trump message has been, let's be self-interested.
00:47:40.020
We're not out there to do anything other than to protect our own, not to protect people in other
00:47:46.100
countries. Yeah. You know, we have concerns about the sea lanes in the South China seas. That's about
00:47:52.260
our trade. We have concerns about protecting Americans abroad and we can launch drone attacks on, on
00:47:59.940
murderers who do that. Um, but the, there's been a fundamental shift in American foreign policy under
00:48:08.580
Trump where your kinds of arguments are found to be less pressing or, you know.
00:48:14.660
Yeah, well, I'm not saying it's an, I mean, I agree with you. I, I mean, I don't think America
00:48:19.620
should be the world policeman. I spent a fair bit of time reading the Afghanistan papers. What an
00:48:24.420
unmitigated disaster that unplanned fire hose of trillions of dollars with, I mean, it's just
00:48:33.380
absolutely, I'm against American adventurism and the Globocop approach. I guess I, um, I, I just want,
00:48:41.540
I don't want America to be diminished and that's as an outside friend and ally. I did say last word to
00:48:47.700
you and then I, then I felt like I had to jam in another word. Tell me what you, let's, let me switch
00:48:52.900
gears because I got you on, on the Skype. I know that you've, uh, had the president's ear on a few
00:48:58.820
matters. We're in the, we're less than a year away, um, till the election in November. I can't
00:49:05.780
say that any of the Democrat, uh, contenders are, uh, impressive to me. Who knows if Hillary will throw
1.00
00:49:11.700
her hat in in the late entry. It looks to me like, uh, the cards are lining up well for Trump to
00:49:18.420
have a success in his reelection. Give me your thoughts on 2020.
00:49:23.220
Well, first of all, 2020 includes the impeachment. That's obviously going to fizzle,
00:49:28.180
right? It's going to be a tremendous embarrassment. And then you get people on the left
00:49:33.780
running on the most left-wing policies that you could possibly imagine, right? I mean,
00:49:39.460
you know, of course they're socialists, right? I mean, they're running on socialism
00:49:44.420
and they're not going to win on that. And that, you know, I, so I, I think I don't want to say
00:49:50.900
anything is assured in American politics, but I'm very confident Trump would be reelected.
00:49:57.700
And at that point, the left is going to have to decide, you know, do we, uh, lower our guns a little
00:50:04.820
bit and try to get along a little better with people we despise? Um, or do we look for some out,
00:50:12.980
some way of getting out of all of this stuff? And that's when I think they'll start looking at
00:50:18.740
secession. I mean, we already have massive interposition. We, we have states have declared
00:50:25.140
themselves sanctuary states, uh, who don't enforce federal immigration laws. Um, you know, Portland,
00:50:33.460
Oregon, Oregon, they permitted a mob to, uh, threaten ICE workers, federal immigration workers
00:50:42.020
to forbid them from leaving their building. Finally, the federal government had to send in
00:50:46.820
federal marshals to protect its own employees. Um, that's, you know, that's not Fort Sumter,
00:50:53.540
but you know, something that wasn't all that far either.
00:50:56.740
So, you know, we have massive interposition, even attempts at nullification of federal laws
00:51:04.340
that are, you know, that's tantamount to secession. So it's a smaller step than you might think.
00:51:10.980
And the animosities here are so deep. It's not so hard to imagine. Indeed, it's easy to imagine.
00:51:19.300
Hmm. You know what? Uh, hearing it that way, perhaps the book is more
00:51:23.860
a hand book or a manual for upset Democrats the day after Trump wins again, more so than for
00:51:33.220
Republicans. Maybe that's your point. I look forward to reading the book. Professor,
00:51:37.140
you've been very generous with your time today, and I look forward to when we next speak.
00:51:43.700
Right on. Well, there you have it, Professor Frank Buckley. He's at George Mason University's
00:51:49.380
Scalia School of Law. And he joined us today via Skype
00:51:53.380
from Alexandria, Virginia. Stay with us. More Ahead on the Rebel.
00:52:06.180
Hey there. Final thoughts today. What do you think of Donald Trump's speech at Davos?
00:52:11.460
In a way, it was boring. And what I mean by that is it wasn't a dramatic,
00:52:19.060
a new initiative. It wasn't trying to be fashionable. It wasn't like it was just exactly what you would
00:52:25.060
expect the leader of the United States to say to a gathering of the world's investors and
00:52:30.900
billionaires and political leaders. Like it, it wasn't exciting or dramatic or innovative. It was just
00:52:38.020
good. It was great. But on terms that fancy Justin Trudeau would say, oh, that's so obsolete. We're
00:52:46.660
about climate feminism or social justice or transgender pride or whatever. Stuff that actually
00:52:53.380
has nothing to do with the World Economic Forum. I remember when Justin Trudeau was given the floor
00:52:58.020
at Davos. I think it was last year. And he went on and on and on about gender quotas for boards.
00:53:04.100
And look, give that speech at the Pussyhat March. Give that speech to a high school class or something,
00:53:12.020
to a teacher's federation. You've got the world's billionaires in a room and you're not wooing them
00:53:18.820
with economic arguments. In fact, you're scaring them with gender and transgender regulations.
0.98
00:53:25.060
What an idiot we have as a prime minister. All right. That's our show for today. Until tomorrow,
00:53:30.180
on behalf of all of us here at Red Bull World Headquarters, good night and keep fighting for freedom.