Dr. Etan Haim is a whistleblower from Texas Children s Hospital where he uncovered doctors secretly performing transgender procedures to gender confused children. Well, he has been indicted by the federal government on a bunch of bogus charges, and a judge is threatening him with federal prison if he does not stop talking about this case. Now, his wife, Andrea Haim, is here to tell us what is really going on.
00:00:01.000Dr. Etan Haim is a whistleblower from Texas Children's Hospital, where he uncovered doctors secretly performing transgender procedures to gender-confused children.
00:00:15.420Well, he has been indicted by the federal government on a bunch of bogus charges, and he has just been given a gag order.
00:00:24.280The judge is threatening him with federal prison if he does not stop talking about this case.
00:00:29.820Well, now his wife, Andrea Haim, who is a lawyer, is here to tell us what is really going on.
00:00:39.000This is a fascinating and disturbing look at the incompetence and the evil that exists in parts of our government, and it's time for us to share the arrows with the Haim family.
00:00:51.520This episode is brought to you by our friends at Good Ranchers. Go to GoodRanchers.com. Use code Allie at checkout. That's GoodRanchers.com, code Allie.
00:01:08.960Andrea, thanks so much for taking the time to join us. I saw your thread on Axe.
00:01:14.160Some people are probably familiar, if they remember Vanessa Sivage's episode that we did, but could you just remind us, who is your husband?
00:01:23.160Yeah, absolutely. Thank you so much for having me on, Allie Beth.
00:01:25.560So my name is Andrea Haim. My husband is Dr. Etan Haim.
00:01:29.880He is a general surgeon, and he was a whistleblower who exposed that Texas Children's Hospital,
00:01:35.260which is the largest children's hospital in the world, was lying to the public about the existence of its transgender program for children.
00:01:44.200As a result of his whistleblowing, the Texas legislature passed SB 14, which was the law banning transgender care for minors in the state of Texas,
00:01:55.620And an investigation started into Texas Children's from the Texas Attorney General's Office.
00:02:02.100After that, we received a felony indictment against my husband.
00:02:06.280He's been indicted on four felony counts for various completely made up and baseless violations of HIPAA.
00:02:13.860And we've been fighting that since June of 2023.
00:02:18.500So, you know, I think I do think what happened was in retaliation for him speaking out.
00:02:23.040But ultimately, our goal was always to protect children.
00:02:27.280I'm speaking out today instead of him because my husband is under what we've been calling a de facto gag order or a non-gag gag order.
00:02:37.000He's been really active on X, posting about what's happened to us in this case and some of the government corruption that we've experienced.
00:02:44.860And the judge has basically instructed him not to continue to speak out, you know, about the government, about the prosecutors.
00:02:54.900And we don't know the consequences for violating that.
00:02:59.060And I can get into, you know, specifically what we think that order means.
00:03:02.720But for now, it's safer for me to be the one speaking out on his behalf.
00:03:06.840OK, so tell me what your husband saw that compelled him to speak out about it.
00:03:14.420Obviously, we know that these transgender procedures, the medications prescribed, it wasn't supposed to be happening.
00:03:24.080But what specifically did he see that made him say, OK, I've got to say something about this?
00:03:30.260So we have been married only a couple of months.
00:03:31.960We got married in August of 2022 and in fall of 2022, Etan was working as a surgery resident.
00:03:39.600So he was doing his surgical training at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, one of the best surgery training programs in the country.
00:03:47.080And they cover a variety of hospitals around the Texas Medical Center, which is the largest medical center in the world, including Texas Children's, the largest children's hospital in the world.
00:03:58.880And some of his colleagues had told him that they were implanting puberty blocking devices into children as young as 11 years old, 11, 12, 13 year old kids.
00:04:11.460So we sort of heard this just as a rumor.
00:04:13.980My husband had done those procedures before, but only on kids who actually had real hormonal deficiencies and needed that treatment.
00:04:22.300So the fact that they were doing it on kids who claim to have gender dysphoria was really surprising.
00:04:27.580So he told me that this, you know, that he had heard rumors of this going on.
00:04:31.880People had told him specifically that they had done it.
00:04:35.380And, you know, we started to look into it further.
00:04:38.880And the first thing I did was Google Texas Children's, you know, transgender program.
00:04:47.860Texas Children's didn't put anything out.
00:04:49.440And the only thing that you could see was a statement from March of 2022, in which Texas Children's Hospital stated unequivocally that they were stopping their program due to a Texas Attorney General opinion that these procedures may be considered child abuse under Texas law.
00:05:21.740And if you Google Texas Children's, you know, you can find the most rare chromosomal diseases.
00:05:26.920You know, everything has a place because people need to know to go online and look for doctors that treat their child's condition.
00:05:34.300So we started to hear that this was happening.
00:05:36.280And then someone sent my husband a link to a Zoom conference in January of 2023, which was hosted by the Baylor College of Medicine Medical Ethics Organization.
00:05:48.340It is essentially a medical ethics student organization.
00:05:52.940And I actually joined myself under my maiden name so my husband wasn't implicated and reported that.
00:06:00.000And what we learned is that Texas Children's had an extensive transgender medicine program.
00:06:06.740They were implanting puberty blockers and doing and prescribing puberty blockers on children as young as 11 years old.
00:06:13.760And they started doing this only three days after they said that they paused or stopped the program.
00:06:18.660And that they, you know, were they had the doctors who were part of this program on there.
00:06:25.680And those doctors said that they were prescribing puberty blockers to children, that they were telling parents that they needed to agree or consent to giving children puberty blockers.
00:06:38.620Otherwise, you know, since they use this line, which I know that Vanessa said a lot as well, and people in the media talked about, which is that, would you rather have a living son or a dead daughter?
00:06:49.500And I think this is one of the most malicious lies that has to do with those transgender medicine children.
00:06:55.140And not only that, but recently, just last week, in an oral argument before the Supreme Court, the attorney for the ACLU admitted that there's no evidence that puberty blockers on children or, you know, these hormonal interventions decrease the risk of suicide.
00:07:12.720So they completely backed away from it.
00:07:15.780And we knew that they were doing that to parents.
00:07:17.880We knew they were doing that to children.
00:07:19.180And they admitted in that Zoom conference as well that they were doing it to hide in a way that would hide it from governing medical bodies by failing to publish or, you know, to write down consults to the transgender clinic.
00:07:33.580So the whole thing was, you know, extremely, within a hospital, it was public.
00:07:37.820But to, you know, the outside public, to parents who may be taking their children to Texas Children, you would never know that this program existed.
00:08:33.640Go to CozyEarth.com slash Relatable, code Relatable.
00:08:36.580Okay, so that was 2022 that he started speaking up about it?
00:08:45.720It was actually the only person that he found out about it.
00:08:50.200He found out about it in fall of 2022.
00:08:53.240We started learning more about it in spring of 20, in winter of 2023.
00:08:59.120We had that Zoom conference, which I mentioned.
00:09:01.580He also found a Grand Rounds lecture, which was, you know, these are hosted by the pediatric program at Texas Children's.
00:09:09.800They're open to the public, and they are essentially, you know, like the most prestigious lecture series within the hospital, which states the institutional priorities.
00:09:18.880So we learned from that that the program existed in exactly how they were starting children on puberty blockers, young, then moving to cross-text hormones, and then advising, moving on to actual surgeries, including phalloplasty, vaginoplasty, things like that.
00:09:34.240So we started to learn about that, and then he started reaching out anonymously to journalists in spring of 2023.
00:09:43.980He wanted to get the story out and have people know what was happening, that Texas Children's was lying to the public.
00:09:49.940But at that time, we were completely anonymous.
00:09:52.340You know, he didn't want anyone to know his identity, frankly.
00:09:54.720And then, alongside the journalist, Christopher Ruffo, in May 2023, Chris Ruffo finally picked up the story and saw what was happening.
00:10:06.860In addition to the evidence I just mentioned, my husband provided redacted surgeries and endocrine clinic schedules, which showed unequivocally that they were doing transgender procedures on children, at Texas Children's, starting only three days after they said that they stopped.
00:10:23.300And my husband provided schedules that were redacted.
00:10:26.220He didn't release any protective patient information, just the fact that these procedures were happening.
00:10:31.000And this was 2023, that he was talking to Christopher Ruffo, and he just thought, okay, I need to get this out there.
00:10:37.780Can you tell me, before we go on, why did it disturb your husband so much?
00:10:43.000Not just when it comes to the hospital lying about it.
00:10:46.840Obviously, there's an ethical issue there.
00:10:48.760But I am gathering that he was disturbed by the procedures themselves.
00:10:54.720And so, medically and morally, why was he against these procedures happening?
00:11:01.280The procedures involved, so the main thing that Texas Children's was doing that we were aware of were puberty blockers.
00:11:09.400They were prescribing medication puberty blockers and doing injections.
00:11:13.120And they were also implanting surgical devices into the office.
00:11:16.240And my husband's done these procedures before, and he explained them to me at length.
00:11:19.560Essentially, what you do is you cut into a child's arm, and you implant a small device that's about this big that, you know, stays, I believe it's for a year that it stays in there.
00:11:30.500And the puberty blockers, as was admitted, again, in the Supreme Court oral argument in the Scremeni case last week, render children infertile.
00:11:39.080The evidence has overwhelmingly showed that children who start three blockers will never have, you know, well, in almost all cases, not be able to have children.
00:11:51.800They also have long-term effects, including affecting brain development, your heart, your growth.
00:11:59.320You know, young boys may never have adult genitalia.
00:12:03.240You know, it stunts your growth in every way.
00:12:05.160There are 20-year-olds with osteoporosis because of the hormones that they're started on.
00:12:23.760So I think, you know, people say, or at least on, you know, proponents of transgender care for children have said that these procedures are irreversible.
00:34:26.820I think that I was just going to say, I think the biggest thing that's happened in this case is that the government's initial indictment charged him with false pretense that he had illegally accessed records under false pretenses.
00:34:40.400Their belief was that he had, quote, no reason to be accessing medical records at Texas Children's.
00:34:48.800At the time he accessed the medical records, he was officially working as part of their residency program.
00:34:55.360He was officially working at another hospital.
00:34:57.180But what the government knew and what they failed to include in the indictment was that my husband actually was treating patients at Texas Children's Hospital, both adult patients and pediatric patients, even when he was working at this other hospital, because he was often called to assist with surgeries there.
00:35:14.040And we knew that in April of 2023, he actually performed surgery at Texas Children's.
00:35:19.320So he had every reason to be in their medical system and to be accessing their medical records.
00:35:23.280So the government knew that and they indicted him anyway and said that he had no reason.
00:35:29.380When we pointed that out, they actually had to go back and change their indictment to take all of that out.
00:35:37.900They also had so they had to change their indictment once and then they had to change it again because they had multiple typos in their indictment, including where they didn't even include the statute that they were charging him under.
00:35:53.060The most legally operative part of the indictment was a typo.
00:35:57.380They charged him with a statutory provision that didn't exist.
00:36:00.200So they embarrassed themselves and they had to change it.
00:36:02.740They also initially just said that he was that the victims were Texas Children's doctors and patients.
00:36:11.160Later, they changed it to say that the victims were Texas Children's hospital and the doctors.
00:36:21.000I mean, there's a lot of things that made it very clear that, you know, I think it was Stalin's head of the secret police area who said, show me the man and I'll show you the crime.
00:36:53.660Also, even if it ends up that he is vindicated, the fact that you guys have had to spend your life savings while you've had a baby instead of just celebrating his, you know, his graduation and then getting pregnant and have a baby, which I know that you have enjoyed and celebrated all of those things.
00:37:09.860But it is against this backdrop of this investigation.
00:37:13.720And instead of saving for your child's future, you have had to spend all of your money, all these donations on legal fees.
00:37:34.800If you are looking to protect yourself or your children or someone in your family from the predation of porn, explicit online content, then you need to partner with Covenant Eyes.
00:37:50.780This is a software that you download on your devices to block pornography and explicit content.
00:37:59.400They also have an app, a victory app, with different kinds of transparency and accountability tools.
00:38:06.460You can partner with an accountability partner who can actually see your internet activity, just making sure that you are staying on the straight and narrow.
00:38:14.920When it comes to what you're filling your mind with and what you see online, go to CovenantEyes.com slash Allie.
00:38:22.880When you do, you can use Covenant Eyes for free for 30 days.
00:38:30.580They have been in the anti-porn game for years, and their software will really help you if that's something that you're trying to protect yourself from.
00:38:45.780Tell me what happened on December 3rd with this gag order.
00:38:49.680So, December 3rd, and I just want to return to one thing about having our daughter.
00:38:53.480I think this is illustrative of exactly what the toll that it's taken on our family.
00:38:59.920So, my daughter was born on September 25th.
00:39:02.480Unexpectedly, she was a couple weeks early, but I had gone in for my 38-week appointment and had high blood pressure, and so my doctor is up-inducing me early.
00:39:14.040I gave birth to my daughter by emergency C-section on September 25th.
00:39:21.040On September 26th, my husband was due in Houston for a hearing in federal court.
00:39:27.100So, I actually had an emergency C-section, you know, a few hours before my husband had to leave to go to Houston.
00:39:35.200And, you know, he spent a few, I think, months, maybe two hours at most with me and our daughter, and he had to leave when I was still in post-op recovery.
00:39:48.280Unfortunately, my parents were able to be there with me, but that's the type of toll that this has taken, is that something is, you know, happy.
00:39:55.000The best day of my life was the day that, you know, our baby daughter was born, and my husband had to leave early because of this proceeding.
00:40:02.980And then, for weeks after that, I was, you know, I constantly think about the fact that he's being charged with 10 years in prison.
00:40:15.740You've got a lot going on in your mind and your body to be also dealing with this, and now you're basically the spokesperson for your husband because he can't speak up.
00:40:54.900All of the worry that we've had, all of the financial tolls, you know, it's been immense.
00:41:01.280But I think, you know, they're trying to say, to your point, that this isn't worth it to speak up.
00:41:05.860And as somebody who's been through it and has seen my husband go through it, I don't think either of us for a second would have changed what he did because protecting these children and what they're doing to these kids and the life that they're leaving them with and taking away their choice, you know, to have a family and leaving them with irreparable medical conditions is so much worse than what's happened to us.
00:41:30.420So, I don't think either of us would have changed that.
00:41:54.320So, the government recently moved for what's called a gag order to stop him from speaking out.
00:42:01.360And there are two things that pursue this.
00:42:03.580My husband, you know, as I mentioned, has been very active in the media.
00:42:06.100He has a very active account on X where he talks about, in honest terms, what has happened to us throughout this case, what the government's been doing.
00:42:15.880And in most cases, he uses clips of, you know, screenshots of public hearings from this case, transcripts of public hearings, transcripts of motions that anyone can download on the Internet.
00:42:26.900So, he's just been talking about what's happened.
00:42:30.180And two things have happened recently in this case that I think, you know, in some ways probably precipitated their request for a gag order.
00:42:37.100One of these is that the government absolutely embarrassed themselves at a hearing a couple of weeks ago on a motion to dismiss.
00:42:44.600They, you know, the lead prosecutor was completely unprepared.
00:42:48.440They were, you know, disciplined by the judge for not being prepared for the typos that I mentioned in the indictment, for various other things, practicing without a law license, things like that.
00:43:00.080So, my husband was publishing, you know, transcripts of that hearing and commenting on them.
00:43:06.200The other thing that we learned is that the lead prosecutor on the case, the one who had been pushing this all along, had serious financial conflicts and personal conflicts with Texas Children's Hospital.
00:43:19.220Her brother, who's the CEO of their family company, has contracts with several hospitals in the medical center.
00:43:26.020And both her brother and her aunt are fundraisers for Texas Children's Hospital.
00:43:46.680My husband has been talking about that publicly.
00:43:48.500There was a Fox News article that came out about these conflicts recently.
00:43:52.440And after all of this, so she's now no longer on the case.
00:43:57.000We don't know why, but I suspect it has something to do with those two things.
00:44:01.400Shortly after that, you know, my husband's been posting on X since at least January 2024.
00:44:08.400But they've only moved for a gag order recently.
00:44:10.820And they asked the court to silence him, to stop him from what they called online bullying of prosecutors.
00:44:17.020Mind you, this is the same office that commonly prosecutes cartel members and serious, violent offenders that they're going after my husband for bullying.
00:44:29.520They said that, you know, he was likely to taint a jury pool, which is just an absolutely ridiculous argument.
00:44:38.400The jury pool would have been 5.5 million people.
00:44:40.860So, just, you know, an absolutely ridiculous motion that was designed to shut him up.
00:44:47.440Because what he was saying was things that they didn't like.
00:44:51.020And on December 3rd, we had a hearing in front of the judge where the government walked through all of the things that they found objectionable.
00:45:00.080And some of these were things that they didn't like.
00:45:02.700Really, what it was is they didn't like what my husband was saying.
00:45:05.460They don't like that he's calling them corrupt.
00:45:37.920And he, you know, imposed what we've been calling a non-gag, gag order or a de facto gag order.
00:45:45.940He told Eitan and his attorneys to essentially stop talking about the case in the media, to stop talking about the judge, to stop talking about the prosecutors.
00:45:55.440We don't know exactly what's barred by it, but he did threaten my husband with federal prison if he continues to engage in similar conduct to what he had been doing on X.
00:46:07.380Yeah. So, you said the judge threatened Eitan with federal prison and his attorneys with sanctions if they continue to post so-called inflammatory content on X about the DOJ's corruption in this case.
00:46:20.300And you also said that when the judge, I guess, put up these X posts and threatened, you know, your husband with federal prison, that it was so absurd that there was audible laughter in the courtroom, including a post from one of Eitan's attorneys, which referred to the bungling, illicit, twitching pile of catastrophe that this case is.
00:46:42.160So, these posts were the ones put up that the judge was trying to very seriously say, see, these are awful, these are inflammatory, this is why we must put a gag order on you.
00:46:50.100And you're saying people in the courtroom laughed?
00:46:53.640The judge, I want to be really clear about this. It wasn't the judge that put them up, it was the prosecutors.
00:47:08.840It's not only were they listing Eitan's posts, but they were listing a post from his attorneys and then from various ex-users who, you know, made these comments.
00:47:19.700I think, you know, one of them called the prosecution team a clown car of incompetent midwits or, you know, something like that.
00:47:27.400There was audible laughter in the courtroom.
00:47:29.020I mean, there was media there, you know, people on our side were there, there were some other prosecutors there.
00:47:36.300There was audible laughter when they put these things up.
00:48:03.860Early February is when it's scheduled.
00:48:05.360I think February 10th is jury selection.
00:48:08.940So, for now, I think we're just moving forward.
00:48:12.940We're trying to get the word out of what happened in this case.
00:48:15.940I think, you know, essentially what the judge did by not writing down a gag order.
00:48:21.220Normally, if you're going to gag someone's First Amendment rights, if you're going to stop them from exercising their constitutional right to speak, typically you would put that in an order on paper that we can appeal to the appellate court.
00:48:45.960So, for now, I'm going to continue to speak out.
00:48:49.520I think what happened with this gag order hearing is a travesty.
00:48:54.420I do think it's unconstitutional, in my opinion.
00:48:57.700And so, I'm not going to allow the government to tell us what we can and can't say about this case.
00:49:03.780And people need to know because the gag order is just the culmination of everything that has happened to us in this case at the hands of the government.
00:49:10.660It's, you know, the cherry on the top of a sundae of incompetence and corruption that we've seen.
00:49:18.460And so, to me, it's important that people know what's happening in this case.
00:49:22.760They know that my husband's First Amendment rights are under attack.
00:49:27.740But I'm not bound by the jurisdiction of the court.
00:49:30.520And I can speak freely about what has been happening to us.
00:49:33.760So, I'm going to continue to do that pending trial.
00:49:45.520Over 38,000 businesses have future-proofed their business with NetSuite by Oracle,
00:49:50.320the number one cloud ERP, bringing accounting, financial management, inventory, HR into one fluid platform.
00:49:58.000With one unified business management suite, there's one source of truth giving you the visibility and control you need to make quick decisions.
00:50:06.740Real-time insights and forecasting so you can look into the future with actionable data.
00:50:11.600You can close your books a lot more quickly, saving you really valuable time.
00:50:16.640Right now, you can download the CFO's Guide to AI and Machine Learning at netsuite.com slash Allie.
00:50:25.120That free guide is at netsuite.com slash Allie.
00:50:29.580My goodness, the fact that they would try to inhibit his First Amendment rights because their feelings were hurt or they were embarrassed.
00:50:39.280I'm looking at some of these posts that he retweeted.
00:50:43.600I don't know all of these ex-users, but I'd like to see government officials learn their job is public, paid for by the public, and open to the public scrutiny.
00:50:51.060The number of effeminate clowns at DOJ who blatantly engage in bad faith legal work is stunning.
00:50:56.300It is my life's mission to professionally skewer and embarrass these absolute stooges.
00:51:00.640Someone, I don't know who this person is on X and X user.
00:51:05.080The prosecutorial team is a clown car of incompetent midwits, and it's not going well for them.
00:51:12.660So now the DOJ, and it just goes on and on, explaining what happened.
00:51:16.920And so I know that your lawyers are fighting for his First Amendment rights.
00:51:23.720Sorry if you've already explained this, but is there a chance that this could be lifted?
00:51:27.960He will continue to be able to speak out?
00:52:14.660I think, you know, this is just something that we're going to have to live with.
00:52:18.500And he's abiding by the judge's instruction, as are his attorneys.
00:52:23.160So it's just a matter of how do we continue to get the message out, you know, and my personal desire to have people know what's going on in this case.
00:52:33.260Yes. And amen. Well, we're going to be praying for y'all and following this closely if there's anything else that we can do.
00:52:40.440I mean, my audience is really, really good at rallying around people who are we call it sharing the arrows.
00:52:46.660And that's exactly what you and your husband are doing.
00:52:48.960Rather than saying, we see this thing going on, I don't want to get involved.
00:52:53.600I'm too scared to get involved because of the risk to my career or my life.
00:52:58.240He decided and you decided to stand up and say, you know what?
00:53:01.900No, I'll take whatever arrows you're willing to throw at me because this cause is worth it.
00:53:06.260And when that happens, the rest of us need to stand up and try to bolster you as much as possible.