Rebel News Podcast - April 30, 2021


Two Ontario MPPs say Chinese-Canadian Doctor's “Wuhan Pneumonia” Sign Spreads Asian Hate

Topics
Mentioned
I’m suing Catherine McKenna and Steven Guilbeault — and I'll take you through the lawsuit Alberta moves from the most free province to the least free

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

165.98

Word count

3,974

Sentence count

281

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A Chinese-Canadian doctor in the Chinese language uses the phrase Wuhan Pneumonia and a Chinese critic says it s racist. But the doctor s Chinese and the message isn t in Chinese, and the patients are Chinese. Who would be behind causing such strife? Well, I ll give you one guess: And yeah, it s the Chinese embassy.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00.000 Hello, my rebels. A crazy case out of Ontario. A Chinese-Canadian doctor in the Chinese language 1.00
00:00:06.460 uses the phrase Wuhan pneumonia, and a Chinese critic says it's racist. But the doctor's Chinese,
00:00:14.340 and the message isn't in Chinese, and the patients are Chinese. Who would be behind causing such 0.99
00:00:20.020 strife? Well, I'll give you one guess. And yeah, it's the Chinese embassy. I'll give you the details
00:00:24.640 next ahead. But before I do, let me invite you to become a subscriber to Rebel News Plus. It's
00:00:29.260 the video version of this podcast. Eight bucks a month, pretty good deal. It's about half the cost
00:00:33.680 of Netflix, and I think it's content you won't find anywhere else. We're one of the few independent
00:00:39.100 voices left in Canada, and we do rely on your dough, because we don't take any dough from Trudeau.
00:00:44.440 Go to rebelnews.com and click subscribe. I really appreciate it. Thanks. Here's to the show.
00:00:59.260 Tonight, are Canadian politicians running errands for Beijing's dictatorship here in Canada?
00:01:10.520 It's April 29th, and this is the Ezra Levant Show.
00:01:13.260 Why should others go to jail when you're a biggest carbon consumer I know?
00:01:19.100 There's 8,500 customers here, and you won't give them an answer.
00:01:23.180 The only thing I have to say to the government about why I'm publishing it is because it's
00:01:27.580 my bloody right to do so.
00:01:33.820 Oh, here's a crazy story for you. Let me show you the headline. 0.94
00:01:37.080 So just to be clear what's going on here, there is a doctor in Ontario who in Chinese, not even in
00:01:54.220 English, so he's speaking to fellow Chinese Canadians, refers to COVID-19 as the Wuhan
00:02:01.600 pneumonia, which is where it came from, and that is what it does to you.
00:02:07.080 And yet Canadian politicians are telling this doctor not to say that. Let me read a little
00:02:13.900 bit of this story. It's from the National Post. Two Toronto-based politicians are pressing a
00:02:20.020 Chinese-Canadian doctor to remove a sign on his office door in Chinese that refers to COVID-19
00:02:26.040 as the Wuhan pneumonia, complaining the wording could incite anti-Asian hatred. Let me stop you
00:02:32.100 right there. If the only people who can read it are Chinese speakers, odds are they are 1.00
00:02:38.920 ethnically Chinese. I mean, there are some Caucasian or non-Chinese people who speak Chinese,
00:02:44.680 but if you're in a Chinese neighborhood going to a Chinese doctor whose door has Chinese writing,
00:02:49.420 odds are you're Chinese too. What's the likelihood that that will whip you up into anti-Chinese fervor?
00:02:56.080 You're probably Chinese yourself, and you're going to a Chinese doctor by choice. Does this make any
00:03:01.380 sense? Here, I'll read a little more. The English part of the sign, which explained Dr. Kester-Kahn's
00:03:07.280 office protocol during the pandemic, referred only to COVID. So who complained? Was it a patient?
00:03:16.800 Get this. Vincent Key, a progressive conservative member of the provincial legislature with a history
00:03:23.860 of ties to the Chinese government, said Kong may have made an innocent mistake, but it doesn't matter
00:03:29.600 that the mention of Wuhan was in Chinese. So a politician came to stir up trouble, and this politician
00:03:37.180 calls himself a progressive conservative. Then again, these days, anyone does, don't they? I mean,
00:03:42.740 they even let Doug Ford and Aaron O'Toole call themselves conservatives. Let me read a bit more.
00:03:48.140 Key had earlier posted about the issue in an anti-racism forum on the China-based WeChat social
00:03:55.560 media site, saying that if the physician did not change the notice, he and fellow Tory MPP Aris Babikian
00:04:03.020 would hold a news conference to publicize the issue. So just to understand, WeChat is an amazing app,
00:04:10.940 but it's Chinese, and I don't mean ethnically Chinese or in the Chinese language. I mean,
00:04:16.120 it is rooted in China, and it carries with it the Chinese government's values. It's an amazing app.
00:04:22.640 It's like Facebook and Twitter and PayPal combined. It's an app that shows, though, that China is your 0.98
00:04:29.920 center, not Canada. In Canada, you can use Facebook in Chinese. You can use Twitter in Chinese. When you're
00:04:36.220 on WeChat, you're showing where your center of gravity is. Isn't it funny that this Canadian 1.00
00:04:42.060 conservative would make threats about embarrassing this doctor in a Chinese WeChat app? I found that
00:04:50.240 was very interesting. The National Post, to their credit, interviewed a pro-democracy critic of
00:04:57.140 Communist China, a Chinese man himself named Chuck Kwan. Here's what Chuck Kwan said.
00:05:01.240 This is the playbook of Chinese consulates in Canada. They are using this anti-Asian hate
00:05:09.220 to rally the troops, win the hearts and minds of Chinese Canadians. As in, this is a non-issue.
00:05:18.500 But these two MPPs, both of whom disgracefully seem to set their North Star by China, they're trying
00:05:27.100 to whip this up, not because there's a real problem, but to alienate Chinese Canadians from 0.74
00:05:32.380 Canada. It's sort of like a Black Lives Matter stoking division, except for this has been 0.90
00:05:38.340 coordinated by the Chinese embassies and consulates. I'll read just a little more.
00:05:43.980 Key and Babikian have repeatedly attended Confederation of Toronto Chinese Canadian organizations
00:05:52.620 and related events alongside China's Toronto Consul General, including the celebrations in 2018 and
00:06:00.660 19 of the 69th and 70th anniversary of the founding of People's Republic of China.
00:06:07.260 So that's a pro-dictatorship lobby group. They were celebrating not the Chinese culture, language, food,
00:06:16.280 history, heritage. It's all wonderful things. They were celebrating the communist regime at an event
00:06:22.640 next to the Chinese diplomats here. How on earth is that even abided here? There's a lot going on here,
00:06:32.580 Chinese meddling in our politics with the approval and passive support, I suppose, of the Conservative 0.98
00:06:39.520 Party and the government, but also the fake whipping up of divisions amongst people in our society. It
00:06:46.820 reminds me of the official approach taken by Theresa Tam and Justin Trudeau and others at the outset of
00:06:54.960 the virus. You know, there were very early critics of the government who said, you've got to stop those
00:07:02.640 flights from China. You've got to stop people flying here from Wuhan and other places and just going into
00:07:09.160 schools. There was a petition made to the school board in the York regional district to have some
00:07:15.900 sort of limits. And maybe if someone was coming right over from Wuhan that maybe they wear a mask or
00:07:20.420 maybe don't go into class. And funny enough, those are the rules now a year later. But when that alarm
00:07:26.080 was raised in a very modest way, it was called racist then too. Except for then, as in now, the people
00:07:35.060 behind the petition were Chinese-Canadian families worried about what they had learned about the
00:07:41.580 virus and Canada having its guard down. There's a lot of craziness here. Wokeism, taking offense where
00:07:49.340 there is none, whipping up divisions between different races, stoking things for some headlines.
00:07:56.440 I think the darkest part is this is being coordinated by the Chinese embassy and no one seems to care.
00:08:01.920 Kudos on the National Post for even writing the story. I think this is only going to continue
00:08:07.720 until we start to treat the Chinese embassy and its actions in Canada the same way we did during the
00:08:14.140 Cold War towards the Soviet bloc embassies. Stay with us. More ahead. 0.98
00:08:31.920 Statements by members. The Honourable Member for Hastings, Lennox Addington.
00:08:35.720 Madam Speaker, lockdowns with no end in sight are being endorsed by federal leaders and are destroying
00:08:41.960 our communities. The impact on Canadians' lives is severe. Ordinary people are being investigated by
00:08:47.620 police for organizing peaceful protests against the lockdowns. Last week, I heard from a young
00:08:52.900 business owner in my riding. She told me if things don't change soon, she will likely have to declare
00:08:57.920 bankruptcy. The Liberal budget will be of no help to her. Others have confided to me that their
00:09:02.900 children have had to be medicated to reduce suicidal thoughts. Tragically, the budget fails
00:09:07.720 to address the surging youth mental health tsunami we are witnessing. Canadians look to their leaders
00:09:12.760 for help, but instead their concerns appear to be falling on deaf ears. We can look south of the border
00:09:17.960 to see many U.S. states have reopened and are better from an economic, social, and mental health
00:09:23.000 perspective. It's time to recognize that quarantining to healthy helps no one and to end these draconian
00:09:28.940 lockdowns once and for all. There you have it. Derek Sloan, independent MP, was elected as a
00:09:35.000 conservative but was made to walk the plank in a bizarre moment by Erin O'Toole, who I note has fallen 0.88
00:09:43.780 far down in the polls. The latest Ipsos polls. We'll have to do a story about that another day.
00:09:47.720 Just shockingly low. 17 points back in Ontario, Erin O'Toole. Third place in Quebec and BC. I think
00:09:56.120 part of it is his embrace of the carbon tax and part of it is his cancel culture approach to MPs like
00:10:02.780 Derek Sloan, who joins us now via Skype. Derek, great to see you again.
00:10:07.540 Glad to be here. Thanks.
00:10:08.820 You know, I sometimes wonder, I look at the United States, there's 50 different states.
00:10:13.240 There's, of course, a very lively Congress. And there's a range of opinions on the lockdowns.
00:10:20.180 You have states like Texas, South Dakota, Florida that are very hands-free. Here's an image of
00:10:25.480 the big UFC fight in Florida. Just a packed stadium. I don't see any masks there. You got that approach.
00:10:32.920 And then you have your more lockdown states. But even California and New York are not as locked down
00:10:37.860 as long as Canada. North of the border, no official party, either in government or opposition,
00:10:45.020 is against lockdowns. You got lockdowns in conservative Alberta, Manitoba, Ontario, the
00:10:53.120 federal opposition. Why is it that only independents like you and Randy Hillier, and I think I've just
00:11:00.300 gone through the whole list now, are the only guys on the other side of this debate?
00:11:08.020 Well, it basically comes down to just sheer cowardice. And you're right. We don't have to
00:11:15.400 be the first, you know, province or country to open up. We have examples close to us that are
00:11:21.300 faring well. The data is coming out. You know, we just had, we'll talk about this later, but I just
00:11:26.800 was reviewing the results of an 80, a study that looked at 80 different studies by a Canadian
00:11:33.760 professor. And he said that lockdowns are 282 times as harmful as their benefits. The data is out.
00:11:41.660 It's a lack of courage, and frankly, cowardice on behalf of Canadian politicians.
00:11:47.520 You know, a lot of people criticized Ron DeSantis, that's the governor of Florida,
00:11:51.440 when he was one of the first to say, we're going to loosen up. And there was a moment there,
00:11:57.360 I didn't know if he could lean into the wind, but he did. And he actually led other people to join him.
00:12:03.580 So it wasn't just that he put his finger in the air, saw which way the wind was going. He made
00:12:08.700 the wind go in a certain direction, just by relentlessly saying things like you just said that,
00:12:15.300 like, he's a real master of the facts, more than most TV pundits or reporters are. I got to think
00:12:21.620 that someone who had a reasonable, not radical, but just a thoughtful, common sense approach to
00:12:29.060 lifting the lockdowns, I got to think not only would they do well, like Ron DeSantis is,
00:12:34.360 but they would create sort of a new voter coalition. It wouldn't just be traditional conservative
00:12:39.940 voters. It would be people, people who are just apolitical. They don't think left wing,
00:12:45.080 right wing, they're just sick of this. And you'd probably have, you know, working class people who 1.00
00:12:50.180 have been locked out of their jobs, mom and pop business. I'm just saying, you say people are
00:12:54.860 afraid, I get it. But isn't there a big payoff for the, for the leaders who take a chance on this?
00:13:02.340 Well, I think there is. And, you know, I think that there's, there's two different groups of people
00:13:06.820 in this country. There's sort of the media party people, like the media elites and those that pay
00:13:12.880 attention to them. And then there's average Canadians. And I think, unfortunately, too many 0.99
00:13:17.760 political parties base their activities on whatever the CBC or the Globe and Mail has said,
00:13:24.060 but they're really missing out on where the average person is. And more and more people are
00:13:28.580 becoming disenfranchised. I mean, I saw a poll that says six out of 10 Canadians don't like any
00:13:33.260 federal political party. There is an opportunity for, for a party or for a movement to capture
00:13:40.480 that position. And I think you're totally right. Now, you're not just speaking, you know, in a
00:13:48.460 figurative, sorry, in an abstract manner. I understand that recently you attended a church
00:13:57.400 in Aylmer, Ontario, and that the police chief has announced that he intends to, to prosecute
00:14:06.280 you, to give you a summons. Can you tell us what happened? What did you allegedly do? And what are
00:14:15.040 you going to do about this summons? Well, I haven't been served with anything. I have read, as you have
00:14:22.900 in the news, that apparently I seem to be one of several people that are being charged under the
00:14:29.460 Reopening Ontario Act. So I, I intend, whatever I do get charged with, and again, this is, you know,
00:14:36.340 a provincial offense. It's not a criminal charge. I intend to fight it. I know many people who have
00:14:41.580 received tickets. The government is not, they're too afraid to fight these in court. They're, you know,
00:14:47.460 throwing them down, they're, they're kicking the ball down the road because they don't want to
00:14:50.800 actually have to go toe to toe with a real argument that addresses the, the charter or, or other
00:14:56.120 arguments. So, um, they, they would rather just be able to give, you know, they would rather the fear
00:15:01.380 factor be there. They don't want one case to be able to knock down their ability to keep the entire 0.68
00:15:06.560 province under lock and key. Um, I, uh, so I was at the church service in Elmer. Uh, man, it was, I'll,
00:15:14.060 I'll tell you, Ezra, um, you know, I've been to church before many times, but I have never, uh,
00:15:19.940 been to this church, but, you know, to be, to be in that church with people who are,
00:15:23.720 you know, doing what they think to be right. Uh, you know, the police were outside and everything.
00:15:27.640 I have never seen a more positive and exciting service and it's available online. They stream
00:15:33.080 it live. Wow. What a powerful sermon by, uh, by some very humble people that live there in Elmer.
00:15:39.060 And, uh, I was, I was proud to be there. You know, that's exactly how I felt when I went to the
00:15:44.360 Grace Life Church just outside Edmonton. And I'm not even Christian by the way, but I went there
00:15:49.400 and I was just washed over by a feeling of normal. I just thought, geez, I forgot what it was like
00:15:55.340 in the before times. And, uh, if I was in Edmonton, I would be going every week. I'll tell you that.
00:16:00.400 Uh, let me ask you a few technical questions. Grace Life Church, uh, before they were expropriated
00:16:06.880 and turned into a police garrison, took a very strong line against police, police coming onto the
00:16:12.680 property or into the church during services. They simply said to police,
00:16:16.800 you cannot interrupt our church service. And they knew that section 176.2 of the criminal code
00:16:23.260 forbids anyone from disturbing, uh, a religious service. And so in the end, actually police raided
00:16:31.620 it on a weekday at 6 a.m., I think, to avoid breaking that law. Can you tell me what was it
00:16:38.100 like in Elmer? Do they let the cops on the property? Do they let the cops in the building? Because sometimes
00:16:44.000 churches know their rights and sometimes they sort of get walked over.
00:16:49.860 So the, the, at Elmer, they kind of have security at the road that, that, uh, that lets cars in or
00:16:56.740 doesn't let other cars in. Uh, I don't know if the police tried to get in or not, but they basically
00:17:01.660 just stayed out at the road. And, uh, I, I don't know if they were surveilling the scene or what they
00:17:07.280 were doing, but they, uh, I don't know if they tried to enter, uh, but I didn't see them doing so.
00:17:12.560 Well, then how would they know that you were there? I mean, I guess you could have mentioned
00:17:17.060 it or tweeted about it, but how would they know what you would have done? How would they know
00:17:21.600 enough to, to charge you? And of course I'm a former lawyer myself. I know that the standard
00:17:27.400 for these men, I think, I don't know what charge you'll get, but it's typically beyond a reasonable
00:17:32.860 doubt or it's a high standard. It's not like civil court where it's like balance of probabilities,
00:17:38.520 50, 50 kind of thing. If they didn't, if they weren't in the church, how do they know what
00:17:43.660 you did? How do they know where you stood? How do they know anything? I think this goes
00:17:48.600 to your theory that maybe the whole thing is just a shock and awe to try and scare people.
00:17:53.440 Like if they didn't actually see you do what you allegedly did, how could they send you a
00:17:58.480 ticket?
00:17:58.760 Well, the, uh, the service was live streamed and myself and another politician, Randy Hillier,
00:18:06.460 uh, were invited up to the front along with the two, two others. So there is a picture floating
00:18:11.900 around of me being at the front of that service. Uh, CBC picked it up. So I'm assuming that's where
00:18:17.980 they're getting their info from, but I'm not sure.
00:18:20.100 Yeah. And you know what, come to think of it, that's probably right. If you mentioned it was live
00:18:22.620 streamed. Well, let me say one more thing, because you mentioned that you think that the authorities
00:18:26.960 are going to kick the can down the road to avoid having a hearing on this. That's our
00:18:31.100 experience. As you may know, we have a project called fight the fines.com. We've crowdfunded
00:18:36.560 lawyers for almost a thousand people. And I don't think we've had a single trial, but I've just
00:18:43.860 asked our team for a count. I think we're up to 20 wins without even a trial because the
00:18:50.100 prosecutors look at the case and say, I'm not, I'm not running with this. And no one wants
00:18:55.920 to be that test case because everyone says, well, these are likely unconstitutional.
00:19:01.260 The size of them probably renders them unconstitutional too, like a $1,500 ticket.
00:19:07.020 Um, the enforcement of them, if it's a church involved or other. So we, we represent close
00:19:13.420 to 1000 people, but they will not let us have our day in court. Cause I think that I, I mean,
00:19:20.520 I don't want to raise expectations or hopes, but there's a chance all 1000 people we represent
00:19:26.080 will just be let to go free. Cause this whole thing was either to scare people off or just
00:19:32.080 to see who's so afraid they'll pay the ticket just to get out of a pickle.
00:19:36.580 Yeah, I, I agree with you. And you know, if they wanted to, if they really did think they
00:19:40.820 were in the right and wanted to send a message, then why not dig in? I mean, but as you say,
00:19:46.560 I have yet to meet someone who has disputed a ticket that has actually gotten their day
00:19:51.180 in court. Yeah. Well, it's very interesting. Um, I, uh, I want to thank you for coming on
00:19:57.400 the show. We, we played the clip of you in parliament. I'm glad you're still making
00:20:00.820 representations as an MP. I know your website is Derek Sloan dot CA. And, uh, last time we
00:20:07.520 spoke, I asked you if you were any clearer on your public plans. And I know that if you have
00:20:13.580 a plan, you'll want to announce it in your own way. But, uh, can you tell me if your thinking
00:20:18.900 has clarified yet on what you plan to do, given that you've been, uh, ousted from Aaron O'Toole's
00:20:25.560 party? Well, I don't have anything further to report. I would recommend that people, uh, sign
00:20:31.700 up for my email on my website. Uh, that will probably be the first place that I start to,
00:20:37.560 uh, make clear my plans. Uh, but I'd be happy to come on again, uh, uh, when, uh, when those plans
00:20:43.960 have, uh, crystallized and, and hash them out with you. Yeah. Well, make sure you do. I, I mean,
00:20:48.520 I, I enjoyed having you come on the show when you were running for the leadership. I, I said to our
00:20:53.120 viewers, and I think, you know, this, that I felt like you, uh, promoted true conservative ideas and
00:20:59.220 you were respectful of the populist nature of conservatives in Canada. I think you were sort of
00:21:03.900 a fan favorite and, uh, we were outraged at the injustice and the clear false, the false pretext
00:21:12.080 with which you were given the heave ho by Aaron O'Toole, who I think is turning into a disastrous
00:21:17.160 leader. So I think I speak for many of our viewers when I say we very much look forward to seeing what
00:21:23.520 you do next and whether it's in the elected political arena or in some sort of NGO or action
00:21:29.240 group. Um, you clearly are showing some courage on this pandemic issue. I look forward to you
00:21:35.120 letting us know when you're ready to make that announcement. And I hope you'll come on our show,
00:21:39.320 maybe even in a live stream to talk about it, because, uh, I tell you, it can't come soon enough.
00:21:44.880 As I mentioned that America has its fighters, but in Canada, they're very few in numbers. So,
00:21:49.860 so please do call us when you're ready for that. Absolutely. Thank you.
00:21:53.920 All right. There you have it. His name is Derek Sloan is the MP for Hastings, Lennox and Addington.
00:21:59.920 And you can go to his website and get on his email list at DerekSloan.ca. Stay with us more ahead.
00:22:08.560 Hey, welcome back to my show last night. Loretta writes, the manner in which Trudeau speaks that Ezra
00:22:24.740 was trying to describe, I refer to as his phony thespian voice. You're so right. He sort of looks 1.00
00:22:31.120 in the camera and he over enunciates. I did not do that. And you can trust me. I almost always add
00:22:42.060 ladies because I, you know, that's how he talks and things. Paul writes, there was a similar case
00:22:47.240 here in Ottawa a little while ago, pre COVID when the mayor banned some of his critics might want to
00:22:52.680 check the precedent set on that. I know that lawsuit. We read that lawsuit before we filed our lawsuit.
00:23:00.520 That's what you're talking about, suing a government official who bans people from following them on
00:23:04.920 Twitter. Look, I just think it's a really bad thing for government officials to start to treat
00:23:10.560 the instruments of the state as personal weapons of war. I mean, I do not care and I am not interested
00:23:16.860 in the personal Twitter feeds or Facebook feeds of politicians. I just don't care. But official
00:23:23.380 government offices with the official government broadcast banning me, that's outrageous. And I think
00:23:29.260 it's, it violates my rights in a number of ways. We'll see what the courts say. All right, my friends,
00:23:33.760 thanks for joining us today until tomorrow. On behalf of all of us here at Rebel World Headquarters,
00:23:38.300 to you at home, good night and keep fighting for freedom.
00:23:40.880 Thank you.
00:23:54.420 Thank you.
00:23:55.960 Thank you.