Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey - August 19, 2026


Ep 1386 | Did Patrick Clancy Do It? Fact-Checking Lindsay Clancy’s Defenders

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Ep 1385 | 'He's a Warlock:' Kathryn Krick’s Spiritual Father’s Dark Secrets Ep 1387 | The Addiction Causing Men to Live As 'Trans' | LaRell Herbert

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 25 minutes

Words per minute

183.78

Word count

15,654

Sentence count

900

Harmful content

Misogyny

36

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

57

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Did Patrick Clancy do it? That is the question and the accusation that is circulating on TikTok.
00:00:07 And can women actually ever be blamed for doing something evil? Also, my debate with Monty
00:00:15 Mader going through some debate strategies and some logical fallacies to look out for to equip
00:00:20 you in conversations about things that are really important. We've got all of that and more on
00:00:24 today's episode of Relatable. It's brought to you by our friends at Olive App. Olive is a food
00:00:28 scanning app that exposes what the labels don't seed oils dyes additives even hidden toxins if
00:00:34 there's something in your baby's food that shouldn't be olive shows you clearly simply
00:00:38 and immediately download all of today
00:00:40 hey y'all welcome to relatable happy wednesday hope everyone is having a wonderful week so far
00:00:55 If you have not listened to her, I watched Monday's episode about Catherine Crick, the
00:00:59 self-appointed apostle, her connection to a man named George Davey, the Tanzanian so-called
00:01:05 prophet and the allegations against him and what Catherine Crick may have known about
00:01:12 George Davey's misconduct and really scary sexual predation against some of her friends.
00:01:20 You got to go and check that out.
00:01:22 share that with people in your life who just may need to wake up to what this movement really seems
00:01:28 to be about. And remember, pray for everyone involved in that story for both repentance
00:01:34 and then healing and protection as well. Today, we are going to get into Lindsay Clancy and the
00:01:39 reaction on TikTok. These women who claim to be online sleuths and claim to have some kind 1.00
00:01:46 of intuition about who really killed Lindsay Clancy's children. And we're going to kind of
00:01:51 psychoanalyze this and look at some of the cultural influences that are creating this
00:01:56 narrative in our minds, especially in women, especially in feminist minds that a woman can
00:02:02 never really be guilty. She can never truly be held accountable for anything evil she does 0.88
00:02:08 because it is probably nuanced. She's probably misunderstood. Now we covered the Lindsay Clancy
00:02:14 trial a couple of weeks ago, and we looked at all of the different angles, all of the
00:02:19 antidepressants, so-called the SSRIs that she was on, their interactions, the arguments of
00:02:26 the prosecution versus the defense, how we balance understanding and compassion, sensitivity, and
00:02:32 also with justice and with the realization that these little children were the victims of a
00:02:39 brutal murder. So if you want more details about all of that, the details of the case and the trial,
00:02:45 go back and listen to or watch that episode with Lindsay Clancy. But today we'll get into
00:02:51 the TikTokification of our justice system and where it shows we are when it comes to 0.99
00:02:58 the feminist mind in America and why it really, really matters for the discerning Christian.
00:03:05 But first, I just want to briefly kind of go through some highlights from my Jubilee debate
00:03:11 that came out last Friday against a woman named Monty Mader. She is a very popular
00:03:17 ex-vangelical, um, influencer. I think she's got almost 3 million followers on, um, on Instagram
00:03:25 and we faced off in a format for Jubilee called face off. And I want to get into a little bit
00:03:33 about the format that might not have been obvious from the get-go. Some of the things about the
00:03:38 rules. And my strategies for how I approach debates like this, as you guys probably know,
00:03:43 this was my second Jubilee debate, very, very different than the surrounded debate that I did
00:03:48 last October. And we'll go through just a couple back and forths. And then we will also go through
00:03:54 one of the claims that she made. And we will go through the details that we didn't have time to
00:04:02 go through in the actual debate. And I also want to highlight a specific strategy and how you guys
00:04:09 can navigate it, um, in your everyday life and how, and how to spot it. So first let's just talk
00:04:15 about what this debate was. We already put up the thumbnail. If you haven't watched the full debate,
00:04:19 I really encourage you to, rather than just looking at the clips, it's hard to capture
00:04:24 what really happened in the back and forth in just 90 seconds or 60 seconds. So this was a
00:04:29 very interesting format. The rules are this. So each of us brought two claims. I had my two claims.
00:04:36 She had her two claims. Um, my two claims were about, um, abortion. Christians cannot,
00:04:45 or must oppose abortion. And also Christians cannot affirm same sex marriage. Her two claims 0.70
00:04:50 were that America are, is not, and will never be a Christian nation. And also that patriarchy,
00:04:56 not feminism is at odds with Christ ministry and teaching. So four total claims, and there
00:05:02 are 16 minutes per claim that we get to go back and forth. And that is split into her eight minutes 0.59
00:05:11 in my eight minutes. Now we can use our eight minutes. However we want to, when we are done
00:05:18 speaking, we had to press this little clock, um, that signified that the other person could talk.
00:05:26 But while the other person was talking, they could talk for their full eight minutes at
00:05:29 once.
00:05:29 If they wanted to, they could only talk for 30 seconds or 10 seconds, or they could talk
00:05:33 for three minutes.
00:05:34 However, they wanted to use their time.
00:05:35 They could, but you could not interject.
00:05:37 She couldn't interrupt me.
00:05:38 I was not allowed to interrupt her.
00:05:41 It was really more of a monologue off.
00:05:45 Like it was her monologue than my monologue.
00:05:48 It wasn't really a back and forth.
00:05:50 The reason why I don't find that conducive to coming to a clarifying point or coming
00:05:55 to a place of understanding and commonality at all, why I actually don't think this format is
00:06:01 helpful for the audience, even if it feels less stressful is because you cannot respond to the
00:06:07 other person's claim because they make too many claims in a matter of say five minutes that
00:06:12 they're talking. You've got to pick and choose what claims you are going to respond to. And never
00:06:18 do you have the ability to stop and say, hang on a second, hang on, hang on. You just said that,
00:06:24 but earlier you said that. Can you help me understand how those two things go together?
00:06:27 Or hang on a second. Can you please define that? That's what I prefer to do in debates. That's why
00:06:32 I loved Surrounded. It's probably a stressful experience, maybe for the viewer. Maybe it
00:06:38 stresses you out that they're running to the chair and we're going back and forth and all of that.
00:06:42 But I liked that. And there is a way to be able to interject and to clarify and to follow up
00:06:48 without being rude and interrupting. You can go back and watch my Surrounded debate and you can
00:06:53 see kind of how I balance those two things of allowing the person to really get out their
00:06:58 argument, but quickly following up with a clarification and defining our terms. As you
00:07:03 guys have heard me say, so often defining your terms is the most important part of any debate,
00:07:08 defining your own terms and making them define their terms so that you can get on the same page.
00:07:16 Let me play you an example of us attempting to do that, even though it's really difficult,
00:07:21 because again, when the person goes on for five or six minutes, you only have so many claims that
00:07:28 you can actually address, especially if someone's trying to give like a two minute history lesson
00:07:33 on something. The most important thing you can do is get down to brass tacks. The most important
00:07:38 thing you can do is get back to the claim. Because if we get off the reservation and start going down
00:07:43 this history back and forth, then we lose sight of what is actually being argued. So that's kind
00:07:48 of what happened here. We started talking about abortion. She starts talking about the long
00:07:54 historical precedent of conservatives trying to oppose abortion, which we'll get into in just a
00:07:58 minute. And this is my rerouting us back to the main point. Here is salt one. Well, first, let me
00:08:07 say this is her part of her claim. And then the second clip will be me clarifying what that
00:08:13 actually means. Salt one. I want to talk about definitions a little bit, because I know that
00:08:18 it's emotionally compelling to say killing babies. It's not a baby. That's not me being contrarian.
00:08:23 That's accuracy. Embryo up to the end of eight weeks. And then we have a fetus. And I think it's
00:08:27 very important so that we're actually getting to the facts of the matter. But what we are saying
00:08:32 is we are not saying you can go up and kill someone anytime you want. The distinction here is
00:08:35 do my organs, does my bloodstream, does my marrow have to keep them alive? Do I have to put myself
00:08:41 in harm's way or risk death in order for this life to be viable? I think you have an absolutely
00:08:46 solid argument after viability but we know that that is not one of the bulk of abortions happen
00:08:51 late second and third trimester is almost exclusively for fatal fetal abnormalities
00:08:55 stillbirths partial miscarriages and medical emergencies and medical professionals should be
00:09:00 allowed to make that call in conjunction with their patient and their patient's safety first of
00:09:04 all fetus is latin for small child and so we can get into the semantics of it it's all a human being
00:09:10 i mean just because we call a child a toddler or we call a child a baby doesn't mean that it's not
00:09:15 a child doesn't mean that it's not a human adolescent teen these are all different
00:09:19 designations that we use for different stages of life that doesn't change the value of someone
00:09:23 viability extremely arbitrary standard for whether or not a person should be murdered i mean
00:09:28 we're not just talking about okay is it okay for the dentist to pull a tooth we are talking about
00:09:33 is it okay for a doctor for an abortion provider to be able to inject the heart of a baby to cause
00:09:39 cardiac arrest and then induce delivery to kill that baby and then to throw that baby away like
00:09:45 toxic waste. That's what we're talking about. So as you can see, there are a million things that 1.00
00:09:49 I could have responded to even in that. I could have responded to the fact that she's now saying
00:09:53 I have a good argument after viability when earlier she said that life doesn't begin until
00:09:58 first breath. So life doesn't actually begin until they're outside of the womb and can breathe on
00:10:02 their own. And now she's saying, oh, maybe it's around 24, 24 weeks that you have an argument for
00:10:07 being pro-life. I could have addressed this idea that late-term abortion, second and third trimester
00:10:13 are only for all of these reasons, like the health of the mother, cancer diagnoses. That's
00:10:20 not a reason to abort a child in the second or third trimester. We have babies as young as 19
00:10:25 weeks who are able to be born and survive outside of the womb. If the baby's got to come out,
00:10:30 then you deliver the baby. You shouldn't have to kill the baby first. That's a two-day long 0.74
00:10:34 process if you're talking about late-term abortion that is obviously dangerous for the child, but 0.97
00:10:38 also dangerous for the mother. And then I did eventually respond to the biblical support for
00:10:44 life starting at conception and also the logical and scientific support of that. But you see how
00:10:49 I brought it down to brass tacks. Hang on a second. Let's define our terms. That was very
00:10:54 difficult in this kind of format. But if you go watch the entire debate, you will see that that
00:11:00 was my strategy to get us back to the claim, to get us back to the main points. And that's what
00:11:05 I encourage you to do as well, because it's really easy when someone is spouting a lot of
00:11:10 information that might seem factual because they're very confident to kind of follow them
00:11:16 down that trail, but that's called a red herring. That is making an argument that is actually
00:11:20 totally unrelated and irrelevant to the logic and the substance of the main claim. It's your job to
00:11:26 get back to the main claim and to simplify the abortion conversation as much as you possibly can.
00:11:32 So that's all I'll play for in that segment.
00:11:34 And then we also talked about this idea that America is not a Christian nation and that
00:11:39 Christian nationalism are basically Christians trying to infuse our worldview into law and
00:11:45 into public policy and how that shouldn't be allowed. 0.93
00:11:49 And I have some questions about that.
00:11:52 We'll get into that in a second.
00:11:53 Let me pause.
00:11:54 Let me tell you about our first sponsor.
00:11:55 It's Fellowship Home Loans.
00:11:57 If buying a home is on your family's list this year, listen up.
00:12:01 the smart move is not waiting until you find the perfect house. The smart move is getting
00:12:05 pre-qualified right now before you even start looking because in this market, the good houses
00:12:09 sell in days. And if you are not pre-qualified, you don't have that leg up if you are trying to
00:12:14 buy a house. And that's where Fellowship Home Loans comes in. For 20 years, Mike and Brian
00:12:18 have helped families walk into open houses ready to move in with a lender in their corner who can
00:12:22 actually close the deal quickly. They do loans that other lenders can't. They've got different
00:12:26 programs. They've got different down payment options, custom solutions based around your
00:12:30 family's unique situation. Everything is done in-house with their incredible hardworking team,
00:12:35 one roof, one team, all with a servant-led mentality. Get pre-qualified today. Go to
00:12:40 fellowshiphomeloans.com slash Allie for $500 back at closing. Fellowship Home Loans,
00:12:45 mortgage lending by the book. Nationwide Mortgage Bankers, DBA Fellowship Home Loans,
00:12:49 Equal Housing Lender, NMLS number 819382.
00:12:52 under the umbrella of the claim that we are not and never will be a christian nation we talk about
00:13:03 some of that in the founding documents but something that i found more interesting was this
00:13:08 idea that christians should only allow our religion to dictate our behavior and that we
00:13:15 shouldn't try to influence the law with our beliefs dot three christian conservatives
00:13:19 themselves are making these appeals to the Bible as justification for their actions and
00:13:25 justifications for the laws they want to pass without engaging in science or data as an
00:13:30 explanation for those laws versus when you look at progressive candidates, for instance,
00:13:34 there is typically here's the data, here's what we know, here's why we're proposing this,
00:13:39 and this is how it works. But we know that's not true. We know what the science says about
00:13:43 something like gender. There really is XX and XY, and it's very obvious that a man should not be 1.00
00:13:48 playing in women's sports it's an appeal to ideology it's an appeal to ideology to say you 0.99
00:13:53 know a person can be small enough can be young enough that they don't actually have value and
00:13:57 rights and that a person's organ actually trumps the right to life of that little baby but you do
00:14:03 what a lot of progressives do is claim that their views are coming from a place of data their views
00:14:08 are always coming from a place of science their views are coming from this neutral position
00:14:12 and conservative christians ours are just coming from subjective religion which yes i'm not going
00:14:17 to lie and say, oh no, God has nothing to do with my perspective on the value of human life. Of
00:14:23 course, I believe all people are made in the image of God. Not everyone believes that. That is the
00:14:28 thrust of what I believe and is underneath everything I believe. But yes, I can appeal to
00:14:32 logic. I can appeal to science to make the argument for why abortion is unethical wrong and therefore
00:14:37 should be illegal. Or I can definitely appeal to biology, as many non-Christians do, when it comes 0.99
00:14:43 to the reality of the gender binary, which is the same thing as the reality of the sex binary. 0.63
00:14:49 And so I just don't think it's quite fair to say progressive candidates are the ones appealing to
00:14:54 facts and logic. There's nothing factual or logical by saying that a man can become a woman. 0.61
00:14:59 You can have that belief, but when you start to legislate that, well, then you're forcing 0.66
00:15:04 your religious belief on me. You've become your own kind of theocrat.
00:15:08 So that's obviously just a ridiculous claim, progressives claim to be on the side of 0.75
00:15:13 science and logic and facts. And that is just not true. And it's increasingly obvious that that's 0.92
00:15:19 not true. The idea that a fetus becomes a person suddenly in the birth canal, or the idea that a
00:15:25 man can become a woman via declaration, that is a fanciful ideological belief that they are
00:15:31 enforcing through the law on us and on children. It's okay when they do it, but not when we do it. 0.96
00:15:37 And I point out this hypocrisy, ESOP 5.
00:15:41 Religion is a fence that I place on my lawn. 0.70
00:15:44 It is not a fence I can place on your lawn.
00:15:46 So when I start to make legislation or vote for bills that enforce my belief,
00:15:50 my belief that is strictly my religious belief,
00:15:52 on other people where now you have to follow my belief system
00:15:56 instead of I can't participate in that, I can't do that,
00:16:00 I don't believe in that for my religion,
00:16:02 then you start to actually infringe on the religious liberties of others.
00:16:05 You said your religious beliefs are a fence on your own lawn, not a fence that you can put on
00:16:09 other people's lawn. But I can think of Christians who have had to abide by beliefs that are not
00:16:15 theirs. I think, for example, about Jack Phillips. He's the cake baker out of Colorado, Masterpiece
00:16:20 Cake Shop. He said, look, I just can't make a cake that celebrates a gay wedding. I'll make you a
00:16:25 cake, but it goes against my religious beliefs. Well, the state of Colorado came after him,
00:16:30 and it was only after over a decade of litigation, and his case made it all the way to the Supreme
00:16:34 court that finally the supreme court said okay you've got a first amendment right to be able to
00:16:39 you know express your artistic creativity the way that you want to in a way that aligns with
00:16:43 your values i could go on and on jessica bates she is a mom out of oregon she tried to adopt
00:16:49 some kids out of foster care and they said look if you don't abide by what we believe
00:16:54 about lgbtq ideology then you can't adopt so everywhere i actually see progressives using
00:17:00 what I would call their quasi-religious beliefs and say, no, these are neutral. We're enforcing
00:17:05 them via legislation. And if you don't abide by them, then you're a bigot, then you'll get in
00:17:10 trouble. So that's what I don't really understand. Why is it Christian nationalism or a theocracy
00:17:15 for me to say, here's my belief about abortion. I do think it should be reflected in law versus 0.96
00:17:20 when say a progressive does the same thing from their perspective. Yeah, that's the whole thing
00:17:27 is that really it comes down to conservative Christians and conservative Christians alone
00:17:32 are the ones who are not allowed to bring our worldview into the voting booth. Look, no law
00:17:38 is moral. Every law is a should. We hear this phrase that is so nonsensical over and over again
00:17:44 that you can't legislate morality. I'm not saying that Monty said that, but I hear that a lot. You
00:17:49 can't legislate morality. All legislation is moral. The speed limit is moral. It's saying that
00:17:55 you can only go this fast because of this underlying moral belief that human life matters
00:18:01 and putting human life at risk by driving as fast as you want and driving recklessly
00:18:06 is not okay. So every single law has a presupposition that is based in a worldview
00:18:13 about who is in charge, what is right, and what is wrong. There's no such thing as a neutral policy.
00:18:19 It's just that progressives want you to believe that they are coming from a place of neutrality
00:18:24 when in fact they're not. They've got their own religious beliefs, their fanciful, fantastical
00:18:30 beliefs, and we have our beliefs. It's just that ours are backed up by an authority that's higher
00:18:37 than ourselves, that transcends the power of the government. It also happens to be the same
00:18:42 authority that most of the founders believed in too. So that's the truth. Really, progressives
00:18:47 have the power. They have the power. They want the power. It's really not about who wants power
00:18:52 and who doesn't. I hear that a lot. Oh, it's so scary that Christians want power. Well, one worldview
00:18:57 is always going to dominate. One worldview is going to dictate what kind of laws we have.
00:19:01 The question is which worldview is better? Which one has better fruit? Which one comes up with
00:19:06 better, more protective laws? I think we can look at progressive secularism and the fruit that it
00:19:12 has produced throughout history. We can look at 20th century communism, socialism, the totalitarianism
00:19:17 that came out of atheism and progressivism in the name of elevating the poor and including
00:19:24 the marginalized and making life better for the least of these, progressivism ended up
00:19:30 bearing the fruit of death and destruction and poverty.
00:19:33 And I would say Christianity has been the greatest force for good and for liberty throughout
00:19:40 all of history, forging Western civilization to create the greatest culture and nation
00:19:45 that has ever existed for every single kind of person. And so just don't be intimidated by that,
00:19:52 by this idea that if you're a Christian conservative, you are the only one who has
00:19:55 to check your worldview at the door. It's just not true. Everyone should be able to bring the
00:19:59 fullness of their worldview to the table and let's duke it out and let's debate and may the best
00:20:04 worldview win. All right, let's get into a little bit of a logic class for a second. I want to talk
00:20:12 about a particular strategy that you may see from influencers that you might see online or that you
00:20:18 might experience from people in your life. And this is not something that is exclusive to
00:20:23 progressives. I see this kind of tactic being used by a lot of people and it's very convincing.
00:20:30 And it is a logical fallacy called a gish gallop. And a gish gallop is a debate tactic where 0.93
00:20:37 someone gives a rapid fire stream of arguments or points and some of them might be correct 0.79
00:20:44 and some of them are not this is an attempt to kind of overwhelm their opponent or even
00:20:49 overwhelm their audience with a quantity of claims that can't actually be debunked because
00:20:56 there are so many that if you try to go through each claim one by one you would end up going down
00:21:02 the trail of a red herring of something that actually doesn't have to do with the main point
00:21:07 at all, or you end up having this tangential conversation and then you go off the reservation
00:21:13 and you lose the spirit of what the debate is supposed to be about. And it would just take a
00:21:17 lot of time. So gish galloping is when someone talks really fast and tries to overwhelm you 1.00
00:21:23 with all of these different points. And so your senses are completely overtaken and you're not 0.93
00:21:28 actually able to break them down one by one. And what I would say again, is that your response to
00:21:34 a gish gallop when someone is going on and on and on. Let me tell you this historical argument. 0.97
00:21:38 Let me give you all of these so-called facts. Let me throw all of these things in your face
00:21:42 really fast and really confidently so that it seems like I really know what I'm talking about
00:21:46 and you couldn't possibly go against me. Your job is not to meet them by responding to every
00:21:51 argument or talking just as quickly. Your response has to be slow down. Slow down. You can even say
00:21:56 that out loud. Slow down. Hang on a second. I want to go back to the claim. I want to go back to what
00:22:02 two originally said, and let me get down to what this actually means. Let me give you an example
00:22:08 of what a gish gallop can look like. Here's thought six. Throughout the early church, that it was not 1.00
00:22:14 considered murder. St. Augustine decided that until the quickening, until viability, it was not
00:22:19 considered a crime or murder in the church. That was changed by Pope Pius IX in 1869. And the
00:22:25 evangelical community within the 20th century didn't really care that much about it. It wasn't
00:22:29 a motivator for their voting block and it really wasn't something they rallied around.
00:22:33 In fact, in 1968, Christianity Today hosted 25 theologians who really debated abortion.
00:22:38 Is it right?
00:22:39 Is it wrong?
00:22:40 When can it happen?
00:22:41 When shouldn't it happen?
00:22:42 And they all agreed collectively that in all or some cases, it should be permissible.
00:22:46 You're part of the Southern Baptist Church Convention, which acknowledged the right of
00:22:50 abortion, supported it in three separate church edicts, as did the Dallas Theological Seminary,
00:22:54 saying that they believed that a woman's right to her body and autonomy superseded all else.
00:22:59 And that abortion should be permissible in incest cases, as well as for the mental, physical, and spiritual health of the mother.
00:23:06 The overwhelming evangelical community supported the passage of Roe.
00:23:10 She then goes on to make the argument, and we can't play, you know, entire clips on this show, it would go on and on.
00:23:17 She then goes on to make the argument that the only, she talks about Jerry Falwell, she talks about Liberty University, she talks about Bob Jones.
00:23:23 She talks about how evangelicals in the 70s and 80s were really trying to find the issue
00:23:30 that was going to rally the base, and segregation was one of those issues, and then they figured
00:23:37 out that they could use abortion as a way to kind of mobilize evangelicals, but it wasn't
00:23:42 sincere, that Christians didn't really care about it.
00:23:45 And she's trying to make the point that this makes the Christian conservative opposition
00:23:50 to abortion superficial, that we're just being manipulated by the patriarchal powers that be
00:23:56 to oppose the murder of children. Um, now we'll get into the actual fact based debunking of these
00:24:04 claims, but I do just want to point something out that this dish galloping that we just saw 0.99
00:24:10 overwhelming seeming facts that she had this script plant. And this was something that I knew
00:24:19 going in that this particular format is going to be really good for someone who is not a strong
00:24:25 debater, but has a really good command of their monologue and is really good at memorizing a
00:24:32 narrative and then repeating that. And when that was really demonstrated to me was something that
00:24:39 actually wasn't kept in the final version. It was something that was mostly edited out and the real
00:24:45 version, there is a different ordering of the claims, which is fine. That doesn't take away
00:24:50 from the integrity of the debate that Jubilee decided to rearrange that. But actually in the
00:24:56 real debate, we first talk about same-sex marriage and I make my claim that Christians should be 0.93
00:25:01 against it. Well, her response to my claim about same-sex marriage, she goes on in real life. She
00:25:07 went on for about five minutes about abortion. And she actually says exactly what she said
00:25:13 in that clip that we just played that had nothing to do with my claim whatsoever. Here's thought
00:25:19 seven. And in the 20th century, evangelicals in America did not really have a particular opinion
00:25:24 on abortion overall as a voting bloc. It really didn't matter. In fact, in the early 70s, the SBC
00:25:30 released three churchwide edicts supporting the passage of Roe, that a woman's bodily autonomy
00:25:34 was supreme, that for her mental, physical, and spiritual health, that abortion should be on the
00:25:40 table in all or some cases. So really, for the bulk of church history, Christians have in some 0.77
00:25:44 form or another affirmed abortion. Are you saying that all of those people were not Christians?
00:25:51 This segment and this claim is about same-sex marriage.
00:25:54 So you might have thought that we just played the clip from earlier again. We didn't. This was a
00:26:00 separate part of the debate. This was in response to my claim that Christians should be against
00:26:04 same-sex marriage. And as I said, in real life, she went on for five minutes with the exact same
00:26:11 verbatim monologue that she actually meant for the abortion claim, which again, in real life,
00:26:17 the abortion claim wasn't actually made until later in our debate. So she has a script in her
00:26:23 mind. She is very, very good at reciting that script, which is a skill. I'm not necessarily
00:26:29 starily dunking on that, but I just want you to understand how gish galloping works and how this
00:26:36 strategy works. You've got a script in your mind. She memorized the script. She stuck to the script
00:26:41 so much so that she wasn't actually listening to my claims. I made a claim about same-sex marriage 0.63
00:26:47 and they kept in about 30 seconds of her monologue on abortion that she had repeated again later
00:26:54 that I just played you. Okay. So actually she had her answers canned, ready to go. This was not a
00:27:02 debate where she was willing to go back and forth with anything I was saying. If you watch the
00:27:06 debate, you can see that I'm trying to address some of her points. I'm trying to say, you said
00:27:11 this, here's my response to that. And instead of her engaging with those things, she instead did
00:27:18 her monologues, which were almost verbatim, the monologues that she also puts on her social media.
00:27:24 So I understand why her supporters, if you follow her social media and you're like, okay,
00:27:28 this is exactly what I expected from Monty to repeat the same things that she says on
00:27:32 social media here, no matter what the question was, no matter what the claim is, um, then
00:27:37 I can see how you enjoyed that.
00:27:39 Okay.
00:27:39 That's not a debate.
00:27:41 That's not an engaging conversation.
00:27:43 That's not a back and forth.
00:27:45 Again, that is a monologue off where one person is trying to engage and kind of get to a place
00:27:50 of commonality, at least when it comes to definitions.
00:27:52 And the other person is reciting a monologue that may or may not have anything to do with
00:27:57 the topic at hand at all.
00:27:59 So just understand that you might be talking to someone in a debate that has a script in
00:28:04 front of them that is going to gish gallop, that is going to try to overwhelm you with
00:28:08 all different kinds of points, some of which are true, some of which are not true, some
00:28:13 of which are compelling, some of which are not compelling, but just seem so overwhelming.
00:28:17 And when someone has memorized a script, it's very hard to poke through that and to get
00:28:22 to the point that you want to get to or try to get through to them, you've just got to go back
00:28:28 to the main thing. You just got to go back to the main claim. And my purpose for doing that,
00:28:35 my purpose for engaging in these debates at all is not to change Monty's mind. That would be
00:28:40 amazing if one day the Holy Spirit changed her mind and changed her heart. It's not to change
00:28:44 the mind of her supporters. You can read some of the comments and just how vile they are. I've
00:28:50 gotten the most vile messages since this debate was published, not only wishing that I would die,
00:28:56 but wishing the baby that I am carrying would die, that I would miscarry. And so those people,
00:29:02 I'm not saying all of her followers, but certainly the messages in the comments represent a callousness.
00:29:07 My debate is not for them, although of course we pray for them as well. My debate is for you.
00:29:13 Me going into these situations to go back and forth with these ideas is to hopefully,
00:29:18 by the grace of God exemplify how you can respond with kindness, with respect, um, with peace,
00:29:26 without compromising at all in what is good, right, and true. And that is what I also wanted
00:29:31 to demonstrate in the Jubilee debate. Can you engage with people with compassion, with humanity,
00:29:36 with care, without compromising at all? I think a lot of people, especially Christians,
00:29:41 think that in order to love someone, you have to nuance your positions. You have to compromise a
00:29:46 little bit. You have to give in just a few, uh, in a few areas in order to relate to someone.
00:29:52 You don't have to do that. I think Jesus gives us a really good example of how not to do that,
00:29:57 of how to love people, meet them where they are without compromising even a centimeter
00:30:01 on what is true. So that's why I do this. It's really for the Christian women in my audience.
00:30:06 Yes. If there are people on the fence, one of my favorite comments that I got in the YouTube video
00:30:10 of, um, my surrounded debate, the top comment is someone saying, look, I'm not religious.
00:30:15 like I don't believe in anything that Ali said, but I don't know any good response to her abortion
00:30:23 arguments. And I don't take credit for that. That's all by the grace of God. But that, I mean, 0.64
00:30:29 that's a win. That's for sure a huge win when something like that happens. And you just have
00:30:33 to trust that God is going to use your obedience to his word to accomplish what he wants to
00:30:36 accomplish. But my main purpose in going into these things is to show you here's how you engage.
00:30:43 and here's something you could say. I will never do it perfectly. There's always going to be things
00:30:47 I wish I did and said differently, but, um, I hope to demonstrate how to kind of faithfully
00:30:54 engage with secular and progressive arguments from a biblical perspective. All right. I promised
00:30:58 that we would debunk some of the claims that she made about the history of abortion. If you're
00:31:03 brought this whole monologue that she gave and you're meant to respond, I think that you should
00:31:09 just go to the main point of killing babies is wrong, but it's also good information to learn
00:31:13 and it's good things to know the truth about the early church on abortion and the evangelical
00:31:17 movement and the 20th century and why we actually fight for the lives of the unborn. So we'll get
00:31:21 to that in just a second. Let me pause and tell you about our next sponsor. It's Adele Natural
00:31:25 Cosmetics. If you come to share the arrows this year, share the arrows on October 10th, you will
00:31:30 be able to meet our friends at Adele. They are so awesome. They have been a faithful supporter of
00:31:36 the show for, uh, for years. And I, uh, have been a faithful user of their products for years. I
00:31:43 absolutely love Adele. I use their essential cleanser, their essential moisturizer. I love,
00:31:47 especially we're getting into fall y'all and we're getting into Christmas time soon. They always have
00:31:52 an amazing holiday line that smells so good is so, it's so high quality too. You're never going to
00:31:58 get anything fake, no synthetic fragrances, no endocrine disruptors. Everything is completely
00:32:03 holistic. They are a Jesus first family centered, unapologetically pro-life family owned company.
00:32:10 Go to Adele natural cosmetics.com use code Allie at checkout for 25% off your first purchase.
00:32:15 That's Adele natural cosmetics.com code Allie.
00:32:24 I do just want to say before we get back into it, if you are looking for apologetics for theology
00:32:30 and for clarity and for courage.
00:32:32 If you are looking to be around more like-minded women
00:32:35 and you are looking to get Bible-based teaching
00:32:38 for one day, come to Share the Arrows,
00:32:40 October 10th, Dallas, Texas.
00:32:42 It's going to be an incredible, Holy Spirit-filled day.
00:32:45 We pray by the grace of God.
00:32:47 It has been thus far.
00:32:48 We're so thankful.
00:32:49 Share the Arrows this year is brought to you
00:32:51 by our friends at We Heart Nutrition.
00:32:54 We've got Shane and Shane leading worship.
00:32:56 We've got Rosario Butterfield, Kosti,
00:32:57 Hannah, Lisa Childers, Natasha Crane, Audrey Brogy,
00:32:59 Grace Anna Castle, Barry, yours truly. I'm talking to each of the speakers in the next
00:33:03 couple of weeks, just honing exactly what the talks are going to be. Y'all, it's going to be
00:33:07 so good. I cannot wait. Go to sharethearrows.com. You can use any of the speakers' first names,
00:33:13 plus the number 15 when you go to Ticketmaster, and you can get 15% off your ticket. Come one,
00:33:19 come all. I am so excited about it. Sharethearrows.com. All right, let's get into this
00:33:24 quick fact check, this idea that Christians didn't care about abortion until like the 1970s.
00:33:31 Now, first of all, what happened in the 1970s, y'all? What happened in the 1970s? Roe v. Wade
00:33:37 happened. And so, yeah, before that, it wasn't as much of a political debate as it was after the
00:33:43 passage of Roe v. Wade. That's obviously going to be true. Guys, I have even heard conservative 1.00
00:33:48 pastors repeat that talking point as a way to try to discredit the Republican party and those of us
00:33:55 who vote Republican, I can't speak for Republican politicians, um, and our opposition to abortion
00:34:00 to try to invalidate it or to act like it's superficial. I'm like, what happened in the
00:34:04 1970s? Roe v. Wade was passed in the 1970s that basically allowed abortion through all nine
00:34:10 months for various reasons. Okay. So of course that mobilized people, it radicalized the abortion
00:34:16 movement, the abortion movement, the pro-abortion movement, by the way, became extremely mobilized
00:34:21 before, during, and after the 1970s too. No one talks about that. Okay, let's back up though.
00:34:27 Let's go to the early church. The claim that the early church did not regard abortion
00:34:31 as killing is wrong. If we look at the Didache, it is one of the earliest Christian documents we
00:34:37 have that summarizes what the early church believed in the first century. Most scholars
00:34:41 date the Didache to the late first century or the early, uh, early second century. And it's really
00:34:46 short summary of the worst sins. It prohibits abortion. You shall not practice magic. You
00:34:51 shall not practice witchcraft. You shall not murder a child by abortion, nor kill that which 0.71
00:34:56 is begotten. And you know, it's interesting that the Didache actually connects the practice of magic
00:35:02 with child sacrifice, because that's exactly what we see throughout the whole Old Testament. 0.85
00:35:07 when the Lord is warning his people, warning ancient Israel, hey, don't be a part of those 0.74
00:35:12 cultural practices over there, which include necromancy, which include mediums, which include 0.97
00:35:17 practicing magic and sorcery, which is forbidden by the way for God's holy people and is punishable
00:35:23 by death. He also says within those dictates, he says, do not offer your child as a sacrifice to
00:35:29 their gods, which apparently was something that was happening. It seems that idolatry,
00:35:33 sexual immorality and child sacrifice are always intertwined. We even see that in the New Testament
00:35:39 when Paul is talking about worshiping the creature rather than the creator who is blessed forever,
00:35:44 amen, in Romans 1. This is in a passage about homosexuality, about exchanging natural desires
00:35:51 for unnatural ones and the sins which are an abomination to God, sins against your own body, 0.59
00:35:56 which are sins of sexual immorality. So from the very beginning, the church understood this because
00:36:01 God has understood this and his word has relayed this. So it shows from the very start that
00:36:05 Christians have interpreted the Bible as being against abortion. There's a church father and
00:36:09 theologian, Tertullian, around AD 200. He also wrote that Christians may not destroy a baby in
00:36:15 the womb. In Apology, which is a text defending Christian faith, he writes, in our case, murder
00:36:20 being once for all forbidden, we may not destroy even the fetus in the womb. While as yet the
00:36:25 human being derives blood from other parts of the body for its sustenance, to hinder a birth is
00:36:30 merely a speedier man killing, nor does it matter whether you take away a life that is born or
00:36:35 destroy one that is coming to the birth. Now, Monty claimed also in her gish gallop that St.
00:36:40 Augustine, um, some people say Augustine, some people say Augustine, uh, held that until the
00:36:47 quickening until viability, it was not considered a crime or murder in the church. Well, that was
00:36:51 changed, uh, by Pope Pius, or she says that was changed by Pope Pius IX in 1869. Okay. Again,
00:37:00 that's interesting because she's simultaneously making the claim that Christians didn't say
00:37:04 anything or care very much about abortion until the 1970s. And then she's also saying, well,
00:37:09 all the way back in 1869, things were changed. So again, that is the thing about a gish gallop 0.99
00:37:14 is like, oh gosh, that seems so overwhelming. You know, so much history. But then when you 1.00
00:37:18 start thinking, hang on, what are you talking about? Are you talking about first breath,
00:37:22 which you said earlier? Are you talking about viability or you talk about quickening,
00:37:25 which is not the same thing as viability, by the way, quickening is when you can feel the baby
00:37:29 move. I felt this baby move around 14 weeks. That's not viability. A baby's not viable until
00:37:34 really the right now it's probably 24 weeks. That's what they say, but babies survive earlier
00:37:40 than that too. And so you see how we're getting into all of these arbitrary changing, uh, changing
00:37:45 standards for when it's okay to kill a person, when it's okay to kill a human being. But when
00:37:51 someone talks really fast and confidently, you don't break them down sentence by sentence. And
00:37:55 of course I didn't have time to do that with my eight minutes either. So it's true that when
00:37:59 commenting on Exodus 21, 22, which addresses the penalty for someone who strikes a pregnant woman
00:38:04 and causes a miscarriage, um, Augustine suggests that the passage may refer to an unformed embryo
00:38:11 for reference. Here's Exodus 21, 22, when men strive together and hit a pregnant woman. So
00:38:15 that her child or her children come out, but there is no harm. Uh, the one who hit her shall
00:38:21 surely be fined as the woman's husband shall impose on him and he shall pay as the damages
00:38:26 determined. Here's Augustine's commentary and questions on the Heptatook. If therefore there
00:38:34 is an unformed embryo animated in an unformed way, since the great question of the soul is not
00:38:39 to be rushed into rashly with thoughtfulness, thoughtless opinion. Then on this account,
00:38:44 the law does not pertain to homicide because it is not yet possible to say that a living soul
00:38:50 in this body, since it is bereft of sense, if the soul be in flesh that is not yet formed and hence
00:38:57 not yet endowed with sense. So although Augustine suggests that the embryo is unformed, this does
00:39:04 not mean that he approved of abortion. This passage still treats causing a miscarriage as
00:39:08 a punishable crime. So Augustine's question is about the severity of the defense or of the offense
00:39:13 rather, and whether it should be classified as homicide. And his question is really,
00:39:18 when are we in salt? And Augustine doesn't really seem to know. And it could be because he didn't
00:39:24 really understand the science at the time, that actually a unique human life with all of his or
00:39:30 her DNA is there and present at the moment of conception. He was probably influenced by the
00:39:36 world that he inhabited at the time. In the ancient Greco-Roman tradition, there were many
00:39:41 competing theories about when babies actually became and sold and therefore became people.
00:39:45 So Augustine drew from Aristotle's theory, which was that babies were unsold 40 days after
00:39:50 conception for males and 90 days for females. Aristotle wrote this theory sometime between
00:39:55 335 and 322 BC. It was popular until the 19th century. Also, a lot of the early fathers were
00:40:01 just influenced by the pagan culture when it came to the idea of children before and after birth.
00:40:09 I'm not saying everything that they believed and taught was colored by those pagan beliefs,
00:40:15 but remember at the time in the ancient Greco-Roman world, it was believed that children
00:40:19 were not full people at all, that they were basically on the level of animals and barbarians.
00:40:25 They didn't have the fullness of the logos, which they didn't have the fullness of reason,
00:40:31 of rationale, of thinking. That's what that meant. And so their degradation, their objectification,
00:40:37 and their abuse was routinely justified because of the belief that they lacked full personhood.
00:40:44 The only people who had full personhood, and I bring this up in the debate,
00:40:48 in this time was the adult free male, and they were the only ones given rights.
00:40:53 And so you see how the pagan argument really hasn't changed.
00:40:56 From all the way back then, when Aristotle was trying to separate humanity from personhood,
00:41:01 the Greek scholars, the Roman scholars at the time, trying to separate humanity from personhood
00:41:05 in order to justify mistreatment of certain kinds of people. Well, the pro-abortion argument is the
00:41:10 same today. You're trying to separate humanity from personhood to justify killing. It's no 0.75
00:41:15 different. Pagan's going to pagan. In his work on marriage and concupiscence, Augustine says that 1.00
00:41:21 all abortion is a sin. And he even says of married couples that they're not even really married if
00:41:26 they resort to these practices. So he says this sometimes indeed this lustful cruelty, or if you
00:41:32 please, cruel lust resorts to such extravagant methods as to use poisonous drugs to secure
00:41:37 barrenness or else it's unsuccessful in this to destroy the conceived seed by some means previous
00:41:44 to birth, preferring that his offspring should rather perish than receive vitality, or if it
00:41:49 was advancing to life within the womb should be slain before it was born. So abortion. Well,
00:41:55 if both parties alike are so flagitious, they are not husband and wife. And if such were their 0.85
00:42:00 character from the beginning. They have not come together by wedlock, but by debauchery.
00:42:04 That is very intense. As for Pius IX's 1869 action that Monty cites, it just changed the
00:42:12 church's penalty for an early stage abortion to be even more severe. Abortion was already
00:42:16 considered a grave sin, but Pius made abortion at any stage an automatic excommunication. Good
00:42:23 on pious the 10th or pious the ninth rather now let's fast forward to evangelicals in the 1960s
00:42:30 and 70s because she says that this was all just a ploy to try to get republicans more power through
00:42:36 the evangelicals and that it was really segregation that was a boon for this community at the time so
00:42:44 she says that they didn't care about the issue of abortion until the 70s again roe v wade passed
00:42:51 the Supreme Court, or it was decided by the Supreme Court in 1973. So yeah, that would kind
00:42:57 of line up. Immediately after the Roe decision, though, Christianity Today published a response
00:43:02 to crying the decision, stating in its Roe decision, the Supreme Court has clearly decided
00:43:07 for paganism. That was back when Christianity Today, pre-Russell Moore times, pre-Trump was
00:43:14 actually producing Christian content. And it was exactly right. It was making a decision in favor 0.93
00:43:21 of paganism and child sacrifice also in responding to this new issue of nationwide abortion it was a
00:43:27 new issue in the 1970s the southern baptist convention you heard her cite the sbc initially
00:43:32 adopted resolutions in the 1970s the 1971 sbc resolution supported legislation allowing abortion
00:43:40 in cases of rape incest severe fetal deformity and threats to the mother's emotional mental or
00:43:45 physical health but the same resolution also explicitly said the state had a responsibility
00:43:50 to affirm the sanctity of human life, including fetal life, and to protect those who cannot
00:43:54 protect themselves.
00:43:55 Now, let me just say something about the SBC in 1971 and its resolution on abortion. 0.53
00:44:00 It was wrong.
00:44:01 That is nonsensical.
00:44:02 That's a nonsensical position to say that you allow abortion because of the circumstances
00:44:07 surrounding a child's conception, because of a diagnosis that the child has, or because
00:44:13 the mother has some emotional or mental health problem that makes her not want to have a
00:44:17 child and then say that you want to protect the sanctity of life. What's also not as included is
00:44:21 that the SBC in the seventies and the early eighties was sprinting to the left. It wasn't
00:44:27 until the 1980s that the SBC had a big conservative reformation and went back to what is good, right
00:44:34 and true when it comes to theology, which also affected the politics of the SBC. So this was in
00:44:40 the liberalization of the SBC time saying, yeah, we are okay with abortion in these cases. Um,
00:44:46 but not okay in these other cases. And so the change in the SBC is a part of a much bigger
00:44:53 story of the Southern Baptist convention and also has nothing to do with actually what is true.
00:44:59 There were a lot of people throughout history who were wrong. A lot of people who claim to
00:45:04 be Christians who were wrong about all sorts of things. That doesn't mean that I have to agree
00:45:09 with them or that what we know to be true about abortion today is somehow negated by them being
00:45:13 wrong. That's stupid. Progressive is also used to believe certain things that they no longer 1.00
00:45:19 believe. That doesn't negate a progressive's belief today in the fact that a man, or like in
00:45:25 the idea that a man can become a woman when, you know, 15 years ago, no progressive said that they
00:45:30 would have said the opposite. They would have thought that was crazy. So what someone believes
00:45:35 today is not negated by what someone believed 20 years ago or 50 years ago. By 1976, only five years
00:45:41 later, the SBC was calling abortion the termination of an innocent life. In 1977, it explicitly
00:45:46 opposed abortion on demand. And by 1980, it supported prohibiting abortion except to save
00:45:51 the mother's life. So this is all happening as the SBC has a change in leadership. It is
00:45:57 moving more theologically conservative. The shift also occurred during a revolution in our ability
00:46:02 to observe life inside the womb. Obstetric ultrasound really only became widely available
00:46:08 during the 1970s with real-time ultrasound becoming increasingly widespread around the
00:46:13 end of the decade and into the 1980s. I think if you talk to a lot of our moms, like my mom,
00:46:18 my mother-in-law, they were having my sisters-in-law, my mom was having my brothers in the early
00:46:23 80s, having routine ultrasounds was not normal. Even in the suburban areas or in the cities in
00:46:31 the 1980s, sometimes you would get an ultrasound if something was wrong, but that was not routine.
00:46:36 But it became more and more routine, 80s and 90s. We saw a window into who these little human
00:46:42 beings were, and it became harder and harder to understand and to justify abortion, the killing
00:46:49 of these little babies that are so clearly human. There were also books that were published at the
00:46:55 time, movies that were published at the time, like The Silent Scream, that actually analyzed what is
00:47:01 happening inside the womb when these babies are being killed. And we saw that these babies are
00:47:07 actually seen to scream and cry as the abortion needle is being plunged into their heart to cause
00:47:12 a cardiac arrest. And so we're acting like this is all just superficial, nefarious, somehow racist
00:47:20 political pandering when there were very real theological, cultural, and scientific reasons
00:47:25 that people were becoming more animated against abortion.
00:47:29 Also, abortion, as I said earlier,
00:47:33 it was becoming a nationwide issue on the left.
00:47:36 When you look at the history of Planned Parenthood,
00:47:38 when you look at the history of NARAL,
00:47:41 you will see that before, during, and after the decision of Roe
00:47:45 that they became more public.
00:47:47 They became more propagandistic.
00:47:50 They began their campaign to go into schools,
00:47:53 to be called Planned Parenthood.
00:47:55 NARAL became very powerful in the 70s and 80s. This began the debates in the presidential
00:48:04 campaigns about abortion. This was not simply an evangelical power play. There were a lot of
00:48:13 dynamics that were creating this mobilization of Christians against abortion. I'm so thankful for
00:48:18 it because after almost half a century, we got Roe v. Wade overturned because of this animation
00:48:25 against this objective evil. So in the centuries of discussion of abortion, Christians have debated
00:48:31 issues. There have been Christians on different sides of the issue, like when exactly the baby
00:48:36 isn't sold, the proper ecclesiastical penalties for abortion, whether they're extreme circumstances
00:48:42 where abortion might be acceptable, but they don't override the normative Christian position
00:48:47 for literally 2000 years, that babies are people killing them through abortion is a sin, that it
00:48:53 is wrong. And even if every Christian for the past 2000 years had been wrong about this, it doesn't 0.58
00:48:59 change the fact that all humans are people and killing an innocent person is always wrong and 0.71
00:49:05 should be illegal period. Okay. That's what you have to get back to. But you also just have to
00:49:11 realize that just because someone is confident and talks fast, just because they list what sounds
00:49:16 like a bunch of facts doesn't mean that what they're saying is actually true. And so don't
00:49:22 allow yourself to be overwhelmed with a gish gallop. Don't allow yourself to be taken by 1.00
00:49:26 someone's posture, by someone's confidence, because there were so many factual errors in
00:49:31 what was said and so many inconsistencies in her argument over those 16 minutes. I obviously didn't
00:49:38 have time to address all of them today or in the debate, but it's important just to slow down and
00:49:42 get down to the fundamentals. All right. Now I want to talk about Lindsay Clancy and I want to
00:49:48 talk about the TikTokification of her case and the feminist mind and what it tells us about our
00:49:53 culture and especially feminist culture. Let me pause and tell you about Patriot Mobile. So
00:49:58 Patriot Mobile for more than 12 years has been living their values by standing in the gap for
00:50:03 every American who believes freedom is worth fighting for. Their business was founded on a
00:50:07 simple conviction. If culture is being shaped through commerce, then Americans deserve a real
00:50:11 conservative alternative. Today, Patriot Mobile is America's only Christian conservative wireless
00:50:16 provider, offering premium priority nationwide service on any of the three major U.S. networks
00:50:22 with unlimited data plans, international roaming, and 100% U.S.-based customer support.
00:50:26 Make the switch today.
00:50:27 You'll be voting with your dollar.
00:50:29 When you do, you will be aligned with the company that aligns with your values, that's
00:50:33 fighting for the things that you want to fight for.
00:50:34 Go to PatriotMobile.com slash Allie or call 972-PATRIOT.
00:50:38 Use promo code Allie for a free month of service.
00:50:41 PatriotMobile.com slash Allie, code Allie.
00:50:46 so in our episode on lindsey clancy we talked about patrick clancy how he's taken the stand
00:50:53 some of the things in his testimony the things that he has said and i understand why you could
00:51:00 look at patrick clancy just look at him and think oh i don't know about this guy he feels a little
00:51:06 bit sketchy that's unfortunate for him because if you were to paint a picture of what a villain
00:51:11 looks like, he would kind of fit the bill of the caricature of a villain. People also don't like
00:51:16 the fact that he got married so quickly after this and how he talks on the stand, even his
00:51:20 posture. Well, TikTok and the mommy sleuths on that platform have run with this, have run with
00:51:27 all of these kind of superficial characteristics of Patrick Clancy, and they claim to have solved
00:51:32 this mystery and they are pinning the murders on him. Now, just to backtrack a little bit,
00:51:37 if you haven't been following this, Lindsay Clancy is a mother who has, according to her
00:51:44 legal team, admitted to killing her three young children and attempting to kill herself while her
00:51:48 husband was out of the house. She is currently on trial to determine whether she can be held
00:51:52 criminally responsible for their deaths or whether her postpartum psychosis rendered her
00:51:57 not criminally responsible. As I said, we've looked at all of these angles, all the different
00:52:02 medications she was on, how she was able to accomplish this. But it does come down to the
00:52:08 fact that Lindsay's own team is not disputing her actions. Her lawsuit against her medical
00:52:17 provider says this. So she's suing her medical providers for all these different interacting
00:52:21 medications she was on. Lindsay now faces a lifetime of physical disability, psychological
00:52:26 trauma, and the unbearable grief of waking up every day, knowing she killed her children,
00:52:29 all of which could have been prevented had defendants provided competent care. Okay. So
00:52:35 that is what they are alleging. Her lawsuit also says that she experienced auditory hallucinations
00:52:42 in which a demanding powerful male voice ordered her to kill her children. The filing says that 0.51
00:52:46 she said, I lost all control. My body started acting without any control on my part. I was
00:52:50 just following commands, all action. This voice demanded action. Um, now I just want to give you
00:52:57 a trigger warning just to remind you of what she did. Okay. So this was, I think about eight months
00:53:05 postpartum. She went through some hard births. She was going through some hard time. We've got, 0.50
00:53:09 you know, diary entries that has published saying that she's going through a hard time.
00:53:13 She asked her husband to leave the house, to run a couple errands. Now she had also completed a
00:53:19 hospital stay at the time. And I think maybe her husband thought she was doing better that she had
00:53:24 improved. Um, but on this day she told her husband, Hey, I want you to go pick up dinner and
00:53:30 pick up this other thing that would keep him occupied for a while while he was gone. This
00:53:36 is very disturbing for me to talk about. I'm sure it's disturbing to hear too. She brought her
00:53:40 children down five, three, eight months into the basement and strangled each of them one by one 1.00
00:53:45 with exercise bands. Now I I'm not trying to get us to dwell on this because I understand it's so
00:53:50 dark, but I do think it's important to really, to really get this. Like if we are going to say,
00:53:56 well, it was just the psychosis or it was just the medication. Think about the strength and
00:54:01 the resolve and the persistence and the callousness that it takes to strangle your small
00:54:06 children one by one with exercise bands while the other ones are crying, while the other ones are
00:54:11 asking mommy, what are you doing? While the other ones are probably trying to run away.
00:54:16 I just can imagine that whoever went first, either the five or the three-year-old is trying
00:54:22 to run away. And she is, she successfully prevented them all from doing so, held them all down with
00:54:28 brute strength and killed them all, held that exercise band as tightly as she could until they 1.00
00:54:33 stopped breathing and died. Okay. She did that to her baby. She did that to her toddler. She did 1.00
00:54:38 that to her five-year-old. I just want us to remember that, that no matter what you think
00:54:42 about what caused this, those are the victims. And that's what happened to the victims. And those
00:54:48 are the primary victims, no matter what. Okay. But it seems like the feminists on TikTok and
00:54:53 just women on TikTok in general, they're not having that. Okay. I have, I've seen so few 0.99
00:54:59 videos talking about the children and talking about what they must have suffered in so many
00:55:05 videos, especially on TikTok, about how badly we should feel about Lindsay Clancy. I do feel bad
00:55:13 for Lindsay Clancy just having gone through separate. Let's separate that. Lindsay Clancy
00:55:18 before she murdered her children. I can understand the circumstance that she was in, the struggle
00:55:23 that she had, the medications, which I'm against, by the way, SSRIs in the vast majority of cases.
00:55:30 I just think that they can exacerbate symptoms rather than fix them.
00:55:34 And so I think she had a lot going on.
00:55:36 It can be true that we say she was failed in a variety of ways.
00:55:40 We can ask, why did her husband leave her alone in all of these things? 0.60
00:55:44 But at the end of the day, she methodically killed her children.
00:55:48 And I cannot say with any confidence and you cannot say with any confidence that it was
00:55:52 psychosis that caused that or that it was the medication that caused that.
00:55:56 We just don't know.
00:55:57 And the truth is people who commit heinous crimes are all on probably the spectrum of
00:56:01 psychosis.
00:56:02 They're probably insane in one way or another.
00:56:05 And if we said, well, no one could possibly do this without being insane, then no one's 0.71
00:56:11 going to prison for anything.
00:56:12 Then we never have justice for any victims and we don't protect anyone else from being
00:56:16 harmed again.
00:56:17 Okay.
00:56:18 If that's how our justice system is working, that we're negating justice because of someone's
00:56:22 mental health diagnosis in every single case, then we have no justice system.
00:56:26 Okay. 0.85
00:56:27 Also, by the way, like you can't close all the insane asylums, which is basically what we've 0.54
00:56:32 done, what Ronald Reagan did in the 1980s and say that mentally ill people can't go to jail. 0.58
00:56:37 And so all of us have to bear the brunt of that. I'm sorry, that just doesn't work.
00:56:41 So, but that is not the narrative that is being taken by the feminists on TikTok. The popular 0.99
00:56:46 theory is that Patrick Clancy actually murdered them. Okay. That it couldn't possibly be Lindsay,
00:56:51 that it was Patrick Clancy.
00:56:53 And what evidence do they have?
00:56:56 Vibes. 1.00
00:56:57 Here is Lisa Rinna.
00:56:59 She's saying that she and her therapist,
00:57:01 shock of all shocks,
00:57:03 came up with this theory
00:57:04 that it could not have possibly been Lindsay.
00:57:08 It's not nine.
00:57:09 Chit-chat.
00:57:11 All right, he did it.
00:57:13 Patrick did it.
00:57:14 Patrick's the one who did it.
00:57:16 Not Lindsay.
00:57:18 Patrick did it.
00:57:18 Because, you know, 1.00
00:57:19 i also heard that women typically don't strangle so awful to even say but that isn't what a woman
00:57:36 would do they don't strangle i was actually in therapy today and my therapist and i were talking
00:57:43 about it. And she said, I said, well, what do they do? She said, well, they poison or I said,
00:57:49 or, or drown them. Like we literally had that conversation today. Um, and she looks at me and
00:57:58 she goes, he did it. Wow. Yeah. And now, yeah. Yeah. I mean, how can you say this publicly? So
00:58:07 casually? I mean, this has massive implications on this person's life as far as we know, and we
00:58:13 don't know everything but as far as we know from all the facts that we have and her own admission
00:58:18 by the way that she killed her children like he is just a guy who walked in to his wife being
00:58:24 paralyzed after throwing herself out the out of the window and finding the dead bodies of his
00:58:29 strangled children in the basement and now he has to go through these tiktok lawyers who are accusing
00:58:36 him of actually being the murderer based on nothing except for vibes i think that's wrong
00:58:42 I don't have any affinity towards this guy. I don't know him. I'm not saying that he is some
00:58:46 virtuous dude. I literally have no clue. I just think it's wrong to accuse people of things
00:58:51 without evidence and just based on feelings. But as we know from the past year, that's very
00:58:56 lucrative business. It's very popular business to accuse people of murder or being included in
00:59:03 a plot of murder based on just what you know and what you feel. Here's another TikTok user that
00:59:09 has become popular over the past few weeks peddling this theory saw 10 the more i watch
00:59:14 this trial the more i am convinced that patrick did it i don't think that he thought lindsey
00:59:21 would be alive for this trial to even happen i think it would be case closed suicide murder
00:59:30 type situation and he could go run off with his new family what are y'all's thoughts
00:59:37 okay so what would be the reason for lindsey saying that she did it and admitting that she
00:59:44 did it you don't think the defense team who wants her to be let off or at least get her out of prison
00:59:50 for the rest of her life would come up with an alternate theory like that like these people
00:59:55 think that they care more about lindsey clancy than her lawyers do and i promise that you don't
01:00:02 If that was a viable theory, her lawyers would be pursuing that.
01:00:06 Her lawyers would be at least presenting that to the jury because that's what their job 0.98
01:00:10 is to cast doubts on her culpability.
01:00:13 But they have not taken that route.
01:00:14 They have not said maybe it wasn't her.
01:00:18 They have simply said, yeah, it was her, but this is why she was suffering and it's not
01:00:23 really her fault.
01:00:25 Okay, this is what they do.
01:00:27 And it's not just in this case, but in all of these cases, they will exploit.
01:00:32 the gaps. They will look at a story and they will say, well, that's weird. That's weird.
01:00:38 That's strange. It doesn't seem like I have an answer for that. And they will put all of those
01:00:43 pieces together without actually tying them together. They'll just kind of throw them at you,
01:00:48 gish gallop. And they will say, look at all of these different things that are happening. 1.00
01:00:52 Isn't that strange? I don't know. I'm not, I don't know. It's just weird. It's just odd. I'm just
01:00:58 saying it's odd. And all they've done is plant suspicion. And so the next time you see a video
01:01:03 and the next time you see a video and the next time you see a video, suddenly you think that
01:01:07 you have all of this knowledge of this alternate theory that is really true. But when it comes
01:01:13 down to it, you don't. If someone were to ask you, like, what is the evidence against Patrick
01:01:17 Clancy? I guarantee you, you would start to clam up and not know what to say because you've been
01:01:22 gish galloped. You've been overwhelmed with seeming facts that are really just vibes. And 1.00
01:01:27 that's not enough to slander a person. That's not enough to accuse a person. So there's also this,
01:01:33 like, let me give you an example of this. Um, they're looking at like, people have too much
01:01:39 time on their hands. There's too much time on their hands. Okay. They just really do. So some
01:01:43 of these people are looking at video surveillance footage of Patrick's shoes, which look different
01:01:49 in the surveillance footage from CVS just after 5 30 PM, the day of his kid's death.
01:01:54 and from 3v the restaurant where he picked up takeout the two places where she told him to go
01:01:59 at about 5 54 p.m the footage was not played to implicate patrick in the actual trial but to
01:02:04 establish a timeline event but people are saying that okay wait his shoes look different and so he
01:02:10 must be going home in between cvs and in between 3v and maybe that is like how he committed these
01:02:17 crimes and when he committed the crimes however the different appearances of the shoes could
01:02:22 potentially be explained by the fact that the footage was taken from two different angles,
01:02:25 okay? On two different surveillance systems, accounting for the different resolutions and
01:02:29 angles. It is likely that Patrick did not change his shoes. And like, it just, that's not enough.
01:02:37 It's just not enough. And even if he did, that alone doesn't prove any guilt. Like we need,
01:02:44 we need something. Like you need a hobby. Like I would never wish hard times on this nation,
01:02:50 but I look at some of the men and women and their behavior on social media, and I'm like,
01:02:54 you need something that is bringing you into the battlefield, okay? Men need to go work at
01:03:00 steel factories again. Women need to start sewing again. We need something that is occupying our 1.00
01:03:06 time more than things like this, okay? Because this is leading people into a dark place.
01:03:12 TikTok users are also taking the DNA analyst testimony out of context by claiming that the
01:03:17 exercise bands used to kill the children did not include lindsey's dna at all and only had
01:03:22 patrick so here's what they're saying it's not 11 okay we're gonna try this again because i just
01:03:26 got a community violation so i'm getting caught up on my clancy news and i just heard that they
01:03:33 did not find any of her dna on the exercise bands that were used to smurder the children
01:03:39 but patrick's the husband his dna was on the van so so you're telling me a woman
01:03:48 in psychosis had the wherewithal to clean off all the dna but just hers not the children
01:03:59 and not his that's what you're telling me okay that's not even true okay it was expected that
01:04:07 his DNA would also be on the exercise bands. He was the one who removed them from his children's
01:04:11 necks after he found them dead. They had also been probably been used before. Former Massachusetts
01:04:16 state police forensic scientist, uh, Katerina Stashen, I think is how you pronounce her last
01:04:22 name testified that DNA from all five family members was actually found on the set of exercise
01:04:27 band, but not on every swab of every portion of the band. So Lindsay's DNA was detected
01:04:32 on at least some of the samples there's a forensic scientist amy santoro explained in a tiktok video
01:04:38 that the fact that the dna results were a complex mixture from related people with very similar dna
01:04:43 profiles makes the data difficult to interpret she also added that patrick's amplified state
01:04:49 where he could have been rushed and sweating as he removed the bands could have caused him to leave
01:04:53 more skin cells behind so again all of this is not necessarily an indication that he is guilty now
01:05:01 if someone has real evidence, then I think that that should be brought forth. But again,
01:05:06 all of these are vibes. Okay. Um, another reason why conspiracy theorists think Patrick Clancy is
01:05:12 actually guilty in this case is Lindsay's body temperature, which was 82 degrees when she arrived
01:05:16 at the hospital there. They argue that her body didn't have enough time to drop to that level.
01:05:22 Like my goodness, y'all, um, in the 20 to 30 minutes, it took for Patrick to return from 0.82
01:05:27 running a few short errands and so tiktokers are asking like why was she so cold but it's probably 0.92
01:05:35 obvious that lindsey clancy she cut her wrists and she cut her neck before jumping out of a
01:05:42 second story window according to the prosecution these facts are not disputed by lindsey and her
01:05:47 defense and that when you do that you can get hypothermia like your body temperature can go
01:05:53 down. Dr. James Chow, he's a plastic and reconstructive surgeon with more than 25 years
01:05:57 of experience. He told parade.com that Clancy's hypothermia was medically possible, not only
01:06:03 because of heat loss that she would have incurred lying injured on the frozen ground on a January
01:06:07 night in Massachusetts. Hello, but also because of blood loss, shock, and a spinal cord injury
01:06:12 that impairs the body's ability to shiver and constrict blood vessels to maintain his core
01:06:17 temperature. I mean, that makes a lot of sense. Again, it's just so strange how they're pulling
01:06:22 out these random factoids and they're connecting them to nothing except for their own feelings.
01:06:27 You will be overwhelmed by the videos that are defending Lindsay Clancy and going against
01:06:34 Patrick Clancy and all of these people who think that they have this very interesting view on
01:06:39 things. And they have now raised almost $900,000 on GoFundMe as of Tuesday morning with a goal of
01:06:48 reaching 2 million, um, to support Lindsay, to support her family. The page says that the funds
01:06:55 are for her parents. But if you look at the image associated with the page in the comments,
01:06:59 you can see that this page is also meant to support Lindsay. Like obviously they are portraying
01:07:05 Lindsay as the victim here and she is being protected by all of these women. She is, if you
01:07:10 don't know this paralyzed from the waist down from her apparent attempt to kill herself by throwing 1.00
01:07:14 herself out of the window. And then you've got all of these women who are standing around supposed 1.00
01:07:19 to be protecting her and raising $2 million on her behalf. Okay. So it's this AI generated image 1.00
01:07:28 that is trying to depict that. Commenters on the page say things like we stand with her. We believe
01:07:34 her. We will continue to stand by her as the truth comes to light. And please use my donation to
01:07:39 better investigate Patrick's role in this tragedy. Wow. Okay. So there is actually a cultural reason
01:07:48 that has been going on for at least 20 plus years, probably more than that, that I think
01:07:55 is making theories like this so popular. And it is this idea that a woman is so complicated 1.00
01:08:04 and so complex and so buried by the patriarchy that anything she does can be understood
01:08:12 from the perspective of her being a victim of oppression. Even if she does do an evil thing,
01:08:21 even if she does take part in violence and wickedness, there was probably a good reason
01:08:27 for it. That's the idea that we hear. We'll get into that in just a second. Let me pause,
01:08:32 tell you about our next sponsor and that is good ranchers. Okay. Kids are heading back to school in
01:08:38 your home and you want to make sure that you've got dinner ready for that night. And you want to
01:08:44 make sure that it's nutritious, that it's something that your kids actually want to eat. That's why
01:08:47 you need to get all of your American meat from good ranchers, American chicken, American beef,
01:08:53 American steak, American chicken nuggets, hot dogs, all of that, all from an American farm or
01:08:58 Ranch. We love Good Ranchers. We eat it almost every night in our home. The ground beef, the
01:09:03 chicken, the seafood, it is also high quality. It just saves you time and money too. It comes right
01:09:08 to your front door on dry ice every month. You never have to go to the grocery store and worry
01:09:12 about getting the right cut of steak and you know exactly where it's coming from. This is an awesome
01:09:17 family-owned Christ-centered company that you want to support. Go to goodranchers.com slash
01:09:22 Allie. Get $50 off anything on their site. That's goodranchers.com slash Allie for $50 off.
01:09:33 So here's what I said on X a few days ago. To understand some of the unconditional defense
01:09:38 of Lindsay Clancy, because by the way, some of it is unconditional. I saw a TikTok video of a
01:09:43 woman rocking her baby and she was saying, me too, Lindsay, me too. Yikes. Yikes. Okay.
01:09:49 to understand some of the unconditional defense of lindsey clancy and the baseless accusations
01:09:55 of her husband circulating on feminist tiktok you have to clue in on to the content that women are
01:10:01 consuming on a daily basis the backdrop of their brains is made up of true crime podcasts fiction 1.00
01:10:06 books tv shows movies that paint every woman even murderous ones as complex heroines who did a
01:10:13 horrible thing as her only chance at freedom and empowerment. She's portrayed as, uh, she's 0.98
01:10:19 portrayed as at best brave and unhindered and at worst layered and misunderstood. This dynamic has
01:10:25 completely warped the lib female consciousness and conscience. They cannot imagine a world in 1.00
01:10:30 which a woman, especially a struggling one, struggling one just did an evil thing and should 0.97
01:10:34 be held accountable for it for the past 20 or so years. Pop culture has contributed to this idea 0.99
01:10:42 that women are always victims in one way or another, no matter how evil their actions might 1.00
01:10:47 be. Like I think of a few, I think of a few things. I think of a few songs, movies, TV shows, 0.98
01:10:53 and books in popular culture. There is this song by Taylor Swift in 2020 called Nobody, No Crime.
01:10:59 It's a dark song. And Taylor sings about a friend named Esty, whose husband has a mistress. And
01:11:05 after Esty disappears and the husband marries the mistress, the singer talks about how she
01:11:09 kills the husband. So the lyrics say, good thing my daddy made me get a boating license when I was
01:11:14 15 and I've cleaned enough houses to know how to cover up a scene. Good thing Esty's sister going
01:11:19 to swear she was with me. Good thing his mistress took out a big life insurance policy. No body, 1.00
01:11:25 no crime. No, no body, no crime. I wasn't letting up until the day that he died. Okay. Anyone
01:11:33 remember the song from the 90s earl had to die now unfortunately i know all of the lyrics
01:11:41 from this song because there were a lot of country songs that i probably sang on my way to
01:11:46 kindergarten that i had no idea what they meant but i could repeat verbatim the lyrics from you
01:11:52 like who's bad have your boots been under i got in trouble for singing that at kindergarten
01:11:55 um had no idea what that meant and this is also one of those songs and it wasn't until later in
01:12:01 life that I'm like, Oh, they're talking about murdering someone. The Dixie chicks Earl had to 1.00
01:12:05 die. Now I don't have to read you all of the lyrics, but basically it's a song about this 1.00
01:12:10 guy named Earl who was a horrible guy. Okay. It was a husband who was abusing, um, Mary or, uh,
01:12:17 not Marianne was abusing the other woman Wanda. And so Marianne, her friend and Wanda, they got
01:12:24 together to kill Earl, to poison him. Earl had to die. Okay. You probably remember that now that's 0.98
01:12:30 not to say that Earl shouldn't have been severely punished and shouldn't have gone to jail for the
01:12:36 rest of his life and wasn't an awful person or that we don't want Wanda to have protection from
01:12:42 Earl. But this is another one of those ideas that if a woman commits a horrible crime, it was
01:12:49 probably because she was being abused or oppressed in some way. All of these kind of shape our
01:12:55 conscience and our consciousness. Remember the TV series, which I watched at the time,
01:12:59 probably didn't think that much of it, starting in 2017, the series Big Little Lies. It ran for
01:13:06 two seasons. To be honest, it wasn't very good. It was one of those very first shows that was so
01:13:12 much of the slop of nothing happens, nothing happens, nothing happens. One thing almost
01:13:17 happens at the end, and then you have to watch the next episode. It was a star-seted cast with
01:13:22 Laura Dern, Reese Witherspoon, Nicole Kidman. It's a murder mystery, and it's set in a wealthy
01:13:26 coastal town and um we know from the start that perry right this character is dead but we don't
01:13:33 know how he died it's gradually revealed that perry was abusive to his wife celeste and had
01:13:39 also previously raped another uh character and so in the climax of the movie bonnie another character
01:13:46 pushes him down a flight of stairs during a confrontation the group of women then cover up
01:13:50 the truth and claimed that he simply fell. Okay. So again, horrible person, horrible crimes
01:13:58 committed. We don't like him. We think he's terrible. That's all true. But this plays into
01:14:02 the idea that if a woman commits a terrible crime, it must be for a good reason, because that's the 0.99
01:14:07 only reason a woman would ever do something that awful. If we look at books and you know, my team, 0.99
01:14:13 they included this one and I was like, I didn't think about this as being an example. And it's
01:14:18 Where the Crawdads Sing. It's the 2018 novel by Delia Owens. I really enjoyed this book. Some of
01:14:24 you out there I've talked to, you didn't like Where the Crawdads Sing because you thought it
01:14:27 was too depressing. I love depressing books. That's one thing about me. I want to sob and
01:14:31 cry at the end of the book. And I did sob and cry at the end of the book. But this is also one of
01:14:37 those examples. She's suspected in the death of a local man by her neighbors because she's seen as
01:14:42 strange. She's tried, found not guilty, but at the end of the book, it's revealed that she did
01:14:48 actually kill him when he tried to rape her. Now, I don't think it's wrong for him, for her to have
01:14:54 killed someone who was trying to rape her. That is self-defense. Um, if that is what is happening, 0.90
01:15:00 but again, contributes to the idea that the only reason a woman would do anything is if something 1.00
01:15:04 is happening to her. The housemate series by Freda McFadden have not read the series.
01:15:09 It's a collection of psychological thrillers about a young woman hired as a live-in house
01:15:14 made by wealthy households with dark secrets.
01:15:17 In this first book, she kills the husband who tried to rape her, again, contributing 1.00
01:15:22 to this idea that women only do things when they're pushed to the edge or it can't actually 0.99
01:15:27 fully be her fault. 0.56
01:15:29 And then we have the category of films and cultural examples of women not being able 0.67
01:15:37 to be portrayed unconditionally as villains, but really as complicated and nuanced and even
01:15:44 justified in their terrible actions. I think about Elsa from Frozen. She's the complex
01:15:50 protagonist. She shuts out her own sister throughout her childhood. And then when she 0.88
01:15:54 grows older, she freezes her kingdom because of her anger. She sings, let it go. And she says, 0.50
01:16:00 no right, no wrong, no rules for me. I'm free. Now we do see that she suffers the consequences
01:16:05 of her isolation and of her selfishness. And ultimately she has to be selfless in order for
01:16:11 her to overcome some of those things and the consequences of her actions. So I'm not saying
01:16:16 Frozen is all a bad lesson, but this is an example. There was actually no real villain in Frozen.
01:16:23 It wasn't really Elsa. It was this complicated female figure whose past trauma kind of justified 0.99
01:16:30 her selfishness in how rude and mean she was to her sister, Anna. Also, there's another Disney
01:16:37 movie. They're trying to do this. There's all kinds of Disney movies that are trying to retell
01:16:44 the story from the villain's perspective. And one of them is a new movie that's going to come out
01:16:49 called Stepsisters. And it's going to be a live action spinoff of Cinderella. And it's an early
01:16:54 development. And, uh, it features the protagonist to wicked step sisters. Now this rendering of
01:17:02 the story is going to be from their perspective. And what is it going to portray that they're
01:17:06 really just misunderstood that it, they weren't actually just rude. They weren't actually just
01:17:13 mean. They weren't actually just covetousness or covetous and jealous that really they had
01:17:19 their own issues and we should be more understanding. Disney does this over and over
01:17:24 again, telling the story from the villain's perspective. It's supposed to blur the lines
01:17:29 of virtue and vice. It's supposed to blur the lines of good and evil. I think it perpetuates
01:17:35 this idea because so far I've only really seen it from the female perspective, the female villain's
01:17:39 perspective, that a woman only acts in a way that is wrong when there is some circumstance that is 0.90
01:17:49 causing her to act that way. It's also just what progressives get wrong all the time about human
01:17:56 nature. When they see nature versus nurture, they think everything is nurture. They don't believe
01:18:03 in a sin nature. They don't believe that there is an objective right and wrong. So that worldview
01:18:08 really comes out in all of the art that they create, but it also affects our minds and how we
01:18:14 see real life situations. There are all kinds of true crime podcasts. There's crime junkie,
01:18:19 there's morbid, there's lady killers. And this one specifically goes through women who have 1.00
01:18:26 killed, but it then unpacks how society and abuse and circumstances really pushed them to kill.
01:18:33 There's also a female criminals podcast that covers similar cases with more of a focus on
01:18:39 psychology and motive. Five of the top 10 podcasts on Apple podcasts are true crime.
01:18:44 And so this just goes to show, this is a very popular category. This is also, um, convinced
01:18:50 a bunch of women that they know more than they do. Okay. And that they are more, um, 0.83
01:18:58 sophisticated and smarter than they actually are when it comes to sleuthing. Now I'm not saying
01:19:04 that all women who follow true crime are actually dumb or that they don't know anything or that 0.98
01:19:09 they're never asking good questions. But I think that these kinds of podcasts fill us with the 0.98
01:19:14 kind of confidence that we shouldn't have. And there are some people that I do just want to ask
01:19:19 like, okay, let me give you an example. Like I'm bad at math. Okay. Like I'm, I'm not good at math.
01:19:26 And if there were a podcast out there that was saying that two plus two equals five,
01:19:30 and they were giving what seemed like a very convincing argument for that. And it sounded
01:19:35 good to me and it made sense to me. And they totally convinced me that two plus two equals
01:19:39 five. But my friend who was always really good at math is like, Hey, I don't think so. Like,
01:19:45 that's not right. And here's why what he's saying is wrong. It would be really dumb of me to think
01:19:50 about my brain and look back on my life and insist that I'm right. I think some people who think that
01:19:56 they know better than the defense team and think that they know better than all of these people
01:20:00 who are actual experts should think back in their life and be like, have I traditionally been
01:20:04 someone who people say is smart? Like, have I been someone who figures things out easily and
01:20:12 is like really, uh, really adept at these kinds of investigations? And if the answer is no,
01:20:19 then you're probably just wrong here. Like you're probably just going off vibes. Like I think we
01:20:25 need to have a better self-assessment of like what our skills actually are and leave some things,
01:20:31 not everything, but some things up to the experts because you could be ruining someone's life
01:20:36 by your vibes and by publicizing your vibes, right? And this is all kind of the secular
01:20:42 mindset of right versus wrong and male versus female too. All right. Last sponsor for the day
01:20:47 is Shopify. If you've been sitting on a business idea, but keep telling yourself someday that is
01:20:54 understandable. A lot of people have been exactly where you are, but Shopify exists to make it so
01:20:59 much easier. Once you launch Shopify is a game changer. Their checkout is so smooth, especially
01:21:05 with shop pay customers, finish purchases in one tap and their info is saved for next time.
01:21:10 That means more sales and way less abandoned carts. And because Shopify handles the heavy
01:21:15 lifting, you actually have time to grow your business and enjoy the sunny days with the people
01:21:20 that you love with Shopify. Nothing stands between your idea and a real business. So go make one.
01:21:24 If you're ready to stop putting off your business and start hearing that,
01:21:27 then you're ready for Shopify.
01:21:28 Start your free trial at shopify.com slash Allie, shopify.com slash Allie.
01:21:38 Remember that scripture reminds us not to call conspiracy everything that the world calls
01:21:43 conspiracy.
01:21:44 Isaiah 520 reminds us, woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who put darkness for
01:21:49 light and light for darkness, who put bitter for sweet and sweet for bitter.
01:21:53 Proverbs 11.1, a false balance is an abomination to the Lord, but a just weight is his delight.
01:21:58 God cares a lot about justice. He cares a lot about truth. And that's why in the Old Testament,
01:22:02 as he is giving his law to ancient Israel, he says that you shall speak the truth about your
01:22:08 neighbor and that justice is impartial, that it's truthful, that it's direct, that it's
01:22:14 proportional, that it is not based on hearsay and that you can be charged by the presence of
01:22:21 two or three eyewitnesses. Like the old Testament law giving gives us a precedent for giving rights
01:22:29 to both the accused and the accuser. And in the court of social media, you don't have those rights
01:22:34 as the accused. You have no rights. You don't even have the rights to a defense because you
01:22:40 don't have an attorney that's pleading for you and arguing on your case. You are totally at the
01:22:45 whims of the mob and that's wrong. And Christians shouldn't contribute to that. You shouldn't 1.00
01:22:49 contribute to that if someone is presenting something to you without evidence. It's not to
01:22:55 say that people can't actually bring, like we did this on Monday, bring real evidence and real
01:23:01 testimony forward and shine light and blow the whistle on evil things that are happening,
01:23:05 but you've got to have a good case for it, right? Proverbs 24, 23. These also are sayings of the
01:23:12 wise. Partiality in judging is not good, okay? So showing partiality to one side or the other,
01:23:19 one gender or the other based on what feels right to you. Not good. Leviticus 19, 15, you shall do
01:23:25 no injustice in court. You should not be partial to the poor, nor defer to the great. People forget
01:23:29 about that, but in righteousness or in truth, you shall judge your neighbor. James 2, 1, my brothers
01:23:35 show no partiality as you hold the faith in our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory.
01:23:40 Be careful what you consume. Be careful what you repost. Be careful what you perpetuate.
01:23:45 Check our minds and we need to make sure that we are being renewed in the spirit of our mind
01:23:50 We need to make sure that the assumptions that we have the conclusions that we come to
01:23:54 Are affected by the truth the reality that is really there that is observable
01:23:59 But also the truth that we read in scripture and that if we don't know it's okay to just opt out of a conversation and say
01:24:04 I don't have this is okay
01:24:06 I don't have the capacity to be following the lindsey clancy story right now
01:24:11 I don't have the capacity to dig into and research what is actually true and what actually happened.
01:24:16 So I'm not going to watch all the TikTok conspiracies about that. That would be the
01:24:21 responsible thing to do. Okay. The responsible thing to do isn't to say, well, I don't have
01:24:26 time to do it. So I am going to delegate my critical thinking to TikTokers. That's probably 1.00
01:24:29 the worst thing you can do. And by the way, you shouldn't delegate your critical thinking to me
01:24:33 either. I hope to actually equip you to critically think and help you ask the right questions,
01:24:37 but you shouldn't let me do your thinking for you. You should be thinking because God gave you
01:24:42 a brain. And if you find yourself in a position of like, okay, I think that I'm allowing other
01:24:47 people to think and speak for me, then maybe it's time to just opt out of the commentator
01:24:52 space altogether. I'm saying that as a podcaster, only listen to the podcasts that are actually
01:24:56 helping you get more deeply into God's word and ask the right questions and to seek the truth
01:25:01 better, not the ones that are attempting you to shut your brain off. All right. I know that was
01:25:07 a lot. That's all we got time for today. We will be back here on Friday.