Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey - June 27, 2024


Ep 1027 | Rosaria Butterfield Rebukes Seminaries, Dennis Prager Defends Lust


Episode Stats

Length

47 minutes

Words per Minute

153.3305

Word Count

7,350

Sentence Count

484

Misogynist Sentences

17

Hate Speech Sentences

23


Summary

Rosaria Butterfield is calling out seminaries for giving approval to insidious LGBTQ ideas. Also, we are discussing some commentary from Dennis Prager about the sinfulness of lust and masturbation. And also, we will talk about a trend on TikTok called The Passenger Princess. We ve got all that on today s episode of Relatable.


Transcript

00:00:00.680 Rosaria Butterfield is calling out seminaries for giving approval to insidious LGBTQ ideas.
00:00:09.160 Also, we are discussing some commentary from Dennis Prager about the sinfulness or the
00:00:15.980 not-so-sinfulness of lust and masturbation.
00:00:20.000 And also, we will talk about a trend on TikTok called The Passenger Princess.
00:00:26.320 We've got all of that on today's episode of Relatable.
00:00:30.000 Hey guys, welcome to Relatable.
00:00:41.320 Happy Thursday.
00:00:42.280 Hope everyone has had a wonderful week.
00:00:44.820 Okay, yesterday's conversation with Dr. Keneally.
00:00:47.760 I know you guys loved that.
00:00:49.760 You guys have been asking me to have her on when I posted last week that she was coming
00:00:54.040 on the show.
00:00:54.580 Y'all were so pumped.
00:00:56.680 She's amazing.
00:00:57.300 Just so much insight.
00:00:58.460 Make sure you follow her.
00:00:59.420 Listen to that episode or watch it if you haven't already.
00:01:03.440 If you or someone in your life has cancer, you've got to listen to it.
00:01:07.840 But really, it was just so good for general health.
00:01:10.060 Answered a lot of my questions.
00:01:12.040 All right.
00:01:12.460 We've got quite a few things to get to today before I get into it.
00:01:15.520 Just a reminder, our Share the Arrows event is going to be amazing.
00:01:20.160 It is on September 28th.
00:01:22.420 If you are a Relatable, Relatable, Relatable, so a woman, a Christian conservative woman in
00:01:28.520 particular, you are going to love this event.
00:01:30.460 It is September 28th in Dallas, Texas.
00:01:33.500 Elisa Childers, Abby Halberstadt, Francesca Battistelli, and Rosaria Butterfield will all
00:01:39.680 be there.
00:01:40.080 And of course, I will be there too, sharethearrows.com for more information.
00:01:46.000 All right.
00:01:46.360 Speaking of Rosaria Butterfield, who you will get to see in the flesh if you are going to
00:01:52.100 be at the Share the Arrows event.
00:01:53.980 Our first story has to do with her.
00:01:55.840 If you don't know who Rosaria Butterfield is, you are missing out.
00:02:00.300 She's been on this podcast now a couple of times.
00:02:02.760 We've talked about her testimony before.
00:02:04.900 She's written several books about her testimony, and she is such a strong voice for the Bible,
00:02:11.700 for biblical theology.
00:02:13.440 So she used to be a queer theory, critical theory professor at Syracuse University.
00:02:18.280 She was a lesbian feminist activist, and she worked hard to ensure that LGBTQ, so-called
00:02:25.840 people, they weren't really called that then, had quote-unquote equal rights.
00:02:30.840 So the redefinition of marriage is something that she had at the top of her agenda when
00:02:36.800 she was this feminist activist several decades ago.
00:02:40.320 And then through the hospitality of a Christian neighbor, she heard the gospel.
00:02:44.700 She realized the truth of God's word, the truth of who Jesus was.
00:02:48.460 She converted to Christianity.
00:02:50.480 She realized through the process of spirit-empowered sanctification that she could no longer
00:02:55.640 as a Christian be in this relationship with another woman that she had been in for years
00:03:01.360 and years at that point, practically a spouse.
00:03:05.480 She walked away from that relationship.
00:03:07.840 She walked away from her former way of life.
00:03:11.080 As I said, now she is a Christian author, apologist, I think just an incredible defender of the faith,
00:03:17.780 especially when it comes to this cultural moment, the attempt to normalize and glorify sexual depravity.
00:03:24.560 She is such a bold voice against that in a variety of ways.
00:03:28.700 She also is a wife and a mother to four, and she's just incredible.
00:03:36.280 She offers so much clarity and courage in this age of chaos, cowardice, and confusion.
00:03:42.440 And now she is rebuking a seminary, the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.
00:03:50.620 In fact, there's a lot of good people there, a ton of people that we've had on our show
00:03:55.720 that work there, and I think in general it is a great institution.
00:04:00.540 But Rosaria Butterfield is calling them out for something in particular, and that is for
00:04:05.080 approving Nate Collins' dissertation.
00:04:08.560 So if you have no idea what I'm talking about, let me back up a little bit and give you some
00:04:12.700 context to explain why this matters.
00:04:14.880 So Rosaria Butterfield recently criticized evangelical institutions for their acceptance of LGBTQ
00:04:22.800 ideology, and more specifically, she actually criticized Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
00:04:30.160 for credentializing heresy and sin—that is her terminology—by approving the dissertation
00:04:36.560 of Nate Collins all the way back in 2017.
00:04:39.360 Collins' dissertation became the book, All But Invisible, Exploring Identity Questions
00:04:45.120 at the Intersection of Faith, Gender, and Sexuality.
00:04:48.220 Collins would also go on to found Revoice.
00:04:51.840 This is an organization that has embraced the view that Christians can live out a so-called
00:04:57.600 LGBTQ identity if they remain celibate.
00:05:01.260 This is often referred to as Side B Christianity.
00:05:04.320 We will link the recent episode that we did where we explained Side B Christianity versus
00:05:10.160 Side A versus Side X versus Side Y, exactly what all of that means.
00:05:16.480 And so he is a part of Side B Christianity, which really says that you can, you know, remain
00:05:23.360 celibate, but it's fine to call yourself a so-called gay Christian or a trans Christian.
00:05:28.300 And this is not something that I subscribe to, but this is an increasingly popular position.
00:05:34.740 It's something that also Rosaria Butterfield has spoken out against.
00:05:38.240 So has Christopher Yuan, Beckett Cook, all of these people we've had on our podcast before.
00:05:43.720 In an episode of the American Reformer podcast that aired in February of this year, Rosaria
00:05:49.680 joined Timon Klein and Josh Abitoy to describe how critical theory and queer theory have made
00:05:56.560 their way into the church.
00:05:59.080 And she talks about this particular instance of Nate Collins' dissertation being approved
00:06:03.840 at SBTS.
00:06:05.220 So here's that.
00:06:06.920 I remember reading it and saying, this is one of the most God-forsaken things I've read as,
00:06:13.520 you know, as a Christian ever.
00:06:15.800 What are you all thinking?
00:06:17.520 He mishandles both the Bible and critical theory and queer theory all at the same time,
00:06:24.820 which is really kind of, it's an amazing achievement.
00:06:28.780 Bad ideas don't run a culture amok until the church starts applauding them.
00:06:38.120 And we've seen a good bit of that.
00:06:40.860 Maybe this was just the first time it came to my desk.
00:06:43.800 Okay, so the title of Nate Collins' dissertation was Virgin as Secondary Gender Identity in
00:06:54.620 1 Corinthians 7 and its Jewish and Greco-Roman background.
00:07:00.980 So Rosaria argues that by approving this dissertation, they kind of approved this idea.
00:07:07.700 I mean, approving a dissertation doesn't necessarily mean you agree with every part of the dissertation,
00:07:12.920 but she argues that this is God-forsaken, that he mishandles the Bible, and he actually
00:07:19.960 mishandles critical and queer theory.
00:07:22.380 He actually misunderstands and misapplies those things too.
00:07:25.740 And she, of course, says tongue-in-cheek that that's an amazing achievement.
00:07:29.520 And I really found this profound when she said that bad ideas don't run a culture amok
00:07:35.700 until the church starts applauding them.
00:07:40.440 And so I'd be interested to see what the response would be of those who did approve
00:07:46.420 this dissertation version as a secondary gender identity in 1 Corinthians 7.
00:07:52.060 That is insane.
00:07:53.980 It's insane.
00:07:54.740 So let me back up a little bit about who Nate Collins is and his relationship with SBTS.
00:08:01.180 So he did an interview with Preston Sprinkle in 2015.
00:08:05.680 We've talked about Preston Sprinkle before.
00:08:07.520 I think Preston Sprinkle has a lot of good things to say, but we disagree on things like
00:08:12.200 so-called pronoun politeness.
00:08:13.780 He would also say that it is valid to identify as a gay Christian.
00:08:17.540 I think, oh my goodness, that is a paradoxical abomination or maybe an abominable paradox because
00:08:25.780 you are identifying as that which God calls sin and trying to wed it with being a new creation.
00:08:32.380 It's like saying I'm an old new creation that is not in accordance with scripture.
00:08:37.000 That is not in accordance with the gospel.
00:08:39.640 You are still holding on to that such were some of you part of your life.
00:08:46.040 You are still holding on to the old self by identifying as two things that really don't
00:08:51.620 go together.
00:08:52.260 So I really disagree with him on that, even though ultimately Preston will say that biblical
00:08:59.020 marriage is between one man and one woman.
00:09:02.560 How we handle these issues is very different in a lot of ways.
00:09:09.380 So as I said, Nate Collins and Preston, they had a conversation together in 2015.
00:09:15.420 And Collins describes how he is same-sex attracted and how he kind of weds these two identities
00:09:22.700 of being same-sex attracted and a Christian together, which kind of laid the foundation
00:09:27.480 for everything we're talking about, the dissertation, revoice and all that.
00:09:30.620 So Collins also says that he is a same-sex attracted man in a mixed orientation marriage.
00:09:52.240 So that's one spouse is straight.
00:09:55.120 He uses that language while the other opposite sex spouse is attracted to the same sex.
00:10:00.440 So he has a wife, Sarah, that he is married to, but he is still attracted to men.
00:10:09.580 He says, he says, by the time we were married, I hadn't become straight because I still experienced
00:10:14.320 same-sex attractions.
00:10:15.200 At the same time, a one-woman orientation had been developing within me during my relationship
00:10:20.760 with Sarah.
00:10:21.340 So marrying her felt like the most natural thing to do.
00:10:23.800 And also, my heart had, in fact, grown to long for.
00:10:29.380 He also says he's not bisexual.
00:10:32.660 And so this is how he kind of describes his relationship there.
00:10:37.340 And then a little more about this thesis that Rosaria Butterfield has recently called out,
00:10:43.700 the virgin, a secondary gender identity in 1 Corinthians 7.
00:10:47.520 There are some quotes from this.
00:10:50.240 He says, this dissertation will argue the thesis that the Greek word for virgin functions as
00:10:56.060 a label that indexes the secondary gender identity in Paul's discussion of virgins in 1 Corinthians 7.
00:11:02.000 He says he will distinguish between primary gender identity and secondary gender identity.
00:11:07.260 He says primary gender identity is binary and reflects the original divine intent to create
00:11:13.120 male persons and female persons.
00:11:15.100 And secondary gender identity, on the other hand, is non-binary and is the result of the
00:11:19.540 pluriform effects of the enculturation of gender within human society, which, of course,
00:11:24.440 is completely theologically and biologically untrue.
00:11:28.840 And yet that is a part of his thesis.
00:11:30.720 He says that his thesis will also illustrate the significance of the sex-gender distinction
00:11:37.200 within Christian theology in ways that are less than apparent to secular forms of gender theory.
00:11:44.920 He talks about the differences in gender identities throughout Scripture.
00:11:50.400 His conclusion is, we began with a survey of feminist and contemporary gender theory in order
00:11:56.240 to discern the kinds of answers theorists have provided to the question, what is gender identity?
00:12:00.860 We observed that responses to this question followed several discernible patterns.
00:12:05.560 Each of them might inform Christian doctrine of gender.
00:12:08.820 Also in 2017, Nate published much of the material in a book titled All But Invisible,
00:12:17.100 Exploring Identity Questions at the Intersection of Faith, Gender, and Sexuality.
00:12:21.820 Collins explores the cultural background of what he describes as the intersection
00:12:25.080 between a gay identity and a Christian identity.
00:12:29.640 Collins is speaking from his own experience, of course, in his so-called mixed orientation marriage.
00:12:37.720 And so while Collins might, at the end of the day, agree that marriage biblically should be
00:12:44.700 between one man and one woman, I think we have some very serious fundamental theological disagreements
00:12:51.100 on what identity is and, again, what it means to be a new creation.
00:12:57.940 Maybe there is some common ground there in how we understand pushing our feelings to the side
00:13:05.420 and obeying the design that God has created for his people.
00:13:10.920 But it sounds to me like there is a lot of secularism in how he is viewing God's commands and how he is
00:13:20.420 viewing a scripture's descriptions of what gender, of what sex actually are.
00:13:27.240 Rosari's opinion on Collins' writing and bringing queer theory into Christian circles,
00:13:32.260 she says she compares, for example, critical race theory to a broken leg while trying to run a marathon.
00:13:39.140 It won't kill you, but you should get to a hospital to treat it right away.
00:13:43.300 The same would be true of queer theory.
00:13:44.800 And of course, she's an expert on queer theory.
00:13:47.240 She then compares critical queer theory to a massive heart attack.
00:13:50.440 This is why the church needs to wake up and drive it out of the evangelical institution.
00:13:55.160 So let me kind of correct myself there.
00:13:58.220 She says critical race theory being what it is, and we've talked about that many times on this podcast,
00:14:05.120 basically the belief that there is the black and brown oppressed and the white oppressor,
00:14:10.440 and everything is viewed through that lens.
00:14:14.880 She says that that is injurious, that that is going to harm your faith, that is going to hurt your theology,
00:14:21.380 and you need to get that fixed right away, but it's not going to quickly destroy it.
00:14:28.660 She says that critical queer theory is a massive heart attack,
00:14:32.900 and it will absolutely bring the faith, bring your doctrines to ruin.
00:14:39.020 It has to be driven out of evangelical institutions.
00:14:42.420 I don't know if we were talking right now if she would agree with this.
00:14:45.900 I actually think critical race theory is just as dangerous as critical queer theory.
00:14:51.960 I really do, and I actually think in some ways it's even more dangerous
00:14:55.740 because I think a lot of Christians see it as more innocuous,
00:14:59.380 and there is some kind of guilt attached to it for the white evangelical,
00:15:04.340 and so they start redefining justice in terms of critical race theory much more quickly
00:15:10.720 than they will redefine marriage or redefine sexuality in terms of critical queer theory.
00:15:18.320 So I think that they are equally dangerous just in different ways
00:15:23.100 because both of them beg us to ask the question, did God really say?
00:15:29.860 What is Revoice?
00:15:31.140 This is Nate Collins' organization.
00:15:33.420 Maybe you've heard it before.
00:15:35.140 The website says that it exists to support and encourage Christians who are sexual minorities
00:15:40.280 so they can flourish in historic Christian traditions.
00:15:43.660 Revoice was founded in 2018.
00:15:45.580 A group of Christians gathered.
00:15:46.880 Most of them were gay slash same-sex attracted to create events for supporting
00:15:51.720 and encouraging one another.
00:15:57.240 In theory, this may not sound necessarily bad
00:16:02.100 because people who struggle with same-sex attraction recognize that it is a disordered desire
00:16:07.120 and that same-sex relationships, same-sex behavior, that that is a sin,
00:16:13.960 that that is something that should be repented of,
00:16:15.920 that that's something that should be resisted, and we should embrace God's design.
00:16:20.600 Those people should have community.
00:16:22.540 They should be able to go to church.
00:16:24.120 They should be able to walk the road of sanctification empowered by the Holy Spirit
00:16:30.460 alongside other Christians that struggle in a variety of ways.
00:16:34.680 The problem with revoice is that it really blurs the lines between affirmation and love,
00:16:45.060 I would say, like true, godly, truth-filled love,
00:16:48.700 where you don't rejoice in wrongdoing but just rejoice in the truth,
00:16:52.800 and affirmation of sin, of course, which we believe is cruelty.
00:16:56.220 I think that revoice really blurs the lines between those two things.
00:17:00.280 For example, they say,
00:17:01.320 we believe that theological dialogue about the nature of sexual orientation is necessary
00:17:05.460 and that continued conversation regarding the discipleship and spiritual care
00:17:08.920 of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and other same-sex attracted Christians.
00:17:12.300 So see, they use the multiple labels.
00:17:14.400 They don't just say same-sex attracted.
00:17:16.900 They say gay, lesbian, bisexual,
00:17:18.620 as if that can be an active part of your identity as a Christian,
00:17:22.000 is especially important.
00:17:24.020 While discussions about terminology can be fruitful,
00:17:26.020 we believe they can also cause unnecessary division within the family of God
00:17:29.900 and needless pain for many non-straight Christians.
00:17:32.860 Whether individuals choose gay or same-sex attracted or to describe their orientation,
00:17:38.700 I don't even think orientation is the right language for the Christian.
00:17:43.000 I just don't because God orients our hearts when we become Christians towards the things
00:17:48.580 that He loves.
00:17:49.900 And orientation, I think, sounds like something that is fixed,
00:17:53.540 something that is innate and permanent that cannot be removed or changed at all.
00:17:59.260 And while we don't know if someone who is same-sex attracted,
00:18:02.220 that their attractions will necessarily change in the direction of the opposite sex,
00:18:09.820 we do know that God can do that, that of course He can.
00:18:13.440 It may always be a struggle for them,
00:18:16.620 a true repentance-centered struggle for them,
00:18:20.820 or maybe it won't be.
00:18:22.740 But the fact of the matter is, is that God can change that.
00:18:25.200 And saying orientation, again, sounds so stagnant and fixed,
00:18:27.800 I don't think that's right theologically.
00:18:30.120 They say orientation experience is a matter of wisdom and liberty.
00:18:34.160 I'm not sure about that.
00:18:35.720 And should divide, should not divide believers
00:18:38.540 who otherwise share a commitment to historic Christian teaching about marriage and sexuality.
00:18:43.680 Like if you look at the revoiced staff bios,
00:18:47.180 there is a woman claiming bisexual identity.
00:18:49.640 She has she, her pronouns in her profile.
00:18:53.160 And then a same-sex attracted male who shares his apartment with his quote-unquote chosen brother
00:18:58.180 and refers to it as a committed friendship.
00:19:01.340 I mean, would you ever recommend that a man and a woman who are not married and are committed to sexual purity,
00:19:11.380 that they share an apartment together?
00:19:13.600 Of course not.
00:19:14.680 And that's what also I find within these side B and even like side A Christian circles,
00:19:20.740 is that there doesn't seem to be the same kind of commitment to general sexual purity
00:19:25.160 as there is among like side X or side Y Christians.
00:19:30.280 Again, go listen to that episode to get an explanation of all of those things.
00:19:34.540 But those of us who consider ourselves, you know, conservative Christians,
00:19:38.820 I would never encourage a young woman to live with a man
00:19:43.340 if she is trying to follow God's design for purity.
00:19:47.260 And so why would I encourage someone who is same-sex attracted,
00:19:50.600 who is trying to remain celibate and who is truly struggling against that
00:19:55.060 in an effort to work out his salvation with fear and trembling?
00:19:58.400 I would say never put yourself in the position of living with a man
00:20:01.960 where you are just going to be placed into temptation.
00:20:05.000 I would say that in itself is a sin.
00:20:07.860 Um, they have also raised money, Revoice has raised money during June,
00:20:13.680 what they call Pride Month, to support LGBTQ plus slash SSA communities.
00:20:20.020 More specifically, the money goes towards Reach,
00:20:22.060 a leadership development cohort that quote unquote equips LGBTQ plus slash SSA
00:20:27.520 Christ followers to become kingdom leaders.
00:20:30.900 So this is what I'm talking about when I'm talking about blurring the lines.
00:20:35.000 Um, when it comes to affirmation, which I think is sinful,
00:20:40.280 affirmation of sin versus truth-filled love,
00:20:44.340 acknowledging and submitting to God's design for sexuality, uh, and marriage
00:20:49.480 and resisting temptation towards disorder.
00:20:54.300 Uh, that's what Revoice does.
00:20:56.460 It blurs those lines to where a lot of Christians are confused.
00:21:00.360 Remember, God is not the God of confusion.
00:21:02.440 He is the God of peace.
00:21:03.840 This seems to be a group that thinks that they are nicer than God,
00:21:07.320 that they are kinder than God, they're more merciful than God,
00:21:10.300 that they can kind of let God off the hook for those inconvenient passages
00:21:13.880 like Genesis 1 or 1 Corinthians 6 or, uh, Romans 1.
00:21:18.360 We need to kind of caveat and nuance that and make it more palatable for a gay world.
00:21:25.200 And I don't think that's going to cut it.
00:21:27.220 I just don't.
00:21:27.760 I think that causes actually a lot more chaos.
00:21:30.260 And so Rosaria Butterfield's point has proven true that I think his dissertation,
00:21:36.680 maybe that's not what caused the establishment of Revoice.
00:21:39.940 Maybe that didn't lay the sole foundation for his book and his ideas,
00:21:43.820 which really have taken root in a lot of evangelicalism,
00:21:47.240 but it probably played a role when it never should have been accepted in the first place
00:21:52.800 because it was so ridiculous on its face.
00:21:55.480 And so, like, I see Rosaria Butterfield as such a prophetic voice.
00:22:01.680 And I don't even mean that in, like, the charismatic sense.
00:22:05.120 I just mean that she is a forthright,
00:22:09.620 forth-telling voice about the issues within Christianity,
00:22:14.680 the issues within the world.
00:22:15.860 And I see her rebukes, her calling out, her criticism as acts of courageous love.
00:22:23.620 I know that these days you hear any kind of negativity or criticism.
00:22:28.180 People take it as a personal attack.
00:22:31.420 I don't see it as that at all.
00:22:33.800 I see it as her caring so much about the body of Christ.
00:22:37.160 I see it.
00:22:38.000 She just has such intense compassion and experience because of the life that she lived.
00:22:42.360 She knows very well what it looks like to be deceived, even so recently as repenting
00:22:47.020 of this so-called pronoun politeness that she once engaged in for the sake of evangelism.
00:22:52.800 She now realizes that that's telling a lie,
00:22:55.640 that you are trying to be the aroma of Christ while affirming the stench of death.
00:23:01.640 And we can't do that.
00:23:03.100 And so I just, I always love when she speaks the truth.
00:23:06.620 She's such an encouragement to me.
00:23:09.000 And that's why you got to come hear her and share the arrows of it.
00:23:12.260 TheSeptemberShareTheEarrows.com.
00:23:14.920 All right.
00:23:15.540 So that's one thing that's going on in the Christian world today.
00:23:18.520 There is never a dull moment within evangelicalism.
00:23:21.720 And even in like all different subsets of Christianity, there is just so much going on.
00:23:27.320 So many fault lines being drawn.
00:23:30.440 And all of us are just trying to navigate it with as much truth and grace as we possibly can.
00:23:35.760 You guys are helping me do that.
00:23:39.060 So let us continue to spur one another on toward loving good works.
00:23:42.440 And actually, just to put a flying point on the last segment, let me just,
00:23:58.280 I'm going to read you a quote from Rosaria.
00:24:02.500 She says this after reading Psalm 113.
00:24:05.400 She said,
00:24:35.400 No one told me to pray the gay away because every sermon told me to drive a fresh nail
00:24:45.740 into every sin every day.
00:24:48.660 No one needed to.
00:24:50.680 Because every sermon told me to drive a fresh nail into every sin every day.
00:24:56.380 No one needed to.
00:24:58.760 Thought that was so good.
00:25:00.980 And actually, it's a good transition into our next topic about morality and what Jesus says
00:25:09.200 about sexual morality and not just what we do, but also what we think and what we look at.
00:25:17.220 And this centers on a video of Dennis Prager that has been going around on X recently,
00:25:24.580 although it is from 2023.
00:25:26.320 And he is with Charlie Kirk at Arizona State University for Turning Point USA's Health,
00:25:34.100 Wealth, and Happiness 2.0 event last year.
00:25:38.660 And he makes some comments about masturbation, about lust, about what Jesus actually has to say
00:25:48.180 about lust.
00:25:48.780 And let me say first that I really respect Dennis Prager.
00:25:54.520 I'm so thankful for the work that he has done, how PragerU has educated millions and millions
00:26:00.400 of people.
00:26:02.940 And so I really, really disagree with him on this.
00:26:07.080 And I think that this argument is harmful in a lot of ways.
00:26:11.660 But I agree with Dennis Prager on the vast majority of things.
00:26:15.440 And of course, I am just so thankful for his influence and his courage over the years.
00:26:20.280 But I just wanted to respond to this because I could see how this thinking is convincing
00:26:26.020 for a lot of people.
00:26:28.020 So you might remember last year, April 2023, Prager was a part of a discussion panel hosted
00:26:33.100 by Jordan Peterson, in which he said that lust and pornography are not a big deal to him
00:26:39.240 as a Jew, he says, because Judaism is only concerned with action or behavior of adultery,
00:26:46.020 not with the heart, as Christians believe.
00:26:50.600 And of course, that is simply not true.
00:26:53.160 Even if you look at the Ten Commandments, not even looking at it from a Christian perspective,
00:26:57.020 just from a Jewish perspective, you look at the Ten Commandments, what is one of the
00:27:01.120 Ten Commandments?
00:27:02.160 I mean, actually, a lot of the commandments really have to do with the heart and the mind
00:27:05.980 and your belief, not only what you do, but I think specifically of thou shalt not covet.
00:27:12.060 You shouldn't covet your neighbor's wife or your neighbor's ox or your neighbor's house.
00:27:17.280 You shouldn't even want something that is not yours.
00:27:20.460 It wasn't just thou shalt not steal that was already covered in the Ten Commandments.
00:27:25.480 It's like you shouldn't steal, but you also shouldn't even want something that is not
00:27:29.940 yours.
00:27:30.320 So, I don't think that you can look at God's law giving to Israel and deduce that God only
00:27:35.860 cares about what we do externally.
00:27:38.480 So, again, not even just looking at it from my Christian New Testament perspective, that's
00:27:44.160 not accurate.
00:27:45.600 But he also says that certain external actions are not sin.
00:27:51.780 And this was, again, in this conversation last year in 2023.
00:27:57.340 So, I'll let you listen to this for yourself.
00:28:01.660 Here is salt one.
00:28:03.440 If masturbation is evil, then I think we have raped the term evil of its moral power.
00:28:12.720 Masturbation may be a sin, and even that is debatable because there's nothing, not a
00:28:18.540 hint of masturbation being a sin in the Bible.
00:28:22.480 I know the Hebrew Bible.
00:28:23.960 I know the Torah almost by heart in Hebrew.
00:28:25.920 There is not a hint of masturbation being a sin in the Old Testament or in the New Testament.
00:28:36.920 Okay, so this is in response to a question that asked Dennis, you outraged many Christians
00:28:41.700 when you said on a podcast a few months ago that you don't believe, and this is something
00:28:45.440 that Dennis Prager said, that you don't believe masturbating to animated pictures of child
00:28:50.200 pornography is wrong or you don't find it evil.
00:28:52.460 This is fundamentally at odds with Christian teachings about lust, extramarital sex, and
00:28:56.960 sins of the heart.
00:28:57.600 Christ even says in Matthew 5, 29, that these sins are enough to lead souls to hell.
00:29:02.980 How can you say Judeo-Christian values are universal to both faiths when something as essential as
00:29:08.560 good and evil are different?
00:29:11.840 And so, I think that's a really good question.
00:29:13.960 He did say that at the time, and I'm pretty sure that we responded to it on the show.
00:29:19.600 And so, basically what he says is that not all sins are evil, not in any of our religions
00:29:26.020 to the best of my knowledge.
00:29:28.440 He says in Catholicism, for example, it is a sin if you are healthy enough to go to Mass
00:29:33.060 and you never go.
00:29:33.980 But I don't know any Catholics that would say you're evil or it is evil if you don't attend
00:29:40.020 Mass.
00:29:40.420 This seems to me kind of some kind of semantic debate.
00:29:44.520 He says all evil is sin, but not every sin is evil.
00:29:48.380 I guess it depends on how you are defining evil.
00:29:55.080 He says, if you want to call masturbation evil, fine.
00:29:59.720 I use the term evil for rape, torture, murder, and the like.
00:30:02.680 If masturbation is evil, he says, then we have raped the term evil of its moral power.
00:30:08.400 You heard him say that in the clip.
00:30:13.620 And then he goes on to specifically answer this part about AI, child sex abuse material.
00:30:19.120 He says, let me just say my thinking has changed on the issue of artificial intelligence and
00:30:23.760 child porn.
00:30:24.740 I am now 100% opposed to it.
00:30:26.760 By the way, if all pornography were eradicated, we would have a much better society.
00:30:31.120 I just want to make that clear.
00:30:32.800 That is my position, which is really good to hear.
00:30:35.600 I'm so glad to hear that because really what started this conversation was even before
00:30:41.580 what he said about artificial intelligence, child sex abuse material was when he said publicly
00:30:50.880 that he didn't think that pornography was necessarily wrong, that it's not necessarily a bad thing
00:30:56.860 to look at porn.
00:30:57.600 So it seems like he has changed his position on that.
00:31:02.620 And then he goes on to talk more about masturbation.
00:31:07.820 He says, if God thinks that that is a sin, you have a different God than I do.
00:31:13.160 He says, my God has common sense, loves human beings, and understands that circumstances determine
00:31:18.300 a lot of things.
00:31:19.140 Is it wrong to lie?
00:31:20.120 Is it a sin to lie?
00:31:21.720 Yes.
00:31:21.940 Where the Germans are the Poles who hid a Jew and lied to Nazis about hiding a Jew.
00:31:26.000 Did they commit a sin?
00:31:27.460 And then he speaks to what I think a lot of our response would be, okay, but lust is always
00:31:34.120 a sin.
00:31:34.520 That's not really a circumstantial thing.
00:31:36.640 Jesus said it would be better to pluck out your eye than to look lustfully after a woman.
00:31:43.940 He then argued that we are alienating people from God if we interpret Matthew 5.29 as Jesus
00:31:52.520 prohibiting lust.
00:31:54.620 Here's Sato.
00:31:55.460 This is why religion turns people off.
00:31:59.060 When you go around telling people masturbation is a sin and you're committing evil, believe
00:32:04.120 me, you are not bringing people to God.
00:32:06.520 You are alienating people from God.
00:32:09.120 In the Christian belief, private thought, private belief, it's not necessarily as sinful, but
00:32:14.320 there's gradations of sin as well.
00:32:16.540 And it's hotly debated, but I think it's clear Christ said to lust after a woman.
00:32:21.040 Well, he didn't actually, and there's no reason you would know this.
00:32:24.360 No, no, no, no.
00:32:26.040 In fact, almost no Christian knows this.
00:32:29.260 I did research because I didn't believe Jesus said that because Jesus was a Jew.
00:32:35.640 It's not normative in Judaism that thinking something is equivalent to doing something.
00:32:42.200 And he was very normative in virtually all of his teachings.
00:32:48.160 So Charlie clearly disagrees with Dennis Prager there and is trying to speak up and push
00:32:54.120 back against him.
00:32:55.400 And I, of course, agree with Charlie on this because it is very obvious that Jesus is speaking
00:33:01.760 against less.
00:33:02.440 And of course, if you see this in context, what Jesus is doing to all of the laws is saying,
00:33:07.240 look, all of these laws were always about the heart.
00:33:09.660 And so I think that Jesus would have the same message, Dennis Prager, as he did to his audience
00:33:16.820 then as he was speaking even to the Pharisees when he was like, no, it's not enough that you
00:33:22.480 have this external obedience.
00:33:23.760 This law was always supposed to go down to heartfelt obedience, to heart-driven obedience.
00:33:30.820 So it's not enough not to steal.
00:33:34.500 You also shouldn't covet.
00:33:36.440 It's not enough not to just commit adultery.
00:33:39.160 You also shouldn't lust.
00:33:42.500 And so that is the point of this passage in Matthew 5, that real faith is not just about
00:33:49.780 externally what you do.
00:33:51.440 It was always supposed to be at the heart level, the soul level, the motivation level.
00:33:57.720 And so he goes on to say that it's actually been mistranslated from the Greek.
00:34:02.520 He said, if you covet another woman, it is as if you committed adultery with your heart.
00:34:06.660 That's what he's arguing Jesus actually meant.
00:34:08.600 And he says, I happen to agree with that coveting is banned in the Ten Commandments.
00:34:11.920 I know the Ten Commandments by heart in Hebrew.
00:34:14.280 There's a difference between covet and lust.
00:34:17.980 Well, I'm not so sure that there is.
00:34:20.280 If you are wanting another man's wife, if you are wanting a woman that is not your own,
00:34:25.380 that is a form of lust.
00:34:26.500 You are desiring something that is not yours.
00:34:29.700 He says there's no prohibition of lust in the Old Testament.
00:34:34.980 There's a prohibition on coveting.
00:34:36.800 So that must have been what Jesus meant.
00:34:41.440 Again, I think that this is probably comes down to semantics.
00:34:45.820 And of course, words are important.
00:34:47.520 Interpretation is important.
00:34:49.300 But to say that Jesus did not prohibit lust, that would not be in keeping with our understanding
00:34:56.280 of Scripture as a whole, and certainly not Jesus' message as a whole, not the New Testament
00:35:00.560 as a whole.
00:35:02.400 And our understanding about sin and human nature and how God is killing the old self and giving
00:35:08.240 us a new self.
00:35:09.500 Of course, Jesus is talking about the desires of our heart.
00:35:25.960 All right.
00:35:26.720 So here is thought three of Dennis Prager.
00:35:29.080 I just want to say I have brought more Americans to Christianity than any living Christian.
00:35:34.760 Okay.
00:35:35.380 That is that I know that for a fact.
00:35:37.900 I brought more Jews to Judaism than any living Jew.
00:35:42.060 So I know how to make the case for God and Bible and religion really effectively.
00:35:48.120 And I'm telling you, when we come out with stuff that people just intuitively understand,
00:35:54.120 that doesn't make moral sense.
00:35:56.800 We are not doing God or our Bible any service.
00:36:01.420 Okay.
00:36:02.040 I'm not really sure how you quantify that.
00:36:03.920 I praise God if there have been people who have been brought to Christianity through Dennis
00:36:08.040 Prager.
00:36:08.480 He does talk about the Bible.
00:36:09.860 And as we know, the Word of God does not return void.
00:36:11.960 So I think it's entirely possible that someone would have started reading the Bible because
00:36:15.740 of Dennis Prager talking about the Bible, and then they would have realized the truth
00:36:19.580 of God's Word and the truth of Christianity.
00:36:21.860 And I absolutely praise God for that.
00:36:23.720 As I said, Dennis Prager has done absolutely a lot of good work.
00:36:26.160 I'm not really sure how you quantify that he has brought more people to Christianity than
00:36:31.060 any living Christian.
00:36:32.680 In fact, I can probably say that that is absolutely not true, because Dennis Prager does good work
00:36:38.940 when he is talking about some really important issues, and maybe even when he is talking about
00:36:43.680 Scripture too.
00:36:45.060 But he does not believe in the gospel, and so he has not shared the gospel.
00:36:48.860 And I promise you that there are Christians who have shared the gospel, maybe people we
00:36:54.460 don't even know, whose names we don't even know, who God has used to bring more people
00:36:59.480 to Christ, because his gospel is the good news that people are then latching on to.
00:37:05.900 And as I've said many times, we don't have to apologize for God.
00:37:08.460 We don't have to take him off the hook.
00:37:10.720 We don't have to pretend like his word is too hard to do or too hard to understand, because
00:37:15.620 the Holy Spirit gives us understanding.
00:37:17.200 It gives us the ability to obey.
00:37:19.500 Again, when God makes us new, a new creation, he also empowers us to obey him.
00:37:24.820 And it's always going to be a struggle against the flesh, but struggling against lust is that
00:37:29.860 struggle against the flesh.
00:37:31.140 I think actually, intuitively, we understand that masturbation and that lusting after someone
00:37:37.960 else is not right.
00:37:39.460 I actually think people really intuitively understand that, because you take a secular couple, and
00:37:45.120 the woman is sitting there at dinner across from her boyfriend or for her husband, that
00:37:52.340 guy leans over and checks out the back of the waitress.
00:37:56.700 Do you think that secular woman thinks, that's awesome?
00:38:00.120 That is great.
00:38:00.920 At least he's not cheating on me.
00:38:02.460 It's totally fine.
00:38:03.740 I guarantee you that at least 90% of women, if not more, no matter their background would
00:38:10.640 say, are you freaking kidding me?
00:38:12.600 Are you kidding?
00:38:13.660 And then that would start a fight, because there is something innate in us that wants
00:38:17.640 faithfulness, that wants loyalty, that wants exclusivity, wants monogamy.
00:38:22.640 And not just in deed, but also in thought.
00:38:26.820 Most women or men, if they found out that their significant other was thinking about other people,
00:38:33.480 that would be a big problem.
00:38:34.860 Because they would say, okay, you're dissatisfied with me.
00:38:37.000 You are wanting something that I am not giving you, and that would cause a lot of heartache
00:38:41.540 and despair.
00:38:42.120 So I think he's wrong when he says that intuitively people understand that masturbation and lust
00:38:46.960 are not really evil, they're not really sins, and we don't need to worry about that.
00:38:51.020 We mostly just need to focus on, you know, externalities.
00:38:56.420 I don't think so.
00:38:57.580 I think that's a secular way of thinking.
00:38:59.500 I honestly think that is a morally delusional way of thinking.
00:39:03.480 And it certainly is an anti-gospel, anti-Jesus way of thinking that he takes over the whole
00:39:11.960 self, the whole heart, that there is not a centimeter of the self that Christ does not
00:39:18.840 say mine to.
00:39:21.180 When he becomes king, when he becomes ruler, he takes over.
00:39:26.120 He gets rid of the old man bit by bit throughout our lives.
00:39:29.700 It is a painful process, that process of refining, that process of sanctification, that process
00:39:35.700 of holiness.
00:39:36.240 It is letting go of our selfishness.
00:39:38.540 It's letting go of our lust.
00:39:40.200 It's letting go of our desires and getting something better, more fulfilling, more satisfying.
00:39:49.040 And I think that that's kind of what ties the first two segments of this podcast together,
00:39:54.080 that understanding that the gospel really is better than the things we want in this life,
00:39:59.820 no matter how much we want them.
00:40:03.040 All right.
00:40:03.960 That's all we got for the serious aspects of this podcast.
00:40:08.360 Now we have to talk about one final thing to end our week.
00:40:13.940 And I will bring producer Brie in on this.
00:40:16.480 And that has to do, have you heard this term before?
00:40:19.500 That has to do with passenger princesses, a passenger princess.
00:40:25.720 Have you heard of this term?
00:40:27.680 So there was this tweet that went viral on Axe or post that went viral on Axe that says,
00:40:34.320 this lady just picked her husband up from the airport, kissed him, and immediately went
00:40:39.160 to the passenger seat LMAO.
00:40:42.200 And this post got like tens of thousands of likes.
00:40:45.780 I don't even know how many likes it has now.
00:40:47.800 And then I quote tweeted this, and I didn't think it would get as much traction as it did
00:40:53.240 my response to it.
00:40:54.360 But I said, does every wife not do this?
00:40:57.260 Unless my husband is recovering from major surgery, I ain't driving.
00:41:02.180 And that is the truth.
00:41:03.480 I think my husband might actually say, no, even if I'm recovering from major surgery, you're
00:41:10.660 not driving.
00:41:11.200 And some people who desperately need to go touch their hand on grass were very upset with my
00:41:22.400 response for some reason.
00:41:23.960 Like some of the quote tweets on my tweet and some of the responses, the replies to both
00:41:28.800 my tweet and the original tweet were so just unabashedly misogynistic and weird that I feel
00:41:36.200 like I have to explain myself, although I'm sure a lot of you understand the dynamic at
00:41:40.920 play here and why we are in fact passenger princesses when our husbands are around.
00:41:46.460 Okay, so let me just play you this TikTok.
00:42:00.780 This will give you a visual of what a passenger princess is.
00:42:04.020 And even I can't totally relate to this exact setup.
00:42:08.220 This is the general situation that we're talking about.
00:42:11.680 Stop five.
00:42:16.460 Okay, so a passenger princess is a woman who gets in the front seat.
00:42:46.440 front seat and gets comfortable.
00:42:49.340 And basically, you've got your just your miniature little oasis there.
00:42:54.800 You're just like a little, I don't know, cube of luxury.
00:43:01.020 You have everything exactly how you want it.
00:43:03.580 You've got your drink receptacles at least two, probably three.
00:43:07.580 For me, it's usually coffee, water and like some kind of juicer protein shake.
00:43:12.580 She's got her bag.
00:43:13.560 She's got her blanket.
00:43:14.500 She's got her slippers.
00:43:15.400 She's got her music.
00:43:17.220 And then your husband is the one who has to navigate and has to drive.
00:43:22.020 And your job when you get in the car is to think about absolutely nothing.
00:43:25.520 You just completely check out.
00:43:27.060 You cannot even be trusted to tell him when the next turn is because that is not your job.
00:43:32.100 When you are a passenger princess, you just get in and you let him drive.
00:43:36.480 Now, the only difference between this TikTok situation and then my situation with my husband,
00:43:42.800 because I guess I am a passenger princess.
00:43:44.440 I had never heard this term before I tweeted what I did, is that I probably wouldn't bring
00:43:51.040 a blanket.
00:43:52.180 I would definitely not turn the heat up like she did.
00:43:54.720 And I would not put my feet up on the dash.
00:43:56.780 And my husband would not want me to put my feet up on the dash because that is dangerous.
00:44:02.880 But other and also if we have kids in the car, that whole thing about her like taking the
00:44:07.500 phone and turning it to the music that she wanted, that would never happen.
00:44:10.480 Because everyone knows when you have kids in the car, kids are in charge of what is being
00:44:15.080 listened to.
00:44:16.100 And you do that so then you can actually have a conversation with your spouse in the front row.
00:44:24.080 So that would be the only distinction there.
00:44:26.820 But it's a great dynamic.
00:44:30.280 It's a great dynamic.
00:44:31.900 And my husband wants it to be that way.
00:44:34.980 He wants me to be able to get in the car and to not have to think about anything and for him to
00:44:39.400 drive.
00:44:39.680 He wants to drive.
00:44:41.000 It's not like I insist on being a passenger princess.
00:44:44.100 This is the dynamic my husband prefers.
00:44:46.860 I do not drive on road trips.
00:44:48.400 I completely would if he asked me to.
00:44:51.520 But I never do.
00:44:52.480 It doesn't matter if we are driving 15 hours.
00:44:54.440 I do not drive one hour.
00:44:55.640 Again, I would.
00:44:56.980 But he does not want me to.
00:44:58.340 So I have a passenger princess for life.
00:45:01.800 Now, let me just read you.
00:45:04.080 I'll just read you one response.
00:45:05.480 There were a lot of deranged responses.
00:45:07.740 But this person responded, I'm legit starting to think there's something wrong with women.
00:45:13.180 Why are you so many averse to driving?
00:45:15.880 It actually and legitimately might help y'all get over your neuroses.
00:45:21.120 I'm not a neurotic person, by the way.
00:45:24.300 Self-determinate forward momentum.
00:45:28.940 Really does improve negative emotion.
00:45:32.160 Okay.
00:45:32.420 Self-determinate forward momentum.
00:45:34.820 Like walking?
00:45:36.400 Like just moving forward.
00:45:37.740 Like you know that I still do that, right?
00:45:39.500 Like I'm not a wheelchair princess.
00:45:41.840 Like I don't make him push me around everywhere.
00:45:44.240 And you know that we drive like we do drive.
00:45:47.620 I drive myself.
00:45:49.180 I drive my kids all the time.
00:45:50.840 It's not like my husband is my chauffeur.
00:45:53.120 It's just that when my husband is with me, he is going to be in the driver's seat.
00:45:58.500 And that's normal.
00:46:00.500 And some people also like, oh my gosh, the gender dynamics among fundamentalists, among Americans.
00:46:07.760 They're so crazy.
00:46:09.060 It's so ugly.
00:46:10.560 No one said that you have to do that, Miss Mary Sue.
00:46:15.020 If you want to drive and you want your husband to be a passenger prince, and that is the dynamic that you'll have, then I love that for you, Mary Sue.
00:46:26.240 I truly do.
00:46:27.200 So now, Bree, we were talking about this and you were saying, oh, you don't know if you have anything to say, but okay, I know that you drive yourself, but do you enjoy driving?
00:46:38.400 Would you prefer to be a passenger princess?
00:46:41.240 Yeah, of course.
00:46:42.400 I actually consider myself a really good driver.
00:46:45.040 Yeah.
00:46:45.280 But if I had the opportunity to be a passenger princess, yeah, absolutely.
00:46:51.340 To turn my mind off?
00:46:52.780 Yes.
00:46:53.440 Yeah.
00:46:54.040 I'm an aspiring passenger princess.
00:46:55.980 Yes, an aspiring passenger princess, a potential passenger princess.
00:47:01.800 So you don't think it is, I don't know, speaking to the laziness or the uselessness of women, like some people were saying on X.
00:47:10.200 Yeah, no, I don't.
00:47:13.020 I don't think that.
00:47:14.520 No, I think it's also just kind of like a cute trend.
00:47:17.480 And I think people need to get over that.
00:47:19.420 Yeah, they really do.
00:47:21.200 You know what?
00:47:21.800 Going into a holiday week and, you know, a travel week and a travel season, I just want to say cheers to all of you fellow passenger princesses out there.
00:47:33.360 We will be passenger princessing it up over the next few weeks.
00:47:38.140 All right.
00:47:38.580 That's all we've got for this week.
00:47:39.840 We will be back here on Monday.
00:47:41.900 We will be back here on Monday.
00:47:51.140 Thank you.
00:47:53.340 Thank you.
00:47:54.820 Thank you.
00:47:55.100 Take care.
00:47:55.400 Take care.
00:47:55.520 Take care.
00:47:55.620 Bye.
00:47:55.960 Bye.